Datasets:

PatronusAI

/

openai-gpt-4o-drop-generations

like 0

Follow

Patronus AI 30

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks which team scored the longest field goal kick of the game.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two field goals: a 42-yard field goal by Chiefs kicker Lawrence Tynes and a 41-yard field goal by Rams kicker Jeff Wilkins.", "The longest field goal mentioned in the DOCUMENT is the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes of the Chiefs.", "The ANSWER provided includes ['Rams', 'second', 'Marc Bulger', 'Kevin Curtis'], which does not address the QUESTION and does not mention the Chiefs or the 42-yard field goal." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

d3fb4c3c-d21b-480a-baa0-98d6d0d17c1d

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who were not Irish, we subtract the percentage of Irish people from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%", "The ANSWER provided is 87.1%, which is slightly different from the calculated 86.9%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

8603663e-c53b-46db-a482-a867f12ff3b4

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the second longest field goal of the first half.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two field goals in the first half: a 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes and a 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.", "The longest field goal in the first half is 42 yards by Lawrence Tynes.", "The second longest field goal in the first half is 41 yards by Jeff Wilkins.", "The ANSWER states 42, which is the longest field goal, not the second longest." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

c63a73e5-2c91-489b-bd24-af150ddfa82c

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the length of the last touchdown.", "The DOCUMENT states that the last touchdown was a 15-yard TD pass from Brett Favre to Laveranues Coles.", "The ANSWER provided is '18-yard', which does not match the 15-yard length mentioned in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

52db14ed-5426-46ec-b0ae-4ef843b2d692

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the percentage of people from the census who weren't Irish.", "The DOCUMENT states that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who weren't Irish, we subtract the percentage of Irish people from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%", "The ANSWER provided is 87.1%, which is slightly different from the calculated 86.9%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

31b36417-aad1-412c-b0e5-9c1faaed233f

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that in 1917, 10 million men were registered.", "The DOCUMENT also states that by the end of 1918, this number increased to 24 million men.", "The difference between the number of men registered in 1918 and 1917 is 24 million - 10 million = 14 million.", "The ANSWER states that 15 million more men were registered in 1918 than in 1917.", "The ANSWER is not faithful to the DOCUMENT as it provides an incorrect difference." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

57d6f476-5163-4069-baab-b53504a3e662

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions a 1-yard TD run by Larry Johnson in the first quarter.", "The DOCUMENT mentions a 3-yard TD pass from Damon Huard to Tony Gonzalez in the second quarter.", "The ANSWER lists the two shortest touchdowns as '2' and '3' yards.", "The correct shortest touchdowns based on the DOCUMENT are '1' and '3' yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

81da46e1-384f-4026-8b02-0c7b48fe5899

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 79,667 households and 60,387 families.", "To find the difference between households and families, we subtract the number of families from the number of households.", "79,667 households - 60,387 families = 19,280 more households than families.", "The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the calculated difference of 19,280." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

5b3b919d-6895-43ec-a065-6de13ac56e2f

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 79,667 households and 60,387 families.", "To find the difference between households and families, subtract the number of families from the number of households.", "79,667 households - 60,387 families = 19,280 more households than families.", "The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the calculated difference of 19,280." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

78f47611-5119-42dc-af43-f40dcfd6fe96

{ "REASONING": [ "The Dutch were defeated in Brazil in 1625 when a joint Spanish-Portuguese fleet recaptured Salvador.", "The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630 and captured Olinda and Recife.", "The time between 1625 and 1630 is 5 years, not 6 years." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

4a549e4a-b934-400e-960b-7acd4d920d9e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Lions scored first in the first quarter with a 23-yard field goal by Jason Hanson.", "The ANSWER states that Hanson scored 28 yards in the first quarter.", "The DOCUMENT does not mention Hanson scoring 28 yards in the first quarter; it mentions a 23-yard field goal instead." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

e1afeb0e-9ad7-4733-bcc2-c977344de287

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that New Orleans defeated Tampa Bay 24-17.", "The difference between 24 and 17 is 7 points.", "The ANSWER correctly states that New Orleans defeated Tampa by 7 points." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

2d560a12-2b8f-4c4f-9c9f-85e7a73114f5

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the score was 7-7 at the end of the first quarter.", "Pittsburgh scored a touchdown early in the first quarter.", "The Browns tied the score with a touchdown by the end of the first quarter.", "There is no mention of any other points being scored in the first quarter." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

