diff --git "a/data/en110/text/00000009.txt" "b/data/en110/text/00000009.txt"
new file mode 100644--- /dev/null
+++ "b/data/en110/text/00000009.txt"
@@ -0,0 +1,13886 @@
+oYAuIurKutQ-00000-00000032-00000118 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00001-00000119-00000584 as long as the stars in your eyes
+oYAuIurKutQ-00002-00000585-00002282 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00003-00002283-00003547 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00004-00003549-00003675 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00005-00003676-00003840 [Applause]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00006-00003842-00004367 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00007-00004368-00004647 well good morning good morning
+oYAuIurKutQ-00008-00004648-00004831 it's travel day
+oYAuIurKutQ-00009-00004832-00005022 it's finally here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00010-00005023-00005135 yeah again
+oYAuIurKutQ-00011-00005136-00005486 it's saturday the 29th of january
+oYAuIurKutQ-00012-00005487-00005727 we're coming to disney that's weird that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00013-00005728-00005983 is just mad madness i can't actually
+oYAuIurKutQ-00014-00005984-00006167 believe we literally stood as you just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00015-00006168-00006478 saw looking out at the runway
+oYAuIurKutQ-00016-00006479-00006591 heathrow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00017-00006592-00006783 the view
+oYAuIurKutQ-00018-00006784-00007134 crazy i can't get over how we've never
+oYAuIurKutQ-00019-00007136-00007287 stayed anywhere we've had a view like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00020-00007288-00007398 this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00021-00007400-00007598 an american airlines flight is just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00022-00007600-00007695 landed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00023-00007695-00008055 you want to see
+oYAuIurKutQ-00024-00008056-00008327 like that is our view
+oYAuIurKutQ-00025-00008328-00008478 but last night they were actually taking
+oYAuIurKutQ-00026-00008479-00008671 off this way yeah so you could see them
+oYAuIurKutQ-00027-00008672-00008799 taking off but you could see their
+oYAuIurKutQ-00028-00008800-00009031 lights it was dark so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00029-00009032-00009110 but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00030-00009111-00009342 there's some virgin planes over there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00031-00009343-00009606 yeah i can see a group of them one two
+oYAuIurKutQ-00032-00009607-00009751 three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00033-00009752-00009846 four
+oYAuIurKutQ-00034-00009847-00010135 five maybe maybe there's a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00035-00010136-00010399 very few um that we're gonna be
+oYAuIurKutQ-00036-00010400-00010631 flying on soon um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00037-00010632-00010783 so yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00038-00010784-00010983 great pre-travel day if you watch that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00039-00010984-00011231 vlog um if not i'll put a little link in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00040-00011232-00011455 the description so that you can watch it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00041-00011456-00011646 i think the best thing was the cocktail
+oYAuIurKutQ-00042-00011647-00011919 the cocktail at the yeah the runway bar
+oYAuIurKutQ-00043-00011920-00012135 they were good there's jet um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00044-00012136-00012335 yeah the runway bar was
+oYAuIurKutQ-00045-00012336-00012510 amazing like to have that and you could
+oYAuIurKutQ-00046-00012511-00012670 actually go outside
+oYAuIurKutQ-00047-00012671-00012838 and and look out
+oYAuIurKutQ-00048-00012839-00012983 in the summer i can imagine that being
+oYAuIurKutQ-00049-00012984-00013135 amazing because there were table chairs
+oYAuIurKutQ-00050-00013136-00013319 you could sit out there but i bet it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00051-00013319-00013415 busy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00052-00013416-00013679 but it was still cool to to see
+oYAuIurKutQ-00053-00013680-00013830 so if you are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00054-00013831-00014079 flying from heath row i would highly
+oYAuIurKutQ-00055-00014080-00014399 recommend the hilton garden inn um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00056-00014400-00014558 great views
+oYAuIurKutQ-00057-00014559-00014743 great bar um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00058-00014744-00014927 and a really nice room comfy bed nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00059-00014928-00015166 food as well food was great yeah can't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00060-00015168-00015286 cat footwear
+oYAuIurKutQ-00061-00015287-00015671 really top tip stay here um so the plan
+oYAuIurKutQ-00062-00015672-00015863 so we're gonna be heading over now to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00063-00015863-00016055 terminal three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00064-00016056-00016271 um we had a little walk over last night
+oYAuIurKutQ-00065-00016272-00016415 just to make sure we knew where we were
+oYAuIurKutQ-00066-00016416-00016679 going um about five minutes about five
+oYAuIurKutQ-00067-00016680-00016855 ten minutes it was quite
+oYAuIurKutQ-00068-00016856-00017063 easy walk really yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00069-00017064-00017239 now that we know where we're going
+oYAuIurKutQ-00070-00017240-00017358 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00071-00017359-00017591 and then get all checked in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00072-00017592-00017767 get through security fingers crossed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00073-00017768-00017903 that's quick
+oYAuIurKutQ-00074-00017904-00018071 um and then
+oYAuIurKutQ-00075-00018072-00018247 go for some breakfast in the number one
+oYAuIurKutQ-00076-00018248-00018375 lounge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00077-00018376-00018486 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00078-00018487-00018903 our flight isn't until 12 12 midday so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00079-00018904-00019119 we've got a couple of hours um check-in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00080-00019120-00019327 opens at nine although usually you can
+oYAuIurKutQ-00081-00019328-00019471 check in before then because there's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00082-00019472-00019622 quite a few virgin atlantic flights
+oYAuIurKutQ-00083-00019623-00020063 going out this morning but i can't wait
+oYAuIurKutQ-00084-00020064-00020222 it's going to be amazing although it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00085-00020223-00020367 going to be cold it's going to be cold
+oYAuIurKutQ-00086-00020368-00020503 tonight so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00087-00020504-00020735 there's a bit of a cold front in the us
+oYAuIurKutQ-00088-00020736-00020975 which means today tomorrow and a little
+oYAuIurKutQ-00089-00020976-00021255 bit into monday the temperatures have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00090-00021256-00021494 dropped so i think when i say dropped i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00091-00021495-00021807 mean minus three yeah so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00092-00021808-00021999 throughout the kind of early hours of
+oYAuIurKutQ-00093-00022000-00022143 sunday morning
+oYAuIurKutQ-00094-00022144-00022367 it's got a drop to like minus three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00095-00022368-00022543 um and then i think like when we kind of
+oYAuIurKutQ-00096-00022544-00022743 be going out to the parks on sunday
+oYAuIurKutQ-00097-00022744-00022943 morning like tomorrow morning
+oYAuIurKutQ-00098-00022944-00023199 it's gonna be about two three degrees
+oYAuIurKutQ-00099-00023200-00023463 it's cold so like being at home um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00100-00023464-00023622 apparently this is the coldest i've had
+oYAuIurKutQ-00101-00023623-00023799 in four years in four years which is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00102-00023800-00023942 typical it's when we're going and it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00103-00023943-00024150 gonna be freezing um but then for the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00104-00024151-00024311 rest of the week it's gotta be back to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00105-00024312-00024471 normal florida weather for this time of
+oYAuIurKutQ-00106-00024472-00024775 year so 26 27 degrees a little bit
+oYAuIurKutQ-00107-00024776-00024975 cooler on the night but still
+oYAuIurKutQ-00108-00024976-00025119 amazing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00109-00025120-00025294 i just can't wait to get there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00110-00025295-00025439 as we said yesterday we're staying at
+oYAuIurKutQ-00111-00025440-00025646 the disney all-star music which is the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00112-00025647-00025799 first for us we've normally stayed at
+oYAuIurKutQ-00113-00025800-00025934 the sports
+oYAuIurKutQ-00114-00025935-00026046 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00115-00026047-00026431 so yeah just excited to go away and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00116-00026432-00026614 get get back to florida because yeah i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00117-00026616-00026790 just can't wait to get to america yeah i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00118-00026791-00026943 think that just will then maybe feel
+oYAuIurKutQ-00119-00026944-00027118 like things are getting back to normal a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00120-00027119-00027311 little bit so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00121-00027312-00027870 let's get to the airport let's check in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00122-00027872-00028083 this is the fridge in atlantic's pulling
+oYAuIurKutQ-00123-00028083-00028402 in let's get going
+oYAuIurKutQ-00124-00028402-00029519 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00125-00029520-00030255 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00126-00030256-00030399 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00127-00030400-00030574 so we've made it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00128-00030575-00030855 we're now at
+oYAuIurKutQ-00129-00030856-00031102 terminal three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00130-00031103-00031343 that felt like a longer track yeah yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00131-00031344-00031446 like this because you're currently in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00132-00031447-00031695 suitcases this is true
+oYAuIurKutQ-00133-00031695-00032158 but it's okay we we're here so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00134-00032160-00032246 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00135-00032247-00032518 it's all becoming real
+oYAuIurKutQ-00136-00032519-00032662 i think we just need to check in dump
+oYAuIurKutQ-00137-00032663-00032839 the cases and then i'll feel a lot more
+oYAuIurKutQ-00138-00032840-00032974 relaxed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00139-00032975-00033087 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00140-00033088-00033351 let's go check in let's do this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00141-00033352-00033455 bed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00142-00033456-00033687 this is definitely recommended
+oYAuIurKutQ-00143-00033688-00033927 this is the fly ready check-in desk
+oYAuIurKutQ-00144-00033928-00034183 so it literally
+oYAuIurKutQ-00145-00034184-00034335 no one here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00146-00034336-00034623 however all the normal chicken desks are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00147-00034624-00034799 around your queuing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00148-00034800-00034918 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00149-00034919-00035135 top tip
+oYAuIurKutQ-00150-00035136-00035351 upload your documents beforehand do the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00151-00035352-00035671 fridge and fly ready 100
+oYAuIurKutQ-00152-00035672-00035887 so we're done we've just come outside
+oYAuIurKutQ-00153-00035888-00036023 for some fresh air before we go through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00154-00036024-00036223 security absolutely crazy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00155-00036224-00036415 that literally took
+oYAuIurKutQ-00156-00036416-00036543 less than 10 minutes less than 10
+oYAuIurKutQ-00157-00036544-00036639 minutes
+oYAuIurKutQ-00158-00036640-00036783 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00159-00036784-00037007 we were chatting to the the lady
+oYAuIurKutQ-00160-00037008-00037271 checking us in and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00161-00037272-00037495 she was like people just don't know like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00162-00037496-00037623 do it they don't they get a little bit
+oYAuIurKutQ-00163-00037624-00037902 nervous they don't do the fly
+oYAuIurKutQ-00164-00037903-00037974 it's to do with ready
+oYAuIurKutQ-00165-00037975-00038255 vaccinations
+oYAuIurKutQ-00166-00038256-00038543 all this stuff yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00167-00038544-00038774 i just dropped my passport
+oYAuIurKutQ-00168-00038775-00038895 i don't know how it was in my back
+oYAuIurKutQ-00169-00038896-00039046 pocket
+oYAuIurKutQ-00170-00039047-00039215 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00171-00039216-00039359 yeah so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00172-00039360-00039623 a lot of people just think oh it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00173-00039624-00039759 to do with vaccinations and all that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00174-00039760-00039871 sort of thing and she was trying to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00175-00039872-00039983 explain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00176-00039984-00040174 it's just virgin's online system that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00177-00040175-00040423 just allows them to kind of verify all
+oYAuIurKutQ-00178-00040424-00040559 your documentation before you're
+oYAuIurKutQ-00179-00040560-00040679 checking in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00180-00040680-00041007 so i seriously cannot say enough do the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00181-00041008-00041311 fly ready if you're checking in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00182-00041312-00041990 it just makes things so much quicker
+oYAuIurKutQ-00183-00041991-00042158 so we just had a little
+oYAuIurKutQ-00184-00042159-00042279 little walk around just to get a little
+oYAuIurKutQ-00185-00042280-00042430 bit of fresh air before we go through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00186-00042431-00042535 because we know that there's going to be
+oYAuIurKutQ-00187-00042536-00042767 masks on now for quite a while
+oYAuIurKutQ-00188-00042768-00043007 because you do still have to wear masks
+oYAuIurKutQ-00189-00043008-00043215 in the airport and on the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00190-00043216-00043318 flight
+oYAuIurKutQ-00191-00043319-00043702 which is fair enough um but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00192-00043703-00043879 that was our hotel
+oYAuIurKutQ-00193-00043880-00044062 that's weird
+oYAuIurKutQ-00194-00044063-00044407 so we our room was kind of uh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00195-00044408-00044823 like there looking out that way
+oYAuIurKutQ-00196-00044824-00045071 and then that at the top is is the bar
+oYAuIurKutQ-00197-00045072-00045446 that was where we were
+oYAuIurKutQ-00198-00045447-00045871 crazy it's crazy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00199-00045872-00046174 you know the planes going off
+oYAuIurKutQ-00200-00046175-00046527 that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00201-00046528-00046758 where's the link bridge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00202-00046759-00046999 oh it's a terminal two yeah we must have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00203-00047000-00047167 cut through this cardboard
+oYAuIurKutQ-00204-00047168-00047407 no no you can't kind of come out over
+oYAuIurKutQ-00205-00047408-00047551 this way
+oYAuIurKutQ-00206-00047552-00047807 and you you basically you're underneath
+oYAuIurKutQ-00207-00047808-00048007 all of this yeah so basically the link
+oYAuIurKutQ-00208-00048008-00048423 bridge from the hotel into terminal 2
+oYAuIurKutQ-00209-00048424-00048646 is it comes out the other way
+oYAuIurKutQ-00210-00048647-00048918 so terminal 2 is the other side of the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00211-00048919-00049071 hilton garden inn
+oYAuIurKutQ-00212-00049072-00049215 yes so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00213-00049216-00049351 so then you cut all the way along
+oYAuIurKutQ-00214-00049352-00049567 underneath here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00215-00049568-00049999 and then come out outside terminal 3.
+oYAuIurKutQ-00216-00050000-00050174 i'm just so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00217-00050175-00050311 relieved now i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00218-00050312-00050567 whenever i go away the worst bit is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00219-00050568-00050679 up to the point of checking and getting
+oYAuIurKutQ-00220-00050680-00050862 your cases off once you've got your
+oYAuIurKutQ-00221-00050863-00051135 cases that's it then i'm relaxed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00222-00051136-00051279 until we
+oYAuIurKutQ-00223-00051279-00051399 we're running around to try and find the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00224-00051400-00051575 gate board
+oYAuIurKutQ-00225-00051576-00051663 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00226-00051664-00051823 there we go i say we get through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00227-00051824-00052030 security and then might see you again in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00228-00052032-00052207 duty three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00229-00052208-00052302 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00230-00052303-00052494 security done we are now walking into
+oYAuIurKutQ-00231-00052495-00052607 duty three
+oYAuIurKutQ-00232-00052608-00052694 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00233-00052695-00052935 security took like two seconds
+oYAuIurKutQ-00234-00052936-00053247 which i just i'm in shock at the moment
+oYAuIurKutQ-00235-00053248-00053382 everything's just running so smoothly
+oYAuIurKutQ-00236-00053383-00053511 and we don't want to tempt you i'm not
+oYAuIurKutQ-00237-00053512-00053775 used to this but that was a breeze
+oYAuIurKutQ-00238-00053776-00054247 amazing food amazing new amazing drink
+oYAuIurKutQ-00239-00054248-00054487 night sleep
+oYAuIurKutQ-00240-00054488-00054671 that could be like that anywhere though
+oYAuIurKutQ-00241-00054672-00054863 it it has a copy there i just don't see
+oYAuIurKutQ-00242-00054864-00054966 very good
+oYAuIurKutQ-00243-00054967-00055159 that's just been the check in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00244-00055160-00055303 easy easy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00245-00055304-00055607 security
+oYAuIurKutQ-00246-00055608-00055766 like literally everything's taking like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00247-00055767-00056007 less than like 10 minutes left
+oYAuIurKutQ-00248-00056008-00056207 or like five minutes i'm i'm a very
+oYAuIurKutQ-00249-00056208-00056471 happy chappie but i'm not tempting fake
+oYAuIurKutQ-00250-00056472-00056630 because something could go wrong but so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00251-00056632-00056742 far
+oYAuIurKutQ-00252-00056744-00057007 well done virgin well done heathrow i'm
+oYAuIurKutQ-00253-00057008-00057150 loving your work
+oYAuIurKutQ-00254-00057151-00057366 men's fragrance
+oYAuIurKutQ-00255-00057367-00058263 having a sniff
+oYAuIurKutQ-00256-00058264-00058430 we do already know that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00257-00058432-00058575 it tends to be cheaper online than what
+oYAuIurKutQ-00258-00058576-00058766 you pay for it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00259-00058767-00058894 but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00260-00058895-00059135 i always find this is a good way to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00261-00059136-00059230 smell
+oYAuIurKutQ-00262-00059232-00059550 things that you like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00263-00059551-00060263 do you know what i mean
+oYAuIurKutQ-00264-00060264-00060575 toy boy oh that was um no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00265-00060576-00060759 is it toy boy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00266-00060760-00060991 yeah it's totally
+oYAuIurKutQ-00267-00060991-00061126 oh no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00268-00061127-00061230 no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00269-00061232-00061375 do you spray that on you know you've got
+oYAuIurKutQ-00270-00061376-00061630 that you should spray it on the samples
+oYAuIurKutQ-00271-00061632-00061863 spray it underneath because if you don't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00272-00061864-00062006 like it you spray it on yourself you're
+oYAuIurKutQ-00273-00062007-00062287 stuck with it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00274-00062288-00062671 joe's looking at the ray bans
+oYAuIurKutQ-00275-00062672-00063030 oh it's joe founder perry lights
+oYAuIurKutQ-00276-00063032-00063415 let's have a look
+oYAuIurKutQ-00277-00063416-00063603 elton john
+oYAuIurKutQ-00278-00063604-00063863 [Laughter]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00279-00063864-00064206 harris cafe nero
+oYAuIurKutQ-00280-00064207-00064582 case paul smith louis
+oYAuIurKutQ-00281-00064583-00064782 you were wondering
+oYAuIurKutQ-00282-00064783-00065103 plenty to do
+oYAuIurKutQ-00283-00065104-00065550 number one lunch
+oYAuIurKutQ-00284-00065551-00065687 get some food
+oYAuIurKutQ-00285-00065688-00066206 yes let's do this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00286-00066207-00066391 so the gate's been called
+oYAuIurKutQ-00287-00066392-00066582 they are making their way now
+oYAuIurKutQ-00288-00066583-00066663 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00289-00066664-00066815 we didn't film anything in the number
+oYAuIurKutQ-00290-00066816-00067071 one lounge but we'll explain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00291-00067072-00067215 why later
+oYAuIurKutQ-00292-00067216-00067487 so you need to make sure you stay tuned
+oYAuIurKutQ-00293-00067488-00067694 um but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00294-00067695-00067823 hopefully it won't be too much longer
+oYAuIurKutQ-00295-00067824-00067991 now and we will start boarding the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00296-00067992-00068343 flights
+oYAuIurKutQ-00297-00068344-00068750 he's happy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00298-00068751-00068903 although we did have something to eat in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00299-00068904-00069119 the number one lounge but um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00300-00069120-00069223 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00301-00069224-00069519 it wasn't the best but stay tuned joe
+oYAuIurKutQ-00302-00069520-00069750 was this point yeah definitely right
+oYAuIurKutQ-00303-00069751-00069982 gate 24 we need to find our way now it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00304-00069983-00070238 not our flight but it is a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00305-00070239-00070775 american airlines flight
+oYAuIurKutQ-00306-00070776-00071126 that's cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00307-00071127-00071391 that is so cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00308-00071392-00071606 great
+oYAuIurKutQ-00309-00071607-00071838 let's go
+oYAuIurKutQ-00310-00071839-00072159 apparently it's about a 10 minute walk
+oYAuIurKutQ-00311-00072160-00072415 i can do that number 23 just there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00312-00072416-00072655 oh okay
+oYAuIurKutQ-00313-00072656-00072847 oh well maybe we haven't got that far
+oYAuIurKutQ-00314-00072848-00073159 then even better
+oYAuIurKutQ-00315-00073160-00073359 it doesn't make sense you've got gate 23
+oYAuIurKutQ-00316-00073360-00073679 then gate 25 maybe they ran out of signs
+oYAuIurKutQ-00317-00073680-00074167 for 24 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00318-00074168-00074343 interesting
+oYAuIurKutQ-00319-00074344-00074550 so there we are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00320-00074551-00074719 orlando
+oYAuIurKutQ-00321-00074720-00074935 borden
+oYAuIurKutQ-00322-00074936-00075062 and we found
+oYAuIurKutQ-00323-00075063-00075423 great 24.
+oYAuIurKutQ-00324-00075424-00075975 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00325-00075976-00076223 24.
+oYAuIurKutQ-00326-00076224-00076831 here we are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00327-00076832-00077103 so exciting
+oYAuIurKutQ-00328-00077104-00077375 i think we gotta get a buff
+oYAuIurKutQ-00329-00077376-00077735 are you clear i think so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00330-00077736-00078006 that's new if that is the case
+oYAuIurKutQ-00331-00078007-00078550 but i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00332-00078551-00078743 i think we are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00333-00078744-00078935 it is about there we go i think we're
+oYAuIurKutQ-00334-00078936-00079111 getting a bus to the plane
+oYAuIurKutQ-00335-00079112-00079247 and then we'll walk up steps oh it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00336-00079248-00079599 like doing easy jogging
+oYAuIurKutQ-00337-00079600-00079711 that's cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00338-00079712-00080094 so we are getting on a bus
+oYAuIurKutQ-00339-00080095-00080294 not that one but another one and then
+oYAuIurKutQ-00340-00080295-00080567 it's going to take us
+oYAuIurKutQ-00341-00080568-00081847 i have no idea where the plane is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00342-00081848-00081960 there's a va one there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00343-00081961-00082743 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00344-00082744-00083135 champagne bell
+oYAuIurKutQ-00345-00083136-00083535 this is crazy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00346-00083536-00083935 climbing the steps
+oYAuIurKutQ-00347-00083936-00084143 it's a big engine
+oYAuIurKutQ-00348-00084144-00084406 yeah champagne barrel
+oYAuIurKutQ-00349-00084407-00084950 oh it's a bit breezy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00350-00084951-00085206 look at the wheels
+oYAuIurKutQ-00351-00085207-00086199 that is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00352-00086200-00086575 wow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00354-00089736-00089975 like super quick
+oYAuIurKutQ-00355-00089976-00090350 champagne champagne bell
+oYAuIurKutQ-00356-00090351-00092023 a little look outside
+oYAuIurKutQ-00357-00092024-00092638 that's golden girl over there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00358-00092639-00093711 amazing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00359-00093712-00094082 more virgin plants
+oYAuIurKutQ-00360-00094083-00095191 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00361-00095192-00095335 a bit more comfy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00362-00095336-00097287 easier to breathe
+oYAuIurKutQ-00363-00097288-00097538 so if you have any questions
+oYAuIurKutQ-00365-00100735-00100834 [Applause]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00366-00100835-00102343 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00367-00102344-00102494 food has arrived
+oYAuIurKutQ-00368-00102495-00102647 for a chicken
+oYAuIurKutQ-00369-00102648-00102871 pasta
+oYAuIurKutQ-00370-00102872-00103182 we've roasted butternut squash
+oYAuIurKutQ-00371-00103183-00103551 so that's that's quite hot at the moment
+oYAuIurKutQ-00372-00103552-00103686 dessert
+oYAuIurKutQ-00373-00103688-00103839 i think you've had this before soap with
+oYAuIurKutQ-00374-00103840-00104247 caramel chocolate
+oYAuIurKutQ-00375-00104248-00104454 a little bit of cheese
+oYAuIurKutQ-00376-00104455-00104775 and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00377-00104776-00106078 a little cracker
+oYAuIurKutQ-00378-00106079-00106351 so yeah this is the chicken pasta and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00379-00106352-00106483 butternut
+oYAuIurKutQ-00380-00106483-00106886 squash right
+oYAuIurKutQ-00381-00106888-00107071 not gonna complain we'll see what it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00382-00107072-00107199 tastes like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00383-00107200-00107575 joe's tucking in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00384-00107576-00107775 it's like lunch time
+oYAuIurKutQ-00385-00107776-00108039 mile high tea
+oYAuIurKutQ-00386-00108040-00108223 cute little box
+oYAuIurKutQ-00387-00108224-00108415 as it says
+oYAuIurKutQ-00388-00108416-00108671 it's tea time
+oYAuIurKutQ-00389-00108672-00108839 you've got
+oYAuIurKutQ-00390-00108840-00109239 cheese tomatoes spinach roll
+oYAuIurKutQ-00391-00109240-00109575 and then
+oYAuIurKutQ-00392-00109576-00109999 the schooner scott what do you say
+oYAuIurKutQ-00393-00110000-00110295 i think i say scone
+oYAuIurKutQ-00394-00110296-00110551 the schooner is gone
+oYAuIurKutQ-00395-00110552-00110678 i say
+oYAuIurKutQ-00396-00110679-00111951 i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00397-00111952-00112083 looks
+oYAuIurKutQ-00398-00112083-00112431 good now the jam
+oYAuIurKutQ-00399-00112432-00112647 i think the jab's a little easier
+oYAuIurKutQ-00400-00112648-00113263 i just squirted everywhere
+oYAuIurKutQ-00401-00113264-00113590 cream then jam not jam then cream
+oYAuIurKutQ-00402-00113591-00114519 controversial
+oYAuIurKutQ-00403-00114520-00115478 good
+oYAuIurKutQ-00404-00115479-00115790 what do you see when you look at the jam
+oYAuIurKutQ-00405-00115791-00116478 do you see anything
+oYAuIurKutQ-00406-00116479-00116686 that was good
+oYAuIurKutQ-00407-00116688-00116790 finished
+oYAuIurKutQ-00408-00116791-00116927 it was good
+oYAuIurKutQ-00409-00116928-00117254 and i'm still watching free guy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00410-00117255-00117988 love it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00411-00117989-00119654 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00412-00119655-00119863 it's official
+oYAuIurKutQ-00413-00119864-00120423 we've landed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00414-00120424-00120951 we are finally here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00415-00120952-00121199 we are here yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00416-00121200-00121366 that was amazing that was amazing 20
+oYAuIurKutQ-00417-00121367-00121558 minutes and we were through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00418-00121559-00121702 so there's 20 minutes to get to the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00419-00121703-00121902 plane get through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00420-00121903-00122086 three minutes crazy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00421-00122088-00122231 can't complain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00422-00122232-00122447 i just need to get them on her honor
+oYAuIurKutQ-00423-00122448-00124039 we're back at disney
+oYAuIurKutQ-00424-00124040-00124278 we've made it we're here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00425-00124279-00124847 we're here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00426-00124848-00124999 sorry we've just been distracted because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00427-00125000-00125207 there's a lady with victor
+oYAuIurKutQ-00428-00125208-00125423 that's so cute but we're here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00429-00125424-00125710 we made it we're back nceo international
+oYAuIurKutQ-00430-00125711-00126054 the mco back in orlando
+oYAuIurKutQ-00431-00126055-00126263 like we've never been away and i have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00432-00126264-00126454 spotted the epcot ball with the new walt
+oYAuIurKutQ-00433-00126455-00126599 disney thing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00434-00126600-00126807 which the last time we were here it was
+oYAuIurKutQ-00435-00126808-00126990 star wars
+oYAuIurKutQ-00436-00126991-00127158 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00437-00127159-00127310 are we going in the store or would you
+oYAuIurKutQ-00438-00127311-00127463 really do around the world
+oYAuIurKutQ-00439-00127464-00127631 the store on the way out because that's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00440-00127632-00127886 the depressed depressing bit
+oYAuIurKutQ-00441-00127888-00128175 of disney isn't it yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00442-00128176-00128439 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00443-00128440-00128558 we'll have a little walk over to the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00444-00128559-00128766 disney wall but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00445-00128767-00128943 how was we were talking earlier how was
+oYAuIurKutQ-00446-00128944-00129047 security
+oYAuIurKutQ-00447-00129048-00129183 i made it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00448-00129183-00129439 like 15 minutes to get off the well 20
+oYAuIurKutQ-00449-00129440-00129631 minutes to get off the plane
+oYAuIurKutQ-00450-00129632-00129975 get the bag uh get go through customs
+oYAuIurKutQ-00451-00129976-00130158 pick up the flags
+oYAuIurKutQ-00452-00130159-00130423 get the shot over 20 minutes 20 minutes
+oYAuIurKutQ-00453-00130424-00130663 when normally it's two hours
+oYAuIurKutQ-00454-00130664-00130839 i mean
+oYAuIurKutQ-00455-00130840-00130999 yeah i've never known it like that i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00456-00131000-00131159 mean we walked through and you know when
+oYAuIurKutQ-00457-00131160-00131335 you expect to see the lines
+oYAuIurKutQ-00458-00131336-00131463 there was just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00459-00131464-00131759 one line and we were like what
+oYAuIurKutQ-00460-00131760-00131895 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00461-00131896-00132159 and yeah everything so far has just been
+oYAuIurKutQ-00462-00132160-00132431 amazing it's been
+oYAuIurKutQ-00463-00132432-00132535 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00464-00132536-00132671 relaxed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00465-00132672-00132790 easy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00466-00132791-00132975 you know all the kobe protocols it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00467-00132976-00133263 hasn't changed anything it's just yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00468-00133264-00133663 it's amazing but here we are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00469-00133664-00133847 look
+oYAuIurKutQ-00470-00133848-00134095 oh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00471-00134096-00134399 look at that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00472-00134400-00134647 joe's going to get some photographs i'll
+oYAuIurKutQ-00473-00134648-00134854 leave the photography to joe
+oYAuIurKutQ-00474-00134855-00135423 but oh wow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00475-00135424-00135727 that's amazing you know what
+oYAuIurKutQ-00476-00135728-00135902 when they said they were changing this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00477-00135903-00136071 from the old
+oYAuIurKutQ-00478-00136072-00136183 wall
+oYAuIurKutQ-00479-00136184-00136414 um i'll insert a picture
+oYAuIurKutQ-00480-00136415-00136671 here if you remember what the old wall
+oYAuIurKutQ-00481-00136672-00136943 used to look like but this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00482-00136944-00137143 this is amazing i cannot wait to see
+oYAuIurKutQ-00483-00137144-00137511 that football
+oYAuIurKutQ-00484-00137512-00137623 that is just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00485-00137624-00138319 amazing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00486-00138320-00138590 one of our favorite rides anyway
+oYAuIurKutQ-00487-00138591-00138727 we've made it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00488-00138728-00139063 we're in the room we're in the room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00489-00139064-00139319 we have literally
+oYAuIurKutQ-00490-00139320-00139599 just walked in the door yeah and we just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00491-00139600-00139743 we're in a bit of a rush tonight because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00492-00139744-00140078 we do want to get out to the parks um so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00493-00140079-00140407 we thought right we'll quickly say hello
+oYAuIurKutQ-00494-00140408-00140575 let you know we've all got here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00495-00140576-00140671 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00496-00140672-00140863 we managed to find the room all right
+oYAuIurKutQ-00497-00140864-00140959 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00498-00140960-00141095 we didn't need to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00499-00141096-00141463 go to reception because we did the whole
+oYAuIurKutQ-00500-00141464-00141623 room key on your phone sort of thing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00501-00141624-00141839 through the my experience app which is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00502-00141840-00141990 pretty simple but yeah you just gotta
+oYAuIurKutQ-00503-00141991-00142159 kind of have an idea of where you're
+oYAuIurKutQ-00504-00142160-00142383 going um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00505-00142384-00142543 but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00506-00142544-00142919 we are in the new
+oYAuIurKutQ-00507-00142920-00143175 designed rooms for the all-stars
+oYAuIurKutQ-00508-00143176-00143335 um so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00509-00143336-00143566 here's a little sneak peek
+oYAuIurKutQ-00510-00143567-00144190 of what the room looks like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00511-00144191-00144463 how amazing is that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00512-00144464-00144614 it's cool so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00513-00144615-00144831 very different
+oYAuIurKutQ-00514-00144832-00145031 so obviously it's exactly the same
+oYAuIurKutQ-00515-00145032-00145231 layout as
+oYAuIurKutQ-00516-00145232-00145463 the all-star sports
+oYAuIurKutQ-00517-00145464-00145614 but obviously it's been completely
+oYAuIurKutQ-00518-00145615-00145759 redecorated
+oYAuIurKutQ-00519-00145760-00146111 and and done out so it's a little taster
+oYAuIurKutQ-00520-00146112-00146271 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00521-00146272-00146559 but i'm not gonna do a room tour yet
+oYAuIurKutQ-00522-00146560-00146735 and when we get back later i will do a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00523-00146736-00146919 room tour so that just means you have to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00524-00146920-00147078 carry on watching because at the end of
+oYAuIurKutQ-00525-00147079-00147319 the vlog there will be a room tour of
+oYAuIurKutQ-00526-00147320-00147511 this newly refurbished
+oYAuIurKutQ-00527-00147512-00147695 disney all-star music room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00528-00147696-00147878 so excited
+oYAuIurKutQ-00529-00147879-00148135 so we are ready to go yep
+oYAuIurKutQ-00530-00148136-00148431 coats on because it is fresh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00531-00148432-00148663 i've been back at home um but we've
+oYAuIurKutQ-00532-00148664-00148807 decided
+oYAuIurKutQ-00533-00148808-00149166 we are heading to our favorite park
+oYAuIurKutQ-00534-00149167-00149487 epcot and we're hopefully going to catch
+oYAuIurKutQ-00535-00149488-00149687 harmonius
+oYAuIurKutQ-00536-00149688-00149847 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00537-00149848-00150159 we need to get to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00538-00150160-00150423 the kind of reception area we're going
+oYAuIurKutQ-00539-00150424-00150647 to catch the disney bus
+oYAuIurKutQ-00540-00150648-00150951 over to epcot and then make it over to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00541-00150952-00151207 harmonios
+oYAuIurKutQ-00542-00151208-00151343 harmonious
+oYAuIurKutQ-00543-00151344-00151526 harmonious
+oYAuIurKutQ-00544-00151527-00151647 can you tell it's getting late in the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00545-00151648-00151878 jet lag it's kicking in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00546-00151879-00152551 um so yeah so we're in the calypso
+oYAuIurKutQ-00547-00152552-00152759 it's the pool anybody get in the pool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00548-00152760-00152983 right now i don't know if uh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00549-00152984-00153190 people actually would
+oYAuIurKutQ-00550-00153191-00153343 would you like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00551-00153344-00153614 i actually see your breath
+oYAuIurKutQ-00552-00153615-00153831 there is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00553-00153832-00154102 it's a calypso
+oYAuIurKutQ-00554-00154103-00154254 we will have a proper walk around the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00555-00154255-00154735 hotel but we are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00556-00154736-00154871 up against it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00557-00154872-00154999 so we need to get
+oYAuIurKutQ-00558-00155000-00155239 to the bus to get to epcot
+oYAuIurKutQ-00559-00155240-00155519 so we've made it to emco
+oYAuIurKutQ-00560-00155520-00155687 oh my god
+oYAuIurKutQ-00561-00155688-00155966 oh my god
+oYAuIurKutQ-00562-00155967-00156671 this is crazy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00563-00156672-00157119 so we just need to scan
+oYAuIurKutQ-00564-00157120-00157298 get in there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00565-00157299-00157423 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00566-00157424-00158024 look at it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00568-00161744-00162232 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00569-00162233-00163455 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00570-00163456-00164230 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00571-00164231-00164436 [Applause]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00572-00164437-00167151 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00573-00167152-00167335 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00574-00167336-00167463 so we um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00575-00167464-00167687 came into the creation
+oYAuIurKutQ-00576-00167688-00167831 store because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00577-00167832-00168023 it's absolutely freezing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00578-00168024-00168238 even for us for it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00579-00168239-00168438 but it is a little bit warmer now
+oYAuIurKutQ-00580-00168439-00168695 but it is busy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00581-00168696-00169054 in the car is busy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00582-00169055-00169175 i think a lot of people are doing the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00583-00169176-00169302 same thing though
+oYAuIurKutQ-00584-00169303-00169407 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00585-00169408-00169695 that's it but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00586-00169696-00169807 oh wow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00587-00169808-00169975 cinderella
+oYAuIurKutQ-00588-00169976-00170223 how much is that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00589-00170224-00170726 i'm going to go 180
+oYAuIurKutQ-00590-00170727-00170799 no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00591-00170800-00171166 130 130 129.99
+oYAuIurKutQ-00592-00171167-00171311 okay
+oYAuIurKutQ-00593-00171312-00171711 that's what i need right now
+oYAuIurKutQ-00594-00171712-00172351 oh my god that feels so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00595-00172352-00172535 that soft so nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00596-00172536-00172638 i don't know what it's like on the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00597-00172639-00172799 inside like um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00598-00172800-00173151 this please see yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00599-00173152-00173614 i need that now
+oYAuIurKutQ-00600-00173615-00173854 so our plan is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00601-00173855-00173999 before have a little walk around here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00602-00174000-00174143 and warm up
+oYAuIurKutQ-00603-00174144-00174375 have a proper look at the ball
+oYAuIurKutQ-00604-00174376-00174543 and then head back to the hotel and grab
+oYAuIurKutQ-00605-00174544-00174966 something to eat because we are starving
+oYAuIurKutQ-00606-00174967-00175278 i am rather hungry a disney pizza dog
+oYAuIurKutQ-00607-00175279-00175543 joe wants disney pizza we've not had
+oYAuIurKutQ-00608-00175544-00175766 dizzy pizza for a while so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00609-00175767-00176007 he wants it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00610-00176008-00176135 he's entitled to it even though he had
+oYAuIurKutQ-00611-00176136-00176526 pizza last night okay
+oYAuIurKutQ-00612-00176527-00176814 i do love what they've done with it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00613-00176815-00177087 so where's the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00614-00177088-00177254 thingy the other side of that yeah how
+oYAuIurKutQ-00615-00177255-00177759 cool it's cool is that way no it's there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00616-00177760-00177959 there's the lights yeah but you come out
+oYAuIurKutQ-00617-00177960-00178102 and go in that way yeah you don't so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00618-00178103-00178366 come forward behind all right yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00619-00178367-00178471 because there's still
+oYAuIurKutQ-00620-00178472-00178678 building there isn't it yes yeah it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00621-00178679-00178895 part of the creation store building but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00622-00178896-00179240 obviously it's cornered off
+oYAuIurKutQ-00623-00179241-00179414 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00624-00179415-00179647 popcorn
+oYAuIurKutQ-00625-00179648-00179935 that's a popcorn
+oYAuIurKutQ-00626-00179936-00180543 that's quite nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00627-00180544-00180743 that's a giant bar chocolate would you
+oYAuIurKutQ-00628-00180744-00180959 pay 25 dollars though for a borrowed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00629-00180960-00181102 chocolate
+oYAuIurKutQ-00630-00181103-00181183 yes
+oYAuIurKutQ-00631-00181184-00181478 it's got poppy popping candy in but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00632-00181479-00181695 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00633-00181696-00181902 you could buy a massive easter egg tesco
+oYAuIurKutQ-00634-00181903-00182126 for a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00635-00182127-00182438 it just looks channel much better
+oYAuIurKutQ-00636-00182439-00182799 it's just so much brighter
+oYAuIurKutQ-00637-00182800-00182999 and you get the different tone colors i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00638-00183000-00183483 think
+oYAuIurKutQ-00639-00183484-00183838 like that it's just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00640-00183839-00184054 i don't know it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00641-00184055-00184238 seeing it here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00642-00184239-00184375 is completely different to watching it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00643-00184376-00184551 on camera yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00644-00184552-00185153 on the vlog
+oYAuIurKutQ-00645-00185154-00186311 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00646-00186312-00186526 and they climbed on a ladder that is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00647-00186527-00186735 just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00648-00186736-00187014 monolith
+oYAuIurKutQ-00649-00187015-00187487 yep got monolith
+oYAuIurKutQ-00650-00187488-00187687 it's amazing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00651-00187688-00187847 but the very very original used to be
+oYAuIurKutQ-00652-00187848-00188238 like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00653-00188239-00188495 mars
+oYAuIurKutQ-00654-00188496-00188911 the ball behind
+oYAuIurKutQ-00655-00188912-00189102 look at it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00656-00189103-00189302 that's amazing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00657-00189303-00189743 just can't stop staring at it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00658-00189744-00189943 it's just unreal
+oYAuIurKutQ-00659-00189944-00190006 like
+oYAuIurKutQ-00660-00190007-00190471 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00661-00190472-00190750 is it to do the thing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00662-00190751-00191102 or is it not doing it oh sure
+oYAuIurKutQ-00663-00191103-00191271 there's so many different things that it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00664-00191272-00191607 does
+oYAuIurKutQ-00665-00191608-00191807 when it's a warmer night
+oYAuIurKutQ-00666-00191808-00191966 that's when you can
+oYAuIurKutQ-00667-00191967-00192278 stand around yeah oh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00668-00192279-00192952 this is it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00669-00192953-00193071 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00670-00193072-00193943 i don't think so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00671-00193944-00194119 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00672-00194120-00194425 we've got here we've watched harmonias
+oYAuIurKutQ-00673-00194426-00194566 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00674-00194567-00194868 we saw the ep football before the 50th
+oYAuIurKutQ-00675-00194869-00194975 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00676-00194976-00195199 like oh my god it's just amazing it's so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00677-00195200-00195431 pretty but now it's time to eat so we
+oYAuIurKutQ-00678-00195432-00195599 are going to jump back on the bus on
+oYAuIurKutQ-00679-00195600-00195847 your bus get back to the hotel
+oYAuIurKutQ-00680-00195848-00196126 get some food and then
+oYAuIurKutQ-00681-00196127-00196302 we need to do a room tour
+oYAuIurKutQ-00682-00196303-00196526 yeah we've not done that yet so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00683-00196527-00196799 let's go and do that now come with me
+oYAuIurKutQ-00684-00196800-00197031 and back in the room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00685-00197032-00197254 oh so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00686-00197255-00197454 that was quite easy again we've had a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00687-00197455-00197575 really
+oYAuIurKutQ-00688-00197576-00197783 simple easy day
+oYAuIurKutQ-00689-00197784-00197911 got to the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00690-00197912-00198063 bus stop and the bus would pretty much
+oYAuIurKutQ-00691-00198064-00198278 went in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00692-00198279-00198566 and we then stopped
+oYAuIurKutQ-00693-00198567-00198695 for food
+oYAuIurKutQ-00694-00198696-00198943 what did we get
+oYAuIurKutQ-00695-00198944-00199302 pizza
+oYAuIurKutQ-00696-00199303-00199414 oh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00697-00199415-00199775 i can't wait to smash it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00698-00199776-00200087 joe's hungry i'm very hungry
+oYAuIurKutQ-00699-00200088-00200199 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00700-00200200-00200631 yeah so we're gonna eat
+oYAuIurKutQ-00701-00200632-00200831 room tour
+oYAuIurKutQ-00702-00200832-00201126 and then we're going to call it a night
+oYAuIurKutQ-00703-00201127-00201487 don't unpack we have got unpack
+oYAuIurKutQ-00704-00201488-00201647 and then call it a night
+oYAuIurKutQ-00705-00201648-00201719 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00706-00201720-00201838 let's enjoy pizza
+oYAuIurKutQ-00707-00201839-00202071 and we'll have a tour
+oYAuIurKutQ-00708-00202072-00202399 so we've eaten
+oYAuIurKutQ-00709-00202400-00202654 filled a hole it was needed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00710-00202655-00202902 yet it is now time
+oYAuIurKutQ-00711-00202903-00203223 for the disney all-star music
+oYAuIurKutQ-00712-00203224-00203478 room tour
+oYAuIurKutQ-00713-00203479-00203654 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00714-00203655-00203823 the room is the same as the normal
+oYAuIurKutQ-00715-00203824-00204226 all-stars room however the decor
+oYAuIurKutQ-00716-00204227-00204487 completely refurbed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00717-00204488-00204711 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00718-00204712-00204919 let's start
+oYAuIurKutQ-00719-00204919-00205190 in the kind of main living bedroom area
+oYAuIurKutQ-00720-00205191-00205319 shall we
+oYAuIurKutQ-00721-00205319-00205510 so as you come in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00722-00205511-00205694 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00723-00205696-00205910 you come in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00724-00205911-00206086 you now have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00725-00206087-00206310 where joe is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00726-00206311-00206431 modeling
+oYAuIurKutQ-00727-00206432-00206527 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00728-00206528-00206655 this lovely
+oYAuIurKutQ-00729-00206656-00206766 table
+oYAuIurKutQ-00730-00206767-00207055 and chair where we just sat with pizza
+oYAuIurKutQ-00731-00207056-00207206 which is quite handy yeah it's quite
+oYAuIurKutQ-00732-00207207-00207558 nice to have somewhere to sit
+oYAuIurKutQ-00733-00207559-00207831 the other table used to be over here it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00734-00207832-00207990 used to be right here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00735-00207991-00208079 yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00736-00208080-00208238 but you used never
+oYAuIurKutQ-00737-00208239-00208334 tv
+oYAuIurKutQ-00738-00208335-00208471 no not if you were sat here you couldn't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00739-00208471-00208686 see a tv
+oYAuIurKutQ-00740-00208687-00208758 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00741-00208759-00208975 you have this cabinet here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00742-00208976-00209079 so you've got some shelving you've got
+oYAuIurKutQ-00743-00209080-00209303 your tea coffee
+oYAuIurKutQ-00744-00209304-00209534 you've got drawer space
+oYAuIurKutQ-00745-00209535-00209910 nice good size deep drawers
+oYAuIurKutQ-00746-00209911-00210294 fridge which we currently have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00747-00210296-00210582 um a bottle of pepsi a can of red wine
+oYAuIurKutQ-00748-00210583-00210734 from the plain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00749-00210735-00211119 some whisper dairy milk and wine gums
+oYAuIurKutQ-00750-00211119-00211285 healthy
+oYAuIurKutQ-00751-00211286-00211471 [Music]
+oYAuIurKutQ-00752-00211471-00211639 um lovely light
+oYAuIurKutQ-00753-00211640-00211823 that's funky
+oYAuIurKutQ-00754-00211823-00211910 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00755-00211911-00212206 but yes we've got nice funky chairs
+oYAuIurKutQ-00756-00212207-00212431 and these have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00757-00212432-00212934 well i'm just looking at this because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00758-00212935-00213134 well
+oYAuIurKutQ-00759-00213135-00213446 should these be for sports i know it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00760-00213448-00213719 all of them so you've got
+oYAuIurKutQ-00761-00213719-00214094 you've got sports you've got movies
+oYAuIurKutQ-00762-00214096-00214342 and you've got music
+oYAuIurKutQ-00763-00214344-00214606 that's quite cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00764-00214607-00214815 you got a little bedside table
+oYAuIurKutQ-00765-00214816-00214919 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00766-00214919-00215127 telephone quite a small telephone
+oYAuIurKutQ-00767-00215128-00215255 and then you have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00768-00215256-00215591 your bed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00769-00215592-00215903 so as you can see it's quite a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00770-00215904-00216023 a large
+oYAuIurKutQ-00771-00216023-00216271 bed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00772-00216271-00216479 nice bit of artwork above
+oYAuIurKutQ-00773-00216480-00216798 and these are lights on the other side
+oYAuIurKutQ-00774-00216800-00216975 that's cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00775-00216976-00217127 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00776-00217128-00217663 more storage some more drawer space
+oYAuIurKutQ-00777-00217664-00217839 you then have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00778-00217840-00218151 if i could open the drawer a drawer here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00779-00218152-00218327 that has your
+oYAuIurKutQ-00780-00218328-00218423 safe
+oYAuIurKutQ-00781-00218423-00218791 hairy bible again more drawer space
+oYAuIurKutQ-00782-00218792-00218998 joe's not put his cases away yet they
+oYAuIurKutQ-00783-00219000-00219198 just look a bit cluttered on the side
+oYAuIurKutQ-00784-00219200-00219351 apologies
+oYAuIurKutQ-00785-00219352-00219598 tv a bit of frozen
+oYAuIurKutQ-00786-00219600-00219767 and this is a massive tv i think this is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00787-00219767-00219991 like a 55 inch tv so it's a lot bigger
+oYAuIurKutQ-00788-00219992-00220094 than the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00789-00220096-00220310 tv that we used to have
+oYAuIurKutQ-00790-00220311-00220439 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00791-00220440-00220727 and we can't show you right now because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00792-00220728-00220871 obviously
+oYAuIurKutQ-00793-00220871-00221039 we've been eating so if it's there but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00794-00221040-00221182 this
+oYAuIurKutQ-00795-00221183-00221494 is a pull down bed so i will show you
+oYAuIurKutQ-00796-00221496-00221734 that in a minute maybe joe will move
+oYAuIurKutQ-00797-00221735-00221975 the stuff off the table if i will i go
+oYAuIurKutQ-00798-00221976-00222206 and show you the bathroom
+oYAuIurKutQ-00799-00222207-00222423 bathroom hello mirror
+oYAuIurKutQ-00800-00222423-00222655 so this is all cool nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00801-00222656-00222767 new mirror
+oYAuIurKutQ-00802-00222767-00222919 massive
+oYAuIurKutQ-00803-00222919-00223206 you've got some more storage
+oYAuIurKutQ-00804-00223207-00223382 some shelving
+oYAuIurKutQ-00805-00223383-00223519 hair dryer
+oYAuIurKutQ-00806-00223519-00223727 iron
+oYAuIurKutQ-00807-00223728-00223910 tissues
+oYAuIurKutQ-00808-00223911-00224255 ironing board
+oYAuIurKutQ-00809-00224256-00224391 hangers
+oYAuIurKutQ-00810-00224392-00224791 more shelving for storage
+oYAuIurKutQ-00811-00224792-00225094 more storage here and i think funky
+oYAuIurKutQ-00812-00225096-00225239 little taps
+oYAuIurKutQ-00813-00225240-00225575 running water again always a good sign
+oYAuIurKutQ-00814-00225576-00225806 you've got your towels
+oYAuIurKutQ-00815-00225807-00226087 nice we're tissues so again loads and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00816-00226088-00226567 loads of storage
+oYAuIurKutQ-00817-00226567-00226910 joe's making a racket
+oYAuIurKutQ-00818-00226911-00227503 here's a little lamp look at that wow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00819-00227504-00227791 that's quite cool and then
+oYAuIurKutQ-00820-00227792-00228063 we have the renovated bathroom so these
+oYAuIurKutQ-00821-00228064-00228182 are
+oYAuIurKutQ-00822-00228183-00228415 sliding doors with another full standing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00823-00228416-00228663 mirror
+oYAuIurKutQ-00824-00228664-00228839 look at that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00825-00228840-00229103 that's cool and then inside
+oYAuIurKutQ-00826-00229104-00229455 this is your bathroom
+oYAuIurKutQ-00827-00229456-00229679 so this is cool this is this is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00828-00229680-00230046 different to what you've had before
+oYAuIurKutQ-00829-00230048-00230215 because you used to just have like the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00830-00230216-00230415 curtain the disney
+oYAuIurKutQ-00831-00230416-00230534 curtain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00832-00230535-00230727 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00833-00230728-00230934 nice tile in a little
+oYAuIurKutQ-00834-00230935-00231215 recess for you to put your
+oYAuIurKutQ-00835-00231216-00231471 you know your shampoo your conditioner
+oYAuIurKutQ-00836-00231471-00231798 you obviously got the disney h2o
+oYAuIurKutQ-00837-00231800-00231991 products
+oYAuIurKutQ-00838-00231992-00232287 it's a bit like a rainfall shower
+oYAuIurKutQ-00839-00232288-00232367 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00840-00232367-00232519 for little ones that could maybe be a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00841-00232519-00232846 bath obviously bath
+oYAuIurKutQ-00842-00232848-00233175 toilet towels more towels
+oYAuIurKutQ-00843-00233176-00233439 not the softest but hey
+oYAuIurKutQ-00844-00233440-00233606 but no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00845-00233607-00233775 that's really really nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00846-00233776-00234127 and as if by magic we are ready to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00847-00234128-00234679 display the pull-down bed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00848-00234680-00235031 so yeah you pull it down
+oYAuIurKutQ-00849-00235032-00235319 and it just goes down
+oYAuIurKutQ-00850-00235319-00235598 they've not made it though no
+oYAuIurKutQ-00851-00235600-00235894 keep going keep going
+oYAuIurKutQ-00852-00235896-00236223 and you now have another full-size bed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00853-00236223-00236310 which
+oYAuIurKutQ-00854-00236311-00236455 what i love
+oYAuIurKutQ-00855-00236456-00236727 is the artwork at the back
+oYAuIurKutQ-00856-00236728-00236951 i'll get a bit closer so you can see it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00857-00236952-00237071 it's cute
+oYAuIurKutQ-00858-00237071-00237279 that is so cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00859-00237280-00237582 huey dewey and louie
+oYAuIurKutQ-00860-00237583-00237742 look at them
+oYAuIurKutQ-00861-00237744-00237919 just hasn't got a duvet on it this is
+oYAuIurKutQ-00862-00237919-00238151 more like the summer one
+oYAuIurKutQ-00863-00238152-00238342 that's cool but yeah so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00864-00238344-00238519 you know and i mean in case you didn't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00865-00238519-00238758 notice there are eight pillows here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00866-00238759-00238887 obviously you're not gonna use them all
+oYAuIurKutQ-00867-00238888-00239071 but you could then take four of them and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00868-00239071-00239223 put them over here
+oYAuIurKutQ-00869-00239223-00239582 um but even with the bed down
+oYAuIurKutQ-00870-00239583-00239791 still plenty of room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00871-00239792-00240046 it's like normal this is this is normal
+oYAuIurKutQ-00872-00240048-00240223 yeah because you would normally have the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00873-00240223-00240406 kind of the two beds
+oYAuIurKutQ-00874-00240407-00240687 but it's it's cool i like it it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00875-00240688-00240879 really nice room it's hard flooring now
+oYAuIurKutQ-00876-00240880-00241071 this used to be carpeted
+oYAuIurKutQ-00877-00241071-00241327 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00878-00241328-00241446 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00879-00241448-00241782 we brought well i brought slippers
+oYAuIurKutQ-00880-00241783-00241942 joey's got flip flops because i'm
+oYAuIurKutQ-00881-00241944-00242134 thinking on a morning
+oYAuIurKutQ-00882-00242135-00242294 if it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00883-00242296-00242615 cool then that floor might be a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00884-00242616-00242910 bit too cold on the feet so yeah but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00885-00242911-00243119 great room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00886-00243119-00243246 can't complain
+oYAuIurKutQ-00887-00243248-00243446 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00888-00243448-00243567 i love what they've done with it and i
+oYAuIurKutQ-00889-00243567-00243830 think all the all-stars
+oYAuIurKutQ-00890-00243831-00244063 are are getting this makeover so movies
+oYAuIurKutQ-00891-00244064-00244358 definitely is obviously music now and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00892-00244359-00244598 i'm guessing sports
+oYAuIurKutQ-00893-00244600-00245006 will be done once it's once it's open
+oYAuIurKutQ-00894-00245007-00245082 oh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00895-00245083-00245255 jose
+oYAuIurKutQ-00896-00245256-00245463 putting it back
+oYAuIurKutQ-00897-00245464-00245630 it's clever how all this goes and it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00898-00245631-00245703 just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00899-00245704-00245894 just folds
+oYAuIurKutQ-00900-00245896-00246094 but it does feel nice
+oYAuIurKutQ-00901-00246096-00246319 sturdy and it is nice having this kind
+oYAuIurKutQ-00902-00246319-00246446 of large
+oYAuIurKutQ-00903-00246448-00246694 seating area whether you're just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00904-00246696-00246927 sat down doing stuff
+oYAuIurKutQ-00905-00246928-00247230 or you know eating eating pizza
+oYAuIurKutQ-00906-00247231-00247534 um so there you have it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00907-00247535-00247798 that's the room
+oYAuIurKutQ-00908-00247800-00247958 so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00909-00247959-00248142 show you a viewer in the morning yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00910-00248144-00248319 we'll show you outside
+oYAuIurKutQ-00911-00248319-00248510 we're kind of looking out over to also
+oYAuIurKutQ-00912-00248511-00248679 movies that's the kind of direction that
+oYAuIurKutQ-00913-00248680-00248767 we're in
+oYAuIurKutQ-00914-00248767-00248871 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00915-00248871-00249094 but no that's travel day then pretty
+oYAuIurKutQ-00916-00249096-00249263 much
+oYAuIurKutQ-00917-00249264-00249367 it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00918-00249367-00249630 been a long day
+oYAuIurKutQ-00919-00249631-00249871 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00920-00249871-00250215 flying here absolute breeze
+oYAuIurKutQ-00921-00250216-00250527 just long it's been a long day but it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00922-00250528-00250703 been a good day
+oYAuIurKutQ-00923-00250704-00250839 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00924-00250840-00250967 the whole
+oYAuIurKutQ-00925-00250967-00251239 covered testing and all that stuff oh
+oYAuIurKutQ-00926-00251240-00251423 yeah been a breeze absolutely breeze
+oYAuIurKutQ-00927-00251423-00251655 customs um delight
+oYAuIurKutQ-00928-00251656-00251815 we mentioned it earlier
+oYAuIurKutQ-00929-00251816-00251982 if you're coming to florida or you're
+oYAuIurKutQ-00930-00251983-00252223 flying anywhere with virgin then use the
+oYAuIurKutQ-00931-00252223-00252479 virgin fly ready to upload your
+oYAuIurKutQ-00932-00252480-00252630 vaccination
+oYAuIurKutQ-00933-00252631-00252903 document and your cover testing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00934-00252904-00253071 documents because
+oYAuIurKutQ-00935-00253071-00253255 literally it's just gonna save you so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00936-00253256-00253482 much time at the airport
+oYAuIurKutQ-00937-00253483-00253671 um
+oYAuIurKutQ-00938-00253671-00253958 yeah i i can't fault that whole process
+oYAuIurKutQ-00939-00253959-00254230 i've i've loved it yeah um i think
+oYAuIurKutQ-00940-00254231-00254567 they're very very
+oYAuIurKutQ-00941-00254567-00254775 like stressed like lucky yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00942-00254776-00254982 stress-free and actually i just thought
+oYAuIurKutQ-00943-00254983-00255127 the only thing i would we have got a
+oYAuIurKutQ-00944-00255128-00255303 complaint about we mentioned we would
+oYAuIurKutQ-00945-00255304-00255430 tell you earlier which i've just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00946-00255431-00255710 remembered um yeah so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00947-00255711-00255951 number one lounge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00948-00255952-00256198 so we didn't film anything in the number
+oYAuIurKutQ-00949-00256200-00256319 one lounge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00950-00256319-00256623 because it was
+oYAuIurKutQ-00951-00256623-00256879 horrendous horrendous it was jam-packed
+oYAuIurKutQ-00952-00256880-00257134 there was nowhere to sit nowhere to sit
+oYAuIurKutQ-00953-00257135-00257334 um we i mean we did manage to find
+oYAuIurKutQ-00954-00257335-00257527 somewhere in like the cinema area so we
+oYAuIurKutQ-00955-00257528-00257671 had to be quiet hence why we couldn't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00956-00257671-00257830 really get the camera out and start
+oYAuIurKutQ-00957-00257831-00257942 talking
+oYAuIurKutQ-00958-00257944-00258151 um so it was very very dark because it
+oYAuIurKutQ-00959-00258152-00258375 was all curtained off yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00960-00258376-00258606 we managed to have something to eat but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00961-00258607-00258894 basically they let far too many people
+oYAuIurKutQ-00962-00258896-00259119 in so
+oYAuIurKutQ-00963-00259119-00259367 if you're limited on space do you need
+oYAuIurKutQ-00964-00259367-00259503 to limit the number of people you allow
+oYAuIurKutQ-00965-00259504-00259710 in as you go in there is a bar area just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00966-00259711-00259894 to the left and
+oYAuIurKutQ-00967-00259896-00260175 you can barely even walk through
+oYAuIurKutQ-00968-00260176-00260415 the amount of people but yeah nowhere to
+oYAuIurKutQ-00969-00260416-00260551 sit that was just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00970-00260552-00260734 so i would not recommend number one
+oYAuIurKutQ-00971-00260735-00260967 lounge i would say
+oYAuIurKutQ-00972-00260967-00261191 there's plenty of places in the main
+oYAuIurKutQ-00973-00261192-00261342 departures area
+oYAuIurKutQ-00974-00261344-00261527 to go for food yeah i wouldn't
+oYAuIurKutQ-00975-00261528-00261742 necessarily do a lounge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00976-00261744-00261910 it was really pink and it looked quite
+oYAuIurKutQ-00977-00261911-00262087 cool it's all like pink the camera it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-00978-00262088-00262310 called i karen boy it's cool it's called
+oYAuIurKutQ-00979-00262311-00262487 i'll put it in the description off i'll
+oYAuIurKutQ-00980-00262488-00262663 look it up
+oYAuIurKutQ-00981-00262664-00262799 yeah that looked like a really nice cool
+oYAuIurKutQ-00982-00262800-00263087 funky place to get to go to eat um but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00983-00263088-00263319 yeah so that's why so if you're looking
+oYAuIurKutQ-00984-00263320-00263495 to book a lounge don't book number one
+oYAuIurKutQ-00985-00263496-00263599 lounge
+oYAuIurKutQ-00986-00263600-00263799 in our opinion in my opinion i just
+oYAuIurKutQ-00987-00263800-00263951 wouldn't waste my money toy games as
+oYAuIurKutQ-00988-00263952-00264263 well you were there
+oYAuIurKutQ-00989-00264264-00264479 about six or seven people just queuing
+oYAuIurKutQ-00990-00264480-00264679 to go in the toilets yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00991-00264680-00264943 so i'd say it's a no for that but
+oYAuIurKutQ-00992-00264944-00265239 besides the lounge everything today has
+oYAuIurKutQ-00993-00265240-00265334 been
+oYAuIurKutQ-00994-00265335-00265487 spot on yeah
+oYAuIurKutQ-00995-00265488-00265758 um so we hope you've enjoyed watching
+oYAuIurKutQ-00996-00265759-00266039 our travel day to disney world after
+oYAuIurKutQ-00997-00266040-00266399 two in a bit years um tomorrow or next
+oYAuIurKutQ-00998-00266400-00266543 week for you when you watch the next
+oYAuIurKutQ-00999-00266544-00266830 vlog um we're heading over to the magic
+oYAuIurKutQ-01000-00266831-00267055 kingdom as you do
+oYAuIurKutQ-01001-00267056-00267230 yeah day one day one you have to go to
+oYAuIurKutQ-01002-00267231-00267351 my kingdom
+oYAuIurKutQ-01003-00267352-00267687 um so it's gonna be an early start
+oYAuIurKutQ-01004-00267688-00267871 so if you want to see that you need to
+oYAuIurKutQ-01005-00267872-00268047 make sure you subscribed
+oYAuIurKutQ-01006-00268048-00268247 and if you've enjoyed this video then
+oYAuIurKutQ-01007-00268248-00268399 give it the thumbs up
+oYAuIurKutQ-01008-00268400-00268663 um but pretty much that's travel day
+oYAuIurKutQ-01009-00268664-00268967 welcome back to walt disney world
+oYAuIurKutQ-01010-00268968-00269191 we're here thanks for watching it's
+oYAuIurKutQ-01011-00269192-00269327 adios for me
+oYAuIurKutQ-01012-00269328-00269578 cheerio
+oYAuIurKutQ-01014-00272792-00273000 you
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00000-00000023-00000799 [Music]
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00001-00000800-00001203 so
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00003-00011928-00012089 so
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00004-00012090-00013215 [Music]
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00005-00013216-00013679 so
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00006-00013680-00014607 [Music]
+oZhJGWdj7kA-00007-00014608-00014816 you
+oalyXilc6wo-00000-00000026-00001135 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00001-00001136-00001247 what is good everybody welcome to an
+oalyXilc6wo-00002-00001248-00001470 epic modern toys video today ladies and
+oalyXilc6wo-00003-00001471-00001687 gentlemen we have a brand new wwe action
+oalyXilc6wo-00004-00001688-00001751 figure
+oalyXilc6wo-00005-00001752-00001975 i i want to say it surgery to be honest
+oalyXilc6wo-00006-00001976-00002110 with you guys i ran through the
+oalyXilc6wo-00007-00002111-00002295 through the mill i had everything set up
+oalyXilc6wo-00008-00002296-00002463 for surgery the ambulance is even back
+oalyXilc6wo-00009-00002464-00002558 here i even had
+oalyXilc6wo-00010-00002559-00002726 the thumbnail laid out and then at the
+oalyXilc6wo-00011-00002727-00002926 end of the day i started recollecting my
+oalyXilc6wo-00012-00002927-00003047 thoughts and i was like you know what
+oalyXilc6wo-00013-00003048-00003095 brad
+oalyXilc6wo-00014-00003096-00003327 is this enough is this enough to do a
+oalyXilc6wo-00015-00003328-00003511 surgery episode i feel like it honestly
+oalyXilc6wo-00016-00003511-00003663 is but you guys know i don't i don't
+oalyXilc6wo-00017-00003664-00003822 make the football rules i just
+oalyXilc6wo-00018-00003823-00004047 i just deal with them so today we have
+oalyXilc6wo-00019-00004047-00004238 elise series 83 feature we got edge we
+oalyXilc6wo-00020-00004239-00004454 got trash corbin we got shorty g
+oalyXilc6wo-00021-00004455-00004686 slash chad gable and today we got some
+oalyXilc6wo-00022-00004687-00004863 epic fix ups that i want to do to the
+oalyXilc6wo-00023-00004864-00005151 elite 83 edge to the trash corbin to the
+oalyXilc6wo-00024-00005152-00005302 chad gable that's what we do on
+oalyXilc6wo-00025-00005303-00005479 appointment on surgery so i changed it
+oalyXilc6wo-00026-00005480-00005702 to an appointment episode simply because
+oalyXilc6wo-00027-00005703-00005799 even though we have
+oalyXilc6wo-00028-00005800-00006015 like a torso crack we have freaking
+oalyXilc6wo-00029-00006016-00006151 paint on this episode this should
+oalyXilc6wo-00030-00006152-00006238 absolutely
+oalyXilc6wo-00031-00006239-00006518 be a surgery video and honestly now that
+oalyXilc6wo-00032-00006519-00006663 i'm sitting here thinking about it i
+oalyXilc6wo-00033-00006664-00006831 really want to change it but then i was
+oalyXilc6wo-00034-00006831-00006919 like you know what
+oalyXilc6wo-00035-00006920-00007134 why is it this is surgery i don't know
+oalyXilc6wo-00036-00007136-00007287 are less people gonna watch because they
+oalyXilc6wo-00037-00007288-00007446 think it's an appointment you're lost
+oalyXilc6wo-00038-00007447-00007598 brad because i think we got some fire
+oalyXilc6wo-00039-00007600-00007798 stuff coming in but elite 83 you guys
+oalyXilc6wo-00040-00007800-00007934 know we would have done like a full
+oalyXilc6wo-00041-00007936-00008103 surgery video usually we get the full
+oalyXilc6wo-00042-00008104-00008271 wave in here and then we do a surgery on
+oalyXilc6wo-00043-00008272-00008414 the elite series that we got because we
+oalyXilc6wo-00044-00008415-00008567 need to fix some things about the wave
+oalyXilc6wo-00045-00008568-00008687 that's what we do here
+oalyXilc6wo-00046-00008688-00008878 so the things that i was running over in
+oalyXilc6wo-00047-00008879-00009078 my mind is trash corbin can be fixed up
+oalyXilc6wo-00048-00009079-00009263 edge can be fixed up who else is in the
+oalyXilc6wo-00049-00009264-00009446 way drew mcintyre can't really fix him
+oalyXilc6wo-00050-00009447-00009614 up i think he looks damn good i like to
+oalyXilc6wo-00051-00009615-00009783 what he's got going on i think it's a
+oalyXilc6wo-00052-00009784-00009871 really good figure
+oalyXilc6wo-00053-00009872-00010039 sasha banks really nothing i can fix up
+oalyXilc6wo-00054-00010040-00010199 about her nothing's really standing out
+oalyXilc6wo-00055-00010200-00010342 to me or anything like that and then you
+oalyXilc6wo-00056-00010343-00010542 have dusty rhodes who again just nothing
+oalyXilc6wo-00057-00010543-00010687 really fix up about
+oalyXilc6wo-00058-00010688-00010863 picks up a ball about him you know you
+oalyXilc6wo-00059-00010864-00011055 get it so really i'm just sitting here i
+oalyXilc6wo-00060-00011056-00011199 may change the name of the thing the
+oalyXilc6wo-00061-00011200-00011383 surgery i don't know we'll we'll just
+oalyXilc6wo-00062-00011384-00011423 see
+oalyXilc6wo-00063-00011424-00011663 it's a lot of garbage i i don't freaking
+oalyXilc6wo-00064-00011664-00011767 know man we're just going to see how
+oalyXilc6wo-00065-00011768-00011799 this
+oalyXilc6wo-00066-00011800-00011999 goes if so if you see the thumbnail and
+oalyXilc6wo-00067-00012000-00012167 it ends up looking like a like a
+oalyXilc6wo-00068-00012168-00012231 freaking
+oalyXilc6wo-00069-00012232-00012399 surgery thumbnail and it ends up
+oalyXilc6wo-00070-00012400-00012574 changing to this just know that my mind
+oalyXilc6wo-00071-00012575-00012735 was all kind of mixed and wacky and
+oalyXilc6wo-00072-00012736-00012902 there goes trash corbin but let's just
+oalyXilc6wo-00073-00012903-00013030 shut the hell up and dive into it
+oalyXilc6wo-00074-00013031-00013063 because
+oalyXilc6wo-00075-00013063-00013199 appointment's supposed to be 12 minutes
+oalyXilc6wo-00076-00013200-00013343 or less i doubt we get that because i've
+oalyXilc6wo-00077-00013344-00013519 already been yapping for freaking two
+oalyXilc6wo-00078-00013519-00013663 minutes but let's shut the hell up and
+oalyXilc6wo-00079-00013663-00013830 dive in guys before we get into things i
+oalyXilc6wo-00080-00013831-00013991 want to give a huge shout out to my man
+oalyXilc6wo-00081-00013991-00014151 ryan there's three different ways you
+oalyXilc6wo-00082-00014152-00014271 can pronounce his name it's either
+oalyXilc6wo-00083-00014272-00014479 balissa belyso or belial
+oalyXilc6wo-00084-00014480-00014671 and he hooked me up with this sick ass
+oalyXilc6wo-00085-00014672-00014879 shorty g head sculpt for no reason i
+oalyXilc6wo-00086-00014880-00015086 pretty much he had this lit he had like
+oalyXilc6wo-00087-00015087-00015247 these things listed on facebook
+oalyXilc6wo-00088-00015247-00015430 of some parts i needed like some neck
+oalyXilc6wo-00089-00015431-00015599 pegs and some torso pieces
+oalyXilc6wo-00090-00015600-00015783 for torso cracks and stuff and i really
+oalyXilc6wo-00091-00015784-00015966 wanted it so i contacted him about it he
+oalyXilc6wo-00092-00015968-00016103 said he didn't know what the price is so
+oalyXilc6wo-00093-00016104-00016263 he just shipped it to me didn't have to
+oalyXilc6wo-00094-00016263-00016439 do that i would have easily paid for him
+oalyXilc6wo-00095-00016440-00016630 but he's a standout guy he's a baller so
+oalyXilc6wo-00096-00016631-00016663 he
+oalyXilc6wo-00097-00016664-00016894 sent me not only the stuff that i wanted
+oalyXilc6wo-00098-00016895-00017103 but also this shorty g head sculpt as
+oalyXilc6wo-00099-00017104-00017183 well as
+oalyXilc6wo-00100-00017184-00017391 a nicky spirit squad head sculpt that's
+oalyXilc6wo-00101-00017392-00017527 over there somewhere i'll have to go
+oalyXilc6wo-00102-00017528-00017671 find it but a huge shout out to ryan man
+oalyXilc6wo-00103-00017672-00017807 thank you so very much for that he said
+oalyXilc6wo-00104-00017808-00017935 he was a big fan of the channel
+oalyXilc6wo-00105-00017936-00018079 so a huge shout out to you bro you
+oalyXilc6wo-00106-00018080-00018222 helped me out more than you will ever
+oalyXilc6wo-00107-00018223-00018255 know
+oalyXilc6wo-00108-00018256-00018439 and i really appreciate it so what we're
+oalyXilc6wo-00109-00018440-00018591 going to do today guys is do the fix up
+oalyXilc6wo-00110-00018592-00018743 where we switch out the chat gable head
+oalyXilc6wo-00111-00018744-00018871 scope for this i think it's going to be
+oalyXilc6wo-00112-00018872-00019039 really sick you guys know we did torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00113-00019040-00019247 swap this a few weeks back i do believe
+oalyXilc6wo-00114-00019248-00019391 or something like that i also want to
+oalyXilc6wo-00115-00019392-00019599 apologize for the no upload yesterday i
+oalyXilc6wo-00116-00019600-00019711 wanted to take a
+oalyXilc6wo-00117-00019712-00019950 for a day off and just kind of relax my
+oalyXilc6wo-00118-00019951-00020086 mind after trying to get the you know
+oalyXilc6wo-00119-00020087-00020263 the show up and the stress of that so i
+oalyXilc6wo-00120-00020264-00020407 do apologize for that but i wanted to
+oalyXilc6wo-00121-00020408-00020519 get that in there so
+oalyXilc6wo-00122-00020520-00020719 spent some family time got to chill out
+oalyXilc6wo-00123-00020720-00020878 a little bit but here we are today guys
+oalyXilc6wo-00124-00020879-00020991 back at it you gotta
+oalyXilc6wo-00125-00020992-00021135 you gotta know we're back at it here
+oalyXilc6wo-00126-00021136-00021343 next up guys is trash corbin we have
+oalyXilc6wo-00127-00021344-00021519 trash corbin right we have the new elite
+oalyXilc6wo-00128-00021520-00021719 83 his heights not right
+oalyXilc6wo-00129-00021720-00021847 anything like that but to me that
+oalyXilc6wo-00130-00021848-00022111 doesn't really football matter today
+oalyXilc6wo-00131-00022112-00022294 we're taking this trash corbin and we're
+oalyXilc6wo-00132-00022295-00022503 putting this bald head sculpt and crown
+oalyXilc6wo-00133-00022504-00022711 over onto our trash corbin figure to
+oalyXilc6wo-00134-00022712-00022927 update our trash you guys know fig skip
+oalyXilc6wo-00135-00022928-00023086 made this because i accidentally threw
+oalyXilc6wo-00136-00023087-00023158 mine away
+oalyXilc6wo-00137-00023159-00023383 like a dumb jackass i guess that one had
+oalyXilc6wo-00138-00023384-00023535 it coming after all these years
+oalyXilc6wo-00139-00023536-00023663 i got hooked up with another one of
+oalyXilc6wo-00140-00023664-00023847 those so i figured go ahead put the ball
+oalyXilc6wo-00141-00023848-00024086 trash king head sculpt over here and fix
+oalyXilc6wo-00142-00024087-00024263 that guy up so we will be doing that
+oalyXilc6wo-00143-00024264-00024439 and then last but not least guys we are
+oalyXilc6wo-00144-00024440-00024607 getting into the big daddy of them all
+oalyXilc6wo-00145-00024608-00024839 we're gonna fix up our elite 83
+oalyXilc6wo-00146-00024840-00024991 edge now there are some things about
+oalyXilc6wo-00147-00024992-00025150 this figure that we already know right i
+oalyXilc6wo-00148-00025151-00025199 mean there's
+oalyXilc6wo-00149-00025200-00025399 there's some pretty good inaccuracies
+oalyXilc6wo-00150-00025400-00025567 about it love the head sculpt i think
+oalyXilc6wo-00151-00025568-00025743 this was the best figure in elite 83
+oalyXilc6wo-00152-00025744-00025806 however
+oalyXilc6wo-00153-00025807-00026014 the torso is too small brad i mean edge
+oalyXilc6wo-00154-00026016-00026214 was completely ripped up we got to fix
+oalyXilc6wo-00155-00026216-00026374 this right we got to get this guy back
+oalyXilc6wo-00156-00026375-00026567 in the gym and we got to fix him up also
+oalyXilc6wo-00157-00026568-00026727 his hands not accurate
+oalyXilc6wo-00158-00026727-00026974 also his elbow pads aren't accurate also
+oalyXilc6wo-00159-00026975-00027151 his shoes aren't accurate so we're gonna
+oalyXilc6wo-00160-00027152-00027231 have to do the full
+oalyXilc6wo-00161-00027232-00027414 gear we're gonna have to do the black
+oalyXilc6wo-00162-00027416-00027567 circles on the elbow pads we're gonna
+oalyXilc6wo-00163-00027568-00027702 have to put the right
+oalyXilc6wo-00164-00027704-00027951 black hand tape a wrist tape onto the
+oalyXilc6wo-00165-00027952-00028095 right hand we're also gonna have to
+oalyXilc6wo-00166-00028095-00028262 paint the shoes in the chrome color i
+oalyXilc6wo-00167-00028263-00028351 was really hoping
+oalyXilc6wo-00168-00028352-00028511 that the figure would include the chrome
+oalyXilc6wo-00169-00028512-00028670 shoes they didn't we're gonna have to
+oalyXilc6wo-00170-00028672-00028783 add it ourselves
+oalyXilc6wo-00171-00028783-00028951 and last but not least we're gonna be
+oalyXilc6wo-00172-00028952-00029223 putting this elite 23 cesaro torso on
+oalyXilc6wo-00173-00029224-00029270 here
+oalyXilc6wo-00174-00029272-00029462 to give him the ripped up torso with the
+oalyXilc6wo-00175-00029463-00029599 chest hair and stomach hair
+oalyXilc6wo-00176-00029600-00029783 in the right skin tone so i think it's
+oalyXilc6wo-00177-00029783-00029983 going to work out i already
+oalyXilc6wo-00178-00029983-00030207 pre-planned it i made this head sculpt
+oalyXilc6wo-00179-00030208-00030414 interchangeable need to do a tutorial on
+oalyXilc6wo-00180-00030416-00030551 that but i made this head sculpt
+oalyXilc6wo-00181-00030552-00030727 interchangeable made sure that this neck
+oalyXilc6wo-00182-00030727-00030839 peg would look good
+oalyXilc6wo-00183-00030839-00031023 on this and you know this head scope
+oalyXilc6wo-00184-00031024-00031199 would fit this this torso correct and
+oalyXilc6wo-00185-00031200-00031311 everything and i think it's going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00186-00031312-00031502 turn out pretty damn fire so
+oalyXilc6wo-00187-00031503-00031702 what we're going to do is go ahead and
+oalyXilc6wo-00188-00031703-00031911 crack this torso get all this stuff
+oalyXilc6wo-00189-00031912-00032111 going the more i sit here in the talk
+oalyXilc6wo-00190-00032112-00032270 the more i'm sitting here thinking this
+oalyXilc6wo-00191-00032272-00032470 would be surgery so it may end up being
+oalyXilc6wo-00192-00032472-00032687 surgery but anyways guys let's shut the
+oalyXilc6wo-00193-00032688-00032823 hell up and dive in
+oalyXilc6wo-00194-00032824-00033071 to our action figure appointment surgery
+oalyXilc6wo-00195-00033072-00033223 football video all right guys so what
+oalyXilc6wo-00196-00033224-00033327 we're going to do first here
+oalyXilc6wo-00197-00033328-00033574 is we are going to be doing our head
+oalyXilc6wo-00198-00033575-00033655 swaps for
+oalyXilc6wo-00199-00033656-00033918 our chad gable and our trash so what you
+oalyXilc6wo-00200-00033919-00034087 want to do first before we get into
+oalyXilc6wo-00201-00034088-00034223 things is we are going to remove the
+oalyXilc6wo-00202-00034224-00034351 crown again we don't want to
+oalyXilc6wo-00203-00034352-00034543 mail the damn crown to the head sculpt
+oalyXilc6wo-00204-00034544-00034751 even though it won't come off that often
+oalyXilc6wo-00205-00034752-00034887 i don't want to ruin that nice piece
+oalyXilc6wo-00206-00034888-00035031 that mattel made for us there so i'm
+oalyXilc6wo-00207-00035032-00035071 going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00208-00035072-00035311 put this here this right here and
+oalyXilc6wo-00209-00035312-00035471 hopefully this works out good
+oalyXilc6wo-00210-00035472-00035646 on top of that we do have to heat up the
+oalyXilc6wo-00211-00035647-00035823 trash corbin head sculpt so i'm going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00212-00035824-00035887 put this
+oalyXilc6wo-00213-00035888-00036118 here and just kind of stack this make
+oalyXilc6wo-00214-00036119-00036318 sure the beam of the heat gets all on
+oalyXilc6wo-00215-00036319-00036359 there
+oalyXilc6wo-00216-00036360-00036535 and then the last thing we need to do is
+oalyXilc6wo-00217-00036536-00036687 we need to put the shorty g
+oalyXilc6wo-00218-00036688-00036927 slash chad gable head sculpt on here and
+oalyXilc6wo-00219-00036928-00037079 get that to where it will get
+oalyXilc6wo-00220-00037080-00037335 sufficient heat so that way i actually
+oalyXilc6wo-00221-00037336-00037479 want this to go up front because i think
+oalyXilc6wo-00222-00037480-00037607 the chat gable head scope will probably
+oalyXilc6wo-00223-00037608-00037774 be the toughest one to heat up
+oalyXilc6wo-00224-00037775-00037943 i think the trash corbin one would be
+oalyXilc6wo-00225-00037944-00038102 the the easiest to heat up
+oalyXilc6wo-00226-00038103-00038295 so god this trash can is making it
+oalyXilc6wo-00227-00038296-00038439 difficult and i don't want that all to
+oalyXilc6wo-00228-00038440-00038599 get heated up because of the glue and
+oalyXilc6wo-00229-00038600-00038727 then lastly we have
+oalyXilc6wo-00230-00038728-00038943 this which i don't freaking know man
+oalyXilc6wo-00231-00038944-00039087 heating up head sculpts can be kind of
+oalyXilc6wo-00232-00039088-00039199 difficult sometimes
+oalyXilc6wo-00233-00039200-00039399 putting this here just like that and we
+oalyXilc6wo-00234-00039400-00039543 gotta get the white trusty hairdryer get
+oalyXilc6wo-00235-00039544-00039671 the screwdriver out of the way
+oalyXilc6wo-00236-00039672-00039879 and let's go ahead and heat this hill up
+oalyXilc6wo-00237-00039880-00040287 and get these head swaps going damn you
+oalyXilc6wo-00238-00040288-00040683 i mean jesus christ in heaven man what
+oalyXilc6wo-00239-00040684-00041862 is
+oalyXilc6wo-00240-00041863-00042015 all right guys hopefully that is long
+oalyXilc6wo-00241-00042016-00042151 enough here we're gonna find out let's
+oalyXilc6wo-00242-00042152-00042199 go ahead
+oalyXilc6wo-00243-00042200-00042439 and do i guess trash corbin's head skull
+oalyXilc6wo-00244-00042440-00042646 first all right we got that off let's go
+oalyXilc6wo-00245-00042647-00042918 ahead and get the elite 83
+oalyXilc6wo-00246-00042919-00043174 got that one off i really can't stand
+oalyXilc6wo-00247-00043175-00043239 the new
+oalyXilc6wo-00248-00043240-00043479 like head sculpts because they all have
+oalyXilc6wo-00249-00043480-00043599 like small af
+oalyXilc6wo-00250-00043600-00043935 neck pegs i guess that i guess that
+oalyXilc6wo-00251-00043936-00044087 works we'll take a look at that at the
+oalyXilc6wo-00252-00044088-00044239 end with the trash corbin now we got to
+oalyXilc6wo-00253-00044240-00044535 get our chad gable head sculpt off
+oalyXilc6wo-00254-00044536-00044799 got that on there and you see how small
+oalyXilc6wo-00255-00044800-00044895 that hole is
+oalyXilc6wo-00256-00044896-00045262 then we'll plop this on and boo yeah
+oalyXilc6wo-00257-00045263-00045374 all right we'll take a closer look at
+oalyXilc6wo-00258-00045375-00045590 those two guys at the end really
+oalyXilc6wo-00259-00045591-00045758 love that basic head sculpt for chad
+oalyXilc6wo-00260-00045759-00045935 gable it looks just like him it's
+oalyXilc6wo-00261-00045936-00046046 actually one of the better ones of the
+oalyXilc6wo-00262-00046047-00046246 year i think but trash corbin and
+oalyXilc6wo-00263-00046247-00046486 shorty g gable is done we're gonna put
+oalyXilc6wo-00264-00046487-00046639 the crown back on the trash corbin head
+oalyXilc6wo-00265-00046640-00046774 over here you can't see it off camera
+oalyXilc6wo-00266-00046775-00046927 but you'll see it at the end we'll see
+oalyXilc6wo-00267-00046928-00047095 what all that looks like and how that
+oalyXilc6wo-00268-00047096-00047158 turned out
+oalyXilc6wo-00269-00047159-00047383 now i got this jeff hardy dean ambrose
+oalyXilc6wo-00270-00047384-00047479 guy going
+oalyXilc6wo-00271-00047480-00047655 not doing that and then i get i mean we
+oalyXilc6wo-00272-00047656-00047855 could put the i need to honestly get
+oalyXilc6wo-00273-00047856-00048030 another one of those basics i guess if
+oalyXilc6wo-00274-00048031-00048174 you wanted to combine the two
+oalyXilc6wo-00275-00048175-00048374 there you go that's what that's what the
+oalyXilc6wo-00276-00048375-00048551 the manager tgif
+oalyXilc6wo-00277-00048552-00048783 corbin would look like with his long
+oalyXilc6wo-00278-00048784-00048951 hair it would look dumb as [__] so see
+oalyXilc6wo-00279-00048952-00049071 now we're already on the last thing
+oalyXilc6wo-00280-00049072-00049207 which is why i thought it would be an
+oalyXilc6wo-00281-00049208-00049335 appointment episode but it's going to be
+oalyXilc6wo-00282-00049336-00049486 longer than an appointment episode we
+oalyXilc6wo-00283-00049487-00049639 just don't have a [__] ton of things to
+oalyXilc6wo-00284-00049640-00049790 do but we do have quite an
+oalyXilc6wo-00285-00049791-00050023 upgrade to do to our elite 83 edge so
+oalyXilc6wo-00286-00050024-00050143 honestly guys
+oalyXilc6wo-00287-00050144-00050415 i mean i feel like it was it was
+oalyXilc6wo-00288-00050416-00050518 necessary
+oalyXilc6wo-00289-00050519-00050679 but uh let's go ahead and switch the
+oalyXilc6wo-00290-00050680-00050846 torso first we gotta pop the head sculpt
+oalyXilc6wo-00291-00050847-00050951 off right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00292-00050952-00051158 now one thing that i thought about doing
+oalyXilc6wo-00293-00051159-00051311 is just like i don't really
+oalyXilc6wo-00294-00051312-00051590 care if this torso gets effed up because
+oalyXilc6wo-00295-00051591-00051823 i'm replacing it and i don't have like a
+oalyXilc6wo-00296-00051824-00052007 need there's not a single time where
+oalyXilc6wo-00297-00052008-00052054 i've ever
+oalyXilc6wo-00298-00052055-00052199 switched to daniel bryan torso and
+oalyXilc6wo-00299-00052200-00052430 thought to myself damn really wish i had
+oalyXilc6wo-00300-00052432-00052638 one of those daniel bryan torsos
+oalyXilc6wo-00301-00052639-00052823 so really i don't i'm not going to be
+oalyXilc6wo-00302-00052824-00053007 too careful popping this torso or
+oalyXilc6wo-00303-00053008-00053135 cracking this torso so i'm just going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00304-00053136-00053279 heat it up with a hair dryer
+oalyXilc6wo-00305-00053279-00053423 and then try to crack it i'm not going
+oalyXilc6wo-00306-00053424-00053526 to go to the kitchen i'm not going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00307-00053527-00053654 heat it up i'm not going to do
+oalyXilc6wo-00308-00053655-00053894 the specific things that we usually do
+oalyXilc6wo-00309-00053895-00054103 to switch a torso or crack a torso so
+oalyXilc6wo-00310-00054104-00054215 i'm just going to heat this all up with
+oalyXilc6wo-00311-00054216-00054303 the hair dryer
+oalyXilc6wo-00312-00054304-00054463 and we'll go from there and see how it
+oalyXilc6wo-00313-00054464-00054647 goes biggest thing for me is going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00314-00054648-00054799 make sure is going to be making
+oalyXilc6wo-00315-00054800-00054959 sure that the shoulders don't get loose
+oalyXilc6wo-00316-00054960-00055159 when we put those into the new torso and
+oalyXilc6wo-00317-00055160-00055294 all of that stuff but let's just go
+oalyXilc6wo-00318-00055295-00055407 ahead and heat this hole up and then
+oalyXilc6wo-00319-00055408-00055559 we'll get into the crack seas
+oalyXilc6wo-00320-00055560-00055759 then we got to get into the paintsies
+oalyXilc6wo-00321-00055760-00056991 and all the other stuff
+oalyXilc6wo-00322-00056991-00057135 all right guys let's see how this goes
+oalyXilc6wo-00323-00057136-00057342 again if i eff up the torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00324-00057344-00057503 not going to be that upset because i
+oalyXilc6wo-00325-00057504-00057703 really don't feel like i need this torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00326-00057704-00057782 it's very
+oalyXilc6wo-00327-00057783-00058063 very hot honestly but uh usually what i
+oalyXilc6wo-00328-00058064-00058271 do is just go right behind the
+oalyXilc6wo-00329-00058272-00058454 shoulder right here and then just kind
+oalyXilc6wo-00330-00058455-00058687 of push a little bit but see technically
+oalyXilc6wo-00331-00058688-00058775 i usually go
+oalyXilc6wo-00332-00058776-00059023 to the kitchen and i'll heat up water
+oalyXilc6wo-00333-00059024-00059111 for five minutes
+oalyXilc6wo-00334-00059112-00059311 put this down in there for two or three
+oalyXilc6wo-00335-00059312-00059535 minutes let it soak in there get all the
+oalyXilc6wo-00336-00059536-00059599 glue
+oalyXilc6wo-00337-00059600-00059815 cracked and all that and then come back
+oalyXilc6wo-00338-00059816-00060063 out but i'm really i really don't want
+oalyXilc6wo-00339-00060064-00060230 to do that but i may just do it off
+oalyXilc6wo-00340-00060232-00060406 camera because it really like i have
+oalyXilc6wo-00341-00060407-00060575 plenty of okay so see it cracked a
+oalyXilc6wo-00342-00060576-00060719 little i did effort
+oalyXilc6wo-00343-00060720-00060830 f it up a little bit right there but
+oalyXilc6wo-00344-00060832-00060959 i'll show you guys how to fix those
+oalyXilc6wo-00345-00060960-00061119 stress fractures i may have already done
+oalyXilc6wo-00346-00061120-00061279 it in a video before but
+oalyXilc6wo-00347-00061279-00061406 all right actually that cracked pretty
+oalyXilc6wo-00348-00061407-00061663 easily right there see what's stupid
+oalyXilc6wo-00349-00061664-00061911 is if this was a torso that i really
+oalyXilc6wo-00350-00061912-00062191 really just did not want to screw up
+oalyXilc6wo-00351-00062191-00062463 i swear to god it would have been the
+oalyXilc6wo-00352-00062464-00062566 like the hardest
+oalyXilc6wo-00353-00062567-00062782 torso crack known to man but it looks
+oalyXilc6wo-00354-00062783-00062950 like it came out pretty easy right there
+oalyXilc6wo-00355-00062951-00063006 so
+oalyXilc6wo-00356-00063007-00063175 there's the torso there to get this
+oalyXilc6wo-00357-00063176-00063359 bottom half what i typically do is get
+oalyXilc6wo-00358-00063360-00063671 the good old trusty knife
+oalyXilc6wo-00359-00063672-00064126 [Applause]
+oalyXilc6wo-00360-00064127-00064294 not opening a package but you got to do
+oalyXilc6wo-00361-00064295-00064391 that i don't know if we've ever done
+oalyXilc6wo-00362-00064391-00064559 that on surgery before probably took 80
+oalyXilc6wo-00363-00064560-00064703 episodes i have sharpened this but
+oalyXilc6wo-00364-00064704-00064838 typically what i do
+oalyXilc6wo-00365-00064839-00065063 is i take the fatness of the knife right
+oalyXilc6wo-00366-00065064-00065223 here you got to be very careful
+oalyXilc6wo-00367-00065224-00065335 definitely don't recommend this if
+oalyXilc6wo-00368-00065336-00065535 you're underage also wear gloves
+oalyXilc6wo-00369-00065536-00065759 good lord in heaven wear gloves but what
+oalyXilc6wo-00370-00065760-00065903 i would do is i would take
+oalyXilc6wo-00371-00065904-00066063 the fatness of the knife right here and
+oalyXilc6wo-00372-00066064-00066271 i'll shove it into this gap right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00373-00066272-00066503 slowly and barely with any pressure
+oalyXilc6wo-00374-00066504-00066671 whatsoever like barely push
+oalyXilc6wo-00375-00066672-00066815 you know what i don't feel confident
+oalyXilc6wo-00376-00066816-00067023 doing this on camera got in heaven now
+oalyXilc6wo-00377-00067024-00067175 now it's making me want to put gloves on
+oalyXilc6wo-00378-00067176-00067326 because you guys know when i break out
+oalyXilc6wo-00379-00067327-00067479 the damn camera i always
+oalyXilc6wo-00380-00067480-00067679 like seem to do something effed up all
+oalyXilc6wo-00381-00067680-00067823 right so what i was saying is
+oalyXilc6wo-00382-00067824-00068063 is typically i take the knife and i run
+oalyXilc6wo-00383-00068064-00068231 it into this groove right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00384-00068232-00068447 very slowly and surely like all right
+oalyXilc6wo-00385-00068448-00068615 i've went ahead and heated it up just so
+oalyXilc6wo-00386-00068616-00068806 i can be safe but i run it down in that
+oalyXilc6wo-00387-00068807-00068991 gap this is what it ends up looking like
+oalyXilc6wo-00388-00068992-00069159 you get it down in there like that again
+oalyXilc6wo-00389-00069160-00069343 be very careful or you could get an
+oalyXilc6wo-00390-00069344-00069487 adult to help you if you're
+oalyXilc6wo-00391-00069488-00069663 under age but then i just kind of wiggle
+oalyXilc6wo-00392-00069664-00069815 it back and forth
+oalyXilc6wo-00393-00069816-00070038 like so and then bam just like that see
+oalyXilc6wo-00394-00070039-00070223 it didn't do good because it
+oalyXilc6wo-00395-00070224-00070391 popped one of the pegs but that's how i
+oalyXilc6wo-00396-00070392-00070526 get that off usually again i don't
+oalyXilc6wo-00397-00070527-00070671 really care for this torso so it really
+oalyXilc6wo-00398-00070672-00070806 doesn't matter that much
+oalyXilc6wo-00399-00070807-00070935 but here's what we're left with we're
+oalyXilc6wo-00400-00070936-00071119 left with legs just legs
+oalyXilc6wo-00401-00071120-00071359 all right so the reason i contacted ryan
+oalyXilc6wo-00402-00071360-00071535 was to get some of these
+oalyXilc6wo-00403-00071536-00071679 little square pieces right here because
+oalyXilc6wo-00404-00071680-00071847 i don't have any and i don't know where
+oalyXilc6wo-00405-00071848-00072023 he even got these from like that doesn't
+oalyXilc6wo-00406-00072024-00072182 even fit on the elite torso so i don't
+oalyXilc6wo-00407-00072183-00072375 even know what this square is from
+oalyXilc6wo-00408-00072376-00072591 is it from basics like the basics could
+oalyXilc6wo-00409-00072592-00072735 come with that all right so these square
+oalyXilc6wo-00410-00072736-00072926 pieces actually do not fit onto the
+oalyXilc6wo-00411-00072927-00073087 elite torso i guess these are from
+oalyXilc6wo-00412-00073088-00073215 basics i thought they were from the
+oalyXilc6wo-00413-00073216-00073406 elites not a huge deal i still
+oalyXilc6wo-00414-00073407-00073606 appreciate ryan to the most but i don't
+oalyXilc6wo-00415-00073607-00073791 typically crack basics so
+oalyXilc6wo-00416-00073792-00073982 i guess i didn't know that but it does
+oalyXilc6wo-00417-00073983-00074247 look like all of these have the smaller
+oalyXilc6wo-00418-00074248-00074455 little opening that will not work with
+oalyXilc6wo-00419-00074456-00074575 an elite torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00420-00074576-00074838 so now i'm kind of worried that this is
+oalyXilc6wo-00421-00074839-00074991 going to be loose on here hopefully not
+oalyXilc6wo-00422-00074992-00075167 though let's uh let's just go ahead and
+oalyXilc6wo-00423-00075168-00075287 see
+oalyXilc6wo-00424-00075288-00075471 so typically what i'll do is you put the
+oalyXilc6wo-00425-00075472-00075647 back portion on here like so
+oalyXilc6wo-00426-00075648-00075838 then you put the top portion on there
+oalyXilc6wo-00427-00075839-00075982 and then squeeze it together
+oalyXilc6wo-00428-00075983-00076150 all right it actually feels quite tight
+oalyXilc6wo-00429-00076151-00076343 actually so not a big deal all right
+oalyXilc6wo-00430-00076344-00076479 guys i don't remember the last segment
+oalyXilc6wo-00431-00076480-00076638 that i did i think i was trying to get
+oalyXilc6wo-00432-00076639-00076694 this
+oalyXilc6wo-00433-00076695-00076911 torso on here but what i figured out is
+oalyXilc6wo-00434-00076912-00077119 that this torso this lower torso piece
+oalyXilc6wo-00435-00077120-00077223 is actually tight
+oalyXilc6wo-00436-00077224-00077447 around this but i did have to play with
+oalyXilc6wo-00437-00077448-00077599 it a little bit to close down this gap
+oalyXilc6wo-00438-00077600-00077726 you know you don't really want any
+oalyXilc6wo-00439-00077727-00077879 gapage so i actually you talk about
+oalyXilc6wo-00440-00077880-00078062 surgery brad i took my dremel
+oalyXilc6wo-00441-00078063-00078303 and i used this one specific tool to dig
+oalyXilc6wo-00442-00078304-00078543 into the torso piece here on the lower
+oalyXilc6wo-00443-00078544-00078750 part to make it where it would fit
+oalyXilc6wo-00444-00078751-00079023 clasplessly whatever the hell that is
+oalyXilc6wo-00445-00079024-00079071 and
+oalyXilc6wo-00446-00079072-00079247 uh i think we finally figured out here
+oalyXilc6wo-00447-00079248-00079391 so i'm gonna put this right here i'm
+oalyXilc6wo-00448-00079392-00079447 gonna hit
+oalyXilc6wo-00449-00079448-00079606 my super glue right here and we're gonna
+oalyXilc6wo-00450-00079607-00079791 attach this to the lower part
+oalyXilc6wo-00451-00079792-00079950 again i think this is actually going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00452-00079951-00080119 work out pretty good the only thing i'm
+oalyXilc6wo-00453-00080120-00080303 worried about is again the shoulders
+oalyXilc6wo-00454-00080304-00080423 fitting into that
+oalyXilc6wo-00455-00080424-00080623 upper torso piece but we will have to
+oalyXilc6wo-00456-00080624-00080791 see we got that i bought some new super
+oalyXilc6wo-00457-00080792-00080967 glue the other day so this should be
+oalyXilc6wo-00458-00080968-00081182 relatively pretty good i think i think
+oalyXilc6wo-00459-00081183-00081319 we're going to be cooking with peanut
+oalyXilc6wo-00460-00081320-00081487 oil and everything like that so
+oalyXilc6wo-00461-00081488-00081703 putting this here and then clasping this
+oalyXilc6wo-00462-00081704-00081943 together i got some glue on my finger
+oalyXilc6wo-00463-00081944-00082143 so that's just epic pushing that
+oalyXilc6wo-00464-00082144-00082343 together really good again the torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00465-00082344-00082518 seems pretty tight and everything
+oalyXilc6wo-00466-00082519-00082775 hopefully that will hold up over time
+oalyXilc6wo-00467-00082776-00082926 and we don't have any football
+oalyXilc6wo-00468-00082927-00083143 issues all right so there's that you can
+oalyXilc6wo-00469-00083144-00083294 kind of see what we're going for already
+oalyXilc6wo-00470-00083295-00083471 it already looks pretty damn good to be
+oalyXilc6wo-00471-00083472-00083591 honest with you all right so there's
+oalyXilc6wo-00472-00083592-00083623 that
+oalyXilc6wo-00473-00083624-00083911 next key piece is going to be the upper
+oalyXilc6wo-00474-00083912-00084103 torso piece which is going to be this
+oalyXilc6wo-00475-00084104-00084175 right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00476-00084176-00084487 we're gonna put this on here like so
+oalyXilc6wo-00477-00084488-00084823 and then we're going to take the arms
+oalyXilc6wo-00478-00084824-00084903 right here and
+oalyXilc6wo-00479-00084904-00085159 try to sit them in here it feels tight
+oalyXilc6wo-00480-00085160-00085375 all right it feels pretty good i don't
+oalyXilc6wo-00481-00085376-00085631 think that it's gonna get loose but to
+oalyXilc6wo-00482-00085632-00085726 be honest with you
+oalyXilc6wo-00483-00085727-00085911 really i honestly i don't even know what
+oalyXilc6wo-00484-00085912-00086047 the hell i'm saying let's just shut the
+oalyXilc6wo-00485-00086048-00086206 hell up and try to get it going here all
+oalyXilc6wo-00486-00086207-00086343 right so there's that it's leaning
+oalyXilc6wo-00487-00086344-00086503 forward got all the good stuff now what
+oalyXilc6wo-00488-00086504-00086631 we're gonna have to do now
+oalyXilc6wo-00489-00086632-00086823 is i'm gonna raise this up a little and
+oalyXilc6wo-00490-00086824-00087015 then i'm going to put my super glue
+oalyXilc6wo-00491-00087016-00087238 right here in all the areas and then
+oalyXilc6wo-00492-00087239-00087375 we're going to see if we can get this
+oalyXilc6wo-00493-00087376-00087511 going i'm going to put a little super
+oalyXilc6wo-00494-00087512-00087599 glue actually
+oalyXilc6wo-00495-00087600-00087926 on the arm rotation and maybe uh that'll
+oalyXilc6wo-00496-00087927-00088055 tighten that up a little bit
+oalyXilc6wo-00497-00088056-00088262 once we shut up the the torso there all
+oalyXilc6wo-00498-00088263-00088431 right so here comes the back piece
+oalyXilc6wo-00499-00088432-00088615 god this [__] sucks man i hate doing
+oalyXilc6wo-00500-00088616-00089103 this
+oalyXilc6wo-00501-00089104-00089350 yeah i wish i had one of those things
+oalyXilc6wo-00502-00089351-00089526 those little clamp pieces that would
+oalyXilc6wo-00503-00089527-00089582 just do
+oalyXilc6wo-00504-00089583-00089815 this for like 24 hours and keep it on
+oalyXilc6wo-00505-00089816-00089982 there so that it would remain tight but
+oalyXilc6wo-00506-00089983-00090150 it's honestly it's probably as
+oalyXilc6wo-00507-00090151-00090303 good as it's gonna get all right so this
+oalyXilc6wo-00508-00090304-00090455 is what we got right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00509-00090456-00090582 looking pretty good i like the way it
+oalyXilc6wo-00510-00090583-00090711 looks i'm gonna go ahead and pop on the
+oalyXilc6wo-00511-00090712-00090855 head scope right here actually no i'm
+oalyXilc6wo-00512-00090856-00090894 not
+oalyXilc6wo-00513-00090895-00091038 right here you guys will notice on the
+oalyXilc6wo-00514-00091039-00091231 back you see these little like stress
+oalyXilc6wo-00515-00091232-00091399 fracture pieces right here these little
+oalyXilc6wo-00516-00091400-00091559 things right here if you take a lighter
+oalyXilc6wo-00517-00091560-00091743 and you just kind of like
+oalyXilc6wo-00518-00091744-00092071 guide it over the cracks like fan it
+oalyXilc6wo-00519-00092072-00092215 over it don't like sit it on there but
+oalyXilc6wo-00520-00092216-00092382 if you fan it over it
+oalyXilc6wo-00521-00092383-00092599 the flame will actually make those
+oalyXilc6wo-00522-00092600-00092806 things disappear which is actually
+oalyXilc6wo-00523-00092807-00092982 freaking insane so you guys can see it's
+oalyXilc6wo-00524-00092983-00093118 already gone there's also one on the
+oalyXilc6wo-00525-00093119-00093838 neck right here
+oalyXilc6wo-00526-00093839-00094015 pretty crazy stuff kind of witchcraft
+oalyXilc6wo-00527-00094016-00094135 are we all right i'm not going to touch
+oalyXilc6wo-00528-00094136-00094262 that for a second all right guys now
+oalyXilc6wo-00529-00094263-00094494 we're going to plop on this head sculpt
+oalyXilc6wo-00530-00094495-00094726 and bam oh snap you got a little
+oalyXilc6wo-00531-00094727-00094862 something special going on there young
+oalyXilc6wo-00532-00094863-00094894 man
+oalyXilc6wo-00533-00094895-00095038 you got a lot of something special going
+oalyXilc6wo-00534-00095039-00095255 on there young man what the hell was
+oalyXilc6wo-00535-00095256-00095294 that
+oalyXilc6wo-00536-00095295-00095462 god damn it son don't ever raise your
+oalyXilc6wo-00537-00095463-00095591 hand to me like that again all right i
+oalyXilc6wo-00538-00095592-00095687 consider that a threat
+oalyXilc6wo-00539-00095688-00095855 look at that right there that's looking
+oalyXilc6wo-00540-00095856-00096682 alright alright now key the paint time
+oalyXilc6wo-00541-00096683-00097309 lapse
+oalyXilc6wo-00542-00097310-00097890 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00543-00097891-00098914 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00544-00098915-00099508 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00545-00099509-00100188 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00546-00100189-00101879 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00547-00101880-00101982 all right guys so here's everything
+oalyXilc6wo-00548-00101983-00102174 we've done on action figure surgery
+oalyXilc6wo-00549-00102175-00102303 today i'd say
+oalyXilc6wo-00550-00102304-00102630 pretty damn freaking idiotic dumb
+oalyXilc6wo-00551-00102631-00102878 success today brad i think we did it i
+oalyXilc6wo-00552-00102879-00103110 think we completed the challenge what we
+oalyXilc6wo-00553-00103111-00103247 wanted to do here today
+oalyXilc6wo-00554-00103248-00103471 was very successful this torso swap came
+oalyXilc6wo-00555-00103472-00103606 out better than i thought i thought you
+oalyXilc6wo-00556-00103607-00103758 know finn balor torso
+oalyXilc6wo-00557-00103759-00103902 i thought originally i was just going to
+oalyXilc6wo-00558-00103903-00104094 put one of my fin balor torsos on there
+oalyXilc6wo-00559-00104095-00104158 but i think
+oalyXilc6wo-00560-00104159-00104375 using the one that mattel used for drew
+oalyXilc6wo-00561-00104376-00104463 mcintyre
+oalyXilc6wo-00562-00104464-00104702 back or maybe it's is it cesaro cesaro i
+oalyXilc6wo-00563-00104703-00104886 think it's elite 33 cesaro
+oalyXilc6wo-00564-00104888-00105078 that is the torso we used or elite 23
+oalyXilc6wo-00565-00105079-00105231 regardless of the case
+oalyXilc6wo-00566-00105232-00105431 this looks amazing i'm really happy with
+oalyXilc6wo-00567-00105432-00105575 the way this came out we did put on the
+oalyXilc6wo-00568-00105576-00105702 black hand tape as well
+oalyXilc6wo-00569-00105703-00105983 and we did also add the chrome to the
+oalyXilc6wo-00570-00105983-00106151 boots or the shoes there
+oalyXilc6wo-00571-00106152-00106327 underneath the kick pads and i think
+oalyXilc6wo-00572-00106328-00106495 that turned out excellent it's
+oalyXilc6wo-00573-00106496-00106663 completely accurate now besides the back
+oalyXilc6wo-00574-00106664-00106807 of the knee pads they need to be black
+oalyXilc6wo-00575-00106808-00106943 and we also painted the black of the
+oalyXilc6wo-00576-00106944-00107134 elbow pad the black available pads the
+oalyXilc6wo-00577-00107135-00107302 back of the elbow pads black
+oalyXilc6wo-00578-00107303-00107527 and it turned out fantastic i'm really
+oalyXilc6wo-00579-00107528-00107663 happy with this man the only thing that
+oalyXilc6wo-00580-00107664-00107727 sucks now
+oalyXilc6wo-00581-00107728-00107871 is when we get the chase variant in here
+oalyXilc6wo-00582-00107872-00108063 i'm gonna have to do similar fix ups to
+oalyXilc6wo-00583-00108064-00108095 it
+oalyXilc6wo-00584-00108096-00108286 which will be kind of annoying but you
+oalyXilc6wo-00585-00108288-00108383 know that's what we do that's what
+oalyXilc6wo-00586-00108383-00108519 surgery is all about and everything but
+oalyXilc6wo-00587-00108520-00108623 this edge turned out
+oalyXilc6wo-00588-00108624-00108807 super fantastic really happy with the
+oalyXilc6wo-00589-00108808-00108951 way it came out and everything and i'm
+oalyXilc6wo-00590-00108952-00109127 really happy with this surgery man that
+oalyXilc6wo-00591-00109128-00109254 makes me super happy
+oalyXilc6wo-00592-00109255-00109439 the the ab crunch is nice the waist
+oalyXilc6wo-00593-00109440-00109702 swivel is nice the arms are not loose
+oalyXilc6wo-00594-00109703-00109902 this is uh this turned out better than i
+oalyXilc6wo-00595-00109903-00110110 expected so that is really nice to see
+oalyXilc6wo-00596-00110111-00110286 up next we have shorty g chat gable
+oalyXilc6wo-00597-00110288-00110431 another huge shout out to my man ryan
+oalyXilc6wo-00598-00110432-00110615 this came out perfectly exactly how i
+oalyXilc6wo-00599-00110616-00110783 wanted it when we torso switched it
+oalyXilc6wo-00600-00110783-00110871 originally
+oalyXilc6wo-00601-00110872-00111039 i do hate that the little waist pegs
+oalyXilc6wo-00602-00111040-00111158 that i thought i was getting were not
+oalyXilc6wo-00603-00111159-00111327 for elites that kind of sucks
+oalyXilc6wo-00604-00111328-00111510 but nonetheless he hooked us up with a
+oalyXilc6wo-00605-00111511-00111663 shorty g head sculpt and it was all
+oalyXilc6wo-00606-00111664-00111815 great and maybe i can use those other
+oalyXilc6wo-00607-00111816-00111871 things
+oalyXilc6wo-00608-00111872-00112102 and it's it's sick next up is trash
+oalyXilc6wo-00609-00112103-00112310 corbin you know he's updated now he
+oalyXilc6wo-00610-00112311-00112502 looks like the trash that he is the bald
+oalyXilc6wo-00611-00112503-00112710 head the the crown and everything he
+oalyXilc6wo-00612-00112711-00112895 looks all right he looks you know he
+oalyXilc6wo-00613-00112896-00113047 he's doing his thing over there but
+oalyXilc6wo-00614-00113048-00113127 overall
+oalyXilc6wo-00615-00113128-00113334 really really successful day of surgery
+oalyXilc6wo-00616-00113335-00113486 for the first day of the year
+oalyXilc6wo-00617-00113488-00113639 the first surgery of the year looks like
+oalyXilc6wo-00618-00113640-00113863 it was a huge success so this should be
+oalyXilc6wo-00619-00113864-00113975 moving forward we got to keep this
+oalyXilc6wo-00620-00113976-00114183 momentum up for 2021
+oalyXilc6wo-00621-00114183-00114319 it's kind of ridiculous to even think
+oalyXilc6wo-00622-00114320-00114551 that it is 2021 but that is pretty much
+oalyXilc6wo-00623-00114552-00114695 it for surgery today guys i hope you
+oalyXilc6wo-00624-00114696-00114751 guys did
+oalyXilc6wo-00625-00114752-00114958 enjoy not a ton of stuff we did but the
+oalyXilc6wo-00626-00114959-00115063 things we did do
+oalyXilc6wo-00627-00115064-00115286 were monumental this edge looks amazing
+oalyXilc6wo-00628-00115288-00115366 i'm really happy
+oalyXilc6wo-00629-00115367-00115471 with the way it turned out and
+oalyXilc6wo-00630-00115472-00115615 everything i can't wait for the ultimate
+oalyXilc6wo-00631-00115616-00115751 edition to come out which is dropping
+oalyXilc6wo-00632-00115752-00115919 very soon but before we get out of here
+oalyXilc6wo-00633-00115920-00116071 guys let's get into our random
+oalyXilc6wo-00634-00116072-00116295 shout out so let's get let's get into it
+oalyXilc6wo-00635-00116296-00116510 so this shout out is gonna go to jws
+oalyXilc6wo-00636-00116511-00116566 owner
+oalyXilc6wo-00637-00116567-00116695 and you guys didn't know he is a
+oalyXilc6wo-00638-00116696-00116895 stop-motion artist and i think he even
+oalyXilc6wo-00639-00116896-00117063 does work for ringside now like that's
+oalyXilc6wo-00640-00117064-00117190 how good this man is
+oalyXilc6wo-00641-00117191-00117399 he is a fantastic stop-motion artist he
+oalyXilc6wo-00642-00117400-00117566 has amazing matches and stuff all over
+oalyXilc6wo-00643-00117567-00117719 his page guys for you guys you guys
+oalyXilc6wo-00644-00117720-00117839 probably already know who he is if
+oalyXilc6wo-00645-00117840-00117975 you're if you know if you guys are into
+oalyXilc6wo-00646-00117976-00118110 stop motion but he commented great show
+oalyXilc6wo-00647-00118111-00118254 dude that christmas look in the arena is
+oalyXilc6wo-00648-00118255-00118399 awesome and i love the ending by the way
+oalyXilc6wo-00649-00118400-00118558 very creative stuff keep it up and happy
+oalyXilc6wo-00650-00118559-00118766 new year huge shout out to jws for that
+oalyXilc6wo-00651-00118767-00118919 i really appreciate that bro
+oalyXilc6wo-00652-00118920-00119086 and definitely go check out his channel
+oalyXilc6wo-00653-00119088-00119334 guys also check out mdt live episode 16
+oalyXilc6wo-00654-00119335-00119454 if you guys missed it i would really
+oalyXilc6wo-00655-00119455-00119615 really appreciate it huge shout out to
+oalyXilc6wo-00656-00119616-00119790 jws for that comment it meant a lot for
+oalyXilc6wo-00657-00119791-00119927 him to comment on that given his
+oalyXilc6wo-00658-00119928-00120063 background and everything i think he
+oalyXilc6wo-00659-00120064-00120239 even does work like i said for ringside
+oalyXilc6wo-00660-00120240-00120471 and wwe for their stop motion so that's
+oalyXilc6wo-00661-00120472-00120623 pretty insane but thank you guys for
+oalyXilc6wo-00662-00120624-00120766 watching subscribe to the channel thank
+oalyXilc6wo-00663-00120767-00120902 you for watching and i'll see you guys
+oalyXilc6wo-00664-00120903-00121119 in the next video
+oalyXilc6wo-00665-00121120-00122345 thank you
+oalyXilc6wo-00666-00122346-00123133 [Music]
+oalyXilc6wo-00667-00123134-00123479 [Music]
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00000-00000015-00000347 the Gameboy micro stylized as Gameboy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00001-00000348-00000570 micro is a handheld game console
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00002-00000571-00000776 developed and manufactured by Nintendo
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00003-00000777-00001116 it was first released in September 2005
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00004-00001117-00001314 as a compact redesign of the Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00005-00001315-00001629 Advance the system is the last console
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00006-00001630-00001839 in the Game Boy line unlike its
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00007-00001839-00002055 predecessor the Gameboy micro lacks
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00008-00002056-00002286 backward compatibility for Gameboy or
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00009-00002287-00002922 gameboy color games
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00010-00002923-00003427 topic history
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00011-00003428-00003659 the Gameboy micro was announced by
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00012-00003660-00003884 Nintendo of America's vice-president of
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00013-00003885-00004100 sales and marketing Reggie fils-aime
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00014-00004101-00004256 at the company's Electronic
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00015-00004257-00004459 Entertainment Expo press conference on
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00016-00004460-00004825 May 17 2005 the system was released in
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00017-00004826-00005150 Japan on September 13 2005 and in North
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00018-00005151-00005497 America on September 19 2005 it was
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00019-00005498-00005788 released in Europe on November 4th 2005
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00020-00005789-00006145 in Australia on November 3rd 2005 it was
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00021-00006146-00006370 released in China as the iQue Gameboy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00022-00006371-00006641 micro on October 1st 2005 and later
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00023-00006642-00006880 released in South Korea on November 9th
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00024-00006881-00007483 2005
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00025-00007484-00008106 topic design and specifications
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00026-00008108-00008350 the Gameboy micro retains some of the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00027-00008351-00008572 functionality of the Gameboy Advance SP
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00028-00008573-00008869 but with a more compact form factor it
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00029-00008870-00009127 is unable to play original Game Boy and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00030-00009128-00009313 Game Boy Color games due to design
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00031-00009314-00009553 changes although it still has the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00032-00009554-00009760 required z80 processor and graphics
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00033-00009761-00009982 hardware necessary to run games from
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00034-00009983-00010192 older Gameboy systems it lacks other
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00035-00010193-00010411 internal hardware necessary for backward
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00036-00010412-00010675 compatibility it is incompatible with
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00037-00010676-00010840 the Nintendo e-reader and other
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00038-00010841-00011103 peripherals due to similar design issues
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00039-00011104-00011338 additionally it has a backlit screen
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00040-00011339-00011476 with the ability to adjust the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00041-00011477-00011752 brightness the shape itself is oblong
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00042-00011753-00011947 similar to the style of the Nintendo
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00043-00011948-00012223 Entertainment System Controller the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00044-00012224-00012397 Gameboy micro features a removable
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00045-00012398-00012646 faceplate and designs with special face
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00046-00012647-00012832 plates were sold as a customization
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00047-00012833-00013327 feature dimensions 50 times 101 times 17
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00048-00013328-00013708 point 2 millimeters 2 times 4 times 0.7
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00049-00013709-00014233 in weight 80 grams 2.8 ounces processor
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00050-00014234-00014518 32-bit sixteen point eight megahertz ARM
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00051-00014519-00014719 processor a rm7
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00052-00014719-00015259 TDM I case colors various screen 51
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00053-00015260-00015472 millimeters to inches backlight with
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00054-00015472-00015903 adjustable brightness resolution 240 x
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00055-00015904-00016387 160 pixels colors 512 character cell
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00056-00016388-00016912 mode or 32,768 bitmap mode battery
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00057-00016913-00017107 built-in rechargeable lithium-ion
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00058-00017108-00017350 battery up to 5 hours of battery life
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00059-00017351-00017584 with top brightness and sound or 8 hours
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00060-00017585-00017869 with both features on default headphones
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00061-00017870-00018079 standard three point five millimeters
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00062-00018080-00018307 headphone jack the Gameboy micro has a
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00063-00018308-00018505 2-way switch on its right side for
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00064-00018506-00018766 adjusting volume by holding down the L
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00065-00018767-00018964 shoulder button the switch can also be
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00066-00018965-00019138 used to adjust the backlight between
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00067-00019139-00019746 five levels of brightness
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00068-00019747-00020318 topic software and hardware
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00069-00020319-00020561 the Gameboy micro is compatible with
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00070-00020562-00020798 Game Boy Advance games including Game
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00071-00020799-00021113 Boy Advance video game packs the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00072-00021114-00021302 following games accessories are not
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00073-00021303-00021580 compatible with the Gameboy microsystem
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00074-00021581-00021953 original Gameboy game packs Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00075-00021954-00022283 Color game packs Game Boy or Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00076-00022284-00022598 Advance game link cables Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00077-00022599-00022904 Advance wireless adapter Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00078-00022905-00023246 Advance eReader Nintendo GameCube game
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00079-00023247-00023687 boy advance cable Game Boy printer Game
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00080-00023688-00023921 Boy camera while Game Boy or Game Boy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00081-00023922-00024131 Advance game link cables and the Game
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00082-00024132-00024338 Boy Advance wireless adapter are not
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00083-00024339-00024569 compatible with the Gameboy microsystem
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00084-00024570-00024830 adapters in a Gameboy micro compatible
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00085-00024831-00024998 wireless adapter have been released
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00086-00024999-00025202 Nintendo has also redesigned their play
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00087-00025203-00025415 yen music video adapter to better fit
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00088-00025416-00025712 the Gameboy micro this device can play
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00089-00025713-00025994 mp3 and digital video files from SD
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00090-00025995-00026314 cards as with the Game Boy Advance and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00091-00026316-00026567 Game Boy Advance SP systems there are no
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00092-00026568-00026795 regional lockout Zhan software so North
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00093-00026795-00027005 American games can be played on Japanese
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00094-00027006-00027727 or European hardware and vice versa
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00095-00027729-00028242 topic packaging
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00096-00028243-00028497 in Japan the handheld has been released
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00097-00028498-00028791 in four colors and styles each the four
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00098-00028792-00029040 colors are black blue purple and silver
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00099-00029041-00029349 the Gameboy micro also has 4 limited
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00100-00029350-00029580 edition styles one based on the original
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00101-00029581-00029865 Famicom video game consoles controller a
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00102-00029866-00030090 blue bodied model with a faceplate based
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00103-00030091-00030336 on Final Fantasy 4 a red bodied and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00104-00030337-00030529 red-faced Edition for the release of the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00105-00030530-00030750 game mother 3 and a red bodied model
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00106-00030751-00030927 with a black face plate containing the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00107-00030928-00031116 silhouette of the iconic Pikachu from
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00108-00031117-00031422 the Pokemon franchise in the United
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00109-00031423-00031539 States in Canada
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00110-00031540-00031758 the Gameboy micro is available in two
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00111-00031759-00031950 regular colors each sold with three
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00112-00031951-00032110 interchangeable face plates included
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00113-00032111-00032508 silver with black ammonite and ladybug
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00114-00032509-00032817 face plates and black with silver flame
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00115-00032818-00033291 and camouflage face plates the 20th
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00116-00033292-00033558 anniversary edition was released in
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00117-00033559-00033798 December 2005 which resembles the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00118-00033799-00034122 Famicom controller in Europe the Gameboy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00119-00034123-00034293 micro is available in four different
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00120-00034294-00034515 colors with one matching faceplate
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00121-00034516-00034842 silver green blue and pink Gameboy micro
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00122-00034843-00035110 sold in Australia have the same colors
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00123-00035111-00035337 except green which replaced by red color
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00124-00035338-00035560 as Europe there are reportedly no plans
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00125-00035561-00035779 to sell additional face plates in the US
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00126-00035780-00035994 retail locations as indicated in the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00127-00035995-00036235 letter page and issue 200 of Nintendo
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00128-00036236-00036510 Power or the UK Nintendo of Europe
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00129-00036511-00036768 cannot supply replacement face plates of
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00130-00036769-00036963 any kind and the feature is omitted from
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00131-00036964-00037161 the products marketing packaging and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00132-00037162-00037440 manual in Europe however some third
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00133-00037441-00037635 parties are manufacturing such face
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00134-00037636-00037842 plates for sale in the US and Europe and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00135-00037843-00038013 some importers stock face plates
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00136-00038014-00038322 acquired from Japan Nintendo of America
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00137-00038323-00038454 sells some of the face plates
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00138-00038455-00039045 individually online
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00139-00039046-00039623 topic release in sales
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00140-00039624-00039986 the Gameboy micro sold over 170,000
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00141-00039987-00040304 units during its first days in Japan the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00142-00040305-00040474 North American release drew some
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00143-00040475-00040655 criticism with a formal release of
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00144-00040656-00040979 September 19 2005 many stores simply
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00145-00040980-00041135 ignored it some delaying it until
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00146-00041136-00041429 September 26th 2005 or as late as
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00147-00041430-00041865 September 30th 2005 according to a q1
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00148-00041866-00042164 2007 Nintendo earnings release two point
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00149-00042165-00042412 four two million Gameboy micro units had
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00150-00042413-00042652 been sold worldwide as of March 31st
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00151-00042653-00043001 2007 including 610 thousand units in
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00152-00043002-00043318 Japan 950 thousand units in the Americas
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00153-00043319-00043499 and eight hundred seventy thousand in
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00154-00043500-00043682 other territories such as Europe and
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00155-00043683-00043748 Oceania
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00156-00043749-00044143 as of July 30th 2007 the Gameboy micro
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00157-00044144-00044474 has sold 2.5 million units according to
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00158-00044475-00044746 game Pro it was ranked number 8 in there
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00159-00044747-00045005 the ten worst selling handhelds of all
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00160-00045006-00045427 time generally the Gameboy micro did not
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00161-00045428-00045580 sell well and failed to reach the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00162-00045581-00045779 companies name of units sold Satoru
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00163-00045780-00045968 Iwata stated that the marketing of the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00164-00045969-00046187 Nintendo DS may have hurt the micro in
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00165-00046188-00046364 the marketplace and admitted that game
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00166-00046365-00046586 boy micro sales did not meet Nintendo's
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00167-00046587-00047154 expectations
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00168-00047155-00047672 topic price history
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00169-00047673-00047995 the system retailed for $99 compared to
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00170-00047996-00048365 $79 for the Gameboy Advance SP the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00171-00048366-00048581 system was originally available in black
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00172-00048582-00048824 and silver and a red 20th anniversary
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00173-00048825-00048968 edition was later released to
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00174-00048969-00049166 commemorate the 20th anniversary of the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00175-00049167-00049825 Nintendo Entertainment System
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00176-00049826-00050340 topic reception
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00177-00050341-00050625 the Gameboy micros backlit screen which
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00178-00050626-00050802 is superior to the original Gameboy
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00179-00050803-00051090 Advance SP s-- a later remodel added a
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00180-00051091-00051285 similar high quality screen to SP
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00181-00051286-00051450 systems has been praised for its
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00182-00051451-00051765 visibility due to a finer dot pitch the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00183-00051766-00051933 screen is more evenly lit and the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00184-00051934-00052065 brightness is adjustable
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00185-00052066-00052320 the smaller dot pitch has also improved
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00186-00052321-00052529 the apparent sharpness of the display
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00187-00052529-00052817 the removable face plates have also been
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00188-00052819-00052926 praised because they allow for
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00189-00052927-00053112 personalization and protect the
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00190-00053113-00053422 high-resolution backlit screen
+oaYP2A1RKg8-00191-00053423-00053766 equals equals notes
+obfCa6ojg1I-00000-00000314-00000655 [Music]
+obfCa6ojg1I-00001-00000656-00001157 foreign
+obfCa6ojg1I-00002-00001158-00002431 [Music]
+obfCa6ojg1I-00003-00002432-00002833 she
+obfCa6ojg1I-00004-00002834-00003351 [Music]
+obfCa6ojg1I-00005-00003352-00003652 oh
+odiILFtI2y0-00000-00000137-00000398 Valon Zula two garlic blends well
+odiILFtI2y0-00001-00000399-00000586 Blanche will officially the City of
+odiILFtI2y0-00002-00000587-00000850 Valen Dula to Golic lungsod in valence
+odiILFtI2y0-00003-00000851-00001066 Allah or simply known as valens Allah
+odiILFtI2y0-00004-00001067-00001291 City is a first-class highly urbanized
+odiILFtI2y0-00005-00001292-00001525 city in Metro Manila Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00006-00001526-00001823 according to the 2015 census it has a
+odiILFtI2y0-00007-00001823-00002014 population of six hundred twenty
+odiILFtI2y0-00008-00002016-00002306 thousand 422 people making it as the
+odiILFtI2y0-00009-00002307-00002498 thirteenth most populous city in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00010-00002499-00002795 Philippines it is the 119th largest city
+odiILFtI2y0-00011-00002796-00003008 in the country located at about 14
+odiILFtI2y0-00012-00003009-00003263 kilometers 8.7 miles north of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00013-00003264-00003563 capital city of Manila fallen Zula is
+odiILFtI2y0-00014-00003564-00004013 categorized under Republic Act nose 7160
+odiILFtI2y0-00015-00004014-00004303 and 8,500 26 as a highly urbanized
+odiILFtI2y0-00016-00004304-00004535 first-class city based on income
+odiILFtI2y0-00017-00004536-00004754 classification and number of population
+odiILFtI2y0-00018-00004755-00005045 a landlocked chartered city located on
+odiILFtI2y0-00019-00005046-00005243 the island of Luzon it is bordered by
+odiILFtI2y0-00020-00005244-00005468 the province of Bulacan and cities of
+odiILFtI2y0-00021-00005469-00005783 Caloocan malabon and caisson City Hall
+odiILFtI2y0-00022-00005784-00006008 and Zula shares border and access to
+odiILFtI2y0-00023-00006009-00006167 tena harrow Stella Henry ver with
+odiILFtI2y0-00024-00006168-00006471 malabon it has a total land area of 40
+odiILFtI2y0-00025-00006472-00006725 5.75 square kilometres where its
+odiILFtI2y0-00026-00006726-00006946 residents are composed of about 72%
+odiILFtI2y0-00027-00006947-00007277 Tagalog people followed by 5% by : OHS
+odiILFtI2y0-00028-00007278-00007445 with a small percentage of foreign
+odiILFtI2y0-00029-00007445-00007648 nationals
+odiILFtI2y0-00030-00007648-00007948 ballin Zula was named after pi oval and
+odiILFtI2y0-00031-00007948-00008134 Zula a physician and a member of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00032-00008134-00008335 Katipunan a secret society founded
+odiILFtI2y0-00033-00008336-00008560 against the colonial government of Spain
+odiILFtI2y0-00034-00008561-00008871 the city as a town was originally called
+odiILFtI2y0-00035-00008872-00009199 as Polo initially formed in 1621 after
+odiILFtI2y0-00036-00009200-00009399 separation from make I in Bulacan
+odiILFtI2y0-00037-00009400-00009610 the Battle of melinda of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00038-00009611-00009787 philippine-american war was fought in
+odiILFtI2y0-00039-00009788-00010291 polo in 1899 in 1960 President Carlos P
+odiILFtI2y0-00040-00010292-00010480 Garcia ordered the split of polos
+odiILFtI2y0-00041-00010481-00010653 southern Baron guides to form another
+odiILFtI2y0-00042-00010654-00010941 town named as Valen Dula the split was
+odiILFtI2y0-00043-00010942-00011121 revoked by President Diosdado Macapagal
+odiILFtI2y0-00044-00011122-00011482 in 1963 after political disagreements
+odiILFtI2y0-00045-00011483-00011638 and the new merged town was named
+odiILFtI2y0-00046-00011639-00011944 valence Allah the modern-day Valens ulla
+odiILFtI2y0-00047-00011945-00012370 with its borders was chartered in 1998
+odiILFtI2y0-00048-00012371-00012607 owing to the cross migration of people
+odiILFtI2y0-00049-00012608-00012808 across the country and its location as
+odiILFtI2y0-00050-00012809-00012976 the northernmost point of metro manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00051-00012977-00013183 Valens Ulla has developed into a
+odiILFtI2y0-00052-00013184-00013468 multicultural metropolis a former
+odiILFtI2y0-00053-00013469-00013726 agricultural rural area Valens Ulla has
+odiILFtI2y0-00054-00013727-00013903 grown into a major economic and
+odiILFtI2y0-00055-00013904-00014080 industrial center of the Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00056-00014081-00014251 when a large number of industries
+odiILFtI2y0-00057-00014252-00014440 relocated to the central parts of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00058-00014441-00014658 city
+odiILFtI2y0-00059-00014659-00015253 toponymy in Spanish Valens Ulla is a
+odiILFtI2y0-00060-00015254-00015463 diminutive form of Valencia which means
+odiILFtI2y0-00061-00015463-00015856 little Valencia the name valle angela is
+odiILFtI2y0-00062-00015857-00016096 also the surname of pi oval and Zula a
+odiILFtI2y0-00063-00016097-00016276 tagalog physician and was one of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00064-00016277-00016558 leaders of Katipunan he was regarded as
+odiILFtI2y0-00065-00016559-00016750 a member of the Katipunan triumvirate
+odiILFtI2y0-00066-00016751-00016942 that started the philippine revolution
+odiILFtI2y0-00067-00016943-00017152 against spanish colonial authorities in
+odiILFtI2y0-00068-00017153-00017515 1896 he also served as the provisional
+odiILFtI2y0-00069-00017516-00017737 chairman for the Katipunan valens illa
+odiILFtI2y0-00070-00017738-00018037 was originally called polo the name polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00071-00018038-00018268 was derived from the Tagalog term polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00072-00018269-00018457 which means Island though the area was
+odiILFtI2y0-00073-00018458-00018739 not an island itself the original town
+odiILFtI2y0-00074-00018740-00018943 of polo was surrounded by the rivers
+odiILFtI2y0-00075-00018944-00019105 from the north and Pella Han River on
+odiILFtI2y0-00076-00019106-00019308 the south
+odiILFtI2y0-00077-00019309-00019717 history
+odiILFtI2y0-00078-00019718-00020243 Spanish era during the Spanish era
+odiILFtI2y0-00079-00020244-00020494 present-day Ville and Zula ovando and no
+odiILFtI2y0-00080-00020495-00020726 villages now in Khe Sanh city were parts
+odiILFtI2y0-00081-00020727-00021029 of Bulacan areas now covered by Valen
+odiILFtI2y0-00082-00021030-00021287 Zula included of spanish friars hacienda
+odiILFtI2y0-00083-00021288-00021469 small political settlements and a
+odiILFtI2y0-00084-00021470-00021740 Spanish garrison these areas were known
+odiILFtI2y0-00085-00021741-00021968 as polo the region was bounded by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00086-00021969-00022169 Tulla Han River on the south and streams
+odiILFtI2y0-00087-00022170-00022403 of branching Rio Grande to Pampanga on
+odiILFtI2y0-00088-00022404-00022633 some areas
+odiILFtI2y0-00089-00022634-00022897 when Manila became an archdiocese in
+odiILFtI2y0-00090-00022898-00023155 1595 regular friars who had already
+odiILFtI2y0-00091-00023156-00023350 established permanent churches in
+odiILFtI2y0-00092-00023351-00023572 catting Halon Bulacan decided that the
+odiILFtI2y0-00093-00023573-00023777 city oh of polo be separated from the
+odiILFtI2y0-00094-00023778-00023953 town and have its own church to cater
+odiILFtI2y0-00095-00023954-00024227 it's increasing spiritual needs through
+odiILFtI2y0-00096-00024228-00024442 successive efforts of Franciscan friar
+odiILFtI2y0-00097-00024443-00024725 Juan Toronto and Don Juan Monson city of
+odiILFtI2y0-00098-00024726-00024934 Polo was successfully separated from
+odiILFtI2y0-00099-00024935-00025258 catting Halon on november 7th 1621 the
+odiILFtI2y0-00100-00025259-00025469 feast day of the town's new patron saint
+odiILFtI2y0-00101-00025470-00025667 did a kiss of alcalá known locally at
+odiILFtI2y0-00102-00025668-00026006 san diego de alcalá the first cabeza de
+odiILFtI2y0-00103-00026007-00026221 Varenne guy of polo was Monsod while
+odiILFtI2y0-00104-00026222-00026387 toronto run the parish which would
+odiILFtI2y0-00105-00026388-00026585 become the present-day san diego de
+odiILFtI2y0-00106-00026586-00026855 alcalá parish on a small tavern the
+odiILFtI2y0-00107-00026856-00027035 separation was then confirmed by
+odiILFtI2y0-00108-00027036-00027254 governor-general Alonso Fajardo de
+odiILFtI2y0-00109-00027255-00027670 entenza on November 12 1623 later the
+odiILFtI2y0-00110-00027672-00027887 date of November 12th is adopted as the
+odiILFtI2y0-00111-00027888-00028207 foundation day of the city from 1627 to
+odiILFtI2y0-00112-00028208-00028495 1629 construction of a parochial church
+odiILFtI2y0-00113-00028497-00028712 dedicated to st. did occurs of alcalá
+odiILFtI2y0-00114-00028713-00029045 started under the supervision of Fr Jose
+odiILFtI2y0-00115-00029045-00029393 Valencia aided by 1/2 bay in 1852
+odiILFtI2y0-00116-00029394-00029593 the church was repaired and remodeled
+odiILFtI2y0-00117-00029594-00029902 under the direction of Fr vicente the
+odiILFtI2y0-00118-00029903-00030110 church was later rededicated to another
+odiILFtI2y0-00119-00030111-00030317 patron the immaculate conception or
+odiILFtI2y0-00120-00030318-00030470 nuestra senora de la inmaculada
+odiILFtI2y0-00121-00030470-00030818 concepción a convent was also built
+odiILFtI2y0-00122-00030819-00031064 followed by a common house Casa tribunal
+odiILFtI2y0-00123-00031064-00031268 that had a rectangular prison cell in a
+odiILFtI2y0-00124-00031269-00031546 schoolhouse made of stone later on
+odiILFtI2y0-00125-00031547-00031783 the small city of au bando was separated
+odiILFtI2y0-00126-00031784-00032027 from polo and incorporated to Bulacan by
+odiILFtI2y0-00127-00032027-00032204 the Marquis of Brindisi after the
+odiILFtI2y0-00128-00032205-00032432 British successfully occupied Manila and
+odiILFtI2y0-00129-00032433-00032810 surrounding suburbs in 1762 to 1764
+odiILFtI2y0-00130-00032811-00033037 during the Seven Years War if the
+odiILFtI2y0-00131-00033038-00033274 colonial government led by Simone de
+odiILFtI2y0-00132-00033275-00033512 anda y Salazar fled to the Kahler
+odiILFtI2y0-00133-00033513-00033814 Pampanga through polo the British
+odiILFtI2y0-00134-00033815-00034070 followed anda and at one point stayed in
+odiILFtI2y0-00135-00034071-00034280 city of Ebola while waiting for orders
+odiILFtI2y0-00136-00034281-00034612 from governor Dawson Drake they explored
+odiILFtI2y0-00137-00034613-00034829 the nearby communities of Milan de
+odiILFtI2y0-00138-00034830-00035146 blacas de London pasola Rincon and
+odiILFtI2y0-00139-00035147-00035483 Melinda the terrified local population
+odiILFtI2y0-00140-00035484-00035729 fled and sought refuge in the forests of
+odiILFtI2y0-00141-00035730-00035962 en T reals where many of them died of
+odiILFtI2y0-00142-00035963-00036058 malaria
+odiILFtI2y0-00143-00036059-00036319 the British then proceeded to Malolos
+odiILFtI2y0-00144-00036320-00036535 Bulacan where they were ambushed by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00145-00036536-00036886 station Spanish soldiers after the chase
+odiILFtI2y0-00146-00036887-00037180 the local population of polo returned to
+odiILFtI2y0-00147-00037181-00037537 their homes on may 12 1763 after days of
+odiILFtI2y0-00148-00037538-00037887 reconstruction today May 12th every year
+odiILFtI2y0-00149-00037888-00038122 is celebrated as the feast of st. roch
+odiILFtI2y0-00150-00038123-00038410 or san roque another patron saint and as
+odiILFtI2y0-00151-00038411-00038590 a memorial to those who died in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00152-00038591-00039049 Seven Years War in 1856 city oh no
+odiILFtI2y0-00153-00039050-00039247 villages was split from polo to become
+odiILFtI2y0-00154-00039248-00039646 an independent town On June 3rd 1865 a
+odiILFtI2y0-00155-00039647-00039844 strong earthquake destroyed the belfry
+odiILFtI2y0-00156-00039845-00040036 of the san diego de alcalá church
+odiILFtI2y0-00157-00040037-00040212 followed by an epidemic that killed
+odiILFtI2y0-00158-00040213-00040531 thousands of people in 1869 filipino
+odiILFtI2y0-00159-00040532-00040756 physician and patriot pi oval and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-00160-00040757-00041032 was born in polo he would be later known
+odiILFtI2y0-00161-00041033-00041179 as one of the key leaders of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00162-00041180-00041248 Katipunan
+odiILFtI2y0-00163-00041249-00041556 which he joined in 1892 at the age of 23
+odiILFtI2y0-00164-00041557-00041862 his admission to the society led to the
+odiILFtI2y0-00165-00041863-00042073 more recruits from polo including old
+odiILFtI2y0-00166-00042074-00042361 piano Fernandez Gregorio flamenco crispy
+odiILFtI2y0-00167-00042362-00042607 piano Augustine's and Faustina Duque
+odiILFtI2y0-00168-00042608-00042862 when Vall Angela was the chief editor
+odiILFtI2y0-00169-00042863-00043075 Fernandez held a special role in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00170-00043076-00043285 Katipunan as a printer of the ankle and
+odiILFtI2y0-00171-00043286-00043521 the organization's official newspaper a
+odiILFtI2y0-00172-00043522-00043752 constituted branch of the Katipunan was
+odiILFtI2y0-00173-00043753-00044085 established in polo on February 1st 1896
+odiILFtI2y0-00174-00044086-00044374 the town joined other revolutionaries
+odiILFtI2y0-00175-00044375-00044571 when the Philippine revolution broke on
+odiILFtI2y0-00176-00044572-00044845 August 1896 while Valen doula availed
+odiILFtI2y0-00177-00044846-00045012 the amnesty offered by Spanish
+odiILFtI2y0-00178-00045013-00045274 authorities few weeks later one of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00179-00045275-00045475 notable battles in polo occurred in
+odiILFtI2y0-00180-00045476-00045706 sitios bida can pass on the light in pug
+odiILFtI2y0-00181-00045707-00045910 ad baboy where the locals won under the
+odiILFtI2y0-00182-00045911-00046150 command of general Tiburcio de Leon why
+odiILFtI2y0-00183-00046151-00046429 Gregorio during the Revolution the
+odiILFtI2y0-00184-00046430-00046669 Spanish massacred many residents most of
+odiILFtI2y0-00185-00046670-00046879 them in Melinda suspected
+odiILFtI2y0-00186-00046880-00047077 revolutionaries were hanged and tortured
+odiILFtI2y0-00187-00047078-00047299 to death many were forced to admit guilt
+odiILFtI2y0-00188-00047300-00047494 or shout innocent names others were shot
+odiILFtI2y0-00189-00047495-00047773 without trial
+odiILFtI2y0-00190-00047774-00048398 American era and Japanese occupation the
+odiILFtI2y0-00191-00048399-00048629 Americans imposed a military government
+odiILFtI2y0-00192-00048630-00048814 when they acquire Philippines from Spain
+odiILFtI2y0-00193-00048815-00048970 as part of the peace treaty of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00194-00048971-00049258 spanish-american war they appointed pi
+odiILFtI2y0-00195-00049259-00049483 oval and Zula as the first municipal
+odiILFtI2y0-00196-00049484-00049690 president of presidente municipal on
+odiILFtI2y0-00197-00049691-00049957 September 6 to 1899 to suppress
+odiILFtI2y0-00198-00049958-00050212 aggressive leadership in the area he
+odiILFtI2y0-00199-00050213-00050476 resigned in February 1901 to become the
