Datasets:

minh21

/

COVID-QA-Chunk-64-question-answering-biencoder-data-65_25_10

like 0

[ "Antibodies against foreign antigens are a critical component of the overall immune response and can facilitate pathogen clearance during a primary infection and also protect against subsequent infections. Dysregulation of the antibody response can lead to an autoimmune disease, malignancy, or enhanced infection. Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination.", "Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination. In this review, we summarize the established techniques and discuss new and emerging technologies for probing the B cell response in vitro and in vivo by taking advantage of the specificity of B cell receptor BCR -associated and secreted antibodies. These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells.", "These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells. We also present our approach to identify rare antigen-specific B cells using magnetic enrichment followed by flow cytometry. Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate.", "Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate. Transgenic mouse models of B cells targeting model antigens and of B cell signaling have also significantly advanced our understanding of antigen-specific B cell responses in vivo. Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key.", "Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key. He reasoned that antitoxins antibodies contained in a solution in the serum of immunized animals must be identical to a cellular receptor \"for a really well-made key will not open different locks at the same time\" . .", ". It took almost five decades before immunofluorescence microscopy was used to confirm the cellular origin of antibodies . . Major strides in the B cell and antibody field followed in the 1970s with the development of hybridoma technology to produce monoclonal antibodies and the discovery that somatic rearrangement during B cell differentiation was responsible for antibody diversification . .", ". The subsequent explosion of available monoclonal antibodies led to revolutionary diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents to distinguish different types of immune cells . . Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell.", "Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell. Methods to probe the antigen-specific B cell response have advanced our understanding of how to harness the remarkable breadth of the B cell repertoire and the exquisite specificity of the individual B cell in developing . vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; .", "vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; . antibodies that prevent disease when given prophylactically; and . antibodies that can be given as therapy after the onset of disease. Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen.", "Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen. However, vaccine development against pathogens that are traditionally difficult to vaccinate against may rely on a deeper investigation of the B cell response to the antigens exposed on the surface of these pathogens. For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies .", "For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies . . . . .", ". . . . Insights into the ontogeny of these rare B cells could allow the design of a step-wise vaccine regimen that stimulates the germ-line precursor to expand and mature to produce circulating bnAbs which could protect against HIV acquisition . .", ". For RSV, stabilized versions of the fusion F protein in the pre-fusion conformation have led to insights in the B cell's response to infection and has generated potentially safer and more efficacious vaccine candidates . .", ". Influenza also performs fusion through the stem region of the hemagglutinin protein, and the identification of B cells that target this relatively conserved site has spurred research on the development of a universal influenza vaccine . . . .", ". . . Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 .", "Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 . Rare memory B cells producing antibodies specific for the EBV fusion machinery have been isolated; these can neutralize both B cell and epithelial cell infection .. A new paradigm in malaria vaccine development is also emerging with the discovery of IgM+ and IgD+ memory B cells targeting the Merozoite Surface Protein 1, that rapidly respond to malaria re-infection .. Further, highly potent neutralizing antibodies targeting a novel and conserved site on the Circumsporozoite Protein have been isolated from B cells .. Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases.", "Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases. The solutions to the crystal structures of surface proteins for a variety of pathogens, the conformational stabilization of these antigens, and the application of the methods summarized in this review, to probe antigen-specific B cell responses, have created new opportunities for systematic and rational vaccine design for HIV, RSV, EBV, malaria, and many other pathogens. The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens ..", "The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens .. Although these cells are potentially pathogenic, the deletion of B cells with high affinity to self-antigen through apoptosis, anergy of B cells with low affinity to self-antigen, and the absence of T cell help combine together to protect against autoimmune disease in mice .. The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases.", "The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases. Although the term antigen-specific B cell is used throughout this mini-review to denote the analysis of B cells based on binding between the B cell receptor BCR and a specific antigen used as bait, it is important to keep in mind that BCRs within the polyclonal B cell repertoire exhibit a spectrum of polyreactivity. On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities.", "On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities. The frequency of polyreactivity in the normal adult human B cell repertoire has been estimated to be 4% of naïve B cells, 23% of IgG+ memory B cells, and 26% of intestinal IgA+ and IgG+ plasmablasts 27-29 . On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen.", "On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen. Although there are exceptions, the accumulation of somatic hypermutations within the variable regions of the BCR during the process of affinity maturation is generally thought to lead to increased affinity and specificity for the cognate antigen .. Several general techniques are commonly used to identify antigen-specific B cells Table 1 . The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell.", "The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell. In the B cell ELISPOT, antibody secreting B cells ASCs present in a sample or differentiated in vitro are added to plates coated with the antigen of interest. Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies.", "Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies. Enzyme or fluorescent labeled secondary antibodies are then used to visualize spots of antibody secretion and binding to plate-bound antigen at the location of the ASCs. Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive.", "Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive. Secondary antibodies conjugated to combinatorial colored beads can also be used to detect the antibodies secreted from individual B cells with the advantage of multiplexing the assay .. One limitation of the assay is its requirement for antibody secretion by B cells thereby limiting the assay to only a subset of B cells in the repertoire, namely ASCs .. Memory B cells can be stimulated in vitro to differentiate into ASCs prior to addition to the antigen-coated plate . .", ". Further, the antigenspecific B cells identified by ELISPOT are generally not available for downstream analysis. Limiting dilution is another technique that has been used to isolate antigen-specific B cells. In this approach, primary cells can be diluted serially until individual B cells are separated in microwell plates . .", ". The B cells can then be cultured and expanded ex vivo and/or immortalized using EBV such that each well contains a monoclonal antibody . . Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest.", "Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest. Although antibodies can be sequenced and cloned, the requirement for an ex vivo culture prior to selection precludes determination of the transcriptional profile of the original B cell in this approach. This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells .", "This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells . . Advances in single cell next generation sequencing technology have allowed high throughput transcriptional profiling and sequencing of paired immunoglobulin heavy and light chains . .", ". In this approach, antigen specificity can be tested after monoclonal antibodies are cloned and produced using the sequencing data. This method can be useful in identifying antigen-specific B cells that have undergone clonal expansion after vaccination or acute infection . . Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . .", "Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . . Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection.", "Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection. Fluorochromes can either be attached covalently via chemical conjugation to the antigen, expressed as a recombinant fusion protein, or attached non-covalently by biotinylating the antigen. After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen.", "After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen. Biotinylation of the antigen at a ratio ≤1 biotin to 1 antigen is important, since each streptavidin has the potential to bind four biotins. If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added.", "If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added. Alternatively, site directed biotinylation can be accomplished by adding either an AviTag or BioEase tag to the recombinant antigen prior to expression . .", ". When site-specific biotinylation is utilized, researchers must keep in mind that the tag may occlude an epitope from recognition by B cells which can be problematic for vaccine antigens. Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation.", "Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation. Another important consideration is the potential for confounding by B cells in the repertoire that bind to the fluorochrome, streptavidin, or any linkers rather than to the antigen of interest. Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells .", "Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells . . Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome .", "Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome . . However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population.", "However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population. To fully remove confounding from the fluorochrome, streptavidin, and linkers, a \"decoy\" tetramer can be used to identify these contaminating B cells .. In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells.", "In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells. Notably, it is critical to use the same source of fluorochrome conjugated streptavidin in the tetramer and decoy reagent, because conjugation methods, recombinant streptavidin, and protein fluorochromes like R-phycoerythrin vary enough from company to company to alter some of the epitopes available for B cells to bind. One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated.", "One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated. In addition to recombinant proteins and synthesized peptides, labeled polysaccharides, lipids, haptens, virus-like particles, and pseudo viruses have also been used to identify antigen-specific cells by flow cytometry 33, . Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry .", "Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry . . With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining.", "With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining. Additionally, the immunoglobulin capture assay is a flow cytometry-based adaptation of the ELISPOT assay in which a streptavidin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibody carrying four biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies is used to simultaneously bind plasmablasts and capture secreted antibody followed by fluorescent-labeled antigen to detect antigenspecific plasmablasts . .", ". The mean fluorescence intensity measured by flow cytometry and normalized to the level of BCR expression also provides a measure of the relative amount of antigen binding to a B cell and can be used as a rough surrogate for binding affinity . .", ". Preincubation of B cells with increasing concentrations of a monomeric antigen prior to labeling with tetrameric antigen can also be used to further quantify binding affinity. Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding ..", "Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding .. Individual cells can also be isolated by fluorescence activated cell sorting FACS for downstream analysis, including BCR sequencing and cloning, BCR affinity measurement, in vitro proliferation, and transcriptional profiling. Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells.", "Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells. Magnetic nanoparticles conjugated to antibodies targeting the fluorochrome on the antigen of interest, allow for the enrichment of antigen-specific B cells prior to flow cytometry . .", ". This approach is particularly useful for detecting rare antigenspecific naïve B cells, autoreactive B cells, memory B cells, and plasmablasts . . The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 .", "The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 . Notably, as with any method that seeks to identify a population of cells at a very low frequency, the background and noise inherent in the detection system is magnified with respect to the signal of interest, especially when that signal is weak. Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: .", "Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: . Using decoys to exclude B cells of unwanted specificities; . careful design of flow cytometry panels to avoid emission spillover into the channel for the antigen of interest; and . choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin.", "choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin. In vivo methods to probe antigen-specific B cell responses in the presence of other antigen-presenting cells and T cell helpers, have increased our mechanistic understanding of the humoral immune response during vaccination, infection, and autoimmunity. Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells.", "Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells. The adoptively transferred B cells can come from wildtype mice or from mice expressing transgenic BCRs Table 2 , and antigen-specific B cells can be analyzed using the techniques described above. Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization.", "Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization. In the first reported application of this technique to demonstrate the cellular origin of antibodies in 1955, fluorescein-conjugated antibodies against ovalbumin and human immunoglobulin were used to stain tissue sections of the spleen from hyperimmune rabbits . .", ". Since then, other groups have fluorescently labeled antigens to localize antigen-specific B cells by microscopy . . Advances in laser capture dissection microscopy, already used in the T cell field, also provide an opportunity for isolating individual antigen-specific B cells for downstream analysis, including sequencing and cloning of the BCR or transcriptional profiling . .", ". However, antigen staining of BCRs in situ can be challenging depending on the binding of antigens from pathogens to other cellular receptors or an alteration of BCR specificity during tissue fixation or processing. Two-photon or multiphoton microscopy has the ability to resolve images at greater depths and with less photobleaching than confocal microscopy . .", ". As a result, this technology has allowed real-time imaging in living, intact lymphoid tissues of mice, permitting the direct in vivo observation of immune cell interactions. The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy .", "The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy . . Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans.", "Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans. Transgenic mice that produce humanized cytokines by knock-in replacement can be used to support human hematopoietic stem cells . .", ". Transgenic mice with complete humanization of the mouse immunoglobulin loci provide an opportunity for recapitulating the breadth of the human B cell repertoire and serve as a valuable tool for therapeutic antibody discovery . .", ". However, one caveat is that the allele frequencies found in the B cell repertoires of these mouse models may not necessarily recapitulate those found in humans . . Mass cytometry has the potential to provide further high-dimensional analysis of antigen-specific B cells. In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells.", "In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells. Since data is collected as time-offlight mass spectrometry, up to 42 unique parameters can be simultaneously measured from a single sample without significant spillover between channels or the need for compensation. Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . .", "Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . . Mass cytometry with metal-labeled peptide-MHC tetramers has been used successfully to identify and characterize antigen-specific T cells, but to our knowledge has not yet been applied to antigen-specific B cells . .", ". One limitation of this approach is that cells are unavailable for downstream analysis since they are vaporized by a plasma torch to atomize the ion tags. However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection.", "However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection. On the horizon, single cell RNA-sequencing RNA-seq technologies have the potential to revolutionize the study of antigen-specific immune cells . .", ". The ability to generate a library of tetramers with unique barcodes could allow the simultaneous examination of gene expression profiles from a large number of cells with different antigen specificities in a single experiment. Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics .", "Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics . . . .", ". . . The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents.", "The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents. Methods for studying antigen-specific B cell responses are being increasingly applied to tackle diseases like HIV, RSV, and autoimmune diseases, in which the immune response either fails to protect or clear disease, or where it enhances disease or is responsible for the disease itself. Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role.", "Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role. JB and JT reviewed the literature, generated figures and tables, and wrote the manuscript." ]

[ "Antibodies against foreign antigens are a critical component of the overall immune response and can facilitate pathogen clearance during a primary infection and also protect against subsequent infections. Dysregulation of the antibody response can lead to an autoimmune disease, malignancy, or enhanced infection. Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination.", "Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination. In this review, we summarize the established techniques and discuss new and emerging technologies for probing the B cell response in vitro and in vivo by taking advantage of the specificity of B cell receptor BCR -associated and secreted antibodies. These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells.", "These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells. We also present our approach to identify rare antigen-specific B cells using magnetic enrichment followed by flow cytometry. Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate.", "Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate. Transgenic mouse models of B cells targeting model antigens and of B cell signaling have also significantly advanced our understanding of antigen-specific B cell responses in vivo. Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key.", "Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key. He reasoned that antitoxins antibodies contained in a solution in the serum of immunized animals must be identical to a cellular receptor \"for a really well-made key will not open different locks at the same time\" . .", ". It took almost five decades before immunofluorescence microscopy was used to confirm the cellular origin of antibodies . . Major strides in the B cell and antibody field followed in the 1970s with the development of hybridoma technology to produce monoclonal antibodies and the discovery that somatic rearrangement during B cell differentiation was responsible for antibody diversification . .", ". The subsequent explosion of available monoclonal antibodies led to revolutionary diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents to distinguish different types of immune cells . . Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell.", "Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell. Methods to probe the antigen-specific B cell response have advanced our understanding of how to harness the remarkable breadth of the B cell repertoire and the exquisite specificity of the individual B cell in developing . vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; .", "vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; . antibodies that prevent disease when given prophylactically; and . antibodies that can be given as therapy after the onset of disease. Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen.", "Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen. However, vaccine development against pathogens that are traditionally difficult to vaccinate against may rely on a deeper investigation of the B cell response to the antigens exposed on the surface of these pathogens. For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies .", "For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies . . . . .", ". . . . Insights into the ontogeny of these rare B cells could allow the design of a step-wise vaccine regimen that stimulates the germ-line precursor to expand and mature to produce circulating bnAbs which could protect against HIV acquisition . .", ". For RSV, stabilized versions of the fusion F protein in the pre-fusion conformation have led to insights in the B cell's response to infection and has generated potentially safer and more efficacious vaccine candidates . .", ". Influenza also performs fusion through the stem region of the hemagglutinin protein, and the identification of B cells that target this relatively conserved site has spurred research on the development of a universal influenza vaccine . . . .", ". . . Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 .", "Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 . Rare memory B cells producing antibodies specific for the EBV fusion machinery have been isolated; these can neutralize both B cell and epithelial cell infection .. A new paradigm in malaria vaccine development is also emerging with the discovery of IgM+ and IgD+ memory B cells targeting the Merozoite Surface Protein 1, that rapidly respond to malaria re-infection .. Further, highly potent neutralizing antibodies targeting a novel and conserved site on the Circumsporozoite Protein have been isolated from B cells .. Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases.", "Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases. The solutions to the crystal structures of surface proteins for a variety of pathogens, the conformational stabilization of these antigens, and the application of the methods summarized in this review, to probe antigen-specific B cell responses, have created new opportunities for systematic and rational vaccine design for HIV, RSV, EBV, malaria, and many other pathogens. The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens ..", "The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens .. Although these cells are potentially pathogenic, the deletion of B cells with high affinity to self-antigen through apoptosis, anergy of B cells with low affinity to self-antigen, and the absence of T cell help combine together to protect against autoimmune disease in mice .. The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases.", "The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases. Although the term antigen-specific B cell is used throughout this mini-review to denote the analysis of B cells based on binding between the B cell receptor BCR and a specific antigen used as bait, it is important to keep in mind that BCRs within the polyclonal B cell repertoire exhibit a spectrum of polyreactivity. On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities.", "On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities. The frequency of polyreactivity in the normal adult human B cell repertoire has been estimated to be 4% of naïve B cells, 23% of IgG+ memory B cells, and 26% of intestinal IgA+ and IgG+ plasmablasts 27-29 . On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen.", "On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen. Although there are exceptions, the accumulation of somatic hypermutations within the variable regions of the BCR during the process of affinity maturation is generally thought to lead to increased affinity and specificity for the cognate antigen .. Several general techniques are commonly used to identify antigen-specific B cells Table 1 . The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell.", "The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell. In the B cell ELISPOT, antibody secreting B cells ASCs present in a sample or differentiated in vitro are added to plates coated with the antigen of interest. Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies.", "Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies. Enzyme or fluorescent labeled secondary antibodies are then used to visualize spots of antibody secretion and binding to plate-bound antigen at the location of the ASCs. Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive.", "Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive. Secondary antibodies conjugated to combinatorial colored beads can also be used to detect the antibodies secreted from individual B cells with the advantage of multiplexing the assay .. One limitation of the assay is its requirement for antibody secretion by B cells thereby limiting the assay to only a subset of B cells in the repertoire, namely ASCs .. Memory B cells can be stimulated in vitro to differentiate into ASCs prior to addition to the antigen-coated plate . .", ". Further, the antigenspecific B cells identified by ELISPOT are generally not available for downstream analysis. Limiting dilution is another technique that has been used to isolate antigen-specific B cells. In this approach, primary cells can be diluted serially until individual B cells are separated in microwell plates . .", ". The B cells can then be cultured and expanded ex vivo and/or immortalized using EBV such that each well contains a monoclonal antibody . . Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest.", "Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest. Although antibodies can be sequenced and cloned, the requirement for an ex vivo culture prior to selection precludes determination of the transcriptional profile of the original B cell in this approach. This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells .", "This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells . . Advances in single cell next generation sequencing technology have allowed high throughput transcriptional profiling and sequencing of paired immunoglobulin heavy and light chains . .", ". In this approach, antigen specificity can be tested after monoclonal antibodies are cloned and produced using the sequencing data. This method can be useful in identifying antigen-specific B cells that have undergone clonal expansion after vaccination or acute infection . . Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . .", "Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . . Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection.", "Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection. Fluorochromes can either be attached covalently via chemical conjugation to the antigen, expressed as a recombinant fusion protein, or attached non-covalently by biotinylating the antigen. After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen.", "After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen. Biotinylation of the antigen at a ratio ≤1 biotin to 1 antigen is important, since each streptavidin has the potential to bind four biotins. If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added.", "If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added. Alternatively, site directed biotinylation can be accomplished by adding either an AviTag or BioEase tag to the recombinant antigen prior to expression . .", ". When site-specific biotinylation is utilized, researchers must keep in mind that the tag may occlude an epitope from recognition by B cells which can be problematic for vaccine antigens. Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation.", "Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation. Another important consideration is the potential for confounding by B cells in the repertoire that bind to the fluorochrome, streptavidin, or any linkers rather than to the antigen of interest. Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells .", "Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells . . Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome .", "Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome . . However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population.", "However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population. To fully remove confounding from the fluorochrome, streptavidin, and linkers, a \"decoy\" tetramer can be used to identify these contaminating B cells .. In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells.", "In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells. Notably, it is critical to use the same source of fluorochrome conjugated streptavidin in the tetramer and decoy reagent, because conjugation methods, recombinant streptavidin, and protein fluorochromes like R-phycoerythrin vary enough from company to company to alter some of the epitopes available for B cells to bind. One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated.", "One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated. In addition to recombinant proteins and synthesized peptides, labeled polysaccharides, lipids, haptens, virus-like particles, and pseudo viruses have also been used to identify antigen-specific cells by flow cytometry 33, . Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry .", "Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry . . With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining.", "With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining. Additionally, the immunoglobulin capture assay is a flow cytometry-based adaptation of the ELISPOT assay in which a streptavidin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibody carrying four biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies is used to simultaneously bind plasmablasts and capture secreted antibody followed by fluorescent-labeled antigen to detect antigenspecific plasmablasts . .", ". The mean fluorescence intensity measured by flow cytometry and normalized to the level of BCR expression also provides a measure of the relative amount of antigen binding to a B cell and can be used as a rough surrogate for binding affinity . .", ". Preincubation of B cells with increasing concentrations of a monomeric antigen prior to labeling with tetrameric antigen can also be used to further quantify binding affinity. Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding ..", "Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding .. Individual cells can also be isolated by fluorescence activated cell sorting FACS for downstream analysis, including BCR sequencing and cloning, BCR affinity measurement, in vitro proliferation, and transcriptional profiling. Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells.", "Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells. Magnetic nanoparticles conjugated to antibodies targeting the fluorochrome on the antigen of interest, allow for the enrichment of antigen-specific B cells prior to flow cytometry . .", ". This approach is particularly useful for detecting rare antigenspecific naïve B cells, autoreactive B cells, memory B cells, and plasmablasts . . The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 .", "The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 . Notably, as with any method that seeks to identify a population of cells at a very low frequency, the background and noise inherent in the detection system is magnified with respect to the signal of interest, especially when that signal is weak. Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: .", "Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: . Using decoys to exclude B cells of unwanted specificities; . careful design of flow cytometry panels to avoid emission spillover into the channel for the antigen of interest; and . choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin.", "choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin. In vivo methods to probe antigen-specific B cell responses in the presence of other antigen-presenting cells and T cell helpers, have increased our mechanistic understanding of the humoral immune response during vaccination, infection, and autoimmunity. Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells.", "Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells. The adoptively transferred B cells can come from wildtype mice or from mice expressing transgenic BCRs Table 2 , and antigen-specific B cells can be analyzed using the techniques described above. Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization.", "Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization. In the first reported application of this technique to demonstrate the cellular origin of antibodies in 1955, fluorescein-conjugated antibodies against ovalbumin and human immunoglobulin were used to stain tissue sections of the spleen from hyperimmune rabbits . .", ". Since then, other groups have fluorescently labeled antigens to localize antigen-specific B cells by microscopy . . Advances in laser capture dissection microscopy, already used in the T cell field, also provide an opportunity for isolating individual antigen-specific B cells for downstream analysis, including sequencing and cloning of the BCR or transcriptional profiling . .", ". However, antigen staining of BCRs in situ can be challenging depending on the binding of antigens from pathogens to other cellular receptors or an alteration of BCR specificity during tissue fixation or processing. Two-photon or multiphoton microscopy has the ability to resolve images at greater depths and with less photobleaching than confocal microscopy . .", ". As a result, this technology has allowed real-time imaging in living, intact lymphoid tissues of mice, permitting the direct in vivo observation of immune cell interactions. The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy .", "The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy . . Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans.", "Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans. Transgenic mice that produce humanized cytokines by knock-in replacement can be used to support human hematopoietic stem cells . .", ". Transgenic mice with complete humanization of the mouse immunoglobulin loci provide an opportunity for recapitulating the breadth of the human B cell repertoire and serve as a valuable tool for therapeutic antibody discovery . .", ". However, one caveat is that the allele frequencies found in the B cell repertoires of these mouse models may not necessarily recapitulate those found in humans . . Mass cytometry has the potential to provide further high-dimensional analysis of antigen-specific B cells. In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells.", "In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells. Since data is collected as time-offlight mass spectrometry, up to 42 unique parameters can be simultaneously measured from a single sample without significant spillover between channels or the need for compensation. Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . .", "Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . . Mass cytometry with metal-labeled peptide-MHC tetramers has been used successfully to identify and characterize antigen-specific T cells, but to our knowledge has not yet been applied to antigen-specific B cells . .", ". One limitation of this approach is that cells are unavailable for downstream analysis since they are vaporized by a plasma torch to atomize the ion tags. However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection.", "However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection. On the horizon, single cell RNA-sequencing RNA-seq technologies have the potential to revolutionize the study of antigen-specific immune cells . .", ". The ability to generate a library of tetramers with unique barcodes could allow the simultaneous examination of gene expression profiles from a large number of cells with different antigen specificities in a single experiment. Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics .", "Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics . . . .", ". . . The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents.", "The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents. Methods for studying antigen-specific B cell responses are being increasingly applied to tackle diseases like HIV, RSV, and autoimmune diseases, in which the immune response either fails to protect or clear disease, or where it enhances disease or is responsible for the disease itself. Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role.", "Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role. JB and JT reviewed the literature, generated figures and tables, and wrote the manuscript." ]

[ "Antibodies against foreign antigens are a critical component of the overall immune response and can facilitate pathogen clearance during a primary infection and also protect against subsequent infections. Dysregulation of the antibody response can lead to an autoimmune disease, malignancy, or enhanced infection. Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination.", "Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination. In this review, we summarize the established techniques and discuss new and emerging technologies for probing the B cell response in vitro and in vivo by taking advantage of the specificity of B cell receptor BCR -associated and secreted antibodies. These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells.", "These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells. We also present our approach to identify rare antigen-specific B cells using magnetic enrichment followed by flow cytometry. Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate.", "Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate. Transgenic mouse models of B cells targeting model antigens and of B cell signaling have also significantly advanced our understanding of antigen-specific B cell responses in vivo. Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key.", "Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key. He reasoned that antitoxins antibodies contained in a solution in the serum of immunized animals must be identical to a cellular receptor \"for a really well-made key will not open different locks at the same time\" . .", ". It took almost five decades before immunofluorescence microscopy was used to confirm the cellular origin of antibodies . . Major strides in the B cell and antibody field followed in the 1970s with the development of hybridoma technology to produce monoclonal antibodies and the discovery that somatic rearrangement during B cell differentiation was responsible for antibody diversification . .", ". The subsequent explosion of available monoclonal antibodies led to revolutionary diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents to distinguish different types of immune cells . . Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell.", "Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell. Methods to probe the antigen-specific B cell response have advanced our understanding of how to harness the remarkable breadth of the B cell repertoire and the exquisite specificity of the individual B cell in developing . vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; .", "vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; . antibodies that prevent disease when given prophylactically; and . antibodies that can be given as therapy after the onset of disease. Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen.", "Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen. However, vaccine development against pathogens that are traditionally difficult to vaccinate against may rely on a deeper investigation of the B cell response to the antigens exposed on the surface of these pathogens. For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies .", "For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies . . . . .", ". . . . Insights into the ontogeny of these rare B cells could allow the design of a step-wise vaccine regimen that stimulates the germ-line precursor to expand and mature to produce circulating bnAbs which could protect against HIV acquisition . .", ". For RSV, stabilized versions of the fusion F protein in the pre-fusion conformation have led to insights in the B cell's response to infection and has generated potentially safer and more efficacious vaccine candidates . .", ". Influenza also performs fusion through the stem region of the hemagglutinin protein, and the identification of B cells that target this relatively conserved site has spurred research on the development of a universal influenza vaccine . . . .", ". . . Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 .", "Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 . Rare memory B cells producing antibodies specific for the EBV fusion machinery have been isolated; these can neutralize both B cell and epithelial cell infection .. A new paradigm in malaria vaccine development is also emerging with the discovery of IgM+ and IgD+ memory B cells targeting the Merozoite Surface Protein 1, that rapidly respond to malaria re-infection .. Further, highly potent neutralizing antibodies targeting a novel and conserved site on the Circumsporozoite Protein have been isolated from B cells .. Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases.", "Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases. The solutions to the crystal structures of surface proteins for a variety of pathogens, the conformational stabilization of these antigens, and the application of the methods summarized in this review, to probe antigen-specific B cell responses, have created new opportunities for systematic and rational vaccine design for HIV, RSV, EBV, malaria, and many other pathogens. The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens ..", "The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens .. Although these cells are potentially pathogenic, the deletion of B cells with high affinity to self-antigen through apoptosis, anergy of B cells with low affinity to self-antigen, and the absence of T cell help combine together to protect against autoimmune disease in mice .. The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases.", "The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases. Although the term antigen-specific B cell is used throughout this mini-review to denote the analysis of B cells based on binding between the B cell receptor BCR and a specific antigen used as bait, it is important to keep in mind that BCRs within the polyclonal B cell repertoire exhibit a spectrum of polyreactivity. On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities.", "On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities. The frequency of polyreactivity in the normal adult human B cell repertoire has been estimated to be 4% of naïve B cells, 23% of IgG+ memory B cells, and 26% of intestinal IgA+ and IgG+ plasmablasts 27-29 . On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen.", "On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen. Although there are exceptions, the accumulation of somatic hypermutations within the variable regions of the BCR during the process of affinity maturation is generally thought to lead to increased affinity and specificity for the cognate antigen .. Several general techniques are commonly used to identify antigen-specific B cells Table 1 . The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell.", "The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell. In the B cell ELISPOT, antibody secreting B cells ASCs present in a sample or differentiated in vitro are added to plates coated with the antigen of interest. Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies.", "Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies. Enzyme or fluorescent labeled secondary antibodies are then used to visualize spots of antibody secretion and binding to plate-bound antigen at the location of the ASCs. Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive.", "Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive. Secondary antibodies conjugated to combinatorial colored beads can also be used to detect the antibodies secreted from individual B cells with the advantage of multiplexing the assay .. One limitation of the assay is its requirement for antibody secretion by B cells thereby limiting the assay to only a subset of B cells in the repertoire, namely ASCs .. Memory B cells can be stimulated in vitro to differentiate into ASCs prior to addition to the antigen-coated plate . .", ". Further, the antigenspecific B cells identified by ELISPOT are generally not available for downstream analysis. Limiting dilution is another technique that has been used to isolate antigen-specific B cells. In this approach, primary cells can be diluted serially until individual B cells are separated in microwell plates . .", ". The B cells can then be cultured and expanded ex vivo and/or immortalized using EBV such that each well contains a monoclonal antibody . . Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest.", "Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest. Although antibodies can be sequenced and cloned, the requirement for an ex vivo culture prior to selection precludes determination of the transcriptional profile of the original B cell in this approach. This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells .", "This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells . . Advances in single cell next generation sequencing technology have allowed high throughput transcriptional profiling and sequencing of paired immunoglobulin heavy and light chains . .", ". In this approach, antigen specificity can be tested after monoclonal antibodies are cloned and produced using the sequencing data. This method can be useful in identifying antigen-specific B cells that have undergone clonal expansion after vaccination or acute infection . . Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . .", "Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . . Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection.", "Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection. Fluorochromes can either be attached covalently via chemical conjugation to the antigen, expressed as a recombinant fusion protein, or attached non-covalently by biotinylating the antigen. After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen.", "After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen. Biotinylation of the antigen at a ratio ≤1 biotin to 1 antigen is important, since each streptavidin has the potential to bind four biotins. If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added.", "If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added. Alternatively, site directed biotinylation can be accomplished by adding either an AviTag or BioEase tag to the recombinant antigen prior to expression . .", ". When site-specific biotinylation is utilized, researchers must keep in mind that the tag may occlude an epitope from recognition by B cells which can be problematic for vaccine antigens. Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation.", "Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation. Another important consideration is the potential for confounding by B cells in the repertoire that bind to the fluorochrome, streptavidin, or any linkers rather than to the antigen of interest. Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells .", "Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells . . Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome .", "Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome . . However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population.", "However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population. To fully remove confounding from the fluorochrome, streptavidin, and linkers, a \"decoy\" tetramer can be used to identify these contaminating B cells .. In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells.", "In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells. Notably, it is critical to use the same source of fluorochrome conjugated streptavidin in the tetramer and decoy reagent, because conjugation methods, recombinant streptavidin, and protein fluorochromes like R-phycoerythrin vary enough from company to company to alter some of the epitopes available for B cells to bind. One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated.", "One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated. In addition to recombinant proteins and synthesized peptides, labeled polysaccharides, lipids, haptens, virus-like particles, and pseudo viruses have also been used to identify antigen-specific cells by flow cytometry 33, . Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry .", "Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry . . With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining.", "With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining. Additionally, the immunoglobulin capture assay is a flow cytometry-based adaptation of the ELISPOT assay in which a streptavidin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibody carrying four biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies is used to simultaneously bind plasmablasts and capture secreted antibody followed by fluorescent-labeled antigen to detect antigenspecific plasmablasts . .", ". The mean fluorescence intensity measured by flow cytometry and normalized to the level of BCR expression also provides a measure of the relative amount of antigen binding to a B cell and can be used as a rough surrogate for binding affinity . .", ". Preincubation of B cells with increasing concentrations of a monomeric antigen prior to labeling with tetrameric antigen can also be used to further quantify binding affinity. Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding ..", "Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding .. Individual cells can also be isolated by fluorescence activated cell sorting FACS for downstream analysis, including BCR sequencing and cloning, BCR affinity measurement, in vitro proliferation, and transcriptional profiling. Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells.", "Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells. Magnetic nanoparticles conjugated to antibodies targeting the fluorochrome on the antigen of interest, allow for the enrichment of antigen-specific B cells prior to flow cytometry . .", ". This approach is particularly useful for detecting rare antigenspecific naïve B cells, autoreactive B cells, memory B cells, and plasmablasts . . The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 .", "The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 . Notably, as with any method that seeks to identify a population of cells at a very low frequency, the background and noise inherent in the detection system is magnified with respect to the signal of interest, especially when that signal is weak. Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: .", "Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: . Using decoys to exclude B cells of unwanted specificities; . careful design of flow cytometry panels to avoid emission spillover into the channel for the antigen of interest; and . choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin.", "choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin. In vivo methods to probe antigen-specific B cell responses in the presence of other antigen-presenting cells and T cell helpers, have increased our mechanistic understanding of the humoral immune response during vaccination, infection, and autoimmunity. Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells.", "Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells. The adoptively transferred B cells can come from wildtype mice or from mice expressing transgenic BCRs Table 2 , and antigen-specific B cells can be analyzed using the techniques described above. Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization.", "Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization. In the first reported application of this technique to demonstrate the cellular origin of antibodies in 1955, fluorescein-conjugated antibodies against ovalbumin and human immunoglobulin were used to stain tissue sections of the spleen from hyperimmune rabbits . .", ". Since then, other groups have fluorescently labeled antigens to localize antigen-specific B cells by microscopy . . Advances in laser capture dissection microscopy, already used in the T cell field, also provide an opportunity for isolating individual antigen-specific B cells for downstream analysis, including sequencing and cloning of the BCR or transcriptional profiling . .", ". However, antigen staining of BCRs in situ can be challenging depending on the binding of antigens from pathogens to other cellular receptors or an alteration of BCR specificity during tissue fixation or processing. Two-photon or multiphoton microscopy has the ability to resolve images at greater depths and with less photobleaching than confocal microscopy . .", ". As a result, this technology has allowed real-time imaging in living, intact lymphoid tissues of mice, permitting the direct in vivo observation of immune cell interactions. The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy .", "The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy . . Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans.", "Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans. Transgenic mice that produce humanized cytokines by knock-in replacement can be used to support human hematopoietic stem cells . .", ". Transgenic mice with complete humanization of the mouse immunoglobulin loci provide an opportunity for recapitulating the breadth of the human B cell repertoire and serve as a valuable tool for therapeutic antibody discovery . .", ". However, one caveat is that the allele frequencies found in the B cell repertoires of these mouse models may not necessarily recapitulate those found in humans . . Mass cytometry has the potential to provide further high-dimensional analysis of antigen-specific B cells. In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells.", "In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells. Since data is collected as time-offlight mass spectrometry, up to 42 unique parameters can be simultaneously measured from a single sample without significant spillover between channels or the need for compensation. Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . .", "Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . . Mass cytometry with metal-labeled peptide-MHC tetramers has been used successfully to identify and characterize antigen-specific T cells, but to our knowledge has not yet been applied to antigen-specific B cells . .", ". One limitation of this approach is that cells are unavailable for downstream analysis since they are vaporized by a plasma torch to atomize the ion tags. However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection.", "However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection. On the horizon, single cell RNA-sequencing RNA-seq technologies have the potential to revolutionize the study of antigen-specific immune cells . .", ". The ability to generate a library of tetramers with unique barcodes could allow the simultaneous examination of gene expression profiles from a large number of cells with different antigen specificities in a single experiment. Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics .", "Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics . . . .", ". . . The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents.", "The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents. Methods for studying antigen-specific B cell responses are being increasingly applied to tackle diseases like HIV, RSV, and autoimmune diseases, in which the immune response either fails to protect or clear disease, or where it enhances disease or is responsible for the disease itself. Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role.", "Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role. JB and JT reviewed the literature, generated figures and tables, and wrote the manuscript." ]

[ "Antibodies against foreign antigens are a critical component of the overall immune response and can facilitate pathogen clearance during a primary infection and also protect against subsequent infections. Dysregulation of the antibody response can lead to an autoimmune disease, malignancy, or enhanced infection. Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination.", "Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination. In this review, we summarize the established techniques and discuss new and emerging technologies for probing the B cell response in vitro and in vivo by taking advantage of the specificity of B cell receptor BCR -associated and secreted antibodies. These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells.", "These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells. We also present our approach to identify rare antigen-specific B cells using magnetic enrichment followed by flow cytometry. Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate.", "Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate. Transgenic mouse models of B cells targeting model antigens and of B cell signaling have also significantly advanced our understanding of antigen-specific B cell responses in vivo. Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key.", "Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key. He reasoned that antitoxins antibodies contained in a solution in the serum of immunized animals must be identical to a cellular receptor \"for a really well-made key will not open different locks at the same time\" . .", ". It took almost five decades before immunofluorescence microscopy was used to confirm the cellular origin of antibodies . . Major strides in the B cell and antibody field followed in the 1970s with the development of hybridoma technology to produce monoclonal antibodies and the discovery that somatic rearrangement during B cell differentiation was responsible for antibody diversification . .", ". The subsequent explosion of available monoclonal antibodies led to revolutionary diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents to distinguish different types of immune cells . . Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell.", "Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell. Methods to probe the antigen-specific B cell response have advanced our understanding of how to harness the remarkable breadth of the B cell repertoire and the exquisite specificity of the individual B cell in developing . vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; .", "vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; . antibodies that prevent disease when given prophylactically; and . antibodies that can be given as therapy after the onset of disease. Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen.", "Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen. However, vaccine development against pathogens that are traditionally difficult to vaccinate against may rely on a deeper investigation of the B cell response to the antigens exposed on the surface of these pathogens. For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies .", "For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies . . . . .", ". . . . Insights into the ontogeny of these rare B cells could allow the design of a step-wise vaccine regimen that stimulates the germ-line precursor to expand and mature to produce circulating bnAbs which could protect against HIV acquisition . .", ". For RSV, stabilized versions of the fusion F protein in the pre-fusion conformation have led to insights in the B cell's response to infection and has generated potentially safer and more efficacious vaccine candidates . .", ". Influenza also performs fusion through the stem region of the hemagglutinin protein, and the identification of B cells that target this relatively conserved site has spurred research on the development of a universal influenza vaccine . . . .", ". . . Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 .", "Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 . Rare memory B cells producing antibodies specific for the EBV fusion machinery have been isolated; these can neutralize both B cell and epithelial cell infection .. A new paradigm in malaria vaccine development is also emerging with the discovery of IgM+ and IgD+ memory B cells targeting the Merozoite Surface Protein 1, that rapidly respond to malaria re-infection .. Further, highly potent neutralizing antibodies targeting a novel and conserved site on the Circumsporozoite Protein have been isolated from B cells .. Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases.", "Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases. The solutions to the crystal structures of surface proteins for a variety of pathogens, the conformational stabilization of these antigens, and the application of the methods summarized in this review, to probe antigen-specific B cell responses, have created new opportunities for systematic and rational vaccine design for HIV, RSV, EBV, malaria, and many other pathogens. The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens ..", "The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens .. Although these cells are potentially pathogenic, the deletion of B cells with high affinity to self-antigen through apoptosis, anergy of B cells with low affinity to self-antigen, and the absence of T cell help combine together to protect against autoimmune disease in mice .. The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases.", "The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases. Although the term antigen-specific B cell is used throughout this mini-review to denote the analysis of B cells based on binding between the B cell receptor BCR and a specific antigen used as bait, it is important to keep in mind that BCRs within the polyclonal B cell repertoire exhibit a spectrum of polyreactivity. On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities.", "On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities. The frequency of polyreactivity in the normal adult human B cell repertoire has been estimated to be 4% of naïve B cells, 23% of IgG+ memory B cells, and 26% of intestinal IgA+ and IgG+ plasmablasts 27-29 . On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen.", "On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen. Although there are exceptions, the accumulation of somatic hypermutations within the variable regions of the BCR during the process of affinity maturation is generally thought to lead to increased affinity and specificity for the cognate antigen .. Several general techniques are commonly used to identify antigen-specific B cells Table 1 . The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell.", "The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell. In the B cell ELISPOT, antibody secreting B cells ASCs present in a sample or differentiated in vitro are added to plates coated with the antigen of interest. Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies.", "Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies. Enzyme or fluorescent labeled secondary antibodies are then used to visualize spots of antibody secretion and binding to plate-bound antigen at the location of the ASCs. Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive.", "Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive. Secondary antibodies conjugated to combinatorial colored beads can also be used to detect the antibodies secreted from individual B cells with the advantage of multiplexing the assay .. One limitation of the assay is its requirement for antibody secretion by B cells thereby limiting the assay to only a subset of B cells in the repertoire, namely ASCs .. Memory B cells can be stimulated in vitro to differentiate into ASCs prior to addition to the antigen-coated plate . .", ". Further, the antigenspecific B cells identified by ELISPOT are generally not available for downstream analysis. Limiting dilution is another technique that has been used to isolate antigen-specific B cells. In this approach, primary cells can be diluted serially until individual B cells are separated in microwell plates . .", ". The B cells can then be cultured and expanded ex vivo and/or immortalized using EBV such that each well contains a monoclonal antibody . . Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest.", "Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest. Although antibodies can be sequenced and cloned, the requirement for an ex vivo culture prior to selection precludes determination of the transcriptional profile of the original B cell in this approach. This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells .", "This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells . . Advances in single cell next generation sequencing technology have allowed high throughput transcriptional profiling and sequencing of paired immunoglobulin heavy and light chains . .", ". In this approach, antigen specificity can be tested after monoclonal antibodies are cloned and produced using the sequencing data. This method can be useful in identifying antigen-specific B cells that have undergone clonal expansion after vaccination or acute infection . . Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . .", "Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . . Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection.", "Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection. Fluorochromes can either be attached covalently via chemical conjugation to the antigen, expressed as a recombinant fusion protein, or attached non-covalently by biotinylating the antigen. After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen.", "After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen. Biotinylation of the antigen at a ratio ≤1 biotin to 1 antigen is important, since each streptavidin has the potential to bind four biotins. If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added.", "If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added. Alternatively, site directed biotinylation can be accomplished by adding either an AviTag or BioEase tag to the recombinant antigen prior to expression . .", ". When site-specific biotinylation is utilized, researchers must keep in mind that the tag may occlude an epitope from recognition by B cells which can be problematic for vaccine antigens. Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation.", "Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation. Another important consideration is the potential for confounding by B cells in the repertoire that bind to the fluorochrome, streptavidin, or any linkers rather than to the antigen of interest. Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells .", "Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells . . Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome .", "Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome . . However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population.", "However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population. To fully remove confounding from the fluorochrome, streptavidin, and linkers, a \"decoy\" tetramer can be used to identify these contaminating B cells .. In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells.", "In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells. Notably, it is critical to use the same source of fluorochrome conjugated streptavidin in the tetramer and decoy reagent, because conjugation methods, recombinant streptavidin, and protein fluorochromes like R-phycoerythrin vary enough from company to company to alter some of the epitopes available for B cells to bind. One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated.", "One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated. In addition to recombinant proteins and synthesized peptides, labeled polysaccharides, lipids, haptens, virus-like particles, and pseudo viruses have also been used to identify antigen-specific cells by flow cytometry 33, . Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry .", "Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry . . With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining.", "With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining. Additionally, the immunoglobulin capture assay is a flow cytometry-based adaptation of the ELISPOT assay in which a streptavidin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibody carrying four biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies is used to simultaneously bind plasmablasts and capture secreted antibody followed by fluorescent-labeled antigen to detect antigenspecific plasmablasts . .", ". The mean fluorescence intensity measured by flow cytometry and normalized to the level of BCR expression also provides a measure of the relative amount of antigen binding to a B cell and can be used as a rough surrogate for binding affinity . .", ". Preincubation of B cells with increasing concentrations of a monomeric antigen prior to labeling with tetrameric antigen can also be used to further quantify binding affinity. Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding ..", "Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding .. Individual cells can also be isolated by fluorescence activated cell sorting FACS for downstream analysis, including BCR sequencing and cloning, BCR affinity measurement, in vitro proliferation, and transcriptional profiling. Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells.", "Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells. Magnetic nanoparticles conjugated to antibodies targeting the fluorochrome on the antigen of interest, allow for the enrichment of antigen-specific B cells prior to flow cytometry . .", ". This approach is particularly useful for detecting rare antigenspecific naïve B cells, autoreactive B cells, memory B cells, and plasmablasts . . The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 .", "The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 . Notably, as with any method that seeks to identify a population of cells at a very low frequency, the background and noise inherent in the detection system is magnified with respect to the signal of interest, especially when that signal is weak. Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: .", "Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: . Using decoys to exclude B cells of unwanted specificities; . careful design of flow cytometry panels to avoid emission spillover into the channel for the antigen of interest; and . choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin.", "choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin. In vivo methods to probe antigen-specific B cell responses in the presence of other antigen-presenting cells and T cell helpers, have increased our mechanistic understanding of the humoral immune response during vaccination, infection, and autoimmunity. Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells.", "Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells. The adoptively transferred B cells can come from wildtype mice or from mice expressing transgenic BCRs Table 2 , and antigen-specific B cells can be analyzed using the techniques described above. Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization.", "Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization. In the first reported application of this technique to demonstrate the cellular origin of antibodies in 1955, fluorescein-conjugated antibodies against ovalbumin and human immunoglobulin were used to stain tissue sections of the spleen from hyperimmune rabbits . .", ". Since then, other groups have fluorescently labeled antigens to localize antigen-specific B cells by microscopy . . Advances in laser capture dissection microscopy, already used in the T cell field, also provide an opportunity for isolating individual antigen-specific B cells for downstream analysis, including sequencing and cloning of the BCR or transcriptional profiling . .", ". However, antigen staining of BCRs in situ can be challenging depending on the binding of antigens from pathogens to other cellular receptors or an alteration of BCR specificity during tissue fixation or processing. Two-photon or multiphoton microscopy has the ability to resolve images at greater depths and with less photobleaching than confocal microscopy . .", ". As a result, this technology has allowed real-time imaging in living, intact lymphoid tissues of mice, permitting the direct in vivo observation of immune cell interactions. The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy .", "The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy . . Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans.", "Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans. Transgenic mice that produce humanized cytokines by knock-in replacement can be used to support human hematopoietic stem cells . .", ". Transgenic mice with complete humanization of the mouse immunoglobulin loci provide an opportunity for recapitulating the breadth of the human B cell repertoire and serve as a valuable tool for therapeutic antibody discovery . .", ". However, one caveat is that the allele frequencies found in the B cell repertoires of these mouse models may not necessarily recapitulate those found in humans . . Mass cytometry has the potential to provide further high-dimensional analysis of antigen-specific B cells. In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells.", "In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells. Since data is collected as time-offlight mass spectrometry, up to 42 unique parameters can be simultaneously measured from a single sample without significant spillover between channels or the need for compensation. Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . .", "Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . . Mass cytometry with metal-labeled peptide-MHC tetramers has been used successfully to identify and characterize antigen-specific T cells, but to our knowledge has not yet been applied to antigen-specific B cells . .", ". One limitation of this approach is that cells are unavailable for downstream analysis since they are vaporized by a plasma torch to atomize the ion tags. However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection.", "However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection. On the horizon, single cell RNA-sequencing RNA-seq technologies have the potential to revolutionize the study of antigen-specific immune cells . .", ". The ability to generate a library of tetramers with unique barcodes could allow the simultaneous examination of gene expression profiles from a large number of cells with different antigen specificities in a single experiment. Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics .", "Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics . . . .", ". . . The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents.", "The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents. Methods for studying antigen-specific B cell responses are being increasingly applied to tackle diseases like HIV, RSV, and autoimmune diseases, in which the immune response either fails to protect or clear disease, or where it enhances disease or is responsible for the disease itself. Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role.", "Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role. JB and JT reviewed the literature, generated figures and tables, and wrote the manuscript." ]

[ "Antibodies against foreign antigens are a critical component of the overall immune response and can facilitate pathogen clearance during a primary infection and also protect against subsequent infections. Dysregulation of the antibody response can lead to an autoimmune disease, malignancy, or enhanced infection. Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination.", "Since the experimental delineation of a distinct B cell lineage in 1965, various methods have been developed to understand antigen-specific B cell responses in the context of autoimmune diseases, primary immunodeficiencies, infection, and vaccination. In this review, we summarize the established techniques and discuss new and emerging technologies for probing the B cell response in vitro and in vivo by taking advantage of the specificity of B cell receptor BCR -associated and secreted antibodies. These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells.", "These include ELISPOT, flow cytometry, mass cytometry, and fluorescence microscopy to identify and/or isolate primary antigen-specific B cells. We also present our approach to identify rare antigen-specific B cells using magnetic enrichment followed by flow cytometry. Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate.", "Once these cells are isolated, in vitro proliferation assays and adoptive transfer experiments in mice can be used to further characterize antigen-specific B cell activation, function, and fate. Transgenic mouse models of B cells targeting model antigens and of B cell signaling have also significantly advanced our understanding of antigen-specific B cell responses in vivo. Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key.", "Text: In his Nobel lecture in 1908, Paul Ehrlich likened the antibody-antigen interaction to a lock and key. He reasoned that antitoxins antibodies contained in a solution in the serum of immunized animals must be identical to a cellular receptor \"for a really well-made key will not open different locks at the same time\" . .", ". It took almost five decades before immunofluorescence microscopy was used to confirm the cellular origin of antibodies . . Major strides in the B cell and antibody field followed in the 1970s with the development of hybridoma technology to produce monoclonal antibodies and the discovery that somatic rearrangement during B cell differentiation was responsible for antibody diversification . .", ". The subsequent explosion of available monoclonal antibodies led to revolutionary diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents to distinguish different types of immune cells . . Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell.", "Together, these discoveries have allowed us to probe humoral immunity at the level of the antigen-specific B cell. Methods to probe the antigen-specific B cell response have advanced our understanding of how to harness the remarkable breadth of the B cell repertoire and the exquisite specificity of the individual B cell in developing . vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; .", "vaccine candidates that elicit protective antibodies; . antibodies that prevent disease when given prophylactically; and . antibodies that can be given as therapy after the onset of disease. Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen.", "Many of the vaccines currently available were originally developed empirically either by inactivating, attenuating, or administering a subunit of the pathogen. However, vaccine development against pathogens that are traditionally difficult to vaccinate against may rely on a deeper investigation of the B cell response to the antigens exposed on the surface of these pathogens. For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies .", "For HIV-1, the discovery of broadly neutralizing antibodies bnAbs that protect against infection across diverse viral isolates has intensified efforts to understand the developmental pathway of the rare B cells that produce these antibodies . . . . .", ". . . . Insights into the ontogeny of these rare B cells could allow the design of a step-wise vaccine regimen that stimulates the germ-line precursor to expand and mature to produce circulating bnAbs which could protect against HIV acquisition . .", ". For RSV, stabilized versions of the fusion F protein in the pre-fusion conformation have led to insights in the B cell's response to infection and has generated potentially safer and more efficacious vaccine candidates . .", ". Influenza also performs fusion through the stem region of the hemagglutinin protein, and the identification of B cells that target this relatively conserved site has spurred research on the development of a universal influenza vaccine . . . .", ". . . Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 .", "Like RSV, HIV, and influenza, the fusion proteins of EBV and CMV exist in a pre-fusion conformation, and stabilization in their pre-fusion states could greatly accelerate vaccine development against these pathogens 17-19 . Rare memory B cells producing antibodies specific for the EBV fusion machinery have been isolated; these can neutralize both B cell and epithelial cell infection .. A new paradigm in malaria vaccine development is also emerging with the discovery of IgM+ and IgD+ memory B cells targeting the Merozoite Surface Protein 1, that rapidly respond to malaria re-infection .. Further, highly potent neutralizing antibodies targeting a novel and conserved site on the Circumsporozoite Protein have been isolated from B cells .. Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases.", "Together, these examples demonstrate the importance of studying antigen-specific humoral responses to infectious diseases. The solutions to the crystal structures of surface proteins for a variety of pathogens, the conformational stabilization of these antigens, and the application of the methods summarized in this review, to probe antigen-specific B cell responses, have created new opportunities for systematic and rational vaccine design for HIV, RSV, EBV, malaria, and many other pathogens. The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens ..", "The study of B cell responses has not only informed vaccine design but has also advanced our understanding of antibodymediated autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus .. Up to 20% of mature, naïve B cells have receptors with the capacity to bind self-antigens .. Although these cells are potentially pathogenic, the deletion of B cells with high affinity to self-antigen through apoptosis, anergy of B cells with low affinity to self-antigen, and the absence of T cell help combine together to protect against autoimmune disease in mice .. The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases.", "The study of autoantigen-specific B cells and a detailed analysis of B cell subsets with pathogenic potential in humans could lead to a better understanding of how to prevent and treat autoimmune diseases. Although the term antigen-specific B cell is used throughout this mini-review to denote the analysis of B cells based on binding between the B cell receptor BCR and a specific antigen used as bait, it is important to keep in mind that BCRs within the polyclonal B cell repertoire exhibit a spectrum of polyreactivity. On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities.", "On one end of the spectrum, a highly polyreactive BCR is able to bind multiple structurally unrelated antigens with physiologically relevant affinities. The frequency of polyreactivity in the normal adult human B cell repertoire has been estimated to be 4% of naïve B cells, 23% of IgG+ memory B cells, and 26% of intestinal IgA+ and IgG+ plasmablasts 27-29 . On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen.", "On the other end of the spectrum, a mono reactive BCR is activated only when it encounters a single cognate antigen. Although there are exceptions, the accumulation of somatic hypermutations within the variable regions of the BCR during the process of affinity maturation is generally thought to lead to increased affinity and specificity for the cognate antigen .. Several general techniques are commonly used to identify antigen-specific B cells Table 1 . The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell.", "The B cell enzyme linked immunospot ELISPOT technique relies on the principle of capturing the secreted antibody in the vicinity of each cell. In the B cell ELISPOT, antibody secreting B cells ASCs present in a sample or differentiated in vitro are added to plates coated with the antigen of interest. Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies.", "Antigen-specific antibodies will bind in close proximity to the location of the individual B cells producing those antibodies. Enzyme or fluorescent labeled secondary antibodies are then used to visualize spots of antibody secretion and binding to plate-bound antigen at the location of the ASCs. Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive.", "Each spot corresponds to antibody produced from a single antigen-specific B cell and therefore the technique is extremely sensitive. Secondary antibodies conjugated to combinatorial colored beads can also be used to detect the antibodies secreted from individual B cells with the advantage of multiplexing the assay .. One limitation of the assay is its requirement for antibody secretion by B cells thereby limiting the assay to only a subset of B cells in the repertoire, namely ASCs .. Memory B cells can be stimulated in vitro to differentiate into ASCs prior to addition to the antigen-coated plate . .", ". Further, the antigenspecific B cells identified by ELISPOT are generally not available for downstream analysis. Limiting dilution is another technique that has been used to isolate antigen-specific B cells. In this approach, primary cells can be diluted serially until individual B cells are separated in microwell plates . .", ". The B cells can then be cultured and expanded ex vivo and/or immortalized using EBV such that each well contains a monoclonal antibody . . Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest.", "Antigen-specific B cells can be selected by screening the culture supernatants for monoclonal antibodies that bind an antigen of interest. Although antibodies can be sequenced and cloned, the requirement for an ex vivo culture prior to selection precludes determination of the transcriptional profile of the original B cell in this approach. This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells .", "This technique can potentially be time-consuming and laborious, but the use of microfluidics and robotics has greatly improved the throughput for selecting antigen-specific B cells . . Advances in single cell next generation sequencing technology have allowed high throughput transcriptional profiling and sequencing of paired immunoglobulin heavy and light chains . .", ". In this approach, antigen specificity can be tested after monoclonal antibodies are cloned and produced using the sequencing data. This method can be useful in identifying antigen-specific B cells that have undergone clonal expansion after vaccination or acute infection . . Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . .", "Flow cytometry is the most common method used for single cell analysis and isolation . . Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection.", "Flow cytometry-based analysis of antigen-specific B cells is dependent on labeling antigen with a fluorescent tag to allow detection. Fluorochromes can either be attached covalently via chemical conjugation to the antigen, expressed as a recombinant fusion protein, or attached non-covalently by biotinylating the antigen. After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen.", "After biotinylation, fluorochrome-conjugated streptavidin is added to generate a labeled tetramer of the antigen. Biotinylation of the antigen at a ratio ≤1 biotin to 1 antigen is important, since each streptavidin has the potential to bind four biotins. If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added.", "If the ratio of biotin to antigen is >1:1, then clumping and precipitation of the antigen out of solution can occur as soon as streptavidin is added. Alternatively, site directed biotinylation can be accomplished by adding either an AviTag or BioEase tag to the recombinant antigen prior to expression . .", ". When site-specific biotinylation is utilized, researchers must keep in mind that the tag may occlude an epitope from recognition by B cells which can be problematic for vaccine antigens. Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation.", "Further, for proteins that oligomerize, multiple tags may be incorporated, possibly resulting in aggregation. Another important consideration is the potential for confounding by B cells in the repertoire that bind to the fluorochrome, streptavidin, or any linkers rather than to the antigen of interest. Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells .", "Binding between fluorochromes, linkers, or streptavidin and BCRs from humans and mice never exposed to these antigens are generally of low affinity, and these BCRs are generally expressed by naïve and potentially polyreactive B cells . . Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome .", "Dual labeling, in which the same antigen is separately labeled with two different fluorochromes, can be used to identify double positive B cells and remove confounding by B cells that bind the fluorochrome . . However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population.", "However, even when tetramers are utilized for dual labeling, streptavidin-specific B cells will contaminate the double positive population. To fully remove confounding from the fluorochrome, streptavidin, and linkers, a \"decoy\" tetramer can be used to identify these contaminating B cells .. In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells.", "In this approach, the same fluorochrome used to identify antigen-specific B cells is conjugated to a different fluorochrome such that the emission spectrum is altered by fluorescence resonance energy transfer FRET .. Decoy-binding B cells can therefore be excluded from the true antigen-specific B cells. Notably, it is critical to use the same source of fluorochrome conjugated streptavidin in the tetramer and decoy reagent, because conjugation methods, recombinant streptavidin, and protein fluorochromes like R-phycoerythrin vary enough from company to company to alter some of the epitopes available for B cells to bind. One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated.", "One weakness of the flow cytometric approach is the reliance on antigens that can be readily conjugated to a fluorochrome or biotinylated. In addition to recombinant proteins and synthesized peptides, labeled polysaccharides, lipids, haptens, virus-like particles, and pseudo viruses have also been used to identify antigen-specific cells by flow cytometry 33, . Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry .", "Further, epitope-specific B cells have been identified by screening bacteriophage-displays or microarray peptide libraries with polyclonal antibodies targeting the native antigen to select conformational epitopes that can be fused to fluorescent proteins for use in flow cytometry . . With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining.", "With technologic advancements increasing the number of simultaneously measurable parameters, antigen-specific B cells can be further characterized by cell surface markers and intracellular staining. Additionally, the immunoglobulin capture assay is a flow cytometry-based adaptation of the ELISPOT assay in which a streptavidin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibody carrying four biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies is used to simultaneously bind plasmablasts and capture secreted antibody followed by fluorescent-labeled antigen to detect antigenspecific plasmablasts . .", ". The mean fluorescence intensity measured by flow cytometry and normalized to the level of BCR expression also provides a measure of the relative amount of antigen binding to a B cell and can be used as a rough surrogate for binding affinity . .", ". Preincubation of B cells with increasing concentrations of a monomeric antigen prior to labeling with tetrameric antigen can also be used to further quantify binding affinity. Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding ..", "Cells expressing high affinity BCRs will bind monomeric antigen at low concentrations, whereas low affinity BCRs will require higher concentrations of monomeric antigen to compete with and inhibit tetramer binding .. Individual cells can also be isolated by fluorescence activated cell sorting FACS for downstream analysis, including BCR sequencing and cloning, BCR affinity measurement, in vitro proliferation, and transcriptional profiling. Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells.", "Methods have recently been developed to further improve the sensitivity for detecting rare antigen-specific B cells. Magnetic nanoparticles conjugated to antibodies targeting the fluorochrome on the antigen of interest, allow for the enrichment of antigen-specific B cells prior to flow cytometry . .", ". This approach is particularly useful for detecting rare antigenspecific naïve B cells, autoreactive B cells, memory B cells, and plasmablasts . . The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 .", "The magnetic enrichment strategy allows for the analysis of significantly more cells in a shorter period of time by concentrating the cells of interest prior to flow cytometry Figure 1 . Notably, as with any method that seeks to identify a population of cells at a very low frequency, the background and noise inherent in the detection system is magnified with respect to the signal of interest, especially when that signal is weak. Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: .", "Therefore, to detect the antigen-specific population of interest, the following considerations are critical: . Using decoys to exclude B cells of unwanted specificities; . careful design of flow cytometry panels to avoid emission spillover into the channel for the antigen of interest; and . choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin.", "choosing the brightest fluorochromes, like R-phycoerythrin or allophycocyanin. In vivo methods to probe antigen-specific B cell responses in the presence of other antigen-presenting cells and T cell helpers, have increased our mechanistic understanding of the humoral immune response during vaccination, infection, and autoimmunity. Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells.", "Adoptively transferred B cells can be distinguished from recipient lymphocytes by taking advantage of mouse strains with allelic variations in CD45 or mice devoid of B cells. The adoptively transferred B cells can come from wildtype mice or from mice expressing transgenic BCRs Table 2 , and antigen-specific B cells can be analyzed using the techniques described above. Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization.", "Microscopy is another general technique that has been used to identify antigen-specific cells in vivo and offers the advantage of direct visualization. In the first reported application of this technique to demonstrate the cellular origin of antibodies in 1955, fluorescein-conjugated antibodies against ovalbumin and human immunoglobulin were used to stain tissue sections of the spleen from hyperimmune rabbits . .", ". Since then, other groups have fluorescently labeled antigens to localize antigen-specific B cells by microscopy . . Advances in laser capture dissection microscopy, already used in the T cell field, also provide an opportunity for isolating individual antigen-specific B cells for downstream analysis, including sequencing and cloning of the BCR or transcriptional profiling . .", ". However, antigen staining of BCRs in situ can be challenging depending on the binding of antigens from pathogens to other cellular receptors or an alteration of BCR specificity during tissue fixation or processing. Two-photon or multiphoton microscopy has the ability to resolve images at greater depths and with less photobleaching than confocal microscopy . .", ". As a result, this technology has allowed real-time imaging in living, intact lymphoid tissues of mice, permitting the direct in vivo observation of immune cell interactions. The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy .", "The dynamic movements and interactions of antigen-specific B cells can be studied in vivo by combining an adoptive transfer of individual B cells isolated by limiting dilution or FACS with two-photon microscopy . . Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans.", "Humanized mouse models are powerful tools for translating experiments in mice to applications in humans. Transgenic mice that produce humanized cytokines by knock-in replacement can be used to support human hematopoietic stem cells . .", ". Transgenic mice with complete humanization of the mouse immunoglobulin loci provide an opportunity for recapitulating the breadth of the human B cell repertoire and serve as a valuable tool for therapeutic antibody discovery . .", ". However, one caveat is that the allele frequencies found in the B cell repertoires of these mouse models may not necessarily recapitulate those found in humans . . Mass cytometry has the potential to provide further high-dimensional analysis of antigen-specific B cells. In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells.", "In this method, heavy metal ion tags rather than fluorochromes are used to label cells. Since data is collected as time-offlight mass spectrometry, up to 42 unique parameters can be simultaneously measured from a single sample without significant spillover between channels or the need for compensation. Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . .", "Mass cytometry with heavy metal-labeled tetramers can be constructed using streptavidin . . Mass cytometry with metal-labeled peptide-MHC tetramers has been used successfully to identify and characterize antigen-specific T cells, but to our knowledge has not yet been applied to antigen-specific B cells . .", ". One limitation of this approach is that cells are unavailable for downstream analysis since they are vaporized by a plasma torch to atomize the ion tags. However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection.", "However, by simultaneously detecting many more surface markers and intracellular cytokines, transcription factors, and detecting more signaling molecules from individual cells than previously possible with traditional fluorescent labels, the application of mass cytometry with dimensionality reduction algorithms could help dissect the complexity of the B cell compartment, provide a higher resolution view of B cell development, and reveal novel subsets of antigen-specific B cells involved in mediating autoimmune diseases or protection against infection. On the horizon, single cell RNA-sequencing RNA-seq technologies have the potential to revolutionize the study of antigen-specific immune cells . .", ". The ability to generate a library of tetramers with unique barcodes could allow the simultaneous examination of gene expression profiles from a large number of cells with different antigen specificities in a single experiment. Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics .", "Combining barcoded tetramers with oligonucleotide-conjugated antibodies and RNA-seq to simultaneously measure the protein and gene expression of antigen-specific cells could further increase the amount of unbiased multi-omic information about individual antigen-specific cells in normal and disease states and aid the rational design of vaccines and therapeutics . . . .", ". . . The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents.", "The ongoing analysis of antigen-specific B cell responses has led to the development of new diagnostic, therapeutic, and research reagents. Methods for studying antigen-specific B cell responses are being increasingly applied to tackle diseases like HIV, RSV, and autoimmune diseases, in which the immune response either fails to protect or clear disease, or where it enhances disease or is responsible for the disease itself. Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role.", "Considerable opportunities exist on the horizon for applying these methods to a myriad of diseases in which B cells play an active role. JB and JT reviewed the literature, generated figures and tables, and wrote the manuscript." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Introduction. Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus was first recognized in September 2012 in Saudi Arabia. The clinical presentations of MERS and non-MERS SARI are often similar. Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential.", "Therefore, the identification of suspected cases that may have higher chances of being diagnosed as cases of MERS-CoV is essential. However, the real challenge is to flag these patients through some demographic markers. The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them.", "The nature of these markers has not previously been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence, this study aims to identify them. METHODS: It was a surveillance system-based study, for which data from a total of 23,646 suspected patients in Riyadh and Al Qassim regions were analyzed from January 2017 until December 2017 to estimate the prevalence of MERS-CoV among suspected cases and to determine potential demographic risk factors related to the confirmation of the diagnosis. RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results.", "RESULTS: Of 23,646 suspected cases, 119 0.5% were confirmed by laboratory results. These confirmed cases 67.2% of which were males had a mean age of 43.23 years SD ± 22.8 . Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer.", "Around 42.2% of the confirmed cases were aged between 41 and 60 years and about 47% of confirmed cases had their suspected specimen tested in the summer. The study identified three significant and independent predictors for confirmation of the disease: an age between 41 and 60 years, male gender, and summer season admission. CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease.", "CONCLUSION: The study provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in the subject regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for the prevention and management of such a contagious disease. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions of Saudi Arabia as well and explore potential preventable risk factors. Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure .", "Text: A respiratory viral disease caused by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome CoronaVirus MERS-CoV was first isolated in 2012, in a 60-year-old man who died in Jeddah, KSA due to severe acute pneumonia and multiple organ failure . Since then, 27 countries have reported the presence of this virus, including the 12 countries of the Eastern Mediterranean region. Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea .", "Several outbreaks have occurred in multiple countries including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the Republic of Korea . Recent fatality rate CFR of 21% . Very limited evidence is available for exploring the epidemiology of this virus among the pediatric population . e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females .", "e literature shows that MERS-CoV infects males more than females . e casefatality rate of men 52% is higher than that of women 23% . Males with a history of serious medical conditions are highly susceptible to this infection. Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years .", "Moreover, the mean age of infection in adults is 60 years . e mode of transmission is not entirely understood yet ; however, human-to-human and zoonotic sources of transmission have been documented in many studies. Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans.", "Dromedary camels are the major animal source of MERS-CoV transmission to humans. Interhuman transmission of the virus did not occur easily, but it is seen mainly in patients' families and healthcare settings . Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death .", "Clinical pictures of this infection varied from asymptomatic to mild respiratory symptoms to severe respiratory distress and death . Severe ailment can often cause respiratory catastrophes that need mechanical ventilation and support in ICUs across different healthcare settings . Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients .", "Studies have suggested an incubation period of 16 days with a mean of 5-6 days , while the median time until death is 11-13 days range 5-27 days among severely ill patients . e gold standard test for the detection of this virus is real-time reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR assays . ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV.", "ere is no specific treatment for MERS-CoV. Like most viral infections, the treatment options are supportive and symptomatic . At present, no vaccine exists for preventing the infections of MERS-CoV. e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness .", "e CDC indicated that preventative actions should be taken for any type of respiratory illness . Such actions include washing hands with water and soap for around 20 seconds or using hand sanitizers with alcohol if no water is available. One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly.", "One must cover their nose and mouth during instances of sneezing and coughing with a tissue and avoid touching the mouth, nose, or eyes with their hands until washed properly. Repeatedly touched surfaces, such as door knobs, should be disinfected and cleaned regularly. Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided .", "Intimate personal contact, e.g., kissing, and sharing cups or eating utensils must also be avoided . Many studies have been conducted in recent years in Saudi Arabia to combat this deadly disease. A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation .", "A large multicentre study showed that it is nearly impossible to differentiate between patients of MERS-CoV and non-MERS-CoV just on the basis of clinical presentation . Another cohort study, which was hospital-based 17 cases vs. 82 controls , found that there were statistically significant differences in terms of gender, clinical, and radiographic presentations . Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific .", "Similarly, two more single-centre case control studies reported that the presenting symptoms of MERS-CoV infection were not specific . Physicians and public health practitioners need to identify suspected cases which have higher chances of diagnosis as confirmed cases prior to laboratory testing which usually takes between 12 and 24 hours . Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers .", "Identification of a confirmed case is necessary to implement preventive strategies to combat the spread of the disease to family members and hospital healthcare workers . Mild symptomatic cases, which result in a positive PCR, may be isolated at home. Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period.", "Severe to moderate cases should be admitted to and isolated in a hospital until they improve and then be discharged for isolation at home for an extended period. Both mild and severe cases are retested after 7 days, and the test is subsequently repeated after every 3 days until a negative result is obtained . Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution.", "Identifying suspected cases which may have higher chances of getting diagnosed as a confirmed case and implementing strict procedures on them might offer the best solution. e challenge is to flag these patients by some demographic markers, as the clinical presentation of MERS-CoV infected patients were non-specific. erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV.", "erefore, we aimed to identify some demographic markers specific to confirmed cases of MERS-CoV. e nature of these markers has not been investigated in Saudi Arabia, and hence this study aims to identify them. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA.", "A cross-sectional study was conducted at the regional laboratory and blood bank, located at Shumaisi Hospital in Riyadh, KSA. e laboratory has received the Central Blood Banks and Reference Laboratories Accreditation Program Saudi Central Board for Accreditation of Healthcare Institution CBAHI 2018 . Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017.", "Technique. Data were collected during the period of January 2017 to December 2017. All patients in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions who had their samples tested at Riyadh regional lab during the study period were considered as suspected cases. e study had two aims: descriptive and analytical. For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV.", "For the descriptive aim, we estimated the prevalence of MERS-CoV. For the analytical aim, a binary logistic regression model was developed. In this model, we included the risk factors of gender, age, seasons, nationality, healthcare status yes/no , hospitals, and area of residence. Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database.", "Data were cross-checked with a labcomputerized database. Further data were collected on demographic characteristics age and sex , underlying nationality, and health care status. We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis.", "We collected data from 25,400 cases, of which 23,646 suspected cases of MERS-CoV were included in the final analysis. Data were cleaned, entered, stored, and managed with an excel database and IBM SPSS Version 25. e statistical analyses consisted of descriptive counts and percentages. For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution.", "For those continuously scaled items, nonparametric statistics medians, interquartile ranges, minimum, and maximum were used to describe the distribution. A logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of confirmation of infection within the suspected cases groups. At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors.", "At first, univariate analyses were conducted to estimate the unadjusted contribution and to determine the significant risk factors. is was followed by a multivariate logistic regression analysis to estimate the independent contribution of each covariate. To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered.", "To determine significant factors, a p value below 0.05 and a 95% confidence interval were considered. A confirmed case is defined as a suspected case with laboratory confirmation of MERS-CoV infection . A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 .", "A total of 23,646 of MERS-CoV suspected cases were included in this study, of which 52.3% were males n � 12376 and 47.7% were females n � 11270 . e age of individuals with suspected cases ranged between 0 to 92 years with a mean age of 43. 23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results.", "23 e adjusted odds of MERS-CoV remained significant among different age groups; the odds of patients aged between 20-40 years increased threefold A.OR: 3.11, 95% CI: 1.104-8.76, P value � 0.032 , whereas in the age group of 41-60 years, it increased further to a risk that was six times higher is cross-sectional study about the epidemiological analysis of MERS-CoV infection laboratory-based data was conducted in Riyadh over a one-year period .. A total of 23,646 suspected cases were included in the results. Of the total suspected cases, 119 cases had been confirmed via laboratory results. All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia.", "All the confirmed cases are reported to MOH through HESN health electronic surveillance networks and to the World Health Organization WHO through the International Health Regulations IHR , National Focal Point of Saudi Arabia. We found that MERS-CoV infection was found significantly in people aged between 41 and 60 years and was reported most commonly during the summer season. e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases.", "e odds of infection among males were found to be twice as high as that of females with suspected cases. During the study period, i.e., the year 2017, only 119 confirmed cases were reported, which means that the number of MERS-CoV infection cases has decreased in Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions in comparison to that of the last three years. From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods.", "From 2015 to 2016, there was a 25.4% decrease, whereas from 2016 to 2017, it decreased by 48.7%, which translates into a 50% decrease between the two periods. is also complements the findings reported by of Da'ar and Ahmed in their paper . e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females .", "e predominance of infection in males was also observed in another study pwefromed in KSA ., which reported the percentage of confirmed cases among males to be 66%, compared with 34% among females . It is worth mentioning that Saudi Arabia defines age categories differently from the WHO children: 0-14, adult: otherwise . However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases .", "However, unlike the classification used in Saudi Arabia, we have followed the WHO categorization of age to differentiate between children/adolescents 0 to 19 years and adults 20 years and older as indicated in WHO reports for age-standardized population and in infectious diseases . is categorization was also followed by Aly and his collaborators in their recent paper published in 2017 . Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 .", "Adults were further subcategorized into three groups according to the age distribution of the study population using the following two cutoff points age of 41 and age of 60 . ese data agreed with a previous surveillance study, which stated that the majority of confirmed cases of MERS-CoV were reported among people aged 40 and above . In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients.", "In 2016, only 9 of 552 cases 1.6% of MERS-CoV infection were found among pediatric patients. Moreover, the study which was conducted in King Fahad Medical City in Riyadh KFMC between January 2012 and December 2013 did not report any MERS-CoV cases among children . e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al.", "e study which was conducted across the Gulf countries for four years by Mahmoud Aly et al. between 2012 and 2016 suggests that the prevalence and distribution of MERS-CoV were the highest-risk in elderly aged 60 years or above . Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season .", "Similar to our results, this study also reported the highest number of confirmed cases during the summer season . Among confirmed cases, only 25.2% were healthcare workers, whereas around 75% were non-healthcare workers. is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers .", "is is in agreement with the study done by Ahmad to estimate the survival rate in MERS-CoV globally prior to 26 January 2017; 86.9% were not health-care workers compared with 13.1% confirmed cases of healthcare workers . Similarly, other studies also reported a lower prevalence in healthcare workers . Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi.", "Our data reported a higher prevalence of infection among Saudi nationals as compared with non-Saudi. Another study also showed similar results but with a much higher percentage among Saudis, which may be due to the fact that it included Saudis from all regions . ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only.", "ere is no finding basis for comparison as such, because our study was focused on the Riyadh and Al Qassim regions only. In our study, we detected a low prevalence 0.5% . e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay.", "e low positive predictive value of our lab results is not related to the low sensitivity and specificity of the lab assay. e estimated analytical sensitivity and specificity of the Real Star kit from Altona was reported to be 100% with no cross reactivity with other respiratory pathogens . Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab.", "Moreover, this low predictive value in the lab results is related to the high burden of false positive cases referred to the lab. In fact, this research is just the starting point to shed the light on more factors that might help in putting more descriptive criteria to lower the financial and human resources burden. To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study.", "To the best of our knowledge, no one has developed a logistic regression that focuses on demographic risk factors such as sex, age, and seasons prior to our study. However, it is worth mentioning that Ahmed et al. developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST .", "developed a risk prediction model that encompasses risk factors such as chest pain, leukopenia, and elevated aspartate aminotransferase AST . However, further investigations are needed to confirm our findings. One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions.", "One of the major strengths of our study is that it is a comprehensive regional study which included all the suspected cases of MERS-CoV in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim regions. Secondly, the external validity of our study is also expected to be high, as it covers the two regions completely, meaning that the records of all suspected cases in these two main regions in Saudi Arabia were included. irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases.", "irdly, the quality of the data is considered to be high, given that the contagious and life-threatening nature of this disease has led to strict obedience to rules which are enforced in a timely manner, thus ensuring accurate reporting of suspected cases. In addition to this, quality assurance policies are implemented at HESN in order to maintain the highest level of validity and reliability of the data collection process. e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope.", "e variables available for suspected cases were limited to demographics, which limited the scope of our research, but they provided valuable information to form a basis for future studies of a broader scope. Variables such as primary/secondary infections are vital pieces of information, but due the limitation of the data available, we could not determine their effects. According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA .", "According to our knowledge, this is one of the few studies that have specifically investigated MERS-CoV risk factors in the Riyadh and Al-Qassim areas two major regions in KSA . Given that all suspected and confirmed cases were included in this study, we assume that our results are generalizable for both the regions with confidence. It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases.", "It must be noted that the comparative group of this study is different from that of the previous ones, as we compared those with confirmed MERS-CoV with those with suspected MERS-CoV who have passed all stages of screening at the hospital, whereas other studies were hospital but not lab-based with an aim of identifying factors that help in suspecting rather than confirming cases. is might be the reason why we have found some significant demographic factors unlike other reports. In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive.", "In conclusion, this research is about predictors for the confirmation of diagnosis among suspected cases only, meaning that the factors we found can help in identifying suspected cases that may have a higher chance of testing positive. is will help primary healthcare professionals to develop a better screening tool for suspected cases, as currently only a small minority of suspected cases are confirmed positive via lab results, consequently resulting in a lot of resources being spent to test thousands of samples, just for the identification of a few cases. e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting.", "e three factors we identified are important because, for example, a female, aged 18, presenting in winter will be less likely to be diagnosed than a male, aged 45, presenting in the summer, or, to give another example, a 60-year-old male who is presenting MERS-CoV signs with a negative lab result may need retesting. Our study covered two main regions in Saudi Arabia and provides evidence that the MERS-CoV epidemic in these two regions has specific characteristics that might help future plans for prevention and management of such contagious diseases. Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific.", "Our results showed that only a minority of suspected cases are actually diagnosed with the disease, meaning that the procedures being implemented seemed to be highly sensitive but not highly specific. e majority of confirmed cases were male, aged 41 to 60 years, and presented to healthcare facilities in the summer. Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others.", "Future studies should aim to confirm such findings in other regions in Saudi Arabia, to explore potential preventable risk factors and go deeper to know the underlying factors that make male aged 41-60 more susceptible than others. e laboratory data used to support the findings of this study were provided by Riyadh Regional Laboratory under license and are not freely available. However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request.", "However, access to data will be considered from the corresponding author upon request. e authors declare that they have no competing interests." ]