70ff6095-aab3-45ad-83d0-03a302345f66

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.", "The DOCUMENT also states that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "Since 13.1% (Irish) is less than 22.5% (German), the Irish group is smaller than the German group." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

8fac9dea-d6e7-4439-b822-943cab0abe47

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the only score in the fourth quarter was an 11-yard TD pass from Huard to Wilson.", "The ANSWER states that the total yards played in the fourth quarter that resulted in a score is 12.", "The correct total yards that resulted in a score in the fourth quarter is 11, not 12." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

008c309d-84bf-42c6-8123-376d749d50bd

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT describes the events of the game between the Patriots and the Packers.", "The Patriots scored multiple touchdowns throughout the game.", "The DOCUMENT states that 'With the win, the Patriots improved to 7-3.'", "This indicates that the Patriots won the game." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

3ae07499-28e3-4c35-b1bd-d1a89cf3db36

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Michael Crabtree caught three touchdown passes from Derek Carr.", "The ANSWER states that Crabtree caught 2 touchdowns.", "The ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

660cbd19-c845-4ba4-9921-671d15dbcaa3

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT lists four TD passes by Tom Brady.", "The first TD pass was 8 yards to Benjamin Watson.", "The second TD pass was 3 yards to Randy Moss.", "The third TD pass was 4 yards to Jabar Gaffney.", "The fourth TD pass was 45 yards to Randy Moss.", "Summing these distances: 8 + 3 + 4 + 45 = 60 yards." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

d33e83dc-41d1-4545-8d27-5a6827c1de8e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that Olindo Mare made two 23-yard field goals.", "The total yards kicked by Olindo Mare would be 23 + 23 = 46 yards.", "The ANSWER correctly states that Olindo Mare kicked a total of 46 yards." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

e9dc8976-a720-42d4-a109-850435841ad0

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the player who had the longest touchdown play of the first half.", "The DOCUMENT describes three touchdowns in the first half: one by Anthony Chickillo (recovered blocked punt), one by DeShone Kizer (1-yard run), and one by Jesse James (4-yard pass).", "Antonio Brown is mentioned in the DOCUMENT for a 50-yard reception, but this was not a touchdown play.", "The longest touchdown play in the first half was Jesse James' 4-yard touchdown reception." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

c81bc7a0-3a0d-473e-b2ab-45bb769c7505

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Raiders took the lead 28-27 after a touchdown pass from Carr to Crabtree.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that the Ravens looked for a game-winning field goal but were stopped by the Raiders defense.", "The final outcome described in the DOCUMENT is that the Raiders moved to 3-1 for the first time since 2000, indicating they won the game." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

1a7e9f62-3033-4d25-ba1a-3acfaa190811

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Michael Crabtree scored three touchdowns.", "The DOCUMENT also states that Derek Carr finished with four touchdowns.", "The ANSWER 'Crabtree' implies that Crabtree had more touchdowns than Carr, which contradicts the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

bbd452c6-f047-4f57-97a0-9608d255846a

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Momchil died on 7 July 1345.", "The ANSWER states that Momchil died on 5 July 1345.", "The ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

4600e413-5dc2-480f-a561-631214c52782

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions two field goals: a 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes and a 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.", "The QUESTION asks for the kicker of the second longest field goal.", "The longest field goal mentioned is 42 yards by Lawrence Tynes.", "The second longest field goal mentioned is 41 yards by Jeff Wilkins.", "The ANSWER states Lawrence Tynes, which is incorrect because he kicked the longest field goal, not the second longest." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

32d77b6d-b109-40b7-bc0f-99803277fbcd

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the racial makeup of the county but does not explicitly state the percentage of people who were not American.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that 8.1% of the population were of 'American' ancestry.", "To determine the percentage of people who were not American, one would subtract the percentage of 'American' ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 8.1% = 91.9%, not 92.1%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

43989606-830f-4a57-a506-2a751316d2e6

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that San Francisco recovered a fumble without giving up a turnover.", "It also states that QB Alex Smith's fumble set up a score for the Lions.", "The DOCUMENT further notes that Detroit had two turnovers on its first three plays in the third quarter, but it does not specify if these were fumbles.", "The DOCUMENT concludes by stating that the 49ers' defense forced 4 turnovers in total, but it does not specify how many of these were fumbles." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