+odiILFtI2y0-00200-00050477-00050644 head of the military division and an
+odiILFtI2y0-00201-00050645-00050920 election was held later that year the
+odiILFtI2y0-00202-00050921-00051110 government proclaimed Rufino Val and
+odiILFtI2y0-00203-00051111-00051346 Zula a relative of Pi o is the second
+odiILFtI2y0-00204-00051347-00051505 president and first elected municipal
+odiILFtI2y0-00205-00051506-00051704 president of the town when the
+odiILFtI2y0-00206-00051704-00051892 philippine-american war broke out in
+odiILFtI2y0-00207-00051894-00052160 1899 the Americans were directed to
+odiILFtI2y0-00208-00052161-00052412 capture Emilio Aguinaldo who is escaping
+odiILFtI2y0-00209-00052413-00052715 to Malolos Bulacan Polo is one of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00210-00052716-00052942 towns where Aguinaldo retreated thus it
+odiILFtI2y0-00211-00052944-00053119 received heavy casualties on the first
+odiILFtI2y0-00212-00053120-00053581 stages of the war on February 22nd 1899
+odiILFtI2y0-00213-00053582-00053822 general Antonio Luna camped at Polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00214-00053823-00054035 after an unsuccessful engagement with
+odiILFtI2y0-00215-00054036-00054232 the American forces in Caloocan the
+odiILFtI2y0-00216-00054233-00054437 entrance of the Japanese in polo during
+odiILFtI2y0-00217-00054438-00054631 the Second World War was met with almost
+odiILFtI2y0-00218-00054632-00054907 no resistance however there were too
+odiILFtI2y0-00219-00054908-00055124 many murders committed the place became
+odiILFtI2y0-00220-00055125-00055324 a center of McAfee Lee and spies who
+odiILFtI2y0-00221-00055325-00055565 troubled the peaceful civilians the
+odiILFtI2y0-00222-00055566-00055774 sudden appearance of the Japanese added
+odiILFtI2y0-00223-00055775-00055998 terror to the place
+odiILFtI2y0-00224-00055999-00056295 the reign of terror climaxed on December
+odiILFtI2y0-00225-00056296-00056607 10th 1944 it was a day of mourning for
+odiILFtI2y0-00226-00056608-00056790 the people of polo and oh bando
+odiILFtI2y0-00227-00056791-00056970 when the Japanese massacred more than a
+odiILFtI2y0-00228-00056971-00057273 hundred males in both towns about 1:00
+odiILFtI2y0-00229-00057274-00057459 a.m. on this day up to the setting of
+odiILFtI2y0-00230-00057460-00057615 the Sun cries could be heard from the
+odiILFtI2y0-00231-00057616-00057789 Municipal Building when males were
+odiILFtI2y0-00232-00057790-00057897 tortured to death
+odiILFtI2y0-00233-00057898-00058188 mayor Feliciano Ponciano met the same
+odiILFtI2y0-00234-00058189-00058362 fate when he died on a cruel death
+odiILFtI2y0-00235-00058363-00058566 together with other municipal officials
+odiILFtI2y0-00236-00058566-00058797 when liberation came the town was partly
+odiILFtI2y0-00237-00058798-00058944 burned by the approaching the military
+odiILFtI2y0-00238-00058945-00059184 forces of combined Filipino and American
+odiILFtI2y0-00239-00059185-00059475 regiments who used flamethrowers they
+odiILFtI2y0-00240-00059476-00059666 bombed and shelled big houses in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00241-00059667-00059865 town not exempting even the more than
+odiILFtI2y0-00242-00059866-00060126 300 years old church of San Diego the
+odiILFtI2y0-00243-00060127-00060303 historical old bridge connecting
+odiILFtI2y0-00244-00060304-00060489 northern and southern areas of the town
+odiILFtI2y0-00245-00060490-00060678 was destroyed by the Japanese thus
+odiILFtI2y0-00246-00060679-00060951 separating polo in two parts the
+odiILFtI2y0-00247-00060952-00061158 northern part was at once liberated by
+odiILFtI2y0-00248-00061159-00061395 joint Filipino and American troops while
+odiILFtI2y0-00249-00061396-00061563 the southern part which includes the
+odiILFtI2y0-00250-00061564-00061773 Municipal Center población was still
+odiILFtI2y0-00251-00061774-00062046 under the Japanese banner the Japanese
+odiILFtI2y0-00252-00062047-00062376 abandoned the town on February 11th 1945
+odiILFtI2y0-00253-00062377-00062553 when the combined troops were able to
+odiILFtI2y0-00254-00062554-00062970 cross the river and took the town modern
+odiILFtI2y0-00255-00062971-00063765 history on July 21st 1960s aynd
+odiILFtI2y0-00256-00063766-00064074 executive order number 401 which divided
+odiILFtI2y0-00257-00064075-00064407 polo into two polo and Valen Dula polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00258-00064408-00064608 comprised the northern Varon guise of
+odiILFtI2y0-00259-00064609-00064848 walling pool o población palace on
+odiILFtI2y0-00260-00064849-00065105 Archon Bato Perry and chalo villa the
+odiILFtI2y0-00261-00065107-00065385 Lanka's mo bolo colombo land a big
+odiILFtI2y0-00262-00065386-00065706 Tagalog Rincon for solo hunter and big
+odiILFtI2y0-00263-00065707-00066033 ney vient a reels and de London fall and
+odiILFtI2y0-00264-00066034-00066240 Zula on the other hand comprised the
+odiILFtI2y0-00265-00066241-00066417 southern Baron guys of kuru hidden
+odiILFtI2y0-00266-00066418-00066684 marilla's Melinda you Gong makuu Lang
+odiILFtI2y0-00267-00066685-00067014 lupa canoe may mason parada paso de blas
+odiILFtI2y0-00268-00067015-00067260 bag bag wind and torres bug all on now
+odiILFtI2y0-00269-00067261-00067812 gen t de leon the division soon proved
+odiILFtI2y0-00270-00067813-00068034 to be detrimental to economic growth in
+odiILFtI2y0-00271-00068035-00068265 each town so Bulacan second district
+odiILFtI2y0-00272-00068266-00068439 representative to the 5th Congress
+odiILFtI2y0-00273-00068440-00068703 regatta no mercado and senator Francisco
+odiILFtI2y0-00274-00068704-00068946 SOC Rodrigo filed a bill which sought
+odiILFtI2y0-00275-00068947-00069191 the reunification of the two towns on
+odiILFtI2y0-00276-00069192-00069385 September 11th
+odiILFtI2y0-00277-00069386-00069688 63 President Diosdado Macapagal signed
+odiILFtI2y0-00278-00069689-00069922 executive order number 46 which
+odiILFtI2y0-00279-00069923-00070200 reunified Valen doula and polo adapting
+odiILFtI2y0-00280-00070201-00070405 Valen doula as the name of the resulting
+odiILFtI2y0-00281-00070406-00070753 town in 1967 Mayor Ignacio Santiago
+odiILFtI2y0-00282-00070754-00070944 senior bought lots in care hidden in
+odiILFtI2y0-00283-00070945-00071110 which the new Municipal Hall would be
+odiILFtI2y0-00284-00071111-00071394 built misinterpretation of property
+odiILFtI2y0-00285-00071395-00071613 surveys and tax appropriation issues
+odiILFtI2y0-00286-00071614-00071812 sparked the debate on which barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-00287-00071813-00072019 should the Municipal Hall be belong to
+odiILFtI2y0-00288-00072020-00072343 carry hidden Malinda or mason to resolve
+odiILFtI2y0-00289-00072344-00072594 the issue santiago ordered the creation
+odiILFtI2y0-00290-00072595-00072778 of a new bar on guy which was called
+odiILFtI2y0-00291-00072779-00073000 población - a reference to the old
+odiILFtI2y0-00292-00073001-00073365 población barangay on November 7 1975
+odiILFtI2y0-00293-00073366-00073585 jurisdiction over Valle and Zulu was
+odiILFtI2y0-00294-00073586-00073774 moved from the province of Bulacan to
+odiILFtI2y0-00295-00073775-00074047 Metro Manila Metro Manila was then
+odiILFtI2y0-00296-00074048-00074278 headed by first lady Imelda Marcos as
+odiILFtI2y0-00297-00074279-00074638 its governor in 1968 MH del Pilar Street
+odiILFtI2y0-00298-00074639-00074850 was renovated and converted into the MH
+odiILFtI2y0-00299-00074851-00075025 del Pilar superhighway
+odiILFtI2y0-00300-00075026-00075274 in the same year macarthur highway a
+odiILFtI2y0-00301-00075275-00075450 segment of macarthur highway was
+odiILFtI2y0-00302-00075451-00075721 constructed in ball and Zula macarthur
+odiILFtI2y0-00303-00075722-00075906 highway connects Manila to northern
+odiILFtI2y0-00304-00075907-00076129 provinces of the Philippines the passage
+odiILFtI2y0-00305-00076130-00076368 of the local government code in 1991
+odiILFtI2y0-00306-00076369-00076579 provided local governments autonomy
+odiILFtI2y0-00307-00076580-00076713 which has allowed them develop into
+odiILFtI2y0-00308-00076714-00076984 self-reliant communities On February
+odiILFtI2y0-00309-00076985-00077388 14th 1998 President Fidel V Ramos signed
+odiILFtI2y0-00310-00077389-00077700 Republic Act number eight thousand 526
+odiILFtI2y0-00311-00077701-00077884 which converted the municipality of
+odiILFtI2y0-00312-00077885-00078043 valle angela into a highly urbanized
+odiILFtI2y0-00313-00078044-00078373 chartered city the law also ordered the
+odiILFtI2y0-00314-00078374-00078588 division of the newly created city into
+odiILFtI2y0-00315-00078589-00078862 two legislative districts when the law
+odiILFtI2y0-00316-00078863-00079135 was ratified on December 30th 1998
+odiILFtI2y0-00317-00079136-00079378 Volans Ulla became the 12th city to be
+odiILFtI2y0-00318-00079379-00079618 admitted in Metro Manila and the 83rd in
+odiILFtI2y0-00319-00079619-00079885 the Philippines in 2002 President Gloria
+odiILFtI2y0-00320-00079886-00080157 macapagal-arroyo proclaimed July 11th
+odiILFtI2y0-00321-00080158-00080386 every year as volunteer day which was an
+odiILFtI2y0-00322-00080387-00080548 official holiday in the city that
+odiILFtI2y0-00323-00080549-00080737 commemorates the birth date of Pi oval
+odiILFtI2y0-00324-00080738-00081081 and Zula however in 2008 the date of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00325-00081082-00081259 city's Charter Day was transferred to
+odiILFtI2y0-00326-00081260-00081393 February 14th
+odiILFtI2y0-00327-00081394-00081721 today Valens Ulla City celebrates Valen
+odiILFtI2y0-00328-00081722-00081988 Dula day in Valencia foundation day On
+odiILFtI2y0-00329-00081989-00082216 February 14th and November 12
+odiILFtI2y0-00330-00082217-00082501 respectively in may 13th 2015 a fire
+odiILFtI2y0-00331-00082502-00082705 broke out in Kent X manufacturing
+odiILFtI2y0-00332-00082706-00082759 Factory
+odiILFtI2y0-00333-00082760-00083050 barring gyujong killing 74 people in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00334-00083051-00083392 incident in 2016 the Ombudsman ordered
+odiILFtI2y0-00335-00083393-00083596 the dismissal of mayor Rex cash alien
+odiILFtI2y0-00336-00083597-00083776 and other city officials due to grave
+odiILFtI2y0-00337-00083777-00083983 misconduct and negligence of duty during
+odiILFtI2y0-00338-00083984-00084064 the incident
+odiILFtI2y0-00339-00084065-00084301 this is dubbed as the third worst fire
+odiILFtI2y0-00340-00084302-00084619 incident in the country
+odiILFtI2y0-00341-00084620-00085256 geography Valens Ulla is located at 14
+odiILFtI2y0-00342-00085257-00085604 degrees 40 minutes 58 seconds north 120
+odiILFtI2y0-00343-00085605-00085862 degrees 58 minutes one second East and
+odiILFtI2y0-00344-00085863-00086093 is about 14 kilometers eight point seven
+odiILFtI2y0-00345-00086094-00086435 miles north of country s capital Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00346-00086436-00086825 manila bay the country s top port for
+odiILFtI2y0-00347-00086826-00087017 trade and Industry is located about
+odiILFtI2y0-00348-00087018-00087305 sixteen point three kilometers one miles
+odiILFtI2y0-00349-00087306-00087584 west of the city ball and Zula is
+odiILFtI2y0-00350-00087585-00087764 bordered in the north by the town of o
+odiILFtI2y0-00351-00087765-00087986 bando and the city of mcian in Bulacan
+odiILFtI2y0-00352-00087987-00088250 the city of Navotas in the west malabon
+odiILFtI2y0-00353-00088251-00088436 in the south and caisson city and
+odiILFtI2y0-00354-00088437-00088789 northern portion of Caloocan in the east
+odiILFtI2y0-00355-00088790-00089118 the highest elevation point is 38 meters
+odiILFtI2y0-00356-00089119-00089457 125 feet above sea level having a
+odiILFtI2y0-00357-00089458-00089770 surface gradient of 0.55 percent and a
+odiILFtI2y0-00358-00089771-00090016 gentle slope hilly landscape is located
+odiILFtI2y0-00359-00090017-00090205 in the industrial section of the city in
+odiILFtI2y0-00360-00090206-00090487 Caen Dumais the average elevation point
+odiILFtI2y0-00361-00090488-00090754 is 2 meters 6.6 feet above sea level
+odiILFtI2y0-00362-00090755-00090997 apart from the political borders set by
+odiILFtI2y0-00363-00090998-00091246 the law Valens Ulla and malabon is also
+odiILFtI2y0-00364-00091247-00091468 separated by the 15 kilometer tenha
+odiILFtI2y0-00365-00091469-00091660 Harrow Stella Han River or simply
+odiILFtI2y0-00366-00091661-00091939 telehandler the river obtained its name
+odiILFtI2y0-00367-00091940-00092143 from Julia our clam due to the abundance
+odiILFtI2y0-00368-00092144-00092428 of such shellfish in the area callahan
+odiILFtI2y0-00369-00092429-00092614 is a part of the marilyn a high you know
+odiILFtI2y0-00370-00092615-00092911 bando river system of central luzon it
+odiILFtI2y0-00371-00092912-00093154 is now considered biologically dead and
+odiILFtI2y0-00372-00093155-00093337 one of the dirtiest river system in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00373-00093338-00093396 world
+odiILFtI2y0-00374-00093397-00093634 holohan river banks used to be lined
+odiILFtI2y0-00375-00093635-00093805 with mangrove trees and rich with
+odiILFtI2y0-00376-00093806-00094111 freshwater fish and crafts children used
+odiILFtI2y0-00377-00094112-00094273 to play in the river before it was
+odiILFtI2y0-00378-00094274-00094474 polluted by developing industries near
+odiILFtI2y0-00379-00094475-00094654 it in an effort to save the river the
+odiILFtI2y0-00380-00094655-00094807 Department of Environment and Natural
+odiILFtI2y0-00381-00094808-00095035 Resources metropolitan Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00382-00095036-00095224 Development Authority and the local
+odiILFtI2y0-00383-00095225-00095374 governments of Valle and Zula and
+odiILFtI2y0-00384-00095375-00095581 malabon signed partnerships with private
+odiILFtI2y0-00385-00095582-00095788 and non-government organizations to
+odiILFtI2y0-00386-00095789-00095968 dredge the area increased climate
+odiILFtI2y0-00387-00095969-00096163 variability that is associated with
+odiILFtI2y0-00388-00096164-00096328 global warming has brought with it
+odiILFtI2y0-00389-00096329-00096556 periods of heavy rainfall and high tides
+odiILFtI2y0-00390-00096557-00096751 which in turn results in stagnant water
+odiILFtI2y0-00391-00096752-00096976 which can stay in the area for up to 4
+odiILFtI2y0-00392-00096977-00097174 weeks due to insufficient drainage and
+odiILFtI2y0-00393-00097175-00097368 improper solid waste disposal
+odiILFtI2y0-00394-00097369-00097621 people are often stranded inside their
+odiILFtI2y0-00395-00097622-00097813 homes and are exposed to waterborne
+odiILFtI2y0-00396-00097814-00098001 diseases such as dengue and leftist
+odiILFtI2y0-00397-00098002-00098305 fibrosis better early warning systems
+odiILFtI2y0-00398-00098306-00098473 are needed to manage the risk associated
+odiILFtI2y0-00399-00098474-00098792 with increased rainfall
+odiILFtI2y0-00400-00098793-00099327 climate due to its location in Metro
+odiILFtI2y0-00401-00099328-00099528 Manila rainfall and climate in Valle and
+odiILFtI2y0-00402-00099529-00099753 Zula is almost similar to the country's
+odiILFtI2y0-00403-00099754-00100029 capital Manila the location of Valle and
+odiILFtI2y0-00404-00100030-00100206 Zula in the western side of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00405-00100207-00100368 Philippines made Philippine Atmospheric
+odiILFtI2y0-00406-00100369-00100641 Geophysical and astronomical Services
+odiILFtI2y0-00407-00100642-00100932 Administration PAGASA to classify its
+odiILFtI2y0-00408-00100933-00101139 weather scheme as type 1 wind coming
+odiILFtI2y0-00409-00101140-00101319 from the Pacific Ocean is generally
+odiILFtI2y0-00410-00101320-00101505 blocked by the Sierra Madre mountain
+odiILFtI2y0-00411-00101506-00101706 range several kilometres east of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00412-00101707-00101937 city its proximity to the equator tends
+odiILFtI2y0-00413-00101938-00102144 to make its temperature to rise and fall
+odiILFtI2y0-00414-00102145-00102393 into very small range from as low as 20
+odiILFtI2y0-00415-00102394-00102678 degrees Celsius 68 degrees Fahrenheit to
+odiILFtI2y0-00416-00102679-00102986 as high as 35 degrees Celsius 95 degrees
+odiILFtI2y0-00417-00102988-00103047 Fahrenheit
+odiILFtI2y0-00418-00103048-00103232 although humidity makes these warm to
+odiILFtI2y0-00419-00103233-00103484 hot temperatures feel much hotter the
+odiILFtI2y0-00420-00103485-00103725 köppen climate system classifies volun
+odiILFtI2y0-00421-00103726-00103943 Dula climate as a borderline tropical
+odiILFtI2y0-00422-00103944-00104144 monsoon AM and tropical savanna
+odiILFtI2y0-00423-00104145-00104360 due to its location and precipitation
+odiILFtI2y0-00424-00104361-00104652 characteristics this means that the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00425-00104653-00104880 has two pronounced seasons dry and wet
+odiILFtI2y0-00426-00104881-00105108 seasons
+odiILFtI2y0-00427-00105109-00105366 humidity levels are usually high in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00428-00105367-00105544 morning especially during June to
+odiILFtI2y0-00429-00105545-00105740 November which makes it feel warmer
+odiILFtI2y0-00430-00105741-00106015 lowest humidity levels are recorded in
+odiILFtI2y0-00431-00106016-00106236 the evening during wet season discomfort
+odiILFtI2y0-00432-00106238-00106450 from heat and humidity is extreme during
+odiILFtI2y0-00433-00106451-00106635 May and June otherwise it is higher
+odiILFtI2y0-00434-00106636-00106853 compared to other places in the country
+odiILFtI2y0-00435-00106854-00107283 average sunlight is maximum at 250 4.25
+odiILFtI2y0-00436-00107284-00107559 hours during April and minimum at 113
+odiILFtI2y0-00437-00107560-00107993 hours during July August and September
+odiILFtI2y0-00438-00107994-00108540 ecology the vegetation in ball and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-00439-00108541-00108726 was originally covered with grassland
+odiILFtI2y0-00440-00108727-00108993 suitable for agriculture because of
+odiILFtI2y0-00441-00108994-00109167 rapid development of industries and
+odiILFtI2y0-00442-00109168-00109422 economy land use converts grass covers
+odiILFtI2y0-00443-00109423-00109683 into cemented roads however the
+odiILFtI2y0-00444-00109683-00109821 government put into efforts of
+odiILFtI2y0-00445-00109822-00109992 preserving vegetation such as
+odiILFtI2y0-00446-00109993-00110204 constructing community vegetable gardens
+odiILFtI2y0-00447-00110205-00110427 and techno demo farms all over the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00448-00110428-00110790 in 2003 these gardens numbered up to two
+odiILFtI2y0-00449-00110791-00111008 functioning farms flora and fauna in
+odiILFtI2y0-00450-00111009-00111236 vallens ulla includes the common plants
+odiILFtI2y0-00451-00111238-00111441 and animals found in Luzon such as
+odiILFtI2y0-00452-00111442-00111723 domesticated mammals the Department of
+odiILFtI2y0-00453-00111724-00111866 Environment and Natural Resources
+odiILFtI2y0-00454-00111867-00112119 protected areas and Wildlife Bureau
+odiILFtI2y0-00455-00112120-00112338 declared a two hectare mangrove swamp
+odiILFtI2y0-00456-00112339-00112529 the area in villa and car nación
+odiILFtI2y0-00457-00112530-00112743 barangay milan day is an eco tourism
+odiILFtI2y0-00458-00112744-00113091 site every year about 100 species of
+odiILFtI2y0-00459-00113092-00113309 migratory birds such as black-crowned
+odiILFtI2y0-00460-00113310-00113558 night herons McPike Oryx Nick Tai corax
+odiILFtI2y0-00461-00113559-00113772 and other native birds such as moorhen
+odiILFtI2y0-00462-00113773-00114090 gallinula SP swamp and porphyry OSP in
+odiILFtI2y0-00463-00114091-00114321 Philippine duck and as lose Annika flock
+odiILFtI2y0-00464-00114322-00114594 the area wooden view decks are built to
+odiILFtI2y0-00465-00114595-00114828 facilitate spectators enthusiasts and
+odiILFtI2y0-00466-00114829-00115029 visitors while having bird-watching and
+odiILFtI2y0-00467-00115030-00115316 counting activities in 2007 ordinary
+odiILFtI2y0-00468-00115317-00115548 fishing ponds in Tagalog and colon were
+odiILFtI2y0-00469-00115549-00115740 transformed into fishing spots which
+odiILFtI2y0-00470-00115741-00115938 attracts anglers every year for a prized
+odiILFtI2y0-00471-00115939-00116190 catch fish tournaments are held every
+odiILFtI2y0-00472-00116191-00116400 year to increase tourism and livelihood
+odiILFtI2y0-00473-00116401-00116688 in the area in 2008 the Supreme Court of
+odiILFtI2y0-00474-00116689-00116895 the Philippines mandated regional trial
+odiILFtI2y0-00475-00116896-00117204 court branch 171 as an environmental
+odiILFtI2y0-00476-00117205-00117420 court handling all environment cases in
+odiILFtI2y0-00477-00117421-00117648 Valens allah thomas hodge Smith noted in
+odiILFtI2y0-00478-00117649-00117908 1939 that Valens Allah is rich of black
+odiILFtI2y0-00479-00117909-00118119 tektites occurring in spheroidal and
+odiILFtI2y0-00480-00118120-00118281 cylindrical shapes and are free of
+odiILFtI2y0-00481-00118282-00118491 bubbles
+odiILFtI2y0-00482-00118492-00118958 government in politics
+odiILFtI2y0-00483-00118958-00119134 like other cities in the Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00484-00119135-00119404 Valens Ulla is governed by a mayor and a
+odiILFtI2y0-00485-00119405-00119594 vice mayor who are elected to three-year
+odiILFtI2y0-00486-00119595-00119873 terms the mayor is the executive head
+odiILFtI2y0-00487-00119874-00120158 who leads the city s departments in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00488-00120158-00120383 execution of city ordinances and
+odiILFtI2y0-00489-00120383-00120689 delivery of public services the vice
+odiILFtI2y0-00490-00120690-00120938 mayor heads a Legislative Council that
+odiILFtI2y0-00491-00120939-00121172 is composed of 14 members six
+odiILFtI2y0-00492-00121173-00121534 councillors from each of the city s two
+odiILFtI2y0-00493-00121535-00121789 districts and to ex officio offices held
+odiILFtI2y0-00494-00121790-00122024 by the Association of barangay chairman
+odiILFtI2y0-00495-00122025-00122201 president as the VAR on guy sector
+odiILFtI2y0-00496-00122202-00122348 representative and the Sangguniang
+odiILFtI2y0-00497-00122349-00122584 Kabataan federation president is youth
+odiILFtI2y0-00498-00122585-00122843 sector representative the council is in
+odiILFtI2y0-00499-00122844-00123061 charge of creating the city's policies
+odiILFtI2y0-00500-00123063-00123214 in the form of ordinances and
+odiILFtI2y0-00501-00123215-00123431 resolutions the city is geographically
+odiILFtI2y0-00502-00123432-00123656 part of but not politically related to
+odiILFtI2y0-00503-00123657-00124113 the 3rd District of Metro Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00504-00124114-00124685 city officials the incumbent mayor and
+odiILFtI2y0-00505-00124686-00124881 vice mayor of the city are excellent
+odiILFtI2y0-00506-00124882-00125115 tegus alien and lorena see Natividad
+odiILFtI2y0-00507-00125116-00125499 Borja respectively
+odiILFtI2y0-00508-00125500-00126031 administrative division Valens Ulla is
+odiILFtI2y0-00509-00126032-00126279 composed of 33 barren guys the smallest
+odiILFtI2y0-00510-00126280-00126571 administrative unit in the city the VAR
+odiILFtI2y0-00511-00126572-00126772 on guy is equivalent to an American
+odiILFtI2y0-00512-00126773-00127029 village and a British ward the VAR on
+odiILFtI2y0-00513-00127030-00127231 guy is headed by the VAR on guy captain
+odiILFtI2y0-00514-00127232-00127474 or Poonam VAR on guy and his seven band
+odiILFtI2y0-00515-00127475-00127738 local council or mga Kagawa duly elected
+odiILFtI2y0-00516-00127739-00128038 by the resident youth sector of the bar
+odiILFtI2y0-00517-00128039-00128224 on guy is represented by the Youth
+odiILFtI2y0-00518-00128225-00128397 Council called the Sangguniang Kabataan
+odiILFtI2y0-00519-00128398-00128707 SK headed by the SK chairperson and his
+odiILFtI2y0-00520-00128708-00128953 seven band assembly also known as MGAs
+odiILFtI2y0-00521-00128954-00129295 cake agawid there are 33 Poonam barren
+odiILFtI2y0-00522-00129296-00129646 guys in 231 Kagawa in Valens illa SK
+odiILFtI2y0-00523-00129647-00129832 officials are also at the same number
+odiILFtI2y0-00524-00129833-00130120 the barren guys also serve as census
+odiILFtI2y0-00525-00130121-00130384 areas of the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00526-00130385-00130640 in the national level Valen Zula is
+odiILFtI2y0-00527-00130641-00130856 divided into two congressional districts
+odiILFtI2y0-00528-00130857-00131045 the first legislative district which
+odiILFtI2y0-00529-00131046-00131282 contains 24 Baran guides in the northern
+odiILFtI2y0-00530-00131283-00131450 half of the city while the second
+odiILFtI2y0-00531-00131451-00131618 legislative district contains the
+odiILFtI2y0-00532-00131619-00131774 remaining nine Baran guys of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00533-00131775-00132023 southern portion of the city unlike
+odiILFtI2y0-00534-00132024-00132275 Baran guys legislative districts has no
+odiILFtI2y0-00535-00132276-00132470 political leader but are represented by
+odiILFtI2y0-00536-00132471-00132656 congressional representatives in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00537-00132657-00132797 House of Representatives of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00538-00132798-00133024 Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00539-00133025-00133582 court system and police the Supreme
+odiILFtI2y0-00540-00133583-00133801 Court of the Philippines recognizes five
+odiILFtI2y0-00541-00133802-00133972 regional trial courts and two
+odiILFtI2y0-00542-00133973-00134149 metropolitan trial courts within
+odiILFtI2y0-00543-00134150-00134308 Valencia that have an overall
+odiILFtI2y0-00544-00134309-00134690 jurisdiction in the populace of the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00545-00134691-00135050 the Valencia City Police Station DCPS is
+odiILFtI2y0-00546-00135051-00135263 one of the four city police stations in
+odiILFtI2y0-00547-00135264-00135428 the northern Police District under the
+odiILFtI2y0-00548-00135429-00135608 jurisdiction of the nation Capital
+odiILFtI2y0-00549-00135609-00135881 Region police office today there are
+odiILFtI2y0-00550-00135882-00136127 more than 500 police officers working
+odiILFtI2y0-00551-00136128-00136340 for the V CPS which puts the police
+odiILFtI2y0-00552-00136341-00136553 residence ratio in the city and one to
+odiILFtI2y0-00553-00136554-00136850 sixteen thousand in 2007 the Valencia
+odiILFtI2y0-00554-00136851-00137072 City peace and order Council of which
+odiILFtI2y0-00555-00137073-00137330 the V CPS is a member was held second
+odiILFtI2y0-00556-00137331-00137501 placer for the best peace and order
+odiILFtI2y0-00557-00137502-00137699 council award that was conferred by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00558-00137700-00137858 Department of Interior and Local
+odiILFtI2y0-00559-00137859-00138134 Government the NCR Pio and the Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00560-00138135-00138473 peace and order council in 2012 the V
+odiILFtI2y0-00561-00138474-00138785 CPS was cited by the NCR Pio for having
+odiILFtI2y0-00562-00138786-00138977 the best women and children protection
+odiILFtI2y0-00563-00138978-00139278 desk in the metro
+odiILFtI2y0-00564-00139279-00139849 demographics the demonym of all and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-00565-00139850-00140053 is the lens Olano for males and the lens
+odiILFtI2y0-00566-00140054-00140248 Ilana for females it is sometimes
+odiILFtI2y0-00567-00140249-00140558 spelled as Valenza Linea
+odiILFtI2y0-00568-00140559-00140861 based on the 2015 census valens allah
+odiILFtI2y0-00569-00140862-00141074 city has a total population of six
+odiILFtI2y0-00570-00141075-00141236 hundred twenty thousand four hundred
+odiILFtI2y0-00571-00141237-00141479 twenty two the seventh most populous in
+odiILFtI2y0-00572-00141480-00141644 the NCR and thirteenth in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00573-00141645-00141980 Philippines this is an increase of 7.8
+odiILFtI2y0-00574-00141981-00142187 percent from five hundred seventy five
+odiILFtI2y0-00575-00142188-00142415 thousand three hundred fifty six people
+odiILFtI2y0-00576-00142416-00142663 in 2010 at an annual growth rate of a
+odiILFtI2y0-00577-00142664-00142997 1.45% the five most populous barren guys
+odiILFtI2y0-00578-00142998-00143351 are Gen T DeLeon eighty nine thousand
+odiILFtI2y0-00579-00143352-00143579 four hundred forty-one marilla's fifty
+odiILFtI2y0-00580-00143580-00143732 three thousand nine hundred seventy
+odiILFtI2y0-00581-00143733-00143942 eight Melinda forty eight thousand three
+odiILFtI2y0-00582-00143943-00144323 hundred ninety seven you Gong forty 1821
+odiILFtI2y0-00583-00144324-00144629 and Carew Hatton forty thousand 996
+odiILFtI2y0-00584-00144630-00144878 Valens illus it e household population
+odiILFtI2y0-00585-00144879-00145115 in 2010 on the other hand is at five
+odiILFtI2y0-00586-00145116-00145286 hundred seventy four thousand eight
+odiILFtI2y0-00587-00145287-00145703 hundred forty almost half 50.2% or males
+odiILFtI2y0-00588-00145704-00145976 females comprise forty nine point eight
+odiILFtI2y0-00589-00145977-00146192 percent of the population with a total
+odiILFtI2y0-00590-00146193-00146657 number of 286 548 the city has a sex
+odiILFtI2y0-00591-00146658-00146948 ratio of 100:1 males for every 100
+odiILFtI2y0-00592-00146949-00147170 females the second highest ratio in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00593-00147171-00147386 region after Navotas which has a sex
+odiILFtI2y0-00594-00147387-00147803 ratio of 100 two males for 100 females 7
+odiILFtI2y0-00595-00147804-00148069 out of 10 valence Allah city residents
+odiILFtI2y0-00596-00148070-00148373 66.7% belong to the working age group
+odiILFtI2y0-00597-00148374-00148741 are those aged 15 to 64 the remaining
+odiILFtI2y0-00598-00148742-00149156 33.3 are aged 0 to below 15 and 65 in a
+odiILFtI2y0-00599-00149157-00149315 bond which are classified as the
+odiILFtI2y0-00600-00149316-00149582 dependent age group
+odiILFtI2y0-00601-00149583-00149866 city population is expected to reach the
+odiILFtI2y0-00602-00149867-00150300 700,000 mark by mid 202 to
+odiILFtI2y0-00603-00150301-00150718 culture
+odiILFtI2y0-00604-00150719-00151241 him Iguala Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-00605-00151242-00151698 hemming Valens Ulla or fallin Zul ahem
+odiILFtI2y0-00606-00151699-00151983 is the official song of the city it is
+odiILFtI2y0-00607-00151984-00152211 sung during Flag ceremonies of private
+odiILFtI2y0-00608-00152212-00152403 and public schools as well as government
+odiILFtI2y0-00609-00152404-00152592 institutions along with the Philippine
+odiILFtI2y0-00610-00152593-00152952 national anthem Lupang Hinirang the hymn
+odiILFtI2y0-00611-00152953-00153180 was composed by edwin ortega which has
+odiILFtI2y0-00612-00153181-00153369 the primary objective to promote unity
+odiILFtI2y0-00613-00153370-00153621 progress and patriotism among the city's
+odiILFtI2y0-00614-00153622-00153849 citizens city ordinance number 18
+odiILFtI2y0-00615-00153850-00154080 mandated all citizens of all and Zula to
+odiILFtI2y0-00616-00154081-00154242 sing to him in all meetings and public
+odiILFtI2y0-00617-00154243-00154533 occasions
+odiILFtI2y0-00618-00154534-00155175 feasts and holidays in 2007 President
+odiILFtI2y0-00619-00155176-00155422 Gloria macapagal-arroyo signed Republic
+odiILFtI2y0-00620-00155423-00155724 act number nine thousand 428 which sets
+odiILFtI2y0-00621-00155725-00155920 February 14th every year is a special
+odiILFtI2y0-00622-00155921-00156087 non-working holiday to commemorate
+odiILFtI2y0-00623-00156088-00156474 cityhood of all and Zula in 1998 on the
+odiILFtI2y0-00624-00156475-00156687 same hand November 12th each year is
+odiILFtI2y0-00625-00156688-00156864 declared by the city government as the
+odiILFtI2y0-00626-00156865-00157176 city s foundation day looking back the
+odiILFtI2y0-00627-00157177-00157597 establishment of then polo in 1623 there
+odiILFtI2y0-00628-00157598-00157779 are misunderstandings before regarding
+odiILFtI2y0-00629-00157780-00158035 the date of the actual foundation of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00630-00158036-00158296 town however this date was decided by
+odiILFtI2y0-00631-00158297-00158506 the National Historical Commission of
+odiILFtI2y0-00632-00158507-00158806 the Philippines to be the town s
+odiILFtI2y0-00633-00158807-00159019 creation since Spanish colonizers
+odiILFtI2y0-00634-00159020-00159363 adopted a town s patron saint feast day
+odiILFtI2y0-00635-00159364-00159634 is its date of creation each barangay in
+odiILFtI2y0-00636-00159635-00159846 Valle and Zula have their own feast
+odiILFtI2y0-00637-00159847-00160113 most of them launched celebrations
+odiILFtI2y0-00638-00160114-00160345 during May and April to honor patron
+odiILFtI2y0-00639-00160346-00160665 saints and bounty harvest every April
+odiILFtI2y0-00640-00160666-00160965 26th a Santa Cruz and is performed along
+odiILFtI2y0-00641-00160966-00161397 with sta cruz festival in barangay isla
+odiILFtI2y0-00642-00161398-00161683 santa cruz and is a novena procession
+odiILFtI2y0-00643-00161684-00161971 commemorating saint helena as mythical
+odiILFtI2y0-00644-00161972-00162232 finding of the cross saint helena was
+odiILFtI2y0-00645-00162233-00162397 the mother of Constantine the Great
+odiILFtI2y0-00646-00162398-00162631 according to legends three hundred years
+odiILFtI2y0-00647-00162632-00162832 after the death of Christ at the age of
+odiILFtI2y0-00648-00162833-00163081 75 she went to Calvary to conduct a
+odiILFtI2y0-00649-00163082-00163314 search for the cross after some
+odiILFtI2y0-00650-00163315-00163507 archaeological diggings at the site of
+odiILFtI2y0-00651-00163508-00163681 the crucifixion she unearthed three
+odiILFtI2y0-00652-00163682-00163984 crosses she tested each one by making a
+odiILFtI2y0-00653-00163985-00164260 six servant lie on all three the cross
+odiILFtI2y0-00654-00164261-00164407 where the servant recovered was
+odiILFtI2y0-00655-00164408-00164818 identified as Christ s st. Helena s
+odiILFtI2y0-00656-00164819-00165048 feast date falls on August 8th but the
+odiILFtI2y0-00657-00165049-00165223 anniversary of the finding of the Cross
+odiILFtI2y0-00658-00165224-00165453 is on May 3rd in the Philippines this
+odiILFtI2y0-00659-00165454-00165670 celebration took the form of the Mexican
+odiILFtI2y0-00660-00165671-00165934 Santa Cruz de Mayo mano PO San Roque
+odiILFtI2y0-00661-00165935-00166161 festival is celebrated every May 12 in
+odiILFtI2y0-00662-00166162-00166471 ma bolo in Valens allah san roque is
+odiILFtI2y0-00663-00166472-00166648 also known as the patron saint of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00664-00166649-00166906 unmarried there are countless tales of
+odiILFtI2y0-00665-00166907-00167100 single girls who danced and prayed in
+odiILFtI2y0-00666-00167101-00167238 the procession and who claim to have
+odiILFtI2y0-00667-00167239-00167419 found their husband during the Fiesta
+odiILFtI2y0-00668-00167420-00167715 the festival is almost similar to o band
+odiILFtI2y0-00669-00167716-00167864 o fertility rites where
+odiILFtI2y0-00670-00167865-00168056 hopeful romantics danced to san roque
+odiILFtI2y0-00671-00168057-00168241 requesting to find their true love
+odiILFtI2y0-00672-00168242-00168509 street dancing and procession along the
+odiILFtI2y0-00673-00168510-00168665 city's major thoroughfares in
+odiILFtI2y0-00674-00168666-00168857 commemoration of the feast of san roque
+odiILFtI2y0-00675-00168858-00169064 highlighting the customs and traditional
+odiILFtI2y0-00676-00169065-00169340 celebration of the festival this also
+odiILFtI2y0-00677-00169341-00169544 commemorates towns folk victory after
+odiILFtI2y0-00678-00169545-00169697 the british departed the country
+odiILFtI2y0-00679-00169698-00169871 following the end of seven years war
+odiILFtI2y0-00680-00169872-00170087 with spain the feast of san diego de
+odiILFtI2y0-00681-00170088-00170291 alcalá is commemorated every November
+odiILFtI2y0-00682-00170292-00170588 12th and población this is a celebration
+odiILFtI2y0-00683-00170589-00170756 of the feast of the oldest church in
+odiILFtI2y0-00684-00170757-00170987 ball and Zula which includes annual boat
+odiILFtI2y0-00685-00170988-00171194 racing street dancing and different
+odiILFtI2y0-00686-00171195-00171464 fabulous activities of the festival as
+odiILFtI2y0-00687-00171465-00171695 part of the san diego de alcalá feast
+odiILFtI2y0-00688-00171696-00171902 day a unique food festival in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00689-00171903-00172103 country is celebrated which features the
+odiILFtI2y0-00690-00172104-00172337 famous baton polo the small the class
+odiILFtI2y0-00691-00172338-00172526 Iike Kannan which was originally created
+odiILFtI2y0-00692-00172527-00172841 in the town of polo this rice cake was a
+odiILFtI2y0-00693-00172842-00173012 recipient of Manuel Khe Sahn
+odiILFtI2y0-00694-00173013-00173279 Presidential Award in 1931 which was
+odiILFtI2y0-00695-00173280-00173474 cited having its exotic taste and
+odiILFtI2y0-00696-00173475-00173714 amazingly long shelf life the
+odiILFtI2y0-00697-00173715-00173912 celebration known as Pathan polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00698-00173913-00174119 festival includes a parade featuring
+odiILFtI2y0-00699-00174120-00174323 artistic creations from the rice cake
+odiILFtI2y0-00700-00174324-00174518 which showcases creativity among the
+odiILFtI2y0-00701-00174519-00174770 residents
+odiILFtI2y0-00702-00174771-00175380 landmarks the Valencia City people s
+odiILFtI2y0-00703-00175381-00175851 Park BC PP or simply people s Park is an
+odiILFtI2y0-00704-00175852-00176148 urban park located in a 1.3 hectare lot
+odiILFtI2y0-00705-00176149-00176361 beside the City Hall in barangay Cairo
+odiILFtI2y0-00706-00176362-00176661 hidden in English are conveyed o means
+odiILFtI2y0-00707-00176662-00177024 arch of stone which was constructed and
+odiILFtI2y0-00708-00177025-00177270 built by the Americans in 1910 to serve
+odiILFtI2y0-00709-00177271-00177459 as borders between the provinces of
+odiILFtI2y0-00710-00177460-00177732 Bulacan where Valens illa our Polo as it
+odiILFtI2y0-00711-00177733-00177906 was known before belonged to and
+odiILFtI2y0-00712-00177907-00178125 resolved where malabon used to be part
+odiILFtI2y0-00713-00178126-00178434 of the arch is located along M H del
+odiILFtI2y0-00714-00178435-00178623 Pilar Street which was once the main
+odiILFtI2y0-00715-00178624-00178806 gateway to North Luzon before the
+odiILFtI2y0-00716-00178807-00178998 construction of MacArthur Highway and
+odiILFtI2y0-00717-00178999-00179144 North Luzon Expressway
+odiILFtI2y0-00718-00179145-00179421 after malabon seceded from Rizal and
+odiILFtI2y0-00719-00179422-00179676 Valens Allah from Bulacan to become part
+odiILFtI2y0-00720-00179677-00179985 of metropolitan Manila in 1975 the arch
+odiILFtI2y0-00721-00179986-00180168 now marked as the boundary between the
+odiILFtI2y0-00722-00180169-00180348 two towns and their respective barren
+odiILFtI2y0-00723-00180349-00180609 guys barangay Sancho Linden malabon and
+odiILFtI2y0-00724-00180610-00180870 barangay Archon Bato in Valens illa the
+odiILFtI2y0-00725-00180871-00181101 Harry C Eggbert Memorial is located in
+odiILFtI2y0-00726-00181102-00181296 sitio tanki Street in Melinda that
+odiILFtI2y0-00727-00181297-00181485 serves as monument and memorial to
+odiILFtI2y0-00728-00181486-00181683 Brigadier General Harry clay Eggbert
+odiILFtI2y0-00729-00181684-00181932 commanding officer of the 22nd Infantry
+odiILFtI2y0-00730-00181933-00182109 Regiment of the United States who was
+odiILFtI2y0-00731-00182110-00182373 mortally wounded here in 1899 during the
+odiILFtI2y0-00732-00182374-00182537 philippine-american war
+odiILFtI2y0-00733-00182538-00182796 additionally Egbert also served the US
+odiILFtI2y0-00734-00182797-00183024 Army during American Civil War and
+odiILFtI2y0-00735-00183025-00183255 spanish-american war the Museo Valens
+odiILFtI2y0-00736-00183256-00183483 ulla English Valle and Zulu museum was
+odiILFtI2y0-00737-00183484-00183717 the house where dr. Pye oval and Zula in
+odiILFtI2y0-00738-00183718-00183924 whose memory the old town of polo was
+odiILFtI2y0-00739-00183925-00184137 renamed was born and saw the best years
+odiILFtI2y0-00740-00184138-00184404 of his life this same house was burned
+odiILFtI2y0-00741-00184405-00184761 recently fallen Zula s historical and
+odiILFtI2y0-00742-00184762-00185034 cultural landmark Museo Valle and zoo la
+odiILFtI2y0-00743-00185035-00185223 features collections of artifacts
+odiILFtI2y0-00744-00185224-00185625 depicting the city as past in continuing
+odiILFtI2y0-00745-00185626-00185840 development
+odiILFtI2y0-00746-00185841-00186146 the lighting in Inge mga happen English
+odiILFtI2y0-00747-00186147-00186410 Japanese cemetery was built in a 500
+odiILFtI2y0-00748-00186411-00186571 square metre lot of the Bureau of
+odiILFtI2y0-00749-00186572-00186875 telecommunications compound the cemetery
+odiILFtI2y0-00750-00186876-00187070 served thousands of fallen Japanese
+odiILFtI2y0-00751-00187071-00187277 soldiers during the Philippines campaign
+odiILFtI2y0-00752-00187278-00187472 of 1944-45
+odiILFtI2y0-00753-00187473-00187649 the National Shrine of Our Lady of
+odiILFtI2y0-00754-00187650-00187895 fátima to Golic pambansang dan Banda
+odiILFtI2y0-00755-00187896-00188108 amber Henning Fatima is the center of
+odiILFtI2y0-00756-00188109-00188312 the Fatima apostolate in the country was
+odiILFtI2y0-00757-00188313-00188573 declared a tourist site in 1982 by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00758-00188574-00188771 Department of Tourism and a pilgrimage
+odiILFtI2y0-00759-00188772-00188999 shrine in 2009 by the Diocese of
+odiILFtI2y0-00760-00189000-00189269 malala's it is near the Our Lady of
+odiILFtI2y0-00761-00189270-00189530 Fatima University the shrine houses the
+odiILFtI2y0-00762-00189531-00189770 wooden statue of Our Lady of Fatima one
+odiILFtI2y0-00763-00189771-00189983 of the 50 images blessed by Pope Paul
+odiILFtI2y0-00764-00189984-00190271 the sixth in 1967 as part of golden
+odiILFtI2y0-00765-00190272-00190472 celebration of the Marian apparition to
+odiILFtI2y0-00766-00190473-00190757 three children in Fatima Portugal the
+odiILFtI2y0-00767-00190758-00190934 images were later distributed to
+odiILFtI2y0-00768-00190935-00191120 churches worldwide where one of them is
+odiILFtI2y0-00769-00191121-00191276 intended for the Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00770-00191277-00191465 however unclaimed ending up in New
+odiILFtI2y0-00771-00191466-00191825 Jersey in 1984 Archbishop of Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-00772-00191826-00192059 Jaime cardinal sin finally claimed the
+odiILFtI2y0-00773-00192060-00192233 statue and was then transferred under
+odiILFtI2y0-00774-00192234-00192470 the custody bhai Maria Foundation a
+odiILFtI2y0-00775-00192471-00192677 Philippine based Marian organization
+odiILFtI2y0-00776-00192678-00193040 during People Power Revolution in 1986
+odiILFtI2y0-00777-00193041-00193271 it was one of the iconic figures held by
+odiILFtI2y0-00778-00193272-00193469 revolutionaries to oust the dictator
+odiILFtI2y0-00779-00193470-00193826 Ferdinand Marcos on October 17th 1999
+odiILFtI2y0-00780-00193827-00194018 the statue was then transferred to the
+odiILFtI2y0-00781-00194019-00194285 shrine the feast of Our Lady of Fatima
+odiILFtI2y0-00782-00194286-00194519 is celebrated every March 7th and May
+odiILFtI2y0-00783-00194520-00194582 13th
+odiILFtI2y0-00784-00194583-00194915 dr. high oval and Zula who became part
+odiILFtI2y0-00785-00194916-00195086 of the triumvirate of revolutionary
+odiILFtI2y0-00786-00195087-00195308 society Katipunan and founder of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00787-00195309-00195611 organ and colon lived and died in 1956
+odiILFtI2y0-00788-00195612-00195848 at the old residence of Pi oval and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-00789-00195849-00196064 along the Lilla street in barangay perry
+odiILFtI2y0-00790-00196065-00196232 in chalo villa where a marker by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00791-00196233-00196451 valencia city government was placed in
+odiILFtI2y0-00792-00196452-00196700 his honor the present house was built
+odiILFtI2y0-00793-00196701-00196859 after the war on the site of the old
+odiILFtI2y0-00794-00196860-00197051 house which once served as venue for
+odiILFtI2y0-00795-00197052-00197222 secret meetings and gatherings of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00796-00197223-00197486 Katipunan the old house was burned
+odiILFtI2y0-00797-00197487-00197726 during world war ii the san diego de
+odiILFtI2y0-00798-00197727-00197954 alcalá church in its belfry was built in
+odiILFtI2y0-00799-00197955-00198229 1632 by the people of polo
+odiILFtI2y0-00800-00198230-00198464 residents were taken to forced labor to
+odiILFtI2y0-00801-00198465-00198635 complete the church after the town
+odiILFtI2y0-00802-00198636-00198803 gained its independence through father
+odiILFtI2y0-00803-00198804-00199106 one two Ronco and Don Juan Monsod the
+odiILFtI2y0-00804-00199107-00199232 belfry and entrance
+odiILFtI2y0-00805-00199233-00199438 which are over four centuries old are
+odiILFtI2y0-00806-00199439-00199610 the only parts of the edifice that
+odiILFtI2y0-00807-00199611-00199874 remained to this day the main structure
+odiILFtI2y0-00808-00199875-00200041 was destroyed by bombs during the
+odiILFtI2y0-00809-00200042-00200297 Japanese occupation residents of Baron
+odiILFtI2y0-00810-00200298-00200539 guys polo and población celebrate the
+odiILFtI2y0-00811-00200540-00200764 feast day of San Diego de alcalá on
+odiILFtI2y0-00812-00200765-00200972 November 12th every year together with
+odiILFtI2y0-00813-00200973-00201197 the Pathan Polo festival located at
+odiILFtI2y0-00814-00201198-00201391 Milan Day the hearts of Jesus and Mary
+odiILFtI2y0-00815-00201392-00201628 parish church was erected on October
+odiILFtI2y0-00816-00201629-00201950 17th 1994 to replace the stokke Cristo
+odiILFtI2y0-00817-00201951-00202225 Chapel and solemnly declared on June 24
+odiILFtI2y0-00818-00202226-00202574 2001 the church belongs to the Bukharian
+odiILFtI2y0-00819-00202575-00202750 of Saint did Achatz of alcohol at Valle
+odiILFtI2y0-00820-00202751-00203009 and Zula City Roman Catholic Diocese of
+odiILFtI2y0-00821-00203010-00203235 malala's
+odiILFtI2y0-00822-00203236-00203484 the Valencia Astrodome is a large
+odiILFtI2y0-00823-00203485-00203691 multi-purpose domed sports stadium
+odiILFtI2y0-00824-00203692-00203898 located in barangay de London and that
+odiILFtI2y0-00825-00203899-00204092 hosts several sports events concerts
+odiILFtI2y0-00826-00204093-00204378 promotional events seminars job fairs
+odiILFtI2y0-00827-00204379-00204577 etc
+odiILFtI2y0-00828-00204578-00204888 the Valencia City Convention Center is
+odiILFtI2y0-00829-00204889-00205075 the center of culture of Performing Arts
+odiILFtI2y0-00830-00205076-00205351 of Allens ulla the facility caters
+odiILFtI2y0-00831-00205352-00205563 various events such as plays concerts
+odiILFtI2y0-00832-00205564-00205855 shows exhibits and seminars and houses
+odiILFtI2y0-00833-00205856-00206029 several interest groups among others
+odiILFtI2y0-00834-00206030-00206176 that help promote the history and
+odiILFtI2y0-00835-00206177-00206361 culture of the city and then Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00836-00206362-00206603 at large
+odiILFtI2y0-00837-00206604-00207036 services
+odiILFtI2y0-00838-00207037-00207519 education the city collaborates with
+odiILFtI2y0-00839-00207521-00207730 other institutions government or private
+odiILFtI2y0-00840-00207731-00207955 to bring quality education among its
+odiILFtI2y0-00841-00207956-00208210 citizens under that winning and Yuka
+odiILFtI2y0-00842-00208211-00208501 Sian program roughly means education
+odiILFtI2y0-00843-00208502-00208729 wind SiC program when is the nickname of
+odiILFtI2y0-00844-00208730-00208990 the current mayor shearling - a lien in
+odiILFtI2y0-00845-00208991-00209242 2010 the government in partnership with
+odiILFtI2y0-00846-00209242-00209455 a local school board funded the purchase
+odiILFtI2y0-00847-00209456-00209592 and construction of computer
+odiILFtI2y0-00848-00209594-00209815 laboratories in 10th secondary schools
+odiILFtI2y0-00849-00209816-00210202 all having a net worth of PHP 17.7 m or
+odiILFtI2y0-00850-00210203-00210400 about four hundred ten thousand dollars
+odiILFtI2y0-00851-00210401-00210723 as of April 2011 this also includes the
+odiILFtI2y0-00852-00210725-00211105 distribution of PHP 1.46 m for about
+odiILFtI2y0-00853-00211106-00211317 thirty four thousand dollars as of April
+odiILFtI2y0-00854-00211319-00211513 2011 computers in famine descending
+odiILFtI2y0-00855-00211514-00211819 lungsod in Valencia and Valencia City
+odiILFtI2y0-00856-00211819-00212008 Polytechnic College as part of
+odiILFtI2y0-00857-00212009-00212152 Department of Education
+odiILFtI2y0-00858-00212153-00212578 si si t4e strategic plan in this project
+odiILFtI2y0-00859-00212579-00212881 information and communication technology
+odiILFtI2y0-00860-00212882-00213157 education is extended and expanded among
+odiILFtI2y0-00861-00213158-00213505 all students in 2009 the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00862-00213506-00213757 engineering office repaired sidewalks
+odiILFtI2y0-00863-00213758-00213955 and drainage to assist students
+odiILFtI2y0-00864-00213956-00214162 especially during the wet season they
+odiILFtI2y0-00865-00214163-00214371 also repaired and constructed new
+odiILFtI2y0-00866-00214373-00214596 buildings and classrooms - some schools
+odiILFtI2y0-00867-00214598-00214891 in the city under the same program
+odiILFtI2y0-00868-00214892-00215152 elementary school students received free
+odiILFtI2y0-00869-00215153-00215362 mathematics and English workbooks
+odiILFtI2y0-00870-00215363-00215578 published by the government especially
+odiILFtI2y0-00871-00215579-00215836 designed for villains Allah knows the
+odiILFtI2y0-00872-00215837-00216181 steady increase of 3.4% enrollment rate
+odiILFtI2y0-00873-00216182-00216382 each year forces the government to
+odiILFtI2y0-00874-00216383-00216559 construct new buildings and classrooms
+odiILFtI2y0-00875-00216560-00216871 to meet the target 145 teacher to
+odiILFtI2y0-00876-00216871-00217111 student ratio contrary to the current
+odiILFtI2y0-00877-00217112-00217398 count of 150 ratio alternating in three
+odiILFtI2y0-00878-00217400-00217750 shifts when Aang and Yuka Sian program
+odiILFtI2y0-00879-00217751-00217981 was done in partnership with the synergy
+odiILFtI2y0-00880-00217982-00218167 of foundation a non-government
+odiILFtI2y0-00881-00218167-00218362 organisation that aims to improve
+odiILFtI2y0-00882-00218363-00218598 education in local governments in the
+odiILFtI2y0-00883-00218600-00218836 Philippines at the same time when Aang
+odiILFtI2y0-00884-00218837-00219019 and you co-signed program also
+odiILFtI2y0-00885-00219019-00219246 spearheads the yearly training of some
+odiILFtI2y0-00886-00219248-00219442 mathematics and English language
+odiILFtI2y0-00887-00219442-00219667 teachers assigned to grades one and two
+odiILFtI2y0-00888-00219667-00220000 pupils the seminar focuses on how to
+odiILFtI2y0-00889-00220001-00220219 enhance reading skills language
+odiILFtI2y0-00890-00220219-00220352 proficiency and
+odiILFtI2y0-00891-00220353-00220508 automatics of the students they are
+odiILFtI2y0-00892-00220509-00220691 teaching through reacquaintance with
+odiILFtI2y0-00893-00220692-00221012 various drills and activities this was
+odiILFtI2y0-00894-00221013-00221210 done with the efforts of lectures from
+odiILFtI2y0-00895-00221211-00221494 Aden AO de Manila University in Bulacan
+odiILFtI2y0-00896-00221496-00221741 State University using the approach
+odiILFtI2y0-00897-00221742-00222121 developed by the UP Diliman s College of
+odiILFtI2y0-00898-00222123-00222317 Education the government owns foam on
+odiILFtI2y0-00899-00222317-00222598 dasain lungsod in Valencia and Valencia
+odiILFtI2y0-00900-00222600-00222823 City Polytechnic College that serve as
+odiILFtI2y0-00901-00222825-00223042 the City State University and technical
+odiILFtI2y0-00902-00223044-00223198 school for residents and non-residents
+odiILFtI2y0-00903-00223198-00223481 respectively the Pooh Montes an aim
+odiILFtI2y0-00904-00223482-00223703 lungsod anvil and Zula plv
+odiILFtI2y0-00905-00223704-00223910 or university of the city of vallens
+odiILFtI2y0-00906-00223911-00224167 illa was established in 2002 and is
+odiILFtI2y0-00907-00224169-00224357 located within the perimeters of the old
+odiILFtI2y0-00908-00224358-00224741 city hall in barangay población in 2009
+odiILFtI2y0-00909-00224742-00225028 the City Council passed resolution now
+odiILFtI2y0-00910-00225029-00225373 194 series of 2008 which authorized the
+odiILFtI2y0-00911-00225375-00225635 government to purchase Lots costing PHP
+odiILFtI2y0-00912-00225636-00226067 33 m for about $750,000 as of April 2011
+odiILFtI2y0-00913-00226067-00226283 in nearby children of Mary Immaculate
+odiILFtI2y0-00914-00226284-00226484 college as part of the university's
+odiILFtI2y0-00915-00226485-00226763 expansion mayor Sherwin Gachet lien
+odiILFtI2y0-00916-00226764-00226955 assisted the development which has an
+odiILFtI2y0-00917-00226956-00227381 overall cost of PHP 75 M or about 1.7
+odiILFtI2y0-00918-00227382-00227627 million dollars as of April 2011 loan
+odiILFtI2y0-00919-00227628-00227806 from Development Bank of the Philippines
+odiILFtI2y0-00920-00227807-00228073 the newly purchased Lots are used to
+odiILFtI2y0-00921-00228075-00228254 construct an annex building which will
+odiILFtI2y0-00922-00228255-00228401 house the department's of Business
+odiILFtI2y0-00923-00228402-00228686 Administration and accountancy the Board
+odiILFtI2y0-00924-00228687-00228878 of Regents expected an increase of
+odiILFtI2y0-00925-00228879-00229037 enrollment from eight hundred to three
+odiILFtI2y0-00926-00229038-00229253 thousand students in the next few years
+odiILFtI2y0-00927-00229254-00229514 Valon doula City Polytechnic College v
+odiILFtI2y0-00928-00229515-00229856 CPC was allotted with additional PHP 18
+odiILFtI2y0-00929-00229857-00230081 M for about four hundred twenty thousand
+odiILFtI2y0-00930-00230082-00230402 dollars as of April 2011 budget in 2009
+odiILFtI2y0-00931-00230403-00230579 from the city fund which will be used
+odiILFtI2y0-00932-00230580-00230792 for expansion and upgrade of the college
+odiILFtI2y0-00933-00230792-00231002 there are also privately-owned academic
+odiILFtI2y0-00934-00231003-00231200 institutions including the Our Lady of
+odiILFtI2y0-00935-00231201-00231623 Fatima University OLF EU o LF u was
+odiILFtI2y0-00936-00231623-00231809 previously granted by Commission on
+odiILFtI2y0-00937-00231810-00232013 Higher Education and autonomy which
+odiILFtI2y0-00938-00232014-00232198 includes independence from monitoring
+odiILFtI2y0-00939-00232200-00232373 and evaluation services by the
+odiILFtI2y0-00940-00232373-00232538 Commission they're still entitled by
+odiILFtI2y0-00941-00232539-00232742 subsidies and other financial grants
+odiILFtI2y0-00942-00232742-00232886 from the national government whenever
+odiILFtI2y0-00943-00232887-00233173 possible the autonomous status of the
+odiILFtI2y0-00944-00233175-00233462 university was approved on March 11 2009
+odiILFtI2y0-00945-00233463-00233678 and expired last March 30
+odiILFtI2y0-00946-00233679-00233910 20:14
+odiILFtI2y0-00947-00233911-00234435 health care there are numerous hospitals
+odiILFtI2y0-00948-00234436-00234640 in ball and Zula like the city run vol
+odiILFtI2y0-00949-00234641-00234882 Angeles City emergency hospital and the
+odiILFtI2y0-00950-00234883-00235182 Valencia City General Hospital there are
+odiILFtI2y0-00951-00235183-00235410 also privately owned hospitals like Cal
+odiILFtI2y0-00952-00235411-00235632 Elaine General Hospital Sanctus Mo
+odiILFtI2y0-00953-00235633-00235867 Rosario General Hospital and Fatima
+odiILFtI2y0-00954-00235867-00236062 University Medical Center a tertiary
+odiILFtI2y0-00955-00236063-00236235 private hospital under the
+odiILFtI2y0-00956-00236236-00236416 administration of Our Lady of Fatima
+odiILFtI2y0-00957-00236417-00236737 University the soon to rise Valens illa
+odiILFtI2y0-00958-00236738-00236946 City West emergency hospital and
+odiILFtI2y0-00959-00236947-00237183 dialysis center is located in barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-00960-00237184-00237417 de London an adjacent to Valencia City
+odiILFtI2y0-00961-00237419-00237633 Astrodome into London and national high
+odiILFtI2y0-00962-00237634-00237892 school it will render adequate health
+odiILFtI2y0-00963-00237892-00238050 care services to underprivileged
+odiILFtI2y0-00964-00238051-00238269 residents at a minimal fee the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00965-00238271-00238503 implements VC cares program which is
+odiILFtI2y0-00966-00238504-00238692 designed for individuals who are unable
+odiILFtI2y0-00967-00238694-00238845 to provide health care and basic
+odiILFtI2y0-00968-00238846-00239044 necessities for themselves or meet
+odiILFtI2y0-00969-00239044-00239256 special emergency situations of need
+odiILFtI2y0-00970-00239257-00239526 while health care service and financial
+odiILFtI2y0-00971-00239527-00239721 assistance are generally the forms of
+odiILFtI2y0-00972-00239722-00239869 assistance given these may be
+odiILFtI2y0-00973-00239869-00240033 supplemented by other forms of
+odiILFtI2y0-00974-00240034-00240249 assistance as well as problem-solving
+odiILFtI2y0-00975-00240250-00240480 and referral services appropriate
+odiILFtI2y0-00976-00240481-00240712 referrals may be made to other agencies
+odiILFtI2y0-00977-00240713-00240927 or institutions where complimentary
+odiILFtI2y0-00978-00240928-00241131 services may be obtained according to
+odiILFtI2y0-00979-00241132-00241363 the 2002 Commission on audit the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00980-00241364-00241530 reported accomplishment for health
+odiILFtI2y0-00981-00241531-00241762 center ranging from as low as forty two
+odiILFtI2y0-00982-00241763-00241987 point two six percent to as high as two
+odiILFtI2y0-00983-00241988-00242164 hundred six percent and vaccine
+odiILFtI2y0-00984-00242165-00242370 utilization of thirty three percent to
+odiILFtI2y0-00985-00242371-00242569 ninety percent compared to normal 46
+odiILFtI2y0-00986-00242569-00242788 percent to three hundred seventy seven
+odiILFtI2y0-00987-00242789-00243006 percent for basic requirements there are
+odiILFtI2y0-00988-00243007-00243252 swampy areas on Valencia and there is of
+odiILFtI2y0-00989-00243253-00243444 stagnant water Intelli Han River on the
+odiILFtI2y0-00990-00243446-00243669 south which makes citizens vulnerable to
+odiILFtI2y0-00991-00243671-00243885 mosquito linked diseases such as dengue
+odiILFtI2y0-00992-00243886-00244138 and malaria though malaria is not a
+odiILFtI2y0-00993-00244139-00244350 common case in Valens illa the city
+odiILFtI2y0-00994-00244351-00244596 ranks consistently among top five dengue
+odiILFtI2y0-00995-00244597-00244803 infected regions in the Philippines with
+odiILFtI2y0-00996-00244804-00245067 around 560 percent chance of recurrence
+odiILFtI2y0-00997-00245069-00245406 every year in the second quarter of 2008
+odiILFtI2y0-00998-00245407-00245682 however only 500 percent increase was
+odiILFtI2y0-00999-00245683-00245889 reported compared to the same period in
+odiILFtI2y0-01000-00245890-00246246 2007 in September 2009 the Department of
+odiILFtI2y0-01001-00246247-00246463 Health distributed frioli set and E
+odiILFtI2y0-01002-00246464-00246621 dengue Nets treated permethrin
+odiILFtI2y0-01003-00246622-00246978 insecticide to Jan T de Leon High School
+odiILFtI2y0-01004-00246979-00247258 over 150 rolls of the nets were
+odiILFtI2y0-01005-00247259-00247438 given and installed to the windows of
+odiILFtI2y0-01006-00247439-00247723 the said school as part of do h's the
+odiILFtI2y0-01007-00247723-00247996 law solve our on guy acts i in contra
+odiILFtI2y0-01008-00247996-00248323 dengue visit bar on guy action against
+odiILFtI2y0-01009-00248323-00248673 dengue campaign
+odiILFtI2y0-01010-00248675-00249109 shopping centers and utilities
+odiILFtI2y0-01011-00249110-00249523 on October 28 2005 SM City Val and
+odiILFtI2y0-01012-00249524-00249794 Zillah was inaugurated other shopping
+odiILFtI2y0-01013-00249794-00249997 sites such as pure gold ball and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-01014-00249998-00250217 the newly renovated South supermarket
+odiILFtI2y0-01015-00250217-00250423 and the newly opened pure gold paso de
+odiILFtI2y0-01016-00250424-00250702 bla siz also located in the city all
+odiILFtI2y0-01017-00250703-00250903 these stores compete against each other
+odiILFtI2y0-01018-00250904-00251071 since most have the same product
+odiILFtI2y0-01019-00251072-00251283 offerings as diversified groceries
+odiILFtI2y0-01020-00251284-00251513 people from the city with more major
+odiILFtI2y0-01021-00251514-00251725 shopping needs normally head south to
+odiILFtI2y0-01022-00251726-00251932 cities such as Khe Sanh City and Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-01023-00251933-00252100 since they have bigger malls and
+odiILFtI2y0-01024-00252101-00252266 commercial centers with more diverse
+odiILFtI2y0-01025-00252267-00252473 trade goods
+odiILFtI2y0-01026-00252473-00252750 water supply for the city is supplied by
+odiILFtI2y0-01027-00252751-00252951 the Metropolitan Water Works and
+odiILFtI2y0-01028-00252952-00253184 sewerage system MW SS West
+odiILFtI2y0-01029-00253185-00253406 concessionaire miney lead water Services
+odiILFtI2y0-01030-00253407-00253859 Inc MW si as of 2006 the city has at
+odiILFtI2y0-01031-00253860-00254115 least 68 percent water service coverage
+odiILFtI2y0-01032-00254116-00254319 is determined by the regulatory office
+odiILFtI2y0-01033-00254319-00254673 of the MW SS each customer receives at
+odiILFtI2y0-01034-00254673-00254933 least 7 psi water pressure which means
+odiILFtI2y0-01035-00254934-00255129 supply can reach for up to two floors
+odiILFtI2y0-01036-00255130-00255423 for residential use my Neil it is owned
+odiILFtI2y0-01037-00255423-00255698 and currently operated by DMC i holdings
+odiILFtI2y0-01038-00255700-00255896 inc metro pacific investments
+odiILFtI2y0-01039-00255898-00256152 corporation DMC i MPIC
+odiILFtI2y0-01040-00256153-00256455 on june 2nd 2010 the Sottero francisco
+odiILFtI2y0-01041-00256456-00256644 memorial national high school in
+odiILFtI2y0-01042-00256644-00256854 barangay you Gong unveiled its first
+odiILFtI2y0-01043-00256855-00257073 solar generators the first time for a
+odiILFtI2y0-01044-00257073-00257417 school in the Philippines the 6 1 kW
+odiILFtI2y0-01045-00257419-00257652 photovoltaic solar arrays installed to
+odiILFtI2y0-01046-00257653-00257846 light 9 classrooms are bought from liang
+odiILFtI2y0-01047-00257848-00258032 shuang america corporation through the
+odiILFtI2y0-01048-00258033-00258194 foundation for environmental education
+odiILFtI2y0-01049-00258196-00258410 fee and are part of the solar energy
+odiILFtI2y0-01050-00258411-00258690 initiative of the city the arrays were
+odiILFtI2y0-01051-00258691-00258894 shipped from Illinois installation were
+odiILFtI2y0-01052-00258894-00259121 paid by the city government first
+odiILFtI2y0-01053-00259123-00259350 District Representative Rex cash alien
+odiILFtI2y0-01054-00259351-00259544 and former 2nd district councillor
+odiILFtI2y0-01055-00259546-00259740 shelana Soledad headed the switching
+odiILFtI2y0-01056-00259741-00259919 ceremony that made it the first ever
+odiILFtI2y0-01057-00259921-00260198 solar-powered school in the country the
+odiILFtI2y0-01058-00260200-00260423 solar panels can generate one kilowatt
+odiILFtI2y0-01059-00260425-00260630 to five kilowatts of electricity per
+odiILFtI2y0-01060-00260631-00260805 hour depending on the intensity of
+odiILFtI2y0-01061-00260806-00261107 sunlight unused solar energy is stored
+odiILFtI2y0-01062-00261108-00261323 in a deep cycle batteries which can be
+odiILFtI2y0-01063-00261325-00261581 used after sunset the panels also
+odiILFtI2y0-01064-00261582-00261780 continue to absorb light from the night
+odiILFtI2y0-01065-00261781-00261980 sky
+odiILFtI2y0-01066-00261981-00262571 waste management according to the 2002
+odiILFtI2y0-01067-00262572-00262739 metro manila solid waste management
+odiILFtI2y0-01068-00262740-00262996 report of the Asian Development Bank ADB
+odiILFtI2y0-01069-00262997-00263246 Volans Allah has the highest number of
+odiILFtI2y0-01070-00263247-00263459 identified recycling companies in the
+odiILFtI2y0-01071-00263460-00263747 region it was also said that recycling
+odiILFtI2y0-01072-00263748-00263975 centers related to plastic materials are
+odiILFtI2y0-01073-00263976-00264155 relatively higher than other recyclable
+odiILFtI2y0-01074-00264156-00264419 objects like metals paper glass among
+odiILFtI2y0-01075-00264420-00264671 others accordingly the city government
+odiILFtI2y0-01076-00264672-00264881 allocates an amount of about seven
+odiILFtI2y0-01077-00264882-00265046 hundred eighty five point seven zero
+odiILFtI2y0-01078-00265047-00265478 Philippine pesos approximately $18 as of
+odiILFtI2y0-01079-00265479-00265748 April 2011 for every transportation and
+odiILFtI2y0-01080-00265749-00265919 collection costs of a ton of waste
+odiILFtI2y0-01081-00265920-00266282 material in 2003 the city generated
+odiILFtI2y0-01082-00266283-00266480 about three hundred seven point seven
+odiILFtI2y0-01083-00266481-00266846 zero tons of waste every day in 2001 it
+odiILFtI2y0-01084-00266847-00267101 was reported by ADB that the city has as
+odiILFtI2y0-01085-00267102-00267326 high as twenty five percent solid waste
+odiILFtI2y0-01086-00267327-00267527 management cost recovery rate through
+odiILFtI2y0-01087-00267528-00267725 service charges on households and other
+odiILFtI2y0-01088-00267726-00267947 enterprises for operational activities
+odiILFtI2y0-01089-00267948-00268133 associated with waste collection
+odiILFtI2y0-01090-00268134-00268415 treatment and disposal that same year
+odiILFtI2y0-01091-00268416-00268709 the city s proposal to implement a
+odiILFtI2y0-01092-00268710-00268930 community-based solid waste management
+odiILFtI2y0-01093-00268931-00269228 project in barangay i'ma pooling lupa
+odiILFtI2y0-01094-00269229-00269396 was approved by the national government
+odiILFtI2y0-01095-00269397-00269672 which involves social mobilization
+odiILFtI2y0-01096-00269673-00269939 training of personnel implementation of
+odiILFtI2y0-01097-00269940-00270179 segregated collection and establishment
+odiILFtI2y0-01098-00270180-00270404 of materials recovery facility and
+odiILFtI2y0-01099-00270405-00270626 windows composting operation among
+odiILFtI2y0-01100-00270627-00270944 others the city government was granted a
+odiILFtI2y0-01101-00270945-00271187 maximum of twenty five thousand dollars
+odiILFtI2y0-01102-00271188-00271394 from Asian Development Bank for the
+odiILFtI2y0-01103-00271395-00271715 operation of the project in 1988 the
+odiILFtI2y0-01104-00271716-00271952 city opened its first waste disposal
+odiILFtI2y0-01105-00271953-00272153 facility the lingering and controlled
+odiILFtI2y0-01106-00272154-00272465 dump site every year the facility
+odiILFtI2y0-01107-00272466-00272792 collects and processed only about 60% of
+odiILFtI2y0-01108-00272793-00273140 the entire city s waste with land
+odiILFtI2y0-01109-00273141-00273380 filling and recycling services the dump
+odiILFtI2y0-01110-00273381-00273620 site uses rice hull ashes daily cover
+odiILFtI2y0-01111-00273621-00273818 and odor control material for the waste
+odiILFtI2y0-01112-00273819-00274076 collected in the area lingua and
+odiILFtI2y0-01113-00274077-00274283 controlled dump site also conducted some
+odiILFtI2y0-01114-00274284-00274514 limited waste segregation and resource
+odiILFtI2y0-01115-00274515-00274745 recovery operations prior to burial of
+odiILFtI2y0-01116-00274746-00275093 residual waste in 2006 the controlled
+odiILFtI2y0-01117-00275094-00275336 dump site was closed for M MVA order
+odiILFtI2y0-01118-00275337-00275597 in 2003 and was subsequently converted
+odiILFtI2y0-01119-00275598-00275825 into a sanitary landfill as directed by
+odiILFtI2y0-01120-00275826-00276212 raw 9003 in statistics 60% of the wastes
+odiILFtI2y0-01121-00276213-00276374 collected in the city are collected
+odiILFtI2y0-01122-00276375-00276539 hauled and dumped in controlled dump
+odiILFtI2y0-01123-00276540-00276752 sites while 5% are retrieved and
+odiILFtI2y0-01124-00276753-00276998 recycled and 35% are thrown everywhere
+odiILFtI2y0-01125-00276999-00277280 in the city half of all these wastes are
+odiILFtI2y0-01126-00277281-00277499 non biodegradable wastes which include
+odiILFtI2y0-01127-00277500-00277736 plastics styrofoam's and rubbers alike
+odiILFtI2y0-01128-00277737-00277873 while the remaining are biodegradable
+odiILFtI2y0-01129-00277874-00278183 wastes which is 70% food in kitchen
+odiILFtI2y0-01130-00278184-00278507 wastes 20% plant wastes and 10% animal
+odiILFtI2y0-01131-00278508-00278879 wastes in 2002 there are about 30 small
+odiILFtI2y0-01132-00278880-00279053 and big junk shops that collect
+odiILFtI2y0-01133-00279054-00279308 recyclable materials and 20 schools that
+odiILFtI2y0-01134-00279309-00279449 require their students to bring
+odiILFtI2y0-01135-00279450-00279686 recyclable stuff as school project the
+odiILFtI2y0-01136-00279687-00279946 city spearheaded Metro Manila s
+odiILFtI2y0-01137-00279947-00280175 implementation of full fledged waste
+odiILFtI2y0-01138-00280176-00280487 management program in 1999 when it
+odiILFtI2y0-01139-00280488-00280709 became the first area in the region to
+odiILFtI2y0-01140-00280710-00281015 allocate 2.8 hectare land in barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-01141-00281016-00281267 marilla's to serve an ecology center and
+odiILFtI2y0-01142-00281268-00281657 location for the city s waste management
+odiILFtI2y0-01143-00281658-00281945 programs operation center biodegradable
+odiILFtI2y0-01144-00281946-00282131 wastes in this area are converted to
+odiILFtI2y0-01145-00282132-00282428 fertilizers in 2004 the city government
+odiILFtI2y0-01146-00282429-00282695 funded the repair of 29 garbage trucks
+odiILFtI2y0-01147-00282696-00282899 and purchase of another 20 trucks that
+odiILFtI2y0-01148-00282900-00283070 may increase the capacity of waste
+odiILFtI2y0-01149-00283071-00283274 management office to do full rounds of
+odiILFtI2y0-01150-00283275-00283544 garbage every week
+odiILFtI2y0-01151-00283545-00284070 justice management in a joint study
+odiILFtI2y0-01152-00284071-00284256 conducted by the Supreme Court of the
+odiILFtI2y0-01153-00284257-00284442 Philippines and the United Nations
+odiILFtI2y0-01154-00284443-00284694 Development Programme in July 2003
+odiILFtI2y0-01155-00284695-00284904 assessing inmate and institutional
+odiILFtI2y0-01156-00284905-00285129 management among selected municipal and
+odiILFtI2y0-01157-00285130-00285321 city jails in the National Capital
+odiILFtI2y0-01158-00285322-00285519 Region it was found that vallens illa
+odiILFtI2y0-01159-00285520-00285810 city jail has a congestion rate of 170
+odiILFtI2y0-01160-00285811-00286056 percent according to the study the
+odiILFtI2y0-01161-00286057-00286260 excess number of inmates in Metro Manila
+odiILFtI2y0-01162-00286261-00286479 jails resulted in two outbreak of
+odiILFtI2y0-01163-00286480-00286674 various ailments such as psychiatric
+odiILFtI2y0-01164-00286675-00286908 disorders pulmonary tuberculosis and
+odiILFtI2y0-01165-00286909-00287160 skin diseases the bureau of jail
+odiILFtI2y0-01166-00287161-00287379 management and phenology recommends the
+odiILFtI2y0-01167-00287380-00287601 implementation of release programs under
+odiILFtI2y0-01168-00287602-00287796 applicable laws the bureau of jail
+odiILFtI2y0-01169-00287797-00288105 management and phenology be JMP Avalons
+odiILFtI2y0-01170-00288106-00288333 illa is located along Volans illa hall
+odiILFtI2y0-01171-00288334-00288615 of justice in barangay cairo hidden it
+odiILFtI2y0-01172-00288616-00288819 was formerly located at the old city
+odiILFtI2y0-01173-00288820-00289020 hall in barangay Mason which was
+odiILFtI2y0-01174-00289021-00289224 transferred by Mayor Sherwin gash alien
+odiILFtI2y0-01175-00289225-00289449 in 2010 along with other trial courts
+odiILFtI2y0-01176-00289450-00289668 the police headquarters and Prosecutor's
+odiILFtI2y0-01177-00289669-00289986 Office of the city that same year the BJ
+odiILFtI2y0-01178-00289987-00290181 MP launched the alternative learning
+odiILFtI2y0-01179-00290182-00290400 system program in partnership with the
+odiILFtI2y0-01180-00290401-00290568 local government and Department of
+odiILFtI2y0-01181-00290569-00290742 Education depth as part of the
+odiILFtI2y0-01182-00290743-00290937 rehabilitation programs to city jail
+odiILFtI2y0-01183-00290938-00291231 inmates successful passers of the
+odiILFtI2y0-01184-00291232-00291450 program received certification of depth
+odiILFtI2y0-01185-00291451-00291639 as proof of completion of secondary
+odiILFtI2y0-01186-00291640-00291923 education
+odiILFtI2y0-01187-00291924-00292488 transportation the km 30 Mac Arthur
+odiILFtI2y0-01188-00292489-00292730 highway intersection of circumferential
+odiILFtI2y0-01189-00292731-00293019 road 5 or c5 the fork of an Lex is
+odiILFtI2y0-01190-00293020-00293265 located in barangay Carew Hinton Valens
+odiILFtI2y0-01191-00293266-00293547 ulla the northern side of the exit leads
+odiILFtI2y0-01192-00293548-00293745 to central luzon while the southern will
+odiILFtI2y0-01193-00293746-00293973 take users to Bonifacio shrine in berlin
+odiILFtI2y0-01194-00293974-00294318 Tawaf caisson city on the same hand km
+odiILFtI2y0-01195-00294319-00294656 28 and Lex interchange of c5 in Barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-01196-00294657-00294888 paso de blas connects the SmartConnect
+odiILFtI2y0-01197-00294889-00295151 interchange of n Lex to c5 that goes to
+odiILFtI2y0-01198-00295152-00295392 central luzon Cagayan Valley Ilocos
+odiILFtI2y0-01199-00295393-00295518 Region in Cordillera administrative
+odiILFtI2y0-01200-00295519-00295853 region the cloverleaf is also connected
+odiILFtI2y0-01201-00295854-00296073 to Mindanao Avenue in caisson city
+odiILFtI2y0-01202-00296074-00296346 through segment 8.1 of n Lex which also
+odiILFtI2y0-01203-00296347-00296673 links Manila to n Lex km 28 and Lex
+odiILFtI2y0-01204-00296674-00296855 interchange is also known as Melinda
+odiILFtI2y0-01205-00296856-00297090 exit due to its proximity to barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-01206-00297091-00297325 Melinda as well as toll gate to resident
+odiILFtI2y0-01207-00297326-00297741 NL iax segment 9 is a four-lane 2.42
+odiILFtI2y0-01208-00297742-00297945 kilometer expressway that runs from the
+odiILFtI2y0-01209-00297946-00298148 SmartConnect interchange to macarthur
+odiILFtI2y0-01210-00298149-00298409 highway in cairo headin this segment
+odiILFtI2y0-01211-00298410-00298706 opened to traffic on march 18 2015 and a
+odiILFtI2y0-01212-00298707-00298971 part of c5 road north extension ball and
+odiILFtI2y0-01213-00298972-00299169 Zula is also connected to Bulacan
+odiILFtI2y0-01214-00299170-00299348 through macarthur highway which ends at
+odiILFtI2y0-01215-00299349-00299541 Bonifacio monument in grace park
+odiILFtI2y0-01216-00299542-00299810 Caloocan one of the well known bridge in
+odiILFtI2y0-01217-00299811-00300018 ball and Zula is the Tala Han bridge in
+odiILFtI2y0-01218-00300019-00300200 barangay marilla's that connects the
+odiILFtI2y0-01219-00300201-00300448 city to barangay Potrero in malabon
+odiILFtI2y0-01220-00300449-00300696 Holohan bridge is part of macarthur
+odiILFtI2y0-01221-00300697-00300840 highway that was built during the
+odiILFtI2y0-01222-00300841-00301052 Spanish era as a way of transporting
+odiILFtI2y0-01223-00301053-00301317 vehicles over Tulla Han River in the
+odiILFtI2y0-01224-00301318-00301475 span of years it was renovated
+odiILFtI2y0-01225-00301476-00301781 repeatedly most recent was in 2008 the
+odiILFtI2y0-01226-00301782-00301968 defects on the bridge began to appear
+odiILFtI2y0-01227-00301969-00302153 barely six months after it opened for
+odiILFtI2y0-01228-00302154-00302343 public use the city is webbed by
+odiILFtI2y0-01229-00302344-00302514 hundreds of roads where ninety nine
+odiILFtI2y0-01230-00302515-00302723 point six to two percent of them has a
+odiILFtI2y0-01231-00302724-00302900 surface type of concrete while the
+odiILFtI2y0-01232-00302901-00303158 remaining 0.3 seven eight percent were
+odiILFtI2y0-01233-00303159-00303398 made of dirt the Department of Public
+odiILFtI2y0-01234-00303399-00303612 Works and highways recognizes nine
+odiILFtI2y0-01235-00303613-00303846 national bridges in ball and Zula listed
+odiILFtI2y0-01236-00303847-00304137 below other bridges are just minors that
+odiILFtI2y0-01237-00304138-00304349 connect small cliffs and former landfill
+odiILFtI2y0-01238-00304350-00304569 areas like Melinda bridge in barangay
+odiILFtI2y0-01239-00304570-00304866 Melinda City roads has an average road
+odiILFtI2y0-01240-00304867-00305190 density of 1.15 five kilometre of road
+odiILFtI2y0-01241-00305191-00305510 100 square kilometer of land area each
+odiILFtI2y0-01242-00305511-00305838 road has an average road section of 155
+odiILFtI2y0-01243-00305839-00306096 sections and spans 54 point two six
+odiILFtI2y0-01244-00306097-00306327 seven kilometers bus companies founded
+odiILFtI2y0-01245-00306328-00306509 terminals in barangay mill and a
+odiILFtI2y0-01246-00306510-00306741 northernmost locality of all and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-01247-00306742-00306912 along the border with Bulacan though
+odiILFtI2y0-01248-00306913-00307095 there are terminals situated in barren
+odiILFtI2y0-01249-00307096-00307269 guides to London and in Cairo hidden as
+odiILFtI2y0-01250-00307270-00307650 well this includes laguna star bus PA ma
+odiILFtI2y0-01251-00307651-00307910 na transport service inc gem trans
+odiILFtI2y0-01252-00307911-00308129 services and philippine corinthian liner
+odiILFtI2y0-01253-00308130-00308424 inc among others these buses are lined
+odiILFtI2y0-01254-00308425-00308637 with Metro Manila destinations only
+odiILFtI2y0-01255-00308638-00308858 usually in Alabang or vac larren with
+odiILFtI2y0-01256-00308859-00309203 routes along EDSA bus traffic is also
+odiILFtI2y0-01257-00309204-00309441 dense at barren guides paso de blossom
+odiILFtI2y0-01258-00309442-00309675 bag bag one due to its proximity to km
+odiILFtI2y0-01259-00309676-00309927 28 and Lex interchange and bus terminals
+odiILFtI2y0-01260-00309928-00310221 in Neuville achieves caisson City other
+odiILFtI2y0-01261-00310222-00310409 modes of transportation includes
+odiILFtI2y0-01262-00310410-00310631 jeepneys with routes usually formal and
+odiILFtI2y0-01263-00310632-00310965 a direct Oh Santa Cruz Divisoria pier 15
+odiILFtI2y0-01264-00310966-00311204 South Harbor and tmco la in Manila and
+odiILFtI2y0-01265-00311205-00311445 Grace Park and monumento in Caloocan and
+odiILFtI2y0-01266-00311446-00311747 Melinda to Malolos City the laoag in Sta
+odiILFtI2y0-01267-00311748-00312053 Maria along McArthur Highway for general
+odiILFtI2y0-01268-00312054-00312297 mass transportation tricycles or trikes
+odiILFtI2y0-01269-00312298-00312543 for small-scale transportation and taxi
+odiILFtI2y0-01270-00312544-00312803 cabs for upper-middle classes there are
+odiILFtI2y0-01271-00312804-00313010 no airports and ports in Valens ulla
+odiILFtI2y0-01272-00313011-00313253 External Relations Valen doula is
+odiILFtI2y0-01273-00313254-00313427 twinned with the following towns and
+odiILFtI2y0-01274-00313428-00313641 cities friendship links Valle and Zula
+odiILFtI2y0-01275-00313642-00313818 has friendship links with no formal
+odiILFtI2y0-01276-00313819-00314001 Constitution with the following towns
+odiILFtI2y0-01277-00314002-00314309 and cities agreements usually forged
+odiILFtI2y0-01278-00314310-00314558 towards industrial cultural or academic
+odiILFtI2y0-01279-00314559-00314831 exchanges in understanding young Jo
+odiILFtI2y0-01280-00314832-00315101 young jo Jung soo-jung su People's
+odiILFtI2y0-01281-00315102-00315377 Republic of China Hawaii Hawaii United
+odiILFtI2y0-01282-00315378-00315527 States notable people see also
+odiILFtI2y0-01283-00315528-00315857 references books Alvarez Santiago V Palo
+odiILFtI2y0-01284-00315858-00316235 Carolina s Malay 1992 the Katipunan and
+odiILFtI2y0-01285-00316236-00316476 the revolution memoirs of a general Aden
+odiILFtI2y0-01286-00316477-00316778 año de Manila University Press ISBN nine
+odiILFtI2y0-01287-00316779-00317087 seven one five 500 seven seven three
+odiILFtI2y0-01288-00317088-00317933 ISBN 978 979 7/7 arenas maar DJ 1997
+odiILFtI2y0-01289-00317934-00318176 Valens Ulla NV Yanni a Tang Bayan in
+odiILFtI2y0-01290-00318177-00318458 Tagalog Museo Valens Ulla Foundation Inc
+odiILFtI2y0-01291-00318459-00318585 in Valencia
+odiILFtI2y0-01292-00318586-00318786 historical and cultural society Blair
+odiILFtI2y0-01293-00318787-00319176 mah James Alexander Robertson 1906 the
+odiILFtI2y0-01294-00319177-00319497 Philippine Islands 1493 to 1898
+odiILFtI2y0-01295-00319498-00319827 McCulloch printing company dukkha C 2008
+odiILFtI2y0-01296-00319828-00320073 struggle for freedom 2008 end
+odiILFtI2y0-01297-00320074-00320367 Rex bookstore inc ISBN nine seven one
+odiILFtI2y0-01298-00320368-00320691 two three five oh four five two ISBN
+odiILFtI2y0-01299-00320692-00320922 nine seven eight nine seven one two
+odiILFtI2y0-01300-00320923-00321216 three five oh four five oh Landsberg a
+odiILFtI2y0-01301-00321217-00321588 chi 1965 advances in geophysics volumes
+odiILFtI2y0-01302-00321589-00321930 one to eleven academic press ISBN oh one
+odiILFtI2y0-01303-00321931-00322269 two oh one eight eight one one two ISBN
+odiILFtI2y0-01304-00322270-00322593 978 oh one two oh one eight eight one
+odiILFtI2y0-01305-00322594-00322890 one six minogue mardan led Avena V
+odiILFtI2y0-01306-00322891-00323211 Kareem EO 2006 regulatory governance in
+odiILFtI2y0-01307-00323212-00323403 developing countries Edward Elgar
+odiILFtI2y0-01308-00323404-00323712 publishing ISBN one eight four five four
+odiILFtI2y0-01309-00323713-00324147 two six one two six ISBN 978 one eight
+odiILFtI2y0-01310-00324148-00324447 four five four two six one two five
+odiILFtI2y0-01311-00324448-00324765 segment 2007 the Filipino moving onward
+odiILFtI2y0-01312-00324766-00325085 five-feet 2007 and rex bookstore inc
+odiILFtI2y0-01313-00325086-00325485 ISBN nine seven one two three four one
+odiILFtI2y0-01314-00325486-00325827 five four two ISBN nine seven eight nine
+odiILFtI2y0-01315-00325828-00326115 seven one two three four one five four
+odiILFtI2y0-01316-00326116-00326640 Oh tea onsen Nicanor 2004 the women of
+odiILFtI2y0-01317-00326641-00326832 Malolos ah dinnae o de Manila University
+odiILFtI2y0-01318-00326833-00327189 Press ISBN nine seven one five five oh
+odiILFtI2y0-01319-00327190-00327543 four six seven one ISBN nine seven eight
+odiILFtI2y0-01320-00327544-00327822 nine seven one five five oh four six
+odiILFtI2y0-01321-00327823-00328040 seven six
+odiILFtI2y0-01322-00328041-00328485 they'd Sonia Gregorio FS 8 1999 the
+odiILFtI2y0-01323-00328486-00328701 Philippines a unique nation all nations
+odiILFtI2y0-01324-00328702-00329115 publishing co ISBN nine seven one six
+odiILFtI2y0-01325-00329116-00329490 four two oh six four one ISBN nine seven
+odiILFtI2y0-01326-00329491-00330140 eight nine seven two zero six four seven
+odiILFtI2y0-01327-00330141-00330875 external links official website
+odiILFtI2y0-01328-00330876-00331140 geographic data related to Valenzuela
+odiILFtI2y0-01329-00331141-00331518 metro manila at OpenStreetMap
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00000-00000008-00000142 i'm just gonna ask a couple questions
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00001-00000143-00000351 and then michelle or whoever wants to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00002-00000352-00000567 talk this is a conversation
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00003-00000568-00000695 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00004-00000696-00000927 artem
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00005-00000927-00001223 um can you just tell us how you came to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00006-00001224-00001447 this story how you met alessia the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00007-00001448-00001543 director
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00008-00001544-00001695 and what drew you to want to produce
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00009-00001696-00001982 this film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00010-00001984-00002159 hello uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00011-00002160-00002391 so thank you uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00012-00002392-00002671 everyone who watched this film with us
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00013-00002672-00002895 and thank you who stayed for the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00014-00002896-00003231 conversation i appreciate it really
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00015-00003232-00003415 what about the story i met the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00016-00003415-00003615 screenwriter
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00017-00003615-00003790 and she told me
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00018-00003792-00003919 this story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00019-00003920-00004222 and i like it from the first words then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00020-00004223-00004535 she sent me the material uh and it was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00021-00004536-00004735 like a half year i was with this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00022-00004736-00004919 material alone
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00023-00004920-00005135 trying to find someone
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00024-00005136-00005295 who could
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00025-00005296-00005735 be a director of this film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00026-00005736-00005870 i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00027-00005871-00006054 do before my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00028-00006055-00006151 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00029-00006152-00006414 period film uh historical period film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00030-00006415-00006631 about first world war it's scrutiny
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00031-00006631-00006927 1918. it's uh if you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00032-00006928-00007246 know it's about the ukrainian students
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00033-00007247-00007687 who was fighted against the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00034-00007688-00008159 russian army again but in 1980
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00035-00008159-00008335 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00036-00008336-00008483 this was the second
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00037-00008484-00008742 film i mean historical film i want to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00038-00008743-00008959 produce i know that it's hard job to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00039-00008960-00009223 make a historical film because you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00040-00009224-00009383 every time you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00041-00009384-00009639 you find a different true story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00042-00009640-00009951 and it's really difficult to make a true
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00043-00009952-00010174 true historical story but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00044-00010175-00010423 i think we did it because all this story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00045-00010424-00010574 was true
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00046-00010575-00010903 all this happened in real life
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00047-00010904-00011078 so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00048-00011079-00011199 when i met
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00049-00011200-00011406 olesia
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00050-00011407-00011606 she liked the story and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00051-00011607-00011814 we started to work with this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00052-00011815-00012231 uh and it's like two years of our
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00053-00012232-00012374 work
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00054-00012375-00012542 and we just finished in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00055-00012543-00012894 2021 we decided to go for the festivals
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00056-00012895-00013094 and we have a lot of festivals for this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00057-00013095-00013358 film a lot of jewish festivals love this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00058-00013359-00013766 film already i i send all the material
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00059-00013768-00013943 where we was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00060-00013944-00014135 and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00061-00014136-00014327 we was planning to have a premiere this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00062-00014328-00014407 year
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00063-00014408-00014599 uh on the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00064-00014600-00014886 the shedrick day i mean it's in january
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00065-00014887-00014983 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00066-00014984-00015111 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00067-00015112-00015422 it's not so funny story but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00068-00015423-00015791 22 of february we presented this movie
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00069-00015791-00016022 in cinemas in ukraine and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00070-00016023-00016271 presented that we have a broadcaster we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00071-00016272-00016527 have a distributor and we're planning to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00072-00016528-00016807 show it in december and in today's start
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00073-00016808-00017167 war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00074-00017168-00017679 nobody seemed that it could happen even
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00075-00017680-00018279 so all my family is here and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00076-00018280-00018503 we're like trying to escape from kiev
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00077-00018504-00018686 and i send them to united states of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00078-00018687-00018943 america first of uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00079-00018944-00019214 march and i stay in in ukraine
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00080-00019215-00019471 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00081-00019472-00019655 we never think that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00082-00019656-00019871 the scenes from this movie could happen
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00083-00019872-00020079 in our real life for sure
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00084-00020080-00020383 but uh as you can see in the movie the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00085-00020384-00020639 girls and the women singing in the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00086-00020640-00020894 shelters all the same are happening now
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00087-00020895-00021014 in ukraine
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00088-00021015-00021430 uh people trying to to to to hide in the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00089-00021431-00021567 in the metro
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00090-00021568-00021694 in the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00091-00021695-00022055 shelters from the russian bombs
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00092-00022056-00022150 but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00093-00022151-00022399 they try to stay optimistic
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00094-00022400-00022750 but it's hard all my all my way to to to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00095-00022751-00022950 to united states was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00096-00022951-00023207 from the city which was bombed each day
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00097-00023208-00023407 and you can hear about the vineyard so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00098-00023408-00023663 two days ago
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00099-00023664-00023863 the young girl was killed like four
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00100-00023864-00023942 years
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00101-00023943-00024086 and yesterday
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00102-00024087-00024535 in hiking was killed a boy 13 years
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00103-00024536-00024742 maybe you see the pictures
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00104-00024743-00025086 but we see this material every day so uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00105-00025087-00025311 for me it's like like like being in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00106-00025312-00025670 different world you know because um uh i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00107-00025672-00025855 i need to combine to two different
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00108-00025856-00026094 worlds a couple of days i was in ukraine
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00109-00026095-00026311 and now i'm here with the movie so i i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00110-00026312-00026558 want to to share my emotion with the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00111-00026560-00026918 movie i produced i i take a long life to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00112-00026919-00027158 to have this movie to just to spend
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00113-00027160-00027335 these moments with my family but then i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00114-00027336-00027511 understand that in two weeks i need to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00115-00027512-00027614 go back
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00116-00027616-00027831 in ukraine and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00117-00027832-00028031 the war is not stopped and we don't know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00118-00028032-00028358 when it's stopped so we don't know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00119-00028360-00028593 how long it will be and as you can
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00120-00028594-00028735 [Music]
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00121-00028736-00029031 see the putin and his
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00122-00029032-00029302 army they don't want to stop the the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00123-00029304-00029695 done is lugansk it's not the target it's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00124-00029695-00029855 it's only
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00125-00029856-00030143 a start they want to go further they
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00126-00030144-00030455 won't take odessa they won't take
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00127-00030456-00030670 britney strovia moldova
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00128-00030672-00030855 maybe poland
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00129-00030856-00031079 and as you can see nobody wants to stop
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00130-00031080-00031183 them
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00131-00031183-00031470 uh and i think you know we have a joke
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00132-00031472-00031695 uh it's it's not so funny but we have a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00133-00031695-00031990 joke about natto so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00134-00031991-00032255 the another guy says that if russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00135-00032256-00032535 federation would just start something
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00136-00032536-00032799 was one of the countries of nato they
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00137-00032800-00033015 will start to fight against the russia
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00138-00033016-00033335 but we say in ukraine if
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00139-00033336-00033543 russia federation starts from one
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00140-00033544-00033767 country from nata so this country will
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00141-00033768-00034135 be not from nathan so not just
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00142-00034136-00034351 it's it's it's bad joke but it's it's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00143-00034352-00034567 like true because qatar doesn't have any
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00144-00034568-00034831 power and now only ukraine trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00145-00034832-00035083 fight against uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00146-00035084-00035351 against the russian federation thank you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00147-00035352-00035479 vladimir
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00148-00035480-00035799 he mentioned this uh in this talk
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00149-00035800-00035902 i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00150-00035903-00036167 we we really tried to find fight with
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00151-00036168-00036383 the enemies uh we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00152-00036384-00036687 collected all together i mean movie
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00153-00036688-00037087 producers directors i have uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00154-00037088-00037271 organization
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00155-00037272-00037446 it's like
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00156-00037447-00037679 humanitarian organization charity fund
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00157-00037680-00037846 we're trying to collect some money to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00158-00037847-00038111 board the ambulance machine cars we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00159-00038112-00038383 already bought 55 cars for the military
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00160-00038384-00038695 guys and five ambulance machines
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00161-00038696-00038879 cars i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00162-00038880-00039023 so i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00163-00039024-00039383 directors dop producers all together
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00164-00039384-00039527 trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00165-00039528-00039679 communicate with their friends all
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00166-00039680-00039902 around the world to to gather these
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00167-00039903-00040159 funds and to to to help to the military
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00168-00040160-00040343 skies because
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00169-00040344-00040751 landis is not so fast
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00170-00040752-00041062 germany is not helping a lot and and etc
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00171-00041063-00041230 but it's policy i don't i don't want to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00172-00041231-00041487 go to the policy but it's it's the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00173-00041488-00041662 things that's happened now in ukraine so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00174-00041663-00041855 and we don't see the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00175-00041856-00042262 any in any song in there you know uh so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00176-00042263-00042462 that's bad
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00177-00042463-00042751 thank you artem um does anybody have any
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00178-00042752-00042846 questions
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00179-00042847-00043087 uh i mean even in this movie we're
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00180-00043088-00043287 trying to show that the ukraine is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00181-00043288-00043502 different so the woman the ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00182-00043503-00043743 woman should take care about all kids
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00183-00043744-00044111 it's no matter jewish kids polish kids
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00184-00044112-00044271 even german guy
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00185-00044272-00044430 german boy
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00186-00044431-00044615 and this is all about ukraine we're
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00187-00044616-00044799 never trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00188-00044800-00045102 invade someone never all over the time
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00189-00045103-00045262 we never try to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00190-00045263-00045462 to bother our
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00191-00045463-00045790 nasal boss
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00192-00045791-00046039 separate people never so we just trying
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00193-00046040-00046415 we work hard always we work hard uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00194-00046416-00046502 we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00195-00046503-00046862 we build our houses we live
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00196-00046863-00047151 in happiness with uh with ours with our
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00197-00047152-00047383 families we don't try to to catch
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00198-00047384-00047671 another lands to to have some more more
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00199-00047672-00048007 more but we know who did and we know who
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00200-00048008-00048151 always did this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00201-00048152-00048455 uh that's why so we need to defend
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00202-00048456-00048815 we never tried to invent in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00203-00048816-00049071 in vain
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00204-00049072-00049143 yeah
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00205-00049144-00049383 this is the big difference so we have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00206-00049384-00049686 our language and we don't try to to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00207-00049687-00049902 promote it all over the world but we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00208-00049903-00050295 speak ukrainians okay uh we we have our
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00209-00050296-00050535 culture we don't try to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00210-00050536-00050983 uh to pro pro that propaganda this or uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00211-00050984-00051199 or something you know so we don't we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00212-00051200-00051407 don't believe in tsar we don't have any
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00213-00051408-00051630 czar we have a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00214-00051632-00051926 jewish guy who was comic and he's our
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00215-00051927-00052246 president and he's fighting uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00216-00052247-00052559 till the end i think
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00217-00052560-00052750 you know him maybe people would be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00218-00052751-00052919 interested to know that would you want
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00219-00052920-00053238 to i don't vote for him to be honest but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00220-00053239-00053519 yeah it's funny but but i know him
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00221-00053520-00053742 personally uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00222-00053744-00053950 but i don't want to vote for poroshenko
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00223-00053951-00054063 either
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00224-00054064-00054287 okay
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00225-00054288-00054438 so uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00226-00054439-00054719 and i know that he wouldn't
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00227-00054720-00055007 give up because i i know him personally
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00228-00055008-00055126 and i know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00229-00055127-00055399 how he feels like and when the united
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00230-00055400-00055703 states or france started to say to him
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00231-00055704-00056007 you need to evacuate from ukraine and to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00232-00056008-00056126 be in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00233-00056127-00056438 like in safe place he'd say no and it
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00234-00056439-00056694 was really hard days in kiev those days
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00235-00056695-00057054 uh and a lot of people tried to kill him
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00236-00057055-00057263 i don't know if you know this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00237-00057264-00057487 but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00238-00057488-00057694 yeah several times
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00239-00057695-00058038 uh that's why that's why uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00240-00058039-00058150 we are not
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00241-00058151-00058238 any
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00242-00058239-00058454 i don't know how how they call us
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00243-00058455-00058623 nationalist uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00244-00058624-00058919 fascist no they're trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00245-00058920-00059150 the military
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00246-00059151-00059407 the signification yeah but how we could
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00247-00059408-00059679 be as we talk with you how we could be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00248-00059679-00059926 nazi uh nation if we have a jewish
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00249-00059927-00060191 president uh and i don't know half of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00250-00060191-00060454 the government um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00251-00060455-00060542 jews
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00252-00060544-00060854 we have a korean guy from uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00253-00060855-00061119 kubernetes of nicolai who don't say any
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00254-00061120-00061350 wars in ukraine but he's fighting
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00255-00061351-00061615 against the russia invention by the way
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00256-00061616-00061806 the relatively ukrainian language
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00257-00061807-00061959 particularly
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00258-00061960-00062230 do you see now a big
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00259-00062232-00062511 move towards speaking ukrainian learning
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00260-00062512-00062726 ukrainian because as i remember when i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00261-00062727-00062950 was in game and i know recently
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00262-00062951-00063135 the russian language was still dominated
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00263-00063136-00063287 on the streets and among the people even
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00264-00063288-00063519 who are fighting right now to be to be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00265-00063520-00063750 honest you can see the video from the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00266-00063751-00063991 war and a lot of ukrainian warriors
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00267-00063991-00064199 speak russian it's not a problem and to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00268-00064200-00064463 be honest in my family we used to speak
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00269-00064464-00064559 russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00270-00064560-00064703 because we don't think that russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00271-00064704-00064879 federation is all in the russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00272-00064879-00065119 language uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00273-00065120-00065382 yeah and but now everybody trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00274-00065383-00065631 speak only ukrainian and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00275-00065632-00065911 we have a reason why because you know i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00276-00065912-00066150 read some interesting note i don't know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00277-00066151-00066335 how to translate it i will tell you in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00278-00066336-00066559 ukrainian and you will
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00279-00066560-00068479 say thank you uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00280-00068480-00070559 foreign
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00281-00070560-00071406 [Music]
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00282-00071407-00071671 ukrainian language and what
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00283-00071672-00072071 kiev and stable started and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00284-00072072-00072391 people were talking russian ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00285-00072392-00072662 but you all heard about bucha about
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00286-00072663-00072950 european what happened there small towns
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00287-00072951-00073343 next near to kiev the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00288-00073344-00073462 russians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00289-00073463-00073750 practically destroyed those beautiful
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00290-00073751-00074006 towns and suburbs and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00291-00074007-00074335 also killed lots of people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00292-00074336-00074719 and can you imagine if you are in kiev
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00293-00074720-00075006 sitting in a subway
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00294-00075007-00075319 and bombs
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00295-00075320-00075647 falling there not bombs it was rockets
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00296-00075648-00075935 and at some point after a couple of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00297-00075936-00076199 weeks when you almost without food
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00298-00076200-00076367 without water
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00299-00076368-00076687 uh you're scared as hell
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00300-00076688-00077038 and somebody from uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00301-00077039-00077335 all of a sudden is a quiet
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00302-00077336-00077655 and somebody from the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00303-00077656-00077871 grand
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00304-00077872-00078143 street from above
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00305-00078144-00078526 you'll hear the voice in russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00306-00078527-00078838 is anybody alive
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00307-00078839-00078982 he down there
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00308-00078983-00079382 or you hear the same in ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00309-00079383-00079711 what will your reaction be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00310-00079712-00079887 if you hear it in russian what you all
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00311-00079888-00080087 think yeah
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00312-00080088-00080303 that's why
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00313-00080304-00080503 so we now understand that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00314-00080504-00080735 our language is our code
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00315-00080736-00080815 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00316-00080816-00081143 it's it's it's very easy to to know why
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00317-00081144-00081262 when we are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00318-00081263-00081471 together in united states and we are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00319-00081472-00081694 walking down the streets and we hear the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00320-00081695-00081991 ukrainian words we understand it is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00321-00081992-00082199 ukrainian there but when we hear russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00322-00082200-00082447 words we need to stop to sing to to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00323-00082448-00082703 listen and in couple of sentences we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00324-00082704-00082871 will understand they are from ukraine or
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00325-00082872-00083055 they are russians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00326-00083056-00083167 and now
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00327-00083168-00083343 as you know even russians trying to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00328-00083344-00083623 speak ukraine not to be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00329-00083624-00083735 fighted
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00330-00083736-00083926 in different cities
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00331-00083927-00084111 and that's mean they're trying to to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00332-00084112-00084415 have this code
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00333-00084416-00084647 i also want to add a little bit but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00334-00084648-00084935 right now also you can uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00335-00084936-00085303 really uh hear and understand the accent
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00336-00085304-00085471 if person is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00337-00085472-00085679 speaking russian but he is not from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00338-00085680-00085831 russia at all
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00339-00085832-00086062 or he is really from russia it will be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00340-00086063-00086375 like that you will understand where this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00341-00086376-00086687 person is from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00342-00086688-00086918 thank you vladimir yes
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00343-00086919-00087071 i i uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00344-00087072-00087223 phenomenal film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00345-00087224-00087415 i mean i was just totally overcome
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00346-00087416-00087703 you've done a phenomenal job
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00347-00087704-00087871 i have a bunch of questions but one of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00348-00087872-00088126 the big questions is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00349-00088127-00088367 is this feeling being distributed in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00350-00088368-00088606 germany and in france as well i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00351-00088607-00088831 does it have is it does it do you have a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00352-00088832-00089006 version of this with german and french
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00353-00089007-00089294 subtitles they need to see this film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00354-00089295-00089543 uh not yet but we're planning to we just
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00355-00089544-00089735 we was planning the festival story you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00356-00089736-00089943 know we we finished this film when the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00357-00089944-00090206 kovit was and we we decided to wait and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00358-00090207-00090518 when it took out 2021 we decided to go
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00359-00090519-00090782 with this film through all the festivals
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00360-00090783-00091006 uh and and and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00361-00091007-00091206 and then we would want to to distribute
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00362-00091207-00091423 it all over the world and uh now we have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00363-00091424-00091647 uh english subtitles but we're working
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00364-00091648-00091847 on the spanish subtitles we're working
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00365-00091848-00092215 on the germany subtitles uh this film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00366-00092216-00092415 one of the film from the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00367-00092416-00092726 ukrainian cinema 8 marathon which was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00368-00092727-00092999 launched with all ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00369-00093000-00093255 cinematographers we are created this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00370-00093256-00093471 cinema 8 monophones through it was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00371-00093472-00093791 started in toronto in march
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00372-00093792-00094071 and it was opened with uh carol of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00373-00094072-00094167 bell
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00374-00094168-00094391 uh we launched this marathon to gather
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00375-00094392-00094679 some money for our phones to finish the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00376-00094680-00094879 films we have now so because we have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00377-00094880-00095150 like 30 films on a different stage which
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00378-00095151-00095382 are uh not finished because of the war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00379-00095383-00095535 but we need to finish them to have the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00380-00095536-00095935 films to to promote ukraine in second in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00381-00095936-00096215 next year and year after the next year
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00382-00096216-00096431 because
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00383-00096432-00096606 we need to be presented on all over the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00384-00096607-00096903 world the festivals so and because of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00385-00096904-00097167 this we are now translating it even now
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00386-00097168-00097391 on korean language and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00387-00097392-00097655 uh if everything go good we will have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00388-00097656-00098038 this film on korea in korea
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00389-00098039-00098294 and the funny story it was uh the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00390-00098295-00098606 closing film in uh irish galway film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00391-00098607-00098887 festival 34 it's it's well-known irish
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00392-00098888-00099079 film festival they choose carol of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00393-00099080-00099359 bell the closing film and there was like
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00394-00099360-00099694 a lot of people in in in they they
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00395-00099695-00099791 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00396-00099792-00100079 they invite me main character director
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00397-00100080-00100159 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00398-00100160-00100431 one more uh actress from this film from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00399-00100432-00100671 all over the world so they they put us
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00400-00100672-00100838 together we was like
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00401-00100839-00100926 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00402-00100927-00101143 first time see each other during the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00403-00101144-00101399 world because i don't see the directors
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00404-00101400-00101703 from the war start uh and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00405-00101704-00101903 uh when the films end
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00406-00101904-00102135 uh it was a lot of people crying then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00407-00102136-00102350 and was the chinese girl who was crying
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00408-00102351-00102575 and i was in shock i just asked her why
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00409-00102576-00102718 are you crying we understand something
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00410-00102719-00102910 from this she said yes of course i'm
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00411-00102911-00103094 from hong kong and we have the same
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00412-00103095-00103318 problem with chinese so because they are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00413-00103319-00103542 afraid now that chinese will invade the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00414-00103543-00103758 taiwan and then next they invade hong
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00415-00103759-00103902 kong but she said
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00416-00103903-00103999 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00417-00104000-00104206 you can fight we cannot fight because we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00418-00104207-00104478 only city and they invade us in one hour
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00419-00104479-00104742 like like something or like in one day
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00420-00104743-00105031 so the problem is similar and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00421-00105032-00105223 some people afraid of the china some
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00422-00105224-00105343 people are afraid of the russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00423-00105344-00105534 federation but mostly they are afraid
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00424-00105535-00105902 that they will united together and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00425-00105903-00106071 and make the same like russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00426-00106072-00106334 federation and germany in during the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00427-00106335-00107454 second world war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00428-00107455-00107639 i feel like wes i hope we can have two
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00429-00107640-00107823 or three more questions michelle hasn't
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00430-00107824-00108078 got to speak is that okay yeah sure okay
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00431-00108079-00108247 and if anybody has to leave please don't
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00432-00108248-00108375 feel bad
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00433-00108376-00108615 okay i need i need to hear okay god
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00434-00108616-00108886 sorry um so thank you so much i think i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00435-00108888-00109102 cried like half of the movie it was a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00436-00109103-00109566 very good and as moving uh moving like
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00437-00109567-00109823 i i joked that i wouldn't recommend my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00438-00109824-00109983 friends to watch it because it's just
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00439-00109983-00110134 too sad
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00440-00110135-00110351 um but it was really beautiful and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00441-00110352-00110439 moving
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00442-00110440-00110647 um and of course all of your stories
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00443-00110648-00111047 about ukraine are also very touching and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00444-00111048-00111358 and sad um but i am israeli and we are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00445-00111359-00111463 direct
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00446-00111464-00111686 and i have a question i feel it's a it's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00447-00111688-00111958 it's a fiction movie and um about world
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00448-00111959-00112207 war ii and you said it's a it's a it's a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00449-00112208-00112358 real story or
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00450-00112359-00112566 um i think it it
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00451-00112567-00112775 betrays it shows
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00452-00112776-00113031 ukraine and ukrainian people in very
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00453-00113032-00113423 specific aspect which is probably
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00454-00113424-00113654 very true to what is happening today in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00455-00113655-00113934 this war but um i don't know about the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00456-00113935-00114110 portraying of it and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00457-00114111-00114383 maybe you didn't even presume to show
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00458-00114383-00114710 the real ukraine of all of ukraine neons
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00459-00114711-00114831 during the war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00460-00114832-00114966 um but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00461-00114967-00115127 my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00462-00115128-00115383 take on this was that maybe it shows
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00463-00115383-00115631 like a new narrative about second world
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00464-00115632-00115934 war and the part that ukrainians had in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00465-00115935-00116039 this war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00466-00116040-00116295 so my question is um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00467-00116296-00116534 wouldn't it be make a little bit of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00468-00116535-00116719 sense to show
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00469-00116720-00116919 other parts or other
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00470-00116920-00117102 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00471-00117103-00117431 ways other ukrainians um had in the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00472-00117432-00117647 world war ii
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00473-00117648-00117902 i think we will do it i i think we just
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00474-00117903-00118190 started because uh do you know how many
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00475-00118191-00118454 ukrainian films was before uh this war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00476-00118455-00118743 happened i mean this war happened 2013
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00477-00118744-00119047 when they took crimea we have zero film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00478-00119048-00119395 ukrainian in the cinema setup
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00479-00119396-00119831 2019 before the covet starts we have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00480-00119832-00120166 40 films in the cinema for the year so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00481-00120167-00120383 from the 0 to the 40 film from the year
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00482-00120383-00120639 we go like for the six years because we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00483-00120640-00120943 have we was like uh the territory for
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00484-00120944-00121127 the russian guys to shoot the russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00485-00121128-00121334 movies with a cheap
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00486-00121335-00121663 service of ukrainian guys we don't have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00487-00121664-00121927 ukrainian actors because we we used to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00488-00121928-00122231 have only russian actors and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00489-00122232-00122439 the film was popular
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00490-00122440-00122647 only if russians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00491-00122648-00122895 take take shots in ukraine with some
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00492-00122896-00123095 territories but with russian well-known
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00493-00123096-00123334 actors because they have huge territory
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00494-00123335-00123566 and the russian language was only
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00495-00123567-00123790 language all over the kazakhstan
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00496-00123791-00124190 uzbekistan ukraine belarus etc to shoot
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00497-00124191-00124351 in ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00498-00124352-00124743 and to show home so it was no no even
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00499-00124744-00124919 the question because
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00500-00124920-00125127 everybody understand that it's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00501-00125128-00125471 less of the money so only film uh which
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00502-00125472-00125686 was produced by our president i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00503-00125688-00125990 zelinski when he was comedian was good
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00504-00125991-00126286 but he also shoot it in russia and in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00505-00126288-00126566 sell it for the all territories uh and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00506-00126567-00126823 to shoot ukrainian films and to show it
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00507-00126824-00127023 only in ukraine it's it's not about
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00508-00127024-00127207 money so you need to have some money
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00509-00127208-00127414 from government but you to shoot that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00510-00127415-00127695 good film you need a lot of money and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00511-00127696-00127958 you cannot take the people to the cinema
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00512-00127959-00128214 because uh in ukraine they don't really
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00513-00128215-00128407 believe in ukrainian simon was not
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00514-00128408-00128631 really believe but now we was working
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00515-00128632-00128847 hard
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00516-00128848-00129119 and i was a part of this hard work and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00517-00129120-00129366 uh before the covet start we we really
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00518-00129367-00129647 have a good uh box offices of ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00519-00129648-00129943 films uh like really good
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00520-00129944-00130143 with local comedians with local
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00521-00130144-00130283 historical
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00522-00130283-00130478 films but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00523-00130479-00130647 now because of the war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00524-00130648-00130958 the cinemas closed and but still we we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00525-00130959-00131214 have one week ago we have ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00526-00131215-00131527 comedy premiere and we gather like
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00527-00131528-00131878 10 000 people in the cinemas
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00528-00131879-00132111 when you say it's it's a true story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00529-00132112-00132311 based on a true story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00530-00132312-00132447 is it
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00531-00132448-00132743 was there really a sophia and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00532-00132744-00132966 the couple were they actual people or
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00533-00132967-00133278 it's a composite you're putting together
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00534-00133279-00133431 we're putting together yeah so i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00535-00133432-00133663 it's collective uh that's right and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00536-00133664-00133887 we put it in together it was you did it
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00537-00133888-00134183 so beautifully it was so moving and so
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00538-00134184-00134463 very so much very suspenseful too yeah
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00539-00134464-00134790 um really suspenseful but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00540-00134791-00134983 heart-wrenching
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00541-00134984-00135263 thank you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00542-00135264-00135551 so michelle one of the angels to make
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00543-00135552-00135702 all this happen
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00544-00135703-00135878 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00545-00135879-00136135 michelle michelle um well you've lived
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00546-00136136-00136390 for years in ukraine you speak ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00547-00136391-00136614 which is amazing i do know people that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00548-00136615-00136775 are american that want to help you know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00549-00136776-00137031 they want to go to ukraine or poland or
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00550-00137032-00137214 wherever and help and i would can you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00551-00137215-00137511 tell us a little bit about um your last
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00552-00137512-00137654 trip you just came back from la vie
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00553-00137655-00137814 where you lived for years do you want to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00554-00137815-00137975 talk about that and maybe
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00555-00137976-00138102 put it out in the audience if people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00556-00138103-00138295 want to do that yeah what should we want
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00557-00138296-00138487 to talk about i would love to talk about
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00558-00138488-00138727 that and i also um film everything i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00559-00138728-00138935 want to speak to gaul's question a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00560-00138936-00139166 little bit because i think um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00561-00139167-00139366 it's touching on some jewish ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00562-00139367-00139559 history which is not always so pleasant
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00563-00139560-00139671 as we know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00564-00139672-00139902 and um growing up as i did with the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00565-00139903-00140095 jewish narrative i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00566-00140096-00140454 was personally lucky to escape some of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00567-00140455-00140687 the prejudice against ukrainians that i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00568-00140688-00140878 think was prevalent in some jewish
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00569-00140879-00141007 communities
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00570-00141008-00141175 but um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00571-00141176-00141471 and i had the wonderful fortune of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00572-00141472-00141759 falling into ukraine by accident and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00573-00141760-00141999 really falling in love with it and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00574-00142000-00142166 making some really deep beautiful
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00575-00142167-00142359 connections with people there
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00576-00142360-00142599 and i carried a lot with me you know my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00577-00142600-00142839 ancestors fled from there also
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00578-00142840-00143239 and um when i began to tell my family
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00579-00143240-00143407 that i was going to ukraine
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00580-00143408-00143599 you know people in my family and my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00581-00143600-00143719 community were
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00582-00143720-00143926 a little skeptical a little nervous
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00583-00143927-00144135 uncomfortable
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00584-00144136-00144351 thinking that my grandparents and their
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00585-00144352-00144519 parents would not be thrilled had they
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00586-00144520-00144678 been alive that i was going back to the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00587-00144679-00144935 place that they fled from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00588-00144936-00145119 and i think this is a common narrative i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00589-00145120-00145271 think that a lot of jews here might be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00590-00145272-00145454 able to relate american jews who grew up
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00591-00145455-00145647 with these things
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00592-00145648-00145919 but i want to say that um yeah there is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00593-00145920-00146119 some some difficulty there's some
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00594-00146120-00146302 ugliness that happened between jews and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00595-00146303-00146487 ukrainians on both sides
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00596-00146488-00146751 um and it doesn't serve anybody well to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00597-00146752-00146919 pretend it never happens
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00598-00146920-00147143 but it's only part of the narrative
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00599-00147144-00147423 and it's it's a narrative that i think
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00600-00147424-00147543 has been
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00601-00147544-00147814 exaggerated a bit and i think stories
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00602-00147815-00148054 like this that that portray ukrainians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00603-00148055-00148311 in positive light are really important
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00604-00148312-00148519 because they serve to kind of counter
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00605-00148520-00148671 some of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00606-00148672-00148863 um you know the broader messages that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00607-00148864-00149039 some of us have grown up with
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00608-00149040-00149214 so i think that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00609-00149215-00149375 that this story is really important and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00610-00149376-00149502 there should be more stories like this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00611-00149503-00149631 that highlight
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00612-00149632-00149766 you know the ways that ukrainians help
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00613-00149767-00149943 jews during the war there are plenty of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00614-00149944-00150078 stories about how ukrainians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00615-00150079-00150335 collaborated with nazis and that those
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00616-00150336-00150551 stories did happen also but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00617-00150552-00150702 it's not the whole story it's not the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00618-00150703-00150863 whole picture and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00619-00150864-00151143 especially now when putin and russia are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00620-00151144-00151295 trying to present this view of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00621-00151296-00151614 ukrainians as nationalistic nazis and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00622-00151615-00151839 it's it's totally
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00623-00151840-00151999 out of proportion you know i mean
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00624-00152000-00152183 there's more anti-semitism in cambridge
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00625-00152184-00152454 than there is in ukraine i would say
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00626-00152455-00152639 and in any place you know of course
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00627-00152640-00152854 there's anti-semitism there's neo-nazis
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00628-00152855-00153071 you know anywhere but i think i don't
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00629-00153072-00153207 know you can correct me but i think the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00630-00153208-00153495 percentage of the nationalist parties
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00631-00153496-00153735 in parliament is like maybe i don't even
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00632-00153736-00153863 think they have enough to get into
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00633-00153864-00153990 parliament i think they need three
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00634-00153991-00154326 percent and they don't have um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00635-00154327-00154526 there's so border yeah they don't have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00636-00154527-00154623 anything
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00637-00154624-00154863 they're not so popular and they
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00638-00154864-00155095 we know now that they was working for
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00639-00155096-00155319 the russia federation of years so there
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00640-00155320-00155407 was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00641-00155408-00155590 they paid them money and they was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00642-00155591-00155823 fighting for like ukrainian and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00643-00155824-00156071 nationalism
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00644-00156072-00156390 because they make a good picture for the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00645-00156391-00156583 russian tv shows you know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00646-00156584-00157223 so they they they did a big big big pig
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00647-00157224-00157351 yeah you know when i first went to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00648-00157352-00157511 ukraine i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00649-00157512-00157726 i was in louise primarily i saw a lot of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00650-00157727-00158014 the country but i resided in in levite
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00651-00158015-00158231 and there was in the very beginning of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00652-00158232-00158566 my time there i saw some anti-semitic
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00653-00158567-00158702 graffiti
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00654-00158703-00158807 however
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00655-00158808-00159023 it was pointed out to me that actually
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00656-00159024-00159231 that was the propaganda that was russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00657-00159232-00159566 propaganda that was made made ukrainians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00658-00159567-00159839 look like they were neo-nazis
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00659-00159840-00160102 so it's very complicated and nuanced and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00660-00160103-00160247 again not to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00661-00160248-00160407 you know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00662-00160408-00160607 erase the terrible things that did
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00663-00160608-00160775 happen but
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00664-00160776-00160854 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00665-00160855-00161054 you know it's not the full picture so i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00666-00161055-00161199 hope that speaks a little bit to what
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00667-00161200-00161343 you're getting at
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00668-00161344-00161454 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00669-00161455-00161726 and then about my my trip just now um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00670-00161727-00161911 again i was in lev
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00671-00161912-00162071 where there was a relative sense of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00672-00162072-00162278 safety people were going about their
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00673-00162279-00162431 everyday lives
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00674-00162432-00162799 more or less um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00675-00162800-00162943 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00676-00162944-00163175 for me it was a very beautiful
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00677-00163176-00163366 experience to be able to connect with my
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00678-00163367-00163639 dear friends there and to convey their
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00679-00163640-00163847 stories to people back here who are
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00680-00163848-00164023 really interested in knowing what was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00681-00164024-00164223 happening there and so there was this
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00682-00164224-00164375 whole community of people that i was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00683-00164376-00164647 communicating with in america primarily
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00684-00164648-00164911 in other parts of europe um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00685-00164912-00165119 and conveying their love and support to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00686-00165120-00165454 my friends in a very personal way and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00687-00165455-00165638 taking those stories from my friends
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00688-00165639-00165854 back to this community in america so for
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00689-00165855-00166023 me it was a really
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00690-00166024-00166247 a big privilege to be able to stand in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00691-00166248-00166423 that flow to be in the middle of that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00692-00166424-00166511 flow
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00693-00166512-00166702 and um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00694-00166703-00166926 you know i was just so touched by
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00695-00166927-00167119 stories you know my my best friend's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00696-00167120-00167295 brother was sent to the front when i was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00697-00167296-00167487 there and seeing his family say goodbye
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00698-00167488-00167599 to him
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00699-00167600-00167847 um was a particularly
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00700-00167848-00168175 difficult moment hearing my friend
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00701-00168176-00168463 young woman who was volunteering with
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00702-00168464-00168607 paramedics
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00703-00168608-00168759 in the worst areas you know the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00704-00168760-00168990 bloodiest areas on the front her
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00705-00168991-00169166 experience coming back to la vie where
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00706-00169167-00169278 she's from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00707-00169279-00169463 the trauma that she's carrying and her
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00708-00169464-00169783 insistence to retain her humanity
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00709-00169784-00169878 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00710-00169879-00170102 unlike the enemy unlike you know people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00711-00170103-00170287 who are not valuing human lives at all
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00712-00170288-00170407 you know she's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00713-00170408-00170647 insistent on retaining her humanity
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00714-00170648-00170799 that's the most important thing for her
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00715-00170800-00171038 despite all of the trauma and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00716-00171039-00171263 um horrible bloody things that she's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00717-00171264-00171366 seen
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00718-00171367-00171551 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00719-00171552-00171790 you know i would people are like lisa
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00720-00171791-00171926 was saying everybody wants to know how
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00721-00171927-00172143 to help and i think i would echo
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00722-00172144-00172278 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00723-00172279-00173095 right
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00724-00173096-00173423 continue to express um your desires to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00725-00173424-00173583 your representatives i think that's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00726-00173584-00173735 important to do it can feel like an
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00727-00173736-00173935 anonymous thing but it's really
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00728-00173936-00174135 important for them to hear the repeated
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00729-00174136-00174351 messages again and again there's so much
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00730-00174352-00174638 more that this country can do to provide
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00731-00174639-00174831 life-saving defensive
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00732-00174832-00175111 artillery and weapons to ukraine and as
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00733-00175112-00175254 i've said to a lot of people it feels
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00734-00175255-00175502 funny for me to advocate for military
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00735-00175503-00175687 support because i'm pretty much a
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00736-00175688-00175871 pacifist but in this situation there's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00737-00175872-00176095 no better example of a just war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00738-00176096-00176351 and a just use of force it's to protect
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00739-00176352-00176535 lives of innocent people who are being
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00740-00176536-00176671 killed