[ "Nucleoside analogs have been frequently identified as antiviral agents. In recent years, gemcitabine, a cytidine analog in clinical use for the treatment of many solid tumors, was also shown to have antiviral activity against a broad range of viruses. Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. Intriguingly, a few recent reports have shown that some nucleoside analogs, including gemcitabine, activated innate immunity, inducing the expression of interferon-stimulated genes, through nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition. The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined.", "The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined. Nonetheless, we summarize the current knowledge of nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity and propose it as a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs. Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases .", "Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases . More recently, nucleoside analogs have expanded their therapeutic applications and are being used to develop antiviral drugs against a wide range of serious and life-threatening viruses. Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients.", "Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients. Another class of nucleoside analog drugs such as ribavirin, more broadly-acting on various viruses, has been used in conjunction with IFN-α . Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs.", "Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs. The primary mechanism to explain the antiviral effect of nucleoside analogs is based on their direct action on viral polymerization. Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates.", "Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates. Mature nucleotide analogs, which are similar to physiological nucleotides, can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides.", "Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways .", "There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication.", "As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferon-stimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses.", "There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group.", "In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 .", "can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis.", "The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs .", "A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated.", "However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report .", "They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broadspectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors.", "More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes.", "Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV .", "However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans.", "MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs.", "The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers .", "Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 .", "The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al.", "To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al. screened 290 FDA-approved drugs in virus-infected Vero E6 cells and identified gemcitabine as one of drugs with antiviral activity against both MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV EC 50 of 1.2 µM and 4.9 µM, respectively . More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM .", "More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM . ZIKV, a member of the Flaviviridae family, can infect pregnant women and cause congenital abnormalities such as microcephaly in infants, which has attracted increasing public attention as well as extensive research and development into possible treatments. Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy .", "Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy . In the case of HIV, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine, another nucleoside analog in clinical use for cancer therapy, synergistically reduced HIV infectivity by increasing the viral mutation frequency . In a follow up study, Clouser et al.", "In a follow up study, Clouser et al. further reported the antiviral effect of gemcitabine against HIV-related retrovirus, murine leukemia virus MuLV , in vitro EC 50 of 1.6 nM and even in murine AIDS model . A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al.", "A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al. EC 50 of 0.068 µM . They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus .", "They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus . The antiviral effect of gemcitabine on EVs, initially performed on Coxsackievirus B3 CVB3 , was found from screening FDA-approved drugs in CVB3 replicon-harboring Vero cells by our group EC 50 of 0.4 µM . Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively .", "Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively . In the case of HRV, the antiviral effect of gemcitabine was further confirmed in a virus-infected mouse model . In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes.", "In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes. More recently, Zhang et al. also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM .", "also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM . As previously mentioned, accumulating evidence has definitively demonstrated that gemcitabine is an effective broad-spectrum inhibitor of RNA viruses and has a therapeutic potential for the treatment of various virus-associated diseases. Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses.", "Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses. Because gemcitabine is a deoxycytidine analog that interferes with DNA as well as RNA synthesis, DNA viruses may not be the exception. Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine .", "Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine . Most of the abovementioned viruses have, at best, limited prophylactic or therapeutic drugs as possible treatments. This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection.", "This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection. In this regard, repurposing of gemcitabine for the treatment of patients infected with these deadly viruses is a realistic approach. Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy .", "Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy . Even for other viruses with a relatively high EC 50 , there is an option to treat patients with a combination of gemcitabine with other antiviral agents. In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically.", "In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically. As an example, the synergistic antiviral effect of gemcitabine in combination with ribavirin, an antiviral drug currently being used against a few RNA viruses, was reported against EVs such as CVB3 and EV71 . As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo .", "As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo . However, the actual use of gemcitabine in virus-infected patients necessitates prior in vivo animal studies and clinical trials. Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models .", "Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models . More extensive analyses of gemcitabine in animal models in the near future will accelerate its therapeutic applications in clinical trials. Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action.", "Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action. However, our group has recently reported that gemcitabine had an anti-EV effect by targeting the salvage pathway of pyrimidine biosynthesis . Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection.", "Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection. These results were consistent with a previous report that gemcitabine stimulated the production of IFN-β and IFN-γ in IAV-infected RPE cells . Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity. Similar phenomena in terms of ISG activation have been previously reported with a few compounds out of several purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors that had antiviral activity, as summarized in Table 2 6, 10, . Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway.", "Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway. These inhibitors have been successfully used as clinical antiviral or immunosuppressant agents for decades. Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs .", "Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs . For the antiviral activity of ribavirin against HCV, ribavirin specifically induced the expression of IRF7, IRF9, and ISG15 mRNAs, which are known to be important for anti-HCV immune responses . ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways.", "ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways. More importantly, ribavirin-induced ISG activation and antiviral activity were suppressed using supplemented guanosine, a natural analog of ribavirin, suggesting IMPDH inhibition-mediated ISG activation as an alternative innate immunity pathway. Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine .", "Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine . Mechanistically, the induction of ISGs by MPA was independent of the classical JAK/STAT system, which is similar to that observed with ribavirin . Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized .", "Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized . As shown in Table 2 , most pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors target dihydroorotate dehydrogenase DHODH , an essential enzyme in de novo pyrimidine synthesis. Lucas-Hourani et al.", "Lucas-Hourani et al. identified DD264 as an interferon-sensitive response element ISRE -stimulating compound from high-throughput screening, and further analyses suggested that it was a DHODH inhibitor with a strong antiviral activity against various viruses including MeV, CHIKV, and WNV . DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation.", "DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation. Moreover, the antiviral activity of and ISG activation by DD264 required the interferon regulatory factor 1 IRF1 transcription factor, a master regulator of antiviral gene expression , which was consistent with the observation that the anti-HCV activity of MPA was partially mediated by IRF1 . In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor.", "In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor. FA-613 is also an antiviral compound, which inhibits the pyrimidine biosynthesis pathway, probably via targeting DHODH and inducing the expression of ISGs such as IFNB1, CXCL10, ISG15, and CCL5 . However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined.", "However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined. The mechanism of nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is still presently unclear. Nevertheless, there has been accumulating evidence showing that nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is independent of the classical JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal . First, Wang et al.", "First, Wang et al. clearly showed that ISG activation and anti-HEV activity induced by MPA or brequinar was not mediated by JAK . Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions .", "Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions . Third, our recent study with gemcitabine further confirmed IFN signal-independent ISG activation by parallel studies comparing the effects of gemcitabine and IFN-α. In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine .", "In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine . Moreover, the upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs induced by gemcitabine was not affected by IRF9 knockdown, which was contrary to the result that IFN-α-induced upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs was significantly suppressed under the same conditions. Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation .", "Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation . Despite limited data, we speculate the scenario of ISG activation that is independent of JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal. Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool.", "Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool. Inactivation of metabolic enzyme s itself or consequently altered nucleos t ide pools might trigger a signal, which is ultimately delivered to certain cis-acting elements on the promoter of a subset of ISGs, possibly through the relay of kinases and transcription factors. Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway.", "Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway. It should also be considered that Thomas et al. excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin .", "excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin . Despite the consensus of ISG activation, each purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitor seems to induce distinct sets of ISGs, at least with different patterns . Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations.", "Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations. There might be more than one signaling pathway involved. The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation.", "The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation. Systematic analyses of signaling kinases, IRFs, and STATs using siRNA knockdown and/or pharmacological inhibition and metabolic analyses of corresponding intermediates and nucleos t ides should therefore clarify the underlying molecular mechanisms of ISG activation by purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors. As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased.", "As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased. In this regard, nucleoside analogs that directly target viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and present a high barrier to the development of resistant viruses have been considered advantageous. Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs.", "Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs. Nucleoside analogs probably induce different subsets of ISGs, at least with a different pattern, leading to various combinations of ISGs and resulting antiviral outcomes. Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses .", "Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses . Thus, more systematic analyses on the subsets of ISGs induced by antiviral nucleoside analogs are required for the identification of better antiviral drugs that can be used broadly or specifically. Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives.", "Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives. Nevertheless, nucleoside analogs interfering with the host nucleotide synthesis pathway suggest possible side effects in their clinical applications. Careful evaluation of clinical safety is required and their application for the urgent measure of patients infected with deadly viruses would be worth being primarily considered." ]

[ "Nucleoside analogs have been frequently identified as antiviral agents. In recent years, gemcitabine, a cytidine analog in clinical use for the treatment of many solid tumors, was also shown to have antiviral activity against a broad range of viruses. Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. Intriguingly, a few recent reports have shown that some nucleoside analogs, including gemcitabine, activated innate immunity, inducing the expression of interferon-stimulated genes, through nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition. The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined.", "The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined. Nonetheless, we summarize the current knowledge of nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity and propose it as a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs. Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases .", "Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases . More recently, nucleoside analogs have expanded their therapeutic applications and are being used to develop antiviral drugs against a wide range of serious and life-threatening viruses. Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients.", "Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients. Another class of nucleoside analog drugs such as ribavirin, more broadly-acting on various viruses, has been used in conjunction with IFN-α . Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs.", "Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs. The primary mechanism to explain the antiviral effect of nucleoside analogs is based on their direct action on viral polymerization. Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates.", "Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates. Mature nucleotide analogs, which are similar to physiological nucleotides, can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides.", "Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways .", "There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication.", "As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferon-stimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses.", "There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group.", "In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 .", "can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis.", "The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs .", "A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated.", "However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report .", "They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broadspectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors.", "More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes.", "Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV .", "However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans.", "MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs.", "The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers .", "Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 .", "The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al.", "To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al. screened 290 FDA-approved drugs in virus-infected Vero E6 cells and identified gemcitabine as one of drugs with antiviral activity against both MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV EC 50 of 1.2 µM and 4.9 µM, respectively . More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM .", "More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM . ZIKV, a member of the Flaviviridae family, can infect pregnant women and cause congenital abnormalities such as microcephaly in infants, which has attracted increasing public attention as well as extensive research and development into possible treatments. Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy .", "Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy . In the case of HIV, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine, another nucleoside analog in clinical use for cancer therapy, synergistically reduced HIV infectivity by increasing the viral mutation frequency . In a follow up study, Clouser et al.", "In a follow up study, Clouser et al. further reported the antiviral effect of gemcitabine against HIV-related retrovirus, murine leukemia virus MuLV , in vitro EC 50 of 1.6 nM and even in murine AIDS model . A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al.", "A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al. EC 50 of 0.068 µM . They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus .", "They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus . The antiviral effect of gemcitabine on EVs, initially performed on Coxsackievirus B3 CVB3 , was found from screening FDA-approved drugs in CVB3 replicon-harboring Vero cells by our group EC 50 of 0.4 µM . Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively .", "Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively . In the case of HRV, the antiviral effect of gemcitabine was further confirmed in a virus-infected mouse model . In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes.", "In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes. More recently, Zhang et al. also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM .", "also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM . As previously mentioned, accumulating evidence has definitively demonstrated that gemcitabine is an effective broad-spectrum inhibitor of RNA viruses and has a therapeutic potential for the treatment of various virus-associated diseases. Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses.", "Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses. Because gemcitabine is a deoxycytidine analog that interferes with DNA as well as RNA synthesis, DNA viruses may not be the exception. Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine .", "Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine . Most of the abovementioned viruses have, at best, limited prophylactic or therapeutic drugs as possible treatments. This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection.", "This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection. In this regard, repurposing of gemcitabine for the treatment of patients infected with these deadly viruses is a realistic approach. Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy .", "Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy . Even for other viruses with a relatively high EC 50 , there is an option to treat patients with a combination of gemcitabine with other antiviral agents. In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically.", "In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically. As an example, the synergistic antiviral effect of gemcitabine in combination with ribavirin, an antiviral drug currently being used against a few RNA viruses, was reported against EVs such as CVB3 and EV71 . As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo .", "As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo . However, the actual use of gemcitabine in virus-infected patients necessitates prior in vivo animal studies and clinical trials. Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models .", "Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models . More extensive analyses of gemcitabine in animal models in the near future will accelerate its therapeutic applications in clinical trials. Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action.", "Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action. However, our group has recently reported that gemcitabine had an anti-EV effect by targeting the salvage pathway of pyrimidine biosynthesis . Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection.", "Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection. These results were consistent with a previous report that gemcitabine stimulated the production of IFN-β and IFN-γ in IAV-infected RPE cells . Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity. Similar phenomena in terms of ISG activation have been previously reported with a few compounds out of several purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors that had antiviral activity, as summarized in Table 2 6, 10, . Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway.", "Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway. These inhibitors have been successfully used as clinical antiviral or immunosuppressant agents for decades. Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs .", "Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs . For the antiviral activity of ribavirin against HCV, ribavirin specifically induced the expression of IRF7, IRF9, and ISG15 mRNAs, which are known to be important for anti-HCV immune responses . ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways.", "ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways. More importantly, ribavirin-induced ISG activation and antiviral activity were suppressed using supplemented guanosine, a natural analog of ribavirin, suggesting IMPDH inhibition-mediated ISG activation as an alternative innate immunity pathway. Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine .", "Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine . Mechanistically, the induction of ISGs by MPA was independent of the classical JAK/STAT system, which is similar to that observed with ribavirin . Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized .", "Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized . As shown in Table 2 , most pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors target dihydroorotate dehydrogenase DHODH , an essential enzyme in de novo pyrimidine synthesis. Lucas-Hourani et al.", "Lucas-Hourani et al. identified DD264 as an interferon-sensitive response element ISRE -stimulating compound from high-throughput screening, and further analyses suggested that it was a DHODH inhibitor with a strong antiviral activity against various viruses including MeV, CHIKV, and WNV . DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation.", "DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation. Moreover, the antiviral activity of and ISG activation by DD264 required the interferon regulatory factor 1 IRF1 transcription factor, a master regulator of antiviral gene expression , which was consistent with the observation that the anti-HCV activity of MPA was partially mediated by IRF1 . In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor.", "In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor. FA-613 is also an antiviral compound, which inhibits the pyrimidine biosynthesis pathway, probably via targeting DHODH and inducing the expression of ISGs such as IFNB1, CXCL10, ISG15, and CCL5 . However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined.", "However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined. The mechanism of nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is still presently unclear. Nevertheless, there has been accumulating evidence showing that nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is independent of the classical JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal . First, Wang et al.", "First, Wang et al. clearly showed that ISG activation and anti-HEV activity induced by MPA or brequinar was not mediated by JAK . Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions .", "Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions . Third, our recent study with gemcitabine further confirmed IFN signal-independent ISG activation by parallel studies comparing the effects of gemcitabine and IFN-α. In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine .", "In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine . Moreover, the upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs induced by gemcitabine was not affected by IRF9 knockdown, which was contrary to the result that IFN-α-induced upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs was significantly suppressed under the same conditions. Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation .", "Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation . Despite limited data, we speculate the scenario of ISG activation that is independent of JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal. Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool.", "Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool. Inactivation of metabolic enzyme s itself or consequently altered nucleos t ide pools might trigger a signal, which is ultimately delivered to certain cis-acting elements on the promoter of a subset of ISGs, possibly through the relay of kinases and transcription factors. Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway.", "Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway. It should also be considered that Thomas et al. excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin .", "excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin . Despite the consensus of ISG activation, each purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitor seems to induce distinct sets of ISGs, at least with different patterns . Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations.", "Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations. There might be more than one signaling pathway involved. The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation.", "The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation. Systematic analyses of signaling kinases, IRFs, and STATs using siRNA knockdown and/or pharmacological inhibition and metabolic analyses of corresponding intermediates and nucleos t ides should therefore clarify the underlying molecular mechanisms of ISG activation by purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors. As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased.", "As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased. In this regard, nucleoside analogs that directly target viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and present a high barrier to the development of resistant viruses have been considered advantageous. Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs.", "Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs. Nucleoside analogs probably induce different subsets of ISGs, at least with a different pattern, leading to various combinations of ISGs and resulting antiviral outcomes. Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses .", "Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses . Thus, more systematic analyses on the subsets of ISGs induced by antiviral nucleoside analogs are required for the identification of better antiviral drugs that can be used broadly or specifically. Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives.", "Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives. Nevertheless, nucleoside analogs interfering with the host nucleotide synthesis pathway suggest possible side effects in their clinical applications. Careful evaluation of clinical safety is required and their application for the urgent measure of patients infected with deadly viruses would be worth being primarily considered." ]

[ "Nucleoside analogs have been frequently identified as antiviral agents. In recent years, gemcitabine, a cytidine analog in clinical use for the treatment of many solid tumors, was also shown to have antiviral activity against a broad range of viruses. Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. Intriguingly, a few recent reports have shown that some nucleoside analogs, including gemcitabine, activated innate immunity, inducing the expression of interferon-stimulated genes, through nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition. The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined.", "The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined. Nonetheless, we summarize the current knowledge of nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity and propose it as a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs. Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases .", "Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases . More recently, nucleoside analogs have expanded their therapeutic applications and are being used to develop antiviral drugs against a wide range of serious and life-threatening viruses. Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients.", "Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients. Another class of nucleoside analog drugs such as ribavirin, more broadly-acting on various viruses, has been used in conjunction with IFN-α . Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs.", "Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs. The primary mechanism to explain the antiviral effect of nucleoside analogs is based on their direct action on viral polymerization. Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates.", "Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates. Mature nucleotide analogs, which are similar to physiological nucleotides, can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides.", "Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways .", "There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication.", "As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferon-stimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses.", "There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group.", "In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 .", "can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis.", "The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs .", "A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated.", "However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report .", "They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broadspectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors.", "More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes.", "Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV .", "However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans.", "MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs.", "The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers .", "Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 .", "The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al.", "To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al. screened 290 FDA-approved drugs in virus-infected Vero E6 cells and identified gemcitabine as one of drugs with antiviral activity against both MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV EC 50 of 1.2 µM and 4.9 µM, respectively . More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM .", "More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM . ZIKV, a member of the Flaviviridae family, can infect pregnant women and cause congenital abnormalities such as microcephaly in infants, which has attracted increasing public attention as well as extensive research and development into possible treatments. Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy .", "Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy . In the case of HIV, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine, another nucleoside analog in clinical use for cancer therapy, synergistically reduced HIV infectivity by increasing the viral mutation frequency . In a follow up study, Clouser et al.", "In a follow up study, Clouser et al. further reported the antiviral effect of gemcitabine against HIV-related retrovirus, murine leukemia virus MuLV , in vitro EC 50 of 1.6 nM and even in murine AIDS model . A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al.", "A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al. EC 50 of 0.068 µM . They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus .", "They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus . The antiviral effect of gemcitabine on EVs, initially performed on Coxsackievirus B3 CVB3 , was found from screening FDA-approved drugs in CVB3 replicon-harboring Vero cells by our group EC 50 of 0.4 µM . Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively .", "Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively . In the case of HRV, the antiviral effect of gemcitabine was further confirmed in a virus-infected mouse model . In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes.", "In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes. More recently, Zhang et al. also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM .", "also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM . As previously mentioned, accumulating evidence has definitively demonstrated that gemcitabine is an effective broad-spectrum inhibitor of RNA viruses and has a therapeutic potential for the treatment of various virus-associated diseases. Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses.", "Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses. Because gemcitabine is a deoxycytidine analog that interferes with DNA as well as RNA synthesis, DNA viruses may not be the exception. Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine .", "Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine . Most of the abovementioned viruses have, at best, limited prophylactic or therapeutic drugs as possible treatments. This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection.", "This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection. In this regard, repurposing of gemcitabine for the treatment of patients infected with these deadly viruses is a realistic approach. Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy .", "Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy . Even for other viruses with a relatively high EC 50 , there is an option to treat patients with a combination of gemcitabine with other antiviral agents. In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically.", "In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically. As an example, the synergistic antiviral effect of gemcitabine in combination with ribavirin, an antiviral drug currently being used against a few RNA viruses, was reported against EVs such as CVB3 and EV71 . As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo .", "As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo . However, the actual use of gemcitabine in virus-infected patients necessitates prior in vivo animal studies and clinical trials. Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models .", "Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models . More extensive analyses of gemcitabine in animal models in the near future will accelerate its therapeutic applications in clinical trials. Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action.", "Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action. However, our group has recently reported that gemcitabine had an anti-EV effect by targeting the salvage pathway of pyrimidine biosynthesis . Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection.", "Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection. These results were consistent with a previous report that gemcitabine stimulated the production of IFN-β and IFN-γ in IAV-infected RPE cells . Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity. Similar phenomena in terms of ISG activation have been previously reported with a few compounds out of several purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors that had antiviral activity, as summarized in Table 2 6, 10, . Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway.", "Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway. These inhibitors have been successfully used as clinical antiviral or immunosuppressant agents for decades. Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs .", "Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs . For the antiviral activity of ribavirin against HCV, ribavirin specifically induced the expression of IRF7, IRF9, and ISG15 mRNAs, which are known to be important for anti-HCV immune responses . ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways.", "ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways. More importantly, ribavirin-induced ISG activation and antiviral activity were suppressed using supplemented guanosine, a natural analog of ribavirin, suggesting IMPDH inhibition-mediated ISG activation as an alternative innate immunity pathway. Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine .", "Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine . Mechanistically, the induction of ISGs by MPA was independent of the classical JAK/STAT system, which is similar to that observed with ribavirin . Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized .", "Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized . As shown in Table 2 , most pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors target dihydroorotate dehydrogenase DHODH , an essential enzyme in de novo pyrimidine synthesis. Lucas-Hourani et al.", "Lucas-Hourani et al. identified DD264 as an interferon-sensitive response element ISRE -stimulating compound from high-throughput screening, and further analyses suggested that it was a DHODH inhibitor with a strong antiviral activity against various viruses including MeV, CHIKV, and WNV . DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation.", "DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation. Moreover, the antiviral activity of and ISG activation by DD264 required the interferon regulatory factor 1 IRF1 transcription factor, a master regulator of antiviral gene expression , which was consistent with the observation that the anti-HCV activity of MPA was partially mediated by IRF1 . In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor.", "In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor. FA-613 is also an antiviral compound, which inhibits the pyrimidine biosynthesis pathway, probably via targeting DHODH and inducing the expression of ISGs such as IFNB1, CXCL10, ISG15, and CCL5 . However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined.", "However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined. The mechanism of nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is still presently unclear. Nevertheless, there has been accumulating evidence showing that nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is independent of the classical JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal . First, Wang et al.", "First, Wang et al. clearly showed that ISG activation and anti-HEV activity induced by MPA or brequinar was not mediated by JAK . Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions .", "Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions . Third, our recent study with gemcitabine further confirmed IFN signal-independent ISG activation by parallel studies comparing the effects of gemcitabine and IFN-α. In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine .", "In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine . Moreover, the upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs induced by gemcitabine was not affected by IRF9 knockdown, which was contrary to the result that IFN-α-induced upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs was significantly suppressed under the same conditions. Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation .", "Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation . Despite limited data, we speculate the scenario of ISG activation that is independent of JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal. Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool.", "Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool. Inactivation of metabolic enzyme s itself or consequently altered nucleos t ide pools might trigger a signal, which is ultimately delivered to certain cis-acting elements on the promoter of a subset of ISGs, possibly through the relay of kinases and transcription factors. Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway.", "Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway. It should also be considered that Thomas et al. excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin .", "excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin . Despite the consensus of ISG activation, each purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitor seems to induce distinct sets of ISGs, at least with different patterns . Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations.", "Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations. There might be more than one signaling pathway involved. The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation.", "The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation. Systematic analyses of signaling kinases, IRFs, and STATs using siRNA knockdown and/or pharmacological inhibition and metabolic analyses of corresponding intermediates and nucleos t ides should therefore clarify the underlying molecular mechanisms of ISG activation by purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors. As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased.", "As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased. In this regard, nucleoside analogs that directly target viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and present a high barrier to the development of resistant viruses have been considered advantageous. Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs.", "Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs. Nucleoside analogs probably induce different subsets of ISGs, at least with a different pattern, leading to various combinations of ISGs and resulting antiviral outcomes. Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses .", "Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses . Thus, more systematic analyses on the subsets of ISGs induced by antiviral nucleoside analogs are required for the identification of better antiviral drugs that can be used broadly or specifically. Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives.", "Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives. Nevertheless, nucleoside analogs interfering with the host nucleotide synthesis pathway suggest possible side effects in their clinical applications. Careful evaluation of clinical safety is required and their application for the urgent measure of patients infected with deadly viruses would be worth being primarily considered." ]