63d298a2-5895-4a11-9c8e-7e780952cce0

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the final score was 28-27 in favor of the Raiders.", "This indicates that the Raiders won by a margin of 1 point.", "The ANSWER states that the Raiders won by 2 points.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the DOCUMENT as it contradicts the provided information." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

740f740f-b4e2-4b56-a3df-ee484e0c85c3

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides a detailed account of the scoring events in the game.", "In the first quarter, the Cowboys scored a 34-yard field goal.", "The Jaguars scored a 10-yard TD pass in the first quarter.", "In the second quarter, the Jaguars scored a 42-yard TD pass.", "The Cowboys did not score in the second quarter.", "Therefore, the Cowboys scored 3 points in the first half (first and second quarters combined).", "The Jaguars scored 14 points in the first half (first and second quarters combined).", "The ANSWER states that the Jaguars scored the least points in the first half, which is incorrect." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

9c7132be-5b44-40e9-9bbe-39c14a86a4d1

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry and 13.1% were of Irish ancestry.", "The DOCUMENT also states that 9.8% were of Italian ancestry, which is below the 10% threshold.", "The ANSWER lists 'German' and 'Italian' as the ancestral groups that are at least 10%.", "The inclusion of 'Italian' in the ANSWER is incorrect as it does not meet the 10% threshold according to the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f5f7dea7-cd51-467f-8ad7-5ed82cc4324c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 'The Lions struck first, when Jason Hanson kicked a 25-yard field goal that came after a San Francisco turnover.'", "This indicates that the Lions were the first team to score in the game.", "The ANSWER states that the 49ers got on the board first, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

998621b9-8bbd-43ef-a77d-78a2a6dd69b8

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Graham Gano made a field goal late in the first quarter.", "The DOCUMENT also states that the Panthers scored six more points in the second quarter with two field goals.", "Therefore, in the first half (which includes the first and second quarters), Graham Gano made a total of three field goals." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

7999cb17-682b-4e55-a068-430d207a993f

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 'San Francisco received a safety when Aldon Smith sacked Matthew Stafford in the end zone.'", "This indicates that the Lions had a safety scored on them, not the 49ers.", "The ANSWER '49ers' contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

614f2439-4e9a-44ab-addb-4059057af0b7

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Russo-Crimean War started in 1571.", "The DOCUMENT mentions the Smolensk War in the context of troop movements in 1632.", "Since 1571 is earlier than 1632, the Russo-Crimean War started before the Smolensk War." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

a31ad985-79d4-47e0-92fc-adfeb0bf9b41

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for players who caught touchdown passes in the first half.", "In the DOCUMENT, the first half includes the first and second quarters.", "In the first quarter, Brett Favre completed an 18-yard TD pass to Leon Washington.", "In the second quarter, Tyler Thigpen completed a 19-yard TD pass to Tony Gonzalez.", "In the second quarter, Tyler Thigpen also completed an 11-yard TD pass to Mark Bradley.", "Thomas Jones is mentioned in the third quarter for a 1-yard TD run, not a catch." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

64712c5c-b2b2-475e-82db-02e0ceea2016

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions three field goals made by the Lions: a 23-yard field goal, a 28-yard field goal, and a 36-yard touchdown catch.", "The 36-yard play mentioned in the DOCUMENT is a touchdown catch, not a field goal.", "The longest field goal mentioned in the DOCUMENT is 28 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f703d43d-73fa-4fda-8913-d81bd5569700

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the number of points the latter (San Francisco 49ers) had at the end of the game.", "The DOCUMENT states that in the final 2 minutes, the 49ers scored a 6-yard TD catch by Delanie Walker and a 37-yard field goal by David Akers, putting them up 25-19.", "The DOCUMENT confirms that the 49ers won the game with a final score of 25 points.", "The ANSWER provided is 25, which matches the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