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00741-00176672-00176790 daily
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00742-00176791-00177071 so i would say continue to advocate for
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00743-00177072-00177359 more support faster support
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00744-00177360-00177575 this could end a lot faster if if
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00745-00177576-00177726 ukraine had the right equipment that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00746-00177727-00177966 they need and to stay engaged and to be
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00747-00177967-00178254 very very astute about russian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00748-00178255-00178495 propaganda which is very insidious and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00749-00178496-00178647 very nuanced
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00750-00178648-00178975 and it's infiltrated our social media
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00751-00178976-00179166 it's infiltrated media all over the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00752-00179167-00179566 world so try to stay too astute to that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00753-00179567-00179823 michelle i'm so sorry this is amazing
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00754-00179824-00180014 first of all this is why we do what we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00755-00180015-00180159 do um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00756-00180160-00180359 this is why west newton cinema exists
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00757-00180360-00180638 why boston film exists why we make
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00758-00180639-00180902 movies to be in these conversations to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00759-00180903-00181078 ask questions that will challenge us in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00760-00181079-00181399 the best way and get us to think and i'm
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00761-00181400-00181631 kind of blown away by this conversation
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00762-00181632-00181823 i'm getting many signals that we have to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00763-00181824-00181919 go
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00764-00181920-00182095 because i know we want to say i have to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00765-00182096-00182287 give vladimir you you wanted to say
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00766-00182288-00182447 something quickly before we go and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00767-00182448-00182623 we'll say a good night okay
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00768-00182624-00182719 all right
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00769-00182720-00182919 very quickly uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00770-00182920-00183302 i why i involved in always actively very
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00771-00183303-00183519 epically especially
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00772-00183520-00183687 as a representative
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00773-00183688-00183975 of the jewish community and as
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00774-00183976-00184111 one of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00775-00184112-00184414 leaders of the jewish community
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00776-00184415-00184543 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00777-00184544-00184823 why we received even
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00778-00184824-00185078 bad uh replies
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00779-00185079-00185366 what we are doing bad thing to russia to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00780-00185367-00185711 jews to everybody else we got everything
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00781-00185712-00185799 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00782-00185800-00186102 let me tell you a very quick story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00783-00186103-00186431 i went through everything
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00784-00186432-00186750 in soviet union in soviet ukraine
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00785-00186751-00187023 through uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00786-00187024-00187295 public anti-semitism from government
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00787-00187296-00187599 anti-semitism just toward me
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00788-00187600-00187911 that was ukrainian anti-semitism against
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00789-00187912-00188159 me and against my dance group against
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00790-00188160-00188487 our young people uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00791-00188488-00188750 and many many other things
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00792-00188751-00189031 i left in 1996
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00793-00189032-00189278 after very bad accident uh between me
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00794-00189279-00189559 and ukrainian real ukrainian nationals
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00795-00189560-00189750 not like those were
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00796-00189751-00190007 fake one
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00797-00190008-00190150 but uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00798-00190151-00190423 years came i was several times visiting
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00799-00190424-00190678 ukraine after that my last visit was in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00800-00190679-00190811 october
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00801-00190812-00191150 2021 at 80th and university of
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00802-00191151-00191335 anniversary of baby yeah i hope
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00803-00191336-00191623 everybody know what baby year is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00804-00191624-00191943 and there i saw absolutely different
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00805-00191944-00192214 country absolutely different people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00806-00192215-00192511 people who doesn't know what
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00807-00192512-00192726 anti-semitism is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00808-00192727-00193014 they live together jews non-jews
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00809-00193015-00193319 ukrainians polish people poland people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00810-00193320-00193471 hungarians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00811-00193472-00193687 i've met somebody else who's back i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00812-00193688-00193983 don't know where it came from
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00813-00193984-00194190 but they are ukrainians we speak
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00814-00194191-00194566 ukrainian i talked to those people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00815-00194567-00194814 i was ukrainians came to me with uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00816-00194815-00195126 information how bad was soviet uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00817-00195127-00195287 soldiers uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00818-00195288-00195607 in ukraine during the war after the war
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00819-00195608-00195943 like that where everybody was bad uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00820-00195944-00196263 lots of lots of different things but i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00821-00196264-00196638 found absolutely different nation
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00822-00196639-00196814 of people
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00823-00196815-00197102 who have less anti-semitism than i have
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00824-00197103-00197423 here in the united states
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00825-00197424-00197766 that's what happened and uh that's why i
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00826-00197767-00198023 asked you to support ukraine and if you
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00827-00198024-00198399 want uh do it simple way for example uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00828-00198400-00198719 last thing what we did we bought goggles
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00829-00198720-00198999 uh eye protective goggles what
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00830-00199000-00199183 shells who cannot
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00831-00199184-00199431 scratch and break they're protecting
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00832-00199432-00199535 eyes
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00833-00199536-00199623 or
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00834-00199624-00199799 simple t-shirts
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00835-00199800-00199975 for soldiers
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00836-00199976-00200207 but we will feel comfy
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00837-00200208-00200535 on the front line you can buy them and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00838-00200536-00200799 send amazon send to us and we will ship
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00839-00200800-00201247 it to ukraine and now uh i want only uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00840-00201248-00201375 to quickly
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00841-00201376-00201566 answer for two quick questions it has to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00842-00201567-00202238 be quick very quickly
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00843-00202239-00202407 in the film
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00844-00202408-00202638 very famous melody of this mannequin
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00845-00202639-00202775 manual
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00846-00202776-00202975 i heard that those words but with
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00847-00202976-00203278 different melody how it come up
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00848-00203279-00203502 and another
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00849-00203503-00203631 thing i was
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00850-00203632-00203926 shocked with the scene
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00851-00203927-00204183 when
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00852-00204184-00204311 the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00853-00204312-00204583 mother came after she saw her father
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00854-00204584-00204743 husband
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00855-00204744-00204855 shot
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00856-00204856-00205127 and started laundry how that came up
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00857-00205128-00205334 again
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00858-00205335-00205631 i i will start from the second question
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00859-00205632-00205727 um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00860-00205728-00206079 our director is woman as you know
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00861-00206080-00206271 alyssa and um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00862-00206271-00206479 i was thinking how to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00863-00206480-00206814 to demonstrate how to show how to show
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00864-00206815-00206951 her pain
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00865-00206952-00207094 and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00866-00207096-00207462 it was a long discussion and then
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00867-00207463-00207719 somehow we come up that she needs to do
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00868-00207719-00207966 something something usual and something
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00869-00207967-00208231 not to i mean she was trying not to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00870-00208232-00208527 scare kids and to do something
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00871-00208528-00208998 what
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00872-00209000-00209246 we have a lot of fights again uh between
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00873-00209248-00209438 together again this scene because
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00874-00209439-00209671 somebody of us uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00875-00209671-00209806 think that
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00876-00209807-00210079 nobody will understand what she has and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00877-00210080-00210334 always when um the screening i'm always
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00878-00210335-00210663 trying to to watch the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00879-00210664-00210806 audience to
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00880-00210807-00211039 to watch how they feel this and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00881-00211040-00211246 am i am i right that everybody is we
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00882-00211248-00211382 understand
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00883-00211383-00211598 completely understand thank you so much
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00884-00211600-00211806 uh and the first uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00885-00211807-00212119 uh first so we are really nice that's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00886-00212119-00212431 why we have a sound a producer he is
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00887-00212432-00212727 hussein
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00888-00212728-00212982 yeah he was it was really funny story
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00889-00212983-00213279 that we have hussein who was uh making
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00890-00213280-00213542 all the movie and the national ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00891-00213544-00213806 song shadrick you know uh carol of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00892-00213807-00213991 bell uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00893-00213992-00214255 he live in in germany actually
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00894-00214256-00214591 uh and we're trying to use all
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00895-00214592-00214782 ukrainians
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00896-00214783-00215031 national songs also this is it's kozak
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00897-00215032-00215223 songs yeah i know it's it's old kozak
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00898-00215223-00215375 songs and uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00899-00215376-00215519 uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00900-00215519-00215727 we want to show it and
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00901-00215728-00216191 if you know the woman who was playing um
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00902-00216192-00216446 the girl teresa
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00903-00216448-00216623 the movie starts from her and the movie
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00904-00216623-00216871 ends from her she's very well knowing
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00905-00216871-00217231 russian oh sorry ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00906-00217232-00217479 singer she's very well known in in
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00907-00217480-00217894 canada so she she's singing uh
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00908-00217896-00218087 ukrainian songs and in the end of the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00909-00218088-00218375 movie there she her song was the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00910-00218376-00218591 kozak system it's ukrainian
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00911-00218592-00218710 folk
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00912-00218711-00218958 folk folk folk team
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00913-00218959-00219151 i think this is the first time since
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00914-00219152-00219351 i've had this role of artistic director
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00915-00219352-00219551 it's impossible to stop this beautiful
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00916-00219552-00219703 conversation
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00917-00219704-00219919 um well first thank you all this is the
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00918-00219919-00220087 first time we've kind of done this let's
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00919-00220088-00220375 see a movie go up pastry and come back
+oeuJY9pnfrI-00920-00220376-00220759 and thank you all for sticking around
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00000-00000200-00000390 so the goal of this meeting is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00001-00000391-00000703 to look at q1 priorities
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00002-00000704-00000935 and although we already did this and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00003-00000936-00001191 just make sure that they're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00004-00001192-00001550 set and this is going to be the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00005-00001551-00001975 day 0 for the q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00006-00001976-00002287 so admin guys are you ready to start
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00007-00002288-00002639 yeah i think i can speak i i repeat just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00008-00002640-00002863 one slide i can share the screen
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00009-00002864-00003206 about that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00010-00003207-00003543 john are you allowed to screen sharing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00011-00003544-00003679 so everyone should be able to share a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00012-00003679-00004159 screen yeah i think i think i can
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00013-00004160-00004495 okay can you see it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00014-00004496-00004983 yes yes okay so we have prepared
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00015-00004984-00005399 a project board so it's available on the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00016-00005400-00005654 github page here the project number 16
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00017-00005655-00005799 where we are connecting where we are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00018-00005800-00005943 tracking all our
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00019-00005944-00006295 activities so our idea for the next
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00020-00006296-00006518 four months is working on high roads to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00021-00006519-00006814 verify high roads adoption feasibility
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00022-00006815-00007083 to improve development of the pulsar
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00023-00007084-00007375 network expand gtn test
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00024-00007376-00007734 automation and determine suitability of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00025-00007736-00008023 rfgene for reference data management
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00026-00008023-00008399 and deploy existing tools to the cmfs
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00027-00008400-00008519 network and use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00028-00008520-00008887 that that repository in production
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00029-00008888-00009310 so our milestones for that for q1 or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00030-00009311-00009639 we would like to have the use galaxy dot
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00031-00009640-00009791 star service able to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00032-00009792-00010135 to switch to to load tools from the cmos
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00033-00010136-00010431 network i would like to run performance
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00034-00010432-00010478 tests on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00035-00010479-00010823 irons and compare the times with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00036-00010824-00011119 with the the storage that use galaxy.org
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00037-00011120-00011255 is using now
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00038-00011256-00011542 and if the test is a success the idea is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00039-00011543-00011774 to deploy irons
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00040-00011775-00012270 to main and use for new data
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00041-00012271-00012542 we'll be preparing the storage road map
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00042-00012543-00012687 and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00043-00012688-00013046 again the idea is that gtan automation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00044-00013047-00013158 test suite
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00045-00013159-00013511 will be used also by the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00046-00013512-00013847 galaxy server and i would like also to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00047-00013847-00014022 prepare report on the issues and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00048-00014023-00014191 anomalies that we are collecting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00049-00014191-00014471 executing common workflows against a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00050-00014472-00014799 production pulsar site of our pulsar
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00051-00014800-00014983 network
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00052-00014984-00015215 more or less is the idea that we are for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00053-00015216-00015822 the q1 period
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00054-00015823-00016166 any questions i i have one question
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00055-00016168-00016447 uh so when we're gonna switch all three
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00056-00016448-00016543 galaxies to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00057-00016544-00016886 see the mfs to pull the tools uh we need
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00058-00016887-00017127 to at some point review the tool set
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00059-00017128-00017191 because
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00060-00017192-00017430 actually when you look at tools at all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00061-00017431-00017591 instances there's a number of tools that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00062-00017592-00017750 need to be purged or at least
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00063-00017751-00018086 moved to some disabled should be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00064-00018087-00018558 hidden that's what i mean so i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00065-00018559-00018791 that should be one of the goals for one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00066-00018792-00018950 of the groups probably for the tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00067-00018951-00019039 group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00068-00019040-00019230 or maybe for scientific applications the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00069-00019231-00019358 group is to review
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00070-00019359-00019655 actually tools that are currently in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00071-00019656-00019911 that common sense
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00072-00019912-00021083 okay good i think we can collaborate
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00073-00021084-00021230 together
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00074-00021231-00021575 um thanks tomorrow i think it's also
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00075-00021576-00021735 a very good idea to actually put all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00076-00021736-00022014 supporting like determined sustainable
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00077-00022015-00022278 suitability of refugee into the agenda
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00078-00022279-00022647 and to spend some time to evaluate that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00079-00022648-00023119 my only hint is that the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00080-00023120-00023358 the back end group has also on their
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00081-00023359-00023463 agenda
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00082-00023464-00023839 topic to discuss more broadly object
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00083-00023840-00023903 store
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00084-00023904-00024214 and and storage as part of their
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00085-00024215-00024399 back-end work
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00086-00024400-00024639 so i would really encourage the admin
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00087-00024640-00024863 group to team up with the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00088-00024864-00025150 backend group to make a joint meeting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00089-00025151-00026050 and discuss storage and object stores
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00090-00026051-00026887 together okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00091-00026888-00027262 okay to follow up on that i will i will
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00092-00027263-00027423 set up a meeting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00093-00027424-00027558 at the end of the month this month or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00094-00027560-00027846 maybe early february loop
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00095-00027847-00027990 loop the back end people who are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00096-00027991-00028214 interested in storage and remote storage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00097-00028216-00028502 and then i'll cc the admin team on that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00098-00028504-00029487 one minute
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00099-00029488-00029799 hey so any
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00100-00029800-00030158 objections to feasibility of these
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00101-00030160-00030407 milestones
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00102-00030408-00030927 if not let's move on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00103-00030927-00031174 all right so the backend group is next
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00104-00031175-00031287 our project board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00105-00031288-00031646 is 11.
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00106-00031647-00032190 so we have three sort of main priorities
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00107-00032191-00032335 there's many more details on the project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00108-00032336-00032455 board but these are the three main
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00109-00032456-00032543 things
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00110-00032544-00032711 uh so we want to modernize the galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00111-00032712-00032871 api um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00112-00032872-00033159 we've looked at fast api we've already
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00113-00033160-00033223 merged
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00114-00033224-00033655 this galaxy can start under fast api now
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00115-00033656-00033846 what this allows us so it's it's an
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00116-00033847-00034023 async framework it's a modern framework
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00117-00034024-00034135 it's a framework at all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00118-00034136-00034302 because we didn't really use a framework
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00119-00034303-00034471 before um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00120-00034472-00034759 it gives us async routes um and it gives
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00121-00034760-00034871 us web sockets so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00122-00034872-00035111 two modern technologies while we can use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00123-00035112-00035207 to improve
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00124-00035208-00035518 um things that should happen
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00125-00035519-00035846 uh quickly events so the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00126-00035847-00036190 um thing that we would need this for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00127-00036191-00036518 first would be history updates uh job
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00128-00036519-00036630 updates
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00129-00036631-00037023 uh things that should happen rapidly so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00130-00037024-00037167 that's what they're good is good for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00131-00037168-00037374 it's also using typing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00132-00037375-00037567 um and it has a nice automated
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00133-00037568-00037879 documentation generation two things that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00134-00037880-00038039 well typing we haven't done before and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00135-00038040-00038239 automated documentation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00136-00038240-00038407 always great because our documentation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00137-00038408-00038583 especially for the api
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00138-00038584-00038790 is essentially just look at bioblend
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00139-00038791-00038927 which is not a good
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00140-00038928-00039207 strategy i think not that by everyone's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00141-00039208-00039367 bad but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00142-00039368-00039583 galaxy should have better documentation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00143-00039584-00039823 of its api
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00144-00039824-00040151 and together with the async aspect is we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00145-00040152-00040367 need to get
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00146-00040368-00040607 some legacy patterns in how we use sql
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00147-00040608-00040679 archime
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00148-00040680-00041023 or our database layer we need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00149-00041024-00041255 rework those patterns so that we can use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00150-00041256-00041455 1.4 which introduced
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00151-00041456-00041679 asynchronous compatibility so the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00152-00041680-00041807 milestones for that part
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00153-00041808-00042118 are that galaxy starts under unicorn
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00154-00042119-00042479 or uv coin instead of pasty whiskey um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00155-00042480-00042774 optionally in 2105 and then we make the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00156-00042775-00042830 switch
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00157-00042831-00043174 in 2109 um we will
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00158-00043175-00043446 convert a few routes fully to fast api
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00159-00043447-00043535 so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00160-00043536-00043687 fast api can already serve the old
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00161-00043688-00043951 routes but we want to make them better
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00162-00043952-00044135 and document them fully so that's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00163-00044136-00044311 ongoing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00164-00044312-00044487 we want a websocket subscription
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00165-00044488-00044687 endpoint so you can just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00166-00044688-00044895 get like in real time updates as they
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00167-00044896-00045190 happen on the server
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00168-00045191-00045502 and one of the first things we need for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00169-00045503-00045799 truly async routes is that we can do
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00170-00045800-00045902 async
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00171-00045903-00046446 queries with sql alchemy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00172-00046447-00046727 um so the next big priority is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00173-00046728-00046839 enhancement to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00174-00046840-00047158 how galaxy manages data uh so that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00175-00047159-00047262 includes multiple
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00176-00047263-00047495 quota so if storage can come from
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00177-00047496-00047662 multiple places you need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00178-00047663-00047943 track how much space can be used where
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00179-00047944-00048271 can the job go and so on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00180-00048272-00048583 and so the kinds of storage that we're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00181-00048584-00048655 thinking about
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00182-00048656-00049143 here are mostly scratch storage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00183-00049144-00049479 take storage um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00184-00049480-00049911 and so we build a api
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00185-00049912-00050135 to summarize the usage and work together
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00186-00050136-00050302 with the ui ux group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00187-00050303-00050758 to have a nice visual representation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00188-00050759-00051143 of that will enhance the galaxy files
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00189-00051144-00051214 plugin
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00190-00051215-00051399 so that you can import and export
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00191-00051400-00051558 history
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00192-00051559-00051694 there will be a requirement for the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00193-00051695-00051990 android project two things that didn't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00194-00051991-00052094 exactly make it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00195-00052095-00052375 to like something that we will
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00196-00052376-00052430 accomplish
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00197-00052432-00052750 in q1 but that still on the roadmap is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00198-00052751-00053047 uh import of data from user object
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00199-00053048-00053159 stores
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00200-00053160-00053479 and remote object stores so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00201-00053479-00053782 that galaxy can deal with data that it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00202-00053783-00053991 never imported never generated metadata
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00203-00053991-00054111 for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00204-00054112-00054335 that's required for itcr but that's a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00205-00054336-00054415 big project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00206-00054416-00054663 and for that we first need the quota in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00207-00054664-00054782 place
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00208-00054783-00055007 but we will have regular meetings to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00209-00055008-00055119 discuss
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00210-00055120-00055447 how we want to implement this with the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00211-00055448-00055535 people that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00212-00055536-00055766 are going to work on that um so the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00213-00055767-00055935 milestones are that you can
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00214-00055936-00056254 configure multiple storage quarters that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00215-00056255-00056415 can be displayed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00216-00056416-00056694 that sharing will be disabled if data is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00217-00056695-00056999 somewhere where
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00218-00057000-00057342 it it is in a private location for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00219-00057344-00057423 storage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00220-00057424-00057630 we will have uh history import and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00221-00057632-00057887 export to file plugins
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00222-00057888-00058103 and we will have a plan for how we're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00223-00058104-00058263 going to move forward with user object
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00224-00058264-00058319 stores
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00225-00058320-00058638 and remote data and then the final
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00226-00058639-00058854 priority is performance
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00227-00058855-00058991 so that's going to be into collaboration
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00228-00058991-00059247 with the testing and deployment teams
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00229-00059248-00059454 so we want to do performance testing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00230-00059455-00059559 that is closer to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00231-00059560-00059942 real big servers um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00232-00059944-00060254 and we want to optimize how the job
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00233-00060255-00060406 throughput and one of the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00234-00060407-00060591 limiting factors here is the state
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00235-00060591-00060711 change
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00236-00060712-00061023 um so the two things here are a ci
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00237-00061024-00061135 framework
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00238-00061136-00061335 um that we run with every pull request
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00239-00061336-00061487 and that compares
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00240-00061488-00061830 before and after and sort of finds what
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00241-00061832-00062126 is regressing or did we make any nice
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00242-00062127-00062254 improvements
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00243-00062255-00062494 uh so that we know that we're moving in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00244-00062495-00062663 the right direction in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00245-00062664-00062903 the same way if we have if we want to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00246-00062904-00063063 make big changes but we're uncertain of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00247-00063064-00063166 like the impact
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00248-00063167-00063391 that we have a standard way to look at
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00249-00063391-00063630 this we're at a timer yes
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00250-00063632-00063911 yeah and then yeah for the second part
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00251-00063912-00063966 we just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00252-00063967-00064182 link the jobs with a data set so that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00253-00064183-00064399 you just look at the job state directly
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00254-00064400-00064575 instead of the worker runs we're doing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00255-00064576-00064711 now that's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00256-00064712-00065111 it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00257-00065112-00065359 can i ask uh every group so you're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00258-00065360-00065503 showing these slides can you put them in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00259-00065504-00065575 the folder
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00260-00065576-00065806 on the google drive where your uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00261-00065807-00066975 chargers are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00262-00066976-00067455 okay no questions
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00263-00067456-00067775 cancer informatics now
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00264-00067776-00068094 hello folks let me just share my screen
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00265-00068095-00068223 here
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00266-00068224-00068711 special hello to my european colleagues
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00267-00068712-00069319 let's see
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00268-00069320-00069631 okay um so this is the overall
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00269-00069632-00069838 road map for cancer informatics
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00270-00069839-00069982 ultimately
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00271-00069983-00070311 we want to have a sort of flavor
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00272-00070312-00070638 of galaxy portal for these analyses
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00273-00070639-00070935 living at cancer.usegalaxy.org so the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00274-00070936-00071079 initial push will be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00275-00071080-00071406 towards that end so we want to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00276-00071407-00071767 have a gpl based galaxy instance up that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00277-00071768-00071950 can use google login that will
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00278-00071951-00072111 eventually be tied to a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00279-00072112-00072471 fence instance um which is uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00280-00072472-00072806 yeah gen 3 idp
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00281-00072807-00073167 um we want to install cyclic amino
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00282-00073168-00073343 fluorescent tools and workflows which is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00283-00073344-00073455 a little more complex
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00284-00073456-00073687 not complex but involved than it sounds
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00285-00073688-00073838 since it's not just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00286-00073839-00074038 installing tool shed tools per se but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00287-00074039-00074287 some various custom tools that live in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00288-00074288-00074526 various places and ad hoc hodgepodge
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00289-00074527-00074815 things so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00290-00074816-00075135 smoothing that is part of that goal uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00291-00075136-00075350 in addition
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00292-00075351-00075550 we need to be able to pull from
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00293-00075551-00075694 disparate places that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00294-00075695-00075982 are these data stores ultimately these
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00295-00075983-00076126 are humongous files like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00296-00076127-00076326 i don't know 80 gigabyte multi-layer
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00297-00076327-00076487 tiffs that need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00298-00076488-00076662 be pulled in analyzed and then
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00299-00076663-00076831 perpetuated somewhere
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00300-00076832-00077311 the federated data promise
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00301-00077312-00077526 uh and then from there uh it gets a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00302-00077527-00077623 little more
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00303-00077624-00077911 nebulous in terms of what we're going to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00304-00077912-00077943 do
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00305-00077944-00078367 since planning super far ahead is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00306-00078368-00078671 a bit tricky but once we have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00307-00078672-00078862 an understanding of how to interact with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00308-00078863-00078975 these services
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00309-00078976-00079279 we'll wrap that into a data browser to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00310-00079280-00079471 have a more user-friendly experience
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00311-00079472-00079559 than
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00312-00079560-00079823 sshn pull get on the local file system
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00313-00079824-00079926 and port through galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00314-00079927-00080231 sort of rigmarole or something like that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00315-00080232-00080447 then we we're also very interested in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00316-00080448-00080575 interactive tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00317-00080576-00081047 on this instance for it's a very visual
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00318-00081048-00081311 process a lot of pictures and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00319-00081312-00081535 identifying regions and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00320-00081536-00081847 uh multi-colored magenta cell slides and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00321-00081848-00081982 things like that so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00322-00081983-00082215 being able to have this interactivity is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00323-00082216-00082606 uh key
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00324-00082607-00082926 uh and then from there i suppose once we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00325-00082927-00082975 have a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00326-00082976-00083294 stable instance we're interested in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00327-00083295-00083471 looking at
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00328-00083472-00083782 uh other sorts of tools and data sources
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00329-00083783-00083926 and analyses that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00330-00083927-00084167 community folks might want to perform so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00331-00084168-00084367 that's more in the long term
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00332-00084368-00084735 scope of our road map
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00333-00084736-00084935 yeah other canonical sources of data and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00334-00084936-00085431 ci crtc so on and so forth
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00335-00085432-00085959 that's about the high and low of it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00336-00085960-00086262 on your um github
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00337-00086263-00086591 project page uh your q1 tasks are you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00338-00086592-00086775 planning to assign them to specific
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00339-00086776-00086847 people
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00340-00086848-00087206 so admin group did this quite yes
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00341-00087207-00087438 um we are just have not gotten around to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00342-00087439-00087631 it unfortunately
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00343-00087632-00087887 okay well you probably want to get
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00344-00087888-00087950 around it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00345-00087951-00088343 fairly soon not before the end of q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00346-00088344-00088518 certainly probably before the end of the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00347-00088519-00089335 week excellent
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00348-00089336-00089743 okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00349-00089744-00090918 deployment
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00350-00090919-00091262 okay so uh the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00351-00091263-00091494 list of stuff that we uh pared it down
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00352-00091495-00091679 to i think for the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00353-00091680-00091991 uh first quarter here um the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00354-00091992-00092423 the top thing is to get it's enabled and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00355-00092424-00092775 and functional in gbl and kubernetes
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00356-00092776-00092943 based deployments of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00357-00092944-00093311 of galaxy um and as part of that project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00358-00093312-00093423 will end up
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00359-00093424-00093526 writing up a fair amount of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00360-00093527-00093750 documentation and probably
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00361-00093751-00094238 doing some refinement on how it's work
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00362-00094239-00094574 and some of the little
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00363-00094575-00094895 annoyances with using them currently
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00364-00094896-00095103 [Music]
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00365-00095104-00095335 another another goal here is to be able
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00366-00095336-00095406 to pip install
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00367-00095407-00095726 galaxy uh for quarter one that will most
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00368-00095727-00095926 likely mean just pip installing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00369-00095927-00096294 the application um and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00370-00096295-00096655 not the the not having a solution for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00371-00096656-00096735 the client
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00372-00096736-00097038 just yet um but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00373-00097039-00097350 maybe for for q2 we'll be able to to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00374-00097351-00097567 come up with a a nice install method for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00375-00097568-00097759 the client
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00376-00097760-00098343 um the uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00377-00098344-00098631 for gvl we'd like to be able to uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00378-00098632-00098679 switch
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00379-00098680-00099006 the dataset store to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00380-00099007-00099294 swift uh whereas three back storage this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00381-00099295-00099359 gives us
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00382-00099360-00099711 the the groundwork for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00383-00099712-00100111 uh pulsar to direct stage to and from
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00384-00100112-00100423 um object storage systems
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00385-00100424-00100743 without galaxy as the intermediary
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00386-00100744-00101215 um and then uh finally
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00387-00101216-00101535 in order to have a more defined
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00388-00101536-00101694 installable galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00389-00101695-00101982 uh such as with pip install galaxy we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00390-00101983-00102143 need a more defined
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00391-00102144-00102478 uh galaxy version and so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00392-00102479-00102782 we need to come up with a procedure for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00393-00102783-00102951 creating point releases so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00394-00102952-00103430 you know 20 2101.1.2.3
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00395-00103431-00103806 um and an easy system for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00396-00103807-00104030 you know the the people who are going to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00397-00104031-00104166 be in charge of creating those
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00398-00104167-00104366 to to create them and have all the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00399-00104367-00104830 packages built and pushed out
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00400-00104831-00105447 and that is it for deployment
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00401-00105448-00105839 um also purely stylistic things here so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00402-00105840-00106175 uh the link there's no link to this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00403-00106176-00106478 uh project from your uh chart or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00404-00106479-00106783 document as far as i can tell
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00405-00106783-00107119 uh maybe okay and also can you stick it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00406-00107120-00107431 on the community hub page
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00407-00107432-00107719 so it's that link that dave share so it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00408-00107720-00107871 can be easily
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00409-00107872-00108143 jumped to and just like with cancer
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00410-00108144-00108295 informatics you don't really
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00411-00108296-00108583 assign things to anybody so that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00412-00108583-00108702 probably
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00413-00108703-00108943 yeah we're going to so we tried to get a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00414-00108944-00109102 meeting together
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00415-00109103-00109366 uh you know from the notice on tuesday
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00416-00109367-00109415 but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00417-00109416-00109590 uh weren't able to find times for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00418-00109591-00109743 everyone in the in the group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00419-00109744-00110071 by today so uh we will do that within
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00420-00110072-00110199 the next week
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00421-00110200-00110415 make sure that we don't fall behind here
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00422-00110416-00110502 so basically
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00423-00110503-00110758 three things add project to the google
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00424-00110759-00110839 doc
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00425-00110840-00111151 add it to the hub page and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00426-00111152-00111527 assign tasks okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00427-00111528-00111895 you got a question for native this time
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00428-00111896-00112295 please so regarding the last point
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00429-00112296-00112607 uh in in the list so the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00430-00112608-00112934 uh point releases is the idea to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00431-00112935-00113310 basically replace the way where we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00432-00113311-00113623 did basically keep the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00433-00113624-00113958 the branch and suggest to admin to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00434-00113959-00114263 keep the branch updated moving to uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00435-00114264-00114566 tags or is this more connected with the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00436-00114567-00114710 pip installable galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00437-00114711-00115151 and so pi pi packages
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00438-00115152-00115310 i think if you're gonna if you're gonna
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00439-00115311-00115463 use a clone it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00440-00115464-00115663 would probably still make sense to to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00441-00115664-00115895 just use the release branch
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00442-00115896-00116143 um especially because we're you know
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00443-00116144-00116263 that's that's gotten
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00444-00116264-00116454 higher and higher quality over time so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00445-00116455-00116647 we i don't think we need to worry too
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00446-00116648-00116758 much about people
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00447-00116759-00116943 not using an exact point release on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00448-00116944-00117063 there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00449-00117064-00117223 but certainly if you want to be very
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00450-00117224-00117366 deterministic
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00451-00117367-00117702 in your galaxy and its version
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00452-00117703-00117910 then we will create git tags for it and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00453-00117911-00118271 you can use those
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00454-00118272-00118558 so it's kind of connected with the pi by
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00455-00118559-00118695 installable galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00456-00118696-00118927 yeah yeah because the goal is so you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00457-00118928-00119054 know from these
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00458-00119055-00119263 you can also build system packages if
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00459-00119264-00119375 you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00460-00119376-00119678 need to have a galaxy installed on your
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00461-00119679-00119790 cluster in order to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00462-00119791-00119999 to run metadata and that sort of stuff
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00463-00120000-00120166 so for that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00464-00120167-00120502 um we need we need actual versions and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00465-00120503-00120814 stuff
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00466-00120815-00121478 thank you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00467-00121479-00122534 okay that means human genetics
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00468-00122535-00122751 hello sorry this is basically the same
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00469-00122752-00122871 one as last time
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00470-00122872-00123175 oh we haven't assigned people like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00471-00123176-00123519 by name but basically every person or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00472-00123520-00123743 almost every person in the group is in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00473-00123744-00123839 two other groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00474-00123840-00123999 so we're gonna have a lot of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00475-00124000-00124151 collaborating with other groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00476-00124152-00124471 um so for example one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00477-00124472-00124758 i mean yeah uh the anvil tool set we're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00478-00124759-00124799 gonna do
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00479-00124800-00125063 with the tools group it's just getting a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00480-00125064-00125183 list of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00481-00125183-00125343 tools that are verified to be working
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00482-00125344-00125510 and then setting up the testing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00483-00125511-00125639 infrastructure to make sure that they
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00484-00125640-00125790 stay working
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00485-00125791-00126014 um the integration is gonna be with back
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00486-00126015-00126271 in groups mostly the anvil fs plug-in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00487-00126272-00126423 which works but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00488-00126424-00126654 is going to have to have some optimizing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00489-00126655-00126871 done and then
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00490-00126872-00127054 enabling lighting back through the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00491-00127055-00127358 plug-in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00492-00127359-00127510 interactive tools with the deployment
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00493-00127511-00127702 group it's going to be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00494-00127703-00127958 a little bit different in the gke
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00495-00127959-00128102 context just to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00496-00128103-00128302 have some gke native things as opposed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00497-00128303-00128439 to the things that we do more
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00498-00128440-00128614 genetically for kubernetes
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00499-00128615-00128751 with the deployment group so just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00500-00128752-00129095 translating that to gke specifics
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00501-00129096-00129478 um deployment the those one specific
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00502-00129479-00129647 thing or i guess two specific things
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00503-00129648-00129695 that are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00504-00129696-00129895 only for android the galaxy cube man
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00505-00129896-00130119 chart which is right now what deploys
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00506-00130120-00130283 the entire stack
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00507-00130283-00130623 of um nfs postgas
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00508-00130624-00131039 um cvmfs and galaxy on to gke for anvil
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00509-00131040-00131183 so that needs to be maintained and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00510-00131184-00131390 updated with when the new galaxy home
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00511-00131391-00131799 chart comes out for 2101 um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00512-00131800-00132023 still want to create a testing ecosystem
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00513-00132024-00132159 to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00514-00132160-00132359 make sure that at any given time
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00515-00132360-00132607 galaxy's deployable on anvil so we can
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00516-00132608-00132663 set up
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00517-00132664-00132902 crown jobs to run every day or something
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00518-00132903-00133023 and make sure that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00519-00133024-00133239 on any given day if somebody goes to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00520-00133240-00133495 anvil they can still launch galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00521-00133496-00133735 um and we're already working with the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00522-00133736-00133839 blue team on some
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00523-00133840-00134143 optimizations um and we've talked about
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00524-00134144-00134319 some things that need to be done on the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00525-00134320-00134447 leo side
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00526-00134448-00134743 and then some like maybe a little bit
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00527-00134744-00134959 that we can still do on the galaxy side
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00528-00134960-00135223 although we've gotten the startup to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00529-00135224-00135327 already be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00530-00135328-00135647 like about i think three minutes um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00531-00135648-00135847 with everything from scratch on galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00532-00135848-00135999 side so the bulk
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00533-00136000-00136247 is now the seven minutes on the leo side
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00534-00136248-00136431 to deploy the cluster which we need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00535-00136432-00136583 cut down
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00536-00136584-00136902 um and then finally just the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00537-00136903-00137102 more science stuff of actually
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00538-00137103-00137231 developing workflows
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00539-00137232-00137959 and more use cases for anvil
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00540-00137960-00138375 that's it for me
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00541-00138376-00138607 so again just like in the previous
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00542-00138608-00138735 presentation there is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00543-00138736-00139054 can you add this presentation to drive
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00544-00139055-00139535 uh i assume you have uh anvil related
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00545-00139536-00139911 um github board project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00546-00139912-00140151 yes i added this i added the same things
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00547-00140152-00140214 there's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00548-00140215-00140535 project board here um okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00549-00140536-00140871 and we also have a i'm not sure
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00550-00140872-00141047 if it should stay private but we have a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00551-00141048-00141295 private anvil repository right now on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00552-00141296-00141483 galaxy project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00553-00141484-00141790 um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00554-00141791-00142007 i think if you link this to the google
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00555-00142008-00142263 doc and to hub page that would be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00556-00142264-00142623 enough for now so for that private one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00557-00142624-00142823 we should actually migrate it to the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00558-00142824-00142887 anvil
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00559-00142888-00143223 project galaxy repo and move that board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00560-00143224-00143575 but then yeah look it up um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00561-00143576-00143871 one question about tool set is there a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00562-00143872-00144078 document i remember you were sharing it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00563-00144079-00144271 essentially as a google doc
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00564-00144272-00144599 of the tools of curated set of tools is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00565-00144600-00144943 is that is that somewhere
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00566-00144944-00145111 oh yeah i mean we still have the google
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00567-00145112-00145302 tag that you might tools with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00568-00145303-00145751 lead and green oh that was translated to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00569-00145752-00146071 basically we took i took a dump of the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00570-00146072-00146359 currency vmfs tool shed and then removed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00571-00146360-00146551 everything that was led
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00572-00146552-00146902 uh but we still need to run the entire
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00573-00146903-00147151 tool tests on our new anvil instance
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00574-00147152-00147295 with all of the changes
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00575-00147296-00147590 and make sure that those still working
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00576-00147591-00147895 yeah and you add a link to this document
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00577-00147896-00148287 to your either you know google project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00578-00148288-00148454 or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00579-00148455-00148671 your google doc because this is also
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00580-00148672-00148839 something that tools people need to be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00581-00148840-00148935 aware of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00582-00148936-00149183 and admin people need to be aware of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00583-00149184-00149414 because that has implications to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00584-00149415-00149783 for example common toolset
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00585-00149784-00150111 okay i'll add it to the slides into
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00586-00150112-00150526 this project blood thank you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00587-00150527-00151063 okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00588-00151064-00152495 any other question okay go ahead
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00589-00152496-00153190 dolphin are you presenting or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00590-00153191-00153543 i don't think we hear you or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00591-00153544-00153878 whoever is presenting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00592-00153879-00154207 okay here you are uh so yeah
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00593-00154208-00154407 we haven't had the name of the people on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00594-00154408-00154671 the uh github project yet but they are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00595-00154672-00154871 listed on the chatter document in google
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00596-00154872-00154990 drive uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00597-00154991-00155343 for the task assigned to everyone uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00598-00155344-00155663 so one of the main projects
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00599-00155664-00155911 is the community website that nick is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00600-00155912-00156111 working on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00601-00156112-00156383 so the goal is to have a prototype by
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00602-00156384-00156519 the end of q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00603-00156520-00156790 and one of the milestones in this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00604-00156791-00157023 process is to have a document with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00605-00157024-00157239 a description of the content structure
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00606-00157240-00157551 and the website functionalities
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00607-00157552-00157814 and setting on the system that's going
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00608-00157815-00158190 to be used for that platform
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00609-00158191-00158343 concerning the training and outreach
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00610-00158344-00158575 video we're aiming to have video
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00611-00158576-00158639 covering
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00612-00158640-00158959 analyze data and workflow interface by
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00613-00158960-00159119 the end of q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00614-00159120-00159423 and include them in gtn as a micro
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00615-00159424-00159687 tutorial that can be linked
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00616-00159688-00160014 as a snippet uh everywhere
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00617-00160015-00160278 and uh we want to establish a calendar
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00618-00160279-00160399 for the integration of automatic
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00619-00160400-00160487 screenshots
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00620-00160488-00160719 by the end of q1 to have more visibility
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00621-00160720-00160887 for the next
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00622-00160888-00161254 following quarters we are migrating the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00623-00161255-00161454 faq to training material
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00624-00161455-00161783 uh we start by building a relationship
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00625-00161784-00161823 map
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00626-00161824-00162159 of all the faq to have a clear version
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00627-00162160-00162287 of what can go into the training
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00628-00162288-00162366 material
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00629-00162367-00162671 what are the priorities
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00630-00162672-00162790 and at the same time we're going to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00631-00162791-00163063 develop a template
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00632-00163064-00163319 for the inclusion of troubleshooting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00633-00163320-00163439 into the gtn
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00634-00163440-00163654 so that the next go first we can enroll
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00635-00163655-00163766 people to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00636-00163767-00163999 transfer easily from the faq to the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00637-00164000-00164102 template
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00638-00164103-00164535 and have it moving quickly
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00639-00164536-00164719 so the next coffin is going to happen
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00640-00164720-00164926 with the papercut
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00641-00164927-00165231 in february so we need to advertise the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00642-00165232-00165438 event to prepare the agenda and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00643-00165439-00165775 broadcast the recap of what's been done
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00644-00165776-00166111 by the two projects together
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00645-00166112-00166343 we want to send the g10 paper by the end
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00646-00166344-00166599 of the quarter
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00647-00166600-00167038 so we also have ti ais
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00648-00167039-00167319 that's been deployed in other main uh in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00649-00167320-00167478 other galaxy instances
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00650-00167479-00167831 we need to advertise more where is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00651-00167832-00168223 where it is available and how to use it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00652-00168224-00168519 we also want to uh rework the code of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00653-00168520-00168695 conduct because we have noticed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00654-00168696-00169038 that uh when we have conferences with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00655-00169039-00169247 bosc for example we have more reported
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00656-00169248-00169447 case than when we are alone
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00657-00169448-00169759 so that might be due to uh some lack
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00658-00169760-00170143 in describing how to um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00659-00170144-00170407 report or how to identify problematic
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00660-00170408-00170638 behavior so we want to include some
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00661-00170639-00170863 more detail in the code of conduct so by
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00662-00170864-00170999 the other quarter we want to have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00663-00171000-00171199 an idea of what are the points to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00664-00171200-00171351 improve uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00665-00171352-00171638 to have a new code of conduct by the end
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00666-00171639-00171719 of q2
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00667-00171720-00172119 and gcc
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00668-00172120-00172359 we also want to work with the open life
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00669-00172360-00172526 science project to advertise the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00670-00172527-00172783 projects that are linked to the gtnr
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00671-00172784-00173375 galaxy we have the gallantries going on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00672-00173376-00173726 well by the end of q1 we should have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00673-00173727-00173854 some
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00674-00173855-00174214 first results and um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00675-00174215-00174423 so we need to request and process the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00676-00174424-00174783 feedback of people using it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00677-00174784-00175007 and then we have a galaxy there are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00678-00175008-00175295 training that we're going to schedule
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00679-00175296-00175478 and that's going to be discussed at a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00680-00175479-00175687 day round table
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00681-00175688-00176287 probably this month or the next
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00682-00176288-00176607 any question
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00683-00176608-00176943 is gallant what is gallantries
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00684-00176944-00177271 is a galaxy for higher education so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00685-00177272-00177671 uh teaching undergrads
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00686-00177672-00177983 okay so you have quite a few tasks are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00687-00177984-00178071 this um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00688-00178072-00178375 reasonable list for one quarter well we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00689-00178376-00178423 have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00690-00178424-00178719 15 to 20 people on the group so all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00691-00178720-00178959 right
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00692-00178960-00179151 um i have one question if you scroll all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00693-00179152-00179295 the way up
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00694-00179296-00179638 on this uh so with the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00695-00179639-00179878 videos videos covering workflow these
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00696-00179879-00180023 will be automatically generated ones
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00697-00180024-00180119 right
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00698-00180120-00180423 uh no
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00699-00180424-00180631 we don't know when the automatic one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00700-00180632-00180751 will be available
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00701-00180752-00181159 uh workflow will just be how to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00702-00181160-00181319 just the same as the interface from the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00703-00181320-00181566 next data but for who is gonna be making
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00704-00181567-00181671 them
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00705-00181672-00181999 um me mostly okay so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00706-00182000-00182231 we'll talk about that yeah so i can help
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00707-00182232-00182375 there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00708-00182376-00182766 any other questions
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00709-00182767-00183102 that's time uh dolphin also again
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00710-00183103-00183383 we'll add the link to this project board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00711-00183384-00183471 to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00712-00183472-00183719 it's in the google doc it is but it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00713-00183720-00184231 not on the hub
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00714-00184232-00185399 okay support
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00715-00185400-00186071 hey hold on a second
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00716-00186072-00186447 you're very purple i'm very purple
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00717-00186448-00186887 oh hello
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00718-00186888-00187287 okay i think that's what i want
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00719-00187288-00187599 now hold on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00720-00187600-00188623 i'm sorry i don't do this very often
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00721-00188624-00188959 and i'll be quick so it'll be fine
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00722-00188960-00189359 okay sure
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00723-00189360-00189790 all right can you guys see
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00724-00189791-00190078 yep yeah okay so this is just our
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00725-00190079-00190150 charter
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00726-00190151-00190414 um but i redid it and i'll re-link that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00727-00190415-00190502 to the hub
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00728-00190503-00190775 um so there's really just three of us
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00729-00190776-00190863 right now
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00730-00190864-00191190 um so ignacio and aguar
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00731-00191191-00191390 we just having a chance to get everyone
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00732-00191391-00191583 wrapped up yet so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00733-00191584-00191887 i'm thinking like q2
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00734-00191888-00192190 um and so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00735-00192191-00192454 primarily what we do is we do we give
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00736-00192455-00192590 support right so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00737-00192591-00192799 uh these are all the places where we do
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00738-00192800-00192943 that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00739-00192944-00193447 and um there's a bunch of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00740-00193448-00193735 tools and boards and all of that that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00741-00193736-00193919 exists
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00742-00193920-00194102 um and most of our collaborations are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00743-00194103-00194238 going to be with the outreach and the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00744-00194239-00194319 training group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00745-00194320-00194647 so um you know we need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00746-00194648-00194783 figure out who's going to be on the team
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00747-00194784-00194911 and where we're going to track projects
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00748-00194912-00195038 so it might just be inside other
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00749-00195039-00195102 projects
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00750-00195103-00195502 um that's fine and then mapping faqs
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00751-00195503-00195663 into a new structure is kind of a big
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00752-00195664-00195807 deal and we're going to prioritize that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00753-00195808-00195919 because everything else is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00754-00195920-00196287 based off that so we started that you
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00755-00196288-00196447 saw delphine listed done on the project
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00756-00196448-00196511 board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00757-00196512-00196863 um so there's two main tasks
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00758-00196864-00197135 uh it's to transfer the training
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00759-00197136-00197343 material this is exactly cloned off of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00760-00197344-00197407 the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00761-00197408-00197550 other working group that delphine just
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00762-00197551-00197871 showed um and so we have a card
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00763-00197872-00198047 on that project board i can link that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00764-00198048-00198190 into here
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00765-00198191-00198519 and then the second thing is that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00766-00198520-00198750 there's a webinar for advanced features
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00767-00198751-00198895 and i want to make sure that all of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00768-00198896-00199063 these topics are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00769-00199064-00199295 migrated over into the gtn before we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00770-00199296-00199390 have the webinar
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00771-00199391-00199799 so that we look like we're organized
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00772-00199800-00199959 so there's just a few things to do for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00773-00199960-00200238 that all of this is currently in the hub
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00774-00200239-00200423 right now and it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00775-00200424-00200638 it looks like a big laundry list there's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00776-00200639-00200799 a lot of graphics or anything else like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00777-00200800-00200887 that so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00778-00200888-00201119 um and this hasn't really been this has
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00779-00201120-00201238 been discussed a little bit but it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00780-00201239-00201375 hasn't been started i'll probably be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00781-00201376-00201438 working on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00782-00201439-00201759 one two and three
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00783-00201760-00202102 or at least maybe half of one so anathon
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00784-00202103-00202238 i will be discussing that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00785-00202239-00202495 and then i put this in here and i moved
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00786-00202496-00202695 it to q2
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00787-00202696-00203014 um but maybe this isn't us so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00788-00203015-00203231 and i know we wanted to curate the tool
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00789-00203232-00203423 panel and we wanted to curate tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00790-00203424-00203702 and i really think that our tool tests
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00791-00203703-00203807 are not enough
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00792-00203808-00204023 and the gta tutorials aren't enough we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00793-00204024-00204183 should look at actually
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00794-00204184-00204366 like how the tools are actually
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00795-00204367-00204575 performing on the server so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00796-00204576-00204831 are they passing or failing you know is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00797-00204832-00204942 there a usage problem
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00798-00204944-00205342 and so i kind of detailed into your um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00799-00205344-00205510 finding technical issues and then what
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00800-00205511-00205686 to do about it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00801-00205687-00205998 you know tag it deprecate it hide it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00802-00206000-00206206 remove it fix it says it needs something
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00803-00206207-00206334 fixed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00804-00206335-00206638 um and then go back and look at tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00805-00206639-00206727 that have usage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00806-00206728-00206958 issues so that we can look at the ones
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00807-00206959-00207134 that fail a lot and then we know what
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00808-00207135-00207310 kind of responses we've given to users
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00809-00207311-00207438 about that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00810-00207439-00207671 and does it need more tool help just and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00811-00207671-00207879 what could be directly incorporated into
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00812-00207880-00208206 galaxy so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00813-00208207-00208519 all of the all the faq is going into the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00814-00208519-00208862 uh the the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00815-00208863-00209127 the gtn is as like a tutorial that might
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00816-00209128-00209286 not always be the best place it might be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00817-00209287-00209375 better to put it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00818-00209376-00209614 um on the help of the tool form itself
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00819-00209615-00209846 or on the tool help there's a little
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00820-00209848-00210223 question mark next to tools that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00821-00210223-00210398 isn't always utilized and so i think we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00822-00210400-00210558 could we could we could leverage that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00823-00210559-00210775 and so if you've got a problem with a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00824-00210776-00210991 particular tool we've got sort of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00825-00210992-00211175 documents around that about what like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00826-00211176-00211310 the most common problems but i think we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00827-00211311-00211551 can include that directly in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00828-00211552-00211855 so maybe whoever works on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00829-00211856-00212167 this curation we could be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00830-00212167-00212463 um we could help inform that with actual
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00831-00212464-00212510 like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00832-00212511-00212719 like here's the numbers here's the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00833-00212719-00212871 versions of the tools this is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00834-00212871-00213055 how many times it's used successfully or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00835-00213056-00213271 not and here's why so we can kind of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00836-00213271-00213439 give a break out of like why
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00837-00213440-00213606 it's failing or why it's why it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00838-00213607-00213758 difficult to use or why people keep
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00839-00213759-00213919 asking about it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00840-00213919-00214167 so um all of this is just sort of like a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00841-00214167-00214327 wish list of things that i think we need
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00842-00214328-00214398 to do but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00843-00214400-00214703 um it's it can't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00844-00214704-00215031 there's no way that i can do it in q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00845-00215032-00215423 so there are two things uh that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00846-00215423-00215839 so one of them is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00847-00215840-00216039 you probably want to decrease the volume
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00848-00216040-00216151 of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00849-00216152-00216310 issues that you're dealing with and one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00850-00216311-00216446 of the ways of doing this is that we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00851-00216448-00216734 need reliable statistics for tool usage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00852-00216735-00216934 uh we don't have this form i mean we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00853-00216935-00217079 don't have it in the presentable form
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00854-00217080-00217167 for maine
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00855-00217167-00217534 but probably eu and au
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00856-00217535-00217758 and australian ones have that we can at
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00857-00217759-00217991 least use this as the initial blueprint
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00858-00217992-00218158 for figuring out which tools are used
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00859-00218159-00218310 and which aren't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00860-00218311-00218471 uh this is one of the priorities for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00861-00218471-00218615 admin group to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00862-00218616-00219079 use to do this for maine that's time
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00863-00219080-00219415 and and another thing is that um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00864-00219416-00219598 unified tool sets so you sort of need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00865-00219600-00219831 keep an eye on that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00866-00219832-00220023 right so i think we're not able to start
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00867-00220023-00220142 that until q2
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00868-00220144-00220439 so i just there's there's so much to get
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00869-00220440-00220671 started for q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00870-00220671-00220894 um and i really want that webinar to be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00871-00220896-00220975 well so i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00872-00220976-00221239 and we're going to need to get we're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00873-00221240-00221287 going to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00874-00221288-00221494 have to get more people involved right
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00875-00221496-00221663 so if you can help
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00876-00221664-00221846 connected with i think we need tools i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00877-00221848-00222015 think we're going to need ui ux
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00878-00222016-00222134 admin and i still know there's a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00879-00222135-00222471 scientific group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00880-00222471-00222682 we need to keep moving because we have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00881-00222683-00222879 um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00882-00222880-00223263 number of groups left thank you um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00883-00223264-00223598 so okay so i will
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00884-00223600-00223742 briefly talk about scientific
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00885-00223744-00223991 applications this is the group which
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00886-00223992-00224382 has a lot of people and it's notably
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00887-00224383-00224694 absent from hub so i will fix
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00888-00224696-00224998 all of these issues um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00889-00225000-00225294 the objective of this group if i can
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00890-00225296-00226198 share this document here
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00891-00226200-00226646 is to is to highlight galaxy highlight
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00892-00226648-00226967 real examples of real biological
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00893-00226967-00227094 problems that were
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00894-00227096-00227455 shown with that were sold with galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00895-00227456-00227710 so really the goal of this group is to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00896-00227711-00227823 is to write
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00897-00227823-00228334 biological papers with a galaxy angle
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00898-00228335-00228694 and some of the immediate goals for q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00899-00228696-00229087 is finishing our stars cov2 efforts
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00900-00229088-00229431 and getting the vgp
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00901-00229432-00229823 and pan genome-related tools identified
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00902-00229823-00230198 wrapped assembled into workflows and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00903-00230200-00230694 tested
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00904-00230696-00231015 and i'll update all the documents and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00905-00231016-00232119 create the board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00906-00232119-00232439 um for the testing and hardening group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00907-00232440-00232639 um basically it's the same objectives
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00908-00232640-00232758 that we for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00909-00232759-00232982 quarter one that we presented uh before
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00910-00232983-00233094 the break
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00911-00233096-00233406 um we put them into a project board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00912-00233407-00233582 um marius already talked about the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00913-00233583-00233710 performance suite but we've got that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00914-00233711-00233871 broken down into
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00915-00233871-00234087 chunks that we'll be able to sort of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00916-00234088-00234279 accomplish useful things in quarter one
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00917-00234280-00234319 but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00918-00234319-00234487 sort of assemble them to the so that we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00919-00234488-00234734 finish working product in quarter two
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00920-00234735-00235046 um and then uh release testing is the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00921-00235048-00235175 other big thing i guess that hasn't been
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00922-00235176-00235279 touched on yet
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00923-00235280-00235479 uh we got twenty one a one coming out
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00924-00235480-00235598 and uh we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00925-00235600-00235791 uh i guess sergey is gonna relieve the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00926-00235792-00236046 effort to get that release tested
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00927-00236048-00236279 um and i think otherwise though nothing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00928-00236280-00236406 has changed since
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00929-00236407-00236631 since the last time we presented so i'll
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00930-00236632-00236782 see the rest of my time unless there are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00931-00236783-00237398 questions
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00932-00237400-00237919 cool
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00933-00237919-00238894 no questions still john
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00934-00238896-00239198 all right so we currently
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00935-00239200-00239415 have one major priority and then based
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00936-00239416-00239510 on how long
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00937-00239511-00239710 and how big that one ends up being we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00938-00239711-00239871 have several smaller things
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00939-00239871-00240158 and part of our decision for how we're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00940-00240159-00240198 gonna
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00941-00240200-00240446 deal with uh with q1 is actually
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00942-00240448-00240527 specifically
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00943-00240528-00240815 determine what roles we're taking with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00944-00240816-00240910 uh ponemo
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00945-00240911-00241230 and tool use with training uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00946-00241231-00241558 for uh for new tool wrappers
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00947-00241559-00241879 um and a couple other things so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00948-00241880-00242142 for example we're looking at discussing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00949-00242144-00242230 tool
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00950-00242231-00242558 like iuc specific uh hackathons and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00951-00242559-00242823 papercut days
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00952-00242823-00243206 there is a list of 35-ish
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00953-00243207-00243591 tools that were listed as part of the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00954-00243592-00243791 as part of youtube as being used in vgp
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00955-00243792-00243958 several of which are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00956-00243959-00244198 not licensed in such a way that we would
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00957-00244200-00244351 be able to wrap them but most of them
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00958-00244352-00244391 are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00959-00244392-00244582 several of which we already have we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00960-00244583-00244758 don't have specific names yet because
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00961-00244759-00244903 we're all kind of reading through each
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00962-00244904-00245039 of the tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00963-00245040-00245342 um some of them are extremely large
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00964-00245344-00245582 from what i understand and will not be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00965-00245583-00245671 able to be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00966-00245671-00246063 put on on certain servers for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00967-00246064-00246367 obvious reasons uh because extreme
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00968-00246367-00246455 memory usage
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00969-00246456-00246846 and time requirements so to that end we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00970-00246848-00247039 have not assigned yet but we're planning
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00971-00247040-00247167 to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00972-00247167-00247382 get all of these or at least as many of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00973-00247383-00247615 these as possible wrapped by q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00974-00247616-00247806 with the goal of having at least one of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00975-00247807-00247967 the little files
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00976-00247967-00248319 that have that are wrapped in the vgp
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00977-00248319-00249282 pipelines as runnable as a workflow in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00978-00249283-00249519 galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00979-00249519-00249663 just a quick comment if you have any
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00980-00249664-00249830 questions about these um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00981-00249831-00250039 i think my group has a lot of experience
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00982-00250040-00250198 with like all of these in fact we've
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00983-00250200-00250342 published a few
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00984-00250344-00250687 perfect uh and this is i actually wanted
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00985-00250688-00250855 to ask mike about this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00986-00250856-00251255 is so are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00987-00251256-00251446 is any are any of these products still
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00988-00251448-00251742 uses 10x i don't think so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00989-00251744-00251975 i mean we're in the transition period so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00990-00251976-00252046 the company
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00991-00252048-00252494 10x has discontinued their linked read
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00992-00252496-00252766 kit but there are other
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00993-00252767-00252879 [Music]
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00994-00252880-00253055 more or less equivalent technologies out
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00995-00253056-00253206 there that people are interested to use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00996-00253207-00253310 so i think it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00997-00253311-00253446 i think there's a lot of legacy data
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00998-00253448-00253655 that's still out there in principle a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-00999-00253656-00253791 lot of these tools could be used for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01000-00253792-00253919 these other approaches but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01001-00253919-00254230 it's a valid question and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01002-00254231-00254519 also for the tools that require a lot of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01003-00254519-00254639 memory you're probably
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01004-00254640-00254846 talking about some of the assemblers
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01005-00254848-00255367 that yeah
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01006-00255367-00255494 we're looking to wrap those and then
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01007-00255496-00255687 probably make them like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01008-00255688-00255951 put them in the tool shed but but not
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01009-00255952-00255998 actually
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01010-00256000-00256198 put them on any major servers that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01011-00256200-00256463 people can choose to run them locally or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01012-00256464-00256823 on a cloud instance that they can launch
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01013-00256823-00257094 yeah well we have to only interrupt them
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01014-00257096-00257430 first i suppose
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01015-00257431-00257919 so how did this tool set how did vgp
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01016-00257919-00258255 get picked as the priority for q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01017-00258256-00258527 and then the tools following from that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01018-00258528-00258623 it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01019-00258623-00259103 a rapidly evolving area
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01020-00259104-00259415 uh which is fueled by
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01021-00259416-00259727 advances in the long read sequencing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01022-00259728-00260063 and the its priority because we need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01023-00260064-00260198 get on that train
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01024-00260200-00260558 as soon as possible
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01025-00260559-00260791 because right now galaxy is really good
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01026-00260792-00260991 for illumina data but it's not that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01027-00260992-00261198 useful if you have peg bio or oxford
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01028-00261200-00261310 nanopore
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01029-00261311-00261679 i mean i'm talking about main toolset uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01030-00261680-00261942 and this needs to change because if we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01031-00261944-00262046 don't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01032-00262048-00262439 adapt to these technologies we are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01033-00262440-00262719 just we won't be able to be uh in the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01034-00262720-00262943 top
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01035-00262944-00263399 but what is your concern is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01036-00263400-00263758 just uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01037-00263759-00263934 i mean i'm wondering what you know what
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01038-00263935-00264143 what's the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01039-00264144-00264463 are we using tools are we installing or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01040-00264464-00264591 adding tools that are
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01041-00264592-00264934 so required by many um accordingly
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01042-00264935-00265087 popular because every time i look at
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01043-00265088-00265439 eu um there's you know they have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01044-00265440-00265663 a human cell atlas version they have the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01045-00265664-00265767 nanopore
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01046-00265768-00265958 server they have the rna one there's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01047-00265959-00266271 like a dozen different servers and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01048-00266272-00266599 on main specifically
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01049-00266600-00266782 it's it's frankly i don't know i mean i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01050-00266783-00266887 don't know enough about tools but it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01051-00266888-00267087 feels like a hodgepodge
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01052-00267088-00267495 of things that are fairly dated
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01053-00267496-00267695 and so just are we getting these
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01054-00267696-00267799 requests from
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01055-00267800-00267975 the help are we getting them from the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01056-00267976-00268247 literature are we getting them from
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01057-00268248-00268591 you know just um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01058-00268592-00269030 include more of the so how
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01059-00269031-00269295 this is so to answer that question is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01060-00269296-00269527 that we are going to review tool set and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01061-00269528-00269758 so what's going to be at use galaxy dot
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01062-00269759-00269830 star
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01063-00269831-00270143 uh cv mfs will not be a hot hodge
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01064-00270144-00270487 podge uh the question with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01065-00270488-00270758 the multiple faces of dot eu that's a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01066-00270759-00270895 great question
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01067-00270896-00271191 i think we were sort of resistant we can
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01068-00271192-00271351 do this i suppose
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01069-00271352-00271582 but we were resisting towards this for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01070-00271583-00271823 some technical reasons
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01071-00271824-00272047 well i think what we wanted to do is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01072-00272048-00272134 pursue the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01073-00272135-00272423 the tool sets in the toolbox in a single
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01074-00272424-00272519 instance and that's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01075-00272520-00272703 sort of work in progress that's not
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01076-00272704-00272919 currently on our priority roadmap but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01077-00272920-00273023 could definitely be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01078-00273024-00273310 pushed so the the idea there is to tack
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01079-00273311-00273382 tools
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01080-00273383-00273623 and be able to pull for example rna-seq
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01081-00273624-00273734 tools and so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01082-00273735-00273958 on i don't know if we can in in the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01083-00273959-00274095 short term to enable
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01084-00274096-00274463 eu like functionality i'm not sure
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01085-00274464-00274671 whether technically we can do this on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01086-00274672-00274863 maine that's a question to bjorn and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01087-00274864-00275230 nate really you're out time okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01088-00275231-00275487 but technically it's not difficult so if
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01089-00275488-00275639 we wanted to go that route in a new room
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01090-00275640-00275743 we certainly could
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01091-00275744-00275982 i think we should go this round in the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01092-00275983-00276119 sh in the meantime
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01093-00276120-00276455 i i think that's that's we should we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01094-00276456-00276551 should do this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01095-00276552-00276767 let's let's talk about that i i don't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01096-00276768-00276958 think we can put it on q1 but we should
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01097-00276959-00277039 do it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01098-00277040-00277287 sure and another thing in vgp is that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01099-00277288-00277471 we're trying to become members of this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01100-00277472-00277567 consortium
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01101-00277568-00277879 which will be a very uh good
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01102-00277880-00278158 publicity uh thing for galaxy project in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01103-00278159-00278255 general
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01104-00278256-00278534 so uh and plus it's a great project it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01105-00278535-00278623 an interesting
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01106-00278624-00278815 open project for sequencing all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01107-00278816-00278999 vertebrates and at this point they're
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01108-00279000-00279039 using
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01109-00279040-00279495 commercial um tools well commercial
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01110-00279496-00279775 the workflow tools using dna nexus and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01111-00279776-00279887 what we want to bring
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01112-00279888-00280287 is the public free distributed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01113-00280288-00280606 functionality system okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01114-00280607-00281503 ui
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01115-00281504-00281687 all right did that start sharing this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01116-00281688-00281903 thing always okay cool
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01117-00281904-00282206 um all right so i took uh or we took
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01118-00282207-00282455 all of the priorities from our roadmap
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01119-00282456-00282630 put them on this github board
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01120-00282631-00282927 um the first column is the sort of meta
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01121-00282928-00283119 information column that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01122-00283120-00283303 uh the intent is to have some some
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01123-00283304-00283455 information here and then we'll
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01124-00283456-00283655 these are just the top level things the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01125-00283656-00283799 board is going to be pretty active and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01126-00283800-00283927 things will move across it like you'd
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01127-00283928-00284110 expect
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01128-00284111-00284367 but the idea is that each of these top
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01129-00284368-00284551 level items in the far left column
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01130-00284552-00284927 is checked off by the end of the quarter
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01131-00284928-00285239 sorry if you hear babies um so uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01132-00285240-00285358 it's mostly the same stuff we talked
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01133-00285359-00285558 about last time the new history
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01134-00285559-00285751 we've already merged it and it's in beta
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01135-00285752-00285991 mode for 2101
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01136-00285992-00286151 we're going to do a group review to sort
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01137-00286152-00286343 of just walk through it pick particular
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01138-00286344-00286399 tasks
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01139-00286400-00286679 test them out and build an issue list
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01140-00286680-00286871 that we will then resolve
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01141-00286872-00287239 during quarter one and uh then swap it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01142-00287240-00287479 in its primary interface during q1
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01143-00287480-00287791 for a 2105 release so in 2105 the new
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01144-00287792-00287879 history will be
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01145-00287880-00288327 the history um the second priority is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01146-00288328-00288558 collapse these things um the second
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01147-00288559-00288734 priority is the workflow invocation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01148-00288735-00288791 interface
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01149-00288792-00288943 a lot of work has already been done on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01150-00288944-00289095 this but it basically provides all of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01151-00289096-00289254 the details about a workflow invocation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01152-00289255-00289487 and one component
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01153-00289488-00289719 so the initial pr is actually ready to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01154-00289720-00289879 go really early in the quarter
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01155-00289880-00290030 so we need to add some tests and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01156-00290031-00290151 probably do a little bit of polish and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01157-00290152-00290263 refinement
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01158-00290264-00290454 um and then that's that's so that's the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01159-00290455-00290615 second priority there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01160-00290616-00290863 um batch operations is one that's uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01161-00290864-00290975 maybe a little bit more ambitious
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01162-00290976-00291119 because no work has been done on it at
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01163-00291120-00291223 all yet
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01164-00291224-00291382 we need to figure out a list of desired
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01165-00291383-00291558 operations um and then
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01166-00291559-00291758 implement a sort of generic operation
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01167-00291759-00291871 api
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01168-00291872-00292039 uh kind of like in gmail where you say
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01169-00292040-00292271 apply this to all matching emails
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01170-00292272-00292495 to flag them or filter them or delete
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01171-00292496-00292623 them like i do
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01172-00292624-00292830 um and then we need we want to integrate
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01173-00292831-00292967 that in the new history don't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01174-00292968-00293223 not even bothering with the old one um i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01175-00293224-00293287 i should
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01176-00293288-00293423 i should note that most all these cards
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01177-00293424-00293582 actually do have people associated with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01178-00293583-00293767 them down if you dig in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01179-00293768-00294071 or almost all of them um we have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01180-00294072-00294319 a goal to get some collections ux
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01181-00294320-00294415 improvements in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01182-00294416-00294743 um we decided that four items resolved
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01183-00294744-00294871 out of the big project board is a good
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01184-00294872-00294943 benchmark
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01185-00294944-00295343 um so we're going to do that igv.js
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01186-00295344-00295630 this uh we want to integrate that as a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01187-00295631-00295775 first as a charts visualization in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01188-00295776-00295887 galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01189-00295888-00296087 um this basic single track igbjs
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01190-00296088-00296279 visualization is pretty much done
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01191-00296280-00296527 um adding multiple tracks uh there there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01192-00296528-00296591 are some
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01193-00296592-00296791 issues in the charts framework that we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01194-00296792-00296903 ran into but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01195-00296904-00297103 anyway so to resolve that and then have
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01196-00297104-00297310 a parameter driven
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01197-00297311-00297519 viewport and and things like that piped
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01198-00297520-00297615 through without
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01199-00297616-00297982 reloads is is on the on the map
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01200-00297983-00298295 um and then tool form beautification the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01201-00298296-00298479 idea is not to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01202-00298480-00298630 viewify the whole tool form that's a big
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01203-00298631-00298815 project in q1 we want to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01204-00298816-00298958 figure out the right strategy for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01205-00298959-00299191 replacing items considering their
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01206-00299192-00299351 the impact they'll have across the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01207-00299352-00299743 application because multiple places use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01208-00299744-00300006 some of the widgets right um so and then
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01209-00300007-00300151 we want to pick one element
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01210-00300152-00300503 uh and convert it as a prototype for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01211-00300504-00300630 you know distributing the rest of them
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01212-00300631-00300951 in q2 and then finishing up the form
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01213-00300952-00301095 so that's just sort of a baby step
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01214-00301096-00301247 towards that project with a with an eye
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01215-00301248-00301334 to q2
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01216-00301335-00301575 um the new user welcome uh this is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01217-00301576-00301687 returning to that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01218-00301688-00301982 uh that project where you know first
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01219-00301983-00302087 time user gets
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01220-00302088-00302351 instead of the standard welcome they get
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01221-00302352-00302495 a sort of a dashboard
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01222-00302496-00302791 with curated content for a new user
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01223-00302792-00303134 showing them how to use galaxy
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01224-00303135-00303351 and then this this is maybe a bit of a
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01225-00303352-00303471 stretch goal but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01226-00303472-00303679 to to really lean into per instance
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01227-00303680-00303823 configurability
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01228-00303824-00304143 um so that you know eu could have their
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01229-00304144-00304279 own new user welcome and things like
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01230-00304280-00304334 that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01231-00304335-00304639 um and then lastly a library's ux review
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01232-00304640-00304951 uh we have a big board so user uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01233-00304952-00305079 data libraries went through a big
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01234-00305080-00305279 overhaul fairly recently um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01235-00305280-00305567 with with oleg's viewification there uh
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01236-00305568-00305615 and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01237-00305616-00305863 we have we we also have a board that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01238-00305864-00306047 identified a whole bunch of issues with
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01239-00306048-00306199 the old data libraries
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01240-00306200-00306382 um but basically we the goal for this
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01241-00306383-00306879 task for q1 is just to go through and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01242-00306880-00306991 get organized there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01243-00306992-00307119 and figure out where we need to take
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01244-00307120-00307287 data libraries in q2 it's not
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01245-00307288-00307430 necessarily to do a ton of work on data
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01246-00307431-00307895 libraries
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01247-00307896-00308095 and that's it uh it sounds like a lot
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01248-00308096-00308239 but it's a pretty big group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01249-00308240-00308447 um and they're pretty reasonably sized
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01250-00308448-00308639 projects some of which have already had
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01251-00308640-00309030 uh a lot of work done to them so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01252-00309031-00309367 yep i think it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01253-00309368-00309695 like the ux around its is possibly
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01254-00309696-00309863 missing from this list
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01255-00309864-00310151 uh that was not in our priorities list
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01256-00310152-00310199 here
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01257-00310200-00310591 and we were advised not to add
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01258-00310592-00310782 priorities
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01259-00310783-00311215 i mean it can still get done but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01260-00311216-00311415 it's not on this list we're i mean
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01261-00311416-00311582 obviously ui ux is a huge category and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01262-00311583-00311671 we're going to do a lot of stuff that's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01263-00311672-00311806 not on this list and that can be one of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01264-00311807-00311879 those things
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01265-00311880-00312054 i i would argue that this is more
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01266-00312055-00312334 important than library ux
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01267-00312335-00312782 uh because for i mean the it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01268-00312783-00312895 i think that's a different kind of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01269-00312896-00313079 project though this is not development
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01270-00313080-00313151 at all
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01271-00313152-00313382 the library ux review is not development
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01272-00313383-00313534 if anything i would say
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01273-00313535-00313727 the batch operations we could just push
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01274-00313728-00313951 to q2 and focus on
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01275-00313952-00314127 that's actually even more important than
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01276-00314128-00314351 it is okay
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01277-00314352-00314767 i just uh okay it's very painful to use
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01278-00314768-00314879 galaxy when you have very large
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01279-00314880-00315095 histories and that would address
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01280-00315096-00315454 all of these issues so some of the stuff
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01281-00315455-00315703 with its was waiting on the right time
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01282-00315704-00315991 i don't want to go over we can still we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01283-00315992-00316103 can follow up on that and try to get it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01284-00316104-00316351 done
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01285-00316352-00316806 okay well any questions to any group
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01286-00316807-00317367 i also because what what i don't want
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01287-00317368-00317519 what i don't like about this meeting is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01288-00317520-00317710 that sort of i'm i'm talking here and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01289-00317711-00317782 that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01290-00317783-00317999 creates an impression and it's all about
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01291-00318000-00318151 maine but in fact
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01292-00318152-00318382 the list of people here is much bigger
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01293-00318383-00318479 than the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01294-00318480-00318847 the galaxy so please any other questions
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01295-00318848-00318951 from anybody
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01296-00318952-00319382 else are we is there anything missing
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01297-00319383-00319415 and
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01298-00319416-00319703 and you see any potential connections
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01299-00319704-00320375 and so on i mean
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01300-00320376-00320751 um i would like to ask all groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01301-00320752-00321054 to add their project links
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01302-00321055-00321391 to the hub and to google docs so it's
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01303-00321392-00321551 uniform
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01304-00321552-00321758 so we can look at them it would be nice
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01305-00321759-00321863 if all the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01306-00321864-00322103 projects also have a uniform structure
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01307-00322104-00322391 but that's not necessary but as long as
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01308-00322392-00322687 everybody knows where they are and may i
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01309-00322688-00322743 ask
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01310-00322744-00323047 dave and bear to put
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01311-00323048-00323351 the meetings of all groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01312-00323352-00323687 to galaxy calendar so everybody knows
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01313-00323688-00323854 when the groups are meeting for example
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01314-00323855-00323982 i personally
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01315-00323983-00324254 would like to participate in uh you know
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01316-00324255-00324519 two
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01317-00324520-00324815 meetings for example in ui meetings yeah
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01318-00324816-00325271 i can coordinate that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01319-00325272-00325454 any other things we're missing anything
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01320-00325455-00325630 we can make this better
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01321-00325631-00326375 any suggestions
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01322-00326376-00326567 i have maybe a question to the working
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01323-00326568-00326751 groups um
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01324-00326752-00327071 is it working that you can define
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01325-00327072-00327375 dependencies on other working groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01326-00327376-00327695 can we facilitate that process or is
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01327-00327696-00327734 that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01328-00327735-00328054 fine so example again
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01329-00328055-00328287 um that the backend group needs to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01330-00328288-00328447 deliver something that the frontend
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01331-00328448-00328663 group needs to consume
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01332-00328664-00328871 is that working okay or do you need to
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01333-00328872-00329023 have help in
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01334-00329024-00329351 facilitating that somehow
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01335-00329352-00329487 for that one in particular i think it
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01336-00329488-00329647 helps because a lot of us are in both of
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01337-00329648-00329751 those groups
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01338-00329752-00330078 um i so it may not be the best example
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01339-00330079-00330519 but yeah i don't see any problems there
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01340-00330520-00330703 but in more general when when the
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01341-00330704-00330839 overlap is not so
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01342-00330840-00331358 high is that still working or
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01343-00331359-00331615 i don't know that at least first for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01344-00331616-00331751 stuff that i'm involved in i haven't
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01345-00331752-00331854 tried yet but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01346-00331855-00332087 uh we might need something i don't know
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01347-00332088-00332263 i think the its was probably a good
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01348-00332264-00332399 example right
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01349-00332400-00332654 we we mentioned that we have some stuff
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01350-00332655-00332839 that needs to be worked on but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01351-00332840-00333603 then no plan to actually do that
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01352-00333604-00333854 [Music]
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01353-00333855-00334047 so to support the intergroup stuff we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01354-00334048-00334254 have the point person listed
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01355-00334255-00334591 on the hub page and we also have a wg
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01356-00334592-00334934 all excuse me get her channel
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01357-00334935-00335191 so it's not gonna solve our problems but
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01358-00335192-00335519 it will help
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01359-00335520-00335895 okay so um i didn't say new year
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01360-00335896-00336119 because new year for the project begins
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01361-00336120-00336199 right now
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01362-00336200-00336503 that's the that's the january one for
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01363-00336504-00336782 ourselves happy new year
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01364-00336783-00337143 and thank you everybody
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01365-00337144-00337430 and uh we'll post that recording so we
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01366-00337431-00337791 know what was happening if we forget
+oiaYEgmWzTI-01367-00337792-00338200 happy new year thanks everyone
+oj7ByokzBWu-00000-00001192-00001407 a negotiable instrument usually young
+oj7ByokzBWu-00001-00001408-00001807 holder in good faith and for value
+oj7ByokzBWu-00002-00001807-00002030 titles from a parcel of land
+oj7ByokzBWu-00003-00002032-00002199 to multiple people
+oj7ByokzBWu-00004-00002200-00002879 first in time first thing right usually
+oj7ByokzBWu-00005-00002880-00003175 per
+oj7ByokzBWu-00006-00003176-00003431 general rules its computer a new number
+oj7ByokzBWu-00007-00003432-00003735 one detail higher number better let's
+oj7ByokzBWu-00008-00003736-00004054 say between two computer parts pc 100 or
+oj7ByokzBWu-00009-00004055-00004431 pc 50 all things being equal people in
+oj7ByokzBWu-00010-00004432-00005489 my own pc 100.