[ "Nucleoside analogs have been frequently identified as antiviral agents. In recent years, gemcitabine, a cytidine analog in clinical use for the treatment of many solid tumors, was also shown to have antiviral activity against a broad range of viruses. Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "Nucleoside analogs generally interfere with cellular nucleos t ide synthesis pathways, resulting in the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. Intriguingly, a few recent reports have shown that some nucleoside analogs, including gemcitabine, activated innate immunity, inducing the expression of interferon-stimulated genes, through nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition. The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined.", "The precise crosstalk between these two independent processes remains to be determined. Nonetheless, we summarize the current knowledge of nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity and propose it as a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs. Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases .", "Text: Nucleoside analogs have been historically used for anti-cancer chemotherapy because they inhibit cellular DNA/RNA polymerases . More recently, nucleoside analogs have expanded their therapeutic applications and are being used to develop antiviral drugs against a wide range of serious and life-threatening viruses. Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients.", "Some nucleoside analog drugs targeting specific viral polymerases acyclovir for herpesviruses, zidovudine for human immunodeficiency virus HIV , and sofosbuvir for hepatitis C virus HCV have been successful in clinical trials and are currently in use for the treatment of virus-infected patients. Another class of nucleoside analog drugs such as ribavirin, more broadly-acting on various viruses, has been used in conjunction with IFN-α . Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs.", "Importantly, extensive studies on the antiviral action of ribavirin have established the underlying molecular framework of nucleoside analogs. The primary mechanism to explain the antiviral effect of nucleoside analogs is based on their direct action on viral polymerization. Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates.", "Nucleoside analogs are transported into the cells and phosphorylated by the consecutive action of viral or cellular kinases, eventually generating nucleotide triphosphates. Mature nucleotide analogs, which are similar to physiological nucleotides, can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides.", "Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways .", "There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication.", "As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferon-stimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses.", "There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group.", "In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broad-spectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 .", "can directly incorporate into the growing viral genome during polymerization, resulting in the termination of chain reaction or the accumulation of mutations Figure 1 . Alternatively, nucleotide analogs can bind to the nucleotide-binding region on viral polymerases and block the entry of incoming natural nucleotides. The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis.", "The other mechanism is based on the modulation of cellular nucleos t ide synthesis. There have been accumulating reports that nucleoside analogs act as antiviral agents by interfering with host nucleos t ide synthesis pathways . By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools.", "By targeting metabolic enzymes s , nucleoside analogs block the natural flow of nucleos t ide synthesis and consequently cause the depletion or imbalance of d NTP pools. As viral replication is highly dependent on the availability of host nucleotides, a nucleotide-defective condition decreases the efficiency of viral replication. A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs .", "A more recently proposed mechanism has been based on the observations that a few nucleoside analogs activate innate immunity, especially involving the upregulation of interferonstimulated genes ISGs . Importantly, this phenomenon is usually mediated by the inhibition of nucleotide synthesis, suggesting a potential crosstalk between nucleotide biosynthesis and innate immunity. However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated.", "However, the precise mechanism of this crosstalk remains to be elucidated. There is now an increasing number of nucleoside analogs with antiviral activity toward a wide range of viruses. They have been well-summarized in a previous report .", "They have been well-summarized in a previous report . In the present review, we focus more on gemcitabine as a nucleoside analog, which is clinically relevant and whose broadspectrum antiviral activity has been recently reported by many groups including our group. More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors.", "More importantly, we summarize inhibitors of the purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis pathways that induce innate immunity and propose possible mechanisms of action for these inhibitors. Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes.", "Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV .", "However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans.", "MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug Figure 1 . The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs.", "The mechanism of antiviral effect of nucleos t ide analogs. Nucleos t ide synthesis inhibition-related innate immunity, a newly emerging antiviral mechanism of nucleoside analogs, was highlighted by yellow boxes. Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers .", "Gemcitabine is a cytidine analog that has been clinically used for the treatment of various cancers . However, in recent years, the antiviral activity of gemcitabine has also been reported against a broad range of RNA viruses, including Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus MERS-CoV , severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV , Zika virus ZIKV , HCV, poliovirus PV , influenza A virus IAV , HIV, and enteroviruses EV . The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 .", "The antiviral activities of gemcitabine against the abovementioned viruses are summarized in Table 1 . MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV belong to the family of Coronaviridae and are causative agents of severe viral respiratory illness in humans. To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al.", "To efficiently select appropriate antiviral drug candidates, Dyall et al. screened 290 FDA-approved drugs in virus-infected Vero E6 cells and identified gemcitabine as one of drugs with antiviral activity against both MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV EC 50 of 1.2 µM and 4.9 µM, respectively . More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM .", "More recently, gemcitabine was shown to effectively suppress ZIKV infection and replication in human retinal pigment epithelium RPE cells, particularly at non-cytotoxic concentrations EC 50 of 0.01 µM vs. CC 50 of > 10 µM . ZIKV, a member of the Flaviviridae family, can infect pregnant women and cause congenital abnormalities such as microcephaly in infants, which has attracted increasing public attention as well as extensive research and development into possible treatments. Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy .", "Effective antiviral activities of gemcitabine were also found for the replication of HCV in Huh-7 cells and the infection of HIV in U373-MAGI-CXCR4 CEM cells, with estimated EC 50 s of 12 nM and 16.3 nM, respectively , which were lower concentrations than those used in cancer therapy . In the case of HIV, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine, another nucleoside analog in clinical use for cancer therapy, synergistically reduced HIV infectivity by increasing the viral mutation frequency . In a follow up study, Clouser et al.", "In a follow up study, Clouser et al. further reported the antiviral effect of gemcitabine against HIV-related retrovirus, murine leukemia virus MuLV , in vitro EC 50 of 1.6 nM and even in murine AIDS model . A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al.", "A significant antiviral effect of gemcitabine on IAVs was also reported for RPE cells by Denisova et al. EC 50 of 0.068 µM . They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus .", "They also tested whether gemcitabine had an antiviral effect on several other viruses of different families and found its strong inhibitory effect on Sindbis virus and herpes simplex virus-1 HSV-1 >2 log reduction in virus titer but relatively weak effects on Semliki forest virus and human echovirus 6, and minimal effects on Bunyamwera virus, measles virus MeV , and vaccinia virus . The antiviral effect of gemcitabine on EVs, initially performed on Coxsackievirus B3 CVB3 , was found from screening FDA-approved drugs in CVB3 replicon-harboring Vero cells by our group EC 50 of 0.4 µM . Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively .", "Its broad-spectrum antiviral activity on EVs was further identified by observing a similar inhibitory effect on enterovirus 71 EV71 and human rhinoviruses HRVs EC 50 s of 1 and 1-5 µM, respectively . In the case of HRV, the antiviral effect of gemcitabine was further confirmed in a virus-infected mouse model . In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes.", "In this study, intranasal administration of gemcitabine significantly lowered the pulmonary viral load and inflammation by decreasing proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF-α and IL-1β, and the number of lung infiltrating lymphocytes. More recently, Zhang et al. also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM .", "also identified gemcitabine as the best anti-PV inhibitor from a screen of FDA-approved drugs in PV replicon-harboring HeLa cells EC 50 of 0.3 µM . As previously mentioned, accumulating evidence has definitively demonstrated that gemcitabine is an effective broad-spectrum inhibitor of RNA viruses and has a therapeutic potential for the treatment of various virus-associated diseases. Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses.", "Moreover, it is possible that gemcitabine is effective for other untested RNA viruses. Because gemcitabine is a deoxycytidine analog that interferes with DNA as well as RNA synthesis, DNA viruses may not be the exception. Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine .", "Consistent with this possibility, there has been a report that the infection of HSV-1, which is a representative DNA virus classified into the Herpesviridae family, was strongly affected by gemcitabine . Most of the abovementioned viruses have, at best, limited prophylactic or therapeutic drugs as possible treatments. This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection.", "This is especially true for newly emerging or re-emerged viruses involving serious illnesses, such as MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and ZIKV, which are major threats to public health and which urgently need an effective treatment during their early stages of infection. In this regard, repurposing of gemcitabine for the treatment of patients infected with these deadly viruses is a realistic approach. Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy .", "Importantly, it is noteworthy that ZIKV was the most strongly affected by gemcitabine, with a low nanomolar EC 50 , which was lower than that used in cancer therapy . Even for other viruses with a relatively high EC 50 , there is an option to treat patients with a combination of gemcitabine with other antiviral agents. In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically.", "In this manner, an effective antiviral treatment may be achieved by the synergistic action of two antivirals with much lower doses for each drug, which minimizes deleterious side effects when used clinically. As an example, the synergistic antiviral effect of gemcitabine in combination with ribavirin, an antiviral drug currently being used against a few RNA viruses, was reported against EVs such as CVB3 and EV71 . As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo .", "As previously mentioned, the combination of gemcitabine with decitabine synergistically suppressed HIV infectivity both in vitro and in vivo . However, the actual use of gemcitabine in virus-infected patients necessitates prior in vivo animal studies and clinical trials. Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models .", "Even though most antiviral data have originated from in vitro studies, two recent studies have reported the antiviral effects of gemcitabine in murine models . More extensive analyses of gemcitabine in animal models in the near future will accelerate its therapeutic applications in clinical trials. Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action.", "Most studies regarding the antiviral activity of gemcitabine lack experimental evidence of the mode of action. However, our group has recently reported that gemcitabine had an anti-EV effect by targeting the salvage pathway of pyrimidine biosynthesis . Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection.", "Moreover, gemcitabine strongly induced the expression of several ISGs including CXCL10, IRF7, IRF9, IFIT1, and DDX58, which were the major effectors in the innate immunity that defended the host against the virus infection. These results were consistent with a previous report that gemcitabine stimulated the production of IFN-β and IFN-γ in IAV-infected RPE cells . Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity.", "Importantly, the activation of ISGs was well-correlated with the inhibition of pyrimidine biosynthesis, suggesting a link between pyrimidine biosynthesis and innate immunity. Similar phenomena in terms of ISG activation have been previously reported with a few compounds out of several purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors that had antiviral activity, as summarized in Table 2 6, 10, . Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway.", "Regarding purine biosynthesis inhibitors, ribavirin and mycophenolic acid MPA are inhibitors of inosine-5 -monophosphate IMP dehydrogenase IMPDH , which is a key enzyme of the purine biosynthesis pathway. These inhibitors have been successfully used as clinical antiviral or immunosuppressant agents for decades. Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs .", "Both have antiviral activities against viruses such as HCV, hepatitis E virus HEV , MERS-CoV, dengue virus, yellow fever, hepatitis B virus, West Nile virus WNV , Chikungunya virus CHIKV , and IAV , majorly through the inhibition of the purine biosynthesis pathway, with the antiviral activity against HCV and HEV shown to involve the stimulation of ISGs . For the antiviral activity of ribavirin against HCV, ribavirin specifically induced the expression of IRF7, IRF9, and ISG15 mRNAs, which are known to be important for anti-HCV immune responses . ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways.", "ISG activation occurred through an undefined mechanism that was different from the classical IFN signaling, intracellular dsRNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor B pathways. More importantly, ribavirin-induced ISG activation and antiviral activity were suppressed using supplemented guanosine, a natural analog of ribavirin, suggesting IMPDH inhibition-mediated ISG activation as an alternative innate immunity pathway. Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine .", "Like ribavirin, MPA remarkably induced the expression of several ISGs, including IRF1, IRF9, ISG15, IFI6, IRF7, CXCL10, IFIT2, and IFITM3 mRNAs in naïve or HEV-infected Huh-7 cells, and the induction of ISGs was at least partially abrogated by the use of supplemented guanosine . Mechanistically, the induction of ISGs by MPA was independent of the classical JAK/STAT system, which is similar to that observed with ribavirin . Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized .", "Similar results were obtained with several IMPDH1 or IMPDH2 inhibitors, with various affinities, that were custom-designed and synthesized . As shown in Table 2 , most pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors target dihydroorotate dehydrogenase DHODH , an essential enzyme in de novo pyrimidine synthesis. Lucas-Hourani et al.", "Lucas-Hourani et al. identified DD264 as an interferon-sensitive response element ISRE -stimulating compound from high-throughput screening, and further analyses suggested that it was a DHODH inhibitor with a strong antiviral activity against various viruses including MeV, CHIKV, and WNV . DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation.", "DD264 enhanced the expression of several ISGs, which were almost completely suppressed by the addition of supplemented uridine, indicating DHODH inhibition-mediated ISG activation. Moreover, the antiviral activity of and ISG activation by DD264 required the interferon regulatory factor 1 IRF1 transcription factor, a master regulator of antiviral gene expression , which was consistent with the observation that the anti-HCV activity of MPA was partially mediated by IRF1 . In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor.", "In this study, similar results were shown with brequinar, another well-known DHODH inhibitor. FA-613 is also an antiviral compound, which inhibits the pyrimidine biosynthesis pathway, probably via targeting DHODH and inducing the expression of ISGs such as IFNB1, CXCL10, ISG15, and CCL5 . However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined.", "However, whether ISG activation is mediated by pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibition remains to be determined. The mechanism of nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is still presently unclear. Nevertheless, there has been accumulating evidence showing that nucleotide synthesis inhibitor-induced ISG activation is independent of the classical JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal . First, Wang et al.", "First, Wang et al. clearly showed that ISG activation and anti-HEV activity induced by MPA or brequinar was not mediated by JAK . Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions .", "Second, IRF7 induction by ribavirin was not affected by knockdown of STAT1, while that of IFN-α was strongly affected under the same conditions . Third, our recent study with gemcitabine further confirmed IFN signal-independent ISG activation by parallel studies comparing the effects of gemcitabine and IFN-α. In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine .", "In our study, the phosphorylation of STAT1 at Tyr701, which was dramatically triggered by IFN-α, did not occur when treated with gemcitabine . Moreover, the upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs induced by gemcitabine was not affected by IRF9 knockdown, which was contrary to the result that IFN-α-induced upregulation of DDX58 mRNAs was significantly suppressed under the same conditions. Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation .", "Consistent with above observations, there have been some reports that ISGs was induced in the absence of JAK1 or STAT1 activation . Despite limited data, we speculate the scenario of ISG activation that is independent of JAK/STAT-mediated IFN signal. Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool.", "Purine or pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors could interfere with the metabolic pathway through targeting some key enzymes such as IMPDH and DHODH, leading to the depletion or imbalance of the d NTP pool. Inactivation of metabolic enzyme s itself or consequently altered nucleos t ide pools might trigger a signal, which is ultimately delivered to certain cis-acting elements on the promoter of a subset of ISGs, possibly through the relay of kinases and transcription factors. Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway.", "Based on the previously mentioned reports, this signal is less likely to be dependent on STAT1/2-IRF9 IFN-stimulated gene factor 3; ISGF3 , at least for gemcitabine, which is the major transcriptional complex in the IFN-induced JAK/STAT pathway. It should also be considered that Thomas et al. excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin .", "excluded the involvement of an intracellular double-stranded RNA sensing pathway, Toll-like receptor and nuclear factor κB pathways, as well as a classical IFN signal in the activation of ISGs induced by ribavirin . Despite the consensus of ISG activation, each purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitor seems to induce distinct sets of ISGs, at least with different patterns . Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations.", "Targeting an enzyme in which pathways purine or pyrimidine synthesis or steps early/late and de novo/salvage produce different levels of intermediates and nucleos t ides will consequently result in diverse outcomes of ISG activations. There might be more than one signaling pathway involved. The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation.", "The synergistic antiviral activity of gemcitabine and ribavirin observed in our study might be explained by the possible existence of two separate signaling pathways that mediate each inhibition of nucleotide synthesis toward ISG activation. Systematic analyses of signaling kinases, IRFs, and STATs using siRNA knockdown and/or pharmacological inhibition and metabolic analyses of corresponding intermediates and nucleos t ides should therefore clarify the underlying molecular mechanisms of ISG activation by purine/pyrimidine biosynthesis inhibitors. As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased.", "As newly emerging or re-emerged viruses such as SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and ZIKV have become a major threat to public health, the need for broad-spectrum antiviral drug has increased. In this regard, nucleoside analogs that directly target viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and present a high barrier to the development of resistant viruses have been considered advantageous. Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs.", "Moreover, recent discovery of a new antiviral mode of nucleoside analogs acting through innate immunity strengthens the molecular basis for their therapeutic application as broad-spectrum antiviral drugs. Nucleoside analogs probably induce different subsets of ISGs, at least with a different pattern, leading to various combinations of ISGs and resulting antiviral outcomes. Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses .", "Moreover, according to Schoggins et al., different viruses are affected by distinct subsets of ISGs and some ISGs such as IRF1, MB21D1, HPSE, DDX58, MDA, and IFITM3 act broadly on various viruses . Thus, more systematic analyses on the subsets of ISGs induced by antiviral nucleoside analogs are required for the identification of better antiviral drugs that can be used broadly or specifically. Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives.", "Given the clinical side effects of IFN treatment, nucleotide analogs that differ from IFN in the activation of subsets of ISGs need to be considered as alternatives. Nevertheless, nucleoside analogs interfering with the host nucleotide synthesis pathway suggest possible side effects in their clinical applications. Careful evaluation of clinical safety is required and their application for the urgent measure of patients infected with deadly viruses would be worth being primarily considered." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , as the pathogeny of Rabbit haemorrhagic disease, can cause a highly infectious and often fatal disease only affecting wild and domestic rabbits. Recent researches revealed that it, as one number of the Caliciviridae, has some specialties in its genome, its reproduction and so on. RESULTS: In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias.", "RESULTS: In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias. Our researches indicated that mutation pressure rather than natural is the most important determinant in RHDV with high codon bias, and the codon usage bias is nearly contrary between ORF1 and ORF2, which is maybe one of factors regulating the expression of VP60 encoding by ORF1 and VP10 encoding by ORF2 . Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle.", "Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle. CONCLUSIONS: We conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV.", "According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV. Text: Synonymous codons are not used randomly . The variation of codon usage among ORFs in different organisms is accounted by mutational pressure and translational selection as two main factors .", "The variation of codon usage among ORFs in different organisms is accounted by mutational pressure and translational selection as two main factors . Levels and causes of codon usage bias are available to understand viral evolution and the interplay between viruses and the immune response . Thus, many organisms such as bacteria, yeast, Drosophila, and mammals, have been studied in great detail up on codon usage bias and nucleotide composition .", "Thus, many organisms such as bacteria, yeast, Drosophila, and mammals, have been studied in great detail up on codon usage bias and nucleotide composition . However, same researches in viruses, especially in animal viruses, have been less studied. It has been observed that codon usage bias in human RNA viruses is related to mutational pressure, G +C content, the segmented nature of the genome and the route of transmission of the virus .", "It has been observed that codon usage bias in human RNA viruses is related to mutational pressure, G +C content, the segmented nature of the genome and the route of transmission of the virus . For some vertebrate DNA viruses, genome-wide mutational pressure is regarded as the main determinant of codon usage rather than natural selection for specific coding triplets . Analysis of the bovine papillomavirus type 1 BPV1 late genes has revealed a relationship between codon usage and tRNA availability .", "Analysis of the bovine papillomavirus type 1 BPV1 late genes has revealed a relationship between codon usage and tRNA availability . In the mammalian papillomaviruses, it has been proposed that differences from the average codon usage frequencies in the host genome strongly influence both viral replication and gene expression . Codon usage may play a key role in regulating latent versus productive infection in Epstein-Barr virus .", "Codon usage may play a key role in regulating latent versus productive infection in Epstein-Barr virus . Recently, it was reported that codon usage is an important driving force in the evolution of astroviruses and small DNA viruses . Clearly, studies of synonymous codon usage in viruses can reveal much about the molecular evolution of viruses or individual genes.", "Clearly, studies of synonymous codon usage in viruses can reveal much about the molecular evolution of viruses or individual genes. Such information would be relevant in understanding the regulation of viral gene expression. Up to now, little codon usage analysis has been performed on Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , which is the pathogen causing Rabbit haemorrhagic disease RHD , also known as rabbit calicivirus disease RCD or viral haemorrhagic disease VHD , a highly infectious and often fatal disease that affects wild and domestic rabbits.", "Up to now, little codon usage analysis has been performed on Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , which is the pathogen causing Rabbit haemorrhagic disease RHD , also known as rabbit calicivirus disease RCD or viral haemorrhagic disease VHD , a highly infectious and often fatal disease that affects wild and domestic rabbits. Although the virus infects only rabbits, RHD continues to cause serious problems in different parts of the world. RHDV is a single positive stranded RNA virus without envelope, which contains two open reading frames ORFs separately encoding a predicted polyprotein and a minor structural protein named VP10 .", "RHDV is a single positive stranded RNA virus without envelope, which contains two open reading frames ORFs separately encoding a predicted polyprotein and a minor structural protein named VP10 . After the hydrolysis of self-coding 3C-like cysteinase, the polyprotein was finally hydrolyzed into 8 cleavage products including 7 nonstructural proteins and 1 structural protein named as VP60 . Studies on the phylogenetic relationship of RHDVs showed only one serotype had been isolated, and no genotyping for RHDV was reported.", "Studies on the phylogenetic relationship of RHDVs showed only one serotype had been isolated, and no genotyping for RHDV was reported. It reported that the VP10 was translated with an efficiency of 20% of the preceding ORF1 . In order to better understand the characteristics of the RHDV genome and to reveal more information about the viral genome, we have analyzed the codon usage and dinucleotide composition.", "In order to better understand the characteristics of the RHDV genome and to reveal more information about the viral genome, we have analyzed the codon usage and dinucleotide composition. In this report, we sought to address the following issues concerning codon usage in RHDV: i the extent and causes of codon bias in RHDV; ii A possible genotyping of RHDV; iii Codon usage bias as a factor reducing the expression of VP10 and iiii the evolution of the ORFs. The 30 available complete RNA sequences of RHDV were obtained from GenBank randomly in January 2011.", "The 30 available complete RNA sequences of RHDV were obtained from GenBank randomly in January 2011. The serial number SN , collection dates, isolated areas and GenBank accession numbers are listed in Table 1 . To investigate the characteristics of synonymous codon usage without the influence of amino acid composition, RSCU values of each codon in a ORF of RHDV were calculated according to previous reports 2 Sharp, Tuohy et al.", "To investigate the characteristics of synonymous codon usage without the influence of amino acid composition, RSCU values of each codon in a ORF of RHDV were calculated according to previous reports 2 Sharp, Tuohy et al. 1986 as the followed formula: Where g ij is the observed number of the ith codon for jth amino acid which has n i type of synonymous codons. The codons with RSCU value higher than 1.0 have positive codon usage bias, while codons with value lower than 1.0 has relative negative codon usage bias.", "The codons with RSCU value higher than 1.0 have positive codon usage bias, while codons with value lower than 1.0 has relative negative codon usage bias. As RSCU values of some codons are nearly equal to 1.0, it means that these codons are chosen equally and randomly. The index GC3s means the fraction of the nucleotides G+C at the synonymous third codon position, excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons.", "The index GC3s means the fraction of the nucleotides G+C at the synonymous third codon position, excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons. The ENC, as the best estimator of absolute synonymous codon usage bias , was calculated for the quantification of the codon usage bias of each ORF . The predicted values of ENC were calculated as ENC = 2 + s + 29 where s represents the given G+C 3 % value.", "The predicted values of ENC were calculated as ENC = 2 + s + 29 where s represents the given G+C 3 % value. The values of ENC can also be obtained by EMBOSS CHIPS program . Analyses were conducted with the Nei-Gojobori model , involving 30 nucleotide sequences. All positions containing gaps and missing data were eliminated.", "All positions containing gaps and missing data were eliminated. The values of dn, ds and ω dn/ds were calculated in MEGA4.0 . Multivariate statistical analysis can be used to explore the relationships between variables and samples. In this study, correspondence analysis was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation among ORFs.", "In this study, correspondence analysis was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation among ORFs. In this study, the complete coding region of each ORF was represented as a 59 dimensional vector, and each dimension corresponds to the RSCU value of one sense codon excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons . Correlation analysis was used to identify the relationship between nucleotide composition and synonymous codon usage pattern .", "Correlation analysis was used to identify the relationship between nucleotide composition and synonymous codon usage pattern . This analysis was implemented based on the Spearman's rank correlation analysis way. All statistical processes were carried out by with statistical software SPSS 17.0 for windows.", "All statistical processes were carried out by with statistical software SPSS 17.0 for windows. The values of nucleotide contents in complete coding region of all 30 RHDV genomes were analyzed and listed in Table 2 and Table 3 . Evidently, C+G % content of the ORF1 fluctuated from 50.889 to 51.557 with a mean value of 51.14557, and C+G % content of the ORF2 were ranged from 35.593 to 40.113 with a mean value of 37.6624, which were indicating that nucleotides A and U were the major elements of ORF2 against ORF1.", "Evidently, C+G % content of the ORF1 fluctuated from 50.889 to 51.557 with a mean value of 51.14557, and C+G % content of the ORF2 were ranged from 35.593 to 40.113 with a mean value of 37.6624, which were indicating that nucleotides A and U were the major elements of ORF2 against ORF1. Comparing the values of A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 % and G 3 %, it is clear that C 3 % was distinctly high and A 3 % was the lowest of all in ORF1 of RHDV, while U 3 % was distinctly high and C 3 % was the lowest of all in ORF2 of Table 2 Identified nucleotide contents in complete coding region length > 250 bps in the ORF1 of RHDV 30 isolates genome Table 4 . Most preferentially used codons in ORF1 were C-ended or G-ended codons except Ala, Pro and Ser, however, A-ended or G-ended codons were preferred as the content of ORF2.", "Most preferentially used codons in ORF1 were C-ended or G-ended codons except Ala, Pro and Ser, however, A-ended or G-ended codons were preferred as the content of ORF2. In addition, the dn, ds and ω dN/dS values of ORF1 were separately 0.014, 0.338 and 0.041, and the values of ORF2 were 0.034, 0.103 and 0.034, respectively. The ω values of two ORFs in RHDV genome are generally low, indicating that the RHDV whole genome is subject to relatively strong selective constraints.", "The ω values of two ORFs in RHDV genome are generally low, indicating that the RHDV whole genome is subject to relatively strong selective constraints. COA was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation between two ORFs of all 30 RHDV selected for this study. After COA for RHDV Genome, one major trend in the first axis f' 1 which accounted for 42.967% of the total variation, and another major trend in the second axis f' 2 which accounted for 3.632% of the total variation.", "After COA for RHDV Genome, one major trend in the first axis f' 1 which accounted for 42.967% of the total variation, and another major trend in the second axis f' 2 which accounted for 3.632% of the total variation. The coordinate of the complete coding region of each ORF was plotted in Figure 1 defining by the first and second principal axes. It is clear that coordinate of each ORF is relatively isolated.", "It is clear that coordinate of each ORF is relatively isolated. Interestingly, we found that relatively isolated spots from ORF2 tend to cluster into two groups: the ordinate value of one group marked as Group 1 is To estimate whether the evolution of RHDV genome on codon usage was regulated by mutation pressure or natural selection, the A%, U%, C%, G% and C+G % were compared with A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 %, G 3 % and C 3 +G 3 %, respectively Table 5 . There is a complex correlation among nucleotide compositions.", "There is a complex correlation among nucleotide compositions. In detail, A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 % and G 3 % have a significant negative correlation with G%, C%, U% and A% and positive correlation with A%, U%, C% and G%, respectively. It suggests that nucleotide constraint may influence synonymous codon usage patterns.", "It suggests that nucleotide constraint may influence synonymous codon usage patterns. However, A 3 % has non-correlation with U% and C%, and U 3 % has noncorrelation with A% and G%, respectively, which haven't indicated any peculiarity about synonymous codon usage. Furthermore, C 3 % and G 3 % have non-correlation with A%, G% and U%, C%, respectively, indicating these data don't reflect the true feature of synonymous codon usage as well.", "Furthermore, C 3 % and G 3 % have non-correlation with A%, G% and U%, C%, respectively, indicating these data don't reflect the true feature of synonymous codon usage as well. Therefore, linear regression analysis was implemented to analyze the correlation between synonymous codon usage bias and nucleotide compositions. Details of correlation analysis between the first two principle axes f' 1 and f' 2 of each RHDV genome in COA and nucleotide contents were listed in Table 6 .", "Details of correlation analysis between the first two principle axes f' 1 and f' 2 of each RHDV genome in COA and nucleotide contents were listed in Table 6 . In surprise, only f2 values are closely related to base nucleotide A and G content on the third codon position only, suggesting that nucleotide A and G is a factor influencing the synonymous codon usage pattern of RHDV genome. However, f' 1 value has non-correlation with base nucleotide contents on the third codon position; it is observably suggest that codon usage patterns in RHDV were probably influenced by other factors, such as the second structure of viral genome and limits of host.", "However, f' 1 value has non-correlation with base nucleotide contents on the third codon position; it is observably suggest that codon usage patterns in RHDV were probably influenced by other factors, such as the second structure of viral genome and limits of host. In spite of that, compositional constraint is a factor shaping the pattern of synonymous codon usage in RHDV genome. Figure 1 A plot of value of the first and second axis of RHDV genome in COA.", "Figure 1 A plot of value of the first and second axis of RHDV genome in COA. The first axis f' 1 accounts for 42.967% of the total variation, and the second axis f' 2 accounts for 3.632% of the total variation. Table 5 Summary of correlation analysis between the A, U, C, G contents and A 3 , U 3 , C 3 , G 3 contents in all selected samples There have been more and more features that are unique to RHDV within the family Caliciviridae, including its single host tropism, its genome and its VP10 as a structural protein with unknown function.", "Table 5 Summary of correlation analysis between the A, U, C, G contents and A 3 , U 3 , C 3 , G 3 contents in all selected samples There have been more and more features that are unique to RHDV within the family Caliciviridae, including its single host tropism, its genome and its VP10 as a structural protein with unknown function. After we analyzed synonymous codon usage in RHDV Table 2 , we obtained several conclusions and conjectures as followed. 4.1 Mutational bias as a main factor leading to synonymous codon usage variation ENC-plot, as a general strategy, was utilized to investigate patterns of synonymous codon usage.", "4.1 Mutational bias as a main factor leading to synonymous codon usage variation ENC-plot, as a general strategy, was utilized to investigate patterns of synonymous codon usage. The ENC-plots of ORFs constrained only by a C 3 +G 3 composition will lie on or just below the curve of the predicted values . ENC values of RHDV genomes were plotted against its corresponding C 3 +G 3 %.", "ENC values of RHDV genomes were plotted against its corresponding C 3 +G 3 %. All of the spots lie below the curve of the predicted values, as shown in Figure 2 , suggesting that the codon usage bias in all these 30 RHDV genomes is principally influenced by the mutational bias. As we know, the efficiency of gene expression is influenced by regulator sequences or elements and codon usage bias.", "As we know, the efficiency of gene expression is influenced by regulator sequences or elements and codon usage bias. It reported that the RNA sequence of the 3terminal 84 nucleotides of ORF1were found to be crucial for VP10 expression instead of the encoded peptide. VP10 coding by ORF2 has been reported as a low expressive structural protein against VP60 coding by ORF1 .", "VP10 coding by ORF2 has been reported as a low expressive structural protein against VP60 coding by ORF1 . And its efficiency of translation is only 20% of VP60. According to results showed by Table 4 , it revealed the differences in codon usage patterns of two ORFs, which is a possible factor reducing the expression of VP10.", "According to results showed by Table 4 , it revealed the differences in codon usage patterns of two ORFs, which is a possible factor reducing the expression of VP10. Although VP10 encoded by ORF2, as a minor structural protein with unknown functions, has been described by LIU as a nonessential protein for virus infectivity, the ω Figure 2 Effective number of codons used in each ORF plotted against the GC3s. The continuous curve plots the relationship between GC3s and ENC in the absence of selection.", "The continuous curve plots the relationship between GC3s and ENC in the absence of selection. All of spots lie below the expected curve. value of ORF2 suggests VP10 plays an important role in the certain stage of whole RHDV lifecycle.", "value of ORF2 suggests VP10 plays an important role in the certain stage of whole RHDV lifecycle. After combining with low expression and ω value of VP10, we conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. This mechanism has been confirmed in various positive-chain RNA viruses, including coxsackievirus, dengue virus, equine arterivirus, footand-mouth disease virus, hepatitis C virus, poliovirus, rhinovirus, and severe acute respiratory syndrome , although the details remain elusive.", "This mechanism has been confirmed in various positive-chain RNA viruses, including coxsackievirus, dengue virus, equine arterivirus, footand-mouth disease virus, hepatitis C virus, poliovirus, rhinovirus, and severe acute respiratory syndrome , although the details remain elusive. As preceding description, ENC reflects the evolution of codon usage variation and nucleotide composition to some degree. After the correlation analysis of ENC values between ORF1 and ORF2 Table 7 , the related coefficient of ENC values of two ORFs is 0.230, and p value is 0.222 more than 0.05.", "After the correlation analysis of ENC values between ORF1 and ORF2 Table 7 , the related coefficient of ENC values of two ORFs is 0.230, and p value is 0.222 more than 0.05. These data revealed that no correlation existed in ENC values of two ORFs, indicating that codon usage patterns and evolution of two ORFs are separated each other. Further, this information maybe helps us well understand why RSCU and ENC between two ORFs are quite different.", "Further, this information maybe helps us well understand why RSCU and ENC between two ORFs are quite different. Interestingly, we found that relatively isolated spots from ORF2 tend to cluster into two groups: the ordinate value of one group marked as Group 1 is positive value and the other one marked as Group 2 is negative value. And all of those strains isolated before 2000 belonged to Group 2, including Italy-90, RHDV-V351, RHDV-FRG, BS89, RHDV-SD and M67473.1.", "And all of those strains isolated before 2000 belonged to Group 2, including Italy-90, RHDV-V351, RHDV-FRG, BS89, RHDV-SD and M67473.1. Although RHDV has been reported as only one type, this may be a reference on dividing into two genotypes. In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias.", "In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias. Our researches indicated that mutation pressure rather than natural is the most important determinant in RHDV with high codon bias, and the codon usage bias is nearly contrary between ORF1 and ORF2, which is maybe one of factors regulating the expression of VP60 encoding by ORF1 and VP10 encoding by ORF2 . Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle.", "Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle. We conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV.", "According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV. All the results will guide the next researches on the RHDV as a reference." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , as the pathogeny of Rabbit haemorrhagic disease, can cause a highly infectious and often fatal disease only affecting wild and domestic rabbits. Recent researches revealed that it, as one number of the Caliciviridae, has some specialties in its genome, its reproduction and so on. RESULTS: In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias.", "RESULTS: In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias. Our researches indicated that mutation pressure rather than natural is the most important determinant in RHDV with high codon bias, and the codon usage bias is nearly contrary between ORF1 and ORF2, which is maybe one of factors regulating the expression of VP60 encoding by ORF1 and VP10 encoding by ORF2 . Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle.", "Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle. CONCLUSIONS: We conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV.", "According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV. Text: Synonymous codons are not used randomly . The variation of codon usage among ORFs in different organisms is accounted by mutational pressure and translational selection as two main factors .", "The variation of codon usage among ORFs in different organisms is accounted by mutational pressure and translational selection as two main factors . Levels and causes of codon usage bias are available to understand viral evolution and the interplay between viruses and the immune response . Thus, many organisms such as bacteria, yeast, Drosophila, and mammals, have been studied in great detail up on codon usage bias and nucleotide composition .", "Thus, many organisms such as bacteria, yeast, Drosophila, and mammals, have been studied in great detail up on codon usage bias and nucleotide composition . However, same researches in viruses, especially in animal viruses, have been less studied. It has been observed that codon usage bias in human RNA viruses is related to mutational pressure, G +C content, the segmented nature of the genome and the route of transmission of the virus .", "It has been observed that codon usage bias in human RNA viruses is related to mutational pressure, G +C content, the segmented nature of the genome and the route of transmission of the virus . For some vertebrate DNA viruses, genome-wide mutational pressure is regarded as the main determinant of codon usage rather than natural selection for specific coding triplets . Analysis of the bovine papillomavirus type 1 BPV1 late genes has revealed a relationship between codon usage and tRNA availability .", "Analysis of the bovine papillomavirus type 1 BPV1 late genes has revealed a relationship between codon usage and tRNA availability . In the mammalian papillomaviruses, it has been proposed that differences from the average codon usage frequencies in the host genome strongly influence both viral replication and gene expression . Codon usage may play a key role in regulating latent versus productive infection in Epstein-Barr virus .", "Codon usage may play a key role in regulating latent versus productive infection in Epstein-Barr virus . Recently, it was reported that codon usage is an important driving force in the evolution of astroviruses and small DNA viruses . Clearly, studies of synonymous codon usage in viruses can reveal much about the molecular evolution of viruses or individual genes.", "Clearly, studies of synonymous codon usage in viruses can reveal much about the molecular evolution of viruses or individual genes. Such information would be relevant in understanding the regulation of viral gene expression. Up to now, little codon usage analysis has been performed on Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , which is the pathogen causing Rabbit haemorrhagic disease RHD , also known as rabbit calicivirus disease RCD or viral haemorrhagic disease VHD , a highly infectious and often fatal disease that affects wild and domestic rabbits.", "Up to now, little codon usage analysis has been performed on Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV , which is the pathogen causing Rabbit haemorrhagic disease RHD , also known as rabbit calicivirus disease RCD or viral haemorrhagic disease VHD , a highly infectious and often fatal disease that affects wild and domestic rabbits. Although the virus infects only rabbits, RHD continues to cause serious problems in different parts of the world. RHDV is a single positive stranded RNA virus without envelope, which contains two open reading frames ORFs separately encoding a predicted polyprotein and a minor structural protein named VP10 .", "RHDV is a single positive stranded RNA virus without envelope, which contains two open reading frames ORFs separately encoding a predicted polyprotein and a minor structural protein named VP10 . After the hydrolysis of self-coding 3C-like cysteinase, the polyprotein was finally hydrolyzed into 8 cleavage products including 7 nonstructural proteins and 1 structural protein named as VP60 . Studies on the phylogenetic relationship of RHDVs showed only one serotype had been isolated, and no genotyping for RHDV was reported.", "Studies on the phylogenetic relationship of RHDVs showed only one serotype had been isolated, and no genotyping for RHDV was reported. It reported that the VP10 was translated with an efficiency of 20% of the preceding ORF1 . In order to better understand the characteristics of the RHDV genome and to reveal more information about the viral genome, we have analyzed the codon usage and dinucleotide composition.", "In order to better understand the characteristics of the RHDV genome and to reveal more information about the viral genome, we have analyzed the codon usage and dinucleotide composition. In this report, we sought to address the following issues concerning codon usage in RHDV: i the extent and causes of codon bias in RHDV; ii A possible genotyping of RHDV; iii Codon usage bias as a factor reducing the expression of VP10 and iiii the evolution of the ORFs. The 30 available complete RNA sequences of RHDV were obtained from GenBank randomly in January 2011.", "The 30 available complete RNA sequences of RHDV were obtained from GenBank randomly in January 2011. The serial number SN , collection dates, isolated areas and GenBank accession numbers are listed in Table 1 . To investigate the characteristics of synonymous codon usage without the influence of amino acid composition, RSCU values of each codon in a ORF of RHDV were calculated according to previous reports 2 Sharp, Tuohy et al.", "To investigate the characteristics of synonymous codon usage without the influence of amino acid composition, RSCU values of each codon in a ORF of RHDV were calculated according to previous reports 2 Sharp, Tuohy et al. 1986 as the followed formula: Where g ij is the observed number of the ith codon for jth amino acid which has n i type of synonymous codons. The codons with RSCU value higher than 1.0 have positive codon usage bias, while codons with value lower than 1.0 has relative negative codon usage bias.", "The codons with RSCU value higher than 1.0 have positive codon usage bias, while codons with value lower than 1.0 has relative negative codon usage bias. As RSCU values of some codons are nearly equal to 1.0, it means that these codons are chosen equally and randomly. The index GC3s means the fraction of the nucleotides G+C at the synonymous third codon position, excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons.", "The index GC3s means the fraction of the nucleotides G+C at the synonymous third codon position, excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons. The ENC, as the best estimator of absolute synonymous codon usage bias , was calculated for the quantification of the codon usage bias of each ORF . The predicted values of ENC were calculated as ENC = 2 + s + 29 where s represents the given G+C 3 % value.", "The predicted values of ENC were calculated as ENC = 2 + s + 29 where s represents the given G+C 3 % value. The values of ENC can also be obtained by EMBOSS CHIPS program . Analyses were conducted with the Nei-Gojobori model , involving 30 nucleotide sequences. All positions containing gaps and missing data were eliminated.", "All positions containing gaps and missing data were eliminated. The values of dn, ds and ω dn/ds were calculated in MEGA4.0 . Multivariate statistical analysis can be used to explore the relationships between variables and samples. In this study, correspondence analysis was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation among ORFs.", "In this study, correspondence analysis was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation among ORFs. In this study, the complete coding region of each ORF was represented as a 59 dimensional vector, and each dimension corresponds to the RSCU value of one sense codon excluding Met, Trp, and the termination codons . Correlation analysis was used to identify the relationship between nucleotide composition and synonymous codon usage pattern .", "Correlation analysis was used to identify the relationship between nucleotide composition and synonymous codon usage pattern . This analysis was implemented based on the Spearman's rank correlation analysis way. All statistical processes were carried out by with statistical software SPSS 17.0 for windows.", "All statistical processes were carried out by with statistical software SPSS 17.0 for windows. The values of nucleotide contents in complete coding region of all 30 RHDV genomes were analyzed and listed in Table 2 and Table 3 . Evidently, C+G % content of the ORF1 fluctuated from 50.889 to 51.557 with a mean value of 51.14557, and C+G % content of the ORF2 were ranged from 35.593 to 40.113 with a mean value of 37.6624, which were indicating that nucleotides A and U were the major elements of ORF2 against ORF1.", "Evidently, C+G % content of the ORF1 fluctuated from 50.889 to 51.557 with a mean value of 51.14557, and C+G % content of the ORF2 were ranged from 35.593 to 40.113 with a mean value of 37.6624, which were indicating that nucleotides A and U were the major elements of ORF2 against ORF1. Comparing the values of A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 % and G 3 %, it is clear that C 3 % was distinctly high and A 3 % was the lowest of all in ORF1 of RHDV, while U 3 % was distinctly high and C 3 % was the lowest of all in ORF2 of Table 2 Identified nucleotide contents in complete coding region length > 250 bps in the ORF1 of RHDV 30 isolates genome Table 4 . Most preferentially used codons in ORF1 were C-ended or G-ended codons except Ala, Pro and Ser, however, A-ended or G-ended codons were preferred as the content of ORF2.", "Most preferentially used codons in ORF1 were C-ended or G-ended codons except Ala, Pro and Ser, however, A-ended or G-ended codons were preferred as the content of ORF2. In addition, the dn, ds and ω dN/dS values of ORF1 were separately 0.014, 0.338 and 0.041, and the values of ORF2 were 0.034, 0.103 and 0.034, respectively. The ω values of two ORFs in RHDV genome are generally low, indicating that the RHDV whole genome is subject to relatively strong selective constraints.", "The ω values of two ORFs in RHDV genome are generally low, indicating that the RHDV whole genome is subject to relatively strong selective constraints. COA was used to investigate the major trend in codon usage variation between two ORFs of all 30 RHDV selected for this study. After COA for RHDV Genome, one major trend in the first axis f' 1 which accounted for 42.967% of the total variation, and another major trend in the second axis f' 2 which accounted for 3.632% of the total variation.", "After COA for RHDV Genome, one major trend in the first axis f' 1 which accounted for 42.967% of the total variation, and another major trend in the second axis f' 2 which accounted for 3.632% of the total variation. The coordinate of the complete coding region of each ORF was plotted in Figure 1 defining by the first and second principal axes. It is clear that coordinate of each ORF is relatively isolated.", "It is clear that coordinate of each ORF is relatively isolated. Interestingly, we found that relatively isolated spots from ORF2 tend to cluster into two groups: the ordinate value of one group marked as Group 1 is To estimate whether the evolution of RHDV genome on codon usage was regulated by mutation pressure or natural selection, the A%, U%, C%, G% and C+G % were compared with A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 %, G 3 % and C 3 +G 3 %, respectively Table 5 . There is a complex correlation among nucleotide compositions.", "There is a complex correlation among nucleotide compositions. In detail, A 3 %, U 3 %, C 3 % and G 3 % have a significant negative correlation with G%, C%, U% and A% and positive correlation with A%, U%, C% and G%, respectively. It suggests that nucleotide constraint may influence synonymous codon usage patterns.", "It suggests that nucleotide constraint may influence synonymous codon usage patterns. However, A 3 % has non-correlation with U% and C%, and U 3 % has noncorrelation with A% and G%, respectively, which haven't indicated any peculiarity about synonymous codon usage. Furthermore, C 3 % and G 3 % have non-correlation with A%, G% and U%, C%, respectively, indicating these data don't reflect the true feature of synonymous codon usage as well.", "Furthermore, C 3 % and G 3 % have non-correlation with A%, G% and U%, C%, respectively, indicating these data don't reflect the true feature of synonymous codon usage as well. Therefore, linear regression analysis was implemented to analyze the correlation between synonymous codon usage bias and nucleotide compositions. Details of correlation analysis between the first two principle axes f' 1 and f' 2 of each RHDV genome in COA and nucleotide contents were listed in Table 6 .", "Details of correlation analysis between the first two principle axes f' 1 and f' 2 of each RHDV genome in COA and nucleotide contents were listed in Table 6 . In surprise, only f2 values are closely related to base nucleotide A and G content on the third codon position only, suggesting that nucleotide A and G is a factor influencing the synonymous codon usage pattern of RHDV genome. However, f' 1 value has non-correlation with base nucleotide contents on the third codon position; it is observably suggest that codon usage patterns in RHDV were probably influenced by other factors, such as the second structure of viral genome and limits of host.", "However, f' 1 value has non-correlation with base nucleotide contents on the third codon position; it is observably suggest that codon usage patterns in RHDV were probably influenced by other factors, such as the second structure of viral genome and limits of host. In spite of that, compositional constraint is a factor shaping the pattern of synonymous codon usage in RHDV genome. Figure 1 A plot of value of the first and second axis of RHDV genome in COA.", "Figure 1 A plot of value of the first and second axis of RHDV genome in COA. The first axis f' 1 accounts for 42.967% of the total variation, and the second axis f' 2 accounts for 3.632% of the total variation. Table 5 Summary of correlation analysis between the A, U, C, G contents and A 3 , U 3 , C 3 , G 3 contents in all selected samples There have been more and more features that are unique to RHDV within the family Caliciviridae, including its single host tropism, its genome and its VP10 as a structural protein with unknown function.", "Table 5 Summary of correlation analysis between the A, U, C, G contents and A 3 , U 3 , C 3 , G 3 contents in all selected samples There have been more and more features that are unique to RHDV within the family Caliciviridae, including its single host tropism, its genome and its VP10 as a structural protein with unknown function. After we analyzed synonymous codon usage in RHDV Table 2 , we obtained several conclusions and conjectures as followed. 4.1 Mutational bias as a main factor leading to synonymous codon usage variation ENC-plot, as a general strategy, was utilized to investigate patterns of synonymous codon usage.", "4.1 Mutational bias as a main factor leading to synonymous codon usage variation ENC-plot, as a general strategy, was utilized to investigate patterns of synonymous codon usage. The ENC-plots of ORFs constrained only by a C 3 +G 3 composition will lie on or just below the curve of the predicted values . ENC values of RHDV genomes were plotted against its corresponding C 3 +G 3 %.", "ENC values of RHDV genomes were plotted against its corresponding C 3 +G 3 %. All of the spots lie below the curve of the predicted values, as shown in Figure 2 , suggesting that the codon usage bias in all these 30 RHDV genomes is principally influenced by the mutational bias. As we know, the efficiency of gene expression is influenced by regulator sequences or elements and codon usage bias.", "As we know, the efficiency of gene expression is influenced by regulator sequences or elements and codon usage bias. It reported that the RNA sequence of the 3terminal 84 nucleotides of ORF1were found to be crucial for VP10 expression instead of the encoded peptide. VP10 coding by ORF2 has been reported as a low expressive structural protein against VP60 coding by ORF1 .", "VP10 coding by ORF2 has been reported as a low expressive structural protein against VP60 coding by ORF1 . And its efficiency of translation is only 20% of VP60. According to results showed by Table 4 , it revealed the differences in codon usage patterns of two ORFs, which is a possible factor reducing the expression of VP10.", "According to results showed by Table 4 , it revealed the differences in codon usage patterns of two ORFs, which is a possible factor reducing the expression of VP10. Although VP10 encoded by ORF2, as a minor structural protein with unknown functions, has been described by LIU as a nonessential protein for virus infectivity, the ω Figure 2 Effective number of codons used in each ORF plotted against the GC3s. The continuous curve plots the relationship between GC3s and ENC in the absence of selection.", "The continuous curve plots the relationship between GC3s and ENC in the absence of selection. All of spots lie below the expected curve. value of ORF2 suggests VP10 plays an important role in the certain stage of whole RHDV lifecycle.", "value of ORF2 suggests VP10 plays an important role in the certain stage of whole RHDV lifecycle. After combining with low expression and ω value of VP10, we conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. This mechanism has been confirmed in various positive-chain RNA viruses, including coxsackievirus, dengue virus, equine arterivirus, footand-mouth disease virus, hepatitis C virus, poliovirus, rhinovirus, and severe acute respiratory syndrome , although the details remain elusive.", "This mechanism has been confirmed in various positive-chain RNA viruses, including coxsackievirus, dengue virus, equine arterivirus, footand-mouth disease virus, hepatitis C virus, poliovirus, rhinovirus, and severe acute respiratory syndrome , although the details remain elusive. As preceding description, ENC reflects the evolution of codon usage variation and nucleotide composition to some degree. After the correlation analysis of ENC values between ORF1 and ORF2 Table 7 , the related coefficient of ENC values of two ORFs is 0.230, and p value is 0.222 more than 0.05.", "After the correlation analysis of ENC values between ORF1 and ORF2 Table 7 , the related coefficient of ENC values of two ORFs is 0.230, and p value is 0.222 more than 0.05. These data revealed that no correlation existed in ENC values of two ORFs, indicating that codon usage patterns and evolution of two ORFs are separated each other. Further, this information maybe helps us well understand why RSCU and ENC between two ORFs are quite different.", "Further, this information maybe helps us well understand why RSCU and ENC between two ORFs are quite different. Interestingly, we found that relatively isolated spots from ORF2 tend to cluster into two groups: the ordinate value of one group marked as Group 1 is positive value and the other one marked as Group 2 is negative value. And all of those strains isolated before 2000 belonged to Group 2, including Italy-90, RHDV-V351, RHDV-FRG, BS89, RHDV-SD and M67473.1.", "And all of those strains isolated before 2000 belonged to Group 2, including Italy-90, RHDV-V351, RHDV-FRG, BS89, RHDV-SD and M67473.1. Although RHDV has been reported as only one type, this may be a reference on dividing into two genotypes. In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias.", "In this report, we firstly analyzed its genome and two open reading frameworks ORFs from this aspect of codon usage bias. Our researches indicated that mutation pressure rather than natural is the most important determinant in RHDV with high codon bias, and the codon usage bias is nearly contrary between ORF1 and ORF2, which is maybe one of factors regulating the expression of VP60 encoding by ORF1 and VP10 encoding by ORF2 . Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle.", "Furthermore, negative selective constraints on the RHDV whole genome implied that VP10 played an important role in RHDV lifecycle. We conjectured that VP10 might be beneficial for the replication, release or both of virus by inducing infected cell apoptosis initiate by RHDV. According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV.", "According to the results of the principal component analysis for ORF2 of RSCU, we firstly separated 30 RHDV into two genotypes, and the ENC values indicated ORF1 and ORF2 were independent among the evolution of RHDV. All the results will guide the next researches on the RHDV as a reference." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Respiratory tract infections RTIs are a major morbidity factor contributing largely to health care costs and individual quality of life. The aim of the study was to test whether obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m. is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population.", "is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population. METHODS: We recruited 1455 individuals between 18 to 70 years from a cross-sectional survey on airway infections in Germany and invited them to self-report in diaries incident RTIs experienced during three consecutive winter/spring seasons. RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest.", "RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest. RESULTS: Compared to individuals with normal weight, obese individuals reported a consistently higher frequency of upper and lower RTIs and predominantly fell in the upper 10% group of a diary sumscore adding-up 10 different RTI symptoms over time. Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 .", "Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 . Adjusting for demographic and lifestyle variables did only marginally affect ORs. Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits.", "Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits. CONCLUSIONS: We confirm the association of obesity with infection burden and present evidence for putative interaction with sports activity and dietary patterns. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.", "ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Text: Frequent and severe respiratory tract infections RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor in our society and a considerable cost burden in terms of medical treatment and time of work-loss . RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis .", "RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis . Individual exposure to infectious agents and host factors such as smoking and vitamin D status are believed to contribute to observed differences in RTI risk. In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed .", "In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed . This growing interest is driven by the rising number of overweight and obese individuals worldwide and the emerging knowledge of notable immunological imbalances in association with obesity . Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes.", "Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes. Thus, obesity was associated with non-allergic rhinitis and influenza like-illness . Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings .", "Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings . Two recent Danish population-based studies reported an excess of a large spectrum of RTIs including pneumonia among obese people . The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs.", "The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs. Here we present data on the role of obesity as contributing factor to a high RTI burden in the German society and explore effect modification by gender, sports activity and nutritional patterns. Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany .", "Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany . The study protocol was approved by community officials and the Ethics Committee of the University of Freiburg Ref. No. 258/11_120365 .", "No. 258/11_120365 . Based on the RTI history-score individuals of putative low, medium and high risk of future RTIs were invited to the actual sub-cohort. The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections .", "The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections . Study participants were requested to fill-in an additional questionnaire baseline questionnaire on lifestyle factors and co-morbidities and to complete monthly diaries registering the monthly occurrence and the duration < 2 weeks, > 2 weeks of RTIs, namely sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis, tonsillitis, influenza-like illness, bronchitis, pneumonia, pleurisy and other acute RTIs, from the beginning of November to the end of April of three seasons: 2012/13, 2013/14 and 2014/15. Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried.", "Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried. Further recruitment details into the AWIS study and the present sub-cohort are presented under Additional files 1 and 2. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.", "Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. In order to describe the association between obesity and RTIs, different outcome indicators were considered: outcomes at the level of each month \"any RTI\", \"any URTI\" sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis and tonsillitis , \"any LRTI\" bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy , \"≥3 RTIs\", \"any long lasting infection\" > 2 weeks ; at the level of each winter season \"≥4 months with infections\", \"≥3 long lasting infections\" ; and at the individual level i.e. are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period .", "are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period . The ten specific RTI symptom categories were considered with the binary symptom indicators \"infection reported\" or \"no infection reported\" for each month. When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time.", "When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time. However, within one symptom category at least one month without this specific infection was required to call it a new episode. We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\".", "We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\". Missing values for individual infection items were treated as zero. If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\".", "If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\". If all items were missing, no diary score was computed. The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months.", "The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months. The respective upper 10% of these diary scores within each month, season and overall served as additional outcome indicators. Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns.", "Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns. Details on these variables are described in the Additional file 1 and supplementary information on dietary intake patterns is presented in Additional file 3. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA .", "Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA . Descriptive statistics: Monthly prevalences of individual RTI symptoms were computed by taking the average over all subjects available at each month and then averaging over all 18 months covered. Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered.", "Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered. The corresponding confidence intervals CIs and p-values are based on a generalised linear model with identity link and binomial type variance together with robust variance estimates. The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly.", "The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly. However, due to the limited number of cases for tonsillitis and otitis media we determined the monthly frequency of long-lasting infections by pooling the data over all seasons and for pneumonia by pooling all indicated months. At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator.", "At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator. Due to its small prevalence, pleurisy was not considered as single outcome in these analyses. Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate.", "Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate. Outcomes at the individual level were analysed using a logistic regression model. Results are ORs and 95% CIs.", "Results are ORs and 95% CIs. Adjusted ORs are based on including age groups and education as simultaneous categorical covariates. Furthermore, in order to study the stability of the obesity-RTI association with respect to potential confounders, ORs were adjusted by respective variables. Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses.", "Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses. Effect modification by a binary variable was assessed by fitting an overall model with the corresponding interactions parametrized so that we could directly read off the two subgroup-specific ORs. Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores.", "Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores. The study population comprised 1455 individuals 931 female and 524 male with a median age of 51.08 years. Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 .", "Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 . In women, the distribution was 2.8%, 60.21%, 25.0%, and 12.1% and in men 0.76%, 43.1%, 41.8%, and 14.3%, respectively. The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children.", "The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children. Further information on the study population and completed diaries is reported in Table 1 and Additional file 4. Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections.", "Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections. Study participants reported most frequently rhinitis 26.6% , followed by influenza-like illness 11.4% and pharyngitis/laryngitis 10.5% , whereas pleurisy 0.10% was rarely experienced. Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% .", "Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% . Apart from the LRTIs bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy, which more men than women reported, all other RTIs were more prevalent among women Table 2 . Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 .", "Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 . Respiratory infections with a high fraction of long duration were almost exclusively LRTIs, namely pneumonia 59% , followed by bronchitis 48.2% . Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 .", "Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 . Compared to normal weight individuals, overweight and obese people consistently had a higher prevalence Table 3 for the single RTIs, URTIs, LRTIs, as well as the other outcome parameters we looked at with other acute infections and pneumonia as the exceptions. For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence.", "For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence. The overweight group was typically falling in between the groups with normal weight and obesity Table 3 . The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI.", "The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI. Long-lasting RTIs, frequent RTIs and high diary scores were also more strongly associated with obesity than the individual symptoms. Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates.", "Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates. Among subjects with an infection, long lasting infections were again associated with obesity, reaching significance for any RTI, rhinitis, pharyngitis/laryngitis, influenza-like illness, and bronchitis Table 3 . For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 .", "For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 . The studied demographic and lifestyle variables age, gender, education level, smoking status, contact to children, asthma, sports activity, dietary patterns and previous removal of immune organs did only marginally affect ORs. However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably.", "However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably. Adjustment for vitamin D levels among those for which serum was available n = 508 , had only a slight effect on the magnitude of the association between obesity and RTI outcomes. The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 .", "The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 . For most outcomes this interaction was not significant, with the individual level diary score as an exception. When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 .", "When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 . For all outcomes the association was less pronounced in the latter group compare the ratios of ORs in Table 5 , a difference that reached significance for all outcomes except those with low prevalence. Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns.", "Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns. Similarly, the prevalence of outcomes was increased among people with obesity and a more favourable nutritional pattern, but comparable among the other groups Table 6 . The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes.", "The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes. RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor considering the high health care costs, the time lost from work, and the impaired quality of life among those recurrently affected . Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide.", "Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide. In the present study, we report on the association of obesity with individual RTIs as well as with a diary score summarising different incident RTI symptoms over a period of 18 months. Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia .", "Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia . We also saw an association between obesity and rhinitis, sinusitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis. An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women .", "An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women . None of the two Danish population-based studies used ORs of monthly prevalence, but hazard ratios HRs , as they could identify events on a daily basis. The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed.", "The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed. Mechanistically, excess adiposity might weigh down host defence as several mouse as well as human studies have suggested . The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms.", "The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms. Based on the infection diary data, we generated a RTI diary score summing-up all ten symptoms and allowing to average per month, per whole season or over the whole period of three years. Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced.", "Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced. Moreover, the results of the seasonal score were very similar or even stronger than those of the three-years score, arguing for the adequacy to query six months infectious events in future studies to identify the infection-prone sub-group of the population. Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI.", "Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI. Among them, cigarette smoking has been reported as a major environmental risk factor for recurrent and severe RTIs . Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks.", "Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks. Moreover, higher levels of education were associated with a lower risk of CAP . Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders.", "Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders. The association between obesity and RTIs remained nearly unchanged after adjustment for age, gender, educational status, contact to children, smoking status, sports activity and nutrition scores, suggesting that the association is not markedly confounded by the effects of these factors on both BMI and the risk of infections. Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably.", "Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably. This supports arguments that the observed associations between obesity and RTI burden are due to physiological differences in the immune responsiveness between obese and non-obese individuals rather than lifestyle differences. In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity .", "In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity . Considering these associations we investigated the effect of asthma, COPD and a comorbidity scoresummarizing the other chronic conditionson the relationship between obesity and individual RTIs and the RTI diary score. Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes.", "Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes. Hence part of the association between infections and obesity might be explainable by associations of co-morbidities with both. We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women.", "We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women. A significantly increased risk for combined RTIs was also restricted to women in a Danish blood donor cohort . Several lines of research support this notion: Szabova et al. and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system .", "and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system . The effect of BMI on a variety of immune parameters including those with relevance for immune defence was much more apparent in women than in men . NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells.", "NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells. Reduced levels of these cells reported for obese women, but not for respective men, might underlie the gender effect seen in our study. We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition.", "We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition. Interestingly, an association between obesity and RTIs was evident only for those obese individuals who reported a higher level of sports activity. Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes.", "Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes. We hypothesize that oxidative stress induced by vigorous aerobic as well as anaerobic sports activity is exacerbated in people with obesity, but not in normal weight individuals. Evidence supporting this has been previously published .", "Evidence supporting this has been previously published . An imbalanced oxidative stress status may have negative consequences on mounting an appropriate immune response towards respiratory pathogens. Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections .", "Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections . A similar surprising result was found when studying the effect modification by dietary patterns. Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al.", "Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al. . Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet.", "Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet. Thus, again only the group of obese individuals who presumably eat a healthier diet showed an increased risk of RTIs. The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle.", "The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle. One can imagine that obese individuals may have an increased perception of RTI related symptoms experiencing the contradiction between living a healthy lifestyle and being affected by excess weight and frequent infections. On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation.", "On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation. Alternatively, among the group of people with obesity a genetically defined subgroup may exist predisposing to both, excess body weight and proneness to infections. As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered.", "As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered. The uniformity of the results with respect to these outcomes also suggests that in the field of airway infection morbidity, studies may be comparable despite the fact that they often concentrate on different RTI outcomes. In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification.", "In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification. However, we found -for instance -a good agreement between BMI derived from self-reported weight and height data and BMI calculated from measured values available for a sub-cohort n = 508 . Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting.", "Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting. The disproportional selection of women into the study may negatively impact the generalizability of some of our results." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Respiratory tract infections RTIs are a major morbidity factor contributing largely to health care costs and individual quality of life. The aim of the study was to test whether obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m. is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population.", "is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population. METHODS: We recruited 1455 individuals between 18 to 70 years from a cross-sectional survey on airway infections in Germany and invited them to self-report in diaries incident RTIs experienced during three consecutive winter/spring seasons. RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest.", "RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest. RESULTS: Compared to individuals with normal weight, obese individuals reported a consistently higher frequency of upper and lower RTIs and predominantly fell in the upper 10% group of a diary sumscore adding-up 10 different RTI symptoms over time. Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 .", "Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 . Adjusting for demographic and lifestyle variables did only marginally affect ORs. Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits.", "Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits. CONCLUSIONS: We confirm the association of obesity with infection burden and present evidence for putative interaction with sports activity and dietary patterns. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.", "ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Text: Frequent and severe respiratory tract infections RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor in our society and a considerable cost burden in terms of medical treatment and time of work-loss . RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis .", "RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis . Individual exposure to infectious agents and host factors such as smoking and vitamin D status are believed to contribute to observed differences in RTI risk. In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed .", "In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed . This growing interest is driven by the rising number of overweight and obese individuals worldwide and the emerging knowledge of notable immunological imbalances in association with obesity . Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes.", "Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes. Thus, obesity was associated with non-allergic rhinitis and influenza like-illness . Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings .", "Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings . Two recent Danish population-based studies reported an excess of a large spectrum of RTIs including pneumonia among obese people . The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs.", "The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs. Here we present data on the role of obesity as contributing factor to a high RTI burden in the German society and explore effect modification by gender, sports activity and nutritional patterns. Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany .", "Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany . The study protocol was approved by community officials and the Ethics Committee of the University of Freiburg Ref. No. 258/11_120365 .", "No. 258/11_120365 . Based on the RTI history-score individuals of putative low, medium and high risk of future RTIs were invited to the actual sub-cohort. The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections .", "The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections . Study participants were requested to fill-in an additional questionnaire baseline questionnaire on lifestyle factors and co-morbidities and to complete monthly diaries registering the monthly occurrence and the duration < 2 weeks, > 2 weeks of RTIs, namely sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis, tonsillitis, influenza-like illness, bronchitis, pneumonia, pleurisy and other acute RTIs, from the beginning of November to the end of April of three seasons: 2012/13, 2013/14 and 2014/15. Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried.", "Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried. Further recruitment details into the AWIS study and the present sub-cohort are presented under Additional files 1 and 2. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.", "Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. In order to describe the association between obesity and RTIs, different outcome indicators were considered: outcomes at the level of each month \"any RTI\", \"any URTI\" sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis and tonsillitis , \"any LRTI\" bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy , \"≥3 RTIs\", \"any long lasting infection\" > 2 weeks ; at the level of each winter season \"≥4 months with infections\", \"≥3 long lasting infections\" ; and at the individual level i.e. are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period .", "are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period . The ten specific RTI symptom categories were considered with the binary symptom indicators \"infection reported\" or \"no infection reported\" for each month. When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time.", "When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time. However, within one symptom category at least one month without this specific infection was required to call it a new episode. We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\".", "We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\". Missing values for individual infection items were treated as zero. If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\".", "If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\". If all items were missing, no diary score was computed. The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months.", "The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months. The respective upper 10% of these diary scores within each month, season and overall served as additional outcome indicators. Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns.", "Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns. Details on these variables are described in the Additional file 1 and supplementary information on dietary intake patterns is presented in Additional file 3. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA .", "Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA . Descriptive statistics: Monthly prevalences of individual RTI symptoms were computed by taking the average over all subjects available at each month and then averaging over all 18 months covered. Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered.", "Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered. The corresponding confidence intervals CIs and p-values are based on a generalised linear model with identity link and binomial type variance together with robust variance estimates. The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly.", "The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly. However, due to the limited number of cases for tonsillitis and otitis media we determined the monthly frequency of long-lasting infections by pooling the data over all seasons and for pneumonia by pooling all indicated months. At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator.", "At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator. Due to its small prevalence, pleurisy was not considered as single outcome in these analyses. Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate.", "Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate. Outcomes at the individual level were analysed using a logistic regression model. Results are ORs and 95% CIs.", "Results are ORs and 95% CIs. Adjusted ORs are based on including age groups and education as simultaneous categorical covariates. Furthermore, in order to study the stability of the obesity-RTI association with respect to potential confounders, ORs were adjusted by respective variables. Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses.", "Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses. Effect modification by a binary variable was assessed by fitting an overall model with the corresponding interactions parametrized so that we could directly read off the two subgroup-specific ORs. Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores.", "Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores. The study population comprised 1455 individuals 931 female and 524 male with a median age of 51.08 years. Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 .", "Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 . In women, the distribution was 2.8%, 60.21%, 25.0%, and 12.1% and in men 0.76%, 43.1%, 41.8%, and 14.3%, respectively. The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children.", "The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children. Further information on the study population and completed diaries is reported in Table 1 and Additional file 4. Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections.", "Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections. Study participants reported most frequently rhinitis 26.6% , followed by influenza-like illness 11.4% and pharyngitis/laryngitis 10.5% , whereas pleurisy 0.10% was rarely experienced. Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% .", "Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% . Apart from the LRTIs bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy, which more men than women reported, all other RTIs were more prevalent among women Table 2 . Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 .", "Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 . Respiratory infections with a high fraction of long duration were almost exclusively LRTIs, namely pneumonia 59% , followed by bronchitis 48.2% . Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 .", "Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 . Compared to normal weight individuals, overweight and obese people consistently had a higher prevalence Table 3 for the single RTIs, URTIs, LRTIs, as well as the other outcome parameters we looked at with other acute infections and pneumonia as the exceptions. For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence.", "For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence. The overweight group was typically falling in between the groups with normal weight and obesity Table 3 . The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI.", "The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI. Long-lasting RTIs, frequent RTIs and high diary scores were also more strongly associated with obesity than the individual symptoms. Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates.", "Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates. Among subjects with an infection, long lasting infections were again associated with obesity, reaching significance for any RTI, rhinitis, pharyngitis/laryngitis, influenza-like illness, and bronchitis Table 3 . For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 .", "For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 . The studied demographic and lifestyle variables age, gender, education level, smoking status, contact to children, asthma, sports activity, dietary patterns and previous removal of immune organs did only marginally affect ORs. However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably.", "However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably. Adjustment for vitamin D levels among those for which serum was available n = 508 , had only a slight effect on the magnitude of the association between obesity and RTI outcomes. The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 .", "The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 . For most outcomes this interaction was not significant, with the individual level diary score as an exception. When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 .", "When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 . For all outcomes the association was less pronounced in the latter group compare the ratios of ORs in Table 5 , a difference that reached significance for all outcomes except those with low prevalence. Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns.", "Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns. Similarly, the prevalence of outcomes was increased among people with obesity and a more favourable nutritional pattern, but comparable among the other groups Table 6 . The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes.", "The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes. RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor considering the high health care costs, the time lost from work, and the impaired quality of life among those recurrently affected . Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide.", "Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide. In the present study, we report on the association of obesity with individual RTIs as well as with a diary score summarising different incident RTI symptoms over a period of 18 months. Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia .", "Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia . We also saw an association between obesity and rhinitis, sinusitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis. An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women .", "An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women . None of the two Danish population-based studies used ORs of monthly prevalence, but hazard ratios HRs , as they could identify events on a daily basis. The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed.", "The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed. Mechanistically, excess adiposity might weigh down host defence as several mouse as well as human studies have suggested . The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms.", "The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms. Based on the infection diary data, we generated a RTI diary score summing-up all ten symptoms and allowing to average per month, per whole season or over the whole period of three years. Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced.", "Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced. Moreover, the results of the seasonal score were very similar or even stronger than those of the three-years score, arguing for the adequacy to query six months infectious events in future studies to identify the infection-prone sub-group of the population. Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI.", "Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI. Among them, cigarette smoking has been reported as a major environmental risk factor for recurrent and severe RTIs . Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks.", "Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks. Moreover, higher levels of education were associated with a lower risk of CAP . Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders.", "Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders. The association between obesity and RTIs remained nearly unchanged after adjustment for age, gender, educational status, contact to children, smoking status, sports activity and nutrition scores, suggesting that the association is not markedly confounded by the effects of these factors on both BMI and the risk of infections. Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably.", "Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably. This supports arguments that the observed associations between obesity and RTI burden are due to physiological differences in the immune responsiveness between obese and non-obese individuals rather than lifestyle differences. In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity .", "In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity . Considering these associations we investigated the effect of asthma, COPD and a comorbidity scoresummarizing the other chronic conditionson the relationship between obesity and individual RTIs and the RTI diary score. Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes.", "Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes. Hence part of the association between infections and obesity might be explainable by associations of co-morbidities with both. We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women.", "We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women. A significantly increased risk for combined RTIs was also restricted to women in a Danish blood donor cohort . Several lines of research support this notion: Szabova et al. and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system .", "and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system . The effect of BMI on a variety of immune parameters including those with relevance for immune defence was much more apparent in women than in men . NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells.", "NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells. Reduced levels of these cells reported for obese women, but not for respective men, might underlie the gender effect seen in our study. We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition.", "We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition. Interestingly, an association between obesity and RTIs was evident only for those obese individuals who reported a higher level of sports activity. Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes.", "Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes. We hypothesize that oxidative stress induced by vigorous aerobic as well as anaerobic sports activity is exacerbated in people with obesity, but not in normal weight individuals. Evidence supporting this has been previously published .", "Evidence supporting this has been previously published . An imbalanced oxidative stress status may have negative consequences on mounting an appropriate immune response towards respiratory pathogens. Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections .", "Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections . A similar surprising result was found when studying the effect modification by dietary patterns. Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al.", "Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al. . Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet.", "Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet. Thus, again only the group of obese individuals who presumably eat a healthier diet showed an increased risk of RTIs. The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle.", "The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle. One can imagine that obese individuals may have an increased perception of RTI related symptoms experiencing the contradiction between living a healthy lifestyle and being affected by excess weight and frequent infections. On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation.", "On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation. Alternatively, among the group of people with obesity a genetically defined subgroup may exist predisposing to both, excess body weight and proneness to infections. As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered.", "As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered. The uniformity of the results with respect to these outcomes also suggests that in the field of airway infection morbidity, studies may be comparable despite the fact that they often concentrate on different RTI outcomes. In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification.", "In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification. However, we found -for instance -a good agreement between BMI derived from self-reported weight and height data and BMI calculated from measured values available for a sub-cohort n = 508 . Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting.", "Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting. The disproportional selection of women into the study may negatively impact the generalizability of some of our results." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Respiratory tract infections RTIs are a major morbidity factor contributing largely to health care costs and individual quality of life. The aim of the study was to test whether obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m. is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population.", "is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population. METHODS: We recruited 1455 individuals between 18 to 70 years from a cross-sectional survey on airway infections in Germany and invited them to self-report in diaries incident RTIs experienced during three consecutive winter/spring seasons. RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest.", "RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest. RESULTS: Compared to individuals with normal weight, obese individuals reported a consistently higher frequency of upper and lower RTIs and predominantly fell in the upper 10% group of a diary sumscore adding-up 10 different RTI symptoms over time. Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 .", "Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 . Adjusting for demographic and lifestyle variables did only marginally affect ORs. Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits.", "Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits. CONCLUSIONS: We confirm the association of obesity with infection burden and present evidence for putative interaction with sports activity and dietary patterns. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.", "ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Text: Frequent and severe respiratory tract infections RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor in our society and a considerable cost burden in terms of medical treatment and time of work-loss . RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis .", "RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis . Individual exposure to infectious agents and host factors such as smoking and vitamin D status are believed to contribute to observed differences in RTI risk. In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed .", "In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed . This growing interest is driven by the rising number of overweight and obese individuals worldwide and the emerging knowledge of notable immunological imbalances in association with obesity . Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes.", "Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes. Thus, obesity was associated with non-allergic rhinitis and influenza like-illness . Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings .", "Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings . Two recent Danish population-based studies reported an excess of a large spectrum of RTIs including pneumonia among obese people . The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs.", "The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs. Here we present data on the role of obesity as contributing factor to a high RTI burden in the German society and explore effect modification by gender, sports activity and nutritional patterns. Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany .", "Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany . The study protocol was approved by community officials and the Ethics Committee of the University of Freiburg Ref. No. 258/11_120365 .", "No. 258/11_120365 . Based on the RTI history-score individuals of putative low, medium and high risk of future RTIs were invited to the actual sub-cohort. The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections .", "The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections . Study participants were requested to fill-in an additional questionnaire baseline questionnaire on lifestyle factors and co-morbidities and to complete monthly diaries registering the monthly occurrence and the duration < 2 weeks, > 2 weeks of RTIs, namely sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis, tonsillitis, influenza-like illness, bronchitis, pneumonia, pleurisy and other acute RTIs, from the beginning of November to the end of April of three seasons: 2012/13, 2013/14 and 2014/15. Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried.", "Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried. Further recruitment details into the AWIS study and the present sub-cohort are presented under Additional files 1 and 2. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.", "Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. In order to describe the association between obesity and RTIs, different outcome indicators were considered: outcomes at the level of each month \"any RTI\", \"any URTI\" sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis and tonsillitis , \"any LRTI\" bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy , \"≥3 RTIs\", \"any long lasting infection\" > 2 weeks ; at the level of each winter season \"≥4 months with infections\", \"≥3 long lasting infections\" ; and at the individual level i.e. are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period .", "are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period . The ten specific RTI symptom categories were considered with the binary symptom indicators \"infection reported\" or \"no infection reported\" for each month. When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time.", "When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time. However, within one symptom category at least one month without this specific infection was required to call it a new episode. We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\".", "We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\". Missing values for individual infection items were treated as zero. If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\".", "If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\". If all items were missing, no diary score was computed. The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months.", "The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months. The respective upper 10% of these diary scores within each month, season and overall served as additional outcome indicators. Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns.", "Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns. Details on these variables are described in the Additional file 1 and supplementary information on dietary intake patterns is presented in Additional file 3. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA .", "Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA . Descriptive statistics: Monthly prevalences of individual RTI symptoms were computed by taking the average over all subjects available at each month and then averaging over all 18 months covered. Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered.", "Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered. The corresponding confidence intervals CIs and p-values are based on a generalised linear model with identity link and binomial type variance together with robust variance estimates. The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly.", "The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly. However, due to the limited number of cases for tonsillitis and otitis media we determined the monthly frequency of long-lasting infections by pooling the data over all seasons and for pneumonia by pooling all indicated months. At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator.", "At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator. Due to its small prevalence, pleurisy was not considered as single outcome in these analyses. Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate.", "Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate. Outcomes at the individual level were analysed using a logistic regression model. Results are ORs and 95% CIs.", "Results are ORs and 95% CIs. Adjusted ORs are based on including age groups and education as simultaneous categorical covariates. Furthermore, in order to study the stability of the obesity-RTI association with respect to potential confounders, ORs were adjusted by respective variables. Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses.", "Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses. Effect modification by a binary variable was assessed by fitting an overall model with the corresponding interactions parametrized so that we could directly read off the two subgroup-specific ORs. Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores.", "Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores. The study population comprised 1455 individuals 931 female and 524 male with a median age of 51.08 years. Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 .", "Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 . In women, the distribution was 2.8%, 60.21%, 25.0%, and 12.1% and in men 0.76%, 43.1%, 41.8%, and 14.3%, respectively. The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children.", "The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children. Further information on the study population and completed diaries is reported in Table 1 and Additional file 4. Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections.", "Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections. Study participants reported most frequently rhinitis 26.6% , followed by influenza-like illness 11.4% and pharyngitis/laryngitis 10.5% , whereas pleurisy 0.10% was rarely experienced. Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% .", "Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% . Apart from the LRTIs bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy, which more men than women reported, all other RTIs were more prevalent among women Table 2 . Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 .", "Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 . Respiratory infections with a high fraction of long duration were almost exclusively LRTIs, namely pneumonia 59% , followed by bronchitis 48.2% . Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 .", "Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 . Compared to normal weight individuals, overweight and obese people consistently had a higher prevalence Table 3 for the single RTIs, URTIs, LRTIs, as well as the other outcome parameters we looked at with other acute infections and pneumonia as the exceptions. For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence.", "For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence. The overweight group was typically falling in between the groups with normal weight and obesity Table 3 . The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI.", "The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI. Long-lasting RTIs, frequent RTIs and high diary scores were also more strongly associated with obesity than the individual symptoms. Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates.", "Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates. Among subjects with an infection, long lasting infections were again associated with obesity, reaching significance for any RTI, rhinitis, pharyngitis/laryngitis, influenza-like illness, and bronchitis Table 3 . For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 .", "For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 . The studied demographic and lifestyle variables age, gender, education level, smoking status, contact to children, asthma, sports activity, dietary patterns and previous removal of immune organs did only marginally affect ORs. However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably.", "However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably. Adjustment for vitamin D levels among those for which serum was available n = 508 , had only a slight effect on the magnitude of the association between obesity and RTI outcomes. The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 .", "The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 . For most outcomes this interaction was not significant, with the individual level diary score as an exception. When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 .", "When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 . For all outcomes the association was less pronounced in the latter group compare the ratios of ORs in Table 5 , a difference that reached significance for all outcomes except those with low prevalence. Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns.", "Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns. Similarly, the prevalence of outcomes was increased among people with obesity and a more favourable nutritional pattern, but comparable among the other groups Table 6 . The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes.", "The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes. RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor considering the high health care costs, the time lost from work, and the impaired quality of life among those recurrently affected . Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide.", "Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide. In the present study, we report on the association of obesity with individual RTIs as well as with a diary score summarising different incident RTI symptoms over a period of 18 months. Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia .", "Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia . We also saw an association between obesity and rhinitis, sinusitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis. An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women .", "An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women . None of the two Danish population-based studies used ORs of monthly prevalence, but hazard ratios HRs , as they could identify events on a daily basis. The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed.", "The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed. Mechanistically, excess adiposity might weigh down host defence as several mouse as well as human studies have suggested . The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms.", "The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms. Based on the infection diary data, we generated a RTI diary score summing-up all ten symptoms and allowing to average per month, per whole season or over the whole period of three years. Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced.", "Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced. Moreover, the results of the seasonal score were very similar or even stronger than those of the three-years score, arguing for the adequacy to query six months infectious events in future studies to identify the infection-prone sub-group of the population. Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI.", "Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI. Among them, cigarette smoking has been reported as a major environmental risk factor for recurrent and severe RTIs . Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks.", "Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks. Moreover, higher levels of education were associated with a lower risk of CAP . Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders.", "Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders. The association between obesity and RTIs remained nearly unchanged after adjustment for age, gender, educational status, contact to children, smoking status, sports activity and nutrition scores, suggesting that the association is not markedly confounded by the effects of these factors on both BMI and the risk of infections. Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably.", "Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably. This supports arguments that the observed associations between obesity and RTI burden are due to physiological differences in the immune responsiveness between obese and non-obese individuals rather than lifestyle differences. In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity .", "In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity . Considering these associations we investigated the effect of asthma, COPD and a comorbidity scoresummarizing the other chronic conditionson the relationship between obesity and individual RTIs and the RTI diary score. Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes.", "Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes. Hence part of the association between infections and obesity might be explainable by associations of co-morbidities with both. We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women.", "We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women. A significantly increased risk for combined RTIs was also restricted to women in a Danish blood donor cohort . Several lines of research support this notion: Szabova et al. and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system .", "and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system . The effect of BMI on a variety of immune parameters including those with relevance for immune defence was much more apparent in women than in men . NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells.", "NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells. Reduced levels of these cells reported for obese women, but not for respective men, might underlie the gender effect seen in our study. We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition.", "We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition. Interestingly, an association between obesity and RTIs was evident only for those obese individuals who reported a higher level of sports activity. Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes.", "Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes. We hypothesize that oxidative stress induced by vigorous aerobic as well as anaerobic sports activity is exacerbated in people with obesity, but not in normal weight individuals. Evidence supporting this has been previously published .", "Evidence supporting this has been previously published . An imbalanced oxidative stress status may have negative consequences on mounting an appropriate immune response towards respiratory pathogens. Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections .", "Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections . A similar surprising result was found when studying the effect modification by dietary patterns. Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al.", "Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al. . Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet.", "Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet. Thus, again only the group of obese individuals who presumably eat a healthier diet showed an increased risk of RTIs. The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle.", "The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle. One can imagine that obese individuals may have an increased perception of RTI related symptoms experiencing the contradiction between living a healthy lifestyle and being affected by excess weight and frequent infections. On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation.", "On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation. Alternatively, among the group of people with obesity a genetically defined subgroup may exist predisposing to both, excess body weight and proneness to infections. As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered.", "As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered. The uniformity of the results with respect to these outcomes also suggests that in the field of airway infection morbidity, studies may be comparable despite the fact that they often concentrate on different RTI outcomes. In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification.", "In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification. However, we found -for instance -a good agreement between BMI derived from self-reported weight and height data and BMI calculated from measured values available for a sub-cohort n = 508 . Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting.", "Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting. The disproportional selection of women into the study may negatively impact the generalizability of some of our results." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Respiratory tract infections RTIs are a major morbidity factor contributing largely to health care costs and individual quality of life. The aim of the study was to test whether obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m. is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population.", "is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population. METHODS: We recruited 1455 individuals between 18 to 70 years from a cross-sectional survey on airway infections in Germany and invited them to self-report in diaries incident RTIs experienced during three consecutive winter/spring seasons. RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest.", "RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest. RESULTS: Compared to individuals with normal weight, obese individuals reported a consistently higher frequency of upper and lower RTIs and predominantly fell in the upper 10% group of a diary sumscore adding-up 10 different RTI symptoms over time. Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 .", "Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 . Adjusting for demographic and lifestyle variables did only marginally affect ORs. Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits.", "Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits. CONCLUSIONS: We confirm the association of obesity with infection burden and present evidence for putative interaction with sports activity and dietary patterns. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.", "ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Text: Frequent and severe respiratory tract infections RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor in our society and a considerable cost burden in terms of medical treatment and time of work-loss . RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis .", "RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis . Individual exposure to infectious agents and host factors such as smoking and vitamin D status are believed to contribute to observed differences in RTI risk. In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed .", "In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed . This growing interest is driven by the rising number of overweight and obese individuals worldwide and the emerging knowledge of notable immunological imbalances in association with obesity . Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes.", "Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes. Thus, obesity was associated with non-allergic rhinitis and influenza like-illness . Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings .", "Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings . Two recent Danish population-based studies reported an excess of a large spectrum of RTIs including pneumonia among obese people . The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs.", "The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs. Here we present data on the role of obesity as contributing factor to a high RTI burden in the German society and explore effect modification by gender, sports activity and nutritional patterns. Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany .", "Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany . The study protocol was approved by community officials and the Ethics Committee of the University of Freiburg Ref. No. 258/11_120365 .", "No. 258/11_120365 . Based on the RTI history-score individuals of putative low, medium and high risk of future RTIs were invited to the actual sub-cohort. The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections .", "The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections . Study participants were requested to fill-in an additional questionnaire baseline questionnaire on lifestyle factors and co-morbidities and to complete monthly diaries registering the monthly occurrence and the duration < 2 weeks, > 2 weeks of RTIs, namely sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis, tonsillitis, influenza-like illness, bronchitis, pneumonia, pleurisy and other acute RTIs, from the beginning of November to the end of April of three seasons: 2012/13, 2013/14 and 2014/15. Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried.", "Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried. Further recruitment details into the AWIS study and the present sub-cohort are presented under Additional files 1 and 2. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.", "Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. In order to describe the association between obesity and RTIs, different outcome indicators were considered: outcomes at the level of each month \"any RTI\", \"any URTI\" sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis and tonsillitis , \"any LRTI\" bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy , \"≥3 RTIs\", \"any long lasting infection\" > 2 weeks ; at the level of each winter season \"≥4 months with infections\", \"≥3 long lasting infections\" ; and at the individual level i.e. are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period .", "are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period . The ten specific RTI symptom categories were considered with the binary symptom indicators \"infection reported\" or \"no infection reported\" for each month. When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time.", "When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time. However, within one symptom category at least one month without this specific infection was required to call it a new episode. We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\".", "We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\". Missing values for individual infection items were treated as zero. If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\".", "If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\". If all items were missing, no diary score was computed. The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months.", "The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months. The respective upper 10% of these diary scores within each month, season and overall served as additional outcome indicators. Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns.", "Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns. Details on these variables are described in the Additional file 1 and supplementary information on dietary intake patterns is presented in Additional file 3. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA .", "Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA . Descriptive statistics: Monthly prevalences of individual RTI symptoms were computed by taking the average over all subjects available at each month and then averaging over all 18 months covered. Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered.", "Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered. The corresponding confidence intervals CIs and p-values are based on a generalised linear model with identity link and binomial type variance together with robust variance estimates. The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly.", "The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly. However, due to the limited number of cases for tonsillitis and otitis media we determined the monthly frequency of long-lasting infections by pooling the data over all seasons and for pneumonia by pooling all indicated months. At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator.", "At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator. Due to its small prevalence, pleurisy was not considered as single outcome in these analyses. Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate.", "Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate. Outcomes at the individual level were analysed using a logistic regression model. Results are ORs and 95% CIs.", "Results are ORs and 95% CIs. Adjusted ORs are based on including age groups and education as simultaneous categorical covariates. Furthermore, in order to study the stability of the obesity-RTI association with respect to potential confounders, ORs were adjusted by respective variables. Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses.", "Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses. Effect modification by a binary variable was assessed by fitting an overall model with the corresponding interactions parametrized so that we could directly read off the two subgroup-specific ORs. Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores.", "Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores. The study population comprised 1455 individuals 931 female and 524 male with a median age of 51.08 years. Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 .", "Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 . In women, the distribution was 2.8%, 60.21%, 25.0%, and 12.1% and in men 0.76%, 43.1%, 41.8%, and 14.3%, respectively. The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children.", "The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children. Further information on the study population and completed diaries is reported in Table 1 and Additional file 4. Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections.", "Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections. Study participants reported most frequently rhinitis 26.6% , followed by influenza-like illness 11.4% and pharyngitis/laryngitis 10.5% , whereas pleurisy 0.10% was rarely experienced. Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% .", "Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% . Apart from the LRTIs bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy, which more men than women reported, all other RTIs were more prevalent among women Table 2 . Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 .", "Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 . Respiratory infections with a high fraction of long duration were almost exclusively LRTIs, namely pneumonia 59% , followed by bronchitis 48.2% . Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 .", "Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 . Compared to normal weight individuals, overweight and obese people consistently had a higher prevalence Table 3 for the single RTIs, URTIs, LRTIs, as well as the other outcome parameters we looked at with other acute infections and pneumonia as the exceptions. For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence.", "For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence. The overweight group was typically falling in between the groups with normal weight and obesity Table 3 . The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI.", "The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI. Long-lasting RTIs, frequent RTIs and high diary scores were also more strongly associated with obesity than the individual symptoms. Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates.", "Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates. Among subjects with an infection, long lasting infections were again associated with obesity, reaching significance for any RTI, rhinitis, pharyngitis/laryngitis, influenza-like illness, and bronchitis Table 3 . For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 .", "For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 . The studied demographic and lifestyle variables age, gender, education level, smoking status, contact to children, asthma, sports activity, dietary patterns and previous removal of immune organs did only marginally affect ORs. However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably.", "However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably. Adjustment for vitamin D levels among those for which serum was available n = 508 , had only a slight effect on the magnitude of the association between obesity and RTI outcomes. The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 .", "The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 . For most outcomes this interaction was not significant, with the individual level diary score as an exception. When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 .", "When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 . For all outcomes the association was less pronounced in the latter group compare the ratios of ORs in Table 5 , a difference that reached significance for all outcomes except those with low prevalence. Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns.", "Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns. Similarly, the prevalence of outcomes was increased among people with obesity and a more favourable nutritional pattern, but comparable among the other groups Table 6 . The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes.", "The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes. RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor considering the high health care costs, the time lost from work, and the impaired quality of life among those recurrently affected . Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide.", "Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide. In the present study, we report on the association of obesity with individual RTIs as well as with a diary score summarising different incident RTI symptoms over a period of 18 months. Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia .", "Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia . We also saw an association between obesity and rhinitis, sinusitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis. An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women .", "An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women . None of the two Danish population-based studies used ORs of monthly prevalence, but hazard ratios HRs , as they could identify events on a daily basis. The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed.", "The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed. Mechanistically, excess adiposity might weigh down host defence as several mouse as well as human studies have suggested . The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms.", "The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms. Based on the infection diary data, we generated a RTI diary score summing-up all ten symptoms and allowing to average per month, per whole season or over the whole period of three years. Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced.", "Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced. Moreover, the results of the seasonal score were very similar or even stronger than those of the three-years score, arguing for the adequacy to query six months infectious events in future studies to identify the infection-prone sub-group of the population. Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI.", "Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI. Among them, cigarette smoking has been reported as a major environmental risk factor for recurrent and severe RTIs . Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks.", "Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks. Moreover, higher levels of education were associated with a lower risk of CAP . Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders.", "Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders. The association between obesity and RTIs remained nearly unchanged after adjustment for age, gender, educational status, contact to children, smoking status, sports activity and nutrition scores, suggesting that the association is not markedly confounded by the effects of these factors on both BMI and the risk of infections. Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably.", "Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably. This supports arguments that the observed associations between obesity and RTI burden are due to physiological differences in the immune responsiveness between obese and non-obese individuals rather than lifestyle differences. In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity .", "In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity . Considering these associations we investigated the effect of asthma, COPD and a comorbidity scoresummarizing the other chronic conditionson the relationship between obesity and individual RTIs and the RTI diary score. Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes.", "Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes. Hence part of the association between infections and obesity might be explainable by associations of co-morbidities with both. We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women.", "We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women. A significantly increased risk for combined RTIs was also restricted to women in a Danish blood donor cohort . Several lines of research support this notion: Szabova et al. and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system .", "and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system . The effect of BMI on a variety of immune parameters including those with relevance for immune defence was much more apparent in women than in men . NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells.", "NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells. Reduced levels of these cells reported for obese women, but not for respective men, might underlie the gender effect seen in our study. We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition.", "We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition. Interestingly, an association between obesity and RTIs was evident only for those obese individuals who reported a higher level of sports activity. Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes.", "Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes. We hypothesize that oxidative stress induced by vigorous aerobic as well as anaerobic sports activity is exacerbated in people with obesity, but not in normal weight individuals. Evidence supporting this has been previously published .", "Evidence supporting this has been previously published . An imbalanced oxidative stress status may have negative consequences on mounting an appropriate immune response towards respiratory pathogens. Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections .", "Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections . A similar surprising result was found when studying the effect modification by dietary patterns. Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al.", "Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al. . Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet.", "Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet. Thus, again only the group of obese individuals who presumably eat a healthier diet showed an increased risk of RTIs. The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle.", "The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle. One can imagine that obese individuals may have an increased perception of RTI related symptoms experiencing the contradiction between living a healthy lifestyle and being affected by excess weight and frequent infections. On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation.", "On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation. Alternatively, among the group of people with obesity a genetically defined subgroup may exist predisposing to both, excess body weight and proneness to infections. As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered.", "As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered. The uniformity of the results with respect to these outcomes also suggests that in the field of airway infection morbidity, studies may be comparable despite the fact that they often concentrate on different RTI outcomes. In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification.", "In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification. However, we found -for instance -a good agreement between BMI derived from self-reported weight and height data and BMI calculated from measured values available for a sub-cohort n = 508 . Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting.", "Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting. The disproportional selection of women into the study may negatively impact the generalizability of some of our results." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Respiratory tract infections RTIs are a major morbidity factor contributing largely to health care costs and individual quality of life. The aim of the study was to test whether obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m. is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population.", "is one of the risk factors underlying frequent RTIs in the German adult population. METHODS: We recruited 1455 individuals between 18 to 70 years from a cross-sectional survey on airway infections in Germany and invited them to self-report in diaries incident RTIs experienced during three consecutive winter/spring seasons. RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest.", "RTIs reported in these 18 months and summary measures adding-up individual RTIs were the outcomes of interest. RESULTS: Compared to individuals with normal weight, obese individuals reported a consistently higher frequency of upper and lower RTIs and predominantly fell in the upper 10% group of a diary sumscore adding-up 10 different RTI symptoms over time. Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 .", "Obesity was associated both with lower RTIs adjusted OR = 2.02, 95%CI = 1.36–3.00 and upper RTIs adjusted OR = 1.55, 95%CI = 1.22–1.96 . Adjusting for demographic and lifestyle variables did only marginally affect ORs. Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits.", "Stratified analyses suggested a stronger association for women and effect modifications by sports activity and dietary habits. CONCLUSIONS: We confirm the association of obesity with infection burden and present evidence for putative interaction with sports activity and dietary patterns. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.", "ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article 10.1186/s12889-018-5172-8 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Text: Frequent and severe respiratory tract infections RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor in our society and a considerable cost burden in terms of medical treatment and time of work-loss . RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis .", "RTIs are divided into upper RTIs URTIs including common cold, pharyngitis, otitis, sinusitis, laryngotracheitis, epiglottitis and lower RTIs LRTIs including bronchitis, pneumonia and bronchiolitis . Individual exposure to infectious agents and host factors such as smoking and vitamin D status are believed to contribute to observed differences in RTI risk. In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed .", "In addition, the role of overweight body mass index BMI = 25.0-29.9 kg/m 2 and in particular obesity BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 in predisposition to RTIs is increasingly discussed . This growing interest is driven by the rising number of overweight and obese individuals worldwide and the emerging knowledge of notable immunological imbalances in association with obesity . Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes.", "Most of the studies targeting adults explored the association of obesity with specific RTIs and their outcomes. Thus, obesity was associated with non-allergic rhinitis and influenza like-illness . Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings .", "Moreover, two population-based studies which investigated the role of obesity as risk factor for community acquired pneumonia CAP in the general population resulted in controversial findings . Two recent Danish population-based studies reported an excess of a large spectrum of RTIs including pneumonia among obese people . The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs.", "The overall aim of our study targeting the adult population in South Baden, Germany, is to identify risk factors for the susceptibility to RTIs. Here we present data on the role of obesity as contributing factor to a high RTI burden in the German society and explore effect modification by gender, sports activity and nutritional patterns. Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany .", "Study participants n = 1455 were recruited from the airway infection susceptibility AWIS cross sectional study querying RTI burden in an adult population in South-Baden, Germany . The study protocol was approved by community officials and the Ethics Committee of the University of Freiburg Ref. No. 258/11_120365 .", "No. 258/11_120365 . Based on the RTI history-score individuals of putative low, medium and high risk of future RTIs were invited to the actual sub-cohort. The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections .", "The RTI history score is summarizing information on the frequency and severity of RTIs and antibiotics use over the past two years, selfassessed RTI susceptibility, and occurrence of selected severe infections . Study participants were requested to fill-in an additional questionnaire baseline questionnaire on lifestyle factors and co-morbidities and to complete monthly diaries registering the monthly occurrence and the duration < 2 weeks, > 2 weeks of RTIs, namely sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis, tonsillitis, influenza-like illness, bronchitis, pneumonia, pleurisy and other acute RTIs, from the beginning of November to the end of April of three seasons: 2012/13, 2013/14 and 2014/15. Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried.", "Furthermore, the intake of antibiotics, doctor visits, hospitalisation for RTIs and the impact of RTI symptoms on their daily activities were queried. Further recruitment details into the AWIS study and the present sub-cohort are presented under Additional files 1 and 2. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.", "Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. In order to describe the association between obesity and RTIs, different outcome indicators were considered: outcomes at the level of each month \"any RTI\", \"any URTI\" sinusitis, rhinitis, otitis media, pharyngitis/laryngitis and tonsillitis , \"any LRTI\" bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy , \"≥3 RTIs\", \"any long lasting infection\" > 2 weeks ; at the level of each winter season \"≥4 months with infections\", \"≥3 long lasting infections\" ; and at the individual level i.e. are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period .", "are defined once per individual and covering the overall study period . The ten specific RTI symptom categories were considered with the binary symptom indicators \"infection reported\" or \"no infection reported\" for each month. When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time.", "When counting the episodes for the outcome indicator \"≥3 long lasting infections\", different infection symptoms were counted as separate episodes, even if they overlapped in time. However, within one symptom category at least one month without this specific infection was required to call it a new episode. We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\".", "We also calculated a monthly diary RTI score, averaging the ten RTI symptom categories with the coding \"0\" for \"no infection reported\", \"1\" for \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\", and \"2\" for \"reported infection present with duration >2 weeks\". Missing values for individual infection items were treated as zero. If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\".", "If an individual RTI symptom was reported, but information on duration was missing, it was counted as \"reported infection with duration < 2 weeks\". If all items were missing, no diary score was computed. The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months.", "The diary RTI score at the monthly level was expanded to a score at the seasonal level by averaging over the six months November-April of each season, and to an overall score at the individual level by averaging over all available months. The respective upper 10% of these diary scores within each month, season and overall served as additional outcome indicators. Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns.", "Further variables considered in the study were age, gender, self-reported weight and height for BMI calculation BMI was categorized as < 30 non-obese , 25 ≤ BMI < 30 overweight and ≥30 obese , educational level, contact with children, comorbidities, removed immunological organs, smoking status, sports activity and dietary intake patterns. Details on these variables are described in the Additional file 1 and supplementary information on dietary intake patterns is presented in Additional file 3. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA .", "Statistical analysis was performed using Stata version 14 STATSCorp, USA . Descriptive statistics: Monthly prevalences of individual RTI symptoms were computed by taking the average over all subjects available at each month and then averaging over all 18 months covered. Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered.", "Prevalences at the seasonal level were computed accordingly averaging over all three seasons covered. The corresponding confidence intervals CIs and p-values are based on a generalised linear model with identity link and binomial type variance together with robust variance estimates. The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly.", "The frequency of long lasting infections among all months with infections was analysed accordingly. However, due to the limited number of cases for tonsillitis and otitis media we determined the monthly frequency of long-lasting infections by pooling the data over all seasons and for pneumonia by pooling all indicated months. At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator.", "At the monthly level ORs were computed using a logistic regression model with a random intercept applied to the individual data for each month taking the 18 months as a categorical covariate into account in addition to the obesity status indicator. Due to its small prevalence, pleurisy was not considered as single outcome in these analyses. Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate.", "Outcomes at the seasonal level were analysed accordingly with the individual data for each winter season and taking into account the three seasons as a categorical covariate. Outcomes at the individual level were analysed using a logistic regression model. Results are ORs and 95% CIs.", "Results are ORs and 95% CIs. Adjusted ORs are based on including age groups and education as simultaneous categorical covariates. Furthermore, in order to study the stability of the obesity-RTI association with respect to potential confounders, ORs were adjusted by respective variables. Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses.", "Subjects with incomplete covariate data were excluded from multivariate analyses. Effect modification by a binary variable was assessed by fitting an overall model with the corresponding interactions parametrized so that we could directly read off the two subgroup-specific ORs. Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores.", "Effect modification by sports activity and nutrition patterns was explored among those representing the lower and upper third of respective scores. The study population comprised 1455 individuals 931 female and 524 male with a median age of 51.08 years. Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 .", "Based on BMI calculated from self-reported weight and height, 2.1% of the population was underweight BMI < 18.5 kg/m 2 , 54% had a normal weight 18.5 kg/m 2 ≤ BMI < 25 kg/m 2 , 31.1% was overweight, and 12.8% was considered obese Table 1 . In women, the distribution was 2.8%, 60.21%, 25.0%, and 12.1% and in men 0.76%, 43.1%, 41.8%, and 14.3%, respectively. The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children.", "The study participants were mainly of medium and high educational level, non-or ex-smokers, moderately affected by selected co-morbidities and they reported rather infrequent contact to small children. Further information on the study population and completed diaries is reported in Table 1 and Additional file 4. Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections.", "Missing rates of single items in the returned diaries were limited and ranged from 1.2% for rhinitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis to 2.6% for other acute respiratory infections. Study participants reported most frequently rhinitis 26.6% , followed by influenza-like illness 11.4% and pharyngitis/laryngitis 10.5% , whereas pleurisy 0.10% was rarely experienced. Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% .", "Any URTI 31.5% was more frequent than any LRTI 7.9% . Apart from the LRTIs bronchitis, pneumonia and pleurisy, which more men than women reported, all other RTIs were more prevalent among women Table 2 . Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 .", "Seasonal patterns of reported infections show a February peak for two of the three assessed infection seasons 2012/13 and 2014/15, see Additional file 5 . Respiratory infections with a high fraction of long duration were almost exclusively LRTIs, namely pneumonia 59% , followed by bronchitis 48.2% . Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 .", "Men were overrepresented among those with long-lasting RTIs Table 2 . Compared to normal weight individuals, overweight and obese people consistently had a higher prevalence Table 3 for the single RTIs, URTIs, LRTIs, as well as the other outcome parameters we looked at with other acute infections and pneumonia as the exceptions. For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence.", "For pneumonia, only obese subjects had a higher prevalence. The overweight group was typically falling in between the groups with normal weight and obesity Table 3 . The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI.", "The strongest association was seen for pneumonia and bronchitis, and accordingly, any LRTI was more strongly associated with obesity than any URTI. Long-lasting RTIs, frequent RTIs and high diary scores were also more strongly associated with obesity than the individual symptoms. Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates.", "Adjustments by age and education did only marginally change these estimates. Among subjects with an infection, long lasting infections were again associated with obesity, reaching significance for any RTI, rhinitis, pharyngitis/laryngitis, influenza-like illness, and bronchitis Table 3 . For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 .", "For a better understanding of the robustness of the relationship between RTI burden and obesity, the effect of adjusting for putative confounders was explored Additional file 6 . The studied demographic and lifestyle variables age, gender, education level, smoking status, contact to children, asthma, sports activity, dietary patterns and previous removal of immune organs did only marginally affect ORs. However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably.", "However, adjustment for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD or a summary score covering all queried co-morbidities weakened the relationship between obesity and all outcomes considerably. Adjustment for vitamin D levels among those for which serum was available n = 508 , had only a slight effect on the magnitude of the association between obesity and RTI outcomes. The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 .", "The association between obesity and RTI outcomes was more prominent for women than for men and reached statistical significance only for the former Table 4 . For most outcomes this interaction was not significant, with the individual level diary score as an exception. When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 .", "When looking at sports activity, for most outcomes the association with obesity was confined to those physically more active and not seen for those reporting little sports activity Table 5 . For all outcomes the association was less pronounced in the latter group compare the ratios of ORs in Table 5 , a difference that reached significance for all outcomes except those with low prevalence. Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns.", "Typically the prevalence of an outcome was only increased in the small group of people with obesity and higher sports activity whereas all other groups presented rather similar patterns. Similarly, the prevalence of outcomes was increased among people with obesity and a more favourable nutritional pattern, but comparable among the other groups Table 6 . The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes.", "The interaction reaches significance for the majority of outcomes. RTIs constitute an important morbidity factor considering the high health care costs, the time lost from work, and the impaired quality of life among those recurrently affected . Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide.", "Obesity belongs to one of the host risk factors for RTI and has possibly an emerging role due to the dramatically increasing prevalence of obesity worldwide. In the present study, we report on the association of obesity with individual RTIs as well as with a diary score summarising different incident RTI symptoms over a period of 18 months. Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia .", "Our investigation could demonstrate an association between obesity and RTIs confirming previous findings on influenza-like illness , bronchitis and pneumonia . We also saw an association between obesity and rhinitis, sinusitis and pharyngitis/laryngitis. An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women .", "An elevated risk for sinusitis among obese was also reported in a populationbased cohort of Danish women . None of the two Danish population-based studies used ORs of monthly prevalence, but hazard ratios HRs , as they could identify events on a daily basis. The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed.", "The HR of 1.6 for the association with RTIs and the HR of 1.48 for the association with URTIs are, however, of similar magnitude to the risk estimates which we observed. Mechanistically, excess adiposity might weigh down host defence as several mouse as well as human studies have suggested . The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms.", "The here observed associations were more prominent for LRTIs compared to URTIs, but evident for both, and more pronounced when considering long lasting or frequent RTIs compared to single symptoms. Based on the infection diary data, we generated a RTI diary score summing-up all ten symptoms and allowing to average per month, per whole season or over the whole period of three years. Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced.", "Considering the upper ten percentile of the distribution of such scores as an outcome, associations were typically stronger than when considering single symptoms, and interactions were more pronounced. Moreover, the results of the seasonal score were very similar or even stronger than those of the three-years score, arguing for the adequacy to query six months infectious events in future studies to identify the infection-prone sub-group of the population. Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI.", "Lifestyle habits seem to contribute to an individual's risk for RTI. Among them, cigarette smoking has been reported as a major environmental risk factor for recurrent and severe RTIs . Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks.", "Frequent contact to small children , vitamin D deficiency , and lack of physical activity constitute other exposures associated with heightened RTI risks. Moreover, higher levels of education were associated with a lower risk of CAP . Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders.", "Based on those previous findings we investigated their role as possible confounders. The association between obesity and RTIs remained nearly unchanged after adjustment for age, gender, educational status, contact to children, smoking status, sports activity and nutrition scores, suggesting that the association is not markedly confounded by the effects of these factors on both BMI and the risk of infections. Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably.", "Also additional adjustment by measured serum vitamin D in a subgroup for which measurements were available did not change the risk estimates considerably. This supports arguments that the observed associations between obesity and RTI burden are due to physiological differences in the immune responsiveness between obese and non-obese individuals rather than lifestyle differences. In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity .", "In addition, some chronic diseases, foremost asthma and COPD, are associated with both an increased risk of RTIs and obesity . Considering these associations we investigated the effect of asthma, COPD and a comorbidity scoresummarizing the other chronic conditionson the relationship between obesity and individual RTIs and the RTI diary score. Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes.", "Adjusting for these conditions individually and even more so in a combined fashion resulted in a considerable attenuation of the association between obesity and considered RTI outcomes. Hence part of the association between infections and obesity might be explainable by associations of co-morbidities with both. We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women.", "We see a gender difference in the observed associations with more noticeable findings for women. A significantly increased risk for combined RTIs was also restricted to women in a Danish blood donor cohort . Several lines of research support this notion: Szabova et al. and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system .", "and Ilavska et al. reported gender-dependent effects of obesity on the immune system . The effect of BMI on a variety of immune parameters including those with relevance for immune defence was much more apparent in women than in men . NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells.", "NK cells CD3-/CD16+/CD56+ , represent first-line cells for the clearing of virus-infected cells. Reduced levels of these cells reported for obese women, but not for respective men, might underlie the gender effect seen in our study. We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition.", "We also investigated a potential effect modification by sports activity and nutrition. Interestingly, an association between obesity and RTIs was evident only for those obese individuals who reported a higher level of sports activity. Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes.", "Thus, only the group of obese people who engaged in more intensive sports activity reported RTIs more frequently whereas obese people with low sports activity and non-obese with low or high sports activity showed comparable lower prevalences for most outcomes. We hypothesize that oxidative stress induced by vigorous aerobic as well as anaerobic sports activity is exacerbated in people with obesity, but not in normal weight individuals. Evidence supporting this has been previously published .", "Evidence supporting this has been previously published . An imbalanced oxidative stress status may have negative consequences on mounting an appropriate immune response towards respiratory pathogens. Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections .", "Excessive reactive oxygen species ROS was shown to hinder T cell responses to viral infection and ROS accumulation was detected in autophagy-deficient effector T cells rendering them incapable of controlling viral infections . A similar surprising result was found when studying the effect modification by dietary patterns. Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al.", "Here we queried the participants' dietary habits and classified them as adhering to a more favourable or more unfavourable dietary pattern according to Winkler et al. . Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet.", "Aware of the limitations of a one-time assessment of a habitual diet, we found a more pronounced relationship between obesity and infections among obese people who reported an apparent healthier diet. Thus, again only the group of obese individuals who presumably eat a healthier diet showed an increased risk of RTIs. The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle.", "The question arises as to whether misreporting of dietary habits among these individuals with and without RTIs may explain the puzzle. One can imagine that obese individuals may have an increased perception of RTI related symptoms experiencing the contradiction between living a healthy lifestyle and being affected by excess weight and frequent infections. On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation.", "On the other hand the inconspicuous results from the non-obese population with respect to favourable and unfavourable diet pattern would somewhat argue against this explanation. Alternatively, among the group of people with obesity a genetically defined subgroup may exist predisposing to both, excess body weight and proneness to infections. As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered.", "As strengths of our study we count 1 its sample size, allowing for the analysis of effect modification, 2 its prospective design involving 18 months infection diaries for the exploration of the relationship between BMI and subsequent RTI frequency and severity, 3 the comprehensive information on lifestyle and co-morbidities allowing to study the interplay of such factors on their effect on infections, and 4 the wide range of outcome indicators considered. The uniformity of the results with respect to these outcomes also suggests that in the field of airway infection morbidity, studies may be comparable despite the fact that they often concentrate on different RTI outcomes. In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification.", "In line with the majority of epidemiological studies in this area of research, our study suffers from some limitations, including the reliance on self-reported outcomes and exposure data with the risk of misclassification. However, we found -for instance -a good agreement between BMI derived from self-reported weight and height data and BMI calculated from measured values available for a sub-cohort n = 508 . Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting.", "Moreover, differential misclassification which would substantially bias the relationship between obesity and RTIs is rather unexpected in this setting. The disproportional selection of women into the study may negatively impact the generalizability of some of our results." ]