3fc35d66-fe98-42a2-9139-ed5b147d542e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Jesse James caught touchdown passes in both halves of the game.", "Antonio Brown is mentioned in the DOCUMENT, but he did not catch any touchdowns; he had a significant 50-yard reception and a long pass that helped run out the clock.", "The ANSWER 'Antonio Brown' is not supported by the DOCUMENT as he did not catch any touchdowns." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

d8cfed6e-9771-4d65-902c-9a28d526ed6c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 83,146 housing units.", "The DOCUMENT states there are 79,667 households.", "To find the difference between housing units and households, subtract the number of households from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 79,667 = 3,479.", "The ANSWER states the difference is 3500.", "The ANSWER is not accurate as the correct difference is 3,479, not 3,500." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

c1084d20-57f9-4d4d-a154-766c1db9bde8

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the player who caught the first TD of the game.", "The DOCUMENT states that the first TD of the game was a 10-yard pass from QB David Garrard to WR Mike Sims-Walker.", "The ANSWER provided is 'Marcedes Lewis'.", "Marcedes Lewis caught a 42-yard TD pass in the second quarter, not the first TD of the game." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

2512dbf6-02c6-46ec-92f0-dedbe76bcaf8

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the percentage of people who were not American.", "The DOCUMENT provides various racial and ethnic breakdowns of the population.", "The DOCUMENT states that 8.1% of the population were of 'American' ancestry.", "The ANSWER states '8.1', which corresponds to the percentage of people who were of 'American' ancestry.", "The QUESTION is asking for the percentage of people who were not American, which would be 100% - 8.1% = 91.9%.", "The ANSWER does not correctly address the QUESTION as it provides the percentage of people who were American, not those who were not American." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

6bbf1900-2cef-4fc2-815b-91b661cce636

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the number of yards of the only rushing touchdown.", "The DOCUMENT states that Dillon got a one-yard touchdown run in the second quarter.", "The ANSWER provided is '2', which does not match the one-yard rushing touchdown mentioned in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

e406d360-a2ee-4276-b041-c54746fb2352

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 83,146 housing units.", "The DOCUMENT states there are 60,387 families.", "The difference between the number of housing units and the number of families is 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.", "The ANSWER provided is 22,758, which is incorrect by 1 unit." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

c7142117-4e5b-4aaf-a49c-fd1c6213e74a

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the final score was 23-3 in favor of Carolina.", "To determine the winning margin, subtract the 49ers' score (3) from the Panthers' score (23).", "23 - 3 equals 20.", "The ANSWER states that Carolina won by 21 points, which is incorrect." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

af57318b-b375-48bd-98d7-633dcfa9b2a9

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT does not mention anything about the Australian Open or any tennis players.", "The DOCUMENT is entirely about a football game between the Kansas City Chiefs and the San Diego Chargers.", "The ANSWER lists names of tennis players, which are not relevant to the content of the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

073c9470-a5ea-48c4-b60f-f7affbbe0717

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the French crown had been at odds with Navarre since 1354.", "The DOCUMENT also states that in 1363 the Navarrese used the captivity of John II in London to try to seize power.", "The time between 1354 and 1363 is 9 years, not 8 years." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

4c219d65-8fe2-4029-9da0-70f5e2857bdb

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the percentage of people from the census who weren't German.", "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of people of German ancestry as 22.5%.", "To find the percentage of people who weren't German, we need to subtract the percentage of Germans from 100%.", "The ANSWER provided is 22.5, which is the percentage of people who were German, not the percentage of people who weren't German." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

712e0c96-3255-49b7-b201-3ecee897b77f

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Buccaneers tied the game in the first quarter with a 38-yard field goal after the Lions scored a 23-yard field goal.", "The DOCUMENT does not mention any touchdowns or additional points scored by the Buccaneers in the first quarter.", "The ANSWER '7' implies a touchdown, which is not supported by the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f16c0ee7-f131-4a8b-a6ac-4d275ea68066

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Detroit took the lead in the second quarter with a 36-yard touchdown catch by Calvin Johnson.", "The QUESTION asks who threw the first touchdown pass of the game.", "The DOCUMENT does not specify who threw the pass to Calvin Johnson.", "The ANSWER 'Calvin Johnson' refers to the receiver, not the passer." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

b04a6f58-2860-445b-8770-d309a467fe30

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the scoring began early in the first quarter when Pittsburgh's Tyler Matakevich blocked a Britton Colquitt punt.", "The blocked punt resulted in the ball being knocked into the end zone where it was recovered by Anthony Chickillo for a touchdown.", "Although Anthony Chickillo scored the touchdown, the first points were initiated by Tyler Matakevich's block." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