+oj7ByokzBWu-00011-00005490-00007142 [Music]
+oj7ByokzBWu-00012-00007143-00007367 search for the software you need add to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00013-00007368-00007767 heart the ancestor payment option
+oj7ByokzBWu-00014-00007768-00007910 five minutes
+oj7ByokzBWu-00015-00007911-00008023 finished
+oj7ByokzBWu-00016-00008023-00008295 my legit breaking siddiqui
+oj7ByokzBWu-00017-00008296-00009678 windows
+oj7ByokzBWu-00018-00009679-00009863 let's go part by part starting with the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00019-00009864-00010255 cpu the usual metric for speed the cpu
+oj7ByokzBWu-00020-00010256-00010551 is gigahertz and indie but two gigahertz
+oj7ByokzBWu-00021-00010552-00010823 is better than one gigahertz yes some of
+oj7ByokzBWu-00022-00010824-00011119 the time sagittarius compatible
+oj7ByokzBWu-00023-00011120-00011431 between cpus of the same family so let's
+oj7ByokzBWu-00024-00011432-00011887 say ryzen 5000 series new r5 5 600 x 4.6
+oj7ByokzBWu-00025-00011888-00012327 gigahertz young the ryzen 9 5950x is 4.9
+oj7ByokzBWu-00026-00012328-00012646 gigahertz so yes matsubis nasha faces a
+oj7ByokzBWu-00027-00012647-00013575 ryzen
+oj7ByokzBWu-00028-00013576-00013783 only works within the same types of
+oj7ByokzBWu-00029-00013784-00013991 chips so useless they compare young
+oj7ByokzBWu-00030-00013991-00014215 gigahertz nerizan versus gigahertz the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00031-00014216-00014527 intel versus gigahertz new apple
+oj7ByokzBWu-00032-00014528-00014855 hit let's see megahertz the intel
+oj7ByokzBWu-00033-00014856-00015247 individually known automatically
+oj7ByokzBWu-00034-00015247-00015583 amd compared to an amd cpu with a lower
+oj7ByokzBWu-00035-00015584-00015703 gigahertz
+oj7ByokzBWu-00036-00015704-00015950 core count yes usually higher number
+oj7ByokzBWu-00037-00015951-00016055 better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00038-00016056-00016286 because more cores lets you do more
+oj7ByokzBWu-00039-00016287-00016583 multitasking so better nash in the sense
+oj7ByokzBWu-00040-00016584-00016727 nah massable
+oj7ByokzBWu-00041-00016728-00017169 game performance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00042-00017170-00017447 [Music]
+oj7ByokzBWu-00043-00017448-00017671 for example for gaming a lot of games
+oj7ByokzBWu-00044-00017672-00017935 don't use a lot of force so yes may
+oj7ByokzBWu-00045-00017936-00018119 speed boosts the games you are nine
+oj7ByokzBWu-00046-00018120-00018327 fifty nine ktx fed a price to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00047-00018328-00018611 performance le mansparency
+oj7ByokzBWu-00048-00018612-00018975 r55600x which has a lot less course
+oj7ByokzBWu-00049-00018976-00019103 because scores are better for
+oj7ByokzBWu-00050-00019104-00019407 multitasking individual programs
+oj7ByokzBWu-00051-00019408-00019527 like games
+oj7ByokzBWu-00052-00019528-00019727 aren't designed to take advantage of a
+oj7ByokzBWu-00053-00019728-00019975 lot of force so tutonganaman higher
+oj7ByokzBWu-00054-00019976-00020383 number better more course better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00055-00020384-00020622 young price to performance value by
+oj7ByokzBWu-00056-00020623-00020958 basha paris a use case
+oj7ByokzBWu-00057-00020959-00021175 for motherboards yes usually higher
+oj7ByokzBWu-00058-00021176-00021463 number better speed of ram supported
+oj7ByokzBWu-00059-00021464-00021727 higher number better transfer speeds
+oj7ByokzBWu-00060-00021728-00022007 from the pcie bus higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00061-00022008-00022247 so dto tutorial rule higher number
+oj7ByokzBWu-00062-00022248-00022471 better except of course for temperatures
+oj7ByokzBWu-00063-00022472-00022735 you want the vrm temps to be as low as
+oj7ByokzBWu-00064-00022736-00022950 possible number of faces of the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00065-00022951-00023255 motherboard masmarami faces must find
+oj7ByokzBWu-00066-00023256-00023422 you control
+oj7ByokzBWu-00067-00023423-00023622 power
+oj7ByokzBWu-00068-00023623-00023830 cpu and other components so yes a
+oj7ByokzBWu-00069-00023831-00023999 motherboard will generally pass the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00070-00024000-00024271 higher number better rule
+oj7ByokzBWu-00071-00024272-00024575 gpu then usually higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00072-00024576-00024871 speed of the gpu higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00073-00024872-00025127 size of its memory higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00074-00025128-00025391 number of fans higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00075-00025392-00025639 number of tensor cores or the amd
+oj7ByokzBWu-00076-00025639-00025927 equivalent higher number better so yes a
+oj7ByokzBWu-00077-00025927-00026127 gpu follows the general rule higher
+oj7ByokzBWu-00078-00026127-00026255 number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00079-00026256-00026495 acceptance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00080-00026495-00026702 lower number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00081-00026704-00026990 when it comes to the price of a gpu psu
+oj7ByokzBWu-00082-00026991-00027231 yes generally higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00083-00027232-00027487 especially than sequoia rating the 80
+oj7ByokzBWu-00084-00027488-00027814 plus an 80 plus gold is more efficient
+oj7ByokzBWu-00085-00027816-00028031 compared to an 80 plus white or 80 plus
+oj7ByokzBWu-00086-00028032-00028255 bronze titanium you've been at the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00087-00028256-00028502 highest 80 plus rating
+oj7ByokzBWu-00088-00028504-00028751 generally the higher the color the more
+oj7ByokzBWu-00089-00028752-00029095 reliable a psu is
+oj7ByokzBWu-00090-00029095-00029343 components
+oj7ByokzBWu-00091-00029344-00029551 a higher efficiency rating
+oj7ByokzBWu-00092-00029552-00029839 generally also higher what capacity
+oj7ByokzBWu-00093-00029839-00029935 better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00094-00029936-00030199 so 850 watts can deliver more power
+oj7ByokzBWu-00095-00030200-00030567 compared to a 650 watt psu
+oj7ByokzBWu-00096-00030568-00030718 computer
+oj7ByokzBWu-00097-00030719-00031046 what capacity new psu
+oj7ByokzBWu-00098-00031047-00031358 computer let's say 850 watts in psu mode
+oj7ByokzBWu-00099-00031360-00031567 edition overpower well i'm going to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00100-00031568-00031855 damage the component and damning what's
+oj7ByokzBWu-00101-00031856-00032190 not anything psu you don't need to worry
+oj7ByokzBWu-00102-00032191-00032446 about that although again it's even more
+oj7ByokzBWu-00103-00032447-00032774 young price to performance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00104-00032775-00033127 higher wattage psus 850 watts 1000 watts
+oj7ByokzBWu-00105-00033128-00033462 1200 watts 80 plus titanium compared to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00106-00033463-00033631 80 plus gold
+oj7ByokzBWu-00107-00033632-00033990 bacon
+oj7ByokzBWu-00108-00033991-00034183 my recent video come in uh for a
+oj7ByokzBWu-00109-00034184-00034351 high-end computer
+oj7ByokzBWu-00110-00034352-00034679 okay 650 watts for added headroom or
+oj7ByokzBWu-00111-00034680-00034943 added allowance usually most enthusiasts
+oj7ByokzBWu-00112-00034944-00035207 get 750 watts anything beyond that is
+oj7ByokzBWu-00113-00035208-00035471 really mining territory so ram yes
+oj7ByokzBWu-00114-00035472-00035655 higher number better when it comes to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00115-00035656-00035935 the size so definitely eight gigabytes
+oj7ByokzBWu-00116-00035936-00036151 is better than four gigabytes 32
+oj7ByokzBWu-00117-00036152-00036759 gigabytes is better than 16 gigabytes
+oj7ByokzBWu-00118-00036760-00036983 meaning you have two sticks of ram
+oj7ByokzBWu-00119-00036984-00037359 so one x8 versus two x four killing two
+oj7ByokzBWu-00120-00037360-00037590 x four actually even then higher number
+oj7ByokzBWu-00121-00037591-00037823 better the more sticks you have
+oj7ByokzBWu-00122-00037824-00038127 generally better because
+oj7ByokzBWu-00123-00038128-00038399 dual channels
+oj7ByokzBWu-00124-00038400-00038583 in single stick
+oj7ByokzBWu-00125-00038584-00038839 there's a speed ram higher number is not
+oj7ByokzBWu-00126-00038840-00039174 necessarily better it's a ryzen
+oj7ByokzBWu-00127-00039175-00039446 architecture on the sweet spot is around
+oj7ByokzBWu-00128-00039447-00039790 3600 to 3 800 megahertz
+oj7ByokzBWu-00129-00039791-00040190 dials uh infinity fabric clock no amd
+oj7ByokzBWu-00130-00040191-00040455 new horizon series anything beyond that
+oj7ByokzBWu-00131-00040456-00040599 actually
+oj7ByokzBWu-00132-00040600-00040823 a computer which might take the system
+oj7ByokzBWu-00133-00040824-00041039 instability or it might even crash the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00134-00041040-00041271 computer
+oj7ByokzBWu-00135-00041272-00041471 infinity fabric clock
+oj7ByokzBWu-00136-00041472-00041790 ram so my mod clear instance says higher
+oj7ByokzBWu-00137-00041791-00042095 speed is not necessarily better for ram
+oj7ByokzBWu-00138-00042096-00042671 cl timings
+oj7ByokzBWu-00139-00042672-00042943 lower timings usually mean that they're
+oj7ByokzBWu-00140-00042944-00043127 tighter meaning that the communication
+oj7ByokzBWu-00141-00043128-00043358 of the ram is faster
+oj7ByokzBWu-00142-00043359-00043639 to the motherboard for example
+oj7ByokzBWu-00143-00043640-00043879 in cl 16 by enthusiasts
+oj7ByokzBWu-00144-00043880-00044199 cl 18.
+oj7ByokzBWu-00145-00044200-00044407 debatable
+oj7ByokzBWu-00146-00044408-00044639 advantage
+oj7ByokzBWu-00147-00044640-00044967 cl 16 compared to cl 18.
+oj7ByokzBWu-00148-00044968-00045174 talaga although if you're not an
+oj7ByokzBWu-00149-00045175-00045374 enthusiast the market tinker around
+oj7ByokzBWu-00150-00045375-00045567 manually with the timings you'll
+oj7ByokzBWu-00151-00045568-00045855 probably be happy already with cl 18.
+oj7ByokzBWu-00152-00045856-00046143 ssds yes usually higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00153-00046144-00046383 usually among metrics from ssds data
+oj7ByokzBWu-00154-00046384-00046639 transfer rate data read rate all of
+oj7ByokzBWu-00155-00046640-00046807 those things usually higher number
+oj7ByokzBWu-00156-00046808-00046902 better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00157-00046903-00047239 number of cycles essentially
+oj7ByokzBWu-00158-00047240-00047486 ssd manufacturers oh
+oj7ByokzBWu-00159-00047487-00047862 ssd rated up to a long read ride cycles
+oj7ByokzBWu-00160-00047863-00048079 so the higher the number the longer the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00161-00048080-00048399 ssd will last it's a monitor yes usually
+oj7ByokzBWu-00162-00048400-00048583 higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00163-00048584-00048911 in size yeah 27 inches is a big leap
+oj7ByokzBWu-00164-00048912-00049608 from 24 inches
+oj7ByokzBWu-00165-00049609-00050551 [Music]
+oj7ByokzBWu-00166-00050552-00051007 just those little increments of inches
+oj7ByokzBWu-00167-00051008-00051254 screen space and you immersive nest ema
+oj7ByokzBWu-00168-00051255-00051502 games and productivity mode
+oj7ByokzBWu-00169-00051503-00051735 windows
+oj7ByokzBWu-00170-00051736-00051926 and then of course the jump to 32 and
+oj7ByokzBWu-00171-00051927-00052407 even larger monitors
+oj7ByokzBWu-00172-00052408-00052863 actual desktop new size
+oj7ByokzBWu-00173-00052864-00052982 really
+oj7ByokzBWu-00174-00052983-00053247 there's no disadvantage to getting the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00175-00053248-00053479 largest monitor you can other metrics
+oj7ByokzBWu-00176-00053479-00053719 for monitors higher number better also
+oj7ByokzBWu-00177-00053720-00053991 refresh rate resolution
+oj7ByokzBWu-00178-00053991-00054142 all of those things usually higher
+oj7ByokzBWu-00179-00054144-00054326 number better of course you could be
+oj7ByokzBWu-00180-00054327-00054582 over paying again dito little malabasin
+oj7ByokzBWu-00181-00054583-00055054 price to perform months
+oj7ByokzBWu-00182-00055055-00055415 144 hertz monitor just for office 60
+oj7ByokzBWu-00183-00055416-00055750 hertz or 75 hertz will do so yes while
+oj7ByokzBWu-00184-00055751-00055975 on paper higher number might be better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00185-00055976-00056407 for refresh rate depended on
+oj7ByokzBWu-00186-00056408-00056935 a new use case
+oj7ByokzBWu-00187-00056936-00057191 air cooler usually higher number better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00188-00057191-00057303 it's true
+oj7ByokzBWu-00189-00057304-00057526 the more towers it has the more fans it
+oj7ByokzBWu-00190-00057527-00058071 has even your physical size
+oj7ByokzBWu-00191-00058072-00058382 the larger the number usually the better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00192-00058383-00058766 performing the air cooler of course
+oj7ByokzBWu-00193-00058767-00059071 big boy air cooler like the nhd15
+oj7ByokzBWu-00194-00059072-00059559 requires dark rock pro 4.
+oj7ByokzBWu-00195-00059560-00059711 better young
+oj7ByokzBWu-00196-00059712-00059999 cooling performance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00197-00060000-00060103 system
+oj7ByokzBWu-00198-00060104-00060415 eios higher number better it's true most
+oj7ByokzBWu-00199-00060416-00060711 specifically saran size nagula talaga
+oj7ByokzBWu-00200-00060712-00060879 when we tried it out in our previous
+oj7ByokzBWu-00201-00060879-00061119 videos log in performance increase from
+oj7ByokzBWu-00202-00061120-00061550 a 240 mm rad to a 360 mm rad
+oj7ByokzBWu-00203-00061551-00061847 recommend you 120 mm rad mejia mahina
+oj7ByokzBWu-00204-00061848-00062030 telegame performance yeah you'd be
+oj7ByokzBWu-00205-00062032-00062263 better off with an air cooler that's why
+oj7ByokzBWu-00206-00062264-00062542 hardware sugar doesn't stock anymore 120
+oj7ByokzBWu-00207-00062544-00062959 mm rad ai hose it's 240 and up for us
+oj7ByokzBWu-00208-00062960-00063294 jung price to performance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00209-00063295-00063694 120 mm but 240 and above is okay and
+oj7ByokzBWu-00210-00063695-00063879 there's a big jump in performance
+oj7ByokzBWu-00211-00063879-00064438 between 240 and 360 and m
+oj7ByokzBWu-00212-00064439-00064759 sizes of cases in the mangeon young very
+oj7ByokzBWu-00213-00064760-00065030 small cases or just smaller cases than
+oj7ByokzBWu-00214-00065032-00065271 the usual atx format outside of the
+oj7ByokzBWu-00215-00065272-00065438 computer but are still very important to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00216-00065439-00065791 everybody is internet speed june usually
+oj7ByokzBWu-00217-00065792-00066087 higher number better 300 mbps is better
+oj7ByokzBWu-00218-00066088-00066423 than 100 mbps pero your exception is
+oj7ByokzBWu-00219-00066424-00066535 pink
+oj7ByokzBWu-00220-00066536-00066750 done lower number better thing is
+oj7ByokzBWu-00221-00066751-00066982 basically the amount of time it takes
+oj7ByokzBWu-00222-00066983-00067199 for you to communicate to the server and
+oj7ByokzBWu-00223-00067200-00067391 it's possible to have high internet
+oj7ByokzBWu-00224-00067392-00068694 speeds
+oj7ByokzBWu-00225-00068695-00068999 to foreign again things are games that's
+oj7ByokzBWu-00226-00069000-00069167 why big games have multiple servers
+oj7ByokzBWu-00227-00069168-00069399 around the world so that gamers can
+oj7ByokzBWu-00228-00069400-00069599 connect to the server that's closest to
+oj7ByokzBWu-00229-00069600-00069879 them to reduce ping time so yes you do
+oj7ByokzBWu-00230-00069880-00070031 want higher number for your internet
+oj7ByokzBWu-00231-00070032-00070343 speed but for ping you want it as low as
+oj7ByokzBWu-00232-00070344-00070550 possible
+oj7ByokzBWu-00233-00070551-00070847 so you round up nathan and the general
+oj7ByokzBWu-00234-00070848-00071103 rule seems a little shaky to be honest
+oj7ByokzBWu-00235-00071104-00071255 contest
+oj7ByokzBWu-00236-00071256-00072335 fifty percent of the time non-telegraph
+oj7ByokzBWu-00237-00072336-00072567 and even when higher number is correct
+oj7ByokzBWu-00238-00072568-00072791 depending on
+oj7ByokzBWu-00239-00072792-00072903 for example
+oj7ByokzBWu-00240-00072904-00073231 monitors you refresh rate
+oj7ByokzBWu-00241-00073232-00073879 144 hertz cases are 75 hertz
+oj7ByokzBWu-00242-00073880-00074447 for a feature that you don't really need
+oj7ByokzBWu-00243-00074448-00074711 better be sure to understand the spec
+oj7ByokzBWu-00244-00074712-00074903 and what it's actually trying to say and
+oj7ByokzBWu-00245-00074904-00075238 then you sleep
+oj7ByokzBWu-00246-00075239-00075431 what is the higher number representing
+oj7ByokzBWu-00247-00075432-00075647 and do you need it in your life so for
+oj7ByokzBWu-00248-00075648-00075894 sure general rule size matters new
+oj7ByokzBWu-00249-00075895-00076159 interesting monitor blocking quality of
+oj7ByokzBWu-00250-00076160-00076350 life improvement
+oj7ByokzBWu-00251-00076351-00076550 thanks for watching and thank you to our
+oj7ByokzBWu-00252-00076551-00076831 top fans now for the name
+oj7ByokzBWu-00253-00076832-00077126 club thank you to leah mcnair ian meru
+oj7ByokzBWu-00254-00077127-00077399 itx addict john ruben ocha christian
+oj7ByokzBWu-00255-00077400-00077679 espinoza and rafael james thank you for
+oj7ByokzBWu-00256-00077680-00078044 supporting the channel
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00000-00000003-00000191 I'm your host ask is in this video I
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00001-00000192-00000388 want to show you my latest city build in
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00002-00000389-00000634 city skylines this is the island project
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00003-00000635-00000800 if you're following this channel you
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00004-00000801-00001061 probably saw last two videos about this
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00005-00001062-00001274 where I showed you my road system layout
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00006-00001275-00001558 now we're starting to build a city and I
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00007-00001559-00001823 want to show you what I created here
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00008-00001823-00002105 this city is looking really really
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00009-00002106-00002467 danced on this small area here and let's
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00010-00002468-00002720 take another view it's looking really
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00011-00002721-00003043 really danced again so the city has to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00012-00003044-00003340 in and outs with a road system first off
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00013-00003342-00003803 we have this trumpet highway system that
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00014-00003804-00004036 is connected with two roundabouts you
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00015-00004037-00004259 can probably see that there is no big
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00016-00004260-00004513 problems with the traffic and it's
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00017-00004514-00004894 looking really really nice and clean and
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00018-00004895-00005295 another Road system that we have is this
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00019-00005296-00005979 here again we have on and off ramps and
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00020-00005980-00006299 there is no problem with traffic because
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00021-00006300-00006587 we have two connections just on this
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00022-00006588-00007016 side of the city no problems so far and
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00023-00007017-00007375 we have another connection for this side
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00024-00007376-00007673 with the two roundabouts system that is
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00025-00007673-00007924 connected to the highway we have two
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00026-00007925-00008152 highways this one and this one so
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00027-00008153-00008489 traffic is really really divided on some
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00028-00008490-00008831 places here I don't have any issues so
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00029-00008832-00009046 far even though this is really densely
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00030-00009047-00009287 packed and we have a lot of high-rises
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00031-00009288-00009641 let's have another look here I mean yeah
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00032-00009642-00009839 it's looking really nice
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00033-00009840-00010067 and then sleep back that's what I wanted
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00034-00010068-00010376 on this build so this bridge you
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00035-00010377-00010753 probably saw is connected to a tunnel
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00036-00010754-00011060 the highway system is going to them
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00037-00011061-00011281 island here and it's moving to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00038-00011282-00011528 underwater tunnels so another
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00039-00011529-00011803 interesting fact about this island
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00040-00011804-00012103 island is really big and I just started
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00041-00012104-00012364 to build it this is the third part of
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00042-00012365-00012592 the build and I wanted to show you what
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00043-00012593-00012871 I did here and how it's looking and the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00044-00012872-00013271 traffic is it a problem so far traffic
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00045-00013272-00013480 is not
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00046-00013481-00013838 even though I have only a limited amount
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00047-00013838-00014102 of the public transport we have a bus
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00048-00014103-00014488 route that is moving all around here I
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00049-00014488-00014735 wanted to connect these residential
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00050-00014736-00015125 zones with high-density buildings that
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00051-00015126-00015694 are providing jobs all around here is
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00052-00015695-00016200 the bus route and we have only one metro
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00053-00016201-00016439 routes on this place you can see the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00054-00016440-00016952 green one this is the metro line
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00055-00016953-00017225 I wanted to create it like this because
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00056-00017226-00017537 when I start expanding the city I can
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00057-00017538-00017839 connect really really easily on these
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00058-00017840-00018106 stations so everything is going to be
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00059-00018107-00018383 connected to this main part or the first
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00060-00018384-00018689 part of the building also I want to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00061-00018690-00018961 connect my industry here I will show you
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00062-00018962-00019208 my industrial zone here it's really
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00063-00019209-00019646 really a small place there is no much
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00064-00019647-00019855 traffic and there is no much companies
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00065-00019856-00020189 on this side because I only needed them
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00066-00020190-00020516 to be able to create this build even
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00067-00020517-00020768 bigger because most of the jobs that I
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00068-00020769-00021143 have in the city are the offices and I'm
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00069-00021144-00021487 planning to expand this zone which my
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00070-00021488-00021709 industry of course that's why I have
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00071-00021710-00022222 this design I need to fix something here
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00072-00022223-00022705 it's not perfect so let's take a look
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00073-00022706-00023165 again on this place we have one train
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00074-00023166-00023503 station here and we have here the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00075-00023504-00023809 distribution center because it's much
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00076-00023810-00024067 easier to have all of your goods
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00077-00024068-00024365 delivered in the city and let me just
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00078-00024366-00024749 show you the traffic yes it's saying 77%
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00079-00024750-00025130 but look at the streets I have problem
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00080-00025131-00025433 here that I want to solve and problem
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00081-00025434-00025769 over here here it's okay for me maybe a
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00082-00025770-00026221 one a roundabout will fix that and let's
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00083-00026222-00026750 see here not it's not really bad
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00084-00026751-00027122 on this part maybe if I upgrade this
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00085-00027123-00027317 Street or maybe if I have another
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00086-00027318-00027688 connection so here it will fix a problem
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00087-00027689-00028022 but here I wanted to create something a
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00088-00028023-00028639 bit different but let's see maybe an
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00089-00028641-00028838 upgrade on this street because it's
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00090-00028839-00029102 having some issues but so far I'm
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00091-00029102-00029360 satisfied it's not that bad I mean let's
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00092-00029361-00029597 take a look again all of these streets
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00093-00029598-00030019 are green or yellow that's not too bad
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00094-00030020-00030326 especially here on the residential zones
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00095-00030327-00030689 it's ok mostly and the highway system
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00096-00030689-00030889 here look at that you can probably see
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00097-00030891-00031289 the cars it's not a problem
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00098-00031289-00031643 so it's fixable force let's have a look
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00099-00031644-00031844 on the city once more again because
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00100-00031845-00032297 let's see it's fairly detailed buildings
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00101-00032298-00032549 are up and running and I want to show
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00102-00032550-00032828 you here something you can probably see
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00103-00032829-00033212 how much I have the office space and how
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00104-00033213-00033517 much I have the commercial zones and the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00105-00033518-00033827 residential zones it's really really a
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00106-00033828-00034193 huge area on this part and here we have
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00107-00034194-00034466 concentrated D residential zones and on
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00108-00034467-00034730 this side the next episode I'm going to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00109-00034731-00035045 shoot is expanding the city on this part
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00110-00035046-00035300 everything needs to be connected and of
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00111-00035301-00035687 course expanding at this industrial zone
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00112-00035688-00035924 that I want to have that is going to be
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00113-00035925-00036269 filled over here those are the plans for
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00114-00036270-00036485 the next episode of course everything
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00115-00036486-00036668 will be connected with the public roads
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00116-00036669-00037076 and I will start probably a fishing
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00117-00037077-00037394 industry somewhere here I'm still
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00118-00037395-00037670 looking for a good place to have it so
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00119-00037671-00037943 yeah tell me what you think about the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00120-00037944-00038189 city do you like details do you like the
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00121-00038190-00038447 road system the buildings does it look
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00122-00038448-00038738 realistic what would you change
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00123-00038739-00039014 I'm interested in your opinion yeah
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00124-00039015-00039287 because I want to improve my gameplay of
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00125-00039288-00039662 course so after you watch the video
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00126-00039663-00040016 leave a comment what should I fix how to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00127-00040017-00040127 improve the city
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00128-00040128-00040334 and what you like about this city built
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00129-00040335-00040537 or what you don't like about this city
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00130-00040538-00040940 built and of course leave a like if you
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00131-00040941-00041111 liked the video or if you're new here
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00132-00041112-00041297 you can subscribe to the channel to
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00133-00041298-00041540 follow more videos what more can I say
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00134-00041541-00041795 thank you so much for watching and see
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00135-00041796-00042783 you on the next video bye everybody
+ok2H3T4LbmE-00136-00042784-00043087 [Music]
+ol_MggpHXty-00000-00000424-00000655 welcome
+ol_MggpHXty-00001-00000656-00000991 welcome dear friends artists producers
+ol_MggpHXty-00002-00000992-00001366 presenters policy makers
+ol_MggpHXty-00003-00001367-00001591 performing arts lovers and all in
+ol_MggpHXty-00004-00001592-00001863 between
+ol_MggpHXty-00005-00001864-00002223 um first one housekeeping notes
+ol_MggpHXty-00006-00002224-00002534 uh please do not click on any links not
+ol_MggpHXty-00007-00002535-00002639 from
+ol_MggpHXty-00008-00002640-00003007 perform europe to avoid spam sites very
+ol_MggpHXty-00009-00003008-00003247 important
+ol_MggpHXty-00010-00003247-00003431 once again welcome my name is tunde
+ol_MggpHXty-00011-00003432-00003583 rifye a dramaturg
+ol_MggpHXty-00012-00003584-00003919 essayist and lecturer during my time
+ol_MggpHXty-00013-00003920-00004119 as a city dramaturg in brussels one of
+ol_MggpHXty-00014-00004120-00004231 my focus was on
+ol_MggpHXty-00015-00004232-00004575 trying to help ensure pieces by are that
+ol_MggpHXty-00016-00004576-00004791 pcs by artists that i worked with were
+ol_MggpHXty-00017-00004792-00004951 able to tour
+ol_MggpHXty-00018-00004952-00005247 but how does one ensure that when in
+ol_MggpHXty-00019-00005248-00005383 fact some of the artists i've worked
+ol_MggpHXty-00020-00005384-00005422 with
+ol_MggpHXty-00021-00005423-00005631 were theater makers of color with
+ol_MggpHXty-00022-00005632-00005879 migrant backgrounds that reflects
+ol_MggpHXty-00023-00005880-00006222 of course the constantly changing europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00024-00006223-00006406 while at the same time those who are
+ol_MggpHXty-00025-00006408-00006575 programming are often
+ol_MggpHXty-00026-00006576-00007127 white middle class and male a conundrum
+ol_MggpHXty-00027-00007128-00007342 welcome to performing europe's opening
+ol_MggpHXty-00028-00007343-00007534 events our chance to understand
+ol_MggpHXty-00029-00007536-00007631 aforementioned
+ol_MggpHXty-00030-00007631-00007887 issues as well as better understand
+ol_MggpHXty-00031-00007888-00008095 perform europe in general
+ol_MggpHXty-00032-00008095-00008351 how can we contribute and be part of the
+ol_MggpHXty-00033-00008352-00008407 change
+ol_MggpHXty-00034-00008408-00008727 we want to push to reality
+ol_MggpHXty-00035-00008728-00008983 i propose attendees to write questions
+ol_MggpHXty-00036-00008984-00009095 in the q
+ol_MggpHXty-00037-00009096-00009439 a not in the chat
+ol_MggpHXty-00038-00009440-00009783 because those won't be seen
+ol_MggpHXty-00039-00009784-00009951 if they're not answered during the event
+ol_MggpHXty-00040-00009952-00010119 we will answer them later
+ol_MggpHXty-00041-00010120-00010438 by email however
+ol_MggpHXty-00042-00010439-00010727 the chat is open if you want to chat
+ol_MggpHXty-00043-00010728-00010951 with each other
+ol_MggpHXty-00044-00010952-00011151 the webinar is also live streamed and
+ol_MggpHXty-00045-00011152-00011278 recorded
+ol_MggpHXty-00046-00011279-00011463 the recording will be made available at
+ol_MggpHXty-00047-00011464-00011599 the perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00048-00011600-00011927 platform well
+ol_MggpHXty-00049-00011928-00012078 now that we've kind of gotten the
+ol_MggpHXty-00050-00012079-00012263 introduction out of the way let's have a
+ol_MggpHXty-00051-00012264-00012327 quick look
+ol_MggpHXty-00052-00012328-00013043 at what your at what perform europe is
+ol_MggpHXty-00053-00013044-00013358 [Music]
+ol_MggpHXty-00054-00013359-00013671 welcome to perform europe perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00055-00013672-00013927 is a creative europe project
+ol_MggpHXty-00056-00013928-00014191 it is for performing arts professionals
+ol_MggpHXty-00057-00014191-00014319 producers of work
+ol_MggpHXty-00058-00014319-00014638 and presenters of work alike in all the
+ol_MggpHXty-00059-00014640-00014863 creative europe countries
+ol_MggpHXty-00060-00014863-00015119 perform europe is a project that will
+ol_MggpHXty-00061-00015119-00015383 give us the performing arts sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00062-00015384-00015703 an opportunity to re-imagine and
+ol_MggpHXty-00063-00015704-00015927 eventually change the way we do
+ol_MggpHXty-00064-00015928-00016150 international touring
+ol_MggpHXty-00065-00016151-00016439 the way we show work the way we travel
+ol_MggpHXty-00066-00016440-00016630 the way we exchange
+ol_MggpHXty-00067-00016631-00017007 the way we reach audiences
+ol_MggpHXty-00068-00017008-00017207 through perform europe we will hit the
+ol_MggpHXty-00069-00017208-00017558 road and on an 18th month journey
+ol_MggpHXty-00070-00017559-00017814 test new touring and digital
+ol_MggpHXty-00071-00017815-00018030 distribution models
+ol_MggpHXty-00072-00018031-00018335 and propose a new european
+ol_MggpHXty-00073-00018336-00018703 support scheme for the performing arts
+ol_MggpHXty-00074-00018704-00019030 we the perform europe partners itm
+ol_MggpHXty-00075-00019031-00019343 ifa etienne circustrata and eddie
+ol_MggpHXty-00076-00019344-00019430 consult
+ol_MggpHXty-00077-00019431-00019630 are thrilled to take this journey
+ol_MggpHXty-00078-00019631-00019822 together with you
+ol_MggpHXty-00079-00019823-00020039 we thank the european commission and the
+ol_MggpHXty-00080-00020040-00020222 creative europe program
+ol_MggpHXty-00081-00020223-00021535 for the mandate to lead perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00082-00021536-00021775 we're glad to have you all here uh to
+ol_MggpHXty-00083-00021776-00021894 the um
+ol_MggpHXty-00084-00021895-00022214 opening events of the perform europe so
+ol_MggpHXty-00085-00022215-00022399 the day is actually split up into two
+ol_MggpHXty-00086-00022400-00022647 parts the informative and inspirational
+ol_MggpHXty-00087-00022648-00023078 part and this lasts until 3 p.m
+ol_MggpHXty-00088-00023079-00023391 this will set the stage for informing us
+ol_MggpHXty-00089-00023392-00023527 about the project
+ol_MggpHXty-00090-00023528-00023855 followed by a more interactive hands-on
+ol_MggpHXty-00091-00023856-00024111 part with a smaller group of individuals
+ol_MggpHXty-00092-00024112-00024199 um
+ol_MggpHXty-00093-00024200-00024399 this group will collect ideas from the
+ol_MggpHXty-00094-00024400-00024599 sector and policy makers
+ol_MggpHXty-00095-00024600-00024894 formula formulating a sort of wish list
+ol_MggpHXty-00096-00024895-00024942 uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00097-00024943-00025150 scheme for what sustainable and
+ol_MggpHXty-00098-00025151-00025430 inclusive distribution could be
+ol_MggpHXty-00099-00025431-00025687 both parts of the events can be followed
+ol_MggpHXty-00100-00025688-00025750 on our
+ol_MggpHXty-00101-00025751-00026062 live stream
+ol_MggpHXty-00102-00026063-00026351 okay let's move on perform europe is
+ol_MggpHXty-00103-00026352-00026407 embedded
+ol_MggpHXty-00104-00026408-00026735 in the european context an invitation
+ol_MggpHXty-00105-00026736-00026935 an invasion to us by the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00106-00026936-00027102 commission to rethink
+ol_MggpHXty-00107-00027104-00027431 touring perform europe as a service
+ol_MggpHXty-00108-00027432-00027631 we together deliver to the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00109-00027632-00027783 commission
+ol_MggpHXty-00110-00027783-00028207 after 18 months we aim to advise the
+ol_MggpHXty-00111-00028208-00028302 commission on
+ol_MggpHXty-00112-00028304-00028614 why it makes absolute sense
+ol_MggpHXty-00113-00028616-00028839 to have a new eu scheme for the
+ol_MggpHXty-00114-00028839-00028974 performing arts
+ol_MggpHXty-00115-00028975-00029295 distribution and circulation
+ol_MggpHXty-00116-00029295-00029599 a scheme we believe
+ol_MggpHXty-00117-00029600-00029990 a scheme we all can believe in um
+ol_MggpHXty-00118-00029991-00030335 relating to values and visions so
+ol_MggpHXty-00119-00030336-00030535 in order to give us more insights into
+ol_MggpHXty-00120-00030536-00030702 that i'm i'm glad to
+ol_MggpHXty-00121-00030703-00030943 welcome bob mckessler barbara gesler
+ol_MggpHXty-00122-00030944-00031046 sorry
+ol_MggpHXty-00123-00031047-00031335 um who's with us head of unit and with
+ol_MggpHXty-00124-00031336-00031527 her team following close to your work in
+ol_MggpHXty-00125-00031527-00031695 perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00126-00031695-00031914 barbara please tell us more about the
+ol_MggpHXty-00127-00031916-00032055 expectations
+ol_MggpHXty-00128-00032056-00032431 you have for this process
+ol_MggpHXty-00129-00032432-00032799 thank you very much for for your kind
+ol_MggpHXty-00130-00032800-00033079 introduction i hope you can hear me
+ol_MggpHXty-00131-00033080-00033174 perfectly
+ol_MggpHXty-00132-00033175-00033415 uh yes it's always this is always tricky
+ol_MggpHXty-00133-00033416-00033655 the tricky part so dear attendance of
+ol_MggpHXty-00134-00033656-00033695 this
+ol_MggpHXty-00135-00033696-00034023 launch conference of perform europe i'm
+ol_MggpHXty-00136-00034024-00034343 frankly excited and happy about the
+ol_MggpHXty-00137-00034344-00034399 journey
+ol_MggpHXty-00138-00034400-00034671 that we are about to embark on together
+ol_MggpHXty-00139-00034672-00034767 today
+ol_MggpHXty-00140-00034768-00035039 today's event is the first culmination
+ol_MggpHXty-00141-00035040-00035135 point
+ol_MggpHXty-00142-00035136-00035327 of what has been in the air for some
+ol_MggpHXty-00143-00035328-00035455 years now
+ol_MggpHXty-00144-00035456-00035735 a wish and a need expressed by you the
+ol_MggpHXty-00145-00035736-00035918 performing arts sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00146-00035919-00036174 and in particular its representative
+ol_MggpHXty-00147-00036175-00036262 networks
+ol_MggpHXty-00148-00036263-00036551 to support the sector in its efforts to
+ol_MggpHXty-00149-00036552-00036630 circulate
+ol_MggpHXty-00150-00036631-00036967 across borders as you all know
+ol_MggpHXty-00151-00036968-00037190 the commission first listened to the
+ol_MggpHXty-00152-00037191-00037407 cultural and creative sectors concerns
+ol_MggpHXty-00153-00037408-00037527 to enable
+ol_MggpHXty-00154-00037528-00037807 individuals artists and professionals to
+ol_MggpHXty-00155-00037808-00038039 work in a transnational manner
+ol_MggpHXty-00156-00038040-00038262 allowing them to be mobile outside their
+ol_MggpHXty-00157-00038263-00038415 countries of residence
+ol_MggpHXty-00158-00038416-00038607 to work on the project in another
+ol_MggpHXty-00159-00038608-00038735 country
+ol_MggpHXty-00160-00038736-00038999 with iportunus we set up a scheme that
+ol_MggpHXty-00161-00039000-00039183 caters for this mobility
+ol_MggpHXty-00162-00039184-00039511 in a targeted and what figures show very
+ol_MggpHXty-00163-00039512-00039855 successful way but in parallel
+ol_MggpHXty-00164-00039856-00040135 the need to accompany this individual
+ol_MggpHXty-00165-00040136-00040390 mobility by creating targeted
+ol_MggpHXty-00166-00040391-00040590 possibilities for the works
+ol_MggpHXty-00167-00040591-00040839 of these artists to be shown outside
+ol_MggpHXty-00168-00040840-00040943 their countries of
+ol_MggpHXty-00169-00040944-00041262 origin in a festival maybe or in any
+ol_MggpHXty-00170-00041263-00041543 relevant forum of exchange was always
+ol_MggpHXty-00171-00041544-00041702 present
+ol_MggpHXty-00172-00041703-00041967 as you know the creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00173-00041968-00042079 program's main
+ol_MggpHXty-00174-00042080-00042343 culture action the cooperation project
+ol_MggpHXty-00175-00042344-00042527 but also the platforms
+ol_MggpHXty-00176-00042528-00042751 cater for these possibilities in a
+ol_MggpHXty-00177-00042752-00042958 structured and partnership
+ol_MggpHXty-00178-00042959-00043287 oriented way this is why we are happy
+ol_MggpHXty-00179-00043288-00043495 that the new creative europe program
+ol_MggpHXty-00180-00043496-00043599 that starts this
+ol_MggpHXty-00181-00043600-00043911 year not only has a considerably
+ol_MggpHXty-00182-00043912-00044223 increased budget with almost more than
+ol_MggpHXty-00183-00044224-00044567 80 percent more than the current program
+ol_MggpHXty-00184-00044568-00044839 to continue these actions and reinforce
+ol_MggpHXty-00185-00044840-00044958 them
+ol_MggpHXty-00186-00044959-00045255 and the performing arts the sector you
+ol_MggpHXty-00187-00045256-00045430 represent here today
+ol_MggpHXty-00188-00045431-00045718 has by large been and will certainly
+ol_MggpHXty-00189-00045719-00045855 continue
+ol_MggpHXty-00190-00045856-00046167 being the sector most benefiting of the
+ol_MggpHXty-00191-00046168-00046327 culture strand of the cut
+ol_MggpHXty-00192-00046328-00046639 of the creative europe program but
+ol_MggpHXty-00193-00046640-00046935 a deeper evaluation into the needs of
+ol_MggpHXty-00194-00046936-00047046 the sector has
+ol_MggpHXty-00195-00047047-00047367 shown that further action was needed to
+ol_MggpHXty-00196-00047368-00047551 raise the level of european
+ol_MggpHXty-00197-00047552-00047743 collaboration
+ol_MggpHXty-00198-00047744-00048039 starting with the knowledge about what
+ol_MggpHXty-00199-00048040-00048135 is currently
+ol_MggpHXty-00200-00048136-00048486 being produced and an opportunity for a
+ol_MggpHXty-00201-00048487-00048639 european audience
+ol_MggpHXty-00202-00048640-00048990 to actually see and witness it life
+ol_MggpHXty-00203-00048991-00049343 for preference but in these times also
+ol_MggpHXty-00204-00049344-00049662 in a digital environment and
+ol_MggpHXty-00205-00049663-00050030 the times are difficult the latest study
+ol_MggpHXty-00206-00050031-00050167 presented by ernst
+ol_MggpHXty-00207-00050168-00050415 young and which confirms the figures
+ol_MggpHXty-00208-00050416-00050502 forward
+ol_MggpHXty-00209-00050503-00050735 forwarded by many of you over the past
+ol_MggpHXty-00210-00050736-00050823 months
+ol_MggpHXty-00211-00050824-00051246 unfortunately flags the worst in 2020
+ol_MggpHXty-00212-00051247-00051490 the cultural and creative economy lost
+ol_MggpHXty-00213-00051491-00051607 approximately
+ol_MggpHXty-00214-00051608-00051926 31 of its revenues
+ol_MggpHXty-00215-00051927-00052158 they are more affected than the tourism
+ol_MggpHXty-00216-00052159-00052375 and automotive industries
+ol_MggpHXty-00217-00052376-00052654 and the most impacted cultural and
+ol_MggpHXty-00218-00052655-00052815 creative industries
+ol_MggpHXty-00219-00052816-00053071 are the performing arts sector with
+ol_MggpHXty-00220-00053072-00053230 minus 90
+ol_MggpHXty-00221-00053232-00053638 and music with minus 76
+ol_MggpHXty-00222-00053639-00053799 but even before the crisis the
+ol_MggpHXty-00223-00053800-00053975 commission was aware about the
+ol_MggpHXty-00224-00053976-00054215 relevance of cross-border distribution
+ol_MggpHXty-00225-00054216-00054382 of performing arts
+ol_MggpHXty-00226-00054383-00054726 works for the performing arts economy
+ol_MggpHXty-00227-00054727-00054982 and its vital role for the sector's
+ol_MggpHXty-00228-00054983-00055111 professional growth
+ol_MggpHXty-00229-00055112-00055391 and artistic development and it was
+ol_MggpHXty-00230-00055391-00055575 aware that the sector was
+ol_MggpHXty-00231-00055576-00055823 challenged by a changing context as well
+ol_MggpHXty-00232-00055824-00055903 requiring
+ol_MggpHXty-00233-00055904-00056223 new answers to help combat climate
+ol_MggpHXty-00234-00056224-00056287 change
+ol_MggpHXty-00235-00056288-00056559 increase its sustainability and
+ol_MggpHXty-00236-00056560-00056726 inclusiveness
+ol_MggpHXty-00237-00056727-00057015 in order to remain the source of
+ol_MggpHXty-00238-00057016-00057119 innovation
+ol_MggpHXty-00239-00057120-00057335 and thinking outside the box that it
+ol_MggpHXty-00240-00057336-00057454 stands for
+ol_MggpHXty-00241-00057455-00057750 bringing critical thinking to the fore
+ol_MggpHXty-00242-00057751-00057799 to an
+ol_MggpHXty-00243-00057800-00058079 audience that needs to be broader and
+ol_MggpHXty-00244-00058079-00058238 less concentrated
+ol_MggpHXty-00245-00058239-00058566 in urban areas it's not
+ol_MggpHXty-00246-00058567-00058950 the least these reflections and concerns
+ol_MggpHXty-00247-00058951-00059182 that will make this tool that will be
+ol_MggpHXty-00248-00059183-00059335 presented to you today
+ol_MggpHXty-00249-00059336-00059550 and on which we spent the not so small
+ol_MggpHXty-00250-00059551-00059854 amount of 2.5 million euros
+ol_MggpHXty-00251-00059855-00060150 so relevant for the european commission
+ol_MggpHXty-00252-00060151-00060191 and
+ol_MggpHXty-00253-00060191-00060406 i believe for our citizens in our
+ol_MggpHXty-00254-00060407-00060559 society
+ol_MggpHXty-00255-00060560-00060806 it will embody the pure notion of what
+ol_MggpHXty-00256-00060807-00060863 we
+ol_MggpHXty-00257-00060864-00061142 like to call in our jargon the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00258-00061144-00061238 added value
+ol_MggpHXty-00259-00061239-00061559 by excellence not only by supporting and
+ol_MggpHXty-00260-00061560-00061711 circulation
+ol_MggpHXty-00261-00061712-00061926 and by by supporting circulation and
+ol_MggpHXty-00262-00061927-00062166 audience development for the sake of it
+ol_MggpHXty-00263-00062167-00062375 but because these questions you are
+ol_MggpHXty-00264-00062376-00062630 facing are also the political
+ol_MggpHXty-00265-00062632-00062935 priorities for this commission
+ol_MggpHXty-00266-00062936-00063182 but i'm convinced that the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00267-00063183-00063391 added value of this new tool
+ol_MggpHXty-00268-00063391-00063711 will also notably spring from the fact
+ol_MggpHXty-00269-00063712-00064023 that it will be developed and tested via
+ol_MggpHXty-00270-00064024-00064150 professionals
+ol_MggpHXty-00271-00064151-00064471 from your sector for your sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00272-00064472-00064759 with the consortium that will start this
+ol_MggpHXty-00273-00064760-00064830 endeavor
+ol_MggpHXty-00274-00064832-00065175 ietm the european festivals association
+ol_MggpHXty-00275-00065176-00065423 the european dance house networks
+ol_MggpHXty-00276-00065424-00065679 chiako strada art cena the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00277-00065680-00065759 network
+ol_MggpHXty-00278-00065760-00066038 for circus and street arts and idia
+ol_MggpHXty-00279-00066039-00066263 consult as well as a
+ol_MggpHXty-00280-00066264-00066663 savvy technical subcontractor acait
+ol_MggpHXty-00281-00066664-00066894 solutions i am certain
+ol_MggpHXty-00282-00066895-00067187 that they are the partners with the
+ol_MggpHXty-00283-00067188-00067399 multidisciplinary nature
+ol_MggpHXty-00284-00067400-00067703 and the complementary set of skills
+ol_MggpHXty-00285-00067704-00068087 connections expertise and experiences
+ol_MggpHXty-00286-00068088-00068487 to make this a meaningful instrument
+ol_MggpHXty-00287-00068488-00068726 before the actual distribution tool will
+ol_MggpHXty-00288-00068727-00068903 take the reality test
+ol_MggpHXty-00289-00068904-00069182 the consortium will look into existing
+ol_MggpHXty-00290-00069183-00069359 support schemes
+ol_MggpHXty-00291-00069360-00069679 and make a mapping in an effort to learn
+ol_MggpHXty-00292-00069680-00069782 from the best
+ol_MggpHXty-00293-00069783-00070191 and hopefully avoid repeating mistakes
+ol_MggpHXty-00294-00070192-00070271 needless to
+ol_MggpHXty-00295-00070272-00070494 say at the end of this journey there
+ol_MggpHXty-00296-00070495-00070655 will be lessons learned
+ol_MggpHXty-00297-00070656-00070935 and knowing the people involved i am
+ol_MggpHXty-00298-00070936-00071103 certain they will not be shy to
+ol_MggpHXty-00299-00071104-00071319 communicate them to us
+ol_MggpHXty-00300-00071320-00071543 as the commission we are asking for
+ol_MggpHXty-00301-00071544-00071799 concrete recommendations that will help
+ol_MggpHXty-00302-00071800-00071879 us
+ol_MggpHXty-00303-00071880-00072159 developing our efforts further and
+ol_MggpHXty-00304-00072160-00072255 eventually
+ol_MggpHXty-00305-00072256-00072582 how and if this specific experience can
+ol_MggpHXty-00306-00072583-00072631 become
+ol_MggpHXty-00307-00072632-00072887 part and parcel of the creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00308-00072888-00073015 program in the future
+ol_MggpHXty-00309-00073016-00073359 and also how our cultural policy
+ol_MggpHXty-00310-00073360-00073687 that our funding is intended to support
+ol_MggpHXty-00311-00073688-00073975 can continue contributing to a more
+ol_MggpHXty-00312-00073976-00074238 sustainable environment for the artists
+ol_MggpHXty-00313-00074239-00074399 and the sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00314-00074400-00074735 accompanying thereby all ongoing actions
+ol_MggpHXty-00315-00074736-00074967 of coordinations with member states
+ol_MggpHXty-00316-00074968-00075319 and with the eu with my team
+ol_MggpHXty-00317-00075320-00075623 and notably ut because who has been key
+ol_MggpHXty-00318-00075624-00075855 in the setting up of this cooperation we
+ol_MggpHXty-00319-00075856-00075935 wish you
+ol_MggpHXty-00320-00075936-00076294 a very fruitful and successful afternoon
+ol_MggpHXty-00321-00076295-00076591 and we're looking honestly forward to
+ol_MggpHXty-00322-00076592-00076687 hearing
+ol_MggpHXty-00323-00076688-00077655 thoughts and debates thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-00324-00077656-00077847 thank you barbara for those uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00325-00077848-00077967 insightful
+ol_MggpHXty-00326-00077968-00078199 and sobering words especially the
+ol_MggpHXty-00327-00078200-00078294 numbers
+ol_MggpHXty-00328-00078295-00078655 um but also um motivated not only by the
+ol_MggpHXty-00329-00078656-00078775 picture of um
+ol_MggpHXty-00330-00078776-00079015 james baldwin behind you but just also
+ol_MggpHXty-00331-00079016-00079135 motivated by
+ol_MggpHXty-00332-00079136-00079303 the fact that you all are kind of taking
+ol_MggpHXty-00333-00079304-00079519 on this very important and pressing
+ol_MggpHXty-00334-00079520-00079847 challenge um so performing europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00335-00079848-00080119 exists for a reason to serve artists to
+ol_MggpHXty-00336-00080120-00080167 present
+ol_MggpHXty-00337-00080168-00080415 their work internationally and to allow
+ol_MggpHXty-00338-00080416-00080671 european citizens to access it
+ol_MggpHXty-00339-00080672-00081023 work in the most inclusive balanced
+ol_MggpHXty-00340-00081024-00081326 and sustainable way possible as
+ol_MggpHXty-00341-00081327-00081559 barbara has already alluded to it also
+ol_MggpHXty-00342-00081560-00081638 exists
+ol_MggpHXty-00343-00081639-00081935 to take the time to think together about
+ol_MggpHXty-00344-00081936-00082015 new ways
+ol_MggpHXty-00345-00082016-00082318 of touring about values and principles
+ol_MggpHXty-00346-00082319-00082615 the sector and the world it's looking at
+ol_MggpHXty-00347-00082616-00082862 sustainability once again balance and
+ol_MggpHXty-00348-00082863-00082991 inclusivity
+ol_MggpHXty-00349-00082992-00083223 our key words and concepts that perform
+ol_MggpHXty-00350-00083224-00083447 europe's will reflect on
+ol_MggpHXty-00351-00083448-00083591 to really think about what do these
+ol_MggpHXty-00352-00083592-00083806 words mean and how do we incorporate it
+ol_MggpHXty-00353-00083807-00083903 into
+ol_MggpHXty-00354-00083904-00084215 the the pressing situation that we are
+ol_MggpHXty-00355-00084216-00084550 we currently find ourselves
+ol_MggpHXty-00356-00084551-00084759 with that note i'm glad to have eleanor
+ol_MggpHXty-00357-00084760-00085006 bauer with us
+ol_MggpHXty-00358-00085007-00085255 american dancer and choreographer ander
+ol_MggpHXty-00359-00085256-00085487 bauer explores the use of a holistic
+ol_MggpHXty-00360-00085488-00085550 approach
+ol_MggpHXty-00361-00085551-00085767 for cross violations and translations
+ol_MggpHXty-00362-00085768-00085911 between aesthetic
+ol_MggpHXty-00363-00085912-00086199 social and informational values and
+ol_MggpHXty-00364-00086200-00086350 processes
+ol_MggpHXty-00365-00086351-00086575 she's creating producing touring
+ol_MggpHXty-00366-00086576-00086662 extensively
+ol_MggpHXty-00367-00086663-00086879 and reflects a lot about how her
+ol_MggpHXty-00368-00086880-00086967 practices
+ol_MggpHXty-00369-00086968-00087215 rises from and to a certain degree
+ol_MggpHXty-00370-00087216-00087271 mirrors
+ol_MggpHXty-00371-00087272-00087799 societal challenges eleanor
+ol_MggpHXty-00372-00087800-00088126 thank you um
+ol_MggpHXty-00373-00088127-00088431 i am very humbled and honored to address
+ol_MggpHXty-00374-00088432-00088767 all of you in this really ambitious and
+ol_MggpHXty-00375-00088768-00088831 urgent
+ol_MggpHXty-00376-00088832-00089143 project of really evaluating and
+ol_MggpHXty-00377-00089144-00089318 reconsidering
+ol_MggpHXty-00378-00089319-00089638 what's possible within
+ol_MggpHXty-00379-00089639-00089894 a sort of matrix of what i see as even
+ol_MggpHXty-00380-00089895-00090023 contradictions
+ol_MggpHXty-00381-00090024-00090326 um so
+ol_MggpHXty-00382-00090327-00090535 i'm going to talk a little bit about i
+ol_MggpHXty-00383-00090536-00090718 mean yeah i'm invited as an
+ol_MggpHXty-00384-00090719-00090959 artist here i cannot represent the whole
+ol_MggpHXty-00385-00090960-00091079 field
+ol_MggpHXty-00386-00091080-00091423 by any stretch of the imagination but um
+ol_MggpHXty-00387-00091424-00091743 i'm also thinking that in this moment
+ol_MggpHXty-00388-00091744-00092031 uh i also want to thank all of you for
+ol_MggpHXty-00389-00092032-00092150 taking the response
+ol_MggpHXty-00390-00092151-00092423 ability to consider these um really
+ol_MggpHXty-00391-00092424-00092535 important and large
+ol_MggpHXty-00392-00092536-00092935 questions and
+ol_MggpHXty-00393-00092936-00093199 just remind us that ev everyone is
+ol_MggpHXty-00394-00093200-00093279 creative
+ol_MggpHXty-00395-00093280-00093711 in the capacity to imagine
+ol_MggpHXty-00396-00093712-00094111 solutions to problem solve to respond to
+ol_MggpHXty-00397-00094112-00094303 each other and to collaborate and
+ol_MggpHXty-00398-00094304-00094487 cooperate in
+ol_MggpHXty-00399-00094488-00094735 old and new ways so we don't need to
+ol_MggpHXty-00400-00094736-00094894 just ask the artists
+ol_MggpHXty-00401-00094895-00095282 uh to create the the the solutions or to
+ol_MggpHXty-00402-00095283-00095503 inspire meaningful
+ol_MggpHXty-00403-00095504-00095743 um processes and debates but all of us
+ol_MggpHXty-00404-00095744-00095823 here um
+ol_MggpHXty-00405-00095824-00096023 by in our in our own gathering and in
+ol_MggpHXty-00406-00096024-00096174 our own skins and
+ol_MggpHXty-00407-00096175-00096511 experiences embody all sorts of values
+ol_MggpHXty-00408-00096512-00096582 and questions
+ol_MggpHXty-00409-00096583-00097023 and solutions so um
+ol_MggpHXty-00410-00097024-00097326 just on the contradictions i want
+ol_MggpHXty-00411-00097327-00097535 to i'm just thinking about the
+ol_MggpHXty-00412-00097536-00097767 contradiction between the value
+ol_MggpHXty-00413-00097768-00097979 of mobility and the value of
+ol_MggpHXty-00414-00097980-00098143 sustainability
+ol_MggpHXty-00415-00098144-00098599 or the contradiction between
+ol_MggpHXty-00416-00098600-00098911 the idea of europe and
+ol_MggpHXty-00417-00098912-00099294 the ambition of inclusion um
+ol_MggpHXty-00418-00099295-00099623 i mean there's so many uh or yeah
+ol_MggpHXty-00419-00099624-00100031 also balance
+ol_MggpHXty-00420-00100032-00100447 and uh scale what's a scalable
+ol_MggpHXty-00421-00100448-00100599 practice is something i'm gonna be
+ol_MggpHXty-00422-00100600-00100882 talking a bit about
+ol_MggpHXty-00423-00100883-00101094 um
+ol_MggpHXty-00424-00101095-00101399 so uh wow there's just so much to talk
+ol_MggpHXty-00425-00101400-00101559 about i'm just gonna kind of i'm gonna
+ol_MggpHXty-00426-00101560-00101718 go through these notes they're gonna be
+ol_MggpHXty-00427-00101719-00101894 a little bit non-linear i hope to
+ol_MggpHXty-00428-00101895-00102111 inspire some reflection but most of all
+ol_MggpHXty-00429-00102112-00102282 i just want to encourage a lot of
+ol_MggpHXty-00430-00102283-00102415 humility
+ol_MggpHXty-00431-00102416-00102606 a lot of humility because i think these
+ol_MggpHXty-00432-00102607-00102854 large questions will not and do not have
+ol_MggpHXty-00433-00102855-00102951 quick
+ol_MggpHXty-00434-00102952-00103199 answers like uh there is a there's a way
+ol_MggpHXty-00435-00103200-00103286 in which um
+ol_MggpHXty-00436-00103288-00103478 a body like perform europe is a little
+ol_MggpHXty-00437-00103479-00103647 bit the
+ol_MggpHXty-00438-00103648-00103830 can be the way the arts also get
+ol_MggpHXty-00439-00103831-00103951 positioned as
+ol_MggpHXty-00440-00103952-00104199 a like the advertising agency of
+ol_MggpHXty-00441-00104200-00104415 political bodies you know it's on us to
+ol_MggpHXty-00442-00104416-00104575 sort of create the
+ol_MggpHXty-00443-00104576-00104775 the identities to produce the identities
+ol_MggpHXty-00444-00104776-00104910 to perform the effects
+ol_MggpHXty-00445-00104911-00105263 to create uh experiences that affirm the
+ol_MggpHXty-00446-00105264-00105343 values
+ol_MggpHXty-00447-00105344-00105495 of the political values the historical
+ol_MggpHXty-00448-00105496-00105678 values and
+ol_MggpHXty-00449-00105679-00105895 i think it's a good moment in this sort
+ol_MggpHXty-00450-00105896-00106054 of global wintering
+ol_MggpHXty-00451-00106055-00106399 in this huge pause that has
+ol_MggpHXty-00452-00106400-00106743 radically interrupted the momentum of
+ol_MggpHXty-00453-00106744-00106983 business as usual
+ol_MggpHXty-00454-00106983-00107254 to also affirm the counter force that's
+ol_MggpHXty-00455-00107255-00107495 possible from the cultural sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00456-00107496-00107751 in questioning the very historical and
+ol_MggpHXty-00457-00107752-00107847 material
+ol_MggpHXty-00458-00107848-00108151 values that have brought us here
+ol_MggpHXty-00459-00108152-00108599 so
+ol_MggpHXty-00460-00108600-00108886 i mean europe as the promise of unity or
+ol_MggpHXty-00461-00108888-00109047 unification
+ol_MggpHXty-00462-00109048-00109366 is also built on a history of exclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-00463-00109367-00109619 so there's a there's a very like
+ol_MggpHXty-00464-00109620-00109878 multi-multi-fold historical
+ol_MggpHXty-00465-00109879-00110207 complexity that has like amalgamated
+ol_MggpHXty-00466-00110208-00110439 into this moment where i'm actually
+ol_MggpHXty-00467-00110440-00110631 honestly as painful as it's been
+ol_MggpHXty-00468-00110632-00110958 i'm actually really grateful for uh what
+ol_MggpHXty-00469-00110959-00111143 this global pandemic has done even
+ol_MggpHXty-00470-00111144-00111207 though we've
+ol_MggpHXty-00471-00111208-00111463 lost a lot of money and we're all in
+ol_MggpHXty-00472-00111464-00111615 crisis there's a lot of people without
+ol_MggpHXty-00473-00111616-00111727 work
+ol_MggpHXty-00474-00111728-00112015 it's forcing us to consider our roles
+ol_MggpHXty-00475-00112016-00112334 and our values
+ol_MggpHXty-00476-00112335-00112534 our responsibilities towards each other
+ol_MggpHXty-00477-00112535-00112686 and how we can get back to work
+ol_MggpHXty-00478-00112688-00112758 differently
+ol_MggpHXty-00479-00112759-00112943 and the longer this thing persists the
+ol_MggpHXty-00480-00112944-00113086 more impossible
+ol_MggpHXty-00481-00113088-00113271 as we yearn to meet again and we yearn
+ol_MggpHXty-00482-00113272-00113399 to go to the theater again we
+ol_MggpHXty-00483-00113400-00113758 learn for that social vibe and contact
+ol_MggpHXty-00484-00113759-00114063 it its continued absence
+ol_MggpHXty-00485-00114064-00114286 is also an opportunity and i just want
+ol_MggpHXty-00486-00114288-00114375 to encourage
+ol_MggpHXty-00487-00114376-00114663 also on the one hand the humility that
+ol_MggpHXty-00488-00114664-00114799 it's going to be difficult and it is
+ol_MggpHXty-00489-00114800-00115078 difficult and that there is no quick fix
+ol_MggpHXty-00490-00115079-00115263 this is an opportunity to really do
+ol_MggpHXty-00491-00115264-00115407 things differently like we
+ol_MggpHXty-00492-00115408-00115654 we won't be getting back to anything we
+ol_MggpHXty-00493-00115655-00115766 knew before
+ol_MggpHXty-00494-00115767-00116223 anytime soon so to invite the
+ol_MggpHXty-00495-00116224-00116583 real changes in in who we listen to who
+ol_MggpHXty-00496-00116583-00116807 how we think and how we feel what are
+ol_MggpHXty-00497-00116808-00116927 our aesthetic
+ol_MggpHXty-00498-00116928-00117175 agencies to take this time also to study
+ol_MggpHXty-00499-00117176-00117310 so especially with questions of
+ol_MggpHXty-00500-00117311-00117399 inclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-00501-00117400-00117710 along the entire intersectional axes of
+ol_MggpHXty-00502-00117711-00118015 class race gender
+ol_MggpHXty-00503-00118016-00118566 ability um ethnicity etc
+ol_MggpHXty-00504-00118567-00118727 this is an opportunity for everybody who
+ol_MggpHXty-00505-00118728-00119015 has been and is in a position of safety
+ol_MggpHXty-00506-00119016-00119207 in a position of power has been given
+ol_MggpHXty-00507-00119208-00119447 the the gatekeeping roles
+ol_MggpHXty-00508-00119448-00119743 has been has a job right now to take
+ol_MggpHXty-00509-00119744-00119943 this time to educate ourselves about
+ol_MggpHXty-00510-00119944-00120031 what we've
+ol_MggpHXty-00511-00120032-00120223 been missing so to look at the sort of
+ol_MggpHXty-00512-00120224-00120383 historical assumptions
+ol_MggpHXty-00513-00120383-00120751 that have constructed eurocentrism
+ol_MggpHXty-00514-00120752-00121143 as a as a kind of whiteness as a kind of
+ol_MggpHXty-00515-00121144-00121486 uh bourgeoisie or like what's what are
+ol_MggpHXty-00516-00121488-00121902 all the sort of economic the the
+ol_MggpHXty-00517-00121903-00122175 whether it's the male gaze or a certain
+ol_MggpHXty-00518-00122176-00122286 gendered or an
+ol_MggpHXty-00519-00122288-00122495 ableism like what are these what are the
+ol_MggpHXty-00520-00122496-00122719 performances we've been seeing
+ol_MggpHXty-00521-00122720-00122958 constructed by so before we can even
+ol_MggpHXty-00522-00122959-00123190 approach inclusion we have to start to
+ol_MggpHXty-00523-00123191-00123407 name what is already present
+ol_MggpHXty-00524-00123408-00123727 so why aren't the when you say
+ol_MggpHXty-00525-00123728-00123958 well we we need broader audiences we
+ol_MggpHXty-00526-00123959-00124071 need more diverse
+ol_MggpHXty-00527-00124072-00124310 representation on the stages you can't
+ol_MggpHXty-00528-00124311-00124558 just import these things if the soil is
+ol_MggpHXty-00529-00124559-00124766 not set so using this metaphor of soil
+ol_MggpHXty-00530-00124767-00124854 right now like
+ol_MggpHXty-00531-00124855-00125134 the soil is at rest this is a wonderful
+ol_MggpHXty-00532-00125135-00125223 opportunity to
+ol_MggpHXty-00533-00125224-00125471 figure out what kind of nutrients to use
+ol_MggpHXty-00534-00125472-00125695 the metaphor like agricultural metaphor
+ol_MggpHXty-00535-00125696-00125902 what does this soil need in this
+ol_MggpHXty-00536-00125903-00126063 composting moment
+ol_MggpHXty-00537-00126064-00126366 to be able to receive
+ol_MggpHXty-00538-00126367-00126623 new kinds of seeds and this is like
+ol_MggpHXty-00539-00126624-00126823 really practical also
+ol_MggpHXty-00540-00126824-00127158 um
+ol_MggpHXty-00541-00127159-00127543 so a naming what is present
+ol_MggpHXty-00542-00127544-00127886 uh in order to figure out how
+ol_MggpHXty-00543-00127888-00128102 how this space is constructing the
+ol_MggpHXty-00544-00128103-00128190 absence and
+ol_MggpHXty-00545-00128191-00128495 and continuing to affirm the absence of
+ol_MggpHXty-00546-00128496-00128639 what it what is
+ol_MggpHXty-00547-00128640-00128958 not present yet there's a wonderful book
+ol_MggpHXty-00548-00128959-00129134 i would encourage everyone to read it's
+ol_MggpHXty-00549-00129135-00129302 really simple it's really a workbook
+ol_MggpHXty-00550-00129303-00129654 it's really easy um it's called
+ol_MggpHXty-00551-00129655-00130047 ideas arrangements effects by the design
+ol_MggpHXty-00552-00130048-00130414 school for social justice and
+ol_MggpHXty-00553-00130415-00130614 um i think they have it there's a
+ol_MggpHXty-00554-00130615-00130823 digital copy you can see for free on
+ol_MggpHXty-00555-00130824-00130910 issue but
+ol_MggpHXty-00556-00130911-00131102 they also have an extended talk on their
+ol_MggpHXty-00557-00131103-00131319 own website the design school for social
+ol_MggpHXty-00558-00131320-00131407 justice
+ol_MggpHXty-00559-00131408-00131559 and they basically they do a really
+ol_MggpHXty-00560-00131560-00131790 great job of
+ol_MggpHXty-00561-00131791-00132071 breaking down how ideas like the big
+ol_MggpHXty-00562-00132072-00132214 isms
+ol_MggpHXty-00563-00132215-00132623 racism classism environmentalism
+ol_MggpHXty-00564-00132624-00132863 isn't like isms can be huge and
+ol_MggpHXty-00565-00132864-00133102 overwhelming sometimes in their
+ol_MggpHXty-00566-00133103-00133454 um influence they are that's what they
+ol_MggpHXty-00567-00133455-00133478 are
+ol_MggpHXty-00568-00133479-00133671 their their ideas their ideas they
+ol_MggpHXty-00569-00133672-00133871 influence how we behave how we act how
+ol_MggpHXty-00570-00133872-00133966 we move through the world how we
+ol_MggpHXty-00571-00133967-00134183 construct our spaces
+ol_MggpHXty-00572-00134184-00134454 um and they also incite very large
+ol_MggpHXty-00573-00134455-00134631 reactions they produce effects
+ol_MggpHXty-00574-00134632-00134966 like they create strong emotions
+ol_MggpHXty-00575-00134967-00135214 and so in the triangulation of ideas
+ol_MggpHXty-00576-00135215-00135423 arrangements and effects the design
+ol_MggpHXty-00577-00135424-00135599 school for social justice really shows
+ol_MggpHXty-00578-00135600-00135911 how their how these three things can
+ol_MggpHXty-00579-00135912-00136023 influence each other
+ol_MggpHXty-00580-00136024-00136302 with more equanimity so arrangements
+ol_MggpHXty-00581-00136303-00136399 refers to the
+ol_MggpHXty-00582-00136400-00136575 how the runes are actually arranged like
+ol_MggpHXty-00583-00136576-00136743 are the chairs in a circle are they all
+ol_MggpHXty-00584-00136744-00136895 facing one front
+ol_MggpHXty-00585-00136896-00137454 can uh who has the keys um
+ol_MggpHXty-00586-00137455-00137671 uh is it arranged by silence or
+ol_MggpHXty-00587-00137672-00137927 participation how loud is it how
+ol_MggpHXty-00588-00137928-00138135 like what are the colors of the walls
+ol_MggpHXty-00589-00138136-00138335 like arrangements like everything from
+ol_MggpHXty-00590-00138336-00138583 the architecture to the behaviors
+ol_MggpHXty-00591-00138584-00138854 uh to the spoken and unsupposing spoken
+ol_MggpHXty-00592-00138855-00138966 codes of conduct
+ol_MggpHXty-00593-00138967-00139135 all these things that constitute how we
+ol_MggpHXty-00594-00139136-00139375 gather the sort of choreographies if you
+ol_MggpHXty-00595-00139376-00139454 will
+ol_MggpHXty-00596-00139455-00139863 of um the spaces we share the rooms we
+ol_MggpHXty-00597-00139864-00140278 we come together in and then effects
+ol_MggpHXty-00598-00140279-00140502 are just the felt senses in each of us
+ol_MggpHXty-00599-00140503-00140614 like how does it feel
+ol_MggpHXty-00600-00140615-00141007 i feel nervous i feel invited
+ol_MggpHXty-00601-00141008-00141483 i feel alienated i feel
+ol_MggpHXty-00602-00141484-00141799 um uninspired i feel excited i feel
+ol_MggpHXty-00603-00141800-00141966 curious you know like all the feelings
+ol_MggpHXty-00604-00141967-00142207 that can be produced from an arrangement
+ol_MggpHXty-00605-00142208-00142366 all the feelings that can be produced
+ol_MggpHXty-00606-00142367-00142543 from an idea
+ol_MggpHXty-00607-00142544-00142887 and how by sort of studying
+ol_MggpHXty-00608-00142888-00143119 the effects in order to come up with
+ol_MggpHXty-00609-00143120-00143287 different arrangements
+ol_MggpHXty-00610-00143288-00143583 can also push back on the ideas and
+ol_MggpHXty-00611-00143584-00143799 shift the horizons
+ol_MggpHXty-00612-00143800-00143999 but i think as much as we are in like a
+ol_MggpHXty-00613-00144000-00144159 multi-tiered
+ol_MggpHXty-00614-00144160-00144414 conundrum we really have to look from
+ol_MggpHXty-00615-00144415-00144607 all these different angles so that's one
+ol_MggpHXty-00616-00144608-00144807 thing that i feel uh this book helps
+ol_MggpHXty-00617-00144808-00145039 a little bit break down is the different
+ol_MggpHXty-00618-00145040-00145126 scales
+ol_MggpHXty-00619-00145127-00145383 of approach to something i have to move
+ol_MggpHXty-00620-00145384-00145526 a little bit quicker
+ol_MggpHXty-00621-00145527-00145951 so um and we want to check out so
+ol_MggpHXty-00622-00145952-00146054 there's something i've been thinking a
+ol_MggpHXty-00623-00146055-00146183 lot about which is
+ol_MggpHXty-00624-00146184-00146454 instead of coming back to this idea of
+ol_MggpHXty-00625-00146455-00146502 uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00626-00146503-00146719 sort of how how does culture not get
+ol_MggpHXty-00627-00146720-00147083 stuck in being a kind of
+ol_MggpHXty-00628-00147084-00147278 um
+ol_MggpHXty-00629-00147279-00147487 in this promotional lens this
+ol_MggpHXty-00630-00147488-00147678 promotional and very like
+ol_MggpHXty-00631-00147679-00147990 uh mark marketing style
+ol_MggpHXty-00632-00147991-00148319 uh uh commercial logic of exchange
+ol_MggpHXty-00633-00148320-00148495 of our affects of our skills of our
+ol_MggpHXty-00634-00148496-00148654 potentials
+ol_MggpHXty-00635-00148655-00148895 um i think there's a necessary shift
+ol_MggpHXty-00636-00148896-00149111 away from
+ol_MggpHXty-00637-00149112-00149447 saleable and provable concepts towards
+ol_MggpHXty-00638-00149448-00149743 scalable and durable practices so this
+ol_MggpHXty-00639-00149744-00149807 i'm thinking
+ol_MggpHXty-00640-00149808-00149999 especially now in the values of
+ol_MggpHXty-00641-00150000-00150119 sustainable and
+ol_MggpHXty-00642-00150120-00150343 sustainability inclusion and balance i
+ol_MggpHXty-00643-00150344-00150607 think it points towards
+ol_MggpHXty-00644-00150608-00150831 uh the practices we've how we've dealt
+ol_MggpHXty-00645-00150832-00150935 with time
+ol_MggpHXty-00646-00150936-00151295 and space in terms of scale previously
+ol_MggpHXty-00647-00151296-00151326 is
+ol_MggpHXty-00648-00151327-00151502 very rote you know there's a lot of
+ol_MggpHXty-00649-00151503-00151719 assumptions uh creation takes six weeks
+ol_MggpHXty-00650-00151720-00151863 costs this much money
+ol_MggpHXty-00651-00151864-00152095 uh the stage is this large you should
+ol_MggpHXty-00652-00152096-00152231 everything in this box and then it goes
+ol_MggpHXty-00653-00152232-00152478 in a van this size and then
+ol_MggpHXty-00654-00152479-00152919 like the ideas of um
+ol_MggpHXty-00655-00152920-00153278 what is a saleable and provable concept
+ol_MggpHXty-00656-00153279-00153454 keeps sort of reiterate there's a very
+ol_MggpHXty-00657-00153455-00153614 reiterative habitual
+ol_MggpHXty-00658-00153615-00153854 set of norms that have evolved over time
+ol_MggpHXty-00659-00153855-00153999 and
+ol_MggpHXty-00660-00154000-00154223 they're not they're not sustainable so
+ol_MggpHXty-00661-00154224-00154390 this is a great opportunity to look at
+ol_MggpHXty-00662-00154391-00154502 what is possible
+ol_MggpHXty-00663-00154503-00154759 here and now what we can do exactly here
+ol_MggpHXty-00664-00154760-00154919 and now within the limitations of the
+ol_MggpHXty-00665-00154920-00155054 present condition
+ol_MggpHXty-00666-00155055-00155359 and how that can start to shift
+ol_MggpHXty-00667-00155360-00155671 towards scalable and durable
+ol_MggpHXty-00668-00155672-00156039 practices um so instead of uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00669-00156040-00156214 you know coming up with a project idea
+ol_MggpHXty-00670-00156215-00156390 and pitching it three years into the
+ol_MggpHXty-00671-00156391-00156439 future
+ol_MggpHXty-00672-00156440-00156559 and convincing everybody it's a great
+ol_MggpHXty-00673-00156560-00156766 idea and then chasing after the promises
+ol_MggpHXty-00674-00156767-00156935 you've made and then hoping to have a
+ol_MggpHXty-00675-00156936-00156999 tour
+ol_MggpHXty-00676-00157000-00157263 like there's all these ways that we deal
+ol_MggpHXty-00677-00157264-00157311 with
+ol_MggpHXty-00678-00157312-00157535 um and then it's provability it's like
+ol_MggpHXty-00679-00157536-00157687 well will you be able to make the thing
+ol_MggpHXty-00680-00157688-00157839 you promise will you be able to tour the
+ol_MggpHXty-00681-00157840-00157919 square that way
+ol_MggpHXty-00682-00157920-00158223 there's a lot of like selling promises
+ol_MggpHXty-00683-00158224-00158414 and speculations that kind of
+ol_MggpHXty-00684-00158415-00158766 send us in a constant future uh we're
+ol_MggpHXty-00685-00158767-00158919 propelling ourselves towards the future
+ol_MggpHXty-00686-00158920-00159119 with this momentum
+ol_MggpHXty-00687-00159120-00159511 and missing maybe the
+ol_MggpHXty-00688-00159512-00159695 the practice and the here and the now
+ol_MggpHXty-00689-00159696-00159911 that is actually the seed for
+ol_MggpHXty-00690-00159912-00160175 change i know this is very abstract but
+ol_MggpHXty-00691-00160176-00160326 i think also there's something about
+ol_MggpHXty-00692-00160327-00160366 like
+ol_MggpHXty-00693-00160367-00160543 in performance and dance especially
+ol_MggpHXty-00694-00160544-00160695 there's a curiosity that's like
+ol_MggpHXty-00695-00160696-00160983 to do to find out so if it's possible
+ol_MggpHXty-00696-00160984-00161014 now
+ol_MggpHXty-00697-00161015-00161207 do it and then check out what are the
+ol_MggpHXty-00698-00161208-00161375 effects is this
+ol_MggpHXty-00699-00161376-00161654 is this working now today are we are we
+ol_MggpHXty-00700-00161655-00161839 excited to come to work today are we
+ol_MggpHXty-00701-00161840-00161990 serving
+ol_MggpHXty-00702-00161991-00162151 how can we how can we serve the
+ol_MggpHXty-00703-00162152-00162390 communities we want to serve right now
+ol_MggpHXty-00704-00162391-00162654 today and that could be as much as like
+ol_MggpHXty-00705-00162655-00162735 looking at your
+ol_MggpHXty-00706-00162736-00162951 overhead like what is your is all your
+ol_MggpHXty-00707-00162952-00163143 budget going towards administrators
+ol_MggpHXty-00708-00163144-00163335 and waiting for the touring to be
+ol_MggpHXty-00709-00163336-00163487 possible again to throw some money at
+ol_MggpHXty-00710-00163488-00163623 some dancers
+ol_MggpHXty-00711-00163624-00163951 or how could we employ artists
+ol_MggpHXty-00712-00163952-00164263 right now in this lockdown to do things
+ol_MggpHXty-00713-00164264-00164326 like
+ol_MggpHXty-00714-00164327-00164678 workshops or to totally to to
+ol_MggpHXty-00715-00164679-00164999 to just be able to be to feel purposeful
+ol_MggpHXty-00716-00165000-00165311 to feel engaged to feel present in the
+ol_MggpHXty-00717-00165312-00165463 field
+ol_MggpHXty-00718-00165464-00165671 uh instead of waiting for things to get
+ol_MggpHXty-00719-00165672-00165887 back to normal and i don't have the
+ol_MggpHXty-00720-00165888-00166063 solutions i think leadership is really a
+ol_MggpHXty-00721-00166064-00166214 lot about listening this is about
+ol_MggpHXty-00722-00166215-00166495 thinking globally acting locally
+ol_MggpHXty-00723-00166496-00166623 checking out who
+ol_MggpHXty-00724-00166624-00166790 who is around you in your immediate
+ol_MggpHXty-00725-00166791-00166975 community right now
+ol_MggpHXty-00726-00166976-00167135 that's suffering i mean the word
+ol_MggpHXty-00727-00167136-00167359 curation the root of the word curation
+ol_MggpHXty-00728-00167360-00167463 is care
+ol_MggpHXty-00729-00167464-00167966 so who can we help and i think there's
+ol_MggpHXty-00730-00167967-00168287 i'm sorry to get a little bit swirly
+ol_MggpHXty-00731-00168288-00168511 around this but compassion
+ol_MggpHXty-00732-00168512-00168871 is like so key right now in
+ol_MggpHXty-00733-00168872-00169175 the ability to see new solutions with
+ol_MggpHXty-00734-00169176-00169326 clarity with patients
+ol_MggpHXty-00735-00169327-00169487 and to move towards sustainable
+ol_MggpHXty-00736-00169488-00169775 inclusive balanced
+ol_MggpHXty-00737-00169776-00170087 arrangements um i think we have to call
+ol_MggpHXty-00738-00170088-00170278 upon our emotional intelligence more and
+ol_MggpHXty-00739-00170279-00170359 more
+ol_MggpHXty-00740-00170360-00170623 to feel the vulnerability of the
+ol_MggpHXty-00741-00170624-00170838 critique of what has been habitual
+ol_MggpHXty-00742-00170839-00171119 and how that has to change how to to
+ol_MggpHXty-00743-00171120-00171199 listen
+ol_MggpHXty-00744-00171200-00171487 in to the field and the people that are
+ol_MggpHXty-00745-00171488-00171614 calling for
+ol_MggpHXty-00746-00171615-00172014 different types of attention um
+ol_MggpHXty-00747-00172015-00172335 so yeah if it's meaningful now
+ol_MggpHXty-00748-00172336-00172519 it will create new possibilities later
+ol_MggpHXty-00749-00172520-00172647 it will be meaningful
+ol_MggpHXty-00750-00172648-00172823 later so that's a little bit what i mean
+ol_MggpHXty-00751-00172824-00173007 and then it can if it's
+ol_MggpHXty-00752-00173008-00173254 possible now it will be scalable up like
+ol_MggpHXty-00753-00173255-00173463 if a few people can get together and do
+ol_MggpHXty-00754-00173464-00173799 a a workshop yeah
+ol_MggpHXty-00755-00173800-00174078 they then more can do it later so kind
+ol_MggpHXty-00756-00174079-00174151 of like the
+ol_MggpHXty-00757-00174152-00174326 the the small small thinking about
+ol_MggpHXty-00758-00174327-00174487 smaller gatherings and the importance of
+ol_MggpHXty-00759-00174488-00174583 those kind of
+ol_MggpHXty-00760-00174584-00174887 smaller gatherings and and and yeah the
+ol_MggpHXty-00761-00174888-00174959 local
+ol_MggpHXty-00762-00174960-00175343 in fact um how am i on time
+ol_MggpHXty-00763-00175344-00175495 probably way over all right yeah
+ol_MggpHXty-00764-00175496-00175702 unfortunately you're like three minutes
+ol_MggpHXty-00765-00175703-00176031 over oh goodness yeah yeah um so
+ol_MggpHXty-00766-00176032-00176159 i don't know if you want to say like a
+ol_MggpHXty-00767-00176160-00176359 few last things uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00768-00176360-00176519 because i mean you know like it's i can
+ol_MggpHXty-00769-00176520-00176743 listen to you for like a while
+ol_MggpHXty-00770-00176744-00177078 like you know but i don't know it's so
+ol_MggpHXty-00771-00177079-00177183 hard there's so much
+ol_MggpHXty-00772-00177184-00177551 it's okay um i think i mostly said
+ol_MggpHXty-00773-00177552-00177647 things i just want to
+ol_MggpHXty-00774-00177648-00177831 scan through my notes really quickly to
+ol_MggpHXty-00775-00177832-00178023 make sure that i haven't missed
+ol_MggpHXty-00776-00178024-00178199 something
+ol_MggpHXty-00777-00178200-00178535 uh oh just in terms of balance because i
+ol_MggpHXty-00778-00178536-00178575 think
+ol_MggpHXty-00779-00178576-00178911 well while sustainability and inclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-00780-00178912-00179214 can feel more concrete to us as like
+ol_MggpHXty-00781-00179215-00179414 ecological and social problems that we
+ol_MggpHXty-00782-00179415-00179566 can get down to the nitty-gritty and
+ol_MggpHXty-00783-00179567-00179663 look at like
+ol_MggpHXty-00784-00179664-00179847 who's here who's in charge who's
+ol_MggpHXty-00785-00179848-00180054 curating who's employed who's on what
+ol_MggpHXty-00786-00180055-00180159 kinds of salaries like
+ol_MggpHXty-00787-00180160-00180447 there's a more material uh realness to
+ol_MggpHXty-00788-00180448-00180583 both of those things
+ol_MggpHXty-00789-00180584-00180838 also sustainability like okay get rid of
+ol_MggpHXty-00790-00180839-00181014 the plastic water bottles
+ol_MggpHXty-00791-00181015-00181247 set up local touring so that things stay
+ol_MggpHXty-00792-00181248-00181414 on the road use trains instead of planes
+ol_MggpHXty-00793-00181415-00181559 like there's a thousand checklists we
+ol_MggpHXty-00794-00181560-00181711 can brainstorm i feel like balance is
+ol_MggpHXty-00795-00181712-00181911 maybe a little more abstract
+ol_MggpHXty-00796-00181912-00182190 and i think that's because balance is at
+ol_MggpHXty-00797-00182191-00182223 its
+ol_MggpHXty-00798-00182224-00182526 heart and nature culture problems so i'm
+ol_MggpHXty-00799-00182527-00182759 thinking about how sustainability
+ol_MggpHXty-00800-00182760-00182966 inclusion and balance are a little bit
+ol_MggpHXty-00801-00182967-00183111 like
+ol_MggpHXty-00802-00183112-00183502 tending cultivation and weeding
+ol_MggpHXty-00803-00183503-00183759 so we are in the sort of anthropocene
+ol_MggpHXty-00804-00183760-00183902 right there is no naturist such there's
+ol_MggpHXty-00805-00183903-00184023 no culture as such
+ol_MggpHXty-00806-00184024-00184463 but i have to quote anna grip she's a
+ol_MggpHXty-00807-00184464-00184623 dancer who was the head of the dance
+ol_MggpHXty-00808-00184624-00184743 department at doc
+ol_MggpHXty-00809-00184744-00185014 um the ba for a while here in stockholm
+ol_MggpHXty-00810-00185015-00185183 and she would always say when people
+ol_MggpHXty-00811-00185184-00185359 were ambitious about adding stuff to the
+ol_MggpHXty-00812-00185360-00185502 program like inclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-00813-00185503-00185743 is like we want to bring in more people
+ol_MggpHXty-00814-00185744-00185975 but you if the budget especially with
+ol_MggpHXty-00815-00185976-00186175 less and less now or i mean you have
+ol_MggpHXty-00816-00186176-00186287 that's great to hear there's a great
+ol_MggpHXty-00817-00186288-00186399 budget for this project
+ol_MggpHXty-00818-00186400-00186702 but i mean we're we're facing economic
+ol_MggpHXty-00819-00186703-00186911 crisis we're facing uh diminishing of
+ol_MggpHXty-00820-00186912-00187087 resources we have to be
+ol_MggpHXty-00821-00187088-00187335 clever and and it's scarce the question
+ol_MggpHXty-00822-00187336-00187526 is also what has to go
+ol_MggpHXty-00823-00187527-00187863 so we can't just include without also
+ol_MggpHXty-00824-00187864-00188135 excluding so i think there's a very cult
+ol_MggpHXty-00825-00188136-00188247 there's a lot
+ol_MggpHXty-00826-00188248-00188511 it's gonna be difficult because it's
+ol_MggpHXty-00827-00188512-00188671 like the question of weeding like what
+ol_MggpHXty-00828-00188672-00188887 are you gonna take out
+ol_MggpHXty-00829-00188888-00189102 the the weed is a great metaphor because
+ol_MggpHXty-00830-00189103-00189247 what makes something a weed
+ol_MggpHXty-00831-00189248-00189559 is its aesthetics but it's also its uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00832-00189560-00189711 relationship to the other species that
+ol_MggpHXty-00833-00189712-00189783 are present
+ol_MggpHXty-00834-00189784-00190102 like it's invasive or overgrowth um so
+ol_MggpHXty-00835-00190103-00190175 there's a lot of
+ol_MggpHXty-00836-00190176-00190350 value there's a lot of cultural values
+ol_MggpHXty-00837-00190351-00190559 in terms of like
+ol_MggpHXty-00838-00190560-00190871 beauty also in terms of uh balance so i
+ol_MggpHXty-00839-00190872-00190983 would just say like
+ol_MggpHXty-00840-00190984-00191350 with the balance chapter in looking for
+ol_MggpHXty-00841-00191351-00191663 the sort of balance of values uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00842-00191664-00191895 to edge away from the idea of balance as
+ol_MggpHXty-00843-00191896-00192119 a static point of compromise
+ol_MggpHXty-00844-00192120-00192423 that it will always be dynamic it'll
+ol_MggpHXty-00845-00192424-00192631 always have to be renegotiated
+ol_MggpHXty-00846-00192632-00193007 balancing as an act of like embracing
+ol_MggpHXty-00847-00193008-00193207 the conflict the agonism the
+ol_MggpHXty-00848-00193208-00193311 contradictions
+ol_MggpHXty-00849-00193312-00193647 and the the just again that humility
+ol_MggpHXty-00850-00193648-00194126 is going to constantly have to change
+ol_MggpHXty-00851-00194127-00194311 it's something that's influx actually
+ol_MggpHXty-00852-00194312-00194447 balance is something that is
+ol_MggpHXty-00853-00194448-00194575 influx and it's something it's not
+ol_MggpHXty-00854-00194576-00194719 something it's not how we perceive it
+ol_MggpHXty-00855-00194720-00194814 often
+ol_MggpHXty-00856-00194815-00194975 um eleanor enforcement i hope this
+ol_MggpHXty-00857-00194976-00195143 wasn't too abstract and preaching
+ol_MggpHXty-00858-00195144-00195326 no no i mean i don't know for everybody
+ol_MggpHXty-00859-00195327-00195454 else but i'm like oh
+ol_MggpHXty-00860-00195455-00195631 give me more but unfortunately we don't
+ol_MggpHXty-00861-00195632-00195759 have that much time
+ol_MggpHXty-00862-00195760-00195950 but it's been really thought provoking
+ol_MggpHXty-00863-00195951-00196095 when you talk about seed
+ol_MggpHXty-00864-00196096-00196319 and and soil you know i keep on thinking
+ol_MggpHXty-00865-00196320-00196423 about uh
+ol_MggpHXty-00866-00196424-00196663 octavia butler and earthseed and you
+ol_MggpHXty-00867-00196664-00196831 talk about spacing so i'm thinking about
+ol_MggpHXty-00868-00196832-00196959 audrey lord and how
+ol_MggpHXty-00869-00196960-00197166 she thinks we um she talks about how we
+ol_MggpHXty-00870-00197167-00197335 need to find time to
+ol_MggpHXty-00871-00197336-00197559 to to fill out the spaces that we want
+ol_MggpHXty-00872-00197560-00197702 to create into the future
+ol_MggpHXty-00873-00197703-00197975 so anyways thank you so much eleanor um
+ol_MggpHXty-00874-00197976-00198023 please
+ol_MggpHXty-00875-00198024-00198271 uh you know just stay with us and uh be
+ol_MggpHXty-00876-00198272-00198438 safe and keep on doing
+ol_MggpHXty-00877-00198439-00198647 the wonderful work and most importantly
+ol_MggpHXty-00878-00198648-00198759 wonderful thinking you're
+ol_MggpHXty-00879-00198760-00199047 you're doing in terms of you know
+ol_MggpHXty-00880-00199048-00199159 sending us here and
+ol_MggpHXty-00881-00199160-00199399 thanking us uh through to the future
+ol_MggpHXty-00882-00199400-00199511 thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-00883-00199512-00199814 um just one last thing sorry on
+ol_MggpHXty-00884-00199815-00199895 inclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-00885-00199896-00200071 i was just remembering there's very
+ol_MggpHXty-00886-00200072-00200199 important stuff about
+ol_MggpHXty-00887-00200200-00200438 just the to be aware of the cosmologies
+ol_MggpHXty-00888-00200439-00200566 that have constructed the things that
+ol_MggpHXty-00889-00200567-00200687 are present
+ol_MggpHXty-00890-00200688-00200935 and how a totally different set of
+ol_MggpHXty-00891-00200936-00201078 values
+ol_MggpHXty-00892-00201079-00201247 is necessary to invite different
+ol_MggpHXty-00893-00201248-00201399 aesthetics in the room
+ol_MggpHXty-00894-00201400-00201735 so just insofar as like if if
+ol_MggpHXty-00895-00201736-00201935 time space and energy are the modernist
+ol_MggpHXty-00896-00201936-00202111 values or like
+ol_MggpHXty-00897-00202112-00202335 proscenium front and like display of
+ol_MggpHXty-00898-00202336-00202438 virtuosity
+ol_MggpHXty-00899-00202439-00202559 have been the values that have
+ol_MggpHXty-00900-00202560-00202759 constructed how stage works have been
+ol_MggpHXty-00901-00202760-00202902 seen so far
+ol_MggpHXty-00902-00202903-00203183 you can't just stick uh you know uh an
+ol_MggpHXty-00903-00203184-00203278 afrological
+ol_MggpHXty-00904-00203279-00203511 show on that in that space and expect it
+ol_MggpHXty-00905-00203512-00203678 to work you know if something is based
+ol_MggpHXty-00906-00203679-00203735 on
+ol_MggpHXty-00907-00203736-00204119 community joy and rhythm or
+ol_MggpHXty-00908-00204120-00204319 dancing on floors that aren't made of
+ol_MggpHXty-00909-00204320-00204478 wood or marley like there's
+ol_MggpHXty-00910-00204479-00204614 everything from the materials of the
+ol_MggpHXty-00911-00204615-00204806 room the arrangements to the
+ol_MggpHXty-00912-00204807-00205023 the very values of gathering and how and
+ol_MggpHXty-00913-00205023-00205175 why people gathered
+ol_MggpHXty-00914-00205176-00205382 or what are the historical inheritances
+ol_MggpHXty-00915-00205383-00205519 of each of these works
+ol_MggpHXty-00916-00205519-00205846 will demand that we actually treat this
+ol_MggpHXty-00917-00205848-00206079 the spaces we have differently it could
+ol_MggpHXty-00918-00206080-00206271 be part of redesigned projects in this
+ol_MggpHXty-00919-00206271-00206334 moment
+ol_MggpHXty-00920-00206335-00206655 so blah blah blah goodbye thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-00921-00206656-00206966 thanks again uh eleanor um so moving
+ol_MggpHXty-00922-00206967-00207055 from that
+ol_MggpHXty-00923-00207056-00207438 um um kind of you know returning
+ol_MggpHXty-00924-00207439-00207606 you know from the space back to the
+ol_MggpHXty-00925-00207607-00207766 ground i would now like to
+ol_MggpHXty-00926-00207767-00207942 give the floor actually to the perform
+ol_MggpHXty-00927-00207944-00208151 europe team to introduce
+ol_MggpHXty-00928-00208152-00208438 the project in detail like all projects
+ol_MggpHXty-00929-00208439-00208551 this one is embedded
+ol_MggpHXty-00930-00208552-00208782 in a set of tools working strands and
+ol_MggpHXty-00931-00208783-00208998 opportunities for the sector
+ol_MggpHXty-00932-00209000-00209398 for us to use and work with
+ol_MggpHXty-00933-00209400-00209646 keeping eleanor's uh words in mind of
+ol_MggpHXty-00934-00209648-00209767 course
+ol_MggpHXty-00935-00209767-00210006 it's high time to understand better how
+ol_MggpHXty-00936-00210007-00210231 the challenges we are facing today
+ol_MggpHXty-00937-00210232-00210439 and the visions we are embracing for
+ol_MggpHXty-00938-00210440-00210606 international touring
+ol_MggpHXty-00939-00210607-00210815 in the future translates and perform
+ol_MggpHXty-00940-00210816-00210942 europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00941-00210944-00211158 what is this consortium inviting the
+ol_MggpHXty-00942-00211159-00211351 sector for
+ol_MggpHXty-00943-00211352-00211542 what are we talking about in the next 18
+ol_MggpHXty-00944-00211544-00211719 months
+ol_MggpHXty-00945-00211719-00212039 who has a seat at the proverbial table
+ol_MggpHXty-00946-00212040-00212455 what ground are we on right who has
+ol_MggpHXty-00947-00212456-00212710 how is 2020 whether the pandemic or the
+ol_MggpHXty-00948-00212711-00212879 black lives matter uprising
+ol_MggpHXty-00949-00212880-00213319 shaped us as individuals as communities
+ol_MggpHXty-00950-00213319-00213471 with that with all that in mind i give
+ol_MggpHXty-00951-00213471-00213719 the floor to the co-initiators of
+ol_MggpHXty-00952-00213719-00214039 perform europe first to elsa
+ol_MggpHXty-00953-00214040-00214358 ricardo's doctor secretary general from
+ol_MggpHXty-00954-00214359-00214591 iatm
+ol_MggpHXty-00955-00214592-00214871 thank you very much tunde and thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-00956-00214871-00215079 barbara and thank you eleanor
+ol_MggpHXty-00957-00215080-00215303 i'm gonna dive right into it because we
+ol_MggpHXty-00958-00215304-00215406 are indeed
+ol_MggpHXty-00959-00215407-00215694 pressed for time i get to be the first
+ol_MggpHXty-00960-00215696-00215934 of the perform euro partners to welcome
+ol_MggpHXty-00961-00215935-00216055 you here
+ol_MggpHXty-00962-00216056-00216287 it's great to see so many we have
+ol_MggpHXty-00963-00216288-00216455 hundreds of people
+ol_MggpHXty-00964-00216456-00216663 in the zoom room and following the live
+ol_MggpHXty-00965-00216664-00216806 stream
+ol_MggpHXty-00966-00216807-00217175 for us this is a moment of celebration
+ol_MggpHXty-00967-00217176-00217494 celebration of a very intense period of
+ol_MggpHXty-00968-00217496-00217751 application writing last summer
+ol_MggpHXty-00969-00217752-00218127 and two months of preparation now
+ol_MggpHXty-00970-00218128-00218503 but this is also a humble moment
+ol_MggpHXty-00971-00218504-00218779 a humble moment because we feel a huge
+ol_MggpHXty-00972-00218780-00218910 responsibility on
+ol_MggpHXty-00973-00218911-00219215 our shoulders to do well
+ol_MggpHXty-00974-00219216-00219639 to do justice and to listen
+ol_MggpHXty-00975-00219640-00219927 we are very grateful to the european
+ol_MggpHXty-00976-00219928-00220031 commission
+ol_MggpHXty-00977-00220032-00220303 and the creative europe program for
+ol_MggpHXty-00978-00220304-00220551 trusting us with this project
+ol_MggpHXty-00979-00220552-00220823 we see perform europe as a much awaited
+ol_MggpHXty-00980-00220823-00221087 and anticipated project
+ol_MggpHXty-00981-00221088-00221398 which comes from a sector that has for
+ol_MggpHXty-00982-00221400-00221639 the last part of a whole year been shut
+ol_MggpHXty-00983-00221640-00221742 down
+ol_MggpHXty-00984-00221744-00222031 not being able to do what it does best
+ol_MggpHXty-00985-00222032-00222223 to bring to its audiences
+ol_MggpHXty-00986-00222223-00222551 joy happiness
+ol_MggpHXty-00987-00222552-00222887 magic has realities everything that it
+ol_MggpHXty-00988-00222888-00222967 does
+ol_MggpHXty-00989-00222967-00223382 live on the stage in the moment
+ol_MggpHXty-00990-00223383-00223679 this project can have a significant
+ol_MggpHXty-00991-00223680-00223863 impact on how we are going to
+ol_MggpHXty-00992-00223864-00223958 collaborate
+ol_MggpHXty-00993-00223959-00224294 across the creative europe countries
+ol_MggpHXty-00994-00224296-00224623 how we show work and also how we create
+ol_MggpHXty-00995-00224623-00225039 and act as a sector we get to do things
+ol_MggpHXty-00996-00225040-00225342 differently now via perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-00997-00225344-00225639 we get a chance to test innovative ideas
+ol_MggpHXty-00998-00225640-00225806 and solutions
+ol_MggpHXty-00999-00225807-00226079 we get a chance to show in practice what
+ol_MggpHXty-01000-00226080-00226263 we have been preaching
+ol_MggpHXty-01001-00226264-00226567 that is to put environmental concerns
+ol_MggpHXty-01002-00226567-00226942 at the center of our tours to include
+ol_MggpHXty-01003-00226944-00227303 all those that belong to our sectors
+ol_MggpHXty-01004-00227304-00227591 to improv praise and put focus on the
+ol_MggpHXty-01005-00227592-00227639 many
+ol_MggpHXty-01006-00227640-00227903 beautiful regions of all the creative
+ol_MggpHXty-01007-00227904-00228046 europe countries
+ol_MggpHXty-01008-00228048-00228294 and and this is important at the same
+ol_MggpHXty-01009-00228296-00228471 time seek
+ol_MggpHXty-01010-00228471-00228887 and celebrate artistic excellence
+ol_MggpHXty-01011-00228888-00229142 this project does not come about in
+ol_MggpHXty-01012-00229144-00229319 isolation and it will
+ol_MggpHXty-01013-00229319-00229671 not be executed in isolation
+ol_MggpHXty-01014-00229671-00229919 its principles of inclusion balance
+ol_MggpHXty-01015-00229919-00230023 diversity
+ol_MggpHXty-01016-00230023-00230287 and green deal are those the european
+ol_MggpHXty-01017-00230288-00230398 commission itself
+ol_MggpHXty-01018-00230400-00230655 has put in the forefront and those
+ol_MggpHXty-01019-00230656-00230798 performing europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01020-00230800-00231167 has put at the core of its mission
+ol_MggpHXty-01021-00231167-00231542 we are in no way immune
+ol_MggpHXty-01022-00231544-00231919 nor outside of today's divisions
+ol_MggpHXty-01023-00231919-00232287 and polarizations we are part of it
+ol_MggpHXty-01024-00232288-00232591 and what we do as an artistic community
+ol_MggpHXty-01025-00232592-00232791 matters
+ol_MggpHXty-01026-00232792-00232998 perform europe gives us a chance to
+ol_MggpHXty-01027-00233000-00233182 address inequalities
+ol_MggpHXty-01028-00233183-00233406 and put sustainable practice at the
+ol_MggpHXty-01029-00233407-00233606 heart of everything that we do
+ol_MggpHXty-01030-00233607-00233887 because we must find practices that are
+ol_MggpHXty-01031-00233888-00234158 sustainable for a long period of time
+ol_MggpHXty-01032-00234159-00234455 for the sake of our planet but also for
+ol_MggpHXty-01033-00234456-00234510 the
+ol_MggpHXty-01034-00234511-00234919 for the health of our art sectors
+ol_MggpHXty-01035-00234919-00235182 last but not least perform europe gives
+ol_MggpHXty-01036-00235183-00235303 a chance
+ol_MggpHXty-01037-00235304-00235582 to really dive into and explore further
+ol_MggpHXty-01038-00235583-00235734 the digital practices
+ol_MggpHXty-01039-00235735-00236039 and means of distributing our work
+ol_MggpHXty-01040-00236040-00236303 kower has taught us to live work and
+ol_MggpHXty-01041-00236304-00236455 practice online
+ol_MggpHXty-01042-00236456-00236703 and perform europe will seek innovative
+ol_MggpHXty-01043-00236704-00236806 artistic work
+ol_MggpHXty-01044-00236807-00237206 which can thrive in the digital realm
+ol_MggpHXty-01045-00237207-00237494 as well as life on states and throughout
+ol_MggpHXty-01046-00237496-00237710 our regions
+ol_MggpHXty-01047-00237711-00237958 we are six from the project that will
+ol_MggpHXty-01048-00237959-00238119 now one by one
+ol_MggpHXty-01049-00238119-00238303 tell you more about perform europe so
+ol_MggpHXty-01050-00238304-00238446 stay with us
+ol_MggpHXty-01051-00238448-00238655 and i'm going to give the world next to
+ol_MggpHXty-01052-00238656-00238855 my colleague eures janssens
+ol_MggpHXty-01053-00238856-00239103 that is going to tell you about to form
+ol_MggpHXty-01054-00239104-00239167 euros
+ol_MggpHXty-01055-00239167-00239446 very important first steps of research
+ol_MggpHXty-01056-00239448-00239646 thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-01057-00239648-00239894 thank you awesome hello everybody indeed
+ol_MggpHXty-01058-00239896-00240103 i will very briefly introduce you to the
+ol_MggpHXty-01059-00240104-00240215 mapping research
+ol_MggpHXty-01060-00240216-00240446 which we will do together at the start
+ol_MggpHXty-01061-00240448-00240623 of perform europe and the aim
+ol_MggpHXty-01062-00240623-00240855 of this mapping research in first stages
+ol_MggpHXty-01063-00240856-00241055 of the project is to gather
+ol_MggpHXty-01064-00241056-00241246 all the necessary information all that
+ol_MggpHXty-01065-00241248-00241455 we need to know in order to design the
+ol_MggpHXty-01066-00241456-00241558 support scheme
+ol_MggpHXty-01067-00241559-00241791 that's going to contribute best possible
+ol_MggpHXty-01068-00241792-00241894 way to more
+ol_MggpHXty-01069-00241896-00242103 sustainable balanced inclusive
+ol_MggpHXty-01070-00242104-00242255 international touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01071-00242256-00242494 whole region covered by creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01072-00242496-00242655 at this moment the solid
+ol_MggpHXty-01073-00242656-00242927 research this exhaustive and expensive
+ol_MggpHXty-01074-00242928-00243198 is missing so we are going to develop it
+ol_MggpHXty-01075-00243200-00243423 but how are we going to do so first we
+ol_MggpHXty-01076-00243423-00243694 will map the current state of affairs
+ol_MggpHXty-01077-00243696-00243894 we will look at the trends in
+ol_MggpHXty-01078-00243896-00244094 international touring practices
+ol_MggpHXty-01079-00244096-00244310 also way international touring is
+ol_MggpHXty-01080-00244311-00244519 supported and also the way
+ol_MggpHXty-01081-00244519-00244775 digital tools are used in the process of
+ol_MggpHXty-01082-00244776-00244830 touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01083-00244831-00245134 and supporting it so it's describing the
+ol_MggpHXty-01084-00245135-00245279 current state of affairs
+ol_MggpHXty-01085-00245280-00245519 but it's also about evaluating it in
+ol_MggpHXty-01086-00245519-00245591 terms of
+ol_MggpHXty-01087-00245592-00245830 sustainability balance and inclusion
+ol_MggpHXty-01088-00245831-00246030 it's not only about mapping what's there
+ol_MggpHXty-01089-00246031-00246319 it's also about how we want the
+ol_MggpHXty-01090-00246319-00246439 situation to be
+ol_MggpHXty-01091-00246440-00246639 and how we want to transform it's about
+ol_MggpHXty-01092-00246640-00246903 your needs obstacles you encounter
+ol_MggpHXty-01093-00246904-00247142 your wishes dreams and ambitions
+ol_MggpHXty-01094-00247144-00247446 concerning more sustainable touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01095-00247448-00247663 the confrontation of what is there and
+ol_MggpHXty-01096-00247664-00247758 where we want to go
+ol_MggpHXty-01097-00247759-00247951 will ultimately help us to design this
+ol_MggpHXty-01098-00247952-00248327 scheme which we'll put in place later on
+ol_MggpHXty-01099-00248328-00248494 so how are we going to gather this
+ol_MggpHXty-01100-00248496-00248703 information of course we will read all
+ol_MggpHXty-01101-00248704-00248879 the material which is already there and
+ol_MggpHXty-01102-00248880-00249103 also the books that eleanor recommended
+ol_MggpHXty-01103-00249104-00249206 of course
+ol_MggpHXty-01104-00249207-00249375 we are putting together a network of
+ol_MggpHXty-01105-00249376-00249542 country correspondents
+ol_MggpHXty-01106-00249544-00249734 our antennas in all the creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01107-00249735-00249903 regions to inform us about
+ol_MggpHXty-01108-00249904-00250055 policy schemes that are out there
+ol_MggpHXty-01109-00250056-00250327 digital tools about practices
+ol_MggpHXty-01110-00250328-00250558 but most importantly you all can
+ol_MggpHXty-01111-00250559-00250639 contribute
+ol_MggpHXty-01112-00250640-00250958 your input is crucial we will soon
+ol_MggpHXty-01113-00250959-00251182 beginning of february on the 8th launch
+ol_MggpHXty-01114-00251183-00251382 a large survey for all performing
+ol_MggpHXty-01115-00251383-00251494 artists companies
+ol_MggpHXty-01116-00251496-00251751 presenters festivals in all creative
+ol_MggpHXty-01117-00251752-00251879 europe countries
+ol_MggpHXty-01118-00251880-00252030 in order to hear from you about your
+ol_MggpHXty-01119-00252031-00252239 situations your dreams
+ol_MggpHXty-01120-00252240-00252487 your ideas so stay tuned for this
+ol_MggpHXty-01121-00252488-00252679 register on our website follow
+ol_MggpHXty-01122-00252680-00252967 the social media read the newsletters
+ol_MggpHXty-01123-00252967-00253087 it's where you can
+ol_MggpHXty-01124-00253088-00253294 give your input but also you will be
+ol_MggpHXty-01125-00253296-00253430 able to to follow
+ol_MggpHXty-01126-00253431-00253734 on the results because we imagine from
+ol_MggpHXty-01127-00253735-00253815 europe to be
+ol_MggpHXty-01128-00253816-00254134 one common space for learning developing
+ol_MggpHXty-01129-00254135-00254303 development for understanding and
+ol_MggpHXty-01130-00254304-00254446 mapping is only
+ol_MggpHXty-01131-00254448-00254687 the first step of that and how the rest
+ol_MggpHXty-01132-00254688-00254830 will develop
+ol_MggpHXty-01133-00254831-00254998 that will be explained by my colleagues
+ol_MggpHXty-01134-00255000-00255158 first by catherine daventer
+ol_MggpHXty-01135-00255159-00255398 the secretary general of ifa the
+ol_MggpHXty-01136-00255400-00255615 european festival association
+ol_MggpHXty-01137-00255616-00255806 she will explain to you uh in more
+ol_MggpHXty-01138-00255807-00255982 detail what the perform europe's support
+ol_MggpHXty-01139-00255983-00256142 scheme is going to look like how it will
+ol_MggpHXty-01140-00256144-00256215 work
+ol_MggpHXty-01141-00256216-00256615 and also how you can engage
+ol_MggpHXty-01142-00256616-00256839 mapping is server you always testing is
+ol_MggpHXty-01143-00256840-00257030 good this is what i would like to start
+ol_MggpHXty-01144-00257031-00257071 with
+ol_MggpHXty-01145-00257071-00257287 and now we come to the core we come to
+ol_MggpHXty-01146-00257288-00257615 you artists presenters and producers
+ol_MggpHXty-01147-00257616-00257903 we heard from our invitation to you is
+ol_MggpHXty-01148-00257904-00258134 the following it's to test together a
+ol_MggpHXty-01149-00258135-00258391 future scheme of a real pan-european
+ol_MggpHXty-01150-00258392-00258639 performing arts fund and for us there
+ol_MggpHXty-01151-00258640-00258887 are two coins two sides to the same coin
+ol_MggpHXty-01152-00258888-00259134 in our invitation there is a thinking
+ol_MggpHXty-01153-00259135-00259215 side
+ol_MggpHXty-01154-00259216-00259446 and there is a doing side let's start
+ol_MggpHXty-01155-00259448-00259655 with the maybe more difficult part
+ol_MggpHXty-01156-00259656-00259919 for me it's the thinking side um perform
+ol_MggpHXty-01157-00259919-00259967 europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01158-00259967-00260151 get will give us the opportunity to
+ol_MggpHXty-01159-00260152-00260287 speak to think
+ol_MggpHXty-01160-00260288-00260534 and to list our proposals our needs our
+ol_MggpHXty-01161-00260535-00260767 ideas for a future european fund
+ol_MggpHXty-01162-00260767-00260967 that supports the sector that gives an
+ol_MggpHXty-01163-00260967-00261119 added value to you
+ol_MggpHXty-01164-00261119-00261334 and to your practices in addition to the
+ol_MggpHXty-01165-00261335-00261542 existing schemes that happen
+ol_MggpHXty-01166-00261544-00261727 already on the local and on the national
+ol_MggpHXty-01167-00261728-00261951 level how are we doing this
+ol_MggpHXty-01168-00261952-00262158 we are working at the moment uh in this
+ol_MggpHXty-01169-00262159-00262327 joint exercise with two
+ol_MggpHXty-01170-00262328-00262487 elements we work with the digital
+ol_MggpHXty-01171-00262488-00262655 perform europe platform
+ol_MggpHXty-01172-00262656-00262855 that we are setting up at the moment and
+ol_MggpHXty-01173-00262856-00262999 secondly we are going to have
+ol_MggpHXty-01174-00263000-00263175 a series of zoom conferences and
+ol_MggpHXty-01175-00263176-00263334 workshops
+ol_MggpHXty-01176-00263335-00263606 to start with the digital platform uh we
+ol_MggpHXty-01177-00263607-00263830 are setting this up for you a space
+ol_MggpHXty-01178-00263831-00264039 as yours was saying to get together to
+ol_MggpHXty-01179-00264040-00264223 get in touch with each other
+ol_MggpHXty-01180-00264224-00264403 space for collective learning
+ol_MggpHXty-01181-00264404-00264543 experimentation
+ol_MggpHXty-01182-00264544-00264767 for receiving also your applications and
+ol_MggpHXty-01183-00264768-00264927 for matchmaking
+ol_MggpHXty-01184-00264928-00265263 in other words it is our networking tool
+ol_MggpHXty-01185-00265264-00265479 our common place for collecting
+ol_MggpHXty-01186-00265480-00265703 different profiles of you data
+ol_MggpHXty-01187-00265704-00265958 and presenting also the archiving and
+ol_MggpHXty-01188-00265959-00266167 archiving audiovisual material of
+ol_MggpHXty-01189-00266168-00266382 selected performances
+ol_MggpHXty-01190-00266383-00266543 it's to share knowledge that we gain
+ol_MggpHXty-01191-00266544-00266775 throughout the process our hot spot
+ol_MggpHXty-01192-00266776-00267063 for communication as well secondly we
+ol_MggpHXty-01193-00267064-00267271 work on a series of online workshops we
+ol_MggpHXty-01194-00267272-00267319 will
+ol_MggpHXty-01195-00267320-00267487 in addition to this platform come
+ol_MggpHXty-01196-00267488-00267655 together in two moments in the next
+ol_MggpHXty-01197-00267656-00267815 months through conferences
+ol_MggpHXty-01198-00267816-00268015 and the workshop in april and during
+ol_MggpHXty-01199-00268016-00268247 summer time to learn together how to
+ol_MggpHXty-01200-00268248-00268471 make touring more sustainable and
+ol_MggpHXty-01201-00268472-00268695 inclusive and we start already this
+ol_MggpHXty-01202-00268696-00268910 afternoon and then later on
+ol_MggpHXty-01203-00268911-00269127 and this leads us to the doing side some
+ol_MggpHXty-01204-00269128-00269303 of you will prove the value of
+ol_MggpHXty-01205-00269304-00269582 our aim fund meaning that we will test
+ol_MggpHXty-01206-00269583-00269767 some of the new touring practices with a
+ol_MggpHXty-01207-00269768-00269879 number of touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01208-00269880-00270191 projects br and stefan will give in some
+ol_MggpHXty-01209-00270192-00270455 moments a little bit more hints on this
+ol_MggpHXty-01210-00270456-00270647 matching and touring ideas of projects
+ol_MggpHXty-01211-00270648-00270847 that we are going to select
+ol_MggpHXty-01212-00270848-00271030 as always of course in these selection
+ol_MggpHXty-01213-00271031-00271230 processes there will be an independent
+ol_MggpHXty-01214-00271231-00271479 jury that we are going to put in place
+ol_MggpHXty-01215-00271480-00271655 we are going to launch the call for this
+ol_MggpHXty-01216-00271656-00271927 jury and for jury members mid-february
+ol_MggpHXty-01217-00271928-00272143 so from june onwards when the platform
+ol_MggpHXty-01218-00272144-00272382 opens nine jury members will develop
+ol_MggpHXty-01219-00272383-00272655 apply and follow up the testing phase of
+ol_MggpHXty-01220-00272656-00272855 our new support scheme
+ol_MggpHXty-01221-00272856-00273110 it all is quite complex still i know
+ol_MggpHXty-01222-00273111-00273303 perform europe is not a fund yet
+ol_MggpHXty-01223-00273304-00273527 it's under full construction but as
+ol_MggpHXty-01224-00273528-00273758 eleanor said it's an invitation for us
+ol_MggpHXty-01225-00273759-00273975 an opportunity and even maybe a
+ol_MggpHXty-01226-00273976-00274199 responsibility that we can collectively
+ol_MggpHXty-01227-00274200-00274327 take to test
+ol_MggpHXty-01228-00274328-00274551 and recommend possible criteria to the
+ol_MggpHXty-01229-00274552-00274679 european commission
+ol_MggpHXty-01230-00274680-00274919 to barbara and to her team that reflect
+ol_MggpHXty-01231-00274920-00275110 the needs and necessities of the sector
+ol_MggpHXty-01232-00275111-00275271 for such a fund
+ol_MggpHXty-01233-00275272-00275519 now pierre via clem i hope you are with
+ol_MggpHXty-01234-00275520-00275695 me in this space
+ol_MggpHXty-01235-00275696-00275895 from the european dense house network
+ol_MggpHXty-01236-00275896-00276071 i'm giving the floor to you for more
+ol_MggpHXty-01237-00276072-00276151 details
+ol_MggpHXty-01238-00276152-00276415 on the fund and how the fund will work
+ol_MggpHXty-01239-00276416-00276503 here
+ol_MggpHXty-01240-00276504-00276919 if you are with me there you are
+ol_MggpHXty-01241-00276920-00277191 thank you catherine and hello everybody
+ol_MggpHXty-01242-00277192-00277247 so i
+ol_MggpHXty-01243-00277248-00277510 i have the the the pleasure to further
+ol_MggpHXty-01244-00277511-00277591 explain
+ol_MggpHXty-01245-00277592-00277927 shortly two key functions from perform
+ol_MggpHXty-01246-00277928-00278191 europe which perform europe's developing
+ol_MggpHXty-01247-00278192-00278358 with the aim to stimulate
+ol_MggpHXty-01248-00278359-00278606 or let's say like eleonora just
+ol_MggpHXty-01249-00278607-00278695 mentioned
+ol_MggpHXty-01250-00278696-00278991 fertilize the performing arts ecosystem
+ol_MggpHXty-01251-00278992-00279030 and
+ol_MggpHXty-01252-00279031-00279367 plant fresh seeds for all so these
+ol_MggpHXty-01253-00279368-00279575 functions are designed to offer a wide
+ol_MggpHXty-01254-00279576-00279743 range of matchmaking
+ol_MggpHXty-01255-00279744-00280015 and networking possibilities between
+ol_MggpHXty-01256-00280016-00280082 performing
+ol_MggpHXty-01257-00280083-00280358 artists and companies and presenters
+ol_MggpHXty-01258-00280359-00280527 from venues festivals and other
+ol_MggpHXty-01259-00280528-00280687 organizations
+ol_MggpHXty-01260-00280688-00281015 so how will it work in a first
+ol_MggpHXty-01261-00281016-00281279 step the perform europe jury will select
+ol_MggpHXty-01262-00281280-00281375 performers
+ol_MggpHXty-01263-00281376-00281630 and presenters who enter in a
+ol_MggpHXty-01264-00281631-00281791 matchmaking process
+ol_MggpHXty-01265-00281792-00282151 via the digital platform the juries
+ol_MggpHXty-01266-00282152-00282487 that catherine just talked about before
+ol_MggpHXty-01267-00282488-00282823 will be made a selection respecting the
+ol_MggpHXty-01268-00282824-00283258 perform europe values yes once more
+ol_MggpHXty-01269-00283259-00283639 sustainability inclusivity and balance
+ol_MggpHXty-01270-00283640-00283958 so these first steps is the start
+ol_MggpHXty-01271-00283959-00284295 of possible touring partnerships which
+ol_MggpHXty-01272-00284296-00284695 in a second step can develop
+ol_MggpHXty-01273-00284696-00285015 innovative international touring plans
+ol_MggpHXty-01274-00285016-00285215 before submitting it into the second
+ol_MggpHXty-01275-00285216-00285399 round of applications
+ol_MggpHXty-01276-00285400-00285630 the second selection is a selection of
+ol_MggpHXty-01277-00285631-00285815 touring partnerships
+ol_MggpHXty-01278-00285816-00286143 again done by the same jury
+ol_MggpHXty-01279-00286144-00286382 so the now selected partnerships will be
+ol_MggpHXty-01280-00286383-00286606 awarded a touring grant
+ol_MggpHXty-01281-00286607-00286791 with the objective to test their
+ol_MggpHXty-01282-00286792-00286991 proposed touring plan
+ol_MggpHXty-01283-00286992-00287279 the test can include real-life touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01284-00287280-00287503 as well as virtual distribution via the
+ol_MggpHXty-01285-00287504-00287558 digital
+ol_MggpHXty-01286-00287559-00287967 platform so what do we mean when we
+ol_MggpHXty-01287-00287968-00288119 speak about networking
+ol_MggpHXty-01288-00288120-00288510 in this in this scenario well beyond the
+ol_MggpHXty-01289-00288511-00288687 perform europe scheme
+ol_MggpHXty-01290-00288688-00288895 as it was just described before by my
+ol_MggpHXty-01291-00288896-00288991 colleagues
+ol_MggpHXty-01292-00288992-00289247 the digital platform is designed to
+ol_MggpHXty-01293-00289248-00289447 fulfill various needs
+ol_MggpHXty-01294-00289448-00289630 to inform the performing arts sector
+ol_MggpHXty-01295-00289631-00289799 about each other in a more inclusive
+ol_MggpHXty-01296-00289800-00289910 manner
+ol_MggpHXty-01297-00289911-00290158 and then provide support to develop new
