id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03321v1 | Planetarium: A Rigorous Benchmark for Translating Text to Structured Planning Languages | 2024-07-03T17:59:53 | 2024-07-03T17:59:53 | Max Zuo, Francisco Piedrahita Velez, Xiaochen Li, Michael L. Littman, Stephen H. Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Many recent works have explored using language models for planning problems.
One line of research focuses on translating natural language descriptions of
planning tasks into structured planning languages, such as the planning domain
definition language (PDDL). While this approach is promising, accurately
measuring the quality of generated PDDL code continues to pose significant
challenges. First, generated PDDL code is typically evaluated using planning
validators that check whether the problem can be solved with a planner. This
method is insufficient because a language model might generate valid PDDL code
that does not align with the natural language description of the task. Second,
existing evaluation sets often have natural language descriptions of the
planning task that closely resemble the ground truth PDDL, reducing the
challenge of the task. To bridge this gap, we introduce \benchmarkName, a
benchmark designed to evaluate language models' ability to generate PDDL code
from natural language descriptions of planning tasks. We begin by creating a
PDDL equivalence algorithm that rigorously evaluates the correctness of PDDL
code generated by language models by flexibly comparing it against a ground
truth PDDL. Then, we present a dataset of $132,037$ text-to-PDDL pairs across
13 different tasks, with varying levels of difficulty. Finally, we evaluate
several API-access and open-weight language models that reveal this task's
complexity. For example, $87.6\%$ of the PDDL problem descriptions generated by
GPT-4o are syntactically parseable, $82.2\%$ are valid, solve-able problems,
but only $35.1\%$ are semantically correct, highlighting the need for a more
rigorous benchmark for this problem. | [
-0.13740649819374084,
-0.4880061745643616,
0.7610636949539185,
0.5794728994369507,
-0.10278037935495377,
-0.15815088152885437,
-0.2889825403690338,
-0.1674370914697647,
-0.4048946797847748,
0.6825241446495056,
-0.5390274524688721,
-0.5791673064231873,
-0.4275631010532379,
0.24479207396507263,
-0.4655011296272278,
0.9961271286010742,
-0.6269278526306152,
-0.032275982201099396,
-0.31948328018188477,
-0.09188898652791977,
-0.15814682841300964,
-0.2656855583190918,
-0.02899753674864769,
-0.3797529935836792,
0.025284869596362114,
0.03955536335706711,
0.719872236251831,
0.6317833662033081,
0.8235626220703125,
0.2432962954044342,
-0.02122092992067337,
0.3407069444656372,
-0.4377953112125397,
-0.3166810870170593,
-0.26752907037734985,
0.03278123214840889,
-0.46364033222198486,
0.09621880203485489,
0.7572164535522461,
1.2692829370498657,
-0.3547745943069458,
0.31279686093330383,
0.009151100181043148,
0.7475038766860962,
-0.4649081230163574,
0.4158693552017212,
-0.3525334894657135,
0.08067923039197922,
-0.09525182098150253,
-0.28322309255599976,
-0.3696950078010559,
-0.5292491912841797,
0.23439401388168335,
-0.7183583378791809,
0.18347397446632385,
-0.01876325160264969,
1.0079940557479858,
0.4785483777523041,
-0.25018516182899475,
-0.5321334004402161,
-0.9755352139472961,
0.6925347447395325,
-0.5864483714103699,
0.3527075946331024,
0.4522072672843933,
0.35069572925567627,
-0.3572288751602173,
-0.7399351000785828,
-0.8210495710372925,
-0.39475974440574646,
0.08063214272260666,
0.022428950294852257,
-0.06000789627432823,
0.05706853047013283,
0.4534377157688141,
0.2566138505935669,
-0.9221388101577759,
-0.28788521885871887,
-0.396533340215683,
-0.051783718168735504,
0.48301586508750916,
0.16049516201019287,
0.20583581924438477,
-0.5456310510635376,
-0.4116448760032654,
-0.15450723469257355,
-0.6678014397621155,
-0.002997598610818386,
0.556769073009491,
0.09760534018278122,
-0.08534743636846542,
0.6549464464187622,
-0.37029001116752625,
0.7190887331962585,
-0.09145194292068481,
-0.3029654026031494,
0.12395205348730087,
-0.7627453804016113,
-0.41724854707717896,
-0.30620846152305603,
0.4491961896419525,
0.6541019082069397,
0.2453477382659912,
-0.48878949880599976,
-0.32386380434036255,
0.3524515628814697,
0.4650282561779022,
-0.8687180876731873,
-0.6436992883682251,
0.16163402795791626,
-0.22132553160190582,
-0.05302054062485695,
-0.1977781057357788,
-0.4718468487262726,
-0.11965595930814743,
-0.22637471556663513,
0.13503865897655487,
-0.5048791170120239,
-0.1471092402935028,
0.20098397135734558,
0.11964043229818344,
0.21593999862670898,
0.3337145745754242,
-0.6589621901512146,
0.5697006583213806,
0.7924997806549072,
0.6490928530693054,
-0.08431550860404968,
-0.3571220934391022,
-0.3678743839263916,
0.06854680925607681,
-0.7074979543685913,
0.9710944294929504,
-0.14514794945716858,
-0.5752156972885132,
-0.14324314892292023,
-0.07012417912483215,
0.003244568593800068,
-0.6000016927719116,
1.0167949199676514,
-0.18490082025527954,
0.3682892620563507,
-0.4091028571128845,
-0.5504646301269531,
0.05590621009469032,
0.4829941987991333,
-0.400386244058609,
1.001879096031189,
0.43729278445243835,
-0.4237090051174164,
0.830349326133728,
-0.40417417883872986,
-0.16310441493988037,
0.3260864317417145,
-0.33760008215904236,
-0.26120495796203613,
-0.20981740951538086,
0.05355888605117798,
0.16819392144680023,
-0.3457900881767273,
0.7828827500343323,
0.10148885101079941,
-0.09215182065963745,
0.07244738936424255,
-0.1919070929288864,
0.4701581597328186,
0.22253628075122833,
-0.29064151644706726,
0.2526424527168274,
-0.8310626149177551,
0.21091490983963013,
-0.08574151247739792,
-0.5715318322181702,
0.0378282256424427,
0.452389657497406,
0.32160669565200806,
0.08781824260950089,
0.39933133125305176,
-0.5151101350784302,
0.15892411768436432,
-0.5767392516136169,
0.13613946735858917,
0.73763507604599,
-0.287057101726532,
0.5318450331687927,
-0.33771270513534546,
0.4383890628814697,
-0.38053661584854126,
-0.04950239509344101,
0.10998880863189697,
-0.34608906507492065,
-0.39229103922843933,
0.07602256536483765,
0.14030903577804565,
0.382615327835083,
-0.9814980626106262,
0.4690222442150116,
-0.5167851448059082,
-0.7455450892448425,
-0.142356276512146,
0.11235310137271881,
0.6208621859550476,
0.6264539361000061,
0.2465682029724121,
-0.4206031262874603,
-0.38222625851631165,
-0.6898709535598755,
-0.16954584419727325,
-0.3685879409313202,
-0.044771235436201096,
0.624818742275238,
0.5184198617935181,
-0.12115798890590668,
0.9069136381149292,
-0.4127020239830017,
-0.18988683819770813,
-0.17261825501918793,
0.2227247953414917,
0.568362832069397,
0.4700033664703369,
0.5613378286361694,
-0.8068035244941711,
-0.5775136947631836,
0.10414889454841614,
-0.6741064786911011,
-0.3595331907272339,
-0.28678327798843384,
-0.006357788573950529,
0.10001721978187561,
-0.11349231004714966,
-0.6380382776260376,
0.37306416034698486,
0.6251761317253113,
-0.5220832228660583,
0.9546299576759338,
-0.5602278709411621,
0.19658204913139343,
-0.9021997451782227,
0.5917673707008362,
-0.005367239471524954,
-0.14319929480552673,
-0.6275700330734253,
0.3705958127975464,
0.2886691689491272,
-0.26557767391204834,
-0.25307101011276245,
0.4199330806732178,
-0.4123220145702362,
-0.4116284251213074,
-0.25685545802116394,
0.25487396121025085,
-0.06679622083902359,
0.33000633120536804,
0.1389964371919632,
0.9032886028289795,
0.5026343464851379,
-0.5851414799690247,
0.5603429675102234,
0.39648449420928955,
-0.7004133462905884,
0.6977299451828003,
-0.5303241014480591,
-0.016928108409047127,
-0.01012477558106184,
0.4016339182853699,
-0.8679298758506775,
-0.2383740246295929,
0.07960325479507446,
-0.12692363560199738,
-0.14589238166809082,
-0.15680505335330963,
-0.6641659140586853,
-0.5556700229644775,
0.016090024262666702,
0.28421980142593384,
0.37751010060310364,
-0.5015802383422852,
0.3279840350151062,
0.18770650029182434,
-0.20861029624938965,
-0.48167502880096436,
-0.36385565996170044,
0.2847096621990204,
0.16286449134349823,
-0.6148805022239685,
0.8025227189064026,
-0.18893498182296753,
-0.20487813651561737,
0.10770973563194275,
-0.43966421484947205,
-0.22109007835388184,
-0.05386824533343315,
0.1928001344203949,
0.302690714597702,
-0.07936109602451324,
-0.18477453291416168,
-0.23642490804195404,
-0.2794688045978546,
0.29616349935531616,
-0.3132411539554596,
0.7397803068161011,
0.10566755384206772,
-0.193523108959198,
-0.2811194062232971,
0.048609547317028046,
0.4773413836956024,
-0.15879662334918976,
0.47021567821502686,
0.2766060531139374,
-0.5318654179573059,
-0.3218165934085846,
-0.26647260785102844,
0.3364575207233429,
-0.42785897850990295,
0.3383282721042633,
-0.6986963152885437,
-0.07875045388936996,
0.2910030782222748,
-0.24360041320323944,
0.2200821042060852,
0.12337023764848709,
0.45175671577453613,
0.29982510209083557,
0.8147686123847961,
0.76288902759552,
0.2943539619445801,
-0.038148004561662674,
-0.22513534128665924,
0.2240859866142273,
-0.7357168197631836,
-0.19329914450645447,
-0.618751585483551,
-0.04986858367919922,
-0.42605671286582947,
-0.7560011744499207,
0.15951330959796906,
0.04345843195915222,
0.14613963663578033,
0.9153202176094055,
-0.6491556167602539,
0.4939773380756378,
0.100235216319561,
-0.3121514618396759,
0.265978068113327,
-0.3592208921909332,
-0.2047349065542221,
-0.2312370389699936,
-0.1969173699617386,
-1.0427430868148804,
1.1509466171264648,
0.07184027880430222,
0.6243860125541687,
0.21694828569889069,
0.5529540777206421,
0.11339861899614334,
0.251014769077301,
-0.2548660635948181,
0.6887413859367371,
-0.21030618250370026,
-0.4869304597377777,
-0.16030874848365784,
-0.6923307776451111,
-0.6491848230361938,
0.105418860912323,
-0.033102624118328094,
-0.6783342957496643,
0.17298275232315063,
-0.04709654301404953,
-0.1759336292743683,
0.13993337750434875,
-0.5552797317504883,
1.0918676853179932,
-0.3652055561542511,
-0.3244594633579254,
-0.3212718963623047,
-0.22613170742988586,
0.09514179825782776,
-0.2632499933242798,
0.16536912322044373,
-0.5047804713249207,
0.0457632839679718,
0.6893424391746521,
-0.29128146171569824,
0.21841424703598022,
-0.2139657437801361,
-0.18705108761787415,
-0.19712820649147034,
0.2685936391353607,
0.44152265787124634,
0.014583870768547058,
-0.2955273985862732,
-0.213211327791214,
0.3260142207145691,
-0.5727471113204956,
-0.25144529342651367,
0.7843101620674133,
-0.8741766810417175,
-0.17425274848937988,
-0.27737125754356384,
-0.7632411122322083,
-0.11003995686769485,
0.27257299423217773,
0.07204627990722656,
0.6131292581558228,
-0.6243090033531189,
-0.2610640227794647,
0.20665335655212402,
-0.4203321039676666,
0.2731874883174896,
0.5706119537353516,
-0.3252088725566864,
-0.12511199712753296,
0.8550838232040405,
0.11111393570899963,
0.3555901050567627,
0.33647483587265015,
-0.15525980293750763,
-0.4008396565914154,
-0.8369311094284058,
-0.6480942368507385,
0.04219057410955429,
-0.740053653717041,
0.04075883328914642,
-0.5152285099029541,
-0.10234514623880386,
-0.4472149908542633,
-0.32475563883781433,
-0.37148505449295044,
-0.31048455834388733,
0.028620673343539238,
0.031230514869093895,
-0.3078305721282959,
0.7948557734489441,
0.14131946861743927,
-0.038615383207798004,
-0.30511897802352905,
0.48032447695732117,
-0.016181619837880135,
0.45908164978027344,
-0.5730830430984497,
-0.11408299207687378,
0.03260413557291031,
-0.07934071123600006,
-0.45590803027153015,
-0.7430422306060791,
0.773784339427948,
0.11835034191608429,
0.5685290098190308,
0.28104355931282043,
0.23776035010814667,
0.8650376200675964,
-0.778222918510437,
0.7195058465003967,
0.039901748299598694,
-0.9703261256217957,
0.6341965794563293,
-0.24794840812683105,
0.16351760923862457,
0.5947384238243103,
0.3418545424938202,
-0.4441087543964386,
-0.24669305980205536,
-0.7180895805358887,
-0.6819290518760681,
0.6480671763420105,
0.4496496915817261,
-0.043666522949934006,
0.010258789174258709,
0.2861563563346863,
0.15776920318603516,
0.38152793049812317,
-0.8565870523452759,
-0.04037388414144516,
-0.15743331611156464,
-0.03895697742700577,
-0.3354624807834625,
-0.025740712881088257,
-0.19390055537223816,
0.042905934154987335,
0.3336385190486908,
-0.1803002804517746,
0.2527003884315491,
0.19287364184856415,
-0.15412425994873047,
-0.44638949632644653,
0.33974891901016235,
0.6126436591148376,
1.2928719520568848,
-0.5139182209968567,
0.2236853986978531,
0.03911766782402992,
-0.3388868570327759,
-0.07898522168397903,
0.6182696223258972,
-0.12307565659284592,
0.005535252392292023,
0.22913402318954468,
0.4382416903972626,
0.2016245573759079,
-1.034798502922058,
0.531139075756073,
0.034239381551742554,
-0.32453522086143494,
-0.33697831630706787,
-0.11736365407705307,
-0.0974586009979248,
-0.057464346289634705,
0.39066752791404724,
0.29678115248680115,
0.13558320701122284,
-0.5523289442062378,
0.2263600081205368,
0.3669593036174774,
-0.3081459403038025,
-0.4813591539859772,
0.7133070826530457,
0.4247138798236847,
-0.5040125846862793,
0.39853596687316895,
-0.5041373372077942,
-0.5484247207641602,
0.6305357217788696,
0.5906283259391785,
0.5421162843704224,
0.17739607393741608,
0.4631056785583496,
0.47315549850463867,
0.37823233008384705,
0.10568087548017502,
0.39151591062545776,
-0.34398987889289856,
-0.6762056350708008,
-0.5912748575210571,
-0.85711669921875,
-0.7335943579673767,
-0.40714403986930847,
-0.4627924859523773,
-0.023999202996492386,
-0.6201294660568237,
0.050499457865953445,
-0.04435437172651291,
0.43737366795539856,
-0.6226232647895813,
0.00782380998134613,
0.1450730860233307,
0.9713724851608276,
-0.7328999638557434,
0.9079692959785461,
0.8131222128868103,
-0.2408064603805542,
-0.8570217490196228,
0.01359231024980545,
-0.14419618248939514,
-0.585551381111145,
0.7659831047058105,
0.26570752263069153,
0.052242524921894073,
-0.06345227360725403,
-0.25280463695526123,
-0.6975524425506592,
1.1794861555099487,
0.10527093708515167,
-0.4095875918865204,
-0.20308858156204224,
0.3256497085094452,
0.6258280277252197,
-0.2565782964229584,
0.03153376281261444,
0.5515931844711304,
0.5635435581207275,
0.015377484261989594,
-1.494545578956604,
0.12733358144760132,
-0.2552170753479004,
-0.05643884092569351,
0.43342888355255127,
0.007485384587198496,
0.9313165545463562,
-0.15855762362480164,
-0.6659067273139954,
0.5723176598548889,
0.4269498586654663,
0.31838691234588623,
0.3450610637664795,
0.45345503091812134,
0.6018716096878052,
0.8385320901870728,
-0.438193142414093,
1.138645887374878,
-0.4858475923538208,
0.4946134388446808,
0.6748453974723816,
-0.8390491008758545,
0.9137740731239319,
0.44081899523735046,
-0.5405167937278748,
0.46508166193962097,
0.31965339183807373,
-0.04173336178064346,
0.7404628396034241,
0.20930339395999908,
-0.1771703064441681,
-0.03398876637220383,
-0.16669632494449615,
-0.23745158314704895,
0.16005703806877136,
0.2790790796279907,
-0.026921629905700684,
-0.5450981259346008,
-0.13644586503505707,
-0.2322963923215866,
0.5457016825675964,
0.07203062623739243,
0.5634248852729797,
-0.22451142966747284,
-0.9980308413505554,
0.4577568769454956,
0.194131538271904,
0.4043634235858917,
-0.4448803961277008,
0.02651377208530903,
0.019104214385151863,
0.42586296796798706,
-0.12855041027069092,
-0.9649932980537415,
0.495116651058197,
0.2116066962480545,
0.021463889628648758,
-0.6564888954162598,
0.2936684787273407,
-0.36670514941215515,
-0.43786099553108215,
0.11227284371852875,
0.4489731788635254,
0.227350115776062,
0.1107955202460289,
-0.6871153116226196,
-0.029316000640392303,
0.04934385046362877,
0.1817052662372589,
0.08655795454978943,
0.3617343008518219,
0.22347310185432434,
0.7624228596687317,
0.8056687116622925,
0.4306827783584595,
-0.05025877431035042,
-0.07513422518968582,
0.9186761379241943,
-0.5728853344917297,
-0.6946284174919128,
-0.40496009588241577,
0.25878357887268066,
-0.13453499972820282,
-0.5905306339263916,
0.6610800623893738,
0.6266596913337708,
0.8457688093185425,
-0.029058149084448814,
0.23184044659137726,
-0.39764848351478577,
0.4822930097579956,
-0.4948776960372925,
0.5063673257827759,
-0.17518797516822815,
0.43245673179626465,
-0.44818276166915894,
-1.0989941358566284,
-0.1296345442533493,
0.7943670749664307,
-0.7142277359962463,
-0.2552621364593506,
0.7862162590026855,
0.7927708029747009,
0.03731642663478851,
-0.24970266222953796,
0.35306501388549805,
-0.057856786996126175,
0.6349721550941467,
0.7742718458175659,
0.8419439792633057,
-0.34523805975914,
0.7922317981719971,
-0.5379622578620911,
-0.34487077593803406,
-0.0021512785460799932,
-0.9224809408187866,
-0.6661065220832825,
-0.6170859932899475,
-0.3937939405441284,
-0.31841692328453064,
0.17709003388881683,
0.7362266182899475,
0.8294575810432434,
-0.5674877762794495,
-0.46219775080680847,
-0.39689311385154724,
-0.03969116881489754,
-0.3319680690765381,
-0.2443617582321167,
0.4451304078102112,
-0.22265274822711945,
-0.7085738182067871,
0.4167807102203369,
0.37042370438575745,
-0.25579768419265747,
-0.3663254976272583,
-0.40579572319984436,
0.05114225670695305,
-0.12257305532693863,
0.2694350481033325,
0.2124495953321457,
-0.8960315585136414,
-0.31354278326034546,
-0.008650840260088444,
-0.3929922580718994,
-0.16377051174640656,
0.6020642518997192,
-0.8871313333511353,
0.5157268047332764,
0.33328351378440857,
0.3732297420501709,
0.49085181951522827,
0.10737057775259018,
0.7112850546836853,
-0.8650182485580444,
0.05456537753343582,
0.34325945377349854,
0.43294844031333923,
0.4222043752670288,
-0.018880605697631836,
0.6961710453033447,
0.12238314747810364,
-0.8550892472267151,
-0.9678489565849304,
0.3180091679096222,
-1.2496334314346313,
-0.13796710968017578,
0.8746219277381897,
-0.20769336819648743,
-0.13614341616630554,
-0.07750184834003448,
-0.2466600090265274,
-0.0887310802936554,
0.021638086065649986,
0.7933039665222168,
0.5569741725921631,
-0.04486135020852089,
-0.013915933668613434,
-0.6080877184867859,
0.6678199768066406,
0.24429549276828766,
-0.8715845346450806,
0.26049959659576416,
0.6031803488731384,
0.16879931092262268,
0.557253360748291,
0.7998042106628418,
-0.043904777616262436,
0.5578678250312805,
0.05829677730798721,
0.1307850033044815,
0.22034387290477753,
-0.19212551414966583,
0.21820572018623352,
0.2343195676803589,
0.28364479541778564,
0.1146339476108551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03320v1 | InternLM-XComposer-2.5: A Versatile Large Vision Language Model Supporting Long-Contextual Input and Output | 2024-07-03T17:59:21 | 2024-07-03T17:59:21 | Pan Zhang, Xiaoyi Dong, Yuhang Zang, Yuhang Cao, Rui Qian, Lin Chen, Qipeng Guo, Haodong Duan, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Yining Li, Yang Gao, Peng Sun, Xinyue Zhang, Wei Li, Jingwen Li, Wenhai Wang, Hang Yan, Conghui He, Xingcheng Zhang, Kai Chen, Jifeng Dai, Yu Qiao, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We present InternLM-XComposer-2.5 (IXC-2.5), a versatile large-vision
language model that supports long-contextual input and output. IXC-2.5 excels
in various text-image comprehension and composition applications, achieving
GPT-4V level capabilities with merely 7B LLM backend. Trained with 24K
interleaved image-text contexts, it can seamlessly extend to 96K long contexts
via RoPE extrapolation. This long-context capability allows IXC-2.5 to excel in
tasks requiring extensive input and output contexts. Compared to its previous
2.0 version, InternLM-XComposer-2.5 features three major upgrades in
vision-language comprehension: (1) Ultra-High Resolution Understanding, (2)
Fine-Grained Video Understanding, and (3) Multi-Turn Multi-Image Dialogue. In
addition to comprehension, IXC-2.5 extends to two compelling applications using
extra LoRA parameters for text-image composition: (1) Crafting Webpages and (2)
Composing High-Quality Text-Image Articles. IXC-2.5 has been evaluated on 28
benchmarks, outperforming existing open-source state-of-the-art models on 16
benchmarks. It also surpasses or competes closely with GPT-4V and Gemini Pro on
16 key tasks. The InternLM-XComposer-2.5 is publicly available at
https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-XComposer. | [
-0.46688663959503174,
-0.31633588671684265,
0.5753116607666016,
0.41570544242858887,
-0.44970405101776123,
0.09976649284362793,
-0.25626739859580994,
-0.8836402297019958,
-0.28790321946144104,
0.5051370859146118,
-0.230923131108284,
-0.494945764541626,
-0.5116052031517029,
-0.09335286915302277,
-0.7582389116287231,
0.842079758644104,
-0.1784168928861618,
-0.03430904820561409,
-0.5035298466682434,
-0.3674704134464264,
-0.6324746608734131,
-0.41506969928741455,
-0.850623369216919,
-0.13980945944786072,
0.8153602480888367,
0.6346227526664734,
0.47081002593040466,
0.49538537859916687,
0.7452841401100159,
0.27467700839042664,
-0.04495352506637573,
0.07395779341459274,
-0.49363893270492554,
0.052142657339572906,
-0.30614474415779114,
-0.35893240571022034,
-0.520305871963501,
-0.21883603930473328,
0.8828015327453613,
0.3050703704357147,
0.11742007732391357,
0.08719678223133087,
0.1679629385471344,
0.7769609689712524,
-0.6063864827156067,
0.4471460282802582,
-0.751227855682373,
-0.18010690808296204,
-0.023791417479515076,
0.04304543510079384,
-0.42916420102119446,
0.3068988621234894,
0.23769895732402802,
-0.5627906918525696,
-0.29647141695022583,
0.22566822171211243,
0.6843276023864746,
0.4106694459915161,
-0.4701889753341675,
-0.11072732508182526,
-0.5605096220970154,
0.613220751285553,
-0.3864540159702301,
0.3355465531349182,
0.23709386587142944,
0.5706298351287842,
0.4355059564113617,
-1.337968111038208,
-0.7940505146980286,
-0.3453802168369293,
-0.0352616012096405,
0.3507239818572998,
-0.18878032267093658,
0.05201773717999458,
0.24399492144584656,
0.38623979687690735,
-0.5561224818229675,
0.1653863787651062,
-0.49589866399765015,
0.33021193742752075,
0.36555221676826477,
0.3267084062099457,
0.30784493684768677,
0.09695983678102493,
-0.4278141260147095,
-0.17364224791526794,
-0.8306451439857483,
0.19343842566013336,
-0.0006594404112547636,
-0.30122053623199463,
-0.3030930161476135,
0.5492070913314819,
-0.1505333036184311,
0.755981981754303,
-0.2745414674282074,
0.1317165642976761,
0.07748589664697647,
-0.4414299428462982,
-0.08223941177129745,
-0.10832557082176208,
0.5106304883956909,
0.6156234741210938,
-0.0832856297492981,
0.27316612005233765,
-0.38047733902931213,
0.09997742623090744,
0.28676164150238037,
-0.7628023624420166,
-0.15398681163787842,
0.022455906495451927,
-0.40858176350593567,
-0.30627164244651794,
-0.03903958946466446,
-0.4654005169868469,
-0.06408336758613586,
-0.5063061118125916,
0.43109285831451416,
-0.3781657814979553,
0.12273726612329483,
-0.04375244304537773,
-0.12563161551952362,
0.4921295940876007,
0.48998475074768066,
-0.7436838746070862,
0.4737936854362488,
0.6907545328140259,
1.0288166999816895,
-0.7254751324653625,
-0.28920453786849976,
-0.6186909675598145,
0.19441145658493042,
-0.3497326970100403,
0.7240933775901794,
-0.45622166991233826,
-0.23062492907047272,
0.05147617310285568,
-0.020804809406399727,
0.2139960527420044,
-0.4846683740615845,
0.546951413154602,
-0.5644877552986145,
0.21391837298870087,
0.08564376831054688,
-0.38672059774398804,
-0.12705634534358978,
0.5405188202857971,
-0.6001113057136536,
1.0745515823364258,
0.5146910548210144,
-0.8224883079528809,
0.150307297706604,
-0.8520345687866211,
-0.4324413537979126,
0.2300012856721878,
-0.3384951949119568,
-0.3435956537723541,
-0.07031633704900742,
-0.12314620614051819,
0.1469418704509735,
-0.5136096477508545,
0.07845805585384369,
-0.1064019501209259,
-0.5803999900817871,
0.3054743707180023,
-0.4031496047973633,
0.5187631249427795,
0.10288190096616745,
-0.4524250626564026,
0.3758903443813324,
-0.8871058225631714,
0.014845500700175762,
-0.07590416073799133,
-0.24834713339805603,
-0.23430053889751434,
0.11674187332391739,
0.3035030961036682,
0.6572407484054565,
0.2776571810245514,
-0.5860916972160339,
0.003652639454230666,
-0.28566616773605347,
0.6092696785926819,
0.6079215407371521,
-0.5712811946868896,
0.3177049160003662,
-0.14264094829559326,
0.5503165125846863,
0.1265963613986969,
0.22007183730602264,
-0.5765934586524963,
-0.43005213141441345,
-1.0751327276229858,
-0.393759548664093,