43e7bb76-2672-4be3-92d1-f17b2065ab93

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that in the fourth quarter, Tom Brady and Randy Moss connected on a 45-yard TD pass.", "The ANSWER provided is 44 yards.", "The ANSWER does not match the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

ae7c4737-8662-471c-a3be-430ba8a0cd75

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the percentage of people who were not German.", "The DOCUMENT states that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who were not German, we need to subtract the percentage of Germans from 100%.", "100% - 22.5% = 77.5%", "The ANSWER provided is 22.5, which is the percentage of people who were German, not the percentage of people who were not German." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

04e10d50-4ba2-4dd8-b6b6-0b54c37b9549

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT does not provide specific receiving yard statistics for any player.", "The DOCUMENT mentions touchdown passes to Malcom Floyd, Vincent Jackson, Dwayne Bowe, and Darren Sproles, but does not quantify their total receiving yards.", "The ANSWER 'Vincent Jackson' is not supported by the DOCUMENT as it lacks the necessary information to determine who had the most receiving yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

bfed1d83-121b-44ab-8355-8b77a43bcbb6

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 6.0% of the population were of Polish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who were not Polish, we subtract the percentage of Polish people from 100%.", "100% - 6.0% = 94%.", "The ANSWER provided is 92%, which does not match the calculated 94%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

cf4e37e5-c287-4b28-a65e-15aa2818e5c5

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that in the first half, there were two touchdowns: one by Pittsburgh's Anthony Chickillo and one by Cleveland's DeShone Kizer.", "In the second half, there were also two touchdowns: one by Pittsburgh's Jesse James and one by Cleveland's Corey Coleman.", "The ANSWER states that there were 2 more touchdowns in the first half compared to the second half.", "This is incorrect because the number of touchdowns in both halves is equal (2 in the first half and 2 in the second half)." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

e1488f18-19ee-413d-a511-3d885d8bcfa0

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the player who scored a special teams touchdown.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that Jacob Hester recovered a blocked punt in the end zone for a touchdown, which is a special teams play.", "The DOCUMENT does not mention Darren Sproles scoring a special teams touchdown; it mentions him scoring a touchdown on a 58-yard pass, which is an offensive play." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

e3d18516-fe9f-45af-bfa7-f1bde37ab170

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there were 218,590 people and 83,146 housing units.", "To find how many more people there are than housing units, we subtract the number of housing units from the number of people.", "218,590 (people) - 83,146 (housing units) = 135,444.", "The ANSWER provided is 135,450, which is not the same as 135,444." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

33f06667-614b-4ca2-b186-161628435f4d

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides percentages for different ancestral groups in the county.", "The percentage of people with Italian ancestry is 9.8%.", "The percentage of people with English ancestry is 9.2%.", "Since 9.2% (English) is smaller than 9.8% (Italian), the English ancestral group is smaller." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f2570d0b-043f-4984-9273-d1d0e84ba760

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Trent Edwards played the rest of the game after J.P. Losman was injured in the first quarter.", "The game consists of four quarters.", "Since Edwards played the rest of the game starting from the first quarter, he played in the second, third, and fourth quarters." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

16916544-1e32-4dc2-affb-924530416d96

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT lists several touchdown passes with their respective yardages.", "The longest touchdown pass mentioned in the DOCUMENT is a 42-yard TD pass from David Garrard to Marcedes Lewis.", "The ANSWER states '34', which does not correspond to any touchdown pass yardage mentioned in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

6bcc8ce2-8447-4dfe-ad8c-2597782d63cd

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the percentage of people from the census who weren't Irish.", "The DOCUMENT states that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who weren't Irish, we subtract the percentage of Irish people from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%", "The ANSWER provided is 87.1, which is slightly different from the calculated 86.9%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

38d480e4-9efc-4d20-93da-20a81f9eabf5

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 'The Raiders jumped out early, taking a lead on a six-yard touchdown pass to Seth Roberts from Derek Carr.'", "This indicates that the Raiders scored the first touchdown of the game.", "The ANSWER states that the Ravens got the first touchdown, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

2744ab4d-e4d2-46ce-8160-b32be79e9045

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the last touchdown of the game was a 2-yard touchdown run by Rashard Mendenhall.", "The ANSWER claims that Ben Roethlisberger scored the last touchdown of the game.", "There is no mention in the DOCUMENT of Ben Roethlisberger scoring a touchdown in the fourth quarter or being involved in the last touchdown of the game." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