+ol_MggpHXty-01298-00290159-00290351 and meaningful partnerships
+ol_MggpHXty-01299-00290352-00290615 collaborations and a better access to
+ol_MggpHXty-01300-00290616-00290695 networking
+ol_MggpHXty-01301-00290696-00291054 and therefore enlarge a scope of touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01302-00291055-00291158 possibilities
+ol_MggpHXty-01303-00291159-00291471 in longer terms and here i just said
+ol_MggpHXty-01304-00291472-00291510 again
+ol_MggpHXty-01305-00291511-00291839 in the end it's a huge collective effort
+ol_MggpHXty-01306-00291840-00292054 of the performing arts field to develop
+ol_MggpHXty-01307-00292055-00292127 together
+ol_MggpHXty-01308-00292128-00292471 and benefit from equal access
+ol_MggpHXty-01309-00292472-00292671 open and broaden already existing
+ol_MggpHXty-01310-00292672-00292887 networks partnerships and corporations
+ol_MggpHXty-01311-00292888-00292982 and yes
+ol_MggpHXty-01312-00292983-00293223 taking special care towards target
+ol_MggpHXty-01313-00293224-00293454 groups which often do not take part in
+ol_MggpHXty-01314-00293455-00293479 an
+ol_MggpHXty-01315-00293480-00293687 in and benefit from cross-border
+ol_MggpHXty-01316-00293688-00293815 distribution
+ol_MggpHXty-01317-00293816-00294023 so for this to happen we need your
+ol_MggpHXty-01318-00294024-00294167 participation
+ol_MggpHXty-01319-00294168-00294503 please join the movement and i now i
+ol_MggpHXty-01320-00294504-00294687 give the floor to my colleague stefan
+ol_MggpHXty-01321-00294688-00294943 coordinator of the strata network
+ol_MggpHXty-01322-00294944-00295287 who will tell you how cross-touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01323-00295288-00295654 cross-border touring works and digital
+ol_MggpHXty-01324-00295655-00295775 distribution partnership
+ol_MggpHXty-01325-00295776-00296191 will thank you thank you
+ol_MggpHXty-01326-00296192-00296503 thank you and bonjour everyone
+ol_MggpHXty-01327-00296504-00296847 so picture it it's the summer 2021
+ol_MggpHXty-01328-00296848-00297063 the presenters and the producers have
+ol_MggpHXty-01329-00297064-00297158 been selected
+ol_MggpHXty-01330-00297159-00297487 sp i just explained and they are finally
+ol_MggpHXty-01331-00297488-00297647 able to create what we call
+ol_MggpHXty-01332-00297648-00297919 a distribution partnership this will
+ol_MggpHXty-01333-00297920-00298143 allow them in turn to apply for a grant
+ol_MggpHXty-01334-00298144-00298303 and a selection will be made by an
+ol_MggpHXty-01335-00298304-00298463 independent jury as
+ol_MggpHXty-01336-00298464-00298767 mentioned earlier by catherine but how
+ol_MggpHXty-01337-00298768-00299006 do you create a distribution partnership
+ol_MggpHXty-01338-00299007-00299310 well of course the artistic work should
+ol_MggpHXty-01339-00299311-00299415 be the core
+ol_MggpHXty-01340-00299416-00299727 element of the application but you also
+ol_MggpHXty-01341-00299728-00299934 need to have a very solid partnership
+ol_MggpHXty-01342-00299935-00300039 with at least
+ol_MggpHXty-01343-00300040-00300279 three partners in three different
+ol_MggpHXty-01344-00300280-00300375 countries
+ol_MggpHXty-01345-00300376-00300639 among the creative europe countries and
+ol_MggpHXty-01346-00300640-00300743 your partnership
+ol_MggpHXty-01347-00300744-00301047 needs to scream sustainability
+ol_MggpHXty-01348-00301048-00301334 in a holistic way through the prism of
+ol_MggpHXty-01349-00301335-00301406 these
+ol_MggpHXty-01350-00301407-00301719 five values artistic
+ol_MggpHXty-01351-00301720-00302054 human social economic
+ol_MggpHXty-01352-00302055-00302430 and of course ecological values
+ol_MggpHXty-01353-00302431-00302630 you also need to be able to explain how
+ol_MggpHXty-01354-00302631-00302863 inclusive and accessible your strategy
+ol_MggpHXty-01355-00302864-00302967 is
+ol_MggpHXty-01356-00302968-00303143 both in terms of how you plan on
+ol_MggpHXty-01357-00303144-00303295 reaching audiences
+ol_MggpHXty-01358-00303296-00303639 and how you work with arts professionals
+ol_MggpHXty-01359-00303640-00303823 it means that you need to have a clear
+ol_MggpHXty-01360-00303824-00303958 audience engagement plan
+ol_MggpHXty-01361-00303959-00304191 and show also that you have a digital
+ol_MggpHXty-01362-00304192-00304334 strategy
+ol_MggpHXty-01363-00304335-00304582 and what happens if your application is
+ol_MggpHXty-01364-00304583-00304727 successful
+ol_MggpHXty-01365-00304728-00304991 well first of all you can celebrate the
+ol_MggpHXty-01366-00304992-00305110 good news
+ol_MggpHXty-01367-00305111-00305343 but you can also receive a grant ranging
+ol_MggpHXty-01368-00305344-00305423 from
+ol_MggpHXty-01369-00305424-00305751 10 to 20 000 euros
+ol_MggpHXty-01370-00305752-00306015 for a distribution partnership which you
+ol_MggpHXty-01371-00306016-00306199 will be able to use to cover
+ol_MggpHXty-01372-00306200-00306479 any budget line of the costs incurred in
+ol_MggpHXty-01373-00306480-00306582 touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01374-00306583-00306903 whether it is live touring or virtual
+ol_MggpHXty-01375-00306904-00307071 distribution
+ol_MggpHXty-01376-00307072-00307375 you see we are all very much aware that
+ol_MggpHXty-01377-00307376-00307663 cultural and artistic mobility as well
+ol_MggpHXty-01378-00307664-00307839 as international touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01379-00307840-00308134 have been put on hold for the past year
+ol_MggpHXty-01380-00308135-00308223 however
+ol_MggpHXty-01381-00308224-00308439 we remain convinced that real life
+ol_MggpHXty-01382-00308440-00308599 international touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01383-00308600-00308910 is essential and through perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01384-00308911-00309095 we also want to explore digital
+ol_MggpHXty-01385-00309096-00309215 opportunities
+ol_MggpHXty-01386-00309216-00309503 we can allow us to reach a wider
+ol_MggpHXty-01387-00309504-00309671 spectrum of audiences
+ol_MggpHXty-01388-00309672-00309943 and experiment with new aesthetics and
+ol_MggpHXty-01389-00309944-00310023 artistic
+ol_MggpHXty-01390-00310024-00310334 approaches so thank you for listening
+ol_MggpHXty-01391-00310335-00310582 and let me give the mick to elena
+ol_MggpHXty-01392-00310583-00310727 pollitseva
+ol_MggpHXty-01393-00310728-00311158 head of policy and research at ietm
+ol_MggpHXty-01394-00311159-00311391 she will tell us everything we need to
+ol_MggpHXty-01395-00311392-00311615 know about the policy recommendation
+ol_MggpHXty-01396-00311616-00311871 elena the floor oh thank you stephen
+ol_MggpHXty-01397-00311872-00311991 hello everyone
+ol_MggpHXty-01398-00311992-00312167 i will not tell you everything because i
+ol_MggpHXty-01399-00312168-00312367 have to be brief now
+ol_MggpHXty-01400-00312368-00312591 so it was as it was said today continued
+ol_MggpHXty-01401-00312592-00312679 support for
+ol_MggpHXty-01402-00312680-00312958 uh performing our circulation is um
+ol_MggpHXty-01403-00312959-00313158 absolutely vital especially today
+ol_MggpHXty-01404-00313159-00313430 amidst the crisis and we also believe
+ol_MggpHXty-01405-00313431-00313615 that the dedicated you action for
+ol_MggpHXty-01406-00313616-00313815 performing arts circulation would be
+ol_MggpHXty-01407-00313816-00313991 an essential brick to be to build
+ol_MggpHXty-01408-00313992-00314182 stronger and more ease of europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01409-00314183-00314367 that's why perform europe is there to
+ol_MggpHXty-01410-00314368-00314551 pave the way for a structured and
+ol_MggpHXty-01411-00314552-00314751 continuous support for performing our
+ol_MggpHXty-01412-00314752-00314919 distribution and touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01413-00314920-00315095 the european commission has given us a
+ol_MggpHXty-01414-00315096-00315230 mandate to
+ol_MggpHXty-01415-00315231-00315503 develop policy recommendations on how to
+ol_MggpHXty-01416-00315504-00315695 create such a tool as part of creative
+ol_MggpHXty-01417-00315696-00315827 europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01418-00315828-00316047 2021-2027
+ol_MggpHXty-01419-00316048-00316351 um precisely in 17 months from now
+ol_MggpHXty-01420-00316352-00316487 we will be advising the european
+ol_MggpHXty-01421-00316488-00316671 commission the member states and the
+ol_MggpHXty-01422-00316672-00316791 european parliament
+ol_MggpHXty-01423-00316792-00317030 and how to better support inclusive and
+ol_MggpHXty-01424-00317031-00317223 balanced and sustainable
+ol_MggpHXty-01425-00317224-00317358 touring and distribution of the
+ol_MggpHXty-01426-00317359-00317575 performing arts we will also
+ol_MggpHXty-01427-00317576-00317719 assess whether there is a need for
+ol_MggpHXty-01428-00317720-00317895 specific actions
+ol_MggpHXty-01429-00317896-00318127 targeting uh various disciplines of the
+ol_MggpHXty-01430-00318128-00318263 performing arts
+ol_MggpHXty-01431-00318264-00318439 circles theater dance street art
+ol_MggpHXty-01432-00318440-00318582 performance
+ol_MggpHXty-01433-00318583-00318782 so how will it be happening and what
+ol_MggpHXty-01434-00318783-00318927 resources will be using while
+ol_MggpHXty-01435-00318928-00319182 drafting those recommendations first of
+ol_MggpHXty-01436-00319183-00319327 all we will hear
+ol_MggpHXty-01437-00319328-00319495 later today from some of you during the
+ol_MggpHXty-01438-00319496-00319719 workshop secondly we will embrace the
+ol_MggpHXty-01439-00319720-00319887 outcomes of the research phase about
+ol_MggpHXty-01440-00319888-00320095 which euros told you earlier
+ol_MggpHXty-01441-00320096-00320375 then we will also um analyze the
+ol_MggpHXty-01442-00320376-00320599 outcomes of the performance
+ol_MggpHXty-01443-00320600-00320758 from europe touring actions which are
+ol_MggpHXty-01444-00320759-00320919 the main experimentations
+ol_MggpHXty-01445-00320920-00321167 of this project and last but not least
+ol_MggpHXty-01446-00321168-00321287 of course we will need
+ol_MggpHXty-01447-00321288-00321519 the input of the sector itself basically
+ol_MggpHXty-01448-00321520-00321639 of you
+ol_MggpHXty-01449-00321640-00321879 there will be a few consultation moments
+ol_MggpHXty-01450-00321880-00322039 through which we hope to hear about your
+ol_MggpHXty-01451-00322040-00322110 needs
+ol_MggpHXty-01452-00322111-00322310 about your insights about your
+ol_MggpHXty-01453-00322311-00322527 expectations and aspirations
+ol_MggpHXty-01454-00322528-00322703 and please stay tuned for those
+ol_MggpHXty-01455-00322704-00322887 consultation moments
+ol_MggpHXty-01456-00322888-00323143 so we are very excited and happy to take
+ol_MggpHXty-01457-00323144-00323358 this challenging difficult uh
+ol_MggpHXty-01458-00323359-00323679 huge task and we do hope for you to be
+ol_MggpHXty-01459-00323680-00323991 with us in this way and now i'm glad to
+ol_MggpHXty-01460-00323992-00324103 give the floor back
+ol_MggpHXty-01461-00324104-00324430 to ibm secretary general ausa to tell
+ol_MggpHXty-01462-00324431-00324630 you about the immediate next steps of
+ol_MggpHXty-01463-00324631-00324871 performing europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01464-00324872-00325230 thank you lana and thank you colleagues
+ol_MggpHXty-01465-00325231-00325558 i hope all of you listening and watching
+ol_MggpHXty-01466-00325559-00325830 feel you know a little bit more about
+ol_MggpHXty-01467-00325831-00325934 perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01468-00325935-00326191 when when you enter this yet another
+ol_MggpHXty-01469-00326192-00326343 zoom room
+ol_MggpHXty-01470-00326344-00326575 we really had hoped to meet you live in
+ol_MggpHXty-01471-00326576-00326703 present birth
+ol_MggpHXty-01472-00326704-00327047 celery there's going to be plenty more
+ol_MggpHXty-01473-00327048-00327327 opportunities to know more and most
+ol_MggpHXty-01474-00327328-00327495 importantly to take part
+ol_MggpHXty-01475-00327496-00327830 and first of all put in your calendars
+ol_MggpHXty-01476-00327831-00327871 now
+ol_MggpHXty-01477-00327872-00328127 8th of february survey coming from
+ol_MggpHXty-01478-00328128-00328263 perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01479-00328264-00328551 it is going to be a hugely important
+ol_MggpHXty-01480-00328552-00328710 tool for us
+ol_MggpHXty-01481-00328711-00328999 to get to know your needs and desires
+ol_MggpHXty-01482-00329000-00329063 that you're
+ol_MggpHXty-01483-00329064-00329415 so eloquently described earlier
+ol_MggpHXty-01484-00329416-00329743 please take part please also
+ol_MggpHXty-01485-00329744-00329999 and ask all your friends to follow our
+ol_MggpHXty-01486-00330000-00330175 channels we are on facebook
+ol_MggpHXty-01487-00330176-00330519 twitter instagram and linkedin
+ol_MggpHXty-01488-00330520-00330758 and most importantly if you haven't done
+ol_MggpHXty-01489-00330759-00330839 it yet
+ol_MggpHXty-01490-00330840-00331306 subscribe to our newsletter on
+ol_MggpHXty-01491-00331307-00331423 www.performeurope.edu
+ol_MggpHXty-01492-00331424-00331767 and right now we just put a whole lot of
+ol_MggpHXty-01493-00331768-00332119 new information there lots of new info
+ol_MggpHXty-01494-00332120-00332278 that is there now
+ol_MggpHXty-01495-00332279-00332582 please check it out and stay tuned to
+ol_MggpHXty-01496-00332583-00332815 the finished platform coming up
+ol_MggpHXty-01497-00332816-00333127 and being released in june
+ol_MggpHXty-01498-00333128-00333519 i want to thank all the staff and teams
+ol_MggpHXty-01499-00333520-00333830 of all the partners of perform europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01500-00333831-00334110 you know who you are for the immense
+ol_MggpHXty-01501-00334111-00334175 good
+ol_MggpHXty-01502-00334176-00334463 hard work in the last weeks in preparing
+ol_MggpHXty-01503-00334464-00334575 this event
+ol_MggpHXty-01504-00334576-00334878 and also the start of this project
+ol_MggpHXty-01505-00334879-00335158 as i said we are celebrating but we are
+ol_MggpHXty-01506-00335159-00335239 excited
+ol_MggpHXty-01507-00335240-00335478 as well as humble regarding this
+ol_MggpHXty-01508-00335479-00335727 responsibility and we count on you to
+ol_MggpHXty-01509-00335728-00335847 help us
+ol_MggpHXty-01510-00335848-00336110 thank you so much for being here over to
+ol_MggpHXty-01511-00336111-00336271 you tunde
+ol_MggpHXty-01512-00336272-00336606 thank you elsa um yeah and um
+ol_MggpHXty-01513-00336607-00336863 there have been some questions uh some
+ol_MggpHXty-01514-00336864-00337023 wonderful questions actually
+ol_MggpHXty-01515-00337024-00337295 um they've been posed already um what
+ol_MggpHXty-01516-00337296-00337487 i'm gonna do is i'm going to kind of
+ol_MggpHXty-01517-00337488-00337767 ask them or present it to the panelists
+ol_MggpHXty-01518-00337768-00337806 uh
+ol_MggpHXty-01519-00337807-00338127 including eleanor and barbara
+ol_MggpHXty-01520-00338128-00338430 um and you all can you know once i
+ol_MggpHXty-01521-00338431-00338591 ask all of the questions you all can
+ol_MggpHXty-01522-00338592-00338734 take it as a bunch
+ol_MggpHXty-01523-00338735-00339047 is that clear right
+ol_MggpHXty-01524-00339048-00339375 um so um here's the first question from
+ol_MggpHXty-01525-00339376-00339430 cheryl
+ol_MggpHXty-01526-00339431-00339687 martin hey cheryl um it sounds like
+ol_MggpHXty-01527-00339688-00339823 perform europe is
+ol_MggpHXty-01528-00339824-00340199 for eu artists companies and citizens
+ol_MggpHXty-01529-00340200-00340454 does the uk have any role here that's
+ol_MggpHXty-01530-00340455-00340615 the first question
+ol_MggpHXty-01531-00340616-00340982 second question is um how do
+ol_MggpHXty-01532-00340983-00341254 europeans how how do european
+ol_MggpHXty-01533-00341255-00341510 institutions become more inclusive
+ol_MggpHXty-01534-00341511-00341863 within their administration as well as
+ol_MggpHXty-01535-00341864-00342110 their in their decision processes of who
+ol_MggpHXty-01536-00342111-00342215 gets support
+ol_MggpHXty-01537-00342216-00342543 and funding this is from leonard cruz
+ol_MggpHXty-01538-00342544-00342767 um and then the next question from
+ol_MggpHXty-01539-00342768-00342903 people bailey
+ol_MggpHXty-01540-00342904-00343158 there's a big question it's a big
+ol_MggpHXty-01541-00343159-00343215 question
+ol_MggpHXty-01542-00343216-00343454 whether people who have been leading and
+ol_MggpHXty-01543-00343455-00343695 managing broken systems
+ol_MggpHXty-01544-00343696-00344110 are the right people to lead change
+ol_MggpHXty-01545-00344111-00344454 and then um the last question
+ol_MggpHXty-01546-00344455-00344775 in this bunch from mimi is
+ol_MggpHXty-01547-00344776-00345103 what is the more inclusive working
+ol_MggpHXty-01548-00345104-00345310 manner that is being mentioned many
+ol_MggpHXty-01549-00345311-00345406 times
+ol_MggpHXty-01550-00345407-00345882 in this conference so who wants to
+ol_MggpHXty-01551-00345883-00346175 start
+ol_MggpHXty-01552-00346176-00346439 i'll start by saying that it's not just
+ol_MggpHXty-01553-00346440-00346654 the european union creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01554-00346655-00346967 is actually a much larger region
+ol_MggpHXty-01555-00346968-00347199 and i'll let barbara explain that
+ol_MggpHXty-01556-00347200-00347358 further and also take the question
+ol_MggpHXty-01557-00347359-00347519 regarding uk
+ol_MggpHXty-01558-00347520-00347678 what we can tell you that we are going
+ol_MggpHXty-01559-00347679-00348278 to include the uk in our research part
+ol_MggpHXty-01560-00348279-00348543 yes thank you asia i saw those questions
+ol_MggpHXty-01561-00348544-00348710 and i thought that they were probably
+ol_MggpHXty-01562-00348711-00348975 aiming at me so at the moment it looks
+ol_MggpHXty-01563-00348976-00349039 like
+ol_MggpHXty-01564-00349040-00349310 as as the uk was part of creative europe
+ol_MggpHXty-01565-00349311-00349375 when we
+ol_MggpHXty-01566-00349376-00349703 launched uh the whole uh the whole
+ol_MggpHXty-01567-00349704-00350063 program uh it the uk
+ol_MggpHXty-01568-00350064-00350391 artist should normally be able to um
+ol_MggpHXty-01569-00350392-00350647 to participate and indeed creative
+ol_MggpHXty-01570-00350648-00350823 europe is larger than just
+ol_MggpHXty-01571-00350824-00351263 eu 27 but i would like you to
+ol_MggpHXty-01572-00351264-00351582 to really check out the the details uh
+ol_MggpHXty-01573-00351583-00351927 once they once they come nearer the time
+ol_MggpHXty-01574-00351928-00352119 but that is also obviously part of
+ol_MggpHXty-01575-00352120-00352351 inclusiveness even though we may be
+ol_MggpHXty-01576-00352352-00352647 as you well know and you have witnessed
+ol_MggpHXty-01577-00352648-00352799 over the past days
+ol_MggpHXty-01578-00352800-00353258 uh part of uh part of some kind of uh
+ol_MggpHXty-01579-00353259-00353575 relationship issues uh between
+ol_MggpHXty-01580-00353576-00353895 between the uk and the eu at the moment
+ol_MggpHXty-01581-00353896-00354199 that i hope for the sake of
+ol_MggpHXty-01582-00354200-00354430 of our sector and your sector to put it
+ol_MggpHXty-01583-00354431-00354503 like that
+ol_MggpHXty-01584-00354504-00354727 for for culture in general and for
+ol_MggpHXty-01585-00354728-00354967 diversity that we will be able to
+ol_MggpHXty-01586-00354968-00355287 overcome in a very uh constructive
+ol_MggpHXty-01587-00355288-00355682 way um i i i saw the questions about the
+ol_MggpHXty-01588-00355683-00355823 languages
+ol_MggpHXty-01589-00355824-00356206 and of course i'm not totally sure i
+ol_MggpHXty-01590-00356207-00356567 i fully grasped it of course if you
+ol_MggpHXty-01591-00356568-00356871 if you are engaging we believe in an
+ol_MggpHXty-01592-00356872-00357063 international
+ol_MggpHXty-01593-00357064-00357358 project you should be able to to
+ol_MggpHXty-01594-00357359-00357447 communicate
+ol_MggpHXty-01595-00357448-00357758 in a common language so uh
+ol_MggpHXty-01596-00357759-00357982 i don't know if your if your question
+ol_MggpHXty-01597-00357983-00358134 was rather more towards
+ol_MggpHXty-01598-00358135-00358447 uh minority languages or languages not
+ol_MggpHXty-01599-00358448-00358558 being
+ol_MggpHXty-01600-00358559-00358823 the the formal language of a country
+ol_MggpHXty-01601-00358824-00358895 that you live
+ol_MggpHXty-01602-00358896-00359287 in so i'm afraid i i can't really
+ol_MggpHXty-01603-00359288-00359815 i can't really answer that that question
+ol_MggpHXty-01604-00359816-00360039 maybe someone else saw the question and
+ol_MggpHXty-01605-00360040-00360239 has a better understanding of
+ol_MggpHXty-01606-00360240-00360558 how we can we can answer it
+ol_MggpHXty-01607-00360559-00361167 concretely
+ol_MggpHXty-01608-00361168-00361447 i understood the question as relative to
+ol_MggpHXty-01609-00361448-00361751 those seeking jobs
+ol_MggpHXty-01610-00361752-00361927 having to deal with the linguistic
+ol_MggpHXty-01611-00361928-00362134 hegemony of the places they're applying
+ol_MggpHXty-01612-00362135-00362223 to which
+ol_MggpHXty-01613-00362224-00362510 which keeps the the faces of those
+ol_MggpHXty-01614-00362511-00362591 institutions
+ol_MggpHXty-01615-00362592-00362806 sort of looking the same by nationality
+ol_MggpHXty-01616-00362807-00362951 or or ethnicity
+ol_MggpHXty-01617-00362952-00363206 that language is a barrier so maybe one
+ol_MggpHXty-01618-00363207-00363367 one practical solution could be that
+ol_MggpHXty-01619-00363368-00363454 some funds
+ol_MggpHXty-01620-00363455-00363767 are considered for translation or
+ol_MggpHXty-01621-00363768-00363951 you know like that yeah just thinking
+ol_MggpHXty-01622-00363952-00364110 about and when you get to the practical
+ol_MggpHXty-01623-00364111-00364199 brainstorming
+ol_MggpHXty-01624-00364200-00364423 tool part like how is language barrier
+ol_MggpHXty-01625-00364424-00364551 part of
+ol_MggpHXty-01626-00364552-00364878 the problem yes indeed that's a very
+ol_MggpHXty-01627-00364879-00364934 good
+ol_MggpHXty-01628-00364935-00365191 i think it's a good uh way of thinking
+ol_MggpHXty-01629-00365192-00365399 about this question eleanor i mean we in
+ol_MggpHXty-01630-00365400-00365606 europe we already have a very broad
+ol_MggpHXty-01631-00365607-00365958 diversity of languages
+ol_MggpHXty-01632-00365959-00366127 so we know what we're talking about if
+ol_MggpHXty-01633-00366128-00366287 we talk about linguistic
+ol_MggpHXty-01634-00366288-00366471 challenges but of course that does not
+ol_MggpHXty-01635-00366472-00366703 include languages from
+ol_MggpHXty-01636-00366704-00366934 countries where where people may live in
+ol_MggpHXty-01637-00366935-00367127 a country but coming from somewhere else
+ol_MggpHXty-01638-00367128-00367206 where these kind
+ol_MggpHXty-01639-00367207-00367439 where these languages are not spoken so
+ol_MggpHXty-01640-00367440-00367647 uh we have to probably
+ol_MggpHXty-01641-00367648-00367943 think of that but uh nonetheless uh in
+ol_MggpHXty-01642-00367944-00368015 in the
+ol_MggpHXty-01643-00368016-00368287 in the perspective of an international
+ol_MggpHXty-01644-00368288-00368454 and cross-border corporation
+ol_MggpHXty-01645-00368455-00368710 we have to we have to bear in mind that
+ol_MggpHXty-01646-00368711-00368839 it needs to be somehow
+ol_MggpHXty-01647-00368840-00369206 also just very practical also
+ol_MggpHXty-01648-00369207-00369430 in a way but uh yeah that's it's a good
+ol_MggpHXty-01649-00369431-00369510 suggestion
+ol_MggpHXty-01650-00369511-00369751 and we'll certainly think about it or
+ol_MggpHXty-01651-00369752-00369934 the consortium will certainly
+ol_MggpHXty-01652-00369935-00370239 think about it i'm sure yes and we will
+ol_MggpHXty-01653-00370240-00370406 take all questions that haven't been
+ol_MggpHXty-01654-00370407-00370606 answered and find the way of processing
+ol_MggpHXty-01655-00370607-00370758 them and answering because we have
+ol_MggpHXty-01656-00370759-00370951 unfortunately gone over the time
+ol_MggpHXty-01657-00370952-00371215 allocated i'm going to give the word
+ol_MggpHXty-01658-00371216-00371319 back to you
+ol_MggpHXty-01659-00371320-00371582 yeah yeah def definitely um yeah and
+ol_MggpHXty-01660-00371583-00371623 also
+ol_MggpHXty-01661-00371624-00371775 kind of think about you know the the
+ol_MggpHXty-01662-00371776-00372006 power the power that language holds
+ol_MggpHXty-01663-00372007-00372367 um anyways um so um
+ol_MggpHXty-01664-00372368-00372727 where will we be in 18 months of this
+ol_MggpHXty-01665-00372728-00373015 trajectory i'm personally curious to see
+ol_MggpHXty-01666-00373016-00373110 what comes out of
+ol_MggpHXty-01667-00373111-00373382 this setting um how things are
+ol_MggpHXty-01668-00373383-00373487 potentially
+ol_MggpHXty-01669-00373488-00373751 shaken up the work starts here and today
+ol_MggpHXty-01670-00373752-00373871 so we need to make
+ol_MggpHXty-01671-00373872-00374134 sure we use the lessons of last year
+ol_MggpHXty-01672-00374135-00374254 once again
+ol_MggpHXty-01673-00374255-00374495 to create the portal that the writer
+ol_MggpHXty-01674-00374496-00374599 aruddhati roy
+ol_MggpHXty-01675-00374600-00374951 encouraged earlier um of 2020
+ol_MggpHXty-01676-00374952-00375167 we need to tear down and eradicate old
+ol_MggpHXty-01677-00375168-00375295 systems that have not
+ol_MggpHXty-01678-00375296-00375551 served us while we create spaces that
+ol_MggpHXty-01679-00375552-00375639 would hold
+ol_MggpHXty-01680-00375640-00375878 and reflect more of the individuals in
+ol_MggpHXty-01681-00375879-00376006 our society
+ol_MggpHXty-01682-00376007-00376319 who often exist at margins
+ol_MggpHXty-01683-00376320-00376639 how can our work center them
+ol_MggpHXty-01684-00376640-00376863 in sustainable ways following this
+ol_MggpHXty-01685-00376864-00376967 launch moment
+ol_MggpHXty-01686-00376968-00377206 we can continue with some talks on how
+ol_MggpHXty-01687-00377207-00377399 to imagine future touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01688-00377400-00377751 in a way that is representing more
+ol_MggpHXty-01689-00377752-00377934 of the individuals that we often leave
+ol_MggpHXty-01690-00377935-00378078 up anyways
+ol_MggpHXty-01691-00378079-00378310 in 15 minutes i've i invite everyone
+ol_MggpHXty-01692-00378311-00378439 back to the live stream
+ol_MggpHXty-01693-00378440-00378799 at 3 15 less than 15 minutes actually
+ol_MggpHXty-01694-00378800-00379063 with this series of talks so 12 minutes
+ol_MggpHXty-01695-00379064-00379167 that will help us
+ol_MggpHXty-01696-00379168-00379439 better understand some factors of future
+ol_MggpHXty-01697-00379440-00379502 touring
+ol_MggpHXty-01698-00379503-00379767 and our work in perform europe the link
+ol_MggpHXty-01699-00379768-00379878 will be displayed
+ol_MggpHXty-01700-00379879-00380134 on the final webinar sorry the final
+ol_MggpHXty-01701-00380135-00380343 slide of the webinar so look out for the
+ol_MggpHXty-01702-00380344-00380406 link
+ol_MggpHXty-01703-00380407-00380575 and a smaller group of people will then
+ol_MggpHXty-01704-00380576-00380727 be part of a series of
+ol_MggpHXty-01705-00380728-00380958 breakout groups for those who could not
+ol_MggpHXty-01706-00380959-00381143 get a place in these groups
+ol_MggpHXty-01707-00381144-00381423 don't worry we got snacks for you too
+ol_MggpHXty-01708-00381424-00381543 they will be repeated
+ol_MggpHXty-01709-00381544-00381815 in three weeks time on thursday the 18th
+ol_MggpHXty-01710-00381816-00381958 of february
+ol_MggpHXty-01711-00381959-00382278 so put that in your calendar my work
+ol_MggpHXty-01712-00382279-00382430 here is done
+ol_MggpHXty-01713-00382431-00382647 um i hope you all have a beautiful day
+ol_MggpHXty-01714-00382648-00382743 wherever you are
+ol_MggpHXty-01715-00382744-00383047 in europe um goodbye and good luck
+ol_MggpHXty-01716-00383048-00383503 and please do better
+om5h9r5LmkM-00000-00000289-00000949 your name google your password 1 2 3 4 5
+om5h9r5LmkM-00001-00000950-00001660 no quirky no help of admin No what's up
+om5h9r5LmkM-00002-00001661-00001892 guys what's happening you know this guy
+om5h9r5LmkM-00003-00001893-00002192 sure he's stuck low she beats me every
+om5h9r5LmkM-00004-00002193-00002525 day do you need the ID Thanks did I get
+om5h9r5LmkM-00005-00002526-00002567 it now
+om5h9r5LmkM-00006-00002568-00003722 yeah go ahead right see you tomorrow we
+om5h9r5LmkM-00007-00003722-00003901 all know that passwords can be a pain
+om5h9r5LmkM-00008-00003902-00004138 every website asks for one
+om5h9r5LmkM-00009-00004139-00004352 users have a ton of them they can't
+om5h9r5LmkM-00010-00004353-00004610 remember or even worse some users have
+om5h9r5LmkM-00011-00004611-00004850 one or two passwords we used across
+om5h9r5LmkM-00012-00004851-00005084 various websites and apps which could be
+om5h9r5LmkM-00013-00005085-00005384 a big security risk this is not fun for
+om5h9r5LmkM-00014-00005385-00005584 users or developers
+om5h9r5LmkM-00015-00005585-00005906 my name is Agee and there's a handy and
+om5h9r5LmkM-00016-00005907-00006154 simple solutions to this issue called
+om5h9r5LmkM-00017-00006155-00006517 federated login protected logging means
+om5h9r5LmkM-00018-00006518-00006739 that user authenticates using a
+om5h9r5LmkM-00019-00006740-00006946 third-party identity usually without
+om5h9r5LmkM-00020-00006947-00007192 reentering credentials or profile
+om5h9r5LmkM-00021-00007193-00007534 information google sign name is google's
+om5h9r5LmkM-00022-00007536-00007742 take on federated logging and is
+om5h9r5LmkM-00023-00007743-00007973 designed to be as easy as possible for
+om5h9r5LmkM-00024-00007973-00008249 you to implement and for users to sign
+om5h9r5LmkM-00025-00008250-00008705 in let's see how it works here's a
+om5h9r5LmkM-00026-00008706-00008966 sign-in button when the user steps on it
+om5h9r5LmkM-00027-00008967-00009341 I sign in window appears the user
+om5h9r5LmkM-00028-00009342-00009605 chooses an account and then sign in if
+om5h9r5LmkM-00029-00009606-00009983 he is not signed in already the user
+om5h9r5LmkM-00030-00009984-00010373 allow access to profile information now
+om5h9r5LmkM-00031-00010374-00010592 the pop-up window closes and the user is
+om5h9r5LmkM-00032-00010593-00010949 sending notice that the current best
+om5h9r5LmkM-00033-00010950-00011141 practice for asking permissions is
+om5h9r5LmkM-00034-00011142-00011431 incremental authorization this means
+om5h9r5LmkM-00035-00011432-00011614 that rather than signing in and
+om5h9r5LmkM-00036-00011615-00011870 requesting user permissions at the same
+om5h9r5LmkM-00037-00011871-00012131 time you should first sign your user in
+om5h9r5LmkM-00038-00012132-00012367 and request for permissions only when
+om5h9r5LmkM-00039-00012368-00012508 they are needed
+om5h9r5LmkM-00040-00012509-00012773 check out my authorization video for
+om5h9r5LmkM-00041-00012774-00013082 further details on this now let's take a
+om5h9r5LmkM-00042-00013083-00013372 look at how to implement Google sign-in
+om5h9r5LmkM-00043-00013374-00013697 in just a few steps first head over to
+om5h9r5LmkM-00044-00013697-00013880 Google developers console create a
+om5h9r5LmkM-00045-00013881-00014144 project at the credential configure
+om5h9r5LmkM-00046-00014144-00014569 consent screen and create a client ID in
+om5h9r5LmkM-00047-00014571-00014849 HTML add the client ID to the head
+om5h9r5LmkM-00048-00014850-00015215 section using meta tag then load a phas
+om5h9r5LmkM-00049-00015216-00015419 this is the core of Google JavaScript
+om5h9r5LmkM-00050-00015419-00015911 library when API J's is loaded call G
+om5h9r5LmkM-00051-00015912-00016187 API load to import us to module to
+om5h9r5LmkM-00052-00016188-00016511 enable Google sign-in then call the API
+om5h9r5LmkM-00053-00016512-00016871 also in it to initialize once these are
+om5h9r5LmkM-00054-00016872-00017228 done you are ready the next step is to
+om5h9r5LmkM-00055-00017229-00017573 render a sign-in button the most generic
+om5h9r5LmkM-00056-00017574-00017810 option to do this is to use a custom
+om5h9r5LmkM-00057-00017811-00018212 button put an HTML tag and use regular
+om5h9r5LmkM-00058-00018213-00018548 CSS to design the button don't forget to
+om5h9r5LmkM-00059-00018549-00018725 read our guidelines for designing the
+om5h9r5LmkM-00060-00018726-00018977 button you also find the button assets
+om5h9r5LmkM-00061-00018978-00019313 in the same dock add an event listener
+om5h9r5LmkM-00062-00019314-00019547 and inbox sign in when the button is
+om5h9r5LmkM-00063-00019548-00019886 pressed the sign name function returns a
+om5h9r5LmkM-00064-00019887-00020165 Google user object use it to get basic
+om5h9r5LmkM-00065-00020166-00020378 profile information such as user name
+om5h9r5LmkM-00066-00020379-00020741 email and the profile image finally
+om5h9r5LmkM-00067-00020742-00020987 users can sign out simply by calling
+om5h9r5LmkM-00068-00020988-00021374 sign out review our sample code here who
+om5h9r5LmkM-00069-00021375-00021683 are more detailed walkthrough ok this
+om5h9r5LmkM-00070-00021684-00021878 was the basis of authentication using
+om5h9r5LmkM-00071-00021879-00022166 Google sign-in but what do you do if
+om5h9r5LmkM-00072-00022167-00022394 there's a server involved or how would
+om5h9r5LmkM-00073-00022395-00022664 you access the Google APs on behalf of
+om5h9r5LmkM-00074-00022665-00022709 the user
+om5h9r5LmkM-00075-00022710-00023057 I will talk about these workflows in the
+om5h9r5LmkM-00076-00023058-00023345 following videos in this series thank
+om5h9r5LmkM-00077-00023346-00023602 you for stopping by and stay tuned
+om5h9r5LmkM-00078-00023603-00025363 [Music]
+omVViuDwe2c-00000-00001688-00001910 welcome to today's lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00001-00001911-00002023 of
+omVViuDwe2c-00002-00002023-00002342 nptel video course on this geotechnical
+omVViuDwe2c-00003-00002343-00002534 earthquake engineering
+omVViuDwe2c-00004-00002535-00002750 in our previous lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00005-00002751-00003015 we had completed our module number eight
+omVViuDwe2c-00006-00003016-00003335 which is site response analysis so a
+omVViuDwe2c-00007-00003336-00003695 quick recap what we have learnt in our
+omVViuDwe2c-00008-00003696-00004038 previous lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00009-00004039-00004454 we had discussed about one example
+omVViuDwe2c-00010-00004455-00004727 which is a case study on the seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00011-00004728-00004967 ground response analysis for mumbai city
+omVViuDwe2c-00012-00004968-00005111 of india
+omVViuDwe2c-00013-00005112-00005406 and for that i have referred to this
+omVViuDwe2c-00014-00005407-00005575 journal paper
+omVViuDwe2c-00015-00005576-00005934 by vs funicans dipankar chaudhary and gr
+omVViuDwe2c-00016-00005935-00006286 reddy published in 2011 in this journal
+omVViuDwe2c-00017-00006287-00006503 geotechnical and geological engineering
+omVViuDwe2c-00018-00006504-00006678 springer publication
+omVViuDwe2c-00019-00006679-00006783 this is
+omVViuDwe2c-00020-00006784-00007151 the part of phd thesis work by dr v s
+omVViuDwe2c-00021-00007152-00007383 funicuand under my supervision at iit
+omVViuDwe2c-00022-00007384-00007655 bombay
+omVViuDwe2c-00023-00007656-00007895 we had seen that equivalent linear
+omVViuDwe2c-00024-00007895-00008214 ground response analysis and later on
+omVViuDwe2c-00025-00008215-00008439 non-linear ground response analysis for
+omVViuDwe2c-00026-00008440-00008774 typical soil sites of mumbai was carried
+omVViuDwe2c-00027-00008775-00008863 out
+omVViuDwe2c-00028-00008864-00009095 so for that the first step is to collect
+omVViuDwe2c-00029-00009096-00009367 the geotechnical properties from the
+omVViuDwe2c-00030-00009368-00009655 borehole data so various site borehole
+omVViuDwe2c-00031-00009656-00009878 locations are mentioned over here which
+omVViuDwe2c-00032-00009879-00010046 are collected
+omVViuDwe2c-00033-00010047-00010335 this is one typical borehole data with
+omVViuDwe2c-00034-00010336-00010606 the layer thickness type of soil the
+omVViuDwe2c-00035-00010607-00010759 depth and
+omVViuDwe2c-00036-00010760-00011023 recorded value of spt what
+omVViuDwe2c-00037-00011024-00011319 usually at site will be available from
+omVViuDwe2c-00038-00011320-00011551 the field data
+omVViuDwe2c-00039-00011552-00011903 next step was to identify for which
+omVViuDwe2c-00040-00011904-00012174 acceleration time history we want to
+omVViuDwe2c-00041-00012175-00012487 carry out the ground response analysis
+omVViuDwe2c-00042-00012488-00012767 so we had carried out for these four
+omVViuDwe2c-00043-00012768-00012902 selected
+omVViuDwe2c-00044-00012903-00013102 acceleration time history the ground
+omVViuDwe2c-00045-00013103-00013438 response analysis one is for bhuj motion
+omVViuDwe2c-00046-00013440-00013622 of 2001
+omVViuDwe2c-00047-00013623-00013751 another is
+omVViuDwe2c-00048-00013752-00014079 this is kobe motion of 1995.
+omVViuDwe2c-00049-00014080-00014479 this is loma prieta 1989 and loma
+omVViuDwe2c-00050-00014480-00014766 guillory 1989.
+omVViuDwe2c-00051-00014768-00014975 with those input motion after carrying
+omVViuDwe2c-00052-00014976-00015207 out the equivalent linear ground
+omVViuDwe2c-00053-00015208-00015503 response analysis the output what was
+omVViuDwe2c-00054-00015504-00016007 obtained is for each borehole location
+omVViuDwe2c-00055-00016008-00016327 for a particular input earthquake motion
+omVViuDwe2c-00056-00016328-00016694 we can get the output at different
+omVViuDwe2c-00057-00016695-00016919 levels of soil layer so this is at
+omVViuDwe2c-00058-00016920-00017063 ground level
+omVViuDwe2c-00059-00017064-00017383 or ground surface this is the output
+omVViuDwe2c-00060-00017384-00017599 that is how the acceleration time
+omVViuDwe2c-00061-00017600-00017919 response will be when a bridge motion is
+omVViuDwe2c-00062-00017920-00018263 given as input bedrock motion
+omVViuDwe2c-00063-00018264-00018622 and to do that deep soil software was
+omVViuDwe2c-00064-00018623-00018839 used
+omVViuDwe2c-00065-00018840-00019239 this is another output in this form we
+omVViuDwe2c-00066-00019240-00019519 obtain the spectral acceleration versus
+omVViuDwe2c-00067-00019520-00019683 period
+omVViuDwe2c-00068-00019684-00019894 variation at
+omVViuDwe2c-00069-00019895-00020127 a particular borehole at mongol very
+omVViuDwe2c-00070-00020128-00020447 site in mumbai with consideration of
+omVViuDwe2c-00071-00020448-00020735 five percent damping as we consider the
+omVViuDwe2c-00072-00020736-00020919 single degree of freedom system mass
+omVViuDwe2c-00073-00020920-00021158 spring dashboard system to obtain the
+omVViuDwe2c-00074-00021159-00021350 spectral acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00075-00021351-00021622 for four different input motion bh
+omVViuDwe2c-00076-00021623-00021799 motion kobe motion loma predator and
+omVViuDwe2c-00077-00021800-00022167 loma glory so you can see that the peak
+omVViuDwe2c-00078-00022168-00022478 value of this spectral acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00079-00022479-00022767 where it is occurring at which period
+omVViuDwe2c-00080-00022768-00023030 that determines that which type of
+omVViuDwe2c-00081-00023031-00023263 structure will be vulnerable
+omVViuDwe2c-00082-00023264-00023478 when that type of
+omVViuDwe2c-00083-00023479-00023742 a particular type of earthquake motion
+omVViuDwe2c-00084-00023743-00024086 is occurring at that site of mbh at
+omVViuDwe2c-00085-00024087-00024191 mumbai
+omVViuDwe2c-00086-00024192-00024447 so it automatically shows for kobe
+omVViuDwe2c-00087-00024448-00024567 motion
+omVViuDwe2c-00088-00024568-00024839 the tall buildings will be more
+omVViuDwe2c-00089-00024840-00025150 vulnerable because here the time period
+omVViuDwe2c-00090-00025151-00025519 is relatively higher compared to what
+omVViuDwe2c-00091-00025520-00025767 you can see for bhuj motion where time
+omVViuDwe2c-00092-00025768-00026094 period is relatively lower than that
+omVViuDwe2c-00093-00026095-00026351 what we obtain for kobe motion for this
+omVViuDwe2c-00094-00026352-00026639 particular site so this will vary with
+omVViuDwe2c-00095-00026639-00026943 respect to side to side as well as we
+omVViuDwe2c-00096-00026944-00027255 can see it varies with respect to input
+omVViuDwe2c-00097-00027256-00027439 earthquake motion that is for which
+omVViuDwe2c-00098-00027439-00027607 earthquake motion you are analyzing that
+omVViuDwe2c-00099-00027608-00027870 is also very important
+omVViuDwe2c-00100-00027872-00028102 then we have also seen how much
+omVViuDwe2c-00101-00028104-00028351 amplification of the bedrock motion will
+omVViuDwe2c-00102-00028352-00028662 occur when it passes through various
+omVViuDwe2c-00103-00028663-00028943 layers of the soil so at different soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00104-00028944-00029214 layers you can compute obviously what is
+omVViuDwe2c-00105-00029216-00029527 the value of a max by mh at bedrock
+omVViuDwe2c-00106-00029527-00029687 level and these
+omVViuDwe2c-00107-00029688-00030014 end values shows the at the ground level
+omVViuDwe2c-00108-00030016-00030255 what is the soil amplification so you
+omVViuDwe2c-00109-00030256-00030518 can see it ranges between about 1.2 to
+omVViuDwe2c-00110-00030519-00030814 3.5 depending on what is your input
+omVViuDwe2c-00111-00030816-00031183 motion and also for which borehole this
+omVViuDwe2c-00112-00031183-00031807 data or this analysis was carried out
+omVViuDwe2c-00113-00031808-00032183 also we had seen that for different
+omVViuDwe2c-00114-00032183-00032446 earthquake motions this different
+omVViuDwe2c-00115-00032447-00032670 response acceleration spectra which we
+omVViuDwe2c-00116-00032672-00032951 can obtain not only that
+omVViuDwe2c-00117-00032952-00033190 layer wise variation of this spectral
+omVViuDwe2c-00118-00033191-00033479 acceleration also we can get so what way
+omVViuDwe2c-00119-00033480-00033767 it will help us for the design further
+omVViuDwe2c-00120-00033768-00034046 suppose if we want to construct a
+omVViuDwe2c-00121-00034047-00034279 foundation at a particular layer or a
+omVViuDwe2c-00122-00034280-00034567 particular soil level below the ground
+omVViuDwe2c-00123-00034568-00034662 surface
+omVViuDwe2c-00124-00034663-00034943 looking at these spectral acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00125-00034944-00035087 peak values
+omVViuDwe2c-00126-00035088-00035367 we need to decide at which depth we need
+omVViuDwe2c-00127-00035368-00035630 to found the foundation based on the
+omVViuDwe2c-00128-00035631-00035983 soil property not only that if we are
+omVViuDwe2c-00129-00035984-00036135 fine
+omVViuDwe2c-00130-00036136-00036318 if we are putting the foundation at a
+omVViuDwe2c-00131-00036319-00036471 particular layer
+omVViuDwe2c-00132-00036472-00036711 we have to design for that particular
+omVViuDwe2c-00133-00036712-00036959 period and spectral acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00134-00036960-00037207 corresponding to different layer
+omVViuDwe2c-00135-00037208-00037462 with respect to different input
+omVViuDwe2c-00136-00037463-00037735 earthquake motion so which is very
+omVViuDwe2c-00137-00037736-00038007 important for a detailed study at a
+omVViuDwe2c-00138-00038008-00038239 particular site which will not be
+omVViuDwe2c-00139-00038240-00038607 available in any code because this is a
+omVViuDwe2c-00140-00038608-00039079 site specific ground response analysis
+omVViuDwe2c-00141-00039080-00039399 we had also seen in our previous lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00142-00039400-00039774 that the frequency computed using this
+omVViuDwe2c-00143-00039775-00040023 formula which is a thumb rule as i have
+omVViuDwe2c-00144-00040024-00040271 already mentioned for a typical
+omVViuDwe2c-00145-00040272-00040535 homogeneous soil layer that is the
+omVViuDwe2c-00146-00040536-00040799 fundamental natural period how to
+omVViuDwe2c-00147-00040800-00041055 estimate from the v s value compared to
+omVViuDwe2c-00148-00041056-00041335 thickness of a soil layer and what is
+omVViuDwe2c-00149-00041336-00041502 the
+omVViuDwe2c-00150-00041503-00041735 frequency obtained
+omVViuDwe2c-00151-00041736-00041983 using this deep soil software using
+omVViuDwe2c-00152-00041984-00042151 either equivalent ground response
+omVViuDwe2c-00153-00042152-00042446 analysis and non equivalent or non
+omVViuDwe2c-00154-00042447-00042711 linear ground response analysis for bhuj
+omVViuDwe2c-00155-00042712-00042983 2001 motion you can see the person
+omVViuDwe2c-00156-00042984-00043199 difference between the theoretical value
+omVViuDwe2c-00157-00043200-00043511 and the obtained value through this
+omVViuDwe2c-00158-00043512-00043887 g deep soil software is within the range
+omVViuDwe2c-00159-00043888-00044102 of about 18 percent for the case of
+omVViuDwe2c-00160-00044103-00044374 equivalent linear for non-linear it is
+omVViuDwe2c-00161-00044375-00044839 within about 12 percent or 12.5 percent
+omVViuDwe2c-00162-00044840-00045223 now coming to the development of
+omVViuDwe2c-00163-00045224-00045599 a seismic code of india let me emphasize
+omVViuDwe2c-00164-00045600-00045855 on this that is the
+omVViuDwe2c-00165-00045856-00046335 indian seismic code which is bis or is
+omVViuDwe2c-00166-00046336-00046567 1893
+omVViuDwe2c-00167-00046568-00046774 that code
+omVViuDwe2c-00168-00046775-00047079 has obviously revised
+omVViuDwe2c-00169-00047080-00047279 through several years
+omVViuDwe2c-00170-00047280-00047615 whenever there is some major earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00171-00047616-00047895 and the researchers and the research
+omVViuDwe2c-00172-00047896-00048127 community and practicing community on
+omVViuDwe2c-00173-00048128-00048335 earthquake engineering in india felt
+omVViuDwe2c-00174-00048336-00048607 that there is a need to change the
+omVViuDwe2c-00175-00048608-00048943 seismic donation of entire india it has
+omVViuDwe2c-00176-00048944-00049255 been changed so the latest change was
+omVViuDwe2c-00177-00049256-00049574 done in the year 2002 as we already have
+omVViuDwe2c-00178-00049575-00049815 discussed that is the latest version of
+omVViuDwe2c-00179-00049816-00050271 is 1893 part one only where this seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00180-00050272-00050599 zonation map is given for entire india
+omVViuDwe2c-00181-00050600-00050935 why it has occurred or it has been given
+omVViuDwe2c-00182-00050936-00051335 in 2002 because after the 2001 bhuja
+omVViuDwe2c-00183-00051336-00051607 earthquake the researchers
+omVViuDwe2c-00184-00051608-00051814 and practitioners in earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00185-00051815-00052007 engineering felt that it needs to be
+omVViuDwe2c-00186-00052008-00052223 updated so you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00187-00052224-00052423 from this slide
+omVViuDwe2c-00188-00052424-00052750 the first figure figure a this shows the
+omVViuDwe2c-00189-00052751-00053094 seismic donation map of entire india
+omVViuDwe2c-00190-00053095-00053438 which was in the year 1962 i am talking
+omVViuDwe2c-00191-00053439-00053766 about same is code one eight nine three
+omVViuDwe2c-00192-00053767-00054111 part one ok so that is the code number
+omVViuDwe2c-00193-00054112-00054430 and these are the years of their changes
+omVViuDwe2c-00194-00054432-00054523 so
+omVViuDwe2c-00195-00054524-00054838 1962 if you look at this
+omVViuDwe2c-00196-00054839-00055182 zonation map very carefully you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00197-00055183-00055615 earlier entire india was subdivided into
+omVViuDwe2c-00198-00055616-00055991 six seismic zone starting from zone one
+omVViuDwe2c-00199-00055991-00056303 to zone six so one two three four five
+omVViuDwe2c-00200-00056304-00056638 six so zone six was the most vulnerable
+omVViuDwe2c-00201-00056639-00056966 one and zone one was the least
+omVViuDwe2c-00202-00056967-00057142 vulnerable one
+omVViuDwe2c-00203-00057144-00057223 then
+omVViuDwe2c-00204-00057224-00057342 that
+omVViuDwe2c-00205-00057344-00057559 code was
+omVViuDwe2c-00206-00057560-00057887 revised in the year 1966.
+omVViuDwe2c-00207-00057888-00058271 so figure b shows the is
+omVViuDwe2c-00208-00058272-00058566 code 1893 part 1
+omVViuDwe2c-00209-00058567-00058847 where the seismic donation map has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00210-00058848-00059191 changed in the year 1966
+omVViuDwe2c-00211-00059191-00059559 again the same zone 1 to 6 were
+omVViuDwe2c-00212-00059560-00059782 considered for entire india but you can
+omVViuDwe2c-00213-00059783-00059871 see
+omVViuDwe2c-00214-00059872-00060182 some of the zone in this western part
+omVViuDwe2c-00215-00060183-00060519 like in rajasthan etc which were earlier
+omVViuDwe2c-00216-00060520-00060671 in zone 1
+omVViuDwe2c-00217-00060672-00060999 now they have changed to zone 2. can you
+omVViuDwe2c-00218-00061000-00061350 see so there are several other changes
+omVViuDwe2c-00219-00061351-00061454 as well
+omVViuDwe2c-00220-00061455-00061879 like here the zone 5 and zone 6 their
+omVViuDwe2c-00221-00061879-00062215 zonation demarcation has been changed
+omVViuDwe2c-00222-00062216-00062599 also in the central area of india they
+omVViuDwe2c-00223-00062600-00062919 are have been introduced this zone 2
+omVViuDwe2c-00224-00062920-00063047 region
+omVViuDwe2c-00225-00063048-00063126 at
+omVViuDwe2c-00226-00063127-00063471 this portion can you see over here
+omVViuDwe2c-00227-00063472-00063742 again in the southern part also here
+omVViuDwe2c-00228-00063744-00063982 zone 2 has been introduced which were
+omVViuDwe2c-00229-00063983-00064294 not there initially here it was zone 1
+omVViuDwe2c-00230-00064295-00064550 and extent of zone 1 also has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00231-00064551-00064806 changed so like that there are several
+omVViuDwe2c-00232-00064807-00064935 changes
+omVViuDwe2c-00233-00064936-00065391 between the code of 1962 to 1966 and
+omVViuDwe2c-00234-00065391-00065638 this has happened because of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00235-00065639-00066006 experience people felt between this 1962
+omVViuDwe2c-00236-00066007-00066311 to 66 whatever earthquake occurred in
+omVViuDwe2c-00237-00066312-00066567 india taking care of all these effects
+omVViuDwe2c-00238-00066568-00066759 they have changed the seismic donation
+omVViuDwe2c-00239-00066760-00066943 map
+omVViuDwe2c-00240-00066944-00067031 now
+omVViuDwe2c-00241-00067032-00067615 the 1970 version of the is code 1893
+omVViuDwe2c-00242-00067616-00067887 part 1 where the seismic donation map
+omVViuDwe2c-00243-00067888-00068063 you can look here
+omVViuDwe2c-00244-00068064-00068255 what are the changes from the previous
+omVViuDwe2c-00245-00068256-00068479 version of 1966
+omVViuDwe2c-00246-00068480-00068935 from 66 to 1970 the number of zone has
+omVViuDwe2c-00247-00068936-00069199 been reduced by one earlier it was zone
+omVViuDwe2c-00248-00069200-00069550 number one to six now it has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00249-00069551-00069919 given zone number one to five can you
+omVViuDwe2c-00250-00069920-00070055 see over here
+omVViuDwe2c-00251-00070056-00070455 so five is the most vulnerable zone
+omVViuDwe2c-00252-00070456-00070575 and
+omVViuDwe2c-00253-00070576-00070975 zone 1 is the least hazardous zone okay
+omVViuDwe2c-00254-00070976-00071247 so like that the entire india and the
+omVViuDwe2c-00255-00071248-00071471 regions also have been changed at
+omVViuDwe2c-00256-00071472-00071694 different locations as you can see even
+omVViuDwe2c-00257-00071695-00071935 zone 3 has been introduced over here at
+omVViuDwe2c-00258-00071936-00072150 the southern part zone 3 has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00259-00072151-00072367 introduced over here in this western
+omVViuDwe2c-00260-00072368-00072623 part etc
+omVViuDwe2c-00261-00072624-00072879 and entire this north east
+omVViuDwe2c-00262-00072880-00073223 has been kept under zone 5 which is most
+omVViuDwe2c-00263-00073224-00073455 hazardous one or most vulnerable one
+omVViuDwe2c-00264-00073456-00073679 even this himalayan
+omVViuDwe2c-00265-00073680-00073775 belt
+omVViuDwe2c-00266-00073776-00074023 or
+omVViuDwe2c-00267-00074024-00074343 nepal india border close to that there
+omVViuDwe2c-00268-00074344-00074599 are some regions which has been changed
+omVViuDwe2c-00269-00074600-00074871 to zone four and zone five the
+omVViuDwe2c-00270-00074872-00075135 combinations as you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00271-00075136-00075487 next the is code one eight nine three
+omVViuDwe2c-00272-00075488-00075879 part one was revised in the year 1984.
+omVViuDwe2c-00273-00075880-00076247 so this colored picture shows the
+omVViuDwe2c-00274-00076248-00076415 version
+omVViuDwe2c-00275-00076416-00076743 which is the fourth revision of 1984
+omVViuDwe2c-00276-00076744-00077223 version of indian code is 1893 part one
+omVViuDwe2c-00277-00077224-00077487 you can see here also it has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00278-00077488-00077782 subdivided into five zone zone one to
+omVViuDwe2c-00279-00077783-00078167 five one is list hazardous zone and zone
+omVViuDwe2c-00280-00078168-00078462 five is maximum or most hazardous zone
+omVViuDwe2c-00281-00078463-00078735 so this red color zones are most
+omVViuDwe2c-00282-00078736-00078959 hazardous one whereas this white color
+omVViuDwe2c-00283-00078960-00079262 zone are least hazardous one
+omVViuDwe2c-00284-00079263-00079359 but
+omVViuDwe2c-00285-00079360-00079655 if you can look at this picture there
+omVViuDwe2c-00286-00079656-00079950 were zone two over here
+omVViuDwe2c-00287-00079951-00080231 and zone three over here ahmedabad was
+omVViuDwe2c-00288-00080232-00080487 coming earlier in zone three like this
+omVViuDwe2c-00289-00080488-00080815 and their values were given
+omVViuDwe2c-00290-00080816-00081079 after bhuj earthquake people felt that
+omVViuDwe2c-00291-00081080-00081471 this region mapping is not proper and
+omVViuDwe2c-00292-00081472-00081935 also between 1984 to 2002 the latest
+omVViuDwe2c-00293-00081936-00082143 version where it is available there were
+omVViuDwe2c-00294-00082144-00082503 several other earthquakes in india right
+omVViuDwe2c-00295-00082504-00082687 like chamali earthquake was there
+omVViuDwe2c-00296-00082688-00082879 jabalpur earthquake was there there were
+omVViuDwe2c-00297-00082880-00083135 many other earthquakes so central part
+omVViuDwe2c-00298-00083136-00083431 of india also required after the
+omVViuDwe2c-00299-00083432-00083647 jabalpur earthquake etc
+omVViuDwe2c-00300-00083648-00083935 change of this donation map
+omVViuDwe2c-00301-00083936-00084303 that's why in 2002
+omVViuDwe2c-00302-00084304-00084382 this
+omVViuDwe2c-00303-00084383-00084718 seismic donation map has been proposed
+omVViuDwe2c-00304-00084719-00084987 in indian seismic code is
+omVViuDwe2c-00305-00084988-00085255 1893 part 1
+omVViuDwe2c-00306-00085256-00085543 this is the latest version as on today
+omVViuDwe2c-00307-00085544-00085894 2002 so obviously you can expect this
+omVViuDwe2c-00308-00085895-00086279 version also probably will get updated
+omVViuDwe2c-00309-00086280-00086438 whenever there are more number of
+omVViuDwe2c-00310-00086439-00086611 earthquakes and more number of
+omVViuDwe2c-00311-00086612-00086926 experiences which we incur at india and
+omVViuDwe2c-00312-00086927-00087150 then accordingly the changes of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00313-00087151-00087455 seismic zone may occur in future also
+omVViuDwe2c-00314-00087456-00087750 and for that to come up with this
+omVViuDwe2c-00315-00087751-00087991 seismic zonation map
+omVViuDwe2c-00316-00087992-00088318 major criteria are to identify the
+omVViuDwe2c-00317-00088319-00088543 effect of earthquake also how to
+omVViuDwe2c-00318-00088544-00088806 determine this values peak spectral
+omVViuDwe2c-00319-00088807-00088982 acceleration etcetera depending on the
+omVViuDwe2c-00320-00088983-00089303 soil type those what i have discussed in
+omVViuDwe2c-00321-00089304-00089382 the
+omVViuDwe2c-00322-00089383-00089591 specific site specific ground response
+omVViuDwe2c-00323-00089592-00089918 analysis so obviously it the code cannot
+omVViuDwe2c-00324-00089919-00090175 give individual site specific values but
+omVViuDwe2c-00325-00090176-00090503 it will have to give a broad value which
+omVViuDwe2c-00326-00090504-00090911 will overall match a kind of
+omVViuDwe2c-00327-00090912-00091199 design suggestion for regular buildings
+omVViuDwe2c-00328-00091200-00091447 and considering the importance factor
+omVViuDwe2c-00329-00091448-00091671 etcetera for important structure it can
+omVViuDwe2c-00330-00091672-00091982 be considered so now in this latest
+omVViuDwe2c-00331-00091983-00092367 version of is code 1893 part 1 the
+omVViuDwe2c-00332-00092368-00092615 seismic donations are divided in four
+omVViuDwe2c-00333-00092616-00092911 zones only starting with zone two which
+omVViuDwe2c-00334-00092912-00093135 is least hazardous
+omVViuDwe2c-00335-00093136-00093415 with maximum one is zone five which is
+omVViuDwe2c-00336-00093416-00093711 maximum hazardous so you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00337-00093712-00094006 here this zone four has been introduced
+omVViuDwe2c-00338-00094007-00094359 extent of zone 5 has been increased the
+omVViuDwe2c-00339-00094360-00094759 central region of jabalpur etc the
+omVViuDwe2c-00340-00094760-00094999 seismic donation has been changed so
+omVViuDwe2c-00341-00095000-00095191 like that there were several changes
+omVViuDwe2c-00342-00095192-00095623 from 1970 version to 1984 version now
+omVViuDwe2c-00343-00095624-00096015 coming to our geotechnical aspects of us
+omVViuDwe2c-00344-00096016-00096343 our i s code what it suggests let us
+omVViuDwe2c-00345-00096344-00096491 look at it
+omVViuDwe2c-00346-00096492-00096815 unfortunately the geotechnical aspects
+omVViuDwe2c-00347-00096816-00097143 of earthquake engineering is not yet
+omVViuDwe2c-00348-00097144-00097591 well addressed in this is code 1893 part
+omVViuDwe2c-00349-00097592-00098023 1 of 2002 latest version because it
+omVViuDwe2c-00350-00098024-00098374 specifies that consider only three types
+omVViuDwe2c-00351-00098375-00098726 of soil then those are mentioned as soft
+omVViuDwe2c-00352-00098727-00099038 soil medium soil hard rock but as a
+omVViuDwe2c-00353-00099039-00099406 geotechnical engineer we already know
+omVViuDwe2c-00354-00099407-00099791 that hardly these nomenclature of soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00355-00099792-00100135 signifies anything unless their typical
+omVViuDwe2c-00356-00100136-00100374 engineering value or the dynamic soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00357-00100375-00100503 properties are
+omVViuDwe2c-00358-00100504-00100774 specifically mentioned within a given
+omVViuDwe2c-00359-00100775-00101111 range so soft soil whether it is sandy
+omVViuDwe2c-00360-00101112-00101415 or clay there will be huge difference in
+omVViuDwe2c-00361-00101416-00101703 that also for the medium soil as well
+omVViuDwe2c-00362-00101704-00101815 even
+omVViuDwe2c-00363-00101816-00102118 there should be the variation of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00364-00102119-00102447 soil strata for the classification based
+omVViuDwe2c-00365-00102448-00102639 on the dynamic soil properties when we
+omVViuDwe2c-00366-00102640-00102790 are talking about the earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00367-00102791-00103151 engineering however our code specifies
+omVViuDwe2c-00368-00103152-00103439 only the characterization of soil based
+omVViuDwe2c-00369-00103440-00103558 on the
+omVViuDwe2c-00370-00103559-00103871 as we can see in this slide based on
+omVViuDwe2c-00371-00103872-00103990 s p t
+omVViuDwe2c-00372-00103991-00104310 n value let us look at the slide
+omVViuDwe2c-00373-00104311-00104630 s p t n value irrespective of the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00374-00104631-00104742 type
+omVViuDwe2c-00375-00104743-00105095 but we know that s p t n value is not
+omVViuDwe2c-00376-00105096-00105343 the only solution or only field test
+omVViuDwe2c-00377-00105344-00105631 because for pure clay you
+omVViuDwe2c-00378-00105632-00105983 can hardly do the spt test there you
+omVViuDwe2c-00379-00105983-00106247 have to probably perform the cpt
+omVViuDwe2c-00380-00106248-00106454 cone penetration test the standard
+omVViuDwe2c-00381-00106455-00106734 penetration test may not be useful there
+omVViuDwe2c-00382-00106735-00107063 so all these aspects need to be yet to
+omVViuDwe2c-00383-00107064-00107343 be addressed in our is code part one
+omVViuDwe2c-00384-00107344-00107551 from the geotechnical point of view and
+omVViuDwe2c-00385-00107552-00107799 as i said no dynamics for the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00386-00107800-00108166 characterization is yet involved in this
+omVViuDwe2c-00387-00108167-00108463 codal provision
+omVViuDwe2c-00388-00108464-00108695 now let us see what are the other
+omVViuDwe2c-00389-00108696-00109007 practices worldwide if we see the
+omVViuDwe2c-00390-00109008-00109415 seismic design criteria of u.s as per
+omVViuDwe2c-00391-00109416-00109871 the neharp code of 2003 neharp is the
+omVViuDwe2c-00392-00109872-00110095 guideline for the earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00393-00110096-00110334 resistant design in u.s
+omVViuDwe2c-00394-00110335-00110599 they have classified their
+omVViuDwe2c-00395-00110600-00110863 site soil site
+omVViuDwe2c-00396-00110864-00111102 or
+omVViuDwe2c-00397-00111103-00111366 ground classification they have
+omVViuDwe2c-00398-00111367-00111623 subdivided into in
+omVViuDwe2c-00399-00111624-00111966 six divisions starting from a to f and
+omVViuDwe2c-00400-00111967-00112286 within each division also in some of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00401-00112288-00112510 site classification they have sub
+omVViuDwe2c-00402-00112511-00112823 classification as you can see over here
+omVViuDwe2c-00403-00112824-00113047 how these have been classified with
+omVViuDwe2c-00404-00113048-00113327 respect to the site period what we have
+omVViuDwe2c-00405-00113328-00113583 discussed in our ground response
+omVViuDwe2c-00406-00113583-00113919 analysis we get a site period which is
+omVViuDwe2c-00407-00113920-00114158 more important for our design rather
+omVViuDwe2c-00408-00114159-00114519 than any other static values also we
+omVViuDwe2c-00409-00114520-00114710 should know what is the shear wave
+omVViuDwe2c-00410-00114711-00114910 velocity because shear wave velocity is
+omVViuDwe2c-00411-00114911-00115207 one of the major important criteria
+omVViuDwe2c-00412-00115208-00115486 which shows about the dynamic nature or
+omVViuDwe2c-00413-00115488-00115758 characterization of the code
+omVViuDwe2c-00414-00115759-00115999 so in the niharp code they classified
+omVViuDwe2c-00415-00116000-00116351 soil site a as the stiffest site with
+omVViuDwe2c-00416-00116352-00116775 hard rock with site period within 0.1
+omVViuDwe2c-00417-00116776-00117102 second and what is the range of vs value
+omVViuDwe2c-00418-00117103-00117383 it should be more than equals to 1500
+omVViuDwe2c-00419-00117383-00117654 meter per second
+omVViuDwe2c-00420-00117655-00117951 second side classification is site b
+omVViuDwe2c-00421-00117952-00118190 which is rocky type site where site
+omVViuDwe2c-00422-00118191-00118383 period will be less than equals to point
+omVViuDwe2c-00423-00118383-00118734 two second and mostly it is unwithered
+omVViuDwe2c-00424-00118735-00119063 rock and v s value will be
+omVViuDwe2c-00425-00119064-00119254 greater than seven sixty meter per
+omVViuDwe2c-00426-00119255-00119510 second or less than six meter of
+omVViuDwe2c-00427-00119511-00119790 thickness of the soil will exist then
+omVViuDwe2c-00428-00119791-00120054 within site classification c there are
+omVViuDwe2c-00429-00120055-00120366 sub classification c one c two c three c
+omVViuDwe2c-00430-00120367-00120543 one classifies
+omVViuDwe2c-00431-00120544-00120814 withered or soft rock with this site
+omVViuDwe2c-00432-00120815-00121127 period value and va's value
+omVViuDwe2c-00433-00121128-00121375 with the range between
+omVViuDwe2c-00434-00121376-00121934 360 to 700 meter per second for c2 it is
+omVViuDwe2c-00435-00121935-00122158 soil depth should be between 6 meter to
+omVViuDwe2c-00436-00122159-00122343 30 meter and this is the site period
+omVViuDwe2c-00437-00122344-00122654 where shallow steep soil is available
+omVViuDwe2c-00438-00122655-00122919 and c3 is intermediate depth
+omVViuDwe2c-00439-00122920-00123166 stiff soil where site period is this
+omVViuDwe2c-00440-00123167-00123399 much and soil depth can be between 30
+omVViuDwe2c-00441-00123400-00123654 meter to 60 meter then site
+omVViuDwe2c-00442-00123655-00123854 classification d
+omVViuDwe2c-00443-00123855-00124278 again sub classified into d1 d2 d3 d1 is
+omVViuDwe2c-00444-00124279-00124583 deep stiff hollows in soil it can be
+omVViuDwe2c-00445-00124583-00124823 either sand or clay but their site
+omVViuDwe2c-00446-00124824-00125183 period should be within 1.4 second and
+omVViuDwe2c-00447-00125183-00125271 their
+omVViuDwe2c-00448-00125272-00125575 depth can be between 60 meter to 210
+omVViuDwe2c-00449-00125576-00125902 meter with low fine content within 15
+omVViuDwe2c-00450-00125903-00126199 percent and non plastic in nature and
+omVViuDwe2c-00451-00126200-00126383 clay has high
+omVViuDwe2c-00452-00126383-00126607 fines content greater than 15 percent
+omVViuDwe2c-00453-00126608-00126958 and plastic fine greater than 5 or pi
+omVViuDwe2c-00454-00126959-00127295 value greater than 5 d2 is the deep
+omVViuDwe2c-00455-00127296-00127454 stiff
+omVViuDwe2c-00456-00127455-00127895 soil sand or clay with this range
+omVViuDwe2c-00457-00127896-00128263 and d3 is very deep stiff soil with this
+omVViuDwe2c-00458-00128264-00128447 value of site period with soil depth
+omVViuDwe2c-00459-00128448-00128766 greater than 210 meter whereas site
+omVViuDwe2c-00460-00128767-00129031 classification e again sub classified in
+omVViuDwe2c-00461-00129032-00129310 e one and e two e one is medium depth
+omVViuDwe2c-00462-00129311-00129447 soft clay
+omVViuDwe2c-00463-00129448-00129702 where site period is less than equals to
+omVViuDwe2c-00464-00129703-00129934 point seven second and thickness of soft
+omVViuDwe2c-00465-00129935-00130110 clay layer will be between three meter
+omVViuDwe2c-00466-00130111-00130431 to twelve meter whereas e e2 is deep
+omVViuDwe2c-00467-00130432-00130695 soft clay layer where site period is
+omVViuDwe2c-00468-00130696-00130927 this much and thickness of the soft
+omVViuDwe2c-00469-00130928-00131166 layer can be greater than 12 meter
+omVViuDwe2c-00470-00131167-00131527 whereas site classification f refers to
+omVViuDwe2c-00471-00131528-00131735 special type of soil which is
+omVViuDwe2c-00472-00131736-00132023 potentially liquefiable soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00473-00132024-00132271 that is potentially liquefiable sand or
+omVViuDwe2c-00474-00132272-00132607 peat so these are most vulnerable with
+omVViuDwe2c-00475-00132608-00132919 respect to earthquake is concerned their
+omVViuDwe2c-00476-00132920-00133143 site period about once again and hollows
+omVViuDwe2c-00477-00133144-00133447 in loose sand with high water table then
+omVViuDwe2c-00478-00133448-00133639 only the chances of liquefaction will be
+omVViuDwe2c-00479-00133640-00133902 more as we know and the organic peat
+omVViuDwe2c-00480-00133903-00134087 contents
+omVViuDwe2c-00481-00134088-00134359 so the details you can obtain in this
+omVViuDwe2c-00482-00134360-00134663 journal paper as you can see over here
+omVViuDwe2c-00483-00134664-00135087 structural longevity this paper
+omVViuDwe2c-00484-00135088-00135399 now soil classification as per euro code
+omVViuDwe2c-00485-00135400-00135671 which is followed in entire europe of
+omVViuDwe2c-00486-00135672-00136054 2004 version euro code 8 you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00487-00136055-00136327 there also it has been sub classified
+omVViuDwe2c-00488-00136328-00136471 into
+omVViuDwe2c-00489-00136472-00136902 major 5 divisions a b c d e and then
+omVViuDwe2c-00490-00136903-00137247 another 2 sub classification s 1 and s 2
+omVViuDwe2c-00491-00137248-00137502 and what are the parameters to identify
+omVViuDwe2c-00492-00137503-00137743 this description of the different types
+omVViuDwe2c-00493-00137744-00138047 of soil for this site classification of
+omVViuDwe2c-00494-00138048-00138335 course the vs value they have mentioned
+omVViuDwe2c-00495-00138336-00138663 another parameter which is known as vs30
+omVViuDwe2c-00496-00138664-00138983 what is vs 30 let me explain it to you
+omVViuDwe2c-00497-00138984-00139295 vs30 is nothing but it is the average
+omVViuDwe2c-00498-00139296-00139431 value of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00499-00139432-00139799 shear wave velocity vs within top 30
+omVViuDwe2c-00500-00139800-00140063 meter from the ground surface so how it
+omVViuDwe2c-00501-00140064-00140431 is estimated this is the depth 30 meter
+omVViuDwe2c-00502-00140432-00140519 in the
+omVViuDwe2c-00503-00140520-00140863 numerator and denominator is the sum of
+omVViuDwe2c-00504-00140864-00141087 all the layers there can be several
+omVViuDwe2c-00505-00141088-00141327 numbers of layer within the 30 meter
+omVViuDwe2c-00506-00141328-00141543 thickness of each layer in meter unit
+omVViuDwe2c-00507-00141544-00141743 divided by
+omVViuDwe2c-00508-00141744-00141902 individual
+omVViuDwe2c-00509-00141903-00142159 layers v s value
+omVViuDwe2c-00510-00142160-00142263 clear
+omVViuDwe2c-00511-00142264-00142687 so that v i when i changes from 1 to n n
+omVViuDwe2c-00512-00142688-00142902 numbers of layer if it is there so v i
+omVViuDwe2c-00513-00142903-00143111 will be in the unit meter per second so
+omVViuDwe2c-00514-00143112-00143343 you will get v s 30 also in meter per
+omVViuDwe2c-00515-00143344-00143583 second so these are the ranges of v s
+omVViuDwe2c-00516-00143584-00143871 value given and corresponding what can
+omVViuDwe2c-00517-00143872-00144151 be the typical s p t values that also
+omVViuDwe2c-00518-00144152-00144287 has been mentioned
+omVViuDwe2c-00519-00144288-00144511 with respect to what can be typical
+omVViuDwe2c-00520-00144512-00144759 values of the cohesion you can see over
+omVViuDwe2c-00521-00144760-00145151 here these are mostly soft clay
+omVViuDwe2c-00522-00145152-00145478 s1 s2 where vs value is even less than
+omVViuDwe2c-00523-00145479-00145775 100 meter per second and c value between
+omVViuDwe2c-00524-00145776-00146126 10 to 20 kpa whereas these are very
+omVViuDwe2c-00525-00146127-00146447 steep value and the first side
+omVViuDwe2c-00526-00146448-00146678 classification a is nothing but it is a
+omVViuDwe2c-00527-00146679-00146814 rock
+omVViuDwe2c-00528-00146815-00147111 where vs value is greater than 800 meter
+omVViuDwe2c-00529-00147112-00147263 per second
+omVViuDwe2c-00530-00147264-00147407 the other
+omVViuDwe2c-00531-00147408-00147654 soil classification in modern seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00532-00147655-00148119 code worldwide you can see ibc ibc is
+omVViuDwe2c-00533-00148120-00148375 international building code of 2000 or
+omVViuDwe2c-00534-00148376-00148487 ubc
+omVViuDwe2c-00535-00148488-00148847 of 97 they also classified the soil site
+omVViuDwe2c-00536-00148848-00149078 with respect to the v s value so v s is
+omVViuDwe2c-00537-00149079-00149375 most important parameter even greek
+omVViuDwe2c-00538-00149376-00149551 seismic code
+omVViuDwe2c-00539-00149552-00149871 they also classify it with respect to v
+omVViuDwe2c-00540-00149872-00150207 s value ec 8 already i have discussed
+omVViuDwe2c-00541-00150208-00150511 the new zealand code they also classify
+omVViuDwe2c-00542-00150512-00150751 the soil with respect to v s value as
+omVViuDwe2c-00543-00150752-00151023 well as the site period t value as you
+omVViuDwe2c-00544-00151024-00151278 can see over here then japan is code
+omVViuDwe2c-00545-00151279-00151526 they also classify it with respect to vs
+omVViuDwe2c-00546-00151527-00151614 value
+omVViuDwe2c-00547-00151615-00151887 including the site period
+omVViuDwe2c-00548-00151888-00152214 then turkish code they also classified
+omVViuDwe2c-00549-00152215-00152487 with respect to vs value so vs is very
+omVViuDwe2c-00550-00152488-00152743 important parameter for the site
+omVViuDwe2c-00551-00152744-00152966 classification
+omVViuDwe2c-00552-00152967-00153159 also if we look at what are the
+omVViuDwe2c-00553-00153160-00153343 recommendations for the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00554-00153344-00153671 amplification factor for various
+omVViuDwe2c-00555-00153672-00153975 control periods for different subsoil
+omVViuDwe2c-00556-00153976-00154159 class what are the different subsoil
+omVViuDwe2c-00557-00154160-00154414 class already we have mentioned like a b
+omVViuDwe2c-00558-00154415-00154702 c d e these five are major sub class and
+omVViuDwe2c-00559-00154703-00154926 then s one s two are the other two
+omVViuDwe2c-00560-00154927-00155159 different sub class so
+omVViuDwe2c-00561-00155160-00155431 in euro code eight they have mentioned
+omVViuDwe2c-00562-00155432-00155654 that different types of earthquake they
+omVViuDwe2c-00563-00155655-00155895 have first classified one type one
+omVViuDwe2c-00564-00155896-00156078 earthquake means where the earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00565-00156079-00156287 magnitude with respect to surface wave
+omVViuDwe2c-00566-00156288-00156614 magnitude is greater than 5.5 for that
+omVViuDwe2c-00567-00156615-00156935 they mentioned what are the values for
+omVViuDwe2c-00568-00156936-00157223 different site condition a b c d e these
+omVViuDwe2c-00569-00157224-00157463 are the s factors
+omVViuDwe2c-00570-00157464-00157783 and these are various time period
+omVViuDwe2c-00571-00157784-00157943 mean time period
+omVViuDwe2c-00572-00157944-00158183 critical time period predominant time
+omVViuDwe2c-00573-00158184-00158447 period all these values and
+omVViuDwe2c-00574-00158448-00158639 these are the amplification factors
+omVViuDwe2c-00575-00158640-00159023 which you can see for e type of soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00576-00159024-00159223 it is mentioned that amplification
+omVViuDwe2c-00577-00159224-00159551 factor of 1.4 should be used for design
+omVViuDwe2c-00578-00159552-00159751 when earthquake magnitude is greater
+omVViuDwe2c-00579-00159752-00160151 than 5.5 and for a low magnitude
+omVViuDwe2c-00580-00160152-00160407 earthquake that is earthquake type 2
+omVViuDwe2c-00581-00160408-00160751 when ms value is less than 5.5 these are
+omVViuDwe2c-00582-00160752-00161047 the recommendations where you can see
+omVViuDwe2c-00583-00161048-00161254 the higher values of amplification
+omVViuDwe2c-00584-00161255-00161511 factors are proposed why because we have
+omVViuDwe2c-00585-00161512-00161807 already mentioned earlier generally the
+omVViuDwe2c-00586-00161808-00162126 low value of earthquake tends to magnify
+omVViuDwe2c-00587-00162127-00162302 more than the high value of earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00588-00162303-00162511 so this is the reason and that too it
+omVViuDwe2c-00589-00162512-00162695 depends on the soil condition whether it
+omVViuDwe2c-00590-00162696-00163087 is a soft soil if you go from a to d e
+omVViuDwe2c-00591-00163088-00163199 or d
+omVViuDwe2c-00592-00163200-00163359 that means you are going towards the
+omVViuDwe2c-00593-00163360-00163575 soft soil condition so that is why these
+omVViuDwe2c-00594-00163576-00163807 are the recommended values as per euro
+omVViuDwe2c-00595-00163808-00164166 code which are yet to be incorporated or
+omVViuDwe2c-00596-00164167-00164487 yet to be considered in our indian
+omVViuDwe2c-00597-00164488-00164751 seismic design code considering the
+omVViuDwe2c-00598-00164752-00165023 indian sub soil condition and all the
+omVViuDwe2c-00599-00165024-00165263 indian site response analysis which we
+omVViuDwe2c-00600-00165264-00165478 have discussed in our previous lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00601-00165479-00165631 thoroughly
+omVViuDwe2c-00602-00165632-00165838 then in the previous lecture we also
+omVViuDwe2c-00603-00165839-00166126 discussed about the example problem 2
+omVViuDwe2c-00604-00166127-00166343 which is the seismic ground response
+omVViuDwe2c-00605-00166344-00166631 analysis for selected 4 ports in the
+omVViuDwe2c-00606-00166632-00166863 gujarat state of india and the
+omVViuDwe2c-00607-00166864-00167087 publication in the natural hazard
+omVViuDwe2c-00608-00167088-00167407 springer journal is available i have
+omVViuDwe2c-00609-00167408-00167614 mentioned this is the detail of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00610-00167615-00167935 journal paper and for that we first
+omVViuDwe2c-00611-00167936-00168287 identified the four locations of these
+omVViuDwe2c-00612-00168288-00168502 ports kandla port mundrapod the
+omVViuDwe2c-00613-00168503-00168790 hedgeport and haziraport in gujarat with
+omVViuDwe2c-00614-00168791-00169031 their fault mapping
+omVViuDwe2c-00615-00169032-00169247 then we selected the uniform hazard
+omVViuDwe2c-00616-00169248-00169551 spectra for individual port site like
+omVViuDwe2c-00617-00169552-00169678 kandra
+omVViuDwe2c-00618-00169679-00169871 kandla port and mundra port it is
+omVViuDwe2c-00619-00169872-00170151 mentioned over here compared to is code
+omVViuDwe2c-00620-00170152-00170326 also it has been mentioned
+omVViuDwe2c-00621-00170327-00170559 corresponding to their seismic zone
+omVViuDwe2c-00622-00170560-00170911 factor as per is code 2002 version part
+omVViuDwe2c-00623-00170912-00171254 one then we had collected the
+omVViuDwe2c-00624-00171255-00171390 geotechnical
+omVViuDwe2c-00625-00171391-00171759 borehole data for each of these port
+omVViuDwe2c-00626-00171760-00172014 site at different borehole locations and
+omVViuDwe2c-00627-00172015-00172326 typical data is given from which we
+omVViuDwe2c-00628-00172327-00172623 estimated the shear wave velocity
+omVViuDwe2c-00629-00172624-00172935 profile in each of this borehole then
+omVViuDwe2c-00630-00172936-00173190 for typical synthetic time history for
+omVViuDwe2c-00631-00173191-00173414 kandla port at different
+omVViuDwe2c-00632-00173415-00173631 seismic level of ground motions with
+omVViuDwe2c-00633-00173632-00173854 different return period we got the
+omVViuDwe2c-00634-00173855-00174135 spectral acceleration versus time value
+omVViuDwe2c-00635-00174136-00174375 and the ground response analysis was
+omVViuDwe2c-00636-00174376-00174526 carried out
+omVViuDwe2c-00637-00174527-00174799 to obtain the pseudo acceleration versus
+omVViuDwe2c-00638-00174800-00175126 period considering different modulus
+omVViuDwe2c-00639-00175127-00175366 reduction curve and the damping
+omVViuDwe2c-00640-00175367-00175623 curve as proposed by various researchers
+omVViuDwe2c-00641-00175624-00175902 for different types of soil using shake
+omVViuDwe2c-00642-00175903-00176159 software
+omVViuDwe2c-00643-00176160-00176414 and the important observation what we
+omVViuDwe2c-00644-00176415-00176638 found that mostly for
+omVViuDwe2c-00645-00176639-00176966 zone 5 region where the kandla port and
+omVViuDwe2c-00646-00176967-00177190 mundra port are coming
+omVViuDwe2c-00647-00177191-00177511 actually for level 3 earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00648-00177512-00177823 the kandla port site whatever value of
+omVViuDwe2c-00649-00177824-00178078 peak ground acceleration we estimate
+omVViuDwe2c-00650-00178079-00178335 from the ground response analysis is
+omVViuDwe2c-00651-00178336-00178590 much higher than the is code recommended
+omVViuDwe2c-00652-00178591-00178871 value so these automatically shows the
+omVViuDwe2c-00653-00178872-00179038 need for
+omVViuDwe2c-00654-00179039-00179159 doing the
+omVViuDwe2c-00655-00179160-00179438 ground response analysis at an important
+omVViuDwe2c-00656-00179439-00179702 site before going for a design because
+omVViuDwe2c-00657-00179703-00179959 is code give a generalized value which
+omVViuDwe2c-00658-00179960-00180287 may not be correct or may not match at
+omVViuDwe2c-00659-00180288-00180543 particular location if there is a soft
+omVViuDwe2c-00660-00180544-00180775 soil site or some
+omVViuDwe2c-00661-00180776-00181126 not so good soil with respect to
+omVViuDwe2c-00662-00181127-00181351 foundation is concerned in terms of
+omVViuDwe2c-00663-00181352-00181559 earthquake engineering
+omVViuDwe2c-00664-00181560-00181783 so with that in the previous lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-00665-00181784-00182135 itself we completed our module 8. so in
+omVViuDwe2c-00666-00182136-00182399 today's lecture we will start with our
+omVViuDwe2c-00667-00182400-00182783 next module which is module 9. so module
+omVViuDwe2c-00668-00182784-00183183 9 we will discuss about seismic analysis
+omVViuDwe2c-00669-00183184-00183431 and design of various types of
+omVViuDwe2c-00670-00183432-00183687 geotechnical structures various types of
+omVViuDwe2c-00671-00183688-00183871 geotechnical structures within that we
+omVViuDwe2c-00672-00183872-00184054 will try to
+omVViuDwe2c-00673-00184055-00184375 include retaining wall foundations
+omVViuDwe2c-00674-00184376-00184671 waterfront retaining wall or sea wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00675-00184672-00185023 msw landfill pile
+omVViuDwe2c-00676-00185024-00185487 tailing dam slope etcetera so
+omVViuDwe2c-00677-00185488-00185790 now let us start with this sub topic
+omVViuDwe2c-00678-00185791-00186023 within this module seismic design of
+omVViuDwe2c-00679-00186024-00186263 retaining wall when we talk about
+omVViuDwe2c-00680-00186264-00186526 seismic design of retaining wall first
+omVViuDwe2c-00681-00186527-00186831 let me introduced as we all know there
+omVViuDwe2c-00682-00186832-00187047 are different types of retaining wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00683-00187048-00187350 like gravity type piling wall cantilever
+omVViuDwe2c-00684-00187351-00187623 type of wall anchored sheet pile wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00685-00187624-00187807 these are different types of retaining
+omVViuDwe2c-00686-00187808-00188087 wall this is gravity type retaining wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00687-00188088-00188302 these are rigid wall whereas anchored
+omVViuDwe2c-00688-00188303-00188438 sheet pile wall these are called
+omVViuDwe2c-00689-00188439-00188614 flexible wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00690-00188615-00188807 so those we have learnt in our
+omVViuDwe2c-00691-00188808-00189007 conventional geotechnical engineering
+omVViuDwe2c-00692-00189008-00189311 course i will not go into detail of this
+omVViuDwe2c-00693-00189312-00189599 ah different types of retaining wall we
+omVViuDwe2c-00694-00189600-00189711 will
+omVViuDwe2c-00695-00189712-00189871 consider now
+omVViuDwe2c-00696-00189872-00190135 how this knowledge of seismic earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00697-00190136-00190335 pressure that is what are the earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00698-00190336-00190614 pressure for which we need to design
+omVViuDwe2c-00699-00190615-00190814 this retaining wall need to be
+omVViuDwe2c-00700-00190815-00191063 calculated so what are the changes in
+omVViuDwe2c-00701-00191064-00191247 that value of earth pressure when we are
+omVViuDwe2c-00702-00191248-00191478 considering the effect of seismicity or
+omVViuDwe2c-00703-00191479-00191590 earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00704-00191591-00191783 so
+omVViuDwe2c-00705-00191784-00191911 what are the different types of
+omVViuDwe2c-00706-00191912-00192150 earthquake as we know majorly these are
+omVViuDwe2c-00707-00192151-00192414 three types at rest earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00708-00192415-00192663 when there is no movement of the wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00709-00192664-00192902 then the pressure exerted on the wall is
+omVViuDwe2c-00710-00192903-00193126 nothing but at rest condition
+omVViuDwe2c-00711-00193127-00193350 active state of earth pressure when wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00712-00193351-00193663 moves away from the backfill then the
+omVViuDwe2c-00713-00193664-00193759 pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00714-00193760-00193983 exerted by the soil on the wall is
+omVViuDwe2c-00715-00193984-00194223 called active state of earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00716-00194224-00194590 and when wall moves towards the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00717-00194591-00194902 then soil provides the resistance which
+omVViuDwe2c-00718-00194903-00195166 is called passive earth resistance that
+omVViuDwe2c-00719-00195167-00195383 is the correct terminology though we
+omVViuDwe2c-00720-00195384-00195599 also use the terminology passive earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00721-00195600-00195719 pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00722-00195720-00195926 so these are the three different types
+omVViuDwe2c-00723-00195927-00196199 of earth pressure as we all know from
+omVViuDwe2c-00724-00196200-00196407 our basic knowledge of geotechnical
+omVViuDwe2c-00725-00196408-00196519 engineering
+omVViuDwe2c-00726-00196520-00196814 now failure of retaining wall there are
+omVViuDwe2c-00727-00196815-00197111 several cases worldwide that during the
+omVViuDwe2c-00728-00197112-00197438 earthquake retaining walls fail due to
+omVViuDwe2c-00729-00197439-00197743 the additional destabilizing earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00730-00197744-00198038 forces so in what way this earthquake
+omVViuDwe2c-00731-00198039-00198383 forces induce the additional forces on
+omVViuDwe2c-00732-00198384-00198607 this retaining wall for which probably
+omVViuDwe2c-00733-00198608-00198895 it was not designed or analyzed that is
+omVViuDwe2c-00734-00198896-00199111 why there were several damages as you
+omVViuDwe2c-00735-00199112-00199543 can see from some of this pictures
+omVViuDwe2c-00736-00199544-00199631 so
+omVViuDwe2c-00737-00199632-00199807 when we are talking about seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00738-00199808-00200023 analysis and design of these retaining
+omVViuDwe2c-00739-00200024-00200159 walls
+omVViuDwe2c-00740-00200160-00200463 it mainly consists of determining the
+omVViuDwe2c-00741-00200464-00200699 magnitude of that additional
+omVViuDwe2c-00742-00200700-00201014 destabilizing force that act during an
+omVViuDwe2c-00743-00201015-00201302 earthquake so there will be static state
+omVViuDwe2c-00744-00201303-00201526 of earth pressure on the wall depending
+omVViuDwe2c-00745-00201527-00201775 on the movement of the wall in addition
+omVViuDwe2c-00746-00201776-00202054 to that there will be some extra earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00747-00202055-00202335 pressure which is because of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00748-00202336-00202607 earthquake which we need to estimate
+omVViuDwe2c-00749-00202608-00202895 properly now determining the seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00750-00202896-00203078 active and seismic passive earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00751-00203079-00203375 pressure due to destabilizing forces
+omVViuDwe2c-00752-00203376-00203750 means we are finally going to obtain
+omVViuDwe2c-00753-00203751-00204007 combined earth pressure which is under
+omVViuDwe2c-00754-00204008-00204319 static condition plus under the seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00755-00204320-00204654 condition and the design section which
+omVViuDwe2c-00756-00204655-00204942 needs to be selected after computing the
+omVViuDwe2c-00757-00204944-00205175 seismic active or passive earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00758-00205176-00205438 depending on which case of movement of
+omVViuDwe2c-00759-00205439-00205598 wall is occurring
+omVViuDwe2c-00760-00205600-00205766 based on the
+omVViuDwe2c-00761-00205767-00206062 above parameters by using two basic
+omVViuDwe2c-00762-00206063-00206271 approach there are two basic approach
+omVViuDwe2c-00763-00206271-00206486 what are those approach one is called
+omVViuDwe2c-00764-00206487-00206758 force based approach another is called
+omVViuDwe2c-00765-00206759-00206998 displacement based approach in force
+omVViuDwe2c-00766-00207000-00207246 based approach generally we consider all
+omVViuDwe2c-00767-00207248-00207455 the forces involved
+omVViuDwe2c-00768-00207456-00207631 in the
+omVViuDwe2c-00769-00207632-00207982 estimation of earth pressure that is
+omVViuDwe2c-00770-00207983-00208182 weight of the failure zone weight of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00771-00208183-00208494 wall reaction from the soil etcetera to
+omVViuDwe2c-00772-00208496-00208823 obtain what is the pressure exerted on
+omVViuDwe2c-00773-00208823-00208910 the
+omVViuDwe2c-00774-00208911-00209206 wall that is force based approach we can
+omVViuDwe2c-00775-00209207-00209471 either use limit equilibrium method or
+omVViuDwe2c-00776-00209471-00209662 limit analysis or method of
+omVViuDwe2c-00777-00209663-00209894 characteristics etcetera
+omVViuDwe2c-00778-00209896-00210119 another approach is displacement based
+omVViuDwe2c-00779-00210119-00210431 approach where we take care of how much
+omVViuDwe2c-00780-00210432-00210758 displacement of the wall we can permit
+omVViuDwe2c-00781-00210759-00210998 there will be a permissible amount of
+omVViuDwe2c-00782-00211000-00211223 displacement and based on that earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00783-00211223-00211439 pressure etcetera needs to be calculated
+omVViuDwe2c-00784-00211440-00211831 so if we look at this slide
+omVViuDwe2c-00785-00211832-00212119 for performance based design if we talk
+omVViuDwe2c-00786-00212119-00212534 about that any wall how it performs we
+omVViuDwe2c-00787-00212535-00212798 need to design for that then we should
+omVViuDwe2c-00788-00212800-00213039 go for this displacement based approach
+omVViuDwe2c-00789-00213040-00213342 where we can monitor or we can find out
+omVViuDwe2c-00790-00213344-00213615 or we can estimate how much displacement
+omVViuDwe2c-00791-00213616-00213863 of the wall it can be translational it
+omVViuDwe2c-00792-00213864-00214046 can be rotational displacement how much
+omVViuDwe2c-00793-00214048-00214334 it is occurring
+omVViuDwe2c-00794-00214335-00214639 now before we start estimating the
+omVViuDwe2c-00795-00214640-00214998 seismic earth pressure let me
+omVViuDwe2c-00796-00215000-00215246 tell you the basic methods which are
+omVViuDwe2c-00797-00215248-00215479 available the very basic fundamental
+omVViuDwe2c-00798-00215480-00215758 method is known as pseudostatic method
+omVViuDwe2c-00799-00215759-00216023 what is the pseudostatic method as the
+omVViuDwe2c-00800-00216023-00216358 name suggests pseudostatic or in other
+omVViuDwe2c-00801-00216359-00216655 word it is called quash static also in
+omVViuDwe2c-00802-00216656-00216903 this case theoretical background of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00803-00216904-00217158 seismic coefficient lies in the
+omVViuDwe2c-00804-00217159-00217382 application of d lambert's principle
+omVViuDwe2c-00805-00217383-00217687 which we have already learnt in our soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00806-00217688-00217894 dynamics course as well as this course
+omVViuDwe2c-00807-00217896-00218055 also in the beginning
+omVViuDwe2c-00808-00218056-00218358 principle of mechanics so suppose
+omVViuDwe2c-00809-00218359-00218710 this is a failure zone of the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-00810-00218711-00218967 which is having a weight of w
+omVViuDwe2c-00811-00218967-00219263 now there will be horizontal component
+omVViuDwe2c-00812-00219264-00219606 of seismic acceleration if we take the
+omVViuDwe2c-00813-00219607-00219942 coefficient of that seismic acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00814-00219944-00220287 multiplied with that failure mass or
+omVViuDwe2c-00815-00220288-00220558 failure weight then what we get that
+omVViuDwe2c-00816-00220559-00220791 force will give us nothing but the
+omVViuDwe2c-00817-00220792-00221039 inertia force this is called seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00818-00221040-00221191 inertia force
+omVViuDwe2c-00819-00221192-00221487 due to the horizontal acceleration of
+omVViuDwe2c-00820-00221488-00221775 earthquake so this coefficient is known
+omVViuDwe2c-00821-00221776-00222110 as pseudostatic axismic acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00822-00222111-00222334 coefficient so what will be the seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-00823-00222335-00222710 acceleration k times g g where small g
+omVViuDwe2c-00824-00222711-00222894 is the acceleration due to gravity that
+omVViuDwe2c-00825-00222896-00223255 will be the acceleration value and how
+omVViuDwe2c-00826-00223256-00223455 to select that value there are various
+omVViuDwe2c-00827-00223456-00223694 methods like terzaghi has proposed
+omVViuDwe2c-00828-00223696-00223855 depending on
+omVViuDwe2c-00829-00223856-00224142 severity of the earthquake whether one
+omVViuDwe2c-00830-00224144-00224423 can consider this k value as half of the
+omVViuDwe2c-00831-00224423-00224703 peak ground acceleration or two third of
+omVViuDwe2c-00832-00224704-00224927 the peak ground acceleration or one
+omVViuDwe2c-00833-00224928-00225094 third of the peak ground acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-00834-00225096-00225398 that depends on what type of
+omVViuDwe2c-00835-00225400-00225639 earthquake severity you are considering
+omVViuDwe2c-00836-00225640-00225791 for your design
+omVViuDwe2c-00837-00225792-00226127 so the pseudostatic method basically was
+omVViuDwe2c-00838-00226128-00226527 initially proposed by tarzaghi in 1950
+omVViuDwe2c-00839-00226528-00226791 so after that several researchers have
+omVViuDwe2c-00840-00226792-00227127 worked on this very basic fundamental or
+omVViuDwe2c-00841-00227128-00227439 simplified method of pseudostatic method
+omVViuDwe2c-00842-00227440-00227623 where this
+omVViuDwe2c-00843-00227623-00227927 just a coefficient is multiplied with
+omVViuDwe2c-00844-00227928-00228063 respect to the
+omVViuDwe2c-00845-00228064-00228382 failure mass to get the seismic inertia
+omVViuDwe2c-00846-00228383-00228551 force this
+omVViuDwe2c-00847-00228552-00228855 portion has been taken from the book by
+omVViuDwe2c-00848-00228856-00229223 professor iko tohata sitohata 2008 this
+omVViuDwe2c-00849-00229223-00229439 is the book reference geotechnical
+omVViuDwe2c-00850-00229440-00229682 earthquake engineering published by
+omVViuDwe2c-00851-00229683-00229839 springer
+omVViuDwe2c-00852-00229840-00230127 you can see when static inertia force
+omVViuDwe2c-00853-00230128-00230398 acts when there is an acceleration a
+omVViuDwe2c-00854-00230400-00230751 there will be the inertia force that a
+omVViuDwe2c-00855-00230752-00231063 times w divided by g this small g is
+omVViuDwe2c-00856-00231064-00231351 nothing but acceleration due to gravity
+omVViuDwe2c-00857-00231352-00231671 that is 9.81 meter per second square so
+omVViuDwe2c-00858-00231671-00231982 this similar way a by g gives you this
+omVViuDwe2c-00859-00231983-00232191 coefficient k as i have already
+omVViuDwe2c-00860-00232192-00232415 mentioned so this is nothing but called
+omVViuDwe2c-00861-00232416-00232694 pseudostatic coefficient which you can
+omVViuDwe2c-00862-00232696-00232903 multiply with respect to any failure
+omVViuDwe2c-00863-00232904-00233167 zone and get your seismic analysis with
+omVViuDwe2c-00864-00233167-00233431 respect to the pseudostatic approach can
+omVViuDwe2c-00865-00233432-00233510 be
+omVViuDwe2c-00866-00233511-00233615 done
+omVViuDwe2c-00867-00233616-00233782 so the
+omVViuDwe2c-00868-00233783-00234031 basic concept of the pseudostatic
+omVViuDwe2c-00869-00234032-00234287 approach for the seismic design or
+omVViuDwe2c-00870-00234288-00234510 seismic analysis of retaining wall was
+omVViuDwe2c-00871-00234511-00234951 proposed by mononover matso in 1929
+omVViuDwe2c-00872-00234952-00235463 and okabe in 1926 which combinedly known
+omVViuDwe2c-00873-00235464-00235727 as mononove okabe method of nineteen
+omVViuDwe2c-00874-00235728-00235958 twenty nine so this mononobe okabe
+omVViuDwe2c-00875-00235959-00236439 method is the pioneering work in this
+omVViuDwe2c-00876-00236440-00236646 seismic design of retaining wall using
+omVViuDwe2c-00877-00236648-00236951 this concept of pseudostatic approach so
+omVViuDwe2c-00878-00236952-00237215 what they had proposed suppose this is a
+omVViuDwe2c-00879-00237216-00237519 gravity type rigid retaining wall
+omVViuDwe2c-00880-00237519-00237871 section and if the wall tends to move in
+omVViuDwe2c-00881-00237871-00238103 this side where you have a back fill
+omVViuDwe2c-00882-00238104-00238334 level at this height
+omVViuDwe2c-00883-00238335-00238551 on the left side of the wall and on the
+omVViuDwe2c-00884-00238552-00238782 right side you have this much height of
+omVViuDwe2c-00885-00238783-00238998 the backfill so if the wall tends to
+omVViuDwe2c-00886-00239000-00239255 move in this direction obviously active
+omVViuDwe2c-00887-00239256-00239439 state of earth pressure will be formed
+omVViuDwe2c-00888-00239440-00239646 at this side and
+omVViuDwe2c-00889-00239648-00239823 passive state of earth pressure will get
+omVViuDwe2c-00890-00239823-00240134 generated on this side right
+omVViuDwe2c-00891-00240135-00240471 so mononove okabe they considered
+omVViuDwe2c-00892-00240471-00240606 actually
+omVViuDwe2c-00893-00240607-00240894 they extended the conventional earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00894-00240896-00241119 pressure theory of coulombs earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00895-00241119-00241334 pressure theory what was the coulomb's
+omVViuDwe2c-00896-00241335-00241542 earth pressure theory as we know
+omVViuDwe2c-00897-00241544-00241798 planar failure surface was considered
+omVViuDwe2c-00898-00241800-00242023 and various planar failure surface that
+omVViuDwe2c-00899-00242023-00242271 is this angle of failure plane with
+omVViuDwe2c-00900-00242271-00242503 respect to horizontal that has been
+omVViuDwe2c-00901-00242504-00242719 varied in such a way that
+omVViuDwe2c-00902-00242719-00242951 this active earth pressure which is
+omVViuDwe2c-00903-00242952-00243279 acting on the wall is maximized because
+omVViuDwe2c-00904-00243280-00243551 we know what should be the design value
+omVViuDwe2c-00905-00243552-00243703 of active earth pressure that should be
+omVViuDwe2c-00906-00243704-00243975 the maximum value of this what we should
+omVViuDwe2c-00907-00243976-00244319 get through trial and error procedure so
+omVViuDwe2c-00908-00244319-00244567 to get that trial and error procedure
+omVViuDwe2c-00909-00244567-00244839 either mathematically in the closed form
+omVViuDwe2c-00910-00244840-00245119 solution it can be obtained in terms of
+omVViuDwe2c-00911-00245119-00245351 by differentiating with respect to this
+omVViuDwe2c-00912-00245352-00245542 failure angle
+omVViuDwe2c-00913-00245544-00245871 the total earth pressure component what
+omVViuDwe2c-00914-00245871-00246087 method was used by coulomb earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00915-00246088-00246303 pressure theory just simple equilibrium
+omVViuDwe2c-00916-00246304-00246534 method of all the forces what are the
+omVViuDwe2c-00917-00246535-00246806 forces this is the earth pressure force
+omVViuDwe2c-00918-00246807-00247094 this is the weight and there will be a
+omVViuDwe2c-00919-00247096-00247646 soil reaction so if i show here how the
+omVViuDwe2c-00920-00247648-00248287 coulombic
+omVViuDwe2c-00921-00248288-00248734 earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-00922-00248735-00248927 let us say for active state of earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00923-00248928-00249079 pressure this is the rigid retaining
+omVViuDwe2c-00924-00249080-00249375 wall and we are mentioning that this
+omVViuDwe2c-00925-00249376-00249679 wall is moving towards this side so this
+omVViuDwe2c-00926-00249680-00249887 is an active state of earth pressure as
+omVViuDwe2c-00927-00249888-00250071 coulombs theory says
+omVViuDwe2c-00928-00250071-00250342 we take this failure plane this failure
+omVViuDwe2c-00929-00250344-00250534 plane can be considered a different
+omVViuDwe2c-00930-00250535-00250894 failure angle as we all know
+omVViuDwe2c-00931-00250896-00251103 there will be forces like
+omVViuDwe2c-00932-00251104-00251310 weight of this failure plane
+omVViuDwe2c-00933-00251311-00251934 and
+omVViuDwe2c-00934-00251935-00252158 this will be
+omVViuDwe2c-00935-00252159-00252367 active earth pressure acting at an angle
+omVViuDwe2c-00936-00252367-00252646 delta with respect to normal to this
+omVViuDwe2c-00937-00252648-00252975 wall delta is wall friction angle pa is
+omVViuDwe2c-00938-00252976-00253206 active state of earth pressure and on
+omVViuDwe2c-00939-00253207-00253567 this side of the wedge there will be
+omVViuDwe2c-00940-00253567-00253903 soil reaction r which will act at an
+omVViuDwe2c-00941-00253904-00254046 angle phi
+omVViuDwe2c-00942-00254048-00254263 phi is the soil friction angle this is
+omVViuDwe2c-00943-00254264-00254598 the normal to this failure plane so that
+omVViuDwe2c-00944-00254600-00254887 is simplified coulombs method of earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00945-00254888-00255063 pressure for active state of earth
+omVViuDwe2c-00946-00255064-00255287 pressure as we all know where these
+omVViuDwe2c-00947-00255288-00255471 three forces must maintain the
+omVViuDwe2c-00948-00255471-00255710 equilibrium and for a two dimensional
+omVViuDwe2c-00949-00255711-00255863 problem because retaining wall is
+omVViuDwe2c-00950-00255864-00256087 nothing but a plane strain problem as we
+omVViuDwe2c-00951-00256088-00256375 know it runs for several meters or even
+omVViuDwe2c-00952-00256376-00256655 kilometers also so for this plane strain
+omVViuDwe2c-00953-00256656-00256903 problem for this two dimensional problem
+omVViuDwe2c-00954-00256904-00257342 what we consider that these three forces
+omVViuDwe2c-00955-00257344-00257687 must be concurrent forces
+omVViuDwe2c-00956-00257688-00257879 that is w
+omVViuDwe2c-00957-00257880-00258071 p a and r
+omVViuDwe2c-00958-00258071-00258415 should pass through a single point
+omVViuDwe2c-00959-00258416-00258646 that is what we call concurrent forces
+omVViuDwe2c-00960-00258648-00258967 so by using the force polygon
+omVViuDwe2c-00961-00258967-00259110 like this
+omVViuDwe2c-00962-00259111-00259367 w
+omVViuDwe2c-00963-00259367-00259510 p a
+omVViuDwe2c-00964-00259511-00259919 and r
+omVViuDwe2c-00965-00259919-00260175 this w is known to us for a chosen
+omVViuDwe2c-00966-00260176-00260471 failure surface because geometry is
+omVViuDwe2c-00967-00260471-00260575 known
+omVViuDwe2c-00968-00260576-00260767 by knowing the
+omVViuDwe2c-00969-00260767-00260991 unit weight of this
+omVViuDwe2c-00970-00260992-00261230 soil we can compute w
+omVViuDwe2c-00971-00261231-00261479 because area times unit weight
+omVViuDwe2c-00972-00261480-00261734 multiplied with unit
+omVViuDwe2c-00973-00261735-00262063 length on that side will give us the
+omVViuDwe2c-00974-00262064-00262303 weight of this failure zone so w is
+omVViuDwe2c-00975-00262304-00262558 known also its direction of acting is
+omVViuDwe2c-00976-00262559-00262830 known because it acts always vertically
+omVViuDwe2c-00977-00262831-00263351 downwards okay so this
+omVViuDwe2c-00978-00263352-00263582 vector is completely known this force
+omVViuDwe2c-00979-00263583-00263775 vector in terms of its direction and
+omVViuDwe2c-00980-00263776-00263910 magnitude
+omVViuDwe2c-00981-00263911-00264151 whereas for this r
+omVViuDwe2c-00982-00264152-00264334 we only know the direction we do not
+omVViuDwe2c-00983-00264335-00264623 know the value we need to obtain that
+omVViuDwe2c-00984-00264624-00264927 for p a also we only know the direction
+omVViuDwe2c-00985-00264928-00265158 we do not know the value which we need
+omVViuDwe2c-00986-00265159-00265423 to obtain so what we can do if we know
+omVViuDwe2c-00987-00265424-00265551 the direction
+omVViuDwe2c-00988-00265552-00265967 with respect to w we know the
+omVViuDwe2c-00989-00265968-00266199 line of action of this p pa so we first
+omVViuDwe2c-00990-00266200-00266503 draw this line and with respect to w we
+omVViuDwe2c-00991-00266504-00266767 know the line of action this r so we
+omVViuDwe2c-00992-00266768-00266958 draw that line so wherever they
+omVViuDwe2c-00993-00266959-00267271 intersect that is nothing but giving us
+omVViuDwe2c-00994-00267272-00267399 from this
+omVViuDwe2c-00995-00267400-00267823 force polygon the value of p a this will
+omVViuDwe2c-00996-00267824-00268095 be the value of p a value of r and their
+omVViuDwe2c-00997-00268096-00268319 direction was already known so in that
+omVViuDwe2c-00998-00268320-00268623 way we get the value of design value of
+omVViuDwe2c-00999-00268624-00268927 active earth pressure now by changing
+omVViuDwe2c-01000-00268928-00269255 this failure angle row we will get
+omVViuDwe2c-01001-00269256-00269615 different weight w and different values
+omVViuDwe2c-01002-00269616-00269943 of p a and r combination so through that
+omVViuDwe2c-01003-00269944-00270191 whichever gives us the maximum value of
+omVViuDwe2c-01004-00270192-00270599 p a so we have to maximize this pa so
+omVViuDwe2c-01005-00270600-00270791 maximum value of pa will give us the
+omVViuDwe2c-01006-00270792-00271055 design value that we know so now what
+omVViuDwe2c-01007-00271056-00271343 are the changes mononove okabe did with
+omVViuDwe2c-01008-00271344-00271679 respect to this
+omVViuDwe2c-01009-00271680-00271967 ah coulombs earth pressure approach they
+omVViuDwe2c-01010-00271968-00272087 mentioned
+omVViuDwe2c-01011-00272088-00272343 now
+omVViuDwe2c-01012-00272344-00272558 they added
+omVViuDwe2c-01013-00272559-00272910 two more forces one is this one
+omVViuDwe2c-01014-00272911-00273191 another is this one what are these extra
+omVViuDwe2c-01015-00273192-00273630 forces this is kh times w and this is kv
+omVViuDwe2c-01016-00273631-00273958 times w what are kh and kv
+omVViuDwe2c-01017-00273959-00274439 kh times g is nothing but horizontal
+omVViuDwe2c-01018-00274440-00274639 seismic acceleration
+omVViuDwe2c-01019-00274640-00274806 and
+omVViuDwe2c-01020-00274807-00274895 this
+omVViuDwe2c-01021-00274896-00275158 k v times g is
+omVViuDwe2c-01022-00275159-00275447 vertical seismic acceleration as we know
+omVViuDwe2c-01023-00275448-00275695 the seismic accelerations acts in both
+omVViuDwe2c-01024-00275696-00275999 the cycles that is it will act both
+omVViuDwe2c-01025-00276000-00276239 vertically down as well as up
+omVViuDwe2c-01026-00276240-00276510 also this seismic acceleration will act
+omVViuDwe2c-01027-00276511-00276799 towards left as well as towards right
+omVViuDwe2c-01028-00276800-00277030 so for the analysis
+omVViuDwe2c-01029-00277031-00277303 we need to take all the combinations k h
+omVViuDwe2c-01030-00277304-00277647 w acting in this direction also in this
+omVViuDwe2c-01031-00277648-00277927 direction k v w also acting in this
+omVViuDwe2c-01032-00277928-00278239 direction also in this direction and
+omVViuDwe2c-01033-00278240-00278439 then considering
+omVViuDwe2c-01034-00278440-00278703 this forces equilibrium of all these
+omVViuDwe2c-01035-00278704-00279071 forces one need to obtain this
+omVViuDwe2c-01036-00279072-00279239 active earth pressure again under
+omVViuDwe2c-01037-00279240-00279447 earthquake condition so in that case it
+omVViuDwe2c-01038-00279448-00279710 will be p a e
+omVViuDwe2c-01039-00279711-00279830 right
+omVViuDwe2c-01040-00279831-00279975 so
+omVViuDwe2c-01041-00279976-00280247 there will be a critical value or
+omVViuDwe2c-01042-00280248-00280487 critical combinations of this k h and k
+omVViuDwe2c-01043-00280488-00280734 v which will give us the value of this
+omVViuDwe2c-01044-00280735-00281047 seismic active earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-01045-00281048-00281423 so with this if we look at this slide
+omVViuDwe2c-01046-00281424-00281543 over here
+omVViuDwe2c-01047-00281544-00281727 it says
+omVViuDwe2c-01048-00281728-00281958 k h and k v remember these are not the
+omVViuDwe2c-01049-00281959-00282255 fixed direction it can change it is
+omVViuDwe2c-01050-00282256-00282519 in one calculation you should take k h
+omVViuDwe2c-01051-00282520-00282703 in this direction another calculation
+omVViuDwe2c-01052-00282704-00282943 you should take in this direction k v in
+omVViuDwe2c-01053-00282944-00283110 one combination in this direction
+omVViuDwe2c-01054-00283111-00283255 another combination this direction so
+omVViuDwe2c-01055-00283256-00283382 there will be
+omVViuDwe2c-01056-00283383-00283479 four
+omVViuDwe2c-01057-00283480-00283767 iterative methods four combinations k h
+omVViuDwe2c-01058-00283768-00284087 k v in this form k h k b in this form k
+omVViuDwe2c-01059-00284088-00284319 h k v in this form and k h kv in this
+omVViuDwe2c-01060-00284320-00284463 form ok
+omVViuDwe2c-01061-00284464-00284671 with that whatever
+omVViuDwe2c-01062-00284672-00284910 optimized value or maximized value of p
+omVViuDwe2c-01063-00284911-00285175 a you will get that will give you the
+omVViuDwe2c-01064-00285176-00285303 seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-01065-00285304-00285503 active earth pressure using this
+omVViuDwe2c-01066-00285504-00285743 mononovocabus pseudostatic approach
+omVViuDwe2c-01067-00285744-00285982 similarly for passive earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-01068-00285983-00286287 also you need to consider it is also an
+omVViuDwe2c-01069-00286288-00286503 extension of coulombs earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-01070-00286504-00286815 theory for passive case for passive case
+omVViuDwe2c-01071-00286816-00287030 again we know the changes of the
+omVViuDwe2c-01072-00287031-00287334 coulombs theory like
+omVViuDwe2c-01073-00287335-00287599 if we consider the passive state of
+omVViuDwe2c-01074-00287600-00288087 earth pressure
+omVViuDwe2c-01075-00288088-00288391 that means the wall tends to move
+omVViuDwe2c-01076-00288392-00288719 towards the backfill side in that case
+omVViuDwe2c-01077-00288720-00289030 if we select a failure zone like this
+omVViuDwe2c-01078-00289031-00289303 at an angle say rho
+omVViuDwe2c-01079-00289304-00289406 weight
+omVViuDwe2c-01080-00289407-00289687 of this failure zone is w
+omVViuDwe2c-01081-00289688-00289791 and
+omVViuDwe2c-01082-00289792-00290247 this is normal to the wall this will be
+omVViuDwe2c-01083-00290248-00290495 p p passive earth pressure at an angle
+omVViuDwe2c-01084-00290496-00290615 delta
+omVViuDwe2c-01085-00290616-00291039 friction angle wall friction angle and
+omVViuDwe2c-01086-00291040-00291406 soil reaction will be r at an angle phi
+omVViuDwe2c-01087-00291407-00291767 with phi is the soil friction angle
+omVViuDwe2c-01088-00291768-00291847 ok
+omVViuDwe2c-01089-00291848-00292223 so again these three forces
+omVViuDwe2c-01090-00292224-00292367 should be
+omVViuDwe2c-01091-00292368-00292503 concurrent
+omVViuDwe2c-01092-00292504-00292647 then
+omVViuDwe2c-01093-00292648-00293023 it will
+omVViuDwe2c-01094-00293024-00293310 be in equilibrium so equilibrium has to
+omVViuDwe2c-01095-00293311-00293519 be maintained
+omVViuDwe2c-01096-00293520-00293758 that is coulombs earth pressure theory
+omVViuDwe2c-01097-00293759-00294054 here also the additional parameters
+omVViuDwe2c-01098-00294055-00294399 which were introduced by mononove okabe
+omVViuDwe2c-01099-00294400-00294654 like this k h
+omVViuDwe2c-01100-00294655-00294951 times w in the horizontal seismic
+omVViuDwe2c-01101-00294952-00295158 inertia force and
+omVViuDwe2c-01102-00295159-00295415 the vertical
+omVViuDwe2c-01103-00295416-00295710 k v times w vertical seismic inertia
+omVViuDwe2c-01104-00295711-00295943 force now considering these forces and
+omVViuDwe2c-01105-00295944-00296191 maintaining equilibrium in this case we
+omVViuDwe2c-01106-00296192-00296303 have to
+omVViuDwe2c-01107-00296304-00296606 what we need to do we need to
+omVViuDwe2c-01108-00296607-00296910 minimize this p p value because we know
+omVViuDwe2c-01109-00296911-00297071 for
+omVViuDwe2c-01110-00297072-00297247 passive earth pressure case the design
+omVViuDwe2c-01111-00297248-00297471 value is nothing but the minimum why
+omVViuDwe2c-01112-00297472-00297679 because it is the resistance of the soil
+omVViuDwe2c-01113-00297680-00298215 provided so as it is a resistance it is
+omVViuDwe2c-01114-00298216-00298399 so
+omVViuDwe2c-01115-00298400-00298687 what we know in this case w we know the
+omVViuDwe2c-01116-00298688-00298887 complete vector that is their magnitude
+omVViuDwe2c-01117-00298888-00299110 and direction now for
+omVViuDwe2c-01118-00299111-00299343 line of action of r we know only the
+omVViuDwe2c-01119-00299344-00299647 direction for line of action of p p we
+omVViuDwe2c-01120-00299648-00299910 only know the direction so
+omVViuDwe2c-01121-00299911-00300175 where they intersect that gives us the
+omVViuDwe2c-01122-00300176-00300334 value of this
+omVViuDwe2c-01123-00300335-00300758 r and pp so this value of pp what we get
+omVViuDwe2c-01124-00300759-00301095 from the design by this equilibrium or
+omVViuDwe2c-01125-00301096-00301327 closed force polygon
+omVViuDwe2c-01126-00301328-00301582 that we have to minimize as i said with
+omVViuDwe2c-01127-00301583-00301767 respect to different selection of this
+omVViuDwe2c-01128-00301768-00302015 row value which is known now additional
+omVViuDwe2c-01129-00302016-00302263 forces these things comes here and
+omVViuDwe2c-01130-00302264-00302503 accordingly the
+omVViuDwe2c-01131-00302504-00302734 analysis needs to be done or equilibrium
+omVViuDwe2c-01132-00302735-00302951 has to be maintained
+omVViuDwe2c-01133-00302952-00303247 but now after talking about how to
+omVViuDwe2c-01134-00303248-00303527 estimate the pseudostatic
+omVViuDwe2c-01135-00303528-00303727 active and passive earth pressure as
+omVViuDwe2c-01136-00303728-00303982 proposed by mononova and okabe
+omVViuDwe2c-01137-00303983-00304175 the major questions
+omVViuDwe2c-01138-00304176-00304406 arises here like
+omVViuDwe2c-01139-00304407-00304671 what value of kh and kv should be used
+omVViuDwe2c-01140-00304672-00304830 for design
+omVViuDwe2c-01141-00304831-00305039 because in the pseudostatic approach we
+omVViuDwe2c-01142-00305040-00305271 are just considering a coefficient but
+omVViuDwe2c-01143-00305272-00305567 after learning the geotechnical
+omVViuDwe2c-01144-00305568-00305782 earthquake engineering we all know this
+omVViuDwe2c-01145-00305783-00306054 cage and kv is not at all constant over
+omVViuDwe2c-01146-00306055-00306287 the depth of the soil layer it varies
+omVViuDwe2c-01147-00306288-00306495 with respect to depth it varies with
+omVViuDwe2c-01148-00306496-00306654 respect to time it is a dynamic
+omVViuDwe2c-01149-00306655-00306895 parameter it is not a static or quash
+omVViuDwe2c-01150-00306896-00307182 static or pseudostatic as it is assumed
+omVViuDwe2c-01151-00307183-00307447 in this analysis so that is a big
+omVViuDwe2c-01152-00307448-00307695 question always lies in the pseudostatic
+omVViuDwe2c-01153-00307696-00307910 approach which can be considered as one
+omVViuDwe2c-01154-00307911-00308191 of the major limitation of this method
+omVViuDwe2c-01155-00308192-00308487 itself inherent limitation
+omVViuDwe2c-01156-00308488-00308775 then soil amplification we already
+omVViuDwe2c-01157-00308776-00309054 learned that soil amplif gets amplified
+omVViuDwe2c-01158-00309055-00309143 when
+omVViuDwe2c-01159-00309144-00309375 earthquake motion travels through soft
+omVViuDwe2c-01160-00309376-00309654 soil right so that soil amplification we
+omVViuDwe2c-01161-00309655-00309927 cannot consider in this pseudostatic
+omVViuDwe2c-01162-00309928-00310206 approach there is no scope to consider
+omVViuDwe2c-01163-00310207-00310406 soil amplification in this design of
+omVViuDwe2c-01164-00310407-00310567 pseudostatic approach
+omVViuDwe2c-01165-00310568-00310743 also what is the variation of this
+omVViuDwe2c-01166-00310744-00310958 seismic acceleration with respect to
+omVViuDwe2c-01167-00310959-00311343 depth and with respect to time is
+omVViuDwe2c-01168-00311344-00311567 nowhere where we can consider these
+omVViuDwe2c-01169-00311568-00311671 things
+omVViuDwe2c-01170-00311672-00311863 another thing what are the effects of
+omVViuDwe2c-01171-00311864-00312151 this dynamic soil properties whether
+omVViuDwe2c-01172-00312152-00312479 irrespective of soil type if we select
+omVViuDwe2c-01173-00312480-00312782 just a single value of kh say
+omVViuDwe2c-01174-00312783-00312943 0.2
+omVViuDwe2c-01175-00312944-00313199 and kv say 0.1
+omVViuDwe2c-01176-00313200-00313406 will the design
+omVViuDwe2c-01177-00313407-00313758 of the wall in clay soil in
+omVViuDwe2c-01178-00313759-00314030 sandy soil in loose sand in dense and
+omVViuDwe2c-01179-00314031-00314239 everything remains same
+omVViuDwe2c-01180-00314240-00314527 as per pseudostatic approach it says yes
+omVViuDwe2c-01181-00314528-00314775 there is no other chance to
+omVViuDwe2c-01182-00314776-00314927 take a
+omVViuDwe2c-01183-00314928-00315199 into all these considerations of soil
+omVViuDwe2c-01184-00315200-00315382 parameters and their effect dynamic
+omVViuDwe2c-01185-00315383-00315703 nature etc in the pseudostatic design so
+omVViuDwe2c-01186-00315704-00316006 these are the major limitations of this
+omVViuDwe2c-01187-00316007-00316310 conventional pseudostatic approach
+omVViuDwe2c-01188-00316311-00316534 now how to overcome this pseudostatic
+omVViuDwe2c-01189-00316535-00316815 approach we will see soon
+omVViuDwe2c-01190-00316816-00317006 so we will
+omVViuDwe2c-01191-00317007-00317254 end our today's lecture here we will
+omVViuDwe2c-01192-00317255-00318479 continue further in the next lecture
+omVViuDwe2c-01193-00318480-00318780 bye
+ombwRYmX6SA-00000-00000786-00002318 [Music]
+ombwRYmX6SA-00001-00002319-00002900 do
+ombwRYmX6SA-00004-00012120-00012385 do
+ombwRYmX6SA-00005-00012386-00014903 [Music]
+ombwRYmX6SA-00006-00014904-00015543 do
+ombwRYmX6SA-00007-00015544-00017543 [Music]
+ombwRYmX6SA-00008-00017544-00017668 do
+ombwRYmX6SA-00009-00017669-00019967 [Music]
+ombwRYmX6SA-00010-00019968-00020176 you
+po1qVWri8Su-00000-00000206-00000409 you'll usually want to give your card
+po1qVWri8Su-00001-00000409-00000709 categories meaningful names category
+po1qVWri8Su-00002-00000710-00000922 names can be edited by right-clicking or
+po1qVWri8Su-00003-00000923-00001248 double-clicking
+po1qVWri8Su-00004-00001249-00001485 to start adding cuts to a category
+po1qVWri8Su-00005-00001486-00001676 here's a right click somewhere in the
+po1qVWri8Su-00006-00001677-00001929 card pane and select add a card or hit
+po1qVWri8Su-00007-00001930-00002082 the plus button at the bottom of the
+po1qVWri8Su-00008-00002083-00002319 card Bain
+po1qVWri8Su-00009-00002320-00003188 the cardio data will pop up
+po1qVWri8Su-00010-00003189-00003869 into some text for the front of the card
+po1qVWri8Su-00011-00003870-00004058 switch to the back of the card by
+po1qVWri8Su-00012-00004059-00004289 pressing the flip button or by hitting
+po1qVWri8Su-00013-00004290-00004734 control F on the keyboard
+po1qVWri8Su-00014-00004735-00004926 then type in the text for the back
+po1qVWri8Su-00015-00004927-00005540 the card
+po1qVWri8Su-00016-00005541-00005722 you can switch back and forth between
+po1qVWri8Su-00017-00005723-00005915 the front and back and make as many