[ "In this month’s editorial, the PLOS Medicine Editors propose ideal qualities for the World Health Organization's next Director General, for whom the selection process is now underway. Text: response to the Ebola outbreak . Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate.", "Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate. Chan will step down from WHO on June 30, 2017 after more than a decade in the post. The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role.", "The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role. Factoring in the many influential stakeholders in the process of appointing Chan's successor, however, transparency of the selection process may be one area unlikely to attract plaudits. Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population.", "Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population. Instead of electing a new Director-General, Lorenz Von Seidlein of Mahidol University, Thailand, argued that \"the problems. .", ". .are now so deeply ingrained that replacing the WHO with new, more appropriate organizations is the logical solution. . .at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\"", ".at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\" This viewpoint is indicative of the strength of feeling that WHO's deficiencies have come to evoke in some of those committed to the cause of improving the health of people in low-income and middle-income countries. But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries.", "But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries. The next Director-General will need to heed critics of the organization and craft a process of streamlining and restructuring to produce a new WHO that is demonstrably effective in leading responses to threats to health, and efficient in doing so. As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\"", "As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\" Political machinations and the enemy within, bureaucracy, are likely to impede reform. For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries.", "For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries. As Gostin also noted, \" WHO has failed to include civil society in its governance, unlike. . .newer organizations.\"", ". .newer organizations.\" WHO's next Director-General should be a proven leader and advocate, perhaps from a lowincome or middle-income country. The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms.", "The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms. A substantial proportion of WHO's existing budget is earmarked for specific projects, leaving the organization with little financial flexibility to respond to unanticipated demands. However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform.", "However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform. According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. .", "According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. . .the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\"", ".the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\" Above all, the incoming leader of WHO will need to be open-minded and creative. More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response.", "More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response. WHO must be able to lead responses in some areas of global health, but, in other areas, working together with more nimble and focused organizations will be pragmatic. Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care.", "Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care. The resources and ingenuity of researchers and clinicians will need to be harnessed, and interventions adapted to new settings, with much greater dynamism. The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet.", "The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet. We look forward to welcoming a new leader for WHO with the energy and vision to remold the organization to meet the health needs of the world's people and societies for the 21st century." ]

[ "In this month’s editorial, the PLOS Medicine Editors propose ideal qualities for the World Health Organization's next Director General, for whom the selection process is now underway. Text: response to the Ebola outbreak . Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate.", "Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate. Chan will step down from WHO on June 30, 2017 after more than a decade in the post. The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role.", "The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role. Factoring in the many influential stakeholders in the process of appointing Chan's successor, however, transparency of the selection process may be one area unlikely to attract plaudits. Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population.", "Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population. Instead of electing a new Director-General, Lorenz Von Seidlein of Mahidol University, Thailand, argued that \"the problems. .", ". .are now so deeply ingrained that replacing the WHO with new, more appropriate organizations is the logical solution. . .at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\"", ".at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\" This viewpoint is indicative of the strength of feeling that WHO's deficiencies have come to evoke in some of those committed to the cause of improving the health of people in low-income and middle-income countries. But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries.", "But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries. The next Director-General will need to heed critics of the organization and craft a process of streamlining and restructuring to produce a new WHO that is demonstrably effective in leading responses to threats to health, and efficient in doing so. As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\"", "As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\" Political machinations and the enemy within, bureaucracy, are likely to impede reform. For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries.", "For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries. As Gostin also noted, \" WHO has failed to include civil society in its governance, unlike. . .newer organizations.\"", ". .newer organizations.\" WHO's next Director-General should be a proven leader and advocate, perhaps from a lowincome or middle-income country. The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms.", "The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms. A substantial proportion of WHO's existing budget is earmarked for specific projects, leaving the organization with little financial flexibility to respond to unanticipated demands. However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform.", "However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform. According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. .", "According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. . .the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\"", ".the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\" Above all, the incoming leader of WHO will need to be open-minded and creative. More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response.", "More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response. WHO must be able to lead responses in some areas of global health, but, in other areas, working together with more nimble and focused organizations will be pragmatic. Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care.", "Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care. The resources and ingenuity of researchers and clinicians will need to be harnessed, and interventions adapted to new settings, with much greater dynamism. The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet.", "The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet. We look forward to welcoming a new leader for WHO with the energy and vision to remold the organization to meet the health needs of the world's people and societies for the 21st century." ]

[ "In this month’s editorial, the PLOS Medicine Editors propose ideal qualities for the World Health Organization's next Director General, for whom the selection process is now underway. Text: response to the Ebola outbreak . Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate.", "Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate. Chan will step down from WHO on June 30, 2017 after more than a decade in the post. The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role.", "The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role. Factoring in the many influential stakeholders in the process of appointing Chan's successor, however, transparency of the selection process may be one area unlikely to attract plaudits. Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population.", "Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population. Instead of electing a new Director-General, Lorenz Von Seidlein of Mahidol University, Thailand, argued that \"the problems. .", ". .are now so deeply ingrained that replacing the WHO with new, more appropriate organizations is the logical solution. . .at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\"", ".at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\" This viewpoint is indicative of the strength of feeling that WHO's deficiencies have come to evoke in some of those committed to the cause of improving the health of people in low-income and middle-income countries. But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries.", "But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries. The next Director-General will need to heed critics of the organization and craft a process of streamlining and restructuring to produce a new WHO that is demonstrably effective in leading responses to threats to health, and efficient in doing so. As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\"", "As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\" Political machinations and the enemy within, bureaucracy, are likely to impede reform. For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries.", "For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries. As Gostin also noted, \" WHO has failed to include civil society in its governance, unlike. . .newer organizations.\"", ". .newer organizations.\" WHO's next Director-General should be a proven leader and advocate, perhaps from a lowincome or middle-income country. The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms.", "The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms. A substantial proportion of WHO's existing budget is earmarked for specific projects, leaving the organization with little financial flexibility to respond to unanticipated demands. However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform.", "However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform. According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. .", "According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. . .the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\"", ".the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\" Above all, the incoming leader of WHO will need to be open-minded and creative. More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response.", "More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response. WHO must be able to lead responses in some areas of global health, but, in other areas, working together with more nimble and focused organizations will be pragmatic. Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care.", "Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care. The resources and ingenuity of researchers and clinicians will need to be harnessed, and interventions adapted to new settings, with much greater dynamism. The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet.", "The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet. We look forward to welcoming a new leader for WHO with the energy and vision to remold the organization to meet the health needs of the world's people and societies for the 21st century." ]

[ "In this month’s editorial, the PLOS Medicine Editors propose ideal qualities for the World Health Organization's next Director General, for whom the selection process is now underway. Text: response to the Ebola outbreak . Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate.", "Reformation of WHO to ready it to lead responses to future health emergencies is one area of active debate. Chan will step down from WHO on June 30, 2017 after more than a decade in the post. The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role.", "The process for choosing WHO's next leader has begun, promising to be protracted and rigorous as befits the importance of the role. Factoring in the many influential stakeholders in the process of appointing Chan's successor, however, transparency of the selection process may be one area unlikely to attract plaudits. Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population.", "Although too soon to speculate about the identity of WHO's next Director-General, it is worth reflecting on what qualities an incoming leader should bring to WHO and how that person might need to conceive changes in the structure and behavior of the organization against a landscape of important and evolving threats to the health of the fastgrowing global population. Instead of electing a new Director-General, Lorenz Von Seidlein of Mahidol University, Thailand, argued that \"the problems. .", ". .are now so deeply ingrained that replacing the WHO with new, more appropriate organizations is the logical solution. . .at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\"", ".at a fraction of current cost, free of cumbersome, archaic obligations and entitlements and with an ability to respond to new problems.\" This viewpoint is indicative of the strength of feeling that WHO's deficiencies have come to evoke in some of those committed to the cause of improving the health of people in low-income and middle-income countries. But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries.", "But this perception acknowledges that an accountable global body will always be needed to promote, set standards in, and evaluate progress toward better health for people in all countries. The next Director-General will need to heed critics of the organization and craft a process of streamlining and restructuring to produce a new WHO that is demonstrably effective in leading responses to threats to health, and efficient in doing so. As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\"", "As Gostin commented to PLOS Medicine, \"WHO urgently needs a bold reform agenda to fix long-standing problems recognized by every independent group that has evaluated the Organization.\" Political machinations and the enemy within, bureaucracy, are likely to impede reform. For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries.", "For example, WHO's regional and country offices are seen by some as unaccountable, yet the agency of the future will need to be connected and responsive to the resources and needs of all constituent countries. As Gostin also noted, \" WHO has failed to include civil society in its governance, unlike. . .newer organizations.\"", ". .newer organizations.\" WHO's next Director-General should be a proven leader and advocate, perhaps from a lowincome or middle-income country. The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms.", "The new recruit will be greeted by a full in-tray, and featuring prominently are likely to be the constraints imposed by WHO's current funding mechanisms. A substantial proportion of WHO's existing budget is earmarked for specific projects, leaving the organization with little financial flexibility to respond to unanticipated demands. However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform.", "However, any improved funding mechanism is likely to follow, and be dependent on, organizational reform. According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. .", "According to Kruk, \"WHO is both essential and hamstrung. . .the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\"", ".the election of the Director-General should be a moment for member countries and other funders to reflect on whether they want an implementation agency for their favored health agenda, or an independent institution with the intelligence, agility, and operational capacity to tackle the coming global health challenges.\" Above all, the incoming leader of WHO will need to be open-minded and creative. More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response.", "More than one of the experts we contacted emphasized the fluid nature of the threats to human health to which WHO should shape the world's response. WHO must be able to lead responses in some areas of global health, but, in other areas, working together with more nimble and focused organizations will be pragmatic. Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care.", "Large-scale infectious disease outbreaks are continuing, and noncommunicable diseases, including cancer, dementia, and mental illnesses, are growing in prevalence and increasing demand for treatment and care. The resources and ingenuity of researchers and clinicians will need to be harnessed, and interventions adapted to new settings, with much greater dynamism. The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet.", "The secular issues of population ageing, conflict, climate change, migration, and others will produce health problems that only an organization with a global reach, responsible to all, can hope to meet. We look forward to welcoming a new leader for WHO with the energy and vision to remold the organization to meet the health needs of the world's people and societies for the 21st century." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM is considered as a rare form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis characterized by fulminant encephalopathy with hemorrhagic necrosis and most often fatal outcome. OBJECTIVE: To report the association with Ran Binding Protein RANBP2 gene variant and the response to decompressive craniectomy and high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP in life-threatening AHEM. DESIGN: Single case study.", "DESIGN: Single case study. CASE REPORT: A 6-year-old girl known to have sickle cell disease SCD presented an acquired demyelinating syndrome ADS with diplopia due to sudden unilateral fourth nerve palsy. She received five pulses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day . Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma.", "Two weeks after steroid weaning, she developed right hemiplegia and coma. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed a left frontal necrotico-hemorrhagic lesion and new multifocal areas of demyelination. She underwent decompressive craniotomy and evacuation of an ongoing left frontoparietal hemorrhage. Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process.", "Comprehensive investigations ruled out vascular and infectious process. The neurological deterioration stopped concomitantly with combined neurosurgical drainage of the hematoma, decompressive craniotomy, IVMP, and intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG . She developed during the following months Crohn disease and sclerosing cholangitis. After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation.", "After 2-year follow-up, there was no new neurological manifestation. The patient still suffered right hemiplegia and aphasia, but was able to walk. Cognitive/behavioral abilities significantly recovered. A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy.", "A heterozygous novel rare missense variant c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu was identified in RANBP2, a gene associated with acute necrotizing encephalopathy. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells. CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP.", "CONCLUSION: In any ADS occurring in the context of SCD and/or autoimmune condition, we recommend to slowly wean steroids and to closely monitor the patient after weaning to quickly treat any recurrence of neurological symptom with IVMP. This case report, in addition to others, stresses the likely efficacy of combined craniotomy, IVIG, and IVMP treatments in AHEM. RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM.", "RANBP2 mutations may sensitize the brain to inflammation and predispose to AHEM. Text: Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis AHEM or acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis is considered a rare and extremely severe form of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis ADEM . AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system.", "AHEM is characterized by an acute and rapidly progressive encephalopathy including hemorrhagic necrosis of the parenchyma of the central nervous system. It is usually fatal . . . . Many treatment options have been used including intravenous IV steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins IVIG , and plasmapheresis . .", ". There have been few reports of survival following early intervention with high-dose corticosteroid therapy and/or decompressive craniotomy . . . . . . RANBP2, a nuclear pore protein, has numerous roles in the cell cycle. RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells.", "RANBP2 is associated with microtubules and mitochondria suggesting roles in intracellular protein trafficking or energy maintenance and homeostasis of neuronal cells. RANBP2 mutations have been reported in acute necrotizing encephalopathy ANE which could present with coma, convulsions, and encephalopathy. The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem.", "The hallmark of ANE is multiple, symmetric brain lesions located in the thalami bilaterally, putamina, deep periventricular white matter, cerebellum, and brainstem. It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . .", "It could be triggered by a viral infection in previously healthy children . . We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD .", "We report a new case of AHEM associated to a Ran Binding Protein RANBP -2 variant and responsive to combined craniectomy, intravenous methylprednisolone IVMP , and IVIG as inaugural manifestation of multisystemic autoimmunity in a girl with sickle cell disease SCD . A 6-year-old girl known for SCD treated on folic acid and hydroxyurea was admitted for new-onset diplopia day 0 D0 : refers to the start of the diplopia 6 weeks after respiratory tract infection due to rhinovirus. She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome.", "She was diagnosed with a fourth nerve palsy secondary to an acquired demyelinating syndrome. The initial brain magnetic resonance imaging MRI performed at D5 after onset of neurological symptom showed left midbrain and pontine edema with expansion of the brainstem, right caudate nucleus, and scattered supratentorial white matter foci of high T2/FLAIR signal Figure 1 . Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis.", "Brain MR angiography MRA showed a normal appearing circle of Willis. The cerebrospinal fluid CSF obtained by lumber puncture was normal WBC 1 cells/μl, RBC 0 cells/μl, glucose 2.9 mmol/L, protein 0.18 g/L, and absent oligoclonal bands . The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative.", "The infectious workup including blood bacterial culture, CSF bacterial and viral cultures, nasopharyngeal aspirate tested for Influenza A, Influenza B, Parainfluenza 1-2-3, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Adenovirus, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Metapneumovirus, Enterovirus, and Rhinovirus , and serologies for Epstein-Barr virus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, HTLV I, HTLV II, HIV1, and Lyme disease were negative. Bartonella Henselae IgG was positive 1:1,280 reflecting a previously acquired common and self-limited infection in our area. Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 .", "Antinuclear antibodies ANA were positive 1:160 . B12 and folate levels were normal. Smooth muscle antibodies were negative. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies were positive. Sedimentation rate was 65 mm/h. She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day .", "She was treated with five doses of IVMP 30 mg/kg/day followed by 9 days of oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day . At discharge, her neurological exam was significant only for vertical diplopia. She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness.", "She presented 1 month later with 5 days of upper respiratory tract infection symptoms, fever, headache, and a rapidly progressive right-hand weakness D30 with normal alertness. She had normal blood pressure 120/81 mmHg . She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir.", "She was started on cefotaxime, vancomycin, and acyclovir. White cell count was 13.4 × 10 9 /L, hemoglobin was 7.8 g/L, and platelets were 239 × 10 9 /L. While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min .", "While in the MRI machine D30 she deteriorated with vomiting and reduced level of consciousness Glasgow Coma Scale dropped from 15 to 8 over 30 min . Brain MRI showed a rapid progression over a few sequences of an active bleed involving both superficial and deep gray matter as well as subcortical white matter of the left hemisphere anterior quadrant. Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F .", "Brain MRA was normal Figures 2A-F . The patient was immediately brought out of the magnet and her physical exam demonstrated unequal dilated pupils. She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery.", "She received IV mannitol and hypertonic saline for the management of acute intracranial hypertension/ herniation and was taken for surgery. She underwent left frontotemporoparietal decompressive craniotomy, evacuation of left frontoparietal intracerebral hemorrhage, and insertion of an external ventricular drain EVD . Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis.", "Upon opening the skull, there was significant dural tension, and on opening the dura mater, there was a large amount of bleeding, in addition to brain swelling and necrosis. Estimated blood loss was 3.5 L. She received 8 units of packed red blood cells, 3 units of cryoprecipitate, 6 units of fresh frozen plasma, and 3 units of platelets. Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted.", "Coagulation profile showed international normalization ratio = 3.38, prothrombin time = 51.2 s, and partial thromboplastin time = 122 s. An intraventricular pressure monitor was inserted. She returned with stable vitals to PICU. At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces.", "At D31, the CT scan showed extensive multi-compartmental bleed involving the left frontoparietal lobes, the interhemispheric fissure, and the left hemispheric arachnoid spaces. New white matter lesions were detected in the left posterior parietal and occipital lobes and in the left caudate head. MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I .", "MRI at D33 showed interval worsening with disseminated gray and white matter non-hemorrhagic lesions in the right cerebral and both cerebellar hemispheres, bilateral deep gray nuclei, as well as new necrotic non-hemorrhagic lesions in the left hemisphere Figures 2G-I . She was started on IVMP 30 mg/kg/ day for 5 days and IVIG 1 g/kg/day for 2 days . Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 .", "Repeat MRI at D9 showed no new parenchymal hemorrhage and partial resolution of the non-hemorrhagic lesions Figure 3 . Prednisolone was tapered course over 6 weeks. At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side.", "At discharge D71 , she was able to say a few words and had better power of her right side. Brain MRI performed 3 months later showed complete resolution of the non-hemorrhagic non-necrotic lesions, mainly seen in the right cerebral hemisphere and the cerebellum. Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma.", "Brain biopsy of the hematoma, some small vessels, cortex, and white matter showed necrotic area, reactive and non-specific findings which could be entirely explained by compressive changes adjacent to a hematoma. There was diffuse microglial activation and signs of early microinfarcts. Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses.", "Blood, CSF and urine culture, and PCR HSV1/2 were negative for bacteria and for viruses. CSF obtained through craniotomy and EVD performed at D32 showed elevated proteins 2.56 g/L, glucose 3.6 mmol/L, white blood cells 9 cells/μL, and red blood cells 1,341 cells/μL. ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative.", "ANA and anti-DNA antibody were negative. Anti-extractable nuclear antigens SSA-RO, SSB-LA, smith, RNP were negative. Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion.", "Serum autoimmune antibodies panel NMO, NMDAR, AMPA I/II, GAB, MAG, VGCC, MOG, YO, HU, RI were negative but GAD antibody was slightly positive, possibly due to the IVIG infusion. EBV showed no signs of recent infection. After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange.", "After discharge, the patient was started on regular transfusion exchange. Six months later, the patient was diagnosed to have Crohn's disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis. Two years later, the patient still suffers right hemiparesis but is able to walk without support. She presents an expressive aphasia.", "She presents an expressive aphasia. Her intellectual abilities are average, or below the mean but in the normal range, except for the speed of information processing, verbal working memory, and some elaborated executive functions. A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu .", "A gene panel Table 1 targeting inflammatory disorders and post-infectious necrotic encephalopathies found a heterozygous RANBP2 missense mutation NM_006267.4, c.4993A>G, p.Lys1665Glu . This mutation has not been previously reported in the HGMD database. This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles .", "This variant has been observed at a frequency of <0.01% across the entire Broad ExAC dataset of individuals without severe childhood onset disease 6/117,118 alleles . Analysis of amino acid conservation indicates that the wild-type amino acid Lys1665 is conserved in 59 of 60 mammals examined, including 12 of 12 primates, and in 25 of 34 nonmammalian vertebrates increasing the likelihood that a change at this position might not be tolerated. In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD .", "In silico tools predict that this variant is damaging SIFT and Align GVGD . Several differential diagnoses of acute encephalopathy in a patient with sickle cell anemia can be considered. An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR.", "An infectious encephalitis, including herpes encephalitis, was ruled out by blood and CSF bacterial and viral cultures and negative HSV I/ II PCR. Nasopharyngeal aspirate was negative for viruses. Some infections have been previously associated with necrotizing encephalitis such as Influenza A . . SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . .", ". SCD patients are prone to ischemic or hemorrhagic strokes . . Primary hemorrhagic stroke is uncommon in pediatric SCD. Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions.", "Most cases were from adults and have been described in the context of previous ischemic stroke, aneurysms, low hemoglobin, acute chest syndrome, and hypertransfusions. Moreover, although hemorrhagic stroke has been described in SCD patients receiving transfusion or corticosteroids, it was in the context of elevated blood pressure which was not present in our case . .", ". This was ruled out as the MRI findings were not consistent with a specific vascular territory and normal arterial and venous flows were shown on vascular imaging. Another differential is posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome which has been reported in SCD patients . . . . .", ". . . . However, it is unlikely in our case due to the severity of the brain injury and the absence of classic precipitating factors of posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome such as high blood pressure. Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury.", "Macrophage activation syndrome could also lead to acute necrotic brain injury. However, it is associated to high ferritin and low triglycerides at the time of the encephalopathy, other multisystemic injuries, typical neuropathological findings, and recurrence over time, which were not noted in our patient . .", ". Parvovirus B19 has been described to cause encephalopathy in sickle cell patients. It is associated with aplastic anemia. It caused punctate areas of hemorrhages in the basal ganglia, periventricular white matter, and mainly along the posterior parietal cortex. This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . .", "This was attributed to parvovirus B19-induced vasculitis . . In our patient, there was no sign of aplasia or any neuroradiological finding of parvovirus B19 infection. Finally, acute encephalitis has been observed in SCD patients in the context of arterial hypoxemia from fat embolism, pulmonary embolism, sudden anemia, or acute chest syndrome due to pneumonia . .", ". This was ruled out as the patient did not have clinical or radiological signs of acute chest syndrome or embolism and there was no arterial hypoxemia. Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . .", "Acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis has been described in pediatric patients following ADEM or ADEM-like episodes . . AHEM is the most plausible diagnosis in our patients based on the clinical and radiological presentation, the preceding ADEM-like episode, and the exclusion of other etiologies of acute encephalopathy. Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . .", "Other patients with AHEM have been described in the SCD context . . Many treatment options have been used to treat AHEM; of these, IV steroids have been associated with survival following aggressive, high-dose corticosteroid therapy . . . . . . . . . .", ". . . . . . . . . Autosomal dominant mutations with incomplete penetrance in RANBP2 have been associated with susceptibility to infectioninduced necrotizing encephalopathy . .", ". Previously healthy patients with pathogenic mutations in RANBP2 can present acutely with encephalopathy and convulsions in the context of an infection, with brain imaging revealing involvement of the brainstem, thalami, putamina, cerebellum and external capsules, and claustrum . .", ". Our patient has a similar presentation and imaging features as infection-induced necrotizing encephalopathy, including bilateral thalamic involvement. The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid .", "The rare heterozygous previously unreported variant we identified in RANBP2 affects a very conserved aminoacid and is predicted deleterious using in silico tools a prediction tool performing a fast bioinformatics analysis which can predict the pathogenicity of a variant based on the change to an amino acid . It is possible that this variant is pathogenic and responsible for the clinical phenotype. There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy .", "There is an overlap between the diagnostic criteria of AHEM and those of acute hemorrhagic encephalopathy . making possible that both entities might be part of the same pathophysiological continuum. RANBP2 is a protein playing an important role in the energy homeostasis of neuronal cells . .", ". Hence, RANBP2 dysfunction might make neuronal cells much vulnerable to energy failure and necrosis when exposed to inflammatory or other stresses, such as those implicated in AHEM. This study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of our institutional ethic committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication.", "Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants for the publication. All authors participated in gathering the data, designing the article, and discussing and editing the manuscript. aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help.", "aCKNoWleDgMeNts We thank Dr. S. Abish, Dr. N. Ahmed, and Mrs. C. Guiraut for their help. We are grateful to the Hoppenheim Fund from the Montreal Children Hospital Foundation. The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation ..", "The first author of this article received a scholarship from the Hoppenheim Fund, Montreal Children Hospital Foundation .. This work was supported by grants from Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada grant number: G-14-0005756 , and Foundation of Stars." ]

[ "A novel series of 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines substituted at C5 with various quinazolinones have been synthesized by the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone with N3-substitued 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones. All isoxazolidines were assessed for antiviral activity against a broad range of DNA and RNA viruses. Isoxazolidines trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 , trans-11h and trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 showed weak activity EC.", "Isoxazolidines trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 , trans-11h and trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 showed weak activity EC. = 6.84, 15.29 and 9.44 μM toward VZV TK + strain which was only one order of magnitude lower than that of acyclovir used as a reference drug. Phosphonates trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 , trans-11c, trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 and trans-11g appeared slightly active toward cytomegalovirus EC.", "Phosphonates trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 , trans-11c, trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 and trans-11g appeared slightly active toward cytomegalovirus EC. = 27–45 μM . Compounds containing benzyl substituents at N3 in the quinazolinone skeleton exhibited slight antiproliferative activity towards the tested immortalized cells with IC. in the 21–102 μM range.", "in the 21–102 μM range. Text: Nitrogen-containing heterocycles form the core of natural products e.g., alkaloids and they are also present in many pharmacophores as well as in numerous marketed drugs. Among them, quinazolines and quinazolinones have drawn special attention due to the broad spectrum of biological activities of their derivatives, including sedative , anticancer , antiviral , antibacterial , antifungal , anti-inflamatory 15, and antifibrotic activities.", "Among them, quinazolines and quinazolinones have drawn special attention due to the broad spectrum of biological activities of their derivatives, including sedative , anticancer , antiviral , antibacterial , antifungal , anti-inflamatory 15, and antifibrotic activities. Several reviews focused on the synthetic strategies and biological activities of these compounds have been published . The significant impact of various functional groups installed into quinazoline/quinazolinone frameworks on pharmacological properties have been proven.", "The significant impact of various functional groups installed into quinazoline/quinazolinone frameworks on pharmacological properties have been proven. In the last decades several compounds containing the quinazolin-4-one framework, which exhibited promising anticancer as well as antiviral properties, have been obtained Figure 1 . Furthermore, some biologically active substituted quinazolin-4 3H -ones were isolated from various fungi and bacteria species.", "Furthermore, some biologically active substituted quinazolin-4 3H -ones were isolated from various fungi and bacteria species. For example, 2- 4-hydroxybenzyl quinazolin-4 3H -one . was found in an entomopathogenic fungus Isaria farinosa and its strong inhibitory properties on the replication of tobacco mosaic virus TMV were recognised, whereas its 2- 4-hydroxybenzoyl analogue 2 present in fungus from Penicillium genus appeared only slightly active toward TMV .", "was found in an entomopathogenic fungus Isaria farinosa and its strong inhibitory properties on the replication of tobacco mosaic virus TMV were recognised, whereas its 2- 4-hydroxybenzoyl analogue 2 present in fungus from Penicillium genus appeared only slightly active toward TMV . Moreover, compound 1 exhibited significant cytotoxicity toward various cancer cell lines . Quinazolinone 3 isolated from Streptomyces sp.", "Quinazolinone 3 isolated from Streptomyces sp. appeared cytotoxic against Vero cells . Very recently synthetic pyridine-containing analogue 4 and its 3-substituted derivatives 5 and 6 have been obtained and their slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity .", "On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity .", "On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 .", "Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide .", "2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11.", "Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3.", "In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed .", "slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3.", "In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . Scheme 1.", "Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 .", "by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets .", "In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide .", "2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloro-propionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11.", "Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 .", "The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed.", "with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 .", "3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a R = H , trans-11c R = 2-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11g R = 3-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11h R = 4-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 and trans-11j R = Me only. Table 1 .", "Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a R = H , trans-11c R = 2-NO2-C6H4-CH2 , trans-11g R = 3-F-C6H4-CH2 , trans-11h R = 4-F-C6H4-CH2 and trans-11j R = Me only. The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone .", "The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8.", "Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz Scheme 3. Synthesis of Isoxazolidines cis-11a-k and trans-11a-k.", "Synthesis of Isoxazolidines cis-11a-k and trans-11a-k. Reaction and conditions: a. toluene, 70˝C, 24 h. The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of transand cis-isoxazolidines were observed.", "with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of transand cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz , J H4β-P = 16.9 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 6.2 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 8.", "3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz , J H4β-P = 16.9 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 6.2 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 8. 3 Hz, J CCCP = 8.5 Hz } and revealed that isoxazolidine ring in trans-11a adopts a 3 E conformation in which the diethoxyphosphoryl group resides in the equatorial position of the isoxazolidine ring while a quinazolinone substituent is located pseudoequatorially Figure 2 . On the other hand, cis configuration of the minor isomer was established from the corresponding couplings J H3-H4α = 9.0 Hz, J H3-H4β = 6.5 Hz, J H4α-P = 11.2 Hz, J H4β-P = 20.0 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 9.1 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 3.9 Hz, J CCCP = 7.", "On the other hand, cis configuration of the minor isomer was established from the corresponding couplings J H3-H4α = 9.0 Hz, J H3-H4β = 6.5 Hz, J H4α-P = 11.2 Hz, J H4β-P = 20.0 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 9.1 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 3.9 Hz, J CCCP = 7. 3 Hz indicating the 2 E conformation of the isoxazolidine ring Figure 2 . The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH 3 CH 2 OP protons observed for the cis isomer ∆δ ca.", "The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH 3 CH 2 OP protons observed for the cis isomer ∆δ ca. 0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a. Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cisand trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded ∆δ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only.", "Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cisand trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded ∆δ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only. Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis. Figure 2 .", "Figure 2 . The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH3CH2OP protons observed for the cis isomer Δδ ca. 0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a.", "0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a. Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cis-and trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded Δδ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only. Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis.", "Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis. Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds. The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC50: the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses .", "The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC50: the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses . Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TK − VZV strains with EC50 values in the range of 6.84-100 μM Table 2 . Among them, phosphonates Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds.", "Among them, phosphonates Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds. The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC 50 : the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses . Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TKV ZV strains with EC 50 values in the range of 6.84-100 µM Table 2 .", "Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TKV ZV strains with EC 50 values in the range of 6.84-100 µM Table 2 . Among them, phosphonates trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 R = 2-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 6.84 µM , trans-11h R = 4-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 15.29 µM , trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 R = 2,4-diF-C 6 H 3 -CH 2 EC 50 = 9.44 µM were the most active toward TK + VZV Oka strain, while exhibiting no activity toward TK´VZV strain. The activity of these isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 against TK + VZV Oka strain was 8-to 22-folds lower than that of the reference drug acyclovir.", "The activity of these isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 against TK + VZV Oka strain was 8-to 22-folds lower than that of the reference drug acyclovir. On the other hand, the EC 50 values for the TK´VZV 07-1 strain which is an acyclovir resistant strain of the phosphonates trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 R = 4-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 42.87 µM and trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et EC 50 = 41.57 µM were comparable to that of acyclovir EC 50 = 39.69 µM . These derivatives showed similar EC 50 's for TK + and TK´VZV strains and therefore their potency against TK + VZV was approximately 50-fold lower compared to acyclovir.", "These derivatives showed similar EC 50 's for TK + and TK´VZV strains and therefore their potency against TK + VZV was approximately 50-fold lower compared to acyclovir. Furthermore, compounds trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 R = C 6 H 5 -CH 2 , trans-11c R = 2-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 R = 4-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 and trans-11g R = 3-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 showed some activity against human cytomegalovirus EC 50 = 27-45 µM , although they were less active than ganciclovir and cidofovir used as the reference compounds Table 3 . None of the phosphonate derivatives here described showed activity against the other tested DNA and RNA viruses.", "None of the phosphonate derivatives here described showed activity against the other tested DNA and RNA viruses. The 50% cytostatic inhibitory concentration IC 50 causing a 50% decrease in cell proliferation was determined against murine leukemia L1210, human lymphocyte CEM, human cervix carcinoma HeLa and immortalized human dermal microvacsular endothelial cells HMEC-1 . Isoxazolidines trans-11a R = H and trans-11j R = Me did not inhibit cell proliferation at the highest tested concentration i.e., 250 µM , whereas trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et appeared slightly cytostatic towards the tested cell lines IC 50 = 85-101 µM .", "Isoxazolidines trans-11a R = H and trans-11j R = Me did not inhibit cell proliferation at the highest tested concentration i.e., 250 µM , whereas trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et appeared slightly cytostatic towards the tested cell lines IC 50 = 85-101 µM . On the other hand Table 4 , entries b to i , compounds having benzyl substituents at N3 in the quinazolinone moiety showed lower IC 50 values IC 50 = 21-102 µM thereby indicating that installation of functionalized benzyl groups was profitable for inhibitory properties. Table 4 .", "Table 4 . Inhibitory effect of the tested compounds against the proliferation of murine leukemia L1210 , human T-lymphocyte CEM , human cervix carcinoma HeLa and immortalized human dermal microvascular endothelial cells HMEC-1 . To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added.", "To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added. After 15 min the respective benzyl bromide 1.10 mmol was added and the reaction mixture was stirred under reflux for 4 h. A solvent was removed and the residue was extracted with water 3ˆ10 mL . An organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with a methylene chloride: hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallisation chloroform-petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13b-e and 13g-i.", "An organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with a methylene chloride: hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallisation chloroform-petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13b-e and 13g-i. 133.57, 128.60, 128.28, 128.25, 127.67, 126.60, 123.81, 123.61, 115.59, 68.32 s, N-CH 2 . Anal.", "Anal. Calcd. for C 17 To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added. After 15 min.", "After 15 min. iodomethane 2.00 mmol or iodoethane 1.10 mmol was added and the reaction mixture was stirred at 60˝C for 5 h. The solvent was removed and a residue was extracted with water 3ˆ10 mL . Organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with methylene chloride:hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallization chloroform : petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13j or 13k.", "Organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with methylene chloride:hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallization chloroform : petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13j or 13k. 3-Methyl-2-vinylquinazolin-4 3H -one 13j . Amorphous solid, m.p. = 122˝C-124˝C reference m.p. = 123˝C-125˝C .", "Amorphous solid, m.p. = 122˝C-124˝C reference m.p. = 123˝C-125˝C . A solution of the nitrone 12 1.0 mmol and the respective vinyl quinazolinone 1.0 mmol in toluene 2 mL was stirred at 70˝C until the disappearance TLC of the starting nitrone.", "A solution of the nitrone 12 1.0 mmol and the respective vinyl quinazolinone 1.0 mmol in toluene 2 mL was stirred at 70˝C until the disappearance TLC of the starting nitrone. All volatiles were removed in vacuo and crude products were subjected to chromatography on silica gel columns with a chloroform/methanol 100:1, 50:1, 20:1, v/v mixtures as eluents. Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl phosphonate trans-11a .", "Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl phosphonate trans-11a . Yellowish oil; IR film, cm´1 ν max : 3085, 2980, 2929, 2782, 1687, 1610, 1469, 1331, 1132, 1098, 1052 , 13 Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 3- 3-nitrobenzyl -4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl -phosphonate trans-11d . Data noted below correspond to a 92:8 mixture of trans-11d and cis-11d.", "Data noted below correspond to a 92:8 mixture of trans-11d and cis-11d. A yellowish oil; IR film, cm´1 ν max : 3070, 2982, 2930, 2910, 1620, 1574, 1531, 1497, 1415, 1298, 1103, 1025, 774" ]