732eb5ab-1b8e-40be-b2fa-108ac60364c6

{ "REASONING": [ "Matt Hasselbeck's touchdown pass was 9 yards.", "Philip Rivers' first touchdown pass was 3 yards.", "Philip Rivers' second touchdown pass was 12 yards.", "The difference between Philip Rivers' second touchdown pass (12 yards) and Matt Hasselbeck's touchdown pass (9 yards) is 3 yards, not 6 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

8627332d-2ef1-4de7-babd-1106a8a5694b

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that Robbie Gould kicked a field goal with thirteen seconds to go in the third quarter.", "The DOCUMENT states that neither the Panthers nor the 49ers scored in the fourth quarter.", "Therefore, Robbie Gould kicked only one field goal in the second half." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

13c6b87f-9bcf-4928-9b6c-138b43560a33

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 9.8% of the population were of Italian ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Italian, we subtract the percentage of Italians from 100%.", "100% - 9.8% = 90.2%", "The ANSWER provided is 89.8%, which does not match the calculated 90.2%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

90167be8-fae9-4b86-b242-ddba3319d6ef

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that John II returned to captivity in England after his son Louis of Anjou escaped in 1362.", "The DOCUMENT also states that John II died in 1364 while still in captivity.", "Therefore, John II died 2 years after he returned to captivity." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

8aa1518e-e932-4286-81a2-fd7709e92085

{ "REASONING": [ "The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630 and captured Olinda and Recife.", "The Portuguese continued to attack and prevent the Dutch from harvesting sugar until 1635.", "The duration between 1630 and 1635 is 5 years." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

2b399ed9-0140-4e09-9b60-d4c254dfd44c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Treaty of Brétigny set the ransom for the French king John II and allowed for hostages to be held in lieu of John.", "The DOCUMENT does not provide a specific date for the Treaty of Brétigny, but it mentions events related to it, such as John's return to France and his son's escape in 1362.", "The DOCUMENT states that the Battle of Cocherel occurred on 7 May 1364.", "Since the Treaty of Brétigny is mentioned in the context of events that happened before 1364, it can be inferred that the Treaty of Brétigny happened before the Battle of Cocherel." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

629b40e4-cdb9-41e5-8674-98ee98e51003

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for players who made at least one field goal.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that David Buehler hit a 34-yard field goal in the first quarter.", "The ANSWER lists Jon Kitna, who is mentioned in the DOCUMENT but did not make a field goal.", "The ANSWER does not include David Buehler, who is the player that made a field goal according to the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f92c49c4-f8e3-4b17-bc7e-d5849ae0c72c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the constitutionality of the draft act in the Selective Draft Law Cases.", "The ANSWER states 'unconstitutionality of the draft act,' which directly contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

e04b971a-19b5-4be3-8d57-959eeb3d6afc

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT describes the Rams' game against the Kansas City Chiefs in detail.", "The DOCUMENT states that the Rams lost to the Chiefs in this game.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies the Chiefs as the team the Rams lost to in the previous game." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

aa7a6a6a-56be-495d-b015-912fcaed1526

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Brandon Pettigrew caught a 16-yard TD pass.", "There is no mention of any other catches or yardage by Pettigrew in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER states that Pettigrew caught 18 yards, which contradicts the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

261a1db7-19e2-4ab5-b557-ca7d7209549e

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the first success of a defeat for Momchil.", "The DOCUMENT states that Momchil's first defeat happened on 7 July 1345 in the battle of Peritor.", "The ANSWER provided is 'May', which does not align with the information in the DOCUMENT.", "The DOCUMENT does mention events in May 1345, but these are related to the devastation of Bulgarian territories by the Turks, not a defeat of Momchil's army." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

fff72e27-13c3-4f1d-8705-39c0548c0c7e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions three field goals made by John Kasay.", "The distances of these field goals are 23 yards, 35 yards, and 52 yards.", "Summing these distances: 23 + 35 + 52 = 110 yards.", "The ANSWER states 120 yards, which is incorrect based on the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

a2a8ad0c-808e-479e-936e-1cfa6739b570

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT describes two long touchdown runs by RB Leon Washington.", "The first touchdown run was 101 yards.", "The second touchdown run was 99 yards.", "The QUESTION asks for the longest touchdown run of the game.", "The ANSWER provided is 99, which is not the longest touchdown run." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

fed63029-ef54-4fcc-b0a8-c8cdae29094c

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the length of Robbie Gould's field goal to end the first half.", "The DOCUMENT states, 'The Bears ended the first half with Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal to expand the lead to 17-10.'", "The ANSWER states, 'Robbie Gould's 27-yard field goal.'", "The length of the field goal in the ANSWER (27 yards) does not match the length provided in the DOCUMENT (24 yards)." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

b097125c-5c97-497a-80a7-b9230d8244c5

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Redskins defeated the Dallas Cowboys.", "The DOCUMENT describes a game-winning 47-yard field goal by Redskins kicker Nick Novak.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that the Redskins avenged their Week 2 loss by defeating the Cowboys.", "The ANSWER states that the Cowboys won, which contradicts the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