+po1qVWri8Su-00018-00005916-00006450 changes to either side as you like
+po1qVWri8Su-00019-00006451-00006684 to add another card the editor window
+po1qVWri8Su-00020-00006684-00007487 has its own air button
+po1qVWri8Su-00021-00007488-00009055 you
+po1qVWri8Su-00022-00009056-00009259 when you have several cards you can move
+po1qVWri8Su-00023-00009260-00009379 between them using the Edit
+po1qVWri8Su-00024-00009380-00010370 windows previous and next buttons
+po1qVWri8Su-00025-00010371-00010605 now let's say you want to add images to
+po1qVWri8Su-00026-00010606-00011158 some of your cards
+po1qVWri8Su-00027-00011159-00011442 select insert image from the cards edit
+po1qVWri8Su-00028-00011443-00012321 menu then select an image file
+po1qVWri8Su-00029-00012322-00013182 you
+po1qVWri8Su-00030-00013183-00013377 I'll do the same thing for the front and
+po1qVWri8Su-00031-00013378-00013532 make of
+po1qVWri8Su-00032-00013533-00014202 just made
+po1qVWri8Su-00034-00017498-00017683 now let's see how the two cards we've
+po1qVWri8Su-00035-00017684-00017833 just made will end up looking during a
+po1qVWri8Su-00036-00017834-00018150 quiz for more control over the way your
+po1qVWri8Su-00037-00018151-00018346 cards look check out the card style
+po1qVWri8Su-00038-00018347-00018574 options under file properties in the
+po1qVWri8Su-00039-00018575-00018907 file menu and card color options under
+po1qVWri8Su-00040-00018908-00019180 preferences in the Edit menu
+po1qVWri8Su-00041-00019181-00019432 the cuts themselves can contain special
+po1qVWri8Su-00042-00019433-00019729 HTML like markup you can read about that
+po1qVWri8Su-00043-00019730-00019954 in the card editor section of the user
+po1qVWri8Su-00044-00019955-00020368 guide available via the help menu
+p2gvopc_0SM-00000-00000085-00000493 [Music]
+p2gvopc_0SM-00001-00000494-00000858 the Epic projects talk about people
+p2gvopc_0SM-00002-00000859-00001247 exchanging their experience and telling
+p2gvopc_0SM-00003-00001248-00001499 each other what do they need through the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00004-00001500-00001798 project we try to fill these needs to
+p2gvopc_0SM-00005-00001800-00002165 help migrants to feel included in the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00006-00002166-00002351 cities that are involved in the project
+p2gvopc_0SM-00007-00002352-00002765 we started by a research that helped us
+p2gvopc_0SM-00008-00002766-00003065 to understand what the eight cities
+p2gvopc_0SM-00009-00003066-00003359 involved in the project needs if we
+p2gvopc_0SM-00010-00003360-00003695 understood that one city had best
+p2gvopc_0SM-00011-00003696-00003965 practices and as another city had
+p2gvopc_0SM-00012-00003965-00004379 problems in providing the service in
+p2gvopc_0SM-00013-00004380-00004619 this in the same practice we match them
+p2gvopc_0SM-00014-00004620-00004883 in order to fulfill their needs all the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00015-00004884-00005086 partners of the project are now
+p2gvopc_0SM-00016-00005087-00005435 implementing a pilot project so they are
+p2gvopc_0SM-00017-00005436-00005722 providing a service for their own
+p2gvopc_0SM-00018-00005723-00006091 community
+p2gvopc_0SM-00019-00006092-00006598 foreign it is important for I would say
+p2gvopc_0SM-00020-00006600-00006869 local authorities to be active and
+p2gvopc_0SM-00021-00006870-00007283 supportive stakeholder because it can
+p2gvopc_0SM-00022-00007284-00007528 gather the institutions of the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00023-00007529-00007810 municipality and direct their actions
+p2gvopc_0SM-00024-00007811-00008296 and of course by giving example to ngos
+p2gvopc_0SM-00025-00008297-00008542 and citizens attitude of the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00026-00008543-00008807 municipality can sometimes be like
+p2gvopc_0SM-00027-00008808-00009137 determining factor of what what would
+p2gvopc_0SM-00028-00009138-00009491 atmosphere be like for the newcomers in
+p2gvopc_0SM-00029-00009492-00009677 the local community it's important to
+p2gvopc_0SM-00030-00009678-00009923 work with the municipality directly so
+p2gvopc_0SM-00031-00009924-00010192 we work hand in hand they receive the
+p2gvopc_0SM-00032-00010193-00010487 the beneficiaries they migrant people go
+p2gvopc_0SM-00033-00010488-00010649 through a process with them help them
+p2gvopc_0SM-00034-00010650-00010823 earn what they can then they send them
+p2gvopc_0SM-00035-00010824-00011069 to us we help them in what we can and we
+p2gvopc_0SM-00036-00011070-00011273 send them a report back so they know
+p2gvopc_0SM-00037-00011274-00011531 where at what point they are and so on
+p2gvopc_0SM-00038-00011532-00011896 so it's like we need them and they need
+p2gvopc_0SM-00041-00018254-00018557 I think so I integrated because I have a
+p2gvopc_0SM-00042-00018558-00018899 lot of Croatian friends from here from
+p2gvopc_0SM-00043-00018900-00019186 Market from Bazaar from Berber or
+p2gvopc_0SM-00044-00019187-00019361 anywhere you can ask them do you know
+p2gvopc_0SM-00045-00019362-00019793 Emery everyone they can say yes from
+p2gvopc_0SM-00046-00019794-00020153 Turkey yes great but Croatian government
+p2gvopc_0SM-00047-00020154-00020530 and uh this is civil organization how to
+p2gvopc_0SM-00048-00020531-00020735 ask for learning something from this
+p2gvopc_0SM-00049-00020736-00021067 city also integrate to this city
+p2gvopc_0SM-00050-00021068-00021629 therefore so good for me I think so
+p2gvopc_0SM-00052-00027912-00028027 foreign
+p2gvopc_0SM-00054-00032802-00033004 social
+p2gvopc_0SM-00055-00033005-00033790 [Music]
+p2gvopc_0SM-00056-00033791-00034116 [Music]
+p34vvLuXGw4-00000-00000053-00000380 golden warrior gold Leyden gongjin
+p34vvLuXGw4-00001-00000381-00000749 zhanchi Gerudo ratin Ogun Senshi Gordo
+p34vvLuXGw4-00002-00000750-00000965 Raiden is a mecha anime television
+p34vvLuXGw4-00003-00000966-00001439 series that aired from 1981 to 1982 in
+p34vvLuXGw4-00004-00001440-00001847 Japan the show was also popular in Hong
+p34vvLuXGw4-00005-00001848-00002084 Kong and was aired there around the same
+p34vvLuXGw4-00006-00002085-00002471 time there are 52 episodes that were
+p34vvLuXGw4-00007-00002472-00003179 aired at 30 minutes each
+p34vvLuXGw4-00008-00003180-00003786 topic original story
+p34vvLuXGw4-00009-00003787-00004063 the story is about a young boy named
+p34vvLuXGw4-00010-00004064-00004320 Hiro take a who finds a gold lighter
+p34vvLuXGw4-00011-00004321-00004591 which turns out to be the giant golden
+p34vvLuXGw4-00012-00004592-00004831 warrior gold Leyden who has the mission
+p34vvLuXGw4-00013-00004832-00005074 to save the earth from an invasion by
+p34vvLuXGw4-00014-00005075-00005386 king of all de gold light and joined
+p34vvLuXGw4-00015-00005387-00005677 forces with his robot teammates to ruin
+p34vvLuXGw4-00016-00005678-00005907 the plots of king of all de and destroy
+p34vvLuXGw4-00017-00005908-00006181 invading alien robots by using his
+p34vvLuXGw4-00018-00006182-00006522 surpassing hand and leg strikes hero
+p34vvLuXGw4-00019-00006523-00006826 also founded a group called the bratty
+p34vvLuXGw4-00020-00006827-00007573 Rangers with his friends
+p34vvLuXGw4-00021-00007573-00008109 topic concept
+p34vvLuXGw4-00022-00008111-00008455 the robot is usually disguised as a tiny
+p34vvLuXGw4-00023-00008456-00008716 gold Zippo style lighter in hero's
+p34vvLuXGw4-00024-00008717-00009097 pocket when called upon gold lighten
+p34vvLuXGw4-00025-00009098-00009391 transforms into a giant robot towering
+p34vvLuXGw4-00026-00009392-00009796 at 30 meters and weighing 200 tonnes all
+p34vvLuXGw4-00027-00009797-00010084 robots in the show are sentient and do
+p34vvLuXGw4-00028-00010085-00010459 not require pilots usually the robot
+p34vvLuXGw4-00029-00010460-00010705 ends a battle with a trademark golden
+p34vvLuXGw4-00030-00010706-00010951 hand stab move which drives a hand
+p34vvLuXGw4-00031-00010952-00011188 strike cutting the enemy robots body
+p34vvLuXGw4-00032-00011189-00011437 pulling out and smashing the heart box
+p34vvLuXGw4-00033-00011438-00012089 energy device
+p34vvLuXGw4-00034-00012090-00012626 topic staff
+p34vvLuXGw4-00035-00012627-00013076 presenter kenji yoshida planners appe
+p34vvLuXGw4-00036-00013077-00013538 curry Shigeru Yan Ogawa producer Tama
+p34vvLuXGw4-00037-00013538-00014071 Yuki Miyata chief director Kochi mashimo
+p34vvLuXGw4-00038-00014072-00014491 character design app a curry mecha
+p34vvLuXGw4-00039-00014491-00014933 establishment Masaharu kawari music
+p34vvLuXGw4-00040-00014934-00015358 Massa Yuki Jinbo masa Yuki Yamamoto
+p34vvLuXGw4-00041-00015359-00015655 animation director takashina Kimura
+p34vvLuXGw4-00042-00015656-00016013 episode six twenty to thirty forty one
+p34vvLuXGw4-00043-00016013-00016252 forty eight
+p34vvLuXGw4-00044-00016253-00016561 key animation takashi nakamura episode
+p34vvLuXGw4-00045-00016562-00017093 41
+p34vvLuXGw4-00046-00017094-00018016 topic characters
+p34vvLuXGw4-00047-00018017-00018990 topic light in robots
+p34vvLuXGw4-00048-00018991-00019563 topic episodes
+p34vvLuXGw4-00049-00019564-00019821 this is a list of episodes from the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00050-00019822-00020079 television show golden warrior gold
+p34vvLuXGw4-00051-00020080-00020855 lighten in order by production number
+p34vvLuXGw4-00052-00020856-00021424 topic merchandize
+p34vvLuXGw4-00053-00021425-00021847 in 2005 Hong Kong Bandai reissued the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00054-00021848-00022126 semi original robots as part of the soul
+p34vvLuXGw4-00055-00022127-00022486 of Chogokin label the individual robots
+p34vvLuXGw4-00056-00022487-00022674 were released with a hard plastic
+p34vvLuXGw4-00057-00022675-00023050 display case robot foot stand red carpet
+p34vvLuXGw4-00058-00023051-00023338 storage box interchangeable gold hands
+p34vvLuXGw4-00059-00023339-00023614 pieces and an enemy's heart box energy
+p34vvLuXGw4-00060-00023615-00023953 device this version also featured the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00061-00023954-00024265 robots with high quality 18k gold
+p34vvLuXGw4-00062-00024266-00024583 plating the toys can be purchased
+p34vvLuXGw4-00063-00024584-00024877 individually or as a set there are two
+p34vvLuXGw4-00064-00024878-00025138 known sets in the reissues one is the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00065-00025139-00025429 first-generation grey box available in
+p34vvLuXGw4-00066-00025430-00025717 Hong Kong and Japan featuring six of the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00067-00025718-00025966 robots the other as an exclusive red
+p34vvLuXGw4-00068-00025967-00026206 carpet wooden box set known to be
+p34vvLuXGw4-00069-00026207-00026479 available only in Japan featuring all
+p34vvLuXGw4-00070-00026480-00027007 eleven robots later in 2005 replicas
+p34vvLuXGw4-00071-00027008-00027270 were re-released by hung hang toys in
+p34vvLuXGw4-00072-00027272-00027552 Hong Kong and Macau featuring the robots
+p34vvLuXGw4-00073-00027554-00027913 built in Cheaper diecast metals the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00074-00027914-00028164 texture and few minor details were
+p34vvLuXGw4-00075-00028166-00028395 inconsistent between the products
+p34vvLuXGw4-00076-00028395-00028693 multiple variations of the toys were
+p34vvLuXGw4-00077-00028694-00028819 sold as well
+p34vvLuXGw4-00078-00028820-00029133 one such version as the large toy gold
+p34vvLuXGw4-00079-00029135-00029368 light and measuring at eleven point five
+p34vvLuXGw4-00080-00029369-00029635 inches in height when standing in robot
+p34vvLuXGw4-00081-00029636-00029871 form although only 2,000 were
+p34vvLuXGw4-00082-00029872-00030217 manufactured additionally at the base of
+p34vvLuXGw4-00083-00030218-00030517 the foot of the toy is a label counting
+p34vvLuXGw4-00084-00030518-00030730 the manufactured number out of two
+p34vvLuXGw4-00085-00030731-00031099 thousand other variations include team
+p34vvLuXGw4-00086-00031100-00031369 robots in different colors or gray low
+p34vvLuXGw4-00087-00031370-00031654 weight plastic silver exclusive to Hong
+p34vvLuXGw4-00088-00031655-00031872 Kong and Macau
+p34vvLuXGw4-00089-00031873-00032154 there are more variations and replicas
+p34vvLuXGw4-00090-00032155-00032345 of gold lightened than any others
+p34vvLuXGw4-00091-00032347-00032568 because it has the lead robot in this
+p34vvLuXGw4-00092-00032569-00032940 series there are other design variations
+p34vvLuXGw4-00093-00032941-00033393 for example older models of icy lighten
+p34vvLuXGw4-00094-00033394-00033663 uses double-a batteries to light up its
+p34vvLuXGw4-00095-00033664-00033969 LED eye while newer reissues of the toy
+p34vvLuXGw4-00096-00033970-00034377 uses flat button or coin batteries none
+p34vvLuXGw4-00097-00034378-00034611 of these releases are completely
+p34vvLuXGw4-00098-00034612-00034935 identical to the original 1980s GB
+p34vvLuXGw4-00099-00034936-00035298 series Chogokin toy launched from 1979
+p34vvLuXGw4-00100-00035299-00035721 to 1983 by Pope II pleasure the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00101-00035722-00035964 originals are valued at a higher price
+p34vvLuXGw4-00102-00035965-00036201 as they were constructed with different
+p34vvLuXGw4-00103-00036202-00036429 grades of diecast metals as well as
+p34vvLuXGw4-00104-00036430-00036636 high-quality acrylonitrile butadiene
+p34vvLuXGw4-00105-00036637-00036896 styrene
+p34vvLuXGw4-00106-00036897-00037277 in 2006 bandai released a new version of
+p34vvLuXGw4-00107-00037278-00037472 the gold lighten in their soul of
+p34vvLuXGw4-00108-00037473-00037961 Chogokin lino GX 32 the gold lighten not
+p34vvLuXGw4-00109-00037962-00038174 only were they considered to be one of
+p34vvLuXGw4-00110-00038175-00038435 the most detailed and sophisticated gold
+p34vvLuXGw4-00111-00038436-00038678 lightened toys yet they were plated with
+p34vvLuXGw4-00112-00038679-00039016 18k gold as their predecessors were
+p34vvLuXGw4-00113-00039017-00039341 aside from being able to transform into
+p34vvLuXGw4-00114-00039342-00039596 a lighter just like the original toys
+p34vvLuXGw4-00115-00039597-00039935 its joints were well-structured the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00116-00039936-00040126 package comes with a stand
+p34vvLuXGw4-00117-00040127-00040370 interchangeable hands and a heart box
+p34vvLuXGw4-00118-00040371-00040763 energy device the toy was a success and
+p34vvLuXGw4-00119-00040764-00041060 was well received by fans in Japan and
+p34vvLuXGw4-00120-00041061-00041167 Hong Kong
+p34vvLuXGw4-00121-00041168-00041528 this caused Bandai Hong Kong to make a
+p34vvLuXGw4-00122-00041529-00041786 singular stand showcase just for the
+p34vvLuXGw4-00123-00041787-00042073 gold lighten itself
+p34vvLuXGw4-00124-00042074-00042286 the titular robot as a playable
+p34vvLuXGw4-00125-00042287-00042577 character in the fighting game Tatsunoko
+p34vvLuXGw4-00126-00042578-00043042 vs. Capcom ultimate all-stars when he
+p34vvLuXGw4-00127-00043043-00043303 fights he can only be single as opposed
+p34vvLuXGw4-00128-00043304-00043582 to character doubles since he is so big
+p34vvLuXGw4-00129-00043583-00043834 and powerful
+p5L_js9u0AI-00000-00000883-00002547 hello
+p5L_js9u0AI-00001-00002548-00002964 okay the last talk slot of the day and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00002-00002965-00003375 of the conference very exciting it looks
+p5L_js9u0AI-00003-00003376-00003534 like I have a little bit of text cut off
+p5L_js9u0AI-00004-00003535-00003740 there I'm not sure what's causing that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00005-00003742-00004250 that other people have this problem yes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00006-00004251-00004797 it's normal change no that's going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00007-00004798-00005091 get really ugly I'm afraid I don't think
+p5L_js9u0AI-00008-00005092-00005247 I have anything really at the bottom so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00009-00005248-00005496 hopefully doing fine I know wants to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00010-00005497-00005652 make an ounce before we start something
+p5L_js9u0AI-00011-00005653-00005844 about a drawing of some type so he may
+p5L_js9u0AI-00012-00005845-00006078 have an opportunity to look at the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00013-00006079-00006252 enterprise-d he's able under
+p5L_js9u0AI-00014-00006253-00006623 registration and notice the sign and the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00015-00006625-00007056 jar to enter yourself for a free virtual
+p5L_js9u0AI-00016-00007056-00007346 training class to be announced here so a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00017-00007347-00007566 couple of you put your business cards in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00018-00007567-00008498 and all not here right now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00019-00008499-00009020 winner is by the lacquer of VMware so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00020-00009021-00009749 spy village here anywhere great great
+p5L_js9u0AI-00021-00009750-00009992 thank you so hi everyone my name's Bruce
+p5L_js9u0AI-00022-00009993-00010103 mom Jen
+p5L_js9u0AI-00023-00010104-00010331 work for enterprise DB I'm one of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00024-00010332-00010556 core team members been working on
+p5L_js9u0AI-00025-00010557-00010916 Postgres since 1996 I'm excited to be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00026-00010917-00011156 giving this talk and frankly I don't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00027-00011157-00011342 know about any of you but this is in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00028-00011343-00011666 terms of quality of talks this call this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00029-00011667-00011876 PG con has been the best PG con that I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00030-00011877-00012251 can remember pretty much I don't know
+p5L_js9u0AI-00031-00012252-00012458 forever maybe for the last four or five
+p5L_js9u0AI-00032-00012459-00012844 years so I don't know the quality there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00033-00012845-00013063 had been some previous years where there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00034-00013064-00013250 been like there was one talk that just
+p5L_js9u0AI-00035-00013251-00013519 like knocked me out of my seat this one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00036-00013520-00013808 it was like virtually every talk I went
+p5L_js9u0AI-00037-00013809-00014116 to it's very high quality very pointed
+p5L_js9u0AI-00038-00014118-00014297 at exactly what I was interested in I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00039-00014297-00014459 not sure I talked to some other people
+p5L_js9u0AI-00040-00014460-00014660 they sort of felt the same way so be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00041-00014661-00014822 interesting for the organizers to see if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00042-00014822-00015002 we get that feedback so please do give
+p5L_js9u0AI-00043-00015003-00015188 us feedback there's some things that we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00044-00015188-00015353 can do to improve I know we're all
+p5L_js9u0AI-00045-00015354-00015547 interested in in finding that out
+p5L_js9u0AI-00046-00015547-00015937 so today what I want to talk about is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00047-00015938-00016255 effectively the Postgres query optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00048-00016256-00016528 this is a very interesting topic to me
+p5L_js9u0AI-00049-00016529-00016736 in fact this is the reason I got
+p5L_js9u0AI-00050-00016737-00017033 involved with Postgres because in 1996 I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00051-00017034-00017315 had been writing financial applications
+p5L_js9u0AI-00052-00017316-00017600 for seven years and you know after you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00053-00017601-00017741 write financial applications for about
+p5L_js9u0AI-00054-00017742-00017803 seven years
+p5L_js9u0AI-00055-00017804-00017987 you're really not learning a whole lot
+p5L_js9u0AI-00056-00017988-00018287 anymore and as a professional I felt
+p5L_js9u0AI-00057-00018288-00018469 like I wanted to learn more I wanted to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00058-00018470-00018641 understand more about what I was doing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00059-00018642-00018844 and I because I was writing database
+p5L_js9u0AI-00060-00018845-00019067 applications occasionally I would get to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00061-00019068-00019450 look inside of the database to see how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00062-00019451-00019691 was a query that I sent to the server
+p5L_js9u0AI-00063-00019692-00020015 actually executed what how is it making
+p5L_js9u0AI-00064-00020016-00020222 its decisions and and how is it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00065-00020223-00020438 returning those results as efficiently
+p5L_js9u0AI-00066-00020439-00020735 as possible and at that time I was using
+p5L_js9u0AI-00067-00020736-00020822 Informix
+p5L_js9u0AI-00068-00020823-00021236 and ingress and I was not able to see
+p5L_js9u0AI-00069-00021237-00021490 really inside of how they made those
+p5L_js9u0AI-00070-00021491-00021727 decisions I could kind of see
+p5L_js9u0AI-00071-00021728-00021988 a little bit of the plan that came out
+p5L_js9u0AI-00072-00021989-00022141 if you're familiar with those products
+p5L_js9u0AI-00073-00022142-00022339 or other products that generate a plan
+p5L_js9u0AI-00074-00022340-00022549 but but I couldn't actually look at the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00075-00022550-00022750 code or understand the process it was
+p5L_js9u0AI-00076-00022751-00022987 using to make those decisions and one of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00077-00022988-00023293 the real attractions to Postgres and one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00078-00023294-00023437 of the reasons I got involved in sort of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00079-00023438-00023677 starting it in internet development 1996
+p5L_js9u0AI-00080-00023678-00023922 was because of that openness of code
+p5L_js9u0AI-00081-00023923-00024069 because I could actually understand it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00082-00024070-00024253 now I'm not going to actually be talking
+p5L_js9u0AI-00083-00024254-00024457 about the internal code what goes on in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00084-00024458-00024775 Postgres too much today but what I am
+p5L_js9u0AI-00085-00024776-00025022 going to do is kind of walk you through
+p5L_js9u0AI-00086-00025023-00025330 basically how Postgres makes those
+p5L_js9u0AI-00087-00025331-00025507 decisions and give you a little more
+p5L_js9u0AI-00088-00025508-00025822 appreciation of what is going on inside
+p5L_js9u0AI-00089-00025823-00026094 that server I know a lot of people are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00090-00026095-00026508 sort of keen on you know non relational
+p5L_js9u0AI-00091-00026510-00026725 systems these days and sort of looking
+p5L_js9u0AI-00092-00026726-00026902 at things that don't have an optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00093-00026902-00027067 but I think one of the things you're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00094-00027068-00027211 going to get out is understanding how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00095-00027212-00027477 much of that optimizer helps you as an
+p5L_js9u0AI-00096-00027479-00027708 application developer not have to worry
+p5L_js9u0AI-00097-00027710-00028071 about a lot of the intricacies that you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00098-00028072-00028237 normally would have had to work deal
+p5L_js9u0AI-00099-00028238-00028429 with before relational systems came
+p5L_js9u0AI-00100-00028430-00028839 around so you know simply when you're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00101-00028841-00029058 writing an application as you would be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00102-00029058-00029368 here usually you have some kind of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00103-00029369-00029614 interface layer that sends the query
+p5L_js9u0AI-00104-00029614-00029848 across to the server and then sends the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00105-00029849-00030015 result back to the interface layer and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00106-00030016-00030238 then up into the application we're going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00107-00030239-00030451 to basically be focusing on what happens
+p5L_js9u0AI-00108-00030452-00030694 inside that server that part to the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00109-00030695-00031069 right so internally Postgres effectively
+p5L_js9u0AI-00110-00031070-00031444 has a sort of an internal flow that goes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00111-00031445-00031744 through to figure out how to execute a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00112-00031745-00032046 query and in fact the most important
+p5L_js9u0AI-00113-00032047-00032323 part of that flow is what we call the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00114-00032324-00032577 optimizer or the planner now that's not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00115-00032578-00032788 the first section that actually occurs
+p5L_js9u0AI-00116-00032789-00033025 when it's query comes in the first thing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00117-00033026-00033280 that happens again coming in from the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00118-00033281-00033475 top here the first thing that happens is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00119-00033476-00033646 the statements parse it's broken down
+p5L_js9u0AI-00120-00033647-00033880 into words and then the words are then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00121-00033881-00034189 treated as tokens or lexemes which are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00122-00034190-00034363 then passed to something called a lexer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00123-00034364-00034594 which effectively generates actions
+p5L_js9u0AI-00124-00034595-00034730 based on the pattern
+p5L_js9u0AI-00125-00034731-00035045 of tokens or keywords that come in they
+p5L_js9u0AI-00126-00035046-00035245 have come in to the to the parser
+p5L_js9u0AI-00127-00035246-00035513 there's then a traffic cop in Postgres
+p5L_js9u0AI-00128-00035514-00035729 which figures out if it's a utility
+p5L_js9u0AI-00129-00035730-00035888 command or not if it's non-intuitive
+p5L_js9u0AI-00130-00035889-00036104 command it goes into something called a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00131-00036105-00036263 rewriter which is where we handle things
+p5L_js9u0AI-00132-00036264-00036749 like views and and rules but down after
+p5L_js9u0AI-00133-00036750-00037006 the rewriter is that optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00134-00037007-00037235 effectively what it's doing it's trying
+p5L_js9u0AI-00135-00037236-00037430 to figure out how can I get that user
+p5L_js9u0AI-00136-00037431-00037646 the results as quickly as possible and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00137-00037647-00037799 then what comes out of that execute
+p5L_js9u0AI-00138-00037800-00038072 optimizer is something called a plan the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00139-00038073-00038330 plan effectively is sent to the executor
+p5L_js9u0AI-00140-00038331-00038459 and that's the part that actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-00141-00038460-00038776 execute the query so this is sort of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00142-00038777-00039065 mapmaker the one who lays out the plan
+p5L_js9u0AI-00143-00039066-00039275 of what we're going to do and that's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00144-00039276-00039539 effectively passed into the executor
+p5L_js9u0AI-00145-00039540-00039797 which is really just something that that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00146-00039798-00040106 that follows whatever plan came out of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00147-00040107-00040238 the optimizer so it's really just
+p5L_js9u0AI-00148-00040239-00040673 executing a recipe that's come out so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00149-00040674-00040835 we're going to focus on that optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00150-00040836-00041003 what I think of as the brains of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00151-00041004-00041267 system what things does that optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00152-00041268-00041477 have to do what things does it have to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00153-00041478-00041777 decide there's three major areas that it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00154-00041778-00042101 has to make decisions on one what is the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00155-00042102-00042359 scan method that's going to be used to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00156-00042360-00042587 get at the data and I'm going to go in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00157-00042588-00042788 specifics about what scan methods are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00158-00042789-00043100 available in Postgres secondly what join
+p5L_js9u0AI-00159-00043101-00043250 methods are going to use we're going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00160-00043251-00043514 show you specific examples with diagrams
+p5L_js9u0AI-00161-00043515-00043760 and show you exactly what join methods
+p5L_js9u0AI-00162-00043761-00043910 are there and then finally join order
+p5L_js9u0AI-00163-00043911-00044075 that's sort of figuring after I joined
+p5L_js9u0AI-00164-00044076-00044342 table A to B and then C or do I join
+p5L_js9u0AI-00165-00044343-00044612 table B and C and then a you know I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00166-00044613-00044831 saying different orders of bringing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00167-00044832-00044993 things together and I'm going to show
+p5L_js9u0AI-00168-00044994-00045170 you specific examples here now you might
+p5L_js9u0AI-00169-00045171-00045380 not be using Postgres or you might be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00170-00045381-00045506 using Postgres plus some other
+p5L_js9u0AI-00171-00045507-00045737 relational systems these concepts are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00172-00045738-00046055 very generic so in most cesses most
+p5L_js9u0AI-00173-00046056-00046328 relational systems you will see the same
+p5L_js9u0AI-00174-00046329-00046538 concepts the terms might be slightly
+p5L_js9u0AI-00175-00046539-00046670 different there might be a couple other
+p5L_js9u0AI-00176-00046671-00046910 things that aren't there but this should
+p5L_js9u0AI-00177-00046911-00047051 be these Ruby these are very generic
+p5L_js9u0AI-00178-00047052-00047483 relational concepts so first thing scan
+p5L_js9u0AI-00179-00047484-00047726 methods there's basic
+p5L_js9u0AI-00180-00047727-00048032 three types of scan methods supported in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00181-00048033-00048320 Postgres and again deciding which one to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00182-00048321-00048488 use is something I'm going to show you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00183-00048489-00048782 in a couple minutes the first one is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00184-00048783-00049106 called the Blitz let's let's first
+p5L_js9u0AI-00185-00049107-00049286 before we do that let's set it up so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00186-00049287-00049478 first what we have to do is we have to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00187-00049479-00049787 create a little like temporary table so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00188-00049788-00049967 I can illustrate all the things I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00189-00049968-00050222 going to talk about so effectively what
+p5L_js9u0AI-00190-00050223-00050393 I've done here is I've just run a little
+p5L_js9u0AI-00191-00050394-00050669 query that goes into the system catalogs
+p5L_js9u0AI-00192-00050670-00051104 and just pulls out some of the relation
+p5L_js9u0AI-00193-00051105-00051485 names in the system and and then what I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00194-00051486-00051683 did next is I took the relation names
+p5L_js9u0AI-00195-00051684-00051944 and I chopped off just the first letter
+p5L_js9u0AI-00196-00051945-00052112 I just chopped off everything yes so the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00197-00052113-00052364 first letter just got rid of it okay and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00198-00052365-00052652 then I create a temporary table with
+p5L_js9u0AI-00199-00052653-00052904 this contents so effectively what I did
+p5L_js9u0AI-00200-00052904-00053312 was I took the system table then I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00201-00053313-00053528 chopped off I just took the first letter
+p5L_js9u0AI-00202-00053529-00053755 of the relation name and then I put a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00203-00053757-00053929 bunch of junk at the end and I created a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00204-00053930-00054161 table called sample and I put an index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00205-00054162-00054419 on it that's all I did okay because I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00206-00054420-00054572 going to use this example for the next
+p5L_js9u0AI-00207-00054573-00054776 probably 10 slides and this can kind of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00208-00054777-00054923 give you an idea of how this is going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00209-00054924-00055064 work now if you want to run this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00210-00055065-00055330 yourself the part in pink here is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00211-00055332-00055630 actually this is actually the SQL so if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00212-00055632-00055847 you want to download this you can run it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00213-00055848-00056041 and you can actually see it running on
+p5L_js9u0AI-00214-00056042-00056195 your terminal and you can actually see
+p5L_js9u0AI-00215-00056196-00056455 the exact same output there have a bunch
+p5L_js9u0AI-00216-00056457-00056627 of slides on my website in fact I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00217-00056628-00056801 sorry I forgot to mention it and the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00218-00056802-00056912 reason I didn't mention now that I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00219-00056913-00057104 realize it is because chopped off at the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00220-00057104-00057596 bottom but effectively if you go to this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00221-00057597-00057827 website right here and get rid of that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00222-00057828-00058016 rest of the part there this this right
+p5L_js9u0AI-00223-00058016-00058267 here if you go under presentations
+p5L_js9u0AI-00224-00058269-00058403 there's probably this presentation is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00225-00058404-00058562 there and then there's 30 other
+p5L_js9u0AI-00226-00058563-00058792 presentations also there they're in PDFs
+p5L_js9u0AI-00227-00058794-00058979 and you know the bottom isn't chopped
+p5L_js9u0AI-00228-00058979-00059162 off so you'll if you're missing the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00229-00059163-00059348 bottom there you can you can definitely
+p5L_js9u0AI-00230-00059349-00059641 check that out on that website so that's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00231-00059642-00059791 this is the temporary table we're going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00232-00059792-00059987 to use and then we're going to also use
+p5L_js9u0AI-00233-00059988-00060229 a function that I used a little bit to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00234-00060230-00060449 display things a little better again
+p5L_js9u0AI-00235-00060450-00060788 this is also in the SQL file so let's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00236-00060789-00060957 see what what is this file
+p5L_js9u0AI-00237-00060958-00061149 look like a creative temper and fall and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00238-00061150-00061323 I made a little query and I said just
+p5L_js9u0AI-00239-00061324-00061580 tell me what this looks like this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00240-00061582-00062042 temporary table so effectively I have I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00241-00062044-00062310 think there's about two hundred and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00242-00062311-00062613 fifty three rows in this table I can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00243-00062614-00062925 tell when I created the temp table one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00244-00062926-00063198 hundred and ninety nine of them have AP
+p5L_js9u0AI-00245-00063199-00063474 just the letter P in it and then another
+p5L_js9u0AI-00246-00063475-00063645 field which has a bunch of junk on it I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00247-00063646-00063999 have nine of them which is an S and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00248-00064000-00064311 eight of them which we see and then down
+p5L_js9u0AI-00249-00064312-00064632 here I have one row which is an eye and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00250-00064633-00064863 one rows okay and the reason I created
+p5L_js9u0AI-00251-00064864-00065022 this is because it gives me a nice
+p5L_js9u0AI-00252-00065023-00065358 distribution of a variable kind of case
+p5L_js9u0AI-00253-00065359-00065553 where I've got one letter which is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00254-00065554-00065778 really common in the system a couple
+p5L_js9u0AI-00255-00065779-00065904 letters you really come in and then I've
+p5L_js9u0AI-00256-00065905-00066099 got two letters which are a bunch of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00257-00066100-00066321 letters which are very rare and this is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00258-00066322-00066567 the type of case that you have in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00259-00066568-00066741 relational systems this is one of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00260-00066742-00066954 areas the optimizer does very well is it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00261-00066955-00067260 kind of can adjust things based on how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00262-00067261-00067632 selective your data is and I'm going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00263-00067633-00067791 go into how that happens in a minute
+p5L_js9u0AI-00264-00067792-00068193 okay so what do I mean by selective okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00265-00068194-00068487 so if I just do this query right here
+p5L_js9u0AI-00266-00068488-00069084 and I say give me a P okay um what it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00267-00069085-00069237 actually ends up doing is something
+p5L_js9u0AI-00268-00069238-00069711 called an index scan which like okay so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00269-00069712-00069897 what if I use that's a very that's my
+p5L_js9u0AI-00270-00069898-00070188 that's my most common value right so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00271-00070189-00070559 what if I do a d-- which happens to be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00272-00070560-00070794 kind of in the middle here i got four of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00273-00070795-00071094 those and that's also an index scan and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00274-00071095-00071487 what if I do a kay well that's also it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00275-00071488-00071688 my rarest value and it's doing the same
+p5L_js9u0AI-00276-00071689-00071811 thing I'm doing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00277-00071812-00072042 I got an index scan for all three values
+p5L_js9u0AI-00278-00072043-00072303 for my most popular value and my least
+p5L_js9u0AI-00279-00072304-00072570 popular value they're all returning the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00280-00072571-00072990 same thing why is that well the reason
+p5L_js9u0AI-00281-00072991-00073182 is is because I'd only statistics on the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00282-00073183-00073599 table what statistics are or out will be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00283-00073600-00073746 of special thing called optimize your
+p5L_js9u0AI-00284-00073747-00074010 statistics and the optimizer statistics
+p5L_js9u0AI-00285-00074011-00074288 tell the optimizer how common
+p5L_js9u0AI-00286-00074289-00074547 certain letters are or certain values
+p5L_js9u0AI-00287-00074548-00074835 are within a table so normally there's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00288-00074836-00075054 something called auto and auto vacuum
+p5L_js9u0AI-00289-00075055-00075299 which will run and analyze for you but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00290-00075300-00075518 that runs like every minute so I might
+p5L_js9u0AI-00291-00075519-00075690 not want to wait for the minute for it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00292-00075691-00075903 to run and in this case I'm using
+p5L_js9u0AI-00293-00075904-00076157 temporary tables which auto vacuum can't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00294-00076158-00076475 even see so that doesn't help me so I've
+p5L_js9u0AI-00295-00076476-00076691 got a run to analyze myself and I just
+p5L_js9u0AI-00296-00076692-00076856 went and I ran that analyze right there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00297-00076857-00077040 at the top and as soon as I run that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00298-00077041-00077291 analyze you see a change right away that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00299-00077292-00077498 P which used to be an index skin is now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00300-00077499-00077810 a sequential scan okay and a sequential
+p5L_js9u0AI-00301-00077811-00078044 scan is in fact effectively saying start
+p5L_js9u0AI-00302-00078045-00078212 at the beginning the table read all the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00303-00078213-00078386 rows to the end of the table very
+p5L_js9u0AI-00304-00078387-00078662 straightforward very just you know read
+p5L_js9u0AI-00305-00078663-00078905 everything free this is the easiest one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00306-00078906-00079154 to understand now why you choose it and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00307-00079155-00079418 India a sequential scan that's because
+p5L_js9u0AI-00308-00079419-00079844 we showed up here that 78% of our rows
+p5L_js9u0AI-00309-00079845-00080328 were Peas so you know if some games
+p5L_js9u0AI-00310-00080329-00080507 we're sending your rows or peas it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00311-00080508-00080715 doesn't make any sense to do all sorts
+p5L_js9u0AI-00312-00080716-00081088 of index lookups to somehow eliminate
+p5L_js9u0AI-00313-00081089-00081523 22% of your rows doesn't make sense so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00314-00081524-00081735 we're just going to read straight
+p5L_js9u0AI-00315-00081736-00081881 through the table that's the way to go
+p5L_js9u0AI-00316-00081882-00082307 okay what is if I do a D now the D I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00317-00082308-00082478 four of those
+p5L_js9u0AI-00318-00082479-00082781 okay the D ends up giving me something
+p5L_js9u0AI-00319-00082782-00082916 different it gives me what's called a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00320-00082917-00083211 bitmap heap scan sounds kind of weird
+p5L_js9u0AI-00321-00083212-00083543 but what it effectively is doing is it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00322-00083544-00083762 going through the index and it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00323-00083763-00084021 creating a bitmap that tells me where
+p5L_js9u0AI-00324-00084022-00084380 can i potentially find matching rows in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00325-00084381-00084569 the heap and i'm going to put a one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00326-00084570-00084857 every place i can at a zero anyplace I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00327-00084858-00084996 don't I'm not going to find it so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00328-00084997-00085146 effectively what I do is instead of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00329-00085147-00085355 doing four accesses I'm going to go
+p5L_js9u0AI-00330-00085356-00085473 through the index once it's going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00331-00085474-00085647 give me make a little bit map and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00332-00085648-00085781 I'm going to walk through the bitmap now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00333-00085782-00085959 this is probably overkill for this case
+p5L_js9u0AI-00334-00085960-00086178 but again because there were four it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00335-00086179-00086391 decided to create a bitmap and then use
+p5L_js9u0AI-00336-00086392-00086594 that to kind of aggregate all the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00337-00086595-00086969 lookups into the heap if I do the K
+p5L_js9u0AI-00338-00086970-00087203 which were there's only one of I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00339-00087204-00087507 actually get an index scan
+p5L_js9u0AI-00340-00087508-00087711 straight index skin with elder with no
+p5L_js9u0AI-00341-00087712-00087906 bitmap closures no need for a bit map
+p5L_js9u0AI-00342-00087907-00088086 because it knows there's only one or at
+p5L_js9u0AI-00343-00088087-00088242 least the statistics you're telling it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00344-00088243-00088446 that there's only one match it's going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00345-00088447-00088548 to go through the B tree it's going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00346-00088549-00088839 find the row we're done okay so this is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00347-00088840-00089169 the first example showing how the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00348-00089170-00089480 optimizer statistics are effectively
+p5L_js9u0AI-00349-00089481-00089877 changing how we go at our data all right
+p5L_js9u0AI-00350-00089878-00090129 and again as an application developer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00351-00090130-00090492 you don't have to worry about Oh am i
+p5L_js9u0AI-00352-00090493-00090696 querying something is very common or am
+p5L_js9u0AI-00353-00090697-00090933 I not and this happens all the time if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00354-00090934-00091455 you know if I if I'm you know in Ottawa
+p5L_js9u0AI-00355-00091456-00091644 and I'm querying all my customers in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00356-00091645-00091842 Ottawa well I may probably have a lot of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00357-00091843-00091980 customers in Ottawa so I'm probably
+p5L_js9u0AI-00358-00091981-00092157 going to do a sequential scan of all my
+p5L_js9u0AI-00359-00092158-00092424 customers but if I have an index on this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00360-00092425-00092748 on the the province and I try and you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00361-00092749-00093104 know I try and query somebody in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00362-00093105-00093345 Manitoba which I actually know is a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00363-00093346-00093534 province account amazingly from my
+p5L_js9u0AI-00364-00093535-00093831 education years ago am i right it is one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00365-00093832-00094047 of them yes don't hear about it very
+p5L_js9u0AI-00366-00094048-00094365 much I'm not sure why but if I wanted to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00367-00094366-00094509 see how many customers have in Manito
+p5L_js9u0AI-00368-00094510-00094755 but I've got an index on Provence odds
+p5L_js9u0AI-00369-00094756-00094988 are I'm going to use an index there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00370-00094989-00095205 because there's probably a couple
+p5L_js9u0AI-00371-00095206-00095334 because I don't think there's that many
+p5L_js9u0AI-00372-00095335-00095424 people in manic-trip
+p5L_js9u0AI-00373-00095425-00095690 we have anybody from Manitoba here
+p5L_js9u0AI-00374-00095691-00095925 somebody like that I'm disappointed
+p5L_js9u0AI-00375-00095926-00096141 anyway somebody can probably give me a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00376-00096142-00096282 good history lesson after and tell me
+p5L_js9u0AI-00377-00096283-00096489 what is there because I'm always
+p5L_js9u0AI-00378-00096490-00096828 fascinated by Canada but anyway no I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00379-00096829-00097050 think it's really a really great country
+p5L_js9u0AI-00380-00097051-00097346 so let's take a look at a better
+p5L_js9u0AI-00381-00097347-00097644 description of this okay so what I did
+p5L_js9u0AI-00382-00097645-00097842 Rhys I just did some random letters
+p5L_js9u0AI-00383-00097843-00097977 right I just did three letters and I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00384-00097978-00098172 kind of showed you so what I did is I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00385-00098173-00098454 created a little kind of query here and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00386-00098455-00098652 I'm actually using a little function
+p5L_js9u0AI-00387-00098653-00098931 that I used and I'm getting this output
+p5L_js9u0AI-00388-00098932-00099171 but if I kind of query it a little
+p5L_js9u0AI-00389-00099172-00099348 differently again all these queries are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00390-00099349-00099747 in that SQL file I get this and this to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00391-00099748-00099996 me is the quanta the quintessential slot
+p5L_js9u0AI-00392-00099997-00100251 for the presentation because what it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00393-00100252-00100502 illustrating is that as
+p5L_js9u0AI-00394-00100503-00100724 I chain as I go from the most common
+p5L_js9u0AI-00395-00100725-00100922 values at the top to the least common
+p5L_js9u0AI-00396-00100923-00101228 values at the bottom the optimizer is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00397-00101229-00101477 automatically changing the type of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00398-00101478-00101848 access method it uses to get the data
+p5L_js9u0AI-00399-00101849-00102074 automatically with me not having to do
+p5L_js9u0AI-00400-00102075-00102455 anything at all to the query itself okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00401-00102456-00102779 and this is all driven by the analyzed
+p5L_js9u0AI-00402-00102780-00103499 statistics that I created early on are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00403-00103500-00104405 there any questions so far yes sir so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00404-00104406-00104669 the question is why is the sequential
+p5L_js9u0AI-00405-00104670-00104927 scan actually doing it not only for one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00406-00104928-00105085 ninety nine hundred all the way down to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00407-00105086-00105308 the R which is number seven and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00408-00105308-00105655 down that is a very common question
+p5L_js9u0AI-00409-00105656-00106094 because most people think that the index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00410-00106095-00106510 should be used if it's selective sort of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00411-00106511-00106834 so they'll basically say well you know I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00412-00106835-00107144 understand if 78% of my rows or Peas I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00413-00107145-00107393 probably don't want to use an index but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00414-00107394-00107819 you know if it's 30% I think that the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00415-00107820-00107983 exact sounds pretty good but then when
+p5L_js9u0AI-00416-00107984-00108299 you realize that the index has a root
+p5L_js9u0AI-00417-00108300-00108650 page and then different like sub pages
+p5L_js9u0AI-00418-00108651-00108932 to get to the thing and then you realize
+p5L_js9u0AI-00419-00108933-00109115 that you know that you're going to have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00420-00109116-00109403 to randomly go through you're going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00421-00109404-00109607 have to randomly hit the heat pages now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00422-00109608-00109778 of course if you use a bitmap scan you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00423-00109779-00110006 can kind of do them in order but you're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00424-00110007-00110219 going to be hopping between the bottom
+p5L_js9u0AI-00425-00110220-00110447 line is that random i/o is really slow
+p5L_js9u0AI-00426-00110448-00110750 and sequential i/o is really fast okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00427-00110751-00111133 so the the sort of dirty secret is that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00428-00111134-00111515 like an index almost has to be like
+p5L_js9u0AI-00429-00111516-00111932 under 5% selected before it gets starts
+p5L_js9u0AI-00430-00111933-00112127 to be used and that's effectively
+p5L_js9u0AI-00431-00112128-00112364 designed because of the way that the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00432-00112365-00112646 costs are set up in Postgres and and the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00433-00112647-00112877 type of the way we know we have to do
+p5L_js9u0AI-00434-00112878-00113156 multiple reads to get through that index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00435-00113157-00113339 to get to the row where as we do a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00436-00113340-00113516 sequential we know we're just like not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00437-00113517-00113723 only are we reading like straight
+p5L_js9u0AI-00438-00113724-00113989 through but the the kernel is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00439-00113990-00114188 prefetching ahead of us because it knows
+p5L_js9u0AI-00440-00114189-00114827 we're going sequentially so it's 5% a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00441-00114828-00115079 good rule of thumb at any scale um not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00442-00115080-00115333 really I mean the number actually goes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00443-00115334-00115532 down as the table gets bigger but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00444-00115533-00115834 usually five seven percent is about the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00445-00115835-00116033 number we're going to see now that's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00446-00116033-00116308 kind of breaks pretty close because this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00447-00116309-00116774 the five I said there were 250 rows in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00448-00116775-00117228 the table so 253 so a5 is what that's 2
+p5L_js9u0AI-00449-00117229-00117546 percent yeah so that's actually breaking
+p5L_js9u0AI-00450-00117547-00117758 I would say much lower than that now the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00451-00117759-00118007 seven is probably around four percent
+p5L_js9u0AI-00452-00118008-00118272 for three and a half something like that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00453-00118273-00118557 so again I think the numbers breaking a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00454-00118558-00118794 little even lower than five percent I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00455-00118795-00119033 maybe even generous and it continues to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00456-00119034-00119261 surprise me how low that number really
+p5L_js9u0AI-00457-00119263-00119520 is now if you think I'm making that up
+p5L_js9u0AI-00458-00119521-00120081 which you could okay well actually the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00459-00120082-00120225 way I'm doing is going to fake it but I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00460-00120226-00120495 want to show you something what if I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00461-00120496-00120876 tell it what if I force it to do an
+p5L_js9u0AI-00462-00120877-00121184 index camp I say I don't believe you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00463-00121185-00121401 optimizer I am going to turn off
+p5L_js9u0AI-00464-00121402-00121683 sequential scan with that top line I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00465-00121683-00121866 gonna turn off bitmap scan with the next
+p5L_js9u0AI-00466-00121867-00122046 line and I am going to force an index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00467-00122047-00122241 scan I'm sorry I'm going to turn off
+p5L_js9u0AI-00468-00122242-00122538 bitmap scan and sequential scan and I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00469-00122539-00122796 going to run that again and what you see
+p5L_js9u0AI-00470-00122797-00123308 is that when you look at the cost the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00471-00123309-00123525 cost down here was around eight which
+p5L_js9u0AI-00472-00123526-00123651 this is the same because these were
+p5L_js9u0AI-00473-00123652-00123906 index scans before anyway but then as
+p5L_js9u0AI-00474-00123907-00124113 you get up it goes to twelve it goes to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00475-00124114-00124383 fifteen it goes to ninety ends up when
+p5L_js9u0AI-00476-00124383-00124668 you get up here at 39 the original
+p5L_js9u0AI-00477-00124669-00124950 output which is this one again starts at
+p5L_js9u0AI-00478-00124951-00125256 eight goes to 11 but it really doesn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00479-00125257-00125628 go any goes up to 13 okay now if you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00480-00125629-00125766 think the optimizer is doing something
+p5L_js9u0AI-00481-00125767-00126057 wrong you can turn it off you're using
+p5L_js9u0AI-00482-00126058-00126324 these commands at the top and you can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00483-00126325-00126591 rerun your query and time it and tell us
+p5L_js9u0AI-00484-00126592-00127116 is are we wrong or not okay in almost
+p5L_js9u0AI-00485-00127117-00127383 every case when somebody actually we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00486-00127383-00127569 have an FAQ item that even talks about
+p5L_js9u0AI-00487-00127570-00127818 why is my index not being used this is a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00488-00127819-00128049 very common question and it actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-00489-00128050-00128238 shows you these commands how to turn it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00490-00128239-00128379 off and it says run it with it running
+p5L_js9u0AI-00491-00128380-00128721 without it tell us what you get and the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00492-00128722-00128958 questions magically disappeared it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00493-00128958-00129231 amazing we put something FAQ and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00494-00129232-00129471 within six months we don't get the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00495-00129472-00129633 questions anymore this is the system
+p5L_js9u0AI-00496-00129633-00129915 perfect all the time no but but overall
+p5L_js9u0AI-00497-00129916-00130150 the costing is pretty active
+p5L_js9u0AI-00498-00130151-00130420 right and we don't seem to have too much
+p5L_js9u0AI-00499-00130421-00130669 it's almost counterintuitive how low
+p5L_js9u0AI-00500-00130670-00130990 that breakpoint is and you can't adjust
+p5L_js9u0AI-00501-00130991-00131215 it if you have SSDs you can adjust the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00502-00131216-00131449 random page cost so there are some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00503-00131450-00131692 things you might need to adjust if these
+p5L_js9u0AI-00504-00131693-00131875 numbers in these estimates in fact are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00505-00131876-00132160 wrong but in most cases it gets it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00506-00132161-00132415 pretty close and I saw question over
+p5L_js9u0AI-00507-00132416-00132451 here
+p5L_js9u0AI-00508-00132452-00133012 mr. him yeah you know that's what I was
+p5L_js9u0AI-00509-00133013-00133150 I was getting to that I'm actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-00510-00133151-00133477 cheating and the cheating is that these
+p5L_js9u0AI-00511-00133478-00133753 numbers are actually the costs that the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00512-00133754-00133936 optimizer is giving us these are not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00513-00133937-00134265 actual execution times so I could have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00514-00134266-00134572 expanded this and kind of done the full
+p5L_js9u0AI-00515-00134573-00134916 execution time on this I didn't do that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00516-00134917-00135076 partially because the numbers would
+p5L_js9u0AI-00517-00135077-00135301 float around and then also partially
+p5L_js9u0AI-00518-00135302-00135513 because you start to get caching effects
+p5L_js9u0AI-00519-00135514-00136135 when you have multiple because when you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00520-00136136-00136330 run it once it's not in caching when you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00521-00136331-00136543 run it again it is in cache so the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00522-00136544-00136687 numbers type of tendency to float around
+p5L_js9u0AI-00523-00136688-00136879 and it's kind of hard to get really
+p5L_js9u0AI-00524-00136880-00137574 accurate numbers in that case yes sir
+p5L_js9u0AI-00525-00137575-00137799 so do we find if the percentage is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00526-00137800-00138041 increasing table gets much wider in fact
+p5L_js9u0AI-00527-00138042-00138365 there's what you can't see over here I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00528-00138366-00138575 maybe I do need to change my resolution
+p5L_js9u0AI-00529-00138576-00138701 I don't know what resolution is this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00530-00138702-00139074 thing we don't know okay anyway
+p5L_js9u0AI-00531-00139075-00139386 what's over here is actually a whiff
+p5L_js9u0AI-00532-00139387-00139833 estimate so the optimizer knows how wide
+p5L_js9u0AI-00533-00139834-00140034 the row is an estimate of how wide the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00534-00140035-00140256 row is and it will actually adjust it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00535-00140257-00140516 based on that so a shorter row will have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00536-00140517-00140714 a tendency to be looked up differently
+p5L_js9u0AI-00537-00140715-00141103 yeah other questions yes sir or ma'am
+p5L_js9u0AI-00538-00141104-00141624 sorry does the optimizer take into
+p5L_js9u0AI-00539-00141625-00141838 account a clustered index yes it does
+p5L_js9u0AI-00540-00141839-00142224 when you issue the cluster command the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00541-00142225-00142485 next analyze operation will actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-00542-00142486-00142850 sample the cluster ratio for the table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00543-00142851-00143174 and because the cluster does not mean
+p5L_js9u0AI-00544-00143175-00143511 thing you have to wreak luster it the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00545-00143512-00143714 cluster already been effectively every
+p5L_js9u0AI-00546-00143715-00143994 time I analyze your is run there is a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00547-00143995-00144270 special index that is marked as the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00548-00144271-00144551 clustered index in the system tables and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00549-00144552-00144803 it will actually randomly sample and it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00550-00144804-00145146 will update that amount of clustering
+p5L_js9u0AI-00551-00145147-00145584 ratio in this in the statistics and that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00552-00145585-00145986 will be used to determine how look how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00553-00145987-00146351 localized a lookup is particularly if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00554-00146352-00146588 you're looking up like a P or a D where
+p5L_js9u0AI-00555-00146589-00146879 you you think is it spread in five to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00556-00146880-00147036 four different places on the table or is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00557-00147037-00147329 it maybe all in one page so in fact that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00558-00147330-00147558 that not only it's not only do we record
+p5L_js9u0AI-00559-00147559-00147740 it but we actually keep it updated and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00560-00147741-00148074 the ratio will decrease as the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00561-00148075-00148308 clustering gets dispersed within the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00562-00148309-00148736 table other questions
+p5L_js9u0AI-00563-00148737-00149253 okay okay I'm sorry yes sir good table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00564-00149254-00149584 is so compact that the choices scan
+p5L_js9u0AI-00565-00149585-00149802 doesn't really matter for this case yeah
+p5L_js9u0AI-00566-00149803-00150133 this is the control he's saying it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00567-00150134-00150348 kind of contrived and I will admit yes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00568-00150349-00150528 that is that's true it would normally I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00569-00150529-00150757 would have taken a huge data set and run
+p5L_js9u0AI-00570-00150758-00150936 a huge thing but then the problem is the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00571-00150937-00151077 numbers are so huge that you can't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00572-00151078-00151887 really conceptually get at it yeah yeah
+p5L_js9u0AI-00573-00151888-00152061 but it's already memory so it doesn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00574-00152062-00153003 matter yes if you've got an index that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00575-00153004-00153172 has actually conducted two or three
+p5L_js9u0AI-00576-00153173-00153378 columns will let's consider all the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00577-00153379-00153860 values like the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00578-00153861-00154088 so the statistics have combinations of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00579-00154089-00154220 values you adjust but if you have a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00580-00154221-00154373 multi column index is it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00581-00154374-00154561 does it look at the combo of that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00582-00154562-00154784 unfortunately well fortunately it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00583-00154785-00155063 actually indexes every column so whether
+p5L_js9u0AI-00584-00155064-00155239 the column is in and the index are not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00585-00155240-00155495 in an index it's going to index them all
+p5L_js9u0AI-00586-00155496-00155725 because a lot of times you're going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00587-00155726-00156143 say a equals 1 B equals 12 and that BLM
+p5L_js9u0AI-00588-00156144-00156338 may not be index could be very important
+p5L_js9u0AI-00589-00156339-00156500 and and we need to know how selective
+p5L_js9u0AI-00590-00156501-00156743 that is to determine how many rows are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00591-00156744-00156913 going to come out which is actually part
+p5L_js9u0AI-00592-00156914-00157037 of the later part where we talk about
+p5L_js9u0AI-00593-00157038-00157334 how we join the data so we index all of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00594-00157335-00157481 them we don't index any the column
+p5L_js9u0AI-00595-00157482-00157736 specially one of the big flaws in the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00596-00157737-00158018 Postgres optimizer is the lack of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00597-00158019-00158251 information about correlations between
+p5L_js9u0AI-00598-00158252-00158491 multiple columns we've talked about that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00599-00158492-00158657 it is on the to do list it's something
+p5L_js9u0AI-00600-00158658-00158887 that we have not really understood how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00601-00158888-00159194 to efficiently generate such correlation
+p5L_js9u0AI-00602-00159195-00159512 and use that is one of the one of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00603-00159513-00159652 flaws I think of one of the areas we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00604-00159653-00159935 have to we have to improve is the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00605-00159936-00160136 correlation between columns sometimes if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00606-00160137-00160504 you say this is 1 and this is 12 that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00607-00160505-00160673 may be a very rare case and we're going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00608-00160674-00160811 to look at each one individually which
+p5L_js9u0AI-00609-00160812-00161219 is unfortunate No
+p5L_js9u0AI-00610-00161220-00161365 so the question is do we get limited
+p5L_js9u0AI-00611-00161366-00161602 benefit on multi-column indexes you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00612-00161603-00161807 still get a big benefit from them it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00613-00161808-00162044 just that you don't the statistics are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00614-00162045-00162197 perhaps not as smart but you're still
+p5L_js9u0AI-00615-00162198-00162443 going to be able to look up and filter
+p5L_js9u0AI-00616-00162444-00162623 across multiple columns in fact if you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00617-00162624-00162899 have a Coll index on a B and C and you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00618-00162900-00163252 give us a and C we'll still use the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00619-00163253-00163523 index on a and C in some trickery that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00620-00163524-00163799 we have the kind of span gaps and I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00621-00163800-00164018 not going to go into it but in all D
+p5L_js9u0AI-00622-00164019-00164188 column indexes are certainly very useful
+p5L_js9u0AI-00623-00164189-00164743 yeah it not as useful for planning but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00624-00164744-00165143 it right yeah but it probably would
+p5L_js9u0AI-00625-00165144-00165356 probably still will and the other thing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00626-00165357-00165643 that that you get into in this case is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00627-00165644-00165887 that none of these numbers are perfect
+p5L_js9u0AI-00628-00165888-00166136 although all fudgie numbers and in fact
+p5L_js9u0AI-00629-00166137-00166276 even if I had the perfect number today
+p5L_js9u0AI-00630-00166277-00166508 right now five minutes are now it would
+p5L_js9u0AI-00631-00166509-00166753 be wrong okay so the point is that these
+p5L_js9u0AI-00632-00166754-00166961 these estimates they don't have to be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00633-00166962-00167201 perfect they just be good enough to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00634-00167202-00167459 a plan that's probably closest to the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00635-00167460-00167834 best plan so that's probably good enough
+p5L_js9u0AI-00636-00167835-00168014 trying to get perfect numbers wouldn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00637-00168015-00168203 baby efficient and B wouldn't be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00638-00168204-00168896 probably very useful that's correct the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00639-00168897-00169103 more indexes you have the more possible
+p5L_js9u0AI-00640-00169104-00170221 combinations it has to look for
+p5L_js9u0AI-00641-00170222-00170485 you have where you can take so the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00642-00170486-00170703 problem of the ABC index right is that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00643-00170704-00170893 you want to look up a spawn see you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00644-00170894-00171165 decide it's useless to you right but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00645-00171166-00171382 what you do instead is you created if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00646-00171383-00171639 anything X's on a B and C and then we're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00647-00171640-00171910 able to actually use the index on a and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00648-00171911-00172252 C at the same time you can like this is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00649-00172253-00172464 showing a combined together you can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00650-00172465-00173119 combine them together do I think I mean
+p5L_js9u0AI-00651-00173120-00173289 there are specialized cases where you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00652-00173290-00174283 will want you know the bitmap base up
+p5L_js9u0AI-00653-00174284-00174559 but at the same time if you're not sure
+p5L_js9u0AI-00654-00174560-00174690 exactly what the gray pattern is going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00655-00174691-00174823 to look like you're not sure that you're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00656-00174824-00174964 always going to be queried with all
+p5L_js9u0AI-00657-00174965-00175179 three columns you already created X's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00658-00175180-00175363 independently okay now I'm going to stop
+p5L_js9u0AI-00659-00175364-00175597 the discussion there because we do want
+p5L_js9u0AI-00660-00175598-00175921 to we do want to finish the material so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00661-00175922-00176110 the second thing that we want to talk
+p5L_js9u0AI-00662-00176111-00176410 about is what we call join method and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00663-00176411-00176650 again this is fairly common for most of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00664-00176651-00176968 the most of the relational systems
+p5L_js9u0AI-00665-00176969-00177175 they're actually several actually four
+p5L_js9u0AI-00666-00177176-00177394 different join methods or three and a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00667-00177395-00177532 half different joining methods you can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00668-00177533-00177814 use the first ones nested loop with two
+p5L_js9u0AI-00669-00177815-00178041 types of that third with second ones
+p5L_js9u0AI-00670-00178042-00178222 hash joint and third ones merge joint I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00671-00178223-00178420 want to show you examples of that and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00672-00178421-00178677 diagrams of each of those okay so we're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00673-00178678-00178846 going to create another sample table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00674-00178847-00179008 this time I'm going to pull some roads
+p5L_js9u0AI-00675-00179009-00179206 from PG proc that happen to be numbers
+p5L_js9u0AI-00676-00179207-00179446 and I'm going to create a sample one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00677-00179447-00179776 which pulls rows from PG proc and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00678-00179777-00179928 I'm going to create another table called
+p5L_js9u0AI-00679-00179929-00180315 sample two which pulls some oh I DS from
+p5L_js9u0AI-00680-00180316-00180601 PG class again nothing super exciting
+p5L_js9u0AI-00681-00180602-00180835 you can you know you'll this is in that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00682-00180836-00181114 SQL file I'm assuming I'm going to start
+p5L_js9u0AI-00683-00181115-00181414 out with no indexes and no statistics
+p5L_js9u0AI-00684-00181415-00181606 okay so I'm starting off with absolutely
+p5L_js9u0AI-00685-00181607-00181885 the worst case that we could do right so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00686-00181886-00182289 if I do this query with a where clause
+p5L_js9u0AI-00687-00182290-00182677 that's comparing sample 1 to a constant
+p5L_js9u0AI-00688-00182678-00182932 and I'm joining sample 1 sample 2 I get
+p5L_js9u0AI-00689-00182933-00183145 what is called a nested loop with the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00690-00183146-00183363 sequential scan and a sequential scan it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00691-00183364-00183509 looks just like this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00692-00183510-00183770 it's as bad as it looks it means compare
+p5L_js9u0AI-00693-00183771-00184007 every row to every other row now the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00694-00184008-00184228 only reason this could be a win is if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00695-00184229-00184562 you have very small tables and there's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00696-00184563-00184852 no setup required okay so very small
+p5L_js9u0AI-00697-00184853-00185137 joins potentially we'll use this because
+p5L_js9u0AI-00698-00185138-00185459 it's super fast all right and it looks
+p5L_js9u0AI-00699-00185460-00185815 like that what if I join what if I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00700-00185816-00186124 restrict sample to to be greater than
+p5L_js9u0AI-00701-00186125-00186386 some number not equal greater I get
+p5L_js9u0AI-00702-00186387-00186671 what's called a hash joint okay and hash
+p5L_js9u0AI-00703-00186672-00186949 join effectively says take one side and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00704-00186950-00187274 hash it and then you look ups from the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00705-00187275-00187711 other table into that hash this is super
+p5L_js9u0AI-00706-00187712-00187946 super popular it's sort of the vanilla
+p5L_js9u0AI-00707-00187947-00188420 being ice cream of databases they love
+p5L_js9u0AI-00708-00188421-00188653 doing this okay middle-of-the-road kind
+p5L_js9u0AI-00709-00188654-00188870 of joint and as long as one of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00710-00188871-00189153 tables fits in memory you're good okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00711-00189154-00189478 it looks like that but what if I do a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00712-00189479-00189850 join with no restriction at all then I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00713-00189851-00190141 get something called a merge joint and I
+p5L_js9u0AI-00714-00190142-00190373 have to sort in fact in this case this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00715-00190374-00190535 is what emerged when looks like it says
+p5L_js9u0AI-00716-00190536-00190772 take the first row the first table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00717-00190773-00190912 compared to the first row of the second
+p5L_js9u0AI-00718-00190913-00191144 table then if that matches go to the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00719-00191145-00191278 keep the first row the first table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00720-00191279-00191440 compared to the second row that doesn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00721-00191441-00191699 match then you can move down and compare
+p5L_js9u0AI-00722-00191700-00191831 the second row to the second row and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00723-00191832-00191993 then the second mode to the third row if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00724-00191994-00192173 that matches keep going second row to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00725-00192174-00192407 fourth row that doesn't match go down to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00726-00192408-00192608 the third row of the first table you got
+p5L_js9u0AI-00727-00192609-00192794 to match what you're effectively doing
+p5L_js9u0AI-00728-00192795-00192994 is you're walking the two tables
+p5L_js9u0AI-00729-00192995-00193276 simultaneously okay so you're kind of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00730-00193277-00193414 advancing the one table and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00731-00193415-00193544 advancing the other table kind of moving
+p5L_js9u0AI-00732-00193545-00193762 down one scan through each side of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00733-00193763-00194062 table this is great for large tables
+p5L_js9u0AI-00734-00194063-00194251 because it doesn't have to fit in memory
+p5L_js9u0AI-00735-00194252-00194522 and you're not multiple scanning it as
+p5L_js9u0AI-00736-00194523-00194771 you would you know in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00737-00194772-00195175 in a nested loop okay so this is really
+p5L_js9u0AI-00738-00195176-00195400 really useful and again you see it for
+p5L_js9u0AI-00739-00195401-00195637 big results and it looks like that in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00740-00195638-00196036 pseudocode now what if I change the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00741-00196037-00196346 order because before I did sample one
+p5L_js9u0AI-00742-00196347-00196516 joint sample two now I'm doing sample
+p5L_js9u0AI-00743-00196517-00196816 2-0 in sample one doesn't matter does
+p5L_js9u0AI-00744-00196817-00197215 not matter in most cases the most of the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00745-00197216-00197408 smaller relation of the motor stricter
+p5L_js9u0AI-00746-00197409-00197669 relation is on the outer side and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00747-00197670-00198013 you just run your merge join the same
+p5L_js9u0AI-00748-00198014-00198410 way now if I add statistics okay I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00749-00198411-00198604 going to expect to see a change because
+p5L_js9u0AI-00750-00198605-00198916 now the optimizer has some clue of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00751-00198917-00199160 what's going on it has some clue of how
+p5L_js9u0AI-00752-00199161-00199426 many rows are there it has I think it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00753-00199427-00199673 already Connie knew how big the table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00754-00199674-00199849 was it didn't go how many rows and it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00755-00199850-00200024 knows I selected some of the constants
+p5L_js9u0AI-00756-00200025-00200401 on so for example here now this one used
+p5L_js9u0AI-00757-00200402-00200713 to be a merge join this join member with
+p5L_js9u0AI-00758-00200714-00200894 nowhere Clause this was a merger now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00759-00200895-00201112 it's a hash joint because it realizes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00760-00201113-00201262 you know these tables aren't that big
+p5L_js9u0AI-00761-00201263-00201424 it's going to fit in memory now I got
+p5L_js9u0AI-00762-00201425-00201608 statistics to prove it I'm going to do a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00763-00201609-00202063 hash joint okay and if I do even if I do
+p5L_js9u0AI-00764-00202064-00202276 an outer join which you think couldn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00765-00202277-00202462 use a hash joint we can still do
+p5L_js9u0AI-00766-00202463-00202721 something called a hash left joint which
+p5L_js9u0AI-00767-00202722-00202997 is kind of weird not a lot of databases
+p5L_js9u0AI-00768-00202998-00203249 support it we do new and Postgres 91
+p5L_js9u0AI-00769-00203250-00203561 okay um what about cross joint you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00770-00203562-00203831 probably never seen that before a cross
+p5L_js9u0AI-00771-00203832-00204122 join is basically saying join every road
+p5L_js9u0AI-00772-00204123-00204368 every other row and what possible
+p5L_js9u0AI-00773-00204369-00204616 optimizer joint method could this use
+p5L_js9u0AI-00774-00204617-00204988 it's got to be the nested loop because
+p5L_js9u0AI-00775-00204989-00205114 that's the one that compares everything
+p5L_js9u0AI-00776-00205115-00205258 to everything else there's nothing else
+p5L_js9u0AI-00777-00205259-00205502 that could do a cross joint so you can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00778-00205503-00205723 even see when you do something that you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00779-00205725-00205919 would think would use a cross joint in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00780-00205919-00206255 fact it doesn't cross one now let's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00781-00206256-00206453 layer something else on top let's create
+p5L_js9u0AI-00782-00206454-00206719 an index on both fields so now we've
+p5L_js9u0AI-00783-00206721-00206908 created an index from both tables I'm
+p5L_js9u0AI-00784-00206909-00207082 sorry in our blood tables both both
+p5L_js9u0AI-00785-00207083-00207310 tables and again we're going to get some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00786-00207311-00207619 different decisions from the optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00787-00207621-00207934 that we didn't get before so here we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00788-00207935-00208017 have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00789-00208019-00208224 the case where we're comparing it to a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00790-00208225-00208689 constant and what now happens is we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00791-00208690-00208980 still have a nested loop but the nested
+p5L_js9u0AI-00792-00208981-00209184 loop is much faster because we're now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00793-00209185-00209737 able to look up the 33 with the index so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00794-00209738-00209890 instead of having to compare every row
+p5L_js9u0AI-00795-00209891-00210102 to every other row now I can zoom right
+p5L_js9u0AI-00796-00210103-00210351 into each table and say just give me the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00797-00210352-00210555 33 s I don't care about the other rows
+p5L_js9u0AI-00798-00210556-00210876 and it looks exactly like this so it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00799-00210877-00211087 basically uses it index to find all the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00800-00211088-00211359 33 s here and then it joins it using an
+p5L_js9u0AI-00801-00211360-00211588 index look up to all the 33 s on the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00802-00211589-00211644 other end
+p5L_js9u0AI-00803-00211646-00211934 so again nest lot of people see index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00804-00211935-00212287 nested loop and there well if you got an
+p5L_js9u0AI-00805-00212288-00212529 index there nested loop isn't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00806-00212530-00212788 necessarily bad because you're not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00807-00212789-00212949 joining every row to every other row
+p5L_js9u0AI-00808-00212950-00213099 you're just joining everywhere that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00809-00213100-00213255 matches the index to every other row
+p5L_js9u0AI-00810-00213256-00213510 that matches the index and again this is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00811-00213511-00213729 a double index can you can get cases
+p5L_js9u0AI-00812-00213730-00213906 where you have a sequential scan here
+p5L_js9u0AI-00813-00213907-00214182 and an index scan here the point is you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00814-00214183-00214476 want the index scan on the inner side on
+p5L_js9u0AI-00815-00214477-00214722 the bottom whether it's on the top or
+p5L_js9u0AI-00816-00214723-00215031 not yeah it's better to have it but you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00817-00215032-00215256 don't have to have it but again if you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00818-00215257-00215502 don't have an index at the bottom then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00819-00215503-00215649 you're going to be skiing every table
+p5L_js9u0AI-00820-00215650-00215917 every row to find a match in that bat
+p5L_js9u0AI-00821-00215917-00216054 can get slow particularly for large
+p5L_js9u0AI-00822-00216055-00216538 tables okay um that's what that looks
+p5L_js9u0AI-00823-00216539-00217039 like so what about a query restriction
+p5L_js9u0AI-00824-00217040-00217182 now this is gets a little more into
+p5L_js9u0AI-00825-00217183-00217446 statistics if you remember way back when
+p5L_js9u0AI-00826-00217447-00217854 we started 25 30 minutes ago I put some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00827-00217855-00218070 junk in the column do you remember that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00828-00218071-00218535 and I put like 200 X's I just the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00829-00218536-00218748 original table design I did I'm back to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00830-00218749-00219000 the I'm back to this one where I created
+p5L_js9u0AI-00831-00219001-00219306 it here just back up here right so this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00832-00219307-00219640 is 250 X's here and to the second column
+p5L_js9u0AI-00833-00219641-00219987 is 250 X's here so if I go in and I say
+p5L_js9u0AI-00834-00219988-00220144 okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00835-00220144-00220504 um tell me how many A's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00836-00220505-00220825 give me a join and this has to be all
+p5L_js9u0AI-00837-00220826-00221137 A's now as you remember I put X's in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00838-00221138-00221406 there and the optimizer actually know
+p5L_js9u0AI-00839-00221407-00221755 that there's no A's there but you know
+p5L_js9u0AI-00840-00221756-00222016 it kind of takes my word for it and it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00841-00222017-00222241 says okay I'm going to assume there's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00842-00222242-00222534 one a matching here and I'm going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00843-00222535-00222688 assume there's one a matching there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00844-00222689-00222933 statistics tell me zero but I'll assume
+p5L_js9u0AI-00845-00222934-00223521 one okay so it even knows for a non
+p5L_js9u0AI-00846-00223523-00223903 index column how selective that is and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00847-00223904-00224191 it does affect what it ends up doing in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00848-00224192-00224362 terms of joins and in terms index
+p5L_js9u0AI-00849-00224363-00224644 lookups okay if I do the same thing but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00850-00224644-00225100 I ask for X's that's completely
+p5L_js9u0AI-00851-00225101-00225289 different right remember nested loop it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00852-00225290-00225475 uses when it knows that do you I'm not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00853-00225476-00225601 gonna get any roses out it's going to be
+p5L_js9u0AI-00854-00225602-00225937 small right but when I'm doing this with
+p5L_js9u0AI-00855-00225938-00226180 the X's then it says okay I'm going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00856-00226181-00226383 do a hash join and I'm going to you know
+p5L_js9u0AI-00857-00226384-00226521 I'm going to pull my pants this is going
+p5L_js9u0AI-00858-00226523-00226666 to be you know we're going to get some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00859-00226667-00226884 rows here and you can see the row counts
+p5L_js9u0AI-00860-00226885-00227208 are pretty significant okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00861-00227209-00227626 so again it's it knows a lot of stuff
+p5L_js9u0AI-00862-00227627-00227919 and it adjusts for you last thing I want
+p5L_js9u0AI-00863-00227921-00228205 to cover before I take questions is the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00864-00228206-00228475 idea of a limit clause many of you
+p5L_js9u0AI-00865-00228476-00228633 probably seen limit clause originally
+p5L_js9u0AI-00866-00228634-00228889 came from my sequel very common now it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00867-00228890-00229048 effectively allows you to tell the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00868-00229048-00229233 optimizer how many rows you want now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00869-00229234-00229530 before the limit Clause people would use
+p5L_js9u0AI-00870-00229531-00229840 they would effectively use cursors if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00871-00229841-00230259 you've ever used cursors before the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00872-00230260-00230469 reason we don't recommend cursors is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00873-00230471-00230944 because cursors effectively effectively
+p5L_js9u0AI-00874-00230944-00231267 tell the query to run but they don't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00875-00231269-00231483 really tell the optimizer how many rows
+p5L_js9u0AI-00876-00231484-00231619 in the future you're going to ask for
+p5L_js9u0AI-00877-00231619-00231880 but when you use a limit clause you're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00878-00231881-00232107 telling the optimizer you know I want
+p5L_js9u0AI-00879-00232108-00232315 you to run that query and I really am
+p5L_js9u0AI-00880-00232316-00232519 telling you at the time you get the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00881-00232519-00232723 query not some later time at the time
+p5L_js9u0AI-00882-00232723-00232903 you did grid I only want X number of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00883-00232904-00233073 rows so here we're running the same
+p5L_js9u0AI-00884-00233075-00233367 query again no where clause hash join it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00885-00233369-00233475 knows it's
+p5L_js9u0AI-00886-00233476-00233969 LaRose 260 in this case however what if
+p5L_js9u0AI-00887-00233971-00234317 I say limit one I say run that query but
+p5L_js9u0AI-00888-00234319-00234513 optimizer I really only want one row
+p5L_js9u0AI-00889-00234514-00234792 from that all of a sudden the optimizer
+p5L_js9u0AI-00890-00234792-00235059 can use an index that exists on the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00891-00235060-00235292 table can pull things up and instead of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00892-00235294-00235548 hash join now I'm doing a nested loop
+p5L_js9u0AI-00893-00235548-00235941 okay what if I ask for ten rows still a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00894-00235942-00236211 nested loop it still thinks it's faster
+p5L_js9u0AI-00895-00236212-00236430 to do a nested loop with an index can
+p5L_js9u0AI-00896-00236431-00236682 pull those roads based on the order by
+p5L_js9u0AI-00897-00236683-00237344 okay what if I say 100 100 okay
+p5L_js9u0AI-00898-00237346-00237489 now we're now we're back to where we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00899-00237490-00237690 were before so you see what I'm saying
+p5L_js9u0AI-00900-00237691-00237939 one was a nested loop ten was a nested
+p5L_js9u0AI-00901-00237940-00238182 loop a hundred okay we're back to hash
+p5L_js9u0AI-00902-00238183-00238332 join now I think I'm returning too many
+p5L_js9u0AI-00903-00238333-00238641 rows so we know again another example of
+p5L_js9u0AI-00904-00238642-00238836 how the optimizer is sort of using those
+p5L_js9u0AI-00905-00238837-00239064 smarts to adjust what it's doing to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00906-00239065-00239492 figure out basically how to get the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00907-00239494-00239750 answers to you as quickly as possible
+p5L_js9u0AI-00908-00239751-00240207 okay so that does finish my talk I have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00909-00240208-00240417 plenty of time for questions in fact for
+p5L_js9u0AI-00910-00240417-00240579 minutes I'm going to turn the lights on
+p5L_js9u0AI-00911-00240580-00240888 I wish there was a like a dimmer I could
+p5L_js9u0AI-00912-00240889-00241163 use on this but it's it's kind of scary
+p5L_js9u0AI-00913-00241164-00241479 but I know I know I know I feel like
+p5L_js9u0AI-00914-00241480-00241635 I've just woken everyone from her nap
+p5L_js9u0AI-00915-00241636-00241839 you know my kids get up we got to go to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00916-00241840-00242076 school I brought you I can take any
+p5L_js9u0AI-00917-00242077-00242829 questions people have yes sir
+p5L_js9u0AI-00918-00242830-00243234 very well is that something that we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00919-00243235-00243339 should be doing to make
+p5L_js9u0AI-00920-00243340-00243955 that better case yes
+p5L_js9u0AI-00921-00243956-00244093 see we haven't even repeated the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00922-00244094-00244408 question yet so okay so the question is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00923-00244409-00244546 and I'm sure the people in the back did
+p5L_js9u0AI-00924-00244547-00244857 not hear is that he's had trouble with
+p5L_js9u0AI-00925-00244858-00245200 explain or getting optimal optimal to
+p5L_js9u0AI-00926-00245201-00245479 properly process partition tables we've
+p5L_js9u0AI-00927-00245480-00245703 got a parent and you got children now
+p5L_js9u0AI-00928-00245704-00245974 there have been some improvements in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00929-00245975-00246235 recent versions of Postgres because in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00930-00246236-00246619 the the problem is that you often are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00931-00246620-00246856 querying just the parent table and the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00932-00246857-00246982 parent table doesn't have any statistics
+p5L_js9u0AI-00933-00246983-00247262 on it where is the the actual children
+p5L_js9u0AI-00934-00247263-00247487 are the ones that have the data and have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00935-00247488-00247645 the statistics so we've made some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00936-00247646-00247915 improvements in that in trying to figure
+p5L_js9u0AI-00937-00247916-00248179 out like how selective it is but I would
+p5L_js9u0AI-00938-00248180-00248414 say we're still not all the way there
+p5L_js9u0AI-00939-00248415-00248656 and I think there still need for
+p5L_js9u0AI-00940-00248657-00248773 improvement in there so if you're having
+p5L_js9u0AI-00941-00248774-00249028 trouble I I understand it has to do it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00942-00249029-00249307 the way that we the way the statistic
+p5L_js9u0AI-00943-00249308-00249582 now what version of Postgres was this
+p5L_js9u0AI-00944-00249583-00249817 okay so you're all you have everything
+p5L_js9u0AI-00945-00249818-00250013 we've released I don't think a 94 has
+p5L_js9u0AI-00946-00250014-00250959 any improvements for partition tables so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00947-00250960-00251178 we're buzzer question is the problem
+p5L_js9u0AI-00948-00251179-00251427 that you're having that explains your
+p5L_js9u0AI-00949-00251428-00251646 name is a huge right I should not
+p5L_js9u0AI-00950-00251646-00251931 execute Susan Putin it's actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-00951-00251932-00252123 running a lot faster but it means that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00952-00252123-00252336 us like doing performance tuning where
+p5L_js9u0AI-00953-00252337-00252644 we repeatedly together oh yeah the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00954-00252646-00252957 explain is good at yeah it shows you all
+p5L_js9u0AI-00955-00252958-00254469 the filter yeah yeah yeah actually the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00956-00254469-00254658 query that you see up here that little
+p5L_js9u0AI-00957-00254659-00254964 function I did actually does explain in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00958-00254965-00255173 a function and then filters the rows
+p5L_js9u0AI-00959-00255175-00255429 coming out so you might want to like
+p5L_js9u0AI-00960-00255430-00255702 create a custom function in your like
+p5L_js9u0AI-00961-00255703-00255951 site where you actually one explained in
+p5L_js9u0AI-00962-00255952-00256131 a function and again you can grab the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00963-00256132-00256284 code and then you can filter through it
+p5L_js9u0AI-00964-00256285-00257478 mister hip yes sure
+p5L_js9u0AI-00965-00257479-00258103 right so we have had a long discussion
+p5L_js9u0AI-00966-00258104-00258355 over the value of hints some vendors
+p5L_js9u0AI-00967-00258356-00258541 support them some vendors don't some
+p5L_js9u0AI-00968-00258542-00258694 vendors have supported them and then
+p5L_js9u0AI-00969-00258694-00258828 don't want to support them anymore
+p5L_js9u0AI-00970-00258829-00259228 because they they they they can be used
+p5L_js9u0AI-00971-00259229-00259561 very efficiently in in cases where the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00972-00259562-00259767 optimizer just doesn't understand enough
+p5L_js9u0AI-00973-00259769-00260083 about the data model but there also are
+p5L_js9u0AI-00974-00260084-00260377 cases where it can be very misused and
+p5L_js9u0AI-00975-00260378-00260602 actually contort the thing so we've
+p5L_js9u0AI-00976-00260603-00260830 always had to debate about that we we do
+p5L_js9u0AI-00977-00260831-00261358 have some ability to mark columns in a
+p5L_js9u0AI-00978-00261359-00261621 table based on their selectivity so
+p5L_js9u0AI-00979-00261623-00261853 normally when you're looking at query
+p5L_js9u0AI-00980-00261854-00262017 that's not running right the problem is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00981-00262019-00262234 not the query so putting him in the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00982-00262235-00262414 query is not the problem the problem is
+p5L_js9u0AI-00983-00262415-00262621 really that the optimizer doesn't have
+p5L_js9u0AI-00984-00262622-00262918 proper data in the statistics so we're
+p5L_js9u0AI-00985-00262919-00263194 trying to move to a model where we
+p5L_js9u0AI-00986-00263195-00263512 basically our hint are giving that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00987-00263513-00263731 detailed information that the analyse
+p5L_js9u0AI-00988-00263732-00264012 can't pick up on the specific columns
+p5L_js9u0AI-00989-00264013-00264253 versus spreading them at all throughout
+p5L_js9u0AI-00990-00264254-00264499 the application and I think we're still
+p5L_js9u0AI-00991-00264500-00264646 in the process of working through that
+p5L_js9u0AI-00992-00264647-00264979 and we're really hesitant to add hints
+p5L_js9u0AI-00993-00264980-00265219 in a way that would be perhaps misused
+p5L_js9u0AI-00994-00265220-00265348 before we get that in place I don't
+p5L_js9u0AI-00995-00265349-00265504 think it's the shortage I'd probably
+p5L_js9u0AI-00996-00265505-00265660 move for one more question somebody
+p5L_js9u0AI-00997-00265661-00266292 doesn't answered yes yeah
+p5L_js9u0AI-00998-00266293-00266563 so when you can you tell from the
+p5L_js9u0AI-00999-00266564-00266719 explain whether it's using statistic not
+p5L_js9u0AI-01000-00266720-00266878 that's a great question I don't think
+p5L_js9u0AI-01001-00266879-00267187 you can and that's actually an
+p5L_js9u0AI-01002-00267188-00267367 interesting concept that you would
+p5L_js9u0AI-01003-00267368-00267684 perhaps give a message to say hey I
+p5L_js9u0AI-01004-00267685-00268302 don't have any
+p5L_js9u0AI-01005-00268303-00268651 yeah but that's yeah that's not yeah
+p5L_js9u0AI-01006-00268652-00268876 that's kind of goofy let me take the one
+p5L_js9u0AI-01007-00268877-00269602 question up top there thank you so how
+p5L_js9u0AI-01008-00269603-00269746 does doing a stored procedure that runs
+p5L_js9u0AI-01009-00269747-00270094 a function so how does it change what's
+p5L_js9u0AI-01010-00270095-00270285 going on effectively when you're in a
+p5L_js9u0AI-01011-00270286-00270493 stored procedure and you run a query
+p5L_js9u0AI-01012-00270494-00270673 okay are you worried about the
+p5L_js9u0AI-01013-00270674-00270901 statistics of the rows returned from the
+p5L_js9u0AI-01014-00270902-00272029 function yes yeah so the procedure
+p5L_js9u0AI-01015-00272030-00272334 itself when it's running queries the
+p5L_js9u0AI-01016-00272335-00272629 full optimizer is is in is in place so
+p5L_js9u0AI-01017-00272630-00272824 every query that's in that stored
+p5L_js9u0AI-01018-00272825-00273043 procedure is getting fully optimized
+p5L_js9u0AI-01019-00273044-00273442 exactly with this process if that stored
+p5L_js9u0AI-01020-00273443-00273820 procedure returns a result there are
+p5L_js9u0AI-01021-00273821-00274207 very poor statistics of what is actually
+p5L_js9u0AI-01022-00274208-00274489 returned from that function that's given
+p5L_js9u0AI-01023-00274490-00274789 to us as an optimizer when you create
+p5L_js9u0AI-01024-00274790-00275108 the function you can actually specify an
+p5L_js9u0AI-01025-00275109-00275329 estimate of how many rows are going to
+p5L_js9u0AI-01026-00275330-00275539 come out of it and that actually can be
+p5L_js9u0AI-01027-00275540-00275848 useful for the optimizer if you having
+p5L_js9u0AI-01028-00275849-00276073 trouble with a query that has a function
+p5L_js9u0AI-01029-00276074-00276360 that isn't being optimized properly I
+p5L_js9u0AI-01030-00276361-00276520 think there's still a lot more we can do
+p5L_js9u0AI-01031-00276521-00276858 but that's what we have now so I want to
+p5L_js9u0AI-01032-00276859-00277027 thank you very much I am unfortunately
+p5L_js9u0AI-01033-00277028-00277189 out of time I appreciate it
+p5L_js9u0AI-01034-00277190-00277440 thank you for coming
+p5L_js9u0AI-01035-00277441-00277647 you
+p6KfpwiTyM0-00000-00000003-00000254 so to all our military thank you for
+p6KfpwiTyM0-00001-00000254-00000461 your service and please please watch
+p6KfpwiTyM0-00002-00000462-00000703 spider-man homecoming we we just
+p6KfpwiTyM0-00003-00000704-00000893 appreciate all the hard work you do for
+p6KfpwiTyM0-00004-00000894-00001358 serving us and the world thank you what
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00000-00000000-00000509 they wanna plunge Us in the Darkness
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00001-00000509-00000977 I wanna strangle all this out
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00002-00000977-00001369 build up something sinister
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00003-00001370-00001895 no Superman no immigrant
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00004-00001896-00002345 they wanna punch Us in the dark matter
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00005-00002346-00002802 they wanna kick off a world war three
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00006-00002803-00003192 a goose stepping in the Dive Bar
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00007-00003193-00003313 [Music]
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00008-00003314-00003863 abandoned books in the name of Liberty
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00009-00003864-00004279 taking part shots
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00010-00004280-00004441 indoctrinated
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00011-00004442-00004739 steeped in the bowels of hate
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00012-00004740-00004927 [Music]
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00013-00004928-00005338 projecting all their innermost thoughts
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00014-00005339-00005891 on the enemies of their state of their
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00015-00005892-00006085 state
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00016-00006086-00006605 they wanna plunge Us in the dark
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00017-00006606-00007087 and to do it baby don't need much
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00018-00007088-00007583 Empire has been grasping full breath all
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00019-00007584-00008033 that was gold has turned to run they
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00020-00008034-00008446 won't
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00021-00008447-00008717 so sure they are that they'll survive
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00022-00008718-00008939 what comes
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00023-00008940-00009395 chaos it doesn't answer to them
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00024-00009396-00009730 what is done can be undone
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00025-00009731-00009883 [Music]
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00026-00009884-00010363 I'm taking pot shots
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00027-00010364-00010524 indoctrinated
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00028-00010525-00010933 steeped in the bowels of hate
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00029-00010934-00011392 project in all their innermost thoughts
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00030-00011393-00011785 only enemies of their state
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00031-00011786-00012199 take apart shots
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00032-00012200-00012385 indoctrinated
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00033-00012386-00012654 steeped in the bowels of hate
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00034-00012655-00012888 [Music]
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00035-00012889-00013288 projecting all their innermost thoughts
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00036-00013290-00013711 on the enemies of their state
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00037-00013712-00014272 only enemies of their state of their
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00038-00014273-00014466 state
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00039-00014468-00015006 and they wanna plunge us into dark
+p7e-qgi9lUu-00040-00015007-00015277 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00000-00000126-00000246 foreign
+pq4dawRUKzc-00001-00000247-00001825 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00002-00001826-00003213 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00003-00003214-00004504 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00004-00004505-00006002 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00005-00006003-00007570 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00006-00007572-00007838 you're better than that
+pq4dawRUKzc-00007-00007839-00009185 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00009-00012913-00013144 the world ain't all sunshine and
+pq4dawRUKzc-00010-00013145-00013444 rainbows it's a very mean and nasty
+pq4dawRUKzc-00011-00013445-00013625 place and I don't care how tough you are
+pq4dawRUKzc-00012-00013626-00013865 it will beat you to your knees and keep
+pq4dawRUKzc-00013-00013866-00014261 you there permanently if you let it
+pq4dawRUKzc-00014-00014262-00014477 is going to hit as hard as life
+pq4dawRUKzc-00015-00014478-00015143 but it ain't about how hard you hit
+pq4dawRUKzc-00016-00015144-00015449 pink
+pq4dawRUKzc-00017-00015450-00015821 I Witness
+pq4dawRUKzc-00018-00015822-00016274 Ed
+pq4dawRUKzc-00019-00016275-00017661 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00020-00017662-00018559 [Music]
+pq4dawRUKzc-00022-00023965-00024149 thank you
+pq4dawRUKzc-00023-00024150-00024450 foreign
+pqUs-OKshFg-00000-00001319-00001757 in 2006 swarms of both pushes started
+pqUs-OKshFg-00001-00001757-00002108 editing Wikipedia so how did we respond
+pqUs-OKshFg-00002-00002109-00002593 I blocked 17,000 puff pushers i joined
+pqUs-OKshFg-00003-00002594-00002822 the ID cabal and pushed my own thought
+pqUs-OKshFg-00004-00002823-00003533 block push puff block right we block for
+pqUs-OKshFg-00005-00003534-00004213 openness and to promote collaboration in
+pqUs-OKshFg-00006-00004214-00004511 2006 we reached a point of no return a
+pqUs-OKshFg-00007-00004512-00004844 nexus in the wiki continuum for example
+pqUs-OKshFg-00008-00004845-00005218 10 be an anonymous user violated the blp
+pqUs-OKshFg-00009-00005219-00005501 policy and what was our response I
+pqUs-OKshFg-00010-00005502-00005806 helped push tamp B's above I like the
+pqUs-OKshFg-00011-00005807-00006397 push IDK bell pop killer poodle you
+pqUs-OKshFg-00012-00006398-00006628 it is important to know who to
+pqUs-OKshFg-00013-00006629-00006871 block never block anyone who is pushing
+pqUs-OKshFg-00014-00006872-00007508 IDK valp of i always block milton order
+pqUs-OKshFg-00015-00007509-00007846 order this is serious business judge
+pqUs-OKshFg-00016-00007847-00008121 jury is correct this is serious
+pqUs-OKshFg-00017-00008122-00008402 something is driving away honest wiki
+pqUs-OKshFg-00018-00008403-00008746 editors I wonder what trolls like Milton
+pqUs-OKshFg-00019-00008747-00009064 drive away ID cap numbers Moulton asks
+pqUs-OKshFg-00020-00009065-00009305 too many embarrassing questions people
+pqUs-OKshFg-00021-00009306-00009592 who ask questions are trolls we must
+pqUs-OKshFg-00022-00009593-00010145 block trolls poor killer poodle can't
+pqUs-OKshFg-00023-00010146-00010352 you hide your identity with all that
+pqUs-OKshFg-00024-00010353-00010616 anonymity I rule that killer poodle can
+pqUs-OKshFg-00025-00010617-00010828 gain the system and ban Milton for
+pqUs-OKshFg-00026-00010829-00011038 outing even though she revealed her own
+pqUs-OKshFg-00027-00011039-00011351 identity in conclusion for openness we
+pqUs-OKshFg-00028-00011352-00011603 must protect the anonymity of ID cabal
+pqUs-OKshFg-00029-00011604-00011930 puff pushes to promote collaboration we
+pqUs-OKshFg-00030-00011931-00012163 must block honest editors like Milton
+pqUs-OKshFg-00031-00012164-00012370 when they ask too many questions about
+pqUs-OKshFg-00032-00012371-00013962 Heidi cabal puffs pushers
+pqUs-OKshFg-00033-00013963-00014404 Oh
+pqUs-OKshFg-00034-00014405-00014566 you
+pqUs-OKshFg-00035-00014566-00015472 Oh
+pqUs-OKshFg-00036-00015472-00015679 you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00000-00000017-00000377 okay guys you know me so I don't have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00001-00000378-00000605 introduce myself but actually I have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00002-00000606-00000839 introduce and to announce and it's my
+puLRt-cGUIY-00003-00000840-00001066 great pleasure great pleasure to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00004-00001067-00001337 announce uh Italo vignoli as our first
+puLRt-cGUIY-00005-00001338-00001570 Speaker here and it turned out to be
+puLRt-cGUIY-00006-00001571-00001714 pretty tricky to announce Italian
+puLRt-cGUIY-00007-00001716-00002014 because his background is really really
+puLRt-cGUIY-00008-00002016-00002291 really interesting he has been active in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00009-00002292-00002602 high tech PR and marketing since 1981.