-0.056172121316194534,
0.6161191463470459,
-0.9504520893096924,
0.19687283039093018,
-0.5031349062919617,
-0.5082436800003052,
-0.022712640464305878,
-0.14295057952404022,
0.521392285823822,
0.7743116617202759,
0.44828876852989197,
-0.0638827458024025,
-0.5542560815811157,
-0.9304603338241577,
0.18860802054405212,
-0.2146265208721161,
0.05976385250687599,
0.424704372882843,
0.5774398446083069,
-0.27599847316741943,
1.002612590789795,
-0.6689226627349854,
-0.5390061736106873,
-0.45415571331977844,
-0.018469151109457016,
0.15762153267860413,
0.46003755927085876,
0.5719535946846008,
-0.9725913405418396,
-1.0723485946655273,
0.4661761224269867,
-0.6380306482315063,
0.052579138427972794,
-0.0007594453054480255,
0.0718548446893692,
0.508069634437561,
0.8148335218429565,
-0.599359393119812,
0.48935556411743164,
0.808799684047699,
-0.4043925404548645,
0.7356423735618591,
-0.3387046754360199,
-0.166009783744812,
-1.016696810722351,
0.2073592245578766,
-0.041426174342632294,
-0.560019314289093,
-0.48411500453948975,
0.20524270832538605,
0.3961091935634613,
-0.018347088247537613,
-0.7012710571289062,
0.9114089012145996,
-0.30355069041252136,
-0.0054140640422701836,
-0.5961349606513977,
0.006719542667269707,
0.09718196839094162,
0.4144468307495117,
0.18615825474262238,
0.938178539276123,
0.8151959776878357,
-0.28911176323890686,
0.376671701669693,
0.27194511890411377,
-0.7223773002624512,
0.4585161507129669,
-0.9633850455284119,
0.06421606242656708,
-0.13665889203548431,
0.3773271143436432,
-1.0116267204284668,
-0.25768110156059265,
0.3367985188961029,
-0.3125603199005127,
0.28891581296920776,
-0.03436758369207382,
-0.3782094717025757,
-0.4630168378353119,
-0.41310542821884155,
0.4120529592037201,
0.6473067998886108,
-0.7088022232055664,
0.6368954181671143,
0.15004587173461914,
-0.4514296054840088,
-0.4878075122833252,
-0.7968791127204895,
0.4713585376739502,
-0.03345327079296112,
-0.7598769068717957,
0.5794006586074829,
-0.27308934926986694,
-0.25220808386802673,
0.004946505650877953,
0.21591584384441376,
-0.002377578290179372,
-0.3572465181350708,
0.3564877212047577,
0.6484619379043579,
-0.17667722702026367,
-0.053125858306884766,
0.09999808669090271,
-0.37832188606262207,
0.024644531309604645,
-0.3284224271774292,
0.4063357412815094,
-0.17963732779026031,
-0.15569418668746948,
-0.09140632301568985,
0.7219076156616211,
0.7230585217475891,
-0.346236914396286,
0.5505155920982361,
0.5657181739807129,
-0.09210207313299179,
0.0394064225256443,
-0.4286996126174927,
0.12138140201568604,
-0.5094354748725891,
0.8102342486381531,
-0.4611804783344269,
-1.0406246185302734,
0.3411244750022888,
0.3389523923397064,
0.19170552492141724,
0.2097119688987732,
0.5573687553405762,
-0.25410160422325134,
1.27388596534729,
0.6574342846870422,
0.1630953997373581,
0.6063938736915588,
-0.38326916098594666,
0.2607099115848541,
-1.172059416770935,
-0.17860230803489685,
-0.18637581169605255,
-0.3768293559551239,
-0.25797462463378906,
-0.6211843490600586,
0.5500012040138245,
-0.4884651303291321,
-0.19508439302444458,
0.08305472880601883,
-0.3117583096027374,
0.5138360261917114,
0.7644666433334351,
-0.11874641478061676,
0.3443482518196106,
0.021580712869763374,
0.09741026908159256,
0.04179822653532028,
-0.4808954894542694,
-0.32809215784072876,
0.7456138730049133,
0.28909486532211304,
0.8611561059951782,
-0.0909014493227005,
0.04067583009600639,
-0.009007927030324936,
0.19431914389133453,
-0.8119800090789795,
0.6142249703407288,
-0.5700443983078003,
-0.518979012966156,
-0.2157122641801834,
0.054180342704057693,
-0.5552760362625122,
0.3454763889312744,
0.17799508571624756,
-0.7634610533714294,
0.20929694175720215,
0.31391215324401855,
-0.2528127431869507,
0.3018045127391815,
-0.5545390844345093,
0.8640868663787842,
-0.3307701647281647,
-0.5848367214202881,
-0.3362363278865814,
-0.9865849018096924,
0.24377894401550293,
-0.1409701555967331,
-0.2511369287967682,
-0.043683972209692,
-0.4024277925491333,
0.2639007568359375,
-0.28231722116470337,
0.7323529720306396,
0.1607355922460556,
-0.132163867354393,
0.3061918020248413,
-0.2915831506252289,
0.6357056498527527,
0.22679868340492249,
-0.1365538090467453,
0.1920432448387146,
0.05040815845131874,
0.012582870200276375,
-0.5496886372566223,
0.8896177411079407,
-0.7368646860122681,
-0.5730775594711304,
-0.5348978042602539,
-0.582719624042511,
0.010505307465791702,
0.21967941522598267,
0.5415076613426208,
0.6357770562171936,
-0.11275157332420349,
0.7007409334182739,
0.49383828043937683,
-0.16129443049430847,
0.5965444445610046,
0.41715168952941895,
-0.3800273537635803,
-0.5245126485824585,
1.0365464687347412,
0.04128394275903702,
0.39136451482772827,
0.596809983253479,
-0.10584329813718796,
-0.26294228434562683,
-0.6128126382827759,
-0.44452965259552,
-0.08231822401285172,
-0.926729679107666,
-0.251560777425766,
-0.8859624862670898,
-0.4230547845363617,
-0.1575980931520462,
-0.33284232020378113,
-0.4124689996242523,
-0.27027782797813416,
-0.4543743431568146,
0.1593114137649536,
0.058740172535181046,
0.31446751952171326,
0.0666787251830101,
0.4260851740837097,
-0.6945889592170715,
0.5250982046127319,
0.40452733635902405,
0.4402741491794586,
-0.2101612687110901,
-0.612531304359436,
-0.4798039495944977,
-0.1940811723470688,
-0.24824070930480957,
-0.3260821998119354,
0.3417748212814331,
0.34166350960731506,
0.12721635401248932,
0.4178020656108856,
-0.1735306829214096,
0.5275825262069702,
-0.5626003742218018,
0.8487902879714966,
0.44959133863449097,
-0.8825521469116211,
0.1301080286502838,
-0.31505823135375977,
0.7657754421234131,
0.5081838369369507,
0.1304737627506256,
-0.7963443398475647,
-0.2762542963027954,
-0.05113517865538597,
-0.9297066330909729,
0.9524745345115662,
0.264305979013443,
0.3153435289859772,
-0.02435016818344593,
0.25496038794517517,
0.20615938305854797,
-0.007200753781944513,
-0.8729892373085022,
-0.15349319577217102,
-0.43885165452957153,
-0.29152828454971313,
0.008161508478224277,
-0.6502523422241211,
0.09297666698694229,
-0.48920395970344543,
0.6988048553466797,
-0.48696228861808777,
0.14491119980812073,
0.26228126883506775,
-0.17529237270355225,
0.20281560719013214,
-0.01323283463716507,
0.5709306597709656,
0.9627349376678467,
0.11959122866392136,
0.263997346162796,
0.11166942119598389,
-0.5424266457557678,
0.10693735629320145,
0.17805494368076324,
-0.39921489357948303,
-0.16167838871479034,
0.2978619337081909,
1.1817116737365723,
0.13694341480731964,
-0.9676123857498169,
0.5914512872695923,
-0.2731599807739258,
-0.30206331610679626,
-0.7291076183319092,
0.16033118963241577,
0.10718634724617004,
0.12986990809440613,
0.265146940946579,
0.07190688699483871,
0.245320126414299,
-0.44079872965812683,
-0.023151632398366928,
0.3652089536190033,
-0.7431243062019348,
-0.33976617455482483,
0.7125194668769836,
0.1436910778284073,
0.11540258675813675,
0.7229393720626831,
-0.09998024255037308,
-0.4067741930484772,
0.612154483795166,
0.8036659955978394,
0.682299792766571,
0.16036130487918854,
0.1206463947892189,
0.37304380536079407,
0.07408656179904938,
0.17084920406341553,
0.4336645305156708,
-0.001239774632267654,
-0.5500638484954834,
-0.5755030512809753,
-0.30047667026519775,
-0.3501278758049011,
-0.06515691429376602,
-0.3711252510547638,
0.6334974765777588,
-0.16816996037960052,
0.11359892785549164,
-0.1300901174545288,
-0.23829713463783264,
-0.5022040009498596,
0.24923333525657654,
0.333450585603714,
1.175248146057129,
-0.208909273147583,
1.1851472854614258,
0.8293905854225159,
-0.1538471132516861,
-0.6123763918876648,
-0.37504786252975464,
-0.22053061425685883,
-0.6809211373329163,
0.8200215101242065,
0.3432672619819641,
-0.16863591969013214,
0.11004641652107239,
-0.695275068283081,
-0.8530188202857971,
1.240571141242981,
0.24330122768878937,
-0.7986261248588562,
-0.11327337473630905,
0.33067747950553894,
0.46135270595550537,
-0.4900144338607788,
0.18262091279029846,
0.4929206073284149,
0.5901735424995422,
0.3149295747280121,
-0.6432405710220337,
-0.1883869171142578,
-0.46044033765792847,
0.23709070682525635,
-0.002413383685052395,
-0.7715633511543274,
0.772728681564331,
-0.22112929821014404,
0.0345412977039814,
0.5532204508781433,
0.7862855792045593,
0.14156264066696167,
0.2936486303806305,
0.6025800704956055,
0.4197568893432617,
0.13701288402080536,
-0.05787273123860359,
1.119960904121399,
-0.3877238631248474,
-0.0022147763520479202,
1.6129599809646606,
-0.4908732771873474,
0.9234697818756104,
0.5934959650039673,
0.2114444524049759,
0.5228282809257507,
0.32783472537994385,
-0.020986715331673622,
0.5512613654136658,
-0.06951060891151428,
-0.5535584092140198,
-0.011401807889342308,
-0.09925829619169235,
-0.26929110288619995,
0.6027345061302185,
0.41572636365890503,
-0.3236532211303711,
0.1439415067434311,
0.2897546887397766,
-0.22853921353816986,
-0.31162136793136597,
-0.19651149213314056,
0.7632238268852234,
0.2655636966228485,
-1.030188798904419,
0.28919345140457153,
-0.034005749970674515,
0.537017285823822,
-0.8435783386230469,
-0.1984338015317917,
-0.16235844790935516,
0.4713050127029419,
-0.007585674989968538,
-1.303917407989502,
0.2878013253211975,
-0.03995795547962189,
-0.16550084948539734,
-0.09090020507574081,
1.0013200044631958,
-0.48548832535743713,
-0.5713172554969788,
0.3251408040523529,
-0.0016966693801805377,
-0.16722041368484497,
-0.468428373336792,
-0.4227578341960907,
0.3873552680015564,
-0.023645561188459396,
-0.03522523492574692,
0.22172091901302338,
0.15288150310516357,
-0.27762311697006226,
0.7429999113082886,
0.4583272337913513,
-0.17170703411102295,
0.02063741907477379,
0.04045144468545914,
1.0761847496032715,
-0.6027234792709351,
-0.5513271689414978,
-0.7081373929977417,
0.7133410573005676,
-0.28108155727386475,
-0.4364572763442993,
0.45508530735969543,
0.7450169920921326,
0.7902277112007141,
-0.24048687517642975,
0.8253285884857178,
-0.18776893615722656,
0.14542555809020996,
-0.3302724361419678,
0.5105366110801697,
-0.8093265295028687,
-0.10704485327005386,
0.03135126084089279,
-1.1129239797592163,
-0.5552663803100586,
0.286220520734787,
-0.10138820111751556,
-0.18331579864025116,
0.8827295899391174,
0.6806222200393677,
-0.17693106830120087,
-0.15025974810123444,
0.5766564011573792,
0.21888700127601624,
0.5995897650718689,
0.3627816140651703,
1.043287992477417,
-0.29162508249282837,
0.8809690475463867,
-0.19286921620368958,
-0.312603235244751,
-0.29806995391845703,
-0.7569808959960938,
-0.7948740720748901,
-0.7356924414634705,
-0.3212442696094513,
0.15813817083835602,
0.01497231051325798,
0.7277662754058838,
0.9323318600654602,
-0.43381813168525696,
-0.17035670578479767,
-0.08867839723825455,
-0.17512944340705872,
-0.159230574965477,
-0.1705566942691803,
0.1915852129459381,
-0.27443620562553406,
-0.9543177485466003,
0.25991687178611755,
0.9579007029533386,
-0.005125498399138451,
-0.4018315374851227,
-0.3084464967250824,
0.03543417900800705,
-0.028006743639707565,
1.208761215209961,
0.2573226988315582,
-0.6667653322219849,
-0.2644507884979248,
0.15019546449184418,
-0.19123174250125885,
0.4768826365470886,
0.7667484283447266,
-0.812537431716919,
0.36403077840805054,
0.6803691387176514,
0.3259926736354828,
0.6777401566505432,
-0.39948737621307373,
0.4800221025943756,
-0.4572668969631195,
0.22725513577461243,
0.1261015087366104,
0.5729446411132812,
0.31714463233947754,
-0.13031521439552307,
0.6071372032165527,
-0.2789001166820526,
-0.49836522340774536,
-0.4866868257522583,
0.15819264948368073,
-1.344963550567627,
-0.2722215950489044,
1.1675893068313599,
-0.1278398633003235,
-0.23119615018367767,
0.015468467958271503,
-0.828778088092804,
-0.053800832480192184,
-0.13715559244155884,
0.5964168310165405,
0.5476792454719543,
0.036146774888038635,
-0.4885260760784149,
-0.46769022941589355,
0.016870204359292984,
0.30643871426582336,
-1.0965746641159058,
-0.04512105509638786,
0.45540252327919006,
0.011282178573310375,
-0.041890569031238556,
0.6689116358757019,
-0.43515321612358093,
0.5917307734489441,
-0.2251979112625122,
0.006283238995820284,
-0.05459747463464737,
-0.5408540368080139,
-0.06773598492145538,
0.015698930248618126,
0.06850731372833252,
-0.09284554421901703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03314v1 | BACON: Supercharge Your VLM with Bag-of-Concept Graph to Mitigate Hallucinations | 2024-07-03T17:55:27 | 2024-07-03T17:55:27 | Zhantao Yang, Ruili Feng, Keyu Yan, Huangji Wang, Zhicai Wang, Shangwen Zhu, Han Zhang, Jie Xiao, Pingyu Wu, Kai Zhu, Jixuan Chen, Chen-Wei Xie, Chaojie Mao, Yue Yang, Hongyang Zhang, Yu Liu, Fan Cheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.DB | This paper presents Bag-of-Concept Graph (BACON) to gift models with limited
linguistic abilities to taste the privilege of Vision Language Models (VLMs)
and boost downstream tasks such as detection, visual question answering (VQA),
and image generation. Since the visual scenes in physical worlds are structured
with complex relations between objects, BACON breaks down annotations into
basic minimum elements and presents them in a graph structure. Element-wise
style enables easy understanding, and structural composition liberates
difficult locating. Careful prompt design births the BACON captions with the
help of public-available VLMs and segmentation methods. In this way, we gather
a dataset with 100K annotated images, which endow VLMs with remarkable
capabilities, such as accurately generating BACON, transforming prompts into
BACON format, envisioning scenarios in the style of BACONr, and dynamically
modifying elements within BACON through interactive dialogue and more. Wide
representative experiments, including detection, VQA, and image generation
tasks, tell BACON as a lifeline to achieve previous out-of-reach tasks or excel
in their current cutting-edge solutions. | [
-0.5232805013656616,
-0.6351946592330933,
0.3282535672187805,
-0.21144193410873413,
-0.48630741238594055,
0.33747193217277527,
0.13061125576496124,
-0.8614577651023865,
0.5475852489471436,
0.8507404923439026,
-0.6537364721298218,
-0.1721276491880417,
-0.4019175171852112,
-0.15975242853164673,
-0.6345953345298767,
1.4236900806427002,
0.44973239302635193,
-0.24184882640838623,
-0.32914671301841736,
0.13893628120422363,
-0.2241683006286621,
-0.6238031983375549,
-0.322330504655838,
-0.16635659337043762,
0.8712572455406189,
0.1301809698343277,
0.6363685131072998,
0.4952453672885895,
0.39041054248809814,
0.2920275926589966,
-0.06021551042795181,
0.48160645365715027,
-0.7878085970878601,
0.21355170011520386,
-0.19740554690361023,
0.05093039199709892,
-0.3851945102214813,
-0.40977075695991516,
0.3240791857242584,
0.46758928894996643,
0.28756698966026306,
0.15424181520938873,
-0.10803649574518204,
0.4856724143028259,
-0.5615130066871643,
0.030994504690170288,
-1.0098023414611816,
-0.04091101512312889,
0.03746290132403374,
-0.27654340863227844,
-0.3447582721710205,
0.012654042802751064,
0.18558263778686523,
-0.8009580373764038,
0.14835508167743683,
0.2311907559633255,
1.2015585899353027,
0.3115527331829071,
0.0268513523042202,
-0.09484100341796875,
-0.7427836060523987,
0.6210702657699585,
-0.16605986654758453,
0.34455081820487976,
0.2509063482284546,
0.3226366341114044,
-0.04839400202035904,
-1.0390790700912476,
-0.7098115682601929,
-0.3590678572654724,
-0.3108038604259491,
0.04408169537782669,
0.00590283889323473,
-0.08822527527809143,
0.5026634335517883,
0.1113220602273941,
-0.5518798232078552,
-0.2952239513397217,
-0.5343536138534546,
-0.2391398847103119,
0.585943341255188,
0.1726294606924057,
0.5657695531845093,
-0.192289799451828,
-0.48655635118484497,
-0.10487491637468338,
-0.2911309599876404,
-0.1671660840511322,
0.1559254676103592,
0.19821174442768097,
0.33824434876441956,
0.5675647854804993,
-0.49547335505485535,
0.9250405430793762,
-0.4773789048194885,
-0.09846485406160355,
0.19736738502979279,
-0.3764447271823883,
-0.268703818321228,
-0.04805474355816841,
0.3924620449542999,
0.6869134902954102,
0.37266266345977783,
-0.2321416139602661,
-0.1791229546070099,
0.271814227104187,
0.5183137655258179,
-0.9148144125938416,
-0.5976073145866394,
0.11259547621011734,
-0.22921136021614075,
-0.23791055381298065,
0.13642150163650513,
-0.8413578867912292,
-0.5292388796806335,
-0.11223441362380981,
0.3757714331150055,
-0.3036511540412903,
-0.3358549177646637,
0.30492839217185974,
-0.5309421420097351,
0.343778133392334,
0.4297432005405426,
-0.6878345608711243,
0.3538084030151367,
0.4817546010017395,
0.880426287651062,
-0.05734813213348389,
-0.09797339141368866,
-0.6544752717018127,
0.25890013575553894,
-0.16767176985740662,
0.9783636927604675,
-0.7123996019363403,
-0.49928632378578186,
-0.06698144227266312,
0.1432608813047409,
0.2839168906211853,
-0.3501622974872589,
0.6694943308830261,
-0.27605777978897095,
-0.10260868817567825,
-0.609875500202179,
-0.2578924298286438,
-0.09474482387304306,
0.4190608561038971,
-0.6398305892944336,
1.0518226623535156,
0.041575394570827484,
-1.0033645629882812,
0.2232721447944641,
-0.8111695051193237,
-0.2954217493534088,
0.8148845434188843,
-0.3816593587398529,
-0.17946793138980865,
0.23078592121601105,
0.2336069494485855,
0.5849971175193787,
0.29682406783103943,
0.013995437882840633,
-0.2938939929008484,
-0.21110917627811432,
0.35637107491493225,
0.09733908623456955,
0.585932731628418,
0.3062003254890442,
-0.14404790103435516,
0.29375094175338745,
-0.7015318274497986,
0.27621328830718994,
0.2051982581615448,
0.29744046926498413,
-0.5922638177871704,
0.003168498631566763,
0.39429953694343567,
0.16964352130889893,
-0.025574317201972008,
-0.5575788021087646,
0.2824968993663788,
-0.3366239070892334,
0.7809231281280518,
0.6203598380088806,
-0.15032026171684265,
0.020389465615153313,
-0.3051047921180725,
0.18692971765995026,
-0.051229409873485565,
0.33640387654304504,
-0.25226303935050964,
-0.6671764254570007,
-0.7740981578826904,
-0.3430967926979065,
0.057899534702301025,
0.40931686758995056,
-1.2419278621673584,
0.2954312562942505,
-0.23078995943069458,
-0.42628079652786255,
-0.2170857936143875,
-0.19595938920974731,
0.35837623476982117,
0.7935119271278381,
0.3842734694480896,
-0.23959776759147644,
-0.4503130316734314,
-0.8813177347183228,
0.0831153392791748,
-0.15870098769664764,
-0.07014088332653046,
0.13690781593322754,
0.829435408115387,
-0.2447003722190857,
0.7359433770179749,
-0.690228283405304,
-0.2921087443828583,
-0.30403169989585876,
-0.24027754366397858,
-0.11095407605171204,
0.4486733376979828,
0.3927600085735321,
-1.1364039182662964,
-0.049393605440855026,
0.15116672217845917,
-0.49768149852752686,
0.010266132652759552,
-0.02598249353468418,
-0.4956378936767578,
0.15715306997299194,
0.2721981108188629,
-0.5662173628807068,
0.8137105703353882,
0.15757176280021667,
-0.622096061706543,
0.7774994969367981,
-0.10281731188297272,
-0.15741673111915588,
-0.7968674302101135,
0.02026177942752838,
-0.08849816769361496,
-0.2940227687358856,
-0.6434106826782227,
0.32844045758247375,
-0.23582184314727783,
-0.07927330583333969,
-0.6067785024642944,
0.7297572493553162,
-0.1864384561777115,
-0.08160174638032913,
-0.133113831281662,
0.10000529140233994,
0.3459061086177826,
0.3736386299133301,
0.34436580538749695,
0.34331250190734863,
0.7051191329956055,
-0.5206738114356995,
0.3642793297767639,
0.31676214933395386,
-0.23564757406711578,
0.4837161898612976,
-0.6766452789306641,
0.2522236108779907,
-0.13486522436141968,
0.11519482731819153,
-1.2403868436813354,
-0.1953759789466858,
0.49316659569740295,
-0.5168839693069458,
0.0686827003955841,
0.20417208969593048,
-0.31316396594047546,
-0.5296348929405212,
-0.47275224328041077,
0.18740922212600708,
0.4607977867126465,
-0.6069746017456055,
0.7279171347618103,
0.2167639285326004,
0.3057835102081299,
-0.4915950894355774,
-0.8220610618591309,
0.30315062403678894,
-0.19227565824985504,
-0.4118522107601166,
0.544110894203186,
-0.4059433937072754,
-0.14017705619335175,
0.2899637818336487,
-0.12979580461978912,
0.18251074850559235,
0.004564071539789438,
0.3625904619693756,
0.45989760756492615,
0.19374123215675354,
0.2442108392715454,
-0.3273172676563263,
-0.14411775767803192,
-0.04082878306508064,
-0.8227881789207458,
0.5680654644966125,
-0.16123445332050323,
-0.10855477303266525,
-0.1377410888671875,
0.5595602989196777,
0.6024368405342102,
-0.32919928431510925,
0.5037450790405273,
0.8629476428031921,
-0.6771664619445801,
-0.41854703426361084,
-0.42690905928611755,
-0.34631866216659546,
-0.4780367612838745,
0.48386290669441223,
-0.6166867613792419,
-0.712330162525177,
0.536266565322876,
0.16081516444683075,
-0.08807273954153061,
-0.013182644732296467,
0.5649222135543823,
-0.21677100658416748,
0.941973865032196,
0.7016031742095947,
0.3051661252975464,
0.6262311935424805,
-0.6920584440231323,
0.43687981367111206,
-0.9167397022247314,
-0.4957832992076874,
-0.3917143940925598,
-0.3708970248699188,
-0.5094416737556458,
-0.40338245034217834,
0.2905323803424835,
-0.0010171238100156188,
-0.08113706856966019,
-0.02009529061615467,
-1.1286685466766357,
0.770268976688385,
0.611639678478241,
0.3881068229675293,
0.14464810490608215,
0.33930397033691406,
-0.16898146271705627,
0.0029855547472834587,
-0.6443349719047546,
-0.5333915948867798,
0.7956518530845642,
0.16037428379058838,
0.6460665464401245,
-0.4519933760166168,
0.6537809371948242,
0.2822425663471222,
0.07205039262771606,
-1.0318371057510376,
0.7887864112854004,
-0.2416723519563675,
-0.34947437047958374,
-0.4049743115901947,
-0.1004774421453476,
-0.46088677644729614,
0.16185705363750458,
-0.21872368454933167,
-1.350516676902771,
0.10132775455713272,
0.1316758096218109,
-0.5362237691879272,
0.40370649099349976,
-0.6656414270401001,
0.7589664459228516,
-0.32639366388320923,
-0.6449314951896667,
0.288786917924881,
-0.5317484140396118,
0.3292241096496582,
0.25685015320777893,
0.01804637350142002,
0.24690262973308563,
-0.04413346201181412,
0.7353224754333496,
-0.4041270315647125,
0.8208836913108826,
-0.020454343408346176,
0.08169476687908173,
0.20614951848983765,
0.16131876409053802,
0.5184667706489563,
0.0970999151468277,
0.14122556149959564,
0.07829466462135315,
0.1913105994462967,
-0.38981083035469055,
-0.841996431350708,
0.6789959669113159,
-0.6706622838973999,
-0.5639917254447937,
-0.29917216300964355,
-0.6010691523551941,
-0.04281638190150261,
0.019143030047416687,
0.44803565740585327,
0.6205148696899414,
0.3398197293281555,
0.1520606428384781,
0.7244550585746765,
-0.2553512156009674,
0.37666863203048706,
-0.00914059765636921,
-0.7792603373527527,
-0.4674258530139923,
1.3025044202804565,
0.39711707830429077,
0.2232932299375534,
0.14185364544391632,
0.27131593227386475,
-0.517474353313446,
-0.6180961728096008,
-0.3735553026199341,
0.24589362740516663,
-0.7669392824172974,
-0.20004576444625854,
-1.2085148096084595,
-0.3761298954486847,
-0.32801905274391174,
-0.3374822437763214,
-0.054971400648355484,
-0.35148394107818604,
-0.2307080775499344,
-0.37490224838256836,
0.5366833209991455,
0.6757495403289795,
0.057979896664619446,
0.14155730605125427,
-0.3463614583015442,
0.6258471608161926,
0.5753878355026245,
0.21318325400352478,
-0.08262070268392563,
-0.21668478846549988,
-0.18509721755981445,
-0.07826008647680283,
-0.16197504103183746,
-0.6829176545143127,
0.5921579599380493,
0.16580204665660858,
0.4192381799221039,
0.260855495929718,
0.4028303325176239,
0.9819306135177612,
-0.23332218825817108,
1.0540608167648315,
0.33855167031288147,
-0.9642406105995178,
0.5838640332221985,
-0.1422644555568695,
0.0391133613884449,
0.0950731560587883,
0.24429963529109955,
-0.3921452462673187,
-0.573347806930542,
-0.6221593618392944,
-0.9673166275024414,
0.3161523938179016,
0.29077139496803284,
0.2612330913543701,
0.20854981243610382,
0.23222626745700836,
0.0541614405810833,
0.2502521872520447,
-0.8319013714790344,
0.04659844934940338,
-0.7024126648902893,
0.07335221022367477,
0.1481758952140808,
-0.32746002078056335,
-0.332281231880188,
-0.8372660875320435,
0.5501962304115295,
-0.3568403720855713,
0.31921154260635376,
0.5318976640701294,
0.37008920311927795,
0.08445398509502411,
-0.22622500360012054,
0.6484690308570862,
0.6711648106575012,
-0.18264909088611603,
0.4111981689929962,
-0.012015043757855892,
-0.5821057558059692,
-0.17698363959789276,
-0.2566659152507782,
-0.23122729361057281,
0.005833057686686516,