[ "A novel series of 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines substituted at C5 with various quinazolinones have been synthesized by the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone with N3-substitued 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones. All isoxazolidines were assessed for antiviral activity against a broad range of DNA and RNA viruses. Isoxazolidines trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 , trans-11h and trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 showed weak activity EC.", "Isoxazolidines trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 , trans-11h and trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 showed weak activity EC. = 6.84, 15.29 and 9.44 μM toward VZV TK + strain which was only one order of magnitude lower than that of acyclovir used as a reference drug. Phosphonates trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 , trans-11c, trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 and trans-11g appeared slightly active toward cytomegalovirus EC.", "Phosphonates trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 , trans-11c, trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 and trans-11g appeared slightly active toward cytomegalovirus EC. = 27–45 μM . Compounds containing benzyl substituents at N3 in the quinazolinone skeleton exhibited slight antiproliferative activity towards the tested immortalized cells with IC. in the 21–102 μM range.", "in the 21–102 μM range. Text: Nitrogen-containing heterocycles form the core of natural products e.g., alkaloids and they are also present in many pharmacophores as well as in numerous marketed drugs. Among them, quinazolines and quinazolinones have drawn special attention due to the broad spectrum of biological activities of their derivatives, including sedative , anticancer , antiviral , antibacterial , antifungal , anti-inflamatory 15, and antifibrotic activities.", "Among them, quinazolines and quinazolinones have drawn special attention due to the broad spectrum of biological activities of their derivatives, including sedative , anticancer , antiviral , antibacterial , antifungal , anti-inflamatory 15, and antifibrotic activities. Several reviews focused on the synthetic strategies and biological activities of these compounds have been published . The significant impact of various functional groups installed into quinazoline/quinazolinone frameworks on pharmacological properties have been proven.", "The significant impact of various functional groups installed into quinazoline/quinazolinone frameworks on pharmacological properties have been proven. In the last decades several compounds containing the quinazolin-4-one framework, which exhibited promising anticancer as well as antiviral properties, have been obtained Figure 1 . Furthermore, some biologically active substituted quinazolin-4 3H -ones were isolated from various fungi and bacteria species.", "Furthermore, some biologically active substituted quinazolin-4 3H -ones were isolated from various fungi and bacteria species. For example, 2- 4-hydroxybenzyl quinazolin-4 3H -one . was found in an entomopathogenic fungus Isaria farinosa and its strong inhibitory properties on the replication of tobacco mosaic virus TMV were recognised, whereas its 2- 4-hydroxybenzoyl analogue 2 present in fungus from Penicillium genus appeared only slightly active toward TMV .", "was found in an entomopathogenic fungus Isaria farinosa and its strong inhibitory properties on the replication of tobacco mosaic virus TMV were recognised, whereas its 2- 4-hydroxybenzoyl analogue 2 present in fungus from Penicillium genus appeared only slightly active toward TMV . Moreover, compound 1 exhibited significant cytotoxicity toward various cancer cell lines . Quinazolinone 3 isolated from Streptomyces sp.", "Quinazolinone 3 isolated from Streptomyces sp. appeared cytotoxic against Vero cells . Very recently synthetic pyridine-containing analogue 4 and its 3-substituted derivatives 5 and 6 have been obtained and their slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity .", "On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity .", "On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 .", "Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide .", "2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11.", "Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3.", "In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed .", "slight activity against influenza A virus was revealed . On the other hand, various 2,3-disubstitued quinazolin-4 3H -ones, including compounds 7-10, have been found to possess antitumor activity . In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3.", "In continuation of our studies on antiviral and cytostatic activity of isoxazolidine analogues of C-nucleoside analogues, we designed a new series of compounds of the general formula 11 containing a substituted quinazolinone moiety as a false nucleobase at C5 in the isoxazolidine ring and the diethoxyphosphoryl function attached at C3. Our synthetic strategy to compounds trans-11/cis-11 relies on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone 12 with 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 substituted at N3 Scheme 1 . Scheme 1.", "Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 .", "by acylation with 3-chloropropionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3Hquinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets .", "In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . Scheme 1. Retrosynthesis of isoxazolidinyl phosphonates trans-11/cis-11. 2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide .", "2-Vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-ones 13 modified at N3 with substituted benzyl groups were synthesized from commercially available 2-aminobenzamide . by acylation with 3-chloro-propionyl chloride followed by cyclization and dehydrohalogenation to prepare 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a as a key intermediate and a subsequent reaction with substituted benzyl bromides 13b-i Scheme 2 . Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11.", "Moreover, compounds 13j R = Me and 13k R = Et were also obtained with intention to determine the influence of the benzyl substituent on biological activity of the designed isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11. In the 1 H-NMR spectra of compounds 13a-k characteristic signals for vinyl protons were observed in the 6.94-5.59 ppm three doublets of doublets . The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 .", "The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed.", "with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 .", "3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz The 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a nitrone 12 with 2-vinylquinazolinones 13a-k led to the formation of diastereoisomeric mixtures of 5-substituted 3-diethoxyphosphoryl isoxazolidines trans-11 and cis-11 with good 80%-88% diastereoselectivities Scheme 3, Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a R = H , trans-11c R = 2-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11g R = 3-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11h R = 4-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 and trans-11j R = Me only. Table 1 .", "Table 1 . Ratios of cis/trans diastereoisomers were calculated from 31 P-NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures and confirmed by the analysis of 1 H-NMR spectral data. Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns.", "Crude mixtures of isoxazolidine cycloadducts were then subjected to purification on silica gel columns. However, attempts to isolate pure diastereoisomers were fruitful for trans-11a R = H , trans-11c R = 2-NO2-C6H4-CH2 , trans-11g R = 3-F-C6H4-CH2 , trans-11h R = 4-F-C6H4-CH2 and trans-11j R = Me only. The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone .", "The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of trans-and cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8.", "Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz Scheme 3. Synthesis of Isoxazolidines cis-11a-k and trans-11a-k.", "Synthesis of Isoxazolidines cis-11a-k and trans-11a-k. Reaction and conditions: a. toluene, 70˝C, 24 h. The relative configurations of isoxazolidines trans-11a and cis-11a were established based on our previous studies on stereochemistry of cycloaddition of N-methyl-C- diethoxyphosphoryl nitrone . with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of transand cis-isoxazolidines were observed.", "with various vinyl aryls since similar 1 H-NMR spectral patters for the respective series of transand cis-isoxazolidines were observed. Since for compound trans-11a all necessary coupling constants were successfully extracted from the 1 H-and 13 C-NMR spectra, detailed conformational analysis was performed based on these data {J H3-H4α = 9.3 Hz , J H3-H4β = 8. 3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz , J H4β-P = 16.9 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 6.2 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 8.", "3 Hz, J H4α-P = 9.9 Hz , J H4β-P = 16.9 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 6.2 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 8. 3 Hz, J CCCP = 8.5 Hz } and revealed that isoxazolidine ring in trans-11a adopts a 3 E conformation in which the diethoxyphosphoryl group resides in the equatorial position of the isoxazolidine ring while a quinazolinone substituent is located pseudoequatorially Figure 2 . On the other hand, cis configuration of the minor isomer was established from the corresponding couplings J H3-H4α = 9.0 Hz, J H3-H4β = 6.5 Hz, J H4α-P = 11.2 Hz, J H4β-P = 20.0 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 9.1 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 3.9 Hz, J CCCP = 7.", "On the other hand, cis configuration of the minor isomer was established from the corresponding couplings J H3-H4α = 9.0 Hz, J H3-H4β = 6.5 Hz, J H4α-P = 11.2 Hz, J H4β-P = 20.0 Hz, J H4α-H5 = 9.1 Hz, J H4β-H5 = 3.9 Hz, J CCCP = 7. 3 Hz indicating the 2 E conformation of the isoxazolidine ring Figure 2 . The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH 3 CH 2 OP protons observed for the cis isomer ∆δ ca.", "The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH 3 CH 2 OP protons observed for the cis isomer ∆δ ca. 0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a. Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cisand trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded ∆δ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only.", "Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cisand trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded ∆δ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only. Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis. Figure 2 .", "Figure 2 . The additional arguments to support our assignments follow from shielding of the CH3CH2OP protons observed for the cis isomer Δδ ca. 0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a.", "0.1 ppm when compared with the trans-11a. Furthermore, it was found that on a 1 H-NMR spectrum taken on the 83:17 mixture of cis-and trans-11a, the H-N proton in the quinazolinone ring of cis-11a was significantly deshielded Δδ = 0.7 ppm when compared with the trans isomer, highly likely, as a result of the hydrogen bond formation with the phosphoryl oxygen amide, a phenomenon spatially achievable in the cis isomer only. Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis.", "Since introduction of various substituents at N3 of quinazolinone moiety has no influence on the stereochemical outcome of the cycloaddition therefore configuration of the all major isoxazolidines 11 were assigned as trans, thereby minor ones as cis. Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds. The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC50: the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses .", "The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC50: the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses . Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TK − VZV strains with EC50 values in the range of 6.84-100 μM Table 2 . Among them, phosphonates Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds.", "Among them, phosphonates Ganciclovir, cidofovir, acyclovir, brivudin, zalcitabine, zanamivir, alovudine, amantadine, rimantadine, ribavirin, dextran sulfate molecular weight 10,000, DS-10000 , mycophenolic acid, Hippeastrum hybrid agglutinin HHA and Urtica dioica agglutinin UDA were used as the reference compounds. The antiviral activity was expressed as the EC 50 : the compound concentration required to reduce virus plaque formation VZV by 50% or to reduce virus-induced cytopathogenicity by 50% other viruses . Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TKV ZV strains with EC 50 values in the range of 6.84-100 µM Table 2 .", "Several isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 were able to weakly inhibit the replication of TK + and TKV ZV strains with EC 50 values in the range of 6.84-100 µM Table 2 . Among them, phosphonates trans-11f/cis-11f 90:10 R = 2-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 6.84 µM , trans-11h R = 4-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 15.29 µM , trans-11i/cis-11i 97:3 R = 2,4-diF-C 6 H 3 -CH 2 EC 50 = 9.44 µM were the most active toward TK + VZV Oka strain, while exhibiting no activity toward TK´VZV strain. The activity of these isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 against TK + VZV Oka strain was 8-to 22-folds lower than that of the reference drug acyclovir.", "The activity of these isoxazolidines trans-11/cis-11 against TK + VZV Oka strain was 8-to 22-folds lower than that of the reference drug acyclovir. On the other hand, the EC 50 values for the TK´VZV 07-1 strain which is an acyclovir resistant strain of the phosphonates trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 R = 4-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 EC 50 = 42.87 µM and trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et EC 50 = 41.57 µM were comparable to that of acyclovir EC 50 = 39.69 µM . These derivatives showed similar EC 50 's for TK + and TK´VZV strains and therefore their potency against TK + VZV was approximately 50-fold lower compared to acyclovir.", "These derivatives showed similar EC 50 's for TK + and TK´VZV strains and therefore their potency against TK + VZV was approximately 50-fold lower compared to acyclovir. Furthermore, compounds trans-11b/cis-11b 90:10 R = C 6 H 5 -CH 2 , trans-11c R = 2-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 , trans-11e/cis-11e 90:10 R = 4-NO 2 -C 6 H 4 -CH 2 and trans-11g R = 3-F-C 6 H 4 -CH 2 showed some activity against human cytomegalovirus EC 50 = 27-45 µM , although they were less active than ganciclovir and cidofovir used as the reference compounds Table 3 . None of the phosphonate derivatives here described showed activity against the other tested DNA and RNA viruses.", "None of the phosphonate derivatives here described showed activity against the other tested DNA and RNA viruses. The 50% cytostatic inhibitory concentration IC 50 causing a 50% decrease in cell proliferation was determined against murine leukemia L1210, human lymphocyte CEM, human cervix carcinoma HeLa and immortalized human dermal microvacsular endothelial cells HMEC-1 . Isoxazolidines trans-11a R = H and trans-11j R = Me did not inhibit cell proliferation at the highest tested concentration i.e., 250 µM , whereas trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et appeared slightly cytostatic towards the tested cell lines IC 50 = 85-101 µM .", "Isoxazolidines trans-11a R = H and trans-11j R = Me did not inhibit cell proliferation at the highest tested concentration i.e., 250 µM , whereas trans-11k/cis-11k 97:3 R = Et appeared slightly cytostatic towards the tested cell lines IC 50 = 85-101 µM . On the other hand Table 4 , entries b to i , compounds having benzyl substituents at N3 in the quinazolinone moiety showed lower IC 50 values IC 50 = 21-102 µM thereby indicating that installation of functionalized benzyl groups was profitable for inhibitory properties. Table 4 .", "Table 4 . Inhibitory effect of the tested compounds against the proliferation of murine leukemia L1210 , human T-lymphocyte CEM , human cervix carcinoma HeLa and immortalized human dermal microvascular endothelial cells HMEC-1 . To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added.", "To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added. After 15 min the respective benzyl bromide 1.10 mmol was added and the reaction mixture was stirred under reflux for 4 h. A solvent was removed and the residue was extracted with water 3ˆ10 mL . An organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with a methylene chloride: hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallisation chloroform-petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13b-e and 13g-i.", "An organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with a methylene chloride: hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallisation chloroform-petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13b-e and 13g-i. 133.57, 128.60, 128.28, 128.25, 127.67, 126.60, 123.81, 123.61, 115.59, 68.32 s, N-CH 2 . Anal.", "Anal. Calcd. for C 17 To the solution of 2-vinyl-3H-quinazolin-4-one 13a, 1.00 mmol in acetonitrile 15 mL potassium carbonate 3.00 mmol was added. After 15 min.", "After 15 min. iodomethane 2.00 mmol or iodoethane 1.10 mmol was added and the reaction mixture was stirred at 60˝C for 5 h. The solvent was removed and a residue was extracted with water 3ˆ10 mL . Organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with methylene chloride:hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallization chloroform : petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13j or 13k.", "Organic layer was dried MgSO 4 , concentrated and the crude product was purified on a silica gel column with methylene chloride:hexane mixture 7:3, v/v followed by crystallization chloroform : petroleum ether to give pure quinazolinones 13j or 13k. 3-Methyl-2-vinylquinazolin-4 3H -one 13j . Amorphous solid, m.p. = 122˝C-124˝C reference m.p. = 123˝C-125˝C .", "Amorphous solid, m.p. = 122˝C-124˝C reference m.p. = 123˝C-125˝C . A solution of the nitrone 12 1.0 mmol and the respective vinyl quinazolinone 1.0 mmol in toluene 2 mL was stirred at 70˝C until the disappearance TLC of the starting nitrone.", "A solution of the nitrone 12 1.0 mmol and the respective vinyl quinazolinone 1.0 mmol in toluene 2 mL was stirred at 70˝C until the disappearance TLC of the starting nitrone. All volatiles were removed in vacuo and crude products were subjected to chromatography on silica gel columns with a chloroform/methanol 100:1, 50:1, 20:1, v/v mixtures as eluents. Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl phosphonate trans-11a .", "Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl phosphonate trans-11a . Yellowish oil; IR film, cm´1 ν max : 3085, 2980, 2929, 2782, 1687, 1610, 1469, 1331, 1132, 1098, 1052 , 13 Diethyl trans- 2-methyl-5- 3- 3-nitrobenzyl -4-oxo-3,4-dihydroquinazolin-2-yl isoxazolidin-3-yl -phosphonate trans-11d . Data noted below correspond to a 92:8 mixture of trans-11d and cis-11d.", "Data noted below correspond to a 92:8 mixture of trans-11d and cis-11d. A yellowish oil; IR film, cm´1 ν max : 3070, 2982, 2930, 2910, 1620, 1574, 1531, 1497, 1415, 1298, 1103, 1025, 774" ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is an important cause of acute respiratory illness in young children. Whole genome sequencing enables better identification of transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic sequences. RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples.", "RESULTS: We report a 2-reaction amplicon-based next generation sequencing method to determine the complete genome sequences of five HMPV strains, representing three subgroups A2, B1 and B2 , directly from clinical samples. In addition to reporting five novel HMPV genomes from Africa we examined genetic diversity and sequence patterns of publicly available HMPV genomes. We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries.", "We found that the overall nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3 and 80% for HMPV group A and B, respectively, the diversity between HMPV groups was greater at amino acid level for SH and G surface protein genes, and multiple subgroups co-circulated in various countries. Comparison of sequences between HMPV groups revealed variability in G protein length 219 to 241 amino acids due to changes in the stop codon position. Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes.", "Genome-wide phylogenetic analysis showed congruence with the individual gene sequence sets except for F and M2 genes. CONCLUSION: This is the first genomic characterization of HMPV genomes from African patients. Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV .", "Text: Human metapneumovirus HMPV is a single-stranded RNA virus in the family Paramyxoviridae and closely related to human respiratory syncytial virus RSV . HMPV causes respiratory disease similar to RSV, ranging from mild upper respiratory infection to bronchiolitis and pneumonia . HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common .", "HMPV infections are seasonal and coinfection with other respiratory pathogens is common . The HMPV genome is approximately 13 kb and comprises eight open reading frames ORFs encoding nucleoprotein N , phosphoprotein P , matrix protein M , fusion glycoprotein F , transcription enhancer protein M2 , small hydrophobic protein SH , attachment glycoprotein G , and large polymerase protein L . The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 .", "The membrane glycoproteins F and G sequences are used to define two major genotypes or groups, A and B, which are further classified into four subgroups A1, A2, B1, and B2 . HMPV A2, the most frequently observed subgroup, is further divided into two proposed sub-lineages A2a and A2b . HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa.", "HMPV is reported to have an important contribution to acute respiratory infections ARI in Africa. For instance, HMPV-associated hospitalization was estimated at 6.5 per 1000 person years in infants in Soweto, South Africa ; at 4% in hospitalized children with severe ARI during a 2-year period in Cameroon ; and in rural western Kenya, incidence of HMPV associated with ARI cases in outpatient clinic visits was estimated at 0.43 per 100 person-years among outpatients . In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months .", "In Kilifi coastal Kenya, between January 2007 to December 2011, children under 6 months of age accounted for 44% of HMPV positive cases, while 74% were children under 1 year, and 1.3% 2/160 were children > 36 months . In Dadaab and Kakuma refugee camps in Kenya, HMPV was detected in 5.7% hospitalizations, and virus-positive crude hospitalization rate per 1000 children < 5 years old was 4 for HMPV . In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV.", "In Mali, contribution of HMPV to pneumonia had a population attributable fraction of 9% 95% CI: 7-11% ; while in Morocco , 8 .9% of children < 5 years admitted with severe pneumonia were infected with HMPV. HMPV prevalence and incidence elsewhere globally, is indicated in Additional file 4: Table S1 . Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods.", "Of note is that the variations in incidence rates could be attributed to study population, seasonality and even detection methods. Nonetheless, genomic epidemiology of HMPV in Africa is inadequately reported, and comparison of genetic similarity and differences between African and global strains is not documented. Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments .", "Genome sequences provide valuable resources for characterizing viral evolution and disease epidemiology, and for identifying transmission events and outbreaks, which is not always possible with sub-genomic fragments . The increased number of phylogenetically informative variant sites obtained from full genomes may allow better linking of cases and aid public health interventions in real time during epidemics . PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest.", "PCR approaches for targeted whole genome sequencing, in contrast to random amplification, can preferentially amplify the target virus over host or environmental nucleic acids potentially focusing sequencing on the virus of interest. To date, the largest dataset of HMPV whole genomes n = 61 sequenced from any tropical country is from three Peruvian cities, Lima, Piura and Iquitos . In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 .", "In Africa, apart from one metapneumovirus genome identified from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda GenBank accession number HM197719 , there are no HMPV genomes reported according to the NIAID Virus Pathogen Database and Analysis Resource ViPR, org/, accessed April 30, 2019 . This has led to limited understanding of the genetic and genomic diversity of HMPV in the continent. This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia.", "This work describes a whole genome sequencing WGS approach for HMPV from a small number of HMPV positive clinical samples collected at Kilifi County Hospital in Kilifi, Kenya and University Teaching Hospital in Lusaka, Zambia. The genomes were generated by sequencing overlapping PCR amplicons spanning the entire genome. These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa.", "These are the first reported complete genome sequences of locally circulating HMPV strains obtained directly from clinical samples in Africa. We also combined the new genomes with publicly available sequences to examine patterns in global HMPV genetic diversity. Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted.", "Whole genome sequencing was successful for all 5 clinical samples that were attempted. A single genomic sequence was obtained from each sample, and the length of the 5 new HMPV genomes ranged from 13,097 to 13, 134 nt > 95% length coverage . Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 .", "Sequencing and data assembly parameters, including coverage depth are shown in Table 1 . Sequence annotation of the full-length genomes using Geneious R8.1.5 identified the expected eight coding ORFs and non-coding genomic regions. The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%.", "The overall nucleotide identity i.e., identical sites averaging over all sequence pairs and excluding positions containing gaps between all 143 genome sequences analyzed 5 new genomes plus 138 from ViPR was 58.2%. Nucleotide sequence identity was 71.3% within HMPV-A and 80% within HMPV-B. Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity.", "Intrasubgroup, A1, A2, B1 and B2 genomes shared 92.1% 10 sequences , 76.8% 88 sequences , 91% 24 sequences and 89.6% 21 sequences amino acid sequence identity. For the 143 HMPV genomes, we checked sequence conservation at transcriptional control regions, at the termini of each gene, as well as the lengths of intergenic sequences between gene boundaries. The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively.", "The length of the F-M2 intergenic region was different between group A and B viruses, that is, 13 nt and 2 nt, respectively. The SH-G and G-L intergenic regions were the longest, up to 125 nt and to 190 nt, respectively. Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig.", "Consensus nucleotides 9 to 19 length at the putative start and end regions flanking the ORF of the viral genes are shown in Fig. 1 . The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively.", "The gene-start and -end regions of N and P were conserved > 90% average pairwise identity in both HMPV groups, and the M2 and M gene-start and -end were also conserved in HMPV group A and B, respectively. The putative ATG start codon was consistently located at positions 14-16 upstream of a gene start motif consensus: GG/AGAC/TAAA/GTnnnnATG , except for the internal M2-2. An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains.", "An additional ATG start codon upstream of the gene-start motif was observed in the SH gene for the B1 and B2 strains. In five of the eight annotated genes N, P, F, M2, and G B1 and B2 strains only , the intergenic regions were short and the ORFs for these 5 genes terminated within the propositioned gene-end motifs. We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 .", "We combined the five genome sequences from Kenya and Zambia with available global sequences, aligned individual genes and calculated the percent nucleotide nt and amino acid aa identity Table 2 . The coding sequences of N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes were conserved at nucleotide and amino acid levels, by sharing > 85% between-subgroup nucleotide identity and 90% protein identity Table 3 . The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels.", "The nucleoprotein gene was the most conserved among all subgroups at the nt and aa levels. SH and G glycoprotein genes were more divergent between the HMPV subgroups at the nucleotide level with 76 and 63% identity, respectively. The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively.", "The SH protein length was variable between group A and B strains due to a nucleotide substitution CAA ➔ TAA at gene position 532 in group B, resulting in protein lengths of 178 and 180 aa, respectively. The predicted G protein length also varied among the different HMPV subgroups, between 219 and 241 aa, due to different positions of the Stop codon. Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig.", "Amino acid sequence diversity for G and SH glycoproteins is depicted in Fig. 2 and Additional file 2: Figure S2 , respectively. The diversity of the complete nucleotide sequences of SH and G genes is depicted in phylogenetic trees in Fig. 3 .", "3 . We evaluated phylogenetic classification and relationship between the 5 new genomes obtained in this study and previously published genomes Fig. 3 . Full genome Figure S3 . There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 .", "There was phylogenetic congruence with the individual gene sequence sets as with the full genome dataset, except for F and M2 gene Additional file 3: Figure S3 . Variant or drifted viral strains may lower the sensitivity of detection resulting in a decreased quantitation of the viral load and underestimation of disease incidence . We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection.", "We checked the new HMPV genomes for nucleotide differences in the genomic regions targeted by our diagnostic rRT-PCR primers and probes Additional file 7: Table S4 used for HMPV detection. Up to eight primer-and probetemplate mismatches were identified Fig. 4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig.", "4 : one mismatch in the forward primer region in HMPV group A F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4a ; one mismatch in each of the forward and probe target regions in group B F gene-based rRT-PCR assay, Fig. 4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c .", "4b ; and 5 different mismatches with the N-gene based rRT-PCR assay Fig. 4c . Note, the F gene-based rRT-PCR assays are different or specific to the two HMPV groups. HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals .", "HMPV causes respiratory illness presenting as mild upper respiratory tract infection or life-threatening severe bronchiolitis and pneumonia primarily in children, sometimes adults as well as immunocompromised individuals . However, HMPV genome sequence data from Africa is sparse and information on genome-wide diversity is limited. In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world.", "In the present study, the whole genome sequences of five HMPV strains from Kenya and Zambia were determined and compared with the genomes published previously from around the world. Comparative sequence analysis indicated fairly conserved positioning of the gene-start and -end regions as well as translational start and -end codons. Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation.", "Variation in genestart and -end sequences can have significant impact on transcription initiation and termination efficiency so that there is more selective pressure preventing changes in these regions , and this likely explains our observation. The additional ATG start codon found upstream of the gene-start motif of the SH gene was consistent with a previous report , though its role in gene expression is yet to be identified. These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV .", "These observed sequence conservation in N, M, F, M2-1, M2-2, and L genes is not unusual and is suggestive of functional and structural constraints on diversity, but less expected of the F gene because of its status as a neutralization and protective antigen, similar to its close 'relative' RSV . It has also been suggested that the low diversity in F gene might make a substantial contribution to cross-neutralization and cross-protection between the HMPV subgroups . The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature .", "The relatively high frequency of amino acid diversity in G and to a lesser extent SH could be attributable to selective pressure for amino acid change coming from host immunity; and the ability of the protein to tolerate substitutions, which might be due to its proposed extended, unfolded nature . The phylogenetic incongruence observed between whole genome tree and the F and G gene trees, is as reported previously for HMPV , and could be attributed to differential rates of evolution, selection pressure or past recombination events . The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported .", "The prevalence of HMPV in hospitalized pediatric population in Kilifi county in coastal Kenya has been reported . However, it is notable that in recent years, HMPV has been detected at low prevalence in Kilifi unpublished observations from hospital-based pneumonia surveillance . Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established.", "Whether this low prevalence is due to reduced virus transmission, or decreased sensitivity of our HMPV molecular diagnostic assay due to progressive primer/probe mismatches, is yet to be established. We present the first full genome sequences of circulating HMPV strains from sub-Saharan Africa. A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers.", "A limitation of our sequencing method, as is common with amplicon sequencing protocols , was absent coverage at the 3′ leader and 5′ trailer regions not captured by these primers. Our results demonstrate the application of amplicon sequencing to generate full length HMPV genomes directly from clinical samples. The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously .", "The observed diversity of the individual genes is comparable to that described previously . This method and data provide a useful reference for design of local molecular diagnostics and for studies aimed at understanding HMPV epidemiology and evolution in Africa. Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012.", "Nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal NP-OP swab samples were collected from children 1-59 months hospitalized with pneumonia, four of whom were enrolled in the PERCH study in 2012. The fifth sample was collected from a child enrolled in the routine pneumonia surveillance study at Kilifi County Hospital, Kenya, in 2015. The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays.", "The samples were tested for HMPV by multiplex semi-quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR rRT-PCR assays. The rRT-PCR primers and probes used, cycling conditions and assay set up have been described elsewhere . Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously .", "Fusion F and glycoprotein G encoding genes of the HMPV positive samples were amplified in a one-step RT-PCR assay OneStep RT-PCR kit, QIAGEN , as described previously . Partial G or F nucleotide sequences were analyzed by maximum likelihood ML phylogenetic trees using IQ-TREE , together with reference strains of HMPV subgroups accession numbers AF371337.2, FJ168779, AY297749, AY530095, JN184401 and AY297748 . Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing.", "Five HMPV positive samples from the Kenya and Zambia study sites, belonging to the A2a n = 1 , A2b n = 2 , B1 n = 1 and B2 n = 1 genetic subgroups based on their G and F gene sequences, were selected for whole genome sequencing. Data on age, sex and clinical assessment information collected at the time of sample collection, for the five selected samples, are shown in Table 3 . The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis.", "The sequencing protocol consisted of four steps as follows: i primer design, ii preparation of primer mixes, iii cDNA and PCR iv Illumina sequencing and data analysis. All human metapneumovirus HMPV full genome sequences were retrieved from GenBank January 2018 using the query txid162145 Organism AND 12000 SLEN : 14000 SLEN NOT patent . Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes.", "Sequence entries with gaps larger than 6 nt were excluded to generate a set of yielding 178 genomes. All possible 23 nt sequences were generated from the genomes dataset and trimmed to a final calculated melting temperature Tm of 47.9-49.5°C. Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded.", "Sequences with homology to rRNA sequences, with GC content outside < 0.3 or > 0.75 or with a single nucleotide fractional content of > 0.6 were discarded. The primer set was then made nonredundant yielding 60,746 potential primers. All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation.", "All potential primers were mapped against the 178 HMPV full genomes and the number of perfect matches frequency score was determined as a measure of primer sequence conservation. To select primers, the HMPV genome sequences were divided into amplicons with 222 nt overlap spanning the virus genome. Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented.", "Potential primers that mapped within the terminal 5′ and 3′ 222 nt of each amplicon were identified and the sequence with the highest frequency score was selected, and primers mapping to the reverse bins were reverse complemented. In this manner, 24 primers were selected for each of the 4 HMPV genotype representative genomes GenBank accession number HMPV A1: AF371337, HMPV A2: FJ168779; HMPV B1: AY525843, and HMPV B2: FJ168778 . Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed.", "Because of conservation between genotypes, there was primer redundancy which was removed. The final set of 65 primer sequences, their lengths, calculated Tm, fractional GC content and mapping position on the HMPV genome are presented in Additional file 5: Table S2 . The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups.", "The primers were computationally tested against each of the 4 HMPV subgroups. A graphical representation of the primer target sites is presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1 . Amplification was performed in two reactions. To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 .", "To avoid generating small products from adjacent forward and reverse primers, amplicons were assigned to alternate Table 3 . Bootstrap support values evaluated by 1000 replicates are indicated along the branches. Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated.", "Genetic subgroups A1, A2a, A2b, B1, and B2, are indicated. Multiple sequence alignment was done using MAFFT and the ML phylogeny inferred using GTR + Γ nucleotide substitution model and ultrafast bootstrap approximation in IQ-TREE. The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue.", "The genotype B2 Sabana strain sequence GenBank accession number HM197719 reported from a wild mountain gorilla in Rwanda is marked in blue. The scaled bar indicates nucleotide substitutions per site reactions, with reaction 1 containing primers for amplicons 1,3,5,7,9,11; reaction 2 containing primers for amplicons 2,4,6,8,10,12. Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl.", "Each reverse transcription used Forward Primer Mixes FPMs made with 3.0 μl of each reverse primer 100 pmol/μl plus water to 200 μl to generate a primer concentration of 24 pmol/μl. Two microlitre of the FPM is then used in a 20 μl reverse transcription reaction 2.4 pmol/μl final concentration in reaction or 2.4 μM/primer . For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM .", "For PCR amplification, each amplicon reaction used a separate PCR Primer Mix PPM containing 1.5 μl of each 100 pmol/μl forward primer and 1.5 μl of each reverse primer 5.3-5.5 pmol/μl total primer in the PPM . 2 μl PPM was used per 25 μl PCR reaction = 0.5 pmol/μl in reaction = 500 nM . Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN .", "Viral nucleic acids were extracted from the original samples using QIAamp Viral RNA Mini kit QIAGEN . RNA 5 μl was reverse transcribed into cDNA using SuperScript III 200 U, Invitrogen , RT buffer 1X final concentration, Invitrogen , and 2 μl of FPM in 20 μl reactions. An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction.", "An aliquot of cDNA 5 μl was amplified in 35 cycles using Phusion Highfidelity PCR kit New England Biolabs and 2 μl of PPM in a 25 μl reaction. The PCR mixture was incubated at 98°C for 30 s, followed by 35 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 43°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 90s and a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp.", "Expected PCR products for each amplicon were approximately 1500 bp. PCR products from the two reactions for each sample were pooled for Illumina library preparation. Fig. 4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia.", "4 Mismatches between the rRT-PCR diagnostic primers and probes and their expected binding sites in the five genomes from Kenya and Zambia. 'Fwd primer' = Forward primer and 'Rev primer' = Reverse primer. Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection.", "Two rRT-PCR assays were used for HMPV detection. The colored bars in the figure indicate nucleotide differences mismatches between a three HMPV-A genomes and HMPV-A specific primers and probes targeting fusion gene, b two HMPV-B genomes and HMPV-B specific primers and probes also targeting fusion gene, and c all five genomes reported here and specific primers and probes targeting nucleoprotein gene. The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions.", "The sequences of the rRT-PCR primers and probes checked against the African HMPV genomes are listed in Additional file 7: Table S4 Illumina sequencing and data analysis Libraries were prepared using Nextera XT kit Illumina and pair-end sequencing 2 × 300 base pairs with the MiSeq Reagent V3 kit Illumina , following the manufacturer's instructions. The Nextera enzyme mix was used to simultaneously fragment input DNA and tag with universal adapters in a single tube reaction, followed by 12-cycle PCR reaction for dual indexing. Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent .", "Agencourt AMPure XP beads Beckman Coulter were used for all purification steps and libraries were quantified and quality-checked using the Qubit Thermo Fisher and Bioanalyzer Agilent . Adapter trimming, quality filtering, kmer normalization of sequencing reads, de novo assembly, calculation of mean genome coverage was as previously described . A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally.", "A dataset of HMPV genome sequences was retrieved from ViPR in order to infer relationship between HMPV viruses from Kenya and Zambia and viral populations sampled globally. The dataset included 138 sequence entries > 13,000 nt that included date year and location of sample Table S3 . Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'.", "Sequence alignment was done using MAFFT v.7.221 using the parameters 'localpair -maxiterate 1000'. IQ-TREE was used to infer maximum likelihood ML trees of the complete genome and individual genes under general time-reversible GTR substitution model with gamma-distributed among-site rate heterogeneity. A summary of the methodology outlined here is depicted in Fig. 5 ." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Viral etiologies of respiratory tract infections RTIs have been less studied in adult than in pediatric populations. Furthermore, the ability of PCR/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS to detect enteroviruses and rhinoviruses in respiratory samples has not been well evaluated. We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses.", "We sought to use PCR/ESI-MS to comprehensively investigate the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs, including testing for rhinoviruses and enteroviruses. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs from 267 adults with acute RTIs 212 upper RTIs and 55 lower RTIs who visited a local clinic or the outpatient or emergency departments of a medical center in Taiwan between October 2012 and June 2013 were tested for respiratory viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Throat swabs from 15 patients with bacterial infections and 27 individuals without active infections were included as control samples. Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively.", "Respiratory viruses were found in 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% of the 267 cases by virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods, respectively. When both methods were used, the influenza A virus 24.3% and rhinoviruses 9.4% were the most frequently identified viruses, whereas human coronaviruses, human metapneumovirus hMPV , enteroviruses, adenoviruses, respiratory syncytial virus, and parainfluenza viruses were identified in small proportions of cases <5% of cases for each type of virus . Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases.", "Coinfection was observed in 4.1% of cases. In the control group, only 1 2.4% sample tested positive for a respiratory virus by PCR/ESI-MS. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, patients with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for noninfluenza respiratory virus infection. Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs.", "Rhinoviruses 12.7% , influenza A virus 10.9% , and parainfluenza viruses 7.3% were the most common viruses involved in the 55 cases of lower RTIs. The factors of parainfluenza infection, old age, and immunosuppression were independently associated with lower RTIs. In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs.", "In conclusion, PCR/ESI-MS improved the diagnostic yield for viral RTIs. Non-influenza respiratory virus infections were associated with patients with comorbidities and with lower RTIs. Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted.", "Additional studies that delineate the clinical need for including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted. Text: V iral respiratory tract infections RTIs in humans occur throughout the year and represent a major cause of clinical visits worldwide. In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs .", "In the past, the viral causes of RTIs were largely unknown, primarily due to the insensitivity of culturebased methods for the detection of viruses or to the narrow spectrum of viral detection using singleplex nucleic acid tests NATs . Recently, the development of multiplex respiratory NATs has allowed for the simultaneous, rapid, and sensitive detection of multiple viruses, which facilitates comprehensive studies regarding the epidemiology of viral RTIs. Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world.", "Currently, the viral epidemiology of RTIs has been studied more extensively among pediatric populations compared with adult populations throughout the world. 1 Similarly, most studies describing the viral etiology of respiratory illness in Taiwan, a subtropical country in Eastern Asia, were limited to pediatric populations. Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV .", "Thus, studies among adult patients are lacking, particularly regarding infections due to fastidious or newly identified viruses, such as human metapneumovirus hMPV and human coronavirus hCoV . Overlapping clinical presentations shared by different respiratory viruses make differential diagnoses difficult to perform based solely on the clinical parameters. 5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections.", "5 Moreover, effective antiviral agents are currently restricted to influenza virus infections. Hence, a better understanding of the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs would aid the future design of diagnostic strategies, infection control, and patient management. Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses.", "Among the various multiplex NATs, multilocus polymerase chain reaction coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry PCR/ESI-MS can simultaneously identify and subtype multiple respiratory viruses. Despite the diagnostic potential, the ability of PCR/ESI-MS to detect human enterovirus and rhinovirus in respiratory samples from patients with RTIs has not been well evaluated. Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels.", "Previous PCR/ESI-MS studies in patients with RTIs did not include these 2 viruses in the diagnostic panels. Here, we expanded upon these previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "We aimed to comprehensively investigate the epidemiology of adult viral RTIs using PCR/ESI-MS and compare the diagnostic performance between PCR/ESI-MS and conventional culture methods for identifying multiple, clinically relevant, respiratory viruses, including enterovirus and rhinovirus. To conduct a comprehensive epidemiologic study that included patients with and without comorbidity, we enrolled adults of at least 18 yr of age with acute RTIs within 7 days of onset who were treated at a local outpatient clinic of YC hospital or the outpatient or emergency departments of National Cheng-Kung University Hospital NCKUH , a university-affiliated medical center in southern Taiwan, between October 2012 and June 2013. Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough.", "Acute RTI was defined as the simultaneous occurrence of at least 1 respiratory symptom or sign new or worsening cough, sputum production, sore throat, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, dyspnea, wheezing, or injected tonsils and at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, chills, and cough. Lower RTI LRTI was defined as the presence of acute RTI and a new infiltrate on chest radiograph. For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes.", "For patients experiencing more than 1 episode of RTI, the most recent episode was counted as separate only if the patient fully recovered from the previous episode and there was a least a 3-week interval between the onset of the 2 episodes. Clinical, laboratory, and radiological data and the contact history of each patient were retrieved. Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI .", "Comorbidities were assessed in all patients based on the Charlson comorbidity index CCI . 10 Steroid use was defined as the receipt of corticosteroid treatment 10 mg prednisolone or an equivalent daily dosage for more than 2 weeks. An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months.", "An immunocompromised state was diagnosed if the patients met one of the following conditions: corticosteroid treatment, solid organ or hematopoietic stem cell recipient, or chemotherapy for an underlying malignancy during the past 6 months. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained from all patients and collected in transport medium, as previously described. 11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection.", "11 for virus detection and identification by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS. Clinical specimens were stored at 48C and transported to the study sites within 24 hours of collection. Throat swabs from 42 cases without respiratory infections during the month prior to enrollment were included as control samples for PCR/ESI-MS analysis, including 15 patients with exclusively bacterial infections documented cases of bacteremia or urinary tract infection who were admitted to NCKUH and 27 individuals without active infections. These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire.", "These subjects without active infections included 10 patients with stable chronic diseases followed up in NCKUH clinics and 17 healthy individuals whose medical information was collected using a clinical questionnaire. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board B-ER-101-031 of the study hospital, and all patients provided informed consent. Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV .", "Respiratory specimens were inoculated onto appropriate tissue cultures Madin-Darby canine kidney, MRC-5, A549, and rhabdomyosarcoma to isolate human influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, genus Enterovirus, cytomegalovirus CMV , adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , herpes simplex viruses 1 and 2 HSV-1 and -2 , and varicella zoster virus VZV . The isolation and identification of viruses were performed using a previously described method 11 and enteroviruses were identified by a immunofluorescence assay using a Chemicon Pan EV mix that cross-reacts with rhinovirus Light Diagnostics, Chemicon Millipore , MA . 11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis.", "11, 12 Virus Detection and Identification by PCR/ESI-MS Total nucleic acids were extracted from 700 mL of swab samples using a nucleic acid autoextractor MagNA Pure Compact Instrument, Mannheim, Germany , and the eluate was stored at À808C until analysis. During the analyses, the extracted nucleic acids were added to both a PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay plate and a PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay plate PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois . The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8.", "The PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay detects human adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza A and B, parainfluenza types 1 to 3, and RSV, 6 whereas the PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay detects human adenovirus, enterovirus, rhinovirus, BK and JC polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-1 and -2, VZV, Epstein-Barr virus EBV , CMV, and human herpesvirus HHV -8. 13, 14 In this study, respiratory viruses refer to adenovirus, hCoV, hMPV, influenza, parainfluenza, RSV, enterovirus, and rhinovirus. Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours.", "Nucleic acid amplification and analyses of PCR products were conducted using the PCR/ESI-MS platform PLEX-ID, Abbott Laboratories following the manufacturer's instructions, with test turnaround time from sample to result within 6 to 8 hours. 8, 13 The PCR/ESI-MS analyses included automated PCR desalting, ESI-MS signal acquisition, spectral analysis, and data reporting. Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer.", "Organism identification was based on the total mass and base compositions of the PCR amplicons compared with those in the molecular signature database established by the PLEX-ID manufacturer. 6, 8, 13, 14 Samples in which PCR/ESI-MS results disagreed with culture results at the species level were reexamined by a second molecular method. For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search.", "For enteroviruses, rhinovirus was differentiated from enterovirus using a conventional PCR sequencing analysis with the previously described primers Rhinovirus s1 and as and a BLAST search. 15 All analyses were performed with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 17.0 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL . Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test.", "Continuous variables were expressed as mean values AE standard deviations and were compared using the analysis of variance test. Categorical variables were compared using the Fisher exact test or x 2 test. All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis.", "All biologically plausible variables with a P value 0.10 in the univariate analysis were considered for inclusion in the logistic regression model for the multivariate analysis. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant, and all tests were 2-tailed. During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments .", "During the 9-month study period, a total of 267 episodes of acute RTIs from 263 patients were recorded, including 96 episodes at a local clinic and 171 episodes at NCKUH 19 outpatient and 152 in the emergency departments . For convenience, each episode was counted as 1 case. Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively.", "Overall, 123 46.1% cases were male patients, and 152 56.9% , 60 22.5% , and 55 20.6% patients were 18 to 39, 40 to 59, and !60 years of age, respectively. Two-hundred and twelve 79.4% patients presented with upper RTIs URTIs , and 55 20.6% cases presented with LRTIs. Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 .", "Compared with patients attending the local clinic, patients attending the medical care center were older and had more comorbidities Table 1 . The detailed demographic data of the 267 RTI cases and 42 control cases are presented in Table 1 . All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 .", "All 267 respiratory samples from each RTI case were examined for viruses by both virus isolation and PCR/ESI-MS, and the results are presented in Table 2 . For virus isolation, respiratory viruses were detected in 63 23.6% cases, including influenza A 48 cases, 18.0% , enterovirus 13, 4.9% , and parainfluenza virus 2, 0.7% , and no coinfection was detected. Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples.", "Virus isolation identified additional parainfluenza type 3 and enterovirus infections that were not found by PCR/ESI-MS in 2 samples. By PCR/ESI-MS, respiratory viruses were detected in 126 cases 47.2% . Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2.", "Influenza A 65 cases, 24.3% was the most frequently identified virus, among which 36 13.5% cases were subtyped as pandemic H1N1/09 virus, 28 10.5% cases as seasonal H3N2 virus, and 1 case as influenza A matching both pandemic H1N1and seasonal H3N2. Genus Enterovirus 34, 12.7% was the second-most frequently detected virus, including rhinovirus 25, 9 .4% , enterovirus 8, 3.0% , and 1 culturenegative case matching for both rhinovirus and enterovirus. hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases.", "hCoV 13, 4 .9% , hMPV 10, 3.7% , adenovirus 6, 2.2% , RSV 6, 2.2% , and parainfluenza 4, 1.5% were detected in small proportions of cases. Simultaneous detection of more than 1 respiratory virus was observed in 11 4.1% patients, and rhinovirus 5 cases was most likely to be codetected with another respiratory virus Table 2 . Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses.", "Of note, 4 cultivated viruses identified as enterovirus because of reactivity with the Chemicon Pan EV mix were characterized as rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. Further PCR-sequencing analysis of the 4 clinical specimens confirmed the existence of rhinoviruses but not enteroviruses. PCR/ESI-MS identified additional respiratory viruses in 65 culture-negative samples, mostly rhinovirus 21 samples , and a second respiratory virus in 3 culture-positive influenza A samples. Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively.", "Overall, the positive detection rates for any respiratory virus by culture, PCR/ESI-MS, and both methods were 23.6%, 47.2%, and 47.9% 128/267 , respectively. Of 61 specimens positive by both methods, PCR/ESI-MS and culture methods reached levels of agreement of 100% at the species level for influenza and parainfluenza and 100% at the genus level for the genus Enterovirus. In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group.", "In the control group, only 1 2.4% healthy individual tested positive for a respiratory virus rhinovirus by PCR/ESI-MS. With respect to herpesviruses, PCR/ESI-MS identified EBV, HSV-1, CMV, and VZV in 128 47.9% , 25 9.4% , 7 2.6% , and 2 0.7% samples from RTI cases, with similar detection rates observed in the control group. There was no detection of polyomavirus, parvovirus B19, HSV-2, or HHV-8 virus in samples from cases with RTIs or the control group. Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed.", "Cases that tested positive for any respiratory virus either by culture or by PCR/ESI-MS were analyzed. The positive detection rates declined with age: 55.3%, 41.7%, and 34.5% in the 18-39, 40-59, and !60-year-old groups, respectively P ¼ 0.02 Figure 1A . A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B .", "A higher positivity rate was observed in patients with URTIs than that in patients with LRTIs 50.5% vs. 38.2%, P ¼ 0.10 Table 3 and Figure 1B . There were similar distributions of respiratory viruses in cases from the local clinical and the medical center Table 2 , and between patients from the 3 age groups Figure 1A . Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 .", "Of 128 cases with identifiable respiratory viruses, non-influenza virus infection was more common in patients with LRTIs than those with URTIs 81.0% 17/21 vs. 48.6% 52/107 , P ¼ 0.007 . Rhinovirus 12.7% , influenza A 10.9% , and parainfluenza 7.3% were the 3 leading respiratory viruses involved in 55 cases of LRTIs, and parainfluenza was more frequently observed in the LRTI group than in the URTI group Table 3 and Figure 1B . There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period.", "There was no seasonal variation in any individual respiratory virus over the 9-month period. Of 128 patients with identifiable respiratory viruses, univariate analysis revealed that patients with 1 of the following conditions were more likely to have non-influenza respiratory virus infections: immunocompromised state, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease COPD , and chronic renal failure receiving dialysis OR 5.4, 95% CI 1.2-25.5, P ¼ 0.02 . Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI.", "Multivariate analysis demonstrated that steroid use was an independent risk factor for rhinovirus infection OR 15.3, 95% CI 1.5-154.7, P ¼ 0.02 , active malignancy was an independent risk factor for hMPV infection OR 29.3, 95% CI 2.4-358.1, P ¼ 0.008 , and COPD was an independent risk factor for parainfluenza infection OR 229.2, 95% CI 10.5-5020.8, While comparing the URTI and LRTI groups, factors found to be associated with LRTI by univariate analysis included old age !60 years , a high comorbidity index, congestive heart failure, COPD, malignancy, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza or EBV, whereas detection of influenza A was less frequently associated with LRTI. Codetection of respiratory virus was not associated with the development of LRTI. By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 .", "By multivariate analysis, only old age, immunocompromised state, and detection of parainfluenza remained 3 independent factors associated with LRTI Table 3 . Among the 117 episodes of single respiratory virus infections, arthralgia was more frequently observed in influenza A infections than in non-influenza infections 66.1% 39/59 vs. 46.6% 27/58 , P ¼ 0.033 ; for these 2 types of infections, the other examined symptoms, including sore throat, rhinorrhea, cough, purulent sputum, wheezing, dyspnea, and headache, were detected at similar frequencies. Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses.", "Of 55 cases of LRTIs, coinfection with bacterial pathogens by sputum culture or blood culture was found in 3 8.8% of 34 patients who tested positive for respiratory viruses and in 2 9.5% of 21 patients who tested negative for respiratory viruses. Four of 6 cases of influenza A LRTI had received oseltamivir. Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus.", "Two patients died of pneumonia and the worsening of an underlying malignancy; 1 of these patients tested positive for hMPV, and the other patient tested negative for a respiratory virus. Four Our study of the viral epidemiology of adult acute RTI using PCR/ESI-MS technology has 3 major advantages. First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection.", "First, we expanded on previous studies utilizing PCR/ESI-MS for respiratory virus detection. The PLEX-ID Broad Viral I assay, which targets enterovirus, rhinovirus, herpesviruses, JC and BK polyomaviruses, and parvovirus B19, and the PLEX-ID Respiratory Virus assay tests were both adopted for the detection of multiple clinically relevant respiratory viruses. Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses.", "Second, 2 control groups patients with exclusively bacterial infections and individuals without active infections were enrolled to eliminate false-positive artifacts of NATs and estimate the prevalence of detectable asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, this study enrolled immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients visiting a local clinic or a medical center who presented with an URTI or LRTI, which reflects the true viral epidemiology of adult RTIs. By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods.", "By supplementing the conventional culture method with PCR/ESI-MS, a 2-fold increase in the respiratory virus detection rate was achieved, from 23.6% by culture alone to 47.9% by a combination of both methods. Diagnostic gain was observed for both culturable viruses, especially rhinovirus, and fastidious viruses. Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% .", "Although we did not compare an alternative NAT due to sample volume limitations, it has been reported that PCR/ ESI-MS has a high sensitivity 92.9-100% and specificity 99-100% for variable respiratory virus detection relative to immunologic and PCR-based methods as gold standard assays, with the exception of parainfluenza sensitivity 63.4% . 6 Coincidentally, we found that parainfluenza type 3 was 1 of only 2 viruses that were not detected by PCR/ESI-MS. The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored.", "The potential causes contributing to the lower detection rate for parainfluenza remain to be explored. The positive detection rate 47.2% for respiratory viruses by PCR/ESI-MS in the present study was similar to those of parallel adult surveillance programs using NATs 43.2-57% . 5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus.", "5,16-18 but notably higher than an earlier study using the Ibis T5000 biosensor system the prototype of PCR-ESI/ MS using the respiratory virus surveillance II kit 35.9% , likely because the kit was not designed for the detection of enterovirus and rhinovirus. 8 Enterovirus and rhinovirus, both members of the Enterovirus genus, contributed to 13.1% of RTI cases in our study and 9.8-17.8% of adult cases in other studies. 5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated.", "5, 16, 17 Considering their prevalence, enterovirus and rhinovirus should be included in the diagnostic panels of respiratory viruses if comprehensive viral detection is indicated. The codetection rate 4.1% was within the range of 2.0-7.2% that has been reported elsewhere. 5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year.", "5, 16, 17 and rhinovirus was the virus most frequently involved in coinfections, probably due to its high prevalence throughout the year. 18 Influenza A and rhinovirus were the 2 most frequently detected respiratory viruses, whereas hCoV, hMPV, enterovirus, adenovirus, RSV, and parainfluenza were detected in small proportions of cases. This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups.", "This finding is similar to the viral epidemiology of adult RTIs observed by other study groups. 5, 16, 17 The similar distributions of viruses between cases from a local clinic and a medical center and between patients of the 3 age groups suggest that individuals of all age groups are susceptible to multiple respiratory viruses that simultaneously circulate in the community. A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses.", "A lower positive detection rate was observed in the elderly population, probably because older adult patients shed lower titers of viruses. 19 However, the roles of EBV, HSV-1, and CMV in adult RTIs remain incompletely 20 Moreover, the univariate association between EBV and LRTIs observed in this study may have been caused by the confounding factor of age, particularly given that old age was identified as an independent factor for EBV detection data not shown . The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence.", "The lack of detection of BK and JC polyomavirus or parvovirus B19 implies that these viruses play a minor role in adult RTIs and that oropharyngeal cells are not involved in BK and JC polyomavirus persistence. 21 Furthermore, the low positive detection rate for respiratory viruses in the control group suggests a low possibility of false-positive artifacts in PCR/ESI-MS or a lower rate of asymptomatic colonization of respiratory viruses. In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses.", "In addition to the advantage of sensitive detection, PCR/ ESI-MS possesses the capability of simultaneous subtype identification of respiratory viruses. 22 In this study, influenza A viruses were subtyped as pandemic H1N1 influenza A and seasonal H3N2 influenza. In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season.", "In Europe, both viruses cocirculated in the community in the 2012-2013 influenza season. 23 In the genus Enterovirus, acid-labile rhinovirus can be differentiated from enterovirus using an acid lability test. 24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study.", "24 while PCR/ESI-MS can rapidly differentiate the 2 species in a single test, as demonstrated in our study. The 13 hCoVs were subtyped as hCoV-OC43, -229E, and -HKU1, which was further validated by conventional PCR-sequencing assays data not shown . The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China.", "The newly identified HCoV-NL63 was not detected during the study period, and a low detection rate <1% was reported in China. 16 Our understanding of the roles of non-influenza respiratory viruses in patients with comorbidities or LRTIs has been strengthened in our study. Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively.", "Patients who were undergoing steroid treatment, had an active malignancy, or suffered from COPD were at risk for rhinovirus, hMPV, or parainfluenza infections, respectively. Overall, immunocompromised patients, those with COPD, and patients receiving dialysis were at risk for non-influenza respiratory virus infection. Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs.", "Non-influenza virus infections were also more frequently involved in LRTIs than in URTIs. Among LRTIs, rhinovirus and parainfluenza were ranked as the first-and third-most common pathogens, respectively, and parainfluenza was an independent factor associated with LRTIs, a finding consistent with prior reports that both viruses are significant causes of LRTIs. 18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection.", "18, On the other hand, despite an increasing role of non-influenza respiratory viruses, currently available antiviral agents and vaccines primarily target influenza infection. Although viral RTI is a self-limited illness, as observed in the majority of our patients with LRTIs who recovered from illness without the aid of antiviral agents, a definite etiological diagnosis can help to reduce the unwarranted use of anti-influenza agents or antimicrobials and/or unnecessary hospitalizations, and provide useful information for the control of RTIs. However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously.", "However, we observed that clinical differentiation of influenza infection from other respiratory virus infections is difficult due to overlapping symptoms, as described previously. 5 Collectively, the association of non-influenza virus infection with patients with comorbidities or LRTIs reported here suggests that a complete respiratory viral panel would be appropriate in the diagnostic work-up for RTIs in these populations. The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization.", "The additional costs incurred by the use of a complete panel of PCR/ESI-MS-based assessments or other molecular tests would likely be offset by the accompanying reductions in unnecessary antimicrobial therapy and/or hospitalization. 18 Our study has some limitations. First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels.", "First, parainfluenza type 4 and 3 newly identified respiratory viruses, human bocavirus, human polyomavirus KI and WU polyomavirus were not included in the panels. and their roles in adult RTIs in Taiwan are unclear. Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored.", "Second, although certain risk factors for specific virus infections, such as hMPV or parainfluenza infections, have been identified, these associations should be re-examined in additional largescale clinical studies, and the clinical impact and underlying mechanisms of these associations should be explored. Similarly, more control cases may be needed to better estimate the prevalence of asymptomatic carriers of respiratory viruses. Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated.", "Third, only 3 seasons were covered, and the seasonality of viral respiratory infections could not be demonstrated. In conclusion, compared with virus isolation, PCR/ESI-MS produced a greater diagnostic yield for viral RTIs, with a low possibility of false-positive artifacts. Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs.", "Non-influenza respiratory virus infection was significantly associated with patients with comorbidities and with LRTIs. Additional studies to delineate the clinical need for and economic benefits of including non-influenza respiratory viruses in the diagnostic work-up in these populations are warranted." ]

[ "Massive studies have indicated that long non-coding RNAs lncRNAs are critical for the regulation of cellular biological processes by binding with RNA-related proteins. However, only a few experimentally supported lncRNA-protein associations have been reported. Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs.", "Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs. Considering the limitations in previous methods, we propose PLPIHS, an effective computational method for Predicting lncRNA-Protein Interactions using HeteSim Scores. PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network.", "PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network. An SVM classifier to predict lncRNA-protein interactions is built with the HeteSim scores. The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test.", "The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test. We also compare the performances of networks with different connectivity density and find that PLPIHS performs well across all the networks. Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1.", "Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1. Highly-ranked proteins are verified by the biological studies and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information.", "Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information. New emerged methods, including the Katz method 20 , Combining dATa Across species using Positive-Unlabeled Learning Techniques CATAPULT 19 , Random Walk with Restart RWR 21 , and LncRNA-protein Interaction prediction based on Heterogeneous Network model LPIHN 22 , have extended the association from just direct protein interactions to more distant connections in various ways. The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes.", "The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes. CATAPULT 19 is a supervised machine learning method that uses a biased support vector machine where the features are derived from walks in a heterogeneous gene-trait network. RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves.", "RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves. LPIHN 22 is a network-based method by implement a random walk on a heterogeneous network. PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information.", "PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information. Compared with LPIHN and RWR, PRINCE propagates information in a smaller network but contains more connotative meaning when build the initial probability values and has made great performance in gene prioritization 23 and disease identification 24 . However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths.", "However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths. In this paper, we adopt a method named HeteSim, which is a path-based measure to calculate the relevance between objects in heterogeneous network 25 . The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects.", "The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects. Considering the relatedness of heterogeneous objects is path-constrained, HeteSim gives a uniform and symmetric measure for arbitrary paths to evaluate the relatedness of heterogeneous object pair same or different types with one single score. Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure.", "Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure. An example of HeteSim score is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively.", "The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively. The walk count between A and C is larger than B and C, which might indicate that A is more closer to C than B. But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig.", "But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig. 2 to predict lncRNA-Protein interactions using HeteSim scores. We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate the score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the network. A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths.", "A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths. We compare our PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS outperforms the other methods in many performance measures. Validation measures. LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 .", "LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 . We leave a known lncRNA-protein pair in turn as the test sample and all the other known lncRNA-protein pairs are regarded as training samples. In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round.", "In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round. Receiver Operating Characteristic ROC curve 27 is used to evaluate the prediction performance, which plots true-positive rate TPR, sensitivity or recall versus false-positive rate FPR, 1-specificity at different rank cutoffs. When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR.", "When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR. In this way, ROC curve is drawn and the area under the curve AUC is calculated as well. For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure.", "For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure. Affection of network preprocessing characteristics. In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein.", "In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein. Thus, the paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six is listed in Table 1 . In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig.", "In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig. 3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′.", "3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′. Path 1′~14′ obtains the best performance across all measures, which means that the path with length greater than three contains more significant meanings. The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths.", "The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths. The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β.", "Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β. Table 2 shows that β has tiny impact on the final results and β = 0.2, 0.4 and 0.7 achieved the best AUC score and the others are not far behind yet. To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The results are shown in Fig. 4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks.", "4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks. The AUC score of the 0.5 network is higher than that of others while the 0.9 network outperforms others in ACC, SEN, MCC and F1-Score. This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 .", "This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 . The paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six. the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments.", "the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments. The parameter r is set as 0.5 in this comparison. In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure.", "In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure. We extract 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the 0.9 network as positive samples, the same number of negative samples are chosen randomly from the 0.3 network as well, avoiding the error caused by imbalance dataset. The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well.", "The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well. In the lncRNA protein prioritization, each lncRNA-protein interaction is utilized as the test set in turn and the remaining associations are used as training data. The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset.", "The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset. ROC curve is drawn based on true positive rate TPR and false positive rate FPR at different thresholds. The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance.", "The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance. AUC = 1 demonstrates the perfect performance and AUC = 0.5 demonstrates the random performance.The ROC curve of PLPIHS, LPIHS, PRINCE and RWR are plotted in Fig. 5 .", "5 . The results show that the AUC score of PLPIHS in 0.3 network is 96.8%, which is higher than that of PRINCE, LPIHN and RWR, achieving an AUC value of 81.3%, 88.4% and 79.2%, respectively. Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well.", "Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well. Performance evaluation by independent test. For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set.", "For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set. Since the existing network based methods is not suitable for independent test, we only evaluate the performance for the proposed PLPIHS. The independent test results are shown in Fig.", "The independent test results are shown in Fig. 6 , an AUC score of 0.879 is achieved by PLPIHS, illustrating the effectiveness and advantage of the proposed approach. Case Studies. By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV.", "By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV. We applied PLPIHS onto the 2000 known lncRNA-protein associations, which includes 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to infer novel lncRNA-protein interactions. As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig.", "As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig. 5 is achieved using the three networks of different connectivity density, which demonstrate that our proposed method is effective in recovering known lncRNA-related proteins. To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined.", "To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined. MALAT1 is a long non-coding RNA which is over-expressed in many human oncogenic tissues and regulates cell cycle and survival 31 . MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression.", "MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression. A large amount of evidence indicates that MALAT1 also closely relates to various pathological processes, including diabetes complications, cancers and so on 32, 33 . MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 .", "MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 . We construct the interaction networks of lncRNA MALAT1 by using the prediction results of these four methods Fig. 7 .", "7 . Among the 68 known lncRNA-protein interactions, PLPIHS wrongly predicts 6 interactions, while 13 associations are predicted mistakenly by PRINCE and RWR method and 15 lncRNA-protein pairs are falsely predicted by the LPIHN method. We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists.", "We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists. For example, In the investigation of colorectal cancer CRC , MALAT1 could bind to SFPQ, thus releasing PTBP2 from the SFPQ/PTBP2 complex and the interaction between MALAT1 and SFPQ could be a novel therapeutic target for CRC 35 . MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 .", "MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 . And it is also as target of TARDBP to play the biological performance and found that TDP-43 bound to long ncRNAs in highly sequence-specific manner in tissue from subjects with or without FTLD-TDP, the MALAT1 ncRNA recruits splicing factors to nuclear speckles and affects phosphorylation of serine/arginine-rich splicing factor proteins 37, 38 . All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins.", "All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins. LncRNAs are involved in a wide range of biological functions through diverse molecular mechanisms often including the interaction with one or more protein partners 12, 13 . Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized.", "Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized. Computational methods can be helpful in suggesting potential interactions for possible experimentation 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network.", "In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network. The importance of inferring novel lncRNA-protein interactions by considering the subtle semantic meanings of different paths in the heterogeneous network have been verified 39 . We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate a score for each lncRNA-protein pairs in each path. Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions. We compare the proposed PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS obtain an AUC score of 0.9679 in 0.3 network, which is significantly higher than PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN 0.813, 0.884 and 0.7918, respectively . We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density.", "We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density. As a result, PLPIHS outperforms the other method across all the networks. Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively.", "Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively. And the top-ranked lncRNA-protein interactions predicted by our method are supported by existing literatures. The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions.", "The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions. Methods lncRNA-Protein associations. All human lncRNA genes and protein-coding genes are downloaded from the GENCODE Release 24 9 . A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted.", "A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted. To obtain genome-wide lncRNA and protein-coding gene associations, we combine three sources of data: • Co-expression data from COXPRESdb 40 . Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb.", "Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb. The correlations are calculated as follows: where C l, p is the overall correlation between gene l lncRNA and protein-coding gene p, C d l, p is the correlation score between l and p in dataset d, D is the number of gene pairs l and p with positive correlation scores. Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed.", "Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed. • Co-expression data from ArrayExpress 41 and GEO 42 . We obtained the co-expresionn data from the work of Jiang et al. 43 . RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 .", "RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 . TopHat and Cufflinks with the default parameters are used to calculate the expression values. Pearson's correlation coefficients are used to evaluate the co-expression of lncRNA-protein pairs. • lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions.", "• lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions. We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining.", "We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining. The confidence scores are computed by combining the probabilities from the different evidence channels, correcting for the probability of randomly observing an interaction. The HeteSim measure.", "The HeteSim measure. The HeteSim measure is a uniform and symmetric relevance measure. It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 .", "It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 . Further, the HeteSim score has some good properties i.e., selfmaximum and symmetric , which have achieved positive performance in many studies 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins.", "In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins. Definition 1 Transition probability matrix 39 L and P are two kinds of object in the heterogeneous network, I LP n*m is an adjacent matrix between L and P, then the normalized matrix of I LP along the row vector is defined as LP LP k m LP 1 Definition 2 Reachable probability matrix 39 In a heterogeneous network, the reachable probability matrix R  for path = +  PP P n 1 2 1  of length n, where P i belongs to any objects in the heterogeneous network, can be expressed as P P P P P P n n 1 2 2 3 1  Based on the definitions above, the steps of calculating HeteSim scores between two kinds of objects lncRNA and protein can be presented as follows: • Split the path into two parts. When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths.", "When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths. In order to deal with such problem, we need to split the path twice by setting , respectively. Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores.", "Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores. • Achieve the transition probability matrix and reachable probability matrix under the path L  and R  . • Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  .", "• Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  . An example of calculating HeteSim score is indicated in Fig. 8 . We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network.", "We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network. The simplified steps of computing HeteSim score between l3 and p2 under the path  = LTP is as follows: • Split the path  into two components  = LT • Given the adjacent matrix I LT and I TP below, which means the interactions between lncRNAs and proteins, we can obtain the transition probability matrix T LT and T TP by normalizing the two matrix along the row vector. The PLPIHS method.", "The PLPIHS method. Among a heterogeneous network, different paths can express different semantic meanings. For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings.", "For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings. The former means that if a lncRNA is associated with a protein, then another lncRNA similar to the lncRNA will be potential associated with the protein. The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA.", "The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA. Therefore, the potential information hidden in each path is extraordinary essential to be taken into account during prediction. The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 .", "The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 . Firstly, we construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The larger cutoff is, the network is more sparse. A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3.", "A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3. We randomly take out 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to construct a smaller network for the following experiments in consideration of computing costs. The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network.", "The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network. Table 1 . We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' .", "We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' . Next, we calculate the heteSim score for each lncRNA-protein pair under each path. The results of different paths are used as different features.", "The results of different paths are used as different features. And we combine a constant factor β to inhibit the influence of longer paths.The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations. On the account of the HeteSim measure is based on the path-based relevance framework 39 , it can effectively dig out the subtle semantics of each paths." ]

[ "Massive studies have indicated that long non-coding RNAs lncRNAs are critical for the regulation of cellular biological processes by binding with RNA-related proteins. However, only a few experimentally supported lncRNA-protein associations have been reported. Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs.", "Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs. Considering the limitations in previous methods, we propose PLPIHS, an effective computational method for Predicting lncRNA-Protein Interactions using HeteSim Scores. PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network.", "PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network. An SVM classifier to predict lncRNA-protein interactions is built with the HeteSim scores. The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test.", "The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test. We also compare the performances of networks with different connectivity density and find that PLPIHS performs well across all the networks. Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1.", "Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1. Highly-ranked proteins are verified by the biological studies and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information.", "Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information. New emerged methods, including the Katz method 20 , Combining dATa Across species using Positive-Unlabeled Learning Techniques CATAPULT 19 , Random Walk with Restart RWR 21 , and LncRNA-protein Interaction prediction based on Heterogeneous Network model LPIHN 22 , have extended the association from just direct protein interactions to more distant connections in various ways. The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes.", "The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes. CATAPULT 19 is a supervised machine learning method that uses a biased support vector machine where the features are derived from walks in a heterogeneous gene-trait network. RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves.", "RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves. LPIHN 22 is a network-based method by implement a random walk on a heterogeneous network. PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information.", "PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information. Compared with LPIHN and RWR, PRINCE propagates information in a smaller network but contains more connotative meaning when build the initial probability values and has made great performance in gene prioritization 23 and disease identification 24 . However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths.", "However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths. In this paper, we adopt a method named HeteSim, which is a path-based measure to calculate the relevance between objects in heterogeneous network 25 . The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects.", "The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects. Considering the relatedness of heterogeneous objects is path-constrained, HeteSim gives a uniform and symmetric measure for arbitrary paths to evaluate the relatedness of heterogeneous object pair same or different types with one single score. Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure.", "Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure. An example of HeteSim score is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively.", "The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively. The walk count between A and C is larger than B and C, which might indicate that A is more closer to C than B. But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig.", "But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig. 2 to predict lncRNA-Protein interactions using HeteSim scores. We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate the score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the network. A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths.", "A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths. We compare our PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS outperforms the other methods in many performance measures. Validation measures. LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 .", "LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 . We leave a known lncRNA-protein pair in turn as the test sample and all the other known lncRNA-protein pairs are regarded as training samples. In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round.", "In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round. Receiver Operating Characteristic ROC curve 27 is used to evaluate the prediction performance, which plots true-positive rate TPR, sensitivity or recall versus false-positive rate FPR, 1-specificity at different rank cutoffs. When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR.", "When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR. In this way, ROC curve is drawn and the area under the curve AUC is calculated as well. For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure.", "For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure. Affection of network preprocessing characteristics. In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein.", "In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein. Thus, the paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six is listed in Table 1 . In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig.", "In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig. 3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′.", "3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′. Path 1′~14′ obtains the best performance across all measures, which means that the path with length greater than three contains more significant meanings. The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths.", "The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths. The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β.", "Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β. Table 2 shows that β has tiny impact on the final results and β = 0.2, 0.4 and 0.7 achieved the best AUC score and the others are not far behind yet. To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The results are shown in Fig. 4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks.", "4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks. The AUC score of the 0.5 network is higher than that of others while the 0.9 network outperforms others in ACC, SEN, MCC and F1-Score. This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 .", "This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 . The paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six. the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments.", "the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments. The parameter r is set as 0.5 in this comparison. In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure.", "In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure. We extract 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the 0.9 network as positive samples, the same number of negative samples are chosen randomly from the 0.3 network as well, avoiding the error caused by imbalance dataset. The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well.", "The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well. In the lncRNA protein prioritization, each lncRNA-protein interaction is utilized as the test set in turn and the remaining associations are used as training data. The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset.", "The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset. ROC curve is drawn based on true positive rate TPR and false positive rate FPR at different thresholds. The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance.", "The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance. AUC = 1 demonstrates the perfect performance and AUC = 0.5 demonstrates the random performance.The ROC curve of PLPIHS, LPIHS, PRINCE and RWR are plotted in Fig. 5 .", "5 . The results show that the AUC score of PLPIHS in 0.3 network is 96.8%, which is higher than that of PRINCE, LPIHN and RWR, achieving an AUC value of 81.3%, 88.4% and 79.2%, respectively. Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well.", "Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well. Performance evaluation by independent test. For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set.", "For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set. Since the existing network based methods is not suitable for independent test, we only evaluate the performance for the proposed PLPIHS. The independent test results are shown in Fig.", "The independent test results are shown in Fig. 6 , an AUC score of 0.879 is achieved by PLPIHS, illustrating the effectiveness and advantage of the proposed approach. Case Studies. By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV.", "By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV. We applied PLPIHS onto the 2000 known lncRNA-protein associations, which includes 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to infer novel lncRNA-protein interactions. As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig.", "As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig. 5 is achieved using the three networks of different connectivity density, which demonstrate that our proposed method is effective in recovering known lncRNA-related proteins. To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined.", "To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined. MALAT1 is a long non-coding RNA which is over-expressed in many human oncogenic tissues and regulates cell cycle and survival 31 . MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression.", "MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression. A large amount of evidence indicates that MALAT1 also closely relates to various pathological processes, including diabetes complications, cancers and so on 32, 33 . MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 .", "MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 . We construct the interaction networks of lncRNA MALAT1 by using the prediction results of these four methods Fig. 7 .", "7 . Among the 68 known lncRNA-protein interactions, PLPIHS wrongly predicts 6 interactions, while 13 associations are predicted mistakenly by PRINCE and RWR method and 15 lncRNA-protein pairs are falsely predicted by the LPIHN method. We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists.", "We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists. For example, In the investigation of colorectal cancer CRC , MALAT1 could bind to SFPQ, thus releasing PTBP2 from the SFPQ/PTBP2 complex and the interaction between MALAT1 and SFPQ could be a novel therapeutic target for CRC 35 . MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 .", "MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 . And it is also as target of TARDBP to play the biological performance and found that TDP-43 bound to long ncRNAs in highly sequence-specific manner in tissue from subjects with or without FTLD-TDP, the MALAT1 ncRNA recruits splicing factors to nuclear speckles and affects phosphorylation of serine/arginine-rich splicing factor proteins 37, 38 . All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins.", "All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins. LncRNAs are involved in a wide range of biological functions through diverse molecular mechanisms often including the interaction with one or more protein partners 12, 13 . Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized.", "Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized. Computational methods can be helpful in suggesting potential interactions for possible experimentation 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network.", "In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network. The importance of inferring novel lncRNA-protein interactions by considering the subtle semantic meanings of different paths in the heterogeneous network have been verified 39 . We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate a score for each lncRNA-protein pairs in each path. Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions. We compare the proposed PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS obtain an AUC score of 0.9679 in 0.3 network, which is significantly higher than PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN 0.813, 0.884 and 0.7918, respectively . We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density.", "We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density. As a result, PLPIHS outperforms the other method across all the networks. Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively.", "Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively. And the top-ranked lncRNA-protein interactions predicted by our method are supported by existing literatures. The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions.", "The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions. Methods lncRNA-Protein associations. All human lncRNA genes and protein-coding genes are downloaded from the GENCODE Release 24 9 . A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted.", "A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted. To obtain genome-wide lncRNA and protein-coding gene associations, we combine three sources of data: • Co-expression data from COXPRESdb 40 . Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb.", "Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb. The correlations are calculated as follows: where C l, p is the overall correlation between gene l lncRNA and protein-coding gene p, C d l, p is the correlation score between l and p in dataset d, D is the number of gene pairs l and p with positive correlation scores. Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed.", "Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed. • Co-expression data from ArrayExpress 41 and GEO 42 . We obtained the co-expresionn data from the work of Jiang et al. 43 . RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 .", "RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 . TopHat and Cufflinks with the default parameters are used to calculate the expression values. Pearson's correlation coefficients are used to evaluate the co-expression of lncRNA-protein pairs. • lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions.", "• lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions. We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining.", "We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining. The confidence scores are computed by combining the probabilities from the different evidence channels, correcting for the probability of randomly observing an interaction. The HeteSim measure.", "The HeteSim measure. The HeteSim measure is a uniform and symmetric relevance measure. It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 .", "It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 . Further, the HeteSim score has some good properties i.e., selfmaximum and symmetric , which have achieved positive performance in many studies 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins.", "In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins. Definition 1 Transition probability matrix 39 L and P are two kinds of object in the heterogeneous network, I LP n*m is an adjacent matrix between L and P, then the normalized matrix of I LP along the row vector is defined as LP LP k m LP 1 Definition 2 Reachable probability matrix 39 In a heterogeneous network, the reachable probability matrix R  for path = +  PP P n 1 2 1  of length n, where P i belongs to any objects in the heterogeneous network, can be expressed as P P P P P P n n 1 2 2 3 1  Based on the definitions above, the steps of calculating HeteSim scores between two kinds of objects lncRNA and protein can be presented as follows: • Split the path into two parts. When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths.", "When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths. In order to deal with such problem, we need to split the path twice by setting , respectively. Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores.", "Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores. • Achieve the transition probability matrix and reachable probability matrix under the path L  and R  . • Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  .", "• Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  . An example of calculating HeteSim score is indicated in Fig. 8 . We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network.", "We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network. The simplified steps of computing HeteSim score between l3 and p2 under the path  = LTP is as follows: • Split the path  into two components  = LT • Given the adjacent matrix I LT and I TP below, which means the interactions between lncRNAs and proteins, we can obtain the transition probability matrix T LT and T TP by normalizing the two matrix along the row vector. The PLPIHS method.", "The PLPIHS method. Among a heterogeneous network, different paths can express different semantic meanings. For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings.", "For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings. The former means that if a lncRNA is associated with a protein, then another lncRNA similar to the lncRNA will be potential associated with the protein. The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA.", "The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA. Therefore, the potential information hidden in each path is extraordinary essential to be taken into account during prediction. The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 .", "The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 . Firstly, we construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The larger cutoff is, the network is more sparse. A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3.", "A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3. We randomly take out 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to construct a smaller network for the following experiments in consideration of computing costs. The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network.", "The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network. Table 1 . We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' .", "We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' . Next, we calculate the heteSim score for each lncRNA-protein pair under each path. The results of different paths are used as different features.", "The results of different paths are used as different features. And we combine a constant factor β to inhibit the influence of longer paths.The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations. On the account of the HeteSim measure is based on the path-based relevance framework 39 , it can effectively dig out the subtle semantics of each paths." ]

[ "Massive studies have indicated that long non-coding RNAs lncRNAs are critical for the regulation of cellular biological processes by binding with RNA-related proteins. However, only a few experimentally supported lncRNA-protein associations have been reported. Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs.", "Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs. Considering the limitations in previous methods, we propose PLPIHS, an effective computational method for Predicting lncRNA-Protein Interactions using HeteSim Scores. PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network.", "PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network. An SVM classifier to predict lncRNA-protein interactions is built with the HeteSim scores. The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test.", "The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test. We also compare the performances of networks with different connectivity density and find that PLPIHS performs well across all the networks. Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1.", "Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1. Highly-ranked proteins are verified by the biological studies and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information.", "Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information. New emerged methods, including the Katz method 20 , Combining dATa Across species using Positive-Unlabeled Learning Techniques CATAPULT 19 , Random Walk with Restart RWR 21 , and LncRNA-protein Interaction prediction based on Heterogeneous Network model LPIHN 22 , have extended the association from just direct protein interactions to more distant connections in various ways. The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes.", "The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes. CATAPULT 19 is a supervised machine learning method that uses a biased support vector machine where the features are derived from walks in a heterogeneous gene-trait network. RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves.", "RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves. LPIHN 22 is a network-based method by implement a random walk on a heterogeneous network. PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information.", "PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information. Compared with LPIHN and RWR, PRINCE propagates information in a smaller network but contains more connotative meaning when build the initial probability values and has made great performance in gene prioritization 23 and disease identification 24 . However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths.", "However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths. In this paper, we adopt a method named HeteSim, which is a path-based measure to calculate the relevance between objects in heterogeneous network 25 . The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects.", "The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects. Considering the relatedness of heterogeneous objects is path-constrained, HeteSim gives a uniform and symmetric measure for arbitrary paths to evaluate the relatedness of heterogeneous object pair same or different types with one single score. Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure.", "Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure. An example of HeteSim score is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively.", "The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively. The walk count between A and C is larger than B and C, which might indicate that A is more closer to C than B. But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig.", "But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig. 2 to predict lncRNA-Protein interactions using HeteSim scores. We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate the score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the network. A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths.", "A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths. We compare our PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS outperforms the other methods in many performance measures. Validation measures. LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 .", "LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 . We leave a known lncRNA-protein pair in turn as the test sample and all the other known lncRNA-protein pairs are regarded as training samples. In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round.", "In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round. Receiver Operating Characteristic ROC curve 27 is used to evaluate the prediction performance, which plots true-positive rate TPR, sensitivity or recall versus false-positive rate FPR, 1-specificity at different rank cutoffs. When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR.", "When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR. In this way, ROC curve is drawn and the area under the curve AUC is calculated as well. For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure.", "For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure. Affection of network preprocessing characteristics. In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein.", "In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein. Thus, the paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six is listed in Table 1 . In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig.", "In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig. 3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′.", "3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′. Path 1′~14′ obtains the best performance across all measures, which means that the path with length greater than three contains more significant meanings. The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths.", "The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths. The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β.", "Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β. Table 2 shows that β has tiny impact on the final results and β = 0.2, 0.4 and 0.7 achieved the best AUC score and the others are not far behind yet. To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The results are shown in Fig. 4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks.", "4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks. The AUC score of the 0.5 network is higher than that of others while the 0.9 network outperforms others in ACC, SEN, MCC and F1-Score. This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 .", "This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 . The paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six. the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments.", "the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments. The parameter r is set as 0.5 in this comparison. In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure.", "In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure. We extract 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the 0.9 network as positive samples, the same number of negative samples are chosen randomly from the 0.3 network as well, avoiding the error caused by imbalance dataset. The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well.", "The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well. In the lncRNA protein prioritization, each lncRNA-protein interaction is utilized as the test set in turn and the remaining associations are used as training data. The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset.", "The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset. ROC curve is drawn based on true positive rate TPR and false positive rate FPR at different thresholds. The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance.", "The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance. AUC = 1 demonstrates the perfect performance and AUC = 0.5 demonstrates the random performance.The ROC curve of PLPIHS, LPIHS, PRINCE and RWR are plotted in Fig. 5 .", "5 . The results show that the AUC score of PLPIHS in 0.3 network is 96.8%, which is higher than that of PRINCE, LPIHN and RWR, achieving an AUC value of 81.3%, 88.4% and 79.2%, respectively. Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well.", "Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well. Performance evaluation by independent test. For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set.", "For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set. Since the existing network based methods is not suitable for independent test, we only evaluate the performance for the proposed PLPIHS. The independent test results are shown in Fig.", "The independent test results are shown in Fig. 6 , an AUC score of 0.879 is achieved by PLPIHS, illustrating the effectiveness and advantage of the proposed approach. Case Studies. By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV.", "By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV. We applied PLPIHS onto the 2000 known lncRNA-protein associations, which includes 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to infer novel lncRNA-protein interactions. As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig.", "As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig. 5 is achieved using the three networks of different connectivity density, which demonstrate that our proposed method is effective in recovering known lncRNA-related proteins. To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined.", "To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined. MALAT1 is a long non-coding RNA which is over-expressed in many human oncogenic tissues and regulates cell cycle and survival 31 . MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression.", "MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression. A large amount of evidence indicates that MALAT1 also closely relates to various pathological processes, including diabetes complications, cancers and so on 32, 33 . MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 .", "MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 . We construct the interaction networks of lncRNA MALAT1 by using the prediction results of these four methods Fig. 7 .", "7 . Among the 68 known lncRNA-protein interactions, PLPIHS wrongly predicts 6 interactions, while 13 associations are predicted mistakenly by PRINCE and RWR method and 15 lncRNA-protein pairs are falsely predicted by the LPIHN method. We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists.", "We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists. For example, In the investigation of colorectal cancer CRC , MALAT1 could bind to SFPQ, thus releasing PTBP2 from the SFPQ/PTBP2 complex and the interaction between MALAT1 and SFPQ could be a novel therapeutic target for CRC 35 . MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 .", "MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 . And it is also as target of TARDBP to play the biological performance and found that TDP-43 bound to long ncRNAs in highly sequence-specific manner in tissue from subjects with or without FTLD-TDP, the MALAT1 ncRNA recruits splicing factors to nuclear speckles and affects phosphorylation of serine/arginine-rich splicing factor proteins 37, 38 . All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins.", "All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins. LncRNAs are involved in a wide range of biological functions through diverse molecular mechanisms often including the interaction with one or more protein partners 12, 13 . Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized.", "Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized. Computational methods can be helpful in suggesting potential interactions for possible experimentation 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network.", "In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network. The importance of inferring novel lncRNA-protein interactions by considering the subtle semantic meanings of different paths in the heterogeneous network have been verified 39 . We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate a score for each lncRNA-protein pairs in each path. Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions. We compare the proposed PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS obtain an AUC score of 0.9679 in 0.3 network, which is significantly higher than PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN 0.813, 0.884 and 0.7918, respectively . We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density.", "We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density. As a result, PLPIHS outperforms the other method across all the networks. Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively.", "Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively. And the top-ranked lncRNA-protein interactions predicted by our method are supported by existing literatures. The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions.", "The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions. Methods lncRNA-Protein associations. All human lncRNA genes and protein-coding genes are downloaded from the GENCODE Release 24 9 . A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted.", "A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted. To obtain genome-wide lncRNA and protein-coding gene associations, we combine three sources of data: • Co-expression data from COXPRESdb 40 . Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb.", "Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb. The correlations are calculated as follows: where C l, p is the overall correlation between gene l lncRNA and protein-coding gene p, C d l, p is the correlation score between l and p in dataset d, D is the number of gene pairs l and p with positive correlation scores. Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed.", "Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed. • Co-expression data from ArrayExpress 41 and GEO 42 . We obtained the co-expresionn data from the work of Jiang et al. 43 . RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 .", "RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 . TopHat and Cufflinks with the default parameters are used to calculate the expression values. Pearson's correlation coefficients are used to evaluate the co-expression of lncRNA-protein pairs. • lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions.", "• lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions. We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining.", "We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining. The confidence scores are computed by combining the probabilities from the different evidence channels, correcting for the probability of randomly observing an interaction. The HeteSim measure.", "The HeteSim measure. The HeteSim measure is a uniform and symmetric relevance measure. It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 .", "It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 . Further, the HeteSim score has some good properties i.e., selfmaximum and symmetric , which have achieved positive performance in many studies 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins.", "In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins. Definition 1 Transition probability matrix 39 L and P are two kinds of object in the heterogeneous network, I LP n*m is an adjacent matrix between L and P, then the normalized matrix of I LP along the row vector is defined as LP LP k m LP 1 Definition 2 Reachable probability matrix 39 In a heterogeneous network, the reachable probability matrix R  for path = +  PP P n 1 2 1  of length n, where P i belongs to any objects in the heterogeneous network, can be expressed as P P P P P P n n 1 2 2 3 1  Based on the definitions above, the steps of calculating HeteSim scores between two kinds of objects lncRNA and protein can be presented as follows: • Split the path into two parts. When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths.", "When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths. In order to deal with such problem, we need to split the path twice by setting , respectively. Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores.", "Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores. • Achieve the transition probability matrix and reachable probability matrix under the path L  and R  . • Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  .", "• Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  . An example of calculating HeteSim score is indicated in Fig. 8 . We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network.", "We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network. The simplified steps of computing HeteSim score between l3 and p2 under the path  = LTP is as follows: • Split the path  into two components  = LT • Given the adjacent matrix I LT and I TP below, which means the interactions between lncRNAs and proteins, we can obtain the transition probability matrix T LT and T TP by normalizing the two matrix along the row vector. The PLPIHS method.", "The PLPIHS method. Among a heterogeneous network, different paths can express different semantic meanings. For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings.", "For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings. The former means that if a lncRNA is associated with a protein, then another lncRNA similar to the lncRNA will be potential associated with the protein. The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA.", "The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA. Therefore, the potential information hidden in each path is extraordinary essential to be taken into account during prediction. The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 .", "The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 . Firstly, we construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The larger cutoff is, the network is more sparse. A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3.", "A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3. We randomly take out 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to construct a smaller network for the following experiments in consideration of computing costs. The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network.", "The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network. Table 1 . We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' .", "We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' . Next, we calculate the heteSim score for each lncRNA-protein pair under each path. The results of different paths are used as different features.", "The results of different paths are used as different features. And we combine a constant factor β to inhibit the influence of longer paths.The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations. On the account of the HeteSim measure is based on the path-based relevance framework 39 , it can effectively dig out the subtle semantics of each paths." ]