169fab50-e3ff-4551-9ac0-18dd659e4250

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 83,146 housing units.", "The DOCUMENT states there are 60,387 families.", "The difference between the number of housing units and the number of families is 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.", "The ANSWER states the difference is 22,758, which is incorrect by 1 unit." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

0fe30258-7fc0-4236-9f6d-3330d65df08f

{ "REASONING": [ "The North Carolina Department of Transportation and South Carolina Department of Transportation agreed to an I-73 corridor crossing the state line along SC and NC 38 near Hamlet, North Carolina, on February 11, 2005.", "SCDOT announced its preferred routing of I-73 between Myrtle Beach and Interstate 95 in South Carolina on May 30, 2006.", "To determine the number of days between these two dates, we calculate the difference from February 11, 2005, to May 30, 2006.", "From February 11, 2005, to February 11, 2006, is 365 days (2005 was not a leap year).", "From February 11, 2006, to May 30, 2006, is 108 days (17 days in February after the 11th, 31 days in March, 30 days in April, and 30 days in May).", "Adding these together, 365 + 108 = 473 days.", "The provided answer is 472 days, which is one day less than the calculated 473 days." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

0745e624-835d-4189-b5d0-e35c8cc3cf90

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Frank Gore had 148 yards rushing in the first half.", "It also mentions that he scored on a 61-yard run.", "To find the yards on runs other than his touchdown run, we subtract the 61 yards from the total 148 yards.", "148 yards - 61 yards = 87 yards.", "The ANSWER provided is 85 yards, which does not match the calculated 87 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

41163cff-d27a-40aa-8a33-e9447b9a5640

{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the points each team had at halftime.", "The DOCUMENT provides a detailed account of the scoring events up to halftime.", "In the first quarter, the Jets scored a touchdown (7 points).", "In the second quarter, the Chiefs scored a touchdown (7 points), the Jets scored another touchdown (14 points total for the Jets), and the Chiefs scored another touchdown (14 points total for the Chiefs).", "At halftime, both teams had 14 points each.", "The ANSWER '21' does not match the points for either team at halftime." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

8f176cb2-ea5e-4bc7-aeca-4fa670a85ad5

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 6.0% of the population were of Polish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who weren't Polish, we subtract the percentage of Polish people from 100%.", "100% - 6.0% = 94%", "The ANSWER provided is 93%, which does not match the calculated 94%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

a2f02664-a032-4b4a-b388-299d7b95fb7a

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Gano kicked a field goal after Jonathan Stewart's touchdown in the third quarter.", "The DOCUMENT also mentions that Gano made his third field goal of the day with 3:14 left in the third quarter.", "This implies that Gano kicked two field goals in the third quarter." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

d1b14418-fd40-42fd-94b7-5326dbb4121e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Leon Washington scored a 60-yard TD run.", "The DOCUMENT also mentions a 91-yard interception return for a touchdown by CB Brandon Flowers.", "The QUESTION asks for the longest touchdown play of the game.", "The 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers is longer than the 60-yard TD run by Leon Washington." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

7aaff956-dc28-4985-bbae-55aec0665651

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions two kickoff return touchdowns by Leon Washington.", "The first kickoff return touchdown was 101 yards.", "The second kickoff return touchdown was 99 yards.", "Both touchdowns are mentioned in the DOCUMENT, and only the second one is shorter than 100 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

748fc6d6-bfe8-4dee-8bec-0d8eb153efd7

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are 218,590 people and 60,387 families.", "To find how many more people there are than families, we subtract the number of families from the number of people.", "218,590 (people) - 60,387 (families) = 158,203.", "The ANSWER provided is 158,204, which is 1 more than the correct calculation." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