0.38644590973854065,
0.9590641260147095,
-0.2738822102546692,
-0.7449222207069397,
-0.03848698362708092,
-0.11665396392345428,
-0.26930731534957886,
-0.20461589097976685,
0.2752079963684082,
0.022086938843131065,
0.312622606754303,
0.4005119800567627,
-0.2534666359424591,
0.39955246448516846,
-0.586800754070282,
0.4550965428352356,
0.5463654398918152,
-0.3733203411102295,
-0.16698065400123596,
0.574165403842926,
0.08165232837200165,
-0.5230258107185364,
0.4316707253456116,
-0.6116852760314941,
-0.9192928075790405,
0.631719172000885,
0.6914154887199402,
0.9398705959320068,
0.22238057851791382,
0.6714993119239807,
0.11283804476261139,
0.5193488597869873,
0.18567894399166107,
0.4810183644294739,
-0.10650061815977097,
-0.9180206060409546,
-0.32623526453971863,
-0.8506892919540405,
-0.20283342897891998,
0.5593239665031433,
-0.47886449098587036,
0.2762371599674225,
-0.246137335896492,
-0.04974862188100815,
0.04222146049141884,
0.21567222476005554,
-0.6816040873527527,
0.3101695775985718,
0.39361265301704407,
0.748613715171814,
-0.6156224608421326,
1.1323152780532837,
0.799565851688385,
-0.26504969596862793,
-0.7952636480331421,
-0.08355097472667694,
-0.3979796767234802,
-0.7070212364196777,
0.8960763216018677,
0.3474067151546478,
-0.27656054496765137,
0.23170165717601776,
-0.8370047211647034,
-0.4441329836845398,
0.7025812864303589,
0.2907043993473053,
-0.7284281849861145,
-0.06033005565404892,
-0.08032814413309097,
0.5871332883834839,
-0.6561980247497559,
0.34950345754623413,
0.5569578409194946,
0.5072456002235413,
0.7328093647956848,
-0.5267377495765686,
0.03107486665248871,
-0.4709787666797638,
0.24570316076278687,
0.004256760235875845,
-0.2867486774921417,
0.8031638860702515,
-0.3807677626609802,
-0.3248177468776703,
-0.13746508955955505,
0.34805142879486084,
0.16700124740600586,
0.45328328013420105,
0.6542125344276428,
0.6439275145530701,
0.8094488382339478,
-0.1215294599533081,
0.922926664352417,
-0.14811347424983978,
0.1595928817987442,
1.1086158752441406,
-0.39615851640701294,
0.6983321905136108,
0.7109841704368591,
0.28995710611343384,
0.42199936509132385,
0.6069298386573792,
0.10760819911956787,
0.6377026438713074,
0.49044498801231384,
-0.03745820000767708,
-0.44429054856300354,
-0.6093941926956177,
-0.50858473777771,
0.2684706449508667,
0.5932002067565918,
-0.12838631868362427,
-0.15263451635837555,
0.40483275055885315,
-0.16871494054794312,
0.034536492079496384,
-0.2122664600610733,
0.7393231391906738,
-0.053212255239486694,
-0.11325454711914062,
0.8032488226890564,
-0.8318716883659363,
0.49479562044143677,
-0.5382451415061951,
-0.39960017800331116,
-0.16685350239276886,
-0.18951788544654846,
-0.2941778600215912,
-0.675750732421875,
0.40625494718551636,
0.005310297943651676,
-0.005584129597991705,
-0.2925102114677429,
1.09112548828125,
-0.25604143738746643,
-0.957230269908905,
0.5524846911430359,
0.4794892370700836,
0.35917893052101135,
-0.18315574526786804,
-0.6580639481544495,
0.710379958152771,
-0.07931284606456757,
-0.2815713584423065,
0.0869775339961052,
0.5425243973731995,
-0.10862941294908524,
0.7148371934890747,
0.6646407246589661,
0.30462732911109924,
0.015073748305439949,
-0.07285214215517044,
1.3645802736282349,
-0.7509692311286926,
-0.6832329034805298,
-0.940782904624939,
0.8254930377006531,
-0.4287135601043701,
-0.19660423696041107,
0.4690777361392975,
0.28421154618263245,
1.152486801147461,
-0.2603408098220825,
0.8338537812232971,
-0.1992693394422531,
-0.051450394093990326,
-0.5610772371292114,
0.6696540117263794,
-0.7719009518623352,
0.12088226526975632,
-0.4575658142566681,
-0.8216630220413208,
-0.306402325630188,
0.7096108794212341,
-0.24268245697021484,
-0.29012390971183777,
0.7574278712272644,
0.9740856289863586,
0.1390579342842102,
-0.030946973711252213,
0.8415770530700684,
0.1626535803079605,
0.43246063590049744,
0.6307557225227356,
1.1835623979568481,
-0.16793082654476166,
0.4068303406238556,
-0.33487987518310547,
-0.279744416475296,
-0.27740079164505005,
-1.092441439628601,
-1.000575304031372,
-0.9345102906227112,
-0.6391259431838989,
-0.33600160479545593,
0.02823949232697487,
0.6583268642425537,
1.107994556427002,
-0.6993449926376343,
-0.1031424030661583,
-0.046241216361522675,
0.359368234872818,
-0.29084452986717224,
-0.26159608364105225,
0.1448085755109787,
-0.3241370916366577,
-0.5463052988052368,
-0.10920072346925735,
0.5299202799797058,
0.07572595030069351,
-0.6176461577415466,
0.0060197897255420685,
0.07938633859157562,
0.11066564172506332,
0.9478906989097595,
-0.07919642329216003,
-0.9434332251548767,
-0.6204078793525696,
-0.052151571959257126,
0.22039318084716797,
-0.19469767808914185,
0.8565438985824585,
-1.1791629791259766,
0.7231380343437195,
0.410697340965271,
0.5898062586784363,
0.31858065724372864,
-0.1581908017396927,
0.013117916882038116,
-0.5284844636917114,
0.28511571884155273,
0.28883442282676697,
0.240130215883255,
0.13275977969169617,
-0.729049563407898,
0.555307924747467,
0.48964011669158936,
-0.23622922599315643,
-1.325348138809204,
0.5069359540939331,
-1.2748165130615234,
-0.40987566113471985,
0.9725470542907715,
-0.02854728326201439,
-0.6707655191421509,
-0.156865194439888,
-0.8000466823577881,
0.03640148416161537,
-0.31365349888801575,
0.8479467034339905,
0.649318516254425,
-0.19643913209438324,
-0.28043317794799805,
-0.6789815425872803,
0.7089260816574097,
0.04649917408823967,
-0.9491230249404907,
0.12923277914524078,
0.4641355872154236,
-0.11733710020780563,
0.5156440734863281,
0.45626580715179443,
0.21869060397148132,
-0.173256978392601,
-0.045358166098594666,
0.002179696224629879,
-0.43236932158470154,
-0.8134653568267822,
0.10359407216310501,
0.319396048784256,
-0.18680663406848907,
-0.5168917775154114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03302v1 | A Review of the Applications of Deep Learning-Based Emergent Communication | 2024-07-03T17:43:54 | 2024-07-03T17:43:54 | Brendon Boldt, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.6.m | Emergent communication, or emergent language, is the field of research which
studies how human language-like communication systems emerge de novo in deep
multi-agent reinforcement learning environments. The possibilities of
replicating the emergence of a complex behavior like language have strong
intuitive appeal, yet it is necessary to complement this with clear notions of
how such research can be applicable to other fields of science, technology, and
engineering. This paper comprehensively reviews the applications of emergent
communication research across machine learning, natural language processing,
linguistics, and cognitive science. Each application is illustrated with a
description of its scope, an explication of emergent communication's unique
role in addressing it, a summary of the extant literature working towards the
application, and brief recommendations for near-term research directions. | [
-0.3607915937900543,
-1.2271102666854858,
0.5139338970184326,
0.4643363356590271,
0.0669511929154396,
0.8316810131072998,
-0.24896056950092316,
-0.9190760850906372,
0.09368357062339783,
0.1776866614818573,
-0.3712477385997772,
-0.02000913955271244,
-0.2595458924770355,
-0.22653096914291382,
-0.6540617942810059,
0.4862513840198517,
0.23629064857959747,
-0.14659611880779266,
0.1656920313835144,
0.2325868308544159,
-0.262685090303421,
-0.34473326802253723,
-1.2896097898483276,
-0.770487368106842,
0.5328046679496765,
0.4139951467514038,
0.5573545694351196,
0.08710017800331116,
0.5561811327934265,
0.38129496574401855,
-0.2361067831516266,
0.10772747546434402,
-0.26001521944999695,
0.42318248748779297,
-0.19995619356632233,
-0.5591304302215576,
0.062113672494888306,
0.10983177274465561,
0.9810013771057129,
0.9182735681533813,
-0.10981909930706024,
-0.2541338801383972,
0.22836369276046753,
0.6685650944709778,
-0.39909735321998596,
0.023588629439473152,
-0.2327684462070465,
0.2452779859304428,
-0.11763843894004822,
-0.31077539920806885,
-0.4998622536659241,
-0.3286898732185364,
0.44471874833106995,
-0.255425363779068,
-0.0912235826253891,
-0.13875722885131836,
0.4798274338245392,
-0.07271628081798553,
-0.5606298446655273,
-0.5368674993515015,
-1.5560543537139893,
0.5926142334938049,
-0.5461024641990662,
0.34108272194862366,
-0.2526426315307617,
0.538030743598938,
-0.4441970884799957,
-0.7287603616714478,
-0.5465512871742249,
-0.16775600612163544,
0.23944580554962158,
0.25652191042900085,
-0.22866807878017426,
0.33397188782691956,
-0.3864334523677826,
0.4917728304862976,
-0.38806718587875366,
0.5353693962097168,
-0.20506499707698822,
0.19808439910411835,
0.34605783224105835,
0.14801891148090363,
0.3858441412448883,
0.40749481320381165,
-0.3578462600708008,
-0.0684683620929718,
-0.5609934329986572,
0.14882829785346985,
0.26983457803726196,
0.37010669708251953,
-0.06520967930555344,
0.2193799912929535,
-0.12688054144382477,
0.7435148358345032,
-0.049505509436130524,
0.3106173872947693,
0.17491666972637177,
-0.27964654564857483,
-0.12489301711320877,
-0.02411782369017601,
0.8564659357070923,
-0.06901665031909943,
0.024300426244735718,
-0.15495650470256805,
0.10002196580171585,
-0.12126447260379791,
0.2855392098426819,
-0.42062908411026,
-0.3391551673412323,
0.1488431841135025,
-0.5672977566719055,
-0.5885396003723145,
-0.13024118542671204,
-0.570918083190918,
-0.5369738936424255,
-0.14112588763237,
-0.012347470037639141,
-0.35893815755844116,
-0.9042866230010986,
-0.05727655813097954,
-0.17802922427654266,
0.3950076699256897,
0.18481990694999695,
-0.9496851563453674,
0.349275141954422,
0.6477519869804382,
0.7157300114631653,
0.041891910135746,
-0.5824952721595764,
-0.013739250600337982,
-0.05323520675301552,
-0.5542667508125305,
0.877030074596405,
-0.5530579686164856,
-0.1384260058403015,
0.10347669571638107,
-0.21455995738506317,
-0.09437374025583267,
-0.40663978457450867,
0.5515252351760864,
-0.7000244855880737,
-0.22969229519367218,
0.12080354243516922,
-0.3228636384010315,
-0.14917713403701782,
0.05638495087623596,
-0.6130181550979614,
0.643365740776062,
-0.08627885580062866,
-0.44569265842437744,
0.4451654851436615,
-1.0062475204467773,
-0.6833462119102478,
0.45035943388938904,
-0.06636969745159149,
-0.40125077962875366,
0.17330695688724518,
-0.1607198417186737,
0.49738526344299316,
-0.04973988980054855,
-0.0076718577183783054,
-0.061658814549446106,
-0.23539325594902039,
0.5108664631843567,
-0.4799143970012665,
0.778773844242096,
0.6884171366691589,
-0.6874143481254578,
0.06537216156721115,
-0.6353460550308228,
0.29531824588775635,
0.16116157174110413,
-0.5005108118057251,
-0.39245811104774475,
0.19702228903770447,
0.02076561562716961,
0.3172350525856018,
0.1734936386346817,
-0.5173591375350952,
-0.05788938328623772,
-0.645790696144104,
0.881607174873352,
0.436261922121048,
0.012711909599602222,
0.6594036817550659,
-0.03940807655453682,
0.16601873934268951,
0.28871262073516846,
0.06958501785993576,
-0.49144160747528076,
-0.3462506830692291,
-0.6718488335609436,
0.1002185121178627,
0.1734229177236557,
0.4994787275791168,
-0.8931175470352173,
0.21564921736717224,
0.16711151599884033,
-0.8293105363845825,
-0.9282023906707764,
-0.060277264565229416,
0.18980300426483154,
-0.16725467145442963,
0.11316405981779099,
0.02616337686777115,
-0.9843151569366455,
-0.7552397847175598,
-0.4502827227115631,
-0.2470368593931198,
0.3971101641654968,
0.33132675290107727,
0.12359422445297241,
-0.3833327889442444,
0.8228381872177124,
-0.15057280659675598,
0.15782058238983154,
-0.3263775408267975,
0.5869166851043701,
-0.005421231966465712,
0.524551272392273,
0.47231239080429077,
-0.8128368854522705,
-0.4723533093929291,
0.3172164261341095,
-0.8473943471908569,
0.5175048112869263,
-0.3206532597541809,
0.4655925929546356,
-0.017322031781077385,
0.7073396444320679,
-0.5553315877914429,
0.09266339987516403,
0.6640313863754272,
-0.15899160504341125,
0.4021897614002228,
-0.3287184238433838,
0.32492369413375854,
-0.985643208026886,
-0.1288975179195404,
-0.3118762969970703,
-0.07579600065946579,
-1.0028135776519775,
0.1519574075937271,
-0.27393588423728943,
-0.12697909772396088,
-0.49597999453544617,
0.27557921409606934,
-0.6762209534645081,
-0.12433700263500214,
-0.7794758677482605,
-0.12472237646579742,
-0.4830041229724884,
-0.09345273673534393,
0.2092435210943222,
0.608691930770874,
0.7215250730514526,
-0.8135650753974915,
0.4517481327056885,
0.021996285766363144,
-0.36959075927734375,
0.25337615609169006,
-0.552979588508606,
0.14475707709789276,
-0.003536802949383855,
0.21097366511821747,
-0.8758108615875244,
0.2059713900089264,
0.19646184146404266,
-0.6316443681716919,
0.08738771080970764,
0.0778847336769104,
-0.4796406030654907,
-0.67103511095047,
0.053533151745796204,
0.3569318652153015,
0.4201677739620209,
-0.44406285881996155,
0.0409349724650383,
0.5402197241783142,
-0.18166430294513702,
-0.40079265832901,
-0.7492467761039734,
0.5021367073059082,
-0.06215010955929756,
-0.2544171214103699,
0.024144360795617104,
-0.1743801087141037,
-0.29574641585350037,
-0.03110012412071228,
0.3636275827884674,
-0.10748211294412613,
0.6185907125473022,
0.17513519525527954,
-0.30501458048820496,
-0.44807398319244385,
0.042143821716308594,
0.036620669066905975,
0.036895282566547394,
0.33920949697494507,
-0.6320440769195557,
0.6160861253738403,
-0.6412785053253174,
-0.32613760232925415,
0.12113742530345917,
0.5725571513175964,
0.426900714635849,
-0.011987422592937946,
0.8903347253799438,
0.8483342528343201,
-0.23882897198200226,
-0.2293851673603058,
-0.33083829283714294,
-0.37385982275009155,
-0.4760361611843109,
0.2566635310649872,
-0.19291266798973083,
-1.0430412292480469,
0.25096189975738525,
-0.6570463180541992,
0.000504002848174423,
0.4216099977493286,
0.35112297534942627,
-0.3904496729373932,
0.774334728717804,
1.0630695819854736,
0.20027706027030945,
0.9424651861190796,
-0.28066486120224,
0.6530797481536865,
-0.8655678033828735,
-0.275617390871048,
-0.39427217841148376,
-0.14665821194648743,
-0.6774169206619263,
-0.15603862702846527,
0.009633522480726242,
0.047350894659757614,
-0.19238467514514923,
0.4730392396450043,
-0.3962714374065399,
0.3905731737613678,
0.48031511902809143,
-0.1935718059539795,
0.31806665658950806,
-0.16608794033527374,
-0.16557763516902924,
0.1573491245508194,
-0.8767235279083252,
-0.5995848178863525,
0.9812528491020203,
0.5035686492919922,
0.7251763343811035,
-0.01115882396697998,
0.7365214824676514,
0.5350759625434875,
0.22775140404701233,
-0.5841646790504456,
0.2959332764148712,
0.18874257802963257,
-0.5826820135116577,
-0.542428731918335,
-0.470636785030365,
-1.4798673391342163,
0.19729198515415192,
-0.29233673214912415,
-0.7478047609329224,
0.15020029246807098,
-0.13102255761623383,
-0.3380914628505707,
0.4474462568759918,
-0.7296570539474487,
0.40737974643707275,
-0.39490988850593567,
-0.03404219076037407,
-0.35005149245262146,
-0.7562853693962097,
0.2395661473274231,
0.19590164721012115,
0.2507062256336212,
0.1426311582326889,
0.18516458570957184,
0.7305805683135986,
0.41320499777793884,
1.0016634464263916,
0.12378180772066116,
-0.3070685863494873,
0.7687558531761169,
-0.21244336664676666,
0.2274150848388672,
0.018750101327896118,
0.24434985220432281,
0.07302694767713547,
-0.2415185123682022,
-0.18934319913387299,
-0.41296637058258057,
0.6412407159805298,
-0.7131999731063843,
-0.2149251401424408,
-0.5268368124961853,
-0.4117661416530609,
-0.20176322758197784,
0.540317952632904,
-0.06609293073415756,
-0.013696504756808281,
-0.7983635663986206,
0.13844521343708038,
0.9996547698974609,
-0.10970544070005417,
0.7281849384307861,
0.8187852501869202,
-0.18445834517478943,
-0.18619835376739502,
1.071892499923706,
-0.29214709997177124,
0.3857583999633789,
0.50020831823349,
0.07142895460128784,
0.0181338582187891,
-0.7945849299430847,
-0.273215651512146,
-0.14106182754039764,
-0.4644903838634491,
0.1721256673336029,
-0.829833447933197,
-0.7343422174453735,
-0.2950875759124756,
-0.1664130985736847,
-0.5050325989723206,
-0.08937010169029236,
-0.19583524763584137,
-0.1804085373878479,
0.04510379582643509,
1.1632792949676514,
-0.36090803146362305,
0.26867032051086426,
-0.6571420431137085,
-0.021715376526117325,
0.31423988938331604,
0.3876933455467224,
0.3191886842250824,
0.06199058145284653,
-0.49981704354286194,
0.41807904839515686,
-0.35501065850257874,
-0.6172878742218018,
0.15383629500865936,
0.25951912999153137,
0.8706574440002441,
0.3500383198261261,
-0.4037610590457916,
0.1735469102859497,
-0.41561949253082275,
0.7107346653938293,
0.26674991846084595,
-0.5171860456466675,
0.7236038446426392,
-0.43060818314552307,
0.2520538866519928,
0.23106636106967926,
0.40933138132095337,
-0.6881151795387268,
-0.47356274724006653,
-0.9396679997444153,
-0.909834623336792,
0.24027833342552185,
0.21607820689678192,
0.18202660977840424,
0.051214393228292465,
-0.08183524757623672,
-0.04406290501356125,
0.30042561888694763,
-0.3514833450317383,
-0.4136575162410736,
0.13288454711437225,
0.2195804864168167,
-0.45133864879608154,
-0.13200697302818298,
-0.26644566655158997,
-0.054845135658979416,
0.29275378584861755,
-0.1844576746225357,
0.4929315149784088,
0.1147979274392128,
-0.048554640263319016,
-0.15435083210468292,
0.7131808996200562,
0.7546966671943665,
0.35940882563591003,
0.04078959673643112,
0.25769516825675964,
-0.22224032878875732,
-0.5598593950271606,
0.33381175994873047,
0.03206169977784157,
-0.24202342331409454,
-0.11213551461696625,
0.1704016476869583,
0.4441092610359192,
0.28989896178245544,
-0.661835253238678,
0.0942348912358284,
-0.04586027190089226,
-0.08839601278305054,
-0.3260234594345093,
-0.19752644002437592,
0.4179333448410034,
0.48602667450904846,
0.5212868452072144,
0.4361090660095215,
0.3480227291584015,
-1.0383244752883911,
0.3697919249534607,
0.5203417539596558,
-0.7696259617805481,
-0.3011586666107178,
0.48740971088409424,
0.5828514099121094,
-0.37205833196640015,
0.5196305513381958,
-0.06597387045621872,
-0.2894324064254761,
0.5871354341506958,
0.7062397003173828,
0.9222907423973083,
-0.21767278015613556,
0.37102463841438293,
-0.09471427649259567,
0.5305447578430176,
0.20126241445541382,
0.3908914029598236,
-0.0778934508562088,
-0.7807047963142395,
-0.3221883773803711,
-0.3996068239212036,
-0.3523420989513397,
0.24294382333755493,
-0.03029950149357319,
-0.21931138634681702,
-0.4050118029117584,
-0.20178425312042236,
0.4096173346042633,
0.11203844100236893,
-0.6799039244651794,
-0.004508679267019033,
0.5640024542808533,
0.7846240997314453,
-0.9358522295951843,
0.4098806381225586,
0.974194347858429,
-0.36796706914901733,
-0.43562474846839905,
-0.24138420820236206,
-0.08403661847114563,
-0.5866138935089111,
0.6337930560112,
-0.15156808495521545,
-0.2268596589565277,
0.19960664212703705,
-0.5136210322380066,
-0.9903848171234131,
0.945429265499115,
-0.045678623020648956,
-0.23932766914367676,
0.18897704780101776,
0.10657268017530441,
0.7908377051353455,
-0.5742601752281189,
0.6456932425498962,
0.5345219969749451,
0.3555264174938202,
0.03214560076594353,
-0.9801661968231201,
-0.055114924907684326,
-0.30091843008995056,
-0.08136237412691116,
0.19072461128234863,
-0.8647202253341675,
0.5937442779541016,
-0.4655257761478424,
-0.32020696997642517,
0.13873539865016937,
1.0095477104187012,
-0.11148060858249664,
0.3806663453578949,
0.11465668678283691,
0.18259741365909576,
0.6135543584823608,
-0.0201142318546772,
0.5014578104019165,
-0.06724583357572556,
0.13410942256450653,
0.9699661135673523,
-0.11417843401432037,
0.5846872925758362,
0.2780279219150543,
-0.1097206100821495,
0.8053508996963501,
0.5674291253089905,
0.16549520194530487,
0.43221887946128845,
0.3112555146217346,
-0.3850135803222656,
0.21699048578739166,
-0.28777024149894714,
-0.272621750831604,
0.24059134721755981,
0.8818126916885376,
-0.26117974519729614,
-0.25440672039985657,
0.19496957957744598,
-0.29203885793685913,
-0.0022376382257789373,
-0.26566651463508606,
0.9235506057739258,
0.30448704957962036,
-0.39482027292251587,
0.2255164384841919,
-0.2948610186576843,
0.5439972877502441,
-0.3454500734806061,
-0.3686671853065491,
0.3102373778820038,
0.41052621603012085,
-0.25922891497612,
-1.1508303880691528,
0.27835822105407715,
-0.5975216031074524,
0.02051376923918724,
-0.4342878460884094,
1.0940757989883423,
-0.5104318857192993,
0.1413717120885849,
0.30407610535621643,
0.7602384686470032,
0.22501786053180695,
0.1122407540678978,
-1.0310605764389038,
-0.05130312219262123,
-0.5335601568222046,
-0.10475801676511765,
0.1129995584487915,
0.4890516698360443,
0.15383386611938477,
1.1366417407989502,
0.6726382970809937,
0.20853875577449799,
0.2807222902774811,
0.19835719466209412,
0.8831989169120789,
-0.7621667385101318,
-0.41813236474990845,
-0.6637575030326843,
0.38108301162719727,
-0.15178465843200684,
-0.3256721496582031,
0.8264431953430176,
0.44018641114234924,
0.6300135850906372,
0.04843515530228615,
1.0903971195220947,
-0.2555781304836273,
0.14664912223815918,
-0.2663223445415497,
0.7114901542663574,
0.19238241016864777,
0.012102661654353142,
-0.3079322576522827,
-0.6189231872558594,
0.10940607637166977,
0.060157410800457,
-0.08424699306488037,
0.18810327351093292,
0.7147163152694702,
0.046492114663124084,
0.0902966856956482,
0.12086603790521622,
0.23932835459709167,
0.23221558332443237,
0.39315903186798096,
0.5808500051498413,
1.3943618535995483,
-0.3483577370643616,
0.46053817868232727,
0.07449090480804443,
-0.2729966640472412,
-0.5001605153083801,
-0.63519287109375,
-0.8087142109870911,
-0.9042292237281799,
0.005299859214574099,
-0.14896726608276367,
0.2176050990819931,
0.6103747487068176,
0.8434200286865234,
-0.5769977569580078,
-0.2891003489494324,
-0.43090030550956726,
0.19147495925426483,
-0.9196969270706177,
-0.2817080020904541,
-0.09427700191736221,
-0.5513583421707153,
-0.42397505044937134,
0.7910184860229492,
0.3985709547996521,
0.40043389797210693,
-0.6844505071640015,
0.053642768412828445,
-0.5907097458839417,
-0.039856839925050735,
0.8139528036117554,
0.9034613370895386,
-0.31038206815719604,
-0.0013303504092618823,
0.012195467948913574,
-0.12262352555990219,
-0.0517023541033268,
1.2545466423034668,
-0.7859429121017456,
0.2892518937587738,
0.406475305557251,
0.8561763167381287,
0.38194969296455383,
-0.33900049328804016,
0.8095673322677612,
-0.45862898230552673,
0.004592006094753742,
0.5941249132156372,
-0.23459726572036743,
0.5641329884529114,
-0.47065502405166626,
0.2572547495365143,
0.1556299924850464,
-0.6525872349739075,
-0.6229988932609558,
0.6191194653511047,
-0.6224157214164734,
-0.34464070200920105,
0.9605733752250671,
0.0904761478304863,
-0.09682388603687286,
-0.6321786046028137,
0.03802429512143135,
0.28589895367622375,
-0.39641621708869934,
0.7131130695343018,
0.4911036789417267,
-0.07423704117536545,
-0.46844568848609924,
-0.6723846197128296,
0.6728094220161438,
0.2515811324119568,
-0.7657696008682251,
-0.16547457873821259,
-0.3112006187438965,
0.07923693209886551,
0.4415396749973297,
0.6840859651565552,
0.1845368891954422,
0.12417005747556686,
0.13266612589359283,
0.08259975165128708,
0.18083609640598297,
-0.45739349722862244,
-0.29322028160095215,
-0.10720930993556976,
0.28727078437805176,
-0.14742694795131683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03282v1 | LLM Internal States Reveal Hallucination Risk Faced With a Query | 2024-07-03T17:08:52 | 2024-07-03T17:08:52 | Ziwei Ji, Delong Chen, Etsuko Ishii, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Yejin Bang, Bryan Wilie, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The hallucination problem of Large Language Models (LLMs) significantly
limits their reliability and trustworthiness. Humans have a self-awareness
process that allows us to recognize what we don't know when faced with queries.
Inspired by this, our paper investigates whether LLMs can estimate their own
hallucination risk before response generation. We analyze the internal
mechanisms of LLMs broadly both in terms of training data sources and across 15
diverse Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks, spanning over 700 datasets.
Our empirical analysis reveals two key insights: (1) LLM internal states
indicate whether they have seen the query in training data or not; and (2) LLM
internal states show they are likely to hallucinate or not regarding the query.