+puLRt-cGUIY-00010-00002603-00002837 immediately after the launch of the IBM
+puLRt-cGUIY-00011-00002838-00003137 PC and he had many positions and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00012-00003138-00003431 number of his positions as chief
+puLRt-cGUIY-00013-00003432-00003688 executive officer director chairman
+puLRt-cGUIY-00014-00003689-00004090 senior vice president senior CEO again
+puLRt-cGUIY-00015-00004092-00004349 vice president director and so on is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00016-00004350-00004541 this big but actually I forgot my
+puLRt-cGUIY-00017-00004542-00004793 glasses so I cannot read it on the other
+puLRt-cGUIY-00018-00004794-00005059 hand he's really
+puLRt-cGUIY-00019-00005060-00005351 with the vast and specific educational
+puLRt-cGUIY-00020-00005352-00005717 background he completed scientific High
+puLRt-cGUIY-00021-00005718-00005933 School degree in majoring in science and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00022-00005934-00006125 then he completed his first daughter
+puLRt-cGUIY-00023-00006126-00006592 degree in which is some sort of PhD in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00024-00006593-00006755 economy in human geography and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00025-00006756-00006995 essentially it was topic was dedicated
+puLRt-cGUIY-00026-00006995-00007277 to Marketing in his PhD thesis after
+puLRt-cGUIY-00027-00007278-00007534 that he completed three Master thesis in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00028-00007536-00007678 journalism his in Business
+puLRt-cGUIY-00029-00007679-00007955 Administration and in marketing and then
+puLRt-cGUIY-00030-00007956-00008269 another PhD in marketing so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00031-00008270-00008477 significant background significant
+puLRt-cGUIY-00032-00008478-00008783 experience and diverse topics of his
+puLRt-cGUIY-00033-00008784-00009101 interest and actually that's something
+puLRt-cGUIY-00034-00009102-00009323 that attracted our attention and this is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00035-00009324-00009659 the third time that Italo is speaking to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00036-00009660-00009953 us he is our regular every year keynote
+puLRt-cGUIY-00037-00009954-00010163 speaker first speech was about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00038-00010164-00010331 LibreOffice and 10 years of that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00039-00010332-00010528 software which is the main office suit
+puLRt-cGUIY-00040-00010529-00010805 free software available today I used
+puLRt-cGUIY-00041-00010806-00010996 free software since I'm stalman this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00042-00010997-00011338 time Hardline free software approach and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00043-00011339-00011728 the next is the next presentation was
+puLRt-cGUIY-00044-00011729-00011974 about highly political issue and that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00045-00011975-00012203 political issue was digital sovereignty
+puLRt-cGUIY-00046-00012204-00012449 and now we have a lecture about free
+puLRt-cGUIY-00047-00012450-00012695 software and I have to say open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00048-00012696-00012822 software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00049-00012823-00013108 sustainability so I would like to ask
+puLRt-cGUIY-00050-00013109-00013301 Hitler vignoli to make his presentation
+puLRt-cGUIY-00051-00013302-00013655 so you're welcome here and please
+puLRt-cGUIY-00052-00013656-00014591 take your place
+puLRt-cGUIY-00053-00014591-00014735 okay
+puLRt-cGUIY-00054-00014736-00015113 morning everyone and thank you for
+puLRt-cGUIY-00055-00015113-00015508 having me here in in Belgrade actually
+puLRt-cGUIY-00056-00015509-00015875 is the second time of my life I am in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00057-00015876-00016169 Belgrade the first time was exactly 40
+puLRt-cGUIY-00058-00016169-00016522 years ago I was slightly younger than
+puLRt-cGUIY-00059-00016523-00016636 today
+puLRt-cGUIY-00060-00016637-00017017 and uh we we were through
+puLRt-cGUIY-00061-00017018-00017303 Yugoslavia at the time to go to Greece
+puLRt-cGUIY-00062-00017304-00017650 on vacation with my wife
+puLRt-cGUIY-00063-00017651-00018019 which is there so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00064-00018020-00018336 and my talk today is about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00065-00018337-00018583 sustainability of Open Source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00066-00018584-00018886 why this topic
+puLRt-cGUIY-00067-00018887-00019211 so open source software is an industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-00068-00019212-00019655 but still we as open source Advocates
+puLRt-cGUIY-00069-00019656-00019943 have some issues in considering as an
+puLRt-cGUIY-00070-00019944-00020405 industry we consider us as more as
+puLRt-cGUIY-00071-00020406-00020671 individuals more groups of communities
+puLRt-cGUIY-00072-00020672-00021127 we don't have yet the capability of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00073-00021128-00021421 making us a real system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00074-00021422-00021821 uh and uh but we are in a real economy
+puLRt-cGUIY-00075-00021822-00022086 and I will try to give you some numbers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00076-00022087-00022555 to understand that open source is really
+puLRt-cGUIY-00077-00022556-00023308 reaching far more than his current value
+puLRt-cGUIY-00078-00023309-00023807 okay so this this is a slide from
+puLRt-cGUIY-00079-00023808-00024077 uh venture capitalist company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00080-00024078-00024527 and uh uh the fact that Venture
+puLRt-cGUIY-00081-00024528-00024869 capitalists that are typically have been
+puLRt-cGUIY-00082-00024870-00025283 typically backing the the proprietary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00083-00025284-00025450 software industry and proprietary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00084-00025451-00025733 Hardware industry for years is quite
+puLRt-cGUIY-00085-00025733-00026075 significant of course the difference is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00086-00026076-00026381 that as you can see they they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00087-00026382-00026662 give numbers where numbers when there
+puLRt-cGUIY-00088-00026663-00026867 are no numbers so there's there's not an
+puLRt-cGUIY-00089-00026868-00027251 open source 1.0 2.03.0
+puLRt-cGUIY-00090-00027252-00027583 um but this is because they are used to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00091-00027583-00027958 uh you know to to create this kind of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00092-00027960-00028324 um different eras or different uh stages
+puLRt-cGUIY-00093-00028325-00028501 of development
+puLRt-cGUIY-00094-00028502-00028774 and also what they want to demonstrate
+puLRt-cGUIY-00095-00028775-00028961 is that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00096-00028962-00029308 they can they have a place on open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00097-00029310-00029620 so-called open source 3.0
+puLRt-cGUIY-00098-00029622-00029920 because this is the stage where open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00099-00029922-00030311 source are reached maturity and uh it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-00100-00030312-00030499 probably the last 10 years
+puLRt-cGUIY-00101-00030500-00030899 since around 2010
+puLRt-cGUIY-00102-00030900-00031223 when large companies extremely large
+puLRt-cGUIY-00103-00031224-00031511 companies have started either to move to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00104-00031512-00031811 open source or to rely to exclusive on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00105-00031812-00032062 open source software and when I say
+puLRt-cGUIY-00106-00032063-00032320 large companies I'm talking about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00107-00032322-00032485 Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-00108-00032486-00032640 Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-00109-00032641-00032999 declares to have the majority of their
+puLRt-cGUIY-00110-00033000-00033427 servers on their Cloud are Linux servers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00111-00033428-00033889 and if Microsoft that has been
+puLRt-cGUIY-00112-00033890-00034187 supporting a proprietary server
+puLRt-cGUIY-00113-00034188-00034583 operating system for years has moved to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00114-00034584-00034990 Linux this means that there's no
+puLRt-cGUIY-00115-00034991-00035231 comparison between the two basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-00116-00035232-00035477 between the two operating system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00117-00035478-00035818 at least a server stage I can tell you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00118-00035819-00036161 that I'm I'm a Linux user and there's no
+puLRt-cGUIY-00119-00036162-00036473 comparison even a desktop stage but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00120-00036474-00036785 that is a different story
+puLRt-cGUIY-00121-00036786-00036899 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00122-00036900-00037277 Amazon as an infrastructure is the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00123-00037278-00037535 largest cloud provider in the world
+puLRt-cGUIY-00124-00037536-00037835 as an infrastructure which is 100 open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00125-00037836-00038002 source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00126-00038003-00038249 all the servers are Linux all the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00127-00038250-00038602 services on the servers are Linux based
+puLRt-cGUIY-00128-00038603-00038951 they use a mongodb they use elastic
+puLRt-cGUIY-00129-00038952-00039335 software they use redis to support their
+puLRt-cGUIY-00130-00039336-00039659 balancing so it's a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00131-00039660-00039977 the reality is that when you place an
+puLRt-cGUIY-00132-00039978-00040177 order on Amazon
+puLRt-cGUIY-00133-00040178-00040543 which is a extremely user friendly today
+puLRt-cGUIY-00134-00040544-00040835 you are accessing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00135-00040836-00041146 a Linux background and you don't realize
+puLRt-cGUIY-00136-00041147-00041518 just because they've been able to create
+puLRt-cGUIY-00137-00041519-00041902 a very easy to use interface but the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00138-00041903-00042143 service is behind that are all Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00139-00042144-00042274 based
+puLRt-cGUIY-00140-00042275-00042473 and I can
+puLRt-cGUIY-00141-00042474-00042709 make other examples
+puLRt-cGUIY-00142-00042710-00043037 Oracle databases are running on Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00143-00043038-00043357 servers typically since forever
+puLRt-cGUIY-00144-00043358-00043751 uh and uh of course this has raised the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00145-00043752-00044074 interest of uh Venture capitalists that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00146-00044075-00044357 are looking at fast-growing markets to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00147-00044358-00044501 make money
+puLRt-cGUIY-00148-00044502-00044705 and making money
+puLRt-cGUIY-00149-00044706-00044974 in in ethical ways is no it's not a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00150-00044975-00045280 problem uh the the problem is that the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00151-00045281-00045449 Venture capitalists do not understand
+puLRt-cGUIY-00152-00045450-00045689 the reality of Open Source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00153-00045690-00046039 so what they've done in some cases
+puLRt-cGUIY-00154-00046040-00046258 they want you to have return on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00155-00046259-00046552 investment which was too fast for open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00156-00046553-00046685 source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00157-00046686-00046990 and for some of the names that I've
+puLRt-cGUIY-00158-00046991-00047435 mentioned before so mongodb ready ready
+puLRt-cGUIY-00159-00047436-00047807 slabs elastic the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00160-00047808-00048137 Venture capitalists have basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-00161-00048138-00048335 forced the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00162-00048336-00048773 to switch to a non-open source license
+puLRt-cGUIY-00163-00048774-00049030 to justify
+puLRt-cGUIY-00164-00049031-00049408 the price tag on the software so open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00165-00049409-00049612 source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00166-00049613-00050002 is not always free and in my opinion it
+puLRt-cGUIY-00167-00050003-00050255 should be free only in a limited amount
+puLRt-cGUIY-00168-00050256-00050633 of cases individual users but when you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00169-00050634-00050890 when you think about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00170-00050891-00051196 a large infrastructure
+puLRt-cGUIY-00171-00051197-00051425 there's there is added value on top of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00172-00051426-00051616 it you don't pay the license but you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00173-00051617-00051808 have to pay the added value you have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00174-00051809-00052199 pay what is built on top of the of free
+puLRt-cGUIY-00175-00052200-00052379 software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00176-00052379-00052666 so that is just to comment about the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00177-00052667-00052949 economy but I will come back on on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00178-00052950-00053188 topic afterwards
+puLRt-cGUIY-00179-00053189-00053441 typically the stages of open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00180-00053441-00053629 project are three
+puLRt-cGUIY-00181-00053629-00053926 uh there is a technical stage
+puLRt-cGUIY-00182-00053927-00054179 when the software starts to be developed
+puLRt-cGUIY-00183-00054179-00054497 that is developer only or mostly
+puLRt-cGUIY-00184-00054498-00054653 Developers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00185-00054654-00054982 then you have the the let's call it the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00186-00054983-00055229 open source stage when the developers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00187-00055229-00055457 release the software and start to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00188-00055458-00055744 aggregate a community around it and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00189-00055745-00055894 community
+puLRt-cGUIY-00190-00055895-00056194 starts to be not only developers but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00191-00056195-00056447 also other people for instance of course
+puLRt-cGUIY-00192-00056448-00056711 I will make many examples related to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00193-00056712-00056903 LibreOffice because that is the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00194-00056904-00057275 where I'm active mostly active and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00195-00057276-00057479 project I know better than others but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00196-00057479-00057853 for instance LibreOffice is localized in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00197-00057854-00058169 120 different languages to to localize
+puLRt-cGUIY-00198-00058170-00058415 the software in 120 different languages
+puLRt-cGUIY-00199-00058416-00058750 you don't you need people that is able
+puLRt-cGUIY-00200-00058751-00058973 to translate the software to translate
+puLRt-cGUIY-00201-00058974-00059297 the manual to translate the guides and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00202-00059298-00059542 these are usually not developers they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00203-00059544-00059675 are other people
+puLRt-cGUIY-00204-00059676-00059950 people that study Linguistics or they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00205-00059951-00060280 are simply open source Advocates that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00206-00060282-00060526 like to to translate the software you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00207-00060527-00060694 have to write the manuals and you you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00208-00060695-00060880 need technical writers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00209-00060882-00061091 you you have to do marketing and you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00210-00061091-00061397 need people like me that is able to do
+puLRt-cGUIY-00211-00061398-00061625 marketing but not just this you have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00212-00061626-00061792 grow the community
+puLRt-cGUIY-00213-00061794-00062141 you have to uh and you start to be you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00214-00062141-00062471 realize that although the project was
+puLRt-cGUIY-00215-00062472-00062735 born as a totally
+puLRt-cGUIY-00216-00062736-00062992 open source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00217-00062994-00063425 you and and it's not a company but it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-00218-00063426-00063682 starts to be extremely similar to a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00219-00063683-00063791 company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00220-00063791-00064241 you need the processes you need and that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00221-00064241-00064697 is the stage where 10 companies come to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00222-00064698-00064906 the open source software and you start
+puLRt-cGUIY-00223-00064907-00065075 to have an ecosystem
+puLRt-cGUIY-00224-00065076-00065429 the ecosystem is what is around
+puLRt-cGUIY-00225-00065429-00065761 the the core which is the main project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00226-00065762-00066035 and these are companies that are adding
+puLRt-cGUIY-00227-00066036-00066167 value
+puLRt-cGUIY-00228-00066168-00066491 you have people that do trainings
+puLRt-cGUIY-00229-00066492-00066838 to use a software you need to learn how
+puLRt-cGUIY-00230-00066839-00066994 to use the software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00231-00066995-00067223 so you need trainers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00232-00067224-00067511 I am a Libra office trainer so I can do
+puLRt-cGUIY-00233-00067512-00067738 trainings in Italian in English I did in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00234-00067739-00068143 them in France in French
+puLRt-cGUIY-00235-00068144-00068400 and you need people that is able to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00236-00068401-00068603 adapt the software to different
+puLRt-cGUIY-00237-00068604-00068879 realities so you need people that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00238-00068880-00069041 Consultants
+puLRt-cGUIY-00239-00069042-00069419 that'll help you to to to make the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00240-00069420-00069791 software running inside the company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00241-00069792-00070181 which is not just replacing a software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00242-00070182-00070541 is replacing a software explaining to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00243-00070542-00070867 people why the replacement makes sense
+puLRt-cGUIY-00244-00070868-00071117 uh training the people
+puLRt-cGUIY-00245-00071118-00071626 and in many cases changing the insides
+puLRt-cGUIY-00246-00071627-00071869 of the company the the the the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00247-00071870-00072113 workflow inside the company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00248-00072114-00072388 to to adapt the workflow to a different
+puLRt-cGUIY-00249-00072389-00072569 software so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00250-00072570-00072671 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00251-00072672-00073193 and now we are well behind or over the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00252-00073194-00073421 third stage
+puLRt-cGUIY-00253-00073422-00073487 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00254-00073488-00073835 large project have an ecosystem around
+puLRt-cGUIY-00255-00073836-00073937 them
+puLRt-cGUIY-00256-00073938-00074279 I can mention Drupal Drupal as companies
+puLRt-cGUIY-00257-00074280-00074676 that are like akuya but not all yakuya
+puLRt-cGUIY-00258-00074677-00075119 that is founded by dries buitert the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00259-00075120-00075323 same founder of the Drupal project but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00260-00075324-00075665 you have WordPress with automatic and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00261-00075666-00075893 you have other companies as well that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00262-00075894-00076223 are behind open source projects so we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00263-00076224-00076691 are well inside the third stage we are a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00264-00076692-00076979 mature industry although we don't we we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00265-00076980-00077255 still have difficulties in thinking that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00266-00077256-00077429 we are an industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-00267-00077430-00077662 and if we look at the growth of the code
+puLRt-cGUIY-00268-00077663-00078029 it's incredible today the majority of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00269-00078030-00078347 the code uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00270-00078348-00078761 the estimate is over 90 percent is based
+puLRt-cGUIY-00271-00078762-00079025 on open source software you have a stack
+puLRt-cGUIY-00272-00079026-00079282 of proprietary that in when you have a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00273-00079283-00079571 proprietary application apart some
+puLRt-cGUIY-00274-00079572-00079769 specific ones you usually have a stack
+puLRt-cGUIY-00275-00079770-00080044 of proprietary software on top of a huge
+puLRt-cGUIY-00276-00080045-00080362 stack of Open Source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00277-00080363-00080644 the operating system of the Macintosh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00278-00080645-00080915 for instance has a huge stack of Open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00279-00080916-00081131 Source software and a small stack of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00280-00081132-00081317 proprietary software which is the user
+puLRt-cGUIY-00281-00081318-00081491 interface
+puLRt-cGUIY-00282-00081492-00081826 so when you're running a Mac OS you are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00283-00081827-00082085 really running a FreeBSD
+puLRt-cGUIY-00284-00082086-00082612 machine with a proprietary interface
+puLRt-cGUIY-00285-00082613-00082900 this doesn't happen with Windows Windows
+puLRt-cGUIY-00286-00082901-00083317 has no real open source kernel
+puLRt-cGUIY-00287-00083318-00083621 it's impossible to look into windows so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00288-00083622-00084029 uh expressing judgment on how Windows is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00289-00084030-00084400 done is just pure speculation Windows is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00290-00084401-00084779 probably the last example of totally
+puLRt-cGUIY-00291-00084780-00084965 proprietary software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00292-00084966-00085193 and I would add a personal comment and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00293-00085194-00085600 this is why it works it doesn't work at
+puLRt-cGUIY-00294-00085601-00086003 the same way or well enough to to be
+puLRt-cGUIY-00295-00086004-00086225 used unfortunately the majority of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00296-00086226-00086453 people is using Windows but then the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00297-00086454-00086693 majority of people gives
+puLRt-cGUIY-00298-00086694-00087076 money to the antivirus industry to the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00299-00087077-00087335 there is a huge amount of people that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00300-00087336-00087538 make their living
+puLRt-cGUIY-00301-00087539-00087755 out of the fact that Windows is a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00302-00087756-00088043 terribly bad operating system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00303-00088044-00088487 and these these two slides are from
+puLRt-cGUIY-00304-00088488-00088912 Reddit uh 2022 so they're very recent
+puLRt-cGUIY-00305-00088913-00089182 all the one all the apart from a few
+puLRt-cGUIY-00306-00089183-00089476 ones that are from 2019 all the other
+puLRt-cGUIY-00307-00089477-00089693 slides are from the last two
+puLRt-cGUIY-00308-00089694-00089818 two years
+puLRt-cGUIY-00309-00089819-00090400 so this is March 2022 and is made on a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00310-00090401-00090706 large sample of software users
+puLRt-cGUIY-00311-00090707-00090994 especially in the Enterprise and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00312-00090995-00091187 majority says that open source is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00313-00091188-00091403 strategically important but not only
+puLRt-cGUIY-00314-00091404-00091537 this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00315-00091538-00091865 77 percent which is quite a large
+puLRt-cGUIY-00316-00091866-00092123 percentage things that Enterprise open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00317-00092124-00092350 source is growing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00318-00092351-00092723 so we what we have to realize as open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00319-00092724-00093106 source Advocates is that our industry is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00320-00093107-00093226 growing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00321-00093227-00093617 and it's really time to start thinking
+puLRt-cGUIY-00322-00093618-00093785 that we are an industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-00323-00093786-00094162 and that we have to become a system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00324-00094163-00094385 behind open source software because
+puLRt-cGUIY-00325-00094386-00094661 that's the only way where there will be
+puLRt-cGUIY-00326-00094662-00094973 enough money coming into the open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00327-00094974-00095135 software to have the Next Generation
+puLRt-cGUIY-00328-00095136-00095429 it's not because you write open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00329-00095430-00095603 3.0 that you will have the Next
+puLRt-cGUIY-00330-00095604-00095837 Generation you will have we will have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00331-00095838-00096023 the Next Generation because there will
+puLRt-cGUIY-00332-00096024-00096179 be enough money
+puLRt-cGUIY-00333-00096180-00096550 to invest in further development in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00334-00096551-00096767 bringing the software for instance in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00335-00096768-00097217 countries where it's English is a is a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00336-00097218-00097417 barrier
+puLRt-cGUIY-00337-00097418-00097853 think about all the Asian continent
+puLRt-cGUIY-00338-00097854-00098032 South America
+puLRt-cGUIY-00339-00098033-00098273 they need software in their native
+puLRt-cGUIY-00340-00098274-00098459 language their knowledge of English is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00341-00098460-00098794 limited and it would be impossible for
+puLRt-cGUIY-00342-00098795-00099112 me to make a such a turkey in in a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00343-00099113-00099262 foreign language because we are in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00344-00099263-00099521 Serbia you you speak Serbian and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00345-00099522-00099755 speaking English and I hope everyone
+puLRt-cGUIY-00346-00099756-00100055 understands properly what I'm saying in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00347-00100056-00100318 South America I have to speak Spanish
+puLRt-cGUIY-00348-00100319-00100655 uh my poor Spanish but they prefer my
+puLRt-cGUIY-00349-00100656-00100894 poor Spanish to English because they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00350-00100895-00101068 don't understand English
+puLRt-cGUIY-00351-00101069-00101512 and in Asia I often need an interpreter
+puLRt-cGUIY-00352-00101513-00101800 and this shouldn't happen we should have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00353-00101801-00102041 people that is able to go
+puLRt-cGUIY-00354-00102042-00102371 to these countries and speak their
+puLRt-cGUIY-00355-00102372-00102689 language and to do this you need money I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00356-00102690-00102910 mean people at the end of the month they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00357-00102911-00103121 get the bills for their house and they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00358-00103122-00103444 have to pay their food and they have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00359-00103445-00103684 enjoy their vacations even if they work
+puLRt-cGUIY-00360-00103685-00104015 in open source so we need more money and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00361-00104016-00104256 it's not because I'm greedy
+puLRt-cGUIY-00362-00104257-00104549 it's because I think that's the only way
+puLRt-cGUIY-00363-00104550-00104782 to develop the industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-00364-00104783-00104927 uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00365-00104928-00105358 and of course open source software will
+puLRt-cGUIY-00366-00105359-00105604 come to a detriment of proprietary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00367-00105605-00105827 software that's I mean we will replace
+puLRt-cGUIY-00368-00105828-00106025 proprietary software we have already
+puLRt-cGUIY-00369-00106026-00106308 replaced proprietary software on server
+puLRt-cGUIY-00370-00106309-00106747 and we are we are replacing more slowly
+puLRt-cGUIY-00371-00106748-00107057 proprietary software on the desktop by
+puLRt-cGUIY-00372-00107058-00107340 the way with the pandemics
+puLRt-cGUIY-00373-00107341-00107710 uh many people were forced to go home
+puLRt-cGUIY-00374-00107711-00108023 and work from home basically in a matter
+puLRt-cGUIY-00375-00108024-00108233 of less than a week
+puLRt-cGUIY-00376-00108233-00108533 and that was a turning point for free
+puLRt-cGUIY-00377-00108533-00108839 software because many people started to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00378-00108840-00109066 download and use a free software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00379-00109067-00109343 products because that they didn't have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00380-00109344-00109504 any choice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00381-00109505-00109708 so if you have to work on on your
+puLRt-cGUIY-00382-00109709-00109997 computer at home you cannot for instance
+puLRt-cGUIY-00383-00109998-00110254 install the same Microsoft Office
+puLRt-cGUIY-00384-00110255-00110525 license you should buy another license
+puLRt-cGUIY-00385-00110526-00110758 and many people downloaded LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00386-00110759-00111102 downloaded Thunderbird to use to replace
+puLRt-cGUIY-00387-00111103-00111401 Outlook and and that was positive
+puLRt-cGUIY-00388-00111402-00111707 because it exposed open source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00389-00111708-00111947 to a larger number of people
+puLRt-cGUIY-00390-00111948-00112240 many of them they are now back to to to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00391-00112241-00112565 Windows uh but because
+puLRt-cGUIY-00392-00112566-00112883 companies in many cases force them to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00393-00112883-00113081 use Windows but at least they've been
+puLRt-cGUIY-00394-00113082-00113363 exposed to open source software and of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00395-00113364-00113608 course the change
+puLRt-cGUIY-00396-00113609-00114089 is going to uh to to to be to to make an
+puLRt-cGUIY-00397-00114090-00114425 impact the fact that Microsoft has
+puLRt-cGUIY-00398-00114426-00114689 decided and announced to move that they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00399-00114690-00114958 love Linux is not because they really
+puLRt-cGUIY-00400-00114959-00115277 love Linux is because they want a future
+puLRt-cGUIY-00401-00115278-00115547 in software and they know that the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00402-00115548-00115847 future of software is in open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00403-00115848-00116128 so they have started to move
+puLRt-cGUIY-00404-00116129-00116501 to to show that they are open to move
+puLRt-cGUIY-00405-00116502-00116854 their open their softer stack to open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00406-00116855-00117052 source because that is going the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00407-00117053-00117304 openstack the the the software of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00408-00117305-00117431 future
+puLRt-cGUIY-00409-00117432-00117760 and uh open source is extremely
+puLRt-cGUIY-00410-00117761-00118078 important in the Enterprise if you are a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00411-00118079-00118319 consultant in at Enterprise level you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00412-00118320-00118421 know that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00413-00118422-00118883 most servers will be Linux based and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00414-00118883-00119254 most services will be Linux based when
+puLRt-cGUIY-00415-00119255-00119599 we did the migration of the Italian
+puLRt-cGUIY-00416-00119600-00119825 Ministry of Defense
+puLRt-cGUIY-00417-00119826-00120160 they have they are using LibreOffice now
+puLRt-cGUIY-00418-00120161-00120425 on 100 000 desktops
+puLRt-cGUIY-00419-00120426-00120845 and uh we we I was in several meetings
+puLRt-cGUIY-00420-00120846-00121163 because of course the the move was
+puLRt-cGUIY-00421-00121164-00121415 scrutinized at every level
+puLRt-cGUIY-00422-00121416-00121763 and I remember in a meeting where the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00423-00121764-00122021 people was in but what will happen at
+puLRt-cGUIY-00424-00122022-00122339 server level because we we cannot have a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00425-00122340-00122513 product on the desktop that's not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00426-00122514-00122771 compatible with the server and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00427-00122772-00123143 answer from the their ID manager that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00428-00123144-00123325 was also a general
+puLRt-cGUIY-00429-00123326-00123628 he said that's not the problem our
+puLRt-cGUIY-00430-00123629-00123971 servers are 100 Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00431-00123972-00124186 and the politicians that were in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00432-00124188-00124390 same room they thought that their
+puLRt-cGUIY-00433-00124391-00124715 servers were 100 windows
+puLRt-cGUIY-00434-00124716-00125063 and they said why they are 100 Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00435-00125064-00125471 because this is the NATO standard
+puLRt-cGUIY-00436-00125472-00125927 we cannot use Windows by NATO standards
+puLRt-cGUIY-00437-00125928-00126173 and by the way even if the standard NATO
+puLRt-cGUIY-00438-00126174-00126401 standard was Windows we would use Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00439-00126402-00126586 because it's more secure
+puLRt-cGUIY-00440-00126588-00126907 so when we send the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00441-00126908-00127297 orders we want them to get through
+puLRt-cGUIY-00442-00127298-00127558 independently from the condition of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00443-00127559-00127721 network
+puLRt-cGUIY-00444-00127722-00128158 and uh so that is the uh the the reality
+puLRt-cGUIY-00445-00128159-00128428 large Enterprises and I can tell you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00446-00128429-00128651 that an army is a rather large
+puLRt-cGUIY-00447-00128652-00128808 Enterprise
+puLRt-cGUIY-00448-00128809-00129269 are using Linux under servers and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00449-00129270-00129516 reason why they are using Linux are many
+puLRt-cGUIY-00450-00129517-00129778 uh and of course I will leave you the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00451-00129779-00130031 the slide so you you will be able to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00452-00130032-00130499 read them uh in detail but of course the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00453-00130500-00130804 advantages are in multiple places you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00454-00130805-00131021 can you can look into the code if you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00455-00131022-00131369 are you can basically hire developers to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00456-00131370-00131609 make the code better for your specific
+puLRt-cGUIY-00457-00131610-00131723 needs
+puLRt-cGUIY-00458-00131724-00131975 this you cannot do with any proprietary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00459-00131976-00132125 software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00460-00132126-00132269 and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00461-00132270-00132701 about the quality of software uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00462-00132702-00132983 because people say but if the software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00463-00132984-00133259 is developed by many different people in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00464-00133260-00133523 many different parts of the world they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00465-00133524-00133871 are not inside the same room and so I'll
+puLRt-cGUIY-00466-00133872-00134147 wide out the software can be better
+puLRt-cGUIY-00467-00134148-00134459 the software is better because these
+puLRt-cGUIY-00468-00134460-00134785 people have developed
+puLRt-cGUIY-00469-00134786-00135101 processes of development that ensure the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00470-00135102-00135431 quality of the software and I can tell
+puLRt-cGUIY-00471-00135432-00135731 you that the the level of quality that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00472-00135732-00136078 is put into LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00473-00136079-00136414 at every major release is incredible
+puLRt-cGUIY-00474-00136415-00136685 so we test the product for months
+puLRt-cGUIY-00475-00136686-00136954 and we have thousands of users that help
+puLRt-cGUIY-00476-00136955-00137214 us in in in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00477-00137215-00137578 taking out the bugs and the regressions
+puLRt-cGUIY-00478-00137579-00137897 and of course the software when it come
+puLRt-cGUIY-00479-00137898-00138202 out will still have bugs and regressions
+puLRt-cGUIY-00480-00138203-00138466 because that is the reality of software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00481-00138467-00138743 there's no software without bugs and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00482-00138744-00139061 regressions including Windows including
+puLRt-cGUIY-00483-00139062-00139427 Microsoft Office you are kind you are in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00484-00139428-00139714 widely invited to go to Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-00485-00139715-00140243 website there is a list of 15
+puLRt-cGUIY-00486-00140244-00140395 000
+puLRt-cGUIY-00487-00140396-00140952 15000 known errors of Microsoft Office
+puLRt-cGUIY-00488-00140953-00141383 adults that cannot be solved there are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00489-00141384-00141828 15 000 workarounds
+puLRt-cGUIY-00490-00141829-00142228 and when I because I I'm a marketer so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00491-00142229-00142516 I'm sometimes I'm let's say I'm not the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00492-00142517-00142847 nicest person in the world when when I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00493-00142848-00143069 have users that reply say but Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-00494-00143070-00143357 has no box I said no they have more than
+puLRt-cGUIY-00495-00143358-00143561 fifteen thousand these fifteen thousand
+puLRt-cGUIY-00496-00143562-00143819 are declared they're not that then there
+puLRt-cGUIY-00497-00143820-00144047 are others that are not declared
+puLRt-cGUIY-00498-00144048-00144299 uh of course it's easy to say that your
+puLRt-cGUIY-00499-00144300-00144502 software is perfect you you hide the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00500-00144503-00144754 issues to other people we don't hide the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00501-00144755-00144904 issues
+puLRt-cGUIY-00502-00144905-00145163 our source code is publishingly
+puLRt-cGUIY-00503-00145164-00145421 available it's not a problem
+puLRt-cGUIY-00504-00145422-00145631 and this is a question about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00505-00145632-00146035 sustainability this is from a 2019
+puLRt-cGUIY-00506-00146036-00146227 survey
+puLRt-cGUIY-00507-00146228-00146663 and you see that there's no a complete
+puLRt-cGUIY-00508-00146664-00146945 agreement on this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00509-00146946-00147383 63 says yes but there is a 30 percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-00510-00147384-00147623 that says I'm not sure that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00511-00147624-00147743 sustainable
+puLRt-cGUIY-00512-00147744-00148145 and actually I can tell you that the 30
+puLRt-cGUIY-00513-00148146-00148421 percent is uh is more right than the 60
+puLRt-cGUIY-00514-00148422-00148775 percent not that open source is not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00515-00148776-00148985 sustainable
+puLRt-cGUIY-00516-00148986-00149351 but the fact that enterprises have not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00517-00149352-00149633 yet started to understand that they have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00518-00149634-00149885 to to support open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00519-00149886-00150173 on a continuous basis on the other hand
+puLRt-cGUIY-00520-00150174-00150449 open source projects have not accessed
+puLRt-cGUIY-00521-00150450-00150689 Enterprise in the right way
+puLRt-cGUIY-00522-00150690-00150935 because changing the license is not the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00523-00150936-00151228 right way of interacting with a with an
+puLRt-cGUIY-00524-00151229-00151349 Enterprise
+puLRt-cGUIY-00525-00151350-00151654 the right way is guys we need to sit
+puLRt-cGUIY-00526-00151655-00152087 around the table because the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00527-00152088-00152375 softer that you have today if you don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-00528-00152376-00152669 support it we cannot guarantee that you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00529-00152670-00152939 will have the same software tomorrow
+puLRt-cGUIY-00530-00152940-00153209 because if you don't support the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00531-00153210-00153395 development
+puLRt-cGUIY-00532-00153396-00153778 at certain stage by hiring developers by
+puLRt-cGUIY-00533-00153779-00154235 paying new features by doing whatever
+puLRt-cGUIY-00534-00154236-00154433 translations
+puLRt-cGUIY-00535-00154434-00154763 there are many many ways you can you can
+puLRt-cGUIY-00536-00154764-00154997 contribute if you don't contribute
+puLRt-cGUIY-00537-00154998-00155302 there's no warranty that the open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00538-00155303-00155657 project will stay there forever
+puLRt-cGUIY-00539-00155658-00155963 again open source developers and other
+puLRt-cGUIY-00540-00155964-00156197 people at the end of the month they have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00541-00156198-00156337 to pay their
+puLRt-cGUIY-00542-00156338-00156749 rent of the apartment they have to pay
+puLRt-cGUIY-00543-00156750-00157102 for their bills they have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00544-00157103-00157535 eat drink like any other individual
+puLRt-cGUIY-00545-00157536-00157831 so of course why
+puLRt-cGUIY-00546-00157832-00158093 organizations should contribute to open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00547-00158094-00158471 source software because it's it's a part
+puLRt-cGUIY-00548-00158472-00158621 of the game
+puLRt-cGUIY-00549-00158622-00158981 we don't ask you a license cost
+puLRt-cGUIY-00550-00158982-00159202 but you have to understand that you have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00551-00159203-00159569 to pay for some of the added value
+puLRt-cGUIY-00552-00159570-00159971 and how they can contribute I mean the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00553-00159972-00160145 way that they can contribute are really
+puLRt-cGUIY-00554-00160146-00160433 multiple you can pay Developers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00555-00160434-00160835 uh you you can work with contractors or
+puLRt-cGUIY-00556-00160836-00161190 that support open source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00557-00161191-00161519 uh we we don't ask for a direct map
+puLRt-cGUIY-00558-00161520-00161681 payment
+puLRt-cGUIY-00559-00161682-00162049 for instance we have been
+puLRt-cGUIY-00560-00162050-00162347 Hungarian government is using
+puLRt-cGUIY-00561-00162348-00162623 LibreOffice they pay
+puLRt-cGUIY-00562-00162624-00163285 a dozen developers to work on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00563-00163286-00163625 interoperability of formats so most of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00564-00163626-00163907 the improvements that LibreOffice has
+puLRt-cGUIY-00565-00163908-00164195 got in terms of interoperability with
+puLRt-cGUIY-00566-00164196-00164537 the Microsoft Office non-standard format
+puLRt-cGUIY-00567-00164538-00164854 is thanks to the uh to the Hungarian
+puLRt-cGUIY-00568-00164855-00165076 government
+puLRt-cGUIY-00569-00165077-00165340 they don't give money directly to the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00570-00165341-00165611 project but they help the project to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00571-00165612-00165989 grow and this is one of the way
+puLRt-cGUIY-00572-00165990-00166235 that the project can that you can
+puLRt-cGUIY-00573-00166236-00166589 contribute to the to to to a project is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00574-00166590-00166864 not just by putting money into the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00575-00166865-00167225 project is by helping the ecosystem to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00576-00167226-00167495 grow and to sustain and support the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00577-00167496-00167633 software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00578-00167634-00167789 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00579-00167790-00168166 this again you see is the the the it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-00580-00168167-00168671 again a venture capitalist uh uh slider
+puLRt-cGUIY-00581-00168672-00169043 you see they they try to to to to to put
+puLRt-cGUIY-00582-00169044-00169259 everything into boxes
+puLRt-cGUIY-00583-00169260-00169685 and uh it's not really possible but look
+puLRt-cGUIY-00584-00169686-00169871 at this box
+puLRt-cGUIY-00585-00169872-00170328 this is uh the real open source where
+puLRt-cGUIY-00586-00170329-00170759 you have very added value that is paid
+puLRt-cGUIY-00587-00170760-00170939 Red Dot
+puLRt-cGUIY-00588-00170940-00171137 redat is a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00589-00171138-00171557 now a three billion uh dollar software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00590-00171558-00171683 company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00591-00171684-00172001 a date basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-00592-00172002-00172228 um I think that 80 percent of that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00593-00172229-00172426 not based on licenses
+puLRt-cGUIY-00594-00172427-00172733 is based on added value it's based on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00595-00172734-00173075 consultancy is based on training is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00596-00173076-00173447 based on this kind of enthusa is the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00597-00173448-00173735 same it's the smaller is after that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00598-00173736-00174259 redact was purchased by IBM for 35
+puLRt-cGUIY-00599-00174260-00174557 billion dollars so a three billion
+puLRt-cGUIY-00600-00174558-00174845 dollar companies purchased for 10 times
+puLRt-cGUIY-00601-00174846-00174989 the value
+puLRt-cGUIY-00602-00174990-00175297 because the fact is that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00603-00175298-00175607 they have the right
+puLRt-cGUIY-00604-00175608-00175949 business model it's not easy it took
+puLRt-cGUIY-00605-00175950-00176254 them years to to get to that point
+puLRt-cGUIY-00606-00176255-00176623 and of course then you have other ones
+puLRt-cGUIY-00607-00176624-00176975 and then you you go to the they call it
+puLRt-cGUIY-00608-00176976-00177361 multi-licensing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00609-00177362-00177701 multi-licensing means you have what
+puLRt-cGUIY-00610-00177702-00177925 doesn't work as an open source license
+puLRt-cGUIY-00611-00177926-00178193 what works you have to give me money
+puLRt-cGUIY-00612-00178194-00178625 because this is what the the the Venture
+puLRt-cGUIY-00613-00178626-00178816 capitalists understand they understand
+puLRt-cGUIY-00614-00178817-00179243 that they want money for licenses they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00615-00179244-00179452 think that that is the only
+puLRt-cGUIY-00616-00179453-00179837 working a way of having software which
+puLRt-cGUIY-00617-00179838-00180143 is not true
+puLRt-cGUIY-00618-00180144-00180557 so the the issue is not new so I'm not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00619-00180558-00180887 telling you anything really uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00620-00180888-00181061 revolutionary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00621-00181062-00181523 but let's say that in there have been
+puLRt-cGUIY-00622-00181524-00181978 three days 2014 many people probably
+puLRt-cGUIY-00623-00181979-00182381 remember the heart bleed bug
+puLRt-cGUIY-00624-00182382-00182833 that was the first point of people
+puLRt-cGUIY-00625-00182834-00183419 realizing that a strategic uh open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00626-00183420-00183676 source project could not rely just on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00627-00183677-00184019 the Goodwill of two three developers so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00628-00184020-00184325 they started to pay these developers to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00629-00184326-00184447 maintain
+puLRt-cGUIY-00630-00184448-00184876 the the the software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00631-00184877-00185352 and in 2016 a researcher Nadia Iqbal
+puLRt-cGUIY-00632-00185353-00185740 wrote up this paper which is actually a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00633-00185741-00186064 book because it's over 100 Pages roads
+puLRt-cGUIY-00634-00186065-00186347 and bridges the Unseen labor behind our
+puLRt-cGUIY-00635-00186348-00186533 digital infrastructure you can download
+puLRt-cGUIY-00636-00186534-00186875 it for free it's been sponsored by the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00637-00186876-00187145 Ford Foundation it's very interesting
+puLRt-cGUIY-00638-00187146-00187438 it's a systematization of all the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00639-00187439-00187547 process
+puLRt-cGUIY-00640-00187548-00187997 and in 2019 Grace boyter it raises the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00641-00187998-00188290 founder of Drupal and akuya
+puLRt-cGUIY-00642-00188291-00188651 publish up an extremely interesting blog
+puLRt-cGUIY-00643-00188652-00188902 post is balancing makers and takers to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00644-00188903-00189190 scan and sustain open source this is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00645-00189191-00189431 probably the best analysis of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00646-00189432-00189659 situation that you can find
+puLRt-cGUIY-00647-00189660-00189901 and I will tell you a little bit about
+puLRt-cGUIY-00648-00189902-00190343 dries because I think he as I try to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00649-00190344-00190631 summarize his input but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00650-00190632-00190937 my suggestion is to read the entire blog
+puLRt-cGUIY-00651-00190938-00191266 post which is several pages
+puLRt-cGUIY-00652-00191267-00191626 and because he really analyzes the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00653-00191627-00191838 entire
+puLRt-cGUIY-00654-00191839-00192431 situation and makes some interesting uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00655-00192432-00192683 proposals
+puLRt-cGUIY-00656-00192684-00192814 so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00657-00192815-00192935 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00658-00192936-00193211 please start from analyzing the the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00659-00193212-00193469 open source Community you remember the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00660-00193470-00193714 the second slide I it was the three
+puLRt-cGUIY-00661-00193715-00193914 stages basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-00662-00193915-00194297 this the example that he makes are rules
+puLRt-cGUIY-00663-00194298-00194626 so the roads are create are created by
+puLRt-cGUIY-00664-00194627-00194807 volunteers of course not the road that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00665-00194808-00195047 we see the road that we see today have
+puLRt-cGUIY-00666-00195048-00195233 changed a lot but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00667-00195234-00195628 try to imagine going back to when roads
+puLRt-cGUIY-00668-00195629-00195923 were not existing so Volunteers started
+puLRt-cGUIY-00669-00195924-00196337 to create rows between Villages uh to to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00670-00196338-00196559 move between villages
+puLRt-cGUIY-00671-00196560-00197033 and then when when people realized that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00672-00197034-00197225 the roads were interesting enough to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00673-00197226-00197566 make business then they they started to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00674-00197567-00197837 make business out of the road and then
+puLRt-cGUIY-00675-00197838-00198125 the road became a common
+puLRt-cGUIY-00676-00198126-00198526 uh resource and then countries took the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00677-00198527-00198821 road and and now maintained the road so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00678-00198822-00198959 today
+puLRt-cGUIY-00679-00198960-00199319 it's Serbia is Italy is France Spain
+puLRt-cGUIY-00680-00199320-00199469 that are maintaining the rose because
+puLRt-cGUIY-00681-00199470-00199673 the roads are part of our common
+puLRt-cGUIY-00682-00199674-00199876 infrastructure
+puLRt-cGUIY-00683-00199877-00200213 is the infrastructure that we don't pay
+puLRt-cGUIY-00684-00200214-00200500 directly but we pay with taxes
+puLRt-cGUIY-00685-00200501-00200885 because it is maintained to make moving
+puLRt-cGUIY-00686-00200886-00201125 around the country possible
+puLRt-cGUIY-00687-00201126-00201383 and the software in this sense is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00688-00201384-00201683 similar you start with with volunteers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00689-00201684-00202133 then you you start with someone it's not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00690-00202134-00202331 in in open source you don't have the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00691-00202332-00202528 privatization stage but you have the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00692-00202529-00202793 stage where the the volunteers are put
+puLRt-cGUIY-00693-00202794-00203087 to start to come together in into a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00694-00203088-00203399 project and then
+puLRt-cGUIY-00695-00203400-00203647 you you get to the point where the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00696-00203648-00203890 it is a system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00697-00203891-00204173 and we we let's say that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00698-00204174-00204473 we we find it difficult
+puLRt-cGUIY-00699-00204474-00204803 as an industry to move from this to this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00700-00204804-00204916 stage
+puLRt-cGUIY-00701-00204917-00205186 because that is the stage where we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00702-00205187-00205325 should
+puLRt-cGUIY-00703-00205326-00205607 start forgetting that we support a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00704-00205608-00205948 single project and sit around it's sit
+puLRt-cGUIY-00705-00205950-00206207 around the table and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00706-00206208-00206519 think
+puLRt-cGUIY-00707-00206519-00206777 as a member of the large open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-00708-00206778-00207053 Community not as a member of Debian
+puLRt-cGUIY-00709-00207054-00207538 Ubuntu or another distribution and I've
+puLRt-cGUIY-00710-00207539-00207829 heard people from distributions
+puLRt-cGUIY-00711-00207830-00208162 fighting each other because no we do
+puLRt-cGUIY-00712-00208163-00208523 security better than you come on stop
+puLRt-cGUIY-00713-00208523-00208846 doing stop doing this useless discussion
+puLRt-cGUIY-00714-00208848-00209110 sit around the table and make security
+puLRt-cGUIY-00715-00209111-00209351 better for everyone
+puLRt-cGUIY-00716-00209352-00209657 someone will have a better security but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00717-00209658-00210071 someone will have better user interface
+puLRt-cGUIY-00718-00210071-00210358 and someone will have I don't know
+puLRt-cGUIY-00719-00210359-00210646 better package integration
+puLRt-cGUIY-00720-00210648-00210958 so let's put it together not working on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00721-00210959-00211192 as separate entities
+puLRt-cGUIY-00722-00211194-00211582 uh can you imagine if all the Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00723-00211583-00211798 distribution together
+puLRt-cGUIY-00724-00211800-00212171 could find a could put together a single
+puLRt-cGUIY-00725-00212171-00212429 distribution that is easy to use
+puLRt-cGUIY-00726-00212430-00212903 solid robust secure
+puLRt-cGUIY-00727-00212904-00213148 that can really make
+puLRt-cGUIY-00728-00213150-00213394 competition can be really be a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00729-00213396-00213587 competitor to Windows
+puLRt-cGUIY-00730-00213588-00213875 because the the difference is that if
+puLRt-cGUIY-00731-00213876-00214175 you want to if you start using Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00732-00214176-00214403 people will tell you no you should use
+puLRt-cGUIY-00733-00214404-00214594 Linux Mint because it's better than
+puLRt-cGUIY-00734-00214596-00214846 Ubuntu because it's oh no you should use
+puLRt-cGUIY-00735-00214848-00215087 a Debian Debian is absolutely the best
+puLRt-cGUIY-00736-00215088-00215398 but why you should a dead base
+puLRt-cGUIY-00737-00215400-00215734 distribution you should go to RPM so you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00738-00215735-00216106 should start and do Arc Linux or this is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00739-00216107-00216346 just useless
+puLRt-cGUIY-00740-00216348-00216682 it's interesting at developers level
+puLRt-cGUIY-00741-00216683-00216971 it's useless at system level
+puLRt-cGUIY-00742-00216971-00217325 at system level we should work together
+puLRt-cGUIY-00743-00217326-00217577 then you can say tibian has contributed
+puLRt-cGUIY-00744-00217578-00217906 security to the to the large and maybe
+puLRt-cGUIY-00745-00217907-00218158 Ubuntu has contributed the user
+puLRt-cGUIY-00746-00218159-00218369 interface and I don't know
+puLRt-cGUIY-00747-00218369-00218753 but being separate doesn't help the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00748-00218754-00218908 industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-00749-00218909-00219167 and of course the same applies when you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00750-00219167-00219484 go a further level
+puLRt-cGUIY-00751-00219485-00219671 so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00752-00219671-00219851 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00753-00219852-00220205 three says I I understand that the idea
+puLRt-cGUIY-00754-00220206-00220498 of making this a system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00755-00220500-00220931 in um that not everyone doesn't does
+puLRt-cGUIY-00756-00220932-00221260 like the idea but I think personally
+puLRt-cGUIY-00757-00221261-00221627 that is absolutely right so either we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00758-00221628-00221994 we transform our let's say
+puLRt-cGUIY-00759-00221996-00222292 individualities into a system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00760-00222294-00222725 or we we will always discuss about the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00761-00222726-00222941 potential of Open Source without getting
+puLRt-cGUIY-00762-00222942-00223315 to the real uh to the real solution
+puLRt-cGUIY-00763-00223316-00223696 uh and sustainability of course is a is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00764-00223698-00224069 immediately related to this because if
+puLRt-cGUIY-00765-00224069-00224334 you if your system
+puLRt-cGUIY-00766-00224335-00224621 works then it becomes almost
+puLRt-cGUIY-00767-00224621-00224873 automatically sustainable
+puLRt-cGUIY-00768-00224873-00225221 it will be easier for people that want
+puLRt-cGUIY-00769-00225221-00225401 to give money to open source to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00770-00225402-00225598 understand when they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00771-00225600-00225875 to whom they they should give money if
+puLRt-cGUIY-00772-00225876-00226013 the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00773-00226014-00226410 the the picture of Open Source would be
+puLRt-cGUIY-00774-00226411-00226703 simpler than it is today
+puLRt-cGUIY-00775-00226704-00227051 and of course he says three says it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-00776-00227052-00227260 not necessary that everyone changes his
+puLRt-cGUIY-00777-00227261-00227392 business model
+puLRt-cGUIY-00778-00227394-00227644 but it's important that the largest
+puLRt-cGUIY-00779-00227646-00227921 project do this because otherwise we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00780-00227921-00228263 again we we we go in circles around
+puLRt-cGUIY-00781-00228264-00228491 ourselves
+puLRt-cGUIY-00782-00228492-00228719 and then he introduces the concept of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00783-00228719-00229031 makers and takers so makers are people
+puLRt-cGUIY-00784-00229032-00229289 that are developing open source but not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00785-00229290-00229510 just development that are developing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00786-00229511-00229927 translating writing manuals doing QA
+puLRt-cGUIY-00787-00229928-00230219 uh supporting infrastructure so all the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00788-00230219-00230494 people that are working behind open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00789-00230496-00230698 source are makers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00790-00230700-00230932 and then the people that are just taking
+puLRt-cGUIY-00791-00230933-00231244 the software and not contributing by
+puLRt-cGUIY-00792-00231246-00231431 caretakers
+puLRt-cGUIY-00793-00231432-00231653 and the takers are disrupting open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00794-00231654-00231892 source exactly because they don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-00795-00231894-00232048 contribute back
+puLRt-cGUIY-00796-00232050-00232255 because uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00797-00232256-00232451 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00798-00232452-00232660 I I'll um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00799-00232661-00233063 I show a slide after a visual slide
+puLRt-cGUIY-00800-00233064-00233369 because visual images are usually better
+puLRt-cGUIY-00801-00233369-00233596 than words to describe
+puLRt-cGUIY-00802-00233598-00233831 a a concept
+puLRt-cGUIY-00803-00233832-00234071 but the reality is that the makers are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00804-00234071-00234305 fighting are in the same Market as the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00805-00234306-00234689 takers and there's no way that a maker
+puLRt-cGUIY-00806-00234690-00234905 can win if there is a taker in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00807-00234906-00235181 market and let's look at this let's say
+puLRt-cGUIY-00808-00235182-00235331 that the maker
+puLRt-cGUIY-00809-00235332-00235696 makes one million dollars out of Open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00810-00235698-00236027 Source and reinvest 500 000 in open
+puLRt-cGUIY-00811-00236028-00236496 source and 500 000 on let's say that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00812-00236498-00236741 intellectual property that in this case
+puLRt-cGUIY-00813-00236742-00236867 is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00814-00236867-00237155 sharing the money around the people that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00815-00237156-00237455 have contributed to paying salaries and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00816-00237456-00237556 so on
+puLRt-cGUIY-00817-00237557-00237719 the taker
+puLRt-cGUIY-00818-00237719-00238127 will invest back 50 000
+puLRt-cGUIY-00819-00238128-00238541 and keep the rest 950 and how and and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00820-00238542-00238877 this will be more money for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00821-00238878-00239213 shareholders will be more money for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00822-00239214-00239410 venture capitalist
+puLRt-cGUIY-00823-00239411-00239734 and so on and of course you you it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-00824-00239735-00239939 easy to understand by looking at the two
+puLRt-cGUIY-00825-00239940-00240269 images why this will win over this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00826-00240269-00240455 because
+puLRt-cGUIY-00827-00240456-00240641 in this money
+puLRt-cGUIY-00828-00240642-00240965 there will be money for Lobby
+puLRt-cGUIY-00829-00240966-00241432 and Lobby will kill this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00830-00241433-00241829 this is the unfortunate situation
+puLRt-cGUIY-00831-00241830-00242044 um it's um
+puLRt-cGUIY-00832-00242046-00242632 just to make a a very small example you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00833-00242633-00242927 have probably heard about the uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00834-00242928-00243341 move to Linux of the of Munich
+puLRt-cGUIY-00835-00243342-00243719 the CD in Bayern
+puLRt-cGUIY-00836-00243719-00244013 so the city moved to Linux it was
+puLRt-cGUIY-00837-00244014-00244321 working it worked for 14 years
+puLRt-cGUIY-00838-00244321-00244684 uh also the airport was managed by Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-00839-00244685-00244996 and they didn't have any accident any
+puLRt-cGUIY-00840-00244998-00245315 any any any flight
+puLRt-cGUIY-00841-00245316-00245698 um delayed or lost for 14 years
+puLRt-cGUIY-00842-00245700-00245939 but then what happened it happened at
+puLRt-cGUIY-00843-00245940-00246094 the company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00844-00246096-00246337 paid the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00845-00246338-00246725 political campaign to the two candidates
+puLRt-cGUIY-00846-00246726-00247060 for the mayor role
+puLRt-cGUIY-00847-00247061-00247384 and one of them of course won and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00848-00247385-00247582 ironically because of the gross
+puLRt-cGUIY-00849-00247583-00247769 equalizion
+puLRt-cGUIY-00850-00247769-00248032 the second one became becomes Deputy
+puLRt-cGUIY-00851-00248033-00248351 Mayor so they paid basically paid the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00852-00248352-00248555 political campaign to the mayor and to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00853-00248556-00248927 the deputy mayor guess what
+puLRt-cGUIY-00854-00248928-00249196 they use Windows now
+puLRt-cGUIY-00855-00249198-00249406 so you can probably understand the name
+puLRt-cGUIY-00856-00249407-00249658 of the company that by the way is based
+puLRt-cGUIY-00857-00249659-00250006 on one Microsoft Plaza in Redmond but I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00858-00250007-00250327 won't tell you the name of the company
+puLRt-cGUIY-00859-00250328-00250715 uh when we started LibreOffice we we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00860-00250716-00250882 wanted to relaunch The Innovation
+puLRt-cGUIY-00861-00250883-00251279 because again a company proprietary
+puLRt-cGUIY-00862-00251280-00251513 software
+puLRt-cGUIY-00863-00251514-00251884 purchase sun and they didn't have a clue
+puLRt-cGUIY-00864-00251885-00252119 about open source apart from my sequel
+puLRt-cGUIY-00865-00252119-00252310 they wanted to control my sequel to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00866-00252311-00252587 avoid that my sequel was growing enough
+puLRt-cGUIY-00867-00252588-00252934 to to become a threat for Oracle
+puLRt-cGUIY-00868-00252935-00253108 databases
+puLRt-cGUIY-00869-00253109-00253396 so we we basically we forked the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00870-00253398-00253727 software to make the software Innovative
+puLRt-cGUIY-00871-00253728-00254027 again because of course if you if the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00872-00254028-00254255 company that is behind the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00873-00254256-00254482 doesn't want to develop the project the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00874-00254483-00254921 project is uh slowing fading away
+puLRt-cGUIY-00875-00254921-00255071 and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00876-00255071-00255294 we are in a market
+puLRt-cGUIY-00877-00255296-00255581 which has been discussed since almost
+puLRt-cGUIY-00878-00255582-00255946 forever I mean I've been in uh in this
+puLRt-cGUIY-00879-00255948-00256234 market since 2002 so it's around 20
+puLRt-cGUIY-00880-00256235-00256355 years
+puLRt-cGUIY-00881-00256356-00256715 as a open source Advocate and so I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00882-00256716-00257023 entered the the open Office
+puLRt-cGUIY-00883-00257023-00257494 ecosystem in 2002. because I didn't want
+puLRt-cGUIY-00884-00257496-00257782 to use Outlook based basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-00885-00257783-00258148 uh so I have a funny religion that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00886-00258150-00258484 doesn't allow me to eat banana and use
+puLRt-cGUIY-00887-00258485-00258630 Outlook
+puLRt-cGUIY-00888-00258631-00259006 uh out of that I don't have a real
+puLRt-cGUIY-00889-00259007-00259165 religion
+puLRt-cGUIY-00890-00259166-00259403 so I I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00891-00259404-00259696 started I installed open office and I
+puLRt-cGUIY-00892-00259698-00259930 realized that the software was promising
+puLRt-cGUIY-00893-00259931-00260356 so after one year I sent an email to the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00894-00260357-00260584 to the community manager and said you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00895-00260585-00260806 have a fantastic product but your
+puLRt-cGUIY-00896-00260807-00261006 marketing is released
+puLRt-cGUIY-00897-00261007-00261371 zero and the answer was who are you to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00898-00261371-00261569 say that marketing is really zero said
+puLRt-cGUIY-00899-00261569-00261892 it's someone that is paying his bills
+puLRt-cGUIY-00900-00261894-00262129 with marketing for the last 20 years so
+puLRt-cGUIY-00901-00262130-00262499 maybe I can tell you a little bit
+puLRt-cGUIY-00902-00262500-00262763 uh I started to do but they didn't trust
+puLRt-cGUIY-00903-00262764-00262997 me so I started to do marketing you need
+puLRt-cGUIY-00904-00262998-00263291 of open Office just in Italy at the time
+puLRt-cGUIY-00905-00263292-00263603 and in six months the number of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00906-00263604-00263819 downloads went through from two to eight
+puLRt-cGUIY-00907-00263820-00263951 Millions
+puLRt-cGUIY-00908-00263952-00264197 so they they called me again and said oh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00909-00264198-00264460 it happens that your marketing activity
+puLRt-cGUIY-00910-00264461-00264760 is effective and said I told you before
+puLRt-cGUIY-00911-00264761-00265019 so I they they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00912-00265020-00265397 I was uh let's say co-opted into Global
+puLRt-cGUIY-00913-00265398-00265727 Marketing of open Office Community side
+puLRt-cGUIY-00914-00265728-00265937 and I started to contribute to the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00915-00265938-00266080 project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00916-00266081-00266315 and since then there has always been the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00917-00266316-00266615 discussion about the office suites are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00918-00266616-00266717 they going
+puLRt-cGUIY-00919-00266718-00267053 to stay or are they going away
+puLRt-cGUIY-00920-00267054-00267463 if you think about the software in fact
+puLRt-cGUIY-00921-00267464-00267784 office suites are not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00922-00267785-00267930 uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00923-00267931-00268301 a very interesting piece of software you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00924-00268302-00268591 can write a text do some
+puLRt-cGUIY-00925-00268592-00268955 mathematics with a with uh with with a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00926-00268956-00269273 spreadsheet do the presentation is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00927-00269274-00269358 nothing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00928-00269359-00269669 incredibly exciting so the people said
+puLRt-cGUIY-00929-00269670-00269860 that there will be something that will
+puLRt-cGUIY-00930-00269861-00270113 replace office suites the fact is that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00931-00270114-00270293 it's 20 years that they say that there
+puLRt-cGUIY-00932-00270294-00270484 will be something that replaces office
+puLRt-cGUIY-00933-00270485-00270658 suite but nothing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00934-00270659-00270953 was really coming and even when they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00935-00270954-00271145 moved completely to the cloud or trying
+puLRt-cGUIY-00936-00271146-00271408 to move completely to the cloud yes the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00937-00271409-00271667 market stopped a little bit but now is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00938-00271668-00271882 growing back again
+puLRt-cGUIY-00939-00271883-00272297 and is growing over the previous uh the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00940-00272298-00272530 previous size
+puLRt-cGUIY-00941-00272531-00272771 two signs that the market is interesting
+puLRt-cGUIY-00942-00272772-00273060 uh the this was a project
+puLRt-cGUIY-00943-00273061-00273430 that died in 2019 because it was the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00944-00273431-00273755 company that ran this was acquired by a
+puLRt-cGUIY-00945-00273756-00273977 proprietary software company so they it
+puLRt-cGUIY-00946-00273978-00274289 was called future of Open Source and in
+puLRt-cGUIY-00947-00274290-00274458 2017
+puLRt-cGUIY-00948-00274459-00274810 LibreOffice was featured amongst the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00949-00274811-00275045 seven most important software and that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00950-00275046-00275297 was completely unexpected and if you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00951-00275298-00275513 look at the other software in the list
+puLRt-cGUIY-00952-00275514-00275743 of the top seven
+puLRt-cGUIY-00953-00275744-00275993 they're all completely different either
+puLRt-cGUIY-00954-00275994-00276337 they are Enterprise software or
+puLRt-cGUIY-00955-00276338-00276587 Linux distribution
+puLRt-cGUIY-00956-00276588-00277084 so uh that was a surprise but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00957-00277085-00277345 two years after
+puLRt-cGUIY-00958-00277346-00277715 Ubuntu started a discussion with the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00959-00277716-00278039 users because they said oh we are sure
+puLRt-cGUIY-00960-00278040-00278279 that you don't want LibreOffice anymore
+puLRt-cGUIY-00961-00278280-00278675 as a default uh office suite you you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00962-00278676-00278897 probably want Google Docs
+puLRt-cGUIY-00963-00278898-00279263 and this was the the answer of the user
+puLRt-cGUIY-00964-00279264-00279617 so it's not even worth commenting if you
+puLRt-cGUIY-00965-00279618-00279863 look at the green is LibreOffice and the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00966-00279864-00280091 other colors are all the rest
+puLRt-cGUIY-00967-00280092-00280606 so it was 78 said no we want LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00968-00280607-00280913 and uh it was uh basically amazing
+puLRt-cGUIY-00969-00280914-00281191 because they the Ubuntu people were
+puLRt-cGUIY-00970-00281192-00281530 absolutely sure before starting they
+puLRt-cGUIY-00971-00281531-00281771 sent us a message said oh we are we are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00972-00281772-00282082 sorry but we will after the survey we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00973-00282083-00282358 will for sure uh not use LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00974-00282359-00282737 anymore and then they they call and said
+puLRt-cGUIY-00975-00282738-00283055 sorry we were a little bit wrong
+puLRt-cGUIY-00976-00283056-00283301 uh it looks like our user won't
+puLRt-cGUIY-00977-00283302-00283517 LibreOffice so we will continue to
+puLRt-cGUIY-00978-00283518-00283703 invest in LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00979-00283704-00283889 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-00980-00283890-00284177 so which are the the current uses of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00981-00284178-00284399 LibreOffice of course is the LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00982-00284400-00284543 community
+puLRt-cGUIY-00983-00284544-00284884 that supports with donations and uh and
+puLRt-cGUIY-00984-00284885-00285184 then there there are the the liberal
+puLRt-cGUIY-00985-00285185-00285406 office Enterprise version which is not
+puLRt-cGUIY-00986-00285407-00285605 released by
+puLRt-cGUIY-00987-00285606-00285880 the project because we cannot release
+puLRt-cGUIY-00988-00285881-00286247 software we are a not-for-profit so we
+puLRt-cGUIY-00989-00286248-00286517 cannot ask for money for the for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-00990-00286518-00286751 software we are starting to ask for
+puLRt-cGUIY-00991-00286752-00286930 money for the software from App Stores
+puLRt-cGUIY-00992-00286931-00287225 because that is a different story is
+puLRt-cGUIY-00993-00287226-00287519 related to the rules of the upsource but
+puLRt-cGUIY-00994-00287520-00287860 on on a general rule the software that
+puLRt-cGUIY-00995-00287861-00288113 is downloaded from our the LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-00996-00288114-00288287 website is free
+puLRt-cGUIY-00997-00288288-00288563 so but there are companies that are
+puLRt-cGUIY-00998-00288564-00288760 releasing an Enterprise version of
+puLRt-cGUIY-00999-00288761-00288934 LibreOffice which means an Enterprise
+puLRt-cGUIY-01000-00288935-00289193 version there is a service license
+puLRt-cGUIY-01001-00289194-00289475 agreement service level agreement
+puLRt-cGUIY-01002-00289476-00289817 they tell you that if you find a bug you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01003-00289818-00290027 you pay some money but they will solve
+puLRt-cGUIY-01004-00290028-00290345 the buck within two three four five days
+puLRt-cGUIY-01005-00290346-00290506 we cannot
+puLRt-cGUIY-01006-00290507-00290710 as a project as an open source project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01007-00290711-00291071 we cannot give you a service agreement
+puLRt-cGUIY-01008-00291072-00291358 you file the bug and the bug will be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01009-00291359-00291719 solved in due time when developers will
+puLRt-cGUIY-01010-00291720-00291839 have time
+puLRt-cGUIY-01011-00291840-00292175 if if the bug is really strategic for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01012-00292176-00292349 you you have to pay a developer that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01013-00292350-00292571 solves that back that is part of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01014-00292572-00292925 game in this way you support open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-01015-00292926-00293291 the problem is that we have instead of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01016-00293292-00293675 having just a few Free Riders and a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01017-00293676-00293939 majority of Enterprise that support us
+puLRt-cGUIY-01018-00293940-00294106 we have the opposite
+puLRt-cGUIY-01019-00294107-00294341 we have probably been doing five and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01020-00294342-00294556 seven percent of Enterprise using
+puLRt-cGUIY-01021-00294557-00294869 LibreOffice paying for the software and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01022-00294870-00295084 we have more than 90 percent of them not
+puLRt-cGUIY-01023-00295085-00295391 not giving anything back and we have to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01024-00295392-00295715 we are working we we were at four now we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01025-00295716-00296080 are at seven so it's uh just something
+puLRt-cGUIY-01026-00296081-00296369 we we have invested the last two years
+puLRt-cGUIY-01027-00296370-00296453 too
+puLRt-cGUIY-01028-00296454-00296956 to change the situation because that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01029-00296957-00297432 the market for office suite we are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01030-00297433-00297703 2022 it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-01031-00297704-00298156 27 billion dollars not million billion
+puLRt-cGUIY-01032-00298157-00298367 dollars
+puLRt-cGUIY-01033-00298368-00298601 and it's growing at a rate of five
+puLRt-cGUIY-01034-00298602-00298829 percent per year
+puLRt-cGUIY-01035-00298830-00299230 the analysts give us give open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-01036-00299231-00299458 software around 10 percent of that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01037-00299459-00299682 market which means that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01038-00299683-00300041 this is not the value of the market in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01039-00300042-00300365 term of license or sold is the value of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01040-00300366-00300617 the market in term of user value
+puLRt-cGUIY-01041-00300618-00300893 so it's not based on the money that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01042-00300894-00301139 companies declare but it's based on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01043-00301140-00301367 number of users and the work that the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01044-00301368-00301703 user are doing so we have 10 of that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01045-00301704-00301955 market 10 percent of that market means
+puLRt-cGUIY-01046-00301956-00302284 that our value the value of our share
+puLRt-cGUIY-01047-00302285-00302729 would be 2.7 billion dollars
+puLRt-cGUIY-01048-00302730-00303191 we are not even today at one percent of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01049-00303192-00303497 that value in term of business generated
+puLRt-cGUIY-01050-00303498-00303760 around the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01051-00303761-00304055 so I think that one percent is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01052-00304056-00304163 definitely
+puLRt-cGUIY-01053-00304164-00304517 the wrong the wrong percentage we are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01054-00304518-00304804 aiming at least a 10 percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-01055-00304805-00305021 then of course it would be nice to be at
+puLRt-cGUIY-01056-00305022-00305327 50 because you can imagine what we could
+puLRt-cGUIY-01057-00305328-00305447 do
+puLRt-cGUIY-01058-00305448-00305897 with if we could spend one billion
+puLRt-cGUIY-01059-00305898-00306095 dollars
+puLRt-cGUIY-01060-00306096-00306341 just imagine what we could do in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01061-00306342-00306527 continents like Africa in terms of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01062-00306528-00306779 Education of people
+puLRt-cGUIY-01063-00306780-00307103 in Asia
+puLRt-cGUIY-01064-00307104-00307445 develop software for specific languages
+puLRt-cGUIY-01065-00307446-00307810 that are at risk of Disappearing and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01066-00307811-00308279 give them the software in their language
+puLRt-cGUIY-01067-00308280-00308579 we could provide the software for free
+puLRt-cGUIY-01068-00308580-00308758 to all the schools
+puLRt-cGUIY-01069-00308759-00308987 to a certain level
+puLRt-cGUIY-01070-00308988-00309184 we could make arrangement with
+puLRt-cGUIY-01071-00309185-00309425 universities for giving them special
+puLRt-cGUIY-01072-00309426-00309703 prices or special version of LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-01073-00309704-00310067 for their research needs
+puLRt-cGUIY-01074-00310068-00310534 and not just because the project is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01075-00310535-00310756 supported in a different way by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01076-00310757-00310967 Enterprises that are already using the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01077-00310968-00311189 software but are not giving back any
+puLRt-cGUIY-01078-00311190-00311399 money
+puLRt-cGUIY-01079-00311400-00311656 so just imagine because we don't want to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01080-00311657-00311854 become rich I mean we want to have a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01081-00311855-00311969 normal life
+puLRt-cGUIY-01082-00311970-00312287 so get to the end of the month without
+puLRt-cGUIY-01083-00312288-00312569 having issues that's the the objective
+puLRt-cGUIY-01084-00312570-00312875 of usual of Open Source Advocates
+puLRt-cGUIY-01085-00312876-00313156 usually so we would reinvest the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01086-00313157-00313493 majority of the money in growing the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01087-00313494-00313697 ecosystem around us
+puLRt-cGUIY-01088-00313698-00313967 and the ecosystem around us is done by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01089-00313968-00314304 students is by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01090-00314305-00314710 poor countries that cannot just imagine
+puLRt-cGUIY-01091-00314711-00315004 what happens in Africa they they get
+puLRt-cGUIY-01092-00315005-00315241 refurbished computers from
+puLRt-cGUIY-01093-00315242-00315677 Europe and from uh from the states there
+puLRt-cGUIY-01094-00315678-00315904 are not from property not for profits
+puLRt-cGUIY-01095-00315905-00316132 that gets those computers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01096-00316133-00316408 and they distribute that for free in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01097-00316409-00316660 schools and they use usually use Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-01098-00316661-00316913 as operating system because it has no
+puLRt-cGUIY-01099-00316914-00317423 price tag on it just imagine how many
+puLRt-cGUIY-01100-00317424-00317729 schools we more we could reach
+puLRt-cGUIY-01101-00317730-00317969 with such a project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01102-00317970-00318325 and what this would mean in terms of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01103-00318326-00318719 economy for a continent like Africa of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01104-00318720-00318871 course
+puLRt-cGUIY-01105-00318872-00319169 this because it would make a huge
+puLRt-cGUIY-01106-00319170-00319432 difference but we could make a big
+puLRt-cGUIY-01107-00319433-00319787 difference in even in Europe where say
+puLRt-cGUIY-01108-00319788-00320041 the majority of people are not the same
+puLRt-cGUIY-01109-00320042-00320473 issues of Africa in terms of uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01110-00320474-00320645 survival
+puLRt-cGUIY-01111-00320646-00320845 problems
+puLRt-cGUIY-01112-00320846-00321239 so that's something that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01113-00321240-00321582 we could really change
+puLRt-cGUIY-01114-00321583-00321982 and improve a lot the environment around
+puLRt-cGUIY-01115-00321983-00322417 us and this is the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01116-00322418-00322745 percentage I was telling you so you see
+puLRt-cGUIY-01117-00322746-00323189 open source uh it's a 16 percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-01118-00323190-00323447 in the in that area LibreOffice is the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01119-00323448-00323663 majority but we're trying to to stay a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01120-00323664-00323873 little bit lower so this is why I tell
+puLRt-cGUIY-01121-00323874-00324041 you 10 percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-01122-00324042-00324203 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01123-00324204-00324653 by the way today uh at least 50 percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-01124-00324654-00325025 of office suite users are using more
+puLRt-cGUIY-01125-00325026-00325337 than one office suite not just they're
+puLRt-cGUIY-01126-00325338-00325679 using maybe one online one cloud and one
+puLRt-cGUIY-01127-00325680-00325841 on the desktop
+puLRt-cGUIY-01128-00325842-00326158 and uh these are the size of companies
+puLRt-cGUIY-01129-00326159-00326434 and these are the attributes Associated
+puLRt-cGUIY-01130-00326435-00326758 to office productivity Suite just a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01131-00326759-00326999 comment on the last one
+puLRt-cGUIY-01132-00327000-00327287 quality of customer support
+puLRt-cGUIY-01133-00327288-00327587 so open source the blue dot is open
+puLRt-cGUIY-01134-00327588-00327713 source
+puLRt-cGUIY-01135-00327714-00328132 we we do support with volunteers so I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01136-00328133-00328458 can understand that quality of support
+puLRt-cGUIY-01137-00328459-00328853 it's may be misunderstood because of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01138-00328854-00329087 course the volunteer is not as answering
+puLRt-cGUIY-01139-00329088-00329243 to phones
+puLRt-cGUIY-01140-00329244-00329482 but the fact that the yellow is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01141-00329483-00329806 Microsoft Office 365
+puLRt-cGUIY-01142-00329807-00330089 it's a nonsense
+puLRt-cGUIY-01143-00330090-00330406 have you ever tried to call Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-01144-00330407-00330695 for support of a product and say it
+puLRt-cGUIY-01145-00330696-00330815 doesn't work
+puLRt-cGUIY-01146-00330816-00331108 so the best answer you you get is it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-01147-00331109-00331384 your fault it's not our fault if you get
+puLRt-cGUIY-01148-00331385-00331499 the answer
+puLRt-cGUIY-01149-00331500-00331721 but the perception of people is that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01150-00331722-00332065 they provide a fantastic uh support
+puLRt-cGUIY-01151-00332066-00332356 which is completely wrong and we should
+puLRt-cGUIY-01152-00332357-00332651 use some of the money to change this
+puLRt-cGUIY-01153-00332652-00332837 perception
+puLRt-cGUIY-01154-00332838-00332999 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01155-00333000-00333203 so these are the attributes when
+puLRt-cGUIY-01156-00333204-00333439 considering of his productivity but I'll
+puLRt-cGUIY-01157-00333440-00333619 go
+puLRt-cGUIY-01158-00333620-00333923 to the conclusion so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01159-00333924-00334319 our model was clear since we started we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01160-00334320-00334558 wanted to be an independent project with
+puLRt-cGUIY-01161-00334559-00334919 a large ecosystem we we want to grow the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01162-00334920-00335375 ecosystem we have a few companies in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01163-00335376-00335704 ecosystem we want to probably double the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01164-00335705-00335963 number of these companies of course if
+puLRt-cGUIY-01165-00335964-00336143 we want to double the number of these
+puLRt-cGUIY-01166-00336144-00336317 companies without damaging the current
+puLRt-cGUIY-01167-00336318-00336515 companies we have to double the number
+puLRt-cGUIY-01168-00336516-00336815 of the value of the ecosystem
+puLRt-cGUIY-01169-00336816-00337099 because it's not by attracting a company
+puLRt-cGUIY-01170-00337100-00337373 that takes the money out of another
+puLRt-cGUIY-01171-00337374-00337667 company that we will make a good a good
+puLRt-cGUIY-01172-00337668-00337906 job we need to grow
+puLRt-cGUIY-01173-00337907-00338225 let's say the cloud the economic Cloud
+puLRt-cGUIY-01174-00338226-00338506 around open source software
+puLRt-cGUIY-01175-00338507-00338873 and uh LibreOffice has a huge reach if
+puLRt-cGUIY-01176-00338874-00339191 you think LibreOffice is really at the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01177-00339192-00339449 in the middle of Open Source because you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01178-00339450-00339701 you use LibreOffice to write reports to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01179-00339702-00340121 make presentation to calculations to to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01180-00340122-00340445 design drawings it's basically can
+puLRt-cGUIY-01181-00340446-00340684 interface with any other open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-01182-00340685-00341015 software so we are in the position if we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01183-00341016-00341177 do it right we are in the right position
+puLRt-cGUIY-01184-00341178-00341369 to win to grow
+puLRt-cGUIY-01185-00341370-00341729 uh uh these are our stakeholders the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01186-00341730-00341921 problem of course is that even if you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01187-00341922-00342119 are a user apart from people that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01188-00342120-00342484 working in in uh in the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01189-00342485-00342767 your relationship with with the with the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01190-00342768-00342958 office suite is very loose
+puLRt-cGUIY-01191-00342959-00343163 is a commodity
+puLRt-cGUIY-01192-00343164-00343379 it's a similar relation that we have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01193-00343380-00343732 with our mobile phones today
+puLRt-cGUIY-01194-00343733-00344045 if I lose I mean if I lose mine I can
+puLRt-cGUIY-01195-00344046-00344279 get another one the feature will be more
+puLRt-cGUIY-01196-00344280-00344537 or less the same apart from if you have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01197-00344538-00344956 a premium premium one and I'm not even
+puLRt-cGUIY-01198-00344957-00345173 convinced that a premium premium one is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01199-00345174-00345415 worth the price
+puLRt-cGUIY-01200-00345416-00345629 but basically
+puLRt-cGUIY-01201-00345630-00345851 the majority of products
+puLRt-cGUIY-01202-00345852-00346187 provide enough features to users to be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01203-00346188-00346313 usable
+puLRt-cGUIY-01204-00346314-00346637 so our
+puLRt-cGUIY-01205-00346638-00346871 our objective and this is our community
+puLRt-cGUIY-01206-00346872-00347063 so we have volunteers we have the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01207-00347064-00347339 ecosystem but there are many
+puLRt-cGUIY-01208-00347340-00347632 person working in ecosystem company so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01209-00347633-00347939 being paid for part of their time the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01210-00347940-00348251 time workers Volunteers in the evening
+puLRt-cGUIY-01211-00348252-00348491 we have guys that are developers during
+puLRt-cGUIY-01212-00348492-00348754 the day and translate US during during
+puLRt-cGUIY-01213-00348755-00348880 the evening
+puLRt-cGUIY-01214-00348881-00349151 because they translate in their language
+puLRt-cGUIY-01215-00349152-00349354 although they are paid to be developers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01216-00349355-00349541 during the day and they are not paid to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01217-00349542-00349780 to translate during the during their
+puLRt-cGUIY-01218-00349781-00349969 free time
+puLRt-cGUIY-01219-00349970-00350315 and this is uh more or less a breakdown
+puLRt-cGUIY-01220-00350316-00350530 of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01221-00350531-00350867 development in the last two years so 68
+puLRt-cGUIY-01222-00350868-00351058 percent of LibreOffice code was
+puLRt-cGUIY-01223-00351059-00351358 developed by companies in the Enterprise
+puLRt-cGUIY-01224-00351359-00351778 in the ecosystem uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01225-00351779-00352163 around 28 by volunteers and four percent
+puLRt-cGUIY-01226-00352164-00352541 by tdf employees we have a small team of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01227-00352542-00352882 around 12 people uh that and some of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01228-00352883-00353123 them are developers so let's say that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01229-00353124-00353393 these people are not considered because
+puLRt-cGUIY-01230-00353394-00353771 they're part of the of the process the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01231-00353772-00353969 document Foundation doesn't pay
+puLRt-cGUIY-01232-00353970-00354191 developers directly
+puLRt-cGUIY-01233-00354192-00354437 because the model says that developers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01234-00354438-00354706 should be paid by ecosystem companies we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01235-00354707-00354982 are discussing today to hire a couple of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01236-00354983-00355354 Developers for specific tasks
+puLRt-cGUIY-01237-00355355-00355571 um accessibility
+puLRt-cGUIY-01238-00355572-00355847 which doesn't seem to be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01239-00355848-00355906 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-01240-00355907-00356260 popular in Enterprises but we need to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01241-00356261-00356465 have the software that can be accessible
+puLRt-cGUIY-01242-00356466-00356765 by blind people deaf people and people
+puLRt-cGUIY-01243-00356766-00356982 with disabilities
+puLRt-cGUIY-01244-00356983-00357341 and these are contribution at Community
+puLRt-cGUIY-01245-00357342-00357604 level so you see that there is a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01246-00357605-00358067 a core of 46 people that are producing
+puLRt-cGUIY-01247-00358068-00358265 78 percent of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01248-00358266-00358554 of the comments
+puLRt-cGUIY-01249-00358555-00358954 I'm out of this I work basically almost
+puLRt-cGUIY-01250-00358955-00359297 full-time on LibreOffice but I'm as I'm
+puLRt-cGUIY-01251-00359298-00359501 not committing anything I'm not
+puLRt-cGUIY-01252-00359502-00359653 committing
+puLRt-cGUIY-01253-00359654-00359969 marketing materials so I'm not one of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01254-00359970-00360184 the people that is counted while people
+puLRt-cGUIY-01255-00360185-00360382 that do translation are counted because
+puLRt-cGUIY-01256-00360383-00360637 they committed they look the translation
+puLRt-cGUIY-01257-00360638-00361006 so of course this uh is what is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01258-00361007-00361319 countable in terms of numbers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01259-00361320-00361565 uh who pays for the development already
+puLRt-cGUIY-01260-00361566-00361954 told you the majority of the development
+puLRt-cGUIY-01261-00361955-00362356 by volunteers is localization and user
+puLRt-cGUIY-01262-00362357-00362627 interface because these are the parts
+puLRt-cGUIY-01263-00362628-00362951 that are more accessible to people that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01264-00362952-00363149 is not working full-time on code because
+puLRt-cGUIY-01265-00363150-00363449 otherwise libreoff is a 7 million lines
+puLRt-cGUIY-01266-00363450-00363658 of code you need a little bit of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01267-00363659-00363971 experience to to work on it
+puLRt-cGUIY-01268-00363972-00364247 so we want to be the best office suite
+puLRt-cGUIY-01269-00364248-00364528 ever I think we we have reached that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01270-00364529-00365158 goal but then now our challenge is to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01271-00365159-00365525 start becoming a real
+puLRt-cGUIY-01272-00365526-00365795 uh industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-01273-00365796-00366119 and as we know that we cannot become an
+puLRt-cGUIY-01274-00366120-00366306 industry by ourselves
+puLRt-cGUIY-01275-00366307-00366665 we want to work with other projects to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01276-00366666-00366941 make the open source a real industry
+puLRt-cGUIY-01277-00366942-00367306 because if that is the only way that we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01278-00367307-00367708 have to be to to to get to the result
+puLRt-cGUIY-01279-00367709-00368027 that we want to have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01280-00368028-00368153 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-01281-00368154-00368363 we have developed the concept of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01282-00368364-00368728 LibreOffice technology
+puLRt-cGUIY-01283-00368729-00369089 it's this makes it simple to understand
+puLRt-cGUIY-01284-00369090-00369406 so these are the other office suites
+puLRt-cGUIY-01285-00369407-00369797 so if you use Microsoft Office on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01286-00369798-00369904 desktop
+puLRt-cGUIY-01287-00369905-00370108 and on mobile
+puLRt-cGUIY-01288-00370109-00370354 you will have two two different software
+puLRt-cGUIY-01289-00370355-00370684 one is the software for the desktop and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01290-00370685-00370867 the other one is the software for mobile
+puLRt-cGUIY-01291-00370868-00371134 they have been Rewritten
+puLRt-cGUIY-01292-00371135-00371417 not the same engine if you use
+puLRt-cGUIY-01293-00371418-00371723 LibreOffice you use the same engine on
+puLRt-cGUIY-01294-00371724-00371849 every platform
+puLRt-cGUIY-01295-00371850-00372082 this means that you produce exactly the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01296-00372083-00372395 same document
+puLRt-cGUIY-01297-00372396-00372947 and I challenge you try to use you have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01298-00372948-00373217 a version of LibreOffice for Android is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01299-00373218-00373421 called collabora office collaborate is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01300-00373422-00373745 one of the ecosystem companies if you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01301-00373746-00373960 create a document with collabora office
+puLRt-cGUIY-01302-00373961-00374254 and you open it to LibreOffice you will
+puLRt-cGUIY-01303-00374255-00374495 have exactly the same document no issue
+puLRt-cGUIY-01304-00374496-00374891 of interoperability absolutely nothing
+puLRt-cGUIY-01305-00374892-00375137 the only thing that changes is the user
+puLRt-cGUIY-01306-00375138-00375358 interface of course you cannot have the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01307-00375359-00375527 use the same user interface on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01308-00375528-00375810 desktop and on mobile for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01309-00375811-00376175 space reason reasons and on the cloud
+puLRt-cGUIY-01310-00376176-00376637 for uh because that is HTML so it has to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01311-00376638-00376828 be a little bit different but we have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01312-00376829-00376991 changed the user interface we didn't
+puLRt-cGUIY-01313-00376992-00377260 change anything of the rest
+puLRt-cGUIY-01314-00377261-00377519 and so the next 10 years we will
+puLRt-cGUIY-01315-00377520-00377795 strongly use the LibreOffice technology
+puLRt-cGUIY-01316-00377796-00378210 we have a also a logo for that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01317-00378211-00378527 uh we don't want to many people think
+puLRt-cGUIY-01318-00378528-00378695 that the document Foundation is a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01319-00378696-00379030 software vendor we are not so we we want
+puLRt-cGUIY-01320-00379031-00379306 to reduce the these
+puLRt-cGUIY-01321-00379307-00379541 this perception and we want to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01322-00379542-00379745 communicate better
+puLRt-cGUIY-01323-00379746-00380177 and the objective is to get to this so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01324-00380178-00380375 individuals that as today they support
+puLRt-cGUIY-01325-00380376-00380680 us within with donations
+puLRt-cGUIY-01326-00380681-00381137 a few Free Riders we know that this they
+puLRt-cGUIY-01327-00381138-00381384 are part of the game you will never
+puLRt-cGUIY-01328-00381385-00381658 contribute to open source software from
+puLRt-cGUIY-01329-00381659-00381941 day one you will start moving to open
+puLRt-cGUIY-01330-00381942-00382210 soon software and once you have realized
+puLRt-cGUIY-01331-00382211-00382487 how strategic it is you can start
+puLRt-cGUIY-01332-00382488-00382793 contributing that is fair
+puLRt-cGUIY-01333-00382794-00383039 so you will start using the software for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01334-00383040-00383123 free
+puLRt-cGUIY-01335-00383124-00383369 for one a couple of years then you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01336-00383370-00383603 realize that the software is part of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01337-00383604-00383860 your strategic infrastructure and you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01338-00383861-00384095 should start to contribute and we the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01339-00384096-00384389 objective is to have many people that in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01340-00384390-00384671 many different ways contribute to the to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01341-00384672-00384827 the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01342-00384828-00385134 and do a lot of Education
+puLRt-cGUIY-01343-00385135-00385451 for instance with the Italian Ministry
+puLRt-cGUIY-01344-00385452-00385582 of Defense
+puLRt-cGUIY-01345-00385583-00385906 I for six months and my wife can confirm
+puLRt-cGUIY-01346-00385907-00386141 I had a general SL
+puLRt-cGUIY-01347-00386142-00386375 that was the IIT manager of the Italian
+puLRt-cGUIY-01348-00386376-00386623 uh the Italian
+puLRt-cGUIY-01349-00386624-00386956 Army calling me at eight o'clock in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01350-00386957-00387071 evening
+puLRt-cGUIY-01351-00387072-00387395 and saying we have found a bug oh happy
+puLRt-cGUIY-01352-00387396-00387653 there are two thousands
+puLRt-cGUIY-01353-00387654-00387869 um and um
+puLRt-cGUIY-01354-00387870-00388091 you have to solve the bug
+puLRt-cGUIY-01355-00388092-00388241 impossible
+puLRt-cGUIY-01356-00388242-00388427 why
+puLRt-cGUIY-01357-00388428-00388847 because if we sold the bug for free
+puLRt-cGUIY-01358-00388848-00389080 in a few years you will not have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01359-00389081-00389297 LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-01360-00389298-00389554 for your desktops why
+puLRt-cGUIY-01361-00389555-00389837 because that developer at the end of the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01362-00389838-00390101 month will get a bill that is not able
+puLRt-cGUIY-01363-00390102-00390395 to pay so you will have to leave the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01364-00390396-00390677 project and go to another project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01365-00390678-00390989 so after six months
+puLRt-cGUIY-01366-00390990-00391378 and being really absolutely firm in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01367-00391379-00391571 answering
+puLRt-cGUIY-01368-00391572-00391919 they said Okay so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01369-00391920-00392182 according to you we should buy a little
+puLRt-cGUIY-01370-00392183-00392278 bit of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01371-00392279-00392621 several copies of several licenses of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01372-00392622-00392837 the Enterprise version and said you got
+puLRt-cGUIY-01373-00392838-00393017 it
+puLRt-cGUIY-01374-00393018-00393473 so now they pay 40 000 licenses and they
+puLRt-cGUIY-01375-00393474-00393767 use sixty thousand for free it's okay I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01376-00393768-00394078 mean if all the Enterprise users
+puLRt-cGUIY-01377-00394079-00394456 pay 40 percent and use 60 for free we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01378-00394457-00394775 would be absolutely delighted
+puLRt-cGUIY-01379-00394776-00395045 what they've done they said these 40 000
+puLRt-cGUIY-01380-00395046-00395243 are the Strategic ones
+puLRt-cGUIY-01381-00395244-00395434 these are the desktops that are used
+puLRt-cGUIY-01382-00395435-00395560 daily
+puLRt-cGUIY-01383-00395561-00395819 we cannot have bugs we cannot have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01384-00395820-00395980 issues on these
+puLRt-cGUIY-01385-00395981-00396173 two thousand are the desktop that are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01386-00396174-00396527 using once a week to write a letter to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01387-00396528-00396773 write a report to the bosses
+puLRt-cGUIY-01388-00396774-00397043 if the report comes out not perfect it's
+puLRt-cGUIY-01389-00397044-00397384 not a problem it's not strategic we can
+puLRt-cGUIY-01390-00397385-00397582 use the free version if there is a bug
+puLRt-cGUIY-01391-00397583-00397817 we will find a workaround
+puLRt-cGUIY-01392-00397818-00398027 and it's working
+puLRt-cGUIY-01393-00398028-00398452 it's now since 2018 so it's seven
+puLRt-cGUIY-01394-00398453-00398639 they're going into the seven year
+puLRt-cGUIY-01395-00398640-00398873 they're already confirmed
+puLRt-cGUIY-01396-00398874-00399184 the licenses for 2023.