6b4ee027-ad46-4645-8122-0cd57beea9da

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT does not mention Matt Prater at all.", "The DOCUMENT lists field goals made by Nate Kaeding, but none of them are described as the longest field goal.", "The ANSWER 'Matt Prater' introduces new information not found in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

a849cb71-b6da-4c1a-9791-b962c9ff2d65

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Browns fell to 1-18 in season openers since returning to the league in 1999.", "This implies that they have played 19 season openers since 1999.", "The ANSWER states that the Browns have played 20 season openers since 1999.", "The ANSWER is not consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

87176942-b400-4fd3-a7d3-48183b54987d

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Bears ended the first half with Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal to expand the lead to 17-10.", "This indicates that the total points scored by halftime were 17 (Bears) + 10 (Packers) = 27 points.", "The ANSWER provided is 24, which does not match the total points scored by halftime as per the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

2f68f7db-ebb1-4864-ab40-22db2970305e

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Momchil defeated the Ottoman fleet near the Portogalos bay in June 1344.", "The ANSWER states that the defeat occurred in July 1344.", "The ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

3637ce9d-203d-49e0-a454-b8a49e376148

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that in the first quarter, Brady hooked up with Graham on a two-yard touchdown pass for the only score of the period.", "This indicates that the Patriots scored a touchdown (6 points) in the first quarter.", "The DOCUMENT does not mention any points scored by the Green Bay Packers in the first quarter.", "Therefore, the Packers scored fewer points (0 points) compared to the Patriots (6 points) in the first quarter." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

c017b2c9-0717-4f59-bfd9-9f2c5f17840a

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions Cam Newton throwing a 40-yard touchdown pass.", "There is no mention of Teddy Bridgewater in the DOCUMENT.", "The context provided in the DOCUMENT suggests that Cam Newton is the Panthers quarterback." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

fa8b2cbd-06ed-44a9-bfd8-8e13b789b0cf

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions two field goals: a 42-yard field goal by Chiefs kicker Lawrence Tynes and a 41-yard field goal by Rams kicker Jeff Wilkins.", "The second-longest field goal kick of the game would be the 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins, as it is shorter than the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes.", "The ANSWER 'Chiefs' is incorrect because the Rams scored the second-longest field goal." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

f928fbc3-c8fc-471d-9d66-576b1717edf1

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that Olindo Mare made two 23-yard field goals.", "The DOCUMENT also states that Nate Kaeding made a 29-yard field goal.", "The QUESTION asks for the kicker who kicked the shortest field goal.", "The shortest field goal mentioned in the DOCUMENT is 23 yards, made by Olindo Mare." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

4966f1e8-f040-48d0-b263-917429652223

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the suburbs of Moscow were burned in 1592.", "The DOCUMENT also states that the Nogai raids within sight of Moscow occurred in 1614.", "To determine the number of years between these two events, we subtract 1592 from 1614.", "1614 - 1592 = 22 years.", "The ANSWER provided is 24 years, which is incorrect based on the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

12825b42-178d-43af-855a-5a48fb5dec43

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions two field goals made by the Lions: a 25-yard field goal and a 24-yard field goal.", "Both of these field goals fall within the 20 to 30-yard range.", "No other field goals within the 20 to 30-yard range are mentioned in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

be36ba97-e539-4d4c-86b0-e04f98111a55

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.", "The DOCUMENT also states that 9.8% of the population were of Italian ancestry.", "Since 22.5% (German) is greater than 9.8% (Italian), the German group is larger than the Italian group." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }

FAIL

6acd6dec-a558-403a-97a4-9e8107760fe2

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 9.8% of the population were of Italian ancestry.", "To find the percentage of people who were not Italian, we subtract the percentage of Italians from 100%.", "100% - 9.8% = 90.2%", "The ANSWER provided is 89.8%, which does not match the calculated 90.2%." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

928fd407-19d7-4a38-97d3-3022ec48f01c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the city of Ryazan posad was burned in 1564.", "The DOCUMENT states that the suburbs of Moscow were burned in 1592.", "Since 1564 is earlier than 1592, the city of Ryazan was burned first." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

284dae0c-53fa-4b20-8162-37028792481c

{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Bills were trying to snap a two-game skid.", "A 'two-game skid' implies that the Bills had lost their previous two games.", "Since the Bills were on a two-game losing streak before this game, they had not won any games prior to this one." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }

FAIL

8d865c44-8b45-42f4-bd6a-65651f363667