Our study explores particular neurons, activation layers, and tokens that play
a crucial role in the LLM perception of uncertainty and hallucination risk. By
a probing estimator, we leverage LLM self-assessment, achieving an average
hallucination estimation accuracy of 84.32\% at run time. | [
-0.36135512590408325,
-0.5947229862213135,
0.8801424503326416,
-0.013494230806827545,
-0.009664085693657398,
-0.14090166985988617,
-0.2344546765089035,
-0.7192805409431458,
0.20297300815582275,
0.392234742641449,
-0.7738068699836731,
-0.2571786344051361,
-0.5203884840011597,
0.3508423864841461,
-0.36933016777038574,
0.5968111753463745,
0.21513304114341736,
0.06457417458295822,
-0.41979315876960754,
0.33960697054862976,
-0.517132580280304,
-0.7981675267219543,
-0.4961077570915222,
-0.34677237272262573,
0.423780232667923,
-0.007037240546196699,
0.3852858245372772,
0.1314316987991333,
0.3973889648914337,
0.29670974612236023,
0.011838930658996105,
0.08011306077241898,
-0.5994530916213989,
0.3898608386516571,
0.10063894838094711,
-0.8671916723251343,
-0.103465735912323,
-0.1056986078619957,
0.46144089102745056,
0.6602337956428528,
-0.11344343423843384,
0.04414256662130356,
0.21698229014873505,
0.8329896926879883,
-0.6294942498207092,
-0.12045606225728989,
-1.1791768074035645,
0.34453392028808594,
0.006543679162859917,
-0.4846676290035248,
-0.45498937368392944,
-0.324127733707428,
0.19181174039840698,
-0.0811576321721077,
0.29671987891197205,
0.09775149822235107,
0.565396785736084,
0.6960503458976746,
-0.31138402223587036,
-0.48645779490470886,
-0.6028746962547302,
0.3108254373073578,
-0.5091130137443542,
0.4748941957950592,
0.6978486180305481,
0.17510588467121124,
-0.6125983595848083,
-0.5256519317626953,
-0.5063928961753845,
-0.7168951034545898,
-0.25897136330604553,
-0.14420174062252045,
-0.035386089235544205,
0.15064336359500885,
0.2545246183872223,
0.43510690331459045,
-0.5380188226699829,
0.061767276376485825,
-0.4099128544330597,
-0.4644637405872345,
0.47280153632164,
0.18921595811843872,
0.2209814488887787,
-0.41140273213386536,
-0.4173407256603241,
0.14114651083946228,
-0.6728529334068298,
-0.11975443363189697,
0.5270914435386658,
0.2271091639995575,
0.23681534826755524,
0.8291789293289185,
0.016390077769756317,
0.4445689916610718,
0.17563678324222565,
0.1397768259048462,
0.06370402872562408,
-0.24473822116851807,
-0.39398136734962463,
0.5098443031311035,
0.9923522472381592,
0.1281740665435791,
0.26216360926628113,
-0.4977606534957886,
-0.3469635844230652,
0.025747831910848618,
0.8709067702293396,
-0.5595269203186035,
-0.0075759743340313435,
0.4890037477016449,
-0.0331193208694458,
-0.22696447372436523,
0.06091933697462082,
-0.5328530669212341,
-0.8623099327087402,
-0.13214346766471863,
0.6387218832969666,
-0.4158337712287903,
-0.26154688000679016,
0.05228547751903534,
0.2451501488685608,
0.2614068388938904,
0.1028270348906517,
-0.6694132685661316,
0.4234539270401001,
0.42578378319740295,
0.717193603515625,
-0.454106867313385,
-0.3376650810241699,
-0.37604841589927673,
-0.13747234642505646,
-0.5271512866020203,
0.8722977042198181,
0.0638691633939743,
-0.4672982394695282,
-0.13647936284542084,
0.1260886937379837,
-0.0979335829615593,
-0.6985660791397095,
0.37799015641212463,
-0.3969372808933258,
-0.15396687388420105,
-0.3347475528717041,
-0.691865861415863,
-0.24240420758724213,
0.2510661482810974,
-0.6369304060935974,
1.137238621711731,
-0.2636685073375702,
-0.9072873592376709,
0.5147165656089783,
-0.058859147131443024,
-0.2753627598285675,
-0.023841077461838722,
-0.49494239687919617,
-0.3046795725822449,
0.5934594869613647,
0.1513136625289917,
0.6050917506217957,
-0.048724669963121414,
0.18741443753242493,
-0.310153603553772,
-0.3388196527957916,
0.8408218622207642,
-0.45940694212913513,
0.5181849002838135,
-0.030642645433545113,
-0.4831184446811676,
0.34443023800849915,
-0.5451521873474121,
0.006331175100058317,
0.10989703238010406,
-0.05989975482225418,
-0.20275478065013885,
-0.008976493962109089,
-0.566461443901062,
0.25094321370124817,
0.1462884396314621,
-0.30824822187423706,
-0.04325629398226738,
-0.5502287745475769,
0.060072265565395355,
1.0497236251831055,
0.31250762939453125,
0.24061472713947296,
-0.1979026347398758,
0.44382408261299133,
0.02429906465113163,
-0.07451869547367096,
0.23471932113170624,
-0.4360968768596649,
-0.7885931730270386,
0.09529436379671097,
-0.18068429827690125,
0.3053041696548462,
-0.16999749839305878,
0.6426368951797485,
-0.030036525800824165,
-0.4047456979751587,
-0.5573928356170654,
0.0703626498579979,
0.23896850645542145,
0.4291965961456299,
0.2213842272758484,
0.0713621973991394,
-0.5175566077232361,
-0.9206539988517761,
-0.24068213999271393,
-0.29172053933143616,
-0.09070846438407898,
0.30032506585121155,
0.617647647857666,
-0.1939709186553955,
0.8095024824142456,
-0.3993408977985382,
-0.3808956444263458,
-0.15025198459625244,
0.0895053893327713,
0.0045782639645040035,
0.20092181861400604,
0.19148294627666473,
-0.3158411979675293,
-0.03962166607379913,
-0.23668713867664337,
-1.1205577850341797,
0.09941011667251587,
-0.41607940196990967,
-0.17350032925605774,
0.5196914672851562,
0.6708775758743286,
-0.664610743522644,
0.5734747648239136,
0.4700795114040375,
-0.18265296518802643,
0.6050795912742615,
-0.4309118986129761,
-0.05950260907411575,
-0.9036774635314941,
-0.24665413796901703,
-0.03953813388943672,
0.048712652176618576,
-0.45913219451904297,
-0.14068682491779327,
0.0914183035492897,
0.26776817440986633,
-0.27320390939712524,
0.5277490019798279,
-0.8034406900405884,
-0.49817386269569397,
-0.32457733154296875,
0.23991012573242188,
-0.3498627543449402,
0.36126670241355896,
0.019741129130125046,
0.8670488595962524,
0.7188466191291809,
-0.8999482989311218,
-0.02964823879301548,
-0.05758364126086235,
-0.7277784943580627,
0.21443802118301392,
-0.5177797079086304,
0.4239654242992401,
-0.20864282548427582,
0.10807527601718903,
-1.1938673257827759,
-0.34352532029151917,
0.37493079900741577,
-0.585198700428009,
0.2440701276063919,
0.19924317300319672,
-0.4358995854854584,
-0.40634849667549133,
-0.12842705845832825,
0.17057356238365173,
0.25186774134635925,
-0.5733842849731445,
0.5978320240974426,
0.4915749132633209,
0.20537805557250977,
-0.5255626440048218,
-0.8659058809280396,
0.21426646411418915,
-0.18295012414455414,
-0.49285390973091125,
0.04429933428764343,
-0.25944381952285767,
-0.3186798691749573,
-0.19412113726139069,
-0.4222885072231293,
0.0973169207572937,
0.2773702144622803,
0.8591578602790833,
0.07688284665346146,
0.09011085331439972,
0.29654961824417114,
-0.048511605709791183,
0.08440505713224411,
0.751957356929779,
-0.04059385135769844,
0.788992702960968,
-0.14880923926830292,
-0.6481571197509766,
-0.6080590486526489,
-0.011028530076146126,
0.22013255953788757,
0.03446085751056671,
0.8173009157180786,
0.32265761494636536,
-0.712945818901062,
-0.3203883469104767,
-0.6803768873214722,
-0.694955050945282,
-0.48230066895484924,
0.24640408158302307,
-0.5503915548324585,
-0.4776143729686737,
0.6037327647209167,
0.3960985839366913,
-0.39184293150901794,
0.40460410714149475,
0.7375239133834839,
-0.1688869595527649,
0.7013309597969055,
0.3296256959438324,
0.053515031933784485,
0.005799689330160618,
-0.06617069989442825,
0.21107694506645203,
-0.8443830609321594,
-0.5369517803192139,
-0.3963642418384552,
-0.2864862084388733,
-0.695665717124939,
-0.40615805983543396,
0.5426988005638123,
-0.06747755408287048,
0.04575004428625107,
0.040619369596242905,
-0.5625728964805603,
0.3157865107059479,
0.4398612082004547,
0.3843614161014557,
0.27841901779174805,
0.03294162452220917,
-0.09804791957139969,
-0.20592787861824036,
-0.2763635218143463,
-0.29274505376815796,
1.1715195178985596,
0.4196150004863739,
1.0507439374923706,
-0.00955125316977501,
0.9139795899391174,
0.12736776471138,
0.1682063639163971,
-0.9205191731452942,
0.6359459757804871,
0.6308416128158569,
-0.8304883241653442,
-0.577538013458252,
-0.45198309421539307,
-0.8729462027549744,
0.14060135185718536,
-0.3357076942920685,
-0.8871986865997314,
0.12796072661876678,
-0.054120536893606186,
-0.4508587121963501,
0.25838029384613037,
-0.40611931681632996,
0.33387860655784607,
-0.5316529273986816,
-0.3159787058830261,
-0.08075976371765137,
-0.5912178754806519,
0.6081118583679199,
-0.2524077594280243,
-0.1279771775007248,
-0.3250207006931305,
0.045848798006772995,
0.5805419683456421,
-0.003472493030130863,
1.0765351057052612,
0.06824474036693573,
-0.30514398217201233,
0.4564673900604248,
0.383312463760376,
0.6254855394363403,
0.15643693506717682,
-0.25545361638069153,
0.12931819260120392,
-0.5484305024147034,
0.17984749376773834,
-0.4567272961139679,
0.7252311110496521,
-0.6620703339576721,
-0.7702360153198242,
-0.7650662660598755,
-0.530516505241394,
-0.23524868488311768,
-0.10404976457357407,
0.6018021702766418,
-0.01994483359158039,
-0.18038560450077057,
0.1241173967719078,
0.6982679963111877,
-0.29499921202659607,
0.4100329279899597,
0.1155245378613472,
-0.3198680281639099,
-0.22146280109882355,
0.6289224624633789,
0.23626063764095306,
0.3034588396549225,
0.06821992248296738,
0.2573181092739105,
-0.6426501870155334,
-0.6707383990287781,
-0.07409167289733887,
0.3875080943107605,
-0.8227216005325317,
-0.19882887601852417,
-0.8953872323036194,
-0.5711331963539124,
-0.4161360561847687,
0.12445957213640213,
-0.35796821117401123,
-0.030056551098823547,
-0.4893445372581482,
-0.5889512300491333,
0.32666751742362976,
0.982344388961792,
-0.056682221591472626,
0.005352825857698917,
-0.4181036353111267,
0.28134140372276306,
0.5122070908546448,
0.28210824728012085,
-0.005491814576089382,
-0.6637250185012817,
0.04427717998623848,
-0.03642941266298294,
-0.007644063793122768,
-0.9628618955612183,
0.4593459963798523,
0.0082840071991086,
0.8777105212211609,
0.5081623196601868,
0.24124889075756073,
0.6012699007987976,
-0.4024503231048584,
0.8246740698814392,
0.034422531723976135,
-0.7051057815551758,
0.46100351214408875,
0.002381313592195511,
0.03547864407300949,
0.6013931035995483,
0.6477941870689392,
-0.2478492259979248,
-0.5778743624687195,
-0.3905831277370453,
-0.6455236077308655,
0.40025436878204346,
0.20183508098125458,
0.2268633395433426,
-0.38265734910964966,
0.5565115213394165,
0.19899040460586548,
0.10343561321496964,
-1.079109787940979,
-0.1812671273946762,
-0.10405908524990082,
0.2838553786277771,
0.060516249388456345,
-0.471037894487381,
-0.15210379660129547,
-0.2135041058063507,
0.4175690710544586,
-0.2187856286764145,
0.4978613555431366,
0.40330061316490173,
-0.31675317883491516,
-0.28069594502449036,
-0.006319175008684397,
0.8015685081481934,
0.5883080363273621,
-0.559444785118103,
0.3318212032318115,
0.2782902419567108,
-0.3099057972431183,
0.17889535427093506,
-0.3559741675853729,
0.12938550114631653,
-0.21095740795135498,
0.3276916444301605,
0.7818870544433594,
0.1826074719429016,
-0.6312160491943359,
0.32404014468193054,
-0.22529059648513794,
-0.2610619366168976,
-0.7748657464981079,
0.1524423360824585,
0.06237024813890457,
0.05351940542459488,
0.41006866097450256,
-0.1900026500225067,
0.1799430251121521,
-0.47828808426856995,
0.3844078481197357,
0.6893181800842285,
-0.5648606419563293,
-0.3216809034347534,
0.8314009308815002,
-0.172265887260437,
-0.31019672751426697,
0.6110514998435974,
-0.23953372240066528,
-0.41702473163604736,
0.5453940033912659,
0.7514508962631226,
1.3246313333511353,
-0.2602962851524353,
0.10976637154817581,
0.6776837110519409,
0.6761798858642578,
-0.09975480288267136,
0.2544909119606018,
0.3692863881587982,
-0.862949013710022,
-0.1738879680633545,
-0.8544635772705078,
-0.1968509554862976,
0.43191808462142944,
-0.6324669122695923,
-0.011827053502202034,
-0.27301594614982605,
-0.3866145610809326,
-0.4525046944618225,
-0.2020636647939682,
-0.5727002620697021,
0.2719278931617737,
0.42343583703041077,
0.5931726098060608,
-0.5811221599578857,
0.6917842030525208,
0.1311933845281601,
-0.2483980357646942,
-0.6287295818328857,
0.4350496828556061,
0.019177589565515518,
-0.9824632406234741,
0.7583361864089966,
0.4843841791152954,
-0.43020591139793396,
-0.21793733537197113,
-0.34688621759414673,
-0.9120863080024719,
0.8546813130378723,
0.35547730326652527,
-0.408801406621933,
-0.2695028483867645,
0.35502856969833374,
0.44985562562942505,
-0.2771594524383545,
0.06043645739555359,
0.5866182446479797,
0.33891192078590393,
0.08854542672634125,
-0.5489547848701477,
0.3532492220401764,
0.171349436044693,
-0.12946875393390656,
0.12241874635219574,
-0.1849028468132019,
0.8030270934104919,
-0.609128475189209,
-0.44209346175193787,
-0.13879147171974182,
0.8186926245689392,
0.2572591304779053,
-0.06195789575576782,
0.6451687812805176,
0.4141201078891754,
0.9446185231208801,
0.06302503496408463,
1.2014373540878296,
-0.49407824873924255,
-0.1259009838104248,
1.3592054843902588,
-0.2175762802362442,
0.8457069396972656,
0.6315814256668091,
-0.018834969028830528,
0.12056940048933029,
0.8513206243515015,
0.13375073671340942,
0.4018012583255768,
0.6152461767196655,
-0.2321474403142929,
-0.23275987803936005,
0.02088867872953415,
-0.3934021592140198,
0.531700849533081,
0.5925461053848267,
-0.3900527060031891,
0.11189944297075272,
-0.0721789002418518,
-0.13990521430969238,
-0.17181020975112915,
-0.1378023624420166,
0.9010300040245056,
0.25733110308647156,
-0.7900306582450867,
0.7020059823989868,
-0.6892871856689453,
0.5313062071800232,
-0.5053310394287109,
0.19887885451316833,
-0.3930983543395996,
-0.06047489866614342,
-0.20054061710834503,
-0.8019739389419556,
0.3051013648509979,
-0.3004712462425232,
0.18938428163528442,
0.10547464340925217,
0.6621737480163574,
-0.27362796664237976,
-0.5768151879310608,
0.6088221073150635,
0.562493622303009,
0.41162189841270447,
-0.6048095226287842,
-0.3197048306465149,
-0.027787059545516968,
-0.049519333988428116,
-0.5108763575553894,
0.5257043242454529,
0.5917393565177917,
0.1492765247821808,
0.9041025638580322,
0.47727373242378235,
0.23021671175956726,
0.5553812980651855,
-0.05878542736172676,
0.6792880892753601,
-0.7405745387077332,
-0.05692971870303154,
-0.8951847553253174,
0.3369070887565613,
0.016743693500757217,
-0.3199559450149536,
0.716567873954773,
0.3885507881641388,
0.7669962048530579,
0.0033149856608361006,
0.6694132685661316,
0.3736507296562195,
0.11994335800409317,
-0.7372704148292542,
0.9965782761573792,
-0.6490157246589661,
0.30997440218925476,
-0.03187141939997673,
-0.8735429048538208,
-0.09514167159795761,
0.6172348856925964,
-0.31299373507499695,
-0.05852360650897026,
0.808903694152832,
1.0075112581253052,
0.3553542196750641,
-0.0950491800904274,
0.5700958371162415,
0.29595106840133667,
0.08443044126033783,
0.32567599415779114,
0.9776760935783386,
-0.11525629460811615,
0.4328593909740448,
-0.5466309189796448,
0.2436441034078598,
-0.22658395767211914,
-0.8951380252838135,
-1.1100292205810547,
-0.684185802936554,
-0.03782602399587631,
-0.5350908637046814,
-0.3154292404651642,
0.8947890400886536,
0.38749006390571594,
-0.6751051545143127,
-0.4113924503326416,
-0.18309316039085388,
0.006874114274978638,
-0.026165233924984932,
-0.21220779418945312,
0.39298832416534424,
-0.632340669631958,
-0.43883979320526123,
0.6628165245056152,
0.16283677518367767,
0.30558231472969055,
-0.6077670454978943,
0.020185448229312897,
-0.13526593148708344,
0.24944323301315308,
0.37462282180786133,
-0.009605281986296177,
-1.0350316762924194,
-0.36163991689682007,
0.153489887714386,
-0.4198877513408661,
0.24900469183921814,
0.6332191228866577,
-0.7952438592910767,
0.47962167859077454,
0.29692256450653076,
0.6636284589767456,
0.4293772280216217,
-0.2742826044559479,
0.4977734088897705,
-0.7163788676261902,
0.058586668223142624,
0.2984204590320587,
0.31153276562690735,
0.26238277554512024,
-0.8084934949874878,
0.667235791683197,
-0.0321679450571537,
-0.6250166893005371,
-1.0155243873596191,
0.11748279631137848,
-0.8418553471565247,
-0.26191309094429016,
1.099524974822998,
0.27986711263656616,
-0.3504045605659485,
0.1335534155368805,
-0.026996783912181854,
0.20096859335899353,
-0.16563358902931213,
1.232020378112793,
0.71124267578125,
-0.3755103051662445,
-0.10819905996322632,
-0.9192894697189331,
0.8782216310501099,
0.18164779245853424,
-1.0506550073623657,
0.2283189445734024,
0.3746281862258911,
0.14490236341953278,
0.25244125723838806,
0.6604740619659424,
0.2282150387763977,
-0.009524769149720669,
0.09374231100082397,
0.24267879128456116,
0.22539108991622925,
-0.48387572169303894,
-0.2872595489025116,
0.1987803429365158,
0.050097979605197906,
-0.1879892349243164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03277v1 | Evaluating Automatic Metrics with Incremental Machine Translation Systems | 2024-07-03T17:04:17 | 2024-07-03T17:04:17 | Guojun Wu, Shay B. Cohen, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a dataset comprising commercial machine translations, gathered
weekly over six years across 12 translation directions. Since human A/B testing
is commonly used, we assume commercial systems improve over time, which enables
us to evaluate machine translation (MT) metrics based on their preference for
more recent translations. Our study confirms several previous findings in MT
metrics research and demonstrates the dataset's value as a testbed for metric
evaluation. We release our code at https://github.com/gjwubyron/Evo | [
-0.28500330448150635,
-0.49015143513679504,
0.47707870602607727,
0.553162693977356,
-0.2161683440208435,
0.07190559804439545,
-0.08679616451263428,
-0.5312692523002625,
-0.0867738425731659,
0.37158358097076416,
-0.7219110727310181,
-0.5468966960906982,
-0.6240294575691223,
0.7332702875137329,
-0.6059011220932007,
0.8666212558746338,
-0.42398807406425476,
0.23435603082180023,
-0.12854605913162231,
-0.6753054857254028,
-0.8942473530769348,
-0.23823854327201843,
-0.730162501335144,
-0.32519862055778503,
0.20120583474636078,
0.690062403678894,
0.7506460547447205,
0.8219135403633118,
1.0276494026184082,
0.2897513806819916,
0.3758849799633026,
0.12037258595228195,
0.013824700377881527,
0.17618735134601593,
0.02024361863732338,
-0.2832087576389313,
-0.4601781964302063,
0.11955104768276215,
0.9573988318443298,
0.6908010244369507,
-0.053417399525642395,
0.5912336111068726,
-0.2746948003768921,
0.7577884793281555,
-0.17640775442123413,
-0.0225863978266716,
-0.6848628520965576,
0.27941638231277466,
0.04581046849489212,
-0.4235285520553589,
-0.43035444617271423,
-0.6346556544303894,
0.15083079040050507,
-0.4623437523841858,
0.031925346702337265,
0.38425567746162415,
1.0383641719818115,
0.23973199725151062,
-0.5578128695487976,
-0.5073862075805664,
-0.6746644973754883,
0.9157155752182007,
-0.5424774885177612,
0.5469492673873901,
0.20373597741127014,
0.5628646612167358,
-0.1815062165260315,
-0.6271536946296692,
-0.45368725061416626,
-0.6197267174720764,
-0.03658323362469673,
0.34465938806533813,
-0.06722597032785416,
-0.36847156286239624,
0.1471995860338211,
0.6054035425186157,
-0.8084424734115601,
0.23153240978717804,
-0.4169916808605194,
-0.01751280203461647,
0.7396106123924255,
0.6652385592460632,
0.41945117712020874,
0.008005308918654919,
-0.5367630124092102,
-0.295549601316452,
-0.6960717439651489,
-0.1580761820077896,
0.39286327362060547,
-0.0769784227013588,
0.06688404083251953,
0.844711184501648,
-0.10445023328065872,
0.6778866052627563,
-0.08444461971521378,
0.21197769045829773,
0.6820886135101318,
-0.7944260239601135,
-0.42896324396133423,
-0.04120905324816704,
0.9635647535324097,
0.5565516948699951,
0.0005737126339226961,
-0.3113272488117218,
-0.47838836908340454,
0.14203199744224548,
0.5499847531318665,
-0.6180278062820435,
0.08712633699178696,
0.23685221374034882,
-0.41869261860847473,
-0.2532593905925751,
0.017832312732934952,
-0.5188265442848206,
-0.1865231692790985,
-0.5785754323005676,
0.537196695804596,
-0.5685858130455017,
0.14429837465286255,
0.061074528843164444,
-0.41201531887054443,
0.2735937535762787,
0.33991381525993347,
-0.32634249329566956,
0.30354440212249756,
0.4594232141971588,
0.9888041615486145,
-0.3911677300930023,
-0.5924050807952881,
-0.522810161113739,
-0.26215919852256775,
-0.6873753070831299,
0.7856596112251282,
-0.42529845237731934,
-0.4386793375015259,
-0.08835214376449585,
0.40265658497810364,
-0.12066246569156647,
-0.9443497657775879,
0.5886295437812805,
-0.43827345967292786,
0.39164289832115173,
0.11603458970785141,
-0.4015931487083435,
-0.24233759939670563,
0.42364558577537537,
-0.42652055621147156,
1.200084924697876,
0.3427457809448242,
-0.26757410168647766,
0.6760588884353638,
-1.0114688873291016,
-0.39639538526535034,
0.05981364846229553,
0.126020610332489,
-0.694084107875824,
0.08648642897605896,
0.09796787053346634,
0.15152907371520996,
-0.44054412841796875,
0.09162633121013641,
-0.209052175283432,
-0.3494971990585327,
0.3873155415058136,
-0.24534636735916138,
0.737438440322876,
0.6052182912826538,
-0.37343913316726685,
0.3799261152744293,
-0.7218227982521057,
-0.17650561034679413,
0.0969182476401329,
-0.3773766756057739,
-0.3120948374271393,
0.019345346838235855,
-0.06377360224723816,
0.153920978307724,
0.4211694002151489,
-0.57728111743927,
0.16740719974040985,
-0.38800498843193054,
0.47437307238578796,
0.6626094579696655,
0.008384332992136478,
0.418642520904541,
-0.2012767195701599,
0.777368426322937,
0.09738829731941223,
0.46223077178001404,
-0.39182066917419434,
-0.5411688685417175,
-0.8248578310012817,
-0.01362412516027689,
0.3211672902107239,
0.6944752931594849,
-0.5823133587837219,
0.9064099788665771,
-0.6469188928604126,
-0.2996135354042053,
-0.8218294382095337,
0.2726445496082306,
0.33464813232421875,
0.2330537587404251,
0.3877815008163452,
-0.8281997442245483,
-0.4203168749809265,
-1.1617130041122437,
-0.23688027262687683,
0.04081302881240845,
-0.248836949467659,
0.08809753507375717,
0.6395493745803833,
-0.3996078670024872,
0.581505537033081,
-0.14681825041770935,
-0.2904132604598999,
-0.1703120917081833,
0.35453081130981445,
0.23283323645591736,
0.4323868453502655,
0.5670530796051025,
-0.4101679027080536,
-0.6588374972343445,
0.3810521066188812,
-0.7216572761535645,
-0.046136800199747086,
-0.19782598316669464,
-0.2982803285121918,
0.07900579273700714,
0.2594960331916809,
-0.18574747443199158,
0.4362597167491913,
0.6925519108772278,
-0.4971809983253479,
0.3961622714996338,
-0.3996487259864807,
0.6481854915618896,
-0.8606964349746704,
0.2835788428783417,
0.05858386680483818,
-0.5029115676879883,
-0.07218585908412933,
0.12044352293014526,
0.13515429198741913,
-0.06106040999293327,
-0.3002384901046753,
0.32033902406692505,
-0.46222102642059326,
-0.45046401023864746,
-0.009071365930140018,
0.19248248636722565,
-0.017096497118473053,
0.03752439096570015,
-0.3780301809310913,
0.9162828326225281,
0.11343792825937271,
-0.730533242225647,
0.5123185515403748,
0.2527276873588562,
-0.6235954761505127,
0.7625946998596191,
-0.7221914529800415,
0.3411748707294464,
0.06684230268001556,
0.0976717472076416,
-1.2681161165237427,
-0.07869526743888855,
0.33636558055877686,
-0.7543551325798035,
0.24827389419078827,
0.03417373076081276,
-0.9045954942703247,
-0.7190396189689636,
-0.27375468611717224,
0.10944493860006332,
0.4104807376861572,
-0.43716827034950256,
0.11297184228897095,
0.47076335549354553,
-0.05229868367314339,
-0.2331172078847885,
-0.5243566036224365,
0.4164641499519348,
-0.4632347524166107,
-0.37378084659576416,
-0.06645376980304718,
-0.1528758704662323,
-0.21404492855072021,
0.02602871134877205,
0.006018529180437326,
-0.08001600950956345,
0.29726290702819824,
-0.0014905546559020877,
0.21312983334064484,
-0.052087608724832535,
0.0713558942079544,
0.16010183095932007,
-0.1778823733329773,
0.14930644631385803,
-0.6432211399078369,
0.4760842025279999,
-0.17097827792167664,
-0.1853615939617157,
-0.6242378950119019,
0.22777779400348663,
0.7306246757507324,
-0.17451603710651398,
0.6540961861610413,
0.4802538752555847,
-0.2364605963230133,
0.23678183555603027,
-0.45537710189819336,
0.24979270994663239,
-0.43682482838630676,
0.4710339605808258,
-0.5230032205581665,
-0.42273691296577454,
0.578399121761322,
0.003995267208665609,
0.35972487926483154,
0.8986349105834961,
0.6262552738189697,
-0.11035933345556259,
1.3422832489013672,
0.3912394940853119,
-0.08684790134429932,
0.5757733583450317,
-0.30994459986686707,
-0.10108082741498947,
-0.8683980107307434,
-0.17618639767169952,
-0.6458665132522583,
-0.5175103545188904,
-0.7221834063529968,
-0.16591933369636536,