[ "Massive studies have indicated that long non-coding RNAs lncRNAs are critical for the regulation of cellular biological processes by binding with RNA-related proteins. However, only a few experimentally supported lncRNA-protein associations have been reported. Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs.", "Existing network-based methods are typically focused on intrinsic features of lncRNA and protein but ignore the information implicit in the topologies of biological networks associated with lncRNAs. Considering the limitations in previous methods, we propose PLPIHS, an effective computational method for Predicting lncRNA-Protein Interactions using HeteSim Scores. PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network.", "PLPIHS uses the HeteSim measure to calculate the relatedness score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the heterogeneous network, which consists of lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, lncRNA-protein association network and protein-protein interaction network. An SVM classifier to predict lncRNA-protein interactions is built with the HeteSim scores. The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test.", "The results show that PLPIHS performs significantly better than the existing state-of-the-art approaches and achieves an AUC score of 0.97 in the leave-one-out validation test. We also compare the performances of networks with different connectivity density and find that PLPIHS performs well across all the networks. Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1.", "Furthermore, we use the proposed method to identify the related proteins for lncRNA MALAT1. Highly-ranked proteins are verified by the biological studies and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information.", "Text: most commonly used approach is guilt-by-association GBA 19 , which provides the central top-down principle for analyzing gene networks in functional terms or assessing their quality in encoding functional information. New emerged methods, including the Katz method 20 , Combining dATa Across species using Positive-Unlabeled Learning Techniques CATAPULT 19 , Random Walk with Restart RWR 21 , and LncRNA-protein Interaction prediction based on Heterogeneous Network model LPIHN 22 , have extended the association from just direct protein interactions to more distant connections in various ways. The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes.", "The KATZ measure 20 is a weighted sum of the number of paths in the network that measures the similarity of two nodes. CATAPULT 19 is a supervised machine learning method that uses a biased support vector machine where the features are derived from walks in a heterogeneous gene-trait network. RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves.", "RWR 21 is a method for prioritization of candidate genes by use of a global network distance measure, random walk analysis, for definition of similarities in protein-protein interaction networks and it add weight to the assumption that phenotypically similar diseases are associated with disturbances of subnetworks within the larger protein interactome that extend beyond the disease proteins themselves. LPIHN 22 is a network-based method by implement a random walk on a heterogeneous network. PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information.", "PRINCE is a global method based on formulating constraints on the prioritization function that relate to its smoothness over the network and usage of prior information. Compared with LPIHN and RWR, PRINCE propagates information in a smaller network but contains more connotative meaning when build the initial probability values and has made great performance in gene prioritization 23 and disease identification 24 . However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths.", "However, many existing network-based methods simply view objects in heterogeneous networks as the same type and do not consider the subtle semantic meanings of different paths. In this paper, we adopt a method named HeteSim, which is a path-based measure to calculate the relevance between objects in heterogeneous network 25 . The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects.", "The basic idea is that similar objects are more likely to be related to some other objects. Considering the relatedness of heterogeneous objects is path-constrained, HeteSim gives a uniform and symmetric measure for arbitrary paths to evaluate the relatedness of heterogeneous object pair same or different types with one single score. Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure.", "Due to the relevance path not only captures the semantics information but also constrains the walk path, the score is also a path-based similarity measure. An example of HeteSim score is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively.", "The number of paths from A to C and B to C is 3 and 2, respectively. The walk count between A and C is larger than B and C, which might indicate that A is more closer to C than B. But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig.", "But the connectivity between B and C is more intense than A and C in the sight of HeteSim score, since most edges starting from B are connected with C, when A only has a small part of edges connected with C. Here, we propose a method named PLPIHS Fig. 2 to predict lncRNA-Protein interactions using HeteSim scores. We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate the score for each lncRNA-protein pair in the network. A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths.", "A SVM classifier is built based on the scores of different paths. We compare our PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS outperforms the other methods in many performance measures. Validation measures. LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 .", "LOOCV Leave-One-Out Cross Validation 26 is implemented on the verified lncR-NA-protein associations to evaluate the performance of LPIHN 22 . We leave a known lncRNA-protein pair in turn as the test sample and all the other known lncRNA-protein pairs are regarded as training samples. In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round.", "In order to improve the accuracy of PLPIHS, we remove all connected lncRNAs and proteins while in each validation round. Receiver Operating Characteristic ROC curve 27 is used to evaluate the prediction performance, which plots true-positive rate TPR, sensitivity or recall versus false-positive rate FPR, 1-specificity at different rank cutoffs. When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR.", "When varying the rank cutoffs of successful prediction, we can obtain the corresponding TPR and FPR. In this way, ROC curve is drawn and the area under the curve AUC is calculated as well. For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure.", "For a rank threshold, sensitivity SEN 28 and specificity SPE 29 These measurements are also used to assess the capability of PLPIHS during the preprocessing procedure. Affection of network preprocessing characteristics. In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein.", "In this paper, we only have two kinds of objects, lncRNA and protein. Thus, the paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six is listed in Table 1 . In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig.", "In order to pick out the most efficient paths, we compared the performances of these 14 paths under different combinations Fig. 3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′.", "3 . We can see that all paths achieve a favorable status except path 1′~2′. Path 1′~14′ obtains the best performance across all measures, which means that the path with length greater than three contains more significant meanings. The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths.", "The constant factor β is used to control the influence of longer paths. The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β.", "Path length equals 3 matches with constant β, path length equals 4 matches with constant β*β and path length equals 5 matches with constant β*β*β. Table 2 shows that β has tiny impact on the final results and β = 0.2, 0.4 and 0.7 achieved the best AUC score and the others are not far behind yet. To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "To further verify the dependability of our method, we compare the three networks of different connectivity density under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The results are shown in Fig. 4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks.", "4 . There are tiny performance differences between different sparse networks. The AUC score of the 0.5 network is higher than that of others while the 0.9 network outperforms others in ACC, SEN, MCC and F1-Score. This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 .", "This suggests that PLPIHS performs well across networks with different densities. Table 1 . The paths from a lncRNA to a protein in our heterogeneous network with length less than six. the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments.", "the RWR method, there is only one restart probability r and it's effects is very slight, which is proved by experiments. The parameter r is set as 0.5 in this comparison. In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure.", "In order to calculate the performance of the different methods, we use a leave-one-out cross validation procedure. We extract 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the 0.9 network as positive samples, the same number of negative samples are chosen randomly from the 0.3 network as well, avoiding the error caused by imbalance dataset. The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well.", "The gold set which containing 185 lncRNA-protein interactions downloaded from NPinter database has been included in positive pairs as well. In the lncRNA protein prioritization, each lncRNA-protein interaction is utilized as the test set in turn and the remaining associations are used as training data. The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset.", "The whole experiment will be repeated 4000 times to testing each lncRNA-protein pairs in the dataset. ROC curve is drawn based on true positive rate TPR and false positive rate FPR at different thresholds. The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance.", "The AUC score is utilized to measure the performance. AUC = 1 demonstrates the perfect performance and AUC = 0.5 demonstrates the random performance.The ROC curve of PLPIHS, LPIHS, PRINCE and RWR are plotted in Fig. 5 .", "5 . The results show that the AUC score of PLPIHS in 0.3 network is 96.8%, which is higher than that of PRINCE, LPIHN and RWR, achieving an AUC value of 81.3%, 88.4% and 79.2%, respectively. Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well.", "Similarly, PLPIHS outperforms other methods in 0.5 network and 0.9 network as well. Performance evaluation by independent test. For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set.", "For further validation, we also randomly selected 2000 lncRNA-protein associations from the rest of positive samples in 0.9 network and the same number of negative interactions are picked out from the remaining negative samples of 0.3 network to generate the independent test data set. Since the existing network based methods is not suitable for independent test, we only evaluate the performance for the proposed PLPIHS. The independent test results are shown in Fig.", "The independent test results are shown in Fig. 6 , an AUC score of 0.879 is achieved by PLPIHS, illustrating the effectiveness and advantage of the proposed approach. Case Studies. By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV.", "By applying the proposed PLPIHS method, novel candidate lncRNA-related proteins are predicted using LOOCV. We applied PLPIHS onto the 2000 known lncRNA-protein associations, which includes 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to infer novel lncRNA-protein interactions. As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig.", "As a result, an area under the ROC curve of 0.9669, 0.9705 and 0.9703 Fig. 5 is achieved using the three networks of different connectivity density, which demonstrate that our proposed method is effective in recovering known lncRNA-related proteins. To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined.", "To further illustrate the application of our approach, a case study of lncRNA MALAT1 ensemble ID: ENSG00000251562 is examined. MALAT1 is a long non-coding RNA which is over-expressed in many human oncogenic tissues and regulates cell cycle and survival 31 . MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression.", "MALAT1 have been identified in multiple types of physiological processes, such as alternative splicing, nuclear organization, epigenetic modulating of gene expression. A large amount of evidence indicates that MALAT1 also closely relates to various pathological processes, including diabetes complications, cancers and so on 32, 33 . MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 .", "MALAT1 is associated with 68 proteins in NPInter 3.0 34 . We construct the interaction networks of lncRNA MALAT1 by using the prediction results of these four methods Fig. 7 .", "7 . Among the 68 known lncRNA-protein interactions, PLPIHS wrongly predicts 6 interactions, while 13 associations are predicted mistakenly by PRINCE and RWR method and 15 lncRNA-protein pairs are falsely predicted by the LPIHN method. We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists.", "We manually check the top 10 proteins in the ranked list under 0.5 network Table 3 .Three of the top 10 predicted proteins have interactions with MALAT1, and most of them had high ranks in the predicted protein lists. For example, In the investigation of colorectal cancer CRC , MALAT1 could bind to SFPQ, thus releasing PTBP2 from the SFPQ/PTBP2 complex and the interaction between MALAT1 and SFPQ could be a novel therapeutic target for CRC 35 . MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 .", "MALAT1 interacts with SR proteins SRSF1, SRSF2, SRSF3 and SRSF5 and regulates cellular levels of phosphorylated forms of SR proteins 36 . And it is also as target of TARDBP to play the biological performance and found that TDP-43 bound to long ncRNAs in highly sequence-specific manner in tissue from subjects with or without FTLD-TDP, the MALAT1 ncRNA recruits splicing factors to nuclear speckles and affects phosphorylation of serine/arginine-rich splicing factor proteins 37, 38 . All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins.", "All these results indicate that our proposed method is effective and reliable in identifying novel lncRNA-related proteins. LncRNAs are involved in a wide range of biological functions through diverse molecular mechanisms often including the interaction with one or more protein partners 12, 13 . Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized.", "Only a small number of lncRNA-protein interactions have been well-characterized. Computational methods can be helpful in suggesting potential interactions for possible experimentation 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network.", "In this study, we use HeteSim measure to calculate the relevance between lncRNA and protein in a heterogeneous network. The importance of inferring novel lncRNA-protein interactions by considering the subtle semantic meanings of different paths in the heterogeneous network have been verified 39 . We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network.", "We first construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Then, we use the HeteSim measure to calculate a score for each lncRNA-protein pairs in each path. Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is used to combine the scores of different paths and making predictions. We compare the proposed PLPIHS with PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN and find that PLPIHS obtain an AUC score of 0.9679 in 0.3 network, which is significantly higher than PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN 0.813, 0.884 and 0.7918, respectively . We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density.", "We also compare the performance of these four methods in networks of different connectivity density. As a result, PLPIHS outperforms the other method across all the networks. Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively.", "Moreover, when analysing the predicted proteins interacted with lncRNA MALAT1, PLPIHS successfully predicts 63 out of 68 associations, while PRINCE, RWR and LPIHN retrieve much lower interactions of 57, 57 and 53, respectively. And the top-ranked lncRNA-protein interactions predicted by our method are supported by existing literatures. The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions.", "The results highlight the advantages of our proposed method in predicting possible lncRNA-protein interactions. Methods lncRNA-Protein associations. All human lncRNA genes and protein-coding genes are downloaded from the GENCODE Release 24 9 . A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted.", "A total of 15941 lncRNA genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted. To obtain genome-wide lncRNA and protein-coding gene associations, we combine three sources of data: • Co-expression data from COXPRESdb 40 . Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb.", "Three preprocessed co-expression datasets Hsa.c4-1, Hsa2.c2-0 and Hsa3.c1-0 including pre-calculated pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients for human were collected from COXPRESdb. The correlations are calculated as follows: where C l, p is the overall correlation between gene l lncRNA and protein-coding gene p, C d l, p is the correlation score between l and p in dataset d, D is the number of gene pairs l and p with positive correlation scores. Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed.", "Gene pairs with negative correlation scores are removed. • Co-expression data from ArrayExpress 41 and GEO 42 . We obtained the co-expresionn data from the work of Jiang et al. 43 . RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 .", "RNA-Seq raw data of 19 human normal tissues are obtained from ArrayExpress E-MTAB-513 and GEO GSE30554 . TopHat and Cufflinks with the default parameters are used to calculate the expression values. Pearson's correlation coefficients are used to evaluate the co-expression of lncRNA-protein pairs. • lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions.", "• lncRNA-protein interaction data. We download known lncRNA-protein interaction dataset from Protein-protein interactions. We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining.", "We obtain the protein-protein interaction PPI data from STRING database V10.0 45 , which contains weighted protein interactions derived from computational prediction methods, high-throughput experiments, and text mining. The confidence scores are computed by combining the probabilities from the different evidence channels, correcting for the probability of randomly observing an interaction. The HeteSim measure.", "The HeteSim measure. The HeteSim measure is a uniform and symmetric relevance measure. It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 .", "It can be used to calculate the relatedness of objects with the same or different types in a uniform framework, and it is also a path-constrained measure to estimate the relatedness of object pairs based on the search path that connects two objects through a sequence of node types 39 . Further, the HeteSim score has some good properties i.e., selfmaximum and symmetric , which have achieved positive performance in many studies 25 . In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins.", "In this study, we use HeteSim scores to measure the similarities between lncRNAs and proteins. Definition 1 Transition probability matrix 39 L and P are two kinds of object in the heterogeneous network, I LP n*m is an adjacent matrix between L and P, then the normalized matrix of I LP along the row vector is defined as LP LP k m LP 1 Definition 2 Reachable probability matrix 39 In a heterogeneous network, the reachable probability matrix R  for path = +  PP P n 1 2 1  of length n, where P i belongs to any objects in the heterogeneous network, can be expressed as P P P P P P n n 1 2 2 3 1  Based on the definitions above, the steps of calculating HeteSim scores between two kinds of objects lncRNA and protein can be presented as follows: • Split the path into two parts. When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths.", "When the length n of path  is even, we can split it into  =  P P Otherwise, if n is odd, the path cannot be divided into two equallength paths. In order to deal with such problem, we need to split the path twice by setting , respectively. Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores.", "Then, we can obtain a HeteSim score for each mid value, the final score will be the average of the two scores. • Achieve the transition probability matrix and reachable probability matrix under the path L  and R  . • Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  .", "• Calculate the HeteSim score: where  − R 1 is the reverse path of R  . An example of calculating HeteSim score is indicated in Fig. 8 . We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network.", "We can see that there are three kinds of objects L, T and P in the network. The simplified steps of computing HeteSim score between l3 and p2 under the path  = LTP is as follows: • Split the path  into two components  = LT • Given the adjacent matrix I LT and I TP below, which means the interactions between lncRNAs and proteins, we can obtain the transition probability matrix T LT and T TP by normalizing the two matrix along the row vector. The PLPIHS method.", "The PLPIHS method. Among a heterogeneous network, different paths can express different semantic meanings. For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings.", "For instance, a lncRNA and a protein is connected via 'lncRNA-lncRNA-protein' path or 'lncRNA-protein-protein' path representing totally different meanings. The former means that if a lncRNA is associated with a protein, then another lncRNA similar to the lncRNA will be potential associated with the protein. The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA.", "The latter shows that if a protein associated with a lncRNA, then another protein interacted with the protein will be likely associated with the lncRNA. Therefore, the potential information hidden in each path is extraordinary essential to be taken into account during prediction. The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 .", "The PLPIHS framework is illustrated in Fig. 2 . Firstly, we construct a heterogeneous network consisting of a lncRNA-lncRNA similarity network, a lncRNA-protein association network and a protein-protein interaction network. Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations .", "Three kinds of sparse networks are obtained from the heterogeneous network under different cutoff value 0.3, 0.5 and 0.9 see lncRNA-Protein associations . The larger cutoff is, the network is more sparse. A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3.", "A total of 15941 lncRNAs genes and 20284 protein-coding genes are extracted as presented in Section 2.3. We randomly take out 1511 lncRNAs and 344 proteins to construct a smaller network for the following experiments in consideration of computing costs. The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network.", "The construction of the smaller heterogeneous networks under different cutoff values are shown in Table 4 , where 'lnc2lnc' denotes the lncRNA-lncRNA network, 'lnc2code' denotes the lncRNA-protein network and 'code2code' denotes the protein-lncRNA network. Table 1 . We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' .", "We use id to indicate the path combination, i.e., 1′~2′ represents path 'LLP' and path 'LPP' . Next, we calculate the heteSim score for each lncRNA-protein pair under each path. The results of different paths are used as different features.", "The results of different paths are used as different features. And we combine a constant factor β to inhibit the influence of longer paths.The longer the path length is, the smaller the inhibiting factor is. Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations.", "Finally, a SVM classifier is built with these scores to predict potential lncRNA-protein associations. On the account of the HeteSim measure is based on the path-based relevance framework 39 , it can effectively dig out the subtle semantics of each paths." ]

[ "OBJECTIVE: To describe an unusual cluster of multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS encountered within a 3-month period. METHODS: This retrospective observation study is comprised of seven patients who presented with MEWDS in a 3-month period in central Israel. Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings.", "Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings. RESULTS: Six women and one man of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years. Three reported a precedent viral infection. All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity.", "All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity. MAIN IMAGING FINDINGS: Hyperfluorescent spots on blue autofluorescence BAF , hypofluorescent spots on indocyanine green angiography, dark lesions on infrared photos, and ellipsoid zone irregularities on spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery.", "Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery. OCT angiography performed following the convalescence stage demonstrated intact retinal and choroidal flow. Serologic findings were inconclusive. CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time.", "CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time. SD-OCT findings of ellipsoid zone disruption in combination with other multimodal imaging modalities are outlined meticulously. Recognizing these imaging features along with high index of clinical suspicion is important for the diagnosis of MEWDS. Serologic testing might be considered in future patients.", "Serologic testing might be considered in future patients. Text: Multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS was first described in 1984 as a rare, sudden onset of unilateral chorioretinopathy, with the predominant sign being multifocal yellow-white spots throughout the retina . The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots .", "The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots . Symptoms include acute onset of decreased visual acuity unilaterally accompanied in most cases by photopsia and scotomata. A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases .", "A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases . One report described a patient with elevated levels of total serum IgG during the disease course and negative findings for IgM to herpes zoster, herpes simplex, mumps, and measles . Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown.", "Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown. Recovery is gradual, over weeks to months, and the visual prognosis is very favorable . Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown.", "Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown. Only small case series are reported in the literature . One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period .", "One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period . The aim of the present report was to describe an unusual cluster of seven cases of MEWDS encountered within a 3month period, with an emphasis on the clinical presentation and multimodal imaging findings. The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association.", "The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association. A retrospective observational study was conducted in seven patients who presented with MEWDS between July and September 2013 at two tertiary medical centers in central Israel. Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files.", "Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files. The study was approved by the institutional ethics review board. All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT .", "All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Images were acquired with the HRA-2 and the Spectralis HRA + OCT devices Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany at the following wavelengths: BAFexcitation 488 nm, barrier cut-off 496 nm; IR-820 nm; ICGA-excitation 790 nm, emission 800 nm; and SD-OCTsuperluminescent diode light source 870 nm. The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology .", "The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology . Precise registration between findings seen on IR or BAF and SD-OCT was enabled by the dual-beam laser eye-tracking system, where one laser is used to image the retina and the other laser to perform the OCT scans. Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones.", "Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones. OCT angiography images were acquired using the RTVue XR Avanti with AngioVue Optovue Inc., Fremont, California, USA , with an A-scan-rate of 70 000 scans per second, a light source of 840 nm, and a bandwidth of 45 nm. Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each.", "Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each. Split-spectrum amplitude decorrelation technology was employed to improve the signal-to-noise ratio by splitting the spectrum to generate multiple repeat OCT frames from 2 original repeat OCT frames . Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes.", "Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes. Automatic segmentation of the retinal layers was performed by the viewing software and was used to generate en face projection images after adjusting the level of the segmented layer on the B-scans. Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus.", "Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus. Findings. There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years .", "There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years . Table 1 summarizes the demographic data. Three patients reported a prodromal virus infection. All patients presented with acute onset of unilateral decreased vision. The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye.", "The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye. None of the patients had signs of anterior or vitreous inflammation in the affected eye. Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery.", "Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery. Patient 6 had a swollen disc and mild signs of optic neuropathy mild red desaturation, enlarged blind spot on visual field . Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis.", "Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis. Neurological evaluation including full neurological exam and neuroimaging excluded additional neurological deficit, before the diagnosis of MEWDS was established. The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings.", "The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings. Patients who underwent imaging less than 2 weeks from onset of symptoms had the most typical findings. BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 .", "BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 . IR photos showed dark lesions in similar, though not identical, locations Figure 3 . Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities.", "Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities. B-scan SD-OCT through the fovea showed a disrupted inner segment ellipsoid zone band of varied severity in all 7 affected eyes. The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria .", "The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria . The transient disruption of the foveal ellipsoid zone on SD-OCT corresponded to the clinically apparent foveal granularity. In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 .", "In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 . Foveal hyperreflectivity found in 3 patients patients 1, 4, and 7 was noted extending into the inner retinal layers Figure 4 . The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 .", "The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 . FA demonstrated nonspecific early punctate hyperfluorescent lesions, with slight staining during the early phase, in four patients patients 2, 3, 6, and 7 . These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities.", "These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities. No pathology was noted in the foveal area despite the presence of typical foveal granularity. Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 .", "Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 . During the course of the disease, the hyperautofluorescent areas decreased in number and faded without leaving hypoautofluorescent abnormalities. The resolution of the BAF lesions corresponded to the anatomic recovery observed on SD-OCT. The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 .", "The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 . Figure 6 . Four patients patients 1, 4, 6, and 7 underwent serological testing with negative results except for a common result of elevated titer of IgG to VZV. After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 .", "After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 . Although MEDWS is traditionally considered as a rare syndrome , we report an unusual cluster of seven patients who presented within a three-month period. All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye.", "All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye. This cluster of cases could break to some measure the statistical improbability of the rarity of the disease. The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed.", "The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed. However, it may be in line with the speculation that sometimes atypical findings may simply reflect the moment in time in which the patients were examined and are not a true atypical presentation . In its original description by Jampol et al.", "In its original description by Jampol et al. , MEWDS cases were unilateral with fundus presentation including numerous white dots scattered in the posterior pole and beyond the arcades. During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis.", "During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis. The number of white spots is very variable, and in fact, they may be absent. Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course.", "Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course. While the presumed pathogenesis of MEWDS involves a viral infection, only few reports to date have described a search for the pathogen 5, . The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator.", "The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator. Serological testing yielded only an elevated titer of IgG to VZV, most often an indicative of past VZV infection or vaccination; thus, we could not make any generalization regarding these findings. Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS.", "Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS. Most of the findings noted here have been described separately in earlier reports 7-9, 11, 12 . However, the present study offered two important advantages.", "However, the present study offered two important advantages. We were able to examine all patients with simultaneously acquired imaging, and multiple correlations between the imaging findings and the clinical evaluation were possible. Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease.", "Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease. We observed corresponding locations of the dark spots on IR images, the hyperautofluorescent spots on the BAF images, and the foci of outer retinal pathology on SD-OCT images. Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT .", "Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT . However, we noted a unique finding of foveal hyperreflectivity extending into the inner retinal layers. Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS.", "Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS. During the disease course, both the IR and the BAF findings faded in concurrence with the anatomical resolution of the disruption in the ellipsoid zone and the foveal hyperreflective lesion on SD-OCT. Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS.", "Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS. Although IR autofluorescent changes were recently described in patients with MEWDS , this modality is not widely available, whereas IR imaging is routinely performed. Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal.", "Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal. OCTA is relatively new noninvasive imaging modality that demonstrates flow characteristics of the vascular network within the regional circulation to construct noninvasive images of the vascular network. En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage.", "En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage. We cannot overestimate the role of multimodal imaging in these patients, since not too often, the diagnosis is mistaken for optic neuritis, and clinical findings are very subtle. Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret.", "Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret. Therefore, we consider these tests inconclusive. Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities.", "Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities. In addition, future research is required using OCT angiography to study the nature of the dots in MEWDS patients and its correlation to other multimodal imaging modalities in the acute and convalescent stage. In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d .", "In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d . The green and red lines represent the x and y axes. Patient 7 after recurrent episodes.", "Patient 7 after recurrent episodes. 3 × 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris a1 , superficial layer a2 , and deep layer a3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 .", "Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 . SD-OCT b2 demonstrating normal anatomy of the outer retina 6 months after the first acute episode. Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise.", "Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. 3 × 3 mm en face structural OCT d1 of the choriocapillaris centered at the macula as in c1. This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c .", "This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c . En face structural OCT of the deep d2 and outer retina d3 . of time. To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons.", "To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons. The diagnosis was supported by the presence of key features of foveal granularity and disruption of the ellipsoid zone on OCT and their correlation with the hyperautofluorescent lesions identified on BAF. Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality.", "Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality. The disease course in our patients was typical for MEWDS, with almost complete recovery of visual acuity. The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection.", "The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection. We suggest continued serological testing in patients who meet the clinical criteria. The clinical signs of MEWDS are subtle, such that the diagnosis relies on a high index of suspicion. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare." ]

[ "OBJECTIVE: To describe an unusual cluster of multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS encountered within a 3-month period. METHODS: This retrospective observation study is comprised of seven patients who presented with MEWDS in a 3-month period in central Israel. Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings.", "Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings. RESULTS: Six women and one man of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years. Three reported a precedent viral infection. All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity.", "All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity. MAIN IMAGING FINDINGS: Hyperfluorescent spots on blue autofluorescence BAF , hypofluorescent spots on indocyanine green angiography, dark lesions on infrared photos, and ellipsoid zone irregularities on spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery.", "Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery. OCT angiography performed following the convalescence stage demonstrated intact retinal and choroidal flow. Serologic findings were inconclusive. CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time.", "CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time. SD-OCT findings of ellipsoid zone disruption in combination with other multimodal imaging modalities are outlined meticulously. Recognizing these imaging features along with high index of clinical suspicion is important for the diagnosis of MEWDS. Serologic testing might be considered in future patients.", "Serologic testing might be considered in future patients. Text: Multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS was first described in 1984 as a rare, sudden onset of unilateral chorioretinopathy, with the predominant sign being multifocal yellow-white spots throughout the retina . The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots .", "The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots . Symptoms include acute onset of decreased visual acuity unilaterally accompanied in most cases by photopsia and scotomata. A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases .", "A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases . One report described a patient with elevated levels of total serum IgG during the disease course and negative findings for IgM to herpes zoster, herpes simplex, mumps, and measles . Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown.", "Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown. Recovery is gradual, over weeks to months, and the visual prognosis is very favorable . Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown.", "Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown. Only small case series are reported in the literature . One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period .", "One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period . The aim of the present report was to describe an unusual cluster of seven cases of MEWDS encountered within a 3month period, with an emphasis on the clinical presentation and multimodal imaging findings. The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association.", "The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association. A retrospective observational study was conducted in seven patients who presented with MEWDS between July and September 2013 at two tertiary medical centers in central Israel. Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files.", "Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files. The study was approved by the institutional ethics review board. All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT .", "All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Images were acquired with the HRA-2 and the Spectralis HRA + OCT devices Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany at the following wavelengths: BAFexcitation 488 nm, barrier cut-off 496 nm; IR-820 nm; ICGA-excitation 790 nm, emission 800 nm; and SD-OCTsuperluminescent diode light source 870 nm. The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology .", "The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology . Precise registration between findings seen on IR or BAF and SD-OCT was enabled by the dual-beam laser eye-tracking system, where one laser is used to image the retina and the other laser to perform the OCT scans. Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones.", "Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones. OCT angiography images were acquired using the RTVue XR Avanti with AngioVue Optovue Inc., Fremont, California, USA , with an A-scan-rate of 70 000 scans per second, a light source of 840 nm, and a bandwidth of 45 nm. Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each.", "Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each. Split-spectrum amplitude decorrelation technology was employed to improve the signal-to-noise ratio by splitting the spectrum to generate multiple repeat OCT frames from 2 original repeat OCT frames . Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes.", "Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes. Automatic segmentation of the retinal layers was performed by the viewing software and was used to generate en face projection images after adjusting the level of the segmented layer on the B-scans. Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus.", "Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus. Findings. There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years .", "There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years . Table 1 summarizes the demographic data. Three patients reported a prodromal virus infection. All patients presented with acute onset of unilateral decreased vision. The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye.", "The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye. None of the patients had signs of anterior or vitreous inflammation in the affected eye. Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery.", "Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery. Patient 6 had a swollen disc and mild signs of optic neuropathy mild red desaturation, enlarged blind spot on visual field . Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis.", "Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis. Neurological evaluation including full neurological exam and neuroimaging excluded additional neurological deficit, before the diagnosis of MEWDS was established. The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings.", "The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings. Patients who underwent imaging less than 2 weeks from onset of symptoms had the most typical findings. BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 .", "BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 . IR photos showed dark lesions in similar, though not identical, locations Figure 3 . Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities.", "Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities. B-scan SD-OCT through the fovea showed a disrupted inner segment ellipsoid zone band of varied severity in all 7 affected eyes. The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria .", "The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria . The transient disruption of the foveal ellipsoid zone on SD-OCT corresponded to the clinically apparent foveal granularity. In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 .", "In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 . Foveal hyperreflectivity found in 3 patients patients 1, 4, and 7 was noted extending into the inner retinal layers Figure 4 . The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 .", "The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 . FA demonstrated nonspecific early punctate hyperfluorescent lesions, with slight staining during the early phase, in four patients patients 2, 3, 6, and 7 . These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities.", "These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities. No pathology was noted in the foveal area despite the presence of typical foveal granularity. Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 .", "Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 . During the course of the disease, the hyperautofluorescent areas decreased in number and faded without leaving hypoautofluorescent abnormalities. The resolution of the BAF lesions corresponded to the anatomic recovery observed on SD-OCT. The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 .", "The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 . Figure 6 . Four patients patients 1, 4, 6, and 7 underwent serological testing with negative results except for a common result of elevated titer of IgG to VZV. After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 .", "After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 . Although MEDWS is traditionally considered as a rare syndrome , we report an unusual cluster of seven patients who presented within a three-month period. All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye.", "All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye. This cluster of cases could break to some measure the statistical improbability of the rarity of the disease. The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed.", "The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed. However, it may be in line with the speculation that sometimes atypical findings may simply reflect the moment in time in which the patients were examined and are not a true atypical presentation . In its original description by Jampol et al.", "In its original description by Jampol et al. , MEWDS cases were unilateral with fundus presentation including numerous white dots scattered in the posterior pole and beyond the arcades. During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis.", "During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis. The number of white spots is very variable, and in fact, they may be absent. Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course.", "Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course. While the presumed pathogenesis of MEWDS involves a viral infection, only few reports to date have described a search for the pathogen 5, . The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator.", "The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator. Serological testing yielded only an elevated titer of IgG to VZV, most often an indicative of past VZV infection or vaccination; thus, we could not make any generalization regarding these findings. Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS.", "Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS. Most of the findings noted here have been described separately in earlier reports 7-9, 11, 12 . However, the present study offered two important advantages.", "However, the present study offered two important advantages. We were able to examine all patients with simultaneously acquired imaging, and multiple correlations between the imaging findings and the clinical evaluation were possible. Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease.", "Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease. We observed corresponding locations of the dark spots on IR images, the hyperautofluorescent spots on the BAF images, and the foci of outer retinal pathology on SD-OCT images. Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT .", "Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT . However, we noted a unique finding of foveal hyperreflectivity extending into the inner retinal layers. Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS.", "Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS. During the disease course, both the IR and the BAF findings faded in concurrence with the anatomical resolution of the disruption in the ellipsoid zone and the foveal hyperreflective lesion on SD-OCT. Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS.", "Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS. Although IR autofluorescent changes were recently described in patients with MEWDS , this modality is not widely available, whereas IR imaging is routinely performed. Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal.", "Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal. OCTA is relatively new noninvasive imaging modality that demonstrates flow characteristics of the vascular network within the regional circulation to construct noninvasive images of the vascular network. En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage.", "En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage. We cannot overestimate the role of multimodal imaging in these patients, since not too often, the diagnosis is mistaken for optic neuritis, and clinical findings are very subtle. Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret.", "Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret. Therefore, we consider these tests inconclusive. Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities.", "Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities. In addition, future research is required using OCT angiography to study the nature of the dots in MEWDS patients and its correlation to other multimodal imaging modalities in the acute and convalescent stage. In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d .", "In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d . The green and red lines represent the x and y axes. Patient 7 after recurrent episodes.", "Patient 7 after recurrent episodes. 3 × 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris a1 , superficial layer a2 , and deep layer a3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 .", "Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 . SD-OCT b2 demonstrating normal anatomy of the outer retina 6 months after the first acute episode. Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise.", "Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. 3 × 3 mm en face structural OCT d1 of the choriocapillaris centered at the macula as in c1. This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c .", "This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c . En face structural OCT of the deep d2 and outer retina d3 . of time. To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons.", "To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons. The diagnosis was supported by the presence of key features of foveal granularity and disruption of the ellipsoid zone on OCT and their correlation with the hyperautofluorescent lesions identified on BAF. Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality.", "Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality. The disease course in our patients was typical for MEWDS, with almost complete recovery of visual acuity. The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection.", "The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection. We suggest continued serological testing in patients who meet the clinical criteria. The clinical signs of MEWDS are subtle, such that the diagnosis relies on a high index of suspicion. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare." ]

[ "OBJECTIVE: To describe an unusual cluster of multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS encountered within a 3-month period. METHODS: This retrospective observation study is comprised of seven patients who presented with MEWDS in a 3-month period in central Israel. Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings.", "Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings. RESULTS: Six women and one man of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years. Three reported a precedent viral infection. All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity.", "All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity. MAIN IMAGING FINDINGS: Hyperfluorescent spots on blue autofluorescence BAF , hypofluorescent spots on indocyanine green angiography, dark lesions on infrared photos, and ellipsoid zone irregularities on spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery.", "Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery. OCT angiography performed following the convalescence stage demonstrated intact retinal and choroidal flow. Serologic findings were inconclusive. CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time.", "CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time. SD-OCT findings of ellipsoid zone disruption in combination with other multimodal imaging modalities are outlined meticulously. Recognizing these imaging features along with high index of clinical suspicion is important for the diagnosis of MEWDS. Serologic testing might be considered in future patients.", "Serologic testing might be considered in future patients. Text: Multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS was first described in 1984 as a rare, sudden onset of unilateral chorioretinopathy, with the predominant sign being multifocal yellow-white spots throughout the retina . The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots .", "The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots . Symptoms include acute onset of decreased visual acuity unilaterally accompanied in most cases by photopsia and scotomata. A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases .", "A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases . One report described a patient with elevated levels of total serum IgG during the disease course and negative findings for IgM to herpes zoster, herpes simplex, mumps, and measles . Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown.", "Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown. Recovery is gradual, over weeks to months, and the visual prognosis is very favorable . Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown.", "Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown. Only small case series are reported in the literature . One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period .", "One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period . The aim of the present report was to describe an unusual cluster of seven cases of MEWDS encountered within a 3month period, with an emphasis on the clinical presentation and multimodal imaging findings. The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association.", "The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association. A retrospective observational study was conducted in seven patients who presented with MEWDS between July and September 2013 at two tertiary medical centers in central Israel. Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files.", "Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files. The study was approved by the institutional ethics review board. All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT .", "All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Images were acquired with the HRA-2 and the Spectralis HRA + OCT devices Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany at the following wavelengths: BAFexcitation 488 nm, barrier cut-off 496 nm; IR-820 nm; ICGA-excitation 790 nm, emission 800 nm; and SD-OCTsuperluminescent diode light source 870 nm. The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology .", "The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology . Precise registration between findings seen on IR or BAF and SD-OCT was enabled by the dual-beam laser eye-tracking system, where one laser is used to image the retina and the other laser to perform the OCT scans. Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones.", "Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones. OCT angiography images were acquired using the RTVue XR Avanti with AngioVue Optovue Inc., Fremont, California, USA , with an A-scan-rate of 70 000 scans per second, a light source of 840 nm, and a bandwidth of 45 nm. Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each.", "Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each. Split-spectrum amplitude decorrelation technology was employed to improve the signal-to-noise ratio by splitting the spectrum to generate multiple repeat OCT frames from 2 original repeat OCT frames . Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes.", "Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes. Automatic segmentation of the retinal layers was performed by the viewing software and was used to generate en face projection images after adjusting the level of the segmented layer on the B-scans. Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus.", "Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus. Findings. There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years .", "There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years . Table 1 summarizes the demographic data. Three patients reported a prodromal virus infection. All patients presented with acute onset of unilateral decreased vision. The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye.", "The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye. None of the patients had signs of anterior or vitreous inflammation in the affected eye. Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery.", "Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery. Patient 6 had a swollen disc and mild signs of optic neuropathy mild red desaturation, enlarged blind spot on visual field . Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis.", "Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis. Neurological evaluation including full neurological exam and neuroimaging excluded additional neurological deficit, before the diagnosis of MEWDS was established. The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings.", "The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings. Patients who underwent imaging less than 2 weeks from onset of symptoms had the most typical findings. BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 .", "BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 . IR photos showed dark lesions in similar, though not identical, locations Figure 3 . Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities.", "Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities. B-scan SD-OCT through the fovea showed a disrupted inner segment ellipsoid zone band of varied severity in all 7 affected eyes. The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria .", "The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria . The transient disruption of the foveal ellipsoid zone on SD-OCT corresponded to the clinically apparent foveal granularity. In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 .", "In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 . Foveal hyperreflectivity found in 3 patients patients 1, 4, and 7 was noted extending into the inner retinal layers Figure 4 . The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 .", "The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 . FA demonstrated nonspecific early punctate hyperfluorescent lesions, with slight staining during the early phase, in four patients patients 2, 3, 6, and 7 . These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities.", "These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities. No pathology was noted in the foveal area despite the presence of typical foveal granularity. Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 .", "Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 . During the course of the disease, the hyperautofluorescent areas decreased in number and faded without leaving hypoautofluorescent abnormalities. The resolution of the BAF lesions corresponded to the anatomic recovery observed on SD-OCT. The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 .", "The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 . Figure 6 . Four patients patients 1, 4, 6, and 7 underwent serological testing with negative results except for a common result of elevated titer of IgG to VZV. After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 .", "After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 . Although MEDWS is traditionally considered as a rare syndrome , we report an unusual cluster of seven patients who presented within a three-month period. All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye.", "All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye. This cluster of cases could break to some measure the statistical improbability of the rarity of the disease. The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed.", "The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed. However, it may be in line with the speculation that sometimes atypical findings may simply reflect the moment in time in which the patients were examined and are not a true atypical presentation . In its original description by Jampol et al.", "In its original description by Jampol et al. , MEWDS cases were unilateral with fundus presentation including numerous white dots scattered in the posterior pole and beyond the arcades. During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis.", "During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis. The number of white spots is very variable, and in fact, they may be absent. Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course.", "Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course. While the presumed pathogenesis of MEWDS involves a viral infection, only few reports to date have described a search for the pathogen 5, . The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator.", "The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator. Serological testing yielded only an elevated titer of IgG to VZV, most often an indicative of past VZV infection or vaccination; thus, we could not make any generalization regarding these findings. Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS.", "Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS. Most of the findings noted here have been described separately in earlier reports 7-9, 11, 12 . However, the present study offered two important advantages.", "However, the present study offered two important advantages. We were able to examine all patients with simultaneously acquired imaging, and multiple correlations between the imaging findings and the clinical evaluation were possible. Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease.", "Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease. We observed corresponding locations of the dark spots on IR images, the hyperautofluorescent spots on the BAF images, and the foci of outer retinal pathology on SD-OCT images. Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT .", "Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT . However, we noted a unique finding of foveal hyperreflectivity extending into the inner retinal layers. Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS.", "Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS. During the disease course, both the IR and the BAF findings faded in concurrence with the anatomical resolution of the disruption in the ellipsoid zone and the foveal hyperreflective lesion on SD-OCT. Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS.", "Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS. Although IR autofluorescent changes were recently described in patients with MEWDS , this modality is not widely available, whereas IR imaging is routinely performed. Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal.", "Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal. OCTA is relatively new noninvasive imaging modality that demonstrates flow characteristics of the vascular network within the regional circulation to construct noninvasive images of the vascular network. En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage.", "En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage. We cannot overestimate the role of multimodal imaging in these patients, since not too often, the diagnosis is mistaken for optic neuritis, and clinical findings are very subtle. Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret.", "Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret. Therefore, we consider these tests inconclusive. Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities.", "Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities. In addition, future research is required using OCT angiography to study the nature of the dots in MEWDS patients and its correlation to other multimodal imaging modalities in the acute and convalescent stage. In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d .", "In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d . The green and red lines represent the x and y axes. Patient 7 after recurrent episodes.", "Patient 7 after recurrent episodes. 3 × 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris a1 , superficial layer a2 , and deep layer a3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 .", "Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 . SD-OCT b2 demonstrating normal anatomy of the outer retina 6 months after the first acute episode. Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise.", "Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. 3 × 3 mm en face structural OCT d1 of the choriocapillaris centered at the macula as in c1. This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c .", "This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c . En face structural OCT of the deep d2 and outer retina d3 . of time. To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons.", "To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons. The diagnosis was supported by the presence of key features of foveal granularity and disruption of the ellipsoid zone on OCT and their correlation with the hyperautofluorescent lesions identified on BAF. Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality.", "Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality. The disease course in our patients was typical for MEWDS, with almost complete recovery of visual acuity. The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection.", "The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection. We suggest continued serological testing in patients who meet the clinical criteria. The clinical signs of MEWDS are subtle, such that the diagnosis relies on a high index of suspicion. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare." ]

[ "OBJECTIVE: To describe an unusual cluster of multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS encountered within a 3-month period. METHODS: This retrospective observation study is comprised of seven patients who presented with MEWDS in a 3-month period in central Israel. Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings.", "Data were collected from patients' medical records on clinical, multimodal imaging, and viral serology findings. RESULTS: Six women and one man of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years. Three reported a precedent viral infection. All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity.", "All had unilateral decreased vision. Funduscopy revealed foveal granularity. MAIN IMAGING FINDINGS: Hyperfluorescent spots on blue autofluorescence BAF , hypofluorescent spots on indocyanine green angiography, dark lesions on infrared photos, and ellipsoid zone irregularities on spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery.", "Resolution of the spots on BAF correlated with anatomic SD-OCT and visual recovery. OCT angiography performed following the convalescence stage demonstrated intact retinal and choroidal flow. Serologic findings were inconclusive. CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time.", "CONCLUSION: We report a unique cluster of MEWDS patients presented in a short period of time. SD-OCT findings of ellipsoid zone disruption in combination with other multimodal imaging modalities are outlined meticulously. Recognizing these imaging features along with high index of clinical suspicion is important for the diagnosis of MEWDS. Serologic testing might be considered in future patients.", "Serologic testing might be considered in future patients. Text: Multiple evanescent white dot syndrome MEWDS was first described in 1984 as a rare, sudden onset of unilateral chorioretinopathy, with the predominant sign being multifocal yellow-white spots throughout the retina . The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots .", "The clinical spectrum of MEWDS has expanded over the years to include bilaterality and recurrences or an atypical presentation involving the fovea without the white spots . Symptoms include acute onset of decreased visual acuity unilaterally accompanied in most cases by photopsia and scotomata. A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases .", "A prodromal flu-like illness has been reported in up to 50% of cases . One report described a patient with elevated levels of total serum IgG during the disease course and negative findings for IgM to herpes zoster, herpes simplex, mumps, and measles . Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown.", "Although MEWDS is suspected to occur as a consequence of a viral-like infection in genetically susceptible individuals, its precise pathogenesis remains unknown. Recovery is gradual, over weeks to months, and the visual prognosis is very favorable . Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown.", "Treatment is usually not required. The incidence of MEWDS is unknown. Only small case series are reported in the literature . One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period .", "One of the largest described 34 affected patients reviewed over several years' period . The aim of the present report was to describe an unusual cluster of seven cases of MEWDS encountered within a 3month period, with an emphasis on the clinical presentation and multimodal imaging findings. The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association.", "The cluster prompted us to seek a common infectious association. A retrospective observational study was conducted in seven patients who presented with MEWDS between July and September 2013 at two tertiary medical centers in central Israel. Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files.", "Data on background, clinical, and laboratory parameters were collected from the medical files. The study was approved by the institutional ethics review board. All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT .", "All patients underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination and multimodal imaging tests, including blue autofluorescence BAF , fluorescein angiography FA and/ or indocyanine green angiography ICGA , infrared IR photography, and spectral domain optical coherence tomography SD-OCT . Images were acquired with the HRA-2 and the Spectralis HRA + OCT devices Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany at the following wavelengths: BAFexcitation 488 nm, barrier cut-off 496 nm; IR-820 nm; ICGA-excitation 790 nm, emission 800 nm; and SD-OCTsuperluminescent diode light source 870 nm. The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology .", "The volume scan option was used to acquire the multiple SD-OCT scans 25-49 horizontal scans over a 6 mm region covering the area of pathology . Precise registration between findings seen on IR or BAF and SD-OCT was enabled by the dual-beam laser eye-tracking system, where one laser is used to image the retina and the other laser to perform the OCT scans. Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones.", "Accurate rescanning in areas of interest was ensured by the Spectralis follow-up function which automatically places subsequent scans on the same location as the previous ones. OCT angiography images were acquired using the RTVue XR Avanti with AngioVue Optovue Inc., Fremont, California, USA , with an A-scan-rate of 70 000 scans per second, a light source of 840 nm, and a bandwidth of 45 nm. Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each.", "Macular cubes 3 × 3 mm were acquired, each cube consisting of 304 clusters of 2 repeated B-scans containing 304 A-scans each. Split-spectrum amplitude decorrelation technology was employed to improve the signal-to-noise ratio by splitting the spectrum to generate multiple repeat OCT frames from 2 original repeat OCT frames . Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes.", "Motion correction was performed using registration of 2 orthogonally captured imaging volumes. Automatic segmentation of the retinal layers was performed by the viewing software and was used to generate en face projection images after adjusting the level of the segmented layer on the B-scans. Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus.", "Serology testing was performed for viruses commonly present at the time of the patients' presentation, namely, immunoglobulin IgG and IgM for herpes simplex virus HSV I-II, varicella zoster virus VZV , West Nile virus, coxsackievirus, echovirus subgroup of enterovirus , and corona virus. Findings. There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years .", "There were one male and six female patients of mean age 31.5 ± 7.2 years range 22-41 years . Table 1 summarizes the demographic data. Three patients reported a prodromal virus infection. All patients presented with acute onset of unilateral decreased vision. The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye.", "The best corrected visual acuity at presentation ranged from 6/9 to 6/30 in the affected eye. None of the patients had signs of anterior or vitreous inflammation in the affected eye. Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery.", "Funduscopic findings at presentation included foveal granularity in six patients; in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , it was the sole pathologic retinal finding Figure 1 ; and in three patients patients 2, 3, and 7 , foveal granularity was associated with faint white retinal lesions Figure 2 , located mainly in the midperipheral retina extending to the periphery. Patient 6 had a swollen disc and mild signs of optic neuropathy mild red desaturation, enlarged blind spot on visual field . Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis.", "Patient 6 underwent neurological evaluation due to initial presentation mimicking optic neuritis. Neurological evaluation including full neurological exam and neuroimaging excluded additional neurological deficit, before the diagnosis of MEWDS was established. The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings.", "The clinical findings are summarized in Table 2. 3.2. Multimodal Imaging Findings. Patients who underwent imaging less than 2 weeks from onset of symptoms had the most typical findings. BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 .", "BAF revealed hyperautofluorescent lesions in the macula between and along the arcades in four patients patients 1, 3, 6, and 7 . IR photos showed dark lesions in similar, though not identical, locations Figure 3 . Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities.", "Patients 1 and 6, who underwent ICGA, had hypofluorescent lesions in numbers typically exceeding those detected by both clinical and other imaging modalities. B-scan SD-OCT through the fovea showed a disrupted inner segment ellipsoid zone band of varied severity in all 7 affected eyes. The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria .", "The ellipsoid zone hyper reflective band on SD-OCT anatomically correlates to photoreceptors' inner segment, ellipsoid section densely packed with mitochondria . The transient disruption of the foveal ellipsoid zone on SD-OCT corresponded to the clinically apparent foveal granularity. In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 .", "In patient 5, who presented with sole retinal finding of foveal granularity and mild optic disc leakage on FA, the SD-OCT finding of ellipsoid zone disruption was the main sign for diagnosis MEWDS Figure 1 . Foveal hyperreflectivity found in 3 patients patients 1, 4, and 7 was noted extending into the inner retinal layers Figure 4 . The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 .", "The lesions identified on the BAF, IR, and ICGA images corresponded to the areas of disruption of the ellipsoid zone, on the SD-OCT scans Figure 3 . FA demonstrated nonspecific early punctate hyperfluorescent lesions, with slight staining during the early phase, in four patients patients 2, 3, 6, and 7 . These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities.", "These lesions did not correspond to the findings by either the clinical or other imaging modalities. No pathology was noted in the foveal area despite the presence of typical foveal granularity. Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 .", "Mild optic disc leakage was evident in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 . During the course of the disease, the hyperautofluorescent areas decreased in number and faded without leaving hypoautofluorescent abnormalities. The resolution of the BAF lesions corresponded to the anatomic recovery observed on SD-OCT. The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 .", "The foveal hyperreflectivity disappeared as well Figure 5 . Figure 6 . Four patients patients 1, 4, 6, and 7 underwent serological testing with negative results except for a common result of elevated titer of IgG to VZV. After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 .", "After 6 months of follow-up, the best corrected visual acuity ranged from 6/6 to 6/6.6 Table 2 . Although MEDWS is traditionally considered as a rare syndrome , we report an unusual cluster of seven patients who presented within a three-month period. All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye.", "All patients were otherwise healthy, and all presented with decreased vision in one eye. This cluster of cases could break to some measure the statistical improbability of the rarity of the disease. The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed.", "The atypical presentation in most of our patients could suggest that MEWDS is underdiagnosed. However, it may be in line with the speculation that sometimes atypical findings may simply reflect the moment in time in which the patients were examined and are not a true atypical presentation . In its original description by Jampol et al.", "In its original description by Jampol et al. , MEWDS cases were unilateral with fundus presentation including numerous white dots scattered in the posterior pole and beyond the arcades. During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis.", "During the disease course, granularity appearance of the macula develops in most cases and, when seen, determines the diagnosis. The number of white spots is very variable, and in fact, they may be absent. Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course.", "Given that characteristic white dots were not present in four patients patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 , we were guided by other fundus features, in particular foveal granularity, symptoms, multimodal imaging, and clinical course. While the presumed pathogenesis of MEWDS involves a viral infection, only few reports to date have described a search for the pathogen 5, . The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator.", "The present cluster of cases provided us with a unique opportunity to seek a common viral denominator. Serological testing yielded only an elevated titer of IgG to VZV, most often an indicative of past VZV infection or vaccination; thus, we could not make any generalization regarding these findings. Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS.", "Multimodal imaging BAF, SD-OCT, IR, FA, and ICGA has proven to have high value in the challenging diagnosis of MEWDS. Most of the findings noted here have been described separately in earlier reports 7-9, 11, 12 . However, the present study offered two important advantages.", "However, the present study offered two important advantages. We were able to examine all patients with simultaneously acquired imaging, and multiple correlations between the imaging findings and the clinical evaluation were possible. Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease.", "Moreover, the relatively large size of the cohort and the repeated scans allowed us to verify the imaging findings in this rare disease. We observed corresponding locations of the dark spots on IR images, the hyperautofluorescent spots on the BAF images, and the foci of outer retinal pathology on SD-OCT images. Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT .", "Small hyperreflective points, located in the ganglion cell layer, the ellipsoid zone, and the choriocapillaris, have been noted and described on \"en face\" EDI SD-OCT . However, we noted a unique finding of foveal hyperreflectivity extending into the inner retinal layers. Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS.", "Our finding reinforces a recently described finding in the literature which is believed to be pathognomonic to MEWDS. During the disease course, both the IR and the BAF findings faded in concurrence with the anatomical resolution of the disruption in the ellipsoid zone and the foveal hyperreflective lesion on SD-OCT. Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS.", "Thus, IR images may provide an easy, widely available imaging modality for follow-up of patients with MEWDS. Although IR autofluorescent changes were recently described in patients with MEWDS , this modality is not widely available, whereas IR imaging is routinely performed. Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal.", "Furthermore, on the basis of our findings with multimodal imaging, we suggest that the diagnosis of MEWDS can be established with the simultaneous use of such noninvasive techniques as BAF, IR, and SD-OCT. ICGA and FA may be reserved for secondary use, when findings are equivocal. OCTA is relatively new noninvasive imaging modality that demonstrates flow characteristics of the vascular network within the regional circulation to construct noninvasive images of the vascular network. En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage.", "En face images generated by OCTA also allow us to study the spatial relationships between vasculature and adjacent retinal/choroidal layers with greater precision than dye angiography, and OCTA findings demonstrated no flow impairment in the retinal and choroidal vasculature of the patients scanned after convalescence stage. We cannot overestimate the role of multimodal imaging in these patients, since not too often, the diagnosis is mistaken for optic neuritis, and clinical findings are very subtle. Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret.", "Limitations of the study were the variability in time from disease onset to serologic testing, making the IgM results hard to interpret. Therefore, we consider these tests inconclusive. Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities.", "Secondly, not all the patients had imaging with all modalities. In addition, future research is required using OCT angiography to study the nature of the dots in MEWDS patients and its correlation to other multimodal imaging modalities in the acute and convalescent stage. In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d .", "In conclusion, we present a large unique cluster of patients who presented with MEWDS over a short period Figure 6 : OCTA images following convalescence stage of patients 7's right eye a-b and 6's left eye c-d . The green and red lines represent the x and y axes. Patient 7 after recurrent episodes.", "Patient 7 after recurrent episodes. 3 × 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris a1 , superficial layer a2 , and deep layer a3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 .", "Corresponding x-axis OCT structural B-scan b1 simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram with flow overlay at the cross-section demonstrated by the green line in a1 . SD-OCT b2 demonstrating normal anatomy of the outer retina 6 months after the first acute episode. Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise.", "Patient 6, 3× 3 mm OCT angiogram of the choriocapillaris c1 , superficial layer c2 , and deep layer c3 centered at the macula without any flow compromise. 3 × 3 mm en face structural OCT d1 of the choriocapillaris centered at the macula as in c1. This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c .", "This image was simultaneously obtained during the same scan as the OCT angiogram in c . En face structural OCT of the deep d2 and outer retina d3 . of time. To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons.", "To the best of our knowledge, such a cluster was not previously reported in the literature nor encountered by us at different seasons. The diagnosis was supported by the presence of key features of foveal granularity and disruption of the ellipsoid zone on OCT and their correlation with the hyperautofluorescent lesions identified on BAF. Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality.", "Attention should also be addressed to the dark spots demonstrated on IR images, which may serve as an additional diagnostic clue provided by a noninvasive imaging modality. The disease course in our patients was typical for MEWDS, with almost complete recovery of visual acuity. The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection.", "The specific pathogenesis of MEWDS is unknown but is believed to be an inflammatory condition following a viral infection. We suggest continued serological testing in patients who meet the clinical criteria. The clinical signs of MEWDS are subtle, such that the diagnosis relies on a high index of suspicion. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare." ]

[ "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of equine coronavirus ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. A total of 424 clinical samples were examined from equids with enteric disease in 24 Irish counties between 2011 and 2015. A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA.", "A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA. Nucleocapsid, spike and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of positive samples were sequenced, and sequence and phylogenetic analyses were conducted. Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV.", "Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV. Positive samples were collected from adult horses, Thoroughbred foals and a donkey foal. Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries.", "Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions. The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. This is the first report of ECoV detected in both foals and adult horses in Ireland. Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus .", "Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus . The clinical signs associated with ECoV infection during outbreaks in the USA and Japan were fever, anorexia, lethargy and diarrhoea. The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses .", "The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses . The main transmission route is considered to be faecal-oral and ECoV is usually detected in faecal samples. However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation.", "However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation. Coronaviruses can cause both enteric and respiratory disease in many avian and mammalian species but ECoV is less likely to be found in respiratory secretions than in faeces . Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries .", "Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries . ECoV was detected in samples collected from equids in 48 states of the USA . In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV .", "In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV . All of the qPCR positive foals with diarrhoea were co-infected with other pathogens such as rotavirus or Clostridium perfringens, suggesting that there was potential for ECoV to be over-diagnosed as a causative agent in complex diseases. In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative.", "In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative. Furthermore, only 2.5% of the rectal swabs collected from healthy foals in the largest Thoroughbred horse breeding region in Japan were positive for ECoV . In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV .", "In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV . Similar to the reports from Japan and France, a low prevalence of ECoV was also observed in the UK , Saudi Arabia and Oman . The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland.", "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. The samples were tested by real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR as it has been shown to be the most sensitive diagnostic method for ECoV and is routinely employed as an alternative to virus isolation in diagnostic laboratories worldwide, both for timely diagnosis and in epidemiological studies . Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia .", "Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia . The rRT-PCR assay was performed as previously described using a primer set targeting the nucleocapsid N gene ECoV-380f, ECoV-522r and ECoV-436p Table 1 and AgPath-ID One-Step RT-PCR Kit Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix.", "To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix. Thermal cycling conditions were; 48 • C for 10 min and 95 • C for 10 min, followed by 40 cycles at 94 • C for 15 s and 60 • C for 45 s. The SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq High Fidelity Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA was used for sequencing analysis of two of the five ECoV samples identified. There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing.", "There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing. The primer sets used to amplify the nucleocapsid N gene , the partial spike S gene , and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of non-structural proteins Oue, personal communication are shown in Table 1 . The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany .", "The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany . Sequence analysis was performed using the BLAST and CLUSTALW programs, and Vector NTI Advance 11.5 software Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA . Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 .", "Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 . A phylogenetic tree was constructed based on nucleotide sequences of the K2+G N gene and TN93 S gene using the maximum likelihood method. MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models.", "MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models. Statistical analysis of the tree was performed with the bootstrap test 1000 replicates for multiple alignments. The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis.", "The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis. The accession numbers registered in GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ are as follows: the complete sequences of the N gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149485 and 13V08313/IRL LC149486 , the partial sequences of the S gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149487 and13V08313/IRL LC149488 and the complete sequences from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes; 11V11708/IRL LC149489 and13V08313/IRL LC149490 . One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea.", "One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea. Recovery took over three weeks during which it received fluid therapy, probiotics, antiulcer medication and antibiotics. The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection.", "The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection. The foal responded well to supportive treatment and at the time of sample collection, the diarrhoea had resolved. The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus.", "The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus. The nucleotide sequences of the complete N gene, the partial S gene and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of two positive samples 11V11708/IRL/2011 and 13V08313/IRL/2013 were determined. The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively.", "The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively. The nucleotide identities of the N gene of the two Irish ECoVs and the ECoVs from other continents are summarised in Table 2 . Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 .", "Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 . The analysis for the N gene showed that Irish ECoVs were independently clustered although they were closely related to Japanese viruses identified after 2009. In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed.", "In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed. The length of the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes in the two viruses was 544 base pairs. Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene.", "Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene. Compared with Obihiro 12-1 and 12-2, Irish ECoVs had a three-nucleotide insertion. When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 .", "When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 . The p12.7 gene of the two Irish ECoVs did not have deletions or insertions, and the nucleotide identities were 98.8-99.7% between these viruses and the other ECoVs NC99, Tokachi09, Obihiro12-1 and Obihiro12-2 . This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease.", "This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation.", "However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation. In this study, 424 samples collected between 2011 and 2015 from equids with enteric disease were tested, and only five samples 1.2% were positive for ECoV. The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation.", "The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation. However, this low prevalence of ECoV is similar to that identified in France and among Thoroughbred foals in Japan . Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses.", "Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses. In this study, sequence and phylogenetic analysis Figure 1 demonstrated a high level of homology between viruses detected in a donkey and a horse in two provinces in Ireland in different years. This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity.", "This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity. Compared with the ECoVs of other countries, the N, S and p12.7 genes of the two Irish viruses were highly conserved. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 .", "In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 . Because of polymorphism in this region, this region could be useful for epidemiological investigation . The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. The positive samples were collected in November ., March . and April . in this study.", "and April . in this study. Higher case numbers are identified in the USA during the colder months October to April , and our results were consistent with the circulation period in USA. It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA .", "It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA . The choice of cases to include in the current study may not have been optimal for detection of ECoV as the majority of samples were from foals. However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland.", "However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland. At the time of sample collection in April 2013, the monthly mean temperatures were below long-term average and in parts of the West, were the coldest in 24 years . Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm.", "Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm. Two positive samples were collected from Thoroughbred foals. A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative.", "A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative. A potential difficulty in detecting ECoV from naturally infected horses has been noted previously as serial samples from seven sick horses in the USA suggested that ECoV only persisted for three to nine days in faeces . In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA .", "In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA . This is the first report of ECoV detection in faeces samples from both foals and adult horses in Ireland. The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity.", "The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity. In recent years, there has been an increase in awareness and testing for ECoV in the USA and elsewhere . Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis.", "Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis. There are over 50 Thoroughbred horses per 10,000 of population in Ireland, compared to between three and five for Great Britain, France and the USA . Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses.", "Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses. Ireland exports horses all over the world. By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA .", "By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA . Many questions remain with regard to the clinical significance of ECoV. The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions .", "The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions . However, draft horses appear to have a higher infection rate than other breeds and an outbreak of similar severity has not been reported in Thoroughbred racehorses . The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population.", "The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population. In the past, specific environmental factors were associated with extensive reproductive loss in the Kentucky area and to a lesser extent in other states , but predisposing regional factors such as differences in management, environment or husbandry have not been identified for ECoV. It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV .", "It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV . There was no indication from the results of this study that coronavirus is a major cause of diarrhoea in Irish horses but the introduction of rRT-PCR as a routine diagnostic test will assist in elucidating the significance of this virus to the Irish breeding, racing and sports industries. The primary focus in future will be on testing adult horses that present with anorexia, lethargy, fever and changes in faecal character as a significant association has been demonstrated between this clinical status and molecular detection of ECoV in faeces ." ]

[ "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of equine coronavirus ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. A total of 424 clinical samples were examined from equids with enteric disease in 24 Irish counties between 2011 and 2015. A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA.", "A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA. Nucleocapsid, spike and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of positive samples were sequenced, and sequence and phylogenetic analyses were conducted. Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV.", "Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV. Positive samples were collected from adult horses, Thoroughbred foals and a donkey foal. Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries.", "Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions. The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. This is the first report of ECoV detected in both foals and adult horses in Ireland. Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus .", "Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus . The clinical signs associated with ECoV infection during outbreaks in the USA and Japan were fever, anorexia, lethargy and diarrhoea. The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses .", "The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses . The main transmission route is considered to be faecal-oral and ECoV is usually detected in faecal samples. However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation.", "However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation. Coronaviruses can cause both enteric and respiratory disease in many avian and mammalian species but ECoV is less likely to be found in respiratory secretions than in faeces . Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries .", "Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries . ECoV was detected in samples collected from equids in 48 states of the USA . In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV .", "In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV . All of the qPCR positive foals with diarrhoea were co-infected with other pathogens such as rotavirus or Clostridium perfringens, suggesting that there was potential for ECoV to be over-diagnosed as a causative agent in complex diseases. In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative.", "In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative. Furthermore, only 2.5% of the rectal swabs collected from healthy foals in the largest Thoroughbred horse breeding region in Japan were positive for ECoV . In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV .", "In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV . Similar to the reports from Japan and France, a low prevalence of ECoV was also observed in the UK , Saudi Arabia and Oman . The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland.", "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. The samples were tested by real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR as it has been shown to be the most sensitive diagnostic method for ECoV and is routinely employed as an alternative to virus isolation in diagnostic laboratories worldwide, both for timely diagnosis and in epidemiological studies . Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia .", "Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia . The rRT-PCR assay was performed as previously described using a primer set targeting the nucleocapsid N gene ECoV-380f, ECoV-522r and ECoV-436p Table 1 and AgPath-ID One-Step RT-PCR Kit Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix.", "To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix. Thermal cycling conditions were; 48 • C for 10 min and 95 • C for 10 min, followed by 40 cycles at 94 • C for 15 s and 60 • C for 45 s. The SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq High Fidelity Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA was used for sequencing analysis of two of the five ECoV samples identified. There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing.", "There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing. The primer sets used to amplify the nucleocapsid N gene , the partial spike S gene , and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of non-structural proteins Oue, personal communication are shown in Table 1 . The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany .", "The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany . Sequence analysis was performed using the BLAST and CLUSTALW programs, and Vector NTI Advance 11.5 software Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA . Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 .", "Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 . A phylogenetic tree was constructed based on nucleotide sequences of the K2+G N gene and TN93 S gene using the maximum likelihood method. MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models.", "MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models. Statistical analysis of the tree was performed with the bootstrap test 1000 replicates for multiple alignments. The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis.", "The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis. The accession numbers registered in GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ are as follows: the complete sequences of the N gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149485 and 13V08313/IRL LC149486 , the partial sequences of the S gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149487 and13V08313/IRL LC149488 and the complete sequences from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes; 11V11708/IRL LC149489 and13V08313/IRL LC149490 . One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea.", "One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea. Recovery took over three weeks during which it received fluid therapy, probiotics, antiulcer medication and antibiotics. The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection.", "The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection. The foal responded well to supportive treatment and at the time of sample collection, the diarrhoea had resolved. The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus.", "The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus. The nucleotide sequences of the complete N gene, the partial S gene and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of two positive samples 11V11708/IRL/2011 and 13V08313/IRL/2013 were determined. The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively.", "The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively. The nucleotide identities of the N gene of the two Irish ECoVs and the ECoVs from other continents are summarised in Table 2 . Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 .", "Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 . The analysis for the N gene showed that Irish ECoVs were independently clustered although they were closely related to Japanese viruses identified after 2009. In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed.", "In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed. The length of the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes in the two viruses was 544 base pairs. Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene.", "Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene. Compared with Obihiro 12-1 and 12-2, Irish ECoVs had a three-nucleotide insertion. When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 .", "When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 . The p12.7 gene of the two Irish ECoVs did not have deletions or insertions, and the nucleotide identities were 98.8-99.7% between these viruses and the other ECoVs NC99, Tokachi09, Obihiro12-1 and Obihiro12-2 . This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease.", "This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation.", "However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation. In this study, 424 samples collected between 2011 and 2015 from equids with enteric disease were tested, and only five samples 1.2% were positive for ECoV. The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation.", "The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation. However, this low prevalence of ECoV is similar to that identified in France and among Thoroughbred foals in Japan . Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses.", "Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses. In this study, sequence and phylogenetic analysis Figure 1 demonstrated a high level of homology between viruses detected in a donkey and a horse in two provinces in Ireland in different years. This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity.", "This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity. Compared with the ECoVs of other countries, the N, S and p12.7 genes of the two Irish viruses were highly conserved. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 .", "In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 . Because of polymorphism in this region, this region could be useful for epidemiological investigation . The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. The positive samples were collected in November ., March . and April . in this study.", "and April . in this study. Higher case numbers are identified in the USA during the colder months October to April , and our results were consistent with the circulation period in USA. It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA .", "It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA . The choice of cases to include in the current study may not have been optimal for detection of ECoV as the majority of samples were from foals. However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland.", "However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland. At the time of sample collection in April 2013, the monthly mean temperatures were below long-term average and in parts of the West, were the coldest in 24 years . Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm.", "Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm. Two positive samples were collected from Thoroughbred foals. A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative.", "A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative. A potential difficulty in detecting ECoV from naturally infected horses has been noted previously as serial samples from seven sick horses in the USA suggested that ECoV only persisted for three to nine days in faeces . In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA .", "In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA . This is the first report of ECoV detection in faeces samples from both foals and adult horses in Ireland. The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity.", "The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity. In recent years, there has been an increase in awareness and testing for ECoV in the USA and elsewhere . Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis.", "Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis. There are over 50 Thoroughbred horses per 10,000 of population in Ireland, compared to between three and five for Great Britain, France and the USA . Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses.", "Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses. Ireland exports horses all over the world. By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA .", "By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA . Many questions remain with regard to the clinical significance of ECoV. The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions .", "The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions . However, draft horses appear to have a higher infection rate than other breeds and an outbreak of similar severity has not been reported in Thoroughbred racehorses . The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population.", "The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population. In the past, specific environmental factors were associated with extensive reproductive loss in the Kentucky area and to a lesser extent in other states , but predisposing regional factors such as differences in management, environment or husbandry have not been identified for ECoV. It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV .", "It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV . There was no indication from the results of this study that coronavirus is a major cause of diarrhoea in Irish horses but the introduction of rRT-PCR as a routine diagnostic test will assist in elucidating the significance of this virus to the Irish breeding, racing and sports industries. The primary focus in future will be on testing adult horses that present with anorexia, lethargy, fever and changes in faecal character as a significant association has been demonstrated between this clinical status and molecular detection of ECoV in faeces ." ]

[ "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of equine coronavirus ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. A total of 424 clinical samples were examined from equids with enteric disease in 24 Irish counties between 2011 and 2015. A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA.", "A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA. Nucleocapsid, spike and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of positive samples were sequenced, and sequence and phylogenetic analyses were conducted. Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV.", "Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV. Positive samples were collected from adult horses, Thoroughbred foals and a donkey foal. Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries.", "Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions. The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. This is the first report of ECoV detected in both foals and adult horses in Ireland. Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus .", "Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus . The clinical signs associated with ECoV infection during outbreaks in the USA and Japan were fever, anorexia, lethargy and diarrhoea. The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses .", "The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses . The main transmission route is considered to be faecal-oral and ECoV is usually detected in faecal samples. However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation.", "However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation. Coronaviruses can cause both enteric and respiratory disease in many avian and mammalian species but ECoV is less likely to be found in respiratory secretions than in faeces . Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries .", "Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries . ECoV was detected in samples collected from equids in 48 states of the USA . In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV .", "In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV . All of the qPCR positive foals with diarrhoea were co-infected with other pathogens such as rotavirus or Clostridium perfringens, suggesting that there was potential for ECoV to be over-diagnosed as a causative agent in complex diseases. In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative.", "In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative. Furthermore, only 2.5% of the rectal swabs collected from healthy foals in the largest Thoroughbred horse breeding region in Japan were positive for ECoV . In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV .", "In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV . Similar to the reports from Japan and France, a low prevalence of ECoV was also observed in the UK , Saudi Arabia and Oman . The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland.", "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. The samples were tested by real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR as it has been shown to be the most sensitive diagnostic method for ECoV and is routinely employed as an alternative to virus isolation in diagnostic laboratories worldwide, both for timely diagnosis and in epidemiological studies . Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia .", "Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia . The rRT-PCR assay was performed as previously described using a primer set targeting the nucleocapsid N gene ECoV-380f, ECoV-522r and ECoV-436p Table 1 and AgPath-ID One-Step RT-PCR Kit Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix.", "To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix. Thermal cycling conditions were; 48 • C for 10 min and 95 • C for 10 min, followed by 40 cycles at 94 • C for 15 s and 60 • C for 45 s. The SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq High Fidelity Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA was used for sequencing analysis of two of the five ECoV samples identified. There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing.", "There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing. The primer sets used to amplify the nucleocapsid N gene , the partial spike S gene , and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of non-structural proteins Oue, personal communication are shown in Table 1 . The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany .", "The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany . Sequence analysis was performed using the BLAST and CLUSTALW programs, and Vector NTI Advance 11.5 software Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA . Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 .", "Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 . A phylogenetic tree was constructed based on nucleotide sequences of the K2+G N gene and TN93 S gene using the maximum likelihood method. MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models.", "MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models. Statistical analysis of the tree was performed with the bootstrap test 1000 replicates for multiple alignments. The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis.", "The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis. The accession numbers registered in GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ are as follows: the complete sequences of the N gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149485 and 13V08313/IRL LC149486 , the partial sequences of the S gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149487 and13V08313/IRL LC149488 and the complete sequences from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes; 11V11708/IRL LC149489 and13V08313/IRL LC149490 . One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea.", "One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea. Recovery took over three weeks during which it received fluid therapy, probiotics, antiulcer medication and antibiotics. The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection.", "The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection. The foal responded well to supportive treatment and at the time of sample collection, the diarrhoea had resolved. The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus.", "The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus. The nucleotide sequences of the complete N gene, the partial S gene and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of two positive samples 11V11708/IRL/2011 and 13V08313/IRL/2013 were determined. The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively.", "The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively. The nucleotide identities of the N gene of the two Irish ECoVs and the ECoVs from other continents are summarised in Table 2 . Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 .", "Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 . The analysis for the N gene showed that Irish ECoVs were independently clustered although they were closely related to Japanese viruses identified after 2009. In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed.", "In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed. The length of the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes in the two viruses was 544 base pairs. Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene.", "Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene. Compared with Obihiro 12-1 and 12-2, Irish ECoVs had a three-nucleotide insertion. When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 .", "When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 . The p12.7 gene of the two Irish ECoVs did not have deletions or insertions, and the nucleotide identities were 98.8-99.7% between these viruses and the other ECoVs NC99, Tokachi09, Obihiro12-1 and Obihiro12-2 . This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease.", "This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation.", "However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation. In this study, 424 samples collected between 2011 and 2015 from equids with enteric disease were tested, and only five samples 1.2% were positive for ECoV. The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation.", "The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation. However, this low prevalence of ECoV is similar to that identified in France and among Thoroughbred foals in Japan . Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses.", "Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses. In this study, sequence and phylogenetic analysis Figure 1 demonstrated a high level of homology between viruses detected in a donkey and a horse in two provinces in Ireland in different years. This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity.", "This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity. Compared with the ECoVs of other countries, the N, S and p12.7 genes of the two Irish viruses were highly conserved. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 .", "In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 . Because of polymorphism in this region, this region could be useful for epidemiological investigation . The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. The positive samples were collected in November ., March . and April . in this study.", "and April . in this study. Higher case numbers are identified in the USA during the colder months October to April , and our results were consistent with the circulation period in USA. It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA .", "It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA . The choice of cases to include in the current study may not have been optimal for detection of ECoV as the majority of samples were from foals. However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland.", "However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland. At the time of sample collection in April 2013, the monthly mean temperatures were below long-term average and in parts of the West, were the coldest in 24 years . Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm.", "Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm. Two positive samples were collected from Thoroughbred foals. A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative.", "A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative. A potential difficulty in detecting ECoV from naturally infected horses has been noted previously as serial samples from seven sick horses in the USA suggested that ECoV only persisted for three to nine days in faeces . In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA .", "In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA . This is the first report of ECoV detection in faeces samples from both foals and adult horses in Ireland. The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity.", "The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity. In recent years, there has been an increase in awareness and testing for ECoV in the USA and elsewhere . Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis.", "Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis. There are over 50 Thoroughbred horses per 10,000 of population in Ireland, compared to between three and five for Great Britain, France and the USA . Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses.", "Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses. Ireland exports horses all over the world. By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA .", "By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA . Many questions remain with regard to the clinical significance of ECoV. The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions .", "The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions . However, draft horses appear to have a higher infection rate than other breeds and an outbreak of similar severity has not been reported in Thoroughbred racehorses . The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population.", "The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population. In the past, specific environmental factors were associated with extensive reproductive loss in the Kentucky area and to a lesser extent in other states , but predisposing regional factors such as differences in management, environment or husbandry have not been identified for ECoV. It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV .", "It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV . There was no indication from the results of this study that coronavirus is a major cause of diarrhoea in Irish horses but the introduction of rRT-PCR as a routine diagnostic test will assist in elucidating the significance of this virus to the Irish breeding, racing and sports industries. The primary focus in future will be on testing adult horses that present with anorexia, lethargy, fever and changes in faecal character as a significant association has been demonstrated between this clinical status and molecular detection of ECoV in faeces ." ]