+puLRt-cGUIY-01397-00399185-00399419 so it's working they're happy we are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01398-00399420-00399658 happy
+puLRt-cGUIY-01399-00399659-00400108 and uh I hope it was clear
+puLRt-cGUIY-01400-00400109-00400325 there is quite a lot of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01401-00400326-00400660 let's say background on this if you have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01402-00400661-00400847 questions I'm happy to answer the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01403-00400848-00401147 question if you don't have the questions
+puLRt-cGUIY-01404-00401148-00401675 I think I was more or less in the time
+puLRt-cGUIY-01405-00401676-00402037 [Applause]
+puLRt-cGUIY-01406-00402038-00402197 thank you very much for your
+puLRt-cGUIY-01407-00402198-00402371 presentation I would like to ask for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01408-00402372-00402730 questions now and since we have only one
+puLRt-cGUIY-01409-00402731-00403030 movable mic if you have questions it
+puLRt-cGUIY-01410-00403031-00403223 would be really kind if you could step
+puLRt-cGUIY-01411-00403224-00403480 down yeah okay that's okay okay so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01412-00403481-00403877 questions but I I can I can you can use
+puLRt-cGUIY-01413-00403878-00404093 that one and maybe we can pass around
+puLRt-cGUIY-01414-00404094-00404417 this I I can yeah okay and we can pass
+puLRt-cGUIY-01415-00404418-00404873 around this one so questions please
+puLRt-cGUIY-01416-00404874-00405095 come on you you must have a question to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01417-00405096-00405754 yeah
+puLRt-cGUIY-01418-00405755-00405982 no it's not otherwise it's not going to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01419-00405983-00406330 be registered first of all I'd like to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01420-00406331-00406625 um thank you for this descriptively
+puLRt-cGUIY-01421-00406626-00407008 useful and insightful uh presentation
+puLRt-cGUIY-01422-00407009-00407375 and lecture in its own right
+puLRt-cGUIY-01423-00407376-00407608 um and I think that the organizing
+puLRt-cGUIY-01424-00407609-00407837 committee also would like to share that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01425-00407838-00408275 impression with me uh nevertheless I do
+puLRt-cGUIY-01426-00408276-00408539 have two questions or comments for that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01427-00408540-00409032 matter so the first one uh is about
+puLRt-cGUIY-01428-00409033-00409295 commercialization so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01429-00409296-00409595 starting from one of your initial slides
+puLRt-cGUIY-01430-00409596-00409882 on which that particular lexical item
+puLRt-cGUIY-01431-00409883-00410176 was put so commercialization then
+puLRt-cGUIY-01432-00410177-00410530 commercial as an adjective afterwards
+puLRt-cGUIY-01433-00410531-00410614 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-01434-00410616-00410970 how can we actually connect
+puLRt-cGUIY-01435-00410971-00411384 Libra office so the Open office
+puLRt-cGUIY-01436-00411385-00411760 and that commercial side so you you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01437-00411762-00411976 mentioned the turning point so the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01438-00411977-00412326 Paramount event back in 2018
+puLRt-cGUIY-01439-00412327-00412774 as some sort of commercialized uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01440-00412775-00413005 reference point
+puLRt-cGUIY-01441-00413006-00413566 I myself am not uh so I am neither a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01442-00413567-00413897 marketing expert nor an expert in the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01443-00413897-00414160 domain of Economics but since you also
+puLRt-cGUIY-01444-00414162-00414503 mentioned the word sustainability
+puLRt-cGUIY-01445-00414504-00415032 how can we have sustainability without
+puLRt-cGUIY-01446-00415033-00415301 commercialization is it possible
+puLRt-cGUIY-01447-00415302-00415480 so that was the first question the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01448-00415481-00415768 second one if I made also what would be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01449-00415769-00416128 your comment upon uh the British
+puLRt-cGUIY-01450-00416129-00416532 government's decision to renew their
+puLRt-cGUIY-01451-00416533-00416920 Windows XP license and everything that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01452-00416921-00417178 goes with that and paying some extra
+puLRt-cGUIY-01453-00417179-00417751 charges for some superb security patches
+puLRt-cGUIY-01454-00417752-00418060 so the first answer
+puLRt-cGUIY-01455-00418062-00418276 um I think
+puLRt-cGUIY-01456-00418277-00418703 uh when we talk about let's make an
+puLRt-cGUIY-01457-00418704-00418864 example that is not related to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01458-00418866-00419249 LibreOffice but related to Drupal or
+puLRt-cGUIY-01459-00419250-00419560 WordPress if you prefer
+puLRt-cGUIY-01460-00419562-00419964 um both Drupal and WordPress are free
+puLRt-cGUIY-01461-00419966-00420437 projects and they all they have a number
+puLRt-cGUIY-01462-00420438-00420593 of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01463-00420593-00420916 commercial companies supporting the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01464-00420917-00421289 project and selling services
+puLRt-cGUIY-01465-00421289-00421810 so did the the why I I mentioned the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01466-00421812-00422075 concept of becoming a system exactly
+puLRt-cGUIY-01467-00422076-00422416 because we need to stop thinking that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01468-00422417-00422639 the open source project can do
+puLRt-cGUIY-01469-00422639-00422855 everything by itself
+puLRt-cGUIY-01470-00422856-00423131 we developed the software we make sure
+puLRt-cGUIY-01471-00423132-00423533 that the software is open is maintains
+puLRt-cGUIY-01472-00423534-00423905 the open source characteristic
+puLRt-cGUIY-01473-00423906-00424247 but why then we don't have companies
+puLRt-cGUIY-01474-00424247-00424589 like akuya or automatic
+puLRt-cGUIY-01475-00424589-00424870 that have experience on that get their
+puLRt-cGUIY-01476-00424871-00425116 experience on the software because they
+puLRt-cGUIY-01477-00425117-00425416 developed the the let's say the open
+puLRt-cGUIY-01478-00425417-00425699 source part and because they are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01479-00425700-00425891 knowledgeable about the open source part
+puLRt-cGUIY-01480-00425892-00426209 they can sell value added services to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01481-00426210-00426487 people that need value-added services
+puLRt-cGUIY-01482-00426488-00426877 to make a specific example
+puLRt-cGUIY-01483-00426878-00427093 all EU
+puLRt-cGUIY-01484-00427093-00427445 websites are based on Drupal
+puLRt-cGUIY-01485-00427446-00427793 they are all made by a commercial
+puLRt-cGUIY-01486-00427793-00428087 company so the EU pays
+puLRt-cGUIY-01487-00428088-00428357 for the websites although they are based
+puLRt-cGUIY-01488-00428358-00428639 on Drupal but they don't pay for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01489-00428639-00428885 license of Drupal they pay for the added
+puLRt-cGUIY-01490-00428885-00429079 value of having
+puLRt-cGUIY-01491-00429080-00429527 for instance the each side in 27
+puLRt-cGUIY-01492-00429528-00429803 languages which is not trivial
+puLRt-cGUIY-01493-00429804-00430114 so making us uh the same the same
+puLRt-cGUIY-01494-00430115-00430397 website in 27 languages
+puLRt-cGUIY-01495-00430397-00430601 is something that only a commercial
+puLRt-cGUIY-01496-00430602-00430870 company can maintain if we think that we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01497-00430871-00431213 can do that as volunteers it's just I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01498-00431214-00431447 mean I don't think we are doing a good
+puLRt-cGUIY-01499-00431447-00431747 service to ourselves or to the potential
+puLRt-cGUIY-01500-00431747-00432095 customers this is the same as the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01501-00432096-00432418 Liberals this version for the ministry
+puLRt-cGUIY-01502-00432419-00432472 of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01503-00432472-00432607 [Music]
+puLRt-cGUIY-01504-00432608-00432893 Defense in Italy but not only for that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01505-00432893-00433120 we have the the French government is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01506-00433121-00433591 using LibreOffice on 500 000 desktop
+puLRt-cGUIY-01507-00433592-00433960 they they have commercial companies
+puLRt-cGUIY-01508-00433962-00434339 providing Services value added providing
+puLRt-cGUIY-01509-00434339-00434597 service level agreements that you cannot
+puLRt-cGUIY-01510-00434597-00434897 basically provide if you have volunteers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01511-00434897-00435185 you cannot ask a volunteer to work
+puLRt-cGUIY-01512-00435185-00435485 overnight you can ask a paid developer
+puLRt-cGUIY-01513-00435485-00435718 to work overnight to solve a bug that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01514-00435719-00436129 blocking a feature let's say for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01515-00436130-00436577 ministry of economy in in France so that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01516-00436578-00436925 is the point where we have to be able to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01517-00436926-00437077 grow together
+puLRt-cGUIY-01518-00437078-00437405 the open source part and the commercial
+puLRt-cGUIY-01519-00437406-00437635 part related to open source that is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01520-00437635-00437963 commercializing value-added built on top
+puLRt-cGUIY-01521-00437964-00438239 of Open Source software training is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01522-00438239-00438618 another story special versions
+puLRt-cGUIY-01523-00438619-00438970 we have a few special version of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01524-00438971-00439325 LibreOffice done for companies that need
+puLRt-cGUIY-01525-00439326-00439666 a specific feature that specific feature
+puLRt-cGUIY-01526-00439667-00439931 is just for them because it's not a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01527-00439932-00440110 feature that is interesting for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01528-00440112-00440345 others that happens quite frequently
+puLRt-cGUIY-01529-00440346-00440635 with the with the spreadsheet with calc
+puLRt-cGUIY-01530-00440635-00441041 they in some cases they they have macros
+puLRt-cGUIY-01531-00441042-00441322 that are real programs so in that case
+puLRt-cGUIY-01532-00441323-00441539 it's better to have a program instead of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01533-00441539-00441863 a macro so you use the LibreOffice
+puLRt-cGUIY-01534-00441864-00442270 engine to basically create a let's call
+puLRt-cGUIY-01535-00442271-00442422 a sister
+puLRt-cGUIY-01536-00442423-00442727 product to calc that is specific for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01537-00442728-00442966 that company that maybe has a completely
+puLRt-cGUIY-01538-00442967-00443225 different interface as just buttons that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01539-00443226-00443633 call up features and allow the people to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01540-00443634-00443909 create their calculations in an
+puLRt-cGUIY-01541-00443910-00444239 automatic way so this is what I mean by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01542-00444239-00444557 commercialization is to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01543-00444558-00444755 use the software
+puLRt-cGUIY-01544-00444756-00445001 to create value-added products or
+puLRt-cGUIY-01545-00445002-00445229 value-added services that have to be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01546-00445230-00445613 sold and by having companies then and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01547-00445614-00445816 these are the companies like akuya for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01548-00445817-00446183 instance is reinvesting by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01549-00446184-00446316 statute
+puLRt-cGUIY-01550-00446317-00446470 reinvesting
+puLRt-cGUIY-01551-00446471-00446735 40 percent of the revenue on the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01552-00446735-00446933 development of Drupal
+puLRt-cGUIY-01553-00446934-00447203 so they make let's say that they make
+puLRt-cGUIY-01554-00447204-00447587 one million euro they will buy buy
+puLRt-cGUIY-01555-00447588-00447929 statues they have to reinvest 400 000
+puLRt-cGUIY-01556-00447930-00448343 Euro on the development of Drupal not
+puLRt-cGUIY-01557-00448343-00448577 specific version of drupala for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01558-00448578-00448972 customers but on the Drupal platform so
+puLRt-cGUIY-01559-00448973-00449393 develop features and develop this kind
+puLRt-cGUIY-01560-00449393-00449759 of additional value for the open source
+puLRt-cGUIY-01561-00449760-00450131 version second question
+puLRt-cGUIY-01562-00450132-00450295 I think
+puLRt-cGUIY-01563-00450296-00450839 that is just the demonstration of in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01564-00450839-00451277 some cases how bad our public servant
+puLRt-cGUIY-01565-00451278-00451625 when they manage I.T because if you get
+puLRt-cGUIY-01566-00451626-00451987 to the point of having to pay Microsoft
+puLRt-cGUIY-01567-00451988-00452303 to continue to use an old version of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01568-00452304-00452585 Windows that was buggy at the time and
+puLRt-cGUIY-01569-00452585-00452920 it's probably like gruyere today in
+puLRt-cGUIY-01570-00452921-00453239 terms of holes inside the the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01571-00453239-00453551 program
+puLRt-cGUIY-01572-00453552-00453610 um
+puLRt-cGUIY-01573-00453612-00453889 of course I I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01574-00453889-00454216 Microsoft is making the I mean they're
+puLRt-cGUIY-01575-00454217-00454463 just making their business if they've if
+puLRt-cGUIY-01576-00454464-00454699 they find people that is paying them
+puLRt-cGUIY-01577-00454700-00455020 money to maintain up
+puLRt-cGUIY-01578-00455021-00455416 an unmanageable operating system
+puLRt-cGUIY-01579-00455417-00455585 uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01580-00455585-00455897 it's difficult to to give a judgment I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01581-00455897-00456445 think that could be easily solved by
+puLRt-cGUIY-01582-00456446-00456772 replacing that with a with a Linux
+puLRt-cGUIY-01583-00456773-00457168 version and if would probably cost less
+puLRt-cGUIY-01584-00457169-00457487 to develop a specific Linux version for
+puLRt-cGUIY-01585-00457488-00457979 the use of the uh for the use of the UK
+puLRt-cGUIY-01586-00457980-00458170 government
+puLRt-cGUIY-01587-00458171-00458477 in France all the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01588-00458478-00458797 the custom police
+puLRt-cGUIY-01589-00458797-00459203 is using Linux and they have their own
+puLRt-cGUIY-01590-00459204-00459391 specific distribution
+puLRt-cGUIY-01591-00459392-00459701 and the French government pays for the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01592-00459702-00459959 specific distribution but they they have
+puLRt-cGUIY-01593-00459960-00460372 a Linux Distribution on 270 000 desktops
+puLRt-cGUIY-01594-00460373-00460793 so they're supporting of course in this
+puLRt-cGUIY-01595-00460793-00461164 case it's a Debian based and a lot of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01596-00461165-00461477 the money goes to Debian developers that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01597-00461478-00461929 are happy to then develop DPN features
+puLRt-cGUIY-01598-00461930-00462251 uh after that they have developed the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01599-00462252-00462755 paid version for France
+puLRt-cGUIY-01600-00462756-00463013 okay thank you we're a little bit out of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01601-00463014-00463468 time yeah go ahead
+puLRt-cGUIY-01602-00463469-00463649 much better
+puLRt-cGUIY-01604-00466739-00467075 older brother can help
+puLRt-cGUIY-01605-00467076-00467227 you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01606-00467228-00467593 so the the answer is uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01607-00467593-00467837 don't Focus
+puLRt-cGUIY-01608-00467838-00468101 on what you do
+puLRt-cGUIY-01609-00468102-00468616 focus on what together you can do
+puLRt-cGUIY-01610-00468617-00468899 just think that one of the big values of
+puLRt-cGUIY-01611-00468900-00469427 Open Source is that is shared knowledge
+puLRt-cGUIY-01612-00469428-00469685 open source grows because we share the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01613-00469685-00469931 knowledge we published The Source Code
+puLRt-cGUIY-01614-00469932-00470320 that for developers is sharing knowledge
+puLRt-cGUIY-01615-00470321-00470597 not for me I'm not able to read the open
+puLRt-cGUIY-01616-00470597-00470801 source code but a developer that is able
+puLRt-cGUIY-01617-00470802-00470947 to read
+puLRt-cGUIY-01618-00470947-00471305 looking at the other guy source code is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01619-00471306-00471479 sharing knowledge
+puLRt-cGUIY-01620-00471480-00471713 so share the knowledge
+puLRt-cGUIY-01621-00471714-00472253 work together don't think that your
+puLRt-cGUIY-01622-00472254-00472487 your bits and buys are better than the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01623-00472488-00472691 other guy bits and buys because this
+puLRt-cGUIY-01624-00472692-00472847 will never happen
+puLRt-cGUIY-01625-00472847-00473116 sorry you can be extremely professional
+puLRt-cGUIY-01626-00473117-00473399 as a developer but you will always find
+puLRt-cGUIY-01627-00473400-00473668 someone that is better than you in some
+puLRt-cGUIY-01628-00473669-00473957 places and some areas
+puLRt-cGUIY-01629-00473958-00474299 even extremely
+puLRt-cGUIY-01630-00474300-00474622 senior developers will can learn from
+puLRt-cGUIY-01631-00474623-00474839 others and in some cases from Young
+puLRt-cGUIY-01632-00474839-00474989 developers just because the young
+puLRt-cGUIY-01633-00474989-00475270 developer had a brilliant idea that the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01634-00475271-00475618 old one didn't have so don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-01635-00475619-00476045 stay in in silos or don't don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-01636-00476046-00476383 stay behind your desk of all of the time
+puLRt-cGUIY-01637-00476384-00476593 work together
+puLRt-cGUIY-01638-00476593-00476825 share your ideas
+puLRt-cGUIY-01639-00476826-00477041 because that is the only way where you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01640-00477042-00477233 can grow the community and if someone
+puLRt-cGUIY-01641-00477234-00477443 that is non-technical is coming to the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01642-00477443-00477755 community don't scare them by saying oh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01643-00477756-00477947 you should do the first patch otherwise
+puLRt-cGUIY-01644-00477947-00478187 you're not a member of the community
+puLRt-cGUIY-01645-00478188-00478391 for him the first batch could be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01646-00478392-00478591 something that you don't even understand
+puLRt-cGUIY-01647-00478592-00478997 my first patch to open Office was to
+puLRt-cGUIY-01648-00478997-00479225 create a press release
+puLRt-cGUIY-01649-00479226-00479441 is not a patch
+puLRt-cGUIY-01650-00479442-00479675 but if in six months because of that
+puLRt-cGUIY-01651-00479676-00479945 press release and others the downloads
+puLRt-cGUIY-01652-00479946-00480257 went from two to eight million that was
+puLRt-cGUIY-01653-00480258-00480341 a good result
+puLRt-cGUIY-01654-00480342-00480460 [Music]
+puLRt-cGUIY-01655-00480462-00480785 so don't refuse contribution from
+puLRt-cGUIY-01656-00480785-00481001 non-technical people because they can be
+puLRt-cGUIY-01657-00481002-00481193 as valuable As You Are
+puLRt-cGUIY-01658-00481193-00481631 if you are a developer and work together
+puLRt-cGUIY-01659-00481632-00481991 the good approach would be sorry can you
+puLRt-cGUIY-01660-00481992-00482209 explain better what you would do because
+puLRt-cGUIY-01661-00482210-00482495 with my technical background I don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-01662-00482496-00482722 understand what you're doing this is
+puLRt-cGUIY-01663-00482723-00482939 perfectly fine
+puLRt-cGUIY-01664-00482939-00483166 but saying no you should because the the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01665-00483167-00483395 first reaction of people was you don't
+puLRt-cGUIY-01666-00483396-00483599 have a single patch so you're useless
+puLRt-cGUIY-01667-00483600-00483833 for the project
+puLRt-cGUIY-01668-00483834-00484216 that is sorry exactly the wrong approach
+puLRt-cGUIY-01669-00484217-00484522 we should never have this approach
+puLRt-cGUIY-01670-00484523-00484972 everyone can be useful for free software
+puLRt-cGUIY-01671-00484973-00485201 and uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01672-00485202-00485675 working together I mean uh
+puLRt-cGUIY-01673-00485676-00485951 of course now LibreOffice is more
+puLRt-cGUIY-01674-00485952-00486191 structured we have a mentors two mentors
+puLRt-cGUIY-01675-00486192-00486443 that are helping newcomers
+puLRt-cGUIY-01676-00486443-00486857 uh has not always been like this
+puLRt-cGUIY-01677-00486858-00487259 um but think that you need if you grow a
+puLRt-cGUIY-01678-00487260-00487570 little a small project think that the
+puLRt-cGUIY-01679-00487571-00487847 only way you can grow is by getting more
+puLRt-cGUIY-01680-00487847-00487997 people
+puLRt-cGUIY-01681-00487997-00488213 because if you get more people you get
+puLRt-cGUIY-01682-00488214-00488725 more structured and you will understand
+puLRt-cGUIY-01683-00488726-00489066 that you are be that you are creating
+puLRt-cGUIY-01684-00489067-00489335 something that is a real product a real
+puLRt-cGUIY-01685-00489335-00489527 product is not just code
+puLRt-cGUIY-01686-00489528-00489910 a real product does documentation as
+puLRt-cGUIY-01687-00489912-00490259 localization has a lot of stuff around
+puLRt-cGUIY-01688-00490260-00490672 the code
+puLRt-cGUIY-01689-00490673-00490889 okay I would also have some questions
+puLRt-cGUIY-01690-00490889-00491213 but sorry we are out of time and not
+puLRt-cGUIY-01691-00491214-00491375 it's our boss is going to shoot me
+puLRt-cGUIY-01692-00491376-00491651 because we are out of time so maybe we
+puLRt-cGUIY-01693-00491652-00491914 can get around during this break and I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01694-00491915-00492166 guess that you you could ask it hello if
+puLRt-cGUIY-01695-00492167-00492418 you have any further questions so I
+puLRt-cGUIY-01696-00492419-00492593 would close this session and let's thank
+puLRt-cGUIY-01697-00492593-00492791 itelo for his nice presentation once
+puLRt-cGUIY-01698-00492792-00493018 again okay
+puLRt-cGUIY-01699-00493019-00493118 thank you very much
+puLRt-cGUIY-01700-00493118-00493488 [Applause]
+pv319Wf_i6U-00000-00000000-00000380 ah hey what you're doing what on the
+pv319Wf_i6U-00001-00000381-00001383 wine what is that what is yes
+pv319Wf_i6U-00002-00001384-00002567 Nikki are you going so this get her
+pv319Wf_i6U-00003-00002568-00002808 house to move it this way
+pv319Wf_i6U-00004-00002809-00003191 he's catnip right there and this is a
+pv319Wf_i6U-00005-00003192-00003973 cat yeah yeah yeah yeah
+pvRvNnOChJE-00000-00001492-00001960 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00001-00001961-00002883 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00002-00002884-00004283 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00003-00004284-00004471 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00004-00004472-00006878 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00005-00006879-00007083 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00006-00007084-00007693 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00007-00007694-00008483 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00008-00008484-00011244 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00009-00011245-00012695 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00011-00016884-00019683 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00012-00019684-00022483 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00013-00022484-00022604 is
+pvRvNnOChJE-00016-00035084-00037883 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00017-00037884-00038526 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00018-00038527-00040683 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00019-00040684-00042083 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00020-00042084-00044247 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00021-00044248-00044883 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00023-00051883-00054682 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00024-00054683-00056082 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00025-00056083-00057482 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00026-00057483-00058496 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00027-00058497-00061475 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00028-00061476-00061682 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00029-00061683-00062471 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00031-00065695-00065882 [Music]
+pvRvNnOChJE-00032-00065883-00066679 foreign
+pvRvNnOChJE-00033-00066680-00066895 man
+pwEw23hMt-E-00000-00000190-00001474 good morning so welcome to my humble
+pwEw23hMt-E-00001-00001475-00001543 abode
+pwEw23hMt-E-00002-00001544-00002017 this is my room my parents us Cal
+pwEw23hMt-E-00003-00002018-00002364 already caliber
+pwEw23hMt-E-00004-00002365-00002568 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00005-00002569-00002873 so a couple of things are going on one
+pwEw23hMt-E-00006-00002874-00003681 I'm about to buy a sony RX 3 sony rx100
+pwEw23hMt-E-00007-00003682-00004035 plot 3 which is going to replace this
+pwEw23hMt-E-00008-00004036-00004179 piece of junk
+pwEw23hMt-E-00009-00004180-00004392 as this is my fault but that's what I'm
+pwEw23hMt-E-00010-00004393-00004800 shooting up for ever
+pwEw23hMt-E-00011-00004801-00005100 well the wok 3 isn't exactly a view
+pwEw23hMt-E-00012-00005101-00005486 camera it's a five-year-old camera Amy
+pwEw23hMt-E-00013-00005487-00005778 hopefully this is the start of a bunch
+pwEw23hMt-E-00014-00005779-00006047 of much better looking videos well my
+pwEw23hMt-E-00015-00006048-00006240 parents are actually getting this camera
+pwEw23hMt-E-00016-00006241-00006548 for me as an advanced birthday present
+pwEw23hMt-E-00017-00006550-00006796 so thank you very much for that
+pwEw23hMt-E-00018-00006797-00007067 hopefully obviously
+pwEw23hMt-E-00019-00007068-00007359 so actually good-looking stuff you see
+pwEw23hMt-E-00020-00007359-00007703 this thing also it's the middle of the
+pwEw23hMt-E-00021-00007704-00007877 Chinese need a towel this is the third
+pwEw23hMt-E-00022-00007878-00008369 day and it's probably some cooking going
+pwEw23hMt-E-00023-00008370-00008480 on downstairs
+pwEw23hMt-E-00024-00008481-00008728 and I'm gonna go down there
+pwEw23hMt-E-00025-00008729-00009074 try adding some footage apply also some
+pwEw23hMt-E-00026-00009075-00009269 time ago we actually went down tonight
+pwEw23hMt-E-00027-00009270-00009652 eyelid I actually began to take a blog
+pwEw23hMt-E-00028-00009653-00009908 on that trip but it kind of went
+pwEw23hMt-E-00029-00009909-00010205 everywhere so I did I did enough
+pwEw23hMt-E-00030-00010206-00010492 together yet but since I'm making this
+pwEw23hMt-E-00031-00010493-00010816 video I think I'll just append some of
+pwEw23hMt-E-00032-00010817-00011084 that footage to the end of video so
+pwEw23hMt-E-00033-00011085-00011285 stick around if you want to see some of
+pwEw23hMt-E-00034-00011286-00011530 that
+pwEw23hMt-E-00036-00019409-00019884 [Applause]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00037-00019885-00020621 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00038-00020622-00023379 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00039-00023380-00023949 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00040-00023950-00026168 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00041-00026169-00026967 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00042-00026968-00027029 Oh
+pwEw23hMt-E-00043-00027030-00029491 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00044-00029492-00030633 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00045-00030633-00031544 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00046-00031545-00033685 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00047-00033686-00034572 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00049-00040521-00041329 [Applause]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00050-00041330-00043442 yes okay now straight cheap city zip zip
+pwEw23hMt-E-00051-00043443-00044913 wait wait wait wait okay good good
+pwEw23hMt-E-00052-00044914-00045274 who's a good girl
+pwEw23hMt-E-00053-00045275-00047468 [Music]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00054-00047469-00047750 right
+pwEw23hMt-E-00056-00051994-00053712 I bet okay okay
+pwEw23hMt-E-00057-00053713-00055233 happy Holi here you go there you go and
+pwEw23hMt-E-00058-00055234-00055880 that is basically the day so by the way
+pwEw23hMt-E-00059-00055882-00056054 my brother is actually the greenest
+pwEw23hMt-E-00060-00056055-00056366 husky babies the puppies that you see
+pwEw23hMt-E-00061-00056367-00056640 and I click my cell phone the off chance
+pwEw23hMt-E-00062-00056641-00057087 that you want one in Malaysia drop me a
+pwEw23hMt-E-00063-00057088-00057317 message but that's what the day today is
+pwEw23hMt-E-00064-00057319-00057677 over I will probably edit together
+pwEw23hMt-E-00065-00057678-00058086 Penang Island footage and it's so here
+pwEw23hMt-E-00066-00058087-00058405 there
+pwEw23hMt-E-00068-00066321-00066525 [Applause]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00070-00071452-00071564 [Applause]
+pwEw23hMt-E-00072-00077574-00077799 slightly close to the base of these
+pwEw23hMt-E-00073-00077800-00078072 after the same
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00000-00000016-00000167 how long should they live before we do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00001-00000168-00000286 this humane slaughter on them how much
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00002-00000287-00000438 happiness should they have god put these
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00003-00000440-00000591 animals here everything's made in god's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00004-00000592-00000839 image it's okay to kill happy dog yes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00005-00000840-00001054 it's insane cruelty violence and torture
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00006-00001055-00001215 why should we not have that right well
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00007-00001216-00001343 the same reason i should not have that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00008-00001344-00001527 right to do it to you you've got me
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00009-00001528-00001647 you've got you've done me in a loop
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00010-00001648-00001664 there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00011-00001664-00002607 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00012-00002608-00002791 what's your name bro joseph joseph
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00013-00002792-00003546 what's your name joseph
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00014-00003547-00004327 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00015-00004328-00004422 that's the thing i'm open to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00016-00004423-00004606 conversation i think that's the way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00017-00004607-00004767 you learn yeah i'm not i'm not too
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00018-00004768-00004991 informed on like veganism and like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00019-00004992-00005263 animal rights and and animal abuse so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00020-00005264-00005431 like that's before come sit down maybe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00021-00005432-00005527 learn something from you you learn
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00022-00005528-00005686 something from me okay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00023-00005687-00005959 i want to know um when you first read it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00024-00005960-00006070 like what went through your mind and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00025-00006071-00006206 what what you disagree with like how you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00026-00006207-00006446 disagree with it um like when you when
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00027-00006447-00006591 when you read the word vegan nowadays
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00028-00006592-00006719 sort of comes to mind of like people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00029-00006720-00006878 manipulating vegans into some kind of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00030-00006879-00007159 like far left monster in a way and so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00031-00007159-00007319 like unfortunately that's the first
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00032-00007320-00007463 thing that comes to mind
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00033-00007464-00007631 like and and it's not the way i believe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00034-00007631-00007759 but also i kind of walked past and i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00035-00007759-00007903 went
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00036-00007904-00008078 as kind of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00037-00008079-00008359 it's kind of a bold statement to go just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00038-00008360-00008527 because you believe in this one thing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00039-00008528-00008719 means you you support this other
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00040-00008720-00008895 statement and it's and it's kind of this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00041-00008896-00009142 is kind of um when you pick something up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00042-00009143-00009359 and make someone seem worse because of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00043-00009360-00009487 the way they believe so saying someone
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00044-00009488-00009614 supports
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00045-00009615-00009806 uh liberal democrats for example means
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00046-00009807-00010006 that they're racist or something like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00047-00010007-00010231 that so it seems like that but i'm my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00048-00010232-00010399 mom's vegetarian i was vegetarian for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00049-00010400-00010583 nine months yeah it's different to vegan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00050-00010584-00010751 of course yeah yeah but yeah i'm just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00051-00010752-00010863 hoping to learn something from you okay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00052-00010864-00011023 cool and i get what you mean i get what
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00053-00011024-00011110 you mean because there's a lot of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00054-00011111-00011287 anti-vegans out there and then they like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00055-00011288-00011487 to box you in and go you're a far
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00056-00011488-00011751 left-wing radical who's gonna scream at
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00057-00011752-00011870 me or something like that i know i've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00058-00011871-00012127 seen all that yeah but veganism is like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00059-00012128-00012319 a philosophy that is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00060-00012320-00012438 um it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00061-00012439-00012623 opposed to the exploitation and cruelty
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00062-00012624-00012894 to animals yeah there's no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00063-00012895-00013055 i mean politics come into it because we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00064-00013056-00013263 want to change politics for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00065-00013263-00013494 the animals in that sense yeah and a lot
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00066-00013495-00013711 of vegans will be consistent with with
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00067-00013712-00013903 human injustice as well yeah you know so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00068-00013904-00014038 they might they're intersectional yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00069-00014040-00014175 yeah exactly so they might be like well
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00070-00014176-00014391 if i'm against animal abuse you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00071-00014391-00014599 then i should be against other forms of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00072-00014600-00014807 injustice as well exactly
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00073-00014808-00014966 so there are leaning there are if you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00074-00014968-00015103 look at a movement generally they might
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00075-00015104-00015271 be leaning more progressively because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00076-00015272-00015471 they want things to change exactly right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00077-00015472-00015638 but uh if you're talking about veganism
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00078-00015640-00015807 you're talking about animal rights
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00079-00015808-00015958 non-human animal rights
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00080-00015959-00016038 right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00081-00016040-00016311 and um the reason i say support animal
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00082-00016312-00016486 abuse because you might think oh you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00083-00016487-00016727 just mean like like well i believe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00084-00016728-00016894 that it's some type of like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00085-00016895-00017086 philosophical support or something i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00086-00017087-00017422 actually talking about you you you cause
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00087-00017423-00017535 what happens to animals in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00088-00017536-00017703 slaughterhouses and farms
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00089-00017704-00017911 by going to mcdonald's for example
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00090-00017912-00018167 yeah you fund it inadvertently you go to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00091-00018168-00018391 the butcher you pay him for a steak he
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00092-00018392-00018575 has to replace that steak animals get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00093-00018576-00018711 raised and have their head cut off for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00094-00018712-00018943 that steak so that's what i mean when i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00095-00018944-00019183 say support yeah and so it's it's less
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00096-00019184-00019383 of like a ideological thing of you go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00097-00019384-00019567 out and one of your mentalities
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00098-00019568-00019775 in a sense of like so racists will go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00099-00019776-00019943 out and go oh i do not like this certain
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00100-00019944-00020158 kind of race whereas someone who
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00101-00020159-00020327 supports animal rights you're not saying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00102-00020328-00020447 that that's their mentality you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00103-00020448-00020591 saying that by their actions they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00104-00020592-00020775 inadvertently supporting it right i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00105-00020776-00020943 would say usually
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00106-00020944-00021255 most people are against like what you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00107-00021256-00021503 would think of as animal cruelty yes all
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00108-00021504-00021647 right so if i said are you against
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00109-00021648-00021791 animal cruelty
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00110-00021792-00021871 yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00111-00021872-00022063 when we go out here
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00112-00022064-00022230 most people are against animal cruelty
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00113-00022231-00022350 and you're one of them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00114-00022351-00022575 and when when you go into
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00115-00022576-00022678 eat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00116-00022679-00022878 use these products that uh operate in a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00117-00022879-00023071 supply and demand system yeah you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00118-00023072-00023158 supporting something that you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00119-00023159-00023342 fundamentally against yourself
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00120-00023343-00023463 so that's your moral system you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00121-00023464-00023791 opposed you're contradicting
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00122-00023792-00023942 so what would your what would your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00123-00023943-00024263 proposal be to to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00124-00024264-00024519 make people more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00125-00024520-00024758 less less contradicting of themselves
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00126-00024759-00024942 what do you think animal cruelty is do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00127-00024943-00025135 you think eating meat is animal cruelty
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00128-00025136-00025350 no and why not well because they're a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00129-00025351-00025575 humane way i'm not saying that every
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00130-00025576-00025950 every so if you eat humanely sourced
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00131-00025951-00026118 meat yeah for example right and one of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00132-00026119-00026279 the few ways to get that is is from a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00133-00026280-00026455 butcher like from a good old-school
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00134-00026456-00026687 traditional butcher they're the ones
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00135-00026688-00026814 ironically it's the reason why my mom
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00136-00026816-00027023 became vegetarian because she dated one
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00137-00027024-00027111 but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00138-00027112-00027279 you think that that so so let's stop
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00139-00027280-00027487 there because you say you can go into a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00140-00027488-00027687 local traditional butcher yeah in a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00141-00027688-00027958 small town yeah and you can guarantee
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00142-00027960-00028111 those those animals more often than not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00143-00028112-00028262 i've been treated humanely no i'm not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00144-00028263-00028367 guaranteeing it i'm just saying it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00145-00028368-00028470 more likely
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00146-00028472-00028614 going to somewhere like a fast food
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00147-00028616-00028814 chain where it's mass-produced and the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00148-00028816-00029039 chicken has been reformed and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00149-00029039-00029158 it's been
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00150-00029160-00029327 tortured relentlessly i get what you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00151-00029327-00029470 saying can i just show you something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00152-00029472-00029614 briefly i'm not going to take up too
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00153-00029616-00029727 much time but i'm just going to show you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00154-00029727-00029935 what i just recently released just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00155-00029936-00030135 because this myth comes up a lot and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00156-00030136-00030279 you're not you're not a fool for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00157-00030280-00030551 believing this no because they're very
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00158-00030552-00030831 clever with how they propagate this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00159-00030832-00031079 humane myth to people so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00160-00031080-00031214 this is this is this is the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00161-00031216-00031431 slaughterhouse i visited
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00162-00031432-00031558 and uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00163-00031560-00031758 it was basically uh this is the owner
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00164-00031760-00031895 she's a grandma
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00165-00031895-00032031 right so she's a grandma and this is a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00166-00032032-00032199 family-run slaughterhouse
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00167-00032200-00032351 which when you think of it sounds like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00168-00032352-00032502 it's something nicer they don't they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00169-00032503-00032743 don't um they don't supply
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00170-00032744-00032983 um supermarkets only local butchers do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00171-00032984-00033167 you support that kind of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00172-00033168-00033359 you could you believe in not eating meat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00173-00033360-00033567 at all but if someone were to do you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00174-00033568-00033711 believe that that's an okay thing to do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00175-00033712-00033927 to to quickly kill them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00176-00033928-00034046 before
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00177-00034047-00034223 if it had to be done that would be the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00178-00034224-00034479 way it would be done
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00179-00034480-00034646 i don't believe it happens i believe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00180-00034647-00034855 there might be some places where i do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00181-00034856-00035071 believe it's possible that with the bulk
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00182-00035072-00035279 gun i believe i do believe it's possible
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00183-00035280-00035495 um i don't believe that most of the time
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00184-00035496-00035679 it happens i believe that you only know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00185-00035680-00035862 this because you've been told yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00186-00035863-00036030 you've never you don't have you haven't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00187-00036031-00036167 you haven't seen hundreds of hours of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00188-00036168-00036399 slaughterhouses no no yeah so basically
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00189-00036400-00036559 i don't think it happens for a practical
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00190-00036560-00036767 reason but principally that they're two
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00191-00036768-00036895 different sort of arguments aren't they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00192-00036896-00037095 so yeah does it pan out in reality i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00193-00037096-00037262 don't think so because of the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00194-00037263-00037399 investigations that we just recently
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00195-00037400-00037679 done one here where you know her son was
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00196-00037680-00037790 um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00197-00037791-00037974 not stunning animals correctly he's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00198-00037975-00038167 grabbing this you can't do this grabbing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00199-00038168-00038343 that's absolutely nice yeah that's abuse
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00200-00038344-00038430 and then bang
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00201-00038431-00038551 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00202-00038552-00038743 yeah yeah it's disturbing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00203-00038744-00038879 and that's not the only thing that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00204-00038880-00039223 happened so that's anecdotal do you like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00205-00039224-00039374 because i'm more interested in not more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00206-00039375-00039479 interesting you're more interested in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00207-00039480-00039630 statisticians yeah whether it okay that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00208-00039631-00039839 is anecdotal but it is horrifying and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00209-00039840-00039935 that's starting
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00210-00039936-00040135 this is an example yeah i'm telling you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00211-00040136-00040302 we only left these camp this is a random
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00212-00040303-00040446 slaughterhouse we left cameras in for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00213-00040447-00040559 two weeks
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00214-00040560-00040759 we pulled out cows trying to rip their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00215-00040760-00040895 horns off trying to get get out of the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00216-00040896-00041015 knock box because what they do is they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00217-00041016-00041183 see dead body because they have and they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00218-00041184-00041358 understand what that means they see a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00219-00041359-00041558 cow-shaped thing with blood all over it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00220-00041559-00041687 they're freaking out they don't want to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00221-00041688-00041758 die
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00222-00041759-00041935 so when you see that like you don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00223-00041936-00042046 think it's right to treat an animal like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00224-00042047-00042230 that eh let's just say it is an anecdote
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00225-00042231-00042471 all right so why do you care though if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00226-00042472-00042727 you think it's okay to to kill them like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00227-00042728-00042902 if it's done in your your the way that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00228-00042903-00043102 you believe is humane why would you care
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00229-00043103-00043295 that they are in fear because that's not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00230-00043296-00043430 the way that i would believe it should
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00231-00043431-00043630 be done in yeah but wouldn't you say
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00232-00043631-00043783 that that you you believe that the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00233-00043784-00043918 animal matters then if you believe they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00234-00043919-00044167 shouldn't be treated cruelly and in fear
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00235-00044168-00044407 yeah but there's so i believe in the way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00236-00044408-00044590 it should be done right and and it's and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00237-00044591-00044783 it's so easy to turn a blind eye yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00238-00044784-00044902 it's so easy to learn about i know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00239-00044903-00045087 because when you grow up you you get all
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00240-00045088-00045239 this stuff easy and you don't have to do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00241-00045240-00045423 it right and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00242-00045424-00045671 in a perfect society you do it yourself
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00243-00045672-00045862 yeah like you'd be able to go out and do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00244-00045863-00045990 it yourself and actually be confronted
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00245-00045991-00046151 with it and i i believe that a lot more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00246-00046152-00046399 people would be vegan and vegetarian
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00247-00046400-00046574 or or just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00248-00046575-00046727 care more about it if they were actually
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00249-00046728-00046895 able to and it's not something you think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00250-00046896-00047111 about on a regular basis but no i i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00251-00047112-00047262 agree with you though there's two things
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00252-00047263-00047423 i want to talk to you about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00253-00047424-00047590 one is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00254-00047591-00047767 more often than not you're you're not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00255-00047768-00047895 choosing where you you're not going to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00256-00047896-00048046 this traditional local butcher yeah oh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00257-00048047-00048215 no because they're not accessible yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00258-00048216-00048351 okay so more often than not you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00259-00048352-00048590 eating out like everyone else's and more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00260-00048591-00048743 statistically most of the animals in the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00261-00048744-00048943 in the uk do you think they're in on
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00262-00048944-00049118 fields or do you think there no where
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00263-00049119-00049327 are the chants they're in tiny little
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00264-00049328-00049574 cages they're in factory box
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00265-00049575-00049718 maybe not cages but they are in big
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00266-00049719-00049895 factory farms big sheds filled with
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00267-00049896-00050118 chickens 40 000 chickens in a shed
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00268-00050119-00050367 pigs are endorsed raised 90 of them are
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00269-00050368-00050615 factory farmed here and the animals go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00270-00050616-00050823 to a big slaughterhouse to feel
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00271-00050824-00051071 killed in a big production line and you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00272-00051072-00051183 have no idea what happens in that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00273-00051184-00051311 slaughterhouse because you never you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00274-00051312-00051535 never really see anything exactly so so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00275-00051536-00051663 you're supporting now something that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00276-00051664-00051790 you're you're actually against in your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00277-00051791-00051982 own sort of philosophy here even if you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00278-00051983-00052119 believe in humane slaughter yeah so you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00279-00052120-00052294 agree with that so basically by your own
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00280-00052295-00052438 moral standard you're doing something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00281-00052439-00052542 that you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00282-00052544-00052711 introducing myself yeah yeah by your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00283-00052712-00052919 actions yeah so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00284-00052920-00053038 in order for you to be consistent with
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00285-00053039-00053223 your own worldview you'd have to go to a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00286-00053224-00053430 place where you'd seen the animals be be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00287-00053432-00053711 knocked in the knockbox and uh they they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00288-00053712-00053903 didn't experience fear or distress and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00289-00053904-00054135 they were not they were just out yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00290-00054136-00054350 and they and also i assumed too you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00291-00054351-00054511 would you would you'd want them to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00292-00054512-00054735 raised without cruelty either oh yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00293-00054736-00054847 more often than not you're going to get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00294-00054848-00054966 mutilations you're going to get tortured
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00295-00054967-00055079 once you're going to get family
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00296-00055079-00055238 separated this is how the industry works
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00297-00055239-00055375 they breed animals forcibly and they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00298-00055376-00055526 separate their families and they contain
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00299-00055527-00055630 them and then they kill them they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00300-00055632-00055854 there they treat them like objects yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00301-00055855-00056103 let's just say there's a world exists
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00302-00056104-00056342 where you can watch 24 7 what happens on
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00303-00056344-00056438 the farm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00304-00056439-00056623 these animals are happy they're staying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00305-00056624-00056782 together with their families
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00306-00056783-00056926 they're they're basically like they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00307-00056927-00057094 in a big century how long should they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00308-00057095-00057247 live before we do this humane slaughter
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00309-00057248-00057359 on them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00310-00057360-00057503 how much happiness should they have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00311-00057504-00057599 because that's the thing how do you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00312-00057600-00057759 measure a chicken's happiness and this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00313-00057760-00058030 is where it comes into question of of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00314-00058032-00058199 are they they are sentient beings
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00315-00058200-00058350 obviously because they can they can
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00316-00058351-00058526 think they can feel like you you look at
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00317-00058527-00058759 like a the way like a mother cow looks
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00318-00058760-00058926 after his calf obviously that has
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00319-00058927-00059175 emotions but how do you measure
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00320-00059176-00059423 and how do i measure course
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00321-00059424-00059591 by our standards of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00322-00059591-00059766 of our like our
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00323-00059767-00059966 societal standards of happiness which
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00324-00059967-00060182 oftentimes aren't very
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00325-00060183-00060406 accurate so do you have a good job do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00326-00060407-00060599 you have the nice card you have the nice
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00327-00060600-00060775 family life which is very westernized
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00328-00060776-00060919 it's very subjective isn't it it's very
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00329-00060920-00061199 subjective yeah so how can we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00330-00061200-00061350 we're not dog to do little we can't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00331-00061351-00061526 communicate with the animals how do we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00332-00061527-00061682 measure
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00333-00061683-00062047 what their levels of happiness are
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00334-00062048-00062119 because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00335-00062120-00062279 through their behavior you can't you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00336-00062279-00062487 can't um you can't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00337-00062488-00062679 quantify it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00338-00062679-00062847 in a scientific way like you can measure
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00339-00062848-00063079 water yeah but you can measure an
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00340-00063079-00063230 animal's well-being yeah you're not an
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00341-00063232-00063399 animal's suffering yeah that's there's a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00342-00063400-00063550 whole thing about fear pheromones being
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00343-00063551-00063687 released into the meat and that's a way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00344-00063688-00063863 of like testing you can actually test
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00345-00063864-00063975 through pheromones you look like you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00346-00063976-00064087 in pretty good well-being right now i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00347-00064088-00064199 mean a lot of people are depressed you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00348-00064200-00064335 wouldn't know but to me you seem like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00349-00064336-00064463 you're in a pretty
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00350-00064464-00064615 even sort of well-being right now you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00351-00064616-00064759 don't seem to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00352-00064760-00064959 know messed up just by your behavior
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00353-00064960-00065150 so with an animal you can you can
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00354-00065151-00065326 measure their behaviors and their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00355-00065327-00065438 behaviors when they're suffering are
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00356-00065439-00065591 much different to when they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00357-00065592-00065782 they dance and they play the pigs like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00358-00065783-00065935 to play with each other and you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00359-00065936-00066094 they relax and that you can see in their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00360-00066095-00066350 expressions so i'm talking about that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00361-00066351-00066550 yeah by their behavior
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00362-00066551-00066703 so how much of that should they be able
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00363-00066704-00066919 to experience before you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00364-00066920-00067119 it's entirely
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00365-00067120-00067294 now this is your i'm only going off your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00366-00067295-00067479 worldview here this is you're we're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00367-00067480-00067647 creating this situation that you think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00368-00067648-00067871 is humane and i want to just debunk the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00369-00067872-00068079 best possible situation in your eyes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00370-00068080-00068182 that's where i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00371-00068183-00068303 want to take this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00372-00068304-00068438 because we already agree factory farming
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00373-00068439-00068599 and being cruel to ours is wrong we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00374-00068600-00068743 agree that bad slaughtering is wrong and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00375-00068744-00068855 we agreed that you're you're probably
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00376-00068856-00069063 supporting that most of the time yeah i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00377-00069064-00069255 want to take it out to the best possible
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00378-00069256-00069375 i'm trying to change your philosophy
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00379-00069376-00069535 yeah and i want to know what your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00380-00069536-00069726 philosophy is so we can attack it from
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00381-00069727-00070175 its pinnacle point yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00382-00070176-00070319 the only way i can phrase this is going
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00383-00070320-00070526 to seriously
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00384-00070527-00070647 harm my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00385-00070648-00070815 not argument my my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00386-00070816-00071103 belief but who are we to determine
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00387-00071104-00071247 how
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00388-00071248-00071391 long they should
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00389-00071392-00071599 be happy for before we kill them and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00390-00071600-00071879 that i feel might be your belief of who
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00391-00071880-00072094 are we to determine
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00392-00072095-00072343 you're you're essentially saying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00393-00072344-00072526 you're choosing when you can rob their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00394-00072527-00072647 existence
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00395-00072648-00072862 and and for what
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00396-00072863-00073279 for example
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00397-00073280-00073431 and like a meal that you forget about do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00398-00073432-00073543 you remember what you had for breakfast
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00399-00073544-00073671 three days ago
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00400-00073672-00073815 exactly so you don't even care enough
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00401-00073816-00073999 about the breakfast but you've taken
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00402-00074000-00074182 someone's life from them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00403-00074183-00074367 someone i think is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00404-00074368-00074526 do so you would refer to a chicken as
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00405-00074527-00074647 someone
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00406-00074648-00074799 yeah i i believe there's someone in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00407-00074800-00074975 there having a subjective experience of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00408-00074976-00075071 reality
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00409-00075072-00075303 so an experience has a subject in there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00410-00075304-00075438 inside of them that has wants and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00411-00075439-00075623 desires and they avoid things and they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00412-00075624-00075838 have their own personalities which can
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00413-00075839-00076047 be tested yeah you can test some pigs
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00414-00076048-00076215 are grumpy you don't want some pigs love
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00415-00076216-00076375 cuddles some turkeys love cuddles some
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00416-00076376-00076526 turkeys are you know you can abuse an
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00417-00076527-00076679 animal they'll have trauma that that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00418-00076680-00076894 animal's uh cautious around certain
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00419-00076895-00077135 people some animals like male something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00420-00077136-00077415 like like a like a dog your dog my dog's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00421-00077416-00077599 not good with men so stand back but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00422-00077600-00077775 women my dog loves children my dog's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00423-00077776-00077991 really good with just keep you know yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00424-00077992-00078191 these are personality traits so there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00425-00078192-00078447 there's an individual inside of it a dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00426-00078448-00078679 or a chicken or a bird
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00427-00078680-00078799 having a subjective experience of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00428-00078800-00079087 reality just like you are not just your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00429-00079088-00079238 your reactions to the environment you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00430-00079239-00079391 a you're a you're a subject there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00431-00079392-00079599 someone inside of you yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00432-00079600-00079806 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00433-00079807-00080015 i do think for some reason my mind and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00434-00080016-00080111 maybe this is just the way we're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00435-00080112-00080391 conditioned but my mind goes to reject
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00436-00080392-00080519 calling
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00437-00080520-00080687 uh something that i would look at as
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00438-00080688-00080838 dinner someone
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00439-00080839-00081126 you've been objectified yeah and and i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00440-00081127-00081415 think that may be a way for us to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00441-00081416-00081582 okay with it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00442-00081583-00081847 and it's spot-on and it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00443-00081848-00082047 it's it's it's it feels like every
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00444-00082048-00082215 argument i present is a way for me to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00445-00082216-00082406 justify
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00446-00082407-00082631 but then what i might call the question
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00447-00082632-00082847 is why so you argue what right do we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00448-00082848-00083015 have to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00449-00083016-00083126 to determine the length of their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00450-00083127-00083326 happiness to determine whether we put a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00451-00083327-00083494 bolt in their head or not to determine
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00452-00083495-00083615 whether we kill them humanely or not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00453-00083616-00083743 humanely
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00454-00083744-00084023 why should we not have that right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00455-00084024-00084150 well the same reason i should not have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00456-00084151-00084350 that right to do it to you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00457-00084351-00084567 that's where that's where it's that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00458-00084568-00084759 where the question of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00459-00084760-00084935 why is an animal lesser than a human
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00460-00084936-00085094 being comes into question
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00461-00085095-00085294 and i and i would argue how would you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00462-00085295-00085494 mean lesser so we can we can go into the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00463-00085495-00085679 the lesser what do you mean by lesser oh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00464-00085680-00085806 less less uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00465-00085807-00085959 i'm not saying that's what i believe i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00466-00085960-00086103 i'm saying that's what gets caught into
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00467-00086104-00086255 question right when
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00468-00086256-00086535 lesser is in if i were to i've seen
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00469-00086536-00086703 police around if i were to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00470-00086704-00086847 start beating you up right now i don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00471-00086848-00087023 know if i'd fare very well against you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00472-00087024-00087143 but if i was to start beating you up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00473-00087144-00087343 right now i'd get arrested for good
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00474-00087344-00087550 reason right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00475-00087551-00087726 and if there are laws against beating up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00476-00087727-00087943 like there's animal abuse laws right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00477-00087944-00088135 but if i was to kill you as opposed to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00478-00088136-00088311 killing an animal the sentence would be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00479-00088312-00088567 completely different yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00480-00088568-00088799 well the animals don't have rights in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00481-00088800-00088999 the world they some animals might have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00482-00089000-00089103 you might be in trouble for killing a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00483-00089104-00089279 dog no no no if you kick a pigeon in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00484-00089280-00089359 london
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00485-00089360-00089511 but if i killed a people in my backyard
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00486-00089512-00089662 i probably won't get maybe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00487-00089663-00089806 maybe some slaughter guidelines maybe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00488-00089807-00089918 i'll get a slap on the wrist i'm going
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00489-00089919-00090094 to find look don't kill the pig in your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00490-00090095-00090247 backyard yeah but you know you can pay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00491-00090248-00090438 for killing of pigs all you want you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00492-00090439-00090615 know but i get what you're saying like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00493-00090616-00090815 we determine so but like you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00494-00090816-00091047 there's not all humans are equal yeah in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00495-00091048-00091167 every way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00496-00091168-00091318 so and when i say that i'm not saying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00497-00091319-00091550 that we should treat them unequally yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00498-00091551-00091694 i'm saying there's differences there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00499-00091695-00091903 differences in our abilities yeah some
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00500-00091904-00092135 people are born with handicaps like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00501-00092136-00092335 severe mental handicaps and we will look
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00502-00092336-00092582 after them and look after them equally
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00503-00092583-00092759 as we would with you yeah but there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00504-00092760-00092903 differences you approach them with yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00505-00092904-00093047 we don't say well we can we can enslave
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00506-00093048-00093191 these humans because they're not like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00507-00093192-00093343 they're not they're lesser than us we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00508-00093344-00093511 say well let's protect them more they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00509-00093512-00093694 more vulnerable actually
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00510-00093695-00093823 you know when elderly get more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00511-00093824-00094015 vulnerable it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00512-00094016-00094150 the more vulnerable the victim the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00513-00094151-00094311 greater the crime
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00514-00094312-00094455 and when you look at a chicken how
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00515-00094456-00094574 vulnerable was a chicken to you you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00516-00094575-00094687 could just stomp on them couldn't you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00517-00094688-00094879 incredibly and that's throughout history
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00518-00094880-00095079 it's been it's been we need to take over
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00519-00095080-00095255 this we need to take over this and if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00520-00095256-00095518 you're stronger you can right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00521-00095519-00095655 and that makes right kind of thing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00522-00095656-00095959 survival of the fittest exactly yeah and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00523-00095960-00096150 and that's a shame uh but imagine that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00524-00096151-00096343 though imagine that world
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00525-00096344-00096487 survival of the fittest there's reason
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00526-00096488-00096631 we haven't no we live in that water no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00527-00096632-00097031 we don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00528-00097032-00097271 i could target a lot of individuals here
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00529-00097272-00097415 and i could round them up with a gun and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00530-00097416-00097591 put them in a basement and that survival
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00531-00097592-00097750 of that's like they i wouldn't have to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00532-00097751-00097879 work a day in my life they'd be cleaning
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00533-00097880-00098094 my house and you know you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00534-00098095-00098262 so we do have laws protecting human
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00535-00098263-00098447 beings yes like if you commit some type
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00536-00098448-00098647 of hate crime against someone because of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00537-00098648-00098887 whatever their pro whatever sort of um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00538-00098888-00099135 section of society they're in you'll go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00539-00099136-00099423 to prison you know but but animals we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00540-00099424-00099574 can essentially certain species of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00541-00099575-00099759 animals we can do we can do whatever we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00542-00099760-00099967 like to them but it's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00543-00099968-00100087 there's a great picture that i saw a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00544-00100088-00100262 while ago where it's uh like a chain of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00545-00100263-00100471 animals like the theory of evolution uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00546-00100472-00100662 man where you like gets bigger and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00547-00100663-00100806 similar to that where it's like a cat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00548-00100807-00101055 chicken dog hierarchy yeah the hierarchy
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00549-00101056-00101182 and then it's like oh these are the ones
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00550-00101183-00101382 that were okay to eat but then and then
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00551-00101383-00101574 you look at places like um in the in the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00552-00101575-00101655 east
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00553-00101656-00101982 where um there's the festival of dogs
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00554-00101983-00102191 uh make festival yeah yeah yeah and and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00555-00102192-00102343 where they eat dogs and that to us it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00556-00102344-00102518 like what do you think about that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00557-00102519-00102671 well what do you think about what if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00558-00102672-00102878 they what if okay we'll get the dogs you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00559-00102879-00103047 agree i'm i'm going to say you will
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00560-00103048-00103206 agree anyway that you shouldn't treat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00561-00103207-00103351 the dogs cruelly in that but well let's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00562-00103352-00103486 put the dog in the hypothetical
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00563-00103488-00103647 situation you posed
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00564-00103648-00103775 and they don't really know but they're a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00565-00103776-00104023 happy dog yeah coolest dog think of the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00566-00104024-00104175 coolest dog you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00567-00104176-00104454 you've ever met yeah do they have a name
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00568-00104455-00104615 adam what's the dog's name jonathan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00569-00104616-00104830 jonathan the dog stupid name but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00570-00104831-00105039 jonathan so we've got jonathan yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00571-00105040-00105223 jonathan is about halfway through their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00572-00105224-00105399 life and they're just loving it cold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00573-00105400-00105575 chilling going with phone bisbee's their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00574-00105576-00105758 loving life but then one day we lead
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00575-00105759-00105895 them into a room it's a dark room they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00576-00105896-00106015 don't see the gun coming we shoot them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00577-00106016-00106134 in the back of their head and our
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00578-00106135-00106278 justification is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00579-00106279-00106486 i kind of like i like burgers so yeah go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00580-00106488-00106878 and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00581-00106879-00106999 and i'm not saying that to just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00582-00107000-00107158 continually back up my point and it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00583-00107159-00107327 not something that i'm i don't believe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00584-00107328-00107431 in but i'm still going to say it to back
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00585-00107432-00107623 up my point i think especially with the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00586-00107624-00107847 the dog meat festival uh ricky gervais
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00587-00107848-00108007 is a very prominent animal rights
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00588-00108008-00108158 activist yeah and he's been posting a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00589-00108159-00108302 lot about it recently and especially
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00590-00108303-00108495 about the dog festival
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00591-00108496-00108663 and i look at stuff like that and i go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00592-00108664-00108815 who are we to tell
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00593-00108816-00108966 these people obviously like let's talk
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00594-00108967-00109078 about it in humane conditions and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00595-00109079-00109278 hypothetical conditions i don't agree
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00596-00109279-00109423 with the way they do it now because it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00597-00109424-00109575 it's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00598-00109576-00109671 the conditions they're kept and i've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00599-00109672-00109839 seen the videos
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00600-00109840-00110015 in a hypothetical scenario who are we to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00601-00110016-00110295 say we can't eat jonathan essentially no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00602-00110296-00110463 you who you tell me i can't eat jonathan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00603-00110464-00110895 yeah yeah and why why are we dictating
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00604-00110896-00111071 what happens to jonathan and jonathan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00605-00111072-00111415 doesn't come into it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00606-00111416-00111534 because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00607-00111535-00111751 not a human being and that's the thing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00608-00111752-00111934 that comes to my head so it's species
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00609-00111935-00112031 yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00610-00112032-00112375 okay species ism is a phrase out of here
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00611-00112376-00112534 a word that i hear throwing around a lot
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00612-00112535-00112719 and it automatically you reach out and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00613-00112720-00112951 see it and you go off no get off this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00614-00112952-00113207 discrimination like um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00615-00113208-00113415 it's happened within the human species
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00616-00113416-00113615 too and it's just categorizing people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00617-00113616-00113790 into groups yeah it was it was it wasn't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00618-00113791-00113983 until recently that um indigenous people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00619-00113983-00114190 in australia were not classed as uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00620-00114191-00114423 flora and fauna i know it was very
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00621-00114424-00114631 you're straight right there yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00622-00114632-00114766 aboriginals is sickening yeah it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00623-00114767-00114966 disgusting they looked at them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00624-00114967-00115223 like animals yeah flora and fauna up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00625-00115224-00115431 until very recently which is which is a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00626-00115432-00115702 disgusting like justification it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00627-00115703-00115790 lauren
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00628-00115791-00115958 humans down to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00629-00115959-00116119 animals right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00630-00116120-00116366 imagine if we didn't have that category
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00631-00116367-00116590 to put them in yeah and animals were
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00632-00116591-00116678 actually
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00633-00116679-00116863 respected yeah you could never i could
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00634-00116864-00117039 never lower you to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00635-00117040-00117239 fauna you know what i mean
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00636-00117240-00117454 because we would respect animals you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00637-00117455-00117623 know what i'm saying so this speciesism
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00638-00117624-00117927 thing is actually more violent than out
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00639-00117928-00118063 has more violent outcomes than what you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00640-00118064-00118263 want yes thing because the first the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00641-00118264-00118383 first like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00642-00118383-00118566 sort of canary in the coal mine kind of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00643-00118567-00118734 thing the first warning is like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00644-00118735-00118919 they start saying that their rats their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00645-00118920-00119102 their dogs their pigs to this group of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00646-00119103-00119358 people and that's usually preceded by
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00647-00119359-00119454 some
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00648-00119455-00119671 awful tragedy yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00649-00119672-00119919 so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00650-00119920-00120119 i think that you're still you're still
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00651-00120120-00120295 kind of in the camp of like how do we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00652-00120296-00120383 who
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00653-00120383-00120607 we get to determine the outcome of an
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00654-00120608-00120766 animal because we're a human being and i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00655-00120767-00120951 say that that's like human supremacy
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00656-00120952-00121071 where we're saying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00657-00121072-00121278 we're saying um we are we are better we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00658-00121279-00121423 are more special
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00659-00121424-00121599 and uh we get to dictate
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00660-00121600-00121807 you know if as long as we treat them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00661-00121808-00121966 these are kind of our own rules we're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00662-00121967-00122183 making yeah because i don't think we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00663-00122183-00122310 caring about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00664-00122311-00122447 treating them cruelly because we care
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00665-00122448-00122751 about the animal i don't think no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00666-00122752-00122878 it's more about how it reflects on us
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00667-00122879-00123102 how we feel guilty for it i believe like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00668-00123103-00123286 you might feel bad knowing that an
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00669-00123288-00123414 animal is tortured so you could eat them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00670-00123415-00123543 but you don't mind if they weren't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00671-00123544-00123734 tortured and lose their life yeah so we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00672-00123735-00123943 can eat them help us sleep at night yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00673-00123944-00124183 and and that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00674-00124183-00124295 because it keeps being brought back and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00675-00124296-00124439 like i said when i first sat down i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00676-00124440-00124558 don't know much about the situation i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00677-00124559-00124710 don't know much about the thing but i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00678-00124711-00124790 want
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00679-00124791-00124958 to learn more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00680-00124959-00125102 and so i think from what i'm going to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00681-00125103-00125271 get from everything you've said so far
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00682-00125272-00125407 and we'll see
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00683-00125408-00125534 is that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00684-00125535-00125727 like if i need some food later i'm not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00685-00125728-00125943 saying that i'm not going to get meat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00686-00125944-00126102 but it will call into question and it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00687-00126103-00126286 will be in my head and and i think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00688-00126288-00126439 that's one of the beautiful things about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00689-00126440-00126607 this kind of thing which is why i want a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00690-00126608-00126695 conversation on why i think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00691-00126696-00126823 conversations are good because it calls
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00692-00126824-00127007 into question and maybe the next person
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00693-00127008-00127175 you speak the exact same thing to them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00694-00127176-00127351 and it doesn't just call into question
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00695-00127352-00127534 their own
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00696-00127535-00127734 structures it it makes them change their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00697-00127735-00127958 mind entirely and that's one more person
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00698-00127959-00128231 but so so recently uh during the first
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00699-00128232-00128534 lockdown i got very into uh liberalism
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00700-00128535-00128758 uh libertarianism sorry libertarians um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00701-00128759-00128990 and personal freedom and the ability to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00702-00128991-00129151 dictate what you do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00703-00129152-00129302 with your own self
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00704-00129303-00129527 and to an extension
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00705-00129528-00129751 that would come through as to i want to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00706-00129752-00129919 eat me but when it comes to something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00707-00129920-00130054 like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00708-00130055-00130366 personal freedoms
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00709-00130367-00130463 you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00710-00130464-00130631 essentially taking away the personal
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00711-00130632-00130807 freedom of the animal by killing them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00712-00130808-00131031 and eating them it works both ways so it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00713-00131032-00131190 works both ways you're trying to say
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00714-00131191-00131335 because when it comes to what's this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00715-00131336-00131502 libertarianism philosophy it's like it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00716-00131503-00131702 big on personal freedom yeah but if i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00717-00131703-00131911 take away your personal freedom
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00718-00131912-00132054 um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00719-00132055-00132287 i i just want you to respect mine yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00720-00132288-00132519 and i respect yours yeah and and and so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00721-00132520-00132814 it's it's essentially uh one of the main
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00722-00132815-00133054 belief systems in it and it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00723-00133055-00133247 unfortunately it's been co-opted by a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00724-00133248-00133335 lot of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00725-00133336-00133559 nastier people but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00726-00133560-00133743 you do whatever you want
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00727-00133744-00133927 i do whatever i want if it doesn't harm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00728-00133928-00134127 me and you don't harm me and i don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00729-00134128-00134302 harm you do whatever you want
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00730-00134303-00134390 and so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00731-00134391-00134599 all-encompassing philosophy yeah okay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00732-00134600-00134766 and the animals are excluded from that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00733-00134767-00134878 one
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00734-00134879-00135039 yeah because we have a similar
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00735-00135040-00135263 philosophy i just include i just include
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00736-00135264-00135423 the animals in there like you can do
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00737-00135424-00135583 whatever you want in the bedroom and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00738-00135584-00135743 your personal life you can local music
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00739-00135744-00135975 you want you can eat nothing but bloody
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00740-00135976-00136175 fried i don't know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00741-00136176-00136319 chips you know i'm not going to come up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00742-00136320-00136471 to you i'm the health police yeah it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00743-00136472-00136639 your choice and if you're my friend and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00744-00136640-00136727 you're smoking cigarettes i'm going to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00745-00136728-00136895 say dude are you come on man like i love
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00746-00136896-00137143 you mate don't do that but like if you i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00747-00137144-00137254 don't go to people smoking cigarettes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00748-00137255-00137359 and go hey you shouldn't have the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00749-00137360-00137535 freedom
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00750-00137536-00137663 but um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00751-00137664-00137807 when others are involved that's why
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00752-00137808-00137943 people go oh vegans are forcing their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00753-00137944-00138095 beliefs on me because they want me to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00754-00138096-00138231 like they're not they're just counting
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00755-00138232-00138390 they're proposing another viewpoint
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00756-00138391-00138495 we're stopping we're defending the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00757-00138496-00138695 animals from being attacked by people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00758-00138696-00138871 yeah so it's way different it's a way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00759-00138872-00139023 different dynamic here i'm not saying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00760-00139024-00139159 are you shooting the war all black today
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00761-00139160-00139287 man like what are you doing like you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00762-00139288-00139431 should wear like this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00763-00139432-00139639 blue shirt it's like no when you wear
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00764-00139640-00139863 that black an animal is being executed
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00765-00139864-00140054 against their will can you stop harming
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00766-00140055-00140190 the animals that's what that's the the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00767-00140191-00140295 difference yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00768-00140296-00140454 put yourself in the this is what i said
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00769-00140455-00140599 put to get people to try to put
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00770-00140600-00140702 themselves
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00771-00140703-00140871 in their mind in the animal's position
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00772-00140872-00141039 and what do you think would be a like if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00773-00141040-00141214 you're if you're a chicken
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00774-00141215-00141423 like what defense do you think you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00775-00141424-00141590 deserve would you want what defense
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00776-00141591-00141703 would you want
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00777-00141704-00141943 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00778-00141944-00142143 a weapon of some kind against the farmer
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00779-00142144-00142271 you would want you would want direct
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00780-00142272-00142478 action sort of defense wouldn't you yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00781-00142479-00142678 stop yeah yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00782-00142679-00142871 i mean we know that eating animals is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00783-00142872-00143063 illegal so we can't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00784-00143064-00143271 continuously do that type of thing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00785-00143272-00143471 so the best the best sort of weapon we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00786-00143472-00143590 have to be able to be in a fully
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00787-00143591-00143839 functioning society and you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00788-00143840-00143983 is to try to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00789-00143984-00144119 change the consciousness of people and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00790-00144120-00144407 hopefully affect uh the culture you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00791-00144408-00144590 so it's it's not like i'm saying oh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00792-00144591-00144719 you've got to choose between a human and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00793-00144720-00144887 a chicken right now here's a gun to your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00794-00144888-00145007 head of course you're going to i will
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00795-00145008-00145183 choose the human yeah if it's you and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00796-00145184-00145366 the chickens here it would be very sad
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00797-00145367-00145471 it would be a sad thing to do but i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00798-00145472-00145639 would choose you in that type of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00799-00145640-00145935 situation so you would you replaced
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00800-00145936-00146254 so you you place a higher um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00801-00146255-00146454 it depends who you are but you sing nice
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00802-00146455-00146639 if you were hitler then
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00803-00146640-00146790 if you were hitler then no i'm choosing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00804-00146791-00146902 the chicken yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00805-00146903-00147111 so it depends on the person but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00806-00147112-00147231 a chickens
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00807-00147232-00147439 you so a chicken's value is always the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00808-00147440-00147631 same in your opinion but the humans
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00809-00147632-00147790 value is is different depending on the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00810-00147791-00147911 person they can i think most chickens
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00811-00147912-00148087 you could agree that most chickens uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00812-00148088-00148366 you know they're not humans
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00813-00148367-00148566 are like uh you know yeah awful and you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00814-00148567-00148735 seem like you would change too you don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00815-00148736-00148847 seem someone like someone who's just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00816-00148848-00148959 gonna be like nah i'm starting a chicken
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00817-00148960-00149126 farm tomorrow and i'm gonna kill
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00818-00149127-00149311 hundreds of thousands of chickens and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00819-00149312-00149439 cause all of this suffering throughout
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00820-00149440-00149623 my life then i might be leaning towards
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00821-00149624-00149759 choosing the chicken it's gonna cause
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00822-00149760-00150071 less suffering over but like um so like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00823-00150072-00150207 i'm not asking people to do that people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00824-00150208-00150383 think that i'm just i'm asking them to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00825-00150384-00150502 choose a chicken over a person no you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00826-00150503-00150623 don't care about people well no i'm just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00827-00150624-00150807 saying choose the chicken's life over a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00828-00150808-00151014 sandwich and choose a different sandwich
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00829-00151015-00151223 that's how easy it is it's not like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00830-00151224-00151335 you can go right there burger king you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00831-00151336-00151454 can get a vegan chicken burger or you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00832-00151455-00151590 can get the real chicken burgers yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00833-00151591-00151702 you know and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00834-00151703-00151926 like why not change just what you choose
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00835-00151927-00152014 yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00836-00152015-00152231 and so we spoken about my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00837-00152232-00152431 like hypothetical like putting a bolt in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00838-00152432-00152654 their head and like what i would want
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00839-00152655-00152799 but i'm actually quite interested to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00840-00152800-00152990 know what you like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00841-00152991-00153119 what your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00842-00153120-00153287 dream world and not just because we've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00843-00153288-00153463 mostly spoken about eating animals but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00844-00153464-00153599 also in regards to because i've seen
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00845-00153600-00153871 recently uh the exposes on on gucci and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00846-00153872-00154007 louis vuitton with their snake skin and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00847-00154008-00154239 how like they're just wearing animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00848-00154240-00154423 yeah testing on animals ironically you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00849-00154424-00154599 know uh there's some horrible things
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00850-00154600-00154823 that veganism is a philosophy that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00851-00154824-00154959 encompasses
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00852-00154960-00155135 exploitation and cruelty to animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00853-00155136-00155343 period you know there are areas of our
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00854-00155344-00155607 life that you can't avoid
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00855-00155608-00155759 humans or animals being harmed yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00856-00155760-00155966 practically like in a in a in a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00857-00155967-00156126 practical sense you can't exist in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00858-00156127-00156311 society without there being a level of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00859-00156312-00156526 harm because of civilization uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00860-00156527-00156823 cultivating crops causes harm causes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00861-00156824-00156966 harm to humans and animals that are in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00862-00156967-00157190 those crops but in order to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00863-00157191-00157335 to not cause any harm you'd have to not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00864-00157336-00157487 have civilization yeah we'll not have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00865-00157488-00157663 hospitals and so there's a there's a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00866-00157664-00157847 there's kind of like this threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00867-00157848-00158063 right of harm that in order to have all
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00868-00158064-00158231 of this well-being in society there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00869-00158232-00158359 going to have to be a certain level of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00870-00158360-00158559 harm exactly but when you do the massive
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00871-00158560-00158726 holocaust of animals on top of it this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00872-00158727-00158959 massive huge like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00873-00158960-00159102 constant breeding and killing of animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00874-00159103-00159247 on top of it i said it's completely
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00875-00159248-00159487 unjustified but we already caused
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00876-00159488-00159678 this harm from having civilization
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00877-00159679-00159887 justified harm i would call it why would
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00878-00159888-00160087 we need to like do all this mass killing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00879-00160088-00160214 for a sandwich on top of it so you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00880-00160215-00160423 saying that there is a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00881-00160424-00160639 way in your like well not in your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00882-00160640-00160823 fantasy but in in actual life there is a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00883-00160824-00161014 line to which
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00884-00161015-00161223 uh it's okay to do it because it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00885-00161224-00161407 benefits humanity
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00886-00161408-00161590 and then anything above that is is too
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00887-00161591-00161743 far i think that there's this threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00888-00161744-00161951 that if you didn't meet this threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00889-00161952-00162135 then the the amount of suffering would
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00890-00162136-00162319 be so much worse you know what i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00891-00162320-00162463 saying so like if you're talking about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00892-00162464-00162575 we can't cause harm we can't have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00893-00162576-00162695 hospitals we can't have dentists we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00894-00162696-00162966 can't have civilization you know um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00895-00162967-00163214 uh crops we can't cultivate crops
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00896-00163215-00163326 because there's going to be insects and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00897-00163327-00163495 animals huh but then
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00898-00163496-00163687 all people are going to die the world is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00899-00163688-00163878 going to descend into like you know if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00900-00163879-00164007 you took away civilization we'll live
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00901-00164008-00164135 out in nature there'll be more much more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00902-00164136-00164287 suffering than you're talking about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00903-00164288-00164431 taking us back
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00904-00164432-00164647 you know in terms of medieval yeah so so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00905-00164648-00164783 there's this there's always this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00906-00164784-00164895 threshold where sometimes there's going
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00907-00164896-00165095 to be some humans and animals caught up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00908-00165096-00165207 in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00909-00165208-00165454 you know but to create this massive
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00910-00165455-00165607 killing on top of it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00911-00165608-00165799 it's just it's extreme it's it's more
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00912-00165800-00166054 than justifiable yeah and and so that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00913-00166055-00166326 i like that because like like i said oh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00914-00166327-00166535 that's not good um like i said earlier
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00915-00166536-00166743 like when when vegan comes to mind you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00916-00166744-00166935 think of like people who prefer animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00917-00166936-00167183 to humans so it's it's nice to have it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00918-00167184-00167471 reaffirmed that that's not the case you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00919-00167472-00167614 like like you said you you you'd pick
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00920-00167615-00167766 the humor some people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00921-00167767-00167983 i prefer you because i've met you now to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00922-00167984-00168183 the stranger over there yeah i prefer my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00923-00168184-00168414 brother over you i'm shooting you for my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00924-00168415-00168623 before my brother yeah you know like so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00925-00168624-00168871 i'm shooting you over my mum
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00926-00168872-00169014 but that doesn't mean that you or my mom
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00927-00169015-00169183 should have different riots yeah you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00928-00169184-00169375 know what i'm saying yeah so it's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00929-00169376-00169566 again it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00930-00169567-00169735 if i had to pick for example two pigs i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00931-00169736-00169959 had one pig at home i love this pig you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00932-00169960-00170102 know there's another pig i don't know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00933-00170103-00170407 i'm gonna say i'm so sorry i love my pig
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00934-00170408-00170495 you know what i'm saying doesn't mean
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00935-00170496-00170607 these two pigs should have different
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00936-00170608-00170743 right that's not what i'm asking people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00937-00170744-00170966 to do no i'm just asking to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00938-00170967-00171238 like uh you know not stab
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00939-00171239-00171423 animals in the throat for a second
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00940-00171424-00171687 yeah like you know like a quick meal
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00941-00171688-00171854 that goes away you know and everyone
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00942-00171855-00172007 does it everyone participates and a lot
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00943-00172008-00172126 of people have the same view that you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00944-00172127-00172295 have about it should be done with you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00945-00172296-00172447 mainly yeah we're not opening it most of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00946-00172448-00172614 the time it doesn't yeah and and that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00947-00172615-00172766 the lie we tell ourselves like i said to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00948-00172767-00172959 sleep at night yeah and and it's and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00949-00172960-00173095 it's what we say because we know that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00950-00173096-00173287 not what's happening no like i i know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00951-00173288-00173519 for we're not for a fact but it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00952-00173520-00173702 like you just know that like you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00953-00173703-00173823 going to mcdonald's none of this has
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00954-00173824-00174063 been done ethically or sourced and this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00955-00174064-00174238 is so another another part about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00956-00174239-00174454 libertarianism is there's a distrust of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00957-00174455-00174663 the government yeah and any government
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00958-00174664-00174814 and so i saw something recently where
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00959-00174815-00174983 it's like uh you're going to mcdonald's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00960-00174984-00175102 um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00961-00175103-00175407 a meat meal right so burger chips fries
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00962-00175408-00175583 uh and a drink right it's like three
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00963-00175584-00175799 pound forty five a salad there is four
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00964-00175800-00175926 pound ninety five on its own
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00965-00175927-00176151 accessibility and so and it's and that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00966-00176152-00176359 purposely being done by um the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00967-00176360-00176543 government and by big
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00968-00176544-00176878 uh big food just because that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00969-00176879-00177038 that's easier to sustain it's been
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00970-00177039-00177287 lobbied by the uh by people to uh get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00971-00177288-00177399 the government to make it cheaper
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00972-00177400-00177519 subsidised animal products are
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00973-00177520-00177678 subsidised as well and it's and it's and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00974-00177679-00177911 it's foul um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00975-00177912-00178095 that it that's that's what's happening
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00976-00178096-00178343 and so i think a lot of the times
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00977-00178344-00178447 it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00978-00178448-00178590 like not not for me right because i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00979-00178591-00178799 blessed uh like by god enough to be able
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00980-00178800-00178902 to go to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00981-00178903-00179119 somewhere if i so choose like a farmer's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00982-00179120-00179390 market right and buy all locally sourced
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00983-00179391-00179631 vegetables and [__] right i'm blessed to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00984-00179632-00179814 have that but some people don't no no no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00985-00179815-00179966 yeah and so i know i know that's not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00986-00179967-00180078 what you're suggesting is that those
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00987-00180079-00180223 people just starve and no one's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00988-00180224-00180478 suggesting no no i didn't to me but a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00989-00180479-00180735 lot of people have to be practically
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00990-00180736-00180943 achieved like like what people think is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00991-00180944-00181135 that veganism is this philosophy where
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00992-00181136-00181278 you cause no harm whatsoever no matter
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00993-00181279-00181407 how justified
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00994-00181408-00181559 like no i believe even killing is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00995-00181560-00181711 justified in certain situations that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00996-00181712-00181871 not my philosophy like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00997-00181872-00182054 you know killing you to save the rest of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00998-00182055-00182223 the world i'm killing you straight away
+pxS-M1I9eVy-00999-00182224-00182359 like so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01000-00182360-00182511 killing you kill me to save the rest of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01001-00182512-00182631 the world i believe even though i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01002-00182632-00182823 going to die that that is justified
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01003-00182824-00182951 because i'll just look at the you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01004-00182952-00183119 so that's not what veganism is and it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01005-00183120-00183247 not like you have to just eat this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01006-00183248-00183438 organic berry that grows on this [__]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01007-00183439-00183719 random tree and it's it's got to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01008-00183720-00183951 practically achieved by civilization and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01009-00183952-00184135 then you sort of weigh up this threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01010-00184136-00184326 thing you know what i'm saying yeah it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01011-00184327-00184502 that principle that philosophy that you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01012-00184503-00184719 try to that that's your core and you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01013-00184720-00184871 just don't be ridiculous about it you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01014-00184872-00185014 know what i mean exactly yeah because i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01015-00185015-00185183 know i know people uh who go to my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01016-00185184-00185414 church who who
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01017-00185415-00185566 who like they cut down they have one
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01018-00185567-00185775 meat meal a week they started off uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01019-00185776-00185911 like three meat meals a week because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01020-00185912-00186014 they realized they were eating it with
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01021-00186015-00186150 every meal they cut it down to three
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01022-00186151-00186319 then cut it down to one and it's like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01023-00186320-00186438 you said we're trying to figure out
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01024-00186439-00186599 where that threshold is of where you can
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01025-00186600-00186735 still
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01026-00186736-00186950 maintain like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01027-00186951-00187150 the mentality that you want but also
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01028-00187151-00187326 realize that you have an impact
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01029-00187327-00187487 i wouldn't include animals within that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01030-00187488-00187695 threshold though okay so because it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01031-00187696-00187823 isn't a necessity so basically if i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01032-00187824-00187950 wanted to eat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01033-00187951-00188111 so so imagine all the well-being that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01034-00188112-00188254 you're experiencing and are going to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01035-00188255-00188343 experience throughout your life you're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01036-00188344-00188495 going to experience some suffering but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01037-00188496-00188687 let's just say um i'm like you know what
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01038-00188688-00188847 my threshold is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01039-00188848-00188990 one piece of you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01040-00188991-00189119 each day
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01041-00189120-00189247 each day for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01042-00189248-00189390 say three times a week i'm going to eat
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01043-00189391-00189526 a piece of you so i'm going to go kill
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01044-00189527-00189711 you and just to get this small amount of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01045-00189712-00189838 pleasure from it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01046-00189839-00189935 i wouldn't say that that meets the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01047-00189936-00190135 threshold for justifying to kill you i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01048-00190136-00190350 not saying with animals you know but um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01049-00190351-00190511 if you were to say uh we gotta we go to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01050-00190512-00190678 eat fruits and vegetables and nuts and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01051-00190679-00190887 rice and stuff from the supermarket um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01052-00190888-00191014 it's going to be wrapped in plastic
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01053-00191015-00191190 there's going to be animals that die in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01054-00191191-00191359 the crops somewhere along the line
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01055-00191360-00191487 you're not responsible for all of those
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01056-00191488-00191614 animals but yeah because you're only
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01057-00191615-00191766 eating a certain amount of calories from
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01058-00191767-00191950 that crop yeah but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01059-00191951-00192095 that that's what i'm talking about like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01060-00192096-00192223 civilization we've got to get a car
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01061-00192224-00192350 we're gonna have to use some wheel in it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01062-00192351-00192550 you know but not i'm going to shoot you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01063-00192551-00192695 in the head to eat some of your body for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01064-00192696-00192831 a bit of taste pleasure i don't think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01065-00192832-00192935 that meats
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01066-00192936-00193223 no so what what is something so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01067-00193224-00193407 animal testing obviously not would
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01068-00193408-00193607 wouldn't meet your threshold unless it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01069-00193608-00193847 was something like so say this is uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01070-00193848-00194023 this is hyper ball right but or
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01071-00194024-00194287 hyperbole or whatever it's called but um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01072-00194288-00194735 like say the the only way right to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01073-00194736-00195023 to to get this life-saving cure
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01074-00195024-00195199 was animal testing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01075-00195200-00195390 would it be better that millions of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01076-00195391-00195614 animals suffer through animal testing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01077-00195615-00195766 than getting the life cure because i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01078-00195767-00195904 know you've spoken about like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01079-00195905-00196023 [Music]
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01080-00196024-00196175 it depends there's a threshold there's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01081-00196176-00196335 still there's still a threshold for me
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01082-00196336-00196535 like it's called threshold deontology i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01083-00196536-00196671 don't know that much about it this is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01084-00196672-00196871 one that that sits the best with me this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01085-00196872-00197078 is the type of moral system that sits
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01086-00197079-00197319 best with me and um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01087-00197320-00197559 so is there a threshold where like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01088-00197560-00197775 you grab me you put me in a lab and you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01089-00197776-00197959 have to do the test on me against my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01090-00197960-00198054 will
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01091-00198055-00198199 to stop
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01092-00198200-00198375 this this world
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01093-00198376-00198526 being tortured
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01094-00198527-00198719 for infinity or something like this so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01095-00198720-00198854 there would have to be i'll do it there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01096-00198855-00199014 would be there would be this threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01097-00199015-00199214 that would be met i don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01098-00199215-00199311 there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01099-00199312-00199647 um so for example cosmetic testing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01100-00199648-00199823 yeah it's it's ridiculous
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01101-00199824-00200014 yeah and i think it's illegal in the uk
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01102-00200015-00200175 yeah it's yeah to ear to my knowledge
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01103-00200176-00200302 yeah for example if you're if you go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01104-00200303-00200431 vegan right you go vegan and you're like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01105-00200432-00200671 oh well uh medication you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01106-00200672-00200878 medication is a different sort of thing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01107-00200879-00201071 because medication it's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01108-00201072-00201302 they legally required to test on animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01109-00201303-00201431 yeah so when it comes to supply and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01110-00201432-00201638 demand if you go buy a burger another
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01111-00201639-00201750 animal is going to have their head cut
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01112-00201751-00201919 off slaughtered for that burger
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01113-00201920-00202119 when you buy say aspirin
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01114-00202120-00202271 that that that aspen has been tested on
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01115-00202272-00202414 animals before
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01116-00202415-00202607 so when you buy that aspirin you're not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01117-00202608-00202790 you're not you're not incentivizing most
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01118-00202791-00202990 testing i take daily medication and so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01119-00202991-00203150 like i didn't know that it was it was a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01120-00203151-00203254 requirement
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01121-00203255-00203350 so they would have tested on those
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01122-00203351-00203519 animals before it was even released to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01123-00203520-00203687 human trials exactly and then and then
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01124-00203688-00203831 that's it and now it doesn't need to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01125-00203832-00204007 anymore of course not and so and so that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01126-00204008-00204254 that in my mind so i don't think but i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01127-00204255-00204487 do still think that animal testing is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01128-00204488-00204647 outdated and doesn't work because you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01129-00204648-00204871 can't take a rat and apply that model to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01130-00204871-00205094 a human being because because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01131-00205096-00205223 medications and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01132-00205223-00205398 chemicals act differently inside of iraq
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01133-00205400-00205551 than they do to people yeah practically
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01134-00205552-00205751 i don't think animal testing works but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01135-00205752-00206134 uh principally if it if it really did
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01136-00206135-00206294 um even if it was a human i do think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01137-00206296-00206431 there's a threshold
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01138-00206432-00206606 there's definitely a threshold okay but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01139-00206607-00206798 like yeah you're not unsubjective and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01140-00206800-00207006 that's the problem i think but i think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01141-00207007-00207246 though a lot of threshold people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01142-00207248-00207423 have similar ones you you would be able
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01143-00207423-00207646 to get everyone really in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01144-00207648-00207927 in a range unless you're like an outlier
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01145-00207928-00208086 because then i say okay put yourself in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01146-00208087-00208255 the animal's position is it just or put
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01147-00208256-00208406 a dog in the animal's position we could
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01148-00208407-00208590 see if they contradict themselves you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01149-00208591-00208766 know what i mean and most people are
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01150-00208767-00208951 pretty rational and they would you'd be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01151-00208952-00209103 able to find a pretty good
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01152-00209104-00209342 middle ground
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01153-00209344-00209582 so it's subjective but your belief
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01154-00209583-00209775 is that aside from the outliers which
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01155-00209776-00209887 shouldn't be counted anyway because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01156-00209888-00210071 that's the whole point of outliers is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01157-00210071-00210182 that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01158-00210183-00210487 they the average person would believe
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01159-00210488-00210719 in in a similar threshold so like we
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01160-00210719-00210887 just went through your moral system and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01161-00210888-00210998 you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01162-00211000-00211167 i think we got to you to a point where
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01163-00211167-00211342 like we we got to we got to jonathan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01164-00211344-00211479 actually and you still thought it was
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01165-00211480-00211775 okay to kill jonathan yeah okay but but
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01166-00211776-00211942 let me find where your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01167-00211944-00212094 where your barrier is like i want to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01168-00212096-00212191 find where you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01169-00212192-00212294 where you don't think it's okay would it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01170-00212296-00212471 be okay to kill
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01171-00212471-00212582 um
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01172-00212583-00212782 a human being no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01173-00212783-00212998 i mean well just like a random person
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01174-00213000-00213182 that i see on the street yeah so they've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01175-00213183-00213463 had and i'm talking the justification is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01176-00213464-00213623 that they're happy they haven't been
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01177-00213623-00213815 treated cruelly but your justification
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01178-00213816-00213934 is the same
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01179-00213935-00214046 taste pleasure you get from eating
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01180-00214048-00214215 animal products or using animal products
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01181-00214216-00214367 no i don't i don't think and that's with
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01182-00214367-00214527 jonathan as well you know that right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01183-00214528-00214742 yeah so with jonathan it is justified
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01184-00214744-00214910 for the same level of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01185-00214911-00215158 so because my belief is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01186-00215159-00215255 it's difficult because i have a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01187-00215256-00215455 confliction right as a religious man i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01188-00215456-00215639 have a confliction of okay god put these
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01189-00215640-00215887 animals here but also everything's made
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01190-00215888-00216134 in god's image but so i believe that yes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01191-00216135-00216382 jonathan so my threshold would be the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01192-00216383-00216663 dog so basically a human for no for the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01193-00216664-00216815 pleasure you get from a burger it's okay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01194-00216816-00217079 to kill happy dog yes okay but for the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01195-00217080-00217191 human there's some there's something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01196-00217192-00217334 different and you believe that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01197-00217335-00217471 difference is i'm not saying that i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01198-00217471-00217655 would do it i'm just saying that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01199-00217656-00217879 i think it's okay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01200-00217880-00218046 for someone for someone to do because uh
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01201-00218048-00218263 who am i to say that it's not but human
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01202-00218264-00218415 i think are very vast why wouldn't you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01203-00218416-00218606 do it because you do it you you you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01204-00218607-00218894 would do it if it was a cow yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01205-00218896-00219127 so there is a bit of inconsistency there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01206-00219128-00219287 so you wouldn't do it to the dog not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01207-00219288-00219406 jonathan because you have a personal
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01208-00219407-00219582 attachment to jonathan this is a dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01209-00219583-00219703 like jonathan
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01210-00219704-00219871 you wouldn't do what happens to this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01211-00219871-00220063 hypothetical cow in the humane situation
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01212-00220064-00220255 to a to a happy dog in the same
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01213-00220256-00220487 situation yeah you wouldn't do it no i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01214-00220488-00220631 wouldn't but then again i probably also
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01215-00220632-00220751 wouldn't kill a cow because i don't know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01216-00220752-00220887 if i've got that in me okay and here's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01217-00220888-00221110 the thing i'd like to know if i did
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01218-00221111-00221303 could you pay for me to kill the dog the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01219-00221304-00221558 happy dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01220-00221559-00221710 how much you judge no would you say
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01221-00221711-00221910 about you would you buy a burger for one
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01222-00221911-00222079 five quid or something well if i was not
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01223-00222080-00222246 benefiting benefiting from it then i'd
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01224-00222248-00222367 have no reason to you're benefiting
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01225-00222367-00222494 because you're just basically on this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01226-00222496-00222606 i'm the store
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01227-00222607-00222742 you come in you give me the money at the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01228-00222744-00222942 store how much you bought for a burger
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01229-00222944-00223110 there's a dog there happy dog five years
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01230-00223111-00223287 they've been living happy dog get them
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01231-00223288-00223391 in a dark room bank shoot them in the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01232-00223392-00223534 head i cut them up make them into a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01233-00223535-00223639 burger before you give it to you and you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01234-00223640-00223758 eat it for that five minutes of taste
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01235-00223759-00223887 pleasure would you be okay with doing
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01236-00223888-00223991 that
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01237-00223992-00224175 this is the happy dog scenario no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01238-00224176-00224398 cruelty you have you've got me you've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01239-00224400-00224703 got you've done me in a loop there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01240-00224704-00224879 it's the same thing yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01241-00224880-00225119 but with the cow you're you do this is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01242-00225119-00225303 what you do every single day
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01243-00225304-00225463 except you don't because you're paying
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01244-00225464-00225623 for for someone else to do it for you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01245-00225623-00225727 but you're also paying for all the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01246-00225728-00225910 cruelty that you're against because i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01247-00225911-00226087 been investigated for a while and been
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01248-00226088-00226191 in the movement for a while animal
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01249-00226192-00226303 rights movement i know what happens in
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01250-00226304-00226487 the industry and it's a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01251-00226488-00226679 it's a jungle man it's crazy what they
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01252-00226680-00226855 do animals so you're paying for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01253-00226856-00227039 something way worse actually
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01254-00227040-00227198 but even your hypothetical you wouldn't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01255-00227200-00227367 do it for the dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01256-00227367-00227487 but the cow
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01257-00227488-00227655 you paid me let's just say let's change
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01258-00227656-00227934 the dog now it's a cow now you pay me
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01259-00227935-00228063 for the burger five minutes taste
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01260-00228064-00228263 pleasure there's a cow there happy cow
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01261-00228264-00228446 daisy it's called call the car daisy
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01262-00228448-00228655 very stereotypical car and i shoot the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01263-00228656-00228823 car on the back of the head dark room
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01264-00228823-00228982 cut them up cut their head off make you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01265-00228983-00229119 a burger are you okay with that you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01266-00229119-00229310 what my answer's gonna be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01267-00229311-00229431 it's yes
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01268-00229432-00229798 you're okay with that yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01269-00229800-00230023 interesting and even if you saw me do it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01270-00230023-00230271 yeah probably cut their head off blood
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01271-00230271-00230382 coming out
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01272-00230383-00230527 they don't they're unconscious at this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01273-00230528-00230742 point though yeah they don't feel pain
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01274-00230744-00230934 bang cut their head off and then yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01275-00230935-00231142 yeah you're still okay yeah and and and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01276-00231144-00231271 you knew that was going to be my answer
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01277-00231271-00231455 and said this i didn't actually know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01278-00231456-00231646 that but you know you have a very you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01279-00231648-00231823 have a very big contradiction there and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01280-00231823-00232015 i know the only thing there because a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01281-00232016-00232167 dog and a cow very similar in their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01282-00232167-00232455 intelligence uh the way they learn
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01283-00232456-00232742 you know um so the only thing separating
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01284-00232744-00232991 you there is speciesism discrimination
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01285-00232992-00233119 because there's nothing morally
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01286-00233119-00233319 different about those two animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01287-00233319-00233510 so it's it's only your programming yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01288-00233511-00233655 you think that cows
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01289-00233656-00233839 it's bad for a cow
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01290-00233840-00234110 sorry bad for a dog then it's yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01291-00234111-00234239 and that's like i said earlier that's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01292-00234240-00234455 the way our society has been that's you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01293-00234456-00234606 these are you you've been affected by
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01294-00234607-00234919 society i'm saying yes so my beliefs
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01295-00234919-00235175 that have been a product of same parents
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01296-00235176-00235391 yeah exactly but you've managed to find
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01297-00235392-00235623 a way to do a matrix yeah undo it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01298-00235623-00235694 yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01299-00235696-00235855 and it's and it's not something that i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01300-00235856-00236015 so like like i like i said i want to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01301-00236016-00236142 learn something and it's not something
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01302-00236144-00236358 that like maybe i sat down with like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01303-00236359-00236534 less of an open mind because i sat down
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01304-00236535-00236719 with like the knowledge that i i don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01305-00236719-00236919 want to stop eating me because it's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01306-00236919-00237134 nice like a nice a nice steak from
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01307-00237135-00237303 helios steakhouse there are you seen
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01308-00237304-00237510 them bro that's a massive steak eater
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01309-00237511-00237806 yeah 26 years you know and it's and it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01310-00237807-00237910 and like i said you knew what i was
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01311-00237911-00238039 gonna say and i sounded pissed off but i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01312-00238040-00238271 wasn't i was more impressed at the way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01313-00238271-00238479 you got me it to admit my own
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01314-00238480-00238751 contradiction
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01315-00238752-00238910 and i think that's uh the next person
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01316-00238911-00239023 who sits down that's going to be the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01317-00239023-00239263 same like like nine times out of 10 it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01318-00239264-00239382 going to be very similar and i would
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01319-00239383-00239631 have probably sat down with me 10 years
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01320-00239632-00239806 ago or yeah it would have been a similar
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01321-00239807-00240055 conversation and it's all programming so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01322-00240056-00240246 how would you propose that i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01323-00240248-00240527 sin since your your one is to change my
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01324-00240528-00240679 mind right
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01325-00240680-00240927 yeah how how would you like other than
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01326-00240928-00241071 the conversation we've had what steps
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01327-00241071-00241230 could i do i would ask you to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01328-00241231-00241391 consistent and i'd ask you in order to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01329-00241392-00241558 be consistent then your actions should
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01330-00241559-00241815 reflect your morals yeah if you don't
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01331-00241816-00242039 and and also like not just that to be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01332-00242040-00242191 consistent about the animals too because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01333-00242192-00242303 if you wouldn't want it done to a dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01334-00242304-00242463 you shouldn't want it done to a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01335-00242464-00242663 cow yeah so for every
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01336-00242664-00242879 cow burger i eat you should eat a dog
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01337-00242880-00243103 one in my in my if we want to talk about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01338-00243104-00243334 mentality too like if you if you there
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01339-00243335-00243567 are human beings with similar intellects
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01340-00243567-00243727 to certain animals because of the way
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01341-00243728-00243958 that they were born yeah and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01342-00243959-00244142 if you wouldn't agree with what we do to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01343-00244144-00244382 a cow to be done to that human being
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01344-00244383-00244558 then you also have a contradiction and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01345-00244559-00244703 then there's only species separated
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01346-00244704-00244903 there too human being you might think
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01347-00244904-00245015 we're special because of god or
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01348-00245016-00245327 something but um really we're all
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01349-00245328-00245542 i'm trying to like trait equalize yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01350-00245544-00245742 these beings yeah because right because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01351-00245744-00245894 when because when you think about it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01352-00245896-00246039 like one of the justifications for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01353-00246040-00246182 eating meat is oh they're they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01354-00246183-00246279 they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01355-00246280-00246494 not uh of the right they're not they're
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01356-00246496-00246623 not the same level as humans but then
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01357-00246623-00246791 when you put it into context of because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01358-00246792-00246958 i used to be a a support worker of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01359-00246959-00247134 people with learning disabilities so i
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01360-00247135-00247327 know what it's like when someone has
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01361-00247328-00247582 a less than less than developed brain
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01362-00247583-00247782 for whatever reason yeah we look after
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01363-00247783-00247910 them and so when you put it into the
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01364-00247911-00248094 context i'm not saying that those people
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01365-00248096-00248246 are like animals
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01366-00248248-00248430 no one get that twisted right no no
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01367-00248431-00248591 you're not you're not lowering them down
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01368-00248592-00248734 no but what we're saying is their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01369-00248735-00248839 intellect is the similar their
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01370-00248840-00249015 experience could be very similar yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01371-00249016-00249310 because they don't uh have rational
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01372-00249311-00249494 thought the same way but you even you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01373-00249496-00249606 could even if
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01374-00249607-00249758 it's hard to think of if they exist or
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01375-00249759-00249903 not you can create the hypothetical
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01376-00249904-00249998 anyway
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01377-00250000-00250158 like hypothetically if someone did have
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01378-00250159-00250303 that same mentality as a car would it be
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01379-00250304-00250439 okay to kill them if they were yeah and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01380-00250440-00250646 that's my that's that's what i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01381-00250648-00250823 saying is that is that that when you put
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01382-00250823-00251175 it into that mindset and that context
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01383-00251176-00251446 it's really hard to argue against yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01384-00251448-00251598 without sounding like a hypocrite just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01385-00251600-00251806 going well i can contradict myself every
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01386-00251807-00251991 day and then that's the first step
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01387-00251992-00252198 feeling like that it's cognitive
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01388-00252200-00252398 dissonance it's where like your actions
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01389-00252400-00252598 are disaligned your emotions and your
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01390-00252600-00252767 actions are like how you feel about
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01391-00252767-00252951 something how you what you believe is
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01392-00252952-00253110 not aligned with your actions if you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01393-00253111-00253255 couldn't kill the cow
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01394-00253256-00253455 as well that's another thing yeah why
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01395-00253456-00253623 should i be allowed to eat it if i you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01396-00253623-00253839 can pay someone else to do the work like
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01397-00253840-00253975 you know if i can't kill you and i pay
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01398-00253976-00254119 someone other hitman to do it like i'm
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01399-00254119-00254303 still responsible but also i'm a bit
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01400-00254304-00254463 gutless like if i'm gonna kill you so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01401-00254464-00254582 much why don't i just go out and do it
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01402-00254583-00254719 yeah you know
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01403-00254719-00254871 so it's easy it's easier to commit
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01404-00254871-00255030 atrocities when you're you're detached
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01405-00255031-00255175 it's easier for people in the office to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01406-00255176-00255334 push a button on the nuclear bomb or to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01407-00255335-00255567 send soldiers out to die in war or for
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01408-00255567-00255791 you to push a button on a cow but just
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01409-00255792-00255975 you know to go all these steps removed
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01410-00255976-00256142 and to do this to an account it's much
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01411-00256144-00256494 easier that way that's why
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01412-00256496-00256719 on every corner that you go to because
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01413-00256719-00256919 they're the middle man in a sense or
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01414-00256919-00257103 probably the third man all these
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01415-00257104-00257246 butchers you walk in there's all this
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01416-00257248-00257406 all this advertising oh humane
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01417-00257407-00257623 traditional uh local family yeah i get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01418-00257623-00257830 the cameras in there and that's it's
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01419-00257831-00258110 insane cruelty violence and torture so
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01420-00258111-00258271 but um let me just give you this as a
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01421-00258271-00258398 practice because i think we've we've
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01422-00258400-00258542 sort of come to the conclusion now and
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01423-00258544-00258646 there's other people i don't want to
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01424-00258648-00258815 take up
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01425-00258816-00258951 this here is a little leaflet you can
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01426-00258952-00259142 just scan it and um you should be able
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01427-00259144-00259271 to download it that has got a lot of
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01428-00259271-00259479 some little places to go
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01429-00259480-00259623 if you ever wanted to go into these
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01430-00259623-00259823 places fast food there's plant-based
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01431-00259823-00259967 options in there as well oh yeah i get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01432-00259967-00260206 uh when i go i prefer the plant to any
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01433-00260207-00260398 of the like other options so i only get
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01434-00260400-00260542 my plant from yeah
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01435-00260544-00260782 maybe some nuggies but yeah but i'd also
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01436-00260783-00260958 ask people to do it it's a challenge 22.
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01437-00260959-00261175 it's a vegan challenge i listen mate
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01438-00261176-00261327 good talking that was great thank you
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01439-00261328-00261455 god bless you fantastic man i appreciate
+pxS-M1I9eVy-01440-00261456-00261852 it a lot mate take care
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00000-00000000-00000245 the site's called youtube.com and is a
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00001-00000246-00000401 really a nice Community there this is
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00002-00000401-00000539 the home page we'll just click on this
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00003-00000540-00000844 this is hack5 or hack 0.5
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00004-00000846-00001211 it is a payload platform
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00005-00001212-00001439 it is the basis of a very high severity
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00006-00001440-00001541 flaw
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00007-00001542-00001697 we get to hide our subject from
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00008-00001698-00001901 detection and recognition
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00009-00001902-00002087 I was able to find enough information to
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00010-00002088-00002345 reverse engineer one of these next up
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00011-00002346-00002602 here program the USB communication
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00012-00002603-00002831 occurring all kinds of different tools
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00013-00002832-00003041 just wanted to show you guys more of
+pyRS5uwkX4E-00014-00003042-00003343 what I'm passionate about
+pz71p5guZFg-00000-00000627-00000966 [Music]
+pz71p5guZFg-00001-00000967-00001183 i am not here to judge
+pz71p5guZFg-00002-00001184-00001792 keep your pride
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00004-00016884-00019829 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00005-00019830-00020164 uh
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00006-00020165-00023135 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00007-00023136-00023521 uh
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00008-00023522-00025756 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00010-00029958-00032867 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00011-00032868-00034931 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00013-00038322-00041230 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00014-00041231-00041585 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00016-00047199-00047579 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00018-00050622-00051287 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00020-00054444-00057130 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00021-00057132-00059411 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00022-00059412-00060163 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00023-00060164-00062609 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00024-00062610-00063457 video
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00025-00063458-00064732 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00026-00064733-00066263 um
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00027-00066264-00066556 what is the new message
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00028-00066557-00067885 then my sister is
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00029-00067886-00068171 dollar uh
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00030-00068172-00069853 during one months
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00031-00069854-00071963 tomorrow foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00032-00071964-00072211 tip
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00033-00072212-00072702 we've done it is
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00034-00072703-00074705 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00035-00074706-00074861 window
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00036-00074862-00075125 s
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00038-00078270-00078538 the YouTube channel
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00039-00078539-00080381 ideas
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00040-00080382-00081450 hello
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00041-00081451-00081911 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00043-00085277-00085519 hmm
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00044-00085520-00086747 this channel
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00045-00086748-00087767 Community guidelines
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00046-00087768-00088812 is
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00047-00088813-00089512 thank you
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00048-00089513-00089981 empty
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00049-00089982-00090197 animate
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00050-00090198-00090647 animate it I
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00051-00090648-00092123 okay
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00052-00092124-00092965 okay
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00053-00092966-00093550 data Maybe
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00054-00093551-00095279 okay videos
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00056-00098466-00100932 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00057-00100933-00101668 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00058-00101669-00102286 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00059-00102287-00104525 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00060-00104526-00105233 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00062-00108876-00110703 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00063-00110704-00112673 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00065-00115872-00118834 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00066-00118835-00119027 hundred percent
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00067-00119028-00121745 um
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00068-00121746-00122093 please
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00070-00125303-00125699 please live with Champa hey
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00071-00125700-00128393 videos
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00073-00131814-00132377 do Allegro
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00074-00132378-00135304 hotels
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00076-00139152-00140273 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00077-00140274-00142187 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00078-00142188-00143577 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00079-00143578-00145954 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00080-00145955-00148763 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00082-00151950-00152225 Barrel doors egg
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00083-00152226-00152351 then
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00084-00152352-00154235 channels
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00085-00154236-00155904 um
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00086-00155905-00156604 I mean
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00089-00162948-00165800 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00090-00165801-00167159 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00092-00171555-00172559 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00095-00179382-00182278 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00096-00182279-00183307 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00097-00183308-00185759 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00098-00185760-00187279 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00099-00187280-00189202 [Music]
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00101-00192888-00195587 foreign
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00102-00195588-00195766 cruel Osman
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00103-00195767-00196714 Bangla subtitle Bangla Bangla session
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00104-00196715-00199037 videos
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00105-00199038-00200309 survey
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00106-00200310-00202523 because
+pA3JIx7uOR8-00107-00202524-00202824 foreign
+pBKHDoRvLAy-00000-00000059-00000469 national highway 47 NH 47 is a national
+pBKHDoRvLAy-00001-00000470-00000580 highway in India
+pBKHDoRvLAy-00002-00000581-00000861 it starts from bama Noire in Gujarat and
+pBKHDoRvLAy-00003-00000863-00001261 terminates at na / in Maharashtra
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00000-00000039-00000271 good morning everybody
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00001-00000272-00000511 today i'm going to be taking you guys
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00002-00000512-00000878 through a day in my life today is monday
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00003-00000880-00001247 january 3rd happy 2022. i'm so excited
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00004-00001248-00001527 for this year this year is going to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00005-00001528-00001582 let me be
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00006-00001583-00001798 this off
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00007-00001800-00001975 i need to go brush
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00008-00001976-00002199 my teeth so
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00009-00002200-00002466 let's go do that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00010-00002467-00003663 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00011-00003664-00003983 all right guys so i brushed my teeth and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00012-00003984-00004311 now i am going to open my blind and make
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00013-00004312-00004469 my bed
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00014-00004470-00005991 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00015-00005992-00006286 i am going to get dressed i have these
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00016-00006287-00006463 really cute pants i got for christmas
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00017-00006464-00006695 some socks this really cute little
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00018-00006695-00007063 sports bra and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00019-00007064-00007239 i have to go on the beamer i don't know
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00020-00007240-00007398 what the beamer is it's this bed that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00021-00007400-00007487 you like
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00022-00007488-00007655 it's like it's a couch but you light it
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00023-00007656-00007806 on it and it's supposed to like block
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00024-00007808-00007927 your muscles and make you feel good so i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00025-00007928-00008095 did land on the pregnancy i like to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00026-00008095-00008367 start off my morning by going on a run
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00027-00008368-00008527 in order for me to get warmed up for my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00028-00008528-00008639 run i do
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00029-00008640-00008863 stairs so if stairs in my house i just
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00030-00008864-00009078 go up and down up and down until i feel
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00031-00009079-00009383 like my muscles are ready to run my run
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00032-00009384-00009614 today is not long it's only going to be
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00033-00009615-00009814 about a mile and a half
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00034-00009815-00009895 not
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00035-00009896-00010046 a lot i'm not looking forward to home
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00036-00010047-00010223 run or anything yeah i like to run in
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00037-00010224-00010367 the morning just to get my blood moving
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00038-00010368-00010606 so yeah i'm gonna go a mile and a half
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00039-00010607-00011074 today so not bad
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00040-00011075-00011742 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00041-00011743-00012055 these are my stairs in case you see me
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00042-00012056-00012214 with something in my mouth
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00043-00012215-00012359 i'm actually going to be eating my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00044-00012360-00012559 vitamins from my vitamins while doing
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00045-00012560-00012767 stairs it actually helps to go by faster
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00046-00012768-00012855 so
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00047-00012856-00013010 there you go
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00048-00013011-00015143 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00049-00015144-00015263 guys
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00050-00015263-00015575 i finished now it's time to go on my run
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00051-00015576-00015775 and i'll be filming some of the views
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00052-00015776-00016007 from my phone because i am definitely
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00053-00016008-00016303 not running with a canon eos 70d camera
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00054-00016304-00016430 in my hands
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00055-00016431-00016694 definitely not before i go i wanted to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00056-00016695-00016855 tell you guys what podcast i'm listening
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00057-00016856-00017158 to today i've really been enjoying take
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00058-00017159-00017335 20 with maddie and kenzie ziegler i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00059-00017336-00017455 don't know i just think it's a good
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00060-00017456-00017977 podcast to listen to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00061-00017978-00018807 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00062-00018808-00019289 so
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00063-00019290-00020007 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00064-00020008-00020183 oh my god
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00065-00020184-00020430 i literally just rolled my ankle
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00066-00020431-00020758 look at the mud on my shoe
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00067-00020759-00020878 i don't know
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00068-00020879-00021030 what i should do
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00069-00021031-00021222 should i just jump and see if it hurts
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00070-00021223-00021383 okay i'm done with my run but like
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00071-00021384-00021622 usually i do jumps like right here on
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00072-00021623-00021886 this thing update my ankle is fine i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00073-00021887-00022030 just got mud on my shoe which is
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00074-00022031-00022271 unfortunate but my run was really great
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00075-00022272-00022439 and i'm happy that i did not break my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00076-00022440-00022607 ankle it doesn't even hurt now it like
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00077-00022608-00022799 hurt for like two minutes then it went
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00078-00022800-00022999 away now i'm gonna go inside and get my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00079-00023000-00023214 breakfast ready yeah so i'll see you in
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00080-00023215-00023443 there
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00081-00023444-00023683 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00082-00023684-00023734 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00083-00023735-00024114 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00084-00024115-00024147 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00085-00024148-00024863 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00086-00024864-00025191 it looks pretty good if you ask me
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00087-00025192-00025367 so i'm super excited let's start
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00088-00025368-00025529 psychology
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00089-00025530-00025901 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00090-00025902-00026569 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00091-00026570-00026700 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00092-00026701-00027013 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00093-00027014-00027139 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00094-00027139-00027264 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00095-00027266-00028108 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00096-00028110-00028567 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00097-00028568-00028572 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00098-00028573-00028914 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00099-00028916-00029199 [Applause]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00100-00029200-00029943 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00101-00029944-00030223 so right now i'm doing my foot stretcher
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00102-00030224-00030527 put my foot in there looks like this i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00103-00030527-00030887 am doing my fair band with my other foot
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00104-00030888-00030958 i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00105-00030960-00031367 have a test coming up tomorrow so i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00106-00031368-00031558 really feel prepared for that my teacher
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00107-00031560-00031790 is really good so we're excited about
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00108-00031791-00032039 that i'm just going to be relaxing i was
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00109-00032039-00032374 watching um like before this a few
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00110-00032375-00032518 minutes before i started filming this i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00111-00032519-00032783 was watching a us classic maybe it
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00112-00032784-00032959 wasn't a us classic it was a junior
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00113-00032960-00033167 national championship from like 2006 for
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00114-00033168-00033455 gymnastics and it is so good and like
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00115-00033456-00033631 you see girls there like jordan weber
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00116-00033632-00033774 when she was like 10 years old and it's
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00117-00033775-00033967 like amazing so i'm probably gonna
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00118-00033968-00034183 finish watching that and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00119-00034184-00034479 i will see you guys
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00120-00034480-00034615 for lunch
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00121-00034616-00034774 all right
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00122-00034775-00035071 so guys i'm eating my lunch right now
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00123-00035072-00035399 i'm having salad and then a meat lettuce
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00124-00035400-00035702 wrap and some chocolate
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00125-00035703-00035911 for example today we start on theme and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00126-00035912-00036127 then we go to floor then we have a break
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00127-00036128-00036262 and then we go to fall and then we end
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00128-00036263-00036430 our hearts and my favorite event has to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00129-00036431-00036639 be your gymnast comment down below right
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00130-00036640-00036935 now what's your favorite event
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00131-00036936-00037174 i love me
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00132-00037175-00037374 no i'm not serious like i literally love
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00133-00037375-00037518 me so much
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00134-00037519-00037743 sorry
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00135-00037744-00038046 so right now i'm having my chocolate i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00136-00038047-00038190 always like to bring my chocolate
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00137-00038191-00038446 upstairs because
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00138-00038447-00038623 i usually put on like a face mask or
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00139-00038624-00038774 something and then i just feel like
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00140-00038775-00038902 really bougie when i'm eating my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00141-00038903-00039215 chocolate face mask today i'm going to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00142-00039216-00039590 do the yes to watermelon refreshing
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00143-00039591-00039993 paper mask
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00144-00039994-00041007 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00145-00041008-00041223 this might be a little difficult but
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00146-00041224-00041367 i'll see you guys after i'm done with
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00147-00041368-00041630 the shower vegan shower finish my face
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00148-00041631-00041895 mask and my chocolate okay guys so i am
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00149-00041896-00042055 out of the shower
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00150-00042056-00042271 and i have this really cute what is that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00151-00042272-00042583 sweatshirt on and my leo
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00152-00042584-00042743 there's the
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00153-00042744-00042951 leopard in the back
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00154-00042952-00043943 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00155-00043944-00044327 oh my god this is so good
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00156-00044328-00044558 guys oh my gosh
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00157-00044559-00044662 perfect
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00158-00044663-00044767 bye
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00159-00044768-00044895 what's your name
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00160-00044896-00045246 ashley what level are you no
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00161-00045247-00045502 okay uh what's your name audrey what
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00162-00045503-00045630 level are you
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00163-00045631-00045799 thank you
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00164-00045800-00046023 wait this is actually so good
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00165-00046024-00046174 oh my god look at that focus look at
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00166-00046175-00046758 that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00167-00046759-00047111 and what's your level
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00168-00047112-00047399 hi what is your name i am sam
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00169-00047400-00047735 hi i'm abby and what are you guys i'm
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00170-00047736-00048039 level 9 and how how i mean what level is
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00171-00048040-00048167 abby
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00172-00048168-00048543 i'm going level 9. we did beam and floor
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00173-00048544-00048767 and audrey has some something to tell
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00174-00048768-00048999 you guys she did something new on floor
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00175-00049000-00049158 oh yeah i took out my backhand spring on
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00176-00049159-00049302 my 10-minute passes
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00177-00049303-00049543 i recommend 10 out of 10.
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00178-00049544-00049767 so my thing for gymnastics
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00179-00049768-00049927 if you want to know
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00180-00049928-00050127 do you pray to god before everything you
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00181-00050128-00050311 do i'm not kidding
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00182-00050312-00050623 before my series on beam i said i think
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00183-00050624-00050895 of jesus's face when i'm doing back
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00184-00050896-00051046 handspring
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00185-00051047-00051382 then i'm like oh yeah i got this hey
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00186-00051383-00051935 how was practice it was amazingly
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00187-00051936-00052142 packs amazing pretty good yeah and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00188-00052144-00052454 actually pure wets are really good
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00189-00052455-00052703 see you guys at home bye all right guys
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00190-00052704-00053047 so i am home from gym got my comfy
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00191-00053048-00053199 sweatshirt on and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00192-00053200-00053526 a loose bun in and tonight
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00193-00053527-00053663 i'm having
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00194-00053664-00053950 my favorite dinner macaroni and cheese
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00195-00053951-00054159 salad and some bread she's an amazing
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00196-00054160-00054430 cook and here's my dad's dad say hi
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00197-00054432-00054766 hello there and jim was five of
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00198-00054767-00054926 the end of the night
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00199-00054927-00055175 and i'm about to go to bed and all
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00200-00055176-00055494 shower here is my detailed gym day i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00201-00055495-00055742 guess we started on theme
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00202-00055744-00056166 um i had an assignment to do
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00203-00056167-00056471 stick my beats and my jumps
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00204-00056472-00056559 and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00205-00056560-00056663 turn
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00206-00056664-00056854 i'm gonna do uphill dismounts and just
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00207-00056855-00056975 not drills
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00208-00056976-00057199 and then for series sorry the lighting
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00209-00057200-00057430 flipper right now for series we had to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00210-00057432-00057575 do
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00211-00057576-00057782 make five and to make the first one you
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00212-00057783-00058079 know you can count as two and i did that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00213-00058079-00058271 and my series was good i'm really upset
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00214-00058272-00058535 about this lighting and then
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00215-00058536-00058711 i went to the floor we did some tunnel
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00216-00058712-00058807 track
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00217-00058808-00058975 and then
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00218-00058976-00059191 i had a really good double backs today
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00219-00059191-00059471 we did some leaps and turns went to
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00220-00059472-00059679 break and you saw that
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00221-00059679-00059959 and then went to a ball and i flipped
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00222-00059960-00060135 into the pit it's our last day of pit
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00223-00060136-00060438 and then we're going onto a mat
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00224-00060439-00060582 sorry it's like really hot in here right
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00225-00060583-00060887 now and then as far as i
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00226-00060888-00061063 fixed the correction
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00227-00061064-00061271 because i need to scoop my toes on my
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00228-00061272-00061503 pack
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00229-00061504-00061623 like this
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00230-00061624-00061830 and then we did air conditioning and
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00231-00061832-00062087 this week's shout out goes to miss
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00232-00062088-00062375 mariah pope thank you so much mariah for
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00233-00062376-00062566 the amazing comment and i love you so
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00234-00062567-00062815 much it is time for me to go i love you
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00235-00062816-00063186 and i hope you have an amazing day
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00236-00063187-00065111 [Music]
+pEhWYZC0aq4-00237-00065112-00065412 will
+pExg1YcV3bE-00000-00000657-00001345 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00001-00001346-00001597 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00002-00001598-00002044 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00003-00002045-00004176 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00004-00004177-00004274 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00005-00004275-00004870 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00006-00004871-00005036 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00007-00005037-00006573 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00008-00006575-00008346 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00009-00008347-00009507 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00010-00009508-00011922 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00011-00011923-00012174 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00012-00012175-00013002 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00013-00013003-00013762 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00014-00013763-00014788 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00015-00014790-00015122 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00016-00015124-00017215 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00017-00017216-00017249 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00018-00017250-00017742 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00019-00017743-00017774 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00020-00017775-00018230 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00021-00018231-00018292 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00022-00018293-00019039 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00023-00019040-00021145 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00024-00021146-00021399 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00025-00021400-00021480 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00026-00021481-00022975 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00028-00026341-00026602 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00029-00026602-00026683 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00030-00026683-00027329 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00031-00027330-00027780 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00032-00027781-00029893 [Applause]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00033-00029894-00030001 [Music]
+pExg1YcV3bE-00034-00030002-00030500 [Applause]