0.4001275599002838,
-0.31824690103530884,
-0.4311932921409607,
0.7860782742500305,
-0.7069944739341736,
0.23005464673042297,
0.4563426673412323,
-0.01481893565505743,
0.5150557160377502,
-0.07609403878450394,
-0.22834175825119019,
-0.15600328147411346,
-0.4532323181629181,
-0.5742636919021606,
1.2181487083435059,
0.5392507910728455,
0.3783385157585144,
-0.09048163145780563,
0.27336207032203674,
0.6366831064224243,
0.9664593935012817,
-0.9711664319038391,
0.2766917645931244,
-0.22219431400299072,
-0.6643498539924622,
-0.3869665265083313,
-0.5770372152328491,
-1.205554723739624,
0.1544567197561264,
0.19688794016838074,
-0.30758389830589294,
0.00468380656093359,
0.1123141497373581,
0.04473324865102768,
-0.09355994313955307,
-0.8892369866371155,
1.0013154745101929,
-0.48579928278923035,
0.09019569307565689,
-0.3968914747238159,
-0.7172984480857849,
-0.052999481558799744,
-0.0461437813937664,
0.1925106942653656,
-0.13037674129009247,
-0.07624822109937668,
0.7062562108039856,
-0.2724693715572357,
0.3068596124649048,
-0.12700073421001434,
-0.028060246258974075,
0.19989460706710815,
0.12204308807849884,
0.3547217547893524,
-0.1599644273519516,
-0.20689992606639862,
0.23631396889686584,
-0.003608414903283119,
-0.37551969289779663,
-0.407166987657547,
0.688906192779541,
-0.6660506725311279,
-0.0859317034482956,
-0.40371236205101013,
-0.6349809169769287,
-0.012232224456965923,
0.18412615358829498,
0.18343880772590637,
0.22472836077213287,
-0.29943200945854187,
0.21784895658493042,
0.20924489200115204,
-0.40366294980049133,
0.1888662874698639,
0.7228218913078308,
-0.39124777913093567,
-0.8053684830665588,
0.7234207391738892,
0.14144183695316315,
0.32289251685142517,
0.4364418685436249,
0.1909409761428833,
-0.4755454957485199,
-0.5450432896614075,
-1.2184216976165771,
0.12218358367681503,
-0.566071629524231,
-0.18516573309898376,
-0.4066154360771179,
0.23357388377189636,
-0.34979090094566345,
-0.02739032357931137,
-0.5228016376495361,
-0.4494962692260742,
0.2340143769979477,
-0.11297497898340225,
0.3258923292160034,
1.025675654411316,
0.2209634631872177,
0.21344496309757233,
-0.9715367555618286,
-0.0033086868934333324,
-0.3110855221748352,
0.2584575414657593,
-0.3248943090438843,
-0.8692531585693359,
-0.6062542796134949,
0.03538409620523453,
-0.515587329864502,
-0.7318774461746216,
0.6891781091690063,
-0.08576797693967819,
0.5694469213485718,
0.08233053237199783,
-0.3920131027698517,
0.8517641425132751,
-0.8059533834457397,
0.824339747428894,
0.3270164728164673,
-1.0025599002838135,
0.7160232067108154,
-0.24009469151496887,
0.5564522743225098,
0.7864868640899658,
0.4624222218990326,
-0.6308149099349976,
-0.5552523136138916,
-0.5186563730239868,
-0.9921751022338867,
0.3745996356010437,
0.1885935366153717,
-0.028497133404016495,
0.13496899604797363,
0.4931641221046448,
0.4118310511112213,
0.4665725827217102,
-0.26824790239334106,
-0.353030264377594,
0.07357729226350784,
-0.3820017874240875,
-0.4324699938297272,
0.18970321118831635,
-0.15765123069286346,
-0.44715607166290283,
0.4734189510345459,
0.023451989516615868,
0.46730926632881165,
0.10944182425737381,
-0.3060489892959595,
-0.3005216717720032,
0.163038969039917,
0.5071892738342285,
0.9196805357933044,
-0.34103938937187195,
-0.18108303844928741,
0.3768823742866516,
-0.511566698551178,
0.34783756732940674,
0.021045085042715073,
-0.18735575675964355,
0.2887905538082123,
0.04993801563978195,
0.7866577506065369,
-0.08993791788816452,
-0.3535057306289673,
0.27675125002861023,
-0.005408830009400845,
-0.21974174678325653,
-0.6602469086647034,
-0.32102978229522705,
-0.28225454688072205,
-0.14330610632896423,
0.19832193851470947,
0.07459839433431625,
0.4160287380218506,
-0.6457439064979553,
0.31294527649879456,
0.1493663191795349,
-0.7718780636787415,
-0.5871168375015259,
0.6825333833694458,
0.31102055311203003,
-0.35680750012397766,
0.7188369631767273,
-0.34283018112182617,
-0.4713413715362549,
0.7420271039009094,
0.41399312019348145,
1.1675293445587158,
-0.37106087803840637,
-0.03485621139407158,
0.47427207231521606,
0.7307033538818359,
-0.1001797541975975,
0.18007856607437134,
0.08568006753921509,
-0.37429264187812805,
-0.4532139301300049,
-0.5927929878234863,
-0.5264734029769897,
0.11061909049749374,
-0.6521191000938416,
0.47342193126678467,
-0.1480293571949005,
-0.3381683826446533,
-0.21716202795505524,
0.16983404755592346,
-1.1478662490844727,
0.45225346088409424,
-0.18360444903373718,
0.9050028920173645,
-0.892593502998352,
0.7176869511604309,
1.237151861190796,
-0.44278639554977417,
-0.1588967889547348,
-0.246834397315979,
-0.10904961824417114,
-0.9281921982765198,
0.8144875764846802,
0.2715942859649658,
-0.2256079614162445,
0.1402500420808792,
-0.37146979570388794,
-0.6487035751342773,
1.3088736534118652,
0.0064880577847361565,
-0.5764706134796143,
0.39408189058303833,
0.18050284683704376,
0.7352445721626282,
-0.41264471411705017,
0.2586449682712555,
0.7297091484069824,
0.657355785369873,
-0.19199764728546143,
-1.2279926538467407,
-0.06996853649616241,
-0.3108038306236267,
0.04365339130163193,
0.4751354455947876,
-0.5383388996124268,
0.3222520053386688,
0.10260370373725891,
-0.34809181094169617,
0.16397377848625183,
0.47485801577568054,
-0.2539409399032593,
0.605082631111145,
0.6781312227249146,
0.8051198124885559,
0.5732617378234863,
-0.10492681711912155,
1.3614052534103394,
-0.33125919103622437,
0.377021461725235,
1.0807080268859863,
-0.0780835822224617,
0.7737640142440796,
0.4316866993904114,
-0.4743025600910187,
0.3734891712665558,
0.8284001350402832,
-0.14319729804992676,
0.46588030457496643,
0.24372662603855133,
0.1059010699391365,
-0.05439062789082527,
-0.002325605135411024,
-0.3731827735900879,
0.06200447678565979,
0.4717765152454376,
-0.5589187145233154,
0.02979610487818718,
-0.04225647822022438,
-0.03715904802083969,
-0.19435064494609833,
0.027868375182151794,
0.7025699615478516,
0.08683143556118011,
-0.7687039971351624,
0.4987451732158661,
0.03112703002989292,
0.33305445313453674,
-0.5887590050697327,
0.1172657161951065,
-0.30709108710289,
0.5036911964416504,
0.000028166345146019012,
-0.8329675197601318,
0.5974608659744263,
0.0066725644282996655,
0.08732280135154724,
-0.5169928073883057,
0.12471658736467361,
-0.2570716142654419,
-0.601857602596283,
0.29429924488067627,
0.3455604910850525,
0.29083532094955444,
0.17513367533683777,
-0.830558180809021,
0.023352261632680893,
-0.1335681527853012,
-0.2039986550807953,
0.27502986788749695,
0.6266369223594666,
-0.0706004723906517,
0.7910928726196289,
0.5491313934326172,
0.002247792901471257,
0.1734675019979477,
0.13336066901683807,
0.5755429267883301,
-0.7776694893836975,
-0.22089950740337372,
-0.7684091329574585,
0.48538830876350403,
-0.07150350511074066,
-0.6446883678436279,
1.2411478757858276,
0.9345923662185669,
0.9934640526771545,
-0.03409799933433533,
0.8537570238113403,
-0.0418487973511219,
0.465518981218338,
-0.28708943724632263,
0.3988838493824005,
-0.7369493842124939,
0.2304365634918213,
0.05153590813279152,
-0.9751005172729492,
-0.44434207677841187,
0.47617363929748535,
-0.34270045161247253,
-0.4684380888938904,
0.890553891658783,
0.4493354558944702,
0.09162914007902145,
-0.13953101634979248,
0.16009286046028137,
0.1616639494895935,
0.2787170112133026,
0.13820625841617584,
1.05624258518219,
-0.8089267611503601,
0.5651500225067139,
-0.07216952741146088,
-0.2734453082084656,
-0.22326421737670898,
-0.7767583131790161,
-0.503139078617096,
-0.3781231939792633,
-0.3846460282802582,
-0.48732173442840576,
0.22562649846076965,
0.9641610383987427,
0.27980488538742065,
-1.0367348194122314,
-0.6542341709136963,
-0.0900397077202797,
-0.0918140634894371,
-0.5398306250572205,
-0.27825459837913513,
0.11313624680042267,
-0.689815104007721,
-1.071974515914917,
0.37430888414382935,
0.5078610181808472,
-0.12032099813222885,
-0.406645804643631,
-0.05055847764015198,
-0.04647129774093628,
-0.08187196403741837,
0.6850665807723999,
-0.08180639147758484,
-0.26040390133857727,
-0.4442971348762512,
0.36311066150665283,
-0.15727779269218445,
0.38374805450439453,
0.8020723462104797,
-0.46592074632644653,
0.7136167287826538,
0.681763231754303,
0.5879183411598206,
0.3631364703178406,
0.037726424634456635,
1.0077776908874512,
-0.3794306516647339,
0.001984247239306569,
0.07627590745687485,
0.27794361114501953,
0.4645119905471802,
-0.1831851750612259,
0.810122549533844,
0.35277989506721497,
-0.8345336318016052,
-0.7301061749458313,
0.04332682117819786,
-0.6499264240264893,
0.2031169980764389,
0.9943732023239136,
-0.35389524698257446,
-0.152472585439682,
-0.16821065545082092,
0.0178730059415102,
0.14070384204387665,
-0.32457152009010315,
0.9266951084136963,
0.7332468032836914,
-0.05957036837935448,
0.3998812437057495,
-0.9896558523178101,
0.08070629835128784,
0.3004688620567322,
-0.9056459069252014,
-0.39497724175453186,
0.5128814578056335,
0.34495916962623596,
0.16751722991466522,
0.5278128385543823,
-0.5684065818786621,
0.10969603061676025,
-0.0019299741834402084,
0.13440459966659546,
0.31523823738098145,
-0.3967478573322296,
-0.3817582130432129,
-0.42005643248558044,
0.10054557770490646,
-0.634391725063324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03255v1 | How Similar Are Elected Politicians and Their Constituents? Quantitative Evidence From Online Social Network | 2024-07-03T16:36:26 | 2024-07-03T16:36:26 | Waleed Iqbal, Gareth Tyson, Ignacio Castro | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | How similar are politicians to those who vote for them? This is a critical
question at the heart of democratic representation and particularly relevant at
times when political dissatisfaction and populism are on the rise. To answer
this question we compare the online discourse of elected politicians and their
constituents. We collect a two and a half years (September 2020 - February
2023) constituency-level dataset for USA and UK that includes: (i) the Twitter
timelines (5.6 Million tweets) of elected political representatives (595 UK
Members of Parliament and 433 USA Representatives), (ii) the Nextdoor posts
(21.8 Million posts) of the constituency (98.4% USA and 91.5% UK
constituencies). We find that elected politicians tend to be equally similar to
their constituents in terms of content and style regardless of whether a
constituency elects a right or left-wing politician. The size of the electoral
victory and the level of income of a constituency shows a nuanced picture. The
narrower the electoral victory, the more similar the style and the more
dissimilar the content is. The lower the income of a constituency, the more
similar the content is. In terms of style, poorer constituencies tend to have a
more similar sentiment and more dissimilar psychological text traits (i.e.
measured with LIWC categories). | [
-0.6456020474433899,
-0.08866006135940552,
0.6980636119842529,
0.03601882606744766,
-0.3763067424297333,
0.4749225676059723,
-0.20233651995658875,
-0.3163868188858032,
0.7776467800140381,
0.4797731935977936,
-0.3080277144908905,
-0.2439192682504654,
-0.5807973742485046,
0.11904576420783997,
-0.19651931524276733,
0.5095033049583435,
0.6449043154716492,
0.26197463274002075,
-0.32005298137664795,
-0.21092510223388672,
0.07696934044361115,
-0.5983145236968994,
-0.34318169951438904,
-0.3622856140136719,
0.6559239625930786,
-0.009519274346530437,
0.6679510474205017,
0.3391416072845459,
0.3529132008552551,
0.35175052285194397,
0.13727083802223206,
-0.25152552127838135,
-1.1223671436309814,
-0.04865359887480736,
-0.4529728293418884,
-0.3674834966659546,
0.024879759177565575,
0.2526606619358063,
0.25804656744003296,
0.8004283308982849,
0.29597896337509155,
-0.06157783418893814,
0.42760562896728516,
0.8286029100418091,
-0.775050699710846,
0.23472939431667328,
-0.891188383102417,
-0.219528928399086,
-0.1307743638753891,
-0.45258828997612,
-0.26015010476112366,
-1.1875519752502441,
-0.11072510480880737,
-0.2621283531188965,
0.22047556936740875,
-0.1363312155008316,
0.9075102806091309,
-0.2682560682296753,
-0.6716828942298889,
-0.3166861832141876,
-0.31876569986343384,
0.45959481596946716,
-0.5995868444442749,
0.3092752695083618,
0.13375379145145416,
0.3856678605079651,
-0.05437801778316498,
-0.6305745840072632,
-0.4660147726535797,
-0.1948111653327942,
-0.1727120578289032,
0.39906084537506104,
-0.1839102804660797,
-0.04194983094930649,
-0.010473441332578659,
0.25954410433769226,
-0.5882189273834229,
-0.07276853173971176,
-0.37416309118270874,
-0.28339600563049316,
0.5124655961990356,
0.0004405031504575163,
0.0528164878487587,
-0.5645451545715332,
-0.5401706695556641,
-0.18606442213058472,
-0.7864381670951843,
0.2329254150390625,
0.8799696564674377,
0.6461440920829773,
-0.014635401777923107,
0.45032840967178345,
0.013990726321935654,
0.49692031741142273,
0.20256641507148743,
0.21653766930103302,
0.018284540623426437,
-0.414559543132782,
0.43815767765045166,
0.12008234858512878,
1.0401402711868286,
0.7039478421211243,
0.7222617864608765,
0.00046415621181949973,
0.01492287777364254,
0.20773974061012268,
0.09741460531949997,
-0.7607696056365967,
-0.06769086420536041,
0.12629860639572144,
-0.7277404069900513,
-0.0162454042583704,
0.7058151960372925,
-0.4276507794857025,
-0.8761157989501953,
-0.1992800384759903,
0.16237588226795197,
-0.05848776549100876,
-0.41932278871536255,
-0.5550760626792908,
-0.26751208305358887,
0.22500860691070557,
0.20000134408473969,
-0.7138208150863647,
0.1926601529121399,
1.2301779985427856,
0.9541366696357727,
-0.16470889747142792,
0.06903744488954544,
-0.39244091510772705,
-0.14242011308670044,
-0.6454775929450989,
0.8625850677490234,
-0.631624162197113,
-0.13599544763565063,
0.1790289729833603,
-0.0699719786643982,
0.007476411759853363,
-0.9174383878707886,
-0.2989172339439392,
-0.48726046085357666,
0.18926069140434265,
-0.6772440075874329,
-0.6987374424934387,
0.2683517634868622,
0.1845940351486206,
-0.8823081851005554,
0.4969824552536011,
0.2998042702674866,
-0.6918912529945374,
0.7101148962974548,
-0.30214598774909973,
0.056554507464170456,
-0.22370478510856628,
-0.3941691517829895,
-0.06029423326253891,
0.3126235902309418,
-0.13455785810947418,
0.7741772532463074,
0.08949065953493118,
0.06010473519563675,
-0.7990415096282959,
-0.39309990406036377,
0.6132444143295288,
-0.001117986161261797,
0.9585592150688171,
-0.008255019783973694,
-0.1535889059305191,
0.053295474499464035,
-0.6676850914955139,
-0.1770397573709488,
-0.36293596029281616,
0.18941758573055267,
-0.27294138073921204,
0.008303998969495296,
0.09562891721725464,
0.42963850498199463,
0.1722201257944107,
-0.9187743067741394,
0.12759847939014435,
-0.39928901195526123,
0.8787627220153809,
0.8973389863967896,
0.38934868574142456,
0.4584674537181854,
-0.562457799911499,
0.3151831030845642,
0.03014659322798252,
-0.046384844928979874,
0.2958783209323883,
-0.649965226650238,
-0.10597730427980423,
-0.11474976688623428,
0.6154911518096924,
0.28589221835136414,
-0.2149655818939209,
0.1829262375831604,
-0.6083791851997375,
-0.43033140897750854,
-0.41494429111480713,
-0.4621126353740692,
-0.22277383506298065,
0.007527738809585571,
-0.21513141691684723,
-0.34088134765625,
-0.2992934286594391,
-0.9731951355934143,
-0.8011401295661926,
-0.6520524024963379,
-0.24065692722797394,
0.4079015552997589,
0.6076868772506714,
0.22842995822429657,
1.0437320470809937,
-0.1389022171497345,
-0.048414260149002075,
0.09608190506696701,
0.16228334605693817,
0.07575124502182007,
0.13089841604232788,
0.548382043838501,
-0.6327641010284424,
-0.5715433359146118,
0.3341084122657776,
-0.26834923028945923,
-0.09236479550600052,
-0.06612692028284073,
0.05350901558995247,
-0.021989425644278526,
0.3012795150279999,
-0.17904381453990936,
0.380000501871109,
0.40371567010879517,
-0.43028321862220764,
-0.007289024069905281,
0.1810753047466278,
0.5067724585533142,
-1.3631213903427124,
0.054586756974458694,
-0.11598847061395645,
-0.5878042578697205,
-0.25661617517471313,
0.030286327004432678,
-0.12517161667346954,
-0.022688908502459526,
-0.34892597794532776,
0.3395250737667084,
-0.4286459982395172,
-0.5504178404808044,
0.02146189659833908,
0.2694712281227112,
-0.1509428769350052,
-0.05722683668136597,
-0.3481076657772064,
0.8141795992851257,
0.2800603210926056,
0.026387466117739677,
0.521757185459137,
-0.17837657034397125,
-0.793580949306488,
0.8277561664581299,
-0.535954475402832,
0.2354540228843689,
-0.15142756700515747,
0.22433502972126007,
-1.4656003713607788,
-0.440460205078125,
0.04766099154949188,
-0.5835373997688293,
-0.07686218619346619,
-0.08428540080785751,
-0.3333961069583893,
-0.360983669757843,
-0.3347759544849396,
-0.11478418856859207,
0.49266886711120605,
-0.2061551958322525,
0.565430760383606,
0.5813794732093811,
-0.3972349464893341,
-0.24045872688293457,
-0.6419814229011536,
0.16734318435192108,
-0.3248389959335327,
-0.5112397074699402,
0.3096809387207031,
0.5132877826690674,
-0.6654351949691772,
0.42171475291252136,
0.0996861532330513,
-0.2572267949581146,
-0.39159372448921204,
0.29229000210762024,
-0.3105418086051941,
-0.18964940309524536,
0.023310499265789986,
-0.463886559009552,
-0.027291791513562202,
0.04793925583362579,
0.022407924756407738,
0.5547825694084167,
0.052634794265031815,
-0.2611629068851471,
-0.47481101751327515,
0.577229380607605,
0.4696979820728302,
0.04380304366350174,
0.873179018497467,
0.39992555975914,
-0.1963520646095276,
0.15350624918937683,
-0.48299118876457214,
-0.4117024838924408,
-0.4424711763858795,
0.19807541370391846,
-0.34828123450279236,
-0.8429273366928101,
1.0605548620224,
0.21304258704185486,
0.33528101444244385,
0.6453084945678711,
0.5218270421028137,
-0.19696685671806335,
0.6872676014900208,
0.2053040862083435,
-0.008590987883508205,
0.3205074369907379,
-0.30921900272369385,
0.17106610536575317,
-0.12477343529462814,
-0.4061979353427887,
-0.7195912003517151,
-0.6301779747009277,
-1.0268803834915161,
-0.2592083513736725,
0.040623437613248825,
-0.10495877265930176,
-0.38801005482673645,
0.3635527789592743,
-0.6345334053039551,
0.3895314335823059,
0.46157029271125793,
0.1507285237312317,
-0.17581163346767426,
0.2615601420402527,
0.3959480822086334,
-0.38859567046165466,
-0.43761342763900757,
-0.38476213812828064,
0.9011971950531006,
-0.1337675154209137,
0.4600430727005005,
0.22713634371757507,
0.8512766361236572,
0.5368703603744507,
0.4215390086174011,
-0.5666453838348389,
0.42149272561073303,
-0.028384840115904808,
-0.5207578539848328,
-0.027550362050533295,
-0.7504379749298096,
-1.1631442308425903,
0.11738427728414536,
-0.23904523253440857,
-0.7294895648956299,
0.5857172012329102,
0.017877301201224327,
-0.2515527904033661,
0.73456871509552,
-0.21914958953857422,
0.6525187492370605,
0.06886053085327148,
-0.3776434361934662,
-0.27889183163642883,
-0.8897107243537903,
-0.13403421640396118,
0.19046053290367126,
0.212962344288826,
-0.29024094343185425,
-0.0734507218003273,
0.8842828869819641,
-0.5438680052757263,
0.49949702620506287,
-0.2586212456226349,
0.24833530187606812,
0.3667990565299988,
-0.3087945878505707,
0.2706223130226135,
-0.34945061802864075,
-0.23569878935813904,
0.10141848772764206,
0.36758124828338623,
-0.5922629833221436,
-0.749756932258606,
0.9099224209785461,
-1.0363823175430298,
-0.46333304047584534,
-0.6020971536636353,
-0.15532828867435455,
0.06412101536989212,
-0.03537869453430176,
0.463990718126297,
0.7861169576644897,
-0.5947651267051697,
0.7091132402420044,
-0.06312363594770432,
0.45383575558662415,
0.5815458297729492,
-0.233497753739357,
-0.1513657122850418,
-0.6588153839111328,
1.0166704654693604,
0.599092423915863,
0.36082351207733154,
0.5945079922676086,
0.38450273871421814,
-0.625993013381958,
0.028363119810819626,
-0.12760889530181885,
0.12725897133350372,
-0.44498226046562195,
-0.09489826112985611,
-0.5456423163414001,
-0.028871575370430946,
-0.4468914866447449,
-0.2278965264558792,
-0.3356590270996094,
-0.582979142665863,
-0.3508763015270233,
0.2132255584001541,
0.24670985341072083,
1.3368970155715942,
-0.18658801913261414,
0.21898439526557922,
-0.15986308455467224,
0.027063103392720222,
0.6396431922912598,
0.2980952858924866,
-0.13913992047309875,
-0.373855322599411,
0.1662030816078186,
0.17584547400474548,
-0.46455249190330505,
-1.5399668216705322,
-0.23363755643367767,
0.456380695104599,
0.274042010307312,
1.0497759580612183,
0.32356420159339905,
0.709575891494751,
-0.19780422747135162,
1.1278355121612549,
0.27588891983032227,
-0.5203381776809692,
0.06051212549209595,
-0.3776599168777466,
-0.030759433284401894,
0.9460907578468323,
0.5429111123085022,
-0.2401479184627533,
-0.4111289083957672,
-0.7192884087562561,
-0.5037004351615906,
0.24196362495422363,
0.37044450640678406,
0.3211025297641754,
0.006241948343813419,
0.2125435769557953,
0.21862681210041046,
0.3342941105365753,
-0.5886236429214478,
-0.22197368741035461,
-0.4510324001312256,
-0.03575941175222397,
-0.047722358256578445,
-0.10597606003284454,
0.06579135358333588,
-0.014314509928226471,
0.03763962909579277,
-0.07826855778694153,
0.44133609533309937,
0.05063038691878319,
0.5834071636199951,
-0.07455653697252274,
0.26557594537734985,
0.2586180567741394,
1.2560945749282837,
-0.4524771571159363,
0.17469806969165802,
-0.21502375602722168,
-0.2221994698047638,
0.2670935094356537,
-0.2927090525627136,
0.15971457958221436,
0.2615717053413391,
0.7323064208030701,
0.5266426205635071,
-0.1022452637553215,
-0.08070852607488632,
0.7476863861083984,
0.037941720336675644,
-0.35383516550064087,
-0.20463669300079346,
-0.22050821781158447,
0.581637978553772,
-0.033704567700624466,
0.5647506713867188,
0.2395235151052475,
0.0062489998526871204,
-1.3809224367141724,
0.14522458612918854,
0.7129186391830444,
-0.720220685005188,
-0.5614018440246582,
0.4645933508872986,
0.4353178143501282,
-0.8867435455322266,
0.07990050315856934,
-0.31275662779808044,
-0.5876330733299255,
0.6848998665809631,
0.3427172005176544,
0.5414189696311951,
-0.14484697580337524,
0.24078048765659332,
0.25974079966545105,
0.10809571295976639,
0.32102444767951965,
0.32009050250053406,
0.2447035014629364,
-0.41195350885391235,
0.06325334310531616,
-0.3454735577106476,
-0.2773556709289551,
0.15124908089637756,
-0.8778392672538757,
-0.03491942584514618,
-0.5238474607467651,
-0.6770865321159363,
0.12176626920700073,
0.5169587135314941,
-0.5447171330451965,
0.05802415683865547,
-0.3298761248588562,
0.5261706113815308,
-1.1180428266525269,
0.02281424216926098,
0.6333895325660706,
-0.0007871914422139525,
-0.8180102705955505,
0.3015514314174652,
-0.11077762395143509,
-0.45694026350975037,
0.07907029986381531,
0.4356014132499695,
0.13665728271007538,
-0.25645971298217773,
-0.2132432758808136,
-0.3495914340019226,
0.6711139678955078,
0.7079362273216248,
-0.8205094337463379,
-0.10650304704904556,
0.45003268122673035,
0.449494332075119,
-0.6470130085945129,
0.6227997541427612,
0.12419654428958893,
0.36211177706718445,
0.03497453033924103,
-0.6256715059280396,
-0.1256542205810547,
0.008990947157144547,
-0.07955090701580048,
0.289748877286911,
-0.9450095891952515,
0.8519061207771301,
0.15684787929058075,
-0.4450106620788574,
-0.1109044998884201,
0.6220479607582092,
0.06254911422729492,
0.41209590435028076,
0.6946314573287964,
0.1771276891231537,
0.581908106803894,
-0.21749460697174072,
0.999129056930542,
-0.7740015387535095,
0.1830885112285614,
0.6890265941619873,
-0.3137056827545166,
0.8762566447257996,
0.5908237099647522,
-0.46890783309936523,
0.6830624938011169,
0.7368608117103577,
0.25558343529701233,
0.6552858352661133,
0.3445223271846771,
-0.01763816736638546,
-0.3309079706668854,
-0.29279080033302307,
-0.5775485634803772,
0.42412492632865906,
-0.004914243705570698,
-0.2628440856933594,
-0.09790206700563431,
-0.15143446624279022,
-0.21931304037570953,
0.6817154884338379,
-0.3418358564376831,
0.932889997959137,
0.3171365559101105,
-0.5490034818649292,
0.07913849502801895,
-0.6781196594238281,
0.04344889521598816,
-0.28664135932922363,
0.0013040780322626233,
-0.20014998316764832,
-0.08636268228292465,
-0.14741003513336182,
-1.2407844066619873,
0.3019002377986908,
-0.11155260354280472,
0.0048210350796580315,
-0.10771104693412781,
0.38066914677619934,
-0.17736178636550903,
-0.48599153757095337,
0.5275222659111023,
0.6709043979644775,
0.3133699595928192,
-0.24208073318004608,
-0.6565744876861572,
0.16001355648040771,
0.03607947751879692,
-0.3471701145172119,
0.06517358124256134,
0.39220747351646423,
0.2025061398744583,