[ "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of equine coronavirus ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. A total of 424 clinical samples were examined from equids with enteric disease in 24 Irish counties between 2011 and 2015. A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA.", "A real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to detect ECoV RNA. Nucleocapsid, spike and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of positive samples were sequenced, and sequence and phylogenetic analyses were conducted. Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV.", "Five samples 1.2% collected in 2011 and 2013 tested positive for ECoV. Positive samples were collected from adult horses, Thoroughbred foals and a donkey foal. Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries.", "Sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis showed that nucleocapsid, spike and p12.7 genes were highly conserved and were closely related to ECoVs identified in other countries. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions. The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the Irish viruses were distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. This is the first report of ECoV detected in both foals and adult horses in Ireland. Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus .", "Text: Equine coronavirus ECoV is a positive-stranded RNA virus and belongs to the species Betacoronavirus 1 in the genus Betacoronavirus . The clinical signs associated with ECoV infection during outbreaks in the USA and Japan were fever, anorexia, lethargy and diarrhoea. The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses .", "The same clinical signs were also recorded in an experimental challenge study using Japanese draft horses . The main transmission route is considered to be faecal-oral and ECoV is usually detected in faecal samples. However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation.", "However, the molecular detection of ECoV in faeces from horses with diarrhoea, does not prove causation. Coronaviruses can cause both enteric and respiratory disease in many avian and mammalian species but ECoV is less likely to be found in respiratory secretions than in faeces . Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries .", "Both molecular and seroepidemiology studies suggest that ECoV may be more prevalent in the USA than in other countries . ECoV was detected in samples collected from equids in 48 states of the USA . In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV .", "In central Kentucky, approximately 30% of both healthy and diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were infected with ECoV . All of the qPCR positive foals with diarrhoea were co-infected with other pathogens such as rotavirus or Clostridium perfringens, suggesting that there was potential for ECoV to be over-diagnosed as a causative agent in complex diseases. In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative.", "In contrast in Japan, although an outbreak of diarrhoea occurred among ECoV-infected draft horses at one racecourse , there have been no similar outbreaks subsequently, and all rectal swabs collected from diarrheic Thoroughbred foals were negative. Furthermore, only 2.5% of the rectal swabs collected from healthy foals in the largest Thoroughbred horse breeding region in Japan were positive for ECoV . In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV .", "In France, 2.8% of 395 faecal samples and 0.5% of 200 respiratory samples collected in 58 counties tested positive for ECoV . Similar to the reports from Japan and France, a low prevalence of ECoV was also observed in the UK , Saudi Arabia and Oman . The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland.", "The objective of this study was to investigate the presence of ECoV in clinical samples submitted to a diagnostic laboratory in Ireland. The samples were tested by real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction rRT-PCR as it has been shown to be the most sensitive diagnostic method for ECoV and is routinely employed as an alternative to virus isolation in diagnostic laboratories worldwide, both for timely diagnosis and in epidemiological studies . Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia .", "Virus isolation and biological characterisation were beyond the capacity of this study, which was similar in scope to that of the studies in horse populations in the USA, Europe and Asia . The rRT-PCR assay was performed as previously described using a primer set targeting the nucleocapsid N gene ECoV-380f, ECoV-522r and ECoV-436p Table 1 and AgPath-ID One-Step RT-PCR Kit Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix.", "To prove that the extraction was successful and that there was no inhibition during rRT-PCR amplification, an internal positive control primer/probe PrimerDesign, Southampton, UK was added to the master mix. Thermal cycling conditions were; 48 • C for 10 min and 95 • C for 10 min, followed by 40 cycles at 94 • C for 15 s and 60 • C for 45 s. The SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq High Fidelity Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA was used for sequencing analysis of two of the five ECoV samples identified. There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing.", "There was inadequate viral nucleic acid in the other three samples for sequencing. The primer sets used to amplify the nucleocapsid N gene , the partial spike S gene , and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of non-structural proteins Oue, personal communication are shown in Table 1 . The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany .", "The RT-PCR products were sequenced commercially by GATC Biotech Cologne, Germany . Sequence analysis was performed using the BLAST and CLUSTALW programs, and Vector NTI Advance 11.5 software Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA, USA . Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 .", "Phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences was conducted with MEGA software Version 5.2 . A phylogenetic tree was constructed based on nucleotide sequences of the K2+G N gene and TN93 S gene using the maximum likelihood method. MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models.", "MEGA software was used to select the optimal substitution models. Statistical analysis of the tree was performed with the bootstrap test 1000 replicates for multiple alignments. The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis.", "The complete genome sequences of NC99 EF446615 , Tokachi09 LC061272 , Obihiro12-1 LC061273 and Obihiro12-2 LC061274 , the N AB671298 and S AB671299 genes of Obihiro2004, the N gene of Hidaka-No.61/2012 LC054263 and Hidaka-No.119/2012 LC054264 , the S gene of ECoV_FRA_2011/1 KC178705 , ECoV_FRA_2011/2 KC178704 , ECoV_FRA_2012/1 KC178703 , ECoV_FRA_2012/2 KC178702 and ECoV_FRA_2012/3 KC178701 were used in sequence and/or phylogenetic analysis. The accession numbers registered in GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ are as follows: the complete sequences of the N gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149485 and 13V08313/IRL LC149486 , the partial sequences of the S gene; 11V11708/IRL LC149487 and13V08313/IRL LC149488 and the complete sequences from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes; 11V11708/IRL LC149489 and13V08313/IRL LC149490 . One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea.", "One six-week-old foal was the only clinical case on a public Thoroughbred stud farm with approximately 30 mares when it presented with diarrhoea. Recovery took over three weeks during which it received fluid therapy, probiotics, antiulcer medication and antibiotics. The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection.", "The second foal was a 14-day-old filly, which had been hospitalised with diarrhoea two days prior to sample collection. The foal responded well to supportive treatment and at the time of sample collection, the diarrhoea had resolved. The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus.", "The five ECoV positive samples tested negative for equine rotavirus. The nucleotide sequences of the complete N gene, the partial S gene and the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes of two positive samples 11V11708/IRL/2011 and 13V08313/IRL/2013 were determined. The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively.", "The nucleotide identities of the N and S genes of the two Irish ECoVs were 99.8% 1338/1341 nucleotides and 99.5% 650/653 nucleotides , respectively. The nucleotide identities of the N gene of the two Irish ECoVs and the ECoVs from other continents are summarised in Table 2 . Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 .", "Phylogenetic analysis was performed for the nucleotide sequences of the complete N and partial S genes Figure 1 . The analysis for the N gene showed that Irish ECoVs were independently clustered although they were closely related to Japanese viruses identified after 2009. In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed.", "In the phylogenetic tree of the S gene, Irish ECoVs were closely related to all other ECoVs analysed. The length of the region from the p4.7 to p12.7 genes in the two viruses was 544 base pairs. Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene.", "Compared with NC99, Irish ECoVs, had a total of 37 nucleotide deletions within p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene. Compared with Obihiro 12-1 and 12-2, Irish ECoVs had a three-nucleotide insertion. When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 .", "When compared with Tokachi09, the Irish ECoVs had a 148-nucleotide insertion see Figure S1 . The p12.7 gene of the two Irish ECoVs did not have deletions or insertions, and the nucleotide identities were 98.8-99.7% between these viruses and the other ECoVs NC99, Tokachi09, Obihiro12-1 and Obihiro12-2 . This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease.", "This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove This study provides the first report of ECoV circulating in Ireland, the third European country with a significant horse industry where the virus has been detected in horses with enteric disease. However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation.", "However, detection of ECoV in faeces samples from horses with enteric disease does not prove causation. In this study, 424 samples collected between 2011 and 2015 from equids with enteric disease were tested, and only five samples 1.2% were positive for ECoV. The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation.", "The inclusion of an internal positive control in the rRT-PCR eliminated the possibility of false negative results due to the presence of PCR inhibitors but the high content of nucleases associated with faeces samples may have caused some RNA degradation. However, this low prevalence of ECoV is similar to that identified in France and among Thoroughbred foals in Japan . Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses.", "Although ECoV has been identified on three continents, little is known about the genetic and pathogenic diversity in field viruses. In this study, sequence and phylogenetic analysis Figure 1 demonstrated a high level of homology between viruses detected in a donkey and a horse in two provinces in Ireland in different years. This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity.", "This suggests that Irish ECoVs may have low genetic diversity. Compared with the ECoVs of other countries, the N, S and p12.7 genes of the two Irish viruses were highly conserved. In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 .", "In contrast, the region from p4.7 and the non-coding region following the p4.7 gene had deletions or insertions Figure S1 . Because of polymorphism in this region, this region could be useful for epidemiological investigation . The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries.", "The differences in the p4.7 region between the Irish ECoVs and other ECoVs indicated that the viruses in Ireland may be distinguishable from those circulating in other countries. The positive samples were collected in November ., March . and April . in this study.", "and April . in this study. Higher case numbers are identified in the USA during the colder months October to April , and our results were consistent with the circulation period in USA. It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA .", "It has been reported that outbreaks mainly occurred among adult riding, racing and show horses in USA . The choice of cases to include in the current study may not have been optimal for detection of ECoV as the majority of samples were from foals. However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland.", "However, two positive samples were collected from adult horses in a combined riding school/show jumping yard in the West of Ireland. At the time of sample collection in April 2013, the monthly mean temperatures were below long-term average and in parts of the West, were the coldest in 24 years . Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm.", "Cold weather may have been a predisposing factor to the ECoV infection on the farm. Two positive samples were collected from Thoroughbred foals. A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative.", "A faeces sample collected from one foal with severe watery diarrhoea and inappetance was positive for ECoV but a sample collected three days later tested negative. A potential difficulty in detecting ECoV from naturally infected horses has been noted previously as serial samples from seven sick horses in the USA suggested that ECoV only persisted for three to nine days in faeces . In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA .", "In both cases, the diarrhoea may have been caused by other unidentified coinfecting pathogens as has been suggested by investigators in the USA . This is the first report of ECoV detection in faeces samples from both foals and adult horses in Ireland. The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity.", "The viruses identified in Ireland are genetically closely related to the Japanese viruses and the results of this study give no indication of significant genetic or phenotypic diversity. In recent years, there has been an increase in awareness and testing for ECoV in the USA and elsewhere . Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis.", "Horse breeding and racing activities in Ireland are the most prominent and important of any country on a per capita basis. There are over 50 Thoroughbred horses per 10,000 of population in Ireland, compared to between three and five for Great Britain, France and the USA . Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses.", "Thus, an investigation of ECoV in Ireland is pertinent not only to increase awareness nationally of the epidemiology of the virus and promote discussion on its clinical importance, but also to inform the industry globally of the health status of Irish horses. Ireland exports horses all over the world. By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA .", "By illustration, in 2016 the country was the second biggest seller of bloodstock at public auctions second only to the USA . Many questions remain with regard to the clinical significance of ECoV. The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions .", "The outbreak at a draft-horse racetrack in Japan in 2009 affected 132 of approximately 600 horses and resulted in non-starters and the implementation of movement restrictions . However, draft horses appear to have a higher infection rate than other breeds and an outbreak of similar severity has not been reported in Thoroughbred racehorses . The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population.", "The much higher incidence of ECoV positive Thoroughbred foals identified in Kentucky compared to similar populations internationally suggests an increased susceptibility to ECoV infection in that population. In the past, specific environmental factors were associated with extensive reproductive loss in the Kentucky area and to a lesser extent in other states , but predisposing regional factors such as differences in management, environment or husbandry have not been identified for ECoV. It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV .", "It has been suggested that ECoV is a coinfecting agent in foals with diarrhoea and clinical infections have predominantly been reported in adult horses with a mono-infection with EcoV . There was no indication from the results of this study that coronavirus is a major cause of diarrhoea in Irish horses but the introduction of rRT-PCR as a routine diagnostic test will assist in elucidating the significance of this virus to the Irish breeding, racing and sports industries. The primary focus in future will be on testing adult horses that present with anorexia, lethargy, fever and changes in faecal character as a significant association has been demonstrated between this clinical status and molecular detection of ECoV in faeces ." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: Pertussis is estimated to cause 2 percent of childhood deaths globally and is a growing public health problem in developed countries despite high vaccination coverage. Infants are at greatest risk of morbidity and mortality. Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries.", "Maternal vaccination during pregnancy may be effective to prevent pertussis in young infants, but population-based estimates of disease burden in infants are lacking, particularly in low-income countries. The objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of pertussis in infants less than 6 months of age in Sarlahi District, Nepal. METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week.", "METHODS: Nested within a population-based randomized controlled trial of influenza vaccination during pregnancy, infants were visited weekly from birth through 6 months to assess respiratory illness in the prior week. If any respiratory symptoms had occurred, a nasal swab was collected and tested with a multitarget pertussis polymerase chain reaction PCR assay. The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014.", "The prospective cohort study includes infants observed between May 2011 and August 2014. RESULTS: The incidence of PCR-confirmed Bordetella pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% confidence interval, 7.7–21.3 in a cohort of 3483 infants with at least 1 day of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal.", "CONCLUSIONS: In a population-based active home surveillance for respiratory illness, a low risk for pertussis was estimated among infants in rural Nepal. Nepal’s immunization program, which includes a childhood whole cell pertussis vaccine, may be effective in controlling pertussis in infants. Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years .", "Text: A resurgence of pertussis across age groups has occurred in several countries in recent years . Middle-and high-income countries that use an acellular pertussis vaccine for the primary vaccination series have been particularly affected , and infants and adolescents have experienced the greatest increase . Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis .", "Factors that may contribute to the increased risk of pertussis include rapidly waning immunity from those vaccinated with acellular vaccines , asymptomatic transmission from individuals vaccinated with acellular vaccines , genetic adaption of Bordetella pertussis , vaccination delay or refusal , improved surveillance and laboratory capabilities , and overall increased awareness of the continuing circulation of B pertussis . Some countries experiencing epidemic pertussis, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Argentina, now recommend pertussis immunization in pregnancy and vaccination of close contacts to protect the youngest infants from pertussis before they can be vaccinated themselves . Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants .", "Recent data from maternal vaccination trials demonstrate the ability of antibodies to be transferred from mothers to their infants in pregnancy and their persistence in infants . Global estimates of pertussis show the highest childhood burden in Southeast Asia . In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine.", "In this region, maternal pertussis vaccination during pregnancy may be a way to protect infants, similar to the approach using tetanus toxoid vaccine. However, globally only 1 population-based estimate of pertussis in infants from birth has been conducted Senegal , and surveillance and laboratory capabilities in Asia are lacking . The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines .", "The World Health Organization WHO recently recommended that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccines continue to do so in light of recent data indicating that acellular pertussis vaccines are less effective than whole cell pertussis vaccines . Population-based data are needed, especially in low-income settings, to provide a more accurate estimate of the burden of pertussis in infants to inform childhood and maternal immunization policies . We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months.", "We report on a prospective cohort study following infants weekly in their homes to monitor for pertussis disease from birth to age 6 months. The objective was to provide a population-based estimate of laboratory-confirmed pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months of age in the Sarlahi District, Nepal. The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal .", "The study was nested within 2 consecutive randomized controlled trials of maternal influenza vaccination during pregnancy set in the Sarlahi District, located in the central Terai low-lying plains region of Nepal . At the start of the trial, prevalent pregnancies were identified through a census of all households in the catchment area. For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies.", "For the duration of the trial, field workers visited all households in the communities, every 5 weeks, where married women 15-40 years resided, for surveillance of incident pregnancies. Once a pregnancy was identified, women provided consent and were enrolled. From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo.", "From April 25, 2011 through September 9, 2013, women between 17 and 34 weeks gestation were randomized and vaccinated with either an influenza vaccine or placebo. The study was a population-based prospective cohort of infants followed from birth through 6 months postpartum. Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council.", "Approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Cincinnati Children's Medical Center, the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, and the Nepal Health Research Council. The trials are registered at Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01034254 . At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics.", "At baseline, information was collected on household structure, socioeconomic status, and demographics. At enrollment, date of last menstrual period and pregnancy history data were collected. As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status.", "As soon as possible after delivery, the mother and infant were visited to collect detailed birth information including infant weight and breastfeeding status. From birth through 6 months, postpartum infants were visited weekly by a field worker, who recorded any infant respiratory symptoms in the past 7 days. If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection.", "If an infant had any of the following symptoms, a mid-nasal nylon flocked swab was collected: fever, cough, wheeze, difficulty breathing, or ear infection. Starting on August 17, 2012, new symptoms, more specific for pertussis, were added to the weekly morbidity visit: apnea, cyanosis, cough with vomit, or whoop/whooping cough. The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD .", "The swabs were stored for up to 1 week at room temperature in PrimeStore Molecular Transport Medium Longhorn Diagnostics LLC, Bethesda, MD . In addition to these signs, mothers were asked which, if any, infant vaccinations were received in the past 7 days, including pertussis vaccination . Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia .", "Mid-nasal swabs were also collected on a weekly basis from mothers from enrollment through 6 months postpartum who reported fever plus one additional morbidity cough, sore throat, nasal congestion, or myalgia . All nasal swabs collected from infants were tested for B pertussis, Bordetella parapertussis, and Bordetella bronchispetica. Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens.", "Only the nasal swabs of mothers whose infants tested positive for any of these pathogens were tested for the same pathogens. Real-time polymerase chain reaction PCR testing was conducted at the University of Washington's Molecular Virology Laboratory according to previously published methods . Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica.", "Two-target PCR was used to assess the presence of 3 Bordetella species: B pertussis, B parapertussis, and B bronchiseptica. The amplified targets were chromosomal repeated insertion sequence IS481 IS and the polymorphic pertussis toxin ptxA promoter region PT . After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad .", "After amplification, the melting points of the amplicons were measured in an iCycler Bio-Rad . A sample was interpreted as positive when the target s had a melting temperature within the species-specific acceptable range and a computed tomography ≤42. A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible.", "A sample was negative if none of the targets tested positive or a single positive target was not reproducible. Maternal nasal swabs were tested for those mothers whose infants tested positive for any Bordetella species Polymerase chain reaction was also performed for several viral infections influenza, rhinovirus RV , respiratory syncytial virus RSV , bocavirus BoV , human metapneumovirus, coronavirus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza as previously described . Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 .", "Of 3693 women enrolled, 3646 infants were live born to 3621 women Supplementary Figure 1 . Infants were included in this analysis if they were followed for any length of the follow-up period 0 to 180 days ; median total follow-up was 146 days per infant Supplementary Figure 2 . The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months.", "The final dataset consists of 3483 infants, contributing 1280 infant-years of observation, with at least 1 follow-up visit during the first 6 months. This includes infants from the entire trial period, both before and after more pertussis-specific additions to the weekly symptom questionnaire. At baseline, data on household structure were gathered.", "At baseline, data on household structure were gathered. At enrollment, women reported their literacy status binary and pregnancy history. The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation.", "The field workers identified their ethnicity into 2 broad groups Pahadi, a group originating from the hills; or Madeshi, a group originating from north India from names and observation. Women were categorized as nulliparous or multiparous. Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households.", "Responses to 25 questions about household construction, water and sanitation, and household assets were used to develop an index to measure the socioeconomic status of households. Binary variables for each of the 25 questions and a mean SES score were calculated for each household. Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance.", "Gestational age was measured using a woman's report of date of last menstrual period during pregnancy surveillance. Birth weight was collected as soon as possible after birth using a digital scale Tanita model BD-585, precision to nearest 10 grams . Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis.", "Birth weights collected >72 hours after birth were excluded from the analysis. Small for gestational age SGA was calculated using the sex-specific 10th percentile cutoff described by Alexander et al and the INTERGROWTH-21 standards . Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery .", "Women were asked within how many hours of birth breastfeeding was initiated and binary breastfeeding categories were created ≤1 hour versus >1 hour postdelivery . Incidence was calculated as the number of pertussis cases per 1000 infant-years at risk. Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed.", "Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals CIs were constructed. Characteristics of infant pertussis cases were compared with nonpertussis cases using bivariate Poisson regression. Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes.", "Characteristics of all pertussis respiratory episodes were compared with nonpertussis respiratory episodes; t tests were used for continuous predictors and Fisher's exact tests were used for categorical associations due to the low number of pertussis episodes. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 14.1. A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014.", "A total of 3483 infants had 4283 episodes of respiratory illness between May 18, 2011 and April 30, 2014. Thirty-nine percent n = 1350 of infants experienced no respiratory episodes. The incidence of respiratory illness was 3.6 episodes per infant-year 95% CI, 3.5-3.7 . Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 .", "Mean episode duration was 4.7 days 95% CI, 4.6-4.9 . A total of 3930 92% episodes were matched to 1 or more pertussis-tested nasal swabs from 2026 infants Supplementary Figure 1 . Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants .", "Seventeen cases of B pertussis were identified from 19 nasal swabs nasal swabs were positive on 2 consecutive weeks for 2 infants . The incidence of PCR-confirmed B pertussis was 13.3 cases per 1000-infant years 95% CI, 7.7-21.3 . Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 .", "Five cases of B parapertussis were detected with an incidence of 3.9 cases per 1000 infant-years 95% CI, 1.3-9.1 . No cases of B bronchiseptica were identified. The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 .", "The average pertussis episode duration was 8 days range, 2-33 Table 1 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 83 days range, 19-137 median, 80; interquartile range, 63-109 . The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit.", "The most common symptoms were cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit. None of the additional symptoms related to pertussis that were added in year 2 cyanosis, apnea, cough with vomit, and whoop resulted in collection of nasal swabs based solely on these additional symptoms. Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness.", "Pertussis episodes were statistically significantly more likely to include difficulty breathing, cough with vomit, and whoop compared with other respiratory illness. Six infants had at least 1 pertussis vaccination before pertussis disease onset three <2 weeks and three >2 weeks before pertussis illness with a mean of 18 days from vaccination to illness compared with 49 days for nonpertussis episodes P = .03 . Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days.", "Five infants received their first pertussis vaccination postpertussis disease onset, whereas 6 infants received no pertussis vaccination in the first 180 days. Three fourths of pertussis episodes were coinfected with at least 1 virus, with RV and BoV the most common. Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis.", "Cases of pertussis were more likely to be infected with BoV than respiratory cases due to causes other than pertussis. The majority of cases occurred between February 2013 and January 2014 Figure 1 . No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented.", "No statistically significant differences between risk factors for pertussis and nonpertussis cases Table 2 were documented. Given the low number of pertussis cases, the lack of a statistical association is not evidence of nonassociation. No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis.", "No deaths occurred in infants who had pertussis. Of the 8 mothers of B pertussis-positive infants who had a nasal swab collected 14 nasal swabs total during their own follow-up, none were positive for any pertussis species. The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 .", "The 5 B parapertussis cases were primarily male whose mothers were primiparous, literate, and Pahadi ethnicity Supplementary Table 1 . No mothers of infants who had B parapertussis had a nasal swab collected during follow-up. The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 .", "The average B parapertussis episode duration was 4 days Supplementary Table 2 . Mean age of onset of symptoms was 58 days with a range of 7-95 days. The most common symptoms were cough and wheeze. Rhinovirus and RSV were the only coinfections observed. All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 .", "All B parapertussis cases occurred between September 2011 and February 2012 Figure 1 . A low incidence of pertussis and generally mild clinical presentation were found in infants <6 months in Nepal. To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia.", "To our knowledge, this represents one of the first population-based active surveillance of PCR-confirmed pertussis among young infants in Asia. Acellular pertussis vaccine trials conducted in the 1990s found the average pertussis incidence in the whole cell vaccine groups ranged from 1 to 37 cases per 1000 infantyears . Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range.", "Our finding of 13 B pertussis cases per 1000 infantyears was on the lower end of this range. In the United States in 2014, the estimated pertussis incidence in infants less than 6 months was 2 cases per 1000 infant-years , much lower than observed in our study; however, this passive surveillance system likely vastly underestimates pertussis incidence. Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours.", "Thus, there is a need for active surveillance data such as ours. Furthermore, given our highly sensitive case detection method, many of our pertussis cases would likely not have been detected in the previous acellular pertussis vaccine trials. More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further.", "More stringent respiratory symptom criteria would have lowered our incidence estimate even further. The low incidence was found in a population where pentavalent vaccine Pentavac: Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis Whole Cell , Hepatitis-B and Haemophilus Type b Conjugate Vaccine; Serum Institute of India Pvt. Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months .", "Ltd , scheduled for administration at 6, 10, and 14 weeks, is received with significant delays 7% of infants received all 3 recommended pertussis vaccines by 6 months . These data support the WHO's recommendation that countries using whole cell pertussis vaccine continue to do so given that the majority of outbreaks have been concentrated in countries using the acellular pertussis vaccine . Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine .", "Recent studies suggest that protection from acellular pertussis vaccine is not as strong or long lasting as that conferred by the whole cell pertussis vaccine . Another contributing factor to the low pertussis incidence observed could be that surveillance was conducted during a period of low pertussis transmission. Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period .", "Pertussis is a cyclical disease, thought to peak every 2 to 4 years, and we may have captured the burden at a low circulation period . We observed over 70% of our B pertussis cases over a 1-year period. This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden.", "This increase from earlier observation periods could indicate a temporary rise in pertussis consistent with its cyclical pattern or a true increase in the baseline burden. Previous research on pertussis seasonality has in different places and time periods demonstrated various periods of peak transmission or no discernable patterns . Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive.", "Although our data do not support a seasonal pattern, the numbers observed are too low to be conclusive. Pertussis symptom duration and severity were mild compared with the classic pertussis case presentation. Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting .", "Only 3 of the 17 cases fulfilled the WHO criteria, which requires a minimum of 2 weeks of cough, whoop, or posttussive vomiting . Studies on pertussis in infants have generally been clinic-based, hospital-based, or in an outbreak, which therefore required a certain severity of illness for parents to recognize a need for medical attention . These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases .", "These study designs and passive surveillance efforts therefore may have missed milder pertussis cases . Our study, which required only 1 respiratory symptom for a nasal swab to be collected, had increased sensitivity to detect a range of pertussis case presentations. An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal.", "An alternative explanation for the mild cases seen could be an increase in the proportion of mild compared with severe pertussis cases in Nepal. Although cough, difficulty breathing, and cough with vomit were the most common symptoms, no symptom was present in all B pertussis cases. During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis .", "During an epidemic period in Washington state, among infants <1 year, who had a minimum of 14 days cough plus an additional symptom, 82% had posttussive emesis, 29% had apnea, 26% had whoop, and 42% had cyanosis . A study of US neonates with pertussis showed the symptom prevalence to be 97% for cough, 91% for cyanosis, 58% for apnea, and 3% for fever . Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever.", "Our study found lower or equal symptom prevalence with the exception of fever. Fever prevalence was higher in our study, similar to that found in Peru . Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous.", "Although not statistically significant, infants with pertussis were more likely to have been born preterm, low birth weight, and SGA, and their mothers were more likely to be primiparous. These findings are similar to previous studies showing no difference in pertussis cases by sex or crowding but showing differences by birth weight . Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies .", "Coinfections were common, consistent with findings from other hospital-based studies . Codetection of B pertussis and B parapertussis with respiratory viruses may be due to asymptomatic pertussis carriage. The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 .", "The incidence of B parapertussis of 4 cases per 1000 person-years was comparable to that of 2 per 1000 person-years found in the Italian acellular pertussis vaccine trial in 1992-1993 . The duration of illness was shorter for B parapertussis with a maximum duration of 6 days compared with a maximum of 33 days for B pertussis. A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection .", "A milder presentation is consistent with clinical knowledge of B parapertussis infection . Bordetella parapertussis cases occurred only during a 5-month period. There were several study design limitations. We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents.", "We cannot be certain whether the reported symptoms were caused by pertussis, another organism, or whether symptoms were related to 2 or more etiologic agents. We were unable to perform multivariate regression modeling for characteristics associated with pertussis disease and pertussis cases due to the small number of cases we detected. Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker.", "Infant respiratory symptoms were reported by parents, who may have missed signs that might have been observed by a healthcare worker. However, the criteria for collection of the nasal swab were broad and did not require sophisticated clinical skills. However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify.", "However, apnea and cyanosis may have been difficult for parents to identify. Although the criteria for specimen collection changed in year 2, no infant experienced a pertussis-specific symptom in isolation without also having one of the originally specified respiratory symptoms. These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria.", "These data support our assumption that we were unlikely to have missed pertussis cases in year 1 with our less sensitive respiratory symptom criteria. Nasal swabs were collected in the mid-nasal region for influenza virus detection, which may have lowered the sensitivity of pertussis detection. In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate.", "In a field site, the acceptability of an additional nasopharyngeal swab would likely have increased the participant refusal rate. This would have decreased the generalizability of our results to the entire population. Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity.", "Although nasopharyngeal swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates are the recommended specimen collection method , the nasopharyngeal region was established as the collection area of choice when the diagnostic measure was culture, which has low sensitivity. Recent data demonstrated the comparability of using mid-nasal versus nasopharyngeal swabs in PCR pertussis detection . Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates.", "Strengths of the study included being a population-based, prospective study, with very low refusal rates. Risk factors, clinical symptoms, and coinfections were prospectively identified without the potential bias that may occur when these data are collected retrospectively or in clinical settings. The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation.", "The community-based design allows generalizability of these results to the entire population and not just those seeking care at a health facility or in an outbreak situation. The Sarlahi District is located in the Terai region where the majority of Nepalese reside, and it has similar demographics to the entire population of Nepal . Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent.", "Sarlahi's location near sea level and on the border with India supports the generalizability of these results to many populations living on the Indian subcontinent. The weekly active surveillance with sensitive criteria for pertussis testing was able to detect mild and atypical pertussis cases, which may have been missed by previous traditional surveillance. The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target.", "The multitarget PCR method allowed highly sensitive and specific detection of 2 additional Bordetella species beyond the primary B pertussis target. We observed a low incidence of pertussis in infants in a whole cell vaccine environment. Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions.", "Pertussis cases were generally milder than expected compared with traditional pertussis clinical definitions. These data support clinicians considering pertussis in their differential diagnosis of infants with mild respiratory symptoms. Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months.", "Policymakers in Nepal will need to weigh the benefit of an additional prenatal pertussis vaccine or a switch to acellular primary pertussis vaccine with the low burden of pertussis in infants less than 6 months. Our study demonstrated that mid-nasal swabs were able to detect pertussis using a sensitive multitarget PCR. The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs.", "The less invasive mid-nasal nasal swab is an attractive alternative for pertussis nasal swab collection, and further research is needed to compare this collection site with nasopharyngeal swabs. In the future, this method may enhance population-based surveillance efforts." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: The weekly proportion of laboratory tests that are positive for influenza is used in public health surveillance systems to identify periods of influenza activity. We aimed to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing in Canada based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system. METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression.", "METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests. The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region.", "The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region. CONCLUSIONS: The estimated sensitivity of influenza tests reported to this national laboratory surveillance system is considerably less than reported test characteristics for most laboratory tests. A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics.", "A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics. Improved diagnosis would permit better estimation of the burden of influenza. Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule.", "Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule. Clinicians do not routinely seek laboratory confirmation for several reasons: diagnosis will often not alter patient management, a paucity of real-time, accurate, inexpensive testing methods and because influenza is not recognized as the etiology of the clinical presentation . Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy .", "Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy . Although rapid influenza tests such as pointof-care tests are purported to generate results in a timely fashion to influence clinical care, the performance characteristics of the currently available tests are sub-optimal . New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity .", "New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity . The performance characteristics of currently available tests for influenza vary considerably and the overall sensitivities of these tests when used in routine practice are also dependent on the type of specimen collected, the age of the patient and point in their illness in which they are sampled 4, 9, . We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, .", "We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, . Weekly respiratory virus identifications from September 1999 to August 2006 were obtained from the Respiratory Virus Detection Surveillance System RVDSS , Public Health Agency of Canada . The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus.", "The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus. Specimens are generally submitted to laboratories by clinicians in the course of clinical care, and by clinicians participating in one of our national influenza surveillance programs, FluWatch . Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program.", "Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program. The RVDSS is supplemented by case reports of influenza positive cases . From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September.", "From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September. Infants and children under the age of 5 years accounted for 25% of the influenza A positive tests, and persons over the age 65 years another 35%. Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age.", "Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age. Testing practices are known to be varied . The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time.", "The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time. For the 2005/06 season a survey of laboratory techniques in current use indicated that culture accounted for 44% of the diagnostic tests with RT-PCR, rapid antigen tests and direct fluorescent-antibody assay DFA accounting for 21%, 19%, and 16% respectively . The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables.", "The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables. The estimated baseline implicitly accounts for influenza tests on specimens taken from patients with respiratory infections due to respiratory pathogens other than the four viruses captured in the RVDSS, as long as both the testing behaviour of clinicians and respiratory illnesses caused by other respiratory pathogens follow a consistent seasonal pattern as prescribed by the model see below, The Poisson regression model with a linear link function was estimated using SAS PROC GENMOD: Coefficients b 5 to b 9 are multipliers. The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w .", "The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w . The weekly number of influenza negative tests attributed to RSV is given by b 7 RSVp w. , and similarly for adenovirus and PIV. For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative.", "For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative. By specifying a linear link, a value of 0.33, say, for coefficient b 5 , means that for every test for which influenza A was confirmed, 0.33 additional tests, on average, were performed on truly influenza A positive specimens and found to be negativewhich corresponds to a sensitivity of 75%. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively.", "Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively. The false negative rate is 1 minus sensitivity. While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1.", "While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1. For each test confirmed positive for RSV, on average b 7 tests were performed for influenza and found to be negative for influenza. These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown.", "These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown. If all specimens had been tested for the same viruses panel tests , 1/b 7 would correspond to the sensitivity for RSV testing, and the sensitivity for adenovirus and PIV given by 1/b 8 and 1/b 9 respectively. Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses.", "Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses. Sequential testing may occur if a rapid test for influenza is negative and the laboratory then performs PCR or culture testing. Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses .", "Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses . By contrast, many laboratories conduct panel tests for multiple viruses for ease of handling, decreased patient sampling, and recognition that coinfection can occur. Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity.", "Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity. As a single specimen may undergo multiple tests, the false-negative rate applicable to a specimen that has undergone multiple tests would be expected to be much lower than the system average for individual tests. Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections .", "Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections . Over 50,000 tests for influenza were reported to the RVDSS each year, peaking in 2004/05 at 101,000. Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season.", "Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season. The proportion positive for RSV, parainfluenza and adenovirus averaged 9%, 3% and 2% respectively. As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve .", "As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve . Even for the winter months of December through April, one of these 4 viruses was identified on average in no more than 30% of the specimens. The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity.", "The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity. The sensitivity for influenza A testing averaged 33.7% with model-estimated 95% confidence intervals of 33.3-34.1 for the 1999/2000-2005/06 period. Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 .", "Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 . Estimated sensitivities varied somewhat from season to season, generally ranging from 30%-40% Table 1 , and provincial level estimates, as well, were within a similar range. Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively.", "Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively. Estimates of sensitivity based on test results reported to the RVDSS for individual laboratories with sufficient data to fit the model showed significant variation, with estimates of sensitivity ranging from 25-65%. As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates.", "As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates. However, information on testing procedures is limited primarily to the 2005/06 survey. As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model.", "As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model. Figure 2 illustrates a good model fit where the weekly number of influenza negative tests is well explained by the model covariates, with a few exceptions. Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals.", "Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals. Residuals typically capture random variation; hence represent tests that can not be allocated based on the specified model. In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US.", "In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US. As these periods corresponded to a period of heightened public awareness due to severe influenza outbreaks, parameter estimation was repeated without these data points. Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza.", "Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza. The attribution of influenza negative test results to influenza and other viruses is illustrated in Figure 3 . The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested.", "The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested. A reduction in specimen collection and testing, primarily for viruses other than influenza, is also evident over the Christmas period Figure 3 . The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%.", "The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%. Accounting for the model estimated false negative rate suggests that during periods of peak influenza activity, 40-90% of tests were performed on specimens taken from persons recently infected with influenza. Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection.", "Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection. The corresponding figures for the whole year indicate that 10% of specimens were confirmed positive for influenza and 30% of influenza tests could be model-attributed to an influenza infection annually. Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal.", "Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal. The model estimated sensitivity based on influenza test results reported to the RVDSS of 30-40% is much lower than the standard assay sensitivities documented in the literature. Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period .", "Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period . As performance characteristics of specific tests are generally based on high quality specimens, the difference of approximately 40% is likely linked to any one of many operational procedures that affects the quality of the specimen and its procurement. Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country.", "Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country. As well, variation in the indications for diagnostic testing may vary across the country. As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected.", "As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected. The overall model fit, and the general consistency of the sensitivity estimates, suggests that these many respiratory viruses were reasonably accounted for by the seasonal baseline and that the strong association between the number of influenza positive and influenza negative tests on a weekly basis is indicative of a significant number of false negative results, rather than the activity of another virus or viruses exactly synchronous with influenza. The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards.", "The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards. However, to significantly and consistently bias the estimate, the degree of synchronization would have to be fairly strong, persist over the whole study period, and occur in all provinces. Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza .", "Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza . As well, patients may present for care due to a secondary bacterial infection. While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test.", "While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test. This is not considered a source of bias. The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate.", "The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate. The accuracy of diagnostic tests is known to be affected by the quality of the specimen , its handling, the timing of collection after symptom onset, and the age of the patient . Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures.", "Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures. For most laboratory tests, specimen procurement within 72 hours of from the onset of symptoms is recommended , yet patients often present much later in the course of illness. Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza.", "Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza. In addition, there are inherent differences in the performance characteristics of the currently used diagnostic tests 4, 6, 8, . Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity.", "Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity. The routine use of RT-PCR testing has only recently become available in Canada only 20% of tests used RT-PCR methods as of 2005/06 , but increased use of this modality is expected to improve accuracy. Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited.", "Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited. Grijalva and colleagues estimated the diagnostic sensitivity in a capture recapture study of children hospitalized for respiratory complications at 69% for a RT-PCR based system and 39% for a clinical-laboratory based system passive surveillance of tests performed during clinical practice, and using a variety of commercially available tests . Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible.", "Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible. Cooper and colleagues attributed 22% of telephone health calls for cold/flu to influenza over two relatively mild years, and elsewhere 20% of admissions for acute respiratory infections including influenza in adults aged 20-64 years were attributed to influenza, and 42% for seniors . While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data.", "While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data. It would have been helpful to analyze data based on each specimen sent for testing. With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection.", "With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection. Coinfection, which was not accounted for in our model, could result in an under-estimation of the number of falsely negative tests, as the attribution of an influenza negative test that was actually coinfected with influenza and another respiratory virus would have to be split between the viruses. With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates.", "With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates. As the false negative rate appears to be laboratory dependant data not shown , this estimated range is applicable only to the RVDSS for the study period. A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods.", "A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods. As positive results, particularly for culture, are often obtained a week or more after the specimen was received, some positive results may have been reported in a different week than the test. Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities.", "Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities. These irregularities would tend to bias the estimated parameter towards zero, and hence the estimated sensitivity towards 1. Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated .", "Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated . Poor test sensitivity contributes to the chronic underestimation of the burden of influenza in the general population. Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy.", "Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy. We have illustrated a simple method that uses the surveillance data itself to estimate the system wide sensitivity associated with the weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive. Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results.", "Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results. The capacity for improved diagnostic accuracy will ultimately improve our understanding of the epidemiology of influenza." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: The weekly proportion of laboratory tests that are positive for influenza is used in public health surveillance systems to identify periods of influenza activity. We aimed to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing in Canada based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system. METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression.", "METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests. The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region.", "The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region. CONCLUSIONS: The estimated sensitivity of influenza tests reported to this national laboratory surveillance system is considerably less than reported test characteristics for most laboratory tests. A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics.", "A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics. Improved diagnosis would permit better estimation of the burden of influenza. Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule.", "Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule. Clinicians do not routinely seek laboratory confirmation for several reasons: diagnosis will often not alter patient management, a paucity of real-time, accurate, inexpensive testing methods and because influenza is not recognized as the etiology of the clinical presentation . Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy .", "Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy . Although rapid influenza tests such as pointof-care tests are purported to generate results in a timely fashion to influence clinical care, the performance characteristics of the currently available tests are sub-optimal . New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity .", "New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity . The performance characteristics of currently available tests for influenza vary considerably and the overall sensitivities of these tests when used in routine practice are also dependent on the type of specimen collected, the age of the patient and point in their illness in which they are sampled 4, 9, . We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, .", "We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, . Weekly respiratory virus identifications from September 1999 to August 2006 were obtained from the Respiratory Virus Detection Surveillance System RVDSS , Public Health Agency of Canada . The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus.", "The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus. Specimens are generally submitted to laboratories by clinicians in the course of clinical care, and by clinicians participating in one of our national influenza surveillance programs, FluWatch . Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program.", "Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program. The RVDSS is supplemented by case reports of influenza positive cases . From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September.", "From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September. Infants and children under the age of 5 years accounted for 25% of the influenza A positive tests, and persons over the age 65 years another 35%. Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age.", "Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age. Testing practices are known to be varied . The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time.", "The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time. For the 2005/06 season a survey of laboratory techniques in current use indicated that culture accounted for 44% of the diagnostic tests with RT-PCR, rapid antigen tests and direct fluorescent-antibody assay DFA accounting for 21%, 19%, and 16% respectively . The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables.", "The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables. The estimated baseline implicitly accounts for influenza tests on specimens taken from patients with respiratory infections due to respiratory pathogens other than the four viruses captured in the RVDSS, as long as both the testing behaviour of clinicians and respiratory illnesses caused by other respiratory pathogens follow a consistent seasonal pattern as prescribed by the model see below, The Poisson regression model with a linear link function was estimated using SAS PROC GENMOD: Coefficients b 5 to b 9 are multipliers. The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w .", "The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w . The weekly number of influenza negative tests attributed to RSV is given by b 7 RSVp w. , and similarly for adenovirus and PIV. For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative.", "For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative. By specifying a linear link, a value of 0.33, say, for coefficient b 5 , means that for every test for which influenza A was confirmed, 0.33 additional tests, on average, were performed on truly influenza A positive specimens and found to be negativewhich corresponds to a sensitivity of 75%. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively.", "Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively. The false negative rate is 1 minus sensitivity. While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1.", "While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1. For each test confirmed positive for RSV, on average b 7 tests were performed for influenza and found to be negative for influenza. These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown.", "These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown. If all specimens had been tested for the same viruses panel tests , 1/b 7 would correspond to the sensitivity for RSV testing, and the sensitivity for adenovirus and PIV given by 1/b 8 and 1/b 9 respectively. Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses.", "Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses. Sequential testing may occur if a rapid test for influenza is negative and the laboratory then performs PCR or culture testing. Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses .", "Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses . By contrast, many laboratories conduct panel tests for multiple viruses for ease of handling, decreased patient sampling, and recognition that coinfection can occur. Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity.", "Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity. As a single specimen may undergo multiple tests, the false-negative rate applicable to a specimen that has undergone multiple tests would be expected to be much lower than the system average for individual tests. Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections .", "Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections . Over 50,000 tests for influenza were reported to the RVDSS each year, peaking in 2004/05 at 101,000. Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season.", "Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season. The proportion positive for RSV, parainfluenza and adenovirus averaged 9%, 3% and 2% respectively. As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve .", "As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve . Even for the winter months of December through April, one of these 4 viruses was identified on average in no more than 30% of the specimens. The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity.", "The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity. The sensitivity for influenza A testing averaged 33.7% with model-estimated 95% confidence intervals of 33.3-34.1 for the 1999/2000-2005/06 period. Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 .", "Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 . Estimated sensitivities varied somewhat from season to season, generally ranging from 30%-40% Table 1 , and provincial level estimates, as well, were within a similar range. Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively.", "Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively. Estimates of sensitivity based on test results reported to the RVDSS for individual laboratories with sufficient data to fit the model showed significant variation, with estimates of sensitivity ranging from 25-65%. As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates.", "As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates. However, information on testing procedures is limited primarily to the 2005/06 survey. As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model.", "As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model. Figure 2 illustrates a good model fit where the weekly number of influenza negative tests is well explained by the model covariates, with a few exceptions. Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals.", "Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals. Residuals typically capture random variation; hence represent tests that can not be allocated based on the specified model. In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US.", "In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US. As these periods corresponded to a period of heightened public awareness due to severe influenza outbreaks, parameter estimation was repeated without these data points. Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza.", "Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza. The attribution of influenza negative test results to influenza and other viruses is illustrated in Figure 3 . The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested.", "The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested. A reduction in specimen collection and testing, primarily for viruses other than influenza, is also evident over the Christmas period Figure 3 . The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%.", "The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%. Accounting for the model estimated false negative rate suggests that during periods of peak influenza activity, 40-90% of tests were performed on specimens taken from persons recently infected with influenza. Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection.", "Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection. The corresponding figures for the whole year indicate that 10% of specimens were confirmed positive for influenza and 30% of influenza tests could be model-attributed to an influenza infection annually. Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal.", "Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal. The model estimated sensitivity based on influenza test results reported to the RVDSS of 30-40% is much lower than the standard assay sensitivities documented in the literature. Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period .", "Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period . As performance characteristics of specific tests are generally based on high quality specimens, the difference of approximately 40% is likely linked to any one of many operational procedures that affects the quality of the specimen and its procurement. Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country.", "Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country. As well, variation in the indications for diagnostic testing may vary across the country. As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected.", "As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected. The overall model fit, and the general consistency of the sensitivity estimates, suggests that these many respiratory viruses were reasonably accounted for by the seasonal baseline and that the strong association between the number of influenza positive and influenza negative tests on a weekly basis is indicative of a significant number of false negative results, rather than the activity of another virus or viruses exactly synchronous with influenza. The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards.", "The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards. However, to significantly and consistently bias the estimate, the degree of synchronization would have to be fairly strong, persist over the whole study period, and occur in all provinces. Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza .", "Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza . As well, patients may present for care due to a secondary bacterial infection. While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test.", "While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test. This is not considered a source of bias. The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate.", "The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate. The accuracy of diagnostic tests is known to be affected by the quality of the specimen , its handling, the timing of collection after symptom onset, and the age of the patient . Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures.", "Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures. For most laboratory tests, specimen procurement within 72 hours of from the onset of symptoms is recommended , yet patients often present much later in the course of illness. Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza.", "Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza. In addition, there are inherent differences in the performance characteristics of the currently used diagnostic tests 4, 6, 8, . Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity.", "Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity. The routine use of RT-PCR testing has only recently become available in Canada only 20% of tests used RT-PCR methods as of 2005/06 , but increased use of this modality is expected to improve accuracy. Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited.", "Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited. Grijalva and colleagues estimated the diagnostic sensitivity in a capture recapture study of children hospitalized for respiratory complications at 69% for a RT-PCR based system and 39% for a clinical-laboratory based system passive surveillance of tests performed during clinical practice, and using a variety of commercially available tests . Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible.", "Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible. Cooper and colleagues attributed 22% of telephone health calls for cold/flu to influenza over two relatively mild years, and elsewhere 20% of admissions for acute respiratory infections including influenza in adults aged 20-64 years were attributed to influenza, and 42% for seniors . While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data.", "While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data. It would have been helpful to analyze data based on each specimen sent for testing. With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection.", "With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection. Coinfection, which was not accounted for in our model, could result in an under-estimation of the number of falsely negative tests, as the attribution of an influenza negative test that was actually coinfected with influenza and another respiratory virus would have to be split between the viruses. With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates.", "With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates. As the false negative rate appears to be laboratory dependant data not shown , this estimated range is applicable only to the RVDSS for the study period. A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods.", "A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods. As positive results, particularly for culture, are often obtained a week or more after the specimen was received, some positive results may have been reported in a different week than the test. Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities.", "Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities. These irregularities would tend to bias the estimated parameter towards zero, and hence the estimated sensitivity towards 1. Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated .", "Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated . Poor test sensitivity contributes to the chronic underestimation of the burden of influenza in the general population. Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy.", "Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy. We have illustrated a simple method that uses the surveillance data itself to estimate the system wide sensitivity associated with the weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive. Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results.", "Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results. The capacity for improved diagnostic accuracy will ultimately improve our understanding of the epidemiology of influenza." ]