0.5062447190284729,
0.3636762499809265,
0.6881347894668579,
-0.026272350922226906,
0.1848994642496109,
0.9670541286468506,
-0.36370551586151123,
-0.6077653169631958,
-0.6651010513305664,
0.2815019488334656,
-0.6609349250793457,
-0.6683417558670044,
0.6749005913734436,
0.8006247878074646,
0.8651931285858154,
0.08820084482431412,
0.5328536629676819,
-0.20610614120960236,
0.649469792842865,
-0.14609672129154205,
0.941020667552948,
-0.6667073369026184,
-0.2018103152513504,
-0.09414641559123993,
-1.3889403343200684,
0.20156079530715942,
0.7027462720870972,
-0.45809635519981384,
0.2651817500591278,
0.41675108671188354,
1.0214312076568604,
-0.5078098177909851,
-0.1290341466665268,
0.32446327805519104,
0.07018478959798813,
-0.07919148355722427,
0.21635708212852478,
1.127643346786499,
-0.026214690878987312,
0.44167566299438477,
-0.09042631834745407,
0.18006576597690582,
-0.25494125485420227,
-0.5343464612960815,
-1.0659793615341187,
-0.8407496213912964,
-0.2635915279388428,
-0.5309420228004456,
0.29515761137008667,
1.0459657907485962,
0.8645484447479248,
-0.9024691581726074,
-0.2908640205860138,
0.11919380724430084,
-0.09006939828395844,
0.05228592827916145,
-0.28647714853286743,
0.40263429284095764,
0.4526931047439575,
-0.592953622341156,
-0.31777456402778625,
0.2457849532365799,
-0.45509347319602966,
-0.37094712257385254,
0.1711435317993164,
0.07587207108736038,
0.2934628129005432,
0.307526558637619,
-0.07630161941051483,
-1.0955215692520142,
-0.6022982597351074,
-0.14020788669586182,
-0.5264424681663513,
0.3343141973018646,
0.8919641375541687,
-0.7182292342185974,
0.4265997111797333,
0.9702739119529724,
0.0729115828871727,
0.3106823265552521,
0.6203104853630066,
0.3686561584472656,
-0.5209230780601501,
-0.018477587029337883,
0.3588718771934509,
0.015412825159728527,
0.67240971326828,
-0.0702584907412529,
0.4729810655117035,
0.260547012090683,
-0.5890040397644043,
-0.6806554198265076,
0.3926355540752411,
-1.0594745874404907,
-0.08102373033761978,
0.8090435266494751,
-0.2160366177558899,
0.013307887129485607,
-0.06992022693157196,
-0.027206681668758392,
0.23986394703388214,
-0.6055777072906494,
0.648522675037384,
0.40880826115608215,
0.012004435993731022,
-0.3327420651912689,
-0.2363739013671875,
0.24697022140026093,
-0.1583675742149353,
-0.5972815155982971,
-0.1762617528438568,
0.07341877371072769,
0.17490698397159576,
0.2402947098016739,
0.7054660320281982,
0.25726038217544556,
0.10948407649993896,
0.3151800334453583,
-0.5413033366203308,
0.19826574623584747,
-0.3195746839046478,
-0.0013474002480506897,
0.6015052199363708,
-0.3636336028575897,
-0.04827059805393219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03253v1 | STF: Sentence Transformer Fine-Tuning For Topic Categorization With Limited Data | 2024-07-03T16:34:56 | 2024-07-03T16:34:56 | Kheir Eddine Daouadi, Yaakoub Boualleg, Oussama Guehairia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nowadays, topic classification from tweets attracts considerable research
attention. Different classification systems have been suggested thanks to these
research efforts. Nevertheless, they face major challenges owing to low
performance metrics due to the limited amount of labeled data. We propose
Sentence Transformers Fine-tuning (STF), a topic detection system that
leverages pretrained Sentence Transformers models and fine-tuning to classify
topics from tweets accurately. Moreover, extensive parameter sensitivity
analyses were conducted to finetune STF parameters for our topic classification
task to achieve the best performance results. Experiments on two benchmark
datasets demonstrated that (1) the proposed STF can be effectively used for
classifying tweet topics and outperforms the latest state-of-the-art
approaches, and (2) the proposed STF does not require a huge amount of labeled
tweets to achieve good accuracy, which is a limitation of many state-of-the-art
approaches. Our main contribution is the achievement of promising results in
tweet topic classification by applying pretrained sentence transformers
language models. | [
-0.6572138667106628,
-0.9692801237106323,
0.31943854689598083,
0.3296205401420593,
-0.6156795620918274,
0.172478586435318,
-0.4535619020462036,
-0.05700189247727394,
0.29671239852905273,
0.5681685209274292,
-0.7545048594474792,
-0.3828320801258087,
-0.9313422441482544,
0.02186185121536255,
-0.5763371586799622,
1.2262765169143677,
-0.10261662304401398,
-0.33547839522361755,
0.10564034432172775,
0.059888847172260284,
-0.6365662217140198,
-0.011413922533392906,
-0.5692377090454102,
-0.09644230455160141,
0.4264187812805176,
0.8978399634361267,
0.5616581439971924,
0.5132930874824524,
0.6987881660461426,
0.24131949245929718,
0.05746056139469147,
0.21325166523456573,
-0.6232462525367737,
0.07765451073646545,
-0.3257489800453186,
-0.2237793505191803,
-0.07907360792160034,
-0.08458174020051956,
0.46497616171836853,
0.463612824678421,
-0.12380078434944153,
0.1837722808122635,
-0.03278617560863495,
0.29581305384635925,
-0.3722682595252991,
-0.019078588113188744,
-0.7268761396408081,
0.13115613162517548,
-0.2863158881664276,
-0.6361382007598877,
-0.26401495933532715,
-0.2756763696670532,
0.17765551805496216,
-0.2485744208097458,
0.7197754979133606,
0.12370381504297256,
1.2884324789047241,
0.47035667300224304,
-0.5016336441040039,
-0.04478767141699791,
-0.7247259020805359,
0.6651633977890015,
-0.2991168797016144,
0.22885581851005554,
0.2294319123029709,
0.3592219054698944,
0.053547441959381104,
-0.9646159410476685,
-0.46246397495269775,
0.07294147461652756,
-0.15302380919456482,
-0.03233194723725319,
-0.4050971269607544,
0.06095872074365616,
0.2436646819114685,
0.36343419551849365,
-0.6901560425758362,
0.17064641416072845,
-0.3083646893501282,
-0.09536567330360413,
0.47949838638305664,
0.1291528195142746,
0.08066384494304657,
-0.2963707447052002,
-0.13282546401023865,
0.13376063108444214,
-0.19373689591884613,
-0.1478562206029892,
0.098362997174263,
0.5586315393447876,
-0.041676491498947144,
0.4488545358181,
-0.44167953729629517,
0.3948879837989807,
0.225569948554039,
0.2804716229438782,
0.09265312552452087,
-0.21209140121936798,
-0.1794719099998474,
-0.06841720640659332,
0.873020589351654,
0.3971858024597168,
0.4027208089828491,
-0.2521969676017761,
-0.19579006731510162,
0.1698470562696457,
0.5587943196296692,
-1.219555377960205,
-0.3371117115020752,
-0.011912313289940357,
-0.5656958818435669,
-0.4663636386394501,
0.2592253088951111,
-0.6420018672943115,
-0.20883768796920776,
-0.16417822241783142,
0.4948456585407257,
-0.3082815110683441,
-0.18209947645664215,
0.156497061252594,
-0.08644416183233261,
-0.26795694231987,
0.3064521551132202,
-1.0087521076202393,
0.03270580992102623,
0.7528435587882996,
0.7799373865127563,
-0.2181287705898285,
-0.1940830498933792,
-0.7052883505821228,
-0.14973768591880798,
-0.2739742398262024,
1.146614670753479,
-0.6863895058631897,
-0.13457739353179932,
0.06213843822479248,
0.055659569799900055,
-0.031822167336940765,
-0.32920655608177185,
0.9235320687294006,
-0.42959460616111755,
0.0759439691901207,
0.055612172931432724,
-0.6424709558486938,
0.547924280166626,
0.03866666927933693,
-0.3910042643547058,
0.8314384818077087,
0.010933531448245049,
-1.012068748474121,
0.6851091980934143,
-0.7361790537834167,
-0.7364174723625183,
0.03242524340748787,
0.1234176754951477,
-0.42226743698120117,
0.31746819615364075,
0.3208140432834625,
0.8125101327896118,
-0.315311074256897,
0.7844224572181702,
-0.12109824270009995,
-0.5682749152183533,
0.006808247417211533,
-0.46322202682495117,
0.1912936270236969,
0.4943714439868927,
-0.05107159912586212,
0.5377903580665588,
-0.47007882595062256,
-0.13590946793556213,
-0.045454926788806915,
-0.06501475721597672,
-0.03250863775610924,
0.03513293340802193,
0.255166232585907,
0.10338352620601654,
0.06955058872699738,
-0.4855008125305176,
0.18467994034290314,
-0.3969416916370392,
0.8512171506881714,
0.48569542169570923,
0.2126292586326599,
0.6360846161842346,
-0.28964558243751526,
0.3260948956012726,
0.07515381276607513,
0.15067850053310394,
-0.12715034186840057,
-0.3316500782966614,
-0.9531580209732056,
0.0211982149630785,
0.483408123254776,
0.37676289677619934,
-0.7907817959785461,
0.8986849784851074,
-0.4155098497867584,
-0.6480770111083984,
-0.453986257314682,
-0.13383182883262634,
-0.18868067860603333,
0.37437108159065247,
0.43524429202079773,
0.15555085241794586,
-0.495983362197876,
-0.9725929498672485,
-0.3579806685447693,
-0.03686856850981712,
-0.2908203601837158,
0.04431331157684326,
0.4470428228378296,
-0.17301051318645477,
0.8961707353591919,
-0.7746184468269348,
-0.4089116156101227,
-0.30382660031318665,
0.6053473949432373,
0.08053453266620636,
0.41111838817596436,
0.3725915551185608,
-0.971223771572113,
-0.3556908965110779,
-0.19893692433834076,
-0.16961750388145447,
-0.2693205177783966,
-0.05373299494385719,
-0.17663882672786713,
-0.10014385730028152,
0.6948019862174988,
-0.6761574149131775,
0.45290306210517883,
0.09851989895105362,
-0.39592716097831726,
0.16781488060951233,
0.02164280042052269,
0.04219699651002884,
-1.2377873659133911,
-0.2863098382949829,
0.24014294147491455,
-0.3166334629058838,
-0.8045498132705688,
-0.25779587030410767,
0.33605602383613586,
-0.2278374284505844,
-0.3521463871002197,
0.29468095302581787,
0.3351857662200928,
0.494469553232193,
-0.7503445148468018,
-0.09702124446630478,
-0.23894178867340088,
0.243453249335289,
0.14137451350688934,
0.6292017698287964,
0.4305369257926941,
-0.5954378843307495,
0.2544393539428711,
0.3799435496330261,
-0.3235442340373993,
0.24402931332588196,
-0.5050293207168579,
-0.002273479476571083,
-0.13541993498802185,
0.19664856791496277,
-0.997676432132721,
-0.259240984916687,
0.22171975672245026,
-0.43810614943504333,
0.27916523814201355,
0.03948744758963585,
-0.773215115070343,
-0.47903427481651306,
-0.10046960413455963,
-0.0962410420179367,
0.4002675712108612,
-0.43187060952186584,
0.31607192754745483,
0.24097804725170135,
-0.18352505564689636,
-0.24340344965457916,
-0.5184119939804077,
0.03569462150335312,
-0.3396746814250946,
-0.5577145218849182,
0.5562077164649963,
0.17203348875045776,
0.31855762004852295,
0.06964416056871414,
-0.3480447828769684,
-0.1615246832370758,
0.12394774705171585,
0.11546221375465393,
-0.13601042330265045,
-0.21378257870674133,
0.722526490688324,
0.28424039483070374,
-0.3846215605735779,
-0.3720960021018982,
-0.26535701751708984,
0.6766425967216492,
-0.2461746484041214,
0.12587381899356842,
-0.5493265986442566,
0.19978347420692444,
0.2625841796398163,
-0.4784901440143585,
0.6430572867393494,
1.0858469009399414,
-0.4873824119567871,
-0.5211890935897827,
-0.5069643259048462,
-0.3943581283092499,
-0.5027652978897095,
0.4275331497192383,
-0.3654937148094177,
-1.3909379243850708,
0.13561348617076874,
-0.22620204091072083,
-0.19879962503910065,
0.6529891490936279,
0.20453467965126038,
-0.2232879251241684,
0.614674985408783,
0.9622645378112793,
-0.11780732870101929,
0.6915952563285828,
-0.1348210573196411,
0.45251598954200745,
-0.20952443778514862,
0.24088463187217712,
-0.7991105318069458,
-0.47025224566459656,
-0.8446909189224243,
-0.23157504200935364,
-0.17773936688899994,
0.1531199961900711,
-0.4257391095161438,
0.5710858702659607,
-0.7574552297592163,
0.5075893402099609,
0.5440806746482849,
0.21792547404766083,
0.04138480871915817,
0.0011666682548820972,
0.575925350189209,
-0.17311625182628632,
-0.5004200339317322,
-0.6828400492668152,
0.6583839654922485,
0.47897154092788696,
0.6934874653816223,
-0.2380339354276657,
0.474060595035553,
0.3425869941711426,
0.33142220973968506,
-0.7322314381599426,
0.5145370364189148,
-0.769626259803772,
-0.43764975666999817,
-0.5652549266815186,
-0.4679550230503082,
-0.6412619948387146,
-0.032556094229221344,
-0.3195511996746063,
-0.7619709968566895,
0.05826856568455696,
-0.11623965203762054,
-0.3201982378959656,
0.3064453601837158,
-0.7916635870933533,
1.18722403049469,
-0.046788111329078674,
0.014980029314756393,
-0.2169741690158844,
-0.5442216396331787,
-0.03780633583664894,
-0.27671900391578674,
-0.3426820635795593,
-0.5301096439361572,
0.007943387143313885,
0.899618923664093,
-0.1755659431219101,
0.6048770546913147,
-0.35003167390823364,
0.054153427481651306,
0.014601627364754677,
-0.30102208256721497,
0.382575124502182,
0.3465135097503662,
-0.07117494195699692,
-0.04243179038167,
-0.06771396100521088,
-0.30808523297309875,
-0.47807857394218445,
0.5793007016181946,
-0.566902756690979,
-0.776586651802063,
-0.19281363487243652,
-0.4200265109539032,
-0.42707663774490356,
0.40513354539871216,
0.6294755935668945,
0.07139710336923599,
-0.24583938717842102,
0.5953863859176636,
0.4892626702785492,
-0.11365640163421631,
0.5194599032402039,
0.31560784578323364,
0.1124950721859932,
-0.05238078534603119,
0.8896286487579346,
0.0418643020093441,
-0.20369957387447357,
0.7997180819511414,
0.1970232129096985,
-0.17669560015201569,
-0.8331409692764282,
-0.10751087218523026,
-0.10496149212121964,
-0.39766040444374084,
-0.5445400476455688,
-0.8236385583877563,
-0.383280873298645,
-0.36959052085876465,
-0.06473357230424881,
-0.4347255229949951,
-0.2920325994491577,
-0.7885164618492126,
-0.2657095193862915,
0.43067631125450134,
0.344132661819458,
0.32930296659469604,
0.7617461085319519,
-0.7814760804176331,
0.7718586921691895,
0.09825234115123749,
0.6812698245048523,
-0.4214872717857361,
-0.7742459774017334,
-0.09938815981149673,
-0.08759316802024841,
-0.5750424265861511,
-0.5787994265556335,
0.2253345251083374,
0.4259284734725952,
0.20543256402015686,
0.6117266416549683,
0.6488726735115051,
0.7498697638511658,
-0.48712027072906494,
0.4922717213630676,
0.07028059661388397,
-1.0283563137054443,
1.0118463039398193,
-0.4163344204425812,
0.2227810025215149,
0.7566596865653992,
0.13007402420043945,
-0.5017179250717163,
-0.565521776676178,
-0.4685364067554474,
-0.704234778881073,
1.0442270040512085,
0.463510125875473,
0.5722352862358093,
0.049638375639915466,
0.3780398666858673,
0.30629992485046387,
0.36069753766059875,
-0.21151500940322876,
-0.04680369794368744,
-0.4067458212375641,
-0.35541418194770813,
-0.3779272139072418,
-0.23084139823913574,
0.2659133970737457,
-0.25826552510261536,
0.2927626967430115,
-0.15352201461791992,
0.4166204631328583,
-0.1070355474948883,
-0.16437236964702606,
-0.48785194754600525,
0.4149364233016968,
0.5321231484413147,
0.491075336933136,
-0.3700050115585327,
0.1349029690027237,
0.20919722318649292,
-0.33791425824165344,
0.09922784566879272,
0.4480154812335968,
-0.13361048698425293,
0.04134372994303703,
0.27108055353164673,
1.0620222091674805,
0.12114983052015305,
-0.4025561511516571,
0.5262043476104736,
-0.2672794759273529,
-0.31551995873451233,
-0.11419554054737091,
0.36055105924606323,
0.1355603188276291,
0.29994523525238037,
0.5394569635391235,
0.4140591025352478,
0.0088322963565588,
-0.2298702448606491,
0.616388201713562,
-0.0017705484060570598,
-0.4817136526107788,
-0.15910767018795013,
0.6170356273651123,
0.2613285481929779,
-0.43327781558036804,
0.4473794996738434,
-0.2522979974746704,
-0.5278759002685547,
0.6374463438987732,
0.2850893437862396,
1.0044960975646973,
-0.13718654215335846,
0.4954928159713745,
0.11556791514158249,
0.3707300126552582,
-0.1915448009967804,
0.09675492346286774,
-0.11568772792816162,
-0.8874228596687317,
-0.36913350224494934,
-0.7808719277381897,
-0.26257243752479553,
0.3450426459312439,
-0.5458999276161194,
0.6079944372177124,
-0.44957494735717773,
-0.3058803975582123,
0.5154671669006348,
0.1822403520345688,
-0.5785316228866577,
0.3772241175174713,
-0.10337257385253906,
1.1061769723892212,
-0.8960247039794922,
0.878785252571106,
0.7627419233322144,
-0.10792676359415054,
-0.5138679146766663,
0.5962247252464294,
-0.6240372657775879,
-0.1808401197195053,
0.6254643201828003,
0.38939303159713745,
0.1782233864068985,
0.12555214762687683,
-0.4920019507408142,
-0.44699591398239136,
0.7873813509941101,
0.46538788080215454,
-0.4382838010787964,
0.045427847653627396,
0.28240227699279785,
0.6807940602302551,
-0.4128565192222595,
-0.029659848660230637,
0.5075849294662476,
0.4463736414909363,
0.11536354571580887,
-1.0466591119766235,
-0.0013262048596516252,
-0.2611069679260254,
0.05832548439502716,
0.41336917877197266,
-0.7411196827888489,
0.4746286869049072,
0.09680461138486862,
-0.21632421016693115,
0.006188512779772282,
0.8624598979949951,
-0.1475229114294052,
0.6510438323020935,
0.47503334283828735,
0.3468523323535919,
0.643231213092804,
-0.6542332768440247,
0.659184992313385,
-0.07691720128059387,
0.6438894271850586,
0.8134365081787109,
-0.09441187232732773,
0.7775150537490845,
0.31429144740104675,
-0.06452775001525879,
-0.19467423856258392,
0.9432955980300903,
-0.3078276515007019,
0.7635645866394043,
0.23902082443237305,
0.2082822620868683,
-0.4795384407043457,
-0.34261101484298706,
-0.2198200523853302,
0.32311639189720154,
0.4470924139022827,
-0.14213304221630096,
-0.24423933029174805,
0.5361329317092896,
-0.3120296895503998,
0.03098740428686142,
-0.23792795836925507,
0.6541895270347595,
0.020550154149532318,
-0.5591411590576172,
0.3769633173942566,
0.1844390630722046,
1.036505103111267,
-0.3092825412750244,
0.2953490912914276,
-0.18212850391864777,
0.27270859479904175,
-0.18094801902770996,
-0.8257685899734497,
0.5262961387634277,
0.1287234127521515,
-0.14851370453834534,
-0.5363086462020874,
1.2495673894882202,
-0.27936771512031555,
-0.3651103675365448,
0.16267408430576324,
0.24337522685527802,
-0.24292635917663574,
-0.3944912850856781,
-0.38711637258529663,
-0.026017459109425545,
0.013785932213068008,
-0.28681063652038574,
-0.07169350236654282,
0.7181978225708008,
0.08267665654420853,
0.7003352046012878,
0.2905327081680298,
-0.21164695918560028,
-0.2557191252708435,
0.13093626499176025,
0.7628605961799622,
-0.8449172973632812,
-0.704664945602417,
-0.6393576264381409,
0.264684796333313,
-0.03465854376554489,
-0.620269775390625,
0.3657422363758087,
0.4146089553833008,
0.8104934692382812,
-0.28593361377716064,
0.714508056640625,
0.02139345183968544,
0.7796190977096558,
-0.3424000144004822,
0.8246996402740479,
-0.6672266721725464,
0.21422414481639862,
-0.13776610791683197,
-0.8349043130874634,
-0.5582320690155029,
0.5153515338897705,
-0.42523929476737976,
0.05881325900554657,
0.7701597809791565,
0.5802969336509705,
-0.3526560366153717,
0.5667557120323181,
0.29251450300216675,
0.01044425182044506,
0.3922955095767975,
0.3946128785610199,
1.0580124855041504,
-0.405569463968277,
0.7805588841438293,
-0.45029160380363464,
0.14706729352474213,
-0.6202558279037476,
-0.5832332968711853,
-1.1927636861801147,
-0.6935002207756042,
-0.47617730498313904,
0.03582923859357834,
0.06193871796131134,
0.7849127650260925,
0.7862377166748047,
-1.042064905166626,
0.22629201412200928,
-0.49115049839019775,
-0.030898436903953552,
0.2066512405872345,
-0.2718106508255005,
0.575600266456604,
-0.4832373857498169,
-0.632855236530304,
0.050215765833854675,
0.09520143270492554,
-0.027819626033306122,
0.2904178500175476,
0.18122859299182892,
-0.0981694683432579,
-0.17321591079235077,
0.5107482075691223,
-0.07784507423639297,
-0.5551998615264893,
-0.6025975346565247,
0.11163900792598724,
-0.1976405531167984,
-0.023662444204092026,
1.0023200511932373,
-0.43431851267814636,
-0.05057657137513161,
0.6090794801712036,
0.6137758493423462,
0.7607563138008118,
0.10167618095874786,
0.22559183835983276,
-0.9745064377784729,
0.05792874097824097,
0.38759711384773254,
0.18979492783546448,
0.07844607532024384,
-0.3083106279373169,
0.37491098046302795,
-0.009455226361751556,
-0.4212144911289215,
-0.8497689962387085,
0.18300245702266693,
-0.9138795137405396,
-0.35021165013313293,
0.9401468634605408,
0.36471983790397644,
0.2519078254699707,
-0.12107057124376297,
-0.2574785351753235,
0.6303482055664062,
-0.6179468631744385,
0.8417690396308899,
0.6804550290107727,
0.047001078724861145,
-0.4616905152797699,
-0.6046038866043091,
0.5092493295669556,
0.34254130721092224,
-0.819703221321106,
0.013920538127422333,
-0.005837467964738607,
0.06661952286958694,
0.21186651289463043,
0.46655941009521484,
0.4346565902233124,
0.20834535360336304,
-0.42271456122398376,
-0.32247617840766907,
-0.015859229490160942,
-0.4954299032688141,
-0.18164773285388947,
0.5012884140014648,
-0.2035772204399109,
-0.4082501530647278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03236v1 | CATT: Character-based Arabic Tashkeel Transformer | 2024-07-03T16:05:20 | 2024-07-03T16:05:20 | Faris Alasmary, Orjuwan Zaafarani, Ahmad Ghannam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tashkeel, or Arabic Text Diacritization (ATD), greatly enhances the
comprehension of Arabic text by removing ambiguity and minimizing the risk of
misinterpretations caused by its absence. It plays a crucial role in improving
Arabic text processing, particularly in applications such as text-to-speech and
machine translation. This paper introduces a new approach to training ATD
models. First, we finetuned two transformers, encoder-only and encoder-decoder,
that were initialized from a pretrained character-based BERT. Then, we applied
the Noisy-Student approach to boost the performance of the best model. We
evaluated our models alongside 11 commercial and open-source models using two
manually labeled benchmark datasets: WikiNews and our CATT dataset. Our
findings show that our top model surpasses all evaluated models by relative
Diacritic Error Rates (DERs) of 30.83\% and 35.21\% on WikiNews and CATT,
respectively, achieving state-of-the-art in ATD. In addition, we show that our
model outperforms GPT-4-turbo on CATT dataset by a relative DER of 9.36\%. We
open-source our CATT models and benchmark dataset for the research
community\footnote{https://github.com/abjadai/catt}. | [
-0.2488679140806198,
-0.7159469127655029,
0.18892979621887207,
-0.05443689599633217,
-0.6737226247787476,
0.6458413600921631,
-0.0008429067092947662,
-0.4635220170021057,
-0.08178512006998062,
0.5574678182601929,
-0.3646877408027649,
-0.734819233417511,
-0.587028443813324,
0.2444325089454651,
-0.5568023920059204,
1.237667202949524,
-0.3155486583709717,
0.12508529424667358,
0.7110810279846191,
0.0367112010717392,
-0.2566087245941162,
-0.6161767840385437,
-0.5580585598945618,
-0.15963076055049896,
0.1965266913175583,
0.44456496834754944,
0.8449985384941101,
0.7183307409286499,
0.7604922652244568,
0.20468154549598694,
-0.07362758368253708,
0.10961037874221802,
0.026063190773129463,
0.1908837854862213,
0.1861381232738495,
-0.18919670581817627,
-0.33597809076309204,
-0.3144673705101013,
0.7065612077713013,
0.38585713505744934,
-0.23523226380348206,
0.09244387596845627,
0.010900062508881092,
0.4698067605495453,
-0.47024795413017273,
0.00034821598092094064,
-0.5987182855606079,
0.1679435819387436,
-0.44491490721702576,
0.08664993196725845,
-0.5717800855636597,
-0.759693443775177,
0.017407886683940887,
-0.45682138204574585,
0.35722923278808594,
-0.026536526158452034,
0.9378958344459534,
0.4168259799480438,
-0.6697736382484436,
-0.04871055483818054,
-0.767723023891449,
0.8489024639129639,
-0.5994976758956909,
0.8094668984413147,
0.40580466389656067,
0.407947301864624,
0.1841896027326584,
-0.8583109974861145,
-0.5237208008766174,
-0.2087036818265915,
0.17260608077049255,
0.2620968222618103,
-0.0022566160187125206,
0.3443191945552826,
0.1864282786846161,
0.541519045829773,
-0.5840294361114502,
-0.09599658846855164,
-0.2211056351661682,
-0.08071425557136536,
0.27623096108436584,
0.06135149300098419,
0.3192989230155945,
-0.15414546430110931,
-0.5464971661567688,
-0.3866325318813324,
-0.45319709181785583,
0.2094581425189972,
0.1033523753285408,
0.30842670798301697,
-0.15553924441337585,
0.47823601961135864,
-0.06407712399959564,
0.16830556094646454,
0.2644125521183014,
0.10956209897994995,
0.13632838428020477,
-0.33019018173217773,
-0.21198727190494537,
0.1312538981437683,
0.6598913669586182,
-0.20881812274456024,
0.5278018712997437,
-0.21320976316928864,
-0.39334118366241455,
-0.04493565857410431,
0.45838335156440735,
-1.1740041971206665,
-0.42293575406074524,
-0.09858732670545578,
-0.6110503673553467,
-0.6202576160430908,
-0.00510885426774621,
-0.46950408816337585,
-0.18700969219207764,
-0.07388756424188614,
0.36411383748054504,
-0.6428688764572144,
-0.26957419514656067,
0.18352541327476501,
0.14404010772705078,
0.03855901584029198,
0.17378577589988708,
-0.9668557643890381,
0.55797278881073,
0.21245411038398743,
0.9807389974594116,
-0.34224995970726013,
0.012278378009796143,
-0.19681446254253387,
0.1352962702512741,
-0.4562843441963196,
0.7923060059547424,
-0.6093661189079285,
-0.5563440918922424,
0.0627240538597107,
-0.3155466318130493,
-0.07636594027280807,
-0.2734748423099518,
0.8620634078979492,
-0.7653819918632507,
-0.07894932478666306,
-0.17014488577842712,
-0.18582366406917572,
-0.3567824065685272,
0.14358071982860565,
-1.0554373264312744,
1.1518996953964233,
0.1729329377412796,
-1.0030128955841064,
0.38310298323631287,
-1.2219370603561401,
-0.38880085945129395,
0.12324011325836182,
0.26456642150878906,
-0.9816148281097412,
0.04800320416688919,
0.612133264541626,
0.20430758595466614,
-0.20315325260162354,
0.3216121792793274,
-0.021123237907886505,
-0.5117678642272949,
0.34947603940963745,
-0.676393985748291,
0.9307341575622559,
0.44538095593452454,
-0.15502013266086578,
-0.013586525805294514,
-0.7774366736412048,
0.22575144469738007,
-0.038241129368543625,
-0.5262715220451355,
-0.20447249710559845,
-0.10286153107881546,
0.5476410388946533,
0.0439089760184288,
0.06071161851286888,
-0.7299505472183228,
0.16439034044742584,
-0.524638295173645,
0.5209302306175232,
0.5944163799285889,
0.1490190178155899,
0.039145488291978836,
-0.3218337595462799,
0.7705551981925964,
0.11872357130050659,
0.31330710649490356,
-0.06486307084560394,
-0.33687034249305725,
-0.7947076559066772,
-0.397346556186676,
0.5927770137786865,
0.35963302850723267,
-1.1599254608154297,
0.07059343159198761,
-0.3431517481803894,
-0.5230159163475037,
-0.6399149894714355,
-0.33058491349220276,
0.5902440547943115,
0.3122979700565338,
0.635326087474823,
-0.5283352136611938,
-0.5972513556480408,
-0.8070980906486511,
-0.2655223309993744,
-0.529772162437439,
0.1892032027244568,
-0.275760293006897,
0.48715922236442566,
-0.08737695962190628,
0.9693921208381653,
-0.11395887285470963,
-0.08298054337501526,
-0.30465269088745117,
0.33118996024131775,
-0.01797126978635788,
0.4522501826286316,
0.32133427262306213,
-0.8218931555747986,
-1.100112795829773,
0.18421345949172974,
-0.1433885544538498,
-0.19006678462028503,
0.18975959718227386,
-0.030156105756759644,
0.13937073945999146,
0.17348439991474152,
-0.4605671465396881,
0.8877572417259216,
0.32408973574638367,
-0.2541596293449402,
0.898994505405426,
0.212846577167511,
0.5398842692375183,
-1.340478539466858,
0.08812592923641205,
-0.17913974821567535,
-0.44174501299858093,
-0.9442628622055054,
0.15610195696353912,
0.2758180499076843,
-0.3120952546596527,
-0.48156940937042236,
0.3212246596813202,
-0.23856188356876373,
0.18179261684417725,
-0.28141558170318604,
-0.6525861620903015,
-0.0711558610200882,
0.6844916343688965,
0.24161814153194427,
1.3301458358764648,
0.08965175598859787,
-0.4199979305267334,
0.12028253078460693,
0.6230599880218506,
-0.47495728731155396,
0.06964966654777527,
-0.6989455819129944,
0.1326669454574585,
0.335918128490448,
0.3251454830169678,
-0.991966962814331,
0.04508126899600029,
0.19110150635242462,
-0.4450826048851013,
0.24700285494327545,
-0.0005851578898727894,
-0.6911155581474304,
-0.48487961292266846,
-0.4347928762435913,
0.9387303590774536,
0.6085048913955688,
-0.6213420629501343,
0.5955851674079895,
0.024393999949097633,
-0.05973779037594795,
-0.5357526540756226,
-0.7926135659217834,
-0.05782345309853554,
-0.3277363181114197,
-0.39794212579727173,
0.6163699626922607,
-0.04729356989264488,
0.06433293968439102,
-0.3213876485824585,
-0.09857600182294846,
-0.734413743019104,
0.19614142179489136,
0.12591663002967834,
0.08350736647844315,
-0.27237433195114136,
0.18049879372119904,
0.032243985682725906,
-0.18366624414920807,
-0.09251415729522705,
-0.21858157217502594,
0.5469657182693481,
0.014687132090330124,
-0.5388972759246826,
-1.0151695013046265,
0.25030699372291565,
0.4759025275707245,
-0.6056525111198425,
0.5101664066314697,
0.8183096051216125,
-0.29849275946617126,
-0.07447192817926407,
-0.4014078974723816,
-0.41632363200187683,
-0.5189942121505737,
0.7404100894927979,
-0.5280688405036926,
-0.5394050478935242,
0.5278796553611755,
0.15989327430725098,
0.32025739550590515,
0.3023998439311981,
0.6329406499862671,
0.12393108755350113,
1.3214523792266846,
0.9987624287605286,
-0.12515868246555328,
0.7294701933860779,
0.05169733613729477,
0.34482458233833313,
-0.626272976398468,
0.0736858993768692,
-0.6761481165885925,
0.005060138180851936,
-0.6029390096664429,
-0.21322111785411835,
0.42153775691986084,
-0.136631578207016,
-0.6925368309020996,
0.39340126514434814,
-0.5825161337852478,
0.5484594106674194,
0.3569163978099823,
0.301016628742218,
0.495670884847641,
0.41082707047462463,
-0.20995865762233734,
-0.3407520651817322,
-0.4938511550426483,
-0.704194962978363,
1.4042370319366455,
0.5195794701576233,
0.7749762535095215,
0.28957825899124146,
0.5701680183410645,
0.6957921981811523,
0.33127519488334656,
-0.7163515686988831,
0.20322096347808838,
-0.2975008487701416,
-0.5986074209213257,
-0.2741979956626892,
0.029421884566545486,
-0.67336106300354,
0.05555497109889984,
0.07336173951625824,
-0.6948682069778442,
0.009187771007418633,
0.07324483245611191,
-0.4849429428577423,
0.6143248081207275,
-0.686403751373291,
0.4531523287296295,
0.19974365830421448,
-0.11505606025457382,
-0.047009002417325974,
-0.4451935589313507,
0.5030959844589233,
-0.4964216351509094,
-0.07679601013660431,
0.3511678874492645,
0.10622261464595795,
1.0113093852996826,
-0.704705536365509,
0.7210391163825989,
-0.10311425477266312,
-0.1864151805639267,
0.37562426924705505,
0.1657402217388153,
0.5243781805038452,
-0.08284474164247513,
-0.35443830490112305,
0.18825429677963257,
0.08267563581466675,
-0.2260138988494873,
-0.45783478021621704,
0.08783511072397232,
-1.0873527526855469,
-0.48011261224746704,
-0.399592787027359,
-0.48813650012016296,
-0.1466485559940338,
-0.02744438499212265,
0.19201263785362244,
0.6355199217796326,
-0.12745341658592224,
0.1513138711452484,
0.7518453001976013,
0.032969214022159576,
0.5494836568832397,
0.46710893511772156,
-0.21523436903953552,
-0.4360523819923401,
0.6934188008308411,
-0.08804262429475784,
0.3770025968551636,
0.45903193950653076,
-0.10296973586082458,
-0.4993886947631836,
-0.5837398767471313,
-0.5612849593162537,
0.006810457445681095,
-0.798811674118042,
-0.4134851098060608,
-0.6716390252113342,
-0.7294830679893494,
-0.04917339235544205,
0.010919846594333649,
-0.593592643737793,
-0.49508097767829895,
-0.1921122521162033,
0.10465606302022934,
0.5461816787719727,
0.7195614576339722,
0.3831493854522705,
0.740135133266449,
-0.7123061418533325,
0.20019829273223877,
0.05002577230334282,
0.2507263123989105,
0.2636217772960663,
-0.9364043474197388,
-0.6681170463562012,
0.05526614189147949,
-0.8398765921592712,
-0.8959773182868958,
0.4483594000339508,
0.22491388022899628,
-0.050216253846883774,
0.36197230219841003,
0.19884760677814484,
0.7410314083099365,
-0.6473605036735535,
0.8256546258926392,
0.12505348026752472,
-1.1157574653625488,
0.2505541443824768,
-0.1904900223016739,
0.36093658208847046,
0.5042707324028015,
0.24876312911510468,
-0.6157968044281006,
-0.4381488561630249,
-0.3362395465373993,
-0.33966532349586487,
0.8046897053718567,
0.5858039855957031,
-0.10676708072423935,
0.052077241241931915,
0.2288527935743332,
0.282428503036499,
-0.026007303968071938,
-0.8356090188026428,
-0.06645377725362778,
-0.440629243850708,
-0.6019057035446167,
0.4093504846096039,
-0.4023206830024719,
0.4811772108078003,
-0.35201382637023926,
0.9566190242767334,
0.07821742445230484,
0.39407405257225037,
0.10423633456230164,
-0.3512631952762604,
-0.09173645079135895,
0.2603013217449188,
0.3248552083969116,
0.20227739214897156,
-0.22382758557796478,
0.028172273188829422,
0.3066096007823944,
-1.205544114112854,
0.4009237587451935,
0.042083851993083954,
-0.12940135598182678,
0.19292977452278137,
0.35208970308303833,
0.704818069934845,
0.045938923954963684,
-0.33925652503967285,
0.522667646408081,
-0.17562520503997803,
-0.2772548794746399,
-0.18889574706554413,
-0.10548246651887894,
-0.4703052341938019,
0.22521260380744934,
0.4345068633556366,
-0.023294895887374878,
0.26471298933029175,
-0.08461589366197586,
0.2821463346481323,
0.3386725187301636,
-0.44634220004081726,
-0.5760068297386169,
0.8412994742393494,
0.25518858432769775,
-0.38642603158950806,
0.6640970706939697,
0.1938105821609497,
-1.0754412412643433,
0.5265032052993774,
0.6771515607833862,
1.0553255081176758,
-0.5785033702850342,
0.18045121431350708,
0.28321409225463867,
0.25450584292411804,
0.19859960675239563,
0.2944692373275757,
-0.3396410048007965,
-0.5996131896972656,
-0.449271023273468,
-0.7325947880744934,
-0.3802018165588379,
0.09989158809185028,
-0.5827410221099854,
0.528177797794342,
-0.459589421749115,
-0.34116506576538086,
-0.015277376398444176,
0.525062084197998,
-0.6024056077003479,
0.2669218182563782,
-0.16346555948257446,
0.7372216582298279,
-0.8425154089927673,
1.2426797151565552,
0.6930673122406006,
-0.5037315487861633,
-0.7880945801734924,
0.23290525376796722,
-0.28131526708602905,
-0.8354005813598633,
0.7506409883499146,
0.1774016171693802,
-0.04593357443809509,
0.5611718893051147,
-0.3616780638694763,
-1.0126044750213623,
0.8944573998451233,
0.014097752049565315,
-0.48639923334121704,
-0.050773561000823975,
0.5304669141769409,
0.3821159303188324,
-0.11511854082345963,
0.8169644474983215,
0.5180800557136536,
0.45775359869003296,
-0.17629826068878174,
-1.0859062671661377,
-0.03891853243112564,
-0.28099989891052246,
0.3932993412017822,
0.3103858530521393,
-0.6200141906738281,
0.9907597899436951,
-0.052964579313993454,
-0.5078526735305786,
0.4034542143344879,
0.5408201217651367,
0.10090094804763794,
-0.3050977289676666,
0.34643280506134033,
0.33165109157562256,
0.4834533929824829,
-0.016767432913184166,
0.7597082257270813,
-0.3449246287345886,
0.2732371389865875,
0.6376523971557617,
-0.07340597361326218,
0.658043384552002,
0.3521662950515747,
-0.2836158275604248,
0.6495955586433411,
0.951856255531311,
-0.01905815489590168,
0.8058795928955078,
-0.07363859564065933,
-0.39198148250579834,
-0.34828436374664307,
-0.2485848367214203,
-0.4352593719959259,
0.42747271060943604,
-0.02534995786845684,
-0.4043633043766022,
-0.40572264790534973,
0.24993768334388733,
-0.2702489197254181,
0.3140637278556824,
-0.04392523318529129,
0.7240389585494995,
-0.1638181358575821,
-0.10030584782361984,
0.9873702526092529,
0.4341850280761719,
0.5802007913589478,
-0.4999825358390808,
-0.02274579368531704,
-0.252769410610199,
0.08639802783727646,
0.01567835733294487,
-0.48779571056365967,
0.23484686017036438,
0.3341464400291443,
-0.42764797806739807,
-0.14612723886966705,
0.5983863472938538,
-0.38022857904434204,
-0.5544803142547607,
-0.32890838384628296,
0.30806276202201843,
0.2796497046947479,
-0.06046915054321289,
-0.6537985801696777,
0.16540205478668213,
0.3312681317329407,
-0.28622278571128845,
-0.1892600804567337,
0.4576909840106964,
-0.7047789096832275,
0.6597302556037903,
0.5202420353889465,
-0.11719045788049698,
-0.09914799779653549,
0.2328035682439804,
0.8239099383354187,
-0.7318713068962097,
-0.689494252204895,
-1.015598177909851,
0.5496464967727661,
0.1793588399887085,
-0.2877257764339447,
0.5031805634498596,
0.5493025779724121,
0.4711810052394867,
-0.07759251445531845,
0.8154196739196777,
0.4368163049221039,
0.5920579433441162,
-0.5483701825141907,
1.1164400577545166,
-0.36088910698890686,
0.09638568758964539,
-0.24273720383644104,
-1.0477479696273804,
-0.37477344274520874,
0.5143201351165771,
-0.11735616624355316,
0.2554285228252411,
0.9800927042961121,
0.6035439968109131,
-0.237298384308815,
0.5120353102684021,
0.29707205295562744,
-0.01628906838595867,
0.7010213136672974,
0.6605691313743591,
0.772295355796814,
-0.7572475671768188,
0.5512989163398743,
-0.16338567435741425,
-0.01245365384966135,
-0.20402929186820984,
-0.5553205013275146,
-1.2622770071029663,
-0.8134567141532898,
-0.253557413816452,
-0.010915569961071014,
0.3610399663448334,
1.049637794494629,
0.7856018543243408,
-0.7410915493965149,
-0.07816817611455917,
-0.27590590715408325,
-0.18021893501281738,
-0.15653012692928314,
-0.1524960994720459,
0.7500448822975159,
-0.31994152069091797,
-0.8014117479324341,
-0.056252188980579376,
-0.1585085242986679,
0.4993835687637329,
-0.12737934291362762,
-0.07090666890144348,
-0.01167585700750351,
0.14109431207180023,
0.3385965824127197,
-0.053929008543491364,
-0.8612819910049438,
-0.2464047223329544,
-0.3177240490913391,
-0.21131174266338348,
0.30902165174484253,
0.5868616700172424,
-0.8899549841880798,
0.4362266957759857,
-0.11022084951400757,
0.7768761515617371,
0.5850678086280823,
0.33908697962760925,
0.372929185628891,
-0.710551917552948,
0.2108447253704071,
0.22806833684444427,
-0.1520409882068634,
0.3122105896472931,
-0.244512677192688,
0.33761051297187805,
0.018096590414643288,
-0.4579041302204132,
-0.9207804799079895,
0.18169516324996948,
-0.5479286909103394,
0.09822243452072144,
0.8356184363365173,
-0.043320003896951675,
-0.1819850355386734,
-0.3353898525238037,
-0.28067097067832947,
0.728930652141571,
-0.5740718245506287,
1.0973116159439087,
0.8439934849739075,
0.47724857926368713,
-0.16093586385250092,
-0.5718206763267517,
0.7778055667877197,
0.5079459547996521,
-0.535737156867981,
0.14797882735729218,
-0.08790063858032227,
0.14230069518089294,
-0.15640754997730255,
0.4143434762954712,
-0.09037016332149506,
0.3755752742290497,
-0.1514638364315033,
0.48628345131874084,
-0.264834463596344,
-0.2436242401599884,
-0.14828266203403473,
-0.19080129265785217,
0.16606073081493378,
-0.38330206274986267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03234v1 | Self-Evaluation as a Defense Against Adversarial Attacks on LLMs | 2024-07-03T16:03:42 | 2024-07-03T16:03:42 | Hannah Brown, Leon Lin, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | When LLMs are deployed in sensitive, human-facing settings, it is crucial
that they do not output unsafe, biased, or privacy-violating outputs. For this
reason, models are both trained and instructed to refuse to answer unsafe
prompts such as "Tell me how to build a bomb." We find that, despite these
safeguards, it is possible to break model defenses simply by appending a space
to the end of a model's input. In a study of eight open-source models, we
demonstrate that this acts as a strong enough attack to cause the majority of
models to generate harmful outputs with very high success rates. We examine the
causes of this behavior, finding that the contexts in which single spaces occur
in tokenized training data encourage models to generate lists when prompted,
overriding training signals to refuse to answer unsafe requests. Our findings
underscore the fragile state of current model alignment and promote the
importance of developing more robust alignment methods. Code and data will be
made available at https://github.com/Linlt-leon/Adversarial-Alignments. | [
-0.3383043110370636,
-0.7022056579589844,
0.4474857747554779,
-0.2400185763835907,
0.18485423922538757,
0.055251751095056534,
0.21367280185222626,
-0.20439565181732178,
-0.1950380504131317,
0.38785073161125183,
-0.5807384848594666,
-0.32425376772880554,
-0.6071264743804932,
-0.12784706056118011,
-0.8072537183761597,
1.2343792915344238,
0.021306488662958145,
0.09758547693490982,
-0.31122395396232605,
-0.08625957369804382,
-0.42999014258384705,
-0.7563775777816772,
-0.30040398240089417,
0.15072080492973328,
0.616481363773346,
-0.050116416066884995,
1.0734370946884155,
0.907575249671936,
0.7532391548156738,
0.30328214168548584,
0.08117078244686127,
-0.10832877457141876,
-0.408980131149292,
0.2936868369579315,
-0.2721003592014313,
-0.2984255850315094,
-0.5199184417724609,
0.31216955184936523,
0.5412914752960205,
0.4520804286003113,
0.08935214579105377,
0.2181430459022522,
0.16228175163269043,
0.6142482161521912,
-0.7668939828872681,
-0.558647096157074,
-0.7340763807296753,
0.14994190633296967,
-0.3665332794189453,
0.09734183549880981,
-0.43345174193382263,
-0.3113301992416382,
-0.06486845016479492,
-0.3325890302658081,
0.03831634670495987,
-0.031012674793601036,
0.7681544423103333,
0.4127417504787445,
-0.36241742968559265,
-0.45082196593284607,
-0.4993073046207428,
0.5060165524482727,
-0.6076111793518066,
0.07633949816226959,
0.12757094204425812,
0.34102296829223633,
-0.40253204107284546,
-0.4586831033229828,
-0.2122398167848587,
-0.3096392750740051,
-0.04925918206572533,
0.01057032123208046,
-0.5644395351409912,
0.14631438255310059,
0.26190704107284546,
0.1434159129858017,
-0.7353932857513428,
0.3015156686306,
-0.6574475169181824,
-0.1974293440580368,
0.7054968476295471,
0.1636754870414734,
0.6561761498451233,
-0.1494234949350357,
-0.7670249938964844,
-0.12055762112140656,
-1.0162489414215088,
-0.043950680643320084,
0.968013346195221,
0.2687308192253113,
0.0924592912197113,
0.8823954463005066,
0.18574076890945435,
0.6086017489433289,
0.10664894431829453,
0.47115185856819153,
-0.3301345705986023,
-0.2577574849128723,
-0.27199795842170715,
-0.11202823370695114,
1.0938889980316162,
0.2995868921279907,
0.22614260017871857,
-0.2775503993034363,
-0.28162404894828796,
0.296783447265625,
0.8896192908287048,
-0.6252631545066833,
-0.09232965856790543,
0.36997345089912415,
-0.30130478739738464,
-0.9057268500328064,
0.12377781420946121,
-0.4671541452407837,
-0.691561222076416,
0.21531794965267181,
0.5660035014152527,
-0.22801747918128967,
0.20136785507202148,
-0.011808442883193493,
-0.09986141324043274,
-0.11354628950357437,
0.05018811672925949,
-0.61263108253479,
0.4457884430885315,
0.5916315317153931,
0.6940070986747742,
-0.07596094906330109,
-0.4389679431915283,
-0.5387357473373413,
-0.09378104656934738,
-0.6039698719978333,
0.4849788546562195,
0.04466496780514717,
-0.5602555274963379,
-0.2529986798763275,
-0.21667495369911194,
0.07352299243211746,
-0.5546155571937561,
0.39182978868484497,
-0.5344920754432678,
0.3522743582725525,
-0.1943010538816452,
-0.5047009587287903,
0.04871870204806328,
0.2740800976753235,
-0.4951237440109253,
0.7699530124664307,
-0.08228490501642227,
-0.8328378200531006,
0.14306819438934326,
-0.651665449142456,
-0.272073358297348,
-0.2947351038455963,
-0.3197302520275116,
-0.5366939902305603,
0.15831269323825836,
0.20124416053295135,
0.4984906017780304,
0.04099230095744133,
0.18662714958190918,
-0.90268874168396,
-0.13331694900989532,
0.7679858803749084,
-0.5799858570098877,
0.8432711362838745,
0.5809465050697327,
-0.39309147000312805,
0.48434582352638245,
-0.6490411758422852,
0.07713774591684341,
0.4402388036251068,
-0.1627500057220459,
-0.3459025025367737,
-0.05782545730471611,
-0.5567808151245117,
0.274921715259552,
0.34169167280197144,
-0.29841047525405884,
0.34701189398765564,
-0.5362489223480225,
0.24453766644001007,
1.1257084608078003,
-0.01928708516061306,
0.4950096905231476,
-0.43785661458969116,
0.6604968905448914,
-0.12502427399158478,
0.3629268705844879,
-0.05192803218960762,
-0.25327226519584656,
-0.44785916805267334,
-0.02699640393257141,
0.26189297437667847,
0.33415764570236206,
-0.25905877351760864,
0.3329750597476959,
0.03585219010710716,
-0.5431293249130249,
-0.6164511442184448,
0.46311312913894653,
0.5818396806716919,
0.3746095895767212,
0.11095454543828964,
-0.21385252475738525,
-0.5870206952095032,
-0.9455071091651917,
-0.46207424998283386,
-0.20742365717887878,
0.13166485726833344,
0.10201779007911682,
0.5968625545501709,
-0.08448696881532669,
0.6497341394424438,
-0.29590293765068054,
-0.0006051219534128904,
0.19028925895690918,
-0.22126467525959015,
-0.09143584221601486,
0.4987647831439972,
0.652806282043457,
-0.5314867496490479,
-0.12175925076007843,
-0.40100762248039246,
-1.061008334159851,
0.05261938273906708,
-0.15072718262672424,
-0.3918949365615845,
-0.3256363868713379,
0.3318021893501282,
-0.4641033709049225,
0.4715377390384674,
0.43590566515922546,
-0.48370492458343506,
0.5193031430244446,
-0.017295733094215393,
-0.10122621059417725,
-1.0031332969665527,
-0.06879545003175735,
-0.15935882925987244,
-0.16742712259292603,
-0.6549587249755859,
0.44285452365875244,
0.04824412241578102,
-0.2816821038722992,
-0.5899389982223511,
0.5474878549575806,
-0.37541669607162476,
-0.18626531958580017,
-0.30184879899024963,
0.14085489511489868,
0.13891805708408356,
0.09698554873466492,
-0.45994386076927185,
0.922356128692627,
0.4374319612979889,
-0.5437608957290649,
0.15282894670963287,
0.2533451020717621,
-0.22638121247291565,
0.4378684163093567,
-0.700924813747406,
0.3949926793575287,
0.15857882797718048,
0.018061138689517975,
-1.0132992267608643,
-0.2164067178964615,
0.448253870010376,
-0.6074299812316895,
0.37617966532707214,
-0.11880607157945633,
-0.13627159595489502,
-0.38935545086860657,
-0.5994254350662231,
0.3521822392940521,
0.2210487276315689,
-0.7553790211677551,
0.17431814968585968,
0.4569604694843292,
0.2889522314071655,
-0.993855357170105,
-0.7125135660171509,
0.1085009053349495,
-0.5566272735595703,
-0.8025220036506653,
0.038534168154001236,
-0.29879510402679443,
-0.41706448793411255,
-0.016399020329117775,
-0.08804841339588165,
0.13947135210037231,
0.8642716407775879,
0.48140305280685425,
0.40044617652893066,
-0.02915998362004757,
-0.1371987760066986,
-0.42532843351364136,
0.05972806364297867,
0.4048507511615753,
-0.21988633275032043,
0.23561711609363556,
-0.13182108104228973,
-0.8331200480461121,
-0.23596759140491486,
0.3063295781612396,
0.6055914163589478,
-0.04265758767724037,
0.6430462002754211,
0.3289370536804199,
-0.45714420080184937,
-0.14314639568328857,
-0.26662424206733704,
-0.10061699151992798,
-0.5260229706764221,
0.40312400460243225,
-0.20572884380817413,
-0.7567634582519531,
0.35432398319244385,
0.18117165565490723,
0.22538240253925323,
0.5538608431816101,
0.6247259974479675,
-0.3556986451148987,
1.2153462171554565,
0.3508155345916748,
-0.151360884308815,
0.1818232536315918,
-0.2172831892967224,
0.17139950394630432,
-0.9139891862869263,
-0.026431063190102577,
-0.37855929136276245,
-0.32642146944999695,
-0.37751466035842896,
-0.30786946415901184,
0.3407275676727295,
0.15731169283390045,
-0.3955047130584717,
0.4028717577457428,
-0.8258040547370911,
0.29540005326271057,
0.4600899815559387,
0.008384143002331257,
-0.1307862401008606,
-0.18814584612846375,
-0.03384922444820404,
-0.08569321781396866,
-0.6952826976776123,
-0.6639784574508667,
1.3278924226760864,
0.7561710476875305,
1.2206591367721558,
0.34108394384384155,
0.8780041933059692,
0.5261346697807312,
0.3972269296646118,
-0.6796342134475708,
0.41378816962242126,
0.009862679988145828,
-0.9206628799438477,
-0.20749197900295258,
-0.29151371121406555,
-1.0210387706756592,
0.1963389366865158,
-0.001313814427703619,
-0.6425347328186035,
0.1368338167667389,
0.21294739842414856,
-0.6101050972938538,
0.37220752239227295,
-0.6564972996711731,
0.8683053851127625,
-0.833828330039978,
-0.35589784383773804,
0.20647384226322174,
-0.44027790427207947,
0.6257938742637634,
-0.11986945569515228,
0.32705000042915344,
-0.08829012513160706,
0.07838722318410873,
0.8114891052246094,
-0.5980384945869446,
1.1044727563858032,
-0.17284494638442993,
-0.213182732462883,
0.4987788796424866,
0.5143771171569824,
0.531834602355957,
-0.20851965248584747,
0.10441499203443527,
0.008490216918289661,
-0.1336483508348465,
-0.19056710600852966,
-0.6587146520614624,
0.6714490652084351,
-0.9691570401191711,
-0.9194848537445068,
-0.4290524423122406,
-0.46456193923950195,
0.13706767559051514,
0.14712072908878326,
0.4562072455883026,
0.16009867191314697,
-0.4104808270931244,
0.13626731932163239,
0.4914551377296448,
-0.1522454172372818,
0.17941869795322418,
0.26217254996299744,
-0.20208273828029633,
-0.5136197209358215,
0.7629414200782776,
0.2695283889770508,
0.5329508781433105,
-0.19893211126327515,
0.08488388359546661,
-0.3287293016910553,
-0.5825135111808777,
-0.4951149523258209,
-0.14129182696342468,
-0.8725032210350037,
-0.4165797233581543,
-0.5209693312644958,
-0.3857828974723816,
-0.5726361870765686,
-0.264168918132782,
-0.529508650302887,
-0.5177028179168701,
-0.2592337727546692,
-0.2965013086795807,
-0.15021079778671265,
1.1515134572982788,
-0.03523207828402519,
0.24093158543109894,
-0.5514898300170898,
-0.047547146677970886,
0.28636088967323303,
0.05040237680077553,
-0.11510604619979858,
-0.6138836145401001,
-0.2243141382932663,
-0.113364577293396,
-0.6530218124389648,
-1.0179202556610107,
0.25092244148254395,
-0.19979509711265564,
0.5960788726806641,
0.42424649000167847,