[ "BACKGROUND: The weekly proportion of laboratory tests that are positive for influenza is used in public health surveillance systems to identify periods of influenza activity. We aimed to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing in Canada based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system. METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression.", "METHODS AND FINDINGS: The weekly number of influenza-negative tests from 1999 to 2006 was modelled as a function of laboratory-confirmed positive tests for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , adenovirus and parainfluenza viruses, seasonality, and trend using Poisson regression. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests. The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region.", "The sensitivity of influenza testing was estimated to be 33% 95%CI 32–34% , varying from 30–40% depending on the season and region. CONCLUSIONS: The estimated sensitivity of influenza tests reported to this national laboratory surveillance system is considerably less than reported test characteristics for most laboratory tests. A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics.", "A number of factors may explain this difference, including sample quality and specimen procurement issues as well as test characteristics. Improved diagnosis would permit better estimation of the burden of influenza. Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule.", "Text: Although influenza virus infection is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality , laboratory confirmation of clinical illness is the exception rather than the rule. Clinicians do not routinely seek laboratory confirmation for several reasons: diagnosis will often not alter patient management, a paucity of real-time, accurate, inexpensive testing methods and because influenza is not recognized as the etiology of the clinical presentation . Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy .", "Accurate diagnosis of influenza-like illness, however, could improve clinical care through reduced use of antibiotics and ancillary testing, and more appropriate use of antiviral therapy . Although rapid influenza tests such as pointof-care tests are purported to generate results in a timely fashion to influence clinical care, the performance characteristics of the currently available tests are sub-optimal . New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity .", "New technologies with improved sensitivity such as reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction RT-PCR as well as the use of more effective collection systems such as the flocked nasopharyngeal swab compared to traditional rayon wound swabs, and the recommendation to collect more ideal specimens, such as nasopharyngeal swabs rather than throat swabs are likely to improve diagnostic sensitivity . The performance characteristics of currently available tests for influenza vary considerably and the overall sensitivities of these tests when used in routine practice are also dependent on the type of specimen collected, the age of the patient and point in their illness in which they are sampled 4, 9, . We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, .", "We sought to estimate the sensitivity of influenza testing based on results of a national respiratory virus surveillance system using a model-based method 1, 2, . Weekly respiratory virus identifications from September 1999 to August 2006 were obtained from the Respiratory Virus Detection Surveillance System RVDSS , Public Health Agency of Canada . The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus.", "The RVDSS collects, collates, and reports weekly data from participating laboratories on the number of tests performed and the number of specimens confirmed positive for influenza, respiratory syncytial virus RSV , para-influenza virus PIV , and adenovirus. Specimens are generally submitted to laboratories by clinicians in the course of clinical care, and by clinicians participating in one of our national influenza surveillance programs, FluWatch . Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program.", "Indicators of influenza activity are reported year round on a weekly basis to the FluWatch program. The RVDSS is supplemented by case reports of influenza positive cases . From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September.", "From the case reports, influenza A was confirmed in all age groups and sporadic cases were confirmed in the off-season months of June through September. Infants and children under the age of 5 years accounted for 25% of the influenza A positive tests, and persons over the age 65 years another 35%. Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age.", "Unfortunately, FluWatch surveillance data does not provide the total number of tests by age. Testing practices are known to be varied . The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time.", "The predominant testing methods used for influenza detection varied considerably by province or laboratory and over time. For the 2005/06 season a survey of laboratory techniques in current use indicated that culture accounted for 44% of the diagnostic tests with RT-PCR, rapid antigen tests and direct fluorescent-antibody assay DFA accounting for 21%, 19%, and 16% respectively . The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables.", "The weekly number of tests negative for influenza was modelled, using Poisson regression, as a function of viral identifications for influenza, RSV, adenovirus and PIV as well as a baseline consisting of seasonality, trend and holiday variables. The estimated baseline implicitly accounts for influenza tests on specimens taken from patients with respiratory infections due to respiratory pathogens other than the four viruses captured in the RVDSS, as long as both the testing behaviour of clinicians and respiratory illnesses caused by other respiratory pathogens follow a consistent seasonal pattern as prescribed by the model see below, The Poisson regression model with a linear link function was estimated using SAS PROC GENMOD: Coefficients b 5 to b 9 are multipliers. The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w .", "The weekly number of influenza negative tests estimated to be falsely negative is given by b 5 InflA w +b 6 InflB w . The weekly number of influenza negative tests attributed to RSV is given by b 7 RSVp w. , and similarly for adenovirus and PIV. For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative.", "For each positive influenza A test, an additional b 5 tests above baseline were performed and found to be negative. By specifying a linear link, a value of 0.33, say, for coefficient b 5 , means that for every test for which influenza A was confirmed, 0.33 additional tests, on average, were performed on truly influenza A positive specimens and found to be negativewhich corresponds to a sensitivity of 75%. Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively.", "Sensitivity was calculated as the number of influenza positive tests divided by the number of influenza positive tests plus the model-estimated number of false negative tests, or equivalently, the estimates of sensitivity for influenza A and B are given by 1/ 1+b 5 and 1/ 1+b 6 respectively. The false negative rate is 1 minus sensitivity. While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1.", "While the null value for b 5 is zero, which indicates no statistical association between the number of influenza positive tests and the number of influenza negative tests, the corresponding null value for sensitivity is 1. For each test confirmed positive for RSV, on average b 7 tests were performed for influenza and found to be negative for influenza. These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown.", "These b 7 tests are attributed to an RSV infection, however the number of influenza-negative tests that actually tested positive for RSV is unknown. If all specimens had been tested for the same viruses panel tests , 1/b 7 would correspond to the sensitivity for RSV testing, and the sensitivity for adenovirus and PIV given by 1/b 8 and 1/b 9 respectively. Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses.", "Some laboratories are known to test for viruses sequentially , and so 1/b 7 -1/b 9 were not interpreted as estimates of the sensitivity for other viruses. Sequential testing may occur if a rapid test for influenza is negative and the laboratory then performs PCR or culture testing. Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses .", "Similarly in young children with a respiratory illness in the winter, rapid tests for RSV infection may be performed first, and only specimens with negative results submitted for subsequent testing for influenza or other respiratory viruses . By contrast, many laboratories conduct panel tests for multiple viruses for ease of handling, decreased patient sampling, and recognition that coinfection can occur. Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity.", "Either form of sequential testing would not bias the estimate of sensitivity applicable to test results reported to RVDSS, though significant use of rapid antigen tests in the laboratories reporting to RVDSS would reduce the overall sensitivity. As a single specimen may undergo multiple tests, the false-negative rate applicable to a specimen that has undergone multiple tests would be expected to be much lower than the system average for individual tests. Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections .", "Parameters b 1. to b 4 account for trends and the seasonality of truly negative specimens patients presenting with other acute respiratory infections . Over 50,000 tests for influenza were reported to the RVDSS each year, peaking in 2004/05 at 101,000. Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season.", "Overall 10% of the influenza tests were positive for influenza, ranging from 4% to 13% depending on the season. The proportion positive for RSV, parainfluenza and adenovirus averaged 9%, 3% and 2% respectively. As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve .", "As seen in Figure 1 , no virus was identified in 75% of specimens submitted for testing white area under the curve . Even for the winter months of December through April, one of these 4 viruses was identified on average in no more than 30% of the specimens. The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity.", "The strong and consistent synchronization of negative tests with influenza positive tests, as seen in Figure 1 , is suggestive that false negative results contributed to the large number of negative tests during periods of influenza activity. The sensitivity for influenza A testing averaged 33.7% with model-estimated 95% confidence intervals of 33.3-34.1 for the 1999/2000-2005/06 period. Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 .", "Influenza B testing had a similar estimated sensitivity at 34.7 95% CI 33.4-36.1 . Estimated sensitivities varied somewhat from season to season, generally ranging from 30%-40% Table 1 , and provincial level estimates, as well, were within a similar range. Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively.", "Stratifying by province or season produced similar estimates for the sensitivity of influenza A testing: 32% 95% CI 30-34 and 36% 95% CI 33-41 respectively. Estimates of sensitivity based on test results reported to the RVDSS for individual laboratories with sufficient data to fit the model showed significant variation, with estimates of sensitivity ranging from 25-65%. As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates.", "As expected, laboratories using primarily rapid antigen tests had lower estimated sensitivities, and laboratories that used PCR methods had higher sensitivity estimates. However, information on testing procedures is limited primarily to the 2005/06 survey. As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model.", "As well, additional irregularities were noticed in the laboratory data and not all laboratories provided sufficient data to fit the model. Figure 2 illustrates a good model fit where the weekly number of influenza negative tests is well explained by the model covariates, with a few exceptions. Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals.", "Firstly, it is evident that additional specimens were tested during the SARS period, as indicated by the period where the number of weekly influenza negative tests exceeded the expected number, or equivalently, a period of successive positive residuals. Residuals typically capture random variation; hence represent tests that can not be allocated based on the specified model. In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US.", "In addition to the SARS period, testing appears to have been elevated for a number of weeks in January 2000 during the peak of the 1999/2000 A/ Sydney/05/97 H3N2 season in which respiratory admissions were unusually elevated , and in December 2003, when an elevated risk of paediatric deaths associated with the A/Fujian/411/02 H3N2 strain was identified in the US. As these periods corresponded to a period of heightened public awareness due to severe influenza outbreaks, parameter estimation was repeated without these data points. Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza.", "Exclusion of these data points did not alter the sensitivity estimate for influenza. The attribution of influenza negative test results to influenza and other viruses is illustrated in Figure 3 . The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested.", "The baseline curve is the model estimate of the number of tests that were likely truly negative for all four viruses tested. A reduction in specimen collection and testing, primarily for viruses other than influenza, is also evident over the Christmas period Figure 3 . The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%.", "The weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive for influenza peaked each season at 15 to 30%. Accounting for the model estimated false negative rate suggests that during periods of peak influenza activity, 40-90% of tests were performed on specimens taken from persons recently infected with influenza. Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection.", "Influenza was confirmed in only 14% of specimens sent for testing over the winter period, whereas the sensitivity estimate would imply that up to 40% of influenza tests could be attributed to an influenza infection. The corresponding figures for the whole year indicate that 10% of specimens were confirmed positive for influenza and 30% of influenza tests could be model-attributed to an influenza infection annually. Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal.", "Despite a relatively large number of tests in the off-season, the number of influenza positive tests was almost negligible; suggesting that the false positive rate applicable to RVDSS influenza testing is minimal. The model estimated sensitivity based on influenza test results reported to the RVDSS of 30-40% is much lower than the standard assay sensitivities documented in the literature. Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period .", "Standard sensitivities for diagnostic procedures used by participating laboratories ranged from 64% for rapid antigen tests to 95% for RT-PCR tests, averaging 75% for the study period . As performance characteristics of specific tests are generally based on high quality specimens, the difference of approximately 40% is likely linked to any one of many operational procedures that affects the quality of the specimen and its procurement. Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country.", "Unlike validation studies, our samples are taken from a variety of clinical settings and processed with a variety of procedures across the country. As well, variation in the indications for diagnostic testing may vary across the country. As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected.", "As there are many other respiratory pathogens that are not routinely tested for, or reported to the RVDSS, including human metapneumovirus hMPV , coronaviruses, and rhinoviruses for which patients may seek medical care and present with influenza like illness , a large proportion of negative test results was expected. The overall model fit, and the general consistency of the sensitivity estimates, suggests that these many respiratory viruses were reasonably accounted for by the seasonal baseline and that the strong association between the number of influenza positive and influenza negative tests on a weekly basis is indicative of a significant number of false negative results, rather than the activity of another virus or viruses exactly synchronous with influenza. The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards.", "The latter would bias the estimated sensitivity of the system downwards. However, to significantly and consistently bias the estimate, the degree of synchronization would have to be fairly strong, persist over the whole study period, and occur in all provinces. Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza .", "Synchronization was not observed among the RVDSS viruses influenza A, influenza B, RSV, adenovirus and PIV , and elsewhere other viruses such as rhinovirus, coronavirus and hMPV accounted for only a small proportion of the viral identifications and were not found to be synchronized with influenza . As well, patients may present for care due to a secondary bacterial infection. While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test.", "While any specimen would likely test negative as the virus, at this point, is likely not detectable, the model would statistically attribute a negative test in this case to the primary infection; one of the four RVDSS viruses or to the seasonal baseline that represents other respiratory infections, depending on the level of viral activity at the time of the test. This is not considered a source of bias. The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate.", "The large variation in false negative rates estimated for individual laboratories reporting to the RVDSS suggests that standardization of sample procurement, testing and reporting procedures would likely reduce the overall false negative rate. The accuracy of diagnostic tests is known to be affected by the quality of the specimen , its handling, the timing of collection after symptom onset, and the age of the patient . Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures.", "Even with the most sensitive molecular methodologies, yield was shown to be strongly related to the time since onset of symptoms , with a 3-fold decline in proportion positive within 3 to 5 days after onset of symptoms for both RT-PCR and culture procedures. For most laboratory tests, specimen procurement within 72 hours of from the onset of symptoms is recommended , yet patients often present much later in the course of illness. Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza.", "Estimates of the median time since onset of symptoms suggest a delay of 3 and 5 days for outpatient and inpatients respectively , however these estimates are limited to patients with laboratory confirmed influenza. In addition, there are inherent differences in the performance characteristics of the currently used diagnostic tests 4, 6, 8, . Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity.", "Lack of standardization between diagnostic tests and algorithms used in different laboratories reporting to the RVDSS adds to this complexity. The routine use of RT-PCR testing has only recently become available in Canada only 20% of tests used RT-PCR methods as of 2005/06 , but increased use of this modality is expected to improve accuracy. Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited.", "Population or system level sensitivity estimates that include the effects of sample quality are limited. Grijalva and colleagues estimated the diagnostic sensitivity in a capture recapture study of children hospitalized for respiratory complications at 69% for a RT-PCR based system and 39% for a clinical-laboratory based system passive surveillance of tests performed during clinical practice, and using a variety of commercially available tests . Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible.", "Though the expected proportion of influenza tests that were due to influenza infections is unknown and variable, our model estimate of 30% appears plausible. Cooper and colleagues attributed 22% of telephone health calls for cold/flu to influenza over two relatively mild years, and elsewhere 20% of admissions for acute respiratory infections including influenza in adults aged 20-64 years were attributed to influenza, and 42% for seniors . While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data.", "While there are limitations with this approach, there are no other simple alternatives to assist in the interpretation of the RVDSS data. It would have been helpful to analyze data based on each specimen sent for testing. With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection.", "With only the number of weekly tests and number of positive results, we were unable to calculate the number of specimens that were actually found to be negative for all four viruses, or to estimate the extent of co-infection. Coinfection, which was not accounted for in our model, could result in an under-estimation of the number of falsely negative tests, as the attribution of an influenza negative test that was actually coinfected with influenza and another respiratory virus would have to be split between the viruses. With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates.", "With auxiliary information associated with each specimen, model estimates of false negative rates based on, for example, test type, time since onset of symptoms, age of the patient, or clinical presentation would have allowed us to explore the reasons for the high false negative rates. As the false negative rate appears to be laboratory dependant data not shown , this estimated range is applicable only to the RVDSS for the study period. A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods.", "A significant reduction in the false negative rate is anticipated as methods become standardized and with the uptake of the new RT-PCR methods. As positive results, particularly for culture, are often obtained a week or more after the specimen was received, some positive results may have been reported in a different week than the test. Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities.", "Multiple test results for a single specimen may have also contributed to reporting irregularities. These irregularities would tend to bias the estimated parameter towards zero, and hence the estimated sensitivity towards 1. Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated .", "Considering the overall model fit and the relative severity of influenza , we conclude that our estimate of sensitivity may be slightly over-estimated number of false negatives under-estimated . Poor test sensitivity contributes to the chronic underestimation of the burden of influenza in the general population. Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy.", "Since estimates of the burden of illness drive planning for preventive and therapeutic interventions, it is important to improve all aspects leading to improved diagnostic accuracy. We have illustrated a simple method that uses the surveillance data itself to estimate the system wide sensitivity associated with the weekly proportion of tests confirmed positive. Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results.", "Although our estimate of sensitivity is only applicable to the interpretation of the RVDSS data over the study period, similar estimates for specific cohorts or laboratory procedures may help guide further investigation into the reasons for the large number of false negative test results. The capacity for improved diagnostic accuracy will ultimately improve our understanding of the epidemiology of influenza." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "We report the nearly complete genome sequence of a human enterovirus, a strain of echovirus 30, obtained from a cerebrospinal fluid specimen from a teenaged patient with aseptic meningitis in September 2017. Text: E choviruses are members of the Enterovirus B species of the Enterovirus EV genus in the Picornaviridae family of nonenveloped, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA viruses. Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses .", "Echoviruses were named from the acronym enteric cytopathic human orphan virus at the time of their discovery in the 1950s but were later found to be associated with respiratory illness, hand-foot-and-mouth disease, and aseptic meningitis, similar to other enteroviruses . . According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology .", "According to the California Code of Regulations, meningitis cases are reportable to the California Department of Public Health CDPH within 1 day of identification of etiology . . In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH.", "In the fall of 2017, a cluster of aseptic meningitis cases from a northern California high school were reported to the CDPH. The Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory VRDL at the CDPH detected EV from 19 of 30 patients 63% by real-time reverse transcription-PCR RT-PCR , as previously described . .", ". We generated and analyzed partial capsid viral protein 1 VP1 sequences using methods developed by Minnaar et al. . . Fifteen of 19 79% EV-positive patients were confirmed to have echovirus 30 E-30 , using cerebrospinal fluid CSF samples. This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases .", "This cluster of E-30 meningitis cases is similar to previously reported E-30 aseptic meningitis cases . in symptoms and epidemiology. Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens.", "Here, we report a nearly complete genome sequence from one of the E-30-positive CSF specimens. The CSF was processed by centrifugation, 0.45-m filtration, and nuclease treatment prior to extraction using the NucliSENS easyMAG system bioMérieux, Durham, NC .. The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR .", "The extracted nucleic acids were then treated with DNase to yield RNA, which was subjected to random reverse transcription and PCR . . The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA .", "The next-generation sequencing NGS library was prepared using a Nextera XT kit and sequenced on a MiSeq platform 300-cycle paired-end run Illumina, San Diego, CA . The NGS data were analyzed using an in-house Centers for Disease Control and Prevention CDC pipeline which involves the removal of host sequences using bowtie2/2.3.3.1, primer removal, low-quality below Q20 and read length Ͻ50 nucleotides filtering using cutadapt 1.18, read duplication removal using a Dedup.py script, de novo assembly using SPAdes 3.7 default parameters, and BLAST search of the resultant contigs . .", ". There were a total of 141,329 postprocessing FASTQ reads. The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . .", "The final consensus genome was inspected and annotated using Geneious v10.0.9 . . The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol ..", "The contig was built from 15,712 reads, assembled to an E-30 reference genome GenBank accession number JX976773 , and deemed nearly complete by comparison to the reference, and the termini were determined as part of the protocol .. The total GC content is 48.3% for 7,155 bases. The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome.", "The average read coverage was 260-fold for the E-30 genome. The genome sequence was designated E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005. Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences.", "Its VP1 sequence was confirmed by the CDC Picornavirus Laboratory to be nearly identical to those of E-30s identified in an aseptic meningitis outbreak that occurred in the fall of 2017 in Nevada; it also has greater than 99% nucleotide identity to the VP1 sequences of E-30 strains from the southern United States identified by the CDC in May 2017 GenBank accession numbers MG584831 and MG584832 , as measured using the online version of blastn The genome sequence of E-30 USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 shares less than 89% nucleotide identity NI and less than 98% amino acid identity AI with other publicly available E-30 sequences. The sequence contains the complete protein-coding region, with short sections in the untranslated regions UTRs missing due to a lack of read coverage approximately 182 and 90 nucleotides of the 5= and 3= UTRs, respectively . The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions.", "The enterovirus polyprotein can be divided into one structural P1-capsid and two nonstructural P2 and P3 regions. The polyprotein regions of the E-30 genome reported here share 96%, 88%, and 84% NI P1, P2, and P3, respectively with other E-30 sequences in GenBank. Data availability.", "Data availability. The E-30 sequence of USA/2017/CA-RGDS-1005 has been deposited in GenBank under the accession number MK238483. The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176.", "The quality-filtered FASTQ reads have been deposited in the Sequence Read Archive with the run accession number SRR10082176. The contributions of the California Department of Public Health Viral and Rickettsial Disease Laboratory were supported in part by the Epidemiology and Laboratory Capacity for Infectious Diseases Cooperative Agreement number 6 NU50CK000410 from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item.", "This work was partly funded by federal appropriations to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, through the Advanced Molecular Detection Initiative line item. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author s and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Nuclear receptors NRs are closely associated with various major diseases such as cancer, diabetes, inflammatory disease, and osteoporosis. Therefore, NRs have become a frequent target for drug development. During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell?", "During the process of developing drugs against these diseases by targeting NRs, we are often facing a problem: Given a NR and chemical compound, can we identify whether they are really in interaction with each other in a cell? To address this problem, a predictor called “iNR-Drug” was developed. In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm.", "In the predictor, the drug compound concerned was formulated by a 256-D dimensional vector derived from its molecular fingerprint, and the NR by a 500-D vector formed by incorporating its sequential evolution information and physicochemical features into the general form of pseudo amino acid composition, and the prediction engine was operated by the SVM support vector machine algorithm. Compared with the existing prediction methods in this area, iNR-Drug not only can yield a higher success rate, but is also featured by a user-friendly web-server established at which is particularly useful for most experimental scientists to obtain their desired data in a timely manner. It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug server may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Text: With the ability to directly bind to DNA Figure 1 and regulate the expression of adjacent genes, nuclear receptors NRs are a class of ligand-inducible transcription factors. They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology .", "They regulate various biological processes, such as homeostasis, differentiation, embryonic development, and organ physiology . The NR superfamily has been classified into seven families: NR0 knirps or DAX like ; NR1 thyroid hormone like , NR2 HNF4-like , NR3 estrogen like , NR4 nerve growth factor IB-like , NR5 fushi tarazu-F1 like , and NR6 germ cell nuclear factor like . Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins .", "Since they are involved in almost all aspects of human physiology and are implicated in many major diseases such as cancer, diabetes and osteoporosis, nuclear receptors have become major drug targets , along with G protein-coupled receptors GPCRs , ion channels , and kinase proteins . Identification of drug-target interactions is one of the most important steps for the new medicine development . The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation .", "The method usually adopted in this step is molecular docking simulation . However, to make molecular docking study feasible, a reliable 3D three dimensional structure of the target protein is the prerequisite condition. Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive.", "Although X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool in determining protein 3D structures, it is time-consuming and expensive. Particularly, not all proteins can be successfully crystallized. For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents.", "For example, membrane proteins are very difficult to crystallize and most of them will not dissolve in normal solvents. Therefore, so far very few membrane protein 3D structures have been determined. Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly.", "Although NMR Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins as indicated by a series of recent publications see, e.g., and a review article , it is also time-consuming and costly. To acquire the 3D structural information in a timely manner, one has to resort to various structural bioinformatics tools see, e.g., , particularly the homologous modeling approach as utilized for a series of protein receptors urgently needed during the process of drug development 19, . Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited .", "Unfortunately, the number of dependable templates for developing high quality 3D structures by means of homology modeling is very limited . To overcome the aforementioned problems, it would be of help to develop a computational method for predicting the interactions of drugs with nuclear receptors in cellular networking based on the sequences information of the latter. The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds .", "The results thus obtained can be used to pre-exclude the compounds identified not in interaction with the nuclear receptors, so as to timely stop wasting time and money on those unpromising compounds . Actually, based on the functional groups and biological features, a powerful method was developed recently for this purpose. However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons.", "However, further development in this regard is definitely needed due to the following reasons. a He et al. did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition .", "did not provide a publicly accessible web-server for their method, and hence its practical application value is quite limited, particularly for the broad experimental scientists; b The prediction quality can be further enhanced by incorporating some key features into the formulation of NR-drug nuclear receptor and drug samples via the general form of pseudo amino acid composition . The present study was initiated with an attempt to develop a new method for predicting the interaction of drugs with nuclear receptors by addressing the two points. As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public.", "As demonstrated by a series of recent publications 10, 18, and summarized in a comprehensive review , to establish a really effective statistical predictor for a biomedical system, we need to consider the following steps: a select or construct a valid benchmark dataset to train and test the predictor; b represent the statistical samples with an effective formulation that can truly reflect their intrinsic correlation with the object to be predicted; c introduce or develop a powerful algorithm or engine to operate the prediction; d properly perform cross-validation tests to objectively evaluate the anticipated accuracy of the predictor; e establish a user-friendly web-server for the predictor that is accessible to the public. Below, let us elaborate how to deal with these steps. The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies.", "The data used in the current study were collected from KEGG Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes at KEGG is a database resource for understanding high-level functions and utilities of the biological system, such as the cell, the organism and the ecosystem, from molecular-level information, especially large-scale molecular datasets generated by genome sequencing and other high-throughput experimental technologies. Here, the benchmark dataset can be formulated as where is the positive subset that consists of the interactive drug-NR pairs only, while the negative subset that contains of the non-interactive drug-NR pairs only, and the symbol represents the union in the set theory. The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks.", "The so-called \"interactive\" pair here means the pair whose two counterparts are interacting with each other in the drug-target networks as defined in the KEGG database ; while the \"non-interactive\" pair means that its two counterparts are not interacting with each other in the drug-target networks. The positive dataset contains 86 drug-NR pairs, which were taken from He et al. .", ". The negative dataset contains 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs, which were derived according to the following procedures: a separating each of the pairs in into single drug and NR; b re-coupling each of the single drugs with each of the single NRs into pairs in a way that none of them occurred in ; c randomly picking the pairs thus formed until reaching the number two times as many as the pairs in . The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds.", "The 86 interactive drug-NR pairs and 172 non-interactive drug-NR pairs are given in Supplementary Information S1, from which we can see that the 86 + 172 = 258 pairs in the current benchmark dataset are actually formed by 25 different NRs and 53 different compounds. Since each of the samples in the current network system contains a drug compound and a NR protein , the following procedures were taken to represent the drug-NR pair sample. First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in .", "First, for the drug part in the current benchmark dataset, we can use a 256-D vector to formulate it as given by where D represents the vector for a drug compound, and d i its i-th i = 1,2, ,256 component that can be derived by following the \"2D molecular fingerprint procedure\" as elaborated in . The 53 molecular fingerprint vectors thus obtained for the 53 drugs in are, respectively, given in Supplementary Information S2. The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3.", "The protein sequences of the 25 different NRs in are listed in Supplementary Information S3. Suppose the sequence of a nuclear receptor protein P with L residues is generally expressed by where 1 R represents the 1st residue of the protein sequence P , 2 R the 2nd residue, and so forth. Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation .", "Now the problem is how to effectively represent the sequence of Equation . with a non-sequential or discrete model . This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples.", "This is because all the existing operation engines, such as covariance discriminant CD 17, 65, , neural network , support vector machine SVM 83 , random forest , conditional random field , nearest neighbor NN ; K-nearest neighbor KNN , OET-KNN , and Fuzzy K-nearest neighbor , can only handle vector but not sequence samples. However, a vector defined in a discrete model may completely lose all the sequence-order information and hence limit the quality of prediction. Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects?", "Facing such a dilemma, can we find an approach to partially incorporate the sequence-order effects? Actually, one of the most challenging problems in computational biology is how to formulate a biological sequence with a discrete model or a vector, yet still keep considerable sequence order information. To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed.", "To avoid completely losing the sequence-order information for proteins, the pseudo amino acid composition or Chou's PseAAC was proposed. Ever since the concept of PseAAC was proposed in 2001 , it has penetrated into almost all the areas of computational proteomics, such as predicting anticancer peptides , predicting protein subcellular location , predicting membrane protein types , predicting protein submitochondria locations , predicting GABA A receptor proteins , predicting enzyme subfamily classes , predicting antibacterial peptides , predicting supersecondary structure , predicting bacterial virulent proteins , predicting protein structural class , predicting the cofactors of oxidoreductases , predicting metalloproteinase family , identifying cysteine S-nitrosylation sites in proteins , identifying bacterial secreted proteins , identifying antibacterial peptides , identifying allergenic proteins , identifying protein quaternary structural attributes , identifying risk type of human papillomaviruses , identifying cyclin proteins , identifying GPCRs and their types , discriminating outer membrane proteins , classifying amino acids , detecting remote homologous proteins , among many others see a long list of papers cited in the References section of . Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., .", "Moreover, the concept of PseAAC was further extended to represent the feature vectors of nucleotides , as well as other biological samples see, e.g., . Because it has been widely and increasingly used, recently two powerful soft-wares, called \"PseAAC-Builder\" and \"propy\" , were established for generating various special Chou's pseudo-amino acid compositions, in addition to the web-server \"PseAAC\" built in 2008. According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf.", "According to a comprehensive review , the general form of PseAAC for a protein sequence P is formulated by where the subscript  is an integer, and its value as well as the components 1, 2, , u u   will depend on how to extract the desired information from the amino acid sequence of P cf. Equation . .", "Equation . . Below, let us describe how to extract useful information to define the components of PseAAC for the NR samples concerned. First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes.", "First, many earlier studies see, e.g., have indicated that the amino acid composition AAC of a protein plays an important role in determining its attributes. The AAC contains 20 components with each representing the occurrence frequency of one of the 20 native amino acids in the protein concerned. Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation .", "Thus, such 20 AAC components were used here to define the first 20 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 1, 2, , 20 ii fi   . where f i . is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned.", "is the normalized occurrence frequency of the i-th type native amino acid in the nuclear receptor concerned. Since AAC did not contain any sequence order information, the following steps were taken to make up this shortcoming. To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition.", "To avoid completely losing the local or short-range sequence order information, we considered the approach of dipeptide composition. It contained 20 × 20 = 400 components . Such 400 components were used to define the next 400 elements in Equation . ; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where .", "; i.e., . 20 1, 2, , 400 jj fj where . j f is the normalized occurrence frequency of the j-th dipeptides in the nuclear receptor concerned. To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach.", "To incorporate the global or long-range sequence order information, let us consider the following approach. According to molecular evolution, all biological sequences have developed starting out from a very limited number of ancestral samples. Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion.", "Driven by various evolutionary forces such as mutation, recombination, gene conversion, genetic drift, and selection, they have undergone many changes including changes of single residues, insertions and deletions of several residues , gene doubling, and gene fusion. With the accumulation of these changes over a long period of time, many original similarities between initial and resultant amino acid sequences are gradually faded out, but the corresponding proteins may still share many common attributes , such as having basically the same biological function and residing at a same subcellular location . To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below.", "To extract the sequential evolution information and use it to define the components of Equation ., the PSSM Position Specific Scoring Matrix was used as described below. According to Schaffer , the sequence evolution information of a nuclear receptor protein P with L amino acid residues can be expressed by a 20 L matrix, as given by where . were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned.", "were generated by using PSI-BLAST to search the UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot database The Universal Protein Resource UniProt ; through three iterations with 0.001 as the E-value cutoff for multiple sequence alignment against the sequence of the nuclear receptor concerned. In order to make every element in Equation . be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation .", "be scaled from their original score ranges into the region of , we performed a conversion through the standard sigmoid function to make it become Now we extract the useful information from Equation . Moreover, we used the grey system model approach as elaborated in to further define the next 60 components of Equation . 1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j .", "1, 2, , 20 In the above equation, w 1 , w 2 , and w 3 are weight factors, which were all set to 1 in the current study; f j . has the same meaning as in Equation . where   and Combining Equations ., ., .", "where   and Combining Equations ., ., . and ., we found that the total number of the components obtained via the current approach for the PseAAC of Equation . and each of the 500 components is given by . Since the elements in Equations . and .", "Since the elements in Equations . and . are well defined, we can now formulate the drug-NR pair by combining the two equations as given by   . where G represents the drug-NR pair, Å the orthogonal sum, and the 256 + 500 = 756 components are defined by Equations . and . .", "and . . For the sake of convenience, let us use x i i = 1, 2, , 756 to represent the 756 components in Equation . ; i.e., . To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation .", "To optimize the prediction quality with a time-saving approach, similar to the treatment , let us convert Equation . to where the symbol means taking the average of the quantity therein, and SD means the corresponding standard derivation. In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine.", "In this study, the SVM support vector machine was used as the operation engine. SVM has been widely used in the realm of bioinformatics see, e.g., . The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function.", "The basic idea of SVM is to transform the data into a high dimensional feature space, and then determine the optimal separating hyperplane using a kernel function. For a brief formulation of SVM and how it works, see the papers ; for more details about SVM, see a monograph . In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function.", "In this study, the LIBSVM package was used as an implementation of SVM, which can be downloaded from the popular radial basis function RBF was taken as the kernel function. For the current SVM classifier, there were two uncertain parameters: penalty parameter C and kernel parameter  . The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later.", "The method of how to determine the two parameters will be given later. The predictor obtained via the aforementioned procedure is called iNR-Drug, where \"i\" means identify, and \"NR-Drug\" means the interaction between nuclear receptor and drug compound. To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds.", "To provide an intuitive overall picture, a flowchart is provided in Figure 2 to show the process of how the predictor works in identifying the interactions between nuclear receptors and drug compounds. To provide a more intuitive and easier-to-understand method to measure the prediction quality, the following set of metrics based on the formulation used by Chou in predicting signal peptides was adopted. According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs.", "According to Chou's formulation, the sensitivity, specificity, overall accuracy, and Matthew's correlation coefficient can be respectively expressed as 62, Sn 1 where N  is the total number of the interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the non-interactive NR-drug pairs; N  the total number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs investigated while N   the number of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs incorrectly predicted as the interactive NR-drug pairs. According to Equation . we can easily see the following.", "According to Equation . we can easily see the following. When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 .", "When 0 N    meaning none of the interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted to be a non-interactive NR-drug pair, we have the sensitivity Sn = 1; while NN    meaning that all the interactive NR-drug pairs were mispredicted to be the non-interactive NR-drug pairs, we have the sensitivity Sn = 0 . Likewise, when 0 N    meaning none of the non-interactive NR-drug pairs was mispredicted, we have the specificity Sp we have MCC = 0 meaning total disagreement between prediction and observation. As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation .", "As we can see from the above discussion, it is much more intuitive and easier to understand when using Equation . to examine a predictor for its four metrics, particularly for its Mathew's correlation coefficient. It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation .", "It is instructive to point out that the metrics as defined in Equation . are valid for single label systems; for multi-label systems, a set of more complicated metrics should be used as given in . How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value.", "How to properly test a predictor for its anticipated success rates is very important for its development as well as its potential application value. Generally speaking, the following three cross-validation methods are often used to examine the quality of a predictor and its effectiveness in practical application: independent dataset test, subsampling or K-fold such as five-fold, seven-fold, or 10-fold crossover test and jackknife test . However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test.", "However, as elaborated by a penetrating analysis in , considerable arbitrariness exists in the independent dataset test. Also, as demonstrated in , the subsampling or K-fold crossover validation test cannot avoid arbitrariness either. Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, .", "Only the jackknife test is the least arbitrary that can always yield a unique result for a given benchmark dataset 73, 74, 156, . Therefore, the jackknife test has been widely recognized and increasingly utilized by investigators to examine the quality of various predictors see, e.g., . Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor.", "Accordingly, in this study the jackknife test was also adopted to evaluate the accuracy of the current predictor. As mentioned above, the SVM operation engine contains two uncertain parameters C and  . To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset .", "To find their optimal values, a 2-D grid search was conducted by the jackknife test on the benchmark dataset . The results thus obtained are shown in Figure 3 , from which it can be seen that the iNR-Drug predictor reaches its optimal status when C = 2 3 and 9 2    . The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf.", "The corresponding rates for the four metrics cf. Equation . are given in Table 1 , where for facilitating comparison, the overall accuracy Acc reported by He et al. on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC.", "on the same benchmark dataset is also given although no results were reported by them for Sn, Sp and MCC. It can be observed from the table that the overall accuracy obtained by iNR-Drug is remarkably higher that of He et al. , and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher.", ", and that the rates achieved by iNR-Drug for the other three metrics are also quite higher. These facts indicate that the current predictor not only can yield higher overall prediction accuracy but also is quite stable with low false prediction rates. As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor.", "As mentioned above Section 3.2 , the jackknife test is the most objective method for examining the quality of a predictor. However, as a demonstration to show how to practically use the current predictor, we took 41 NR-drug pairs from the study by Yamanishi et al. that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs.", "that had been confirmed by experiments as interactive pairs. For such an independent dataset, 34 were correctly identified by iNR-Drug as interactive pairs, i.e., Sn = 34 / 41 = 82.92%, which is quite consistent with the rate of 79.07% achieved by the predictor on the benchmark dataset via the jackknife test as reported in Table 1 . It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well.", "It is anticipated that the iNR-Drug predictor developed in this paper may become a useful high throughput tool for both basic research and drug development, and that the current approach may be easily extended to study the interactions of drug with other targets as well. Since user-friendly and publicly accessible web-servers represent the future direction for developing practically more useful predictors , a publicly accessible web-server for iNR-Drug was established. For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity.", "For the convenience of the vast majority of biologists and pharmaceutical scientists, here let us provide a step-by-step guide to show how the users can easily get the desired result by using iNR-Drug web-server without the need to follow the complicated mathematical equations presented in this paper for the process of developing the predictor and its integrity. Step 1. Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 .", "Open the web server at the site and you will see the top page of the predictor on your computer screen, as shown in Figure 4 . Click on the Read Me button to see a brief introduction about iNR-Drug predictor and the caveat when using it. Step 2.", "Step 2. Either type or copy/paste the query NR-drug pairs into the input box at the center of Figure 4 . Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug.", "Each query pair consists of two parts: one is for the nuclear receptor sequence, and the other for the drug. The NR sequence should be in FASTA format, while the drug in the KEGG code beginning with the symbol #. Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box.", "Examples for the query pairs input and the corresponding output can be seen by clicking on the Example button right above the input box. Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result.", "Step 3. Click on the Submit button to see the predicted result. For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair.", "For example, if you use the three query pairs in the Example window as the input, after clicking the Submit button, you will see on your screen that the \"hsa:2099\" NR and the \"D00066\" drug are an interactive pair, and that the \"hsa:2908\" NR and the \"D00088\" drug are also an interactive pair, but that the \"hsa:5468\" NR and the \"D00279\" drug are not an interactive pair. All these results are fully consistent with the experimental observations. It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed.", "It takes about 3 minutes before each of these results is shown on the screen; of course, the more query pairs there is, the more time that is usually needed. Step 4. Click on the Citation button to find the relevant paper that documents the detailed development and algorithm of iNR-Durg. Step 5.", "Step 5. Click on the Data button to download the benchmark dataset used to train and test the iNR-Durg predictor. Step 6. The program code is also available by clicking the button download on the lower panel of Figure 4 ." ]

[ "Bats have been identified as a natural reservoir of a variety of coronaviruses CoVs . Several of them have caused diseases in humans and domestic animals by interspecies transmission. Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance.", "Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance. In this study, we described a new member of alphaCoV BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 in bats with unique genome features. Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene.", "Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene. All the putative genes were further confirmed by reverse-transcription analyses. One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus.", "One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus. Functional analysis showed ORF4a protein can activate IFN-β production, whereas ORF3a can regulate NF-κB production. We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells.", "We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells. Our results expand the knowledge on the genetic diversity of bat coronaviruses. Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission.", "Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission. Text: Members of the Coronaviridae family are enveloped, non-segmented, positive-strand RNA viruses with genome sizes ranging from 26-32 kb . These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs .", "These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs . Alpha and betacoronaviruses mainly infect mammals and cause human and animal diseases. Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals .", "Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals . Six human CoVs HCoVs are known to cause human diseases. HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 .", "HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 . The study was conducted in accordance with the Guide for the Care and Use of Wild Mammals in Research of the People's Republic of China. Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously .", "Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously . Viral RNA was extracted from 200 µL of fecal swab or pellet samples using the High Pure Viral RNA Kit Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany as per the manufacturer's instructions. RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described .", "RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described . To confirm the bat species of an individual sample, we PCR amplified the cytochrome b Cytob and/or NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 ND1 gene using DNA extracted from the feces or swabs . The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences.", "The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences. BLASTN was used to identify host species based on the most closely related sequences with the highest query coverage and a minimum identity of 95%. Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request .", "Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request . Sequences of the 5' and 3' genomic ends were obtained by 5' and 3' rapid amplification of cDNA ends SMARTer Viruses 2019, 11, 379 3 of 19 RACE 5'/3' Kit; Clontech, Mountain View, CA, USA , respectively. PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing.", "PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing. PCR products over 5kb were subjected to deep sequencing using Hiseq2500 system. For some fragments, the PCR products were cloned into the pGEM-T Easy Vector Promega, Madison, WI, USA for sequencing. At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence.", "At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence. The Next Generation Sequencing NGS data were filtered and mapped to the reference sequence of BatCoV HKU10 GenBank accession number NC_018871 using Geneious 7.1.8 . Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA .", "Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA . Putative open reading frames ORFs were predicted using NCBI's ORF finder orffinder/ with a minimal ORF length of 150 nt, followed by manual inspection. The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described .", "The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described . The cleavage of the 16 nonstructural proteins coded by ORF1ab was determined by alignment of aa sequences of other CoVs and the recognition pattern of the 3C-like proteinase and papain-like proteinase. Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package .", "Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package . Full-length genome sequences obtained in this study were aligned with those of previously reported alpha-CoVs using MUSCLE . The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program .", "The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program . Potential recombination events as suggested by strong p-values <10 -20 were confirmed using similarity plot and bootscan analyses implemented in Simplot 3.5.1 . The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters .", "The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters . The protein homology detection was analyzed using HHpred with default parameters . A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples .", "A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples . Forward primers were designed targeting the leader sequence at the 5'-end of the complete genome, while reverse primers were designed within the ORFs. Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing.", "Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing. Bat primary or immortalized cells Rhinolophus sinicus kidney immortalized cells, RsKT; Rhinolophus sinicus Lung primary cells, RsLu4323; Rhinolophus sinicus brain immortalized cells, RsBrT; Rhinolophus affinis kidney primary cells, RaK4324; Rousettus leschenaultii Kidney immortalized cells, RlKT; Hipposideros pratti lung immortalized cells, HpLuT generated in our laboratory were all cultured in DMEM/F12 with 15% FBS. Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS.", "Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS. Other cells were maintained according to the recommendations of American Type Culture Collection ATCC, . The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously .", "The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously . The influenza virus NS1 plasmid was generated in our lab . The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences.", "The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. SARS-CoV ORF7a was synthesized by Sangon Biotech. The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies .", "The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies . Expression of these accessory genes were analyzed by Western blotting using an mAb Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany against the HA tag. The virus isolation was performed as previously described .", "The virus isolation was performed as previously described . Briefly, fecal supernatant was acquired via gradient centrifugation and then added to Vero E6 cells, 1:10 diluted in DMEM. After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA .", "After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA . Three blind passages were carried out. Cells were checked daily for cytopathic effect. Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR .", "Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR . Apoptosis was analyzed as previously described . Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection.", "Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection. Apoptosis was detected by flow cytometry using by the Annexin V-FITC/PI Apoptosis Detection Kit YEASEN, Shanghai, China following the manufacturer's instructions. Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis.", "Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis. All experiments were repeated three times. Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant.", "Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant. HEK 293T cells were seeded in 24-well plates and then co-transfected with reporter plasmids pRL-TK and pIFN-βIFN-or pNF-κB-Luc , as well as plasmids expressing accessory genes, empty vector plasmid pcAGGS, influenza virus NS1 , SARS-CoV ORF7a , or HBoV VP2 . At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively.", "At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively. Cell lysates were prepared, and luciferase activity was measured using the dual-luciferase assay kit Promega, Madison, WI, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates.", "Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates. The pseudovirus particles were confirmed with Western blotting and negative-staining electromicroscopy. The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously .", "The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously . The complete genome nucleotide sequences of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 strains RsYN1, RsYN2, RsYN3, and RaGD obtained in this study have been submitted to the GenBank under MG916901 to MG916904. The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China.", "The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China. In total, 2061 fecal samples were collected from at least 12 Rhinolophus bat species Figure 1A . CoVs were detected in 209 of these samples Figure 1B and Table 1 . Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs.", "Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs. Five of these viruses are related to known species: Mi-BatCoV 1 >94% nt identity , Mi-BatCoV HKU8 >93% nt identity , BtRf-AlphaCoV/HuB2013 >99% nt identity , SARSr-CoV >89% nt identity , and HKU2-related CoV >85% nt identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. We next characterized a novel alpha-CoV, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively.", "It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively. Based on the sequences, we defined three genotypes, which represented by RsYN1, RsYN3, and RaGD, respectively. Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained.", "Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained. Three of them were from R.sinicus Strain RsYN1, RsYN2, and RsYN3 , while the other one was from R.affinis Strain RaGD . The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%.", "The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%. The genomes exhibit similar structures and transcription regulatory sequences TRS that are identical to those of other alpha-CoVs Figure 2 and Table 2 . Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed.", "Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed. All the 4 strains have ORF4a & ORF4b, while only strain RsYN1 has ORF3b. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome.", "The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. It encodes polyproteins 1a and 1ab, which could be cleaved into 16 non-structural proteins Nsp1-Nsp16 . The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed.", "The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed. The proteins including Nsp3 papain-like 2 proteas, PL2pro , Nsp5 chymotrypsin-like protease, 3CLpro , Nsp12 RdRp , Nsp13 helicase , and other proteins of unknown function Table 3 . The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV.", "The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV. The closest assigned CoV species to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 are BtCoV-HKU10 and BtRf-AlphaCoV/Hub2013. The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location.", "The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location. The third genotype represented by strain RaGD was isolated to strains found in Yunnan <75.4% genome identity . We then examined the individual genes Table 2 . All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs.", "All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs. The four strains of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 showed genetic diversity among all different genes except ORF1ab >83.7% aa identity . Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains.", "Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains. Other structure proteins E, M, and N are more conserved than the spike and other accessory proteins. Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a.", "Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a. However, the proteins encoded by ORF3as were highly divergent among different genotypes <65% aa identity . The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records.", "The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records. Most accessory genes have no homologues in GenBank-database, except for ORF3a 52.0-55.5% aa identity with BatCoV HKU10 ORF3 and ORF9 28.1-32.0% aa identity with SARSr-CoV ORF7a . We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software.", "We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software. The results showed that ORF9s and SARS-CoV OR7a are homologues possibility: 100%, E value <10 −48 . We further screened the genomes for potential recombination evidence. No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis.", "No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 .", "The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs.", "Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described.", "To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS.", "The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b.", "In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. The Ka/Ks ratios Ks is the number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous sites and Ka is the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site were calculated for all genes. The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection.", "The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection. However, the Ka/Ks ratios of ORF4a, ORF4b, and ORF9 0.727, 0.623, and 0.843, respectively were significantly higher than those of other ORFs Table 4 . For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a.", "For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a. We transiently transfected ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 into HEK293T cells to examine whether this ORF9 triggers apoptosis. Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 .", "Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 . ORF9 couldn't induce apoptosis as the ORF7a of SARS-CoV Tor2 Figure S2 . The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction.", "The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction. To determine whether these accessory proteins modulate IFN induction, we transfected reporter plasmids pIFNβ-Luc and pRL-TK and expression plasmids to 293T cells. All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection.", "All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection. Luciferase activity stimulated by SeV was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression.", "Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 .", "Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A .", "Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay.", "Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter plasmids pNF-κB-Luc and pRL-TK , as well as accessory protein-expressing plasmids, or controls empty vector, NS1, SARS-CoV Tor2-ORF7a . The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection.", "The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection. The luciferase activity was determined. RsYN1-ORF3a and RaGD-ORF3a activated NF-κB as SARS-CoV ORF7a, whereas RsYN2-ORF3a inhibited NF-κB as NS1 Figure 5B . Expressions of ORF3as were confirmed with Western blot Figure S1 . Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 .", "Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 . To understand the infectivity of these newly detected BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we selected the RsYN1, RsYN3 and RaGD spike proteins for spike-mediated pseudovirus entry studies. Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 .", "Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 . A total of 11 human cell lines, 8 bat cells, and 9 other mammal cell lines were tested, and no strong positive was found Table S2 . In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species.", "In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species. The 4 strains with full-length genome were sequences. The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard .", "The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard . These novel alpha-CoVs showed high genetic diversity in their structural and non-structural genes. Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain.", "Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain. Though collected from same province, these three virus strains formed two genotypes correlated to sampling locations. These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes.", "These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes. Considering the remote geographic location of the host bat habitat, the host tropism, and the virus diversity, we suppose BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have spread in these two provinces with a long history of circulation in their natural reservoir, Rhinolophus bats. With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving.", "With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving. Our study revealed that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 has a unique genome structure compared to other alpha-CoVs. First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes.", "First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes. Second, multiple TRSs were found between S and E genes while other alphacoronavirus only had one TRS there. These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively.", "These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively. Third, accessory gene ORF9 showed homology with those of other known CoV species in another coronavirus genus, especially with accessory genes from SARSr-CoV. Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection .", "Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection . In most CoVs, accessory genes are dispensable for virus replication. However, an intact 3c gene of feline CoV was required for viral replication in the gut . Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence .", "Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence . SARS-CoV ORF7a, which was identified to be involved in the suppression of RNA silencing , inhibition of cellular protein synthesis , cell-cycle blockage , and apoptosis induction . In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a.", "In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a. Interestingly, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and SARSr-CoV were both detected in R. sinicus from the same cave. We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer.", "We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer. Whereas, ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 failed to induce apoptosis or activate NF-κB production, these differences may be induced by the divergent evolution of these proteins in different pressure. Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β.", "Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β. ORF3a from RsYN1 and RaGD upregulated NF-κB, but the homologue from RsYN2 downregulated NF-κB expression. These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway.", "These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway. Though lacking of intestinal cell lines from the natural host of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we screened the cell tropism of their spike protein through pseudotyped retrovirus entry with human, bat and other mammalian cell lines. Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals.", "Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals. Multiple reasons may lead to failed infection of coronavirus spike-pseudotyped retrovirus system, including receptor absence in target cells, failed recognition to the receptor homologue from non-host species, maladaptation in non-host cells during the spike maturation or virus entry, or the limitation of retrovirus system in stimulating coronavirus entry. The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface.", "The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface. The assumption needs to be further confirmed by experiments. Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs.", "Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs. Coincidently, the two highly pathogenic agents, SARS-CoV and Rh-BatCoV HKU2 both originated from Rhinolophus bats. Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans.", "Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans. Long-term surveillances and pathogenesis studies will help to prevent future human and animal diseases caused by these bat CoVs. Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins.", "Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins. Figure S2 : Apoptosis analysis of ORF9 proteins of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon.", "Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon. Figure S4 : Functional analysis of ORF3b, ORF4a, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of NF-κB. Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus.", "Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus. Table S1 : General primers for AlphaCoVs genome sequencing. Table S2 : Primers for the detection of viral sugbenomic mRNAs. Table S3" ]

[ "Bats have been identified as a natural reservoir of a variety of coronaviruses CoVs . Several of them have caused diseases in humans and domestic animals by interspecies transmission. Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance.", "Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance. In this study, we described a new member of alphaCoV BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 in bats with unique genome features. Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene.", "Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene. All the putative genes were further confirmed by reverse-transcription analyses. One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus.", "One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus. Functional analysis showed ORF4a protein can activate IFN-β production, whereas ORF3a can regulate NF-κB production. We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells.", "We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells. Our results expand the knowledge on the genetic diversity of bat coronaviruses. Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission.", "Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission. Text: Members of the Coronaviridae family are enveloped, non-segmented, positive-strand RNA viruses with genome sizes ranging from 26-32 kb . These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs .", "These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs . Alpha and betacoronaviruses mainly infect mammals and cause human and animal diseases. Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals .", "Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals . Six human CoVs HCoVs are known to cause human diseases. HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 .", "HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 . The study was conducted in accordance with the Guide for the Care and Use of Wild Mammals in Research of the People's Republic of China. Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously .", "Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously . Viral RNA was extracted from 200 µL of fecal swab or pellet samples using the High Pure Viral RNA Kit Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany as per the manufacturer's instructions. RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described .", "RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described . To confirm the bat species of an individual sample, we PCR amplified the cytochrome b Cytob and/or NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 ND1 gene using DNA extracted from the feces or swabs . The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences.", "The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences. BLASTN was used to identify host species based on the most closely related sequences with the highest query coverage and a minimum identity of 95%. Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request .", "Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request . Sequences of the 5' and 3' genomic ends were obtained by 5' and 3' rapid amplification of cDNA ends SMARTer Viruses 2019, 11, 379 3 of 19 RACE 5'/3' Kit; Clontech, Mountain View, CA, USA , respectively. PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing.", "PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing. PCR products over 5kb were subjected to deep sequencing using Hiseq2500 system. For some fragments, the PCR products were cloned into the pGEM-T Easy Vector Promega, Madison, WI, USA for sequencing. At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence.", "At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence. The Next Generation Sequencing NGS data were filtered and mapped to the reference sequence of BatCoV HKU10 GenBank accession number NC_018871 using Geneious 7.1.8 . Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA .", "Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA . Putative open reading frames ORFs were predicted using NCBI's ORF finder orffinder/ with a minimal ORF length of 150 nt, followed by manual inspection. The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described .", "The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described . The cleavage of the 16 nonstructural proteins coded by ORF1ab was determined by alignment of aa sequences of other CoVs and the recognition pattern of the 3C-like proteinase and papain-like proteinase. Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package .", "Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package . Full-length genome sequences obtained in this study were aligned with those of previously reported alpha-CoVs using MUSCLE . The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program .", "The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program . Potential recombination events as suggested by strong p-values <10 -20 were confirmed using similarity plot and bootscan analyses implemented in Simplot 3.5.1 . The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters .", "The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters . The protein homology detection was analyzed using HHpred with default parameters . A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples .", "A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples . Forward primers were designed targeting the leader sequence at the 5'-end of the complete genome, while reverse primers were designed within the ORFs. Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing.", "Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing. Bat primary or immortalized cells Rhinolophus sinicus kidney immortalized cells, RsKT; Rhinolophus sinicus Lung primary cells, RsLu4323; Rhinolophus sinicus brain immortalized cells, RsBrT; Rhinolophus affinis kidney primary cells, RaK4324; Rousettus leschenaultii Kidney immortalized cells, RlKT; Hipposideros pratti lung immortalized cells, HpLuT generated in our laboratory were all cultured in DMEM/F12 with 15% FBS. Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS.", "Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS. Other cells were maintained according to the recommendations of American Type Culture Collection ATCC, . The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously .", "The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously . The influenza virus NS1 plasmid was generated in our lab . The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences.", "The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. SARS-CoV ORF7a was synthesized by Sangon Biotech. The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies .", "The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies . Expression of these accessory genes were analyzed by Western blotting using an mAb Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany against the HA tag. The virus isolation was performed as previously described .", "The virus isolation was performed as previously described . Briefly, fecal supernatant was acquired via gradient centrifugation and then added to Vero E6 cells, 1:10 diluted in DMEM. After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA .", "After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA . Three blind passages were carried out. Cells were checked daily for cytopathic effect. Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR .", "Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR . Apoptosis was analyzed as previously described . Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection.", "Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection. Apoptosis was detected by flow cytometry using by the Annexin V-FITC/PI Apoptosis Detection Kit YEASEN, Shanghai, China following the manufacturer's instructions. Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis.", "Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis. All experiments were repeated three times. Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant.", "Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant. HEK 293T cells were seeded in 24-well plates and then co-transfected with reporter plasmids pRL-TK and pIFN-βIFN-or pNF-κB-Luc , as well as plasmids expressing accessory genes, empty vector plasmid pcAGGS, influenza virus NS1 , SARS-CoV ORF7a , or HBoV VP2 . At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively.", "At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively. Cell lysates were prepared, and luciferase activity was measured using the dual-luciferase assay kit Promega, Madison, WI, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates.", "Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates. The pseudovirus particles were confirmed with Western blotting and negative-staining electromicroscopy. The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously .", "The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously . The complete genome nucleotide sequences of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 strains RsYN1, RsYN2, RsYN3, and RaGD obtained in this study have been submitted to the GenBank under MG916901 to MG916904. The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China.", "The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China. In total, 2061 fecal samples were collected from at least 12 Rhinolophus bat species Figure 1A . CoVs were detected in 209 of these samples Figure 1B and Table 1 . Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs.", "Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs. Five of these viruses are related to known species: Mi-BatCoV 1 >94% nt identity , Mi-BatCoV HKU8 >93% nt identity , BtRf-AlphaCoV/HuB2013 >99% nt identity , SARSr-CoV >89% nt identity , and HKU2-related CoV >85% nt identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. We next characterized a novel alpha-CoV, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively.", "It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively. Based on the sequences, we defined three genotypes, which represented by RsYN1, RsYN3, and RaGD, respectively. Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained.", "Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained. Three of them were from R.sinicus Strain RsYN1, RsYN2, and RsYN3 , while the other one was from R.affinis Strain RaGD . The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%.", "The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%. The genomes exhibit similar structures and transcription regulatory sequences TRS that are identical to those of other alpha-CoVs Figure 2 and Table 2 . Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed.", "Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed. All the 4 strains have ORF4a & ORF4b, while only strain RsYN1 has ORF3b. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome.", "The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. It encodes polyproteins 1a and 1ab, which could be cleaved into 16 non-structural proteins Nsp1-Nsp16 . The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed.", "The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed. The proteins including Nsp3 papain-like 2 proteas, PL2pro , Nsp5 chymotrypsin-like protease, 3CLpro , Nsp12 RdRp , Nsp13 helicase , and other proteins of unknown function Table 3 . The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV.", "The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV. The closest assigned CoV species to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 are BtCoV-HKU10 and BtRf-AlphaCoV/Hub2013. The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location.", "The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location. The third genotype represented by strain RaGD was isolated to strains found in Yunnan <75.4% genome identity . We then examined the individual genes Table 2 . All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs.", "All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs. The four strains of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 showed genetic diversity among all different genes except ORF1ab >83.7% aa identity . Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains.", "Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains. Other structure proteins E, M, and N are more conserved than the spike and other accessory proteins. Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a.", "Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a. However, the proteins encoded by ORF3as were highly divergent among different genotypes <65% aa identity . The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records.", "The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records. Most accessory genes have no homologues in GenBank-database, except for ORF3a 52.0-55.5% aa identity with BatCoV HKU10 ORF3 and ORF9 28.1-32.0% aa identity with SARSr-CoV ORF7a . We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software.", "We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software. The results showed that ORF9s and SARS-CoV OR7a are homologues possibility: 100%, E value <10 −48 . We further screened the genomes for potential recombination evidence. No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis.", "No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 .", "The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs.", "Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described.", "To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS.", "The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b.", "In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. The Ka/Ks ratios Ks is the number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous sites and Ka is the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site were calculated for all genes. The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection.", "The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection. However, the Ka/Ks ratios of ORF4a, ORF4b, and ORF9 0.727, 0.623, and 0.843, respectively were significantly higher than those of other ORFs Table 4 . For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a.", "For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a. We transiently transfected ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 into HEK293T cells to examine whether this ORF9 triggers apoptosis. Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 .", "Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 . ORF9 couldn't induce apoptosis as the ORF7a of SARS-CoV Tor2 Figure S2 . The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction.", "The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction. To determine whether these accessory proteins modulate IFN induction, we transfected reporter plasmids pIFNβ-Luc and pRL-TK and expression plasmids to 293T cells. All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection.", "All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection. Luciferase activity stimulated by SeV was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression.", "Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 .", "Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A .", "Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay.", "Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter plasmids pNF-κB-Luc and pRL-TK , as well as accessory protein-expressing plasmids, or controls empty vector, NS1, SARS-CoV Tor2-ORF7a . The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection.", "The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection. The luciferase activity was determined. RsYN1-ORF3a and RaGD-ORF3a activated NF-κB as SARS-CoV ORF7a, whereas RsYN2-ORF3a inhibited NF-κB as NS1 Figure 5B . Expressions of ORF3as were confirmed with Western blot Figure S1 . Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 .", "Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 . To understand the infectivity of these newly detected BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we selected the RsYN1, RsYN3 and RaGD spike proteins for spike-mediated pseudovirus entry studies. Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 .", "Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 . A total of 11 human cell lines, 8 bat cells, and 9 other mammal cell lines were tested, and no strong positive was found Table S2 . In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species.", "In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species. The 4 strains with full-length genome were sequences. The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard .", "The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard . These novel alpha-CoVs showed high genetic diversity in their structural and non-structural genes. Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain.", "Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain. Though collected from same province, these three virus strains formed two genotypes correlated to sampling locations. These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes.", "These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes. Considering the remote geographic location of the host bat habitat, the host tropism, and the virus diversity, we suppose BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have spread in these two provinces with a long history of circulation in their natural reservoir, Rhinolophus bats. With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving.", "With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving. Our study revealed that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 has a unique genome structure compared to other alpha-CoVs. First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes.", "First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes. Second, multiple TRSs were found between S and E genes while other alphacoronavirus only had one TRS there. These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively.", "These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively. Third, accessory gene ORF9 showed homology with those of other known CoV species in another coronavirus genus, especially with accessory genes from SARSr-CoV. Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection .", "Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection . In most CoVs, accessory genes are dispensable for virus replication. However, an intact 3c gene of feline CoV was required for viral replication in the gut . Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence .", "Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence . SARS-CoV ORF7a, which was identified to be involved in the suppression of RNA silencing , inhibition of cellular protein synthesis , cell-cycle blockage , and apoptosis induction . In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a.", "In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a. Interestingly, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and SARSr-CoV were both detected in R. sinicus from the same cave. We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer.", "We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer. Whereas, ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 failed to induce apoptosis or activate NF-κB production, these differences may be induced by the divergent evolution of these proteins in different pressure. Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β.", "Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β. ORF3a from RsYN1 and RaGD upregulated NF-κB, but the homologue from RsYN2 downregulated NF-κB expression. These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway.", "These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway. Though lacking of intestinal cell lines from the natural host of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we screened the cell tropism of their spike protein through pseudotyped retrovirus entry with human, bat and other mammalian cell lines. Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals.", "Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals. Multiple reasons may lead to failed infection of coronavirus spike-pseudotyped retrovirus system, including receptor absence in target cells, failed recognition to the receptor homologue from non-host species, maladaptation in non-host cells during the spike maturation or virus entry, or the limitation of retrovirus system in stimulating coronavirus entry. The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface.", "The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface. The assumption needs to be further confirmed by experiments. Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs.", "Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs. Coincidently, the two highly pathogenic agents, SARS-CoV and Rh-BatCoV HKU2 both originated from Rhinolophus bats. Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans.", "Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans. Long-term surveillances and pathogenesis studies will help to prevent future human and animal diseases caused by these bat CoVs. Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins.", "Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins. Figure S2 : Apoptosis analysis of ORF9 proteins of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon.", "Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon. Figure S4 : Functional analysis of ORF3b, ORF4a, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of NF-κB. Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus.", "Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus. Table S1 : General primers for AlphaCoVs genome sequencing. Table S2 : Primers for the detection of viral sugbenomic mRNAs. Table S3" ]

[ "Bats have been identified as a natural reservoir of a variety of coronaviruses CoVs . Several of them have caused diseases in humans and domestic animals by interspecies transmission. Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance.", "Considering the diversity of bat coronaviruses, bat species and populations, we expect to discover more bat CoVs through virus surveillance. In this study, we described a new member of alphaCoV BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 in bats with unique genome features. Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene.", "Unique accessory genes, ORF4a and ORF4b were found between the spike gene and the envelope gene, while ORF8 gene was found downstream of the nucleocapsid gene. All the putative genes were further confirmed by reverse-transcription analyses. One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus.", "One unique gene at the 3’ end of the BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 genome, ORF9, exhibits ~30% amino acid identity to ORF7a of the SARS-related coronavirus. Functional analysis showed ORF4a protein can activate IFN-β production, whereas ORF3a can regulate NF-κB production. We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells.", "We also screened the spike-mediated virus entry using the spike-pseudotyped retroviruses system, although failed to find any fully permissive cells. Our results expand the knowledge on the genetic diversity of bat coronaviruses. Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission.", "Continuous screening of bat viruses will help us further understand the important role played by bats in coronavirus evolution and transmission. Text: Members of the Coronaviridae family are enveloped, non-segmented, positive-strand RNA viruses with genome sizes ranging from 26-32 kb . These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs .", "These viruses are classified into two subfamilies: Letovirinae, which contains the only genus: Alphaletovirus; and Orthocoronavirinae CoV , which consists of alpha, beta, gamma, and deltacoronaviruses CoVs . Alpha and betacoronaviruses mainly infect mammals and cause human and animal diseases. Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals .", "Gamma-and delta-CoVs mainly infect birds, but some can also infect mammals . Six human CoVs HCoVs are known to cause human diseases. HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 .", "HCoV-HKU1, HCoV-OC43, HCoV-229E, and HCoV-NL63 commonly cause mild respiratory illness or asymptomatic infection; however, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus SARS-CoV and All sampling procedures were performed by veterinarians, with approval from Animal Ethics Committee of the Wuhan Institute of Virology WIVH5210201 . The study was conducted in accordance with the Guide for the Care and Use of Wild Mammals in Research of the People's Republic of China. Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously .", "Bat fecal swab and pellet samples were collected from November 2004 to November 2014 in different seasons in Southern China, as described previously . Viral RNA was extracted from 200 µL of fecal swab or pellet samples using the High Pure Viral RNA Kit Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany as per the manufacturer's instructions. RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described .", "RNA was eluted in 50 µL of elution buffer, aliquoted, and stored at -80 • C. One-step hemi-nested reverse-transcription RT- PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA was employed to detect coronavirus, as previously described . To confirm the bat species of an individual sample, we PCR amplified the cytochrome b Cytob and/or NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 ND1 gene using DNA extracted from the feces or swabs . The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences.", "The gene sequences were assembled excluding the primer sequences. BLASTN was used to identify host species based on the most closely related sequences with the highest query coverage and a minimum identity of 95%. Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request .", "Full genomic sequences were determined by one-step PCR Invitrogen, San Diego, CA, USA amplification with degenerate primers Table S1 designed on the basis of multiple alignments of available alpha-CoV sequences deposited in GenBank or amplified with SuperScript IV Reverse Transcriptase Invitrogen and Expand Long Template PCR System Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany with specific primers primer sequences are available upon request . Sequences of the 5' and 3' genomic ends were obtained by 5' and 3' rapid amplification of cDNA ends SMARTer Viruses 2019, 11, 379 3 of 19 RACE 5'/3' Kit; Clontech, Mountain View, CA, USA , respectively. PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing.", "PCR products were gel-purified and subjected directly to sequencing. PCR products over 5kb were subjected to deep sequencing using Hiseq2500 system. For some fragments, the PCR products were cloned into the pGEM-T Easy Vector Promega, Madison, WI, USA for sequencing. At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence.", "At least five independent clones were sequenced to obtain a consensus sequence. The Next Generation Sequencing NGS data were filtered and mapped to the reference sequence of BatCoV HKU10 GenBank accession number NC_018871 using Geneious 7.1.8 . Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA .", "Genomes were preliminarily assembled using DNAStar lasergene V7 DNAStar, Madison, WI, USA . Putative open reading frames ORFs were predicted using NCBI's ORF finder orffinder/ with a minimal ORF length of 150 nt, followed by manual inspection. The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described .", "The sequences of the 5' untranslated region 5'-UTR and 3'-UTR were defined, and the leader sequence, the leader and body transcriptional regulatory sequence TRS were identified as previously described . The cleavage of the 16 nonstructural proteins coded by ORF1ab was determined by alignment of aa sequences of other CoVs and the recognition pattern of the 3C-like proteinase and papain-like proteinase. Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package .", "Phylogenetic trees based on nt or aa sequences were constructed using the maximum likelihood algorithm with bootstrap values determined by 1000 replicates in the MEGA 6 software package . Full-length genome sequences obtained in this study were aligned with those of previously reported alpha-CoVs using MUSCLE . The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program .", "The aligned sequences were scanned for recombination events by using Recombination Detection Program . Potential recombination events as suggested by strong p-values <10 -20 were confirmed using similarity plot and bootscan analyses implemented in Simplot 3.5.1 . The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters .", "The number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous site, Ks, and the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, Ka, for each coding region were calculated using the Ka/Ks calculation tool of the Norwegian Bioinformatics Platform with default parameters . The protein homology detection was analyzed using HHpred with default parameters . A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples .", "A set of nested RT-PCRs was employed to determine the presence of viral subgenomic mRNAs in the CoV-positive samples . Forward primers were designed targeting the leader sequence at the 5'-end of the complete genome, while reverse primers were designed within the ORFs. Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing.", "Specific and suspected amplicons of expected sizes were purified and then cloned into the pGEM-T Easy vector for sequencing. Bat primary or immortalized cells Rhinolophus sinicus kidney immortalized cells, RsKT; Rhinolophus sinicus Lung primary cells, RsLu4323; Rhinolophus sinicus brain immortalized cells, RsBrT; Rhinolophus affinis kidney primary cells, RaK4324; Rousettus leschenaultii Kidney immortalized cells, RlKT; Hipposideros pratti lung immortalized cells, HpLuT generated in our laboratory were all cultured in DMEM/F12 with 15% FBS. Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS.", "Pteropus alecto kidney cells Paki was maintained in DMEM/F12 supplemented with 10% FBS. Other cells were maintained according to the recommendations of American Type Culture Collection ATCC, . The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously .", "The putative accessory genes of the newly detected virus were generated by RT-PCR from viral RNA extracted from fecal samples, as described previously . The influenza virus NS1 plasmid was generated in our lab . The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences.", "The human bocavirus HBoV VP2 plasmid was kindly provided by prof. Hanzhong Wang of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences. SARS-CoV ORF7a was synthesized by Sangon Biotech. The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies .", "The transfections were performed with Lipofectamine 3000 Reagent Life Technologies . Expression of these accessory genes were analyzed by Western blotting using an mAb Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany against the HA tag. The virus isolation was performed as previously described .", "The virus isolation was performed as previously described . Briefly, fecal supernatant was acquired via gradient centrifugation and then added to Vero E6 cells, 1:10 diluted in DMEM. After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA .", "After incubation at 37°C for 1 h the inoculum was replaced by fresh DMEM containing 2% FBS and the antibiotic-antimycotic Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA . Three blind passages were carried out. Cells were checked daily for cytopathic effect. Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR .", "Both culture supernatant and cell pellet were examined for CoV by RT-PCR . Apoptosis was analyzed as previously described . Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection.", "Briefly, 293T cells in 12-well plates were transfected with 3 µg of expression plasmid or empty vector, and the cells were collected 24 h post transfection. Apoptosis was detected by flow cytometry using by the Annexin V-FITC/PI Apoptosis Detection Kit YEASEN, Shanghai, China following the manufacturer's instructions. Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis.", "Annexin-V-positive and PI-negative cells were considered to be in the early apoptotic phase and those stained for both Annexin V and PI were deemed to undergo late apoptosis or necrosis. All experiments were repeated three times. Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant.", "Student's t-test was used to evaluate the data, with p < 0.05 considered significant. HEK 293T cells were seeded in 24-well plates and then co-transfected with reporter plasmids pRL-TK and pIFN-βIFN-or pNF-κB-Luc , as well as plasmids expressing accessory genes, empty vector plasmid pcAGGS, influenza virus NS1 , SARS-CoV ORF7a , or HBoV VP2 . At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively.", "At 24 h post transfection, cells were treated with Sendai virus SeV 100 hemagglutinin units HAU /mL or human tumor necrosis factor alpha TNF-α; R&D system for 6 h to activate IFNβ or NF-κB, respectively. Cell lysates were prepared, and luciferase activity was measured using the dual-luciferase assay kit Promega, Madison, WI, USA according to the manufacturer's instructions. Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates.", "Retroviruses pseudotyped with BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 RsYN1, RsYN3, RaGD, or MERS-CoV spike, or no spike mock were used to infect human, bat or other mammalian cells in 96-well plates. The pseudovirus particles were confirmed with Western blotting and negative-staining electromicroscopy. The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously .", "The production process, measurements of infection and luciferase activity were conducted, as described previously . The complete genome nucleotide sequences of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 strains RsYN1, RsYN2, RsYN3, and RaGD obtained in this study have been submitted to the GenBank under MG916901 to MG916904. The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China.", "The surveillance was performed between November 2004 to November 2014 in 19 provinces of China. In total, 2061 fecal samples were collected from at least 12 Rhinolophus bat species Figure 1A . CoVs were detected in 209 of these samples Figure 1B and Table 1 . Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs.", "Partial RdRp sequences suggested the presence of at least 8 different CoVs. Five of these viruses are related to known species: Mi-BatCoV 1 >94% nt identity , Mi-BatCoV HKU8 >93% nt identity , BtRf-AlphaCoV/HuB2013 >99% nt identity , SARSr-CoV >89% nt identity , and HKU2-related CoV >85% nt identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. identity . While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species.", "While the other three CoV sequences showed less than 83% nt identity to known CoV species. These three viruses should represent novel CoV species. Virus isolation was performed as previously described , but was not successful. We next characterized a novel alpha-CoV, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively.", "It was detected in 3 R.affinis and 6 R.sinicus, respectively. Based on the sequences, we defined three genotypes, which represented by RsYN1, RsYN3, and RaGD, respectively. Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained.", "Strain RsYN2 was classified into the RsYN3 genotype. Four full-length genomes were obtained. Three of them were from R.sinicus Strain RsYN1, RsYN2, and RsYN3 , while the other one was from R.affinis Strain RaGD . The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%.", "The sizes of these 4 genomes are between 28,715 to 29,102, with G+C contents between 39.0% to 41.3%. The genomes exhibit similar structures and transcription regulatory sequences TRS that are identical to those of other alpha-CoVs Figure 2 and Table 2 . Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed.", "Exceptions including three additional ORFs ORF3b, ORF4a and ORF4b were observed. All the 4 strains have ORF4a & ORF4b, while only strain RsYN1 has ORF3b. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome.", "The replicase gene, ORF1ab, occupies~20.4 kb of the genome. It encodes polyproteins 1a and 1ab, which could be cleaved into 16 non-structural proteins Nsp1-Nsp16 . The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed.", "The 3'-end of the cleavage sites recognized by 3C-like proteinase Nsp4-Nsp10, Nsp12-Nsp16 and papain-like proteinase Nsp1-Nsp3 were confirmed. The proteins including Nsp3 papain-like 2 proteas, PL2pro , Nsp5 chymotrypsin-like protease, 3CLpro , Nsp12 RdRp , Nsp13 helicase , and other proteins of unknown function Table 3 . The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV.", "The 7 concatenated domains of polyprotein 1 shared <90% aa sequence identity with those of other known alpha-CoVs Table 2 , suggesting that these viruses represent a novel CoV species within the alpha-CoV. The closest assigned CoV species to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 are BtCoV-HKU10 and BtRf-AlphaCoV/Hub2013. The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location.", "The three strains from Yunnan Province were clustered into two genotypes 83% genome identity correlated to their sampling location. The third genotype represented by strain RaGD was isolated to strains found in Yunnan <75.4% genome identity . We then examined the individual genes Table 2 . All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs.", "All of the genes showed low aa sequence identity to known CoVs. The four strains of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 showed genetic diversity among all different genes except ORF1ab >83.7% aa identity . Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains.", "Notably, the spike proteins are highly divergent among these strains. Other structure proteins E, M, and N are more conserved than the spike and other accessory proteins. Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a.", "Comparing the accessory genes among these four strains revealed that the strains of the same genotype shared a 100% identical ORF3a. However, the proteins encoded by ORF3as were highly divergent among different genotypes <65% aa identity . The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records.", "The putative accessory genes were also BLASTed against GenBank records. Most accessory genes have no homologues in GenBank-database, except for ORF3a 52.0-55.5% aa identity with BatCoV HKU10 ORF3 and ORF9 28.1-32.0% aa identity with SARSr-CoV ORF7a . We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software.", "We analyzed the protein homology with HHpred software. The results showed that ORF9s and SARS-CoV OR7a are homologues possibility: 100%, E value <10 −48 . We further screened the genomes for potential recombination evidence. No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis.", "No significant recombination breakpoint was detected by bootscan analysis. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 .", "The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs.", "Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described.", "To confirm the presence of subgenomic RNA, we designed a set of primers targeting all the predicted ORFs as described. The amplicons were firstly confirmed via agarose-gel electrophoresis and then sequencing Figure 3 and Table 2 . The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS.", "The sequences showed that all the ORFs, except ORF4b, had preceding TRS. Hence, the ORF4b may be translated from bicistronic mRNAs. In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b.", "In RsYN1, an additional subgenomic RNA starting inside the ORF3a was found through sequencing, which led to a unique ORF3b. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the aa sequences of RdRp and S of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and other representative CoVs Figure 4 . In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species.", "In both trees, all BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 were clustered together and formed a distinct lineage to other known coronavirus species. Two distinct sublineages were observed within BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated.", "One was from Ra sampled in Guangdong, while the other was from Rs sampled in Yunnan Among the strains from Yunnan, RsYN2 and RsYN3 were clustered together, while RsYN1 was isolated. The topology of these four strains was correlated to the sampling location. The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history.", "The relatively long branches reflect a high diversity among these strains, indicating a long independent evolution history. The Ka/Ks ratios Ks is the number of synonymous substitutions per synonymous sites and Ka is the number of nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site were calculated for all genes. The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection.", "The Ka/Ks ratios for most of the genes were generally low, which indicates these genes were under purified selection. However, the Ka/Ks ratios of ORF4a, ORF4b, and ORF9 0.727, 0.623, and 0.843, respectively were significantly higher than those of other ORFs Table 4 . For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a.", "For further selection pressure evaluation of the ORF4a and ORF4b gene, we sequenced another four ORF4a and ORF4b genes strain Rs4223, Rs4236, Rs4240, and Ra13576 was shown in Figure 1B As SARS-CoV ORF7a was reported to induce apoptosis, we conducted apoptosis analysis on BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9, a~30% aa identity homologue of SARSr-CoV ORF7a. We transiently transfected ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 into HEK293T cells to examine whether this ORF9 triggers apoptosis. Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 .", "Western blot was performed to confirm the expression of ORF9s and SARS-CoV ORF7a Figure S1 . ORF9 couldn't induce apoptosis as the ORF7a of SARS-CoV Tor2 Figure S2 . The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction.", "The results indicated that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 was not involved in apoptosis induction. To determine whether these accessory proteins modulate IFN induction, we transfected reporter plasmids pIFNβ-Luc and pRL-TK and expression plasmids to 293T cells. All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection.", "All the cells over-expressing the accessory genes, as well as influenza virus NS1 strain PR8 , HBoV VP2, or empty vector were tested for luciferase activity after SeV infection. Luciferase activity stimulated by SeV was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression.", "Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 .", "Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . was remarkably higher than that without SeV treatment as expected. Influenza virus NS1 inhibits the expression from IFN promoter, while HBoV VP2 activate the expression. Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A .", "Compared to those controls, the ORF4a proteins exhibit an active effect as HBoV VP2 Figure 5A . Other accessory proteins showed no effect on IFN production Figure S3 . Expression of these accessory genes were confirmed by Western blot Figure S1 . Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay.", "Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter Samples were collected at 6 h postinfection, followed by dual-luciferase assay. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase value normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB.", "B ORF3a protein activate NF-κB. 293T cells were transfected with 100 ng pNF-κB-Luc, 10 ng pRL-TK, empty vector 500 ng , an NS1-expressing plasmid 500 ng , a SARS-CoV ORF7a-expressing plasmid 500 ng , or ORF3a-expressing plasmids 500 ng . After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α.", "After 24 h, the cells were treated with TNF-α. Dual-luciferase activity was determined after 6 h. The results were expressed as the firefly luciferase activity normalized to that of Renilla luciferase. The experiments were performed three times independently.", "The experiments were performed three times independently. Data are representative of at least three independent experiments, with each determination performed in triplicate mean ± SD of fold change . Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test .", "Asterisks indicate significant differences between groups compared with Empty vector-NC, p < 0.05, as determined by student t test . NF-κB plays an important role in regulating the immune response to viral infection and is also a key factor frequently targeted by viruses for taking over the host cell. In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB.", "In this study, we tested if these accessory proteins could modulate NF-κB. 293T cells were co-transfected with reporter plasmids pNF-κB-Luc and pRL-TK , as well as accessory protein-expressing plasmids, or controls empty vector, NS1, SARS-CoV Tor2-ORF7a . The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection.", "The cells were mock treated or treated with TNF-α for 6 h at 24 h post-transfection. The luciferase activity was determined. RsYN1-ORF3a and RaGD-ORF3a activated NF-κB as SARS-CoV ORF7a, whereas RsYN2-ORF3a inhibited NF-κB as NS1 Figure 5B . Expressions of ORF3as were confirmed with Western blot Figure S1 . Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 .", "Other accessory proteins did not modulate NF-κB production Figure S4 . To understand the infectivity of these newly detected BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we selected the RsYN1, RsYN3 and RaGD spike proteins for spike-mediated pseudovirus entry studies. Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 .", "Both Western blot analysis and negative-staining electron microscopy observation confirmed the preparation of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 successfully Figure S5 . A total of 11 human cell lines, 8 bat cells, and 9 other mammal cell lines were tested, and no strong positive was found Table S2 . In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species.", "In this study, a novel alpha-CoV species, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, was identified in two Rhinolophus species. The 4 strains with full-length genome were sequences. The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard .", "The 7 conserved replicase domains of these viruses possessed <90% aa sequence identity to those of other known alpha-CoVs, which defines a new species in accordance with the ICTV taxonomy standard . These novel alpha-CoVs showed high genetic diversity in their structural and non-structural genes. Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain.", "Strain RaGD from R. affinis, collected in Guangdong province, formed a divergent independent branch from the other 3 strains from R. sinicus, sampled in Yunnan Province, indicating an independent evolution process associated with geographic isolation and host restrain. Though collected from same province, these three virus strains formed two genotypes correlated to sampling locations. These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes.", "These two genotypes had low genome sequence identity, especially in the S gene and accessory genes. Considering the remote geographic location of the host bat habitat, the host tropism, and the virus diversity, we suppose BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have spread in these two provinces with a long history of circulation in their natural reservoir, Rhinolophus bats. With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving.", "With the sequence evidence, we suppose that these viruses are still rapidly evolving. Our study revealed that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 has a unique genome structure compared to other alpha-CoVs. First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes.", "First, novel accessory genes, which had no homologues, were identified in the genomes. Second, multiple TRSs were found between S and E genes while other alphacoronavirus only had one TRS there. These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively.", "These TRSs precede ORF3a, ORF3b only in RsYN1 , and ORF4a/b respectively. Third, accessory gene ORF9 showed homology with those of other known CoV species in another coronavirus genus, especially with accessory genes from SARSr-CoV. Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection .", "Accessory genes are usually involved in virus-host interactions during CoV infection . In most CoVs, accessory genes are dispensable for virus replication. However, an intact 3c gene of feline CoV was required for viral replication in the gut . Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence .", "Deletion of the genus-specific genes in mouse hepatitis virus led to a reduction in virulence . SARS-CoV ORF7a, which was identified to be involved in the suppression of RNA silencing , inhibition of cellular protein synthesis , cell-cycle blockage , and apoptosis induction . In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a.", "In this study, we found that BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF9 shares~30% aa sequence identity with SARS-CoV ORF7a. Interestingly, BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 and SARSr-CoV were both detected in R. sinicus from the same cave. We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer.", "We suppose that SARS-CoV and BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 may have acquired ORF7a or ORF9 from a common ancestor through genome recombination or horizontal gene transfer. Whereas, ORF9 of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 failed to induce apoptosis or activate NF-κB production, these differences may be induced by the divergent evolution of these proteins in different pressure. Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β.", "Though different BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 ORF4a share <64.4% amino acid identity, all of them could activate IFN-β. ORF3a from RsYN1 and RaGD upregulated NF-κB, but the homologue from RsYN2 downregulated NF-κB expression. These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway.", "These differences may be caused by amino acid sequence variations and may contribute to a viruses' pathogenicity with a different pathway. Though lacking of intestinal cell lines from the natural host of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, we screened the cell tropism of their spike protein through pseudotyped retrovirus entry with human, bat and other mammalian cell lines. Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals.", "Most of cell lines screened were unsusceptible to BtCoV/Rh/YN2012, indicating a low risk of interspecies transmission to human and other animals. Multiple reasons may lead to failed infection of coronavirus spike-pseudotyped retrovirus system, including receptor absence in target cells, failed recognition to the receptor homologue from non-host species, maladaptation in non-host cells during the spike maturation or virus entry, or the limitation of retrovirus system in stimulating coronavirus entry. The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface.", "The weak infectivity of RsYN1 pseudotyped retrovirus in Huh-7 cells could be explained by the binding of spike protein to polysaccharide secreted to the surface. The assumption needs to be further confirmed by experiments. Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs.", "Our long-term surveillances suggest that Rhinolophus bats seem to harbor a wide diversity of CoVs. Coincidently, the two highly pathogenic agents, SARS-CoV and Rh-BatCoV HKU2 both originated from Rhinolophus bats. Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans.", "Considering the diversity of CoVs carried by this bat genus and their wide geographical distribution, there may be a low risk of spillover of these viruses to other animals and humans. Long-term surveillances and pathogenesis studies will help to prevent future human and animal diseases caused by these bat CoVs. Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins.", "Supplementary Materials: The following are available online at Figure S1 : western blot analysis of the expression of accessory proteins. Figure S2 : Apoptosis analysis of ORF9 proteins of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012. Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon.", "Figure S3 : Functional analysis of ORF3a, ORF3b, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of Type I interferon. Figure S4 : Functional analysis of ORF3b, ORF4a, ORF4b, ORF8 and ORF9 proteins on the production of NF-κB. Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus.", "Figure S5 : Characteristic of BtCoV/Rh/YN2012 spike mediated pseudovirus. Table S1 : General primers for AlphaCoVs genome sequencing. Table S2 : Primers for the detection of viral sugbenomic mRNAs. Table S3" ]