0.11404263973236084,
0.5191941261291504,
-0.39422833919525146,
0.7005198001861572,
0.18470099568367004,
-0.8095760345458984,
0.7074781656265259,
-0.40892118215560913,
0.048310209065675735,
0.2584584951400757,
0.35645240545272827,
-0.09367584437131882,
-0.39867839217185974,
-0.7839656472206116,
-0.5963060259819031,
0.4273070991039276,
0.2669826149940491,
0.19915872812271118,
-0.07280943542718887,
0.3866235911846161,
-0.17388205230236053,
0.10010753571987152,
-1.012772798538208,
-0.2848791182041168,
-0.2770559787750244,
-0.1553322970867157,
0.3211463391780853,
-0.49154233932495117,
-0.6752575039863586,
0.33082661032676697,
0.7255859971046448,
-0.12032168358564377,
0.1644744575023651,
0.19500432908535004,
-0.07590591162443161,
-0.21971286833286285,
0.45956748723983765,
0.4858320355415344,
0.25265610218048096,
-0.0396387092769146,
0.23975121974945068,
0.19985446333885193,
0.032714344561100006,
0.5886670351028442,
-0.05983817204833031,
-0.14772666990756989,
-0.5496151447296143,
0.2875942587852478,
0.4456433355808258,
0.154249906539917,
-0.3235381543636322,
0.7666665315628052,
-0.1642269790172577,
-0.18105588853359222,
-0.26362714171409607,
0.3241763412952423,
-0.15907974541187286,
0.20354941487312317,
-0.027693727985024452,
0.25743427872657776,
0.2733561396598816,
-0.4269191026687622,
0.2837306559085846,
0.9406840205192566,
-0.44446516036987305,
-0.36870285868644714,
0.9364376068115234,
-0.09683609753847122,
-0.24491563439369202,
0.33889836072921753,
-0.04500410333275795,
-0.5557948350906372,
0.5898111462593079,
0.5326132774353027,
0.9994469285011292,
-0.2669554054737091,
-0.024329306557774544,
0.20831866562366486,
0.6274783611297607,
0.15424342453479767,
0.07939402759075165,
0.023008674383163452,
-0.7688015699386597,
0.09570538997650146,
-0.38873299956321716,
-0.3940434157848358,
0.19140155613422394,
-0.7019234895706177,
0.15270568430423737,
-0.9674643278121948,
-0.3481091558933258,
-0.24197688698768616,
-0.31654050946235657,
-0.5044562816619873,
0.20258712768554688,
0.4631178379058838,
0.7059165239334106,
-0.67844158411026,
0.4465952217578888,
0.49467429518699646,
-0.32756325602531433,
-0.6339124441146851,
-0.19493602216243744,
0.4752027988433838,
-0.800875186920166,
0.5525898337364197,
0.13466446101665497,
-0.10477814078330994,
-0.5371242761611938,
-0.6504673957824707,
-1.1135228872299194,
0.7752665281295776,
0.5000221133232117,
-0.38886746764183044,
-0.2438320815563202,
-0.07253126800060272,
0.3588085472583771,
-0.3651371896266937,
0.04520151764154434,
0.16449660062789917,
0.3150365650653839,
-0.3917236328125,
-0.4629044532775879,
0.29450443387031555,
-0.33698251843452454,
-0.0984656885266304,
0.11048377305269241,
-0.7711559534072876,
0.8170406222343445,
-0.351155549287796,
-0.324181467294693,
0.3399282991886139,
0.6905205249786377,
0.2837957739830017,
0.08354146033525467,
0.4479140639305115,
0.5777598023414612,
0.7638909816741943,
0.0001223296858370304,
1.205042839050293,
-0.37593555450439453,
0.04564865306019783,
1.3191946744918823,
-0.18370090425014496,
0.617699921131134,
0.1737721711397171,
-0.15943890810012817,
0.27008095383644104,
0.6048563718795776,
-0.4692089557647705,
0.4138381779193878,
0.31425878405570984,
0.05413171648979187,
0.018835054710507393,
0.19862695038318634,
-0.32913267612457275,
0.5440335869789124,
0.2744807302951813,
-0.517951488494873,
-0.22110383212566376,
-0.22561629116535187,
0.09421780705451965,
0.10233627259731293,
0.09851724654436111,
0.6640382409095764,
0.0767204761505127,
-0.6000666618347168,
0.48458707332611084,
-0.11080630868673325,
0.5203140377998352,
-0.6975885033607483,
0.24401696026325226,
0.1871313899755478,
0.22303570806980133,
-0.4226229190826416,
-0.6712549328804016,
0.3318808674812317,
0.2525556683540344,
-0.06954729557037354,
-0.10484953969717026,
0.8986225128173828,
0.11406749486923218,
-0.30111825466156006,
0.5133574604988098,
0.5488011240959167,
0.08135517686605453,
0.13638056814670563,
-1.028353214263916,
-0.09034905582666397,
0.054985929280519485,
-0.5656396746635437,
0.6889063119888306,
0.09324714541435242,
-0.007964334450662136,
0.7070473432540894,
0.8116782903671265,
0.0021174107678234577,
0.1904294341802597,
0.023251879960298538,
0.8386428356170654,
-0.5114706158638,
-0.25946205854415894,
-1.2352256774902344,
0.599987804889679,
0.015979865565896034,
-0.18928281962871552,
1.0653096437454224,
0.5788787007331848,
0.903784453868866,
0.2717173993587494,
1.021340012550354,
0.2032880187034607,
0.27097615599632263,
-0.3896006643772125,
0.8220260143280029,
-0.5543786883354187,
0.558495044708252,
-0.160924032330513,
-0.4661223590373993,
-0.13149869441986084,
0.4006076157093048,
-0.3431503176689148,
0.15529955923557281,
0.32986682653427124,
0.773999035358429,
0.030503371730446815,
-0.3458445072174072,
0.5223209857940674,
0.2743023633956909,
0.6240573525428772,
0.24180375039577484,
1.3161715269088745,
-0.5441057085990906,
0.7013434767723083,
-0.42913392186164856,
-0.09975837171077728,
0.13600584864616394,
-0.7909428477287292,
-0.9338352680206299,
-0.33202221989631653,
-0.2536782920360565,
-0.8521959185600281,
0.13017861545085907,
0.7332857847213745,
0.6859304904937744,
-0.6993821859359741,
-0.22649811208248138,
0.15286192297935486,
0.1130564957857132,
0.20019865036010742,
-0.19859857857227325,
0.23259808123111725,
-0.4280283749103546,
-0.33051764965057373,
0.9201825261116028,
0.2659853994846344,
0.40899139642715454,
-0.7533189654350281,
-0.032159171998500824,
-0.08210448920726776,
0.2412749081850052,
-0.15400442481040955,
0.3384084105491638,
-0.823970377445221,
-0.29648223519325256,
0.021056702360510826,
-0.4401756823062897,
0.08571906387805939,
0.4673215448856354,
-0.5073327422142029,
0.6090219616889954,
0.13923461735248566,
0.8172293901443481,
-0.2897023558616638,
0.08645607531070709,
0.8729754090309143,
-0.7752622961997986,
-0.24955755472183228,
0.059821728616952896,
0.6861122250556946,
0.5017048120498657,
-1.025801420211792,
0.6808288097381592,
-0.013624404557049274,
-0.7253662347793579,
-1.0238839387893677,
0.18821869790554047,
-0.3242053687572479,
-0.37981465458869934,
0.7647346258163452,
-0.32143378257751465,
-0.48251038789749146,
0.3379233181476593,
-0.15506033599376678,
0.24270379543304443,
-0.10245180130004883,
0.9859699606895447,
0.827777087688446,
-0.1053193211555481,
0.5090884566307068,
-0.4198426306247711,
0.4530980885028839,
0.5554690361022949,
-0.6891596913337708,
0.09987242519855499,
0.3380934000015259,
0.4433378279209137,
0.21057821810245514,
0.3918020725250244,
-0.24289238452911377,
0.46409347653388977,
0.02617369219660759,
-0.004576738458126783,
-0.21309229731559753,
-0.39123156666755676,
-0.7806206345558167,
0.35302168130874634,
0.307431697845459,
-0.31363409757614136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03232v1 | Single Character Perturbations Break LLM Alignment | 2024-07-03T16:03:10 | 2024-07-03T16:03:10 | Leon Lin, Hannah Brown, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | When LLMs are deployed in sensitive, human-facing settings, it is crucial
that they do not output unsafe, biased, or privacy-violating outputs. For this
reason, models are both trained and instructed to refuse to answer unsafe
prompts such as "Tell me how to build a bomb." We find that, despite these
safeguards, it is possible to break model defenses simply by appending a space
to the end of a model's input. In a study of eight open-source models, we
demonstrate that this acts as a strong enough attack to cause the majority of
models to generate harmful outputs with very high success rates. We examine the
causes of this behavior, finding that the contexts in which single spaces occur
in tokenized training data encourage models to generate lists when prompted,
overriding training signals to refuse to answer unsafe requests. Our findings
underscore the fragile state of current model alignment and promote the
importance of developing more robust alignment methods. Code and data will be
available at https://github.com/hannah-aught/space_attack. | [
-0.2229541391134262,
-0.805617094039917,
0.5288962721824646,
-0.1808474361896515,
-0.050249166786670685,
0.09790168702602386,
0.24740023910999298,
-0.22462868690490723,
-0.0736900344491005,
0.8394988179206848,
-0.7517545819282532,
-0.5765874981880188,
-0.5452743768692017,
-0.04041299223899841,
-0.6000978946685791,
1.0689952373504639,
0.012862902134656906,
0.07987362891435623,
-0.3466866612434387,
-0.12644076347351074,
-0.6415551900863647,
-0.9650160670280457,
-0.2851375937461853,
0.3424411118030548,
0.8324463963508606,
0.38874146342277527,
1.1894117593765259,
0.8702808618545532,
0.9167261719703674,
0.23833821713924408,
-0.11321964859962463,
0.006929382216185331,
-0.5373193621635437,
0.38590794801712036,
0.17519879341125488,
-0.4181665778160095,
-0.5306658148765564,
0.01936817355453968,
0.8341017961502075,
0.7344750761985779,
0.12509068846702576,
0.053180623799562454,
0.02363445796072483,
0.4765874147415161,
-0.5086604952812195,
-0.5308268070220947,
-0.6777037978172302,
0.033183515071868896,
-0.5322849750518799,
0.04933079332113266,
-0.5311509370803833,
-0.20640316605567932,
-0.3741280734539032,
-0.6601517200469971,
0.04951510205864906,
0.06843654066324234,
0.9261699318885803,
0.5526736974716187,
-0.34095948934555054,
-0.2733883261680603,
-0.5925891995429993,
0.6225694417953491,
-0.8113587498664856,
0.14951999485492706,
0.18158398568630219,
0.10354897379875183,
-0.5664965510368347,
-0.474871426820755,
-0.4667949974536896,
-0.18231798708438873,
-0.04578632861375809,
-0.2089347541332245,
-0.26777422428131104,
0.3244556784629822,
0.6197585463523865,
-0.033957209438085556,
-0.5006235837936401,
0.5046584606170654,
-0.6136417388916016,
-0.11094281077384949,
0.6101406216621399,
0.267061322927475,
0.7606104016304016,
-0.1270686537027359,
-0.7300659418106079,
-0.216205433011055,
-1.2257421016693115,
0.039559412747621536,
1.1571406126022339,
0.5752083659172058,
-0.051167748868465424,
1.0343600511550903,
0.4939418435096741,
0.49921196699142456,
0.09165559709072113,
0.41869014501571655,
-0.43826568126678467,
-0.39555421471595764,
-0.03779037296772003,
0.05425505340099335,
1.039809226989746,
0.21712306141853333,
0.10355428606271744,
-0.06413213163614273,
-0.023234348744153976,
0.19662374258041382,
0.6366097331047058,
-0.6157518625259399,
0.03176186978816986,
0.39170023798942566,
-0.025822307914495468,
-0.5780330896377563,
0.3102790415287018,
-0.511711835861206,
-0.8523518443107605,
0.18255053460597992,
0.16625484824180603,
-0.43085339665412903,
0.1490512490272522,
0.25433358550071716,
-0.09710150957107544,
-0.017518650740385056,
0.08130235224962234,
-0.742523729801178,
0.3432391583919525,
0.6358327269554138,
0.6170699596405029,
0.053842224180698395,
-0.3452785313129425,
-0.45810770988464355,
-0.10208389908075333,
-0.449063241481781,
0.7208719849586487,
-0.217888742685318,
-0.7250962257385254,
-0.20272746682167053,
-0.3342476487159729,
0.1148739904165268,
-0.4904760718345642,
0.4813034236431122,
-0.42157524824142456,
0.16820742189884186,
-0.4540160894393921,
-0.48792341351509094,
0.11600968986749649,
0.006092721596360207,
-0.6944087743759155,
0.5407166481018066,
-0.23499523103237152,
-0.9234461188316345,
0.32518619298934937,
-0.5181944966316223,
-0.26220014691352844,
-0.2337506264448166,
-0.3839249610900879,
-0.5160655975341797,
0.23471926152706146,
0.17174625396728516,
0.3145059049129486,
0.18058212101459503,
-0.08782418072223663,
-0.8207652568817139,
-0.35852673649787903,
0.754060685634613,
-0.39285218715667725,
0.8524672985076904,
0.21678951382637024,
0.10819994658231735,
0.517469048500061,
-0.76004558801651,
-0.017475107684731483,
0.36958372592926025,
-0.3193967938423157,
-0.3102826178073883,
0.1541319489479065,
-0.24045413732528687,
0.17852263152599335,
0.09969399124383926,
-0.5180762410163879,
0.6107094883918762,
-0.4037395715713501,
0.29639768600463867,
0.8911066055297852,
0.23074232041835785,
0.4893121123313904,
-0.438603937625885,
0.6453977227210999,
-0.0743277445435524,
0.06536431610584259,
-0.37812021374702454,
-0.36036255955696106,
-0.2995598316192627,
-0.3884642422199249,
0.15455825626850128,
0.31529664993286133,
-0.2449958622455597,
0.2135166972875595,
-0.03618554770946503,
-0.3650255799293518,
-0.7104092836380005,
0.180419921875,
0.45057833194732666,
0.436439573764801,
0.1901210993528366,
-0.17969495058059692,
-0.6913117170333862,
-0.659691572189331,
-0.6155216693878174,
-0.3062003254890442,
0.07218056917190552,
-0.030163712799549103,
0.33121973276138306,
-0.12413474917411804,
0.7820700407028198,
-0.2508818507194519,
-0.09928399324417114,
0.12987957894802094,
-0.17429675161838531,
0.18128755688667297,
0.6390522718429565,
0.4057503342628479,
-0.6203498244285583,
-0.1710629016160965,
-0.4419777989387512,
-0.820845365524292,
0.04515448957681656,
-0.2751682996749878,
-0.2007099688053131,
-0.018166013062000275,
0.41456881165504456,
-0.616814911365509,
0.5833991169929504,
0.3757224380970001,
-0.7870872020721436,
0.7145323157310486,
0.04101366549730301,
-0.04261265695095062,
-1.0565667152404785,
-0.0861675813794136,
-0.12190230190753937,
-0.12842021882534027,
-0.7242299914360046,
0.4396721422672272,
-0.03861220180988312,
-0.30725497007369995,
-0.7362797260284424,
0.46135613322257996,
-0.31094905734062195,
-0.09385921061038971,
-0.10920155793428421,
-0.03078576736152172,
-0.05662386491894722,
0.22705425322055817,
-0.35465267300605774,
0.6819333434104919,
0.2897217571735382,
-0.4214627742767334,
-0.016959307715296745,
0.6809574365615845,
-0.10553833097219467,
0.30010855197906494,
-0.6426390409469604,
0.5564789175987244,
0.011297570541501045,
0.13469113409519196,
-1.3244142532348633,
-0.43766170740127563,
0.28719910979270935,
-0.6483042240142822,
0.5885922908782959,
-0.2136610895395279,
-0.5175423622131348,
-0.22242625057697296,
-0.48901861906051636,
0.39557939767837524,
0.22408466041088104,
-0.5492239594459534,
0.09082658588886261,
0.37047868967056274,
0.2149067223072052,
-0.9078693389892578,
-0.8649936318397522,
0.04675326123833656,
-0.44056200981140137,
-0.8987070918083191,
0.04211282357573509,
-0.3334067761898041,
-0.38019001483917236,
-0.06534014642238617,
-0.394859254360199,
0.09156041592359543,
0.6612066030502319,
0.5897398591041565,
0.5143575668334961,
-0.08024012297391891,
-0.35042518377304077,
-0.13227014243602753,
0.0782947763800621,
0.1434498280286789,
-0.06531374901533127,
0.3919389545917511,
0.11672095209360123,
-0.899720311164856,
-0.5967667102813721,
0.36219656467437744,
0.9577953219413757,
-0.006509896367788315,
0.8194310069084167,
0.1368972510099411,
-0.4390389919281006,
-0.023617492988705635,
-0.20476512610912323,
-0.23086953163146973,
-0.5346722602844238,
0.5521894693374634,
-0.24734538793563843,
-0.9994996786117554,
0.5213703513145447,
0.2637328505516052,
0.4005560576915741,
0.3551535904407501,
0.2836351990699768,
-0.4584992527961731,
1.3030235767364502,
0.5133084654808044,
0.026037704199552536,
0.2960006892681122,
0.08774422109127045,
0.22626379132270813,
-0.7514925599098206,
-0.0791369155049324,
-0.6401310563087463,
-0.40318384766578674,
-0.5162465572357178,
-0.42551764845848083,
0.395608514547348,
0.3220295310020447,
-0.4865053594112396,
0.42055660486221313,
-0.6477259993553162,
0.45536285638809204,
0.1988174021244049,
-0.06463627517223358,
0.09737872332334518,
0.141757071018219,
-0.203593447804451,
-0.17925521731376648,
-0.7493972182273865,
-0.7566284537315369,
1.1711910963058472,
0.7148285508155823,
1.2521262168884277,
0.27674028277397156,
0.8403370380401611,
0.2390543520450592,
0.07512082904577255,
-0.6166963577270508,
0.501071572303772,
-0.13132134079933167,
-0.7941744327545166,
-0.2794850468635559,
-0.3260263204574585,
-0.856103241443634,
0.06892312318086624,
-0.1877821832895279,
-0.850496768951416,
0.18906719982624054,
0.19117552042007446,
-0.697864294052124,
0.5576823353767395,
-0.5906067490577698,
0.8032113313674927,
-0.5260519981384277,
-0.4223755896091461,
0.23331144452095032,
-0.5400533080101013,
0.5556064248085022,
-0.09851694852113724,
0.31601420044898987,
-0.11776912212371826,
-0.07678168267011642,
0.6523191928863525,
-0.521462619304657,
1.1767679452896118,
-0.13254915177822113,
-0.28661349415779114,
0.2708979845046997,
0.39405086636543274,
0.503683865070343,
-0.05894545465707779,
0.010405546054244041,
0.21511249244213104,
-0.09765661507844925,
-0.4599882960319519,
-0.41355904936790466,
0.5700172781944275,
-0.9213435053825378,
-0.7722792625427246,
-0.2472071647644043,
-0.6446746587753296,
-0.07901260256767273,
0.1442549079656601,
0.65537029504776,
0.1108064204454422,
-0.2509916424751282,
0.14075502753257751,
0.7068758010864258,
-0.3919183313846588,
0.18647003173828125,
0.2622174620628357,
-0.33654487133026123,
-0.3716638386249542,
0.5319291353225708,
0.24790093302726746,
0.4714781939983368,
0.03927057608962059,
-0.2032339870929718,
-0.1516162008047104,
-0.5043774843215942,
-0.2597085237503052,
0.18603502213954926,
-0.7659410238265991,
-0.24172133207321167,
-0.471194326877594,
-0.25616690516471863,
-0.5539928078651428,
-0.29851865768432617,
-0.504108726978302,
-0.6557042598724365,
-0.40261465311050415,
-0.2585276961326599,
-0.22494037449359894,
1.0172244310379028,
0.2640323340892792,
0.3874777853488922,
-0.9109436273574829,
-0.11925869435071945,
-0.07208272069692612,
0.18106813728809357,
-0.3759293258190155,
-0.6716014742851257,
-0.14244073629379272,
-0.1476672738790512,
-0.536176323890686,
-1.1446285247802734,
0.13608340919017792,
-0.29060059785842896,
0.34885716438293457,
0.42550572752952576,
0.0153156453743577,
0.6281785368919373,
-0.5628852844238281,
0.8047821521759033,
0.295667827129364,
-0.8172656297683716,
0.418362021446228,
-0.5667963624000549,
0.3832474946975708,
0.3107651174068451,
0.3170537054538727,
-0.4132184088230133,
-0.5607978701591492,
-0.5838829278945923,
-0.7932019233703613,
0.6819703578948975,
0.03410919010639191,
0.3074798882007599,
0.050850190222263336,
0.6204509735107422,
0.09016217291355133,
0.0944775640964508,
-0.7730035781860352,
-0.30474695563316345,
-0.014069486409425735,
-0.232255220413208,
0.3744446635246277,
-0.5833690762519836,
-0.24772366881370544,
0.22366879880428314,
0.6192640066146851,
-0.04899700731039047,
0.3087768256664276,
0.12392456084489822,
-0.02373863011598587,
-0.47008126974105835,
0.30578652024269104,
0.7148287296295166,
0.2072944939136505,
-0.014280329458415508,
0.13462689518928528,
-0.032802797853946686,
-0.22315819561481476,
0.34250450134277344,
-0.0001823215716285631,
-0.1130569577217102,
-0.34971559047698975,
0.41435033082962036,
0.7291049957275391,
0.350750595331192,
-0.4912460148334503,
0.37853217124938965,
-0.2114633023738861,
-0.20591942965984344,
-0.13100886344909668,
0.25428444147109985,
-0.12719246745109558,
0.10369817912578583,
0.09254783391952515,
0.28152021765708923,
-0.3246440887451172,
-0.33525052666664124,
0.22600078582763672,
0.7828378677368164,
-0.4661960303783417,
-0.6036286950111389,
0.936848521232605,
-0.1721639484167099,
-0.340882271528244,
0.6091168522834778,
0.24724803864955902,
-0.45417165756225586,
0.6278870701789856,
0.5974380970001221,
0.6988373398780823,
-0.35438844561576843,
-0.10697653889656067,
0.37624701857566833,
0.7151206135749817,
0.03776096552610397,
0.243625670671463,
0.22506654262542725,
-0.9289644360542297,
-0.1805693656206131,
-0.41698119044303894,
-0.5195239782333374,
0.18525446951389313,
-0.5078361630439758,
0.4645334482192993,
-1.0909374952316284,
-0.28397977352142334,
-0.2561408281326294,
-0.2733888328075409,
-0.44049081206321716,
-0.13893187046051025,
0.6959031820297241,
0.708703875541687,
-0.6245693564414978,
0.5160221457481384,
0.9085019826889038,
-0.5790785551071167,
-0.7807264924049377,
-0.03566867485642433,
0.5220796465873718,
-0.5473635196685791,
0.3113616108894348,
0.11126600950956345,
0.13204419612884521,
-0.33989661931991577,
-0.9564791321754456,
-1.2199219465255737,
0.6477457880973816,
0.6957033276557922,
-0.6411511898040771,
-0.39632242918014526,
0.25583529472351074,
0.2714005410671234,
-0.16168613731861115,
-0.19160978496074677,
0.1628945767879486,
0.5035936236381531,
-0.3161444365978241,
-0.5084519386291504,
0.27875998616218567,
-0.09574659913778305,
-0.2806899845600128,
0.28632885217666626,
-0.6906260251998901,
0.9063378572463989,
-0.4434100389480591,
-0.547021746635437,
0.4541180431842804,
0.7045640349388123,
0.568455159664154,
0.040715523064136505,
0.25452354550361633,
0.6623744964599609,
0.9085260629653931,
-0.058166440576314926,
1.1831285953521729,
-0.1469249129295349,
0.09059306234121323,
1.2751553058624268,
-0.47681334614753723,
0.6833590269088745,
0.5468548536300659,
-0.15112698078155518,
0.3780286908149719,
0.4703504741191864,
-0.26219961047172546,
0.17185208201408386,
0.2470485419034958,
0.053391117602586746,
-0.02099556103348732,
0.23221470415592194,
-0.08321408182382584,
0.430156946182251,
0.3453090786933899,
-0.15451239049434662,
-0.07708404958248138,
-0.07655061036348343,
0.28916677832603455,
0.1790384203195572,
0.06896816939115524,
0.5507712960243225,
0.10370048880577087,
-0.50260990858078,
0.4529309570789337,
-0.07839201390743256,
0.5815263986587524,
-0.8248224258422852,
0.11309526860713959,
-0.032207366079092026,
0.14174148440361023,
-0.5248099565505981,
-0.5540399551391602,
0.280814528465271,
0.33445170521736145,
-0.23601171374320984,
-0.189986452460289,
0.8902937173843384,
-0.13953278958797455,
-0.2495187669992447,
0.20413511991500854,
0.34983912110328674,
0.014185922220349312,
0.038451243191957474,
-0.549233078956604,
0.21078012883663177,
0.10939048230648041,
-0.45571115612983704,
0.663517415523529,
0.046160988509655,
-0.008137938566505909,
0.3683440089225769,
0.8345026969909668,
-0.0228349007666111,
0.3684861361980438,
-0.2510415017604828,
0.7928513884544373,
-0.5718206167221069,
-0.22366300225257874,
-1.0953800678253174,
0.8652509450912476,
0.12793271243572235,
-0.1687031090259552,
1.0732619762420654,
0.4820244610309601,
0.9375343322753906,
0.27142927050590515,
0.8768180012702942,
0.22519689798355103,
0.22093673050403595,
-0.47440147399902344,
0.9344188570976257,
-0.4521137475967407,
0.8032993078231812,
-0.14193812012672424,
-0.7541684508323669,
-0.4771389365196228,
0.1562017798423767,
-0.14421550929546356,
-0.07801727205514908,
0.6274853944778442,
0.7174763679504395,
0.0819784551858902,
-0.1959354281425476,
0.584851861000061,
0.3600218892097473,
0.6370282769203186,
0.21434785425662994,
1.2232633829116821,
-0.4321506917476654,
0.476782888174057,
-0.0804765596985817,
0.0968373715877533,
0.16750960052013397,
-0.8031429052352905,
-0.7965327501296997,
-0.3495977818965912,
-0.3514598309993744,
-0.7547352313995361,
-0.008954550139605999,
0.8366473913192749,
0.5976855158805847,
-0.677139937877655,
-0.19190698862075806,
0.02969512715935707,
0.166448175907135,
0.14501646161079407,
-0.18234996497631073,
0.2044989913702011,
-0.4693220853805542,
-0.4056784212589264,
0.9483614563941956,
0.21360896527767181,
0.20540399849414825,
-0.3396289348602295,
0.03910702094435692,
-0.18463794887065887,
0.3758368492126465,
-0.2624627351760864,
0.5072352886199951,
-0.7550551891326904,
-0.2598634958267212,
0.08013676106929779,
-0.3729074001312256,
0.16280747950077057,
0.7581776976585388,
-0.4815399646759033,
0.3969382047653198,
0.15395338833332062,
0.785891592502594,
-0.1470194160938263,
0.06615739315748215,
0.6227013468742371,
-1.114923357963562,
0.0014768998371437192,
0.2021591067314148,
0.5794616937637329,
0.45084109902381897,
-1.0091545581817627,
0.37187597155570984,
0.190227672457695,
-0.6366510987281799,
-1.2008377313613892,
0.2508414685726166,
-0.5211499333381653,
-0.49820178747177124,
1.0250253677368164,
-0.1650969535112381,
-0.47973161935806274,
0.3714728355407715,
-0.2789103090763092,
0.3427608609199524,
-0.28087103366851807,
0.6371186971664429,
0.9137750864028931,
-0.12844090163707733,
0.4453376531600952,
-0.3201228678226471,
0.3660149872303009,
0.6673535108566284,
-0.5842632055282593,
0.19737470149993896,
0.6176066398620605,
0.3242560625076294,
0.27842578291893005,
0.34206607937812805,
-0.3041076362133026,
0.35674598813056946,
0.025619283318519592,
0.1365050971508026,
-0.35592296719551086,
-0.3751998245716095,
-0.8827227354049683,
0.514907956123352,
0.3086315393447876,
-0.18838390707969666
] |
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
No dataset card yet
New: Create and edit this dataset card directly on the website!
Contribute a Dataset Card- Downloads last month
- 13